Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Slabnomics

Slabnomics artwork

House of CardLadder Ft. Chris Mcgill

Jul 22, 202550 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Welcoming on Chris Mcgill (@Chris_HOJ) to talk OG sports card podcasting in 2018 with House of Jordans, the origin story of Card Ladder, how to become a podcasting data analyst music producer CEO. We discuss the team at Card Ladder, Underused Tools, Market Dynamics and philosophies, and a peak behind the podcasting curtain. Weekly Newsletter Signup: Slabnomics.com 🎥Youtube 📸Instagram

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Slab Nomics, the intersection of collecting investment and market theory for sports cards. This is episode 11, House of Cards. Today we get to welcome a very special guest, the CEO and head of research for Card Ladder. Chris is an amazing personality, a very tuned-in individual, and very much a pleasure to have on a podcast. He's kind enough to go through all of the history of what it was like to found Card Ladder during the throes of the pandemic, the House of Jordan podcast that he had antecedent to that, as well as sharing some of his personal tidbits about where he came from.

SPEAKER_00He then goes into a little bit about what Card Ladder is looking to do in the future and some features that you might not know about yet. He always says such nice things about what I'm doing here at Slabnomics. So really glad that I was able to have him on. Let us know as always at our Instagram what you think about the podcast, and be sure to follow at Chris underscore H-O-J. Go see all the cool stuff that he has on his Instagram.

SPEAKER_00It is truly an amazing resource what he puts out into the Instagram world there. So without further ado, here is Chris from Card Ladder. Christopher Reginald McGill. Welcome on to Slabnomics podcast.

SPEAKER_01What if it was? What if you just nailed that?

SPEAKER_00I did actually nail someone's middle name the other day.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00I was like, I'll bet I can guess your middle name. And she's like, No, you can't. I'm like, it's Marie, isn't it? And she was aghast, dude. She almost fell over.

SPEAKER_01That is my mother's middle name. So how about that?

SPEAKER_00You it was actually your mother who I was guessing. Okay, leave my mom alone. All right. Now, welcome onto the podcast. I am very, very excited. If y'all don't know, Chris is the CEO of Card Ladder and also the what is it, the chief research officer?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Which is really what I do. CEO is just a title, but Christina, Josh, and our chief content officer, Nick, we all make card letter decision strategic you know stuff together. I'm my my job is mainly these days on the day-to-day is just head of research.

SPEAKER_00Yes. I always come to you well, I need to do this more actually, come to you with the things I need researched more, and uh then you can tell me to leave you alone.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well that that even that part's funny because um when people do, like we'll get hobby companies or collectors who will approach us with uh big research questions, and if they're a question we can answer, it's it's it's Josh who answers it because he's most capable of it he's our CTO, he's most capable of just uh running that report against the data set and producing the results, whereas me, I would be doing the same thing anybody else would be doing. I'd be going to sales history and typing things in and just sort of manually looking it up.

SPEAKER_00So well, tell us a little bit more about the head of research role and uh fun things you could do with that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm completely useless basically. Uh uh with research, uh I don't know, man. I could go on this, I I would bore the audience to death with this, so I'll just keep it big picture. Which is uh my job is it it for several hours a day, and the hours and these hours take place in the middle of the night, actually, usually starting at around 10 p.m. and running until about 2 a.m. uh central time. I'm reviewing all the sales for the day for the catalog of cards that I actively monitor all incoming sales for, uh, which is about I think my mine's maybe 30 or 40,000 cards, something in that range.

SPEAKER_01And so anytime a new sale of that card comes in, I I review it and I vet it. And some cards are easier to review and vet than others, some sell more frequently than others, some just tend to be easier for people to accurately list than others, some tend to get paid more frequently than others. So you know, eventually after years and years of doing this, I've I figure out ways to efficiently go through my work, but I but I do that every day and there are no days off, uh not holidays, nothing, because the hobby market doesn't take a day off.

SPEAKER_01So every day when people wake up and they check uh their card ladder indexes and collection values and go start doing all their research. Um I've I've reviewed the sales for somewhere around 30 or 40,000 cards the night before to make sure that all those indexes populate properly, that we don't fall victim to junk in, junk out, but instead we're feeding our indexes and our data streams with verified reliable data. And then, you know, that those indexes have are are the architecture of the card ladder price modeling, the CL value, the collection values, um, and so on and so forth.

SPEAKER_01So that that's kind of where I sit in the uh data stuff. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Sounds like you're that guy kind of holding back the damn of falsity.

SPEAKER_01And not just me. Uh there's I have my set of sales that I look at. We have Christina, who has uh a subset of cards that she reviews sales for every night, and we have also Joel and Kyle, who are members of our research team who have been with us for several years. Ever since we joined the Collectors Universe family of companies, they came on over, they were previously working for PSA, they came over and started working for us. They specialize more so in uh TCG, but also they have expertise in the sports too, and so that so there's four of us who are who are uh damming up the flood of of bad data that potentially is lurking.

SPEAKER_00Well, that's beautiful. It takes a village, as they say. And speaking of that acquisition, that was what, December 2021?

SPEAKER_01Around that time, yeah. Yep, around that time there about actually I remember actually it was uh it may have been announced in December, but it was pretty sure it was November because I just I I will never forget sprinting to the finish line of that deal. And you know, in the world of acquisitions, there's so much diligence and back and forth and lawyer stuff, and I did go to law school, so that actually helped me a bit to do this, but uh I'm pretty sure it was technically November when the acquisition was uh finalized.

