A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas Part 1
1 hr 19 minAudio
We know you’ve been patiently waiting for it …this week your Traders finally travel to Pyrthian as we cover A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas! This episode is part 1 of 3. Triggers: abduction, claustrophobia, death, drugging, gore, emotional abuse, intentional amnesia, murder, physical abuse, sexual abuse and assault, torture, violence. Tropes: Beauty and the beast retelling, really old fae, forced proximity, enemies to lovers KU: Nope Recommendation: Yes For more information visit https://sarahjmaas.com/.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey friends, just a quick reminder before we get into today's episode, come join us over on our Patreon. That's where we release bonus episodes every other week and we've already got over 20 episodes from 2023 that you can download and binge right now for as little as $3 a month. We've covered so many good books there, Haunting Adeline, Chateau, Gotha Canna, and so many more. That's also where we'll cover any books in a series we continue, so Serpent in Dove, High Mountain Court, Serpent in the Wings of Night. You can continue those series with us on Patreon right now.
Finally, as a patron, we let you know what we're going to read every month so you can read along with us if that's your jam. Anyway, that's all from me, on to today's episode. Tamplin's kind of always an asshole. He's the fucking worst. Like, like if, okay look, Pharah's been abused her entire life so I can see where like she's like the is this love meme but like he's not a good guy and he does not treat people well.
No, and he's also kind of a wet blanket. Yeah, like he's moody and shit. I'm like, girl get out of there. He is like a walking piece of drywall that's sometimes an asshole. Yeah, like I just. Welcome to Your Safe Space. The podcast, your partner, friends, parents, whoever thinks is dirty. Don't have time to read books, want to understand the jokes and the tics-hacks, we got you fam. We're the Spice Traders and we deal in spicy books.
I'm Katie and I need it to make sense. I'm Liz and I'm hypercritical. As always, we start every episode with three things. The first is a generic trigger warning. You can find specific triggers for this book in our show notes so please check those out. Also we do use foul language and talk a lot about sex. Do you have sensitivity to any of this, please give this episode a skip. Secondly, we talk about books. The whole book, nothing but the books that helped me got us. If you plan to read this book and don't want something spoiled right now, don't listen to this episode. Lastly, we acknowledge that a good book can hit you at the wrong time.
The views expressed in our discussion are our opinion and we absolutely don't want to diminish the work and the talent of the authors in our community. That said, we have some notes. So girl, what are we talking about today? Today we are finally talking about A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Mass. This was published in 20. Hey girl, hey. I'm excited. I feel like our listeners may have been waiting for this one.
Girl so hip, Lee. I know. We intentionally put this off until we had more experience and books under our belt. And also we were scared. Yeah, I'm still scared. I'm still scared. Putting it off until we had enough quote unquote experience doing this. But like kind of made it worse because now I'm just like, wow, we've read so many books. I feel like I have a better perspective on what's good and now I don't know if this is it. I know. I know it was kind of a double-edged sword because now I think we're just more critical.
Yeah. So that's fine. Anyway, we're finally here. This was published in 2015 and is the first in an ongoing series currently with four full-length novels and one novella. The novella sucks. If you've read it, spoiler alert now. We'll read it. I'm sorry. I have rage. This is real. The rage is real. Okay. Just real quick diatribe. You told me not to read it and I was like, I'm a completionist. I'm going to read it. I've never regretted anything more in my life.
And I've made some decisions. Let me tell you. There was a decision to be made and you made the fuck out of it. I made the fuck out of it. This book is 419 pages long and so that's a long E for us. Now we talk about our covers. This book, you guys have seen the covers, right? Even if you haven't read it. These are quintessential Romantic books, but I have to say, I don't think I ever looked that closely at any of these covers.
Not in any critical way. I was like, there's the red one. There's the green one. There's the blue one, which sucks. And then there's the purple one. A fourth color. Yeah. Yeah. And a fifth color. But this one is a red background. We have our yellow text. And then we have this strangely Asian art that it looks Asian to me of a wolf with an arrow through its throat, which we get the reason behind that very early on. The cover's great. I mean, I do like it.
It is really stark. The more I look at it, though, the more it looks like it came out of a Chinese restaurant. Yeah, it kind of does. And I feel that way about all of the creatures on the subsequent books too. And they don't fit the theme because this is very much like Anglo-Saxon. Yeah. It's kind of lore. It's kind of a weird choice. It's a weird choice. Yeah. I'm not going to lie, though. I think this is the book that I have the most copies of in my library.
There are some very stunning special editions of these books, and I know you do have some of them. How many copies do you have? So I have three copies. So I have just the vanilla copy hardcover, which I got a custom cover for. And then there's a Barnes and Noble special edition that is black with gold filigree. Oh, yeah. And it comes with a little case. I got that one. That one's pretty. And then I bought the Kindle edition because I wanted to be able to read it in the dark
with my baby napping on me. Yeah, so I have three copies. I think the only other books that I have close to three copies of are the Jane Austen books. Yeah, like classics. Yeah, exactly. I'm curious as we move through this series how you're going to feel about having three copies of these books. Yeah, I will say that I only have three copies of the first book, though. Oh, okay. The other ones I only have one copy. Okay, okay. And I mean, so far, so good.
So far, so good. I think this is crossed. Yeah. There's really not that much to say about the cover. They're very simple. They are nice. They do make a nice collection together. They complement each other. I don't know if this is the first one that started the trend, but it definitely gets the most notice. But the start of the a blank of blank and blank, which now that we've done this one, I am going to make social media with that because can we stop naming books a blank of blank and
blank? Yeah, it's really stale. It gets stale incredibly quick. This series, all of the books are named a blank of blank and blank. However, they're now about, I'm going to go scientific here and say 512 other series that do that same goddamn thing. And I'm not trying to say there's a lack of creativity or whatever. It's just, do we have to do that format? It's just, they're just kind of a mouthful, right?
It's just kind of wordy. And I just, it's all samey. I feel like you're doing yourself a disservice because at this point, if you are writing a book and you're naming it a blank of blank and blank, you are trying to compete with all of the other ones that are a blank of blank and blank. And I'm sorry, but the queen is Sarah J. Mass in that category. Exactly. I don't even know if this came first. I'm sure there's other a blank of blank and blanks. But any other book that comes out that follows that format, I'm just going to compare to Akatar.
100%. Yeah. Which you like, well, you, you put your toe in this water. So like, so there you go. Shut up. I will say that it is nice that it does make a lovely acronym of Akatar. Yes. The others don't do that as well. But we will refer to it as Akatar. You've heard us say Akatar in plenty of other episodes because she's the queen. So that is something that I want your, that I want your opinion on.
People, people on the internet. People. Other people. Them. We'll be super specific. They'll be like, Oh yeah, Akatar as in the first book. And then they'll say like Akamaf and others, you know, for the different acronym. Yeah. Akamaf was the only one I could think of. And in my head, it was Afamar. Um, here, let me pull it up. Let's see. So like Akamaf, Akka, of a court of wings and Akawar.
There we go. Akawar. And then there's Frost. Akosap. Silver flames. Wait, no. Akas. The silver flames piss me off though, because it's not a blank of blank and blank. It's a blank of blank. It's a blank of blank. Yeah. And I don't like that. It should be silver and flames. If we're going to do the thing, make it a thing. Yeah. Make it a thing. I can't be that specific though. Like people, like do that all the time on the internet. I'm like, it's just, the series is literally called a court of flores and flores.
It's just, it's Akasap. Well, it's like Lord of the Rings. Like the series is Lord of the Rings. Not every book is called Lord of the Rings, but I'm not going to call it like the two towers. Like it's Lord of the Rings. I'm talking about the two towers. I'll say that. But yeah, because some books will have its own overarching title, right? This is just the ones of the Runes and Roses. Right. It's the name of the book and the name of the series. Sorry. Okay. Anyway, I agree with you. So I appreciate it. With that big old diatribe on that, Katie, take it away.
