Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Question Everything

Question Everything artwork

The Lying Mouth Slays the Soul

Oct 29, 202648 minAudio

Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Lying is the force that is most diametrically opposed to journalism. So why has it been so hard for journalists to combat it? Earlier this month, Brian was asked to deliver a treatise on this question to an audience of journalists, and writing it took him in a bunch of directions he didn’t expect: from a school playground to ancient religious texts to Alex Jones. Afterwards, people kept saying that we had to run it on Question Everything. Here it is. Question Everything is a production of KCRW and Placement Theory. Follow us on Instagram: @questionverything.podcast. And don’t forget to sign up for our newsletter.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I began this festival asking the question of how we are to get along in this new media landscape. The other week, I was asked to give a speech to close out a three-day audio festival in Richmond, Virginia, called Resonate. The organizer of the conference is a philosopher named Chioki Ianson. He and I chat now and again about the nature of truth and facts, and as I guess philosophers tend to do, other big epistemological questions. The theme of the

Speaker 1festival this year was press, and it was filled with people from the podcasting and public radio worlds offering their diagnoses for what has gone wrong with our media and ideas for how we might fix it. And Chioki asked me if I'd deliver a treatise at the festival. That was his assignment for me. What have I learned reporting on the press and on truth for Question Everything over two years? And could I tell the audience of journalists what I thought we should all be doing? So I gave it a go. And as I put this together,

Speaker 1I found myself heading down paths that I hadn't expected, reading old texts on the subject of dishonesty and, as you'll hear, studying one of journalism's most divisive words. I hadn't been sure we'd run this talk I thought maybe it would be too inside baseball. But afterwards, people kept coming up to me saying, you have to share this on Question Everything. Maybe part of the reason it landed with the audience is that the midterm elections are here. We're about to get a sense of what direction the country wants to head in for the final years of

Speaker 1the Trump era. And it feels like an apt moment as journalists to reflect, how has our work risen to the moment? When has it fallen short? And how can we best serve the public moving forward? So here it is. my keynote speech from the Resonate Podcast Festival just a couple weeks ago in Richmond. Earlier this year, my daughter, who was five then, she just turned six a few weeks ago, came home from the playground and she asked

Speaker 1me a question. She said, Daddy, is Zoran Mamdani evil? Where'd you hear that, baby? She said that her friend... had told her on the playground I started thinking about parents and kind of what I might be learning about their politics you know via one of these playground games of telephone via our kids my daughter then said I heard if you look at Zoramamdani your eyes will fall out oh I said his skin is also poison she

Speaker 1said also Zoramamdani is orange why is he orange she asked And then I realized what might be going on, and I said, wait, do you mean Donald Trump? And she was like, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, that's the one I mean. Donald Trump, is he evil? And I thought about this for a second, and I told her, it depends how you define evil, but Donald Trump does lie

Speaker 1a lot. Why does he lie a lot, she asked. Because it helps him get what he wants, I told her. And she thought about that for a moment. And then she asked, if you look Donald Trump in the eyes, will your eyes fall out? And I told her, I don't know. I've never met him in person. We'd have to test it. And then just to kind of clarify things, I told her, you know, Zohra Mamdani is the mayor of New York, our city. Donald Trump is the president.

Speaker 1He's the president, she said? Who made him the president? I said the majority of people in America voted him president. They chose him. Her mouth was agape. Why did they choose a liar to be president? Pretty good question. One of those good incisive ones that can only come from a kid. Why did we elect a liar as president? When Chioki asked me to do this talk, his instruction

Speaker 1to me was, be occupationally self-reflective. And this conversation I recently had with my kid, it got me focused on lying in ways that I normally wouldn't think about it. The act of it, the history of it, the etymology of the word, the psychology of lying, the experience of it, the experience of doing it and having it done to you and about you, and the way journalists have dealt with it and failed to deal with it. Lying is the force that is most diametrically opposed to journalism, and

Speaker 1yet we have done an awful job combating it. Why has this been so hard for us, and how can we do better? And that's what I want to talk about and consider here with you all, because the issues plaguing the press that have been discussed these last few days, from the decimation of local journalism, to the power bias, to how to deliver truth in different ways that lands with people, what shot through all of it and what we have to contend with is the proliferation and power and lack of accountability for lying that is so toxic right now. And yet, it is still really rare to

Speaker 1hear the word lie in regular mainstream news coverage. When I was coming up in public radio at NPR and member stations and later at This American Life, I don't think I was ever taught explicitly not to use the word lie, but I certainly picked up the message or the gist somehow that you weren't supposed to. And I didn't really question it. There were other words you were supposed to use instead, journalist-y words. So for instance, before he was even running for president, when Donald Trump would lie over many years about Barack Obama not being born in America, NPR would not say Trump was lying. Instead,

Speaker 1NPR's reporters said Trump was stirring the pot. Or he had.

Speaker 2Revived questions about the president's place of birth.

