Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Just a few weeks ago, David Ellison and Paramount were staring down the barrel of a $7 million dollar per day fine for every day their merger with Warner Bros was not finalized, with a 12 state class-action antitrust lawsuit standing in the way. The states, led by California attorney general Rob Bonta, seemed to have Ellison backed into a corner. But then, at what seemed like the 11th hour, Bonta announced a settlement with Paramount that would allow the merger to go through. The deal closed this week, officially giving Trump allies David and his father Larry Ellison control over vast swaths of the entertainment industry, as well CBS News and CNN. Connecticut Attorney General William Tong is mad they didn’t fight harder. In an unusually frank interview, he reflects with Brian on what went wrong with their case, and what the new mega-company Skydance will mean for independent news in America. Also, check out our previous stories on media capture and the Ellison bromance with Trump. Guests: William Tong, Attorney General of Connecticut
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1From KCRW and Placement Theory, this is Question Everything. We investigate how the truth gets buried, distorted, denied, and the ways people are fighting to make it matter again. I'm Brian Reed. This week, David Ellison took over Warner Brothers, meaning he's now in charge of both CBS News and CNN.
Speaker 2Today... I'm speaking to.
Speaker 1One of the officials who tried to stop Ellison from doing this, from gaining control of two of our country's major news networks, and failed.
Speaker 3I said this to David on a Zoom. I said, I don't trust you with news. I'm really angry.
Speaker 2We'll be back with that in a minute.
Speaker 3On Tuesday.
Speaker 1Paramount, which is newly owned by billionaire father-son duo David and Larry Ellison, acquired another media behemoth, Warner Brothers Discovery, for $ 111 billion. Meaning in addition to the Paramount and Warner Brothers movie studios and a bunch of other networks and streamers, the Ellisons are now in charge of CBS News and 60 Minutes, which they got as part of Paramount, and CNN, which was part of Warner Brothers. The new combined mega company is called Skydance. This merger will surely lead to thousands of layoffs, less competition for filmmakers, and probably.
Speaker 2Higher prices for consumers.
Speaker 1It's arguably creating a media monopoly, which is illegal. But the antitrust division in the Department of Justice rubber-stamped the deal to go through. There was a group that tried to stop it. Earlier this year, the Attorney General of California, Rob Bonta, led a collection of Democratic attorneys general from New York, New Jersey, New Mexico, Arizona, Connecticut, and more... 12 states in total, in filing their own antitrust suit to kill the deal. A judge paused the merger, and Paramount and the Ellisons seemed like they were over a barrel.
Speaker 1Because under their agreement with Warner Brothers, once it hit October 1st, they were going to have to pay a $ 7 million penalty for every day the deal did not go through. The judge had set a trial date for March, so that could have cost the Ellisons more than a billion dollars, and they still could have lost a trial. Feeling this pressure, at one point, David Ellison floated the possibility that he would move Paramount's headquarters from California to another state that wasn't suing him, maybe Tennessee, along with its thousands of jobs, if Attorney General Bonta didn't settle
Speaker 1before October 1st. But in interviews, Bonta stood firm, said that didn't scare him.
Speaker 5It seems like what a potential monopolist would do to try to get their way, you know, to threaten a state that is simply doing its job of enforcing the law, It felt like a somewhat desperate, last-ditch effort to blackmail the states into allowing an illegal merger to go through, and that's just not going to happen. And this is an illegal merger.
Speaker 2Period. Full stop. And then, two weeks ago, Bonta and the other states caved.
Speaker 6I'm here to announce a settlement that our coalition of attorneys general has reached with Paramount.
Speaker 1After a weekend of late-night negotiations, they agreed to let the deal go through in exchange for what looks like crumbs. They insisted Paramount release a certain quota of movies, spend a certain amount on production in the U.S., but they did not force the company to carve out CNN or any other cable channels from the deal, which is what some of the AGs had been pushing for. As one longtime Hollywood journalist put it, Bonta folded like a cheap umbrella. People in entertainment, free speech organizations, antitrust lawyers were furious. The ticking fee was about to kick in. Why did
Speaker 1Bonta give up all that leverage? Even at his own press conference announcing the settlement, he seemed tail tucked.
Speaker 6I want to be clear about something right up front. This settlement is not a vote of support for this merger.
