This week we jump into the witchy world of The Coven by Harper L. Woods! Is it a fun student/teacher romance? Yes! Does it have great vampire smut? Also yes! Is it high literature? Absolutely not! This is part 1 of 2. Triggers: Dubious consent, forced feeding, graphic violence, rough and explicit sexual content, forced proximity, betrayal, references to past abuse and traumatic reactions to triggering stimuli, knife violence, graphic depictions of blood, physical harm inflicted upon the main character, ritualistic murder Tropes: Vampires, student/teacher KU: Yes! Recommendation: Both traders recommend! https://www.adelaideforrest.com/#/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey friends, just a quick reminder before we get into today's episode, come join us over on our Patreon. That's where we release bonus episodes every other week and we've already got over 20 episodes from 2023 that you can download and binge right now for as little as $3 a month. We've covered so many good books there, Haunting Adeline, Chateau, Gathakanna, and so many more. That's also where we'll cover any books in a series we continue, so Serpent in Dove, High Mountain Court, Serpent in the Wings of Night. You can continue those series with us on Patreon right now.
Finally, as a patron, we let you know what we're going to read every month so you can read along with us if that's your jam. Anyway, that's all from me, on to today's episode. So yeah girl, what do you think about this book? Oh my god, okay so we've read some really shitty books and we've read some really good books but this book feels like a different sort of brush or freth air? Yeah? A brush or freth air? A different sort of breath of fresh air?
Well we have our cold open, amazing. Totally the cold open air. Welcome to Your Safe Space, the podcast your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books, want to understand the jokes and the tics-tics, we got you fam. We're the spice traders and we deal in spicy books. I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning.
You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes so please check those out. Also we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex. If you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip. Secondly, we talk about books, the whole book, nothing but the books that helped me goddess. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time. The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes.
Okay, so Liz, what are we talking about today? Today we're talking about the Coven by Harper L. Woods. This is a pseudonym used by the author Adelaide Forrest. So those are the same person. If you've seen books by one, they're books by the other. We will refer to Harper L. Woods as that is the name she published The Coven Under. This was published in 2023 and it is the first in a series with at least one other book, The Coven of Bones.
This book is 298 pages long so that's a midi for us. Now this cover, when I first looked at it, I thought it was going to be really cheesy of a book. I don't know why. Something about the cover just like didn't do it for me at first. I think it's the magic mirror on the wall with these like skelly hands on it. So everything about the cover. Yeah. Okay, so basically the cover is black.
There's some rose petals. There's this circular frame and skelly hands. Just skeleton hands up against it. I think it's the skelly hands that upset me because they just look like cheap Halloween decoration to me. They don't look spooky. Yeah, that's it for me. Yeah. And I understand why they're there but they don't look good. No, I think maybe they're too small in relation to this frame.
Like they give me the tiny hand vibe. You know when TikTok people use like the tiny hands? Yes. That's what I feel. I feel the opposite. I feel like they're too big. I feel like the mirror is too small and I don't know what they're trying to do with the mirror. It's like they're scraggling against it and I would prefer them to be like holding the mirror if it's truly that big of a mirror or that small of a mirror. That's true. Holding it would be better but they're really just like pressed up against it. Right. That's weird, catty corner.
It's just and again, I'm not even sure it's a mirror. It's a mirror. It appears at the end of the book. Oh, well I'm not there yet. Yeah. And like I understand why the bones are there like the skeleton hands. We'll find out pretty quickly as we get into the book why, why, but not my favorite thing. It's not my favorite thing. The scale is off. That's the thing because when we get to the purpose of the Skelly hands and I'm just going
to call them Skelly hands. Yeah. I'm here for that in the book. Like it's creepy. It's great. It's well described. Just on the cover. It just looks like tiny hands. All right. So, Katie, take it away. So we're going to be breaking this book into two parts. So this is going to be part one. We're just going to cover chapters one through 20. So let's get into it. This book is on Kindle and limited and you know how I feel about that. I love that. So if you are a KU girly, this one is effectively free.
That's how I think about it. I know that's not true, but, but it feels free. Also we talked about this in our debrief, but I can forgive a lot of, a lot of issues when we have good trash. Having it be on KU also makes me far more forgiving. Oh, 100%. Yeah. Because I haven't spent an individual $7. Exactly. Okay, so before we get into the book, we get a pretty long trigger warning list. So check those out there in our show notes. But I do want to read kind of like what this author says about this book.
She says, quote, the Coven is a dark paranormal romance with gothic vibes in a dark academia setting. The male lead in this series is pushy, domineering and manipulative. He goes beyond my typically morally gray antihero and is in my opinion an actual villain who gets his happily ever after. And I thought this was interesting. I was like, I want to see you write an actual villain that I root for. Me too. And I got to say, I think she's nailing it. I think she's nailing it too, but also I'm kind of getting like big marshmallow vibes
a little bit for some of the things that he does. So I had that thought even at the halfway point, which is where we're going to cover, he doesn't strike me as a villain. Not really like we'll get to it, but they strike a deal where he essentially is like, I'm going to be for the betterment of the Coven like, bro, you're not a villain. Yeah. And like even so spoilers, I have finished the book and I'm going to do my best to like cover part one without giving too much away. But there there are like, that's one of the things. But then like the other one where like she like depletes herself and like he sends her
food the next day. Like, I know. I. But anyway. So let's get into it. We start with a prologue and this prologue is about a dude named Alaric Grayson Thorn, who is our female, no, our male main character. There we go. And I'm just going to refer to this dude as Gray from here on out. Listen, I feel like a big fucking idiot because I read this prologue.
I read his whole name. I have multiple notes that are like, is Alaric Thorn and Gray the same person? Why does he go by Gray? Where does Gray come from? And now I realize it's his middle name and I'm just stupid. But you're so pretty. Thank you. And then, okay. And then we get to the part where she's like, what's your true name? He's like, I'm not going to tell you. And I'm like, bitch, is it Gray? Because she's already calling you that. And now I just realized that I'm just all sorts of wrong. It would have been funny if he was like Alaric Grayson Thorn.
I feel like that would have fit his sass, actually. Wow, I'm dumb. Cool. Cool, cool, cool, cool, cool. Anyway, so Gray is going to see the ruling body of a school named Hollow Grove University and this dude is the headmaster for that school. Hollow Grove University is a witches school and it becomes clear pretty quickly that Gray is also a vampire. So he talks about how the school has fallen into disrepair since it's not been inhabited
by students or anybody else in the last 50 years. It also becomes clear that the school is ruled by something supernatural. So it's a dyad and they are called the Covenant. They are named Susanna Medeza and George Collins and these were two witches who died a long time ago. But rather than staying dead, they were raised again and their spirits now reside in literally their skeletons. Hence the Skellyhands. Hence the Skellyhands. So I understand where the Skellyhands come from.
I can still not like them. Exactly, exactly. I thought the representation of the ruling body of the school was very interesting and I love the idea of having these like alive skeletons just hanging out. Because they also teach classes. They exist, they clock around with their little Skelly feet. I thought it was really interesting too and the way we're introduced to them is they're like in this...it's not a basement.