Speaker 1Birtherism was a conspiracy, a claim, a controversy, a falsehood, an issue, but never a lie. Even after Trump admitted in 2016, despite years of pushing this claim, that Obama was born in the United States, and the New York Times even finally referred to Trump's claim as a lie for the first time, NPR would not. What they opted for at that moment instead was the most preposterous falsehood anyone has attempted to peddle in our political life, which is a whole lot of words to avoid saying the word lie. Compare that to how we used to treat liars.

Speaker 1We used to stone them, give them leprosy, cast them into a lake of fire, throw them off a rock in Rome, even pull their tongues out. Trump got called preposterous, got a bunch of attention, and was elected president. Looking back on it, I think the birther lie was a trial balloon for Trump. He saw what level of bullshit he was able to get away with and how meekly the press would respond. NPR, aside from being the spiritual

Speaker 1forebear to many of us in here, if not some of your current employer, was emblematic of this approach. In fact, as Trump was running for president in 2016, NPR went so far as to publish a policy in writing about how they would not use the word lie. They were proud of it. They wore it as a badge of their journalism. In order to use the word lie, an NPR journalist would have to get special approval from a small group of top editors, I don't know if Trump read this policy, but the message was certainly out there

Speaker 1that he would not be easily called a liar in the press or face consequences for it. On his first full day in office, January 21st, 2017, Trump went to CIA headquarters and told three lies in the same appearance. He claimed his beef with the intelligence community at that time was the media's fault, not his. According to NPR's then national security correspondent, Mary Louise Kelly, that was. He said there were upwards of a million and a half people at his inauguration when there were more like 250,000.

Speaker 2Mary Louise reported, Trump falsely inflated the size of the crowd at his inauguration.

Speaker 1And Trump told the CIA employees that when he'd begun to speak at his inauguration, the rain had stopped immediately.

Speaker 2Mary Louise reported, In fact, you could see water beating on the lapel of his coat.

Speaker 1But she never said he was lying. And at this point, listeners were furious. Hundreds of people wrote the public editor after Mary Louise Kelly's report saying they were shocked, appalled, horrified by NPR's cowardice. Those are all words from listeners. So NPR went on the air and did a segment to explain their reasoning.

Speaker 4President Trump made a string of statements at the CIA over the weekend, but Mary Louise did not use the word lie. And many listeners asked why.

Speaker 1Mary Louise, what exactly did people ask you?

Speaker 2Why are you pussyfooting around? Why not just say he lied?

Speaker 1Just to be clear, pussyfooting was a phrase that someone used.

Speaker 2A direct quote that I think a couple of people tweeted at me.

Speaker 1Okay, why not say he lied?

Speaker 2So this has prompted me to go actually look up the word lie in the Oxford English Dictionary. And here's the definition.

Speaker 1I'll read it.

Speaker 2A false statement made with intent to deceive. Intent being the key word there. Without the ability to peer into Donald Trump's head, I can't tell you what his intent was. I can tell you what he said and how that squares or doesn't with facts.

Speaker 1This rationale is not new. I'm sure most of you have heard it before. It's not only at NPR. It's the rationale I internalized early on. And it has some logic. Lying is normal. done on purpose, so we have to have evidence that the person knew what they said was false and said it anyway in order to factually call it a lie. But sometimes in an effort to be precise, you can end up going all the way back around to being not precise at all. Like, sure, you don't

Speaker 1technically know if Trump remembered that it was him who started the beef with the CIA. So instead of saying he's telling a lie, you end up saying something like this.

Speaker 4Let's talk about what to call a fact that is not a fact.

Speaker 1That is something NPR actually said in that segment about the CIA appearance. I find it incredible. A fact that is not a fact. I love you, NPR. but that is not a paragon of clarity, which is one of the standards of NPR's journalism. If it's not a fact, why are we introducing it as one to say it's not? There is an element of farce when you listen back to NPR's coverage from this time. And it's not just NPR, but here we are at an audio conference. In Trump's first term, I picture a bunch of characters from like an Armando Iannucci episode tripping over each other, trying to

Speaker 1come up with every euphemism they can to avoid saying the word lie.

Speaker 5Call it a deception, an evasion, a technical nicety. NPR will not call it a lie.

Speaker 1So this is the first produced segment in which an NPR journalist used the word lie with official top brass approval to refer to the Trump administration. It was media correspondent David Folkenflik who filed a piece about Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen denying the existence of a policy to separate immigrant kids from their families. David believed there was evidence that Nielsen intended to speak an untruth, so he wanted to use the word lie. And he told me this kicked off a heated debate at the highest levels

Speaker 1of the NPR newsroom. The piece was held for 48 hours over this, while they hashed out whether he should be allowed to say lie. Ultimately, he got approval to do it, but there were some conditions. He had to make clear he wasn't speaking for NPR when he used the word, and he couldn't sign off the normal way, you know, like David Folkenflik, NPR News. Here's what he ultimately said.

