Carolyn Wilkins, former Senior Deputy Governor of the Bank of Canada joins to explain why Canada’s economy is underperforming and how inflation, interest rates, tariffs, deficits and weak investment are affecting Canadians with host Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01My name is Carolyn Wilkins. I'm an ex-central banker from the Bank of Canada.
Aaron PeteYou raised what happened during COVID during that period, having a lot of economists say we're not expecting to see any high-running inflation. We believe that this would be transitory. Did economists broadly get that wrong?
SPEAKER_01Economists, generally, not all, did get it wrong. Central banks waited too long to raise interest rates and to pair back their quantitative easing.
Aaron PeteDo you think a lot of Canada's issues are the Trump tariffs right now, or is it our own internal policies?
SPEAKER_01So clearly the Trump tariffs are bad news for Canada. It's not helpful for Canadians. It's also not helpful for the US. That being said, uh Canada has had structural deficiencies or has been punching below its weight in the economic sense.
Aaron PeteThe Prime Minister has mentioned that he doesn't think the relationship is ever going to go back to what it was. Why do you think that is?
SPEAKER_01They usually don't get unwound, and so they've gone up a lot. Maybe some of the extraordinary tariffs, the 50% would come off, but in general, I wouldn't expect the average tariff rate to come down to where it was prior.
Aaron PeteHow worried are you about where we are in terms of a potential recession? Carolyn, thank you so much for being willing to join us this morning. I'm honored to have you on the show. Would you mind briefly introducing yourself for people who might not be acquainted?
SPEAKER_01Yes, uh, my name is Carolyn Wilkins. I am currently a senior research scholar visiting at Princeton University where I teach a course on financial crises. I'm also at the Bank of England as an external member of their financial policy committee, and I am an ex-central banker from the Bank of Canada.
Aaron PeteTremendous. Well, I wanted to start with uh a low-hanging fruit question, because I find that central banks are very important to democracies, uh, particularly to the West, and yet many people don't understand what they are or how they operate. So, for someone who has never studied economics, what is a central bank? Why does it exist? And what does it actually do?
SPEAKER_01Well, the Bank of Canada was uh founded in in 1935, and the reason at the time was was a little bit different from the reason it exists today. At the time it was during the Depression, and you'll remember, historians will remember just how much pain there was in the Canadian economy and economies around the world, and so and so the Bank of Canada was was designed to provide a centralized way to provide credit to uh to the economy, including including uh agriculture and maybe particular agriculture at that time.
SPEAKER_01It's evolved to have many functions, but the one that is most front-facing for Canadians is their control of inflation and the use of the overnight policy rate to achieve that. And one of the reasons that central banks evolved to that is because history found that high and variable inflation really got in the way of economic stability, people's standard of living, and that and that committing to low and stable inflation, like the Bank of Canada does, uh, was really the best thing that a central bank could do to support the well-being of Canadians.
Aaron PeteWhen the Bank of Canada changes its interest rates, how does that decision actually affect somebody's life through their mortgage, employment, savings, or their business?
SPEAKER_01It has a number of effects. Uh so when the Bank of Canada's overnight rate changes, that induces quite a number of changes uh in the rates uh through the interest rates or borrowing rates, savings rates throughout the Canadian financial system. And the most visible way would be for uh a family that has a mortgage. And if interest rates go down and they happen to have a variable rate, well, then their variable rate on their mortgage will decline immediately.
SPEAKER_01If it's a fixed rate and it comes to term, well, then they will renew at that new rate, whether it's higher or lower. And of course, the most recent experience uh that is that interest rates have been declining. But of course, before that, after COVID, they rose quite a lot and people were and are still uh renewing at higher rates. But they affect a number of other rates in the system, what corporate borrowing might be, uh what kind of savings I get if I'm living on a fixed income and I'm a pensioner.
SPEAKER_01And overall, uh what happens in the economy is if if the bank, the central bank needs to slow the economy to get inflation down, they'll raise interest rates because overall, what that's going to do is create less consumption and investment, less economic activity, uh, which will create the space for prices to come down. Of course, the opposite is true. If if inflation is too low, then lowering interest rates will will induce more consumption, perhaps more investment, depending on the investment environment, and that will get inflation back to target.
