Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Re-integrate

Re-integrate artwork

Fresh Expressions of Christian Ministry (podcast) with Dr. Angie Ward

Jan 19, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

How do we get beyond the competition we often see among different Christian ministries and work together for God’s glory and Kingdom? Churches and nonprofits are all seeking people’s attention, their participation, and especially their funding. But they do so from a scarcity mindset, believing that any funding directed to one organization or church is funding taken away from their own. We all like to say that we work for the same Lord Jesus and for the sake of His kingdom, but in practice, we compete with each other. Into this fray comes Dr. Angie Ward, professor of leadership and ministry at Denver Seminary. She is a leadership author and teacher with nearly 30 years of experience in church, parachurch, and Christian higher education ministry. Her new book is Beyond Church and Parachurch: From Competition to Missional Extension (InterVarsity Press, 2025). In our conversation, Angie Ward offers a new blueprint for churches and all other Christian ministries toward a unified future. In our conversation, * Dr. Ward provides a comprehensive definition of “church.” * She explains why it is essential that we see the church in terms of the people of God united to participate in God’s mission in a variety of ways. * She provides a new paradigm: “Missional Extensions.” This terminology helps us understand how various Christian ministries function and interact. * She provides practical ideas for ministries to cease competing and to start collaborating. Scroll down to learn more about Angie Ward. Thanks for listening! If you enjoyed this podcast, please share it with your friends. Your hosts are Dr. Bob Robinson and David Loughney. For further resources on reintegrating all of life with God’s mission, go to re-integrate.org. Dr. Angie Ward Angie Ward (PhD, Southern Baptist Theological Seminary) is the Director of the Doctor of Ministry Program and Associate Professor of Leadership and Ministry at Denver Seminary. In addition to Beyond Church and Parachurch, she is the author of Uncharted Leadership: 20 Case Studies to Help Ministry Leaders Adapt to Uncertainty (Zondervan, 2023) and I Am a Leader: When Women Discover the Joy of Their Calling (NavPress, 2020). Angie loves running, basketball, humor, and movies. She and her husband live in a college neighborhood in Denver. They have two young adult sons and one very spoiled beagle. Support independent booksellers! We recommend purchasing these books from Byron and Beth Borger at Hearts & Minds Bookstore. They are eager to serve God’s people with great books. Order online through their secure server or call 717-246-3333. Ask for 20% OFF by mentioning that you heard about these books on the Reintegrate Podcast! Get full access to Bob Robinson’s Substack at bobrobinsonre.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02podcast. I'm David Lawney and my co-host is Bob Robinson. Bob, you've been immersed in both the church and the parachurch for 30 years. And honestly, that's as old as I am. So that's pretty crazy. You're looking at the embodiment of your ministry. Anyway. There he is. You've been a church planner, and you've been an executive and campus minister for our favorite college outreach ministry, CCO. When you think of the church and the parachurch,

what comes to mind for you?

SPEAKER_03Well, while CCO's ministry model partners with local churches, what I unfortunately see in most communities is competition between churches and nonprofits for people's attention, for their participation, and especially their funding. Why is that, though? Many of them have a scarcity mindset that any funding that goes to one organization or church is funding that is being taken away from their institution. They say that we all work for the same Lord Jesus and for the

sake of the kingdom.

SPEAKER_03They'll say that, but in practice, they compete with each other. Some church leaders do not appreciate other ministries because They believe that local church is the primary means of God's mission in the world. And then the leaders of parachurch ministries can also lack appreciation for the local church because they think that their ministry is something very important that the church just could not do.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that makes sense. And there's a lot of unfortunate circumstances in what you said. You know, I can tell you that for my generation, we're fed up with that. There's so many young people I see on social media that is just fed up with that. We get inundated with ministries asking for our money, emails, texts, social media prompts, whatever it is. But we don't want to just throw cash at something. We want to support causes and ministries that we actually really believe in.

SPEAKER_02and that we can even get involved with. It makes us feel more connected to the mission. We're also not super excited about the local church, with many of us deconstructing what church life means. Many of my peers are okay with listening to preachers online, to podcasts, and to worship music, and getting together with friends to talk about the Bible and encourage each other. Our perception of church is becoming something very different from that of our parents' generation.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. Into this fray comes Dr. Angie Ward, Professor of Leadership and Ministry at Denver Seminary. She is a leadership author and teacher with nearly 30 years of experience in

SPEAKER_03church, parachurch, and Christian higher education ministry. Her new book, published by University Press, is titled Beyond Church and Parachurch, From Competition to Missional Extension. In light of all those issues you just mentioned, Angie Ward offers a new blueprint for churches and all other Christian ministries toward a unified future. We welcome Dr. Angie Ward to the podcast.

SPEAKER_03Thanks for being with us.

SPEAKER_00I'm so glad to be here. Thanks for having me.

SPEAKER_03So you and I have a lot in common. We both have been engaged in the world of church and parachurch and higher education for around 30 years. You've been training leaders in all these spheres so you know the challenges that they're facing. So could you tell us that story of the classroom epiphany you had during the class on church leadership and how this led to your writing of this book?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So like you said, I mean, I've been all sorts of ministry leadership roles. So church, parachurch, you know, nonprofit, educational, all that. Uh, so, so I'm, and I have a PhD in like in leadership and ministry leadership. So I'm qualified, you know, by some piece of paper to teach. Right. So I, so, um, I was teaching, uh, like a master's level ministry leadership class at a different institution than what I'm at now. And I was teaching, um, I was teaching ministry the way I had been taught it and had experienced it and leadership the way I had been taught it and experienced it.

SPEAKER_00And I grew up kind of came of age in kind of the really big Willow Creek, Bill Hybels, Tom Peters era. But as I'm teaching this to these ministry leaders, I had this kind of stop cold moment in the classroom where, you know, I don't think anybody else knows it, but I sure felt like my blood went cold. As I was talking, I almost had like sort of out of body where I was like, wait a minute, I'm teaching to a particular model here of ministry and leadership, and I don't know how we got to this or if I even buy this model.