Sure. So the queen is not on KU. Lissai. But I get it. Lissai. Yeah. So I can read it to you. Why? Why not? I did buy it on KU. Yeah. Just so I could read it. Because I'm reading this one in paper to go back to my notes. But you know, I like to read in the bathroom at work and it's just way less subtle to walk in with a physical book than a walk in with your phone. Everybody goes to the bathroom with a phone and everybody goes to the bathroom with a book. I feel like if you do that these days, people know you're going to take a shit.
Exactly. And like the good bathroom is not in my building. It's not like I have like a bathroom in my office. Like I got to go to a different building. So like it's really obvious what I'm doing. Yeah. Anyway. Perfect. So since this book is a long year, we're going to be breaking it up into three parts. And so this episode will cover part one, which is going to cover chapters one through 15. So at the end of part three, we will be doing our ratings for the book overall. So before we start, we get some materials, we get a map that I tried really hard to understand,
but I didn't understand it until it was explained later in the book. And I swear to God, I didn't look at this map a single goddamn time the first few times I read this book. I also still don't like this map. Well beyond the fact that it's just England. It's just England and Ireland. But there's also this vague other place that has mountain ranges that look like South America. Okay, exactly. Okay. Now I got to pull this up because like there was another thing there.
This right here is South America. Yeah. Okay. And then so like the one of Prithian, right, which is where our story takes place is like so detailed. And then this other continent, it has just like fuck all on it. And there's like some mountains and one lake. And then like, also is this, is that a shed? I don't know. Or is this all just like desert? Like, yeah, this little bleep is a shed. Yeah, what is that? It's they're tiny mountains and trees. Okay, great. Cool. I'm glad we cleared that up. Yeah, it doesn't make any sense. And it looks like my note says, is this a blow up?
Is this like part of Prithian? Like I have no idea what's happening here actually. If it was a blow up, a blow up, that would make sense because we have the wall. And as far as I know, the wall is only a Prithian thing. It's not like a world thing, but maybe I'm wrong. Also, yeah. I know it's Prithian. I put another end there and it's Prithian. I don't know why he's like parentheses. I cannot say Prithian. It's Prithian. You're so pretty. Thank you. But it can't be a blow up because that shape isn't in.
It's not a blow up. No, but this is the thing. I looked at this map for like literally five minutes and I was like, what am I looking at because. Okay, I've read all of these books. Yeah. Not once that I remember. But let's be honest, I wasn't reading them that closely the first couple of times around. But what I remember is they don't talk about the rest of the world. They talk about Hibern, which is the little it's effectively Ireland. But the rest of the world doesn't exist. There's an off-handed couple of comments in this book where they're like, oh yeah, the
treaty covers the whole world. And so you have that elsewhere too. Why are you telling me that? I don't know. But to your point, we are a solid five books in the series and it's still never mentioned. Like we talk about the going across the seas with the like other mortal queens, but like that's also kind of hand wavy space and time. Yeah, I got real bored on that part of a court of flaming, whatever. Court of flaming theory.
I did too. I did not give two shits of that one because I was like, okay, let's play. We're here for this month. We're here for this month. Yeah, literally it because especially now. Especially now because of the fucking Asta. She's awful. She's so awful. It's really easy to read a court of silver for like left left. It's really easy to read that book and like give her a pass and be like, oh honey, when
you haven't just read how much of a gun she is in book one. I know. But if her book for like whatever, okay, if this series had followed more of a high mountain court where like each book was a different character and the second book was Nesta, oh, I would have needed a lot more to like her. Yeah. Or like maybe just start with an apology. That would have been a nice place to start. I'm fairly certain she never apologizes. I think she continues to be a cunt. We just overlook it because of the smud. Yeah, I think that might be true. Anyway, spending entirely too much time on this map.
Let's talk about more details. So we take place in the UK, right? Which is basically where England and Wales and Scotland are. Ireland is this place called Hibern. But in the mainland UK, we get a bunch of detail, right? This is the only place we get detail. On the south end, there's a wall and below that are the mortal lands and above that are the fairy lands which are divided into different courts starting with spring, then summer, autumn, winter, dawn, day, and night. Then there's a section between winter and dawn called quote, under the mountain.
And that's that's all we got. I didn't like this map the first time. I'm liking it even less. The more you look at it. Yeah. Because also who divides lands like that? No, it's pretty, it's pretty messed up. It does under the mountain really span the entire width of the continent? Okay. I have questions and I haven't gotten there yet because I always thought this concept of being under the mountain was bullshit. Which is a technical term I know.
But now I have even more questions because isn't under the mountain part of Rizan's court? Yeah. It is. But it's not next to his court. No, it should be between. So why does he get to own it? It should be between the day and the night courts. Is that because though, isn't there, and I don't remember, but isn't there like a thing where they don't connect like Rizan of the night court with Rizan of under the mountain? Like it's like there's two different people or he just has a different personality.
He just has a different personality. He's the same guy. Yeah. I know, I know he's the same guy. But I mean, like, do the people understand that he's the same guy? I have questions about that because also somehow he shielded his entire capital city from knowledge and it's like, did you wipe their memories? Yeah. So that's the other thing. I don't know. But a third point is if you're going to tell me that under the mountain spans this whole
the whole continent, the whole continent, and to be clear on the map, there's one mountain. Either that's a huge fucking tunnel system or I could just go around the mountain. I could just go around the one mountain. Yeah. Like. Better yet, take a boat. Yeah. You could just go. I'm gonna say it again. You could just go around the mountain. But they make it sound like you can't pass. Anyway, moving on. We have to get into the actual story here.
You don't want 30 minutes of just bitching about the cover in the map? Yeah. Well, I found something else that I want to pitch about because we don't get Pharah's name for a while. For a while. Yeah. So my notes start off and I don't clock the chapter, but it's at least two chapters in and you know how that grinds my gears. Like just work it in somehow.
I don't know. Make it better. Right. Because to be fair, she's alone for a while, so we don't get her name until one of her sisters says her name. But I still feel like there's a better way to do that. At least when she first walks in the door. But they have a whole conversation. Mainly because they're bitches and they don't greet her. So. Hi ho, Nesta. Yeah. Sorry. Hi ho, Pharah. It's nice to see you. I know because we get her name because Elaine's like being a whiny bitch and is like, Pharah. Yeah, that's simpleton. Anyway, we start off following Pharah.
We don't know what's Pharah, but I'm going to tell you spoilers. It's Pharah. This entire book is told from Pharah's point of view. I think there might be a chapter at the end that's not, but most of the book is from Pharah's point of view, first person. So we follow her as she is hunting. It's the dead of winter and it's been a hard season. So Pharah and her family haven't had much to eat and they ran out of what little provisions that they had like a day ago. So it's imperative that she come back with food to feed her sisters, Nesta and Elaine, and their father. She comes upon a clearing that looks like it has fresh tracks and she waits.
Eventually she sees a doe and as she prepares her bow to shoot it, she realizes that she's not the only one stalking this prey. There is a massive wolf also stalking toward the doe, oblivious to Pharah's presence. Pharah wonders to herself because of its size whether the wolf is just an animal or a shape-shifting fairy from the north since they are so close to the wall or the border between the mortarlands and the phearums. Regardless, she needs the meat and so she shoots the wolf with a special ash arrow with an iron arrowhead just as the wolf kills the doe.
The wolf looks at her with a preternatural awareness and as it does, she shoots it through its eye to kill it. Then she skins it and wraps the doe in the skin and treks home. So for like a hot minute, I was getting a little mad that this book was just the Hunger Games because that's what the first chapter is. I was like, no, I didn't hear anything that. I see what you did there. It's called- It's the Hunger Games meets Beauty and the Beast.
