Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Re-integrate

Re-integrate artwork

Hope for Healthy Intimate Relationships (podcast) with Erin Moniz

Jan 27, 20261 hr 15 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Whether you’re single or married, young or old, finding and keeping meaningful and genuine personal relationships is what we all desire. In our digital age, relationship building is not easy. Young people are finding people to date on apps, and they are communicating with friends on social media. No matter whether you're married or single, we all need to understand how to have healthy relationships. College chaplain Erin Moniz is deeply attuned to the questions and concerns of today’s emerging adults. In her new book, Knowing and Being Known: Hope for All Our Intimate Relationships (IVP, 2025), she explores the essential elements of healthy relationships, addresses the complexities of intimacy, and shines a light on the barriers that can impede genuine connection. What we discuss in this episode: * The secular culture says that the two key benchmarks of full adulthood are (1) Autonomy, and (2) Sexual Activity. * But the sad truth is that this hypersexuality and romance idolatry has seeped into the church. We still see adulthood in these categories, though they're framed slightly differently. * We begin to reimagine a theology that emphasizes the importance of intimacy in all our relationships (with God and with our fellow humans). * The Fall introduced shame into our relationships. Shame is destructive and is not the same as guilt or conviction. * Erin explains how vulnerability is the currency of intimacy. * While marriage and family remain important, the church and other ministries need to focus on what true friendship is and how to develop friends. Scroll down to learn more about Erin Moniz. Thanks for listening! If you enjoyed this podcast, please share it with your friends! Your hosts are Dr. Bob Robinson and David Loughney. For further resources on reintegrating all of life with God’s mission, go to re-integrate.org. Rev. Erin F. Moniz Rev. Erin F. Moniz (DMin, Trinity School for Ministry) is a deacon in the Anglican Church in North America and Associate Chaplain and Director for Chapel at Baylor University, where she disciples emerging adults and journeys with them toward healthy, gospel-centered relationships. Support independent booksellers! We recommend purchasing Erin’s book from Byron and Beth Borger at Hearts & Minds Bookstore. They are eager to serve God’s people with great books. Order online through their secure server or call 717-246-3333. Ask for 20% OFF by mentioning that you heard about these books on the Reintegrate Podcast! Get full access to Bob Robinson’s Substack at bobrobinsonre.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Whether you're single or married, young or old, finding and keeping meaningful and genuine personal relationships is what we all desire. Bob, I would guess that you've had your fair share of conversations with young adults in your college ministry about relationships.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yes, I have. And I don't envy being young and trying to navigate today's waters of friendship and romance. I often wish that young people had a better tools to understand how to date but also just how to have good friends it really is only getting more difficult and in our digital age it's not like those things are bad but relationship building at the end of the day it's not an easy thing to do young people are finding people to date on apps that they're communicating with friends on social media so people my age and even younger are

in desperate need of

SPEAKER_03understanding how to have healthy relationships That's why we had the conversation in this podcast episode with college chaplain Erin Monis. She's deeply attuned to the questions and concerns of today's emerging adults. So in her new book, Knowing and Being Known, Hope for All Our Intimate Relationships, she explores the essential elements of healthy relationships, addresses the complexities of intimacy, and shines a light on the barriers that can impede genuine connections.

SPEAKER_03Hi, Erin. Thanks for joining us on the podcast. We love having you.

SPEAKER_00So good to be here. Thanks for inviting me. So you have been working for several years with emerging adults as an assistant

SPEAKER_03chaplain on a university campus. And then you pursued a doctorate to explore a theology of intimacy. What were you seeing in young adults that you needed to address?

SPEAKER_00Ooh, what were we not seeing, David? I mean, you know, you don't get into campus ministry necessarily thinking, wow, I'm going to become an expert in like relationships in this sort of arena. And yeah, it becomes like an occupational hazard. You just spend, I know for me, it's like 80% of my office hours were spent with students who had questions, but questions... under a large sort of umbrella. I know the word intimacy will often denote like something carnal,

SPEAKER_00but I use it in an attempt to capture what my students were bringing in, which was questions not only about their dating relationships, but also about families. and friendship and singleness and loneliness and so all of these things. So yeah, when I had an opportunity to do a formal research on something that applied directly to my ministry context, it was just staring me in the face. And I'm really glad that I got the chance because it not only changed the way I

SPEAKER_00minister to students on these topics, but it changed my life.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, what you said with the word intimacy, a lot of people, especially young adults, especially college students, think of immediately like romantic relationships. And there's so much more to that. There's so much more to have intimacy with friendships and family relationships. I mean, we can name so many more. But yeah, I think young people do get that confused. So I think that's a good distinction of like, we're not just talking about dating, although that is part of it.

And I know there's probably been many conversations about dating from young people

SPEAKER_03coming into the office and saying, hey, I need this advice or what do you think? And I know Bob's probably dealt with that as well on campus. I have never had to talk to a student.

SPEAKER_02Never Bob. I was going to say, I think I know that's a lie because I think I was one of those. So like, like David and like Brielle was the president of our student org.

SPEAKER_01And then David became president of the student org. And then David and Brielle married when David and Brielle graduated from college. So what I see is a lot of my student leaders are always like, you know, I can, I can name, I think four, at least four. couples that were leaders.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that paired up in the student ministry. Exactly. You know, as most young adults go through a season of life where they're going to a lot of weddings, all their friends are getting married, and then that slows down and things go on. But for us in campus ministry... It's always cuffing season. It's always they're never stopping. They're getting engaged. They're dating. It's just like another round comes through. And it's just it's always, always, always. And so, yeah, yeah, it's just just one of those things. But but I'm really glad for it because I had to ask some hard questions about whether or not I was helping my students.

