Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spice Traders

Spice Traders artwork

The Romanov Oracle by Molly Tullis Part 2

Jun 23, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

This is part 2 of 2. Triggers: sex, violence, language, parental abuse, murder, poverty, child enslavement KU: No Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out https://thebibliophileblonde.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to your safe space. The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks it's dirty. Don't have time to read books? Want to understand all the jokes and the TikToks? We got you fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. Before we get to today's episode, we want to encourage you to check out our Patreon, where we publish extra episodes every other week, as well as ad -free versions of our regular feed episodes. Also, any series we read past the first book, all that coverage is Patreon only, so think series like Akatar, Fourthwing, Guild. Anyway, we really

appreciate the support and encouragement to continue doing something we love and sharing it with you. Thanks in advance for checking that out. As always, we start this episode with three things. First is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes, so please check those out. We also use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to either of those things, our podcast probably isn't for you. Second, our episodes talk about books, the whole book, nothing but the book, so help me goddess. If you don't want something spoiled, don't listen to this episode. And finally, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. Our views discussed in our episodes

are our opinion, and we don't want to diminish the work or the talents of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. Kenny what are we talking about today? So today we're talking about part two of the Romanov Oracle by Molly Toulouse and this is part two of two so if you haven't read the book or Listen to

part one do one of those things. I mean, honestly probably not gonna be that lost because It's hard to follow. Anyway, I think that's the biggest thing I before we start recording I was like hey Danny to review the notes because I don't remember what happened It's not that I don't remember what happened. It's that I'm hoping I just didn't read it clearly, but I've read the notes. It doesn't make any sense. I just they just they do that thing where they go back and forth between two locations a lot and like nothing of substance actually moves the plot

forward. Like everything else is happening off screen. Everything that matters is happening off screen, right? Which is where we should have gotten more like political intrigue. Yes. I mean, honestly, you're going to look at a dynasty and the downfall of a dynasty. You need to talk about the politics. Right. I mean, especially when the dynasty ends because of something that like is politically motivated. Yes. Anyway, anyway, quick orientation, because it's been a hot minute since we recorded and it might be a hot minute since you listened. So part two picks up the

morning after Rasputin was poisoned when they went to that one party that one time. and tried to do the politics thing with a bunch of nameless people and they had that weird like fan language. I forgot about the fan language. That means that she wants to fuck you and so does her husband because she had her family in her mouth. OK, OK. Yeah. So we do we do that. And like it's. The. One one craft. thing about this, just to

bring it up really quick, is that I know that there is like a use case for continuing a scene across chapters. Yeah. That's fine, except when you're doing the arrive early, leave late sin. Repeatedly. Repeatedly. And this poisoning scene is a good example of we arrived way too early and we're sticking around well past the last call. Because like, Mikhail's alive, right? And

she's like, Oh my gosh, I can bring people back from the dead. And that should have just been it. And then they could do like some exposition later in a different scene. But instead we see Anastasia weeping on Mikhail's chest for about... Six pages and like he's fully fine. Also. I don't buy that she would be that distraught. Well, because they don't know each other. That's what I'm saying. Like, unless it's just the sheer shock of like he almost died and somehow you saved him. Right. Sure. Right. So like there's

that there's also the pat words and like descriptions of the scene from the pros, like. For example, quote, Words had the potential to ruin the moment, which like in and of itself is a sentence that ruins the moment. You don't have to put it on the head so much. And then Mikhail continues to be an ass hat because he's had this pattern of bolting every time things get a little bit real or emotional. And he does that immediately now because not only did Anastasia bring him back from the dead and was also distraught about potentially him dying, but he's just like. I can't feel things for you because I still want

to kill you. So, quote, we should both get some sleep. Your grace. And do what with that tomorrow, Mikhail? I don't know. And then and then he's described as, quote, all but running back to his room. What, you scared? Oh, baby. Oh, baby. No, no. Yeah. Also, just like. Why is his mom a ghostly figure? I don't know. And like, is that just in his head? Or like, is she functionally

there? I mean, this was a little bit confusing, too, because she also, she also appeared, like she appears somewhat appears like later in the book. Yeah. Like this one read to me like she was watching from the afterlife. But just like, don't put that. No, it's weird. Why are you introducing ghosts into the story? Right. Or have Anastasia, Anastasia, I can't say her name. It's like. Anastasia. I want to go, I want to go between Anastasia and Anastasia. I'm just going to do Anastasia. Anastasia. Anastasia should have just said like,

I bet Ossia would be like rolling in her grave or whatever. That would have made way more sense. Great. Not a disembodied maybe ghost. Cool. Also the other thing. Okay. It doesn't matter. I'm gonna let it go. You don't have to. I don't know enough about that character Ossia to care enough what her opinion is in the afterlife. No, because she's, she's the I'm your nursemaid, and I'm also your best friend, and I'm also your sister, and I'm also your mom. But you also don't know that I have a son. Right. Who doesn't know about you, either, for some reason? Right. OK, because

that's an interesting point, because wouldn't Rasputin know that his mom has a soft spot for Anastasia? Yes. And wouldn't they have met at some point? I mean, ostensibly, I know we harped on that in part one, but it bothers me. Yeah. It feels like a major plot hole that you could drive your car into. Yeah. I mean, yeah, I could I could drive a lot of things into it. I mean, unless this would be a better story, too. Asya likes Anastasia way better than her own son. So like raised her and functionally abandoned

him. I like that. It was more revenge. I think I think so, too. So then we get like this. awkward scene where like Rasputin has like left like gone back to his quote -unquote rooms and so like Anastasia is just like standing there in the middle of her room like an NPC charging up and then like her parents and a bunch of people come into the room and they're like, oh Darling, we heard the news that Rasputin's dead How would you have heard that if you weren't the one who poisoned him? I know. Way to show your entire

fucking hand immediately. The Sarnas Arena don't make any logical sense as villains. I just. So but Mikael exited the room so that he could step back into the room fully alive and have this big gotcha moment, which doesn't really land, right? Like. You you went out of the room for like artificial purposes these The Tsar and the Tsarina are functionally idiots like yeah, it's not worth it Just make them barge into the room and have him be like sitting there drinking coffee,

right? He doesn't have to make this grand entrance, right? There's so there's a couple of like other lords there There's like three nameless ones that no anesthesia secret fine one of them says like oh we could turn this into like a dark magic resurrection story, which would be clever if we knew anything about like what Rasputin was actually doing for like the revolution because like the underpinning of this is like, oh, we're trying to change the story so that Rasputin isn't a man of the people anymore. And I'm like, is he a man of the people? I don't think so. I haven't

