All of us want to make sense of life - of our work, our relationships, and our place in the world. Who are we? Why are we here? What should we do with our lives? And is there a hope I can cling to as I struggle to make a slight difference in the world? Our guest is Steven Garber. He has spent his life as a teacher of many people in many places, including his work as Senior Fellow for Vocation and the Common Good for the M.J. Murdock Charitable Trust, and the Economics of Mutuality Alliance. He was the founding principal for the Washington Institute for Faith, Vocation and Culture. And Steve continues his work as Senior Fellow for the Institute for Marketplace Transformation. Anybody who is a regular listener to this podcast will have heard the name “Steven Garber” mentioned a lot. Not only was he Bob’s doctoral mentor, but he has also influenced many of our previous guests. Steve is the author of some fantastic books, the latest being Hints of Hope: Essays on Making Peace with the Proximate (Paraclete Press, 2026). In our conversation we discuss: * How our work in this broken world can be frustrating and that even the most beautiful things we see and do show signs of that brokenness. * But that we can, and must, work (empowered by God’s Spirit) toward something “proximate” to how God would want things, bringing hints of the hope that is to come. * The Gospel of John begins with ‘The word became flesh.” While this is the center of Christian theology, it is also a statement of pedagogical genius. We discuss how, in the things we do in our various vocations, we see “words become flesh,” in other words, we see that ideas are not just ideas, but that they can result in practical transformation. * Quoting Samwise Gamgee from the Lord of the Rings, we see that good books (and good movies, good music, good poems, good art) tell the truth about the human condition. * We hear the story of the Mars Corporation (M&Ms, Dove, Pringles, Pedigree Wiskers), a family-owned company who wanted to honor God and people with their business. Steve was asked to help them think through what it might look like to have a more complex bottom line than just about making money, creating a sustainable business model that seeks the flourishing of all entities in the business ecosystem (from the procuring of chocolate from African farmers, all the way to the end user eating a Snickers bar). * They created the Mutuality of Economics Alliance, a model for business that puts human and environmental flourishing at the heart of value creation. * Oxford University’s Saïd Business School teamed with the Economics of Mutuality group to publish Putting Purpose into Practice: The Economics of Mutuality, which is now free online. * Steve mentioned the book Completing Capitalism: Heal Business to Heal the World by Bruno Roche (chief economist for Mars, Inc.) and Jay Jakub (Senior Director of External Research at Mars Inc.), a practical book that sees capitalism as more complete when generating financial capital is joined with generating human, social, and natural capital. Scroll down to learn more about Steven Garber. Thanks for listening! If you enjoyed this podcast, please share it with your friends! Your hosts are Dr. Bob Robinson and David Loughney. For further resources on reintegrating all of life with God’s mission, go to re-integrate.org. Steven Garber Steven Garber served as the Professor of Marketplace Theology at Regent College for several years. He also served as adjunct professor of the Doctor of Ministry in Faith, Vocation, and Culture at Covenant Theological Seminary (where he mentored Bob as he researched how to reintegrate the mission of God with the mission of human vocations). Garber is also the author of Visions of Vocation: Common Grace for the Common Good, The Seamless Life: A Tapestry of Love and Learning, Worship and Work, and The Fabric of Faithfulness: Weaving Together Belief and Behavior. Together with his wife Meg, he lives near children and grandchildren in Virginia. Support independent booksellers! Purchase any of the books mentioned above from Byron and Beth Borger at Hearts & Minds Bookstore. They are eager to serve God’s people with great books. Order online through their secure server or call 717-246-3333. Ask for 20% OFF by mentioning that you heard about these books on the Reintegrate Podcast! Get full access to Bob Robinson’s Substack at bobrobinsonre.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hi, welcome to the Reno Grey Podcast. I'm David Lotney.
SPEAKER_01And I'm Bob Robinson. Anybody who is a regular listener to this podcast will have heard the name Steven
SPEAKER_02Garber, mentioned a lot. Not only was Steve Garber Bob's doctoral mentor, but he has also influenced and gained friends with many of our previous guests.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I am honored to count him as a friend. His wisdom has seeped into my bones and it tends to Do that for anyone who is blessed to have time with him.
SPEAKER_02Yes. He led the doctoral cohort you were in. That was about how faith informs vocation to make a difference in culture.
SPEAKER_01That's right. That's right. Faith, vocation, culture. He was the founding principal of the Washington Institute for Faith, Vocation, and Culture. And so that was basically the title of the doctorate, Faith, Vocation, and Culture. We went around the country and talked with business leaders and pastors, people who were committed to seeing Christians' vocations making a difference for God's mission. So we also went to Washington, D.C., where Steve was anchored, and he talked to people there that he's been talking to who are
trying to work for
SPEAKER_01Jesus in various capacities in government and in NGOs, doing good work in systems of systems. That is pretty broken, but has real opportunities to make impact, but are broken. We heard their stories, we watched what they experienced, we listened to what God is calling these men and women to do.
SPEAKER_02And as I think of those people in Washington, I wonder how do they hold on to hope when they can never bring God's perfect flourishing here? Our guest is Stephen Garber. He has spent his life as a teacher of many people in many places, including
SPEAKER_01Steve is the author of some fantastic books, the latest one being Hints of Hope, Essays on Making Peace
SPEAKER_01Hi Steve.
SPEAKER_00Well, there's the almost Colorado boy in my life.
SPEAKER_01The almost Colorado boy looking at the fully Colorado man.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, when you move there, you have to realize, yes, I don't really deserve the native license plate that Steve Garber does, but I've I'm a semi hopeful native or something. I got here as quick as I could. Maybe that'll be your license plate. Any further plans?
SPEAKER_01We're having a crazy time of packing up this house. It's like, boy, is that fun. Not fun.
SPEAKER_00I remember doing that a year ago now.
SPEAKER_01Where did you move?
SPEAKER_00From Washington, D.C. to Charlottesville, Virginia. Oh, so you were in Virginia before, you just moved to a different part of Virginia. Two hours south, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Two hours south. Three years in this house, it's like a lot of fun to... Try to figure out how to pack that up, and you had, what, probably 40 years in your house, right?
SPEAKER_00We had 35, yeah. They're very, very, very similar, yeah. I told Meg, you know, I know, blindfolded, I could make every turn in this house and know just how many steps to go left and how many steps to go right, and I'd be blindfolded or on the dark, and this was my house. I knew this house. Sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I wish I'd have known that. I could have snuck into your house and moved a bookshelf and made you run into it.
SPEAKER_00Something like that you could have had. But I would say, Bob, it's been a surprising providence a year later that we would like living where we are, so it's been a good move. I didn't know that it would be a year ago. I was pretty up and down as the days went by, but then I finally decided we're going to do it, so I didn't look back after that moment.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's always a great pleasure of mine to introduce friends of mine. So, David, this is my friend Steve. Steve, this is my friend David.