SPEAKER_00And that was a that was a good starting point for me.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, it's the dating relationships. It's the questions about romance. And we live in a culture that's just enmeshed in romance and all that. So it's like the secular culture says that the two key benchmarks to full adulthood are autonomy, number one, and number two, sexual activity. Even our entertainment, you know, friendship, and in your own words, you said,

SPEAKER_01often plays the comic relief to the leading starlet of romance. That's right. That's right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's the relegated role. You say that we're immersed in this culture of hypersexuality and we have made romance an idol.

SPEAKER_01No doubt about that. But how has this hypersexuality and romance idolatry seeped into the church?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, this is this is one of the things that was I think the most heartbreaking in my research was realizing that all of the problems I don't I grew up I grew up in the height of purity culture, we were all very attuned to the messages that we were being fed by culture about And romance and dating and all of these things. And there was this there was this feel that the church was really pushing back against that was trying to create this counter narrative. And I think we we thought that that's exactly what was happening. And I don't want to pick on purity culture too much,

SPEAKER_00because honestly, this has been going on for a long, long time where we've been. Just reacting in different ways to the threats that invade particularly youth culture, some of our more vulnerable demographics in the church. And we try to create this idea that we are creating a different space, talking about things in a different way. But we actually haven't. And this really gets into chapter three of my book where I unpack the chapter

before it talks about kind of all the pitfalls and landmines of the cultural

SPEAKER_00narratives and cultural liturgies about sex and romance and dating. And... And then in the church, we just we sort of change some of the language. We do some reframing. We wouldn't like, for example, we wouldn't ever condone promiscuity. I don't think that would be a message that you would hear in the church. But we would use the same idea of sort of this currency of whether or not you matter. we just flip it over to something like purity and virginity.

SPEAKER_00So that as long as you, and don't hear me say that there aren't virtues to uphold, but when we leverage them, we leverage them as a way to measure whether or not you are succeeding, whether or not you are a good person, whether or not you are... You have made it and it's a very narrow way of looking at obedience and fidelity and chastity, which I think is much more all encompassing and actually demands so much more of us

SPEAKER_00than just obedience. Virginity alone. And so we've taken these ideas and we've borrowed from the culture. We sort of baptized them with some of our language, which explains and really for me was an eye opener to why some of the messages that my students were ingesting and absorbing were not only not necessarily helping them in the relationships, but it wasn't making them more mature Christians. It wasn't leading them towards Christ. Because for whatever reason, this had become unmoored, disconnected,

SPEAKER_00untethered from the fundamentals of our faith of the gospel in Christ. And so all of this effort being put into helping students have good, healthy, pure relationships... for what shockingly wasn't actually seemingly leading them closer to Jesus, which it should have at least done, at the very least. Even if it's not amazing advice about dating, it should at least be drawing them to Christ. And I just saw that this was not the objective,

and it was not sort of the bulk of the content and the frustration of my students,

SPEAKER_00that in their attempts to please God in their relationships, there was some dissonance at work that they couldn't name. which I think is that they were trying to do something that was still somehow disconnected from what was so sacred to them in their faith, the essence of their faith in the gospel. the objective being behavior instead of identity it's like you're good as long as you don't do this but yeah the hypersexuality in in romance

idolatry in the church says in the culture it's like you can have sex with whoever you want just as long as you have consent but the goal is to have sex because that's kind of what you're an adult if you're able to have sex yeah that's how we value as a human yeah

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And so, but in the church, we're like, oh, that's not true. But it's almost true because it's like, if you're married, you can have sex and you're adult and therefore you're good.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's heartbreaking, guys, because this is why we can only talk about singleness as a season. I really lament the fact that the evangelical churches that formed me so well into reading my Bible regularly and brought me to know Christ and gave me so much of a foundation also never created a robust vision for a celibate life. And for people who are now waiting longer to marry,

SPEAKER_00who are single, widow, divorced, for whatever reason, any reason that they're not, they didn't land in a marriage that was able to sustain for years and years, which is a gift. It's a real gift. But for anybody who is outside of that, we don't know what to do with them. And so we just have to say, hang in there, honey. Yeah. somebody's coming. We have this sort of way we do this because we don't know how to say no. If God brings you a marriage partner, that's wonderful.

SPEAKER_00There's a plan for that. There's a calling for that. There's a way the church is exemplified in that. But if that isn't what happens, there is still a call that doesn't have to do necessarily with you being in a waiting room for that inevitable marriage partner. Come what may, your life is full in Christ. And so it's that same idolatry piece. Romance isn't a problem. The idolatry piece is when we allow something other than the gospel to tell us who we are. Nothing but the gospel gets to tell us who we are and what our value is.

Anytime the church slips something in there or culture slips something in there

SPEAKER_00that says, but also this lets us know that you're a successful human being, it's idolatry because it's just something else that is doing what the gospel only has the power to do.

SPEAKER_01We're not doing it on purpose. There's no, you know, desire to say, you know, married people are the only people in our church that have value. We're not doing that. You know, we're not saying that, but we're, our actions are doing that and saying that it's implied. You know, I have many friends who are single and it's like, One friend said, I'm just not going to church anymore. I've been doing this for too long, and I've been treated so poorly for too long.