Speaker 1And then one of the other AGs involved in the case put out a public statement that caught my eye. The attorney general of Connecticut. His name is William Tong. He's also head of the National Association of Attorneys General. Tong wrote that his state had fought to the bitter end for a different outcome. And specifically when it came to news, the hill AG Tong had wanted to die on was protecting journalism. He didn't want CBS and CNN both going to the Ellisons, who, as we've talked about a bunch here on the show, are close with Donald Trump.
Speaker 1And already there's been a lot of evidence that they've pushed CBS's coverage in Trump's favor. Tong wasn't the lead guy in this suit. Rob Bonta was. And he seemed livid about the fact that they had all settled for so little. You put out a statement that caught my eye, and I was hoping you could read the.
Speaker 2Last half of it. Okay. This is Attorney General Tong.
Speaker 4We wanted to save ethical and independent journalism and news. We fought aggressively for that remedy. I am deeply disappointed that we could not do more. Connecticut will continue to fight hard against the enormous corporate power and forces that threaten America's free and competitive markets. And we will fight even harder to defend American consumers that deserve quality products at competitive and fair prices. And that includes ethical and independent journalism.
Speaker 1Tong's intentions seemed in the right place. And yet he failed and was admitting he failed. Not typical for a politician. So I wanted to ask him, what happened? What went wrong to get us to this frightening new state of affairs for journalism? And does he feel he made any mistakes?
Speaker 2Stick around.
Speaker 1After Attorney General Tong read his statement for me, we got right into it. I just want to know what happened.
Speaker 2Why did you guys cave?
Speaker 3I'm really angry. I'm really angry. And I.
Speaker 4Fought as hard as I possibly could for CNN and CBS News. There were a lot of other forces at work beyond Connecticut.
Speaker 3I'm involved in a lot of multi-states.
Speaker 4And as president of the National Association of Attorneys General, I have a unique role and voice in trying to hold states together, including not just Democratic coalitions, but Republican and Democratic coalitions. And there were three states that were differently impacted here than Connecticut, California, New York, and New Jersey.
Speaker 1Differently impacted because they have a lot of film and TV production in particular.
Speaker 3Correct. They have Hollywood.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1This is in large part about Hollywood. You all had a good amount of leverage. Paramount would start having to pay something like $ 7 million a day to Warner Brothers every day that the deal was not consummated past October 1st, which is a huge amount of money. So they really had a lot of incentive if you were going to do a deal to do a good deal.
Speaker 2It seemed like from the outside.
Speaker 1So I got to understand like what happened.
Speaker 4I don't want to be frustrating, but I remind you I'm an attorney general and I'm a lawyer. And so conversations between my fellow attorneys general are privileged.
Speaker 3But that being said, you're right. We had a ton of leverage.
Speaker 4They were going to start paying a $ 7 million ticking fee.
Speaker 3And I thought.
Speaker 4That we could continue to push Paramount and the Ellisons to do better on the antitrust terms, on the labor terms, on news and on independent journalism. So it's deeply frustrating that we didn't use that leverage more.
Speaker 3I remain angry about where we landed.
Speaker 4I told AG Bonta that I would not be shy about expressing how I feel about this.
Speaker 3But this is a litigation.
Speaker 4The hard thing, I'm not making excuses, but the hard thing about multi-state cases is they're multi-state, right? It's a coalition of 12. And it's hard to litigate by committee. I fought as hard as I possibly could, but other states wanted to settle. And this is where this is where it landed.
Speaker 1I understand there's certain privilege issues, but I do want to kind of ask you again, like this is an illegal deal. According to your own case, you filed this antitrust suit on behalf of your constituents in Connecticut. of which a lot of my family members are constituents.
Speaker 2They live there.
Speaker 1What can you say to explain this about the reasons behind it to your own constituents, you know?
Speaker 3Well, let me just say this.
Speaker 4There was a ton of pressure, threats by Paramount to leave California. I personally did not think that threat was credible. To be fair to A.G. Bonta, they weren't threatening to leave Connecticut.
Speaker 1Even though Rob Bonta said he wasn't spooked by David Ellison's threats... other California politicians started to push him publicly to settle, including the governor, Gavin Newsom, Javier Becerra, the frontrunner to be California's next governor, and the mayor of Los Angeles, Karen Bass. Be adults, Becerra said. Get this done at the boardroom, not the courtroom, said Newsom. And that's what Bonta ultimately did.
