The Talented Ms. Goldiee (Listener's Choice Winner in the Signal Awards)
27 minAudio
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! When a promising young freelancer pitched a good story to his magazine, editor Nicholas Hune-Brown was ready to assign it. But as he looked more closely at the pitch and the writer’s bylines across the internet, Nicholas began to realize maybe this writer wasn’t who she seemed. This episode recently won Gold and the Listener's Choice Winner in the 2026 Signal Awards for Best Writing. A version of Nick’s story first appeared in The Local - you can read it here. The UK-based magazine Press Gazette is keeping a running list of AI scandals in journalism, including Victoria Goldiee. You can see that here. Question Everything is a production of KCRW and Placement Theory. Follow us on Instagram: @questionverything.podcast. And don’t forget to sign up for our newsletter. Guests: Nicholas Hune-Brown, Executive Editor at The Local Victoria Goldiee
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1So you may have heard Question Everything has won gold in six categories at this year's Signal Awards. That's a sweep of every category we were nominated in. And maybe even more exciting, honestly, because those are chosen by judges. We won two Listener's Choice Awards, which means you all voted for us over everyone else in those categories. And that's just, I don't know, makes us feel better than anything, honestly. And today we're going to share one of the ones that you picked. You voted one of our episodes as
Speaker 1an example of the best writing in a podcast. We aired it earlier this year. It's called The Talented Miss Goldie. From KCRW and Placement Theory, this is Question Everything. I'm Brian Reid. Today on our show, an editor confronts a writer who he suspects of trickery.
Speaker 2I saw that you had a couple of pieces in PopSugar that I was trying to read, but I think they've been removed. Do you have any idea what we're doing on there?
Speaker 3Oh, yeah.
Speaker 4I think the editor who published the story left the publication.
Speaker 1Stick around. A little while back, I got connected with a journalist who'd found himself embroiled in a bit of a mystery. Nicholas Hewn-Brown is an editor at an online magazine based in Toronto called The Local. Does lots of local coverage to Toronto. Not long before we were put in touch, Nick had put out a call for pitches from freelancers, which is something he loved to do as an editor. welcome new writers into the fold, give them
Speaker 1a platform. And Nick got what he was looking for. A pitch came in from a journalist in Toronto that sounded great at first. But then as he looked deeper at it and the journalists behind it, Nick began to suspect that this writer might not be who she seemed. As he told us when we got put in touch, he soon became obsessed with this writer and finding out everything he could about her. Here's Nick.
Speaker 2Looking for new writers is an important part of my job. I want to bring in new people with new points of view. Young writers are people from communities who aren't always represented in the media. That's not out of any vague, high-minded idea about diversity. It's good for the magazine. It's how we find stories that others don't. It helped us win awards for our tiny newsroom, punching way above our weight. A few months ago, in September, we put a call out for stories about healthcare privatization, which has become a fraught topic in Canada. And I got a pitch from
Speaker 2a new writer that seemed promising. She had a memorable name. Victoria's pitch was about the rise of what she called membership medicine. Healthcare is free here, but new companies were popping up, charging monthly subscription fees, and promising to help you skip the line. Victoria was going to talk to the people using those services, and talk to the people angry about being pushed to the back of the line. It was a story about a trend she said, that
Speaker 2could transform Canada's universal healthcare system into, quote, something resembling Netflix or Amazon Prime.
Speaker 1I liked it.
Speaker 2The Netflix comparison was fun, the analysis seemed sound, and the rest of the writing was sharp. She said she'd written for The Globe and Mail, The Walrus, and Maisonneuve, Canadian outlets that publish the same kind of feature writing we do. Most impressively, she'd already done a lot of the reporting. Victoria said she'd interviewed a consultant in Vancouver. and a 58-year-old construction worker in Hamilton, Ontario. She had a great quote from a prominent Toronto physician, Danielle Martin, who said, quote, Membership medicine is a creeping form of privatization. When I googled Victoria, the author headshot that came up
Speaker 2was of a youthful black woman. According to her bio, she was, quote, a writer with a keen focus on sharing the untold stories of underrepresented communities in the media. And I saw that she had bylines across a whole range of publications. Victoria had written short pieces in The Cut and The Guardian. There were longer, more serious features in publications like The Non-Profit Outrider and The Journal of the.
