We often see setbacks and disasters as events that keep us from our best life. But what if these are actually opportunities to grow in our leadership? Our guest on this episode is Dr. Gayle D. Beebe, who has been a leader for over two decades and has insights into how to overcome the disorienting challenges that we face, both personally and in our leadership. In his new book, The Crucibles That Shape Us: Navigating the Defining Challenges of Leadership, the university president shares personal stories and the wisdom of many other authors and mentors on how we can tackle suffering, revealing that, although we can be confused at first, these situations ultimately can bring us into a deeper relationship with God and also make us better leaders. Beebe identifies seven crucibles - powerful catalysts for transformation - that, when embraced, shape us into what God wants us to be. Scroll down to learn about Gayle Beebe. Subscribe to the podcast on your favorite app! Thanks for listening! Please share this podcast with your friends. Your hosts are Dr. Bob Robinson and David Loughney. Go to re-integrate.org for further resources on reintegrating all of life with God’s mission. Dr. Gayle D. Beebe Gayle D. Beebe has been serving as president of Westmont College in Santa Barbara, California since 2007. Before that, he was president of Spring Arbor University in Michigan. He has also served as dean of the graduate school of theology at Azusa Pacific University. He has three master's degrees: the Master of Divinity from Princeton Theological Seminary, the Master of Philosophy of Religion and Theology from Claremont Graduate University, and the Master of Business Administration in Strategic Management from the Drucker School at Claremont Graduate University. He also has a PhD in Religion and Theology from Claremont Graduate University. Get full access to Bob Robinson’s Substack at bobrobinsonre.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
We often see setbacks and disasters as events that keep us from our best life.
SPEAKER_02But what if they're actually opportunities to grow in our leadership?
SPEAKER_01Our guest on this episode is Dr. Gail D. Beebe, who has been a leader for over two decades and has insights in how to overcome the disorienting challenges that we face, both personally and in our leadership.
SPEAKER_02In his new book, The Crucibles That Shape Us, navigating the defining challenges of leadership, he shares personal stories and the wisdom of many other authors and mentors on how we can tackle suffering, revealing that although we can be confused at first, these situations ultimately can bring us into a deeper relationship with God, and they can also just make us better leaders.
SPEAKER_01Yale D. Beebe has been serving as president of Westmont College in Santa Barbara, California, since 2007. Before that, he was the president of Spring Arbor University in Michigan. He has also served as dean of the Graduate School of Theology at Azusa Pacific University. He has three master's degrees, the Master of Divinity from Princeton Theological Seminary, the Master of Philosophy of Religion and Theology from Claremont Graduate University, and Master of Business Administration in Strategic Management from
the Drucker School
SPEAKER_01at Claremont Graduate University. That were not enough. He also has a PhD in religion and theology from Claremont Graduate University. That's a lot of degrees, Bob.
SPEAKER_02So really yet another guest that is honestly way smarter than us, but we are truly honored to have Dr. Beebe on the podcast.
SPEAKER_01Can you tell us a little about your journey? You've been blessed in a lot of ways, having been asked to lead universities and seeing the fruit of that work, but you've also had hardships as well. So tragedies that have shaped you and could have shook your faith.
SPEAKER_00So can you tell us some of that journey? Well, thank you for the question. Thank you for the opportunity. I love getting to be with you and to talk about the book. And basically, some aspects of it are very much a spiritual pilgrimage, including how do you confront the realities that come to every person and how do you keep them from disorienting you to God and, in fact, helping strengthen your walk with God. I was born and raised in an evangelical Quaker home in Eugene, Oregon.
My parents were both raised in the Friends tradition, and it would be a sister school. They went to George Fox, which is a sister school, Malone University in Canton.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. All four of the children, my three siblings, myself attended there. And then my senior year, I came down to Westmont where I'm now president and did a consortium exchange. And I like to tell people that for the first 22 years of my life, everything pretty much happened in sequence. There was nobody that died out of sequence. There were no cousins who were killed in accidents, no divorces, no cancer victims, anything. And then between age 22 and age 30, everything happened.