SPEAKER_00Okay, during right during the craziest times of the hobby, right? Twenty twenty twenty twenty one. Among them for sure. Let's go back and take a little rewind and talk about your background then, since we didn't really get into that. I didn't know that you practiced law.

SPEAKER_01I never practiced. I went to law school. I actually have a habit in my life of uh getting right to the finish line of my education and then really pivoting into some passion project to avoid having to become a legitimate adult. So when I graduated high school, shortly thereafter, I jumped right into the music industry. I I literally moved from my small town in northern Illinois to Atlanta, Georgia, like three or four days after I graduated high school to just dive head first, not knowing what I was doing really, but trying to get in the music industry. And then the same thing happened after I went back to school, and then I and and then instead of just being satisfied with my uh four-year degree, my bachelor's degree, I said, I'm gonna keep this going and go to law school, and then once law school was over, I said, eh, I'm still not ready to be an adult.

SPEAKER_00Let's start a company in collectibles, in cards. Makes sense. I mean, that all tracks. Um so where is the mixtape, the rap mixtape for when you're in Atlanta, Georgia? When will that surface?

SPEAKER_01There's many of them. When I was in Atlanta, so I've I approached the music industry as a producer, so I was more uh on the keys and and behind the mixing board and and sitting hunched over in front of the laptop, which is still the pose that I strike today as well, but just working in collectibles. But uh my my work is all over the place from the from that from that era. I was really like a f I was full-time in music probably from 04 until 2010, roughly. And then I and then I did it part-time while I went back to school, and then I and now I haven't been in a studio for probably five years.

SPEAKER_01Really ever since Card Lighter started. I haven't worked on music. I haven't touched a keyboard or opened up any software music related.

SPEAKER_00That's actually really cool. I'm into EDM. I've always thought about producing because I like when I make content, I actually start with a song, and then um the best content for me starts with a song, and then I build around that and kind of build a story through that. So I've always thought about going and trying to create some stuff. I looked at um the master class from Dead Mouse. He teaches music production, so of course I know everything there is to know him, right?

SPEAKER_01I love Dead Mouse. I used to watch his live streams 10 or 15 years ago. Yeah, really cool stuff. Yeah, like one of his most famous live streams is when that uh you know that song about uh there's somebody like played a demo of a song for him like on a live stream that it became one of his bigger songs. I think it's called the Velt or something like that. I don't remember exactly, but I think I know what you're talking about. Yeah. Yeah, he's very, very talented producer. He was somebody that I would that I would listen to and just sort of sort of just sit down or lay down in the bed, put the headphones on, and just play his music over and over and listen to all the details and all the subtleties that he was doing and and just learn.

SPEAKER_00Strobe is really cool. I'd imagine that would be a good one to do that for.

unknownOh yeah.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so there was a little bit of law mixed in with a little bit of collecting, uh, but from what I read, and this might be faulty information, you came back to the hobby in 2016, and it was through scooping up a Jordan card, a 1993 to 94 Ultra Scoring Kings Jordan card, if I have the right info. You have all the right info.

SPEAKER_01That is correct. Well done. So yeah, I collected as a kid. I like the I was born in 1986, and so uh I was really like entering my most earliest conscious collecting years when I well right around 1993, 94. Like I my you know, my mom and I would go kind of go garage sailing in the neighborhood, you know, in the early 90s and stuff, and like people would have these little their little homemade packs like of all these 90s or 91 hoops random base cards, and like my mom would buy one for me for 25 cents, and I started filling them into binder pages and stuff.

SPEAKER_01But like I really started becoming more into it right around the time I guess I was eight, nine years old or so. And so it's like the product I have a ton of nostalgia for is is 1993-94 Ultra. That that product. And I think like maybe I I once even got a hobby box of that um for a birthday or something, and the they came the hobby boxes had uh had had the one of the series the the box hit was a power in the key insert, and the other one was scoring kings.

SPEAKER_01And I love both of those. And I had when I was a kid, I had a Chris Weber power in the key that I just loved, and then the card that I never got as a kid, but that I always coveted, it was always sitting in the display case, just feeling out of reach, you know, priced for a hundred or two hundred bucks, whatever, something well beyond my means as a nine-year-old or ten-year-old, was the Michael Jordan 1993-94 Ultra Scoring Kings. So that was the card that I immediately, once I got back into collecting, and I immediately remembered that card. I remember immediately remembered I was wanting it, and that was the one I just went for first.

SPEAKER_01I just went and and snagged that one.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's awesome. I mean, it's an awesome card. I know what that one looks like. Um and those inserts for basketball for the 90s were really cool. I'm not as much a basketball collector, but I do kind of gravitate towards those inserts. Are you a basketball guy or what's your lane?

SPEAKER_01Everything. Yeah, basketball is my favorite sport to collect, it's my favorite sport to watch, it's my favorite sport to play. Michael Jordan is my favorite athlete of all time, so on and so forth. So, yeah, I basketball is definitely my preferred lane, but I certainly collect quite a bit of football and watch quite a bit of football and do fantasy football. So, you know, football is up there too, but basketball is is the main thing. And then but m more of my blind spots are are definitely baseball and hockey. Like I played baseball all throughout my youth and teen years, was on traveling teams and stuff.