I'm saying it all halting because I feel like it was like this, whoa, wait a minute. um and i was and and so i'm like and so i suddenly started questioning like okay wait a minute my job is to teach ministry leadership and i'm not buying maybe what i'm teaching or not understanding you know it's just kind of this odd thing and i thought okay and i have a uh an undergrad degree in in um you know in ministry and leadership i have a master's degree and a phd from reputable seminaries in ministry

SPEAKER_00and leadership And so I've got all this training and all this experience, and I know more about leadership than I do about the church. So I was like, wait a minute, this is a problem for me. And I don't know that I'm the only one that has this problem, because obviously I had not been taught any of that along the way either and all that. And so that led me really on a journey of like... Really going back to the foundational question, like, what is the church? Like, not just local congregation. Like, we use it in so many different ways.

SPEAKER_00So, like, what is the church? What are we supposed to be and do? What was God's original design for it? What does that mean for, like, nonprofits or what we sometimes call the parachurch? And so, like you said, that led me on this multi-year journey of asking that question, asking others that question, talking with other ministry leaders. Am I the only one asking this question? And sometimes yes, and other people are saying, but no, now that you bring it up, you know, kind of thing. And so that led to this book, Beyond Church and Parachurch,

where I kind of put into print what has evolved as my thinking of all this through

SPEAKER_00this process. I think we all just assume we know what that word means, you know, church.

SPEAKER_03Right. But then if you ask five people, you get five definitions. And so when you have these conversations, did you have people like when you ask them more deeply, what do you think this is? Do they go, oh, my goodness.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_03I haven't really thought that deeply about that. Right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we all have some assumptions about it. You know, like we use the word church, first of all, in like 10 to 12 different ways. You know, it's a building. It's a thing we do. You know, we just kind of focus on just bringing the assumptions without even questioning what that is or kind of our definition. And so that was kind of my hunch because I couldn't do it. And then I was part of a gathering. I've been part of this annual gathering of church and nonprofit leaders. And at the first one here in Denver, I asked them, and these are,

you know, these are pastors.

SPEAKER_00These are leaders of like, some of them global ministries, all sorts of type, you know, these are all people who have spent their vocationally and full-time service ministry, like to the church in some way, locally or globally. And I said, okay, take some time, write down what is the church. And by this point, not to my surprise, but sort of to my surprise, it was like, there was just a lot of silence, you know, and people started scratching a few things down. Now, part of it is because it's a kind of a concept or a construct

that's hard to pin

SPEAKER_00down, but people, you know, afterwards were saying, wow, that was a lot harder than I thought to really put that into writing and to give some definition to it. And then I said, okay, then what's the parachurch? And then I said, okay, then draw some visual representation of the relationship. between them, you know, and we were just all over the place. It led to very fruitful, you know, robust conversation and discussion in that group. They were like, so, and I, and that's the point I'm making this book, like this is our identity, not just the place we go to work,

SPEAKER_00you know, or an organization like, we should be able to answer this question, you know? And if, you know, the church is kind of God's plan A or established, you know, by God and, you know, in the scripture, it's like, and our identity, who we are, the body of Christ. So I just feel like we got big problems of everything downstream if we don't answer this question or talk about this first.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I feel like I also had a couple of aha moments just when I was at CCO, but also just when I was in college of what is church and then what is parachurch? How does CCO interact with churches? That was one of the first times where when I was at CCO, one of the things that they told us early is, A difference maker for us is that we're not competing against the church. We're trying to work in partnership with the local churches and community.

SPEAKER_02And that was an eye-opening moment for me. And even before we started speaking with you, when just Bob and I hopped on this call, I was telling Bob that My generation is kind of done, honestly, with how church and ministry have been done in the past. I see so many people going through this deconstruction that's so popular that we've seen in younger generations. And we want to see our money go toward things that we believe in and that we can see results from.

SPEAKER_02And many of us are not convinced that that is the local church, at least from people I've been seeing. So you say that we need to relearn what the Bible teaches about church. what the church should be for its ministry, for its people. So maybe in a nutshell, can you kind of tell us what the church, according to the Bible, is what it's actually meant to be?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. And I want to just follow up real quick on what you said. I think you're, you know, what you said about, you know, you're you're asking questions about, you know, and a generation is asking questions now about what the church. And I think this is we're at a kind of inflection point where it's this is exactly the question we're asking because people are saying like, like, man, this isn't working or I don't like what I'm seeing or, you know, whatever we've been emphasizing for the last 20 years is not getting the results we were seeking,

SPEAKER_00you know, and the pandemic just kind of exposed the cracks that were already there. You know, some people would say, oh, we have, you know, all these signs of like institutional trust is on the decline and all that. All the more reason we need to be asking this, re-asking this question. Yeah. So, yeah, he asked about the definition of church and what the Bible says. Okay, this is my understanding of what Scripture says. And so I'll unpack it a little bit, but I'll read it here. I have it bookmarked in the book. The church,

SPEAKER_00and I put in there biblical ecclesia, which means gathering, that's the word for church that's used in Scripture, is the divinely established, called out, and sent collection of all the people of God around the world, animated and united by the work of Christ and guided by the Holy Spirit, who gather regularly in locally embodied community to recenter their lives around God and to seek to live out kingdom values in the relationships with one another and with the world.

SPEAKER_00And so I try to keep this intentionally general enough, not necessarily vague, but like when I talk about like meet together regularly in community to recenter their lives around God, that can take a lot of different forms. Like that could be liturgical, that could be, you know, it's like, so, but there's some principles behind the whole thing. And so, I mean, when I looked at scripture, you know, read theologians and commentaries, And like the early church and just kind of the church tradition,

SPEAKER_00you know, what was meant by that, that's what I come up with in there. So I'm happy to unpack all the different pieces of that. But like there's a piece of it that's universal. So it's like, you know, all of the people of God around the world, but also primarily in Scripture, in the Testament, ecclesia was a locally embodied gathering of people. But there's a missional component. There's a formational component by it. It's a divinely established in a different way than a

parachurch or nonprofit would be.