SPEAKER_00David, good to meet you here.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, really nice to meet you. I know last time I think it was Brendan that was on the podcast with you guys. So Brendan's a good friend of mine. I was also a student leader working with Bob at the campus.
SPEAKER_00Okay, very good. Yeah. He finds good guys, good helpers, good companions.
SPEAKER_01I've known you, Steve, for about 20 years, but you've been doing good work, helping to reintegrate faith and vocation in all of life for a very long time. You've been doing it professionally for some 40-plus years, I would guess, right?
SPEAKER_00That's a good number, 40-plus years, that's right.
SPEAKER_01You started asking these deep questions of life at a very young age, from your time in Monta Vista, Colorado, to when you dropped out of college and traveled around the world to learn from people all over the world. Can you tell us a bit of that story?
SPEAKER_00So the Monta Vista You know, one is a good one to begin with, Bob, because I was born there, of course, under the wonders and glories of the Sangre de Cristos. So when you move to Colorado, you'll have to go down and ponder these majestic mountains called the Sangre de Cristos, which the Spanish explorers, one night seeing the sunset over the mountains, these 14,000 foot peaks, about 100 miles of them, said, look, in Spanish, Sangre de Cristo. They call these the blood of Christ mountains,
SPEAKER_00which they seem to be tinged with the blood of Christ at sunset. I was born there in a beautifully, I argued with a big smile on my face, it's the most beautifully named town in all of America, Monta Vista, Colorado. So I've always been glad to have been born there instead of some other place. But I would say the most pondering I was doing even in those earliest days was probably my eyes beginning to get used to the world around me and knowing that 20 miles away were these glorious mountains.
SPEAKER_00So I have some cosmic ontological home. Bob Robinson But I, you know, I didn't stay there forever and I moved to California and really grew up in
SPEAKER_00California. And eventually, you know, 20 years later, I dropped out of college, not because I was failing, not so much that, I don't think it was more, I wanted a better reason to be a student than I had, which at that point was simply to pass the next test. You know, to do the reading required and to pass the next test and go on the next test and the next test and finally a last test, then you're done with the semester. And that just seemed to me, in my 20-year-old self, not a very compelling reason to be a college student.
SPEAKER_00And I decided to drop out. Now, in some ways, dropping out maybe was more understandable in that period of time. It was the counterculture, the late counterculture in American society and history. Bob Robinson But I was really the only friend I had who dropped out. I don't think anybody that I really knew very well was thinking about doing that. I decided to do that and lived for a couple of years in what we called then communes, which was a sort of a sociological experiment in the
countercultural days where
SPEAKER_00people who were married, unmarried, living in the same dwelling, working on some common life together. I happened to be in one that was Bob Robinson produced a couple of magazines because I had some journalistic experience. I was, as a 20-year-old, appointed to be the managing editor of these magazines. And one was called Renaissance, A Radically Christian Critique of Culture was the tagline for it. And in some ways that really appealed to me because, you know, revolutionary at heart in some ways.
SPEAKER_00I hitchhiked across America the next summer and made my way to Bob Robinson to Europe the next year delivered another commune. This one was maybe a better known one. It was called Labrie. and people from all over the world hitchhiked their way into the community of Labrie and there were no internets at the time and no brochures, simply the word on the street was if you had an honest question you could give an honest answer at Labrie and that was very intriguing to me, very important to me at the time. I had a question that was burning in my heart and I took that
question there and I began to ask it and think about it and ask it and think about it and ask and think
SPEAKER_00about it some more Bob Robinson I would say, honestly speaking, that that question has still threaded its way through the rest of my life. I've never left that question behind. In the best language of Aslan to the children of Narnia, I've gone further up and further in with that question in all the years since then. But I would say that question is still the driving question of my life. So that's a little bit of that background.
SPEAKER_01All right, we're on pins and needles.
SPEAKER_00Oh my, okay.
SPEAKER_01What's the question? What's the question?
SPEAKER_00Bob Robinson Well, I was living in the Bay Area. So I was hitchhiking every week between Palo Alto and Berkeley, the homes of Stanford University, University of California, and Berkeley. And they were both sort of centers of intellectual robustness, a lot of debate, a lot of everything going on in those years. And, you know, all the lectures and speakers that were coming to speak about the way the world ought to be or how the way the world shouldn't be were coming to those places. And I tried hard to listen in on to many of them. I began to realize that that year,
SPEAKER_00living in that first commune, that every debate I listened to, every idea I heard, argued for, at its heart was always one more window into what we believe to be true about human beings. To put it in sort of philosophical, theological language, what is the nature of man? And I realized that every political argument, every economic analysis, every artistic hope, every sexual, you know, push and shove, was always one more window into what somebody believed to be true about what it
SPEAKER_00means to be human. And I knew enough Christian theology at that point in my life, because I had been raised to think in those terms, but I was wrestling with all that at the time, too, that Christians taught that we made the image of God, That seemed a very short sentence to me as a 20 year old. And I remember thinking, I need to understand what that means. What does it mean to be made in the image of God? And that question took me to Labrie, you know, which I spent time thinking through there. And I would say, honestly,
SPEAKER_00But that's really been the driving question of my life, even, you know, my undergraduate studies eventually, my master's thesis, my PhD work, we're all one more window into and we're working away at that question of who are we as human beings. Even now when I talk about this question of vocation all over the world, I would always say, well, in my mind it's really three questions that have to be looked at together. The first is, who are we? The second is, why are we?
SPEAKER_00And the third is, then what will we do with our lives? So in some ways, I've never really left that question. I've just gone deeper into it over the years of my life. And you realize that when you take those questions seriously, that on one level, every human being takes them seriously in one way or another, whether they think they're being serious or not. Every one of us, every son of Adam, every daughter of Eve, whatever we believe to be true about the universe, Bob Robinson operates out of a sense of, I think this is who I am.
SPEAKER_00I think this is why I am. It could be as starkly, soberly, terrible as, we eat to be married for tomorrow we die. That's all that this is. And it could be any variety of sophisticated, more thoughtful response to that question. But I would say all of us begin there. And so in my mind, there's never ever a boring person out there. It's maybe simply we haven't learned to ask the right questions of other people.