And it's like dark place and they're like all shawled and very spooky. Which is a really great image we get. But then like I said, they also just exist in the school. Like they teach classes. Right, and I just love how the author is so consistent about that because she talks about the clicking of their bones on the floor as they walk and things like that. Exactly, or like them being their skulls, right? But then the narrator will say like, I felt like she smiled, but can you smile if you
don't have a mouth? Right. Or like she'll talk about feeling the gaze, but they don't have eyeballs that's just kind of a feeling you get. Yep, yep, nope, I like that a lot. So the Covenant has summoned the Headmaster to talk about reopening the school. So I'm personally still unclear whether they're reopening it to the outside because the school exists in a magical place called Crystal Hollow, which is basically like it exists in the real world as we would recognize it, but it's like warded from people who aren't magical.
Or if they're just reopening it, period, and there hasn't been students because when Gray is walking these halls, he's like, man, it's really dusty in here, right? So that implies to me that nobody's been there. Exactly, and that continued to be a question I had. Like did you reopen this? Or just to outside? I think it's just to outsiders, but I don't, I don't, I really don't know. Yeah, I feel like, I don't know. The impression that I get is that it's just to outsiders, but it's not clear.
It's almost like the author decided one thing and then changed horses in the middle of a stream. And so we get impressions that both things are true. It's been dusty, nobody lives there. The Covenant in this conversation says something to the effect of, oh, witches have been left to learn magic in the comfort of their own homes for 50 years, right? But then later in the book, we'll have our main character Willow talk about how she and these other students from outside of Crystal Hollow are the only ones that are missing
on the context here that all of these other students who have been going to the school get. Yeah, and that, this is one of a few instances where we get information that just kind of opens up for more questions. 100%. The other thing that has me questioning this is because the person that leads Gray into this chamber is a witch student herself. Yes. So, regardless, it doesn't really matter, but it's one of those holes in the story that you can find at Lantus Inn. It's fine. It's fine.
I'm going to tell you right now, there's a lot of these and there's also like some challenging issues, I'll say, where just like words were meant to be and they're not. Yeah. It doesn't detract from the fact that I enjoyed this book and I read at the top of my lungs to get through it. Same. Like I have a lot of questions and concerns that will come up, but I had a great time. Yeah, same.
So the Covenant goes on to say that they, the school, need fresh blood and Gray asks whether they have concerns about whether they're going to have a repeat of what happened the last time that they opened the school and he alludes internally to us about a massacre that happened 50 years ago. The last thing we learn is that vampires require the blood of witches to live in this world and that they have some kind of pact with the witches to that effect. So it's in here where we get some a line that really confuses me because they have been
made aware of another witch who needs to come to this school. Great. But there's a line that says that Gray says then surely she can merely attend next year. If she's 16, she's far too young to begin at Hollow's Grove for another four years, but it also says that they have to be 20 to attend. So I'm like, so is she 16? And if it's next year and then if it's four years, like is she 16? Is she 20? What does that mean to me? I think she's 20 because I think what the Covenant means, which is very convolutedly
stated is that, or I guess Gray says that line. Yeah. And the other thing is that you have to be 20 to enter. So if this person is 16, then they have four years to extend the invitation. Okay. So, okay, that makes sense. But then there's a part that like, then surely she can merely attend next year. I'm like, but then she would only be 17. So she still can't attend. And it just, So she has to be 20 or not. Right. And that's what confused me. And so the other way that I worked it out in my head was the Covenant says another has
made herself known to us. So in my head, she's 20. I'm going with her 20. And we get some brief one liners about like when you come of age. So in my head, you come of age at 16, but that would be like made known to you. However, she's in hiding, which we'll get to. And it just, this was the question that like stuck in my head for a while for like three chapters. And finally, I noticed like, I don't know why this is fucking with me so much. It just felt really convoluted.
Like if she's 16, she can come next year and you can't be here till your 20. So we have four years. I'm like, what? It just, yeah, it really bothered me. And I just had to say it. Yeah. I mean, I think the other thing too is like, so I had questions about that later when we meet her roommates because her roommates have been attending the school. And so like, I don't actually know how old our protagonist is Willow.
She is at least 20, I think. But I think she might actually be older than that because all of, like if we assume that everybody in the school is 20 when they start, her roommates have attended the school before because they help her to class, right? They know what the fuck is happening and classes started that day. So when did they learn about classes probably when they attended before, which again, the school was it open? So was it open or not? And so I think they're probably in their like second or third year because these people have like experience and Willow doesn't.
But I don't know. Okay, great. I'm glad that you had a question too because I was just like, and I know it, it doesn't fucking matter, but it does matter a little bit because we've said this in other episodes. I don't want to read about a 16 year old having sex. That's the thing. I just math it in my head where, okay, she's homegirls at least 20. Yeah. Great. Great. Sign me up. I'm here for that. Yeah. It's just like really fucked with me because I read that sentence six times and I was like, what?
I'm sorry. What is happening in the planet? Like, what? I think you're right that she's older than 20 because she also talks about like the legacy is attending class together in the same age or whatever. So she's got to be like 22, 23 also, I guess. It was just a terrible sentence and it fucked me up for like four chapters. I wish it wasn't there because you're so right. It is one of those things. It's like, why did you tell me this?
Exactly. Because it doesn't, it doesn't matter. No, it doesn't matter. I mean, look, I'm not here in this particular story for the plot because we talked about this in our debrief, but it's worth saying here that we've read good books and we've read bad books. It's rare that we read a book that threads that line that you have when you read something like fan fiction or just really trashy smut. This book has a plot. I'm interested in the world, but it reads like trashy smut fanfic.
And so like, I know that the trash is right around the corner and so I'm reading at the top of my lungs to get there because I know it's going to be good because that's what this book is existing for. Exactly. Exactly. So I was a little perturbed that immediately I had this wrench thrown into my trash and I'm like, get the fuck out of here with that. Yeah. You're trying to apply like guild levels of world crafting onto this story when she's just not there. I know. It's just what really bothers me.
I'm going to let it go, I promise. But it's in the first fucking chapter and I'm like, no. What? I'm starting off real good. But it doesn't matter. We have to move on. I know. I've let it go. I've let it go. I won't break it up again. We're only half an hour into this. I'm so sorry. I am Liz and I'm hyper critical. Look, just living up to the promise. Okay. Listen, I deliver. You're consistent for sure.
Okay. So two months later, we're introduced to our female main character Willow and it's worth noting at this point that this book is told from first person perspective, alternating between Willow and Gray, which I love. Willow is at the funeral of her mother with her little brother Ash. As they look down into their mother's casket, Willow can hear the townspeople behind her whispering about them. It's clear that all of the townspeople were wary of her mother thinking her a witch and in that thought they would be right. Willow grabs the necklace around her mother's throat and she and Ash go to leave.