Yeah, yeah, like it's called You're Hungry, we get it. Add some fairies in there and you got it. Well, and she's very nonchalant about the fact that this giant fucking wolf, might or might not be magical. And spoiler alert, the wolf was a fairy. What a shitty fucking fairy. He just got- he just did- I don't understand how he just stood there. I got shot through the face. Well, we will learn later that that was a choice that he made.
I forgot about that part even though I've just read it. To be fair, we won't get to that in part one. Great, great, because I was like, I don't remember that. Did I not read it? No, we haven't gotten there yet, but we do find out eventually that this fairy wolf thing could have eviscerated her and chose not to specifically. Okay, good. I'm so glad that you said that wasn't the first part because I was like, did I not read the right chapters? No, you're good. Great, cool. Then it's been a solid like two years since I read this, so I feel like I get a pass.
Totally. So when Farah gets home, we're introduced to just how awful the rest of her family is. We learned that they are a disgraced former gentry, that her father was made lame because of outstanding debts, and her two sisters are useless and entitled. No one feels the need to help out around their dirty cottage except for Farah, and it's here that we learned that her name is actually Farah. She describes her sisters as lovely, with golden skin and honey hair that they all share, but on them it looks refined, on Farah it looks haggard, probably because they treat
her like a slave. She's the only one doing any work. Yeah. Nesta is described as being born with a sneer on her face, and boy is she ever, and Elaine is described as being simple. The thought of being helpful, for example, just never occurred to Elaine rather than Nesta who willfully and gleefully foisted upon Farah. I went through this thought exercise of which one's worse for you to just be intentionally a bitch, or for you to, it doesn't even occur to you to help me, and I think the second
one is worse. It would be worse if I thought that Elaine had any modicum of intelligence, but I don't think that she does. Like if it were you and me, and like the thought of helping somebody just never occurred to me, yeah, that would be bitchy. Yeah. Elaine presents as a simpleton. She has two brain cells to rub together. I'm not joking. I didn't get that impression the first two times that I read this book. I am convinced that she is simple. I am convinced that she is simple too, and I want, if I have to read a book about her,
I want that to be leaned into. She genuinely has a learning disability. That's more than just being illiterate. She actually was damaged by a fever in her youth or something. Right. That sounded really mean. But listen. Another example of how her sisters are terrible is that Nesta and Elaine immediately start arguing about who will get new things from the money that the pelts will fetch.
Fera talks about her boots, how they've basically got holes in them, and Nesta says that she needs new boots despite the fact that she has shiny new boots on. Because she doesn't wear them because she doesn't go outside. No. So Fera starts to butcher the dough, and she remarks that she likes to paint. So she tells us about the violets that she painted for Elaine, the flames for Nesta and the night sky for herself. Forshadowing. That was exciting. I did like coming back to that. It's fun seeing. I like following those breadcrumbs. Yeah.
Yeah. So that evening they die in on venison, and Fera tells us about her mother internally. We learned that she was a cold woman with her kids, and she only had smiles for her father, but she died before they were turned out of their manor house, and on her deathbed she made Fera promise to keep the family together and safe. Okay, so this is. Which seems like a terrible thing to ask a child. Well, not only ask a child, you're asking your youngest child. And I kind of forgot about it, but like the emphasis on like what like giving your word
means. And to be honest, I got a little sick of it because I feel like an eight year old's vow. She does not need to keep that vow anymore or ever. No. Yeah. And I, yeah, let's, let's be clear. She was eight. So who is this mother? Very much a child. That's like, yeah, I'm going to ask this one. Like it's because she always knew that her other children sucked ass because I don't, I just don't understand. Yeah. And Fera tells us that she says something to the effect that in a world that has forgotten
the names of their gods, a promise is currency. And so Fera feels like she must keep her word even though she hates her family. And it feels like maybe a little bit like, I mean, Fera is in an abusive situation. So maybe she's like, I don't know. I have to claim to this to give this meaning. Otherwise this really sucks. Yeah. And I mean, I do kind of get that in a self preservation kind of way, but. Right. And I don't know, she just takes, she takes on a lot of beating.
She takes a beating like it's fucking shitty. It is. And her sisters are useless. I mean, she talks about like how Nesta was supposed to chop wood in the morning and she didn't. And so they've only got like four logs to get them through the night and like, Nesta's just like, you know, I don't like chopping wood and you do it so much faster than me. Bitch, shut up. I just like almost died. I'm the only reason we're not starving to death. Go cut some goddamn wood with your brand new shoes. I would kill her.
I would kill her. I would let them all starve. We would eat her. Anyway, so Fera also tells us that the mortal world is protected by a wall because of a promise from the high Fae from 500 years ago. This promise ends up being called a treaty and we'll learn more about it later. So Fera sisters bring her out of her train of thought as they talk about a local boy named Tomas. Apparently Tomas wants to propose to Nesta and Nesta is overproud about it. But Fera knows better. She knows his family is just as destitute as they are and his parents would never allow
him to marry somebody with nothing to offer. She says as much to Nesta, but Nesta just insults her as a rotting animal who will soon have no one left to remember her and she and Elaine go into their shared room and close the door. Woof. Also, we learn more about Tomas later and woof. Yeah, like just the mean girl attitude here. So we learn later, it's not giving anything away here, that Fera is 19. She is the youngest as we've mentioned.
And so that means that her sisters are at least 20 or let's just say at least 19. One of them is 19, one of them is at least 20, probably older than that. And just the way that they're acting feels a lot like mean girls in high school, like their frontal cortexes are not fully formed like at all and they're just nasty. I want to say something like a part of me wants to be like Sarah J. Masse, you couldn't give them like more interesting personalities than them just being the evil stepsisters. Because now we're getting more Cinderella than Beauty and the Beast.
Right. And I just hate them and I don't really understand why they have to be so hateable. Yeah, like Nesta could be mean and Elaine could be lazy and they could do it in a way that feels a little bit more like age appropriate. That's the thing, it's just not age appropriate. It's like it's just mean girls. Right. Which works when you're 14. Yeah, when you're 14 and when literally Fera is the only one that's keeping them alive. Like that's the other thing that I just don't connect here and it has always felt very implausible
specifically with Nesta because Nesta is such a cunt. She's such a cunt. And like I just can't, I just don't understand one, why Fera would keep somebody like that alive willfully and two, how you could just be so mean to somebody who's literally the only reason why you're alive. Like that's sociopathic levels of disgusting. That's the thing is that like there's no, because she could be mean without being this horrible sociopath.
Right. And then we will read Nesta's book, there is one from her point of view if you haven't read any of these books and I don't understand how she is redeemed even having read it and now going back. Why? Why is she I think it was blinded by the smut. Me too blinded by the smut. I just, I don't understand why she has to be so ungrateful. Like even her just saying like a begrudging like thank you over dinner, it would go a long way, but she just literally nothing.
And Fera tells us later, it's part of part one. I don't call out when it specifically it is, but she chalks it up to Nesta knowing that she and Fera are cut from the same cloth, but Fera is able to fight her own battles and Nesta's not. So she almost couches it in like a jealousy perspective. But again, it's just, it's like, it's like a lot. It's, it's, it's too much. It's too much.