SPEAKER_01I'm just done. And I understand that because it's like, what good are you to our ministry? You're just single. When you get married, then we'll be able to use you. It's like, why are you using me to start with?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is sad and heartbreaking. And it's something that I'm complicit in. Again, before getting into this and really unpacking it, what I saw was a mirror of my own ministry, of my own failings. Because I've been married to my husband 20 years. He's a marriage and family therapist, so isn't that fun? This is just our life. A lot to talk about. So much like we know the things. Right. And yet, like I'm we are very much for strong marriages. We're very much for Christian marriages. We we want to see and champion that.

SPEAKER_00At the same time, I see adult friends more and more who are trying to live faithful lives in a world where marriage may or may not be an option. And I want to have the same sort of zeal and robust theological backing, but then also communal support and energy behind that in the same way that we are for marriages. And I think churches can do it. think these are small moves that we can make. For me, it was just realizing it was happening to then begin to make

course corrections. And so I hope the book encourages folks in that maybe hearing this will spark that desire.

SPEAKER_03It had to hit me a little bit later in life because my wife and I, Bria, we've been married seven years. I feel like we got looking back, I guess at that age at 23, I was like, oh, we're not too young to get married. And like looking back, I'm like, wow, we were young. 23 is young. Yeah. To get married and... But yeah, so we've been together, been married seven years, dated four years before that, knew each other in high school. So like been with each other for a long time. And so for me, I never felt that friction in the church.

SPEAKER_03Like it just... Sometimes things felt easier for me because it was like I had someone to go to things with. I... had conferences I could go to. I had small groups that felt more comfortable because I was a couple that could meet with other couples. And so I was never a single person that had to experience a lot of that. And it wasn't until someone very close to me was telling me about kind of their experience, and they've been single for a while, that And he actually was telling me that he applied for a youth

pastor position.

SPEAKER_03He has a degree in youth ministry, applied for it. And in so many words, they told him no. And a concern they had was he wasn't married.

SPEAKER_00Wasn't married, yeah.

SPEAKER_03And... Ah, it just like, it struck me because I was like, I don't think that that's right. I was like, I don't see how churches could say something like that if you're qualified. And they ended up hiring somebody else who was married.

SPEAKER_01Like youth ministry is like from puberty until they finally get married. Our resources for them in intimacy is all about marriage, being prepared for marriage, being sure you're a virgin. and for your future husband or wife. And what else? One of the things I hear from your book is we are so anemic in our understanding of what God has for us in friendships,

SPEAKER_01in relationship, beyond this romance culture that we're in.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I will say, while most of the churches I know are really doing this more implicitly, it's not an explicit thing. There are churches out there, and I see this more and more on the interwebs, Christian Instagram and all the fun things, where there are voices... from higher platforms within sort of larger constituents in maybe non-denom churches or around who in this nation are saying very explicitly,

SPEAKER_00like, this is your civic responsibility and this is what you do and get married and have kids and do these different things, which is nothing wrong with any of that. I think a little bit more civic responsibility in our world is actually a really good thing. But at the same time, when we mix it with this idea that this is what God wants and if, God forbid, it doesn't work out for you or something else happens. And there's so many circumstances that are just so outside of our control that

SPEAKER_00there's so many people who are like, I'd love to be married. Yeah. But X, Y, or Z, these things are just not necessarily factors that can be used definitively to say you're living a successful and obedient life or you're not. And so to tether that to what the godly life looks like and to say this is the picture leaves so many people out. We have some friends of ours. Sweet friends, they dated into their kind of late 20s, early 30s,

got married.

SPEAKER_00And like a week after their one-year wedding anniversary, he died from an aggressive form of cancer. And so now she's widowed. She was married one year. Now she's not. There's just so many things in this world that we cannot calculate to leave people out. with, I think, just such a narrow narrative that we are hailing explicitly is actually dangerous, not just for the people we're leaving out, but also for what we're saying about Christian marriage. Because I think in some ways, Christian marriages have the ability to be this

SPEAKER_00you know, standard bear. Like it says in Ephesians, we have this picture of the gospel that is emulated and embodied within marriage. And yet, if we're just saying these are boxes you have to check, these are goals, this is what success is, then sometimes the goalposts can feel like they move. I feel like my friends with kids in the church are are often always feeling like they're never quite making it. It's like, has your kid memorized the book of Nehemiah yet? It's like, oh no, you know, just like there's,

SPEAKER_00there's always like this, there's this comparison and the goalposts keep moving. And so I think my question at the end of the day to everyone is like, what are relationships for? Because the short answer, I believe, is the gospel and the kingdom of God in the world. But that's not how I thought about my marriage or my friendships or my relationship with my family, which is why this all reframed my ministry, but also completely reframed my own life and changed my own

relationships in such

SPEAKER_00significant ways that I can never go back. It's been a journey. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And I think for a lot of young people, I know I was this way in college. I kept thinking like, okay, when I get married, like, that's it. I did the thing. Winning. Yeah. Winning. Yeah. And there was just like a sense of like, my life will be complete and all this stuff. And thank goodness that Brielle quickly told me like, hey, I'm not your end all be all. And I can't be like, you have to exist outside of me. And,

you know, thankfully, like we can have a beautiful relationship together.

SPEAKER_03But it does feel like that specifically for young people. I feel like nowadays, like, man, I know with holidays and stuff, we always get questions about, well, what about kids? And what about this? And I just feel like there's so many young people who need to hear, like, you're already enough without the relationship. And I think so many times young, specifically young people are, like, coming out of college and they're... May not feel like enough, whether they're married or having children or whatever the

goalpost keeps moving is

SPEAKER_03buying a house, finding the job. And it's like, hey, you're already enough. Everything is just kind of additional to your life. But like you're already complete. You don't need kids. You don't need. I mean, again, they're all good things. You can have them.