And within that eight short years, it was just very much a really disruptive time. And I look back on some of that as what was the groundwork that was laid in me
SPEAKER_00during the first 22 years of my life that actually became pivotal. And One of the events that was very pivotal, in fact, he's a Malone alum, that he became my favorite pastor. He came out to Oregon, pastored Reedwood French Church. His name is Don Green. Yeah. And Don was killed in a tragic accident on Mount Hood during my first year of seminary at Princeton. He was just a week away from visiting me at Princeton. I went to Princeton because Don had gone there for his own
preparation to be a pastor.
SPEAKER_00And through the grace and providence of God, I was directed to a gentleman named Dr. Diogenes Allen, who had become my thesis advisor and really a very significant person in my life. And Dr. Allen had just finished writing a book called Traces of God in a Frequently Hostile World. And it's a really mundane title for an absolutely brilliant faith-shaping book. And it basically helps you come to terms with the problem of evil and suffering
SPEAKER_00while continuing to believe in God. And what I began to work through in terms of Don's sudden death was the fact that I had never really worked through what I believed about a loving God and the reality of evil and suffering. And so it ended up being kind of a five-year odyssey, and it included finishing seminary, starting my own pastoral ministry in a suburban Portland church, and really continuing to think, pray,
SPEAKER_00process, what did I believe about the problem of evil and suffering? And I eventually became very satisfied with the fact that suffering comes to every one of us. And part of the total response to suffering is, how do we end up redeeming or allowing God to redeem the suffering that we encounter? And this happened, Don died in 82, and that was my first semester at Princeton.
SPEAKER_001989, my dad died quite suddenly of a heart attack. He was only age 60. And he was absolutely my favorite person. It had the most pivotal shaping influence on me. But what was interesting to me is as emotionally devastating as it was, it wasn't spiritually devastating or intellectually challenging because I had resolved those issues. And I actually go into some detail in Chapter 6, The Crucible of Human Suffering, about this. But that was really the path that I got on that helped me
understand how you take some of the most challenging parts of your life and how God uses them to actually
SPEAKER_00refine your character, not just so that you can respond in the moment when you're working through it, but also as preparation for future challenges that are sure to come to you. And so in that seven-year period that my dad died in 89, I was pastoring. And so seven years after Don's death, those seven years included kind of my son and both my grandparents had died. Aunts and uncles had divorced. Cousins had died from cancer.
And so it was just an eight-year tumultuous period that predated me going back to do my dual degree PhD in philosophy of religion and MBA in strategic management.
SPEAKER_00And that was preparation to go into higher ed, which has been my life for the last 30 plus years. Meanwhile, I have had multiple opportunities to actually help other people come through the challenges of evil and suffering, in part because I married my wife of 36 years is a grief recovery counselor. And she helps people walk through some of the most challenging experiences of their life. And she just has the wiring for it. She also has the godly disposition and really the,
SPEAKER_00I would just say, a special grace to be present, emotionally present with people who have really suffered. And I have found that to just be an enormous help and blessing as well. It's interesting because I mentor college students and there's this freshman girl
SPEAKER_01I've been talking to. And in our last discussion, she was like, what I want to talk about is this. I don't know if my faith will hold up if I... experience suffering. She actually said that. So this is where we're going in our discussions with you, because that's, I mean, how astute for an 18-year-old girl to understand that.
SPEAKER_00That was my question. That really was. I mean, you just articulated what really, the path that I went down after Dawn's tragic death was How do I continue to believe in God? How do I make sense of my faith? And this is where Dr. Allen was so pivotal for me. He introduced me to both the theologians who thought through this early on. Irenaeus was really thinking through this, more recent contributors. And then he taught me about the nature of faith.
SPEAKER_00And I would end up reading Pascal's Poncees. The Poncees are my, after the Bible, my favorite book of Christian thought. And Pascal is so helpful in talking through what is the nature of faith and what are things we have to resolve and then what are things that we need to look at differently or resolve differently. And seeing the problem of evil and suffering, even by the way I frame that, it suggests that I view evil and suffering as a problem.
SPEAKER_00Whereas my wife would say, evil and suffering is the way God brings us closer to himself. And that what you see as a barrier, God sees as a passageway. And I have come to discover that, that evil and suffering, the way we depict it, it often is the catalyst for people. It's not the barrier. And that was just something that I had not been able to imagine until I'd gone through it myself and gone through a process of recovery that
indeed deepened my
SPEAKER_00own faith.