SPEAKER_00I think scripture, I think there's something unique, something sacred, not in the sacramental, like I'm not going to try to go to like church doctrine kind of thing, but I think there's something unique about when people gather in that type of community. that in that divinely ordained kind of thing, it's present in a different way than, say, a hiking group in the mountains, a bunch of Christians hiking in the mountains. But that's controversial. I mean, you know,

I listened to a lot of different conversations from different kind of streams of like micro churches or people who are very much into institutional church.

SPEAKER_00And you notice I don't say anything. I talk about the gathered people, but I don't talk about like a, well, locally embodied, but I don't talk about like has to have a brick building or anything like that, but is a locally embodied community.

SPEAKER_03So ekklesia, the Greek word, means gathering. And so very heart of this thing has got to be gathering. So in your definition, these people gather regularly in locally embodied community. And so each one of those words is heavy.

SPEAKER_00Right, right. They're very intentional. And I had to chew on them a lot before putting that out there into print for everybody to rip it apart.

SPEAKER_03This is church and parachurch, so we're going to be talking about parachurch and nonprofits and people Every Christian, lots of Christians, are involved in those, whether they are giving to those or they're actually involved in the ministries themselves, but they're also members of a local congregation. Perhaps. Maybe not. Maybe not. But that's the problem, right? The church is the gathering, is the ecclesia. You cannot be a Christian. You can be a Christian and not meet,

but you're not being biblical, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, right. The idea of kind of an unchurched or ungathered Christian would be anathema to the majority of church history, you know, leaders and yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And so locally and then embodied. Yeah. I argue that it's embodied and not an online, not a merely online experience.

SPEAKER_00In the same way, I don't think you can be, I don't know that you can just have an online, only online marriage. Right.

SPEAKER_03Now, wait a minute. Wherever two or three are gathered, and I see three people on my Zoom meeting right now.

SPEAKER_00Right, right, right. So, well, so the first thing I say to that is Christ is there, but that doesn't automatically make it a church. Not saying Christ isn't there, but Christ being there doesn't automatically make it a church. Christ could be at a CCO gathering, but that doesn't necessarily make it ecclesia. But, you know, when two or three are gathered, I say, okay, well, there's two of you in your marriage. Is that a church? Most people, they would say, oh, no, I guess not. Is your family at church? Some people would say yes. And that the husband is the kind of the bishop or the priest of

his family.

SPEAKER_00And that's a congregation. I don't think there's biblical support for that.

SPEAKER_03There's a community value to this embodied community. It's people loving one another. They're in relationship, caring for one another. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I talk about they gather regularly. Now, it doesn't say it has to be weekly. It doesn't say it has to be Sunday. But Hebrews, let's not forsake the gathering together as some are doing. So gather in locally embodied community to recenter their lives around God. And then our God is a missional God, you know, but so it's not just a missional group, but the people are a missional, you know, who seek to live out kingdom values. That's, again, where I made it more broad, you know,

SPEAKER_00so, you know, like discipleship mission, people use different words for that, right? Live out kingdom values in their relationships with one another and with the world. So it's not just a holy huddle. But it's not just an external mission-focused group either, which is what largely a nonprofit is. It's organized around a particular, that type of mission first. And that's the primary organizing thing.

SPEAKER_03I've had a recent work, a corrective in my understanding, because I went like full in on missional church. And I was like, this is what it's... And then I realized, sure, we're a sent people, but we're also a gathered people. So if I'm just focused on sending, sending, sending, and we're not gathering to worship, we're not gathering to love one another, that is the... How will they know that we are Christians? Yeah. Because we love one another.

SPEAKER_03And that's the witness to the world. And if we're not gathering and loving one another, we're not, that's not the witness anymore. So I just recently, you know, had a pushback on myself on this whole missional, I want to be missional. And I'm like, oh, wait a minute. We're also a gathered community.

SPEAKER_00people yeah yeah and sometimes i mean a lot of these are can be kind of a correction or maybe an overcorrection from a thing that's missing you know so it's like well we were doing too much just gathering together and we were not living among the world being salt and light okay right i get that we're not being evangelistic you know and um so like bill hybels willow creek one of the biggest contributions church history wise was this that the idea re bringing up the idea again and championing that lost people matter to god But we could also be so evangelistic that we're not making

disciples, not just converts.

SPEAKER_00And that discipleship happens in relationship and in close relationship. And, and, and that's how Jesus did it. There's no substitute. You can't scale discipleship. You can't, you can't only do the seven online. You can, you know, and so sometimes we have this, you know, I meet people who have this idea of church as a collection of goods, religious goods and services. And so I can piece them together. I can get Bible teaching from this place. I can listen to the radio and do this, and I can read this Christian book and I can gather with go attend this group for a while and get my worship on,

you know, kind of thing.

SPEAKER_00But there's no meaningful that the rubbing together in relationship. That's what forms us. That's the part we hate because it's hard and messy. You know, church is supposed to be just down and dirty.

SPEAKER_03David's generation, we talk about this a lot. It's like, oh, can I just swipe? This is getting too hard. That's where the good stuff begins. Why is there so much emphasis on reconciliation and loving one another? Because you're in a family. Guess what? We just went through Thanksgiving and... Right, right, right. You know, family tensions, you got to deal with them and you have to deal with them

biblically. Yeah, and I grew up more with the model of church as educational institution.

SPEAKER_00So it was very cognitive. And so if you learned, you know, it was about teaching the Bible, but it was like if you had proper doctrine, proper cognitive, the right information. But over time, I realized, I think we all realize this, that information, not just in the church, but information alone does not equal transformation. It's got to be, you know, practiced and lived out. And so that's where that one part of my model started crumbling.