SPEAKER_01Like I understand the sport pretty well, but I just I I don't really follow it professionally, and and I really don't have much of a connection at all to like hockey or soccer, sports like that.

SPEAKER_00What was your position in baseball?

SPEAKER_01I played pitcher, third base, and first base.

SPEAKER_00All around her.

SPEAKER_01Well, like you know, like you could pitch once every however many games, and if you're not pitching, then you know, if you have a decent arm, they'll put you at third, and if you have size, they'll put you at first. So that's where I slotted in.

SPEAKER_00Did you have any cool nicknames that you'd like to tell the people?

SPEAKER_01No, I didn't have any cool nicknames, but I was such a wimpy hitter. Uh I I had the terrible tendency of stepping out of the box, you know, and I I didn't really like getting beaned. Although once you get beaned, like it's just like, okay, whatever. But I I definitely had a bit of a fear, you know, especially as like getting into that traveling league circuit, and all of a sudden you're like going up against pitchers or throwing the 70s and the 80s and stuff, and I was just like, eh, I I really don't want to get beaned by this ball. And I think that impacted me psychologically as a hitter. But uh, but my my my most fond memory of playing youth baseball was uh my coach had kind of like benched me uh because probably because of my crappy hitting.

SPEAKER_01And so I would just kind of sit in the bench and and then but but then they brought me in at the end of a game and uh and I happened to hit a home run, like my only home run I ever hit. I happened to hit this home run. And then they still bench me in the next game. They were like, we're not buying this. This is a fluke. So like that's like the that was the arc of my baseball career. It's like I got benched and then I had to hit this home run, like, and that was like my peak, and then back to the bench.

SPEAKER_00Dude, that is not the right movie. You know, it's not supposed to go like that.

SPEAKER_01That's not uplifting anybody, that's depressing people.

SPEAKER_00All right. Well, baseball stories aside, you have been very, very successful in many things that you've done, especially with your House of Jordans podcast that you started a long time ago. Uh 2018 is when I think it might have started. Can you talk a little bit about that? I know you said Jordan is your your favorite player, especially on the basketball side. How did that podcast come about, especially so early in uh in these days?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I had the means to make it, which is very important. Um, because like at this time I was living in Los Angeles in Westwood, going to law school, and I had my music studio set up because I was still kind of doing that part-time, and my music studio obviously had microphones and a mixing board and all that type of stuff. And so not only did I have the ability to do a podcast, but I had like lots of different microphones, you know, from like recording acoustic instruments or just uh doing vocals and multiple performers or whatever. So I I had all the tools and I've always loved to blab and to talk, and I had this passion for collecting, and then I had immediate access to Christina, who lived with me, and to my cousin Brian, who also lived in Los Angeles, not so far away.

SPEAKER_01And so we uh we all were kind of getting into cards a little bit more. Um, and and I just said, why don't the three of us just start making a podcast about Michael Jordan cards? There's no sports card podcasts out there. I try to find some to listen to. And I I should qualify that there there's there's there were very few that specifically spokes like basketball, but but I but there certainly was before us there was uh cardboard chronicles with Josh, and there was uh 90s beatball cards with Jake.

SPEAKER_01Those were already on YouTube before. There was the basketball card podcast with Adam Gray, and then um right around the time we started, the the Wax Museum podcast started with uh Kyle. So like there was a there was a little fun the uh a bubble of content forming, but um there just wasn't enough. You know, I wanted to listen to podcasts all the time and stuff, and I I'm all I'm almost I'm always listening to podcasts, so like I just wanted card content. I figured, well, if it's not out there, then make it and and put put something out there.

SPEAKER_01So we we would record one episode a month, roughly, and those episodes would be three to four hours long, and every show would have a script, not not like a a a word-for-word script, but like it would it would it would be something a little more intricate than a than an outline. And and by the time we were like really hitting our stride, I mean I was I was pumping out ten-page script outline things that we would go off of. So, you know, it was just like ideas would accumulate over a month, you know, like we'd record one episode, then you know, just keep start thinking about what we're gonna talk about for the next one, and there would just be these I I would keep a running Apple notes file of just this is an idea, this is an idea.

SPEAKER_01And then eventually the ideas would hit a critical mass and be like, okay, let's get together and let's record the next one.

SPEAKER_00That's awesome. That's long form, and ten pages is no joke to write, I know, because I write a lot of mine. Um so that's that's a lot to talk about. And do you still do as long of a form? I've listened to the crossover, which I think is a little bit different of a format, but tell us what you're doing right now in the podcast realm.

SPEAKER_01Well, during the depths of the pandemic, the crossover would go three or four hours long sometimes. So we you know what nobody like we we made it on Friday nights because nobody was going out, nobody was doing anything. This was suddenly something to do on a Friday night. And we would get pretty large audiences on Instagram live back then. We would pretty routinely be in the three figures of live viewers. Today we don't get that to get to get to that level, people have lives again. But uh, but we would go into like hour three, hour four. But the difference there is that uh the the crossover is still prepared too, but instead of like uh Josh or Christina or myself doing the preparation, it's more so I collect questions from people.

SPEAKER_01And so like people really kind of do the work of coming up with the topics, then we just kind of have to find a way to react to them or play off of them or or uh do something with the topics. But it's definitely different doing that, and that comes out once a week. But now we've really tried to limit that to like 90 minutes, you know, keep that a little bit shorter. But uh but at one time those episodes would would would rage into the three-hour plus realm.

