Are you questioning the value of investing in church life? Are you asking yourself, “Why get up and go to a building with people I barely know? Can’t I just listen to praise songs on my own and find a YouTube sermon from a pastor I like?” These are good and legitimate questions. Many people in their 20s and 30s have come to see church as more of a problem than a solution. Does the church still matter? Dr. Carmen Joy Imes Dr. Carmen Joy Imes (PhD, Wheaton) is Associate Professor of Old Testament at Biola University. She is the author of a new book, Becoming God’s Family: Why the Church Still Matters (InterVarsity Press, 2025). Previously, she published Bearing God’s Name: Why Sinai Still Matters and Being God’s Image: Why Creation Still Matters. In our conversation, we discuss: * Russel Moore recently wrote, “We now see young evangelicals walking away from evangelicalism not because they do not believe what the church teaches, but because they believe the church itself does not believe what the church teaches.” We see this as very true, and hear Dr. Imes’s response and recommendations. * The story of Pentecost in Acts 2 is a dramatic and important moment in the initiation of the New Testament church, but Carmen Imes takes us back to the basis of why Pentecost means so much. We learn from the Old Testament the information that explains what really happened at Pentecost. * We can learn principles from the Old Testament stories that informs how we relate to God and people in the church today. * As Americans, we swim in a culture of individualism and consumerism. Instead of independence, Perhaps we need to teach ourselves and our children how to be interdependent. The Bible actually informs how Christians can become interdependent. * The Letter to the Hebrews has a lot to say about the importance of the local fellowship of believers. We discuss how this Hebrew mindset can help us to connect with others in community. Thanks for listening! If you enjoyed this podcast, please share it with your friends! Your hosts are Dr. Bob Robinson and David Loughney. For further resources on reintegrating all of life with God’s mission, go to re-integrate.org. Where to purchase these books: Support independent booksellers! Purchase any of the books mentioned above from Byron and Beth Borger at Hearts & Minds Bookstore. They are eager to serve God’s people with great books. Order online through their secure server or call 717-246-3333. Ask for 20% OFF by mentioning that you heard about these books on the Reintegrate Podcast! Get full access to Bob Robinson’s Substack at bobrobinsonre.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_02If you're like me, you might have entered a time when you questioned the value of investing in church life. Why get up and go to a building with people you barely know? Can't you just listen to praise songs on your own and find a YouTube sermon from a pastor you like?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Those are good and legitimate questions. I've had great conversations with people in their 20s and 30s who have come to see church as more of a problem than a solution.
SPEAKER_02And Bob, I feel like I've been one of those conversations you have had in the past six months. And for that reason, we are glad to have Dr. Carmen Joy Imes back on the podcast. She is Associate Professor of Old Testament at Biola University in her unique specialty of understanding the world of the Old Testament, that is the worship life of the people of Israel. She has written the new book, Dr. Kerman Imes was on a previous episode of the Reintegrate podcast discussing how
SPEAKER_02the concept of the image of God based on her book
SPEAKER_01Being God's Image, how that we have a human identity made to represent God in God's very good creation. Before that book, she wrote the first book in this trilogy, Bearing God's Name. Hi, Carmen. Hey, it's good to be with you, Bob. We're glad that you are able to join us again. Your new book is titled Becoming God's Family. In the foreword of the book, Esau Macaulay called this a trilogy. Is it? How do they all tie together?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, in a way, they're a trilogy in that the three are kind of like three different threads that go through the Bible. I'm tracing three different threads that weave together, so I suppose you could think of it as a braid. Any of the books stand alone. You can read Becoming God's Family without reading the first two, and you should be just fine. But readers who are familiar with my other books will recognize the kind of tendency to trace the theme through the Bible. I'm trying to show how the entire Bible is portraying something.
SPEAKER_00And in this book, the something is how God's presence shows up in the gathered community. So the first book, Bearing God's Name, was about how the church, we are the people who bear God's name. We inherit that, or we are integrated into the covenant with the Jewish people who Who bear God's name, who were brought into covenant with God at Sinai. And we are now integrated into that covenant through faith in Jesus. So we become his representatives. Being God's image is about how every human being is the image of God.
SPEAKER_00And it leans into that question of what is our human identity and vocation. But I realized after the first two books that you could read those two And still walk away, if you've been deeply formed by an individualist Western context, you could walk away and think, oh, I am God's image and I bear God's name. Doesn't that make me special? And you might miss that the whole Bible is calling us into community and that we are meant to be part of a family, that church is not the kind of thing that is either optional or simply a place
SPEAKER_00that we go to get a little shot of inspiration for the week. But it's actually a community that we become part of that should be like a family, that we show up for each other when life is rough and we serve one another. We carry each other's burdens and celebrate with each other. And so that was the heart behind it. I think right around the midpoint of COVID, I realized, ooh, church is not obvious anymore. All of us who were in a routine of going to church have just disconnected from that routine.
SPEAKER_00In a way that maybe we've never experienced before, and we're going to have to make the case again for why we should go back and what we're missing if we don't.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I was talking to Bob before you joined us about how this book really seems directed right at me and many of my generation. I feel like if you look at the numbers of young people stepping away to church, and I mean, I've also seen young people step into church, but But many of us, a lot of people that I know, and again, myself included, have just kind of had it with church.