SPEAKER_00Because if we were able to ask more creative, more innovative, more persistent, more honest, more eager questions, we would find that all of us, every one of us, lives out of a certain set of assumptions about who we are as human beings, and why we are as human beings. So that's been very important to me. looking at who you are Bob and Marlong friendship together I think about you know some years ago I was invited to speak at the Beijing Film Academy in China which is
the major film school for all of Asia and even though the topic was good stories and good societies I really fixed myself on that question quoting the American novelist and essayist Walker Percy that bad books lie they lie most of all about
SPEAKER_00the human condition Bob Robinson I took that thesis of Purchase and said, well, it's also true, of course, that bad films lie. They lie most of all about the human condition. So took up several of their most prominent Chinese films at that moment in time, and their best director in China, and looking at, so what did he argue in terms of what it means to be a human being? And that was the substance of the day together we had there. So that has taken me all through the years of my life now, and it finds its way into interesting and surprising moments
along the way.
SPEAKER_02As I'm listening to this, that's one thing I really love about your story and your relationship with Bob that is cultivated even on this podcast. I just think of the word intentional. There's a lot of intentional thinking, praying, We'd be honored if you'd read that introduction to the book for us. Would you be willing to do that?
SPEAKER_00I'm glad to do that, really. Let me just make sure that you can see that. But here is the seashell on the cover of the book. And I wanted to work with a publisher that would allow me to have something to say about the cover art. And that had not been true before in my experience, but I, the publisher was gracefully, and they're serious people, they don't want to do stupid things at all, at all, really, but we talked and talked and they said,
SPEAKER_00okay, you know, I found this a Russian painter and after some month or two of negotiations, he said, OK, I'm willing to use you to use my painting for the cover of your book. But if you look carefully, it's not only just a beautifully imagined watercolor of a wonderful shell here, but you'd have to look more carefully to see that, in fact, right here at the very beginning, the very most visible part of the seashell, there's a broken piece.
SPEAKER_00I wanted to find a seashell that was beautiful, but broken. So here is the beginning to the book. I've quoted Václav Havel as a little way into the introduction, the Czechoslovakian poet and playwright and eventually president. Quote, anyone who claims I'm a dreamer who expects to transform hell into heaven is wrong. End quote.
SPEAKER_00So then I wrote, broken hallelujahs, even walking along the beach in the first hour of the morning, I think about the image of a broken hallelujah. As my wife Meg said so plainly, so perceptively, you think about that all the time. And I suppose I do. Step by step I see the shells of the seashore washed by the waves, each one wonderfully imagined, intricately formed, and yet and yet not all that it could be and should be. So very beautiful, but broken too, like everything everywhere.
SPEAKER_00Though in my heart of parts I long for a different life, wanting with all that I am a different world, what I see is always marked by both joy and sorrow, never neat and clean, but instead somehow both at the same time. The work of my life is to find an honest way to live with both together. In other sense, more globally born, all of us work at that, because in some sense, we all have to, the world being what it is. And over the years, I have wondered and wondered again, reading and reading more, living in and through the days of life, feeling the tension of what is and what is not in my very bones.
What is clear to me is that there are some ways of seeing that resolve the tension
SPEAKER_00by denying that there is a tension. That's neither sufficient nor sustainable. Differences are real and they make a difference. All day long we are confronted with both. We have to somehow make sense of the world and our place in it, being honest about both what is glory and what is ruin. But why broken hallelujahs? The words are from the poetic imagination of the singer-songwriter Leonard Cohen, and his words run through my very being. With an artful, haunting eloquence, the song wrestles with the tension of life,
SPEAKER_00the beautiful and the broken together, open-hearted wonder and melancholic despair, a broken hallelujah. Truth be told, I have been walking the beaches of the world for a long time, looking for a perfect shell, sauntering through the surf, hoping that sometime and someday there will finally be. But what I find instead are hundreds and thousands of shells that seem just about perfect, but are not. So many, of course, are terribly broken, now only fragments of what they once were. In the very different ways they make me sigh.
SPEAKER_00But the ones that trouble me are those that appear to be more than that, that seem to be perfect, until I stop and look more closely. The colors are always uniquely created. The shapes are always uniquely crafted. And from six feet away, they're amazingly beautiful. But when I bend over, the cracks are obvious. The almost perfect outline is not quite. The holes stand out. I find that each one is uniquely marred. I first thought of this walking along the Assateague National Seashore in Virginia many years ago, there to take part in that wedding of dear friends.
SPEAKER_00They'd ask me to give the homily, to muse over the meaning of marriage as they made their promises to honor and love, till death do us part. So I did my best to celebrate the day, glorying with them in the happiness of the hour, standing as they were amidst family, friends and flowers, with hope in their hearts. But given where we were, I also reflected on the shells I knew, each one so very special, but each one a reminder that nothing is perfect, wonderful as they were, wounded they were too.
SPEAKER_00Like every marriage I know, like every family I know, like every life I know, from the most personal to the most public, nothing we know is perfect in every way, and only the naive imagine otherwise. Slowly, slowly, we all realize that we have to make peace with the proximate, and simply said, that's the challenge of my life. Approximate justice in the public square. Approximate happiness in a marriage. Approximate pleasure in the work of our days. Every day I cry out against that conclusion, yearning for something more,
SPEAKER_00my inward being groaning with creation itself, and eventually sighing over the weight of the world, knowing that everything is less than it could be and should be. As Bob Dylan said so poetically and profoundly, remembered, everything is broken. Broken dishes, broken parts, broken streets are filled with broken hearts. Yes, everything is broken. As true as it is for individual lives, it's also true for the public square. As it is true for the work and workplaces of our lives. As it is true for the friendships and marriages of our lives.
SPEAKER_00All day long I live with disappointment and grief and pain. Everyone else I know well enough to know. And while I live my life wanting more and expecting more, to remember another poet, Bono, I never find what I'm looking for. And why is that? Because I am a glorious ruin myself. In my heart and mind, I'm never more and never less than that. Both truths threading their way with the fabric of my life. And with strange grace, what is true for me is true for the world. Even the shells have a story to tell if we have eyes to see.
SPEAKER_00So there it is.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thank you for reading that. I love that. You know, one thing that hit me when you were reading that is the quote, but the ones that trouble me are those that seem to be perfect until I stop and look more closely. You know, you say when I bend over, the cracks are obvious. We can't ever expect to find perfection, like you mentioned, not in our work, our marriages, our churches, our society, like you said. But that doesn't mean it can't still be beautiful in the trying
to make things
SPEAKER_02closer to that, or the word that you used, more proximate to that. You hit on it a little bit, but I'd like for you to just talk about what does it mean to quote To quote the subtitle of your book, To Make Peace with the Proximate. What does that look like? Well, proximate, you know, is an unusual word, but it's not an odd word at all.