She's like, let's blow this popsicle stand on the way out. They are costed by a random dude who says that it's customary to remain so that the townspeople can pay their respects and offer condolences. And Willow tells him, when have I ever cared about your customs? So immediately off the bat, Willow has a backbone. I really like her as a character. I do too. She's a little pithy and she knows who she is. She presents much more like, that's why I think she's actually older than 20 because
she presents much more as like at least mid 20s. Yeah, she does. The way that she carries herself, the way that she responds to the world very much. We also don't know how long the school takes point of order. So that's really kind of weird because they're essentially going to college. Like do you graduate when you're like 35? I look. It doesn't matter. It doesn't matter. It's fine. So they move on and they leave and as they do so, we get a little bit of information about
the magic in this world. One of the characteristics of magic in this world is that if it's not used, it will burn up the person within whom it resides. And that is apparently part of what happened to Willow's mother. She was in hiding and now that she is dead, the words that she put in place to hide her Willow and her brother Ash will come down. We also learned that it is customary, particularly for witches like Willow and her mother, green witches, to be buried in the dirt without any casket or anything so that their body can be taken back into their element.
To that end, her mother's ex-partner, ex-husband, anyway, it's Willow's father, will dig up her mother's casket and make sure that she's brought out of it and buried on top of the casket so that she can go back to the earth, essentially. The last bit of information we get is that Willow has very strange eyes. She has one that is amber-colored and one that is violet-colored. My note was, why do they always have to have purple eyes? Dude, the purple eyes is starting to become a trope in and of itself.
Purple eyes or purple hair? Just like, come on. Like, there are other colors. Is this because it's the one color that like isn't in eyes? I don't fucking know. Cerulean. Cerulean! Cerulean! Cerulean! Cerulean! Okay, but beyond the colors of the eyes, I did, okay, okay, wait, let's just, I'm going to reverse really quick. How were the eyes not a dead giveaway to literally every witch she's ever met? I don't know. That is a really good question. That is a great, no one looks at her that closely, Katie.
I guess not. Jeez. I don't know. It's like a husky. Like, wouldn't you like see it from across the room? Really notice that? Nope. All right. Anyway, I really like the magic in this world. I think it's really well done for a book that reads like a trashy smut novel. Indeed. It's really cool. What did you think about it? I thought it was really well done. I really will get more into how the magic works and looks, but it was really well described
and developed. I'm excited to learn more in subsequent books, the other sex of witches and like how those come into play, but the way her magic is described, it's really beautiful and eerie and like the author does a really good job. Yeah. And I thought it was really unique. I don't think we've read anything that has this take on magic. No, it was really unique. And that's where this book treads this weird line of trashy fanfic smut, but also some
like pretty good world building sometimes. It's a very interesting take on all of it, but I did find the magic system, it made sense because that is an easy thing to mess up. And I was underpressed. Yeah. And I think that's why I can forgive some of these other things like how long is the school? How old are these people? Like I can forgive those because the big things in this book, the author got right. Exactly, which is very impressive. So when they get back home, Willow tells Ash to pack his things and get ready to meet his father at the bus station.
Willow has Ash convinced that she will go with him to live with Ash's father and his new family. It's clear in this conversation that Willow is very much aware of what she is and of what their mother was, but Ash has been kept in the dark. Though he is a witch, he will not come into his powers for a while. So this is what we were talking about earlier with the coming of age. And we're given to understand that this is around 16-ish. Willow knows that she must leave her brother alone. They must split up so that she can continue to protect Ash from the Covenant since that's
what their mother was hiding from all these years. And so that she can move on and fulfill this plan that she's been alluding to in her head. Next we get a yield perspective shift to Gray, and he is again before the Covenant and the Tribunal. So the Covenant are those eerie skeletons. They are a part of the Tribunal, which is the ruling body of the school. And the Tribunal is made up of 12 witches, plus the two skeleton people. And the 12 ruling witches are essentially one from each colored house of which.
We'll get into that a little bit more. Anyway, the Covenant tell Gray that they have selected two new students from each of the houses from outside of Crystal Hollow, but there is one more that they need him to collect personally. So far, they've collected two new whites, purples, grays, blues, reds, and yellows from outside the magical barrier surrounding Crystal Hollow. And again, Crystal Hollow is the town in which the school is set. So let's talk about the witches. So whites, purples, grays, blues, reds, and yellows. We don't really get a whole lot of description about what each of these do.
And I'm realizing now that there's a little bit of a discrepancy here because we talk about brown witches later and that they're not included in this. Oh, you're right. Um, anyway, so white witches, magic crystals, purples, magic, cosmos, blues, we're given to understand are water, yellow is fire, red is lust, and I think grays, which is supposed to be browns, are kind of like green witches, which is nature. Yeah, that really confused me.
Yeah. Well, hmm. And then whites, what were whites? Crystals. Crystals. Crystals and rocks and stuff. But not earth because that's brown slash green slash gray. Yeah. Well, so I know I was what I was going to say is I feel like greens can like commune with like the living plants and things. And maybe browns is just like literally the dirt, but then she also uses dirt.
So I don't know. I don't. There's no way to know. It doesn't matter. Anyway, gray is given a file and when he opens it, he sees Willow staring back out at him in a surprise that she exists at all. She shares the last name Medeza, the same as Susanna. And it is clear that she is Susanna's great, great, great, however many great granddaughter and continues a line of green witches that were thought to be extinct. Just as Willow and her mother were prepared after her mother's death, Willow's existence
became known because her mother's wards failed. It's clear in this conversation that the covenant wants Willow to attend the school and this desire is not optional for Willow. Nope. And this shocks Gray because he says everything is based on consent in the school quote from breeding to feeding, they consented every step of the way, even if they had to twist circumstances to gain that consent, they did what they had to do to ease their guilty conscience with lies. And I thought that this was a little odd because as we will see later, there is not a lot of
consent happening in some of the things that unfold in this book. No, there's hardly any consent ever anywhere. So again, that's just a weird thing for you to say to me and then consistently illustrate otherwise. And immediately illustrate otherwise. Even in this conversation, it's contradictory because he's like, oh no, it's all consent based, but I'm going to force her to come. Also why does he have to go personally? It doesn't matter.
So I think because Willow is Susanna's great, great granddaughter, she doesn't want any room for error. That's okay. That makes sense. Like of all of the things in this situation, that was the thing that I had the least amount of questions about. No, you're right. I also didn't have very many questions. I was just wondering. Yeah. I had questions about why he was headmaster. It doesn't matter. I also have questions about why he's headmaster. It doesn't make any fucking sense.
Why? Also, I don't have a whole lot of experience with headmasters, but I assume that you do because you work at a college. He doesn't strike me as doing very headmastery things. No. Also, not at all because also later we will go to his office, but it's his apartment. And I'm like, if you're a headmaster, you have to have like a different office. It cannot just be your home.