been sold on that story. Right. So this gets ugly quickly. The Tsar is like, OK, well, scrap that plan. You're going to marry this other guy because I want you to kill him. Okay. So one of these nobles proceeds to make like very puerile jokes like he's 13 and he's like, you know, you know what husbands and wives do, you know, it could help. You could always do that and then kill him. Wink, wink, wink. How do you think

about them apples? And the czar, her father is like, you know, that's a good idea. It's disgusting. And Anastasia's like, is this real life right now? And of course, Rasputin is like, she's my woman. She won't sleep with anybody. I'm like, you just ran away because you couldn't have feelings for her because you want to kill her. Even after she raised you from the dead. Yeah. OK. Like a little bitch. Yeah. So. The czar pulls out a pistol. Tries to like shoot Rasputin because

he's like a problem. Anastasia like. Body checks her father and then is so pissed that his he missed that he slaps the shit out of Anastasia. So Rasputin crosses the room from wherever he was, like staring into a blank wall and punches the czar who had, quote, never been struck before in his life and says, quote, You touch her again and you'll die. Which usually slaps. does not

slap right well and and and to continue the fire motif from part one like his he's described as having a quote fire and brimstone in his voice because god forbid we miss an emotional beat without a fire reference it just doesn't land because i don't buy his protectiveness also i'm sorry you can't just to put a very fine point on it it hasn't been fine already ostensibly he wants to kill her so what do you care if someone else slaps her i know You want to be the only one who could slap her? I'm the one in charge of your death. Yeah. OK, the only way that works

is in guild. Because that works. It's spam. And it's nice. So the scene is so frustrating, because not only does the czar continually put them into easily -escapable situations that end up biting both of them in the ass, but in this situation, Mikhail has gotten the gun away from. The czar so the czar and the czarina and like the three nobles are essentially like useless because nobody else bought magic or another gun to a magic fight and Anastasia's power is like out and she's got

like all of these like bases and candelabras and like gold dust in the air and she's like choking the life out of the boyer that said she should fuck her new husband and Mikhail is like Girl just hey one minute you could kill him, but I think you're gonna regret it and I'm like no she won't no she won't no she won't So why this guy's a literal nobody right? I'm like, okay. So what's the end game here? Mikael? You're just gonna like back away from this conflict and then What? That's where I think this plot lands flat because I do think there's an interesting

kernel here of Someone who's out for revenge falls in love with that source of animosity right cool in theory brilliant You don't spend enough time building up that confusion in him. So we're stuck being confused by being like, what do you want here? Right. Well, and what's your what's your end game? Because even even in part one, we saw this, but even that gets more apparent in part two, like they don't have a plan here. No, like it's never. OK, if we're to go from

the like if we were going to run away, like where would we go? That that conversation never happens. And so like functionally. This is their house. They're going to, they plan to stay in it. And I'm like, wow, you really don't know how to do this whole like revolution thing to you. That's the thing is like, supposedly there is a revolution. I don't know what they're doing. I don't know if Kale's role is in it. I don't think he has any role in it. No, I think he's just like an orphan boy who chose the name Rasputin for some reason. Well, he was gifted that name, but still.

Right. So. Anastasia says, quote, I think I trust you more than anyone else in this world, Mikhail, and lets them go. And so rather than like capitalize on this opportunity to like remove, bodily remove Rasputin or Anastasia from each other, like the Tsar, the Tsarina and the nobles just leave. They're just like, until next time. I'm like. Is this a Mickey Mouse cartoon? Like, I don't know what it is. Because then, OK, if you think about it in reality, they're going to leave and go to their own rooms down the hall in the same

building until they fight again later and just do about it. What? What is happening here? That doesn't make sense. No. So the one thing like when they're alone. Anastasia says in her internal monologue, quote, I swear to God, if he walks out of here one more time, when I say something fucking vulnerable, my heart won't be able to take it. And I wish that this book would be more readable if it leaned into that. Yeah, of her being like self aware and being like, what the fuck is this guy doing? Right. Like if everybody around her was a fucking idiot and she's the only one that's looking at the situation with

like clear eyes, that would be really funny. It would be so entertaining to read. Right. But alas. So rather than stay in the palace, they go to the boarding house for a night. And I'm just like you're okay one you're reloading off of this poor woman when you don't have to you live in a palace you live in a palace like So you're just gonna you're gonna go like stay have a staycation somewhere and then Go back home their children who got mad at their parents and

they're gonna run away for one night, right? Anyway, so they do that. They're just there for a night Nothing happens. They go back in the morning and they're there in time for breakfast and they get cold oatmeal again because the Tsar is like, well, you hurt my feelings and so you don't get hot food anymore. I don't know what that's the scariest thing the Tsar can think to do to her. Just give her cold food. Not throw

her in the dungeons, not take a nail off for every time you disobey me. Yeah. You just get oatmeal. No wonder you got overthrown Jesus. I know it's They are Mickey Mouse villains. Yeah And I love that it's like you get cold oatmeal you don't get any sugar and you don't get any coffee. Oh boo. Oh kitten. Okay So a little bit later the Tsar comes along to manipulate Anastasia

alone And he like tries the whole we could be a family again routine. I don't believe you've ever been a functional family. I know. And Anastasia has that internal thought, but she doesn't voice it aloud. She's just like, I've never had a father. That could be nice, but she doesn't call him out on his board. No, also because we saw her in childhood where her mom was legitimately abusive. Right. What the fuck are you talking about, dad? I know. Well, and he like he does this for like two seconds. She asks one too many questions and. The Tsar completely loses his cool and he

says, quote, it was your fault. We had to kill that damned woman. And I'm like, well, this is wild behavior. You have to know this is wild behavior. Also, you have no chill. You sound crazy. You are crazy. But lo and behold, this is the reveal that we've all been waiting for, which is that. Anastasia didn't kill Asya at all. It was the Tsar. And I'm like, of course it was. They said it far too often for it to be anything else. It was too obvious for this to be a big reveal. And I think, unfortunately,

I think this was intended to be a reveal to the reader as well as Anastasia. I think so too. But it was immediately apparent to me. Yeah. It was immediately apparent to me the first time. It wasn't even like the fifth time somebody said it. No, the first time. The first time they were like, you killed her. We have to go. Let's go right now. Okay, okay. Weird. The only time there was a question is like when the actual act happens. Right. And you should have just left it at that. Yeah, no one should mention it again. Or nobody should have said like, Anastasia killed killed Osia. They could have just been like, she's dead.