SPEAKER_03Right. Right. So when I was trained to become a pastor, I went to the Willow Creek Pastors Conference, and Bill Hybels said, you know, God, the church is God's way of doing mission in the world.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the local church is the hope of the world, yep. And so I took that to mean that the local churches and the pastoral leadership for

SPEAKER_03which I was training was the thing, the only thing that really matters to bring people to faith and to bring transformation to the world. So those first several years of pastoral ministry, that was pretty heady stuff, stressful stuff, especially when I planted a church. But your definition, while clearly saying church must be these Christians gathered in locally embodied communities, is also much broader than that. Why is it essential that we see the church in terms of the

people of God united to

SPEAKER_03participate in God's mission in a variety of ways?

SPEAKER_00That's a great question. And let me see how I can attack it. You know, I'm just thinking more like what are kind of the false models or assumptions or paradigms we have, which is like, it's all about doing on crusades and conquering for Jesus. Like, or it's just our little group. Like you said, like it all depends on you. Well, that forgets like, or it all depends on America or the Western church. You know, it's like that just... That excludes all of what God is doing in so many pockets of the world.

SPEAKER_00I mean, the local church is good. Local congregation is good for what is called near neighbor missionality. So living on mission like in that proximity. But there's so many other things going on around the world and local churches doing their things in our ends of the earth. And we're their ends of the earth. And so we are all part of the body. We all should be gathering in local ecclesia. And we are all called, not just as organizations, but all of us,

each of us,

SPEAKER_00to be missional, you know, on mission, not just meaning evangelism, but like redemptive, bringing shalom, the full gospel, you know, somewhere and to the world, to the needs of the world. And for some of us, that's right in our backyard. And for others, it's a call to go globally. You know, that's another thing, you know, you're talking about the mission. For me, growing up, missions meant foreign cross-cultural evangelism. And we had a missions conference, you know,

SPEAKER_00and so my world was expanded by the missional conversation, you know, and going like, oh, wow, this doesn't just happen by sending unique people who are called to that. We don't only see them, you know, at the conference and get the reports from them. So just it's a kingdom perspective, I think, you know, it's like the kingdom is just so much bigger than our little corner or a little institution or a little silo or our little empire. And so I think it regains the focus or broadens the focus.

SPEAKER_03It's God's people. The church isn't an institution. But it is a community of people. Yes. But it's also a scattered community. It could be a gathered community, and it could be a scattered community. It's both and. And so what I do, reintegrate, one of my main things is my niche is every single one of you is on a mission field. Guess what? You work 50 hours a week,

and if you're not being a salt and light person, bringing flourishing to your coworkers and to your customers and to your suppliers.

SPEAKER_03And you are not, you're missing your mission. This is your mission.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's not to leave those things and come to more church events or actually leave that and go, yeah, one of the churches we served at, my husband's a pastor. We've served in ministry, pastoral ministry for 25 years before moving back to Denver for me to work here at Denver Seminary. But there was one church we were at where they were There's a person who is just doing all sorts of ministry in the community, and they made that person an elder. And because he was so influential in his ministry leadership, it took him away from the things he was called to do.

SPEAKER_00It was like, you know what? like we need to release you out of here and give you an open hand, go like come worship, you know, be part of our, you know, the, the ecclesia, the embodied community piece of that. But I think we have this, you know, the book I talk about just a whole different model from a structural or very institutional framework where all this stuff happens. Even the scattering has to happen from an institutional base. And it's like, you know what the, the church is very movemental. The people of God are supposed to be, it's a, you know, is a movement.

SPEAKER_00And, and so there's always this tension between, you know, some sort of structure and organization, because that, that can help besides just kind of floating out there and you need that rootedness, but also, you know, so you, so you, you want to have that, but not lose the agility and the mobility. Yeah. And I argue in the book that I think we've largely for the last at least three, four hundred years, I think we've taken an institutional dominant framework where organizations were going to save the world,

SPEAKER_00you know, and so and it comes from, you know, kinds of industry in the early leadership literature, you know, from. 50, 100 years ago was how to have greater impact and greater output and a kind of a mechanistic view of organizations. And we've taken a lot of that just unthinkingly and adopted that to how we do church. And again, moving away from what I think is really it's more like it's apostolic, meaning that like it's a sent missional kind of thing. We are all that as our identity.

SPEAKER_00It's not just the organization that is First Baptist Church is missionalistic. No, we're the body. And so I think we've lost our identity and or given, we've abdicated to institutions. We've abdicated our identity and our work from that identity to institutions and organizations sometimes, too many times.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think there's a lot of times we're waiting for permission, like we're waiting for permission from the churches to be told where to go, what to do, and it When exactly what you said, I mean, we, if we're truly the hands and feet, then we need to move on our own, especially.

SPEAKER_00We've also told you you need permission from us. Yeah, that's in the organizational space, right? It's like you can't do it unless we have the checkpoints and the gatekeepers. So we talked a lot about what is church, the importance of it, but I wanted to discuss.

SPEAKER_02So obviously the listeners know we mentioned this before. So Bob being working in his nonprofit here at Reintegrate, also being a campus minister of a CCO, and I was blessed to be a fellow for CCO a few years back. So CCO, while their ministry model partners with local churches, CCO is what is called a parachurch. So I wanted to talk more now about kind of this definition of parachurch. So can you first define what parachurch means? And then second, kind of tell us the advantages of a parachurch ministry.

SPEAKER_02And then tell us maybe why you don't like that term.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was going to say, well, I was going to say how I define it. I can tell you how it's been historically defined, but skipping ahead to number three, I'll give you, like, I don't like that. And I actually propose a different thing. So, you know, parachurch, and there's kind of not totally clear when this language began to be used, but as these different nonprofits started rising up, Christian nonprofits started, And really, actually, they've been around, side note, they've been around since monastic times.