What? Yeah. Yeah. And like it's large and nice, but. And in the school, but also. But like it has to be different quarters. I'm sorry. This is your home office that you see students in. Look, he's working from home. Well. So back to Willow and she receives a call from her faja and her father is seemingly
furious that she and her brother Ash attended their mother's funeral at all and that Willow hasn't quote disposed of her brother yet. The fuck willow says quote, you're demanding. I give up my entire future for your revenge. The least you can do is understand. I would want to attend my mother's funeral, which again, I love her clap back, but her father is the worst. Yeah, he is the definition of a narcissist who's not hiding anymore. Exactly. But it's also so weird because he supposedly is going to go and do the work of like digging
up her mother so that she can return to the earth. It doesn't seem like he would give a shit. Yeah, I feel like. I got the impression that her mother probably like tricked him into like a bargain or something. Yeah. But if the vampire vessels and the witches can have some kind of pact that they all like abide by, there's got to be some kind of like magical agreement system happening here. That's true. That makes sense. Because you're right. I mean, if he was just left to his own devices, he wouldn't give a flying fuck.
No, because it doesn't seem like he gives a flying fuck at all except for his own revenge. Yeah. It very much is clear as we get through this book that her father procreated in order to serve his own purposes. Yeah. 100%. Okay. So this is when we find out that Willow's father really wants Willow to do something in revenge of his sister and her aunt. And so this person's name is Lorelei. And so I'm going to refer to her as Lorelei because it's just going to be confusing for me to say her and his sister every single time.
Yeah. Anyway, Lorelei had given everything to protect the knowledge of Willow's father's existence from the Covenant. She did this because the Covenant in the school make male witches choose between their magic and the ability to have children. And now Willow's father has brought Willow up to find what I thought was Lorelei's bones. Until our debrief, I thought it was still Lorelei's bones. Yeah. So I'm going to say this is another one of those things that's very confusing.
I'm just going to clarify right now. She's not looking for Lorelei's bones. She's looking for Charlotte Hecate's bones. And so it's giving nothing to tell you that Lorelei Hecate is the direct descendant of Charlotte Hecate who was the first witch. And so she spawned all of the other witches, but her direct line are necromancers. So Lorelei was a necromancer and Willow is part necromancer too. But necromancers need the bones of Charlotte Hecate to be able to channel their power.
That is what Willow has been tasked to find because at some point during the massacre 50 years ago, the bones were stolen and lost. And Lorelei was killed. Oops. Yeah. I just questioned. I can't think about it too hard because I don't understand it. Yep. I'm trying not to think about it too hard either.
Okay. One of the reasons Willow's father is pushing her so hard is because he can't do anything about it himself because he doesn't have any magical aptitude. Their conversation is interrupted though because Willow's front doorbell rings and her father hangs up on her. As Willow goes to the front door, she tells Ash to stay hidden and he does so. This is something that he's been trained to do his entire life so that nobody figures out that he's a male witch. And at the door, she finds, you guessed it, gray.
Willow immediately knows what gray is. Vampires are called vessels in this world because they are literally demons trapped within a human looking shell for all of eternity. Which I did like that explanation of vampire and the use that they have in this book. I still have questions, but I did like it. I did too. Yeah. And there is a reason that this is a thing, right? And I do like how the author was just like, how do I marry these two concepts and make
it make sense? It makes sense. And the backstory here is that vessels didn't used to have one human shell. They would inhabit the bodies of others, but they would burn that body up within a year. And so ostensibly, this was inconvenient, right? For all of the demons walking the earth. And so the demons made a deal with Charlotte Hecate to make these everlasting bodies.
But they've come to realize now that rather than being a convenience, it's a prison, right? They don't have to continually seek new vessels, but they also can't. They can't leave their cage, their flesh prison. Their flesh prison. Yeah. So they are forced to walk the earth until a necromancer unmakes them, which there hasn't been another necromancer in 50 years. So, whoops. So Willow decides to play dumb. He asks whether Ms. Medeza is in and tells her that there is an offer from a prestigious
university for her to study at. Willow says she's not interested. He pushes, but she says that he can leave the invitation in her mailbox and she'll look at it later. He says that he is the invitation and she says that she's definitely not interested. She tries to close the door on him, but he sticks his foot in the jam so she cannot. And as this happens, he gets a better look inside. And unfortunately, Ash has made the decision to try to come and assist his sister. He's got like a knife in his hand and he's six. I love that he's just like, I'm here to fight.
Right. And Gray gets a glimpse of him. Before Gray can use his compulsion on the boy, Willow tells Ash to get back in the kitchen. Willow herself is protected against compulsion because of the necklace that she took from her mother. Gray immediately understands that Ash is Willow's sibling and probably a witch and says that if she comes quietly with him, he won't tell anybody about Ash. Willow? Willow declines that offer and physically attacks Gray so that he gets the fuck out
of her door and she can shut it against him. The trope of vampires not being allowed into someplace without being invited is alive and well in the story. I love it. Because he like shoves his foot like in the door, which I guess that's the most you can get. And she just goes on the assault, which takes him by surprise and also I think begins endearing her to him. 100% because she like, she doesn't literally pull any punches. She like does the miscongeniality like solar plexus, gonads, nostrils, whatever.
Yes, it's amazing. It's really funny. It's so funny. So outside Gray is frustrated and a begrudging burgeoning respect for Willow has blossomed. So he calls one of his backup people, Juliet, and says that she and this other guy, Keros, need to come and help him because he underestimated this witch. Inside Willow and Ash go into the basement where there is a secret passageway out of the house that Willow and her mother made for just such an occasion. Ash at first refuses to go, demanding that Willow tell him what's going on.
And she eventually has to. She tells him just enough so he will comply and go with her. So Willow says that their mother was a green witch and so is Ash, but he won't be able to be a witch until he's older. She then gives him a journal from Willow's aunt, Lorelie, the same one that she's been using to try to find the bones and says that it will explain most of what Ash needs to know when the time comes. Also, this kid's like six. Yeah, he's real young. So the tunnel out of the house emerges some distance away in the woods and Willow's plan
is to have them run toward the bus station where they can meet up with Ash's father and hopefully escape. She of course will cause the distraction so that Ash can get away safely. And boy does she cause the distraction. She uses her green magic to not only distract but also kick the asses of the vessels. And the way that she uses her magic is pretty cool. It's couched as a relationship with the natural world around her. So she asks and the natural world responds, but for a cost and that cost is literally her blood. So she can make trees bend and grow at will.
She can make the earth rise up to meet her and dirt can even heal her wounds. We kind of mentioned before, but I really love the way this magic is laid out because even though the cost is her blood, it's not in like a dark, creepy way. It's in this really beautiful like symbiotic relationship way, which we'll see more of later. I mean, it's kind of creepy, but it's so interesting. And she also talks about how she can feel like the pain and the emotions of the plants.
Like at some point she has to like cut a branch off a tree and she like talks about how like the tree feels that pain and also like how they respond to her. And I just really liked the way all of it was written. I did too. It was really beautiful. And to your point, it's very much couched as like a nourishment right of the plants, not like a predatory or like even painful experience. Like, yeah, it hurts Willow to cut, like to make a cut on herself, but she's happy to
give back to nature because it gives so much to her. Exactly. I just really loved that. I will say that she uses dirt quite a few times to heal herself. And every time my brain goes, rub some dirt in it. Every time my brain was like, keep a little dirt under your pillow for the dirt man. That's even better. Anyway. So Willow and Gray end up getting into a duel of sorts.