Yeah. Because of what happened in that room. She's dead. Trust your reader to make the conclusion. Right. Trust your character to infer things without being told, right? Yeah. So, of course, Mikhail's in the doorway and has heard everything and both of them are shocked. And this is supposed to be like kind of the core emotional engine of the book and it just really doesn't land for me. Again, because we already know. We already know. But this ostensibly gives Mikhail a reason to like actually love Anastasia with his whole heart and not want to kill her anymore. Okay.

You're holding a vendetta against a thing someone did as a child, but that's okay. I know. She was what? 13? Jesus. This makes Anastasia so mad that she lunges for her father. Easily gets tossed aside. Cool. Rasputin aims a pistol at the Tsar. Point blank. And the Tsar goes, quote, You can't kill me. I'm the Tsar of Russia. And Mikhail goes, quote, I'm in love with that woman. Tell me, Moy Tsar, which of these do you think inspires more passion in a man? I'm so bored.

I'm so bored. And again, I don't believe that you're in love. I don't believe that you're in love. I feel like you're in love with the idea of being in love. Yeah. And also the Mozart thing is a really good example of like, they go back and forth between what I assume is Russian and like English, but like not sometimes the Russian words are italicized. Not all the time. No, like here it wasn't. Nope. something about, I know it's not the same word, but it makes me think of moi. And I'm like, why are we speaking French

now? No, I had the same feeling. Yeah. Cause I'm not that familiar with Russian. And so I was just like, is that how you say my in Russian? I mean, I believe the author. Sure. It's annoying. It's annoying. Cause you didn't do it before. Cause it's not like Moisar was like a title that's been used prior to this very moment. Right. Yeah. So it just feels jarring. It is. And it feels like, so I'm I'm kind of equating it to like Your Highness, which is always capitalized in English. Yeah. And I'm like, should it be capitalized

here if it's like my czar is my liege or whatever the official title? Yeah. I don't know. It was just it was just one of those things that like I didn't have enough information and maybe that's on me and maybe it's not. But like contextually, it kind of like made me ask questions that were not important. Exactly. And then I get a little lost in it. So anyway, he says that deeply unhinged thing while he's holding a gun to the Tsar's head. And this time, Anastasia is the one that's like, don't kill him. Quote, his end will be

much more public than this. And I'm like, no, it won't. Just kill him. Just kill him. Also, what do you think you're going to do? Like capture him and take over the whole palace? I don't know. They have no plan. Any plan. Like you're just going to he's going to. You're going to end this, this kerfuffle. He's going to back out of the room and then you're going to do this again in like a day and a half. Like I just, why do we keep doing this? Cause again, he's just going to return to his own bedroom for a couple of days and then give you cold oatmeal and we're going to start again. Just kill him. I just don't

understand. Like it's just such a boring way to like, I'm not even going to say move the plot along because it doesn't, it doesn't move the plot along. Like one, I don't know what the plot is. That's really the thing. Two, there's no building toward anything because neither of these two are actively making it. The only thing that they're maybe actively doing is preventing each other from doing anything that would matter. Yeah. Because there's just no end game. So if we don't know where we're going, why can I root for anything to happen? Yeah. So then we get

the first full -on sex scene against a wall, and then it's in the bed. And it's fine. There's definitely some logistical things that I don't quite understand. They do say the L word a lot and they do this like, say it again, Sam thing, but that was a cosplay reference. They don't say Sam obviously. Which I just feel like is not, it's supposed to be this big payoff rate, but I just don't feel like we earned it. No, also just again, logistically, you just threatened

to kill the czar and he's just gonna. Leave and let you bang in his house, right? Like if I was the czar, I would come back when they're both like vulnerable and in flagrante and then like throw them both in the dungeon. Like, yeah, why would I just let you exist? Yeah. So that kind of the scene's not great anyway, but that ruined it for me. Mm hmm. Because it just didn't make sense. It didn't ruin in the way of that. I was like. Oh, no, this is stressful. Someone could walk in because that would be fine. But I wasn't worried because I knew that wasn't going to happen. And that just upset me. Yeah, it wasn't going

to happen for reasons that like just feel not fully thought through. It's because I think was we mentioned. I think in part one, I don't know if it was on mic or not, but this book gives gives the same vibe as Rise of a Dark Throne, where characters like clip in and out. Yes. And effectively, when the czar and the czarina aren't. physically in the room, they cease to exist. They don't have motives. They don't do anything. There's nothing happening off screen. The only thing that's happening off screen is like this simmering, bubbling, not discomfort, dissatisfaction

within like the population of peasants, quote unquote. And that is the engine that's getting us to the end of the book, which has nothing to do with the characters that we're spending all of our time with. No. And it feels like a nothing burger. Like that could be You could make that much more stressful and more concrete and heavier. Like there's stuff happening that we're hearing about. Right. But it kind of feels like there's like 10 peasants that are kind of pissed off. Right. Well, and it could be much more, it could have been much more interesting. Like if Anastasia was actually a fixture of the court and then also was helping the rebels in

some way, like feeding them information, getting them access to the palace. Like that would be an interesting thing to read. And then there was also this intrigue with like Rasputin and maybe she didn't know if he was truly an agent of her mother or like something like There's just so many different ways this could have gone way better. Yeah. And it didn't. And it just didn't. Yeah. The one other thing that I want to say about the scene is there's this whole, like, scars thing, which just feels like a trope for trope's sake because, like, she's got scars on her back because of the abuse that she suffered at the hands of the priests and her mother. But

she seems fine with she doesn't really have a lot of trauma She doesn't have a lot of trauma about it and like we get like Negative amounts of information about this besides the fact that it happened that they exist that they exist and like like takes his shirt off and he's like, mine are beautiful. Cause he's got scars too. And then he like rips her shirt off or whatever she's wearing. And she's like, they're beautiful Anya. And I'm like, if you fucking call me Anya while you're balls deep in me, I'm going to fucking

murder you. Like I just, this whole thing was so weird. It's not it. Cause she's not, she doesn't have like the don't look at me. She's just kind of there. She's just a cardboard cutout of herself. And then like, okay, one, if you had like body dysmorphia issues because of your scar, that's one thing, but also like this was an incredible trauma that was inflicted upon you. You should have some like emotional reaction about it. To someone seeing and touching it. Right. But she just stands there. Okay. Okay. Okay. Oh my God.

