Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Slabnomics

Slabnomics artwork

Past Results and Predicting Future Returns in Cards

Sep 8, 202620 minAudio

Two data-backed frameworks for buying cards in 2026. First: the psychological barrier learned from 800+ cards. Only one pattern held with strong correlation. Anchoring, cascading demand, and pop-vs-price gaps explain why. Second: the generational window. Pokémon proves demand is predictable. Map and trust. Applied to Ohtani, Lamine Yamal, and sports cards broadly. Data over hype. Use the hype, don't get caught in it. Weekly Newsletter Signup: Slabnomics.com 🎥Youtube 📸Instagram

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00It is with heavy heart that I come to you today to tell you the news that you probably already know. Erling Holland has cut his hair. The inspiration for the Slabnomics look has abandoned us. So I don't know where I'm going to go from here in terms of my hair. But if what you're here for is not looking at my hair, but learning how to make better financial decisions with sports cards and TCG, then you're in the right place. If you love the channel, love the hair, or love sports cards, go ahead and hit the like for me. I'm not going to ask you to subscribe if you haven't yet, because at the end, I want to earn that subscription by today's video.

SPEAKER_00So if we're not talking about trendy hairstyles, what are we talking about and how is it going to be more relevant to you? Well, let me start off by being honest with you. A lot of the times when I talk about my ideas, a lot of my best ideas I save for my paid subscribers. These are the people that pay to get access to the things that I'm really cooking up in terms of my research projects and the data that I'm diving into constantly. So I feel that it's just that they get the best ideas or at least get them way ahead of everyone else. But today, my friends, I'm going to talk to you about ideas that have sprung up from so much research, I find them to be the most interesting and the most powerful ideas for investing in cards for the future.

SPEAKER_00And hey, if you're not familiar with who I am, my name is Matt. I was in corporate finance for eight years professionally, and I studied everything from small business lending to moonlighting as an economist with a foreign exchange company. Nowadays, I've been obsessed with using data in order to institutionalize the hobby, because in 2026, this is where things stand. We have a bifurcated market for those collecting and those trying to flip or invest. And pure collectors, you don't really need to worry about investing.

SPEAKER_00If you have something that you're insanely passionate about, the money is really no object. But if at any time you might sell your cards or you might do it for your kids, then that doesn't mean that you're not a collector, but the investor persona is something that's going to be important for you in your future. So I know when I started this channel, I talked a lot about soccer cards. We had the World Cup coming up, which was a Nexus event that was going to bring a new flood of demand into a very small market. And I expected that this nascent market was going to get a massive boost.

SPEAKER_00That was certainly the case, and there were many learnings and many failings through that process that I've shared with you over the past year or so. In more recent times, though, I've looked at more general cards. I've been looking at everything from goats in every sport, from football to basketball to baseball, and I've been really diving into Pokemon TCG. Now, the beauty of Pokemon TCG, and I'm not going to stay on this too long, so stay with me, is that the players don't get hurt. That removes a pretty massive variable from the equation, and it allows us to understand more about the psychology behind the purchasing of the cards and the market rising and falling.

SPEAKER_00I've done a lot of studies because I have access to a lot of data, but one of the most recent ones that I've done is look at any card that's over$500 in a PSA 10 over the past 25 years. The data that I've been gathering is how those prices for those cards have moved over the past one month, three months, six months, one year, the start of the AI boom, and the start of COVID. I've also gathered data not only for PSA 10s, but for PSA 9s, so I can get a good comparison between those two. This data set ended up being about 800 plus cards, so we're working with a pretty hefty body of data.

SPEAKER_00Talked about everything from BGS 10 being something that's undervalued to PSA 10s not being as difficult as people think they are to get, to showing how different grades of iconic cards, like Jordan's rookie, for example, have actually had better returns from a PSA 1 than a PSA 10 over the past three years. I know that sounds crazy, but the data is actually there to back it up. This is not just my opinion. And that same thing goes for PSA 9s actually starting to accelerate versus PSA 10s in their value.

SPEAKER_00I know people think this is a hot take, but that was from looking at 800 different cards I saw this pattern emerge. So the title of this video is telling you that I'm going to be using data in order to glean learnings from it that we can apply to understanding what the future might hold. Looking at metrics like PSA 9 to 10 ratios in terms of gem rate, and looking at the value between the two and comparing the population of PSA 9 to 10 and the value of PSA 9 to 10, along with the overarching story of how all of these grail cards have moved in their prices, is what helps us paint a full story of what might actually be going on and what's underpinning this rapid rise.