SPEAKER_00It's maybe more unusual than it might be or could be. But like a lot of the words we use in the contemporary, in the Western world, it has a Latin root, proximi or proximatus, which means to be close to or to be nearby. And I first thought about it more seriously many years ago when I was teaching politics on Capitol Hill for a long, long time in my life and wrestling with public policy questions and questions about
tax reform and immigration and education and U.S.-Israel relations and U.S.-Africa
SPEAKER_00relations and all the questions we took up year after year after year. Realizing that, you know, that it was a pipe theme to think that somehow you could get the smartest people in the room, you know, have all the resources you need, needed, and get it done, you know, it would finally get done, you know, you'd finally get this resolved. Everyone on the Hill would be saying, well, that's great. It finally got done, didn't it?
SPEAKER_02You know, there'd always be so much pushing and shoving that maybe a lot of things never got
SPEAKER_00done, because the pushing and shoving became so intense and so conflicted. About 15 years ago, I was asked by the editor of a magazine called Comment, and he said, you've been watching Washington, D.C. a long time, Stephen Garber. Is there a vocation in the political world? And I thought about it for a summer, and I finally offered an essay that I called Making Peace with Proximate Justice. And what I was arguing in the essay was that if you're going to stay in a messy city like Washington, D.C.
SPEAKER_00is, which is messier as the days go by, of course, a city of glory and ruin together. Lord Bismarck, who was the German Chancellor in the mid-1800s, put it, if you want to respect either sausage or law, don't watch either being made. That's a harsh word to say. I think when I first heard him say that, or first read those words, I thought, that's very cynical. I think what I came to realize over the years was that there was a hard-boiled realism about that,
SPEAKER_00that you had to work through Because if you imagined otherwise, you wouldn't stay very long. And for me, as Bob would know, that long interests of my life have been, how do you stick with things? How do you stay at things? How do you keep at it over time? And so for me, the question of having a vocation in the political world was more, how would you stick with this when it's so messy, when it's so hard? And someone just asked of you to give up on things you wanted with all of your heart.
SPEAKER_00And so it seemed to me that if you're going to stick with the hard, difficult, you know, sausage-making of political responsibility, you'd have to be willing to make peace with doing something that was more honest, something more true, something more beautiful, maybe even more good, something more just. But you'd never get everything. In this now-but-not-yet world we live in, which is our theological underpinning, we don't believe in any other world than that world. So if we confess that to be true in our worship, we need to somehow live that out in our work,
SPEAKER_00too. So what does it mean to live that out in the work of political responsibility, other than to somehow say again this day, well, could I give myself today, this week, this year, this next season of my life, to try to do something more honest and true and beautiful and good, something more just, and knowing ahead of time, when all is said and done, not everything that I longed for will actually be seen in this life.
SPEAKER_01week, I'm leading two of my student groups, one at Kent State Stark University's Stark campus, which is in Kenton, Ohio, and one on the main campus in Kent. We're working through the first 14 verses of the Gospel of John. I have it printed on the sheet, and we read it, and we reread it, and they make notes, and they observe what's there, and then they ask their interpretive questions, and we ask those hard questions, and we Bob Robinson And so those opening verses are just amazing. In the beginning was the Word,
and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.
SPEAKER_01He was with God in the beginning. Through Him all things were made. Without Him nothing was made that has been made. In Him was life, and life of the light that And that life was the light of mankind. The light shines in the darkness and the darkness has not overcome it. And then we skip down to verse 14 and we go,
it's interesting, what's this word?
SPEAKER_01How could it be a he? How could there be a personal pronoun for word? It's like, what is going on? And then verse 14, the word became flesh and made his dwelling among us. We have seen his glory, the glory of the one and only Son. Bob Robinson who came from the Father full of grace and truth. In the book, you wrote, and I quote, the Word became flesh, are first of all the very center of the Christian theology that they summarize the meaning of the incarnation,
SPEAKER_01but they are also a statement, I should say, they are also a statement of pedagogical genius. So in terms of how we best learn the deepest things, How do words become flesh, and why is that so important? How do we best learn, as you say, over the shoulder and through the heart?
SPEAKER_00Well, that's such a good question, Bob. So if I've taken this image of the seashell, and I made a confessional homily to this young couple on the shores of Assateague some years ago, I saw them at the Jubilee Conference a few weeks ago, Bob. They were there. They're still married and still working at it. And I'm so glad to see that. It's true of their lives. But I would say that, you know, word become flesh,
as I said, you know, in that. My own PhD is in the philosophy of pedagogy, which is an unusual thing to think about.
SPEAKER_00But I have long been interested in how we learn what we learn. Bob Robinson how we learn in ways that actually shape who we are those have been the deepest questions of my life and so I began to think years ago about that chapter one of the gospel of John the word became flesh and realized that every chapter that follows in the gospel of John every conversation recorded in those chapters is one more window into the reality that the word has become flesh and lives for a while among us so it's this
SPEAKER_00Story of Jesus at the wedding in Cana. It's the story of Jesus and Nicodemus. It's the story of Jesus at the well. It's the story of Jesus and Jesus and Jesus and Jesus and Lazarus and Mary and Martha and all the way to the very end. Every chapter is one more window into what it means that the Word becomes flesh and lives for a while among us. And realizing that we don't learn anything that matters very much to us without seeing that in fact it can be worked out.
We just don't think about anything that you actually believe very much about and
SPEAKER_00you really sort of take into like, this is Bob Robinson, this is who I am. Well, I would say nothing, nothing, Bob, given what I know about you is have you come to cheaply you've it's been hard hard worked it's been hard what hard rot you know you've had to think about it work at it and the things you believe are things you've seen be lived out seem to be worked out in life perfectly no honestly yeah with reality yes you know because we don't actually take anything in that way into the deepest part
SPEAKER_00of who we are that we just read it in a book Bob Robinson as much as you have books in your life behind you right there, much as my house here is full of books. I love books. My wife thinks maybe a little bit too much even though she's a librarian, you know, and she's gracious with me and she says, okay, okay, okay, you know. But we have books everywhere in this house, you know. I love books. But I don't think that the deepest things we learn only come by reading a book. They shape and they influence and they affect and I get that and I love that about good books.
SPEAKER_00But to be changed, be transformed, we have to see that the words could become flesh, that the ideas could have legs. So for me, that's why it's pedagogically genius for God to say, revealing himself through the Apostle John, that this is who Jesus is, the Word became flesh. And then to have it be in the next 20 chapters, one more time, after one more time, after one more time, you want to see what this means, what this looks like? It looks like this. When Jesus took up the conversation with Nicodemus, it looks like this.
SPEAKER_00When he enters into Bethany, and Mary and Martha's grief, and Lazarus's death, it looks like this. And one after one after one, it's always one more window into, and the Word becomes flesh, and lives for a while among us. When it's all said and done, we think, I have a better idea what it means, what the incarnation, theologically speaking, looks like in life. I see what you're saying. I understand that now.