SPEAKER_00I mean, we think of monasteries as these cloistered things, but actually there have been these types of expressions or voluntary societies throughout church history. And there's been this tension between the local congregation and leadership through that. So parachurch has historically meant... organizations that are not a local congregation, that are generally some sort of organized around some sort of specific missional purpose. But they're Christian, they have some level, they have, you know,

SPEAKER_00on some of the spectrum, some level of relationship maybe to, they're at least Christian. And so it's like they have bodies of, the members of the body of Christ are part of it, but that doesn't necessarily make it an ecclesia kind of thing so and part of my problem with para church as a as a name first of all it's like if we don't understand back to what we were talking about before if we if we can't agree on what we mean by church first of all and then what does para mean does para mean like coming alongside like they're equal or or the

local ecclesia is the the center and the foundation and they have to come out of those local you know none of this you know it has to originate from the local

SPEAKER_00congregation there's just so many complications with those terms. You know, what does church mean? What does para mean? And what was your second question, David? You had three in a row there.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So you gave us a definition. So maybe if you could give us some of the advantages of what a parachurch does.

SPEAKER_00Of that type of organization. Yes. Yeah, even though I don't like the name. Yes. So some of the advantages off the top of my head, one, they can just be more specialized and focused. And so, you know, if my local congregation in Denver feels like, hey, we want to be a part of ministering to victims of sex trafficking or unwed mothers in our locality or something across the globe.

Parachurch or those types of nonprofits are so good at that type of focus stuff.

SPEAKER_00They have inns that we do not have In the same way that we have near neighbor kind of mission that they may not, you know, and so there's a focus, a specialization that which means they can kind of maximize resources like, you know, $10,000 to give into one of those organizations for a specific purpose is going to go a lot farther than trying to do that on our own. you know, or not even being able to, you know, it's like, and you think about the range of what are considered parachurch. I mean, a lot of people, they go, well, what do you mean by that?

SPEAKER_00And I start by saying like, okay, Campus Crew or InterVarsity Navigators, you know, CCOUs, some of like, most of the time they, Young Life, you know, some sort of age kind of thing like that, Promise Keepers. But then you start thinking about Denver Seminary, NavPress, Zondervan, Christian Radio, you just start going all the BSF, Fellowship of Christian athletes, see you at the pole, you know, and you just, the amount of those, but they all have very unique, specific purposes.

SPEAKER_00And the other thing, like, they've been historically a great place. They've allowed more women to get involved in ministry and leadership in spaces where they might have closed doors congregationally in those things. And also, they have always been the place to mobilize and utilize the laity. So as the institutional church got more and more credentialed, which not that that's a bad thing, but that meant for a long time, in fact, Vatican II in 1967,

SPEAKER_00I think, I mean, even the Roman Catholic Church started saying, boy, we need to really mobilize the laity because we've gone too specialized where the clergy have to do all the things. And so throughout history, there have been, like I said, voluntary societies, even these monastic kind of communities where there are people in the community, Christians, believers, who wanted to come alongside and would be released to do ministry among the people. through these special like voluntary societies. So, you know, whether it was Bible translation or evangelistic work or gospel tract,

SPEAKER_00especially stuff in their communities where the local gathering was, the Ecclesia was more about preaching the word and the sacraments. And maybe some near neighbor kind of stuff. And so there's well, then you have denominations that had their own. They had congregations and publishing arms and schools. And then you have megachurches that start having a homeless ministry and unwed mothers, you know, pregnancy kind of thing and a mechanics thing and sending doing their own camps and doing their own broadcast. You know, so the lines have just gotten really blurry.

SPEAKER_00But those are, I think, some of that specialization, the utilization of resources, of women, of lay leaders are some of the unique things that what we have historically called the parachurch have been great gifts.

SPEAKER_03We keep using this term, parachurch.

SPEAKER_00I know. What are we going to like? Throw it out. I know.

SPEAKER_03Throw it out. What is your word to replace it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're ready for the big reveal. I know.

SPEAKER_03Here comes the reveal, everybody.

SPEAKER_00Right, right. Well, so let me just do a little background work. You know, I talked about this kind of, I think we're bound by this structural or institutional framework at first. So if you picture like all these, like our president here at Denver Center calls, jokingly, we'll say cylinders of excellence. What he means is silos. So you see these cylinders, right? And they're bounded by locale or denomination or doctrine or all these different things and we're trying to like keep people in them and so it's all it's all based on the holding like the containers and instead I say what if we go to like a functional

perspective more to

SPEAKER_00like okay, the function of the ecclesia is in this community is this, and the ends of, you know, the ends of the earth is where they have this other, you know, local congregation ecclesia. And also you've got someone who's going to the ends of the earth doing this or among these population. And so it's the... You lower the kind of the cylinders and the walls of that to become almost more like if you, you know, nodes on a network or a true ecosystem, you know, where everything's connected and kingdom wise,

SPEAKER_00which it really is. And so we kind of are... You know, we've cut off these things, these connections and these ties. And so, you know, it's more like they're kind of just temporary holding containers for people and resources and they flow more freely along these lines instead of trying to collect them and contain them. And so my new name for that, for all those nodes is missional extensions. And I know it doesn't flow as trippingly off the tongue, you know, parachurch, but a lot of people, you know, parachurch has too many problems and a lot of people haven't

even heard of that

SPEAKER_00term. But It brings back the function of it. We are, all of us, whether it's an organization, an ecclesia, whether it's a nonprofit, whether it's a small group, whether it's us as individuals, we are all missional extensions. We don't have to, like, we're all by being part of the body of Christ. It's not like, And missionaries in my growing up, you know, experience in my stream was always like missionaries and pastors were, first of all,

SPEAKER_00the highest. And it was like the secondary special call that certain people got and others didn't, which lets most of the majority of us off the hook. We're all as the body of Christ. The body, which is us, is supposed to be missional. And so calling it missional extension, it's like, okay, it's back to the function. And then the extension is like where that happens, you know, and we're supposed to be covering the earth.