SPEAKER_00It's so true, David. I appreciate that message because I feel like we forget that because of the Trinity existing before time, that all of creation, everything that God did, that creative effort that is the world and humanity was out of his fullness. It wasn't out of need or lack or scarcity. It was that overflow in the fullness in all creation, whether that's having kids or forming families and getting married, is really a part of us being able to live out of fullness and not being driven by

SPEAKER_00fear, loneliness, or need or scarcity. And yet I believe that that has been commandeered a little bit to say, just be content and then the Lord will give you X, Y, or Z. And to be fair, contentment is one of those lovely practices in Scripture. I mean, Paul has some wonderful things to say about it, but it's not about being content and then these things will come. It's about the fact that because of... Christ on the cross and his resurrection, we are adopted and beloved. And scripture says, because of that,

we are free and we are full and we've been given everything for life and godliness

SPEAKER_00in a way where everything is essential about me because I wear Christ. I can exist in a world of scarcity, but these things don't get to own me or define me anymore. And so I come to my marriage as a free person. I come to my job as a free person. These things don't have that power for me. I can do them well. We can have kids. We can build strong households, not out of our lack, but because we already know who we are because of Christ. And that reminds us of our fullness.

SPEAKER_00And then we get to create that. as little creators and mimic the creation that God, you know, showed us first things in Genesis. So yeah, that's, I hope whoever's listening, if that's all you need. Good night, everyone. You're welcome. Amen.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I think in order to reimagine our theology, to include the importance of intimacy in all of our relationships, we do need to look at the gospel story. So this is, you know, in the Bible, the metanarrative of... And if you're going to Jubilee, you'll hear this. But if you've been to Jubilee in the past, you've heard it. So creation, fall, redemption, and consummation or restoration. So you already kind of mentioned the Trinity. Is there anything else that when we look at the creation part of the story,

SPEAKER_03it provides us with the answer to the cosmic origin of intimacy? I feel like people don't really think about intimacy when they think about Genesis and creation.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I glimpsed a little bit of this in the book, but it was an interesting journey to work on this when I was in my doctoral program, because I had proposed that there's a robust theology of intimacy in scripture, but I didn't know what it was or where it was. I just sort of said, I think it's there. And I would work with my cohort trying to figure it out. And of course, we were so driven to these proof texts that really had only to do not only with behaviors, but with romantic behaviors. relationships, sexual and married relationships specifically. And they're in there and those shouldn't be ignored.

SPEAKER_00But I thought, gosh, where is it? Where is this? There has to be something more than just these things guiding us. And then it was like, I cannot believe I was such an idiot because like it's everywhere. It's literally everywhere. Like God has used the sort of framework of relationship to build everything that we know as Christians, which is why we say our religion is not about a dogma so much as it's about a relationship, relationship with God.

SPEAKER_00And through that, what we see is relationships happening from the very beginning, first and foremost in the Trinity, God's three in oneness in relationship with God's self before time being poured out into a world that's deeply interconnected into two image bearers. He could have chosen one. He could have chosen 16. He chose two. There they are. Given this cultural mandate that is tied to the Great Commission to go on mission together and fill the earth and subdue it in relationship with

each other.

SPEAKER_00And with God. And so relationship just keeps showing up. It's easy to take for granted because as human beings, we're very relational. We're built for it already. So it's weird to think of an idea where there'd be a framework without relationship, but it's very intentional that God did this because then as soon as the fall happens, It makes sense of everything that we feel in this tension within our lives where we feel so drawn to people, compelled by this need to connect and be with others in intimate relationship and

SPEAKER_00friendships and family life and marriages and romance, all these different avenues by which we can be known and seen and loved. And yet there's also this force working against us that is deceit and sin and fear and shame that are all carved out in that, in those first three chapters to let us know like, Hey, here's the human condition. These are the things that pull and tug at us as we are navigating the human condition. But because of Christ, right? because of Christ.

SPEAKER_00And because we now have the Holy Spirit, Pentecost was a game changer, because now not only do we have the Spirit in us helping us to transcend those limitations, but also when I am looking for the location of God, I have to be with other people. And which is a beautiful sentiment until you think about it for about two seconds, and then you're like, oh, no. People? Like, have you met people? They're the worst. You mean I have to be with people?

But that's kind of the idea of God inhabiting His people with the Holy Spirit,

SPEAKER_00that my Christianity, my life, my ability to know that I'm a full human and to be able to really drink deep of that gospel identity that's been gifted to me. has to be done in community. And I don't think just gatherings of individuals that are singing the same songs, listening to the same sermons, and then dispersing so much as like really thinking about the church, the way scripture talks about it, which is this living house built of living stones, the vines and branches and bodies,

SPEAKER_00this organic place. And then we look at our baptismal vows, we see that we are being brought into a family. And this language is not on accident. It's the family of God that started way, way in the beginning that we see these threads being run all throughout scripture that says, there's something here that helps you know who I am. And there's something here that by knowing who I am, you know who you are. And when you can know who you are, you can live out of that instead of some false narrative. I need people in my life who remind me who God is because it's

going to remind me who I am. And I'm going to live out of that instead of some lie I've been sold by some external standard being used by the enemy or some internal lie I've been fed

SPEAKER_00through shame. And praise God that he set it up like that, that our relationships are, I think, so much more important to us being in the gospel, at least than I ever realized.

SPEAKER_03Like as an introvert, you know, I think of like hanging out with people and like anxiety starts to creep up a little bit. And then I'm like, man, couldn't God created the world where we didn't need other people?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, like could he have just like put the Holy Spirit into ice cream? Wouldn't that have been amazing? I just need a little bit more Jesus. I'm going to come over here and just, you know, like I got my vote.

