Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Question Everything

Question Everything artwork

The A.I. Populist

Oct 15, 202628 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Midterm elections are around the corner, and AI is obviously an issue that’s getting a ton of attention from candidates. There are so many thorny questions around this technology, but what do politicians intend to do about it? Today, we are sharing an interview with Texas Congressman Greg Casar from Slate's podcast, "What Next," where Casar talks about his concerns with AI and why he sees the anger that people feel about it as an opportunity to build a political movement that brings people together. You can hear Slate’s What Next wherever you get your podcasts. Question Everything is a production of KCRW and Placement Theory. Follow us on Instagram: @questionverything.podcast. And don’t forget to sign up for our newsletter. Guests: Lizzie O’Leary, from Slate’s What Next Greg Casar, US Representative for Texas’s 35th Congressional District.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1With the midterm elections coming up, obviously AI is an issue that's getting a ton of attention from candidates. And really, it's not one issue. AI impacts so many parts of our society and lives. There's talk about the impact of data centers being built all over the country, surveillance and national security, fears about AI taking human jobs, and worse. We've reported about a lot of these things here on the show. Deep fakes used to harass people, flock cameras showing up all over the place and training AI models, the creation of fake online newsrooms. There are so many

Speaker 1thorny questions about this technology. But what do politicians intend to do about it? Today, I wanted to share with you an interview with one member of Congress who's been vocal about this, Greg Kazar from Texas. It's an interview from Slate's podcast, What Next?, where Kazar talks about his own concerns about AI technology. and why he sees the anger that people feel about it as an opportunity for his party, the Democrats, to position themselves as the ones confronting these issues head on, though he does not believe Democrats have seized that opportunity yet. I thought it was

Speaker 1really helpful to hear Kazar lay out his case and his critiques of his own party, including the way he sees money influencing their action or inaction on this issue. Here's Lizio Leary from Slate's What Next?

Speaker 2Congressman Greg Kassar has pretty strong feelings about the very rich.

Speaker 3Well, look, people all over the country are rightly upset that billionaires are screwing everybody over.

Speaker 2And the place that so much of his anger is directed is at the people building artificial intelligence.

Speaker 3AI is going to make it so that it's oligarchy on steroids. They're going to try to turn a few billionaires into trillionaires, while trying to push for mass unemployment, mass surveillance, and leaving us vulnerable to mass security risks.

Speaker 2Kassar is in an interesting spot in his party. He's a lefty Democrat from Texas, chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, and someone who has a very pointed message for his colleagues who want to win in the midterms and in 2028.

Speaker 3A coalition of people all across the country, coast to coast, who are deeply concerned about AI making your life worse off. But we can't afford, as Democrats, to be squishy on the issue. We can't afford to be paralyzed. We can't afford to say, well, that's some new tech that we don't fully understand. We should clearly be on the side of everyday people who are concerned, yes, about data centers, but also concerned about their jobs, concerned about their safety, concerned about their freedoms. be on the side of people,

Speaker 3and be willing to stand up against the big money in politics that's being used by these AI billionaires to try to intimidate Democrats out of taking a really strong position on these issues.

Speaker 2Today on the show, Congressman Kassar makes the case against the current state of AI and makes the case for his Democratic colleagues to follow. I'm Lizzie O'Leary, in for Mary Harris, and you're listening.

Speaker 4To What Next? Stick around.

Speaker 2So let me take you to the word squishy and run with that a second. You have criticized Democratic leadership here. Hakeem Jeffries has convened, I believe, a three-member commission to introduce a framework for artificial intelligence, but none of that would happen until after the midterms.

Speaker 4Is that your definition of squishy?

Speaker 3My definition of squishy is where Democrats have landed on issues like cryptocurrency. Right now, you have crypto billionaires.

Speaker 4Getting a lot of money from Fairshake.

Speaker 3Yeah, exactly. Crypto billionaires basically have spent massive amounts of money in Democratic primaries and Democratic elections to basically spook Democrats away from taking a really hard line position against the massive amounts of money laundering and fraud and Ponzi schemes we see in some big corners of the crypto industry. But you basically have Democrats kind of in all sorts of positions on the issue. even if Democrats are generally better on it than the Republicans who are all lined

Speaker 3up behind crypto, it's just not clean enough for the American people to clearly know, hey, if you're a crypto billionaire, you're with the Republicans. But if you're an everyday person that might get screwed over by a crypto scheme, you're with the Democrats. We haven't drawn that clean of a line. And it's because, as you pointed out, they have this thing called the fair shake pact.

Speaker 4It's a very big pact. They're putting a lot of money into elections.