SPEAKER_03An extension of what? Not an extension of a local ecclesia.

SPEAKER_00Extension of God's mission around the world.

SPEAKER_03An extension, okay. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, an extension for mission. We are all nodes living out the Missio Dei, like the redemption and reconciliation of all things, extended all over the globe. And like I said, so like, you know, you guys are in Canton, Ohio, I'm in Denver. It doesn't all have to originate in the cylinder that is in the United States. Or it's like my local... mission, missional stuff is my backyard. But someone in Korea may also say,

SPEAKER_00like, I've had students in my class who are who are missionaries to the United States from Korea. And so it also levels the playing field, first of all, not just for clergy, you know, like these highly exalted people are missionaries, you know, versus regular people, it's for everyone across the world. So it's not just it has to originate from these places from these people, then with like this one center, there's no center to this network. So I recently accepted an invitation to be on the steering team

for Malone

SPEAKER_03University's Missional Innovation Hub. It seeks to cultivate collaboration among churches and nonprofits and businesses in our community. But I know that the hub has an uphill climb. Many churches and nonprofits are very cautious about collaboration.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_03It's like there's a sense of territorialism, right? Yes.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_03People are worried that if they collaborate with other ministries, they'll sacrifice their own resources to others. We're all seeking funding, and there's always so much to go around. But at Mission Innovation Hub, we believe, I think, that the kingdom of God is best advanced worldwide. And people are best ministered when Christians work together. We want to see leaders of churches, ministries, nonprofits, for-profits operating in an integrated collaborative ecosystem to inspire and equip each other for kingdom impact.

SPEAKER_03But like I said, uphill climb. What are the main reasons ministries just don't get along and how can we overcome these?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, why don't they get along? One of the reasons that we don't work together, some of it is just simple time and energy constraints. I mean, because it's like, you have to give some, we're so focused on our own mission and keeping, sometimes just keeping the ship afloat that it feels like we can't afford to take that time or energy to do that. I would say we can't afford not to, if you're looking at a kingdom perspective. perspective, but I think there is just kind of that fact of that matter, right? It's like, okay, show me what I would take off my plate, you know, for that kind of thing.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, why don't we get along? A lot of it, like you said, we've got these, we've just, various reasons we have these walls. Sometimes it's doctrinal or theological, you know, it's like, well, you know, you're, you want to feed the homeless and we want to feed the homeless, but, but you have a different doctrinal statement. You know, that's a reality. Sometimes it's like instead of being the function and the mission being the unifying thing, we get divided before we get to the missional piece of it.

SPEAKER_00I think bottom line, a lot of times, and we don't like to hear this or to say this, there is a control piece to it. Who gets to be in charge? Who gets to own the thing? So, you know, I've you know, I know people like ministries who we're just not open handed with our resources. We have the scarcity mindset. And so and the reality is, in one sense, there are some like I only have so many dollars that I can give. And so we're all we're competing, not in the way that we're like, I don't want you to lose,

SPEAKER_00but I don't want you to take away from what I need to win. either, right? So we have this kind of scarcity mindset for things, this kind of, again, this kind of silos or cylinder kind of thing. There's really like the power thing. We don't like if we're asking for prayer, we don't, there's not a, we don't fight over who gets the prayer resources. Like we have this, the mentality of we've got to keep this stuff for us or we have to have to, we get control over where it goes instead of this loose,

SPEAKER_00you know, open-handed kind of thing to it. Like I do a thought experiment sometimes. How long is it's CCO, right? Is that what you guys, how long has that been around? 50 years. Okay, so 1975-ish. Okay, yeah. So my understanding, this may just be lore, but I've heard it a number of times. I couldn't verify it when I was writing the book, is that when Jim Rayburn founded Young Life in 1948, he said it was a 50-year charter because they said in 50 years,

we either need to not exist or we have to completely change how we're doing things

SPEAKER_00because the culture is going to be shifting. I mean, so what if Denver Seminary, which just celebrated its 75th anniversary, What if we said, you know what, we're going to assume we're only supposed to be around for 10 years or 15 years or 20 more years or five or CCO did the same thing. How would that change how we hold our resources and what we do with that? It's a whole perspective flip of things. So part of it, we have this idea that our things have to continue to grow and

continue to live in

SPEAKER_00perpetuity.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and I don't know that's that's I don't know that's necessarily biblical or healthy.

SPEAKER_00I mean, what of health is we're we measured health by how much we gave away every year and by how much we pay we gave down our endowment. We spent down our resources. Instead of how much we put in and how much we earn and how much more. What if we gave, we said, you know what? We lost five staff people this year because they went to so-and-so.

SPEAKER_03We believe in our mission. We think that this is the thing, right? And you're not going to change our mind on that. I mean, so this institution I'm working for is doing the thing that's really important to me. And I am in leadership in this thing because of that. And you're telling me to not increase my endowment so this thing can't continue to do this great work? What do

SPEAKER_00Right. I know. I think we at least need to be willing to ask ourselves that question and ask the board that question instead of assuming. You know, like, I mean, you look at like promise keepers. It still exists, I think, in some form, but it's not what it was before. OK. You know, and so all the demise or whatever. It's like, well, the churches in Revelation aren't around today, you know, and they were doing great work. Some of them, not all of them, you know. So some of them. Right. Yeah, exactly. So.

And so we just have these assumptions about organizations and institutions. And what if it was supposed to what if it's supposed to be just kind of flowing

SPEAKER_00like water and you don't try to capture it? Now, there is a reality. I'm an organizational leadership person. So there's a reality that organizing enables you to do things that you can't do alone. But but there's that fine line of which, you know, when we fall on one side or the other.