Speaker 5Law Society of Scotland.
Speaker 2The overall impression from her publication history was ambitious young freelancer on the rise.
Speaker 5I was sold.
Speaker 2I brought her pitch to the next editorial story meeting. We'd received similar pitches before, but no one had done all the legwork Victoria had. Plus, like I said, we're always eager to try out new people. We decided to assign the story. When I got home from the office that evening, I took a final look at her pitch. But reading it this time, an eerie feeling came over me. The slick pitch suddenly seemed a little too slick. Minor questions I may have brushed aside earlier, eager to just get the story assigned, now gnawed at me. First of all,
Speaker 2lots of Victoria's bylines were in New York magazines and British newspapers. Was she actually in Toronto? Earlier, I'd been impressed that she'd done so much reporting already, even interviewing local construction workers. But as I thought more about it, that jumped out as a red flag. I've freelanced a lot in the past, and I know from experience that doing so many interviews before officially getting hired is a big gamble. Now I felt like I might be taking a gamble if I commissioned this story for Victoria. Before sending a contract, I needed to find out more. I'd
Speaker 2already read some of her work in the U.S., but now I wanted to see what her Canadian reporting was like. I googled her name, along with the names of the Canadian publications she said she'd written for.
Speaker 5Nothing came up.
Speaker 2It appeared she hadn't written for any.
Speaker 5Of those places.
Speaker 2I had one of my colleagues reach out to Danielle Martin, the doctor Victoria claimed she'd interviewed.
Speaker 3Dr.
Speaker 2Martin said she'd never heard of Victoria. I had a feeling of vertigo, of putting my foot onto what should have been solid ground, and finding nothing but air. I emailed Victoria back and asked if those quotes were from her own interviews, and if she'd sent along the stories she'd written for The Walrus and Maisonneuve. She sent a lengthy reply the next day. The quotes I included in the pitch are from original interviews I've conducted over the past few weeks. In terms of previous work, I read a regular newsletter for The Walrus, which gives a good sense of my ability to balance accessibility with depth while
Speaker 2speaking to a broad audience. she attached a link to the Walrus' Lab Insider newsletter. It had someone else's byline. So I emailed the Walrus. An editor wrote back to say that Victoria had never written that newsletter, and she found it odd that Victoria would say that she did. I re-read Victoria's stilted email. Then I re-read her original pitch. And I saw what should have been clear from the start.
Speaker 2The pitch had rote phrasing, like, This story matters because of X. It is timely because of Y. It fits your readership because of Z. Hallmarks of an AI-generated piece of writing.
Speaker 5I was embarrassed.
Speaker 2I had been naively operating with a pre-chat GPT mindset, still assuming a pitch's ideas and prose were actually connected to the person who sent it. Worse, I could see now that the reason I'd like the pitch to begin with was... probably because a large language model somewhere was remixing my own carefully crafted prompt and giving me precisely what I was asking for. I'd put out a call for pitches about healthcare privatization, stories where health and money collide, and Victoria, I presumed, had put my words into a
Speaker 2chatbot and told it to create a strong pitch that responded to my request. The AI was just flattering me, something it's good at, by sending me back what I wanted to hear. I probably should have ended things right there. Send her an email, reject the pitch, tell her I discovered that she'd made up quotes and never interviewed sources. But once I got over that initial embarrassment, I started to feel something else.
Speaker 3Shock.
Speaker 2The boldness of the lies astounded me. Why would a journalist with a successful freelance career take such wild risks to pitch a small publication across the world? Did she have an actual freelance career? Who was this person? Were they a person at all? Since 2022, the byline Victoria Goldie has been attached to dozens of articles. I found a handful of pieces in Business Insider where Victoria told the stories of everyday people. A Trader Joe's sign artist,
Speaker 2an Amazon delivery driver who loved his job, an actor who got leg lengthening surgery. There was an interview Victoria did with actor Nico Santos in Vogue Philippines, a feature on Afrobeats in Rolling Stone, Africa. and a product recommendation for a DVD drive in New York magazine's The Strategist. At this point, I didn't plan to write about this strange freelancer who I was pretty sure had tried to scam us. But I gotta admit, I was curious. If she was making up interviews in her pitches, what else
Speaker 2was she doing in these dozens of stories she'd published in reputable outlets around the world?
