Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Slabnomics

Slabnomics artwork

Swimming Naked: Early Warning Signs in the 2026 Card Market

Sep 1, 202621 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The sports card market is up big. Disney is up 5x in six months. Pokemon volume is at all time highs. So the question everyone is asking: how much longer? Let's talk dry powder. The rotation from modern into vintage. The speculative tells in sealed wax, breaks, and repackers. And the biggest structural throttle on the hobby right now: PSA and Beckett cutting their lower grading tiers, which pushed the raw to grade play from $100 cards up to $250 cards and squeezed collectors out. Volume is a leading indicator. It always peaks. This episode is about what to watch so you are not caught with your pants down when the tide goes out. Topics: sports card market cycle • Pokemon and sealed wax speculation • grading pipeline and PSA tiers • leverage and cash management • vintage versus modern rotation Keep Building. Weekly Newsletter Signup: Slabnomics.com 🎥Youtube 📸Instagram

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The hobby has grown so much over the past two years that many are starting to say, how much longer can it go on? Well, I'm not a soothsayer, but I am someone who has extensive experience in multiple financial markets. I spent five or six years writing for such publications as The Motley Fool, Forbes as a Ghostwriter, and Investopedia, as well as my own articles over at Seeking Alpha, which is a stock trading platform. And then regarding currencies, I wrote for a few years for my company and then for myself, regarding making sense of the most liquid market in the world, currency markets.

SPEAKER_00And while these are not directly correlative to the hobby, as commodities do not map to collectibles perfectly, we're going to be able to glean some insights from those other two markets. We'll bring in some comparative analysis from the movie The Big Short, and we'll talk about things to look for if you're getting worried about the aggressive growth of the hobby. And if you don't believe me that the hobby is going through aggressive growth, and you think that's just a gut feeling that I have, pull up a six-month index on card ladder.

SPEAKER_00You will see that Disney is up 5x, and you'll see multiple other submarkets that are up around 80-90%. These are not normal run-of-the-mill days. But the question remains, will the heydays last? And this is a question that's constantly in my mind whenever I go to my local card shows. Keeping an eye around you and seeing how many people are around, what kind of energy they're bringing, how the vendors are treating their customers, what kind of people are they buying at the tables, what are they looking for?

SPEAKER_00These are all early signal indicators that we can glean some kind of knowledge about where the market is headed. I've gone to two local card shows in the past week and a half or so. The first one was absolutely huge. It was exclusively Pokemon in One Piece, and it was absolutely packed in there. There were kids everywhere, along with their parents, and of course, some 20 and 30-year-old somethings wandering about hunting, like me. But the first thing that I noticed was the energy in that room, and especially because the kids were there and they were excited, they were going for these things.

SPEAKER_00You could see excitement on their faces when they were going up to the tables. Not all the kids are up there trying to make$10,000 deals and have their dad teach them how to be an entrepreneur. Some kids are just there because they enjoy the cards and they love that. And that's no shame if you're trying to teach your kid lessons about life and money. It's just nice to see the heart and the soul still in the hobby. When I see the kids surrounding the shows, that gives me a lot of hope for where we are in this current market cycle. I've been a little bit concerned because I have seen that the monthly volume has spiked to a pretty crazy extent recently.

SPEAKER_00If you pull up dashboard on card ladder, you'll see what the monthly volume looks like for all sealed wax sales as well as singles. Putting it to all time shows you how much over the past year we've had volume truly spike. And volume is a leading indicator, as I've said in other podcasts. So if we have massive volume going on in sales, it's usually indicative of some good market conditions in coming months. But at some point that sales volume always peaks. It has to, right? What goes up must come down, and at some point that sales volume comes down, and then average prices themselves start falling as well.

SPEAKER_00A lot of people are going to try and tell you when the end is near, but instead of trying to stroke my ego by calling a top, I'm just going to talk about things that we can learn from other market corrections and pull them into the hobby so that you're not caught with your pants down when the tide goes out. See, because the first thing that really happens is when credit starts tightening in many markets, that's when we see who's been swimming naked. What that means is when times are good, people can be constantly over-leveraging themselves, buying more than they can afford, and then selling because things have gone up.

SPEAKER_00So they make up the difference of interest payments and the mistakes they might have made in cash flow. When the market turns and now everything's going down, the people that have bought too much and are sitting on too much credit now find themselves unable to meet the demands of their creditors. They're unable to pay off all those credit card bills they've stacked up. When the tide was high, these guys seem to be swimming just fine. But when that credit tide comes in, they were swimming naked. This happens a lot on stocks because people are trading on margin in order to get bigger returns.