SPEAKER_00Fever dream of question answering and talking about froth monsters and all of these things.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Exactly right.

SPEAKER_00So is House of Jordan still going as a podcast?

SPEAKER_01It's not, no, it's not. I mean, um you could sort of say that like the crossover sort of took the baton from it, even though it's stylistically so different. But the House of Jordan's run really went from uh December of 2018 until about June of 2020, and then that was the we got so busy with the launch of Card Ladder that it just became impractical to do that. So that kind of tells you how busy the start of Card Ladder was. During law school, I had time to make four-hour podcasts every month, but Card Ladder didn't allow the time to do that.

SPEAKER_01So like what we tried to do to fill in the gap for a little while was like do interviews. And even then, um, you know, we did like some inter I I did around ten interviews or so that the summer of twenty twenty to keep the ho the House of Jordans podcast feed going, but even then it was just it was it was just taking time away from the early stages of working on card ladder stuff. So So just dropped it completely and then we we also had already started doing the crossover around that time. So like the crossover started sometime in the spring of 2020, I think maybe around April 2020 or something like that.

SPEAKER_01So trying to trying to juggle all those different podcasts and content streams, it just was let's just shift to the crossover. This is by far a lower burden of content creation. This is just collecting questions from people and then talking on air for a while. And people seem to like it too. So that the the content burden like was was a lot easier to just focus on the crossover.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. If I was writing 10 pages of content for a podcast, I would also probably feel the same. Um so let's talk a little bit about the origins of Card Ladder. It started, as you said, there, 2020, was it? Tell us about how the idea came about and how you knew that it had to be something that you brought to life.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can uh you can trace the origins of it back to when I appeared on the Cardboard Chronicles channel on YouTube, which would have been around 2018 or 2019, somewhere in there. Maybe it was even early 2020, I don't know. But it was somewhere, it was, it was, it predates Card Ladder as a as a concept. But uh but Josh invited me on to be a guest on his show, and I brought um a few notebook pages worth of data to sort of talk about the Michael Jordan market, and Josh and I were developing a friendship at that time, and it it just sort of organically occurred to us at some point that um there is uh there there is a use case for making this data more easily accessible to people and maybe not requiring collectors like myself to jot notes into notebook pads, but instead is there a way to better organize this and better structure this?

SPEAKER_01And I th and I sort of like tested this by releasing a little mini dumbed-down version of the product because uh in the early year uh in the early months of 2020, I was releasing this uh this monthly spreadsheet where I was where I was doing data compiling for Michael Jordan auction results and then um uh compiling this historical data set and updating it with new results and sort of adding some insights and stuff. And then I and I was making it available to the House of Jordan's audience for like it's like PayPal me 10 bucks or something, and I'll give you this spreadsheet.

SPEAKER_01And as a as in and it ended up sort of being a proof of concept that people are are willing to pay for the or for organized accessible data, and I was just giving it to them in spreadsheet form. But they were they were willing to, you know, a few hundred people or so are willing to pay for it. And that and I sort of took that back to Josh and I said, look, like we've been talking about this idea of organizing data in into software form, and Josh has one of the most unique, the most unique talent stack in this industry because he has the combination of collector experience, collector knowledge, he has the background in software developing, in web development, and he he also has the the the skills as a manager of people and an identifier of talents to bring in front-end designers and stuff, and just to sort of he he has the ability to really build a terrific software web application if he you know if if he puts his mind to it and if he wants to do it.

SPEAKER_01And so sort of I I sort of brought the con I sort of brought that proof of concept to him with the spreadsheet sales and saying, hey, there's at least an audience of a few hundred people who are willing to pay for this stuff. And then I brought him sort of a business plan that sort of mapped out like, hey, look, like here's here's sort of how this could become a viable business. And those factors, plus our our growing friendship, plus our shared love for collecting cards, plus the fact that the pandemic just kicked in, and so he was working from home, all my classes. I was my final semester of law school, all my classes went to pass fail. And so it just oh it was just a perfect storm of of events that also gave us the time and the and the sort of the boredom of being at home to say, let's put energy into this, let's try this.

SPEAKER_01And then that also happened to coincide with the the with the the collecting industry, the sports card industry taking off, and the Michael Jordan Last Dance documentary, and all these people flooding back in during the pandemic, and all those things kind of came together with uh and and and coincided quite nicely with with what ended up being a soft launch of Card Ladder, which was on June 23rd of 2020, 623, 6 for LeBron, which is the player that Josh collects, and 23 for Michael Jordan.

SPEAKER_00That's amazing. There's a lot of that that I kind of want to dive into, but I would like to ask, um, why is it called Card Ladder?

SPEAKER_01Josh came up with that name. He's very good at naming things. I'm very bad at naming things. I think I like I think my initial name concept was uh we would have to go back and look at that old business plan, but I think the initial name concept was like the basketball 500 or something. That was what I wanted to call it, and then Josh came up with a much more marketable, simple, insightful name of card ladder. And it was just sort of this idea of uh I mean it it's a metaphor in several ways. Like first of all, it's like a the the the original site backbone was the ladder of cards, sort of the idea of ranking cards based on a number of um measurable financial indicators, but but that quickly became apparent that people didn't really want that.