SPEAKER_00We can then take those learnings and we can apply those to any sport. Although Shohei Otani can tear his ACL, the metrics that are going to go around these cards and the way that these values are going to be moving should be similar to the Pokemon market, of course, not the same. So let's get into the theory and the psychology of what's really going on and what's underpinning these price movements. The one pattern that emerged with positive correlation from looking at all these grails from$500 in a PSA 10 up through all years of Pokemon is incredibly simple and it makes a lot of sense to me.

SPEAKER_00It ended up getting over an 80% correlation in the R squared, which is enough for us to call it a strong correlation. To put it simply, in cards that in a PSA 10 were over 10K, we have seen their PSA 9s start appreciating more in price versus their PSA 10 counterpart. Now don't get me wrong, those PSA 10s are still going up. They're still adding value. And if you look at what they've done in the past year, you can see that the PSA 10s have far outstripped the PSA 9s of the same cards.

SPEAKER_00So this isn't something that's been going on for a year, for three years, for five years. It's been something that's been going on for a month or three months. To give you the rationale behind that is to conjecture, but I'm going to do that now. When a card becomes more than$10,000, it breaks a psychological barrier. Anchoring is a very real thing. And if you've read Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman, you know this to be true. He gave some very established studies for this. So the price of something matters.

SPEAKER_00And$10,000 is five digits. It may not seem like a big deal, going from$9,999 to 10,000, but it is in the human mind. And for examples of this, look no further than any online store or even just take a walk in your supermarket or mall. You'll see most prices end in 99. This is something that tells us that it's cheaper. This is something that is a psychological trigger to tell us that it's a sale or a deal. So when that PSA 10 jumps into that five-digit range, that matters.

SPEAKER_00That becomes more of an investment card, which means that the demand for that card has shifted. It's no longer people trying to get it for their PCs, and it's no longer people even trying to flip it. Those have entered into the investor tier buy and hold kind of cards. Now don't hear what I'm not saying, which is that any card below$10,000 is not investment worthy. But I can tell you when these funds are going out and investing in cards, they're definitely not looking at$9,000 cards. So the market dynamic changes.

SPEAKER_00It almost becomes another market when you get into the 10k plus cards. The buying and the selling appetites and motivations change, and the market becomes smaller. Just as importantly, something that I've talked a lot about is the cascading effect and how when things change, we look to the next closest thing in order to scratch that itch. In this case, if a PSA 10 becomes too expensive, you see it at that 10K price tag. And then the first thing you're gonna go look and see what the PSA 9 is. After all, a lot of times a PSA 10 and a PSA 9 are pretty close to each other in terms of real relative condition.

SPEAKER_00So let's say on that 10K card you go look and you see that the 9 is selling for$800. Well, the first thing that I say is what's the pop difference between the two? Because that's how I make sense of that price difference being so vast. Condition is really a rarefier. In some cards that were printed a lot, like the 2022 Prism for the Ronaldo Silver, there's only 21 or 22 PSA 10s, even though there are so many of those silvers available. And that's of course where gem rate is so important.

SPEAKER_00Because if a PSA 10 is worth$10,000 but the PSA 9 is worth only 800, just in terms of supply and demand, there better be at least eight times more PSA 9s than 10s for that card. But what do I find, and what do you find often when you go do this? That PSA 9 population might be 3x, the PSA 10 one. The price tag is 12x, whereas the population is only 3x. And when that card passes that 10k mark, people start paying more attention to it and they start digging into it more.

SPEAKER_00So more eyeballs go into those pop reports, more people start looking at the dynamics and the metrics. And that's when it starts to change. Now we're about halfway through this video. It's going to be a short one because I love doing short videos that are jam-packed. If so far you're loving the content, now hit the subscribe for me and hit the like if you didn't before. I appreciate you guys. So to recap, when a PSA 10 card gets over 10K, oftentimes that PSA 9 equivalent is going to start rising at a more aggressive rate afterwards.

SPEAKER_00The PSA 10 is also going to rise, but in the short term, the PSA 9 is going to usually get a bump, especially in a liquid market like Pokemon. As I like to say, things happen slowly and then all at once. Now the beauty of this screening that you can do is that most cards that are 10K or more are going to be the kind of cards that I would say fit into the basket of investment. These are going to be iconic cards. They're going to be well known. They're going to be well loved. It's very, very difficult to hit that 10K mark if you're just some random card.