SPEAKER_01That's what I do. I teach, right? I mentor college students. And so it's very cheap to do this Bible study and then say, okay, we're done. I've got to figure out ways to, okay, let's figure out how this word that we're learning becomes flesh. What are we going to do? Best learning experiences is like, okay, let's get up and go do something, something that makes this real. So
SPEAKER_01You know, we were talking today, I just had this group, it's like, what does it look like to be glorious human beings made in this image of this Jesus, this God who is the image of God? What does it look like to be the light of the world? What is a real way that you are light? He brings light into the world and he's asking you to be the light. What are some real, tangible ways you can do that? And then Let's talk about that next week as we come back and figure out
how did that go. And let's work together on this and maybe even hang out and do it together and see
SPEAKER_01what it looks like as we hang out and do things together. That's what life was like at Labrie, right? You were together and you saw people trying to live it out, not just teaching in a classroom. But it's like we're actually going to be living this out together.
SPEAKER_00I think it was a transforming pentagogy, Bob. That's what I think drew the people there, the 20-year-olds from all over the world, you know, by the hundreds and the thousands over the years, that it wasn't just ideas. People who imagined Labrie from a distance thought, well, it's a place for intellectuals. They go talk about big ideas, don't they? You know, it's for people who are like that, you know. And I would say, well, you missed the point, really, because the point was to have breakfast together and lunch together and dinner together and be working the gardens together for half of the day,
SPEAKER_00you know, or popping wood for half of the day or, you know, and having a discussion at dinner, every meal was a time for conversation about what you were studying about. So I would say that there, I wrote, had a wonderful, wonderful invitation a few years ago to write the foreword or the, what was it called? It was the new introduction to Schaeffer's book, The God Who Was There. It was a 50th anniversary celebration of the first publishing of the book and the publisher said, would you write the introduction, Steve? I thought, oh my, you know, I could try to do that.
SPEAKER_00But I did, but I mostly talked about Bob Robinson- What it was about the communal, the community life, the communal life, which was its own apologetic, to use a good word here, its own argument for the reality of Christian faith. Bob Robinson- Not so, the ideas being debated or read about, yes, yes, that's a part of everything, never not a part of it. But I would say that the deeper Bob Robinson was a living apologetic of that these are these are beliefs we have we're going to live them out together together in a community
context over days and weeks and come and be part of it come come and see what this looks like in life I agree with you Bob about that that was really the heart of you know much of what the book is about too because I wanted I've told a lot of stories of people in the
SPEAKER_00book Bob Robinson and people who I would say in their different kinds of ways whether Africans or Asians or Europeans or Latin Americans or North Americans whether the people who in some ways have wrestled with this business of the proximate because I want people to see this is not just a Latin word you know just a political essay or fiction on politics in Washington DC but in fact diverse people in diverse places in very different kinds of ways have wrestled with this Bob Robinson I love the thought exercise of making it practical. I think a lot of young people, I remember my time in college,
I came from a background of the church and the people I was around was very
SPEAKER_02reactive and very like, well, heaven's over there. So we're just kind of waiting. And there's not much for us to do now. And unfortunately, that was a lot of my experience until I met Bob and got connected with the CCO of like, wow, there's people taking action. There's people that are doing good things that are bringing light, being light in the world. So I think that's so helpful for young people because I think a lot of young people read scripture and think okay well that's all good but that's very like
SPEAKER_02Bob Robinson So to actually have something come out of it Bob, I remember when you had our college group do Lectio Divina of reading scripture over and over again and focusing on words that stood out to us and That was the first time I had ever done that and I was like wow this is really powerful because I've never done it like this.
SPEAKER_02Usually I read it and I close it and I'm like okay thank you. But to actually meditate on what it meant and then to go out and see how can I actually apply this in a real way. I was transforming and you know speaking of my time in college when I first started college I was a theater major eventually became communications major but I started out in theater I love being involved in telling stories I did
theater throughout high school and when I was little you like to quote Walker Percy it says bad books
SPEAKER_02lie they lie about most about the human condition But I guess the corollary to that is good books and plays, movies, poetry, music, whatever it might be, tell the truth about the human condition.
SPEAKER_00Right. And you can see in that why the book is threaded through with my reflections on movies I've seen or books I've read, because I do think that they're worthy for more reflection. So again, because I wrote the Bob Robinson I wanted the movies to be from all over the world so there's a chapter it finishes with a Polish film there's a chapter that begins with a Chinese film you know and I've done that from beginning to end in the book
because I wanted people to understand that in fact that this is not just an American argument or American idea it's not just to people in the West I wanted people to actually to
SPEAKER_00Bob Robinson- And I do think that bad films, bad, you know, movies, bad political ideas, bad economic ideas in all of these various realms of life that if the corollary is, well, you know, A good film tells the truth about the human condition. A good political vision tells the truth about the human condition.
SPEAKER_00And again, realizing, going back to my own 20-year-old rambling through my own being as a 20-year-old and this dropped-out communal life I was having in the Bay Area, realizing every debate I listened into, every argument I heard being presented in those years, those years, was one more argument for what it means to be a human being. And so whether we can tell the truth about it, but that's fascinating and intriguing and compelling to finally, I would say, are we gonna resist that and repress that and suppress that or
twist that?
SPEAKER_00So the films I've written about in all their variety are, I would say, they're wrestling with what does it mean to be a true human being?
SPEAKER_02And I know some of the examples you used, and I know you love The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings trilogy. I do as well. I was just talking about this with Bob before we started recording about how I watched Lord of the Rings when I was little. I was almost in that target audience when the movies came out. And I remember watching those movies in theater with my dad and sitting in the theater thinking, It was one of the first times I'd watch a story that really hit home with me because the good and evil in the storyline and also just the
story captivated me.
SPEAKER_02It swept me off my feet, took me to someplace new, helped me learn about the characters and cultures even in a fantasy world and the dynamics of their relationships. I remember being little and just being struck by that. So, I mean, they're amazing fantasies, but even as good fantasies tell the truth about the human condition.
SPEAKER_00That's the point.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and as you know, these Hobbits are very human. I know that I have always identified with the Hobbits. Me too. Yeah, they're very identifiable characters. We recently had a guest on the podcast who is a Christian film scholar who lives in New Zealand, and he When I was talking to him about, oh, New Zealand, this is where they filmed a lot of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, he said, yeah, I drive past Hobbiton every day when I come to work.
So that was very cool, very unique, and I tried my best to contain my excitement for that.
SPEAKER_02One place I want to go visit. Bob wanted me to read this quote from J.R.R. Tolkien's The Two Towers that starts your chapter 8 The Words of Samwise Gamgee to Frodo Baggins and they have been through way too much at this point in the story that they honestly should give up hope but Sam says this quote that Bob had asked me to read so It's like in the great stories Mr.