Speaker 4We resolved that lawsuit, but that doesn't mean that we support this deal or think this deal is good for the American people.
Speaker 3We don't.
Speaker 1And.
Speaker 3You know, this is true, frankly, about my.
Speaker 4Case against Purdue Pharma and the Sacklers, against the opioid addiction industry.
Speaker 3You know, against Meta.
Speaker 4I still think in all of those cases that they're doing things that are unlawful and hurt people. But there is a certain point, not Purdue Pharma anymore, because I put them out of business. But at a certain point, you have to resolve a litigation if in your calculus we cannot go any further.
Speaker 3I know that's frustrating. but there's no point at.
Speaker 4Which the conduct of a defendant somehow gets our full blessing, right, in a blue ribbon.
Speaker 3Like, you guys are okay now.
Speaker 1So what was agreed to by Paramount in this deal that resolved litigation? your concerns enough to agree to let the deal go through?
Speaker 3I don't think they've resolved my concerns enough. I wanted full independence for CBS News and CNN. That's obvious.
Speaker 4I wanted them spun out as freestanding, independent public companies. And I said this to the Ellisons. You know, I said this to David on a Zoom. I said, I don't trust you with news. I don't trust you with news.
Speaker 3And I still don't.
Speaker 4And.
Speaker 2And explain why.
Speaker 4Because of what they've done to CBS News, because of the leadership at CBS News and what they've done to 60 Minutes, because of the.
Speaker 3Saccott story.
Speaker 4That that apparently the leadership at CBS News killed about the Supermax prison in.
Speaker 3El Salvador because of, you know, what happened with Scott Pelley.
Speaker 1Scott Pelley, of course, is the correspondent at 60 Minutes who was fired after challenging the new leadership there over their staffing and coverage decisions. Here's a short list of what Tong and the other AGs got Paramount to agree to in exchange for dropping their suit. A commitment to release 30 films a year for the first two years and 32 films a year for the next three, with the majority of those being wide releases, plus four indie films each year. Apparently that's a lofty goal. In the
Speaker 1past 25 years, no studio has released 30 films in a single year. And under this agreement, if Skydance wants to stop producing movies altogether, in five years it can. The company also committed to $ 1. 5 billion in additional production spending in the U.S. over five years. They're putting $ 5 million a year in an indie film fund, another $ 9. 5 million a year in a fund to train affected workers who might lose their jobs. They've agreed to certain limits on the way they can negotiate fees for their cable and streaming channels for the next five years to restrain
Speaker 1some of.
Speaker 2Their market power.
Speaker 1And what Attorney General Tong says he fought for, the company will set up a new editorial independence board to oversee CNN and CBS News, which employees can go to if they fear political interference in their coverage.
Speaker 4We got a couple of key concessions. Number one, no executives, officers, directors can be on this board. And so it'll only be journalists. And also, they can't all be of the same political persuasion or perspective. Now, I realize legit journalists don't have a political persuasion or perspective. But also, like, let's be real here, right? I didn't want Sean Hannity and Laura Ingraham and David Ellison all to be on this board together.
Speaker 3And they're not. That's not going to happen.
Speaker 2But who chooses them? Does the company really choose them?
Speaker 3They do. They do.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 3It's not great.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean there's like a data point here. There was a board that was put in place, I believe, to oversee the Wall Street Journal when Rupert Murdoch bought it.
Speaker 2Yeah. Which ultimately kind of was a kangaroo situation. He came to control it.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1Is there anything– did you guys look at that and put anything in place here to try and mitigate against that to make this like real teeth?
Speaker 3I wanted more, Brian. Yeah.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 3I didn't get it. I took it as far as I could take it.
Speaker 1What's the world we're looking at in terms of news? Like, what do you think it'll be like?
Speaker 3I think it's going to be harder. I think it's going to be harder.
Speaker 4I think they're going to be under one corporate umbrella and we're going to have to watch them like hawks. And if they violate the terms of their commitments on the editorial board, we have to go into court under the consent decree, which is stronger than a settlement agreement. A consent decree is a court-sanctioned, court-ordered agreement and reopen it and say, you guys are not living up to your obligations under the News Editorial Independence Board.
Speaker 1I'd been hopeful about the antitrust approach the states were taking against this merger, going after it as an entertainment monopoly. Government officials trying to regulate news outlets is tricky territory, obviously. And David Ellison effectively used that against the state.