He tells his other two lackeys to go after the boy. And they are pretty evenly matched. He doesn't have any magic, but he's a lot stronger, so he's like, he's got superhuman strength and speed and all of that. And as they fight, Gray remarks that Willow is just like her mother, who had also been a stubborn witch before she faked her own death to escape the covenant. Gray had expected Willow to know nothing about her magic and be totally untrained, but is impressed at the control and the power that she wields. At some point, Gray does pin Willow to the ground and he immediately bites her and feeds
from her. He makes it painful, even though she remarks internally that he could make it feel like ecstasy. Their duel is interrupted, though, when the other two get to Ash and Willow hears Ash screaming. By the time she gets to him at the bus station, the other two vessels there are holding Ash and Gray joins them. So they're using Ash as a bartering chip to make Willow stop fighting, essentially. Willow begs Gray to let Ash go, and he doesn't understand the feeling of love.
He sees it as a weakness, but Willow says that she feels sorry for them that they'll never know such a powerful feeling. Ultimately, Gray lets Ash go and tells him to go to his father, who is waiting by the buses. Ash at first doesn't want to leave Willow, but eventually Gray uses his compulsion and tells Ash to go to his father and never look for his sister. Willow doesn't understand why Gray did this, but he says that one day she's going to owe him a favor in exchange for this. Well, I was okay with that. Does Ash's father know that he is a witch?
Unclear. I'm interested to see what happens with Ash, especially as we learn more about male witches. Yeah, same. And so I have to assume that he knows something is happening, right? Because he has eyes, he saw this happen with Ash. Just a whole bunch of adults swarming him in a parking lot. I'm literally holding him captive.
I have to assume that he knows something. He's got to know something. I'm so interested in it. We do also learn in here how vessels don't understand feelings of love because they literally don't have hearts in their bodies. Yep. Because they're demons. But we learn later that they do have hearts. They're just kept in hell with their actual bodies. And I liked that though. I was like, oh, so you do have a heart? Uh-oh. Uh-oh. What a twist.
Tell me more about the heart that you don't have. I just liked that. Yeah, I did too. So Willow is packed into the vessel's car so they can take her to the school. As they drive away, Gray asks whether she's going to be a problem for him since he's the headmaster and needs to maintain order at the school. In response, Willow tells him, quote, if it's order that you value, then I will give you nothing but chaos. I just love Willow so much. And I love their banter.
Like, even just small things. Like, after he bites her and feeds from her in the forest, she heals the wound and is just like, that was rude. Yes. Exactly. And he's like, well, you're rude. Yeah. I do have to say that one of the things about this book that I love, and I think one of the first tip-offs that I had that the trash was soon to come, was the fact that their banter was immediately at 100. Which I love books that create good banter between romantic parties.
It's just one of my favorite things to read. Same. And it's hard to do. Like, we've read so many books where the conversation is just stilted and not interesting. Exactly. But they immediately have chemistry, and it doesn't feel forced. They feel like real characters that have complicated feelings. Tension. Tension. You can cut it with a knife. So as they drive, it becomes clear that they are in New England and heading to the town of Salem in Massachusetts. It's October and the weather is gloomy, and I just love that whole thing.
I do too. So Willow and Gray are sitting in the back seat of the car, and Juliet and Cows are in the front. Willow and Gray start argue flirting about how much they both despise the coven and who despises them more. And at some point, Juliet pipes up and says, will you two please just fuck and get it over with? You'll feel better. Everyone will feel much better. Willow is horrified, even though she admits internally that her mission to find the bones will likely depend on her seducing this guy at some point.
So instead of flirting directly with Gray, she starts flirting with Keros in the front seat and gets a rise out of Gray almost immediately. He's like zero to territorial in two pages. Which I adore. And poor it, Keros is just frozen. We don't really see a lot of him, but it's described like she reaches forward and runs her hands up his arms and his chest and his neck and he's just like a statue. He's like please don't bring me into this. Alright, please leave me out of this. Thank you.
Poor Keros. I know. As they near the school, they drive up and up into the hills and a fog rolls into the forest around them. In the distances, Willow can just make out the shapes of creatures running through the trees and though she asks what they are, we don't get a straight answer. Gray only says that there are beasts far scarier than witches roaming the forests around the school. We do get an answer to this in part two. When they arrive at the school, the school is described as being a gothic mansion on the outcropping of a cliff.
So literally gothic horror. Which we love. I love. Yes. In the middle of October in New England? Yes honey. Yes, yes please. Near the entrance to the school, there is a memorial to the victims of the massacre from 50 years ago and Willow easily spots her aunt's name, Lorelei Hackate. She as far as anyone in the school is aware was the last Hackate necromancer in the line. So Willow, nobody knows that Willow is related to Hackate at all. Nope.
So the last black witch. Willow is taken immediately to the Covenant. A young man, Iben, meets her with the intention of escorting her but Gray gets territorial immediately and escorts Willow himself. On the way they pass a courtyard that was clearly once a flourishing garden but is barren and dried up now. Willow wonders internally why the brown slash gray witches weren't able to keep it alive. They like green witches commune with the earth for their magic. I don't understand.
Yeah I mean I understand why they need, I understand why the author needed another witch to like be able to do similar things so that Willow would know something is wrong but still. But still. But at least pick one color. Right, make that one color and stick to it. Brown or gray. So as Willow walks into the tribunal chamber, the magic that protects it takes a drop of her blood as some kind of test but we don't hear anything more about this and it doesn't reveal to anyone in the moment that she's a necromancer so like okay.
Right, I don't know. She gets away with it for a while. Yeah. So the tribunal has a ring of 12 chairs so two representatives for each witch house and then the two chairs for the covenant are kind of like on a raised platform behind it. Willow as it is immediately at 100 with the covenant determined to be the most difficult possible. Susanna says that Willow looks nothing like her mother and Willow claps back neither do you. I love it so much. So the brown witch Bray tries to make Willow bow but Willow uses her magic to make the
vines of his chair come alive and strap him to his own seat and everyone is impressed and surprised by her ability to do so. They really underestimated her. They did and I love how she not only claps back but she has the power to do so because I feel like we've read books before that have like a sassy main character right but like she doesn't know how to wield a sword or like her magic blah blah and so she doesn't actually
she can't actually back up her sassiness. Exactly but which is she can back it up and I love that it shocks all of them. Yeah I know they're just like oh okay that's unexpected and the covenant says something to that effect and Willow says quote just because my mother hated all of you doesn't mean she hated what she was which I love to like she continues to kind of bring that up like I disagree with what you're doing here that doesn't mean I don't want to be who I am. Yeah and I thought it was very topical and well done as a theme to say like you can disagree
with the establishment essentially. And still be have pride in who you are and what what you can do. Exactly because I do feel like so often we'll get similar types of characters where it's just like a complete I'm gonna reject everything and she's like no I'm gonna use what I know I'm proud of what I know I'm gonna use it to help like the planet essentially I just don't like how you're doing it. Yeah she's like I'm not gonna let your evil or whatever it is that I disagree with dull
my shine. So the covenant tells her that it's a shame to be alone in the world as a witch but Willow disagrees she sees the controlling manipulative prison that the school actually is and that the Coven represents and understands why her mother wanted nothing to do with it or its breeding program. The breeding program. For real. Willow is dismissed and I've been shows her to her rooms on the way they pass the courtyard again the dead one and Willow decides to do something about it.