SPEAKER_00And for good reasons, David. That's one of the things I try to address in the book is that people who've stepped away have sometimes stepped away for really good reasons. They've been hurt. They've been mistreated. They have decided, I can't put up with hypocrisy anymore. I don't want to have anything to do with an institution that is supporting church. Supporting things that aren't godly or that is sweeping things under the rug and not willing to look at it. So I think the whole Me Too movement,
SPEAKER_00Church Too movement really opened people's eyes to how much sin there is in the church. And a lot of people were like, yeah, peace out. I can go find a different way to spend my Sunday morning. So in the book, I'm trying to hold together that tension of Being honest about the failures of the church, but showing why leaving the church is not a good solution, because we miss out on the big things God wants to do in and through us.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I love that. And yeah, like you were saying, I feel like a lot of people, again, myself included, and a lot of people in my generation have asked those questions of why get up on Sunday to go somewhere where I barely know anybody? Why sing as individuals in the sea of people in the rows around me and just never really experienced community? Why should I put up with the political views that are espoused by some people around me and even from the pastors on the platform preaching and saying harmful things behind a pulpit?
SPEAKER_02But I like what Russell Moore wrote, and you quote, we are walking away from evangelicalism, but not because we do not believe what the church teaches, but because we don't believe the church itself does not believe what the church teaches. I think that's a really powerful quote. So what is your opening kind of just appeal or explanation to my generation as to What is church? What defines church?
SPEAKER_02And why does it still matter?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I toyed with kind of different ways of defining it as I worked through the book. And this is me going off the top of my head right now, but somewhere I land on a definition that's something to the effect of. A church is a gathering of people who An intergenerational and multicultural gathering of people, ideally across class lines as well. Just a very diverse group of people who gather to worship God, to participate in His work,
SPEAKER_00to preach the Word, like to hear the Word preached, to think about His Word, and then to wait for God to come and redeem us all. And it's that waiting piece that kind of grabbed me. I had actually written the whole book. And it gave me a sense of connective tissue for the whole book that it was missing. And one of the things that makes the church so countercultural is this posture of waiting.
SPEAKER_00We live in a culture where every brand wants to tell you that they have figured it out and that they can make your life better. And the church is countercultural in that we gather together around a person we cannot control, ideas we don't fully understand, and an agenda that we're not in charge of. We are just waiting for Christ's return, and we don't know when it will be. But we gather together in recognition that we can't fix the world.
SPEAKER_00Only God can. He says he's coming back. And so we're getting together with other people who have oriented their lives towards his return. And that, I think there's something really refreshing about not needing to have or be the answer to everything, but just coming open-handed together to see what God might do.
SPEAKER_01And to come open-handed to say, Based on the fact that we know where it's going, what do we do now?
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_01Right? It's like if God is restoring all things, how do we become part of the restorative process?
SPEAKER_00Yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_01How do we do that?
SPEAKER_00Right. Not how do I do it, but how do we do it? And it's not a process that the waiting is not passive. The waiting is active because God has shown us in the person of Jesus how to serve, how to live, And so we do that to the best of our ability, but also we can't fix it. So we were just talking before we started recording about my dad has dementia and moved in with us, and we are trying to serve him in a season of life that's really difficult,
SPEAKER_00and we can't fix it. We cannot fix the decline, the degeneration that's going on in his brain. All we can do is love him through it, and I'm tucking him in bed every night and holding his hand and we're praying. Thanking God for what he did that day. We're orienting our home around the waiting for Christ's return and bonding over what we can't fix.
SPEAKER_01A lot we can't fix. Yes. We had Steve Garber on just recently, and his new book is all about being Okay with proximate justice. We can't get all the way to perfect restoration, but it's a story after story of people doing their best and being okay with getting closer to the way the world should be.
SPEAKER_00I was delighted to get to spend a little bit of time with him in February at the Jubilee Conference in Pittsburgh. I was speaking and he came to hear me speak on the topic of this book and how becoming God's family is a way of participating toward that restoration, that we're not in charge of it, but we can participate in it in small ways.
SPEAKER_01A lot of this is about we, we, we. That's interesting. I love this book because you're making the case for church From the vantage point of an Old Testament
SPEAKER_00expert.