Speaker 5Call it a deception, an evasion, a technical nicety. NPR will not call it a lie because it cannot gauge Nielsen's intent. I don't set NPR policy, but I'd say the word lie fits. But what you call it almost doesn't matter. It's that the media and the public register a fundamental fact. Top people speaking for the United States aren't telling the truth, starting with the president.

Speaker 1I'm David Folkenflik. I'm sorry, but I don't know how it almost doesn't matter what you call it. What he wanted to call the statement launched a massive controversy in the newsroom. He was forced to strip his NPR affiliation from his sign-off because he used the word lie. What he called it clearly mattered. I also just want to note here that this question of whether a lie remains a lie if the teller believes it, which apparently is the subject of that Nathan Fielder documentary, which I've not

Speaker 1been able to see because I've been at this... Haven't been able to see it because I've been at this fucking conference, but anyway. I think there is latitude in various definitions of the word lie where intent to deceive is not always strictly necessary, if you look at the definitions. I think, for instance, of someone who says that a certain race is inferior. They may believe that, but it's still a fucking lie. As a kicker to all this.

Speaker 1When my fact checker reached out to NPR to confirm that David's story was indeed the first time an NPR journalist said that the Trump administration had lied, this is what the PR person responded. What David is saying is somewhat true, but perhaps not literally. That came from a news organization PR person on the record. I think what all this means is that this is evidence this was not a coherent policy. It was a policy driven by fear,

Speaker 1which I do get. Calling somebody a liar, through much of history, that kind of shit would land you in a duel. These days, it'll land you in a lawsuit sometimes. The 1908 edition of the Oxford English Dictionary includes a special note under the definition of lie. It says, the word is normally a violent expression of moral reprobation, which in polite conversation tends to be avoided. The synonyms falsehood and untruth being often substituted as relatively euphemistic. So I've

Speaker 1been part of plenty of editorial conversations where you're worried about the blowback if you call someone out for lying. I'm not going to say I've always decided to use the word. And even when we do use the word and decide to go through with it, I think our medium, audio, allows you to hear that fearfulness or at least cautiousness that we're pushing through to do it. So this is just another little moment from 2017 in a two-way Lulu Garcia Navarro was talking about Trump's claim about his inauguration being the biggest ever. And she said off the cuff, I think.

Speaker 6We should say here, Mara, that that was a.

Speaker 1Lie, essentially. You can hear her hesitate there before saying the word. And then she adds the qualifier, a lie, essentially. And, you know, I noticed myself doing something similar in a live onstage interview just a few months ago. I was asking former MAGA influencer Ashley St. Clair about her old tweets. In 2024, you posted kind of pushing the lie that the 2020 election was stolen from Donald Trump. I said the word. It was accurate. But I can hear myself wavering there, kind of stammering a bit. Am I really

Speaker 1going to say this violent expression of moral reprobation to this person's face? What will she do? How will the audience react? Chioki opened the conference by saying our current challenge with the truth feels biblical, and he's right. There's something old and primal at play here with lying. Even my five-year-old has an instinctive reaction to it. Why did we elect a liar? And that's what makes it fraught to accuse somebody of lying, but it's also what makes it fraught to not accuse somebody when it's pretty clear

Speaker 1they're doing it. Not lying is one of the Ten Commandments, for Christ's sakes. In the Bible, the devil is the father of lies. In Islam, if you lie, you're condemned to hellfire. In Judaism, lying lips are an abomination. In Zoroastrianism, the word for lie encompasses the entire concept of evil, the word for lie. Humans have recognized from really early on that lying is incredibly corrosive and threatening to the social fabric and have really tried to discourage people from doing it. And modern studies back this up. They show

Speaker 1that lies can decreased people's willingness to vaccinate. They've driven people to participate in genocide. They've degraded trust in institutions like ours, journalism and governments and health authorities. They've led to an insurrection. And all of that is not to mention the toll that lies take on our spirit as individuals. All right, we're going to take a quick break here and then continue with the speech in a minute. Before

Speaker 1we pick back up with my treatise on lying, I do want to say I was speaking to a room with a lot of current and former NPR journalists, myself included. My work has been shaped heavily by NPR. So to be occupationally self-reflective, I used NPR as my case study. But my critique could have been about any number of major U.S. news outlets, from The New York Times to The Post to The Journal. all of whom made similar choices about using the word lie, particularly in the first Trump term. The reluctance to use it persists. Just the

Speaker 1other day, the Times ran a fact-check article I saw all about Trump's false claims regarding the upcoming elections that used the word falsehoods in the headline instead of lies. NPR did start using the word lie more over the years, specifically in the weeks after the 2020 presidential election, when Trump began lying that it was stolen from him, and also during the 2024 election when Trump, J.D. Vance, and others were spreading lies about Haitians in Ohio eating pets and also about FEMA disaster relief after Hurricane Helene. In