I've been tells her that no one knows why the magic isn't as potent at the school anymore and willow takes that as a sign that something is wrong. Very wrong. Very very wrong. She approaches a rose vine and offers her blood to it the plant is tentative almost like it's afraid of retribution and that breaks willows heart but eventually it does crawl up both of her arms and take from her. Willow has never seen anything like that before because such offerings are forbidden at the
school and willow questions how they can even practice magic at all if they don't give anything back to their elements all they do is take from the world around them. That's not how it should work. No. After the plant releases willow it grows afresh but willow is left weakened and lightheaded as if she were drunk. She uses the soil to heal the cuts on her arms but it doesn't replace the blood she's lost and she's unsteady on her feet or the magic she's lost. Right.
I've been is an awe of what willow did and admires it. He admits that he's given up his magic in the hopes of finding his true love and having a family willow is horrified that he's already made that choice that he's already been forced to make that choice. Something I should note about this is that it comes up a lot as one of the key points that willow disagrees with about the coven so the fact that the coven doesn't practice the old ways which is this offering that we've just seen but also that they treat male witches
like this but we don't get a good reason why male witches are forced to make this choice. No and why it's only male witches that have to make this choice. Right. It's very strange. It is. It's really strange. As Ivan helps willow back to her feet gray comes upon them and sweeps willow into his arms carrying her up to her room willow can't help but notice how good it feels to be held by him and she berates herself internally for finding the prospect of seducing him for more information not quite as odious as she had once thought.
Gray shows her her room and tells her classes start the next day and that one of her roommates can help her navigate her classes as he leaves she calls him gray for the first time hither to she'd been calling him headmaster and no one else calls him gray. It was something that like the someone in the tribunal called him. She's like your name is not a laryg it's gray. So we next see gray that night wandering the halls of the school a bit starstruck and on the back foot from meeting willow.
His feet lead him back to her room where he finds her passed out on top of the sheets still in her jeans. He decides to help her into her pajamas but as soon as he has her pants off he pops a boner and leaves an embarrassment. Immediately pops a boner. Yeah and his internal monologue is like so I definitely want to fuck her but I definitely want her to be like awake for it. Which I appreciated. Yeah I appreciated it too. I mean this whole thing is creepy but like he's a vampire a demon trapped in a vampire's
body so I'm going to give him a lot of leeway here but also I do appreciate that as soon as he realized that it was inappropriate and his body was reacting he was like nope I'm gnawing out of here really fucking. He never touches her like he doesn't do anything he kind of touches her stomach but like that's it. Yeah exactly. Which again which is also where he's not really a villain. He's a gooey teddy bear. A marshmallow. Yeah a villain I feel like would have leaned into that and been way creepier or like gone
through her shit or something. Right or like as soon as he realized that he wanted to fuck her like do that. Yeah or at least like feed from her and her sleep or something. Yeah yeah every time he does something she's awake and even if she might be saying the no no no thing we get the internal monologue that she does want it or it's like in response to him telling her you know tell me to stop or whatever. Exactly which is the only time it works because in real life if you hear no you stop you don't
know their internal monologue but I'm not opposed to it in books when we do know that she want them. Yes oh my gosh I forget where I saw it but somebody was talking about that dynamic about how we read such unhealthy dynamics in these books but would never accept that or put ourselves into those circumstances in real life and somebody couched it as safe insecurity. Which I love. I love that. Because in books you can be assured that like no one's actually going to get hurt or at
least in books we read. But in real life you can't. No exactly and they're not real people so like right I'm okay with that. So before class the next day Willow meets her roommates we have Nova, Margo and Della. They're all from the original witch house bloodlines and they call children like this not children I guess like descendants of these witch bloodlines legacies. So Willow is technically a legacy even though she grew up outside of Crystal Hollow.
So Willow is one of 12 other students from outside Crystal Hollow who will be attending but she won't actually like attend class with any of them because she is a legacy. Willow will attend classes with all of these legacies and again this is one of those things where it's like so her roommates know what's up they've attended this school before they're not 60 so what's happening and we just don't know. We just don't know. Yeah it's fine. As they leave the room Gray has had Ibane deliver a huge breakfast for Willow knowing
that she probably depleted herself not probably knowing that she depleted herself almost entirely during the offering the night before. Again Marshmallow. And one could argue like Gray wants to make sure that she's got enough blood so that he can feed from her but like there are other ways to do that. Right and essentially it's gonna replenish anyway like you don't have to feed her but it comes at a perfect time too because she's saying like her roommates give her a granola bar and she says something like I need food from the earth blah blah blah and suddenly
this delicious breakfast shows up like he didn't have to do that. And it's like an egg McMuffin and like fruits and vegetables and she's just like this is fucking delicious. Right I can only and we get the comment of like my roommates didn't comment on if they thought it was weird but their faces sure did. I know right I love that too. I also loved that we have a protagonist who she's described as being curvy and she has like auburn hair I forget where we get that description but we do get that description
and I'm fine with it but the other thing about this scene in particular is that she's not thin but she's totally like she doesn't have an unhealthy relationship with food. She's like I need this it's replenishing my body like it's delicious I'm gonna fucking eat it like yeah. I think that was such a healthy portrayal again going into like the theming of this book like all about balance like she depleted herself she needs to rebalance the scales like it's just I loved that illustration. Yes it was really well done. There are so many things in this book that are really well done and other things that
are just trash and I'm here for all of it. Yep exactly. So they walk to class together despite I've been not actually attending with them and it's here that Willis suspects that Ivan hopes his future mate is her. Before they head into class Ivan stops Willow alone and tells her that she's playing with fire. He sees that she's she flirts with Gray and says maybe one day she'll realize that vessels like Gray are not an option for her. He ends this interaction by saying quote enjoy your game Willow but just know I play to win
and this is where I texted you and I was like okay girl Ivan you've got some game. I know my type my note was like Ivan is yummy like okay. I almost had the thought of like is this a reverse harem. I would be so okay with the Y choose right here. Right I would be too but I based on what we find out about Gray later I don't think that's the case but we'll see. So and Ivan kind of gets a little sneaky later. He does get a little sneaky but to be fair that's he's only sneaky because of something that the Covenant says.