Yeah. So anyway, when she's alone with her father, Fera tells him that he should talk some sense into Nesta, but he wants Nesta to have hope. Fera knows better than that though and knows that hope for a better life for them is futile. The next day, Fera and her sisters go into town to sell the pelts that she had gotten. On the way, they run into a group of the children of the blessed, which is a cult that worships the Fae like gods. They end up getting into a verbal altercation and it's clear that Fera and her sisters think
poorly of the Fae as do most of their people in town. So the backstory here is that the Fae before this treaty of 500 years ago, this promise, used to keep mortals as slaves and since then have not, but they also like cut them off from most of this island, right? So they got their freedom, but they're kind of left to fend for themselves. It's kind of why they're all very poor, at least in this area. Yeah. So, Fera drags Nesta, specifically, away from this group of people before they can get into
like a physical altercation and she tells her sisters to fuck off while she can sell these pelts. So she ends up approaching a mercenary who is posted up near the fountain. She ends up selling her pelts to this mercenary for more than double than she would get from the regular merchants and the mercenary tells her the reason that she's doing this for Fera is because somebody once showed her a kindness and that it's time for her to repay that. She goes on to warn Fera that the Fae are coming across the wall with more and more frequency and that it's increasingly dangerous to live so close.
She tells Fera that she and her family should leave if they can. Fera goes on to tell us internally that the treaty between the two civilizations was hard fought and originally crafted by eight mortal queens, but it's also very old and it's known that there are holes in the magical wall even when it was first made. I just had a thought about the map because it's an island. The mortal lands are very tiny. They're just like 5,000 mortals left in the world.
I don't know. I had that thought too because there can't be very many of them. No, because it's like the bottom sliver of this island. I mean, we have the mystery continent, but like, is Fera's village the only village on the continent? These are all the humans that exist because she implies that there are other towns. She says, I don't have the time or the money to travel to where I could get a better price, but it can't be that far because it's not that big of a space. Yeah, I think it's misleading because of frankly the proximity of the bigger continent because
if we think that, if we put it in the same context of the UK island, the south of the UK includes London and a couple of other bigger towns like Brighton and things like that. It's possible for there to be a handful of million people, but it's not a lot. I did have that question too because the mercenary even talks about how she did work for a dude who has since left and sailed to the mainland mortal lands. My question immediately was, are we all having this problem or is it just a Prithian problem
that the walls have holes in it? Right, and why and where do the holes come from? And also we learn later, I think Tamlin says, we're always allowed to cross the walls. Yeah, so I don't have that problem. So why are there- What are we doing? What are we doing? The wall is really just a band-aid of cool, go, cool, you're not slaves, I guess. It really feels more like something to keep the mortals out of the fey worlds, like-
Yeah, sure does. You can't sit with those kind of thing? Yeah, I don't know. Anyway, Feyre rejoins her sisters and as they start walking back to their cottage, she sees Isaac. Isaac is a local farm boy and has been her one and only lover for a couple of years now. She admits that there's no love between them, but it's still stung when she found out recently that he was intending to be married to someone else. But she ends up going to meet him anyway and it's implied that they have sex, but we don't see it. Which is fine, I'm kind of glad we don't see it, because I got big ledge vibes, or we
just know it's a thing, but we don't need to see it, because that's not what we're here for. Exactly. And I don't want to read that. No, I don't either. Especially because Feyre describes it as not very coordinated and kind of hurried and very young. Yeah. So that doesn't sound great. It's not like they're both of them, but neither of them are really like in it for the other. Correct. So later that evening, Feyre intends to broach the conversation of Tomas again with Nesta, but is interrupted when a beast, a literal beast, bursts into their house.
Feyre describes this beast as feline with a wolf head, golden fur, and elk-like horns protruding from its head. She immediately moves in front of her family and the beast snarls at her, calling her a murderer. He demands to know who killed the wolf, and Feyre, while her father and sister's cower in the back of the room, faces the beast alone. She asks if this wolf, Fey, had been killed by accident, what would be the price for that accident? My bad. My bad. And this beast tells her that according to the treaty, it's a life for a life.
So this Fey life has been taken. He deserves to take a mortal life in exchange. Relectantly, Feyre understands that she doesn't have a choice, and so she tells him that she's the one that killed this wolf, and that if he's going to kill her, at least do it outside, so that her family doesn't have to clean it up, which I feel like is the epitome of the abuse that she's had to endure all of her life. Uh-huh. And it's very much just, I don't want to be a burden in my death.
How dare I take up space with my death? With my blood on the floor. Right. Surprisingly, this beast tells her that actually she has a choice. She could be killed now, or she can go with him into his lands into Prithian and live out the rest of her life there. She asks him why the fuck would I want to do that when the Fey lands are so dangerous, often fatal to mortals. And she's like, also, why are you telling me about this loophole? This doesn't make any sense. Yeah. Because it doesn't.
No. It doesn't. Even reading this conversation again, I'm like, you're not, you're not giving her a straight answer on everything, like anything. No. And in this realm of the Fey, we get the classic, the Fey can't lie. Yes. Which is always interesting to me, but like, it doesn't make any goddamn sense. Why would you give me that option? And he doesn't give her an answer, but Scoff spent mortals truly are thankless. And he's like, do you want to die or not? Which, what a quick ending to the book if she was like, now I choose D.
Death. I would rather die. And he's like, okay, great. Swipe. Ultimately, she decides to live out her days in Prithyan. Of course. And he tells her they leave immediately. So she's gathering her things. And before she leaves, she looks at Nesta and she's like, Tomas' father beats his mother and neither he nor his brothers do anything about it. She tells her, quote, bruises are harder to hide than poverty, which I thought was really badass. It was really badass. And I like that. I mean, I don't know if she talks to you about this gently, but fuck you, make your own choices.
Right. Her father tells her that if she's ever able to escape from this new predicament that she should never come back and she should make her own way in the world, which like, pfft, Jesus Christ. Fucking dark in here. And she has no words for Elaine. And so she just leaves. Turns out the beast has a white horse waiting for Pharah and she rides this as they turn north toward the wall. She tells us more about the world as they begin this journey. There is indeed a continent to the east of their island. And so that map, even though it's a little bit disorienting, is accurate.
I just have to assume that those lands aren't actually that close. But this other mainland is also divided between mortal and fey lands. This also falls into the category of why are you telling us this now? I have too many questions. I have too many questions and it doesn't become relevant for maybe four books. Okay, like, I think this would have benefited from just showing me Prithyan and not any of the other lands and then exposing that to me as we got into the larger world.
Yeah, because her favorite to have like that much information kind of flies in the face of the other things that we know about her and what she demonstrates to us later, which is she's kind of illiterate, literally and figuratively. Yeah. So like, how does she know so very little about her own world, but she knows enough that there's a mainland that also has this situation, like that doesn't make any fucking sense. That's a really good question. And how did you learn so much about like history and geography, but you don't know how to read? Very good point. Someone taught you something.
She talks about how in the fey lands, they have different ruling systems, but that in Prithyan, the fey lands are split up into the different realms and they're ruled by high lords, which are so powerful that they can, they're rumored at least to be able to level buildings and armies with just a glance. Vera, she believes all of this like doesn't need any convincing. Nope. Nope. Not at all. She tries to make conversation with the beast. Her thought is that she might find a weakness that she might be able to exploit and escape,
but she's met with bitterness and silence and eventually he uses his magic to put her to sleep for at least two days. I did think this was funny because on one hand, like he covers it up by saying like, I didn't want you to know how to get here, which doesn't really make sense because like, where's she going to go? Really I think she just, he just didn't want to talk to her. Right. Yeah. Indicator number one that he's an asshole. Anyway, one of so many. It's important to note here that she identifies magic in this world by its metallic stench.
So she knows when it's happening because she can act, she can literally smell it. When she wakes up, they have arrived at this mansion, but it is very empty, eerily so. She's floored by the abundance of this mansion that sits before her. It's surrounded by gardens and it's made of white alabaster and it's unlike anything she's seen before. It strikes her as odd that it never occurred to her that the fairies might want to live in civilization the same as mortals. When she gets off her horse, she realizes that she's weak from not having eaten anything in two or more days.