We have so much more to get through. I'm so sorry. I know. I'm really sorry. I'm going. So now we get a brief change of perspective, which is a wild choice at this point in the book. We go to the Tsar and for the first time in the entire book he's named outright as Tsar Nicholas II who's the one that got overthrown. Fine cool he's with his like three interchangeable noble advisors people the people that know about Anastasia's blah blah but I just want to call out here because at this point the spelling of the the word for noble which I'm gonna butcher I'm so sorry but it's like no I'm not even going to include that

it's a Russian word it starts with a D and then goes DV O -R -Y -A -N -S -T -V -O has now mutated into D -V -O -R -Y -S -V -A -S -T -O. So the first spelling had an N. The second spelling doesn't have an N. So the V at the end has moved. It is now a T. The V has moved to the end. And then there's yet a third spelling that just goes D -O. And then the rest of it is the same as the first one. So the V has almost completely disappeared. And like... This switches back sometimes

even within the same paragraph. And there's a minimum of three different spellings that's when I stopped counting. And I'm just like, pick one, my friend, anyone. Just pick one. And I don't know anything about the Russian language. But is it a misspelling? Or is there a reason for these to be three different words? Because it just looks sloppy to me. It just reads like a misspelling. Yeah, a repeated misspelling. Right. So that was annoying. Yeah, but anyway, we're looking at Czar Nicholas and these three unnamed guys and they cook up a plan to like forge these

love letters between the Czarina and Rasputin ostensibly to drive a wedge between Anastasia and Rasputin. Yeah. So now I'm fucking your mom. Right. Is what they're trying to do. Yeah. Like I just what was interesting is that like this did actually happen. Like these letters did happen. Yeah. But like it's just So transparent like I like in this story I don't know if it was as transparent in like the the real world but like Jesus Christ and that's where it just feels like

a fun little nugget of true history that you didn't incorporate as well as you could have right exactly and it would have been more meaningful if Rasputin had like any other kind of role in this world besides banging slash killing anesthesia Yeah, because in this story doesn't make sense. Like, he was a child. He was basically exiled. And now he's been back for, I don't know, a month. And he's also been banging your mom the whole time. Yeah. When? When? Because he spends all of his time in two rooms. With Anastasia. With Anastasia. So the last scene that we get in this book, or in this chapter, is that the nobles

or whatever are, quote, chuckling delightfully like a perverted chorus and sneering like schoolboys. And I'm like, we get it. They're bad men. OK, let's move on. You're beating me over the head with this. Yeah, so we move on to Mikhail and Anastasia who are in bed and we get this whole like tell me who you are blah blah blah and Like she talks about like her magic and how it's always been there and he tells her again Like you just need to believe in yourself and I'm like, okay cool. Can we move on? Like this isn't actually a new conversation. We've been having it's just Framed new because now they've slept together.

Yeah But it doesn't add anything to their relationship, right? The only thing that we see at the end of this is Anastasia says quote, I am Anastasia Romanova and I'm going after my father with my magic. Okay, also just outside of any true history, your mom is really the problem. As far as your trauma in this book, as far as I know, right? Your dad is just like a goofball. That's like, I'm mad. Okay. But the only thing that I don't.

Okay. Yes. I'm going to yes. And you, yes. And you've had two, at least two opportunities to go after your dad with magic and you won't. And you chickened out at the last. So what is different about this to be public, I guess. good luck orchestrating that you're gonna have to leave your room to do that sweetheart and you don't like to do that you don't do that unless you're going to a boarding house for some reason yeah so they go into the town again and they find the innkeeper cool and she's the one that tells them that the newspapers

are full of this like scandalous love affair between this guy named Rasputin and this arena. And Anastasia's like, I know who Rasputin is. And she believes it hook, line and sinker and like literally runs away from him. Just give it a half second of thought and realize it was completely illogical. Right. And he like does that thing where he like gets in front of her and he like has his hands like on her face and he's like, listen to me, listen to me. You know, it's a lie. And she's like, it's not a lie. And I'm just the writing here is so Pat. Yeah, it's so flat. Because it could be so dramatic. Again,

you have the true history here. I don't know how, again, how obvious it was. Right. But like. You didn't lend me any reason to why she would believe this, except that she's an idiot. Right. Yeah, she's an idiot who's gullible and like is easily manipulated, which like, OK, great, because like this doesn't even last for long enough for it to feel like real. Like she's mad for. Five pages. And then at the end of this, she's like, I'll always choose you. Well, and again, you're relying on this landing because

the only reason why this would matter is if I'm rooting for them as a couple. Right. So then the threat is that they're going to break up. Right. I don't care. Right. Also. He's not relevant to her plan because they have no plan. So him not existing in her orbit means nothing to me. It means nothing. Yeah, because what you just said is true. The cost of this is that they break up. It's not the cost of this is that an evil czar doesn't get overthrown because they are an integral part of the rebellion, which would be a lot higher stakes than just this interpersonal

fluff. There's just no stakes. No stakes. Burn me alive if you have to. Okay, so the next, so they're at the inn, right? And then so this is so buck wild because the innkeeper, once they've stopped fighting, the innkeeper goes into like a trance -like state and starts channeling Aasia. Why? No reason. No! And like... Asya is basically telling Rasputin, like, she'll always come back,

like, just foster her magic, like, she'll be the downfall of the, you know, the Tsar. I couldn't think of that word to say in my fucking life. The Tsar, she'll be the downfall of the Tsar. All you need to do is love her. And the only thing that Mikhail can say is Asya, which you call your mom Asya's first name. If my dead mother started channeling through somebody that I knew, I'd be like, Mom? I would be like, Joyce? Joyce? That you, girl? Girl, hello. Yeah, Mom? Joyce,

like, if she did that to you, you'd be like, Joyce? Yes. Yes. If your mom started channeling through somebody, it would be weird because she's still alive. But I would be like, Julia, you good girl? Yeah. I'm not going to call my own mom by her name. Did you mean to call me? Like, how can I help? I guess. Sure. Yeah. So they go, that buckwild things happens. And then they go out into the city, which I think is supposed to be like visibly tipping into revolution. And like, I will give the author credit for trying

to show rather than tell. Yes. But like, the way that she does it is like, kids are literally tossing rifles between windows, like sharing arms or I guess. That and then people and dogs are fighting over like food And then yeah, and then the czars like motorcade blouse She does really try to show here and I think honestly it would work I wish we saw some of this earlier

though. I know I know and like I wish we saw some of this earlier. I wish that it mattered to like the characters that we're reading about in a material way. But it doesn't really. And the other wild thing about this, besides the love letters that were almost verbatim to what actually happened, the author pulls out the actual car, which was Nicholas II's actual preferred automobile. This real historical detail like correctly applied. I almost fell over. I was

like, this is not the book we're reading. That's what bothers me because where was that earlier in the story? Because that's honestly what I wanted. I wanted historical fiction, right? Which Traditionally, I don't like, but I like the Romanoff story. Right. See part one on the dedication of the 1996 or whatever year was Anastasia Disney. Give me that. Exactly. So this is crazy that now you're going to be historically accurate. Well, yeah. Now you're going to be historically accurate in a scene that makes fucking no sense because like, OK, just to be clear there in St.