Speaker 5I couldn't let it go.
Speaker 2In my spare time, I found myself creating a timeline of every single article published under the byline Victoria Goldie since 2022. Like a 2024 digital story about climate change memes. That piece quotes Juliet Pinto, a professor at Penn State. I decided to email Professor Pinto. This is a strange question out of the blue, I wrote, but had she ever spoken with a journalist named Victoria Goldie? I sent Pinto a link to the piece where she was quoted talking about her research. She wrote back immediately. I have
Speaker 2not spoken with any reporter about that piece of research. Victoria had written a couple of stories for Vox Media Publication PS, formerly known as PopSugar. But when I tried to read them, they'd been taken down and replaced by a note that says the story's quote did not meet our editorial standards. Phrase I would come across a lot as I followed the digital breadcrumbs Victoria Goldie left behind. I wrote to a former PS editor named Nancy Einhardt to ask what had happened. She said she remembered Victoria's pieces borrowing too heavily from articles published elsewhere. She also
Speaker 2told me that she felt disappointed because she'd really liked Victoria's pitches. She added, that I was the third editor to contact her about Victoria in the past couple of months. She is clearly on a pitch to her, Nancy wrote. I started to wonder, how prolific was this person? In October, after I'd already been digging into her work for a couple of weeks, I woke up to find a new Victoria Goldie story online, in the design publication Dwell, with the headline, How to Turn Your Home's Neglected Corners into
Speaker 2Design Gold. It featured a series of quotes from well-known international designers and architects from Japan to England to California. The most cursory read raised questions that probably should have been asked by editors to begin with. Namely, had a freelancer writing an article whose only purpose was to get readers to buy some lamps actually interviewed ten of the world's top designers and architects?
Speaker 3She hadn't.
Speaker 5I emailed them.
Speaker 2A bunch of them responded to say they'd never heard of Victoria Goldie. but one architect quoted in that piece was more careful in her response. She told me she didn't remember speaking with Victoria, and there was no sign of her in her inbox, but she couldn't be 100% sure.
Speaker 5Either way, she wasn't.
Speaker 2Particularly concerned by her appearance in the article. She wrote, quote, That blew my mind. In this current AI age, I could accept that readers might not really care if stories were being made up, but it never occurred to me that the people being lied about might not be bothered. What does it say about journalism, where we're constantly working our asses off to make sure every I is dotted
Speaker 2and T is crossed, that a source actually doesn't care if a machine made up a quote for her, as long as it sounds mostly right? And while up to now digging into Victoria's old stories had felt like a kind of fun puzzle, for some reason seeing this fresh new story on the internet felt different. Oh my god, Victoria can't be stopped, I messaged my colleagues, sharing a link to the piece. She was out there, at this very minute, preparing a new, increasingly brazen fake story. And some editor was probably out there too, getting ready to
Speaker 2publish it. I don't want to sound naive. I am aware that people lie on the internet. But these lies bugged me. Not so much on Victoria's end, scammers will scam, but on the editorial side. on how simple it had been for such easily debunked lies to slide their way into respected publications. Like, was anyone out there even editing these stories? Plus, let's be honest, I'm a journalist. If a mysterious person in some mysterious location was printing AI
Speaker 2slop in publications around the world, under the noses of her editors, about such an impressive variety of topics, that was a story I wanted to tell. That's how I ended up on the phone with Victoria.
Speaker 3Happy week. So nice to meet you. Hey, Victoria.
Speaker 5How you doing?
Speaker 3I'm fine.