SPEAKER_02The title of your book is The Crucibles That Shape Us. And that's a great word, crucible. And it's one that we may not often hear. So I'm curious, why did you choose that word? And what does it mean to you?
SPEAKER_00Any of us who have done... a manual labor may have been around either crucibles themselves or you're in a steel area or at least the eastern ohio used to be part of the steel belt or the rust belt as some people would call it but the if you've been in like one of my college jobs or helping me with summer employment to put my way through college i worked in an international paper mill And they powered the entire mill with wood debris products that
they would burn in
SPEAKER_00furnaces that would boil water, and it was a steam-powered plant. This was 1980. And so you would see these fiery furnaces that reminded you of some of the still, the pictures of these steel mills. And then I was traveling in the Czech Republic, and I actually... came to a glassblowing factory that had a crucible. And to see the way in which the crucible was used to shape the glass and the fact
SPEAKER_00that it was on, you know, it was just heated to a malleable temperature, that it just seemed like the perfect illustration or example of these experiences of, are the most intense experiences we have. And God uses them to actually shape our character. And that's why I wanted to use that image of the crucible is that it's there. It is what God uses to actually shape us.
SPEAKER_00And it's not that we're malformed. It just becomes a part of our formation. But the crucible is critical, both in terms of how the heat is radiated, but also how the character is shaped.
SPEAKER_02It's a beautiful picture of refinement. And yeah, it's one that we often don't think about, but it encapsulates that idea really well. And you identify specifically seven crucibles that shape us. We want to help our audience get a taste of the book, so we want to explore a few of these. First one being that we might not think of, again, very often, but the crucible of missed meaning. You offer two quotes from authors that encapsulates this problem.
SPEAKER_02And T.S. Eliot wrote, we had the experience, but we missed the meaning. And Daniel, I think it's Kahneman.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Daniel Kahneman.
SPEAKER_02Kahneman. So Daniel Kahneman said he offers his cautionary acronym, W-Y-S-I-A-T-I. What you see is all there is. So how can we keep from what you call cognitive tunneling when we miss the bigger picture? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, gosh, thank you. I mean, those are both great examples from literature. I love the T.S. Eliot quote because it's taken from his poem, The Four Quartets. And I think it actually depicts the experience for so many of us, including students. And I first started using the quote in reference to our international programs when students would do a semester abroad outside the country. where they would have the experience, but totally miss the meaning. And when I was reading the four quartets and thinking about
Elliot's line there,
SPEAKER_00I was thinking about our students that just have these experiences, but literally have no way to put them together. And so part of life is learning how to look. And what Kahneman is doing with his acronym is it's a part of his book, Thinking Fast and Slow, which is a layman's version of the papers he wrote that led to him winning the Nobel Prize in economics for essentially inventing behavioral economics. He's a social psychologist. He and his co-collaborator, the late Amos Tversky, invented it.
SPEAKER_00But what Daniel was trying to say with what you see is all there is, and he's been a guest to Westmont a couple of times, is we have a tendency to believe that we can look at any situation and intuitively understand what's going on. It's where we project that what we see is all there is. And he said that's almost never the case. He said it would be better if we would actually get dropped into a situation and go, what is going on here that I don't know how to see? How am I going to learn to look? And so the first crucible of mismeaning is coming to terms with
the fact that you actually often misunderstand the circumstances and even the situation in which you
SPEAKER_00find yourself. And part of... growing is going through the crucible of actually learning what is the reality of the situation or circumstance in which I'm in. The second one, the crucible of enduring challenge, if I could go to that, is it's meant to be a complement to missed meaning because enduring challenge suggests that so often our understanding is an act of perseverance. And so we miss the meaning because we think we can have
instantaneous knowledge. We capture the meaning when we recognize that over time, we actually do develop wisdom. And I start every morning with my own devotions and I love reading and it's kind of restorative.
SPEAKER_00My life during the day is consumed with meetings and And so reading every morning is critical to me. When I was being discipled after I'd confessed faith, the elder in our church that discipled me, he read the proverb that corresponded to the day. So this morning I read Proverbs 12 and then five Psalms. He would also then read in the New Testament at night. But my point in saying that is when you have a pattern that of reading wisdom literature,
what it does is there is no instant answer.