Okay, Tamlan. So she, on shaky legs, follows the beast inside to a dining room where there's an opulent feast laid out. When this beast gets to the head of the table, he transforms into a man and she realizes that he is Haifa, one of the ruling nobles of the land. He's described as being young looking with his nose, cheeks, and brows covered by quote, a golden mask embedded with emeralds shaped like whirls of leaves. She thinks that this mask must be some kind of high fashion for this world and she doesn't
think another thing about it. She can see, despite the mask, that this guy is a strong jaw and he's also dressed like a warrior as well. His hair is the same like golden color as the pelt in his beast form was. Faehra refuses to eat because of the lore that the fairy food is not for mortals to eat because if they do eat it, then they'll become imprisoned body and soul to their fairy overlords. Which she kind of is already anyway, so like why not just eat the food? Why not go whole hog, right? Yeah, I mean I would.
So Deuter tells her that it's safe and that the doors are always open and she may live anywhere that she wants to, that he is not her jailer. But he doesn't tell, like it's clear that he knows that she's afraid to eat the food, but he doesn't go so far as to say like it's not enchanted, like blah blah blah, whatever, how can I convince you, like he's just like it's fine. Well and like, again fairies can't lie, but you telling me it's fine doesn't really tell me anything. No, because you could be saying under your breath, it's fine for dogs. It's fine for me. Yeah, like it's not poison, but it might make you a slave.
Right. As Faehra contemplates leaving, another man enters and this one has red hair and a fox mask. And he asks this blonde guy whose name is Tamlin, I'm just going to call him Tamlin. He asks Tamlin if Andres is indeed dead. It's clear that Andres was the wolf killed by Faehra and Tamlin tells this other guy about as much. When this man turns to face her, she realizes that he's missing an eye that's been replaced with a magical golden orb that moves as an eye would.
We learn that his name is Lucian and it's clear that both he and Tamlin are surprised, incredulous and viscerally upset that she was the one that was able to kill their friend. They continue to be like assholes about the situation and I, it's kind of spoilery because I know why this happened, but like I don't actually remember the particulars, but like they kind of knew what was going to happen. So like why are they, I don't understand why they're treating her with such disdain. And one, it's not her fault.
Two, Andres will learn, went there and died willingly to break this fucking curse. Like I just don't understand why they're acting this way. I know. I don't understand either. And like I don't really remember Lucian being that big of an asshole because he's really for a while more of an asshole than Tamlin. Like Tamlin's just kind of a wet blanket for a while. I know I said for a while repetitively. But then I, I recall Lucian being sort of a confidant of sorts, but he is just raging. Yeah.
He's at a hundred immediately. And I do think that he gets better with time. And I can kind of understand why he's being more of an asshole in this situation because he doesn't have a dog in this fight. He's a sad lonely boy. Anyway, Pharah is summarily dismissed and goes with another Faye named Alice to her chambers. Alice too wears a mask. I forgot about the mask thing. And at this point in my book, I literally wrote, what's with the masks? Yeah. What's with the masks?
I don't understand. So as she leaves the room, Pharah hears Lucian pushing Tamlin to say enough that whatever Pharah had done, it had dealt them a sore hand. But Tamlin refuses and says that Pharah will remain here and unharmed. He says, quote, her life in that hovel was hell enough. Damn. Yeah. I mean, Tamlin for all of his shortcomings at least has eyes. He does have eyes. But Pharah kind of takes offense at this.
Like, I guess it did look like a hovel compared to him. And I'm like, girl, what would you call it? Yeah. I mean, this is really where we start to see. I mean, we got a little bit of a flavor when she was talking about like specifically how Nesta treated her, but also like Elaine and her father to some extent, like very derogatory, very like putting her down. She can never do anything that's good enough for them, like that kind of thing. And then in this situation, she projects that onto like these Faye because one, they treat her with disdain and two, they're Faye, right?
Like so humans are essentially like bugs to them. They are nothing. Yeah. And it's worth mentioning here that most Faye are immortal or close enough to it. Close enough to it, yeah. So in her chambers, Alice and a couple of other Faye maids, Baith, Fera, they cut her hair and then they try to dress her in a gown, but she begs for her old clothes. So Alice gives in and like holds up her old clothes and are like, I'm not putting you in these. I'm going to put you in this other set of pants.
Cool. Cool. She like storms into the room and comes back with basically scraps of fabric and is like, yo, we tried to wash your clothes and they just fell apart. So yeah. Be naked. I'm not dressing you in this. Yeah. Right. Oh, what? I'm trying to help you. So she gives Fera pants and a tunic and this is what Fera wears for most of the time. Alice then warns Fera to keep her mouth shut and her ears open, except with Lucian because he could stand to be knocked down a few pegs. I did really enjoy that.
The whole time Fera is plotting, she's unsure if Tamlin will be true to his word or simply likes playing with his food. She also doesn't know what to make of the other Faye, treating her with ostensibly respect and she's interested to see how far Tamlin's word will go in that regard. When she's brought back to the dining room, this is when we learn that Tamlin's name is Tamlin. Anyway, Tamlin and Lucian force her to sit and eat using magic. They literally bind her to a chair until she actually eats and has finished her plate.
Which, okay. Yeah. But they do this, but then when she reaches for a second helping of chocolate tort, the food disappears and Tamlin tells her that if she were to eat another bite, she'll throw it up. Which is a tam-tang. Yeah. Do you want me to eat or not? Also, who cares? Who gives a shit? You clearly do. I'm eating. That's what you wanted me to. Yeah. Let me eat. And like, aren't you happy that I am eating? Whatever. Whatever. Yeah. And this is where I have in my notes, it's interesting going back and rereading for a third time and picking up on all of the little things because like, one, if you had
put me to sleep for two plus days and not fed me, I would be pissed. If you did this to me, I would be so pissed. And it just feels like a tease, like to wait until she's like actually comfortable, actually eating, actually excited to eat more. And then you're just like, it's gone. Psych. Oh yeah. Totally a control thing. What? Also, you easily could have woken her up in the two days to feed her, but okay. Yeah. You could have, but you didn't. Because she could have died in those two days. She was already near death.
Yes. But okay. All right. All right. Anyway, so Phaerys released from her invisible bonds and as she leaves, Lucien asks her why she's so insistent on not spending time with them. He says they must be better looking than any mortal she spent time with before. And Phaerys finds this extremely arrogant and she retorts that she doesn't understand why they want to spend so much time with a mortal girl. Oh, to say, yeah, I mean, good point. The next day, Alice ends up dressing her and she goes for a walk.
As she does, she doesn't pass anybody, despite the fact that Alice and Lucien all refer to quote others being in this place. But it's like a ghost town. Like she sees not a soul. Not a one. On her way out of the mansion, she runs into Tamlin and he asks her if she wants a tour. And she says she's also no thanks. Bye. To which she says, do you have a problem with me? And she's like, well, nothing beyond being trapped here for the rest of my life based
on a treaty that I didn't even sign. Also, why? Of course she has a problem with you. Yeah. Let me count the ways. Tam, Tam, like I the lack of empathy, really. The other thing that I really hated about the scene is she the night before she asked him like, well, what am I supposed to do with my time? Like you don't want me to work or anything. And he's like, I don't give a shit what you do. Like I don't care. And so she was like, I'm going to walk in the gardens.
That's my thing for the day. And so she finds like a hallway of paintings, which doesn't matter. But she makes a comment or she's like, I could look at these paintings all day. But no, I'm going to the gardens. No one's making you go to the gardens. Right. You could do that all day. I don't know. It just bugged me. But then, okay. But the thing that bugged me and I think this is very intentional is that Tamlin says, I don't give a fuck what you do, right? And then at every possible point that he can, he does give a fuck what she does.