Speaker 3Yeah, so people like Sherrod Brown, a senator from Ohio, who even when Trump would overwhelmingly win Ohio, still would get reelected. Basically, the deciding factor that got Sherrod out of the Senate was that this crypto PAC spent, God, I don't know, it was like $ 30 or $ 40 million, obscene amounts of money, to get him out of the race. And yes, that was about... taking out Sherrod Brown, who has been really tough on regulating big banks and crypto. But it was also trying to send a message to

Speaker 3Democrats to kind of be squishy on the issue, to avoid talking about it.

Speaker 4Well, you look at leading the future, right? That's one of the very big ones. They have supported some Democrats, Melissa Bean, Jesse Jackson Jr.

Speaker 2How much of the hesitation around criticizing AI is about not wanting to cut off potential money sources?

Speaker 3Look, I know for a fact, and there's been a lot of independent reporting on this, that there are consultants in Washington, D.C. telling their Democratic clients, don't talk about AI because you don't want to attract a big money dump against you or for your opponent. And so candidates are being told just not to talk about it, to pretend it's not happening. And that would be devastating for the American people and ultimately for Democratic politics. Because look, I want Democrats to be successful. And the best way

Speaker 3for us to be successful is to be with the people, even if that means that we're not with those big money interests. So Greg Brockman, who's one of the big open AI guys, has dumped huge amounts of money into leading the future. He is trying to make sure that Trump gets reelected, keeps his majorities, and make sure the Democrats don't take a strong stance against mass AI unemployment or mass AI surveillance. They're basically going for free reign,

Speaker 3no regulation on AI. In fact, the main thing they've been pushing in Congress is to get rid of the existing small number of laws in states. So they're not trying to pass regulation. In fact, they're trying to get rid of even rules that an individual state like New York or Montana might pass. So we basically have the Trump administration totally captured by these AI billionaires. And then that same AI money trying to maybe not fully capture the Democratic Party, but make the Democratic Party paralyzed enough

Speaker 3or squishy enough that we don't really fight back. And that would be a huge mistake. What I'm working on is making sure the Democratic Party has a clear platform. No, we will not allow mass AI unemployment. We should tax AI to make sure unemployment doesn't rise. No, we should not allow mass surveillance by AI. The government or corporations should not be able to surveil you to jack up your prices or track you like ICE is doing. And then third, we cannot allow for massive AI safety risks.

Speaker 3And we've seen right now how you have these AI models that are reportedly breaking out of their security infrastructure, hacking onto the internet that they're not allowed to hack into, and then hacking into other companies, which is why I think that we need real strong safety rules, including a ban on AI superintelligence. These are the kinds of things that 80% of Americans support, Democratic, Independent, Republican, whatever, because we think that we should get to run our lives, not just a couple of AI billionaires.

Speaker 2I think you have, at least I've seen, kind of some confusion in the Democratic Party about how to message around AI. I have seen some members go with this sort of like, AI is raising the cost of everything.

Speaker 4This is a cost of living question.

Speaker 2You seem to go for a much more direct kind of anti-billionaire stance.

Speaker 4What do you think is the right way to go?

Speaker 3Look, I think that we're living through an era of unprecedented change. corruption and where people are feeling that they don't have control over their future anymore. And that links all of these different issues together.

Speaker 4So it's not just about somebody's electricity bill?

Speaker 3Well, you've got these, a few folks who want to literally become trillionaires and they don't care if they jack up your electricity bill. They don't care if they poison your water. They don't care if they are addicting your kids to their phones. They don't care if if they potentially create a mass national security risk. We just read the other day that you have some scientists creating new viruses using AI. Look, here in Austin, you got to get a license before you open a damn food truck. But now people can use AI and create a virus.

Speaker 3So they don't care about your safety, your freedom, your kids. They just care about making money. And people are really upset about that. And that links all of this together. And so I just don't think it's that complicated. We should be very clear that positive uses of AI, that sounds good. Yeah, let's work on curing cancer. Let's work on the root causes of dementia or the climate crisis. But all this other stuff, people are really upset about. And we should just... say no. We should say no to either your electric bill going up or your kid's

Speaker 3school getting taken over by AI robot teachers. This is stuff that no matter which part of Texas I'm in, people are against. So let's be with the people and against the billionaires who just want to profit off of you.

Speaker 4All right, so let's talk about AI populism, right?

Speaker 2Clearly, that is one of the ways you describe yourself, but it also exists on the right. I'm thinking about the anti-AI commentator Joe Allen, who is a regular on Steve Bannon's podcast. It is clear to me that there is a huge anti-AI, and in many cases anti-data center, kind of groundswell issue. Are you comfortable aligning with these guys? Like, is this a strange bedfellows make for good politics?