Speaker 2AGs to try and discredit their case.
Speaker 1Shortly after you all filed this antitrust suit, David Elson actually kind of called you guys out on that, saying that this is really what the cases were about for you and the other Democratic attorneys general, that basically you were upset about the news coverage and who would get to make it and the fact that he would get to control these networks. And that basically that has nothing to do with antitrust, that you not liking his coverage decisions as CBS is not.
Speaker 2A proper use of an antitrust suit. Was he right?
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 2Why not?
Speaker 3He's wrong.
Speaker 4He would have acquired, and it looks like will acquire, extraordinary market power. And this is market power not just over studios and movies and streaming and television and cable channels, but over news. And if he says that we cared about news... And the quality independence of news at the outset of this case, he's right.
Speaker 3I did. I won't speak for everybody else, but I care. There's nothing wrong with that.
Speaker 1So this is just a couple lines from– Ellison wrote an op-ed in the New York Times defending the deal and criticizing your antitrust suit. And he said, I believe this fight is not really about market share. I believe a plainer worry sits beneath the briefs and the news releases.
Speaker 2The news.
Speaker 1The issue is whether I can be trusted as a steward of Warner CNN.
Speaker 3Yeah, good question.
Speaker 2There's been speculation about my politics, my loyalties, and my intentions. Good question.
Speaker 1I mean, it sounds like he could be referring to, do you think he was like you saying to him, I don't trust you with the news on a Zoom?
Speaker 3Let me take a step back. Okay. I represent the sovereign state of Connecticut. Okay. As its lawyer and your family as their lawyer.
Speaker 2Hi, mom.
Speaker 3Hi, mom, I could bring a case for whatever reason we want, okay?
Speaker 4And almost always, 100% of the time, that case is to protect the people of our state.
Speaker 3Whether or not, okay, it ends up being presented as.
Speaker 4A claim or a defense or whether we put on evidence at trial about this issue is a different question, okay?
Speaker 3But all of these cases are always.
Speaker 4An instrument for the sovereign state of Connecticut to protect our people. And so the fact that I have all these concerns is not controversial.
Speaker 3And of no moment.
Speaker 4Let me just jump ahead to your, what I suspect is your ultimate question. It is entirely appropriate for me to raise that in settlement discussions. All of those concerns, that being, well, about news, CBS News and CNN. It is entirely appropriate for me to raise concerns, all of these concerns, and to ask for agreement on those issues. Because in a settlement discussion, that's not a trial. That's not a case. They can agree to anything. They can
Speaker 4agree that Brian is the best podcaster on earth. They can put that in writing. They can consent to whatever they want.
Speaker 1Just to bring inside my thinking, my concerns about this merger have to do with media capture. You know, I have been reporting on that and talking to experts on it over the last couple of years. In particular, there's one expert, Marius Dragomir, who lived in Hungary for years, which is a textbook case of media capture. Media capture basically being when the leadership of a country is able to really bend what was an independent media towards their will and use them more as a megaphone. And this researcher, Marius Dragomir, has studied how media capture took hold under
Speaker 1Orban in Hungary and also in countries around the world. He's laid it down into four repeatable steps that leaders use to do this. And this is stage four, the final stage of media capture, which is allies of the leadership of the president buying up private media organizations and then exerting control over them that can bend them towards the leadership's point of view and will.
Speaker 2And squash out independent reporting.
Speaker 1And he, Marius, this expert, says this is the hardest stage to enact and should take the longest. And he was flabbergasted at how fast it's happened here in the second Trump term. That's his word. And so that was always my concern about this deal. That said, the antitrust concerns don't seem to encompass news coverage. And in fact, like, state attorneys general trying to influence editorial control of news seems like it gets into some dicey First Amendment issues.
Speaker 1And so I wonder if you think it was a mistake to bring that into it.
Speaker 3All of that is nonsense.
Speaker 4And I'm sorry, I'm going to push back really hard.
Speaker 2Okay, do.
Speaker 4You just encapsulated in a minute exactly why you and I are having this conversation.
Speaker 3To everything that you just said, yes, I stipulate to all of that. I agree with all of that.
Speaker 4But I'm here and we're having this conversation because I fought tooth and nail, okay? If you are indicting me for not being able to do more, I accept that.