He gives a big fuck what she does. Yeah. And it's like not the right thing that she's doing. You're right. Okay. Okay. Okay. Tam, Tam. So they go on to have a bit more of a conversation and Tamlin ends up telling Thera that there is a sickness in Prithian, specifically having to do with magic. He tells her that that's why Andres was across the wall, that Tamlin had sent him there to look for a cure. The sickness is spreading, but it's spreading slowly and eventually it will go to the mortal world, but for now, her family is safe.
He tells her that the masks that they all wear are a manifestation of this magical blight that happened 49 years ago and they can't take them off. At that point, I was like, Oh yes, this was a thing. I didn't give a shit about the first time. Yeah. Okay. Because, because what this reminded me of is like, yeah, we'll get more information about the sickness and whatever, but it made me think of light lark or like some of them have like really shitty curses and others just like they can't fly.
Yes. You have masks on like, okay. Boo fucking noob. And they're pretty like whatever. Yeah. No. Um, in the, in this world, very similar to light, like some people had way shittier experiences in the last 50 years. Yeah. So I'm just like, okay. And Farrah even almost feels bad. She's like, Oh wow, well, you didn't have a mask on as your beast. You can either be a beast or wear a mask. What a hard life. And I'm like, they're fucking fine. Okay.
They're fine. Farrah fuck off. Make their mask cover their mouth so they can't eat, like make them blind. Like, no, they're just wearing basically masquerade ball gown masks. They're fine. They're fine. Yeah. That's literally fine. She's like, I would claw my own skin off. I'm like, me wouldn't. You wouldn't though. Like, no, you wouldn't. It's an inconvenience at most. Yeah. Anyway, during her walk in the garden alone, Farrah swears that she keeps hearing someone behind her, maybe even two people, but when she turns to look, there's no one there.
I can't imagine why anyone would be watching you. I can't imagine. At dinner, Farrah is mostly silent, but steals a knife when she thinks no one's looking. Lucian asks her later if she has hobbies and she says no, but Tamlin interjects that she likes to hunt. She corrects Tamlin by saying that she hunts out of necessity. She goes on to ask if either of them have any idea what it's like to not know where their next meal will come from. They don't really have an answer to this, but they end up getting out of her that Farrah is 19 and that her mother died when she was eight of typhus.
So that deathbed promise, she was eight. Who asks an eight-year-old to take care of their entire family? Dude. Why was that promise not for the debt? You know what, it makes a lot of sense though if Nesta is cut from the same cloth as their mother and they're both sociopaths. Yeah, that's true, because it sounds like her mother was like just regal, aloof, cold. I mean, that's what we're told, right? The worst. Absolutely the worst. So the next day Farrah has concocted a plan. She is determined to get Lucian alone in an attempt to have him plead her case to be released
to Tamlin. On the way though, she runs into Tamlin and he offers to take her for a ride in the grounds. She refuses, but thanks him for the offer. She ends up finding Lucian in the stables and he invites her on a hunt. She accepts and he immediately calls her out on her plan. He tells her there's nothing to be done unless Tamlin decides to kill her, which was Lucian's preference, so by all means, have him beg for that. Buy your leave, princess. Farrah asks about the court and the masks and the sickness, but Lucian gets pale and
antsy as he tells her something sent straight from hell is the cause of the blight. He immediately regrets the remark though because of a her who might overhear this comment. Farrah finds this weird that this her could be here and he was dropping in the middle of a forest. This is fucking weird. One thing I wanted to say and if you said it and I just fell asleep for a second, I apologize, but Tamlin does tell her that like her family has been taken care of. So she's so worried about getting home because her family is going to die, but Tamlin's like they're good girl.
Yeah, but again, that's a really good point. I didn't write that down, but again, this is where like just three more words could have gone a long way. I gave them money like yeah, that's four words. Sorry, but he tells her they're taken care of, but she's like even in her head, she's like what the fuck does that mean? Yeah, because what does that mean? Like you gave her you gave them a hundred bucks. You gave them some meat where really what we find out, I don't know if it's even in this book, but like they have a whole new house with like money and shit.
They are just fine. They've basically been restored to their previous status. Yeah, and I don't really understand why he doesn't just tell her that. Yeah, I don't either. And this is the first time that it comes up, but it comes up again and it's like, okay, can you just say more things and increasingly as I'm going through this book, as I'm looking at it with a critical eye, Tamlin really is portrayed as being like kind of bestial. Like he's almost nonverbal in a lot of these conversations.
Yeah, he doesn't. He doesn't do himself any favors. No, like he tells us later that he doesn't, he was not brought up to communicate well, but like there's a difference between communicating well and being able to communicate at all. He can't communicate for shit. Yeah. Anyway, favorite goes on to ask Lucian how he got the golden eye and he tells her it, he got it because he didn't keep his mouth shut, but he does tell her that it wasn't Tamlin who took his eye, but Tamlin was the one that procured the golden eye at a later
date. Their conversation is interrupted though by a bog, bog, boggy, boggy, boggy, boggy, okay, we're going to go with boggy, it's B-O-G-G-E. Boggy. Anyway, Lucian tells Farah not to look at this thing no matter what happens, so she focuses on a tree in the distance and she ends up feeling a biting cold circling them and she hears a voice begging her to look, but she refuses. When this thing is gone, Lucian tells her that if she would have looked at it or acknowledged its existence in any way, it would have made the boggy real and it would have killed her.
He goes on to tell her that there are other nasty things in the woods these days like the cereal for example who would answer any question she had if she trapped it. I don't know why he brings up the cereal in this conversation because the cereal's not dangerous. No, the cereal's not dangerous. It can't even get out of a snubble, we'll get there later, but whatever. But like it's pretty benign, it just looks a little spooky. Yeah, but this is where we learned about the cereal. Later that evening, Tamlin is clearly miffed that Farah jolted him in favor of spending
time with Lucian, but Lucian very adeptly redirects Tamlin's fury by telling him about the boggy and Tamlin leaves immediately to go kill it. Which was another indication to me that Tamlin is just very toxic because Farah has said fuck all about wanting to spend time with him. You've said fuck all about wanting to spend time with her, you owe each other nothing and then you're getting your panties in a twist because she spent time with somebody else. Right, like sure, you invited her out, she's allowed to say no.
Yeah, you're also, you're her captor, you literally took her away from her family. And also that's where he is to your point just animalistic, like not super there because recall he asked, do you have a problem with me? As if that's a genuine question to ask. Right. Yes. Yes, I do. Sure would. Back in her room, Farah sharpens the dinner knife she stole while she watches for Tamlin's
return. She finds it ridiculous that she's doing this, but she can't bring herself to sleep. But then as she's looking out the window, she sees a figure out in the garden and she realizes that it's her father. She grabs her go bag and goes to chase after him. He ends up, he starts to hobble for the gate and so like she's walking toward him, but she never actually reaches him. And right before she's about to exit the gate with her father, Tamlin stops her of all people and tells her to look again.
When she does, she sees not her father, but a bow and arrow leaning up against a tree. Then it changes into a pile of supplies and then it changes in her thought into her father again. Tamlin tells her that this is actually a creature called a puka that takes the form of your deepest desire in order to lure you into a secluded place where then it eats you slowly. She tells her that fey like the puka and the bogey used to be kept in their own lands, but since the blight, the words on those lands have been weakened and that these creatures
now roam more freely. That's fun because the humans also thought they were safe, but the walls are breaking down. Yeah. It's also, I feel compelled to point out here that she's still not meeting anybody else. So we're talking about a handful of people, she's only seeing a handful of people. She's only seen three fairies, maybe five because she's like other handmaids type of things. And she has asked Tamlin about this and Lucian and they kind of hand wave it away like, oh,
you know, people, it's the blight or they're on patrol or whatever. Yeah, but they're not really giving her a straight answer. No, not at all. So Tamlin goes on to ask her in this moment what she planned to do and she tells him, I want to go the fuck home. I made a vow to protect my family and now I can't because of this stupid fucking treaty. And this is where Tamlin tells her again that her family is more well taken care of now than when she was with them. He says they are fed and comfortable. And it's here that Pharah feels off kilter because her vow is effectively fulfilled,
but she derived a lot of meaning from that vow and now she doesn't know how to feel about it. And now, sure, life is literally worthless. Yeah. So this is where Pharah asks again where everyone is and Tamlin is like, well, you know, they're at the border. You know, when I'm here, we don't need a lot of protection because I'm, you know, a bad ass. I'm great. And this is where he talks about training with his father's army to protect the land because it wasn't his original lot to rule.