SPEAKER_02Frodo the ones that really mattered Full of darkness and danger they were. And sometimes, you didn't want to know the end. Because how could the end be happy? How could the world go back to the way it was when so much bad had happened? But in the end, it's only a passing thing, this shadow. Even darkness must pass. A new day will come. And when the sun shines, it will shine out to clear. Those were the stories that stayed with you,
SPEAKER_02that meant something, even if you were too small to understand why. But I think, Mr. Frodo, I do understand. I know now. Folk in those stories had lots of chances of turning back, only they didn't. They kept going because they were holding on to something. That there is some good in this world, and it's worth fighting for. Very, very powerful quote from Tolkien there.
SPEAKER_02And even as I was reading that to prepare for this podcast, I was thinking that's how life can feel sometimes. We We go one more day. Sometimes it's an easier day. Sometimes it's a very difficult day. But we are holding on to the hope that there is some good in this world and it's worth fighting for. I know sometimes can feel so heavy. And again, young people can look at it if they're in college now and
think,
SPEAKER_02Where's the hope? What can I hold on to to bring good into this world? But that's all we need is we're just needing a glimmer of hope.
SPEAKER_00You and I are living in the same world, David, of course. Yes. I agree with you completely about that. You know, we have not talked about this, and I'll just throw it out for maybe we could pursue this a bit, but if there are The title is The Hints of Hope. It's about making peace with the proximate, which is all true. You know, I think it's very true. But there's a threading, an under threading to the book from beginning to end, where I've worked hard to wrestle with the relation of the words metanarrative to
SPEAKER_00narrative. Now, I would say plainly to anybody, those are not words we have to all use to be good people, but they're not bad words either. They're words that people think about, talk about, whether they realize it or not. You know, meta-narrative is what? Well, it's what we think everything in the world is about. You know, and I don't know whether a phrase like this can be recorded on your podcast or not, but, you know, some people in the world simply say, shit happens. That's it. You know, it just, that's what it is.
SPEAKER_00Nothing more, nothing less. Get over it. Stop being a romantic, you know. It isn't anything other than that, so just get over it, okay? Why not then eat, drink from here for tomorrow, we die. Come on, grow up. And, uh, So you see that even that sort of succinct, crude, you know, in-your-face statement of meta-narrative, all of life is this, well, you see, everybody, consciously or not, thoughtfully or not, you know, reflectively or not,
SPEAKER_00everybody answers that question, what we think everything is about. Then the question, of course, if that's what we see on the one hand, would be, Bob Robinson- All of life is this. Well, for me, the looming question then is what are you going to do today with that then? How is this going to affect how you live today? So narrative, metanarrative is that business of holding together what we think everything means with what I think today means. Bob Robinson reads its way through the booklet from beginning to end.
And when I listen to what you say about the conversation with Samwise and company,
SPEAKER_00it's really about that, isn't it, David? I mean, what he's saying is, well, okay, today is this. I don't know what I can even go on because it's so hard. And of course, when you read The Lord of the Rings seriously, I find that in reading them, which I just keep doing and keep doing in my life, I can only read a few pages at a time because it's so rich. You just can't take in a lot, you know, just so much to think about every few pages. But you realize that some of those days are just horrible,
SPEAKER_00awful, horrible, awful days, actually. And it just seems like everything is finally lost, you know. I love, you know, how the very last pages of the whole trilogy, when there are Stand on the very edge of the water looking into the Western world and getting on board the ship. These words are given, but not all tears are evil.
SPEAKER_00Those are really good words to hear in your life, you know, because there's a lot to groan over in this world, a lot to cry about in this world, a lot of things that just don't turn out very well, some things turn out disastrously in this world. But to have, in some ways, the idea that That there are things worth crying about Because that's what we live in A broken, broken, broken, broken world Everything is broken, as Dylan said so plaintively Everything is broken So if we don't have some response to that, you know Other than just to drink our sorrows into the,
SPEAKER_00you know Bob Robinson Bob Robinson- Yeah, I was thinking when I was looking at this question the last
The last part of Lord of the Rings when they're walking up the mountain and Frodo
SPEAKER_02can't go any longer. And Samwise says, I may not be able to carry the ring for you, but I can sure carry you. And he picks him up on his back and carries him. Bob Robinson- Yeah.
You asked me about Walker Percy a while back and he asked me to just say this out
SPEAKER_00loud because people might wonder, well, why hints of hope? Where's that come from? But one of the chapters written a little bit about this, where that language comes from and it's Walker Percy, not surprisingly, but he had suffered terribly. And I won't go into all the grief of his life, other than to say, if you've ever thought about grief, And maybe you have, well all of us have in some ways, but he grieved and grieved and grieved and grieved some more in the first decades
of his life for the worst possible reasons that human beings have to grieve over.
SPEAKER_00That was his life. But at age 45, he had this desire to write something and finally submitted an idea to a publisher that published it after, you know, surprise of surprises. And the novel, the movie gore won the book, the National Book Award for Fiction, which was a great, great surprise to everybody. Who was Walker Percy anyway? We don't know this guy. But when the New York literary critics finally discovered Walker Percy, the winner of the National Book of Her Fiction, the moviegoer,
SPEAKER_00what they thought that they wrote, we have discovered we have an American Albert Camus. So I won't go into the great detail, but Camus was a very notable Nobel Prize winning French novelist philosopher in the 20th century, and who took a certain literary philosophical pride in looking bleakness right in the eye. That was Camus' work. Hero books like The Plague, you know, The Plague. And so here's Walker Percy being discovered as the American Camus.
SPEAKER_00They say, well, then tell us about who you are. You know, why is it you write so much like Camus? You look bleakness right in the eye, Walker Percy. And he said, well, You know, I think you get me, but you don't get me. He says, I have a lot of reasons to take sorrow seriously. You know, when I write, my book is about somebody who wrestles, you know, with melancholy and despair. And I've done that. That's what the novel is all about, actually, the movie goer. But he says, you miss me to think that's all that I've written. Because he said,
there is always going to be a hint of hope in my writing, too.
SPEAKER_00When I first read those words years ago, they just jumped off the page at me, thinking, well, I get that, you know, I get that, you know. Can you be honest about the sorrow? Can you be honest about the pain? Can you be honest about the wound and the brokenness? We all need to be honest about that. But we also need to be honest in Percy's own best, you know, response to the New York literary critics. But there's got to be some honest hope, too, for me. Some hint of hope is the way he put it.