SPEAKER_00I don't care if there's only one on the population. And of course, this doesn't go for any one-of-ones. If anyone says that in the comments, I will be very patient with you, but I know you're trolling. So your first concrete takeaway here is whatever market you're in, start looking at those PSA 10s that are around 10K or just over, and then take a look at their PSA 9s. See what's been happening in that market. One caveat, as always, is that market dynamics that are over all of this, that are umbrellaing everything, like for instance being a bull or bear market, are going to be incredibly important.

SPEAKER_00Don't make the mistake of thinking that you can just go load up on all these PSA 9s and that you're foolproof and that you aren't going to lose money. If we go into an aggressive bear market, which could happen really at any time, those PSA 10s are going to shoot down and the PSA 9s are going to shoot down right there with them. But in a bull market where money is looking for the lowest point, it's going to be a very, very good play. Alright, guys, and now I'm going to give you the second practical thing that goes hand in hand with this that is so incredibly powerful yet so incredibly simple.

SPEAKER_00And let me open this up with just one easy example. When I say seasonality and sports cards, you're probably going to know instantly what I'm talking about. It's well documented that you can buy a baseball card in the offseason when no one's really looking at baseball anymore, and then sell it in the run-up to the season. A lot of times you can get 15-20% just because of the doldrums getting at a great price. And then if you get some luck and some good news on that player, you might even get a higher return. This used to be a foolproof strategy, but because we have information sharing so easily, like on this channel, these edges get worn down little by little each season.

SPEAKER_00And the time that people start buying gets faster and faster each season. But there is one thing that I never hear people talk about. Maybe it's something that's mentioned offhand at times, or it just works itself into a conversation, but I don't see people start using it. I don't see people putting strategies around it. And I'm gonna coin this term as the generational window. Now, people will mention this. They'll say the baby boomers like this guy, or once these guys come into money, I'm sure they'll be looking at this.

SPEAKER_00But do people really plan into this? Do people really look to see when those windows open, when we've seen them in the past, and how we might be able to predict when they're opening in the future? I'm gonna open up with a sports example for you. Shohei Otani is such a worthwhile investment because he bridges pretty much all the generations. It is so clear that Shohei Otani is going to go down as one of the most impactful baseball players ever, and he's popular now with the kids now, but he's also fully respected by boomers and by millennials.

SPEAKER_00He is a cross-generation, cross-cultural, bona fide superstar. There's honestly no one in sports that even comes close to Shohei Otani as far as a market and market cap goes for the future. And this isn't me pumping Shohei because I have a bunch of Shohei Otani I want to sell. I pick up a lot of his rookie cards piece by piece, mostly because they're BGS 10s, and I just sock them away. But when we think of players that are in different generations, we have to understand the flow of the money and when it starts. To go over to another sport for an easy example, La Migne Mall is very young.

SPEAKER_00He's incredibly popular with young kids. I was just down at my family ranch this past weekend, and this little 10-year-old guy was telling me about how his favorite player is Lamigne Mall. And this kid plays baseball, he plays football, and he plays soccer. The draw that La Migne Mall has for the youth is very evident by looking at his social profile. The amount of likes that this kid can get by doing basically nothing is truly astounding. But Lamin is probably not invested in as much by the old heads.

SPEAKER_00They're still buying messy. Their goat is still playing. So the money is stymied in terms of Laminium All right now. The big money is still coming in because pockets will still understand the impact that he has on the game. But all the young kids that are crazy about La Migna Mall have to get money from their dads in order to buy it right now. And their dads might be like, meh. When these kids get older and come into their own money, there will be a massive wave of La Migno if he has managed to keep his persona and his skill evident on the playing field at that time.

SPEAKER_00That's a big if, but if it does happen, think of the repercussions of a new wave of money coming in and what that does to a market. There is no easier way to tell you about this than looking at Pokemon. The beauty of Pokemon is they come out with games, you know when they're coming out with games, and it lines up perfectly with generations. As a millennial, I was there for the first games. As a kid, on like my eighth, ninth birthday, somewhere in there, I got that Game Boy color with the atomic purple and Pokemon Red version.

SPEAKER_00And I played that game into the ground. I also played Gold and Silver when it came out, and also Emerald, but I was getting pretty old by the time that Emerald came out. I was around 15, 16. Kids come in, they play the game, it's not as nerdy anymore, they watch the anime when they're even a little younger, and then they either do the TCG for a small percentage of them, or they age out and they retain those memories of the time that they put in. The intellectual real estate or the IP that that brand has in their brain.