Pharah doesn't ask a follow up question. Not a follow up question to be seen. Not a one. So the next couple of days pass and Tamlin is in a mood about the bagae because he hasn't found it and hasn't been able to kill it yet. And he goes off hunting it every day. Pharah barely sees him and Lucian tells her that this is normal for Tamlin because he has to show strength in order to rule properly. And my perspective is no, he does this because he doesn't know how to process his feelings and is closer to his beast form than his man form.
Yeah, he just doesn't know how to process anything. No. One night Pharah dreams of killing Andrus again the whole time she feels watched, but when she's done skinning the wolf this time, he turns into a man and it jerks her away. Gross. For the first, so fucking gross, she talks about how the body steams in the snow. Yeah. Trauma. This is the first time that she feels shame for what she did. Oof. It's dark in here.
So this same night she goes wandering just so she doesn't have any more nightmares and she begins to make a map of the house because she's determined to learn about her surroundings. As she stands in the main foyer of the house Tamlin comes back. He's covered in blood in his clothes or in tatters. He is devoid of emotion. He's like a space cadet. Here asks him whether he killed the bogey and he says yes. He asks what she's doing and she tells him and he deduces that she can't read. Well, he just says it.
He's like, you can't read, can you? I did actually really enjoy that scene. We're not going to be on the bush here. Like, come on. So knowing that it's just another thing that makes her less ban Pharah deflects asking where they can clean him up and so he leads her to an infirmary. And so this is just one very clear example of where she deflects away from like her supposed weaknesses and doesn't ask for help. But she does that a lot. Like her internal monologue is when she doesn't have any information about something and she's asked a direct question.
Like internally she's hearing these words of like ignorant, worthless, like really harsh things. And she consistently tells us that she hears Nesta saying those words. Yeah, I wonder why. That bitch. So Pharah bandages Tamlin's hand or something and he asks her how she learned to be so good at other things without being able to read. She tells him, quote, that's what happens when you're responsible for lives other than
your own, isn't it? You do what you have to do. And I think it's just so dark in here that fully three other adults relied on somebody who is a child to take care of them. It's so dark in here. And like, I get, I understand why her personality is the way it is, but I do wish that she had more pride in the fact that she's the only reason her family was alive. I wish that she would be a little bit clearer about that. Like she gives her family like so much leeway.
Yeah. Yeah. And she's like, she doesn't give us a good reason. She's just like, yeah. I mean, they treat me like shit, but I did this thing for them. And it's like, okay, how do you feel nothing about it? She's not like bitter. She doesn't say like, I really resent or I hate this. Like she'll say offhanded things like, oh, when our father decided that we existed, right? Like that kind of thing. But I wanted her to have a little bit stronger emotion for being treated like absolute shit. Yeah. The only time she really does say anything is when it's kind of it's, it's family as
a whole. Like you said. There's never really about her with the exception of her. I am a worthless piece of human. Right. Exactly. She's internalized all of that hate to herself, I think. So anyway, the next day she overhears Lucien and Tamlin fighting. Lucien accuses Tamlin of giving up and Tamlin warns him to watch what he says. Farah makes a sound on accident though, and she's forced to enter the room and stop the conversation.
And when she does this, she tries to cover for herself by asking if Lucien is going to ride that day. This is what she does most days. She goes for a ride with Lucien. She has no hobbies. But Lucien's not going for a ride and he foists Farah onto Tamlin. And this is something that Farah really doesn't want. And this is where I really started to notice. And so I went back at all of the other interactions and she had similar internal monologues. But Lucien says to her something like, he can take you for a ride.
And her internal monologue immediately is no. Yep. She has zero interest in spending any time with Tamlin. Yep. And I just, it's interesting to me that it's so visceral. Like no, I don't want to do that. Absolutely not. It is really interesting. Especially knowing where this goes, I'm having a really hard time understanding or remembering how we get anywhere. Truly. Like beyond just straight up settling for this human.
Oh, fairy. It's got to be based in a lot of what she says. Like I don't really remember, but I'm interested to see how her internal monologue toward him changes. Yeah. Because I wouldn't have been into it if it was like, man, I hate this guy, but he's kind of hot. Exactly. But we don't even get any like comment on his appearance really. I mean, like she gives us the basic appearance, but she's never, her internal monologue is never ogling him or admiring him. No. Even I think at some point, maybe they're the first dinner.
Lucian says something like, I get why you don't want to look at me, but like, look at that guy. He's pretty cute, right? And fair. She's like, no. Yeah. Like she'll say things like, like when Tamlin came in and he was injured, she'll say like, oh, he's clearly muscular and like male, but she's not like, and I'm drooling. Right. Like it's not that. It's purely in just like an assessing like he's a dude and he has muscles. Like it means observationally. That's the word. Like she has no, there's zero interest. Yeah.
It's fascinating. It is fascinating. I'm so interested to see how this goes or how it gets to where I know it's going. Right. Exactly. So Farrah ends up telling Tamlin that she doesn't want to go for a hunt. So instead he shows her the library. It's there that she begins on her own to try to improve her reading skills, but she's far too proud to ask for help even when Tamlin offers it. She hears Nesta's voice in her head telling her she's ignorant and worthless.
During her exploration of the library, she also uncovers a wall mural that is part map in part history. It shows the creation of everything from a black cauldron shows the before lands, the battle of the treaty and the after lands. She sees no detail on the mortal lands and finds that offensive, but she also sees one big bald mountain in the north that isn't labeled. But she remarks, this map is probably for Faye. The Faye probably know what that mountain is and it's not for me because I don't live here. Which is also why there's no detail in the mortal lands, girly.
Exactly. Just saying. That evening she seeks Lucian out and asks him how to trap the cereal. He tells her and they kind of have this hypothetical conversation, but it's clear that Lucian knows that she's going to do that. This is so interesting to me. We haven't gotten to the point where we find out his motivations here, but I genuinely wonder if he was trying to kill her. I don't know. I wondered that the first time I read this and reading this conversation again, I really
feel like he was hoping she would die. It's either that or if he was convinced that she was going to be fine. I don't know how he would feel that way, but it's a possibility. So he tells her to use a freshly slaughtered chicken as bait in the middle of a grove of young birch trees and to use a double loop snare to make sure that the cereal's limbs are tied down. He makes it clear that both he and Tamlun will be out for the day.
So Feyre immediately grabs what she needs and she sets out to hunt the cereal. She posts up in a clearing of the correct trees and sets her trap. Hours later she is successful. The cereal appears and is caught in her trap and is described as being clothed in black tattered robes with a veil over its head. It had, quote, a face that looked like it had been crafted from dried, weatherworn bone, its skin either forgotten or discarded, a lipless mouth and two long teeth held by blackened gums, slitted holes for nostrils and eyes, eyes that were nothing more than swirling
pits of milky white, the white of death, the white of sickness, the white of clean picked corpses, end quote. Which is such a great description. It really is. It makes my skin crawl in the best way. Exactly. So I was worried that we had elevated this series like so high that the writing wasn't actually going to be that good, even if the plot was okay. But her writing is really good. Her writing is really good, which I appreciate. Yeah, because I was scared.