SPEAKER_01Most of us start our study of the church by going to Acts 2 and Pentecost. Certainly Pentecost is important, but you're like, wait a minute, let's step back. There's a reason for Pentecost. Pentecost has a deeper, deeper meaning. So what should we know about the Old Testament that enlightens us as to what's really happening at Pentecost?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I get annoyed by doctrinal statements that say something to the effect of the church is something that started at Pentecost. I'm like, no, no, no, no. Pentecost is a Jewish festival, and the people of God were gathered in Jerusalem, and God was fulfilling a promise given to the Jewish people by Jesus before his ascension, where he said to gather and wait for the Spirit to come. And that gathering, the word that's often translated as church in the New Testament is ecclesia, And that word appears all throughout the Old Testament to describe that
SPEAKER_00the Old Testament, the Greek translation of the Old Testament, to describe the assembly of God's people at Mount Sinai when they gather together for a festival. So there's a, I think what I want to help people see is there's a continuity between the gathered assembly in the New Testament of Jewish and Gentile believers in Jesus and the gathering of God's people God's covenant people in the Old Testament. There's not like a break in that chain. It's just one long chain. So I would say, I would say the church started at Mount Sinai when God called the people out
SPEAKER_00of slavery and claimed them as his own. And that's part of what I'm talking about in the book Bearing God's Name. But I think what we miss if we just look at the New Testament to think about what does it mean to be the church is we miss a whole lot of great material in the Old Testament that shows us What happens when it goes well? What happens when it does not go well? We have a lot of good and bad examples in the Old Testament and just a lot of stories that help us even understand Pentecost.
SPEAKER_00So typically when I go to speak at a church on this topic, the topic of this book, I start with Pentecost and the fire falls and the people are speaking in tongues and someone asks, what does this mean? Exactly. And to answer that question, we have to go back to the Old Testament and we have to look at what are all the other places where fire fell in the gathered assembly and didn't burn things up or just fell on the altar and burned up what was on the altar. Like, what is this?
SPEAKER_00And what we discover is that this happened over and over again in the Old Testament as a signal that this is the approved place of worshiping Yahweh. His presence is among us. So for the fire to fall on the heads of people at Pentecost was a way of saying, you guys are the new temple. It's among you that I'm going to show up and do my work. So it's been fun because it's just a very simple thing to do, to do a hop, skip and a jump through the Old Testament and look at fire falling.
SPEAKER_00And lots of people, I've talked to lots of people who grew up in the church like I did when, you know, they've heard all the stories, they've done the Bible read-throughs, but they had never connected those dots to see how that shows us what's actually happening at Pentecost. And it's just a beautiful, it's a beautiful thing that emerges when we realize, oh, God is saying, you're the temple. And then Paul picks up that imagery, of course, and says, you are the temple built together as a dwelling place for God's spirit. And therefore, you're all needed. So one illustration I like to use when I speak is I'll bring along Lego and hand out
SPEAKER_00a Lego block to everyone who comes in. And we talk about how each one of us is like one piece of Lego. And one Lego is kind of dumb by itself. I mean, we're the image of God, right? But it's not fulfilling its purpose by itself. You need a whole lot of Lego to make something cool. To sit at home on a Sunday morning by yourself watching YouTube sermons, even, or streaming on Spotify, your favorite worship music, is still one Lego by itself.
SPEAKER_00We have to be connected to each other to become together the dwelling for the Spirit. And so I think if Paul was writing his letters today, he would say, you, like living Lego, are being built together into a dwelling for the Spirit.
SPEAKER_01I think that's in the Greek. I really do.
SPEAKER_00I mean, we could try. I mean, Lego is a Greek word, but it doesn't mean brick. I think it means I stay or I remain. I'll work on it somehow.
SPEAKER_01The Greek and the Hebrew is very interesting. I mean, many people in our audience don't know this. You mentioned briefly that We know the Old Testament was written primarily in Hebrew and a little bit of Aramaic, and then the New Testament's in Greek. But the New Testament writers would have been reading an Old Testament written in Greek.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_01And so they're attaching these things. And so when they write Ekklesia in the New Testament, in their mind, they're going right back to...
SPEAKER_00That's the thing they've been reading about, hearing about. I need to stop and correct myself before you start getting letters from your listeners. Lego does not mean I stay or I remain. It means I say. It's meno that means I remain. My Greek brain's a little slower than my Hebrew brain. Sorry.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, that's allowed. That's allowed. My Greek and Hebrew brain are completely dilapidated.
SPEAKER_00It's been decades since I've studied Greek, so here we are.
SPEAKER_02And that's better than my non-existent Greek and Hebrew brain, so much appreciated for the input.
SPEAKER_01We just had N.T. Wright on in his new book, God's Homecoming. And one of the things that really struck me, and I'm like, of course, right? Mount Sinai, the Ten Commandments is what's really important. He's like, what's really important is that he's setting up the tabernacle, that the tabernacle will be the place where they worship and are with God and God can be with them. And I was like, of course. And then the temple, of course. But then they rebuild the temple, right?
SPEAKER_01And the fire... Doesn't come into that new, the temple that is in Jesus' day, the fire never came like it did in the Old Testament.
SPEAKER_00And so there's this like ongoing hanging question. And I learned this. When is God going to arrive? When is God going to arrive? This is a little awkward. We have a temple, we're doing the things, but we're not actually sure that God is with us in the same way that he used to be. And then he shows up as fire among the gathered believers who are Hearing about Jesus and responding. And that, to me, is just really powerful because that is the thing they would have been waiting for.
SPEAKER_01And so it is all about this gathering. So it's the gathering around in the tabernacle. It's the gathering around the temple. It's the gathering of these people at Pentecost. And so it is people, not persons, single individuals in their faith with God. That's really interesting.