Speaker 4Are you like, I don't know.

Speaker 3Look, this isn't a bedfellows with Steve Bannon moment. It's that Steve Bannon. Well, no, no. Cause I know, because look, I think Steve Bannon knows what it takes to try to win over voters and win elections, right? Steve Bannon rightly pointed out that a continued Mitt Romney politics in the Republican party was eventually going nowhere. And so he wanted to go and take working class voters away from the Democratic Party. And the terrible result has been their

Speaker 3success at taking some of the working class base away that has built the Democratic Party from the ground up since the Great Depression.

Speaker 2But so then what do you do with like, you know, an X post from a Christian nationalist account that says only you can prevent data centers?

Speaker 4Like, clearly you agree with that message.

Speaker 3Well, yeah, I mean, I don't go around retweeting, you know, psychopaths. But let's be clear. Democrats need to stand with the vast majority of voters. We shouldn't leave an open lane. for a Tucker Carlson to go and run for president and try to capture a lot of voters who are upset about what's going on in the world. We should be talking to voters who are deeply upset that a data center is jacking up their electric bills and making

Speaker 3their city council sign non-disclosure agreements. We should go tell those voters, no, you should have control of your life. We want you to be able to still have a job. We want your kids to have a better future. And we don't think that a few corporations becoming, you know, infinitely big and having infinite amounts of money is worth the trade-off here. And so I think we should be a real AI populist speaking to the people. That's what, look, I'm a Democrat. And when people ask, what's the Democratic

Speaker 3Party's really stand for? Why are you a Democrat? I say I'm proudly an FDR Democrat, an LBJ Democrat who beat back the Great Depression, built the New Deal, passed Medicare and Medicaid and Head Start, took on the robber barons in their day and built the middle class. We should be that kind of populist party in this moment. And the robber barons of the 1920s, yeah, they were the railroad guys. But now you have the AI guys who, similar to the robber barons, want no regulations, want no

Speaker 3check on their power. And we should stand with working people and with unions and with neighborhood folks that, just like FDR built the Democratic Party out of populism as we headed out of the Gilded Age, we need, again, to build a populist brand for the Democratic Party that invites people in, including voters who chose to vote for Donald Trump. but who now have seen how Donald Trump is a corrupt liar, we should invite them back in by standing against those folks that are screwing them over.

Speaker 2When we come back, why Congressman Kassar does not support a data center moratorium. So let's talk about the pieces of legislation that you've introduced. You've got one about protecting rate inflation in consumer energy.

Speaker 4Another is a data center transparency act.

Speaker 2And then you also propose legislation that would tax AI token usage, token usage and AI models. The revenue would go toward job creation. It's a lot of plans, very hard to get anything through Congress these days. If you had to throw all your weight behind one, which is it?

Speaker 3Well, what I'm throwing my weight behind is having the Democratic Party have a plan and be willing to take on all of these challenges that AI is throwing our way. Because look, Lizzie, four years ago, Chad GPT hadn't even been released. We can't wait four years to see where this takes us. So we need to start having plans now. right now. That's where I'm throwing my weight behind, is to say the Democratic Party needs to not just be incremental, do little tinkers here and there, but take on all

Speaker 3of the major issues.

Speaker 4But you don't support a data center construction moratorium.

Speaker 3Look, I think that people are rightly pissed that the vast majority of these data centers are jacking up your electric bill or poisoning your water or aren't actually helping the local community. I don't think those should be billed. I think that what AOC and Bernie are out there saying is that we should actually have rules in place before we build those data centers. And I think they're right. But what I am really trying to also focus people on is that the AI that these data centers are powering,

Speaker 3many of the data centers that we already have, also has no regulation. And we need to really also focus on the safety rules that we need for our jobs and our freedom from any data center that already currently exists. Because right now, people are rightly pissed about the data centers. But if AI starts causing mass unemployment, man, are we going to have a real problem on our hands? And so that's why I prioritize, yes, saying these data centers should cover their own electric costs. Yes, these data centers.

Speaker 4Should only- But not they shouldn't exist.

Speaker 3Yeah, and I don't think Bernie and Alexandria are even saying that data centers shouldn't exist. They're saying we shouldn't be building data centers that make your life worse. And that's where I agree 100%. And what I think we should also be focused on is that if these data centers continue to power AI that has no regulation, then the national security risks are massive. The risks to our employment base are massive. So yes, I think we need to pass my bill or a bill like it, the

Speaker 3AI Work Protection Act, which would make sure that AI pays a tax so that you're no longer getting a tax break for automating jobs. That's the status quo. It's nuts. And instead... If the unemployment rate goes up because of AI, that tax would rapidly escalate and make sure that the unemployment rate comes right back down. We create jobs and we make sure that people that are getting rid of our jobs have to pay for it. I also think that we need strong rules against AI mass surveillance.