SPEAKER_00The answers come over time. The answers come through refinement, and they come by learning how to look, how to create a disposition that really brings about knowledge. fascinating because it seems like today's knowledge is people intuiting everything.
SPEAKER_01They don't think through things. They automatically think, I know, I know, I know. And they're missing everything.
SPEAKER_00Oh, exactly. Well, if you get a chance, Thinking Fast and Slow is just one of the best books I've ever read. It is just so, so interesting what he's actually going after. And so he says, like, Thinking Fast is, Bob, the way you describe it. You just intuitively know. Thinking Slow... is where you have to slow down and say, I've got to engage my higher order thinking. And he said, for example, you can merge with traffic by thinking fast.
SPEAKER_00You just do it intuitively. When you turn left across oncoming traffic, you think slow because you know you're in danger. And this takes a deliberate act to put yourself in harm's way and to exercise judgment. He also says, when you're turning left against traffic, you can't do math. When you're merging with traffic, working intuitively, you can do math. And he gives all of these wild examples of how illustrations of when we think fast, when we think slow, to help us recognize there are so many times when we
functionally know we have to
SPEAKER_00think slow and we think slow, we just don't value it enough. And so he's trying to actually get us to value when deliberative thinking has to kick in.
SPEAKER_01It's thinking slow, not thinking fast, but also seeing peripherally, not seeing just what's in front of you. You need to see everything around you. And that takes a lot of skill, a lot of work to be able to learn how to do, I would think.
SPEAKER_00No, that's actually a good analogy because it is your field of vision. And David, you compared it to my comment on cognitive tunneling. I took the illustration from cognitive tunneling from Charles Duhigg's book, Smarter, Faster, Better. And he tells the story about this Air France jet where the pilots crashed the plane because of cognitive tunneling. The instruments weren't working. They were flying at night. And when they thought they were flying up, they were actually flying down and crashed.
SPEAKER_00And it was a flight from Brazil back to Paris. And it crashed somewhere in the Atlantic. I can't remember where. I remember hearing about the accident, but not knowing it until Charles came out with his book. But his point was cognitive tunneling is where you get so over-focused and on a narrow band of information that you lose the peripherals which actually give you the complete story and and bob what you're suggesting is
exactly what charles was trying to get us to recognize is you have to widen your lens in order to actually capture the meaning the person that he actually he uses another plain
SPEAKER_00analogy a Qantas pilot who has every system go out. And so he resorts to visualizing what it was like to fly his Piper Cub, the first plane he ever learned how to fly on. And that's how he landed like this, you know, 747 or McDonnell Douglas 1011. Yeah. And then the last one that he suggests, which I also found just fascinating, is a neonatal nurse.
And as the illustration of how you have, when you combat cognitive tunneling, how it works.
SPEAKER_00And the neonatal nurse had this capacity to look at a baby, recognize that they were going into distress before the monitor started to indicate it. Just... because she had been a neonatal nurse so long and could anticipate where things were headed. Well, another of the crucibles is what you call awakened moral conscience.
SPEAKER_01You quote Mark Twain. I love this. The two most important days of your life are the day you were born and the day you figure out why. Oh, Here at Reintegrate, we often talk about calling, that God has shaped us, each of us, in particular ways to do work that matters. The moment of awakened moral conscience should spark us to see our work as more than a paycheck, but as a means to participate with God and what His kingdom is doing and
SPEAKER_01infiltrating the fallen world. So on page 72, you shared your statement of purpose for life. He says, here is mine, to maximize the God-given gifts and abilities of those under my care and influence for the greater good and the kingdom of God. How does this direct your daily work?
SPEAKER_00Well, gosh, a beautiful question. I'm in my 25th year as a college president, and so as I was becoming a president, a former psychology professor who then worked in senior management at Microsoft and was trained as an organizational psychologist, offered to be my executive coach for free. And I just had to pay his expenses to get to me, but he would put me into his system and he was doing full-time executive coaching at this time. That was just so beneficial.