SPEAKER_00And when we've grown up in a Western individualist context and we don't know Greek and Hebrew, we hear the word you and we just default in our minds to singular, like you are a temple of the Holy Spirit. And we think I am a temple of the Holy Spirit when it's really we are a temple of the Holy Spirit.
SPEAKER_01Somebody was reading me a passage from the New Testament, and he kept on saying, y'all, y'all.
SPEAKER_00That's helpful. That's helpful. Except if you're from the South, y'all is actually singular and all y'all is plural. We lived in the South long enough to pick that up. So my husband will often greet people with, hey, how are y'all? And he's just talking to one person.
SPEAKER_01It's defaulted back to the individual. We're just so individualistic in America. We are.
SPEAKER_00We are. Yep.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I think like when you're reading the New Testament, sometimes, yeah, you kind of missed the context of, okay, this was a letter written to a group of people, even though that there's terms of you, but it's referring to a group of people, a church, a gathering. And I also think so on the other end of, you know, from the New Testament letters back to talking about the Old Testament, I think anyone who reads, honestly reads the Old Testament will be very troubled by the stories of the people of Yes.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Yes. So what can we learn from those stories from the Old Testament that should inform how we relate to God and to the gathering, to people in church today?
SPEAKER_00One thing I think we learn from these difficult stories is that telling the truth is important. So sometimes people will be like, oh, we shouldn't talk about the bad things that happen in the church because it's like bad PR and we'll turn people away and whatever. It's like, well, the Bible from the very beginning tells bad stories about the patriarchs and matriarchs of our faith. So I begin the book with the story of Abram and Sarah and how they mistreat Hagar. And really, I think what they do to her qualifies as sexual abuse.
SPEAKER_00She has no choice in the matter. She is explicitly mistreated by Sarah and runs away. And it's fascinating that the Bible is not telling us these stories in a way that pats Abraham on the back for being the man of the house. God is not with Abraham in the tent patting him on the back. He's in the desert with Hagar, reassuring her. And letting her know that she is seen and known and showing her hope for her future.
SPEAKER_00So I think it's important because the Bible tells negative stories even about the so-called heroes of the faith. I think that invites us as a church to be honest about the places where we failed as a church. And we could trust that this isn't about, hey, look at us. We have it all together. It's about look at God. He's the one who's faithful even when we're unfaithful. So that's one lesson. And I just think the more we experience life and the ways that people can hurt us
SPEAKER_00and let us down, and the more that we get let down by church leaders or by Bible heroes, that should turn us back to God and His character and His faithfulness. That's what we celebrate. It's not individual successes.
SPEAKER_02I think that that's so powerful. I think that that is a thing that we miss a lot. Yeah, because we want to read about the winds. And even in the dark times of the Old Testament, those dark stories that were like, that's uncomfortable. Like, okay, David and Bathsheba, like, why is this in scripture? The writer could have just left that out. But I think that it is important to visit those things.
SPEAKER_02And I love what you said of God not being in the tent with Abraham, but rather with Hagar in the desert, I think is just a good picture of who God is. Because I think a lot of people can read the Old Testament and go, see, I don't want to serve that God. I don't want to be in that community. Mm-hmm. Because that community is doing weird things and building golden calves and they're still doing that today. And you could argue, yeah, there are churches that are still doing that in different ways now. But that's not where God is.
SPEAKER_02That's not who the God of the Bible is dwelling in. He is with those people who have been outcasted and who are trying to Run after him and seek him. That is where God is. And so I think it's a good challenge for us as we read some of those passages in the Old Testament and the early gatherings to look at that and, yeah, go, we've all failed. We're going to continue to fail. We have to go back to God because he's the only consistent character in this entire story.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's right. We are so trained to look for heroes in the Bible. That's partly because it's how our Sunday school curriculum is often built. Like, here's some moral examples to follow. And it's really hard to break out of that and realize that this is a bigger story. So even you raised the David and Bathsheba question, why is this story in the Bible? I actually think one big reason it's here, and I don't hear people talk about this, is that we need to know the paternity of Solomon because he becomes king next.
SPEAKER_00And there's some sort of muddy, murky story about his birth, like around his birth. And I actually think part of the point of that being in the Bible is so that we know, okay, this is not the son that was born before they were married. It's the son that was born after they were married. And that's not like a go thou and do likewise. It's just a we're sorting out the family line here and seeing what's legit. And we're so hung up on Like, is David a good model to follow or not?
SPEAKER_00Was Bathsheba seductress or not? I think we're actually barking up the wrong tree. And we think of it as a story about David and Bathsheba when it's really a story about David and Uriah. And Bathsheba is sort of a pawn in this story. But the bulk of the chapter is about dialogue between David and Uriah. And the action slows around their You know, back and forth, not around David and Bathsheba. That only takes four verses. Boom, boom, boom, boom, it's done. That's like the backdrop to the story, not the point of the story.
SPEAKER_00So, yeah, David is actually acting like Saul in that story. He is treating his own top fighting man as a threat instead of the Arameans as the threat, just like Saul was treating David as a threat instead of Goliath or, you know, the Philistines. So we have this sort of cycle of leadership where leaders misidentify their enemy.