That was concerned. I was concerned. It's interesting to me too, going back and being like aware of the significance of all of these things, because I've read this book, like the cereal is immediately entertained. Oh yeah. I got the feeling that the cereal wasn't even caught. It was just waiting for an invitation. Well, I do wonder about that because the cereal is repeatedly described as dangerous, but I don't know how, because it's in the snare and it can't get out of the snare.
And I don't know why, because it has hands. And intelligence. Yeah. And some kind of magic, because when it flees, it turns into a puff of smoke. Which couldn't it, couldn't it smoke puff and get out of the snare? Yeah, so part of me wonders if this is, it's staying trapped quote unquote, because it's entertained and then later it's a test. I don't know. But it seems a little farfetched for a fay to be totally captive by a rope snare.
Right, because it's essentially like a super fay. Right. So, yeah. And she's not using a magical snare. No. She put out a chicken and a rope and it was like, oh no, I'm trapped. Oh, I can't get out. Okay. I just, I don't buy it. So Farah gets to asking her questions and the first one that she starts off with is, whatever it is, any way for her to go home. The cereal is like, no girl.
Sorry. She then asks what the cereal knows about Tamlin and the cereal is like, you got to be more specific. I know a lot of things about the High Lord of the Spring Court, if you know what I mean. And Farah's like, excuse me, what? Come again? Come again? Because she's just over here thinking that Tamlin is a noble, not the king of this whole realm. This whole realm. Yeah. Yeah. The cereal ends up telling Farah quote, stay with the High Lord human. That's all you can do. You will be safe. Do not interfere, do not go looking for answers after today or you will be devoured by the
shadow over Perthian. He will shield you from it. So stay close to him and all will be righted. And this is where we get the quintessential quote, stay with the High Lord. Right. Notably, does not name which High Lord. Which High Lord. Yeah. It's implied that it's Tamlin because she asked about Tamlin. However. Yeah. This is where the, the cereal is just like, oh, did I do that? Whoops. But it's also interesting to me that she goes on to say like, I'm gendering the cereal.
The cereal goes on to say, don't interfere, don't go looking for answers. Like Farah immediately goes and does that thing. Like you had to know that that was going to happen. Immediately. Like that's where I kind of feel like the cereal is like, don't go looking for answers. Wink, wink. Farah's like, did you just say wink out loud? Right. It's like, I don't have eyelids, bitch. I don't have eyelids.
Yeah. Um, so spoilers. She's not talking about Tamlin when she says that. Um, which if you're listening to the series and you haven't read, if you're listening to this episode and you haven't read the series, like, you have a wild experience with romantic books. Okay. Because that's the thing is I meant to say this when I was doing the intro, but I didn't realize this book was published in 2015. Like this book has been out almost 10 years. That's kind of wild. I didn't realize it was that old. No, I meant to say that when I read that and I was like, what?
Like I thought it was published in like 2020. Yeah, I did too. But I do think that it's worth like calling out that like Romantic is having like a moment now, but like there's a lot of grind happening specifically for SJM. Yeah, there's a lot of grind happening. Anyway, the cereal is feeling chatty. And so she goes on, sorry, it goes on to tell Farah about Highburn, which is Ireland on that. And it's King who chafed under the treaty and so sent his most trusted warriors to infiltrate
the kingdoms of Prithian so he could make a move. But one of these warriors betrayed him 50 years ago and this person is named the deceiver. Before the cereal can go on though, the cereal interrupts itself and says that they are not alone. They say that they are stalked by the Naga, fairies who are made of shadow and hate and rot, and that these Naga will trap them both if Farah does not free the cereal and run. The Naga appear and they're described as being a horrible mashup of humans and serpents. As they close in, the cereal begs Farah to let it go and Farah eventually does shoot
an arrow at the snare and release the cereal. This is where I'm like, okay, you're really gonna this magical fey that's not a part of a court because it's older than time, can't get out of a rope snare. It's not even like a bear trap. It is just a rope like around its ankle or something. Yeah, but this is, but if you go with the line of like the cereal is kind of like a trickster god and can do whatever the fuck it wants, like I could see where the cereal is engaging in this for its own amusement and was testing Farah, you know.
Exactly. And could have like if Farah had been like, nope, sorry, bitch, I would have escaped. Fully. Yeah. Anyway, so the Naga poofs off and doesn't help Farah. Thanks bitch. Farah then fires another arrow at one of the Naga and then she flees for Tam Tam's place. She screams on the off chance that Lucian or someone else might hear her income running but doesn't hold her breath. The Naga chase her and easily catch up. She fights them off as best she can, but they ultimately tackle her to the ground. She takes the hunting knife that she took from Lucian out of her boot and stabs the
Naga on top of her in the throat, killing it. And that's when Tamlan arrives and dispatches the other two. He goes to help Farah up off the ground. She's in a bad way and so he uses his magic to heal her wounds and he goes on to ask why she's out there. Farah lies and says that she didn't realize that she was so far into the forest. And Tamlan doesn't push. He tells her in a roundabout way that he's impressed that she killed two other Naga on her own, like, you know she's a hunter. She killed one of your people like I can't write and it is roundabout.
It's not even an outright compliment. It's just like, huh? I guess that's impressive. Yeah, he's like, I came upon another dead Naga. Was that you two? Like that's it. Yeah, like cool, bro. Tamlan tells her that he was tracking this group of Naga and four of them broke off from the group. That's why he was close enough to hear her scream. As they walk back to the mansion, Farah mulls over what the serial told her. She begrudgingly decides to stay with Tamlan, but she resolves to tell her family to warn them of the unrest that's happening in Prythian.
She and Tamlan walk in silence because rather than a bloodlust or a sense of accomplishment, all she detects from Tamlan is a deep sense of shame and defeat. Why though? I don't remember why that is. I don't either. I don't either. Also, my second why? Why are you going to tell your family? Why do you give two shits about those people? Let them die. You care. Your vow is fulfilled. And there's clearly no love lost. At no point do we get any sort of like begrudging respect or love.
Not even like, I love them because they're my family. It's just like I have to take care of these fucktards. So because my dead mother made me promise. My dead insane mother who also never loved me. Right. Like why do you have any loyalty to any of these people? I don't know. I get you're young and so maybe that's it. But I like girl. It goes far. It goes really far. It's been so far so long. Yeah. Anyway, so that's where we're going to end part one. And we will pick back up with part two in two weeks.
So join us then to continue the story. But thank you as always for joining us on this journey and let us know what you think on the socials. You can find us basically everywhere at SpiceTradersPod. And if you really like us and want more, consider becoming a Patreon where we release additional episodes on our off weeks. And if you really, really like us, drop us a review wherever you listen. But until next time, we'll see ya. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.
Triggers: graphic violence and gore, depictions of a fictional plague, on-page sexual content (including masturbation), and themes of parent death and chronic illness KU: No Recommendation: No, (give the author money...
Triggers: (From the author): kidnapping, violence, discussions of abuse, BDSM dynamics and play, tentacle play, brief descriptions of injured animal (that receives aid), breath play, bondage, depictions of sub drop,...
Triggers: war, battle, hand-to-hand combat, perilous situations, blood, intense violence, brutal injuries, death, and poisoning KU: No Recommendation: Yes! For more of the author, check out https://rebeccayarros.com/
Triggers: from the author: “explicit violence, explicit sexual violence, dubious consent, murder, gore, torture, kidnapping, and more.” KU: Yes Recommendation: No For more of the author, check out...
Triggers: death of a parent (off page), grief, fantasy violence KU: No Recommendation: both Traders recommend! This is part 2 of 2. For more of the author, check out https://www.lanaferguson.com/