SPEAKER_00Fast forward 13, 14 years, and you get to where they're about 30 years old and they come in to their first discernible income. A wave goes through what they first started with, and then it moves into the next generations. We started seeing Charizard go nuts in the 2020, 2021 with COVID. That's when all the millennials were coming back in buying all the Gen 1. After that, it moved into characters like Umprion and some more of the Gen 2. Pokemon had taken a small hiatus and gone down a little bit, not near as much as sports, by the way.

SPEAKER_00And then we saw that Gen 2 demand come in, and also Gengar, because Gengar, for some reason, everybody loves Gengar. He's spooky, I guess. And then when the market picked back up, we saw Gen 2 pop off, then we started seeing Emerald go, and we saw Rayquaza go absolutely bananas. And this was the tail end of millennials, and maybe a little bit of Gen Z starting to come in as well. Because the old Gen Z started to turn 30 around 2023. And guess what? That's when we saw Gen 3 pop off.

SPEAKER_00And we've seen that demand continue to build, but more in those later generations. So what does this all mean to you, using those examples of how it's moved through Pokemon? We can literally look at when the anime started and which seasons hit what gens. Then we can look at when the games came out, and then we can find when the people that played those games at those ages turned 30, turned 32 somewhere in there, and we can predict when they're going to have income that they can push into cards, the cards that meant something to them as a kid.

SPEAKER_00The nostalgia loop is so powerful and also so predictable. The power of this, you all can go and you can now predict exactly when the market demand is going to pop off in certain Pokemon pockets. Go find the most popular Pokemon of that and start buying their good cards a year before you expect them to pop off. Because the demand is predictable. And the supply is something we have data for. And the funny thing about sports though, and why it doesn't work as much for this, maybe it does.

SPEAKER_00You know, I still need to do a lot more work on the sports side of this. But sports, I think the ebb and the flow move pretty quickly through the market. You can look back and maybe see the guys that are pretty popular with the kids right now and buy their cards maybe later in five or six years. But for sports, most of the value just dries up. Most of the sports value goes into the goats at the end of the day. And very little is left for anyone that's not an absolute elite player or incredibly popular player.

SPEAKER_00Pokemon is so massive that it just keeps going up for these guys, especially the most iconic Pokemon. So the cycles are much more predictable and reliable. So the second practical thing, Slabnomics approved, is to look at where the cycles are in terms of when kids started playing games or when they started getting excited about this player or that player, and predicting when they're going to come into income and having that understanding of where the market is probably going to shift. Add this to the first thing we talked about, which is understanding the PSA 9 to 10 dynamic and how psychology plays a part with prices.

SPEAKER_00And you're going to put yourself in a great position for the future. As always, only buy what you can afford. Be greedy when others are fearful and be fearful when others are greedy. And use the hype, don't get caught in it. As I wrap things up, a lot of people will comment on my videos and say, I can't believe you don't have more subscribers. I appreciate that. But also, it's your fault. Tell everybody about Slabnomics, make sure to like this and thank you so much for being here. Keep building, and as always, I will talk to you later.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Is It Worth Grading Sports Cards & TCG? PSA vs CGC vs Beckett Explained

    Oct 6, 202630 minAudio

    Thinking about grading cards? Start here. After 1,500+ submissions across PSA, Beckett, SGC, and CGC, I break down what each grader actually costs, how long it really takes, where each one wins, where each one fails,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Slabnomics Set Deep Dive: 1996 Topps Chrome Football

    Sep 29, 202622 minAudio

    1996 Topps Chrome Football is the inaugural set of the most important modern chrome brand, and the market still has not priced it correctly. In the first Slabnomics set deep dive, we go through the full history: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Swimming Naked: Early Warning Signs in the 2026 Card Market

    Sep 1, 202621 minAudio

    The sports card market is up big. Disney is up 5x in six months. Pokemon volume is at all time highs. So the question everyone is asking: how much longer? Let's talk dry powder. The rotation from modern into vintage....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Grading Mistakes in Cards: Beginner, Intermediate, and Advanced

    Aug 25, 202618 minAudio

    9 grading mistakes killing your sports card and Pokémon profits broken down by skill level. Matt covers PSA's new 50-70 business day turnaround at the $80 tier, why Beckett only bumps a certain amount off the average,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. PSA vs BGS vs CGC vs SGC vs TAG: Who Actually Grades Hardest

    Aug 18, 202623 minAudio

    Five of the most graded cards in history. Every grade from every grader. The data says a PSA 10 is easier to obtain than most competing top grades, and the market pays for it anyway. Cards analyzed: 2023 Van Gogh...

    Credit the people on this episode