SPEAKER_00And so during one of our sessions, he said, if you were to write, he goes, I don't want you to think about this. I want you to just tell me. If you were to write your mission statement, what would you say is your mission statement? And literally, that's what came out. To maximize the God-given gifts and abilities of those under my care and influence for the greater good in the kingdom of God. Boom. And I realized that is what I'm about. And what was interesting is subsequent to that, a few years later, doing a variety of intake instruments, including the strength finders,
SPEAKER_00number one strength, maximizer. I mean, this, and I didn't even, I didn't consciously know the term back the few years previously, what I was actually articulating on the spot, what I believe my existence is about. Yeah. But one of the ways God has gifted me is I really love helping people understand their gifts and find the right expression of them. And it's partly how much I've appreciated people who did that for me,
SPEAKER_00who said, boy, have you ever thought of this? Why don't you try that? Gosh, I think you'd be good at this. And where people have taken an active interest in me, it really helped. It guided me. And so I, in turn, am trying to do that for the next generations of students that are truly under my care and influence, but especially for the faculty and staff and other administrators at Westmont, where I do have a very active responsibility in being sure that they are growing and developing, but more than anything,
SPEAKER_00that together we're serving God's purposes. And so that's where it originated and kind of where I began to recognize that this is what I'm wired to do and that I find my greatest joy in doing it.
SPEAKER_01This crucible is so important to have this moral awakening. My life and work has to matter, right? Why do you get up in the morning? I talk to so many people, and they don't know why they get up in the morning. They don't know why their work matters. They don't know what they're supposed to be doing to impact the world. And they look at the pastors and the missionaries,
SPEAKER_01and they're like, oh, well, maybe I should do that or something. And so can you help them start to figure out how to get this awakening of moral conscience?
SPEAKER_00Well, Bob, that's a wonderful question and a really difficult one. And one that I don't have a complete answer to, because I think you live with the question your whole life. But I certainly have some guidelines and directions. One of the things I situate that conversation in the example is Martin Luther King Jr. And one of the things I love about his life is the way in which he, no matter what else was going on, he anchored his life to Christ and tried to find God's meaning for his life through the life of the church and
by association through the life of the civil rights movement that he anchored to the church.
SPEAKER_00You know, parenthetically, I just always think it's a mistake to not understand the role that the black church played in the civil rights movement, and especially in the life of MLK. And so when you look at MLK, what was MLK about? In part, MLK was like I want all of the people that have been sidelined and disadvantaged to have the same opportunity to come to an awareness of why God has them here, how God has wired them, and what it would mean for them to discover their gifts and be
able to exercise them.
SPEAKER_00And when he talks about, I want them to be known by the content of their character, not the color of their skin. In part, he's talking about every person having the opportunity to discover their God-given gifts and abilities and to maximize them for the greater good in the kingdom of God. And so that's where I felt... that my own philosophy of life and my own philosophy of leadership really matched up as I was discovering more about King. Now, growing up in a friend's tradition,
King was a favorite because of his nonviolent civil disobedience and his commitment
SPEAKER_00to pacifism. But beyond that, it was his willingness to look at the marginalized populations and not... not capitulate on the gospel, but say a better embodiment of the gospel is bringing them into the fullness of their life in God and really making a difference. And so when I think about your listening audience, I would say begin to experiment. Begin to, if you feel drawn to something,
SPEAKER_00my wife didn't know that she would be a great grief recovery counselor. What she ended up, she married me and two years into our marriage, my dad died. And I was grief stricken. And she was in her final year of her master's program in grief, not particularly oriented to any expression, but thinking she would probably do something in terms of clinical psychology. Well, see, she suddenly got supercharged around the idea of grief recovery, discovered she had a really powerful gift for it. And she had a powerful gift to be present with people who are
having the worst
SPEAKER_00experiences of their life. She didn't know it when she started down that path. But I think if you start down a path, you become experimental and then you pay attention. And I talk about developing an internal conversation that leads to self-correction. I think you have to have spiritual disciplines so that you can grow. And I don't do spiritual disciplines just because I want to be sure I'm checking the box. I do spiritual disciplines because it's the difference between me being effective and not being effective.