Aaron PeteYou raised what happened during COVID, and I would just be interested in your reflections on what took place because I was in law school at the time studying tax law, and one of the first sentences in the intro of the book was when governments uh print money or or put more money into the economy, inflation can happen as a consequence of that. And during that period, I remember very vividly reading that book and then going to the TV and having a lot of economists say, we're not expecting to see any high-running inflation at any point in time.
Aaron PeteWe believe that this would be, I think they said transitory uh in nature and not last at all. And then we did see it spike significantly. And what I thought was unusual was I do think the leader of the official opposition, Pierre Polyev, called it very early on before anything was spiking. And then we saw that come in. Did economists broadly get that wrong? Or am I just remembering maybe one specific outlier case where somebody was saying that? What are your reflections on what took place during that period?
SPEAKER_01Economists generally, not all, uh did get it wrong. And not only in Canada, but in the US, the UK, and many other uh jurisdictions that experienced uh inflation. I've done a number of external reviews of central banks, including in Australia and in Sweden, and could see that there were very similar things going on. Um and I I think central banks have done some good reflection about what went wrong and how they missed it. And so if you give me a minute, I could just say that, you know, at the time when COVID hit, we knew that this would be a very different kind of event or shock than we had seen in many, many years, and perhaps since the you know the early part of the of the 20th century.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and so, and so there wasn't a lot of data to go on, but we knew that there would be really a lot of employment losses, potentially GDP would fall, and there would be downward pressure on inflation and a lot of market turmoil, which especially happened at the beginning. And so many central banks, including the Bank of Canada, and I was there at the time, uh, decided that we needed to quickly establish uh order in markets so that the financial system could put it, could do its job for Canadians and businesses.
SPEAKER_01Um and then, and then we lowered interest rates and made operations that would were intended to create a bridge to to stabilizing the economy and getting inflation back up to target. Um and so I think what I observed from from um that that situation is that the start was was fine, mostly fine, given what we knew. You got to remember playing hindsight quarterback is really easy. Um I left the bank in December 2020, and and things were still very uh very uncertain, and they were for many more months.
SPEAKER_01I think what happened in Canada and elsewhere is that these supply shocks that we saw, the the so remember, so you if you wanted the couch, you had to wait six months or longer, you couldn't find a car. These things were driving up prices in a way that economists, not just central bank economists, thought would be temporary. And that we should look through that. We shouldn't try to slow down the economy or or um slow the recovery because of a price that was not going to continue to rise.
SPEAKER_01It was it was gonna you know stabilize, then so then would inflation and it would eventually fall. As it turns out, what was wrong in many jurisdictions, as it turned out, was that these supply shocks just kept happening. Uh many, many products, broad-based products, were affected. And in fact, demand popped back much faster than expected because remember, the Canadian government was uh prioritizing um keeping people's incomes where they should be if they lost their job or to keep them in their jobs.
SPEAKER_01And so people were spending a lot of money and precisely on the goods that that um were hard to come by. So prices rose, uh central banks waited too long to raise interest rates and to pair back their quantitative easing, and and uh they had to react faster and by more than they would have otherwise because of that. Uh, these are easy lessons to talk about afterwards. At the time, I I don't want to judge, I was no longer there. I just know that what I've seen from the Bank of Canada's own uh post-mortem and from other central banks' external reviews that I've participated, there are serious lessons to be learned and and uh yeah, a little bit of humble pie.
Aaron PeteThis kind of leads into my next question, which is all of this operates somewhat outside of elected governments, right? There's supposed to be a Chinese wall or a separation between government practices and monetary policy. And I'm wondering how you think about that in light of uh President Donald Trump, who has tried to significantly influence uh the US's uh Federal Reserve and where their interest rates are. But I would also say on a much lesser, a much lesser degree, Prime Minister Mark Carney, who actually comes from being the governor uh of the Bank of Canada and moving into a role as Prime Minister, uh, and so ending up holding both roles within our society.