Petersburg, Russia, which is a massive fucking city, even at the turn of century. Fine. Yeah. You're you're going to have me believe that. Anastasia and Rasputin were staying in an inn that are walking around and at that same place in the city Her dad's motor car comes careening around the corner doesn't wait for anybody to get out of the street and people are in the street even though they know that it's a street and He just plows into these people Where are you going girl? Where are you going? What was your point here? And then there's a shot that rings

out and I don't know where the other people in the czars like posse are his three no name people or or like literally anyone a soldier like are they all piled in the motorcade? Like is this a JFK situation? That's OK. That's the vibe I got. JFK situation, right? No, it's not but the shot rings out and I think it hits like a bystander and then the cars like literally running over people and so Anastasia like Explan leashes her magic because she's like innocent people are

dying Well, I don't understand the purpose of the czar to just like plow through just humans I just I don't I don't understand she so she does that but then like we don't get a payoff because the czar just like leaves and then like at a stage it has time to like go heal a boy who was shot in the leg. It's like a random kid that could have mattered later, but doesn't. Doesn't. I mean, just like the guy that she liked or the kid, not the guy, he's the child. They're all children. They're all children. She only heals children and Mikael. Just a country full

of children. There's no adults here. No. But the kid that she broke his collar or whatever, both of these people could have come back as interesting. But this book happens, one, within the course of maybe a month. Maybe. So we don't have time. But also, we just don't have the depth. No. So they go home. I just don't understand. Why would you keep going back to the past? Although you just saw your dad basically mass murder, vehicular manslaughter all over the place. You're

just going to. Go home? Because because he was he decided to drive down a street that was full of people. There are so many other streets, girl. So many. It's a big city. Why you don't have to be right here? No. Why are you in the slums anyway? It's fine. It's fine. So they go home, I guess. And I just like. Anastasia gives like a one line fixer. She's like. The Tsar is going to try to find me and he'll burn the city down to do so. So I'm just going to turn myself in."

And I'm like, I also factually don't believe that. I don't believe that. Also, you just exploded magic where your dad was and then he was the one that drove off. Like if he was really interested in finding you, he could have just like stepped out of the car. Yeah, he basically waved a flag. Right. So they're walking back to the palace. Snipers open up on them. Gunfire and Mikhail somehow realizes that he's the target and so he like pushes Anastasia out of the way offers himself up as bait and he yells back at Anastasia

quote I'll find you in the next life my Anya and I'm like, okay one don't fucking call me that she doesn't like that name She literally told you so many times. I don't call me on you I don't know why he thinks it's cute and why she has stopped correcting him. That's why it feels so toxic. Yes and also He's like, I'm just going to die. I'm just going to die. I'm so bored. Honestly, I kind of think this isn't on the page. But he does this fully knowing that she can just resurrect him. Yeah. Again, the stakes aren't

there. I know. I'll find you the next life in an hour when you bring me back from the dead. Like, yeah. Yeah. You think she's just going to leave you there? She's not. She's not. She's never going to let you die. Ever. Good luck. Good luck, Buttercup. Please let me die. So rather than leaving him for dead, she somehow uses this power that she now is an expert in using sometimes to wrap him in, like, a golden shield. And so, like, he's literally walking through the streets and the bullets are, like, ping, ping, ping,

like, bouncing off of the shield. Crazy. Truly crazy. And then they make it back to the castle and they're fine. OK. Great. So they go back to their room and the Tsar floods the room with soldiers and gives them an ultimatum. Like you have to take back your, you hit me publicly. You have to say you're sorry. You have to take communion and you have to bend to my will or I'll publicly execute you. Okay. Okay. Great.

So in this scene, obviously Anastasia and Mikhail slash Rasputin are not wanting to go willingly. fine. They're not good at it either. No. So and also there's like so many guards which could have happened at any point in time but I guess now the Tsar is like learning from his mistakes or something. The last three times he was threatened with a pistol now he's like maybe I should be protected. Maybe I should be protected. Maybe I should come in with like stronger firepower. So like the guards pull them apart and they put iron handcuffs on Anastasia which like completely

cut off her magic. which feels like something that should have come out before now. Yeah. And she like immediately crumples. She's like, you take my magic away, take it back. And Rasputin like goes to her, like he gets away from the guards or like because she doesn't have magic and he doesn't have a gun, the czar is like, fine, you can cuddle. And so. Rasputin cuddles anastasia and she's like he says quote. It's

still in you Anya It'll never leave end quote and I'm like again with the Anya again with the Anya. Yeah, it undermines everything. He says that could be Maybe cute, right? So then the other weird thing about this is that the czar and the soldiers just leave He's like you have a day to think about it Why why are you letting them be free to think about it? You can give them a day and put them in the fucking dungeon Actually, kill him, put her in the dungeon. You don't need him. You don't need him. You're letting him like he is such a big thorn in your side

at this point. I don't know why he's still around. Who's really in the plot of this story like Rasputin had a role. Cool. We don't he has no role here. He's just like a dude that was brought in to tutor her for her magic for some fucking reason. He's threatened you twice. He's just a guy with a gun. Why are you just letting him be? Because he's not in manacles or anything. He's just like there. Yeah. So they have this this period of time and Anastasia's in like physical body pain. Like her arms are on fire. She's clawing at the change until her fingers bleed. And you will

never guess what Rasputin decides to do. He's like, get this. I'm going to distract her with my dick. This will help. This will help. Also, she says something like it's trying to walk on a broken leg. Like she's in immense pain. Yep. He's like, I'm just going to put my dick in it. Yeah. It'll help, right? Is this anything? Is this anything? Yeah, so like... Ew. Ew, ew. Don't

fucking touch me unless you're gonna help me. I can't like, okay, but also like you're Rasputin. Can't you find a fucking file anywhere and start taking this off me? You're free. You can literally go anywhere. You can go to get something. Both of you can go into town where I'm sure they have like... Irons, what is it? A smithy. Yeah. With a flick forward, whatever. This is a solvable problem. You're choosing not to instead. You're just like, I'm going to, we're going to play with consent and handcuffs right now. When she's

in full body pain. Right. And like, I just, I can't even enjoy the scene because like one, it doesn't make sense. And it just feels so self -centered for him to be like, I want to get off. Well, he does this kind of like illusion of consent where he's like, we can stop if you want. But factually, I don't know if that's true in the way you're doing this. Right. Because she doesn't, to me in this scene, there's nothing about her that's like into this. Right. Well, and like