And if you are actually engaged in spiritual disciplines every day or virtually every day,
SPEAKER_00Think through yesterday. Think through today. What did you find? What was really off-putting to you? What did you feel drawn to? Where did you feel depleted? Where did you feel energized? And then begin to just keep a basic log of that. Some... Some spiritual directors will talk about journaling. I totally believe in journaling. But look for the patterns. Look for how those things really show up in your life. And part of your awakened moral conscience will be just an awakened awareness about
how God has wired you and where you find the greatest joy and the greatest meaning
SPEAKER_00extending or expressing your life energy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I really love that. And I do think it is so critical and important for everyone to have some sort of life mission statement. I think often we think of mission statements of just on a website for a business or whatever we're looking at. And it's like, no, you can have a personal like this. This is what I'm about. This is who I want to be. This is what I want people to recognize in me. And I actually did that in college. I had some of these thoughts and I pulled it up on my notes app
on my phone because it's,
SPEAKER_02it stayed with me for a really long time. And I'll just read my life mission statement, what I wrote back in college. And this actually came from a dark time too, of, I was getting ready to graduate and well, I say a dark time, but I feel like a lot of students go through this of just the, the not knowing and this, this blank space of graduation and adult life. And the middle is weird. And that's when I came out with this just life statement for myself.
SPEAKER_02So I said, for me, true joy can be grasped by striving to be the best possible version of myself, while at the same time acknowledging who Christ is and who I am in him. And then I quoted Psalm 139, 14, which says, and I'm reading the ESV version here. It says, I praise you for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Wonderful are your works and my soul knows it very well. And I think that last part is so important. My soul knows it very well, the work that God's doing in our lives.
SPEAKER_02So I would encourage anybody listening to this, if you're going through grief or if you're going through a difficult time, now is honestly a better time than ever to make a life mission statement to kind of stand your ground on who you are and what you want to become.
SPEAKER_00Well, I totally agree, David. That's beautiful. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And another crucible that shapes us is when we suffer. And, you know, you've talked a little bit about your story earlier. But, you know, when a loved one dies tragically, a natural disaster hits, we're the victims of another evil's deeds. All this can happen in our life. And like I mentioned, you've shared some of your story earlier, but we'd like to hear about how especially the disasters that you and your Westmont community experienced in 2017 and 2018 and just how that shaped
you and the college
SPEAKER_02as a whole. And yeah, now looking back on that, how you've grown through that.
SPEAKER_00Well, thank you. I mean, I feel privileged to talk about it and to just reflect again on it. We did learn so much. And we had been through, back in 08, we were, we endured the tea fire, which burned a lot of campus. And destroyed 231 homes in the area. And again, I would say just as we kind of begin talking about this crucible, every experience I've had of challenge and setback,
SPEAKER_00as I've worked through it, inevitably, it's shown back up. And the learning that I had in an earlier period of life benefited me at a later period. And that happened this time where the Thomas fire of 2017 and the debris flow just a couple of weeks later, the knowing how to get through it included what we had gone through in 2008 with the T fire. And it's a part of I grew up in Western Oregon where it rains all the time. So you never have, you know, this kind of thing.
SPEAKER_00Well, I guess you have it, but it's always in the forest. It's never in residential areas. And so it was new to me. Californians live with the reality of wildfires. To them, it's kind of like tornadoes in Ohio. It's just a news item. It's not really something you can avoid. And so as we looked at how do we work our way through it? In part, it was just ensuring the safety of your people, being sure that they're cared for and that you have done all
the preliminary work
SPEAKER_00so that you have the greatest opportunity to make the best response. We, in this case in 2017, it was a slow moving fire. So we actually opened the campus to 100 fire trucks that came in from all over the Southern California counties. 500 firefighters, and they bivouacked on campus. And they literally hopscotched their way down the mountain, the ridgeline of the Santa Ynez Mountains, just above campus. And they kept the fire from coming to campus.
SPEAKER_00It was just amazing. Well, just a few weeks later, we got word that everything was burned above campus. we received word that this huge storm was coming through, a term I had never heard before, atmospheric river, where it talks about kind of a storm system that basically is like a floating river in the sky that is just going to dump water. But we ended up getting something like six inches of rain in
nine minutes.
SPEAKER_00It was an unfathomable amount. And it caused all of these boulders to break loose, all this mud to break loose. And literally, the creek bed came apart. it would end up destroying 100 homes, killing 23 people and damaging 400 others. And we woke up to it and actually I had awakened because of the heavy rain and had met my daughter. I tell this in chapter six, the met my daughter in the kitchen. We're like, man, this is just outrageous.