Aaron PeteAnd so we can say uh in earnest that we want it to be a certain way, and it has been historically a certain way, but we see two players who have kind of occupied that territory more so than we've seen historically. And I'm just wondering how you think about that.
SPEAKER_01I'm gonna start with there's a lot there. So, and it's a great question. So I'm gonna start with the fundamentals, which is what does that mean, that the Chinese wall or the the independence? And and it's very clear in my mind that independence is operational only. And by that mean, by that I mean the government, the elected government gives gives the Bank of Canada and in many other countries it's the same, either a legislated or a renewed mandate to achieve something. In our case, it's 2% inflation within one to three percent uh inflation bans.
SPEAKER_01The independence comes from saying, okay, given our tools, we are independent to move around those tools in a way that will achieve our mandated target. Okay. It doesn't mean any more than that. And on top of that, it means a lot of accountability. And so we need to be accountable to Parliament, to Canadian citizens. And I see we in a central bank way, I'm no longer at the Bank of Canada with a hard habit to drop. But we need to be accountable. So when we do well, great. When we have, when we've stumbled, we need to be accountable for that.
SPEAKER_01And and so and and I think that where um central banks have have, at least the Bank of Canada and others have done well, is to take that accountability seriously and and do the kind of building they need to do to avoid making the same mistake again. Um with respect to what's happening in the US, it's it's um I think it's I think it's legitimate for an administration and for Congress to ask questions to the Fed about what they've done and why.
SPEAKER_01And the and it's upon Congress, it is upon the Fed to respond to that seriously and openly. Where I see the trouble is when when an administration tries to direct interest rates or direct what the central bank does, whether it's the US or any other country. And that's because there's a fear that that the that the government has the wrong incentives. The US has a lot of debt. So they need to renew it at now higher interest rates. And so the worry is that the incentives of the government is to have lower interest rates, where the incentive of the central bank is to meet its target.
SPEAKER_01And and at the end of the day, it's not a question of who gets their independence and and that sort of like power play. It affects citizens because if inflation gets out of control and interest rates because bond markets react uh go up, well, it's citizens that pay that price. And so you talked about Mark Carney. I worked with Mark Carney when he was at the Bank of Canada, uh, and subsequently in International Forum when he was with the Bank of England, and uh he understands and executes central banking uh very well.
SPEAKER_01I have not, I have not witnessed, uh and this isn't to defend him or not defend him, I have not witnessed any uh misunderstanding about whose job is whose uh in in uh at all. And I think that central bankers are the first to know just how important it is to keep that separate while at the same time making sure that that the accountability and the clarity of the mandate are there so that there is trust on the part of the Canadians that unelected officials are acting on behalf of the government and are accountable for that.
Aaron PeteFascinating. I guess the only reason I ask is because I am like a like a deep fan of democracy within my community, but more broadly. And I get I think a lot about where issues arise and where citizens think they can go to. So, like the central banks can influence employment, housing prices, and the value of people's savings. And yet I don't think most people understand who operates, what are the rules, like all of these mechanisms that I think you understand in a really deep way.
Aaron PeteAnd I do think we've benefited from really good faith actors operating those positions, but we can't take that for granted, right? Like we can't assume that will continue forever. So I just wonder how you think about the democratic process when things are going like we have a housing crisis, people don't have a lot of savings, uh, things aren't working uh in our economy in terms of employment right now as well as they they have historically. And so when these things are going on, a lot of anger is being pointed at politicians, and rightfully so. But I also think that the central bank plays a role in that.
Aaron PeteNot that they don't control everything, but I don't think they participate in the conversation the same way that like we look at our elected politicians too. And many people are not coming to the debate stage to discuss monetary policy and best practice and quantitative easing and all of these things. So I just wonder like you study these and try and give central banks advice. What are your thoughts on the democratic process and and these systems?
SPEAKER_01Yes, I I would I would say three things. The first is is starting where you started, which is which is democracy is important. People need to be reform represented by elected officials. Um and in my mind, um that's kind that's just table stakes. Uh I think there is a utility to uh delegate in a very clear way, it's already done to departments, it's government departments and in other things with clear mandates and with clear expectations and accountability certain tasks because it's just not practical that politicians are gonna do all that.