SPEAKER_00Trading on margin basically means they borrow from their brokerage so that they can buy more than they can actually afford at one time. This use of extra capital provided by the brokerage is called leverage. And being able to deploy extra capital leverages your returns to make them higher than you could have had only with your capital that you had in play. And while times are good, that works perfectly. But when times are bad, the opposite works even more strongly. Traders who are trading on margin are waiting for their assets to go back up.

SPEAKER_00But if they keep heading down, the bank starts to get worried at a certain level. And at a pre-established level, they will do what's called a margin call, which means that the person has to sell off their positions that they were over-leveraged on and at that time settle up on the losses they have for their account. They have to pay the piper. And this might sound like something that won't happen in the card market, but it will. Unless everyone is very disciplined with their expenditures and they keep their cash flow very tight, most people are probably buying a little bit more than they have to in order to try and drive some profits, getting 10% here.

SPEAKER_00But when prices start going down and things are now 30, 35, 40% less than what they were, the bill comes due, as it always does. This whole concept of watching your cash flow is really the heart and soul of any buying and selling of assets. Because what we really want to do is we want to keep balanced in our dry powder, which is our cash, and our assets that we are invested into. In the young stages of the market, you want to be heavily invested into the market because cash on the sidelines is cash that's not making you money from compound interest.

SPEAKER_00Since cash over a long period of time always goes down in value due to inflation. As a market cycle wanes, however, that's when we need to start getting more into our cash reserves. The most legendary stock pickers out there, investors like Warren Buffett or John Lynch, always knew when to scale back their investing and start stockpiling cash so that they could take advantage of opportunities that came in down markets. If you're only making money in up markets, and then when down markets come, you lose a whole bunch of money.

SPEAKER_00A lot of times that can erase all of the gains that you made. On the flip side of that equation, if you had gone to cash at the right time, when the market goes down 40%, you don't have a lot of assets that were going down. Maybe you had only kept assets that you wanted to hold for long term, maybe into the next market cycle, two to four years. And ideally, if you held the rest in cash, as things started to hit different levels of 40% down, 60% down, 70% down sometimes, you can be picking up amazing assets at bargain bin prices.

SPEAKER_00Because everyone was over-levered. But it's the few that were able to have the foresight and the discipline to stockpile cash that are going to make those purchases that can yield 10x returns over the next two, three years. So you might be thinking to yourself, well, how do I know when to start stockpiling cash? See, a lot of times people will do it too early. Six months into a bull market, they might start deciding that they want to start going into cash and then they miss out on the entire bull run.

SPEAKER_00You don't want to be that person. Being all or nothing is usually not the best way to go. So in the stock market world, what people normally do is they use indicators. One big indicator is the VIX index. Also known as the Fear Index, the VIC is the spread between those selling options and buying options in SP futures. And I know that's a lot of jargon there. So basically, the people that are betting on the stock market to go up versus the people that are betting on the stock market to go down.

SPEAKER_00When more people start betting on the stock market to go down, which is normally a much more dangerous play, the VIX index starts rising. And investors take note because now the bets that people are making in the derivatives market are saying we think that the SP is going to go down. And do these people know the future? No. But the more people think that, the more likely that outcome becomes. We're herd animals at the end of the day. It's a fair few who can weather the storm of being in the absolute minority and stay strong in their ideas and convictions.

SPEAKER_00So do we have something like this in the hobby right now? Do we have do we have people betting that something's going to go up and betting that something might go down in the hobby? Unfortunately, we don't. But we do have speculative pockets that we can start to see bubbles forming in and we can take heed. For instance, I mentioned that Disney is up 5x over the past six months. Yeah, that's not normal. Mad props to Disney, but that kind of explosive growth throughout a market is unsustainable.

SPEAKER_00We're also starting to see a little bit less enthusiasm in Pokemon market. And we're even starting to see movement into vintage more than modern and pre-modern. If you mess around with the charts a little bit in Card Ladder, you can put Poké in there and he'll bring up the four different graphs. Start going through the one week versus the one month, and then versus the six month and a year, and you can see the time that vintage started taking over in terms of where people's money is coming.

SPEAKER_00It's very recent. And talking about vintage cards versus modern cards is not arbitrary because this is something that we've understood inherently as human beings, especially in the stock market as far as investment goes. When times are good, people are investing in the most speculative of things. I remember in 2016-2017, everybody was about 3D printing. And it was around this time that NFTs started going as well, and money started going all into NFTs. 3D printing, of course, has amazing uses scientifically, medically, as well as for manufacturing, but NFTs were a pure speculative play.