SPEAKER_00So we went in the backyard, and you could see this. It looked like a Disney movie. It was this red, it was flapping in the wind like one of the scary movies from Disney's child movies. And so I called 911 and said, is there a fire in Santa Barbara? He said, is this an emergency? No, we'll get off the line. Click. And so I said to my daughter, we have got to figure out if this is a fire. Would you get in the car with me and let's just drive down and
we'll try and get a
SPEAKER_00little bearing on it. We got to the bottom of our road, which is just down the road from the entrance to campus, stopped at the fire station. We were going to head further down the hill, which literally, as it turned out, would have taken us right into the debris flow. And we just, you know, I was there and I just thought, you know, let's just head home. I think we'll be able to figure this out from home. So we literally turned around, came back up the hill and found out later that morning that we
would have been just
SPEAKER_00totally wiped out and washed out. I mean, one of our friends, one of our family friends was swept out of his house and they found him a mile or three quarters of a mile on the beach. And he had literally been swept away clear down the road that goes right to the ocean and just washed over the wall. It was that. In some places, they said the water was as high as 20 feet as it came down from the canyon. Eight-ton boulders were bobbing in the water as it came.
SPEAKER_00It was hard to believe. And so that was the natural disaster. We woke up to it. And it didn't touch campus, but it destroyed everything just to the east of campus as the creek bed came apart. And we had to begin to think, okay, how do we safeguard our students? How do we communicate with our parents that everybody's accounted for? It looks terrible, but no student... was injured in it. Nobody's home was destroyed.
And so even though everything happened right next to campus, none of it touched campus.
SPEAKER_00And when we did, one of the 23 that were killed was the father of one of our graduating seniors who we would recognize that commencement that spring. And so the getting through the natural disaster, I mean, again, part of it is thinking earlier in my life about the problem of evil and suffering and reading this book by my thesis advisor, Traces of God in a Frequently Hostile World. One of the things that he talks about is suffering at the hands of nature.
SPEAKER_00which seems like, you know, nature has no mind. It just follows the laws of God and of nature's God and doesn't have any regard for human civilization, human life. If you're in the way, it's just you get wiped out. But it's coming to terms with that so that you can turn around and actually help people who have suffered. I think so often of that passage, from Romans, weep with those who weep, rejoice with those who rejoice, and that having an empathetic capacity to respond to people
where you can thank God
SPEAKER_00that you're not in harm's way, but then you also feel God calling you to help those who are in harm's way. And we had so many opportunities to actually help people who were totally wiped out and thankful to be alive, but everything else had been destroyed. I would end up going to seven memorial services, seven of the 23 people who died I knew. And there was a trauma in that of just the sadness, kind of the ripple effect of sadness. Two of the bodies, it took a long time to find.
SPEAKER_00One of them was the son of this family that we are... Close to we're still, the father and son were killed, the mother and daughter survived, and we're still in fellowship with the mother and daughter. Anyway, so natural disasters are one reality. Suffering at the hands of terminal illness is another where I talk about my mother. And then the third is suffering at the hands of just evil people. And that is a mystery that eludes understanding of how can humans do such
SPEAKER_00treacherous things to other humans? And I think that's one that kind of is a form of evil that we can't make complete sense of. It eludes our understanding. We can understand when a person has been tortured themselves and they turn around and torture. But a person who comes up with just evil on their own is just a veil of mystery. Nevertheless, it happens and we find ways in which we heal.
SPEAKER_00And one of the most prominent writers on forgiveness is a professor down at Virginia Tech whose mother, as a senior citizen, whose mother was murdered in her own home. And he had to walk through the path of forgiving the person who had done the murder. I mean, those kinds of stories are just profound stories that bear witness to God's ability to heal and And frankly, I've never seen anything other than God that could heal from
those kinds of experiences. And that's what I was trying to get at in chapter six with the crucible of human suffering.
SPEAKER_01Last line is so critical, isn't it? It's like, how can I get through this? Yeah, yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. David knows I've suffered enough in my life, lots of physical ailments all through my life.
SPEAKER_01And how am I going to get through this? And the only thing that can do it is God. I mean, you just find yourself going, the only thing I can rely on right now is God. And that's when the grace can come in. That's so true.