SPEAKER_01They've got a lot of things on their plate that are very important. So that's that's kind of the the first set of points. The the second is is that is that Canadians are right to feel that things are not quite right. On the Canadian economy point of view, we've we've been underperforming. People talk about underperforming the US, underperforming the US. I would just say we're underperforperforming our potential given the labor, given the resources that we have, given the rule of law, we have so many advantages and we're not, we're missing the mark.
SPEAKER_01And and so and I think because of the cost of living and the other things you mentioned, yes, they are feeling uncomfortable as saying, how can this be happening? We need to be careful to understand who can achieve what. And I think over time, people have uh uh credited the central bank with more power than it actually has. Yes, in the short run, we can cause employment to go up or down and the and GDP to go up and down, but at the end of the day, or housing to be a little bit more expensive or less expensive.
SPEAKER_01But at the end of the day, the policies are in the hands of the elected officials because those are what I would call structural policies. They're tax policies, they're where they spend the money, the rules of the game that they put in place that determine how many houses get built, how long does it take to get a permit, uh, how much does it cost to get a permit? It's not just the federal government, it's all levels of government. And so if you know, sitting around the kitchen table, it's really complicated to explain who does what and who's responsible, because it looks like everybody is, and so no one is.
SPEAKER_01But the clarity that one needs to have when asking for change is to know where the responsibility lies. And I believe firmly that the responsibility for many things that we're worried about, uh, including in housing, rely lies with governments at all orders of government, uh, because the problem is supply. Uh and so, and it has been for many, many years, the problem with affordability, yes, in part it's inflation, but in part inflation is a function of our govern our economy's capacity to grow without creating inflation.
SPEAKER_01So things like labor restrictions across across provincial borders, things like um time to get a permit or time to uh or cost of getting a permit, those all add to costs that at the end of the day are paid by Canadians.
Aaron PeteJust a follow-up on that, would you be open to, so say the Liberals enter another election, and would you be open to the idea that they should tell Canadians before being elected as part of their party platform what they would give the mandate to the central bank, like what their vision of what that mandate would look like ahead of time so people can think about because as I said, that's just a piece where they are giving a mandate. I'm sure they'd think about it beforehand, but it's not something that usually reaches uh the normal. And I like maybe I'm just a nerd on these things and I'm interested in how they think about these things, but I I wonder about how they they think about that and how Canadians would be able to vote in support of one mandate or another mandate.
SPEAKER_01You know, these are these are excellent options, and and you're talking to a nerd so so um I'm happy about these questions. Uh there's more than one way to do it. Countries do this in many different ways. I happen to like how Canada does it, so let me just tell you what it is. And so, and so the mandate for the central bank is is renewed every five years. It's done with a lot of research and specific questions, interaction with academics and and and communities, and and a lot, I guess, a lot of research.
SPEAKER_01I think I might have said that twice because there is a lot of research to see what would be the economic effects of different monetary policy objectives. And that's agreed to with the governor and whoever happens to be the finance minister at the time, and obviously the finance minister gets cabinet to uh to agree. The finance minister would never do that unless unless the cabinet agreed, and it's done. Uh the reason uh that it's law, it's it's long enough to and it's not uh with an election cycle is because if you politicize uh either directly or inadvertently uh the the inflation target regime, you could cause a lot of uncertainty with investors, uh especially in the bond market, about what the rules of the game are going to be.
SPEAKER_01And so and so there is an advantage to doing it um on a cycle that's not. always um not always synchronized with with elections elections can come very quickly so do you really want every two years if there's uh that to be renewed and um and so i think that i think that it's uh it it's a really good compromise and and uh the fact that the government goes to parliament uh used to appear at parliamentary committees in the senate a couple of times a year it's a perfect opportunity to ask questions leading up to the next renewal about why is it like this why is it not another thing we did get asked questions like that like why is an inflation target 3% or why don't we have it at 0% or you know there are lots of questions that can happen that will feed into the next renewal um so you could do it as you say I think that would create unnecessary uncertainty in an economy like Canada's and I think we've benefited a lot in terms of our access to markets uh and stability of the regime that benefits Canadians in a way uh that isn't permanent in or I mean that it doesn't mean that they're locked into any particular regime you can still change it if if the economy or if circumstructural circumstances in the world mean that another regime would do better.