SPEAKER_02And I love that that is part of the scripture there. And I think that it also, it makes the Psalms more powerful of reading David's lament and prayers. And it's, in a way you can look at it and go, thank goodness that there are some of those stories in there because I can either relate to them or I can see that God's people are messy and we're broken and we've been broken from the beginning and we have to continually cry out to God and have the whole reason for a savior.
SPEAKER_02God works in spite of it all. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes God will not work if we are brushing things under the rug and covering things up, right? The prophets are coming and like, hey, wait a minute. You are mistreating. You do not understand justice. And it's like, who are they railing against? Not the nonbelievers, not the people outside of Israel, but the actual leaders in Israel.
SPEAKER_00Every generation has a tendency to crucify its prophets. And, you know, Saul wants to hear from the Lord. And, oh, too bad, he's alienated all the prophetic voices, and Samuel has died, so his only option is to go try to get Samuel to come up from the dead. And it's like, the Lord who's not speaking to Saul is not speaking to Saul because Saul's been unfaithful, not because Samuel's dead. So he brings Samuel back from the dead in 1 Samuel 28, and Samuel's like— That's a
SPEAKER_01weird story, Samuel coming back from the dead. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_00It's wild. It's wild. The Bible does not prohibit necromancy because it's ineffective, but because it's not the right method for trying to find out God's will. If you have silenced all the prophets, that's why God's not talking to you.
SPEAKER_01As Americans, we swim in a culture of individualism and consumerism, which is just individuals trying to bring some sort of actualization to themselves by what they purchase. So you wrote about Independence Day. You were writing a chapter during Independence Day and wondered if perhaps we need to teach ourselves and our children how to become interdependent. What from the Bible informs your desire to see Christians become interdependent?
SPEAKER_00So many things. But I was really sitting in this spot when I wrote that part of the book, and my neighbors were right outside this window setting off fireworks. And I was like, this is so weird that we do this. And partly I'm thinking about it now, too, as I watch my dad decline. And he needs more and more care. If we have set up our value system to highly value independence, it's harder and harder. The aging process becomes harder than it needs to be because there's some sort of existential failure, a loss of personhood if someone has to help us.
SPEAKER_00But what if from the beginning we recognized we all need each other? And one place where this really jumped out at me is the Lord's Prayer. I've grown up in church. I've heard and prayed this hundreds of times. Why had I never noticed until I was reading Justo Gonzales' book, Teach Us to Pray, that it's plural, our Father, not my Father, give us this day, our daily bread, not give me what I need today. And if we take seriously the pronouns in the prayer,
SPEAKER_00it reorients us to thinking about each other's needs We spend most of our lives trying to be disentangled, but I think there are healthy ways to be entangled. That when you're in need, I respond as if it's my own need, because that's how important you are to me.
SPEAKER_00That's what I mean by becoming God's family. If we're going to pray our Father, Then that means you and I are siblings. And in the book, one of the biggest surprises in my research and writing this book was discovering that in the first century, the sibling relationship was even more intimate and there was a greater need for loyalty or sense of loyalty to siblings than there was to a spouse. And that is not an insight that should lead us to say, okay, from now on, I'm going to be You know, more attached to my brother than my husband.
SPEAKER_00That's not—I don't think that's what that teaches us. What it does show us is that when Paul is writing his letters and refers to believers as brothers and sisters in the Lord, he's using the strongest language available to him to talk about how we need to belong to each other.
SPEAKER_01Our Father gave us our—I just moved to Colorado. So you moved away from Colorado a while ago, but— I just moved to Colorado. In the church we've been attending for the last couple of months, we do the Lord's Prayer every week. And he makes us hold hands as we do it.
SPEAKER_00Which not everyone probably likes.
SPEAKER_01At first I'm like, yeah. I hope this guy washes his hands. But what a great, this is our father. This is our family. We are, you know, our, you know, if I'm caring about our daily bread, it's not my daily bread. It's like, oh, so therefore I need to be on the lookout of how I can care for the people around me. It's, yeah, I'm still not.
SPEAKER_00But that weekly practice is something that's formational. And kids who grow up seeing that happen and being part of it absorb those values as well. And I think that's a beautiful thing. If we can do it in a way that reminds people, this is us, not me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I think I am just talking about just the importance of community, of just gathering. There's been a time where I stepped out of church, my wife and I, because we were just kind of fed up and we were like, man, just what they're saying. Ugh, yikes. We don't necessarily agree and just having some issues. And then recently, like,
SPEAKER_02I went to a Bible study with a friend because I was always kind of like, all right, I'm going to set this down, this church gathering, but I know that I'm still held by God and I'm still being sought after. Mm-hmm. So some time had passed in between, and then I went to a Bible study with my friend, and I was talking to Bob about it, and it was just kind of like a breath of fresh air when I sat in the room. And there was no other way to describe it, I was telling my wife about it,
SPEAKER_02like, It was almost just like my soul was able to breathe for a moment. Yeah, yeah. And talking about some of these practices of like holding hands and just like the weekly repetition of things, of having people in your life, it was a bizarre feeling that kind of made me emotional when I first went because it was like, oh yeah, I have been missing this.