Speaker 1speaking to NPR journalists after my talk, some people said they still have the sense that they're supposed to steer clear of the word lie and do. Others told me they've used the word without getting special approval and without incident. As NPR's public editor said to me in an email, NPR is very much a group of individual products that do not move in unison on an issue like this. A longtime former NPR staffer who was involved in enforcing the lie policy said that they still feel, as they did back in 2016, that the word lie is divisive, and they would look for more thorough ways to describe

Speaker 1someone's actions that didn't speak to intent, let the listeners draw their own conclusions, and that any editor or reporter covering politics and D.C. was aware to not use the word lie except on very rare occasions. To their knowledge, the policy was never updated after 2017. I asked NPR if there's been a formal change in the policy since then, but they didn't respond. Okay, here's the rest of my talk. If you start digging into the history of lying, you're going to end up spending some time with this guy, one of the OG thinkers about it, St. Augustine. Augustine

Speaker 1was haunted by lying. He spent years studying it. He wrote two treatises on it in the fourth and fifth centuries. To him, lying was so troubling because the lying mouth slays the soul. There's a serious moral injury that results from lying that you don't have to be religious to recognize, I think. I have this kind of, I don't know, I guess I'd say like a journalistic pet topic. I'm really interested in people who believed political lies, but then changed their minds to accept the truth. They're not easy

Speaker 1to find, these people, but when we do, we try to tell their stories on our show, question everything. And it's in talking to them and hearing from them that's given me more of an appreciation, I think, for the destructive, but often internal and unspoken and hard-to-put-your-finger-on ways that lies affect us. So just... One example, this woman my producer and I met at the Iowa State Fair last year named Kate. Kate grew up believing that the Sandy Hook school shooting was a hoax. Her dad was a big

Speaker 1Alex Jones listener who pushed that and right after the shooting happened, he told her it wasn't real, that it was a staged event with actors meant to justify gun control. Kate was 14 and she believed this for years until one day during a seminar in college when her professor had their class do an exercise about Sandy Hook on the anniversary.

Speaker 3That day was just like, Hey, today's the anniversary of, of Sandy Hook. And I think we had probably a journal prompt of like, what are your thoughts on this? And I'm thinking to myself, I'm like, wow, everyone around me is, you know, profusely writing and like some are even getting teary eyed. And then we talk about it and I'm like, I've written nothing down. I don't, know what to feel. And then we all spoke about it

Speaker 3and I had to share like with my partner. I was like, I am realizing right now.

Speaker 7That this is real.

Speaker 3I like very scaredly shared that to my class. I was like, you guys, like, I don't feel anything right now. Like as you're all like very emotional, like I feel nothing.

Speaker 2That night for sure.

Speaker 3I felt really distracted with it. I looked up like Sandy Hook stuff and tried to see videos again in a new light from the news of like, you know, did this look like it was fake in any sort of way that I would have thought, you know, these people are acting funny and these are actors. And it was like, no, these people are clearly grieving their children and like loved ones and still just like feeling guilty that I didn't feel anything while reading about it, and

Speaker 3even to this day. I mean, I have to, like, force myself to feel something for this day. No other school shootings do I feel that way, you know. But still, Sandy Hook, in my brain, I have to actively be like, this was real.

Speaker 1People died.

Speaker 7It was bad.

Speaker 1Like, feel something.

Speaker 5Feel something.

Speaker 1You're poking your head right now.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 1Feel something, brain.

Speaker 7Mm-hmm.

Speaker 3Because, I mean, I'm a very emotional person, and every time I hear about a school shooting now, especially when it's, you know, little kids like that, it's heartbreaking.

Speaker 1It's gut-wrenching.

Speaker 3It has me, you know, posting on my social media and, like, calling for gun reform and has me wondering, when will it be enough? Yet that one, you know, was so terrible, but I didn't feel that way yet. and that.

Speaker 1It still is just this like hole.

Speaker 3I felt so ashamed.

Speaker 1Alex Jones's lie about the Sandy Hook families had lots of very tangible dark effects. People who believe this harassed the families of the kids who were killed for years, tortured them online, threatened to kill them, accosted them in person on the street. Some of these families had to go into hiding. This is while they were grieving the worst tragedy imaginable. One father said the lie made his life a living hell. In Kate's case, she didn't do anything outwardly harmful because she believed this lie, but she was harmed by it. It cauterized her ability to care

Speaker 1about other people, which she feels is an essential part of her. The lie robbed her of part of her humanity. This is what lies do, lies about immigrants being dangerous or Jews infiltrating or all Palestinians being terrorists. They at best erode empathy and at worst stir hate. And it has real political effects. With Kate, it prevented her from taking action in favor of gun control that she believes she would have otherwise taken had she known the truth. I think by avoiding the word lie and putting it