That's true that's true because I like Ivan. Yeah I like Ivan too. And I'm glad what I really appreciated because we get we've gotten this monologue where Willow is like fucking with Ivan's head and very much playing this game with him just to kind of get under Gray's skin. I like that we don't get this mopey character and Ivan that's like oh she doesn't want me. I like that he's like I know you're playing with me I'm gonna play back and I'm gonna but I'm kind of here for it yeah I know so like I was like okay I like this dynamic. Yeah I do too.
So of course Gray is teaching her first class. What is the class history how often does he teach it who cares what are the classes does she have who knows. Those details are not in this book and pitch posh on you for asking. That's amazing. So they have glass and Gray says some pretty inappropriate things in this class but I have to remind myself that they're all basically adults. Yeah he basically walks up to her and is like I'm gonna fuck you. Or if you need to be fucked Ivan can do that for you.
And she's just like okay okay. I mean she recovers well or whatever but I was just like what are we talking about. I don't know and like the other students of the class who can because it's even said like the people directly next to me can hear what he's saying. Right okay. So one of the people directly next to her and she's not a part of the plot yet but I just thought it was interesting is Margot and she's a red witch who doesn't like to be touched and one of the first things that Willa says to her is wow that must suck given
where your magic comes from and she's like yeah it does and they like have this immediate connection. I really liked that and I also want to know more about Margot. I do too. Anyway after class Willa stays behind and asks why Gray teaches history to witches as he seems like a pretty biased point of view. During their discussion Gray reveals internally that he knows about the bones of Charlotte Hackate which spoilers is actually what Willa was looking for and it's here that I realized that it's not the bones of Lorelai it's Hackate. Anyway, sorry Charlotte, so were we.
Yeah. Anyway, they talk about how Charlotte Hackate died or rather didn't she was just dismembered and then her pieces scattered so her body couldn't regenerate itself or release her spirit even in death. The conversation and what they talk about really doesn't matter the point is just a ploy to get them close enough and in a compromised position where Willa is proving a point and kisses Gray ever so lightly to get a rise out of him and then when he reacts she tells him that she knows that he was in her room last night and is basically like the next
time you're in my room like have some balls to do something about it or don't ignore me the next day. Yes, don't act like nothing happened. And he tries to deny it and she's like look I smelled you in the room and then the roses told me which is surprising to Gray and I love that the plants like are her narks. I just the way that the magic works and her relationship with the plants is just so good. I know it's so good. And this was such a fun reveal to me because when we had Gray's perspective he has some internal monologue like okay she clearly doesn't know she was asleep the whole time like she's
acting normal and they have this banter and she's like I knew. Gotcha. Yeah and even when she says that he's like you were asleep and she's like yeah. Yeah I was but there are other ways. Anyway, speaking of narks, I've been has gone to fetch Susanna and it's kind of implied that I've been like was spying on them saw this and then went to go get like mommy to like discipline them or break it up. Like was he just like outside the classroom door the whole fucking time?
Waiting for Willow. Well, yeah. Anyway, Susanna's like Gray keep it in your pants and Gray's like well Willow is a willing partner but Willow says that that's a lie so Gray has to let her go. Willow leaves and Susanna tells Gray that he's better off staying away from Willow. Gray says he will do as he pleases within the rules and he intends to invoke dumb dominium. All we know right now is that dominium is not something that's been claimed in centuries
and it's some kind of ownership that a vessel can have over a witch. He tells Susanna to not tell Willow as he will do so when he's ready. I want to know more about this. Yes. So back to Willow who somehow hasn't seen Gray in days despite him being her history teacher. Don't ask questions. Fine. Fine. And she's kind of in her feelings because she's like okay he clearly was into me but like way at. This is making my plan very difficult.
Anyway, she's in the library studying with Ivan and Gray comes and fetches her saying he wants a word. Willow is off kilter again because she hasn't seen him for a while and isn't sure what this conversation is about. They end up going to his office which is in the school but to your point earlier is also where he sleeps. Right like she can see the open door to his bedroom. Like it's his apartment. Yeah it's basically an apartment like whatever it's fine.
It serves a purpose. It's fine. The bed is clearly there for a reason. Yes. We will use it eventually. So Willow asks what Gray's true name is but he declines to tell her saying that true names have power. So the inference here is that his demon has a name that is not Gray. And so then he offers up a truce between them. So they've been kind of like push pulling each other the entire time they've met and
he's like look we can work better together. So let's not be so at odds and work toward a common goal. He's like I want to see the Coven come back to the old ways. You also want that. Let's work together to do that. And in exchange he will protect Willow from the Covenants intention to wed and breed her as soon as possible. Excellent. Yeah. The wed and bred part is really what seals the deal for Willow because Gray tells her like look she's kind of shocked to hear that this has already been a topic of discussion
and he's like I'm pretty sure they were talking about it the moment they knew you existed. Yeah from the get go. So she agrees and they exchange blood to seal the deal. It's a steamy moment but it's only I think she takes blood from his thumb. So he so it's a really steamy moment because he like bites his thumb and like holds it out to her but because he bit his thumb he has like his own blood on his lip and so she like sucks it off of his lip and then his thumb.
Oh yeah. Okay I remember that now. Yeah. Yeah. It's so good. It's so good. It's really it's really making the vampire kink in me like happy because we get the blood sharing because then in turn to seal the deal he has to take some of her blood and instead of like biting her thumb as would be custom he bites her lip. Yep which is great. Anyway so great. Well that note.
Moving on. So next we see Willow in class taught by Susanna the skeleton and Susanna asks the class where magic comes from. No one in class knows what to say beyond quote the source but Willow knows so she's her mining in the situation right so she's like um actually the source is the world around us everything in nature. Susanna essentially says she's right even though she's insufferable and goes on to say that specifically the red and the black witches were made to balance each other out.
That Charlotte Hecate was too powerful for her own good and the coven wanted to put a leash on that. That's what's implied she doesn't outright say that specifically but I have to infer that because I don't know who else would like do that. That's that yeah that was what I understood that to be. And questions I have so many questions so many questions. So this splitting or like I want to say democratizing of powers was pretty easy to do since the
black line in particular so necromancy through the Hecate line only passes to one witch at a time so Laura Lai had it Willow's father was anticipating having it as being her last known relative and when he didn't that's when he realized that he needed to procreate so that it could pass to Willow. So we also learned that Charlotte Hecate made the vessels and they can only be unmade by a necromancer but Susanna poses the question to the class how do you keep vessels in line
when they do not die? How do you convince them not to just take what they need from witches? And the ultimate answer which Willow gives is that you can't. Yes and she does go on to add that the only way to do it would be to in have them in some form of servitude through like a broken bond which is fun coming off of the fact that she just made a bond with the vessel. Yep yep yeah so I'm we don't get a whole lot of detail unlike the parameters of magical
like bargain making here we see it happen but like this was the vessels thing was a product of a broken bond we don't get the details on that just yet but I'm interested to learn more about that in the next book. Me too. So next we're back to Gray and he is being led to the courtyard where Willow made the offering and there past a group of bystanders he finds a body. The body is in the caress of the vines that Willow made an offering to when she first
arrived and this body is of a female witch. Unfortunately her heart has been ripped out. Oops. Can't be revived or brought back or anything like that. Willow arrives shortly afterwards and as they stand there one of the covenants George says they need to close the school but Susanna of course disagrees. This was very reminiscent to me of the Chamber of Secrets. Yeah very Chamber of Secrets. Yes and Willow is not safe we must protect her. We must protect the chosen one. The Chamber of Secrets has been opened.