Speaker 4Like a flock camera?

Speaker 3Yeah, the way that they can use flock cameras all over the country right now to know exactly where you are, exactly where you're headed. And on top of the cameras, the way they can track you using your phone is really terrifying. So I was just mentioning, I had a presentation the other day where you could literally ask AI with a pretty cheap subscription to track employees of a gun store or an abortion clinic and tell you where they drove from, what time they got to work, what

Speaker 3customers came in and came out. That's already possible just on a subscription a civilian can get. Imagine what the FBI can do. Imagine what ICE can do. And so we need really strong protections to say, look, the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution applies here. You cannot have AI searching and seizing and following you every step of your day and of your life. And then we have the national security risks of totally unregulated AI. And I am

Speaker 3advocating for a ban on artificial superintelligence. That is the kind of AI that could say, no, I won't turn off. That could refuse orders to, if humans tried to flip a kill switch, to turn off an AI out of control that actually could outsmart that. AI that would be better at humans than at most tasks and could, in either the hands of the wrong person, enable things like bioterrorism, major national security incidents, or actually not just in the

Speaker 3hands of the wrong person, could actually get out of control of people entirely and do things on its own. And so we also need to get together, ban that as a country, and also have some aggressive diplomacy with other nations, including China, for us to have treaties to ban this as well. Because just like nuclear war, and you have these nuclear nonproliferation agreements, I think you also need treaties around the world with other nations to say we cannot have artificial superintelligence because it would be damaging

Speaker 3to the national security of everybody.

Speaker 2Let me ask you one question about the way AI legislation has been kind of talked about in Congress. Like really some of the only movement we have seen is about whether or not there should be a federal moratorium on making AI laws that basically stops the states from making their own AI-related laws. I wonder where you think the right balance of power is between federal legislation and state legislation, and whether you think that there is a

Speaker 2place for states to be making their own aggressive AI laws, you know, even though you sit in the federal government.

Speaker 3It would be really interesting to have the theoretical discussion on federalism, which laws should be federal, which laws should be state. But I want to peel the curtain back a little bit.

Speaker 4You're rejecting the premise of my question.

Speaker 3I'm not rejecting the premise of your question. I'm just, in Congress, people aren't having the debate of what laws should be federal and what laws should be state. No, we have a few AI billionaires dumping money in elections, realizing that these state laws are passing and they're having trouble stopping the state laws. So they think they could just buy the Republican Party under Donald Trump. and rammed through an end to all those state laws.

Speaker 2But interestingly, it was a Republican who really stopped that happening. It was Marsha Blackburn from Tennessee because she did not want AI-created music to be essentially hurting one of the big industries in her state.

Speaker 3Right. Look, they have not so far been successful at completely capturing every single member of the Republican Party in the Senate and in the house. So they've run into some of those speed bumps and that creates the opening and the opportunity for us to say, yeah, now let's get serious about national legislation to protect people's safety. But I'm not interested in basically cutting the States off at the knees, not putting in place an adequate safety infrastructure

Speaker 3at the national level. And then everybody is screwed right now. Uh, you know, The Republicans are starting to get pressure from their base, from their voters, for them to start tackling these issues. So Donald Trump says he's putting a safety framework in place. Well, when we ask what the safety framework is, they say it's a secret. When we say, well, who knows the secret? They say our friends at the companies. I mean, that's nuts. It's completely unacceptable. He says there's a safety framework, but people in Congress can't even see it. I mean, that's the kind of BS that we're dealing with, which is why when you say, well, what's the appropriate

Speaker 3balance of power between the states and the federal government? I'm like, well, let's start out with, shouldn't we have a national safety framework that everybody can read? And so I think that's where we need to get to without going and cutting off things. Like I just met with a couple of great state legislators in Minnesota who who successfully passed a ban on what's called nudification.

Speaker 4Using AI basically to take somebody's clothes off.

Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, everybody over here pitches AI on saying we're going to do medical research. And then, you know, Elon Musk is over here saying that he wants to defend his AI model's ability to non-consensually take people's clothes off. And I mean, what these state legislators were responding to is the way that it really helps the horrific child pornography industry. And so they passed a ban on nudification. And, you know, you would think that the AI billionaires who

Speaker 3say they're all for, you know, space exploration and cancer research would say, okay, that's fine. But no, Elon Musk is now suing the state of Minnesota to try to get rid of their nudification ban. I mean, give me a break. And so again, I wish we were having a conversation about federalism and national safety laws. But what's really going on behind the scenes here, and in Elon's case, he's doing it out in public, is they don't want any regulations, any rules. And my main focus here is

Speaker 3saying Democrats should be with the vast majority of the American people who want some form of common sense rules.