Aaron PeteInteresting we got to get into current politics I'm wondering I've been I've been following the bond markets just out of curiosity I wonder what is driving the current rise in long-term American bond yields and what is the bond market communicating about inflation government debt and the direction of the American economy so you're gonna get 16 different answers depending you know if you've talked to 12 different economists okay so so uh and so the as as many people know the yields in especially longer term yields in the US treasury market have been rising uh and are now at a level that we haven't seen in a number of years and there's discussion about why that is uh the candidates are just worried about the government debt and and how how um not just the current level but where the projections are going.
SPEAKER_01Uh another worry is related to inflation and and uh whether or not the Fed will do what it takes to get it under control. There could be many other reasons including one where there's just an excess uh competition in the treasury market because corporations especially those related to uh technology are competing for for funds and so that means that the Treasury has to pay up and I think it's a little bit of all of the above the most recent rise uh seems to be more about expectations that the Fed interest rates are more likely to go up than people had thought before and maybe up by more than people had thought before uh rather than any particular any particular uh new concern about the US debt but clearly risk premiums over the last year or so have been rising uh after having been really unusually slow.
SPEAKER_01I mean it low uh you may not remember this but there was a time when we were wringing our hands about low for long and why people weren't pricing in risk in the yield curve. So a little bit of a return to normal and a little bit of uh and a little bit more worry about about higher interest rates in the US and and US debt that spills over to Canada it matters less it it it interest rate movements in the US have always spilled over to Canada especially at the long end um this time we have not been uh we have not been affected as much our our fiscal situation is in better shape I'm not saying it's in in in the kind of shape we want to see in the long run uh but it's but it's in better shape and the credibility of uh fiscal policy and is our credit rating is high uh and so um I wouldn't take that for granted uh but we're we're in a a reasonably good position uh relative to the US in that regard right now a few other reasons that I've heard is that more central banks are looking at uh gold as a reliable uh investment to hold their money in um what are your thoughts on that I you know yes there there are i'm I'm not sure to what extent that is actually having uh a large effect on bond markets uh especially when you think about the volatility that's been a more of a slow kind of accumulation uh there are some uh central banks that that feel that gold is a is a good store of value others that that are banking more on their fundamentals uh to uh to to do that work uh so i wouldn't put that down as a big factor i think one thing i wanted to say that i that i didn't um i don't think canada should be complacent about its fiscal situation yes we need to invest and yes there's there's good ways to spend to spend uh taxpayers money that will hopefully expand capacity but you never you never turn your back on the on the bond market because because they can react quickly and they can smell uh fiscal imprudence uh from quite far fascinating what would a genuine loss of confidence in the American government debt look like and how do we distinguish that from an ordinary bond market adjustment yeah I I'm uncomfortable speculating about that because I wouldn't put that in my base case um uh so um maybe I can bring it back to a financial stability point uh that it could come from loss of confidence or or just a a stumble or a wobble in the bond market or it come could come from up sorry from lot of the US fiscal situation and confidence in that it could come from from uh some other some other uh shock um what can happen and we've seen it in the past we saw it a little bit in in at the beginning of COVID is that if there's a sudden um if there's a sudden shock uh that requires uh holders of treasuries to sell them quickly okay that's going to create spike in interest rates that have repercussions throughout the system it's it's it's like a domino effect and so you end up with things happening that just reinforce that bad bad dynamic I need to sell my treasuries uh the price goes down others have to the price of their collateral has just gone down so they need to raise funds to put more collateral in so they have to sell assets and so on.
SPEAKER_01And that can create the kind of financial instability that requires central banks to come in and and provide liquidity. One episode that we did see was in 2022 in the UK in uh September when the government at the time issued a budget that did not garner market confidence and uh in a way that was severe enough that created a spike in guilts. That created some um some spillovers that were quite serious in liability driven investment funds that were related to pension funds and the Bank of England we had to come in at the time and and uh buy GILTs uh for a very targeted and temporary period of time.