if you're so like. Out of your mind with pain that you're literally like clawing until at your chains until your fingers are bleeding Like are you really even able to focus on whether or not you want to do this? No, that's I'm saying like his like consent check. I think is bullshit, right? It's like it's like taking advantage of somebody who's not in a position to consent. Yes so then we have the scene and at the end of it Anastasia falls asleep with her like pain fever broken or whatever and Rasputin describes it as, quote, a well fucked expression that made

a primal part of Mikhail's chest swell up. Ew. It's disgusting. Yeah, it's really gross. I don't like it. And honestly, so like the mechanics in here of how he uses the chains as like bondage would be great in any other book. Yeah. And if she was in chains for any other reason. Right. And if they didn't hurt. Right. Yeah. So the next day the czar comes in and Anastasia and Michaela, I guess they have a why are they still there? Okay, I just don't understand. I won't

let it go. So They're like, okay great. We have this plan that we haven't been party to so we are learning about this in real time fine Anastasia's like yes, I'll marry him great Can you take my chains off now and his dad and daddy's like fine? Yeah, we can do that but then as soon as her chains are off she tries to use her magic and so like Her dad's like, yeah, I figured this was gonna happen So he has a shit plan a gun pointed at me at Rasputin and he's like don't

do this or I'll kill him and I'm like suddenly Suddenly actually care now you actually care also you could kill him and she would immediately like drop her magic because she can't do two things at once Exactly. You should just kill him, right? So she gets put new she gets put in new irons and these are worse somehow because they're made by an acolyte of Something I don't I don't know what a weird church that we've never really been introduced to right and then the czar starts torturing Rasputin for some reason

Which I don't I don't know why And he starts like opening up the kills old scars one by one personally So don't you have staff for this? I just don't know it would be brutal if I cared But it also doesn't make sense to me Yeah, I don't either and like the whole reason that he's doing this is to try to get Anastasia to like physically bow To him and she doesn't do it But at some point I guess the czar just gets bored and like has Mikhail dragged out and gone to

like the dungeons I don't know why that didn't happen 200 pages ago girl Sorry, I misspoke, not the dungeons. This is when he gets thrown to the mob outside the palace. Yes. Great. There's a mob outside the palace now. BT dubs. Cool. And so the Tsar's like, okay, well, you're going to watch the people kill your boyfriend and I'm going to make you watch from your room. I also, fine. Why would the people kill him? I don't know. I don't know. Essentially, he's of the people. Unless they're just like rabid animals

that are gonna kill anything that's thrown to them. I don't know That's what it that that is how it reads to me because there's no political underpinning for why it would be different No Like did recipe does it appear that restaurant has abandoned the rebellion because he's like in the palace now like give me a reason for them to be for Him to actually be in danger with the people right and was he ever a part of the rebellion to begin with because I don't think he was no Because he was just like in a church and he was here, right? so Anastasia watches this happen, which okay Is kind of wild because like she is now able to see like the gates of the palace

from her window. And to me, that's a new detail. Yeah, I wish we had that before because like if I pictured her as like in like kind of a backwater part of the palace, right? Because she's like the secret that they're trying to like hide. Yeah, like I just I don't. It felt weird that it felt like her room physically changed, moved. Well, especially because if you can see this, then I don't understand how you've spent so much time in this room, and I still don't have any idea of what's going on outside the palace. Exactly. Because I could have had that the whole time if you've been watching. Right. The press of

the mob could have been this thing. And then if your room is right there, how are you sneaking out? If everybody's drunk or in church, but there's a mob outside, how are you getting out? Just pass them. You just don't get it. Casually. So she's forced to watch this. The czar is like, like talking to the mob. And it's like, I have a victim. He is evil. And the crowd's like, yeah. And so he pushes Rasputin out on onto the ground,

like gives him to the mob. And the mob just starts beating him up for some reason. Yeah. Cool and like we we are told quote the last of the light left his eyes, which to me says that he dies I thought he dies which was then really disconcerting when he's not quite dead yet later in the book It should be like the light dimmed in his eyes, right? so Anastasia sees This happen and like she'd like loses her shit. She throws herself

against the window screaming out for Rasputin and it feels like I couldn't tell if there was an earthquake or like a pressure bomb, but like she breaks every window in the Winter Palace at once. Yeah, just with her sheer anger. Right. And so the crowd takes this to mean that God is upset with them. But but okay. Okay. This is the thing that I didn't understand because it's it's it's like Anastasia is part of this but like she broke all of the windows She could

speak to the crowd, but she's not speaking to the crowd. Yeah, she just goes back inside and talks to the guards For some reason and I'm like if you're Anastasia I would fly out of that window to my man get my man's get my man's and save him right talk to the crowd That's not what she's just gonna take the stairs inside or something which like then why did you even have this temper tantrum? Why did you break the window girl? I don't understand So like I said, Anastasia turns around to the guards that are in her room, I guess. She frees herself from the irons that are literally melting off of her skin. She has this burst of a cloud of gold and then passes

out. Cool. OK. I don't know why she passes out. I wish she wouldn't. We also get some additional misspellings or respellings. Yeah. Do you want to call those out? Yeah. So she, again, names herself with her middle name. I'm Anastasia Nicole Avena. Nicole I don't know how to say her name. I don't either but It's well, she said this a couple times and that middle name gets misspelled twice in this back half when it was spelled correctly earlier and it's just I Understand that these

are Russian names put a lot of these a lot of vowels But it just doesn't it seems like something that you should easily catch as editing your own book that you should know how to spell your own character's name Yeah, or don't put her middle name in there I don't need her middle name or don't put a Russian word in there that you're not quite sure about Exactly, or at least if you're not sure about it spell it wrong every time. Yeah, honestly It just feels it just feels sloppy and it's honestly disappointing. Yeah, I agree So like I said, it turns out that Mikhail's not dead Rasputin is not dead Which is fucking

wild because the last light of his eyes went out. He seems dead to me Asya makes another appearance and her voice tells him that Anastasia is alive and free and he has to go get her. Cool. And then Jesus, like a man comes through. And I think we're supposed to know who this person is, but I don't. No, it's unclear. It's like a rando. Right. And he lies to people. He's like, this is not Rasputin. This guy's name is Mikhail. And I'm like, OK. Sure. Sure. Why are people

listening to you? And also, why do people care who he is, one way or the other? Right. And so they spend this time trying to get... The people have stopped beating up Mikhail. But they spend this time arguing about whether Mikhail is Rasputin. And even Mikhail is like, I'm not Rasputin. Rasputin doesn't exist. And I'm like, this is not what I would be spending my time on. No, it's not really what's going on right now. Well, and why can't you just say, I am Rasputin, but what they say about me is a lie? Yeah. Okay. That would