Speaker 2That's after a quick break. Two weeks after she'd first pitched me, and after spending far too many hours trailing the path she'd cut through the internet, I emailed Victoria Goldie, asking if we could talk about her pitch. I'd spent days reading everything Victoria had ever written on the internet. Now I wanted to know who she actually was, and I planned to write about it with a local. I
Speaker 2set up a video call for later that week. Ten minutes before it was set to begin, she emailed to change plans. I look forward to chatting in a bit. I'll be joining via phone, so it'll be a voice call in my end. Convenient, I thought. Moments later, she was on the line, chipper and friendly.
Speaker 5Hey, Victoria, how you doing?
Speaker 3I'm fine.
Speaker 2I'll turn my camera off as well since you're on the phone.
Speaker 5How's your day going so far?
Speaker 2I had so many questions. Was the person on the line even the same person whose writing I'd been reading? Where did she actually live? Does she even care about the corners of a living room? Mostly, I wanted to know why she was doing this. Was she a writer with genuine ambitions who had gotten in way over her head and was now taking some truly outrageous risks? I was ready to be sympathetic. Or was she a simple scammer We'd found easy marks on the overworked editors of the journalism world. But I knew I had to tread lightly.
Speaker 5Whereabouts in Toronto are you? I started with the basics. Whereabouts in Toronto are you?
Speaker 3Bloor.
Speaker 2Bloor?
Speaker 3I'm based in Bloor Street.
Speaker 5Okay, nice.
Speaker 2That's one of the city's busiest commercial streets. It would be like if I asked someone in New York City where they lived, and they just responded, Broadway. I'll admit, I was nervous. I did my best to sound casual. and not like I just spent weeks thinking about this person. I've never interviewed anyone I so desperately wanted to hear the truth from. I had some questions, more questions about the piece and how you want to move forward with it.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2First of all, tell me about how you envision the rest of the reporting process going.
Speaker 4Okay, so the piece basically is about how there's been like a quiet but significant shift towards privatized like subscription style healthcare models.
Speaker 3It's basically like membership medicine.
Speaker 2She talked her way through the story using more or less the same language as the pitch, as if paraphrasing a document in front of her.
Speaker 4More people like Canadians are paying for like healthcare as kind of their own version of Netflix or Amazon, kind of how.
Speaker 3We pay monthly subscriptions for Netflix. Now healthcare is the same way.
Speaker 2I asked her about the interviews she said she'd already done. Is it right that you've done some of those pre-interviews already?
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, just a few.
Speaker 4But I have a list of sources I want to get in touch with.
Speaker 5Yeah, and you said you spoke with Danielle Martin, is that right?
Speaker 3Yes, yes.
Speaker 2We actually, I know her, or we know her at the local, and she said she doesn't remember speaking with you.
Speaker 5Did you actually talk with her?
Speaker 3Oh yeah, I did. I did have my personal assistant talk to her. Okay. Okay, okay.
Speaker 2The idea of a freelance writer with a personal assistant is ridiculous, of course.
Speaker 5But I pushed on. I didn't want to spook her off the phone.
Speaker 2So yeah, I was looking for some of those clippings because I wanted to see what your past work was like.
Speaker 5And I saw that you.
Speaker 4Yeah, I saw more like different things, not just like one topic. I covered multiple stories.
Speaker 2If the person on the other end of the line was put off by my questioning, she didn't show it. Victoria stayed cheery and upbeat, providing quick, if implausible, answers to everything. You mentioned you'd done work for The Walrus and Maisonneuve and The Globe, but I couldn't find those clips.
Speaker 5I don't know, is there... Most of them.
Speaker 3Are in print.
Speaker 5What's that?
Speaker 3I said most of them are in print. I forgot to say.
Speaker 2Most of the stories are in print, Victoria told me. But editors from The Globe and Mail, Maisonneuve and The Walrus told me they do not believe Victoria Goldie has ever written for those publications. I saw that you had a couple of pieces in PopSugar that I was trying to read, but I think they'd been removed with a note that said they didn't meet publication standards.
Speaker 5Do you have any idea what was going on there?
Speaker 4Oh yeah, I think the editor who published the story had left the publication, so that's why they.
Speaker 3Deleted all of the pieces that she covered.
Speaker 5Yeah, okay.