SPEAKER_00And so that's why I chose The Hint of Hope as the title for the book. And the book is full of story after story of people who are working their lives
SPEAKER_01Bob Robinson looking for hints of hope in their specific place and time. The world seems like it's so hard. You know, we're in yet another war. And David's generation, the college generation, they're anxious. It's like, why? Why are we always, always in war? So there's, you know, just layers and layers of terrible things. And even You know, people are in slavery and,
SPEAKER_01you know, it's amazing that, you know, in this day and age, 2026, that so many people are enslaved. And not too long ago, I don't know, a couple decades ago, Linda and I, we discovered that coco is just awful the way it is farmed and the coco farmers are exploited. And we're just like, we can't buy chocolate.
SPEAKER_01We can't buy Hershey's bars anymore. It's like the chocolate is coming from these sources that are just exploiting people and hurting people. And so we're trying to find fair trade chocolates to eat. And we even did a family thing where we had our whole family write Bob Robinson- Letters to the executives of the chocolate companies, you know, dear Mars Corporation, dear Hershey's, dear Nestle, we think that you should do something about the way you resource your chocolate.
SPEAKER_01And so that was really heavy on me. And then, and then you started talking about your work with the Mars Corporation.
SPEAKER_00Ah, I thought you were going to get there probably.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, what? And as you're talking about it, it's like, and I'm explaining it to Linda, and she's like, what? And Mars knows. We need a lot of chocolate. We're Mars. We make M&Ms and Snickers, and we've got a lot of chocolate going out.
SPEAKER_00Dove ice cream bars and all those things.
SPEAKER_01That's right. And so how are we going to, you know, How are we going to source chocolate in a way that's sustainable and it's good and isn't exploitative? And how can we do that tomorrow? We can't do that tomorrow. We can't do that even next year. So how did you get connected with Mars? And how did Mars, everybody should know, Mars is a privately owned company, family owned,
not They don't have to answer to Wall Street so they can decide what they want to do
SPEAKER_01with their money. And so they decided to do something about this. How did that all come about?
SPEAKER_00Well, there's nothing that I'm ever involved with, Bob. It is finally and fully heaven come to earth. I don't think that way. I don't believe that way. And I wouldn't talk about this project in that way. But I would say that it's a certain signpost to me of something good, something better than it might be. Bob Robinson I like the image of a signpost quite a bit, actually, because it isn't saying that everything has happened, this is finally it, you finally got there, but it's just saying a signpost. It's pointing in the direction of, in our language, of the way business could be done and should be done.
SPEAKER_00So 20 years ago, I was drawn into a breakfast with two executives in the Mars Corporation, their headquarters in Washington, D.C. And they had a question for one of the three owners of the Mars Company, one of the Mars family members, who'd asked the question, what's the right level of profit for us as a company? Which, if you just think about it for a moment, you think, why would you even ask a question like that? Isn't that obvious? Wouldn't you make all the money you possibly could make? Come on. Isn't this business? Isn't that what business is about? To maximize profit? Especially if you're under the rules of Freudman capitalism,
SPEAKER_00it's to maximize shareholder profit. That's the whole point of business. It has no other purpose than to maximize shareholder profit. But I spent probably three hours that morning talking to these executives saying, but why? But why? But why are you asking that question? But why are you asking that question? And I could talk about this for three or four hours with you right now, but maybe in two or three minutes, I would simply say that over the next months, we decided to name our conversation that morning, The Economics of Mutuality.
SPEAKER_00And the argument was that if A company like Mars, which is privately held, family owned, it doesn't have any interest at all in being positioned in the marketplace to be bought by somebody else next year. That's not the issue, not the question. The question is always, how do you sustain profitability? How do you keep making money? Think about it for a moment. That's what its driver is. How do you keep making money over time? I said to those executives that morning, literally at that breakfast we first had,
if this is only going to be a conversation with the executives here in Washington,
SPEAKER_00D.C., I'm not interested. This has to have consequence for those who grow cocoa in West Africa, both in Sierra Leone's and the quality of ours of the world. If what we're talking about here in economics of mutuality doesn't have meaning for those who grow cocoa, I'm not really interested in what we're talking about here. Bob Robinson again much more can be said but after we named the project economics of mutuality to argue essentially that to sustain profitability requires an acknowledgement of a more complex bottom line that involves not only you know if
SPEAKER_00you made the made money Bob Robinson maybe made a lot of money because Morris does make a lot of money but actually have you treated people well too honestly and honestly about in the way you do business with them you know have you even taken care of the earth itself as the way you do business because there's more bottom lines to be accounted for than simply the bottom line of making more money there's another bottom line about creation care There's a bottom line about social relationships and working relationship with other people.
So eventually I introduced these executives from that morning breakfast to a man
SPEAKER_00named Peter Berger, who was at that point clearly the leading sociologist in the world. He was at Boston University at the time and he spent his whole career looking at the question of the relationship between democracy and capitalism. And so we had a question about Côte d'Ivoire and Sierra Leone and the cocoa producing countries and wondered would you create a research project for us taking a research team for us to go to live in those countries for as long as you need to be there to help us understand the relationship between healthy
social ecology and
SPEAKER_00financial prosperity Bob Robinson- So we spent two years there doing on the ground research for us, you know, looking at what mattered, what was important, you know, and...
SPEAKER_01What was important to the people there in Sierra Leone, how they see life, how they...
SPEAKER_00Bob Robinson That was exactly the point, Bob. That's precisely what he was pursuing for us. So he did extensive evaluations, extensive analysis of the research they did. And I would say, really on the basis of that, we decided eventually to come public with our thinking and then name it publicly, The Economics of Mutuality. And And I would say that it's, you know, it's a surprising effort.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I've said this all over the world the last few years, but, you know, to put it very simply, the project itself is a surprisingly serious effort to rethink the business of business. And I was in Memphis, Tennessee last week with this project I was in Seoul, South Korea last fall with this project There are a few days of my life that I'm not having some finger into the pie of this question of how to rethink the business of business
Bob Robinson it's never ever in my mind motivated by and we are going to create heaven on earth here that's not not the eschatological vision in my mind it is how could we create something that's an honest window into the way business could be done and should be done realizing a hint of hope a hint of hope exactly Bob that's
SPEAKER_00it that's precisely the point yeah So it's headquartered now in Geneva, Switzerland. And if anyone wanted to pursue it more fully, you could just, it's a remarkably robust website called the Economics of Mutuality Alliance. And there's a thousand, you know, resources there that are available to see what's being done, who's working on this, and how it's being worked out all over the face of the earth right now. There's a link on there for the, an online version of the Oxford book about it.