Animes of the air beware. So the brown witch Bray is also there and he kind of is muttering to himself that the vines wouldn't listen to him and that's when Willow reveals to everybody that she made an offering to these vines and that's why they wouldn't listen to Bray because he wasn't giving them anything. She's kind of horrified at this idea and it immediately throws suspicion on Willow. But it's clear that whatever this thing is that has killed this witch was superhuman
because they haven't found the heart and it's not been surgically removed I'll say. Yeah it's claws and blood and violence. Yeah. One of the students that's kind of hanging around says that maybe Willow is killing off people who are in direct competition for her with Ibane and Willow like claps back and is like I don't give a single fuck about who Ibane was with before I got here. Nope. She even says like you know clearly you don't know but it's more fun if you're willing
to share. Which makes Gray choke so Gray is the one that's narrating this chapter and he's just like I almost fucking lost it. I cannot handle what is happening with this woman right now. So next we have one of your favorite things a dream sequence. As soon as I turned the page and it was in all italics I was like mother fucker.
You know what. But it's a gothic horror like you have to a dream sequence is a crucial part of that. I know and honestly I didn't mind the stream sequence at all because it served a purpose it wasn't it kind of blurred that line of like dream sequence versus vision. And that is what makes it okay to me and I've had that thought or like I will someday write a gothic horror and like there's probably going to be fucking dream sequences. Yeah yeah I totally get that.
I will say that this dream sequence was well done because I could not read it in the middle of the night when I was feeding my child. So it was very scary. Yeah very scary. So let's get a do it. Willow is walking the halls of the school and she hears a feminine voice calling out to her and she eventually follows it to find a woman with long black hair. She recognizes this person from photographs of her aunt Laura Lai and she can see that her aunt has something at her hip that she knows is probably the bag of bones so Charlotte
Hectate's bones. Laura Lai this vision tells Willow that she doesn't have what Willow seeks and then they hear a growl and they feel the ground shake as something takes steps toward them. As it gets closer Laura Lai tells Willow to run and then to wake up. When Willow does wake up she's gasping for breath and her back is on fire. She runs to the bathroom and underneath her shirt she sees three marks in a triangle shape cut into the skin of her back.
Yeah I also so the dream sequence was well done it was very spoopy but also I like when dream sequences bleed into reality. Yes me too. And not in the what was it haunting Adeline way. No was it that one? No it was fucking um wait was it a Chateau? No it was um the one about the Grim Reaper. Oh yeah that was gross.
Yeah this is gonna bother me I'm gonna pull it up. Alright all I can think is death becomes her have you ever seen that movie that movie is great. No but I've recently been seeing like clips from it on TikTok and Instagram and I need to like I need to watch it I think I would like it. You would like it it's very like it's really campy um it's good it's really good. Nice that and practical magic are on my list for this spooky season. I've never seen practical magic. I haven't either um we're gonna watch it.
What the fuck is this? Death's obsession. Death's obsession okay yeah okay yeah those were stupid I didn't like that but I liked this when it was like this thing is chasing you and then when it gets you like you wake up and you're in pain because something has happened to you in the real world. Exactly I liked that um a lot and it didn't make it so it made it creepier because she also has the thought of like I think she says like a blue witch is in a white witches or purple whatever only some of them have visions like it shouldn't be a green witch or a black
witch thing like this shouldn't be a thing that's happening to me. Yes which is one of the reasons why she's incentivized to say to stay quiet. Obviously. So while she's in the bathroom kind of reeling from this experience she's soon joined by Gray who knows that she's bleeding. She tries to deflect saying she's just on her period and he says how am I supposed to uphold my end of the bargain if you aren't honest with me. So eventually she does show him but she's also naked and there's some sexual tension
there obviously. Obviously like I think she's wearing shorts but yeah but she's topless for sure yeah and she's kind of wearing like booty shorts was the vibe I got. So Willow tells him how she got the mark what she saw in the dream but she doesn't tell him that she recognized Lorelai as her aunt she just says you know she saw a woman and nothing about the bones. No. He tells her that he's seen the mark before and it's called the devil's eye. He implies that it was put there by the devil himself and it's not something that vessels
or witches can undo. And she's like it's not like I have him on speed dial. Right. So rather than tending to her like a normal fucking person Gray licks the blood off of her back. In true vampire fashion. And she's like yeah I should have seen that coming. Anyway. Gray asks whether she wants him and she lies to him about it because though she still finds
the idea of a vessel itself abhorrent she is finding it harder and harder to ignore the fact that she's deeply attracted to Gray. Knowing that she lied to him Gray pushes her against the wall and kisses her. As he kisses her he pierces her lips so that he takes more of her blood and the scene is hot but there's a point in which he's like fondling her breast and he says do you think that any of the others will make you feel like this and it just reminds me of that scene in bridesmaids at the beginning where Kristen Wigg is having sex with John Hamm
and John Hamm is like touching her breast and like do you like that and she's like yeah even though clearly it's doing nothing. That is the vibe I got too because like I feel like you haven't earned the right to say that yet because you haven't made me feel anything other than like basic lust yet. Exactly. Like you can ask me that after you make me come but you can't just be like oh yeah do you like that. Yeah like give me mind blowing sex but don't like don't kill the lily like that or prime the pump.
Right and like bro we haven't really done anything so calm down. Right. Calm down. Also you know what I think Ivan probably might make her feel like that. So speaking of making her feel good Gray edges Willow and tries to get her to tell him the truth about what she wants and when she doesn't he uses the fact that he freshly fed from her to compel her to not be satisfied by her own touch or by the touch of anyone else. So basically she can only come with him.
Which is such a dick move and it works. It does work. So it's worth noting here that even though she's wearing the necklace from her mother because he's fed from her and they've exchanged blood that works less and less so the more they do this thing the more access he has to use his compulsion on her. And so this unfortunate set of circumstances will persist until he decides to release her and in her internal monologue she's like this bastard's not going to release me ever. Ever.
Nope. She also asks like if you can compel me why don't you just force me to tell you the truth and he's like because this way is way more fun. Right. And I'm like okay. Alright so that is where we will end part one and don't worry dear listeners part two definitely makes good on all of the promises that part one has given us. Alright so that brings us to the end of part one. Join us in two weeks for part two which will cover chapters 21 through 40 and we will also
include our ratings at the end of that episode. So thank you for joining us on this journey as always. Let us know what you thought on the socials. You can find us at Spice Traders Pod on basically all of the platforms and if you want more consider joining as a patron where we release episodes in our off weeks and if you really like us write us a review wherever you listen. Until next time we'll see ya. Bye. Bye. Bye
Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...
Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...
Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/
Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...
Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/