Speaker 2The phone line makes it a little hard to hear, but she said they deleted the pieces because the editor she worked with had left the publication. Such quick answers to everything. Obviously, publications don't take down pieces because an editor leaves. She was lying to me. And I was pretending not to notice she was lying to me. I don't think I've ever spoken to someone who I suspected was lying to me with each and every response. I wondered where she was based, since her work referenced being in several different locations, like the US, the UK, even Nigeria.
Speaker 2I saw that you've done some work in the UK. Did you come to Toronto recently? Were you in the UK before?
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I did. Recently, like this past year.
Speaker 5Okay, okay, got you.
Speaker 2It was surreal, because after spending weeks reading everything she'd ever published on the internet, despite the lies, despite the fact that much of what I'd read was surely written by a machine, I still felt like I knew something about this person. I saw, or at least convinced myself I saw, the outlines of a real human being. She seemed to be from Nigeria, based on some of her earliest published writings. She was into Afrobeats and loved Korean dramas. She wrote about them over and over. And with that image in my head, of a K-drama-loving young woman emailing
Speaker 2editors around the world from her apartment in Nigeria, I felt some sympathy for her. In my fantasy version of this phone call, after I'd gently led her toward more and more severe inconsistencies, Victoria would be forced to admit to the deceptions. And then we would really talk. I started looking at some other clippings of your work to kind of get a better sense of what you did. So I saw a piece that you did recently for the Law, the Journal of the Law Society of Scotland, I think.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 5And another one about climate memes for Outrider.
Speaker 2Yes. So I was looking at some of the quotes within those stories and some of the people you spoke with. And, for example, in the Law Society of Scotland piece, you quote this professor. Actually, I emailed and she said she never spoke with you. Victoria had hung up. I see
Speaker 2now how foolish my fantasy had been. Whoever was on the other end of that line caught in a nightmarish call that was transforming from a work chat into an audit of their entire professional life, was not going to somehow open up and offer a full explanation. I emailed her back immediately. Had the phone line just dropped? Did she want to jump on another call? No response. I messaged her later that day, too, explaining that I really wanted to hear her perspective.
Speaker 3Nothing.
Speaker 2Eventually, before publishing the story I wrote about Victoria for my magazine... I sent a long note with every made-up quote and inconsistency I'd found, asking for her response. She's never emailed me back. In the days and weeks after our phone call, Victoria seemed to disappear from the internet. Her online writer's portfolio?
Speaker 5Gone.
Speaker 2Her muckrak page, which is a listing of a journalist's published works?
Speaker 5That went too.
Speaker 2An ex-account with her handle that had shared previous stories also vanished. And as I emailed the editors of various publications, one by one Victoria's articles came down. The climate story at Outrider was replaced by a 404 error. A story she'd written for The Guardian came down, with the note saying that it had been removed for editorial standards reasons. The story at Dwell was replaced with a similar note that ends with, Our apologies to our readers and the sources previously cited within. The Journal of the Law Society of Scotland also removed Goldie's article and published an apology
Speaker 2to the journal's readers. I asked each of these publications about their fact-checking. How had Victoria's pieces made it through? And, Would this experience change anything in their editorial process? Only the editor-in-chief of the Journal of the Law Society of Scotland, Joshua King, answered my questions. In an email, King explained that the quotes in the piece raised no red flags because they were, in all honesty, what I would have expected those quoted to have said. He added, And he's right.