SPEAKER_00It was simply, I'm going to buy this, hope it goes up, and I can sell it to someone else for more. And if cards are starting to make you feel that way, then you know that we're in a speculative movement. Trust your gut on that. I think we've already seen a massive speculative bubble pop up in terms of sealed wax. Trying to purchase it in One Piece or Pokemon has been near impossible, except in the Chaos Rising and Pitch Black sets that nobody wants. But trying to find OP17 at your local Target or Walmart is crazy.

SPEAKER_00They'll be sold out in 20 minutes. Everyone's putting different hats on so they can go get two packets at a time of these blister packs. And they're picking these packs up for$6 and selling them for$10 or$11. And you can get two of them. So people are running in, getting two packs, running back out, changing, putting a hat on, whatever, a fake mustache, I don't know, and then getting two more, and then running back out and getting two more. I'm sorry, but this kind of behavior is absolutely silly.

SPEAKER_00People are trying to tell me to do this. And I'm like, you think I'm gonna go out there and spend hours of my time trying to hunt down the ability to go run in and get two packs at a time? Spend hours and hours so that I can go get six bucks a pack? Oh man, I got quite the haul. I made$72 over three hours of running around. It's just silly to me. I don't I don't get it, I don't like it. Just pay$11,$12, let other people waste their time. But this is where people are right now. The quick buck is prevalent, and the lottery type dopamine hits that people are getting from entering into breaks with the possibility, the hope of getting a crazy one-on-one or this rookie's gold auto or this debut patch.

SPEAKER_00The companies that are putting on these brakes and the manufacturers are manufacturing dopamine. They are farming dopamine through these processes of putting out product to the masses. And look, there's been a lot of times where being in brakes, I'm sure, has been a lot of fun. And even something that's been really profitable for people. Back before brakes were such a massive thing and hobby boxes were much cheaper, the entry points actually made a lot of sense. But now people are spending$200,$400,$500 and getting absolutely skunked just for that one possibility or two possibilities that they might hit.

SPEAKER_00It's honestly unsustainable. And the prices of new products going out is unsustainable. So how has it been able to continue? It's the speculative wave that we're seeing, not only in breaking, but also in all of the repackers. The repackers are a business model that bleeds you little by little. The odds are never there for you to make money, but the odds are there for you not to lose money quickly enough that you get scared. I didn't get my chase, but when I ripped this arena club pack, at least I got this thing that I can sell back to them, and I got 92% of my money back.

SPEAKER_00You just lost 8% in five minutes. And then what do we do? We want to go and do it again. Well, this time I won't be lucky. Maybe I'll hit the chase this time. Maybe I'll get that 8% back. Maybe I'll make 10%. And then you lose another 5%. And then you lose another 8%. And at the end of the day, at the end of the hour, at the end of the week, whatever it is, you got sucked dry. We got to curb that gambling appetite in the hobby. We have to go back to collecting things because they were fun, because we liked them.

SPEAKER_00The crazy thing is, you can get the same amount of dopamine or even more by just collecting things that are small versus trying to get these big chases and hits. Whatever your goal is, no matter how small, that's what you can tie your dopamine to. It can literally be something like I want every Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher that's ever existed. And I want to get a card for every player. You can even put fun qualifications on there. The card has to be perfectly centered, or people will do the PSA 1 runs.

SPEAKER_00I think we need to claw back a little bit more of the collecting side of the hobby. Because if we lose that, we do lose the soul of what it's all about. About the connection that we make with ourselves and with each other, about the identity that we can share with other people and we can see manifested, about the memories that we can call back on and feel nostalgic about. This all ties in to one of the biggest indicators for watching where our market is right now, and that's the grading pipeline.

SPEAKER_00Using hindsight, we can see that during the COVID pandemic, after PSA stopped grading, the market soon started heading downward. Now, not every correlation is causation, but I can tell you with certainty that PSA, Beckett, Tag, all of these companies shutting down their lower tiers is affecting the profit margins of those that are flipping cards. Pure and simple. When it takes much longer for you to get your cards back, and when it's much more capital intensive to do that, these are levers that pull back the profit making machine.

SPEAKER_00It's very similar to when the Fed raises interest rates. That makes it hard to borrow, makes it more expensive to borrow, makes money more expensive. If you want to put in just one summarized idea, PSA cutting off the lower tiers and Beckett doing the same has made money making in the hobby more difficult. And it's made collecting more difficult at the same time. If you're a big collector, you're probably not sending in cards$80 a pop. You're probably sitting on them and waiting for some kind of bulk to come back, hoping for some kind of bulk to come back.

SPEAKER_00And the people that are making money through the raw to grade strategies are having to do it with higher and higher dollar amount cards. I mean, you think about it, a card that was$100, you used to be able to send and degrade and make some margins. Right now that's gone up to probably more like$250 raw. So we're seeing the flipping and investing activities within the hobby move further and further up the dollar chains. And we're seeing collector appetite be muted right now or staying raw. This is going to throttle the hobby.