Speaker 1behind this break only in case of emergency glass, journalists, we've allowed ourselves to avoid truly engaging with the moral and emotional dimensions of being lied to or lied about or lied in front of. And when we do that, it's like a signal to people that we just aren't in touch with reality. So many of us are living with the experience of feeling manipulated if we believed a lie or feeling disrespected if we were lied to but knew it was happening or living with the implications of being lied about, like being deported or attacked or having

Speaker 1your rights stripped away. I don't think a falsehood achieves those ends, or an unfounded claim, or a baseless conspiracy, which are the terms news outlets like NPR use to describe Jones's poisonous bullshit for a decade. A lie does that. And what gives the lie its unique power is exactly the thing that a lot of us as journalists say stops us from using the word, intent. This wasn't some passive fiction floating on the breeze like a spore that

Speaker 1landed on Kate. It was a story created and given velocity and power by human beings, people like Alex Jones who knew it wasn't true and were wielding it to gain something. St. Augustine had a name for what we're referring to as intent behind a lie. He called it valentis falendi, the will to deceive. For Augustine, this is what makes a lie so wicked, not the falsity of the statement, but the human will to deceive another human

Speaker 1that drives the false statement. And if you read Augustine's essay on lying, it's really interesting. You see him wrestling through every different possible permutation there might be of the reason for a lie and the impact the lie had. And he's kind of wondering, are any of these justified? And then ranking them from worst to bad. So there's lies against God, a lie meant to hurt somebody but with no clear benefit to the liar, a lie that hurts somebody that does benefit the liar, A lie somebody just tells because they get a kick out of lying,

Speaker 1I guess. A lie somebody tells at a party to flatter somebody with small talk, that's one. And then a so-called noble lie, a lie that's intended to help somebody with little harm. And these are all still sins to Augustine. After kind of really thinking through it, he decides that lying is never OK. But what I got from this, like the point, is that he cares about the why behind the lie. He wants to understand the liar's intent and their motive. It's an essential part of understanding the lie. And I think that's just a natural thing to wonder about.

Speaker 1Why is somebody lying to me? Why is somebody lying about me? I hear from people a lot when I talk to them. Kate brought it up about the Sandy Hook lie.

Speaker 3Why would Alex Jones make that whole thing up?

Speaker 1Why would he do that? Well, he was making a lot of money off of it.

Speaker 7Right.

Speaker 1It's such a simple thing actually when you think about it. Like it was the first thing my kid asked when I told her the president lies a lot, why? That's the human part of this that I think we leave out when we pussyfoot around a lie. And it gets to something bigger than a word choice. I think it points towards maybe a way, and I'll just put it out there for you guys who see what you think, that we can start reconceiving of our jobs. So in that 2017 NPR segment where Mary Louise Kelly outlined her reasoning for not saying that Donald Trump had lied to the CIA, She was joined by Michael Oreskes, who was

Speaker 1the senior VP of News. And on the air, he laid out a vision of what journalists do. It's worth noting that several years after this, Michael Oreskes was asked to resign after repeated allegations that he'd sexually harassed women. And in speaking to NPR's investigators, depending on your definition of the word, he arguably lied about the extent of his misconduct. But here on NPR's air, he talked about how using the word lie, in his view, was actually antithetical to our job as journalists. And what he said

Speaker 1here was also written down in NPR's formal guidance.

Speaker 6Our job as journalists is to report, to find facts, establish their authenticity, and share them with everybody. And I think that when you use words like lie, it gets in the way of that. And it's really important that people understand that these aren't our opinions. These aren't just thoughts we happen to have. These are things we've established through our journalism, through our reporting. And I don't want to do anything that gets in the way of people seeing that reporting. And I think the minute you start branding things with a word like lie, you push people

Speaker 6away from you.

Speaker 1It's ironic that in a statement where Oreskes is saying he wants people to know that journalists aren't just spewing our opinions and thoughts, as far as I can tell, This is a pure opinion about the effect of the word lie. I found no research to back this assertion up, that the word lie pushes people away. I asked NPR if they know of any research that does. They didn't point me to anything. I think this is more a reflection of fear than anything of alienating hypothetical listeners. When in reality, there is research showing that if you know somebody is trying to deceive you, that can be really

Speaker 1impactful information. That knowledge plays a role in how you think about the source and whether to trust them. There was this experiment from scientists at Boston College, researchers told participants a fact. So in this case, the fact was a journalist learned that 463 people attended a local politician's campaign rally. And the people who were told that the journalist's intent was to deceive them were three times more likely to consider the report false. Which is telling, but

Speaker 1it's also kind of a duh finding. It doesn't feel like rocket science that being told that someone is trying to deceive you and why they're trying to deceive you will probably make you trust them less. People care about this. They care about intent. They care about the why. So what if we reoriented and refocused our journalism around that? I know that NPR and probably others have said that they can't know Donald Trump or any subject's intent because they can't peer inside their head. But I disagree. Intent

Speaker 1and motive are reportable. They're part of legal cases all the time, and this can be a more regular part of journalism. Decades before he was president, Trump explained his philosophy about lying in The Art of the Deal. He said this. He said, I call it truthful hyperbole. It's an innocent form of exaggeration and a very effective form of promotion. And people reported on this passage in his first presidency. But just imagine, what if it was mentioned every time NPR was covering Trump's claim that the inauguration

Speaker 1crowd was five times the size it was. You'd report that the number was wrong, sure, but the report could be more tuned to this, reminding listeners every time of his stated intent to deceive them. Or here, in 2018, Leslie Stahl from 60 Minutes explained to a room of journalists at a conference kind of like this one that Trump told her directly why he bashed the media so much and spread lies Like we're the enemy of the people.