Speaker 2One of the academics quoted in Victoria's Law Journal article told me herself that the fake quote sounded like the sort of thing she would say. It was made up, but it reflected her real beliefs. Every media era gets the fabulists it deserves. In the late 90s, a young journalist named Stephen Glass was caught fabricating sources at the New Republic. A few years later, journalist Jason Blair was caught doing the same at the New York Times. Those were major scandals. They caught the public imagination, stories about
Speaker 2ambitious strivers trying to find a shortcut to the prestige and power that came with journalism in that era. This generation's scammers, by contrast, are scavenging in the wreckage of a crumbling media environment. They're taking advantage of an ecosystem uniquely susceptible to fraud, where publications with prestigious names publish rickety journalism under their brands, or fact-checkers have been axed and editors are overworked. where technology has made falsifying pitches and entire articles trivially easy. Freelance journalism today is an underpaid, precarious,
Speaker 2impossible place to build a career. But, it turns out, it's a decent enough arena for a scam. On their website, Outrider says they pay $ 1, 000 per article. Victoria would have been paid about $ 800 for her dwell story. A fee that's difficult to justify if you actually want to interview 10 of the top designers in the world. But a healthy payday if you only need to enter a few words into ChatGPT. And Victoria Gouldie isn't the only one who's figured that out. Last summer, the Chicago Sun-Times accidentally
Speaker 2published an AI-generated summer reading list filled with books that didn't exist. Here in Toronto, an independent publication called The Grind took a chance on some new writers and were inundated with... Scammers tried to pawn off AI-generated stories about fictional places and people. Earlier this year, at least six publications, including Wired, removed stories after it was discovered that the articles, allegedly written by a freelancer named Margot Blanchard, were likely AI inventions. The suspected fraud was only discovered after the editor of the independent publication Dispatch received a suspicious pitch
Speaker 2and began digging into the writer's work. After weeks of trudging through Goldie's online mess, I went back to my inbox to deal with the rest of the pitches that were still sitting there, waiting for me. When we put out our call for pitches, our hope was to bring new writers to our publication. But in a world where you don't know if the person sending the pitch had actually written it, I didn't know how to do that. Looking at the collection of ideas in my inbox now, all I could see was the synthetic sheen of artificial intelligence.
Speaker 2there were probably some promising young writers buried in there somewhere. But I couldn't bear to dig through the bullshit to try to find them.
Speaker 5I idly googled the.
Speaker 2Authors of a few of the pitches that looked most blatantly written by AI. I saw their bylines across the internet. A web of lies and uncanny half-truths entrenched so deeply in the information ecosystem that no one could possibly have the energy to dislodge them. Then I was struck by a brief but genuine moment of bone-deep despair. Then I closed my laptop.
Speaker 1That's Nicholas Hewn-Brown from The Local in Toronto with his now Signal Award winning story, for best writing. We first ran the story in March of this year. And since then, there have been even more tales of weird AI fabrications, hoaxes, corruptions happening in journalism. We actually found a tracker from the Press Gazette in the UK that's like tracking these scandals. Victoria Goldie is on there. Thanks to Callie Anderson for connecting us with Nick. And thanks to Nick and The Local for letting us adapt this story. We'll link to
Speaker 1the version Nick ran in The Local in the show notes. Please, if you haven't, follow us on Instagram at questioneverything.podcast, Substack at questioneverything.substack. And you can always hit me up on Signal with, I don't know, any kind of tip or lead or weird little mystery that you've heard of. It's B-R-I-H-R-E-E-D dot 45 on Signal. This episode was produced by Zach St. Louis and edited by Kevin Sullivan and Neil Drumming. Robin Simeon and I are the executive producers of Question Everything.
Speaker 1Our team also includes producers Sam Egan and Tracy Hunt, contributing editor Jen Kinney, and associate producer Kevin Shepard. Evie Kwong does our social media. This episode was fact-checked by Kim Frieda. Mixing and sound design by Brendan Baker. Our music is by Matt McGinley. Thanks as always to our partners at KCRW, who include Arnie Seipel, Tejal Ajmera, Natalie Hill, and Jennifer Farrow.
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! The New York Times and other publishers are suing OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement, claiming the companies built AI tools like ChatGPT by feeding them...
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Mixed in with the beauty and Love Island videos on producer Tracie Hunte’s TikTok feed, she started seeing clips that seemed to pit Black people against one another....
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Lying is the force that is most diametrically opposed to journalism. So why has it been so hard for journalists to combat it? Earlier this month, Brian was asked to...
Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Voting in this year’s midterms is already underway. And for the past year leading up to this election, the Trump administration has been pushing to get its hands on every...
Midterm elections are around the corner, and AI is obviously an issue that’s getting a ton of attention from candidates. There are so many thorny questions around this technology, but what do politicians intend to do...