Oxford University Press published a book and you could just click in one chapter at a time and the whole thing is free online to understand what does it look like and what's fascinating to me is this this is now Oxford University right and other universities around the world are like let's teach our students what this might
SPEAKER_01look like instead of instead of Bob Robinson- The bottom line is this. Let's make the most money for our stakeholders. Bob Robinson- There's maybe other bottom lines. Bob Robinson- What are we going to think about that? Bob Robinson- What's fascinating is now there are students all around the world who are thinking about the economics of mutuality. Bob Robinson- Another part of that fascination to me is the sociological studies
SPEAKER_01that were done in West Africa. The presumption of most Westerners would be, we know what they need. Let's go in there and give them what they need. And Mars was smart enough. You were smart enough. Peter Berger was smart enough. No, we need to understand what they need. What is their actual life and how they define flourishing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's exactly the point, Bob. Because you're you, I'll say something even to add a little bit of frosting to the cake here. But when I pressed into that first morning, but why are you asking this question? But why this question? And why this question? Finally, the man who then was the chief economist for Mars, he said, well, when I was a graduate student many years ago in Paris, I came across the biblical idea of Jubilee. And he said, I've been fascinated by the idea ever since then, and now I'm trying to think with you guys, you at the table here, what would it look like to take this idea of the Jubilee of God
in a multiple
SPEAKER_00complex bottom line of remunerating not only capital, but remunerating land and people too. What would it look like to work this out in the 21st century political economies that we now know all over the world. Bob Robinson I took those two guys from breakfast several years later to Kentucky to visit Wendell Berry on his farm one day, and he said to us at the very end of the day words which have really shaped my thinking ever since then. They were so profoundly wise and true.
SPEAKER_00But he said this, you know, if you want to make money for a year, you ask certain questions, don't you? But you want to make money for a hundred years, you have to ask other questions. And I would say this project is simply but truly, it's a more 100-year-long project.
SPEAKER_01It's good to make money. It's good to be profitable. But what are we going to do with that profit? And how do we sustain the profitability so that everybody within the ecosystem of our business is benefiting? That's just so wonderful. And of course, they haven't arrived yet. Bob Robinson I don't know where Mars will be in 10 years, 20 years,
SPEAKER_0050 years,
SPEAKER_01but hopefully they'll be closer and closer to Bob Robinson- There's a huge amount of global pushback because of the world and the
SPEAKER_00flesh and the devil, which are not just ideological abstractions, they are realities. Because everywhere we go, there's always the pushback. Somebody saying, oh, come on now. Business is business. Get over it. That isn't real business. Real business is, if I don't screw you, you're going to screw me, so I'll screw you first. And since you guys are Eastern Ohio, you know about the steel industry and what eventually happened with the, you know, go for the jugular economics, you know, be at play over the course of generations.
SPEAKER_00The whole thing got lost eventually, you know, because, you know, It's a short game, it isn't a long game. You can make money for a little while, as Wendell Berry says, but you want to make money for a long time, you have to be willing to actually, I'll use our language, to embrace a more honest economic vision, which is an economics of mutuality, where everybody, the table is a bigger table, and you actually are figuring out some ways to honor everyone at the table, not just those who are the self-proclaimed owners of the game. Bob Robinson you have to be able to enter those who make the
cocoa those who grow the cocoa and actually the trees themselves this has never ever been green wash it's never been green wash ever really because the real economic is if you don't actually steward the trees they won't be there in 25 years so there has to be a
SPEAKER_00more complex bottom line if you want to make money for 100 years
SPEAKER_01I just find that story to be fascinating as, you know, I work a lot with business leaders and I bring this story up a lot because they need to understand, you know, when I talk about this, you know, they're like, oh, come on, Bob. Like you said, it's like, you know, my job is to make money. And it's like, well, what if? What if there's more? What if the goal of the reason God has placed you in This position of leadership is to be a conduit of flourishing
for more than just
SPEAKER_01your business, but every part of the ecosystem of your business.
SPEAKER_00That's a good word, ecosystem, yeah.
SPEAKER_01What if that's the case? And it's like, whoa.
SPEAKER_00And again, you're situated between Pittsburgh and Detroit. So even if you just take those two cities and think about the contrast between what I'm talking about here and what we know to be the sort of the sad histories of both those industrial giant cities in America. You know, the sad, sad story of Detroit was people on the streets in Detroit knew you didn't want to buy a Monday or a Friday car off the assembly lines in Detroit. Why? People didn't like their work at all. They hated their jobs. They got good union salaries, you know, over time, you know, for the work they did,
SPEAKER_00you know, putting the bolt in this tire or whatever it would be. But they didn't, they, the working system was so Bob Robinson so despised it that they didn't make a good crime on Monday because that was after the weekend. On Friday, no longer because the weekend was coming up. So the wisdom on the streets of Detroit was make sure you get a Wednesday serial number. Well, you can do that for a while. In the Wendell Berry's language, if you want to make money for a year, you can ask certain questions. But for a hundred years, you have to ask other questions.
So, you know, what Detroit eventually found was that, you know, that system didn't work.
SPEAKER_00It fell in on itself. And eventually, you know, the big three automakers flew in their private jets to Washington, D.C. to say before, you know, the Congress, we're bankrupt, you know. The big three, you know, were bankrupt. And our model has not worked. You know, what model was working? Well, they do it differently in Japan, didn't they? And we're going to buy Japanese cars after all, then Korean cars after all, because in some ways it was Bob Robinson is a different way to understand how this is supposed to work. I wouldn't say it's romantic or heaven come to earth at all.
SPEAKER_00I was just saying that the way that steel being made in, you know, your neighborhood there and going up to, you know, Detroit as it was on the rail cars and the semis, you know, that industrial belt, you know, that you would live in right there in Eastern Ohio, it's its own poignant window into Thanks for your time, Steve. I appreciate it. These are great stories. The book again, Hints of Hope
SPEAKER_01Essays on Making Peace with the Proximate.
SPEAKER_00You're very welcome. It's a good use of my time to be with you two, David and Bob. Thank you for your friendship and for your interest in what this book is about. Thank you.
Are you questioning the value of investing in church life? Are you asking yourself, “Why get up and go to a building with people I barely know? Can’t I just listen to praise songs on my own and find a YouTube sermon...
God has called each and every one of us to mission, in and through the various vocations we have and the relationships we all have forged. “Mission” is this: We are Sent People. Just as Jesus is the Sent One, now the...
Caleb Campbell joins Bob and David to discuss some of the content in his book, Disarming Leviathan: Loving Your Christian Nationalist Neighbor (InterVarsity Press, 2024). Caleb believes that while it’s possible to be...
We talk with award-winning author Tish Harrison Warren about how to navigate burnout and weariness. Two-thirds of Americans are dissatisfied with their work, and a sense of languishing is widespread. Many of us feel...
Christians are struggling with how to live like Jesus in a violent world. Influencers, politicians, and political pundits are telling us that we need to fight to take America back. When, in the midst of an...