SPEAKER_01Uh but but still we we continue to call that database the ladder. Sort of it's it's just a ladder of cards, uh, you know, sort of rungs of different cards that you can organize them in different ways. And then and then it also became a metaphor that, and I think this is where like collectors and the community sort of took it in this way and helped us to see it in this way that the the the idea of laddering up, a collector sort of climbing a ladder and using this tool, the tool of data and research, um, to help them ladder up. So that I think it that then I think it kind of took on that meaning.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And we are pro using tools and resources to further financial freedom on Slabnomics podcasts. So also pro Card Ladder, our friends at Card Ladder. So um let me ask you then when talking about those financial metrics that you thought were going to be important and they ended up not being, what were those?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I mean it's not that they didn't end up being important, it just ended up not being the product that people really wanted. But I was obsessed with it. Uh and and it's just it's it's funny how products sort of work like that. Like the thing that is the genesis or the spark for that that initially gets the ball rolling might end up not being important at all to the final product. But I came up with something called a ladder score, which is which was like an all-in-one metric. Like if like uh the the analogy in baseball would be winds of our replacement war, the analogy in football would be QBR, the analogy in basketball would be box plus minus.

SPEAKER_01This this idea of an all-in-one metric that looks at specific measurements of of how a card is performed over a given period of time, and just spinning out a number that will tell you, you know, this card is is the hottest card right now, and and or this one and this one is is is trending in the opposite direction. And obviously you can do that uh on your own too. You can just say, well, what is a uh percentage change in price of this card over the last six months or over the last year? But but I but I wanted to make a number that sort of combined a number of different factors that actually matter.

SPEAKER_01Like uh price change matters, but you know, what the other thing that matters is is transaction volume and velocity and and market cap and and sort of you know, a card going from fifty to one hundred dollars is is a doubling in value, but it but the but the but but that's different than a card going from five thousand to ten thousand dollars. And so do you want to look at things from the percentage change point of view? Do you want to look at things from the point of view of absolute dollar change? And if a card goes from fifty to one hundred dollars but it sells twenty times a week, that's different than a card going from five thousand to ten thousand dollars, but it sells once a year.

SPEAKER_01And so uh I wanted to come up with a number that combined all these ideas and and sort of just said, here's one simple metric that measures all of them. And I did. And uh, but but it just nobody maybe it maybe for the same reason that advanced stats and sports don't seem to resonate with the with the sports viewer uh in the same way. I don't I just don't think anybody really cared. I think I think people were like, this is cool, but you know, this is this is several this is abstracted on uh this is abstracted from the on-the-ground facts by several degrees, and instead, let me just let me just see the prices.

SPEAKER_01Like let me just let me just see that. And obviously we were providing that too. But but so like the the latter score was sort of the initial organizing principle, but and it worked fine, it didn't work poorly, but it just became clear that that this isn't why people are coming to us, that people are coming to us instead because they they like this idea of a cleaned data set, and they like this idea of being able to track their collection, and they like this idea of discovery and being able to see all the other cards that are out there and do price research and stuff.

SPEAKER_01And those initial pieces of feedback really steered the card letter product uh in into the direction of being more focused around just a pure research tool of raw data that then we augment with different price modeling tools if if people want to use them, but but they don't need to. The main use case of card letters is is pr is the sales history page, which which you know that's to me that's that's one of the most important screens in the hobby is is being able to go there and look at historical sales of you know, I th there's uh over a hundred million sales in there going back to the early two thousands, and so a r a research database that that people's fingertips.

SPEAKER_01I think that's that's overwhelming the main use case today.

SPEAKER_00So it goes back to the early 2000s, is that for every card? It is, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Uh the uh it that will be difficult for cards that were you know manufactured five years ago, you're not gonna find sales of those cards. It's not impossible. It may be impossible. But we have uh a record from uh about a dozen different marketplaces, inclusive of eBay, that goes back to the early 2000s, uh, but uh with some caveats. So, for example, we don't have fixed price information on eBay results going back to the early 2000s.

SPEAKER_01The fixed price information on eBay starts in around 2020, 2021. So, you know, it's it's not uh a complete or perfect data set. There are limitations, that being one of them. But but um yeah, I mean if you went in there and started searching, let's say, eBay sales of uh the 2003 Topps Chrome LeBron, you'll see sales that were happening in the early 2000s from from in there. I I think those sales go back to around 2004, maybe. I don't remember exactly when that product was released, but I do remember building the historical sales history for that card and having sales go way back to beginning.

SPEAKER_01So there are there's an there's auction results from eBay going way back to then. And then also, you know, marketplaces that have been around for a long time, Heritage, um some of the other ones uh that have sales histories dating back to the 2000s, you can find their their databases are are in sales history too.

SPEAKER_00That's amazing. I really need to go back and take a further look at that because I have some data that I need to pull out and do some things with, and it needs to go back further than 2021.

SPEAKER_01So you can go way back, man. You can go look at what the 1986 FLIR number 57 Michael Jordan PSA 10 was selling for. Yeah, you can look at, you know, in in 2008, I think that was a five thousand dollar card. I mean, and that that's such a nice like kind of benchmark card to compare how all other things are doing relative to it, and sort of see how it's it's uh because because two things can happen at once. That card can sort of reflect a general trend in the industry, but then within the industry or within the card market, different cards sort of outperform or underperform it too.

SPEAKER_01So it's it's just a good benchmark on several levels.