Speaker 3I wanted to do more. I tried to do more.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 4And before I got in this fight, we had nothing. And then post-settlement, there will be an editorial board at CNN and CBS News. We can talk about the quality and the effectiveness of that, but we had nothing. And now we have this editorial board. And I wake up every day. I'm still frustrated, wishing I could have done more.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 4And so if you're saying that you are worried about these concerns and you wanted us to fight more and fight harder, but at the same time, it was improper to do so because somebody said there's some frankly cockeyed First Amendment argument that doesn't really work, number one.
Speaker 3Or number two, it didn't fit neatly in this.
Speaker 4Antitrust lane or that antitrust lane. I would say cut the let's cut the crap here. OK, we need to be street fighters.
Speaker 3In this battle.
Speaker 4And I tried as hard as I could to take this to the streets. And that's why in this fourth stage of media capture, the president in some quarters is winning because they're street fighters. They're willing to do whatever it takes. Let me tell you why it doesn't implicate First Amendment. A First Amendment challenge requires two things, state action, right? That means a government needs to take action against somebody to restrict their speech. And then somebody has to file
Speaker 4a lawsuit to vindicate their rights, okay? If they agreed to divest CNN and CBS News the way I wanted them to, there's no state action.
Speaker 2They agreed.
Speaker 3They can agree to anything. And if they don't bring a lawsuit, it never gets adjudicated.
Speaker 4So let me just go back to this contradiction and your line of questioning. Did you not want me to take on this fight to fight media capture?
Speaker 1No, I want to fight media capture, but I want to feel like we're winning against it.
Speaker 6Okay.
Speaker 3Tell me, tell me how I get the catch 22.
Speaker 2I'm engaging with it. I'm engaging with, tell me.
Speaker 3How you want me to do that. Tell me how you want me to do that.
Speaker 4This is a, with all due respect to contradiction.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 4You're saying you guys didn't do enough. which you shouldn't have done in the first place.
Speaker 3Come on. But we have to get out of our own way in these fights, okay? Like this whole First Amendment thing, sure.
Speaker 4We can have some ivory tower academic discussion about whether this somehow implicates.
Speaker 3Their First Amendment concerns. We just, we got to call.
Speaker 4It for what it is, enormous market power that was going to and may yet still greatly impact the quality of news and enable and empower media capture, which ultimately will greatly damage our republic and our democracy. So if you're indicting me or if anybody's criticizing me for undertaking that fight, I make no apology at all.
Speaker 2That's William Tong, Attorney General of my home state, Connecticut.
Speaker 4I appreciate your questions and I appreciate the spirited discussion.
Speaker 3You can tell I'm frustrated.
Speaker 2That's why I wanted to talk to you. I could tell in your statement you were frustrated.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 3I wanted to do more. That's all I can say. I fought as hard as I could.
Speaker 2Thanks for listening.
Speaker 1As always, I'm on signal at brihreed. 45, B-R-I-H-R-E-E-D.45 for tips or venting, whatever you want to tell me. Our newsletter, questioneverything.substack.com. And we're on Instagram, at questioneverything.podcast. Today's show was produced by Sam Egan and edited by Robin Simeon. Robin and I are the executive producers of Question Everything. Our team also includes producers Tracy Hunt and Zach St. Louis, executive editor Kevin Sullivan, contributing editors Neil Drumming and Jen Kinney,
Speaker 1and associate producer Kevin Shepard. This episode was fact-checked by Annika Robbins, mixing and sound design by Brendan Baker. Our music is by Matt McGinley. Evie Kwong runs our social media. Our partners at KCRW include Arnie Seipel, Tejal Ajmera, Natalie Hill, and Jennifer Farrow.
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! The New York Times and other publishers are suing OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement, claiming the companies built AI tools like ChatGPT by feeding them...
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Mixed in with the beauty and Love Island videos on producer Tracie Hunte’s TikTok feed, she started seeing clips that seemed to pit Black people against one another....
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! When a promising young freelancer pitched a good story to his magazine, editor Nicholas Hune-Brown was ready to assign it. But as he looked more closely at the pitch and...
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Lying is the force that is most diametrically opposed to journalism. So why has it been so hard for journalists to combat it? Earlier this month, Brian was asked to...
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Voting in this year’s midterms is already underway. And for the past year leading up to this election, the Trump administration has been pushing to get its hands on every...