SPEAKER_00That's very true to my experience. We skipped human treachery number three, which dealt with denial and betrayal and just, you know, how do we deal with people who are dominated by Schadenfreude, this term that comes out of psychoanalysis, that means people that not only regret or resent the gifts God has given us, but seek to destroy them. And I think that that was kind of would describe a motive base in Judas, the night of Christ's betrayal.
And then the crucible of personal choice is really trying to get us to acknowledge that a lot of the problems we have in life are ones entirely of our own making.
SPEAKER_00And we just haven't been willing to own that. And so I use the comparison of the ethical and the estate from Kierkegaard. And what I like about that is it's a wonderful contrast that basically plays out the parable of the prodigal son. And in this case, the parable of the prodigal son is the prodigal son can keep all of life's biggest questions at bay, provided he still has his father's wealth. The minute he loses it, the minute the realities of life crash in on him, and he has to make an account for his life.
SPEAKER_00Kierkegaard kind of blends the categories, but the ethical person is, by contrast, a judge who's been married to the same woman for like 40 years. And he is able to build a stable life because he's able to make ethical choices that sustain that kind of life. And it's very much a different depiction of Kierkegaard than we often see. And I actually prefer that depiction of Kierkegaard of basically giving us a civic
morality that grounds our life.
SPEAKER_00Now, in his explicitly Christian books, he talks, he goes beyond the estate and the ethical to the religious category, and specifically those who make a response to the incarnation of Jesus Christ. And in that, he's saying that you make choices that put you in a position to respond to Christ, and that part of the ethical life is taming the appetites taming our carnal appetite so that we actually can be open to God.
And I often love using that analogy when people say, well, I don't want to go to church.
SPEAKER_00What use would that be? And Kierkegaard and before him, Pascal would talk about the right use of habit. And Pascal says, Now, that is a very different view of habit than, oh, my goodness, you form bad habits. But bad habits... can be counteracted by good habits.
And one of the things that Pascal and Kierkegaard both emphasized is good habits
SPEAKER_00put you in the right posture or position for God to work. And so don't view habit as a bad thing. In fact, view it as a very good thing, a blessing from God that actually can put you in proximity to his grace. That wasn't as depressing as you feared.
SPEAKER_01That's so true. The more we allow ourselves to get into the flow of habit, the less we have to think about what we're doing. And we are already in kind of that groove. And A lot of wisdom comes from being in the groove of habit. And you've been doing this and you know this and you've been there. And if you haven't done that,
SPEAKER_01then when the crucibles happen, you don't have that groove to be able to sustain yourself. Yeah, that's right. Thanks for joining us. We really appreciate your insights. This book is pretty amazing. I was surprised at how small it is and how dense it is. I mean, how the heck did you pack so much life stories and literature and all these? It's just amazing.
SPEAKER_01You're very well read, obviously, and you have a lot to share. So we appreciate that.
SPEAKER_00Well, Bob, thank you. I loved getting to write it. I took nearly four years writing it. And very much of the books that I've done, this one is the most of me. It's the most personal. It really reflects the things that matter most to me and the books that have really shaped my intellect and certainly the disciplines that have shaped my life and my character. And So grateful for the Christian intellectual tradition, grateful for those who have contributed to it and just have
loved the opportunity
SPEAKER_00to do the book and then to be in conversation like these with you, where people are really striving to grow in Christ and be enriched by literature that inclines their heart to Christ. So thank you. Oh, Bob, David, great to be with you. Thank you for letting me do this.
Are you questioning the value of investing in church life? Are you asking yourself, “Why get up and go to a building with people I barely know? Can’t I just listen to praise songs on my own and find a YouTube sermon...
God has called each and every one of us to mission, in and through the various vocations we have and the relationships we all have forged. “Mission” is this: We are Sent People. Just as Jesus is the Sent One, now the...
Caleb Campbell joins Bob and David to discuss some of the content in his book, Disarming Leviathan: Loving Your Christian Nationalist Neighbor (InterVarsity Press, 2024). Caleb believes that while it’s possible to be...
We talk with award-winning author Tish Harrison Warren about how to navigate burnout and weariness. Two-thirds of Americans are dissatisfied with their work, and a sense of languishing is widespread. Many of us feel...
All of us want to make sense of life - of our work, our relationships, and our place in the world. Who are we? Why are we here? What should we do with our lives? And is there a hope I can cling to as I struggle to make...