SPEAKER_03for sure. I can do that. But it's getting around people that my anxiety shoots up a little bit. But exactly what you said, there's a beauty in that. There's a beauty that there has to be a connectivity with other people. I mean, there's so much data and science that goes into that. And I think it's a beautiful way that God set that up because even as an introvert who likes my alone time, there's always those moments where I walk away from a conversation and I'm like, man, I really needed that. Like, I didn't know how much I needed that conversation with this

person or this group of

SPEAKER_03people. And so that's the way it's created innately in everybody. And it's a beautiful thing. Before the fall in Genesis 3, there's a little foreshadowing of what it's all about.

SPEAKER_01Genesis 2.25, Adam and his wife were both naked and they felt no shame. You brought up shame a few times now. What is shame? What's the difference between shame on the one hand and guilt or conviction on the other? Why is shame so destructive to our relationships? Yeah. Yeah, I am deeply indebted to folks like Brene Brown and Kurt Thompson, especially. His book, The Soul of Shame, was deeply informative in my research for the book that I wrote.

SPEAKER_00In fact, my editor told me I had to stop quoting him. It was getting obsessive. Kurt Thompson's great. I love him. His work is so good. But there was a need to think about shame in a way that is very specific to highlight part of the human condition that lives in us from a very young age, just like the desire for intimacy, that is wrapped up in deceit and fear and sin, but isn't just about sins that we commit,

SPEAKER_00isn't just about wrong behaviors that we do. And so what's interesting about shame and guilt and conviction is that these words have been used interchangeably in most of Christian history. And it's only recently that people have begun to parse them in a way to think about different theological concepts, which I'm, like I said, deeply indebted for. But shame and guilt and conviction at the outset feel the same. at the very beginning they all feel the same you're not going to feel something different um but these are going to lead you different places so i uh the language

it's usually described as guilt says i did something wrong shame says i am something wrong and and it's really about the places that they lead us because i believe that guilt and conviction are important part of the christian life so that

SPEAKER_00when i do sin when i am insensitive to my husband or my friends or my mom I should feel bad. I should actually experience good conviction and guilt for that, for lowering their dignity in my actions towards them. But that should lead me towards taking responsibility, again, that I can do as a free person. Take responsibility, repentance, repair, forgiveness, being grace givers, grace receivers. The gospel gives us ways to live out that patentry of

over and over and over again in our relationships, which is a beautiful way to know the gospel.

SPEAKER_00But that leads us closer to one another. It leads us closer to Christ. Shame does not. Shame doesn't just say you did something wrong. Shame says you are something wrong, which is why it doesn't necessarily have to be tied to something you did. I was giving a talk the other day to a group of folks who have been through a lot of church trauma and spiritual abuse and are talking about shame. And there's sort of the story of Peter, who's ashamed for something he did after the resurrection, where Christ says,

SPEAKER_00you know, do you love me, Peter, three times? And he's restored for something he did. I was like, but shame also can work in a different way. And it's like the woman with internal bleeding, right? And these are very good parallel stories because in both, there's the evidence of shame, but one is for something that like someone did. That's Peter's story. And for her, it's something that happened to her, something that she had no control over, something that was just a brokenness of the world, but she'd spent all of her money. She wasn't healed. She couldn't be touched. She had ritual uncleanliness, 12 years, 12 years, just destitute.

SPEAKER_00And she sneaks in where she's not supposed to be. She's not supposed to be in a crowd. She's ritually unclean. And anyone she touches is ritually unclean, but she's desperate. And so she touches the hem of the robe. She's healed. She tries to get away. Jesus asks this devastating question, you know, who touched me? And it says in Luke, when she realized that she couldn't go unnoticed because she was trying, she was trying to get in and out of there. And Jesus calls her out in front of everyone. And it says she felt trembling. I'm At best, she was going to get reprimanded.

SPEAKER_00At worst, she might have been stoned. I mean, it was a big, she was in a state and he said, daughter, daughter, your faith has healed you. Go in peace. And I love that because what scholars tell us is that there was a need for her physical healing to not just be the only thing that healed, but her being restored to the community, something in her being restored as a person who gets to be seen and known and a part of something. Her status is reinstated with that familial language of daughter and

in front of everyone, similarly to Peter being told, I called you to feed my sheep.

SPEAKER_00You're not supposed to be fishing anymore, Peter. This is who you are. And God looks at her and says, this is who you are. That is how Jesus frees the people who are enslaved by shame. And so for us, we have shame that attacks our identity. Again, the very thing that only the gospel gets to tell us. Only the gospel gets to tell us who we are and how it matters. So shame comes in and tries to usurp that by telling us a lie, telling us something different, and we'll use whatever it can grab.

SPEAKER_00And it's, I believe, a real powerful tool of the enemy, because we can have shame for all kinds of things that we can't even pinpoint why we feel shame for them. But I know that my favorite sins are often the result of... of me believing a distortion about God, which is usually connected to a distortion about myself. And so my sin behaviors can be rooted back to those lies and the way that shame is just feeding on them in the dark.