be great. Move on. What are we doing about it? And also like, what's the point? Yeah. So Mikhail like gets free of these people. They're like, okay, cool. Sounds good. He goes into the palace, which is now on fire and actively being looted. When was it set on fire? Just, I don't know. When was it starting to be, when did they lose control? When did they cross the gates? Yeah. Cause I thought giving them Mikhail was sort of like here. Have a snack. Right. Well, and

then like she broke all of the windows and she made the sonic boom boom happen. And they were like, oh, my God, it's an act of God. He's mad at us, which to me was like, oh, everything. Let's go home. Let's go home. Yeah. Not let's storm the castle. Right. So Mikhail finds Anastasia like in the ballroom. Like magic pouring off of her like. She's not passed out anymore. She's also cackling like a psychopath. She's also about

to be attacked by one of those noble guys and is suddenly good at killing people. And fine with it. And fine with it. They get this reunion, it's supposed to be funny, it just doesn't make sense. And then they're overtaken by a band of teenage revolutionaries. And they're there to take Anastasia into custody because she's part of the monarchy. Obviously. Okay. And so the wild thing about this is that there are a bunch of teenagers. She has magic. Like, Mikael has

a gun at this point. Raspbian has a gun at this point. And Anastasia's like, don't hurt them. I'll go. And girl, do what? Right, like, what is your... If you kill them here or kill them there, like, you're gonna have to kill somebody. And you were ready, so, like, now you're just gonna go with them? What is your plan here? Right. So they're taken actually to the Czar's private chambers where the Czar and the Czarina aren't there. They're just kind of chilling. They're totally just chilling. We learned that the Czarina

sent Alexi away with money before the gates broke. When did the gates break? I don't know. Also, where's Alexi been this entire time? Who gives a shit? No one. Alexi left Anastasia to rot. Who cares? So a leader who we don't know, a revolutionary leader shows up and is like, okay, dude, you can either surrender as a prisoner of a new state or die, your choice. And the czar says, I will never surrender and tries to like lunge for Rasputin again with a shard of glass. Okay. And Anastasia

grapples him down to the ground with her magic. He drops the shard of magic. She picks it up and drives it into his heart, which is It's vicious for like no reason. It's vicious for no reason. And I just really would have appreciated if like they were like in a firing line and as they were walking out, they heard the bangs. Yeah, that would have been way better. Yeah. Yeah. We are told that like one of the revolutionary people like does shoot him again, just for good measure. Fine. Cool. And then the siren is like, what

about me? Literally, that's a quote. Shut up. And so they're like, they're basically like, I'm sure you'll get something. But then like Anastasia and Raspoon are just allowed to leave. Which I still don't understand. Why would the rebellion think that they're cool? There's been no communication between these different factions. And that's what doesn't land here. It's like, there's chapters missing. Yeah, there's chapters missing. And like, I just, why would they, like they should die too? They should die too, right?

At least Anastasia. at least her and like we don't even get like a hand wavy like you're cool yeah you can go they just kind of trust you right so then we get this weird clothes like they they go out a side door of the palace which feels like they're trying to sneak away and i don't know why they're trying to sneak away who are they sneaking from it's weird because like mckayle's like do you want to grab anything and anastasia's like quote let it all burn mckayle let it all burn and i'm like okay but you need money Neither

of you know how to get a job in like jewels or stuff. You can sell something Something right and then we get this epilogue and there it's one year later I did not need the epilogue there in the French Riviera that they can somehow afford With none of the things that they took from the palace just on her name alone Okay, but this is also a direct contradiction because they they say that they sold gems that anesthesia snuggle smuggled out in her clothes And I'm like so you did take something When did you sew gems into

your clothes? Because you took the time to sew them in and find the gems, instead of just, let it all burn, Mikael. And why were you sneaking out? Like, you just walked out of a room that you were being held prisoner in. Also, like, you killed the bad guy. I don't... No one knows what happened to your mom, I guess, in the old history. You had time. Like, you didn't have to flee. You didn't have to sneak out. You didn't have to sneak out. No. For some reason. I don't understand why. Or, I mean, maybe you did, but we didn't get a reason. Yeah. So okay, we just okay usually I would be down for this But it's

it's literally just an epilogue to show them in their new life and we do get a sex scene But the sex scene is terrible. It's really terrible and suddenly we have this like weird Dom sub relationship There were no seeds planted of that before unless you talk about him like basically nagging her with not calling her her name And it's weird. It's weird. And he ostensibly went for a swim or something. And one of the things

that starts the scene, and he's like, how many times did you touch yourself without me? How long were you gone? I know. Because she said something like four or five. And I'm like, were you gone for a couple of days? Because it felt like you were gone for maybe an hour. You ran to the store. How many times did you touch yourself without me? OK. This is not the kind of book this has been. This character isn't that Randy to be like getting off the second you leave the room. Yeah, I just. I hate it. This is so weird.

It was. This felt like the author wrote a fanfic of her own characters. Right. And like it started out, she just took the names from. Yeah. The Romanov Anastasia thing. It was just like, I'm just going to put this here. Yeah. So yeah, that's the book. I couldn't tell you why we're here. I still don't understand the plot. Yeah. So maybe let's go through, let's go through our ratings so we can have a structured conversation about

this. So let's get into it. I don't think we've, I mean spoilers, we don't recommend this. I don't think we've not recommended a book in a long time. In a really long time. I also don't think we've had like, spoilers for our reviews, ones down the board. Ones, ones, ones across the board. I feel like even Rise of a Dark Throne had a two. Yeah, yeah. Maybe we're just getting meaner. Maybe, I could be. I definitely am meaner postpartum,

so. I'm just... 35 now. All of my fucks are gone. It's 2026, guys. Have you looked at the planet? I ran out of stickers. I ran out of stickers. OK, so let's get into the spice level. How do we rate that? We rated it a 1. Oh. Oh. Oh. We get three scenes, but OK, I'm going to start with the broadest one first. I've never bought their relationship, so the scenes don't land for me. Like, I want the chemistry. I want the communication. This author tries to give that to us, but. There's no buy -in so I don't care,

right? So the first thing is the only one that's like maybe kind of okay The second scene feels like a rape scene to me and the third scene doesn't make sense for these characters at all, right? Yeah, so none of them are enjoyable Yeah, I mean there's that and then there's also like the weird logisticizing of it Like not only are there things that like don't actually make sense like physically Yeah, but there's also things that don't make sense for like how you got into the scene Yeah, it's like they're just kind of in a room together, then suddenly they're banging. Yeah, so the in -context things just kind of are jarring. You