SPEAKER_00I'm not alone. I'm not alone.
SPEAKER_02And there is like a deep desire built within my body of a human that craves this actually. Mm-hmm. And it's just dependent on whether we're listening to that or not.
SPEAKER_00Your soul is a Lego, and it had that satisfying snap as you joined the Bible study.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Yeah, exactly. And I was thinking about your other metaphors that you use in the book. One was a compass. Second was a sailboat. And then, of course, Legos. And choir.
SPEAKER_00I talked about a choir, too.
SPEAKER_02Yes, yeah, a choir. And so I love that a top theologian is writing about Legos. I just, I love that. But I think, so the letter to the Hebrews has a lot to say about the importance of local fellowship of believers, like we're talking about now. So, yeah, we've talked about the Lego and how that connects to it, but... If somebody's hearing this, how do we relate this back to Hebrews? What do these metaphors relate back to the Hebrews?
SPEAKER_00Are you talking about the book of Hebrews in particular? Or were you talking about the Hebrew people of the Old Testament?
SPEAKER_02Well, I guess we could take it either way.
SPEAKER_00I mean, the book of Hebrews is the place where it says, don't give up the habit of meeting together. Don't give up meeting together. Some are in the habit of doing. And it's a very strong, there's strong language there, warning not to do it. And it doesn't totally spell out why. And that's why I use the example of a compass, because this one was really helpful to me, because as somebody with three degrees in theology, You know, I have a bachelor's and a master's and a PhD in Bible and theology.
SPEAKER_00It's pretty rare for me to learn something new on a Sunday morning. And so if I thought, as many Christians do, that we go to church to learn something about God, well, if that's the goal, I could stay home and watch YouTube and I might be able to learn more than my pastor could tell me on a Sunday morning because there's a lot of other things going on on Sunday.
SPEAKER_01Especially if I'm watching Kerman Iams' YouTube channel. I just want a little plug there.
SPEAKER_00I mean, Torah Tuesday. Torah Tuesday is a pretty great channel. You should all subscribe. If church is about learning something new, then there are more efficient ways of doing it. But I believe that church is not primarily about learning new things, but about bringing those things in conversation with my daily life this week. So the analogy of a compass, a compass points north. But if a compass sits next to a magnet,
SPEAKER_00something that's magnetized, or even next to something metal for a while, it can get sort of pulled off center so that its north gets off just by even a few degrees. And if you're going on a long hike, a few degrees makes a big difference to being able to properly orient yourself. So on most Sundays, We're going to walk away from the service feeling like, okay, I did the thing. I don't really know what I got out of that. Nothing really dramatic happened.
SPEAKER_00There wasn't some life-changing conversation. I didn't see fire fall from heaven. Like, why am I doing this? But what's actually happening is like under the hood, to use a different metaphor, like there's this imperceptible reorientation to what matters most. And here's an example of how this worked out for me just not so long ago. It would have been maybe February of this year that I was teaching my Old Testament class at Biola University,
SPEAKER_00as I do every semester. And I was basically preaching through the early chapters of Exodus and about how Moses, when God calls Moses to go back to Egypt, that Moses' first question is, who am I that I should go to Egypt? And God does not respond by listing his qualifications. He responds by saying, I will be with you. It doesn't matter who Moses is. It matters that God is with him. And I preach this to my students every semester. I drill it down.
SPEAKER_00And I did as usual. That Sunday, my pastor was preaching on Exodus chapter 3. He said almost the same thing that I had said in Glass that week. It was uncanny. I'm like, are you following me around? It was wild. And yet I sat there hearing him say the thing I already know and already had said that week. And it hit me in such a fresh way because I was wrestling with an upcoming trip for which I felt Unprepared and unqualified.
SPEAKER_00And I was wrestling with, why me, Lord? Why am I going to speak to this event? I'm not the right person. Who am I that I should do this? And it's so funny how that escaped my notice when I was the one teaching. But when he said it on that Sunday morning, the Holy Spirit went, hello, Carmen, are you listening? And it clicked in a new way. And so I think that's what often happens in church, that we We're thinking about something different than we were thinking about last time we learned this.
SPEAKER_00And it's that new, fresh combination. It's like the improv of the Holy Spirit. We're hearing the new thing in a context of what's happening this week. And it's fresh and living and active because of that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think that that's a good distinction of, again, tying it back to the individualistic culture we have of like, if I'm going to church, what can I learn? I need to learn something. I need to walk away with something. I'm giving you my attendance, maybe my tithe. So now I'm expecting a product back.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it's so consumerism.
SPEAKER_02And that is the culture we live in. So that is often our mindset of going to church, of walking into a building is, all right, I'm here. Better give me something.
SPEAKER_00And a marriage that's transactional like that doesn't go very well, right? We actually just have to spend a lot of time together in ways that are like not particularly meaningful in order to build a lifetime of memories and connection. And so just showing up, making eye contact with people, shaking hands, holding hands even during the Lord's Prayer. Or singing side by side. Like all of these things knit us together as a community so that when I'm not okay, the people next to me notice and they say, hey, you doing okay?