SPEAKER_00Whenever I talk to Chris, I always think of so many things to unpack. Uh so speaking of, well, let's just talk about that Jordan card using it as a benchmark. I've noticed that card letter has a lot of different indices. And I want to ask you, it seems like those were a project that might have been shelved, or just you got to a point where you said these are good enough, we'll kind of leave these indexes where they are.

SPEAKER_00It is, yeah.

SPEAKER_01So we don't add indexes very often at all, or uh I don't know when the last time we added a new index was. I mean, we have all of the category-wide indexes basketball, baseball, football. We have our snapshot of the market index, um, the card letter 50, and then there are some content creators who have like sort of teamed up with us to make their own index too. Um and so like we're amenable to that. Like uh, you know, one of the indexes in there is a collaboration between Gemrate and Topps and ourselves, which is the Bowman 100.

SPEAKER_01So like we'll we'll do that too. But but the uh but that that's those are like uh category indexes, and and so those don't really get added to very much anymore. But uh there's the other set of indexes which are the player and the character indexes. So Pikachu has an index, LeBron James has an index, Pete Crow Armstrong has an index, etc. etc. And those indexes, you know, anytime we add cards of a new player to the latter database, they get an index too. So like there's thousands and thousands of player and character indexes that live on a different screen.

SPEAKER_01So you you have the category indexes on one screen and then the player and character ones on a different screen, and and those indexes continue to grow. Like uh, you know, if any any you know, whoever that there'll be a new crop of quarterbacks this year, and uh they'll they'll eventually start getting indexes too.

SPEAKER_00Does Brock Purdy have an index?

SPEAKER_01He does. Yes, he does.

SPEAKER_00How's his index doing?

SPEAKER_01I don't think it's doing so well. Uh I don't I don't know exactly off the top of my head where his index is at. He never got too hot, like he never reached like Justin Herbert fever levels, but he his um his index is certainly down from where it started. But you know, the interesting the interesting thing about indexes, especially in this good for players who have come out in the last few years, uh, these indexes are constructed um starting from the first sale of the whichever the cards are that the index is tracking.

SPEAKER_01And so inevitably, any player, you can take Victor Wembinyama, you can take Caitlin Clark, you can take Purdy, you can take whoever you want to take. Uh almost all these indexes drop off really quickly. Not because of a reflection of the player necessarily, but because of a reflection of population reports. So like take Wembenyama, for example. His Prism stuff starts coming out, people start grading it. In the early goings, his PSA 10 of his base or of his silver, let's say, it has a population of 10, 20, 50, 100.

SPEAKER_01And people are also scrambling at that time to get one of those cards. There's always this frenzy, it never fails. There's always this frenzy to want to get one of the with the early PSA 10s of these players. But then the PSA pop PSA 10 population is 200, and then it's 500, and then it's a thousand, and then it's two thousand, and and the price just starts coming down. Obviously, that's that's not surprising. That's that's the uh that's the relationship between supply and demand. But uh, but and and so it creates this this this drop-off in the indexes, right? Because a car that starts at 500 bucks when there's just a few on the market, all of a sudden it's fifty bucks when there's thousands on the market.

SPEAKER_01But uh that doesn't end the analysis because as price comes down and supply goes up, it's it's conceivable, in fact, that it often is the case that market cap actually continues to go up. So, you know, uh having uh a thousand copies of a fifty dollar card versus you know having ten copies of a five hundred dollar card, the the thousand copies of fifty has a ten times bigger market cap than the ten copies of f at 500. So it it can it can play out that way where you know people see the price dropping and they're not thinking about how supply is impacting that.

SPEAKER_01So one of the features that is built into card ladder, it's buried in the tool, but it's just one of the ones that's in there, is you can see population growth. There's a curve that we show how populations grow. And so like you can you know you can pull that up for the Web and Yama, Prism, PSA 10 or whatever, and you can see you can sort of track how its population has changed, how its price has changed, and sort of map those things against each other if you want to. But yeah, that that's a long way of saying that Purdy, whoever, whoever the players that we're looking at, um it's it's almost inevitable that their index is going to start up here and then you know come come come down and down and down and down just because those first those first uh sales are always high.

SPEAKER_00That's something that you and I have spoke about off-air, um, and then I spoke about with Ryan at Gemray as well. Just that population always goes up, so technically a lot of the cards are going to go down. Is that something that you really believe? Um, and is that something that you kind of build into your I don't know how much buying and selling you do or if it's more just a collecting piece, but is that something you think about and truly believe in that 99, 95%, whatever percent uh of cards are gonna go down long term?

SPEAKER_01There's certainly an argument for it, and it's something that we have to think about methodologically with index construction, because like we have category-wide indexes. And so you know, the I don't know, let's say the uh I don't know how many cards are in the basketball index right now. I would I would it's definitely in the tens of thousands. The basketball index um well let's see I can the basketball index has sixteen thousand five hundred cards in it. Um and unlike uh the s the the stock market, which has survivor bias, meaning when a stock goes to zero or a company blows up, it just it it it clears out of the market.

SPEAKER_01Sports cards don't have that. The cut these cards don't vaporize when they fall to zero. They're still out there, they're still trading at one cent plus shipping or whatever. And we we definitely have cards in these indexes that started off as maybe a couple bucks apiece, five bucks a piece, ten bucks a piece, and now they're a penny. So these indexes are building in these losses. And we we have to think about that, like as you know, the these category-wide, these truly category-wide indexes that have so many cards that are purporting to represent this market, they they they are there's no filter for the survivor bias.