SPEAKER_03We can be anti-institutional, which is bad. I think we have to have institutions because we have to have people getting together to do big things. But there's a difference between institution and institutionalism, where the institution is the center of what we are all about.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_02As we were talking about, Control and just different reasons that churches may not sometimes work with these nonprofits or vice versa. I remember actually I was sitting in a room one time where a church and a nonprofit were talking about. Creating some marketing materials. And they were debating about, and I kid you not, they were debating about whose logo is on top and the size of the logos.

SPEAKER_02Yep. For, I mean, almost a whole meeting.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And it was one of those moments for me where... I was kind of frustrated because I was like, I really don't think Jesus would have this meeting about this logo size issue that we're having right now. I really think like we're kind of...

SPEAKER_00Look back at your WWJD bracelet and bring that into the conversation.

SPEAKER_02Like we're missing the point here. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, but in the course of it, you feel like, well, of course we need to ask this question. This church parachurch leaders gathering, we invited all these, you know, different leaders, and there were more than zero who said, well, I can't come or won't come or my board won't allow me to come if I'm not able to present about our ministry.

SPEAKER_01That's tough.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. We've all been in this context where, you know, it is about our ministry and

SPEAKER_03And it gets frustrating because now that I'm not in church, I'm not a church leader, and I've been a layperson for a number of years now, I'm now going, wait a minute, you know, why is it so important that our church gets front billing on this thing, right? Or why is it that our pastor is the best pastor in the city and we all have to hear from him, right? Can't we get people together in a room and everybody be equals and let's

SPEAKER_03collaborate and create an ecosystem where we all are like, oh, I didn't think of that. And being open in our hearts and our minds about the things that might be there because the Holy Spirit, we're not the sole possessor of Holy Spirit wisdom. Right. There's got to be others that will help us in these things.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you have, you know, you made a good point about like, like all these ministries are important, you know? And so on one hand, I understand where it's like, okay, well, I, but if, but if I do this, then you're telling me, like you said, you're telling me I have to take away from this very important thing. This is dear to the heart of God. Yeah. Yeah, all of them are. It's more about our mindset, I think, than necessarily the I'm going to give it all away. It's just a question that challenges us because it's a heart

reorientation.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00Right. I'm not saying take all your money from CCO and give it to Denver Seminary, you know, or give it to the homeless, whatever, you know, or a hierarchy of all these different things. But it does reveal that. You know, like when the rich man went into Jesus and said, what do I need to do? You know, what was the law say? And then he says seller and then the rich man went away sad. And so these kind of questions, I think, reveal what we're holding on to and what our assumptions are.

SPEAKER_03I'm getting ready to send out my end of semester newsletter. And there's always an ask in those newsletters. Right.

SPEAKER_00And I write in the book, I'm sure you read this, just about how many of those letters I got in our mailbox one year when I was writing this book. Like how many of those, you know, and some of them are like, you know, if I was a supporter of you and I, you know, I got those from people I know. And then a bunch were just from organizations that, You know, somebody got me on a mailing list somehow, you know, and I just got so many things from certain organizations. And it's just like, OK, I've never had any organization say, we know you have a lot of opportunities.

SPEAKER_00Discern what the Lord is asking you to give. And, you know, if it's this, that's great. But, you know, I don't ever remember getting an email or a letter saying, you know, I got enough this year. Give it to them. Well, you know, I read that in your book, and that's what I decided to put in my newsletter. Okay, for this winter. Or your end of semester one, whatever.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, you're going to make me cry because it's like, I'm going to tell people, do you know how much need there is out there? I know you love my ministry. And if you want to keep giving to my ministry, that's awesome. But man... I have upped my ministry giving to World Relief a ton because USAID got shut down and they need my money. Would you think about giving to them?

Would you think about giving to anything that you see has really been crushed

SPEAKER_03recently that needs your money? Because I'm not crushed.

SPEAKER_00That is so beautiful. And thank you for sharing. And so countercultural and... Like through even our communication as ministry leaders, we're discipling people towards stuff and you're discipling your readers toward a new way of thinking about it. And so I just really respect that a ton.

SPEAKER_03I say it not to boast.

SPEAKER_00No, I know you weren't. That's even more why I respect it because you're not saying it.

SPEAKER_03It's because of what you wrote. It's like, oh my goodness, this is going to have to change. So thank you for that.

SPEAKER_00Wow.

SPEAKER_03Thank you for being on the podcast.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for having me. I wish we could talk forever. I'd love to keep in touch with you all. So glad to be on this conversation with you guys and your listeners. So appreciate it.

SPEAKER_03We will definitely, definitely keep connected.

SPEAKER_00CCO is doing good stuff. Y'all are doing good stuff. Thanks for just the Kingdom Conversations you're facilitating for where you guys, where you're missionally located.

SPEAKER_03I wish I could say the same for Denver Seminary, but I can't. You guys, I don't know.

SPEAKER_00Right, exactly.

SPEAKER_03Joke to joke.

SPEAKER_00I know. Well, blessings on you guys. Great to chat with you. If you're ever in Denver, holler. Love to buy a coffee.

SPEAKER_03I am. I'm in Colorado every year.

SPEAKER_00Oh, for what?

SPEAKER_03Hiking mountains.

SPEAKER_00Do you know where the seminary is? Have you ever been here?

SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, I know where the seminary is.

SPEAKER_00Well, then come on over.

SPEAKER_03I will. That'd be fun. Knock on your door and you're like, oh, there's that guy.

SPEAKER_00That's right. Like I smell this guy from somewhere. Yeah. No, seriously, that'd be fun. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00David, you too. Get out to Colorado.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I've been once and I'm dying to get back. So I'd love to.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'd love to treat you to a meal or something.

SPEAKER_02Hey, sounds good to me.

SPEAKER_00It's a New Denver seminary, man.