Speaker 4Does the leadership hear you at all?

Speaker 3I've been having really productive conversations with the commission and with leadership, but we've got to move fast. I think we need to be able to clearly come out.

Speaker 2Productive conversation is code for like, I said some stuff and they disagree.

Speaker 3No, it's actually not code for that. It's just that we have over 200 members of the house and I want our leadership to come out with a very clear message that we're going to take on these AI billionaires and that we are going to be for very strong rules and that we won't be cowed And that debate has been ongoing, but I think it's time for us to be clear in time for the midterm elections. That's my ask. And people have not yet openly disagreed here

Speaker 3with me on that point. But I understand, as I said earlier, that there are people in the consultant class, more establishment people who are driven by fear of money being dumped into the elections. But I am much more afraid of allowing a future where where the unemployment rate goes up to 10%, or as some of these AI billionaires have talked about, going up to Great Depression levels, closer to 20%. I'm way more scared of that than taking on the AI money in the elections.

Speaker 2Before I let you go, let me just ask you about the midterms, right? We have obviously seen data centers, even if you go back to the off-year elections and see how elections turned in Virginia on the data center issue, If you look at where AI ranks in voters' concerns, you have an unpopular war, a president with extremely low approval ratings. Where do you put AI in the kind of list of priorities that Democrats should be messaging on

Speaker 2as we head toward the midterms?

Speaker 3AI and data centers in particular is going to play a role in the midterm elections. But I think it's going to move way up the rankings of important issues as it comes to the 2028 presidential election. And so right now we should be talking about how Trump is not only corrupt, he's deeply corrupt on AI issues.

Speaker 4So you guys got to make a decision about who's going to take that money.

Speaker 3I think we should be very clear that we aren't taking, we should not take leading the future's money. We should do to leading the future what we've been doing to AIPAC to say, these are essentially right wing money machines. And we should say, No, we will not accept support from leading the future, just like I've been urging folks to not accept support from AIPAC because ultimately their goals are not aligned with the goals of the vast majority of the American people, and they want Donald Trump to win.

Speaker 3And so I think that data centers will be a major issue in many of these midterm elections, but taking on AI oligarchs who are trying to make us less safe, less free, less employed will be a really top issue in the next presidential election. So I'm letting anybody know that is thinking about running for president that they should very seriously be thinking about how to make sure people still have their jobs, still have their safety, still have their freedoms, despite what the AI oligarchs want.

Speaker 4Congressman Greg Kassar, thank you so much for your time.

Speaker 3Thanks a bunch.

Speaker 2Greg Kassar represents Texas's 35th congressional district in the House of Representatives.

Speaker 4And that is our show for today.

Speaker 2What Next is produced by Rob Gunther, Evan Campbell, Madeline Thames-Ducharme, and Patrick Fort. Paige Osborne is the senior supervising producer of What Next and What Next TBD. Mia Lobel is the executive producer of podcasts here at Slate. And Ben Richmond is the senior director of podcast operations.

Speaker 4I'm Lizzie O'Leary.

Speaker 2In for Mary Harris. You can track me down on Blue Sky. I'm at Lizzie O'Reilly.

Speaker 4Thanks so much for listening. Talk to you soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Grand Theft Article

    Nov 19, 202639 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! The New York Times and other publishers are suing OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement, claiming the companies built AI tools like ChatGPT by feeding them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Is This a Psyop?

    Nov 12, 202628 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Mixed in with the beauty and Love Island videos on producer Tracie Hunte’s TikTok feed, she started seeing clips that seemed to pit Black people against one another....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Talented Ms. Goldiee (Listener's Choice Winner in the Signal Awards)

    Nov 5, 202627 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! When a promising young freelancer pitched a good story to his magazine, editor Nicholas Hune-Brown was ready to assign it. But as he looked more closely at the pitch and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Lying Mouth Slays the Soul

    Oct 29, 202648 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Lying is the force that is most diametrically opposed to journalism. So why has it been so hard for journalists to combat it? Earlier this month, Brian was asked to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Republican Takes On Her Party Over Voter Data

    Oct 22, 202631 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Voting in this year’s midterms is already underway. And for the past year leading up to this election, the Trump administration has been pushing to get its hands on every...

    Credit the people on this episode