SPEAKER_01See the the if if everything is trending towards zero, then these markets are gonna, these these indexes for these market, these category-wide markets are gonna be pulling toward pulling all those indexes towards zero. So uh but uh but I don't know. I think there's a way to empirically answer that, and I've never tried to. I but I do see a tendency. I do I definitely see a tendency for cards to trend down, uh, especially ones that that just have higher populations and that and that and that will continue to have those populations grow. And and and as you know, as sports and careers play out, there does seem to be a sort of winner take all dimension to sports legacies that trickles down to the sports card market, I think.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I I agree. I think there's a lot of trickle down, and I think a lot about that when I'm building out my investment TCs of what's going to trickle. Down how far is it going to go? Because you can use that to determine what the liquidity constraints are for the cards that you want to buy. Like, I'm going to have to buy a card to sell it to someone else if that's my investment thesis. So I need to have someone buy this thing, and I need to have them do it in a reasonable amount of time. And if it doesn't trickle down enough, then they're probably not going to do it. So money velocity is something I've been really keying in on a lot lately.

SPEAKER_00Let me ask you one more question, and then we'll go into a rapid fire. So is there anything in the card ladder database uh that people don't know about and you wish they did?

SPEAKER_01Uh well, um I think that I never see users of Card Ladder discussing the um showcase feature, but it's a feature that I use pretty regularly. And the way the showcase feature works is so anybody who has a card letter membership has access obviously to the collection feature. The collection feature is default set to private. Nobody sees it, we can't see it, the public can't see it, nobody can see what's in your card letter collection.

SPEAKER_01However, the user can set that collection to publicly show in the showcase feature. And so then if you if you set that function, uh if you set your collection or par or or parts of it, you can set you can create different collections and you can say some should be visible and showcase and others shouldn't be. And so you can you can go into showcase and you can look at what cards people have made visible from their collections. And so I'll go in there from time to time, just look and just see like what new cards have people added, what are different people's collections look like and stuff.

SPEAKER_01And a couple times I've I've found collectors who have shared their stuff that I then strike up conversations with, maybe do a deal with. And also people use that feature to look at what I have, because I I haven't posted everything that I have to Instagram or to social media, because like when I post a card to social media, it becomes like an event, and I want to spend hours writing a caption and like being very thoughtful about it. But when I put stuff to my card letter collection and then make it publicly available, it's just a few clicks, you know, and it's just there it is, here's the stuff. So people actually sometimes go look at what's in there, and then um, you know, they they know what I'm looking for, and they and and then and then they can tell me what they're looking for, and we can network and maybe help each other.

SPEAKER_01Uh, and and sometimes that happens too. Like I had a a friend who sort of looked into one of my um one of my collections and showcase and said, Hey, I I see you have a card. I have I have a later year of this same exact card, would you be interested? And then we made a deal for it. So that that's that's maybe a feature that that uh that doesn't get discussed a lot. I'm I I think people are using it, but but it doesn't get discussed a ton, which is that showcase screen.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's an amazing feature and one that I'm hearing about as I have these conversations with people that are building platforms. Um just had another one today. So is there follow-up question? Is there a way to search people's collections in a certain way if they put it as uh non-private?

SPEAKER_01There is, yeah. So like some something that I like to do, like there's uh hundreds of thousands of cards in showcase. And uh, and to be clear, this is it is not a marketplace. This is this is just a showcase. There are no prices. We don't allow prices. We do allow people to decide if they want to like connect um with people because they they can turn on or off the ability to have people link out to their social media if people do want to strike up a conversation, but but people can turn that on or off. But like, for example, so I like something I like to do is I just like to type in the name of a player and see how many results come up.

SPEAKER_01So like I went and I punched in Michael Jordan and I got 9,377 results. So there's you know not you know over 9,000 different Michael Jordan cards in here, and then like it becomes difficult to sort them specifically because we don't put prices and we don't let people put prices or declare values, but you can sort of sort by the number of likes. That's one way to sort of sort things, you or you can sort by date added, or really you can just you can just start working the search button, you know. Like if you if you know a specific card that you're looking for, you can start typing it in and try to find it.

SPEAKER_00That's awesome. I resisted making a Dragon Ball Z reference on that 9,000. If you know you know. Uh sweet. I'm going to check that out because there's a lot of cards that I'm trying to hunt for that are hard to find. So I will check out the showcase feature. Anything else you want to pump a little bit before I go, Rapid Fire?

SPEAKER_01That's I think I'm ready. I think I'm ready for Rapid Fire.

SPEAKER_00So let's do it. And also add Chris at Chris underscore hoj on Instagram. He has amazing resources in his highlights, especially. He's known and deservedly so for those resources that he has. I could spend probably like days just going through his highlights, to be honest.

SPEAKER_01That's interesting. I don't know. I don't know if anybody ever looked at highlights or not. I look at them and I see you do too. You're a thorough guy, though.

SPEAKER_00I try to be, I try to be. All right, so rapid fire. First question, and try and keep, you know, however long you might take to respond to it, but we only have a few minutes. So first one, why is Card Ladder a better platform than market movers?