don't have this nice, slow buildup. It's like being thrown into a cold pool. Yes, it is very bad. That you weren't expecting. Yes. And the timing doesn't make sense. The time that they have sex, they should be doing other things. Well, yeah, I mean, like trying to get the fuck out of a palace. Yeah. Just like, OK. So going into writing style, we also rated this a one. And I think it comes down to like two things for me, really. Now, I'm going to say I'm going

to throw a third in there. So the first one is like the misspellings, right? Like I'm going to call them misspellings because I don't I'm not familiar with Russian. And if it was like intentional because you're like conjugating Russian words like. you should make that clearer in some way. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Like just an aside, like this way because there's more of them, this way because there's one of them, this way because they're not all male, like whatever it is. Yeah, because that could be what it is, but it reads like a misspelling. Right. The second thing which

is related is like the inconsistent application of Russian words, like make them all italicized or don't. Yeah. Because it seemed arbitrary, and it took me out of the jantasy, and I just don't. It took away from the story rather than adding to it, and I really don't like that. Yeah. And then the third thing is just stylistically, this book only happens in two places. Yes. It feels like you're inside of a paper cardboard

box. With cardboard characters. With cardboard characters. It's just not. well -executed. No. I also have a fourth thing. And this didn't come up in part two as egregiously. But there's times when perspective would shift mid -sentence or mid -paragraph, which was really jarring, where it would be like, from. His mom's point of view and then suddenly it's like Mikhail could still hear the screams who was talking right? And that was very jarring like I would have to be like, I don't know who's doing what in the scene Well,

and like the author wanted you to know what everybody was thinking all the time without really being omnipotent though, right? There was the other thing that I wanted to call out here. So really, I guess there's five things. The fifth thing is the thing where she does like the mirror. Oh, the mirror language every like she does it a lot. And it's just it's this book isn't tongue in cheek enough to make that work now. But it's like, like the example that we pulled out in part one, but that is one of many examples was a man could die happy looking at a face like

that or something. And then she says, oh, a woman could die happy looking at an ass like that or whatever it is. Yeah, same page, different perspective, same verb, like exact same words, which like. is annoying on the surface for a book that's not tongue in cheek when they're saying it out loud yeah when the characters are not saying it out loud and they're just making those remarks in their internal monologue that the other one doesn't hear and then the other one says the exact same thing and their internal monologue that's fucking weird that's weird and there's a place for that in some books particularly books that do have that tongue in cheek self -awareness correct or there's a place for like poetry of

that like i think there were like I can't call any out. But I feel like there is a good example of that in Guild, where you get the same vibe from both of them, which just kind of lends their connection. This just felt lazy. Yeah. Or like you were trying to be funny, but it doesn't fit in what you're giving me. Exactly. Yeah. I think it could have been better if we leaned into that campiness. Yeah. But we didn't. So here we are. Which brings us to quality of storytelling. How do we rate that? We also gave this a one. No. This story just doesn't make any sense. Nope.

I can't even begin to just there's truly no plot. Like if I were to make a drawn word map of this plot, I wouldn't have one. I have a circle that has these characters that have no plan the whole time. Yeah. And it's illogical. So we mentioned like the czar. Mikhail threatens the czar with a gun at least twice, and he's just allowed to exist in the czar's home freely. Yeah. And. Those are who's a sensibly the villain ceases to exist when he's not on the page, right? So there's

no like external machinations Which if you're gonna write a political politically driven story, which this is historical fiction in some respects. I Need that I need to care. Mm -hmm Yeah, there's no beginning middle end like no there's it happens in three rooms Like we met like we mentioned sorry two rooms the palace and an inn in an instantly that they just kind of go to right like it the mechanics of how people interact don't make sense like It's just flat. Yeah. Also, you set it up. This is an overarching thing, but the story set

up in that Anastasia, this family has magic that will somehow bring down the family. I'm still not convinced that that's what happened. Anastasia's magic isn't even relevant. It's not relevant. And like, I mean, the whole, if you want to call it a climax, like when ostensibly the Tsar gets overthrown and the palace gets overrun, I'm not even sure how that happened. No, like there was a mob at the gates for some reason. Anastasia broke all the windows and then passed out. And then at some point, the plebeians got into the

castle. Like, I just don't what happened. I I don't know what happened. Also, you I had the first half of the book thinking that the Zarina was really the villain because the czar really fact functionally didn't exist in the first half. Right. But then he's the bad guy in the second half and mom ceases to exist. Right. When she's allowed to live. As far as we know it. Yeah. Yeah, but like she was the one that was trying to control slash get her magic to manifest unclear, which also doesn't make sense why she would want

that if magic is the downfall. Right. And then the czar was the one that was like met with all magic. Very bad. No good. And then was like, actually magic. Very useful. You weapon for me. And I'm like, oh, what the fuck? Which I know there's some prophecy again where her magic brings down the Romanovs. Show me that what happened to that what happened to that? I like functionally you didn't I mean, okay fine If you want to make the argument that she killed her father fine great that that that doesn't mean that she's the downfall of the Romanovs also But I don't think with her magic she used a shard of glass.

Yeah, she could be a person girl. Oh my god, so We don't recommend this book. No at all at all I really hate saying something like that because I want all offers to be successful and I want to like be supportive of the craft, but like This is just hard to read, and it's not interesting. And I personally found it flat, boring, confusing. I did not enjoy it. Yeah. And it is still possible, like we say at the top, maybe it just wasn't for us. But I feel pretty strongly about our criticism in here.

Yeah. So again, that's our opinion. Do with that what you will. Do with that what you will. If you loved it, let us know. Cool. Anyway, we did it. Those are our thoughts on the Romanoff Oracle by Molly Toulouse. Thank you as always for joining us on this journey. Let us know what you thought on the socials. You can find us on TikTok, YouTube and Goodreads, the Spice Readers' pod. And if you like our podcast and want more, consider becoming a patron where we release patron exclusive episodes on our off weeks. That's also where we continue any series, like we said, at the top of the show. So if you really, really like us, drop us a review wherever you listen. But until next time, we'll see ya. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Irresistible Urge to Fall for Your Enemy By Brigitte Knightley Part 1

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Surrendering to Scylla by Wren K Morris

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Threshing Day by Rebecca Yarros

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Court of Heathens by K. A. Knight

    Sep 29, 202652 minAudio

    Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Under Loch and Key by Lana Ferguson Part 2

    Sep 21, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/

    Credit the people on this episode