SPEAKER_00You seem a little down. And we have that sort of moment of connection where I feel seen and heard or vice versa. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And those are some of the best, I don't know, gatherings I've been a part of have been of me not walking in going, all right, what can I consume out of this? But it's instead me going, maybe talking about a topic I already know, but now talking about it with somebody who has a different experience with this topic and getting their perspective and going, oh, man, I never thought about it that way. Oh, wow. Yeah. And then having to learn that and then sharing my perspective with them and being heard, actually being heard and listening to others,
SPEAKER_02it brings a whole other dynamic that, again, I think we crave and that God has instilled in us. So, yeah, I think those are beautiful metaphors that we see as a good connection point for all of us.
SPEAKER_00And if you are a Lego, Then you not being there actually leaves a hole in the wall. You know, if we switch metaphors to use Paul's metaphor about the body of Christ, like we're being built together into Christ's body. So, you know, you might be a mouth or a hand or a knee or whatever. Like the body of Christ is disabled in ways like it's not functioning fully as intended if some of us are withholding our gifts from the rest of the body.
SPEAKER_01A friend of mine in the Bible study always said, yeah, we're a body and I think I'm the sphincter.
SPEAKER_00There we go.
SPEAKER_01You need that too.
SPEAKER_00You do. Was he kind of controlling?
SPEAKER_01So you talked about hearing something new to learn something new and it's very cognitive. You see all the books in the back? I am a very cognitive person. You're a learner. But you know what? I'm trying to force myself into realizing this is a gathering of God's people here to be with God. And this is not meant to just be some kind of mental exercise.
SPEAKER_01I'm supposed to allow myself to Feel the emotion of loving this amazing God who loves me first and allow myself to break down and be moved emotionally in this experience with these people around me.
SPEAKER_00And yet I think God works in our personalities and how we're wired too. And perhaps some reframing can help. Like if you're a learner, And you obviously are. Could you reframe learning not as like the sermon is going to be what teaches me, but like what can I learn about people this week that I didn't know? Like pursuing connection with people by learning about what they're into. You know, they're an expert in something that,
SPEAKER_00you know, some guy's an electrician and he could tell you about, you know, the state of things and how is AI impacting his job, if at all. Or whatever. Like we can learn from one another too. And so I remember I'm a very, I'm a bean counter kind of person. I love knowing how many steps I've had in the day, how many pages I've written, how many pages I've read. Like I count things. And one thing that really clicked when I was in college and I became an RA in the dorm resident assistant is that we kept track.
SPEAKER_00We like, we had a time card where we kept track of the number of hours we spent with the girls in our dorm section. And just like quantifying it, it was so helpful to me. And then when we went into Muslim ministry, we had a whole week long class on how to plant churches among Muslims. And he basically had one thing he told us, which I remember to this day. And it was, if you want to plant a church among Muslims, you have to log lots of hours with Muslims. That's basically what you have to do. So there's not like some 10 step plan.
SPEAKER_00It's just go be with them a lot. So for me as a bean counter, that logging hours with people has actually been really helpful.
SPEAKER_01Your husband probably looked at you and said, uh-oh, she's going to log hours.
SPEAKER_00My husband is more of a bean counter than I am, so he resonates with it. He loves it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm pioneering a new ministry here, and so it's like, wow. I'm just going onto a campus that has not had Christian ministry. And so it's like, I just got a lot of hours. I just got to, my face has got to be there. And I've got to be able to talk to students and say, hey, what are you learning? Like the other day, just asking the student, what do you learn in that ethics class that you're taking? I taught ethics once, but this is really exciting to hear what you have to say.
SPEAKER_00And What's the most interesting class you've had this week? Right.
SPEAKER_01But it is patient endurance here.
SPEAKER_00It's amorphous.
SPEAKER_01Slow work. Slow work. I've got to write a newsletter to my supporters and say, hey, a lot's happening. Not really, but I'm trying. Yeah. I spent 13 and a half hours with students this week. Logging my hours.
SPEAKER_02Wow. I can confidently say I am a product of Bob's patience. And I've told people that before. I'm like, that's how I got to know Bob. I was a student of Bob's. And so a good testimony that it does work, even though it seems a lot of waiting.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But I remember a lot of that, Bob. I remember a lot of like, hey, what are you doing? Like, what are you reading? What are you learning? Just trying to get to know the person. And I think as a testimony, as going out and talking about the gospel, it's the best way to do it.
SPEAKER_01Just get integrated with the culture and just be there. And look at David now. He's all grown up.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that was a long time ago.
SPEAKER_00That's great.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for being with us, Carmen. I really appreciate your time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you for your interest in the book. Thanks for reading it and being willing to talk about it. I'm hoping that it will bless a lot of people and help them as they wrestle with the complicated thing that church is. Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_02I don't know about you, Bob, but that wasn't relevant to me at all. I couldn't really pull anything out of that. I was really struggling. Some of the podcasts are
SPEAKER_01just like... Wish there was a more relevant topic, thank you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Gee, I wish this was applicable to my life. Ugh. Ugh. So funny.