SPEAKER_00Because shame wants me to isolate. Shame wants me to pull away. Shame wants me to hide. Intimacy says, be seen. come be with us. We've got you. We know these things. You're okay. It sheds light. Things lose their power in the light. And so these things are always at war. So shame is the enemy of intimacy, but thank God intimacy is also the enemy of shame.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and it's just a great reminder to call out that shame and really just understand, like, okay, where is this stemming from? What does this say about me? Or what should it not say about me? So the next part of the gospel story we want to talk about is redemption. So redemption in Jesus Christ. So the gospel restores our ability to have deep relationships, not only in marriage, but with friends and family. Mm-hmm. so you say this quote that when i read it i was like oh man

that hits um so you say that vulnerability is the currency of intimacy yeah there's the rub yeah gosh and for for an introvert like yourself who who feels anxious around people which i mean that's my students bar none more and more um you you can't have intimacy without

SPEAKER_00vulnerability because every piece of knowledge that you give makes you vulnerable, even if it just feels incidental. But like my husband and I, again, married 20 years, we've got nuclear silos of information that we could just destroy each other with. I mean, the level of intimacy that we have because we're married, because we have access to the deepest levels of human intimacy, as well as just all this shared years and shared knowledge,

SPEAKER_00It's beautiful when it's in a trusting relationship, but it's risky. It's super risky every time. And we're all negotiating vulnerability all the time in our relationships. I mean, that's the tab that stays open, always pulling energy from us in a lot of ways. With any information that we're giving to others, anything that we're letting be seen about ourselves is always very risky. And there isn't a way to eliminate that risk,

no matter what technology sells you. Technology has built massive billion-dollar markets on trying to sell us ways to skip the vulnerability and just feel the connection from parasocial relationships

SPEAKER_00to pornography to AI chatbots. They've got things to sell us. And we buy them because we're like, yes, I just want to connect with people, but I don't want the messiness of being a human. I don't want the messiness of vulnerability. But as the stats continue to show us, we get lonelier and lonelier because those things actually don't work. They're not embodied. They actually diminish the dignity of others and the dignity of ourselves. Yeah. They make us less human. And so they just won't work. Technology can do great things for relationships.

SPEAKER_00I'm a big fan. But it can also be a way to escape, to try to think we can usurp vulnerability and we just can't. But it's tricky because, and I tell my students this, the best way to think about vulnerability, vulnerability on parallel tracks with trust building, and that the two go together.

SPEAKER_03As you were saying that, like, I'm thinking, okay, as an introvert, the conversations I have with my wife are the conversations I don't have with anybody else. And in a way I'm like, that's great. That's kind of like, that's, that's how it should be. Like I'm having conversations with her that, um, And for me to talk to her, she would probably tell you that I'm a talker because with her, I feel comfortable. I feel safe. I can share hard things. For her, even though we have great conversations, sometimes it's a little...

SPEAKER_03it's a little harder for her to share some things. So I also feel like it depends on kind of the person's personality, just like how they communicate. Cause I know sometimes she just needs like prompts from me of saying like, Okay, so this happened in your day. You haven't really talked about it. So, like, I'm going to ask this question if you're comfortable with that. And then just kind of start peeling back some of the layers. And then it opens up to a conversation. But sometimes it does depend on the personality.

SPEAKER_03Like, I know my dad's the same way. Sometimes I have to ask him questions to get him thinking. Yeah. And sometimes I have to relate it to his past a lot, just how he thinks about it. Like, hey, when you were my age, how did this make you feel? And like, why did it make you feel that way? And to get a conversation going.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, we all have our things. We've all been taught from a young age how to protect ourselves. And for some of my students, it's weirdly, oddly counterintuitive where they'll be super vulnerable, super quick. And I'm like, that's not, let's not do that. It's easy, like poor choices. But again, like this all comes from the way that they were formed. And I mean, attachment theory really tells us a lot about how we, how we understand how we create attachments and in our formative years.

SPEAKER_00But the, but the beauty of it is that, um, And there's always ways to be transformed and to move towards being better about being vulnerable and discerning. And all of us are on a journey to discover what we need to unlearn. um and what what can be replaced with the truth of god telling us this is who you are uh in your full humanity my my husband and i are pretty opposite when it comes to communication and boy that was fun for the first several

years of our marriage learning that our communication styles um just wrecked each other and uh but but

SPEAKER_00you can change relationships are deeply sanctifying and i think my marriage, my friendships, just, I'm grateful that, that these things, um, have hopefully made me a better minister to my students, have curbs and bad habits in me, um, to be a better communicator. But for my most intimate relationships, um, That vulnerability is so necessary. And so we have to be lifelong learners. I would love to see church retreats for folks, helping them develop an emotional IQ to be able to learn the

art of communication,

SPEAKER_00not just for married couples, but just like across the board to learn these skills. There's so much we can do to grow. And I would love to see that centered at the local church, but I'm putting a lot on pastors. That's a lot of pastors listening to me go on and on about the local church and like, oh, Aaron, we can't do everything. Come on.

SPEAKER_01So before we let you go, what are some major takeaways for these church leaders to consider in light of the fact that we have marriage, which they major on that. Way to go. Good. Family. Way to go. Good. And friendship. Oh, wait, not so much. But you discovered friendship and family are very related. So can you help us understand these things? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yes, I think people are starting to pick up on the fact that like I'm beating this drum of the art of friendship being kind of the next sort of spiritual discipline that we really focus on. Not just because it's accessible to everyone, but also because I believe it is something that we can talk about in order to strengthen and have good marriages, to date well, to... Build relationships that are so weird when we become adults and we have relationships with our moms and dads and siblings. Like my students are in that transition right now.