SPEAKER_00If we don't get the graders opening back up these tiers within a couple, two, three months, I would say, we're going to start seeing this hit the hobby hard. And I fully expect at some point in the coming months, we will start seeing a softening in the market. Because at the end of the day, raw to grade was one of the few ways to change a card's actual value within the market. Now, to profit, you have to wait for a player to change their position within the hobby, a set to gain more relevance, or an industry like Disney or Marvel, et cetera, to gain prominence and attention.

SPEAKER_00These are more speculative thoughts, right? Than seeing a card, being able to ascertain its condition through a skill that you've cultivated, and being able to then put in some decision making, putting in some capital into that, drawing that value out of the potential. Those are a little bit more of hard skills than the more speculative skills of trying to just figure out what documentary is about to come out and how that's going to juice someone's market. And hey, I love speculation. I built a whole investment fund on it. But when everything is speculation, the foundation falls apart.

SPEAKER_00In the beginning, I said that I was going to pull some stuff from the big short. I know that a lot of you listening have seen that movie. That's my kind of crowd. So I'm sure you can recall that one of the biggest things that happened during the housing crisis is that the housing market started to be built on CDOs, collateralized debt obligations, which are effectively derivatives of the housing market. It was all built on this foundation that default rates for homeowners would never clear a certain threshold, because they never had in history.

SPEAKER_00But we also didn't have the times that were to come during the Great Recession. The housing market became a massive speculative market, something that hadn't really happened much before in the United States. People always found a way not to default in their mortgages in the past because those were usually just their homes. They had to live somewhere. And in all but the toughest times, they would do anything to save their house. But in the events leading up to the Great Recession, when houses became a commodity to flip and profit from, having two, three, four houses became commonplace.

SPEAKER_00And they were no longer the assets that you lived in and cultivated and repaired and raised a family in. But they became speculative assets that just kept going up. So you could keep investing in them, they'd go up, you get your equity out, and then you get another one until everyone was found swimming naked. And when banks and institutions started making these CDOs, they basically bundled together a bunch of bad mortgages to people with bad credit who are buying homes, thinking that they couldn't all default at once, until, of course, they all did.

SPEAKER_00So why do I bring up the big short? It's because we get into the situation where assets become mere vehicles of speculation. And when that happens, a timer gets put on that market. Because speculators don't stay around for the long term. They're always in the middle of what's hot. And when it's not, they move to somewhere else. So that's another indicator for you. The more speculators you hear come in, the more you hear people talk about the hobby like that, the more you should start moving the cash. Watch out for irrational exuberance.

SPEAKER_00I hope you found this podcast educational. I hope it's made you think. The purpose of Slabnomics, as always, is to help you make better investing decisions when it comes to sports cards and TCG. And to that end, please share this with a friend who will also feel the same. It's been a pleasure having you here as always. Thanks so much for being here. And of course, keep building, and I will talk to you later.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Is It Worth Grading Sports Cards & TCG? PSA vs CGC vs Beckett Explained

    Oct 6, 202630 minAudio

    Thinking about grading cards? Start here. After 1,500+ submissions across PSA, Beckett, SGC, and CGC, I break down what each grader actually costs, how long it really takes, where each one wins, where each one fails,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Slabnomics Set Deep Dive: 1996 Topps Chrome Football

    Sep 29, 202622 minAudio

    1996 Topps Chrome Football is the inaugural set of the most important modern chrome brand, and the market still has not priced it correctly. In the first Slabnomics set deep dive, we go through the full history: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Past Results and Predicting Future Returns in Cards

    Sep 8, 202620 minAudio

    Two data-backed frameworks for buying cards in 2026. First: the psychological barrier learned from 800+ cards. Only one pattern held with strong correlation. Anchoring, cascading demand, and pop-vs-price gaps explain...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Grading Mistakes in Cards: Beginner, Intermediate, and Advanced

    Aug 25, 202618 minAudio

    9 grading mistakes killing your sports card and Pokémon profits broken down by skill level. Matt covers PSA's new 50-70 business day turnaround at the $80 tier, why Beckett only bumps a certain amount off the average,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. PSA vs BGS vs CGC vs SGC vs TAG: Who Actually Grades Hardest

    Aug 18, 202623 minAudio

    Five of the most graded cards in history. Every grade from every grader. The data says a PSA 10 is easier to obtain than most competing top grades, and the market pays for it anyway. Cards analyzed: 2023 Van Gogh...

    Credit the people on this episode