Speaker 8And it's just me and my boss and him. He has a huge office. And he's attacking the press. And there were no cameras. There was nothing going on. And I said, you know, that is getting tired. Why are you doing this? You're doing it over and over, and it's boring, and it's time to end that. You've won the nomination. And why do you keep hammering at this? And he said, you know why I do it? I do it to discredit you all and demean you all so when you write negative stories about me, no one

Speaker 8will believe you. Is that that? So put that in your head for a minute.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 8Now are we ready for questions?

Speaker 2We're all absorbing what you just said.

Speaker 1Tons of respect for Leslie Stahl, but I do find it frustrating that she's sharing that two years after the fact at a conference of just journalists. It's something only we would care about. What if she, just imagine this, leaned into that admission from Trump at the time and treated it like a scoop, reported it right then, big story, 60-minute style, Trump admits he trashes the press to trick you into not believing the truth. She could have pushed Trump to address it on camera, made it a regular part of 60 minutes coverage of him every time he lied about the press, explained this is why he was

Speaker 1doing it. Ruth Ben-Ghiat, the expert on authoritarianism, has a phrase she uses to describe something I think similar to what I'm talking about here. It's a tactic for journalists to use with authoritarian liars. She calls it expose the device. She advises journalists not to get in too much of a back and forth with a liar over facts. You should state the facts, obviously, but then focus on drawing out and articulating clearly the reason for the lie. What

Speaker 1purpose does the lie serve? And what are the mechanics behind how the lie is being manufactured and spread. An example of this happened when Dana Bash was interviewing JD Vance on CNN a few days after he spread the lie on TV that Haitians in Ohio were eating domestic pets. For more than 10 minutes, Dana Bash and JD Vance play fact tennis over whether or not those claims are real. And JD Vance, as he does, kind of very smoothly dips and dodges and bats her fact checks away until finally he lets this slip.

Speaker 9Kamala Harris let criminal migrants into this country who then murdered their children. The American media totally ignored this stuff until Donald Trump and I started talking about cat memes.

Speaker 1If I have to, if I have to.

Speaker 9Create stories so that the American media actually pays attention to the suffering of the American people, then that's what I'm going to do, Dana, because you guys are completely letting Kamala Harris coast.

Speaker 1That's the device exposed. He reveals the purpose of the lie. He says he makes up stories and, to get the media to pay attention to what he wants them to pay attention to. And to think there's a problem in Ohio with Haitians. You can feel how that moment lands differently than the straight up fact checking. Interestingly, Dana never used the word lie in this segment, which was like 15, 20 minutes. And I think that's kind of instructive. I personally think we should use the word lie more when it's accurate. But being real, I don't think news organizations

Speaker 1are really gonna start doing this in any meaningful way soon. And even if they did, That change alone wouldn't be enough. I think reporting on the intent and motives of the people using lies and deception to benefit themselves and hurt others, that's what's most important. So I think if we were to make that one of our core missions as journalists, it could make a real difference without requiring us to use the word lie all the time. Exposing the device, I think, is a helpful way to think about this bigger thing that I'm pushing for, which is report rigorously, clearly, relentlessly,

Speaker 1creatively about the human intent behind the lies, whatever you ultimately call them. And so I've started trying to collect little examples of this whenever I notice it. I'll just run through a few so you can keep in your head and think about how you might incorporate this in your work. This one's from Isaac Saul, who publishes a newsletter called Tangle. He wrote a very long newsletter about the propaganda film 2000 Mules by Dinesh D'Souza when it came out, which pushed a ton of lies about the 2020 election being rigged. And this is all the fact check.