SPEAKER_00It's awkward. It's weird. But I believe the art of friendship is a tide that raises all these ships. So practically speaking, it's really valuable. And it's for everyone. It's something everyone can... use and relate to immediately um for all of their relationships but there's not a lot about friendship in scripture seemingly um jesus has this like incorrect like moment in john 15 where he's like you're no longer servants you're friends and no greater love has anyone than lays down his life which of course

was about to

SPEAKER_00foreshadow what he was about to do on the cross um, as, as sort of the ultimate exemplar of this. Um, but, but that's a pretty big, I mean, that's a big, that's a big deal. You would think like there would be a lot more of that motif in scripture. Um, and it was West Hill and others who I'm also indebted to, who helped me sort of see that, uh, there's a story that's told in the three synoptic gospels. where Jesus says, who are my mother and brother and sisters? These are my mother and brother and sisters, my disciples. And so the people that he just called friends,

SPEAKER_00he began to reframe this idea of family, a reframe that the church picked up on immediately and has emulated since the early days of the Christian church, thinking about And what did Christ mean in that moment where, hey, if you have a wonderful biological family of origin, wonderful, that's great. But everyone is invited into the family of God. And we resituate ourselves in baptism into a new family. And so in many ways, the framework of Christian friendship,

what we're going for.

SPEAKER_00is the hospitality of a family, which is really beautiful and such good news, such good news for our single friends, such good news for our families with little kids, such good news for our empty nesters, such good news for our disabled friends, our friends in recovery, our friends suffering from trauma, our friends who just moved miles away from their biofam, our friends who don't have a good family life, our friends who do. It's just such good news for everyone to be able to say,

SPEAKER_00we are doing friendship, not just to have more book clubs and fantasy football groups, which those are great. My husband's in three. They're great. But the purpose is to think of friendship as a kind of healthy, hospitable family unit. And that family motif is all over scripture. It's everywhere. So when Jesus is talking about how we relate to each other, In light of being the church with each other, these image bearers, occupants of the Holy Spirit relating to one another in friendship,

SPEAKER_00we have a framework that is family. And I think there's a lot to unpack there. I only dedicate a few short pages to it in the last few chapters. But I am eager to see this conversation continue. I'm eager to see more and more content coming out about Christian friendship and Because we're kind of bad at it. We don't have the same cultural artifacts as we do for romance. But what if the church was? What if Christianity was? What if our campus ministries were places?

SPEAKER_00This is where Christian friendship is thriving. It's a gravitational pull. for everyone to come and say, this is what it looks like to be in Jesus's family. I think if we learn how to do friendship well, even in conflict, what an incredible embodiment of the gospel. So anyways, that's my pitch.

SPEAKER_01Campus ministry is an awesome opportunity. I always try to help the students realize these guys and girls sitting around the circle are friends. Don't look for romantic partners. Look for friends. Let's talk about how to be friends. Because I can guarantee you it's best to find a romantic partner from a friend than to go for a romantic partner and then try to figure out how to be friends with that person. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, backwards. And so much of marriage is friendship. So much of it is, which is why studying the art of friendship would be so good for our marriages, because in many ways, the things that we think marriage is all about are really just these slices of the pie, important slices, but so much of it is the day to day knowing and seeing each other and just love. being proximate to a person that you choose every day over and over again. And building on that friendship, it makes everything else that much sweeter. So yeah, I'm a big fan, but, but so more, more work to do.

SPEAKER_01Well, there is. And so the next step for church leaders, for ministry leaders, is to start thinking about what are the contexts that I'm creating in which friendships can be organically formed, that people can actually show hospitality to one another— They can have meals together. They can show generosity to one another. They could be in solidarity with each other. How can I create that kind of community? We talk a lot about community in our churches,

and yet many of our churches are just a bunch of individuals coming together for an

SPEAKER_01hour on Sunday morning and then leaving. So we need to start thinking more deeply about what does it look like to create true community? We use that word a lot, and I— You keep using that word. I don't think you know.

SPEAKER_00I got you. I got you. See, that's a deep cut reference for the movies that we love.

SPEAKER_01But that's what I think is going on. Truly. Thanks for being on the podcast.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for having me. This has been super fun, you guys. Absolutely. Absolutely. And Bob, will I see you at Jubilee?

SPEAKER_01You will. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Maybe even David. David needs to come back. I know. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I invited him. It's the Jubilee of Jubilees. It's the 50th Jubilee. So we're inviting all the students that were like, how many Jubilees did you go to, David? David? Four?

SPEAKER_03Four or five? Yeah. Yeah, about four or five. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Nice. Well, it'll be fun to have some friends there, some familiar faces. It's a whole new experience for me. And it's in Pittsburgh, so not too far from, at least where you are, Bob. David, are you in Canton as well? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So not too far. Did you go to Pittsburgh to get your doctorate at the Trinity School of Ministry? Yep. I was there. In fact, I'll be visiting there and giving a sermon right before Jubilee. I'm going to be going by the seminary and seeing some old friends before heading out to Jubilee.

SPEAKER_00So I'm really excited. It's going to be great. So I'll look for you guys. I'll look for you guys there. That'll be so fun. We'll get to connect in real life.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. See you then. Wonderful. Bye. Bye.

SPEAKER_03I still have a vivid memory, which I'm very, very grateful that I have this memory burned into my brain of my first ever friend I ever made. was in preschool I saw this little kid playing with blocks and I'm like hey I like blocks and so I went up next to him and I sat down and I turned over at him and I was like and literally little David was not an introvert like very young David he could go up to anybody and start a conversation so I just

turned to him and I was like hey you want to be friends and it was the first day of preschool and he was like yeah and we were friends for probably like five years until he moved away

SPEAKER_03And years after that, that's how I would make friends. You had something in common. And so then you were like, hey, you want to hang out? You want to eat lunch together at the lunch table? And it felt so easy. And then as an adult... Honestly, if I'm being real, it is still one of my hardest struggles is friendships. And I'm actually like slowly working on a past friendship that fizzled out. So like, yeah, it's so weird as you get older.