SPEAKER_01So how do you apply this to your life?
SPEAKER_02Ah, yeah. That is the question. It's a million-dollar question. It really is. I just go back to when I went to the Bible study a month or two ago now, where just that feeling I had, it was so bizarre. I don't know. Just sitting in that room being like, oh yeah. And it really was emotional. I was like, this is...
SPEAKER_02And even kind of telling myself and knowing like this may not be perfect and I may not be going here a month from now or two months from now. Like this may be it. It's only a four week study and this may be it. But like just deep in my body, I'm like, but for these next four weeks, I am so happy that every week I do have something to look forward to of gathering with people. And it's not even like I talked to all of them a ton or anything like that, but just having the eye contact, being in the same room as physical people, it just helped.
SPEAKER_02So I think the challenge there now is just... Being more in prayer about it, I feel like lately I've gotten lazy with praying about it because I have felt like, well, God knows what I want here. You got it. And kind of like what we're talking about of liturgy of formational things in my life, I feel like it's something I need to return to.
SPEAKER_02I haven't prayed about it in a while. And so it's something I need to return to and go, hey, help me with this. And here's what I'm hoping. And also, so then two is praying about it. And then two is meeting with people, taking those next actions to go, Okay, what is community going to look like? And I know it's going to look different for me. I know it's not probably going to be a typical church service that I grew up in.
SPEAKER_02And that makes me very uncomfortable, if I'm being honest, because it's like, that's so scary. That's 30 years of that. So I have to undo this now, which is terrifying. But at the same time, I think that Brielle has pushed me in a lot of beautiful ways that I'm grateful because I would have never been pushed. And now I think we can hopefully push each other of going, hey, community is really important. And I know it because I felt it deep down in me.
SPEAKER_02And I know it because I see it. I might take courage. Isn't that somebody's word? Courage? Yeah. And you know what? If I'm being honest, I am real sick that I chose that word for this year.
SPEAKER_02I'm really mad at myself. Why couldn't I have picked relax? Lazy. But I picked the word courage. And this has by far been the most courageous thing I've ever had to walk through in my life so far. So yeah, my word being courage this year has really kicked me in the butt and made me do a lot of things I don't want to do. But I'm also grateful for it because it has forced me.
SPEAKER_02As silly as one word can be for a year, it's always been in the back of my head. I'm like, well, David, this takes courage. Right. And that's what you're trying to push yourself into. You're trying to be courageous. Come on. So it has been a courageous year, and I think stepping into a new idea of community is yet another step of courageous.
SPEAKER_01It is. I mean, as you know, I've been attending a new church in a new state, meeting new people in my neighborhood, meeting new people at the coffee shop. It takes courage broach a relationship to say, hey, my name's Bob. What's your name? And tell me something about you. People say, my name's Bob and my name's David.
SPEAKER_01So what do you do, David? I don't ask that question. My question is, so what brings you life? What gives you life? What? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I love that because it brings, to me, it brings more to the conversation because everyone's asking, oh, what do you do for work? Like, that's the question, the usual follow-up after your name. And it's nice to tie something else to your name and your being besides what you with your hands for work. And instead, like, yeah, what's your name? And like, what makes you smile? And I think a different
SPEAKER_02Past David would not enjoy that question. Past David would be like, this guy, what's he trying to do? But I think that David now is appreciative of that question, because it's kind of a breath of fresh air.
SPEAKER_01This David is 30, and when I knew David first, I think he was like 20.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, 20.
SPEAKER_01And he would constantly say to me, oh, I
SPEAKER_02hate past David.
SPEAKER_01That was like his constant joke. Oh, past David. Oh, you know, he used to do this and that. Oh, I hated that guy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Past David, he didn't study for this exam. So now present David hates him. Why was he not studying? Yeah, past David. Past David still gets me in trouble sometimes. But I've learned not to hate him. I've learned, now that I'm 30, I've learned not to hate him. I've learned to learn from him. Learn from past David's mistakes. But appreciate who he was.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate you, Past David, but I just don't like what your decisions were.
SPEAKER_02Yep. I appreciate you being lazy, but I wish we would have paid a little more attention. I appreciate that you were able to play a video game and relax, but we're going to fail now. So, great.
God has called each and every one of us to mission, in and through the various vocations we have and the relationships we all have forged. “Mission” is this: We are Sent People. Just as Jesus is the Sent One, now the...
Caleb Campbell joins Bob and David to discuss some of the content in his book, Disarming Leviathan: Loving Your Christian Nationalist Neighbor (InterVarsity Press, 2024). Caleb believes that while it’s possible to be...
We talk with award-winning author Tish Harrison Warren about how to navigate burnout and weariness. Two-thirds of Americans are dissatisfied with their work, and a sense of languishing is widespread. Many of us feel...
All of us want to make sense of life - of our work, our relationships, and our place in the world. Who are we? Why are we here? What should we do with our lives? And is there a hope I can cling to as I struggle to make...
Christians are struggling with how to live like Jesus in a violent world. Influencers, politicians, and political pundits are telling us that we need to fight to take America back. When, in the midst of an...