Speaker 1This is a very, very, very, very, very long fact check of all the claims in the movie. But at the end of it, Isaac really interestingly includes this section. He writes, I've learned over the years that identifying motives is often the best way to accurately suss out what is going on. And then he outlines for his readers what D'Souza and others involved in the film stood to gain from pushing the election lies. Millions of dollars, maybe a pardon. And I think this is a good example because my team and I actually know it worked. Our producer, Zach St. Louis, who's here, interviewed multiple conservative readers of

Speaker 1Tangle who believed the 2020 election was stolen from Donald Trump, who then read Isaac's reporting and came to realize it wasn't true. One of them specifically said he believed the claims in this movie, 2000 Mules, until he read this newsletter post and realized the filmmakers were lying to him. And just one more that I kind of find creatively inspiring. This is from one of the most legendary investigative reporters of our era, I'd say, Barton Gelman, who brought us the Edward Snowden leaks. In the fall of 2020, as

Speaker 1the presidential election approached, Barton saw what a lot of us were seeing. Trump was lying repeatedly about the integrity of the election system, saying that mail-in voting was rigged. And Barton published a cover story in The Atlantic where he reported out the future. He reported... that Donald Trump's intent in spewing these lies was so that he could refuse to give out power. And it's an incredible story. I don't know if you've read it. He talks to election officials and experts around the country, and he reports

Speaker 1out in the future what will happen as a result of the election lies. He even in that story predicts January 6th as a day that would likely explode in chaos and threaten the transfer of power. And the story may have my favorite nut graph ever, Let us not hedge about one thing. Donald Trump may win or lose, but he will never concede, not under any circumstance. If compelled in the end to vacate his office, Trump will insist from exile as long as he draws breath that the contest was rigged. Maybe you hesitate. Is it a

Speaker 1fact that if Trump loses, he will reject defeat come what may? Do we know that? Technically, you feel obliged to point out the proposition is framed in the future conditional and prophecy is no man's gift and so forth. With all due respect, that is pedophagy. We know this man. We can't afford to pretend. He got the word pedophagy into that nut graph, among everything else. I asked Barton what it felt like to write this. He wrote this, I believe it was like September before the election in November,

Speaker 1before January 6th. How did it feel at that point to report that statement as fact?

Speaker 7So, of course, my editors interrogated that. They did?

Speaker 1Okay, I was wondering, yeah. Tell me about the reaction of your editors.

Speaker 7Don't we want to say unlikely to?

Speaker 1He's unlikely to concede.

Speaker 7Yes. Or there's a risk. And I said, no, it's actually really central to this story. I want to make this a flatly stated premise. This is going to happen. I make a prediction. I believe it is bulletproof. But obviously, it's not literally possible for me to know this now. But let's just suppose this is true. Then what?

Speaker 1Did it feel like you were kind of innovating a bit? Or did it feel like a moment in your career where you were taking a bit of a leap?

Speaker 7It did. I'd never done something like this before. It was not, strictly speaking, traditional kind of evidence-based journalism. But I thought as a story device, it was essential to raise the alarm the way I thought it needed to be raised.

Speaker 1We have to be creative like this. And I think all of us can do this. That's what I find energizing about this approach. It's nimble and expansive. It's really a way that you can start thinking about every aspect of how we do our work, from story choice to interview questions to writing to business strategy of a media outlet. Whether we work in an old school newsroom or independent or if you're a student or if you're doing yaps on TikTok, you can find ways, big and small, to focus on the human intent. And if you work in

Speaker 1an outlet that's tough and they won't let you call a lie a lie, that's okay. I think you can still get these moves past your editors. All right, before we go, I know I'm the last one speaking here and everyone's tired, but as the final presenter at this conference about the many threats that face the press and democracy and truth itself right now, I feel a bit of an obligation to say this. None of what I just mentioned will be enough to save us. New interview tactics, crafty nut graphs, the most aggressive investigative reporting in the

Speaker 1world even will not be enough. I don't think anything I've heard these three days alone will be enough from every amazing presenter who's thinking hard about this. If we want to preserve a free press and a free society, I'm convinced we're going to have to like really reconceive of our jobs in like the biggest sense possible. We're going to have to do things that many of us are not used to doing as journalists, things that make us uncomfortable. We should, for instance, be advocating for tech policy and regulation. Tech platforms are the fields where battles

Speaker 1over truth and lies are won and lost. And right now the incentives driving virality on these platforms are totally fucked and the accountability is absent. But there are humans who are designing these things. They have motives to accrete money and power. And they can be pushed to make different design choices that incentivize more reliable information and fewer lies. But it's going to take advocacy for legislation and policy change. And that is not at odds with our role as journalists. One of the journalistic icons of our time, Maria Ressa,

Speaker 1who won the Nobel Peace Prize for her journalism in the Philippines, has been banging on this drum for years trying to warn the US and other countries that unregulated tech platforms are misinforming the public driving a rise in authoritarianism, and we need to be following her lead. Also, I think as an industry, we should be working on large-scale litigation strategies. Defamation law is being used against us to suppress public interest reporting, but defamation law can also be used for good to punish lying and incentivize truth-telling, and

Speaker 1I think there are creative ways we could be a part of that. There are some very novel Cases right now, for instance, where people are suing AI companies for their chatbots lying about them. And the companies are claiming that the chatbots can't defame them because there's no human intent. But humans control this technology. I don't think we can afford to sit on the sidelines and just document these cases. We should figure out ways to get involved. Maybe we scout plaintiffs. Maybe we raise legal funds. Maybe some of us who are defamed on these platforms become plaintiffs ourselves.