SPEAKER_03It's like life changes. And then I also just think we make excuses to not have friends and we fill our time with other things. So then it gets really, really hard to find friends. relationships and relationships that you can be like actually vulnerable in. Because I do think it's important to have people in your life where you're like, like my coworkers, like, yeah, I know them, but I'm not going to like spill my guts out to them and share my whole life story. They're there for like support throughout the work day. They're there to help me.

SPEAKER_03And I do consider, you know, a good handle. Like they're, they're my friends. Like my work people are my friends, but yeah, again, I should have other people in my life where I'm like, okay, I can have a deep conversation with this person. I can open up more about this and go deeper with this person. And then like, there's some things where it's like, okay, that's only for Brielle. Like, so there's levels of like relationships and vulnerability. It feels like it gets complicated as you get older.

SPEAKER_01We're getting more and more programmed to not be vulnerable to people and not to share with people and to and to not develop deeper friendships that were satisfied with very shallow friendships and were were satisfied with para relationships on on social media accounts and were guilty right and so it's like it's like if i have my wife who else do i need i don't you know i got me myself and i and sometimes my wife

SPEAKER_01And I've got a couple of cats in the house. And what else do I need, right? Right. What's interesting about relationships, about friendships, is that it is the means by which we experience God. What? That's true. We don't see it that way. We don't see relationships. And the deeper the relationship, the more vulnerable we are with people, the more God's Spirit can use that relationship to grow us in our Christianity.

SPEAKER_01That is something we haven't figured out.

SPEAKER_03No, no. But I've had that similar thought where it really does go back to creation. Every relationship is mirroring God's relationship with us. thankfully i mean brielle and i tell each other that we are each other's best friends and like it is true i mean she's my favorite person and she's told me that i'm her favorite person hopefully that's still true as of today i was gonna say wait a minute i thought i was your favorite person i thought

i'm sorry bob you're

SPEAKER_02up there you're up there i'm up there like like

SPEAKER_01Braille's up here, and Bob is, what, 40, 50 notches down? But he's down here somewhere. No, I don't know that many people.

SPEAKER_03You're higher than that. But out of process of elimination, you're higher, Bob.

SPEAKER_01It's all jokes, but yeah, it's good to be friends with your... What's interesting, she talked about marriage and she's like, if you did a pie chart of what a marital relationship looks like, there's basically three pieces of pie. There's a very small sliver, smaller sliver for some people than others is their sex life. There's a larger sliver, a piece of pie,

which is just your cohabitation. Who will take out the garbage and who will mow the lawn and who will clean the sink

SPEAKER_01and all that stuff. And then there's the largest piece of the pie is just your friendship.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, truthfully, because I feel like the majority of it is just like... Yeah, you're your friends and and obviously like, yeah, there are times where it should be a more deeper relationship than that. But yeah, I mean, I think about just like Brianna, I can joke with each other. We throughout the day will save funny videos that we see on Instagram or TikTok. And then at night we show each other to those funny videos. And it's some of our favorite parts of the day because we're just like,

SPEAKER_03man, I've been thinking about showing you this video all day because I know you and I know this is going to make you laugh because it's your type of humor. And like it almost feels like a love language. Like we're like, oh, yes. And like and then it's nice because it's like, oh, they thought about me. They thought about me when they saw the video. I want to show David that I want to show Brielle that. And so it's like those little things. Life is a lot of those little moments. And so if you're best friends with that person, then it does make it that much easier because you're like, I genuinely just like being around them.

SPEAKER_03And then you add in all the other stuff.

SPEAKER_01It's a sweet picture. What I picture is like a sweet picture of you and Brielle cuddling on a couch, licking each other at your phones. And so it's like this intimate time of sharing and just friendship. But it's a marital friendship. So you're close and you're laughing together because you know each other's senses of humor. And that's really cool. That's really a beautiful picture. yeah and it's it's just funny silly videos but i know it goes

deeper than that i know it's like hey it's just it's a point of connection throughout the day of like if we've had a tough day if it if it's just been a long week then some of the best times we look forward to are like yeah let's watch funny videos together and laugh

SPEAKER_03like just belly laugh it's great

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why the Church Still Matters (Podcast) with Dr. Carmen Joy Imes

    Sep 22, 202656 minAudio

    Are you questioning the value of investing in church life? Are you asking yourself, “Why get up and go to a building with people I barely know? Can’t I just listen to praise songs on my own and find a YouTube sermon...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Missional in Your Everyday Life (podcast) with Jon Hietbrink

    Aug 25, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    God has called each and every one of us to mission, in and through the various vocations we have and the relationships we all have forged. “Mission” is this: We are Sent People. Just as Jesus is the Sent One, now the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Loving Your Christian Nationalist Neighbor - Caleb Campbell (audio podcast)

    Jul 4, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Caleb Campbell joins Bob and David to discuss some of the content in his book, Disarming Leviathan: Loving Your Christian Nationalist Neighbor (InterVarsity Press, 2024). Caleb believes that while it’s possible to be...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Tish Harrison Warren: Resilience and Hope in a Season of Exhaustion

    Jun 20, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    We talk with award-winning author Tish Harrison Warren about how to navigate burnout and weariness. Two-thirds of Americans are dissatisfied with their work, and a sense of languishing is widespread. Many of us feel...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Worthwhile Work in a Broken World

    May 7, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    All of us want to make sense of life - of our work, our relationships, and our place in the world. Who are we? Why are we here? What should we do with our lives? And is there a hope I can cling to as I struggle to make...

    Credit the people on this episode