SPEAKER_01I don't know that it is. I I just think that and and I'm not a user of that platform, so I I wouldn't even really be able to speak to it. I just I just know that card ladder is sort of built around the collecting philosophy of Josh, Christine, and myself, and then with a ton of input from the community, that that and the input and the feedback has really steered the product since launch. So, you know, we love it, we use it, and and we take a lot of feedback from other collectors too. So I don't know, I I couldn't comment on a comparison, but but I can say that for what we need, if if if it doesn't exist in card ladder, we we build it right away.

SPEAKER_00Fair answer. Second question: how do I get the card ladder score? Or was it the ladder score? It should still be there.

SPEAKER_01If you click on the ladder, yeah, if you click on the ladder and then you go to score, you get it. And then um within our FAQ, there is an explainer of how it works. Uh the formula, it's it's just a formula. Um I don't even that's buried somewhere in the site these days. How score is calculated. But yeah, you can still get it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm gonna check that out right before I reach out to you to build a slabnomics index, which is you should definitely do that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, put together you should definitely do that.

SPEAKER_00We'd be happy to I have multiple, multiple indexes I want to build, to be honest with you.

SPEAKER_01And you can you can uh build your own custom indexes too, they won't be publicly available, but you can build a custom index and and try those out and see how you like those.

SPEAKER_00The data nerd in me is getting very excited. Uh question three. Are you a coffee drinker? No, tea. You're a tea man. English tea?

SPEAKER_01All teas. I mostly green tea because that seems to be one of the healthier ones, but I'll I'll do Earl Grey, I'll do black teas, I'll do chai teas, I'll do green tea. But but no flavors, no nothing. I don't even put honey, don't put milk, anything. I just raw dog tea tea, even in the middle of the summer.

SPEAKER_00That's a high tea move. High tea move, raw dog and tea. I like it. Slabnomics approved. Uh okay, another question. Where is card letter going from this? What's the thing you're most excited for for the future?

SPEAKER_01I am most excited for walking the floor of the national. This is something that whenever Josh and I get together at card shows, we will walk the floor at the show. We will look over everybody's shoulder, we'll see what apps they're using, and if they're using card ladder, we'll ask them what they like and what things they might want to improve. And if they're using something else, we'll say why, how can we get you to use card ladder? And we will just uh bother and pester people all day. And so that those are great learning experiences because it really helps us figure out what people like, what people don't like, what people want to see, and then Josh builds all that stuff and and takes it to the next level.

SPEAKER_01So that that's what I'm most immediately excited about is just we're gonna get tons of great feedback at the national and it's gonna make the product better.

SPEAKER_00That's badass. Um it's community first always, so always good to hear that you guys are boots on the ground asking these questions and making improvements. Uh okay, that's all the time that we have. Chris, thanks so much for coming on. Uh, once again, if you're not following him on Instagram, it's Chris underscore H O J. Great follow. Make sure to add him. And thanks for listening to Slabnomics. It's been so amazing having you here, Chris. I hope in the future to have you again and maybe we can go a little bit more into data nerdy stuff.

SPEAKER_01Very grateful to have been on the show. Very grateful to have been on the show in its early stages because I see where it's going, and I'd I'd love to come back anytime.

SPEAKER_00Thank you, brother. I appreciate you. Awesome. Hope you guys enjoyed that interview with Chris, one of my favorite people to talk to. Chris and I didn't go too much into the weeds when it comes to the financial side of things, and hopefully we'll be able to do that at a later time in another episode. Would love to have him on in the future. And one more thing to think about before you go. A person is only as good as the tools he or she has available and uses. What are the tools that you use every day?

SPEAKER_00And what are the tools that you hope to see in the future? Is there anything that you've been frustrated by in terms of things that you haven't had available to you yet? It's just a matter of who is going to create those tools for everyone within the hobby. And that person could be you. Always feel welcome to reach out to people, reach out to me on Instagram, let us know if you have ideas that you're trying to work for. Thanks again for listening to Slapnomics.

SPEAKER_00This has been episode 11, House of Cards. Keep building, and we'll talk to you later.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Is It Worth Grading Sports Cards & TCG? PSA vs CGC vs Beckett Explained

    Oct 6, 202630 minAudio

    Thinking about grading cards? Start here. After 1,500+ submissions across PSA, Beckett, SGC, and CGC, I break down what each grader actually costs, how long it really takes, where each one wins, where each one fails,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Slabnomics Set Deep Dive: 1996 Topps Chrome Football

    Sep 29, 202622 minAudio

    1996 Topps Chrome Football is the inaugural set of the most important modern chrome brand, and the market still has not priced it correctly. In the first Slabnomics set deep dive, we go through the full history: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Past Results and Predicting Future Returns in Cards

    Sep 8, 202620 minAudio

    Two data-backed frameworks for buying cards in 2026. First: the psychological barrier learned from 800+ cards. Only one pattern held with strong correlation. Anchoring, cascading demand, and pop-vs-price gaps explain...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Swimming Naked: Early Warning Signs in the 2026 Card Market

    Sep 1, 202621 minAudio

    The sports card market is up big. Disney is up 5x in six months. Pokemon volume is at all time highs. So the question everyone is asking: how much longer? Let's talk dry powder. The rotation from modern into vintage....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Grading Mistakes in Cards: Beginner, Intermediate, and Advanced

    Aug 25, 202618 minAudio

    9 grading mistakes killing your sports card and Pokémon profits broken down by skill level. Matt covers PSA's new 50-70 business day turnaround at the $80 tier, why Beckett only bumps a certain amount off the average,...

    Credit the people on this episode