Speaker 1We need to make these companies liable for their defamatory lies. And that, hopefully, can do some part to force them to be designed to prioritize facts. We also need to be inventing new products and technology ourselves. Our show just got pitched a partnership with NewsGuard, which has created a news-based AI chat bot that relies on vetted sources. And it pays those sources when their information is used by the bot. This is DebunkBot, which we've reported on, which was created by researchers at Cornell, psychology researchers, to convince people out of conspiracy theories. There are also a bunch

Speaker 1of journalists doing interesting things who are trying to make entirely new social media platforms based not around rage and engagement, but discourse and reliable news. If you have skills like this, I don't, but entrepreneurship, engineering, a psych background, really consider how you might use those and apply them to support the truth. And then lastly, we need to be thinking as creatively about the media business as we are about the editorial, and I think raising capital to make meaningful moves. Um, what I find most inspiring kind of in that realm

Speaker 1right now is the onion. Um, lots of, you know, this, I'm sure, you know, the onion came up with this ingenious way to buy Alex Jones's Infowars media company out of bankruptcy, which it was in because the Sandy hook families he defamed had sued him for over a billion dollars. Um, the onion raised money from a gun control nonprofit. got the buy-in of the affected Sandy Hook families, bought InfoWars

Speaker 1at auction, making sure the money would go to the families because Alex Jones is not paying them currently, hasn't paid them a dime. And it's not always been smooth. They've had to fight lots of legal shenanigans. There's been delays. You know, Jones has delayed things. But they've just started to use the channels to undermine and satirize one of the most gruesome liars out there. And their business is thriving doing it. So I think we've got to find and create more opportunities like this. You know, oligarchs aligned with the administration, are consolidating big media companies before our eyes. There are creative maneuvers out there like this that we

Speaker 1can do as journalists, independent outlets, nonprofits. Who can we buy up? Who can we partner with? Whatever a lie might be, whatever way we define it, whatever its metaphysics, we can say things very confidently about what a lie does. A road's trust pits neighbor against neighbor, abets corruption and fascism and violence, and existentially threatens our jobs as journalists. So let's start fucking acting like it. Give it up

Speaker 1for Brian Reed. Hey, yo, Brian.

Speaker 7Hey, yo, Brian, for real, for real? Yeah.

Speaker 4That's what I'm talking about.

Speaker 1Hell yeah.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 1Thank you for listening to my treatise on the nature of lies. I'm very curious to hear what you all think of this. Please let me know on Instagram at questioneverything.podcast or on Substack, questioneverything.substack.com or you can always hit me up on Signal, brihreed. 45, B-R-I-H-R-E-E-D.45. If you like this show, please rate and review us on your podcast app of choice and share it with a friend. Like right now, while I'm telling you, text it to them. My speech

Speaker 1was edited by Neil Drumming and Ted Scheinman. Robin Semien and I are the executive producers of Question Everything. Our team also includes executive editor Kevin Sullivan, producers Zach St. Louis, Sam Egan, and Tracy Hunt, contributing editor Jen Kinney, associate producer Kevin Shepard, and contributing producer Sean Cole. This episode was fact-checked by Annika Robbins. Mixing and sound design by Brendan Baker. Our music is by Matt McGinley. Abby Kwong runs our social media. Special thanks to everyone at the Resonate Podcast Festival, which was so great this year. including Andre Medina, Hannah McHugh, Hala Al-Tanawi, and of course, Chioki Ianson.

Speaker 1Thanks also to Mark and Alicia Smith, and our partners at KCRW, who include Arnie Seipel, Tejla Jamera, Natalie Hill, and Jennifer Farrow. We will see you on the other side of the midterms.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Grand Theft Article

    Nov 19, 202639 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! The New York Times and other publishers are suing OpenAI and Microsoft for copyright infringement, claiming the companies built AI tools like ChatGPT by feeding them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Is This a Psyop?

    Nov 12, 202628 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Mixed in with the beauty and Love Island videos on producer Tracie Hunte’s TikTok feed, she started seeing clips that seemed to pit Black people against one another....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Talented Ms. Goldiee (Listener's Choice Winner in the Signal Awards)

    Nov 5, 202627 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! When a promising young freelancer pitched a good story to his magazine, editor Nicholas Hune-Brown was ready to assign it. But as he looked more closely at the pitch and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A Republican Takes On Her Party Over Voter Data

    Oct 22, 202631 minAudio

    Subscribe to Question Everything (ad-free) here! Voting in this year’s midterms is already underway. And for the past year leading up to this election, the Trump administration has been pushing to get its hands on every...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The A.I. Populist

    Oct 15, 202628 minAudio

    Midterm elections are around the corner, and AI is obviously an issue that’s getting a ton of attention from candidates. There are so many thorny questions around this technology, but what do politicians intend to do...

    Credit the people on this episode