SPEAKER_01Sounds good to me. That's right. You might have figured out that I'm pretty passionate about what we were talking about.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. This is right what I'm really dealing with a lot now. And I'm trying to figure out how to do this collaborative thing. And yeah, so her words in her book and this conversation is very helpful. yeah it's it's interesting it makes me think of my time at cco a lot and i'll never forget when i went to mission view who was at the time like my partner church was cco and i went to one of their board meetings to kind of pitch

myself and cco to

SPEAKER_02them to say hey do you want a partner on this and I remember giving the presentation and I remember being getting asked like are you gonna be like they asked me like are you gonna be in the office like are you gonna be around or you know like we've just we've worked with a lot of college ministers in the past that are like we don't really ever hear from them like they just kind of they do their own thing they kind of run their own thing they occasionally will drop by the office but like they're on their own usually And,

SPEAKER_02you know, I told him, I'm like, no, like I plan on coming here to work at least one or two days a week to get some stuff done, like on my laptop, because they asked me if I like would be at staff meetings. And I was like, yeah, like as long as it works into, you know, like the college's schedule, you know, I'll be in for staff meetings. I'll, you know, obviously like help out on Sundays when I can. And in a way, like I'm an extension of you to this college. And so, yeah. And I remember them being like, wow, that's so different. That's crazy.

SPEAKER_02And their reaction was very positive towards that, which was cool. Because same for me at the time, I thought, yeah, it's partnered with a church, but what does that really look like? And then actually doing it for a year, I'm like, oh yeah, we're not trying to compete against you. We're not trying to up our numbers and making sure that we're winning. There's no winning. We're working with you on this. And that was a whole shift of mindset.

SPEAKER_03So that was cool. The original extensions of the mission of God in the world, and yet the CCO model sees the CCO ministry as that church's extension onto that campus. It's like, this is... how we do that. That's what's unique about the CCA Church partnership model is that we don't pretend to be the church, and we'll never be the church. And so we want college students to be in the church. And so part of our ministry is to say, yeah, we're meeting here on campus.

SPEAKER_03We've got this fellowship. We've got this Bible study. We're having socials. But guess what? I'm inviting you to church. This is where you're going to learn how to be a disciple of Jesus, really. Yeah. is in church, because this is where you're going to be after you graduate. This is where you're going to get that. And I think we do college students a disservice when we give them so much fellowship on campus that they graduate and then they're like,

SPEAKER_03oh, that was so awesome and I'll never find that. And church doesn't give me that because we haven't provided them a vision of what church ministry could, how their participation in the church could look like. Yeah, one thing that we almost did at Revive when I was there that I wish we would have

SPEAKER_02done, but we talked about, going to different churches together as Revive. So like the student organization would go visit, like at the time, like we had Mary there who went to a Catholic church and we were like, let's visit her church. Let's go to a Catholic service.

SPEAKER_03We actually did that after you left.

SPEAKER_02See, it was right after they were like, wait for David to leave.

SPEAKER_03We said, David's gone. Let's start doing that. So wait for him to leave and then we'll do it. But yeah, I mean, it was awesome. And we went to an African-American Pentecostal church. We went to an urban, multi-ethnic church. It was pretty cool.

SPEAKER_02That is really cool. That's like one thing that I wish college, specifically college ministry, did more of. Because you're right, when people leave college, they're going to have to find their own thing. And I did have at least one of those experiences of during new staff training. I think it was new staff training at CCO. My friend Jack and Matthew and I went to an African-American Pentecostal church and it was really cool,

SPEAKER_02but it was so Jack. Now I'm forgetting, I think he was from the Philippines. I could be wrong. I think he's from the Philippines. And then Matthew, who's African-American. So I was literally the only white person in the building. And it was a moment of like, whoa, normally I, like, it just is the way it is. Like I'm the majority at church and now I'm like the minority. I'm literally the only white person here. And okay, that's, and like, at first I was like, that's really weird.

SPEAKER_02And then I'm like, this is kind of cool. Like I get to experience what it feels like to be a I do get to feel like what it looks like for people to look at you and being like, oh, who are you? Because we also like we just picked a random church to go to a new staff training on a Sunday. We were like, let's go visit this church. So also like no one there knew us. It was literally a random church in the city of Pittsburgh. Oh, my goodness. And so everyone's looking at us weird, like, who are these three young kids? And like, who's that white guy? But we had great conversations afterwards with the pastor.

The pastor came and met us and asked us, like, where we're from and what we're doing.

SPEAKER_02And we told him and he prayed with us. And it was really cool. But it was wild. I mean, the church experience was like, oh, this is so different than what I'm used to. But it's kind of neat. I get to see how other people interact with their faith. And that's cool. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why the Church Still Matters (Podcast) with Dr. Carmen Joy Imes

    Sep 22, 202656 minAudio

    Are you questioning the value of investing in church life? Are you asking yourself, “Why get up and go to a building with people I barely know? Can’t I just listen to praise songs on my own and find a YouTube sermon...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Missional in Your Everyday Life (podcast) with Jon Hietbrink

    Aug 25, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    God has called each and every one of us to mission, in and through the various vocations we have and the relationships we all have forged. “Mission” is this: We are Sent People. Just as Jesus is the Sent One, now the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Loving Your Christian Nationalist Neighbor - Caleb Campbell (audio podcast)

    Jul 4, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Caleb Campbell joins Bob and David to discuss some of the content in his book, Disarming Leviathan: Loving Your Christian Nationalist Neighbor (InterVarsity Press, 2024). Caleb believes that while it’s possible to be...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tish Harrison Warren: Resilience and Hope in a Season of Exhaustion

    Jun 20, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    We talk with award-winning author Tish Harrison Warren about how to navigate burnout and weariness. Two-thirds of Americans are dissatisfied with their work, and a sense of languishing is widespread. Many of us feel...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Worthwhile Work in a Broken World

    May 7, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    All of us want to make sense of life - of our work, our relationships, and our place in the world. Who are we? Why are we here? What should we do with our lives? And is there a hope I can cling to as I struggle to make...

    Credit the people on this episode