SPEAKER_01Now confidence was restored uh because the budget was retracted other changes were made uh but you can see that and and at the end of the day stability was restored rather quickly uh it never unraveled to what it could have been had we not intervened but but uh that's the kind of thing that can happen that that uh requires uh support from from central banks or even the government if it gets out of out of hand so when you see like my province British Columbia and the federal government are both running high deficits how does that impact how central banks kind of look at the situation well that from a monetary policy point of view it's about it's about how much is fiscal policy at the time uh contributing to growth okay is it so in the COVID time fiscal policy around the world was quite expansionary and so it was contributing a lot to growth that and that turned out to be uh in some jurisdictions more than others one of the reasons inflation that wasn't just monetary policy in fact it was fiscal policy that that uh that uh boosted demand to the extent that they created and I'm not judging it I'm just that's just a a fact from the studies that have been done that could be wrong but that's those are the studies that have been done um and so and I think when when you look at what rating agencies look at they look not only they look at your the level of your your deficits over the federal level is 2% of GDP around that the the federal uh debt is about 41% it's it doesn't see uh you know in the short term you don't see a path to reducing it um but you've got interest payments uh at a level that that are not insignificant but but um but achievable okay and so and so rating agencies are gonna look at that and they're gonna say well what is the quality of spending that's happening is it consumption something that'll just be here today and gone tomorrow or is it to build capacity in a way that's like a capital investment and so there will be return on it for the economy over time increasing the tax base.
SPEAKER_01I think what the governments I are trying to do is the latter, the the good kind of spending it's much too early to know whether that'll bear fruit uh but that's certainly the intent. And when you think about what Canada needs it needs investment in so many areas and to the extent the government can crowd in public and uh private investment and can create the conditions not just through spending but through changes in regulations and the rules of the game I think that's that's uh it's worth it if it if it works fascinating.
Aaron PeteI've spoken to several economists now about where Canada is and they have a lot of all of them confirmed that they think our internal regulatory policy our own tax policies are the pieces that could be slowing down our economy. And then when I ask them about the tariffs they say that's a factor but that's not the the main piece that we need to address. They say obviously they are against the tariffs and they want to see all of that addressed, but that we have roots here and um many uh premiers and the prime minister talked about we need to address these internal regulatory processes.
Aaron PeteThe whole reason the major projects office started was like we're gonna do this for a bit and then we're gonna be able to kind of redo the whole system and all of their critique of Prime Minister Mark Carney to date has been we haven't seen that kind of real analysis and real review of our own internal policies to date like updating our tax policy was something economist Trevor Toom raised and some other pieces. So I'd be interested where do you see the roots? Do you think a lot of Canada's issues are the Trump tariffs right now or is it our own internal policies?
SPEAKER_01So clearly the Trump tariffs are bad news for Canada it's not helpful for Canadians. It's also not helpful helpful for the US the tariffs are actually being borne uh by the U.S. citizens who are paying higher prices that's part of the reason why their inflation is higher than ours and so it's raising costs for businesses uh changing supply chains in a way that that hurts not only Canada but but the US that being said uh Canada has had structural deficiencies or has been punching below its weight in the economic sense uh in the prosperity sense for people for many many years and that's comes down to productivity uh and low investment low capital investment and and so what that really means is that is that we do need uh to do whatever we can that's that's sustainable okay that that makes sense constitutionally given our constitutional obligations our social obligations and desires to increase the expected rate of return on investment okay and that because it's not high enough companies in Canada are just i leaving or they're never growing in Canada they're going to the US or they're just not growing at all or they're holding back part of it's the uncertainty about the tariffs but part of it is the uncertainty with respect to how long is it going to get to take make my project uh approvable and I can get a shovel in the ground?
SPEAKER_01Is it 10 years? Is it five years when I get approval is it going to be litigated? Uh you know what is it going to cost me to get those approvals and what are the regulations going to be um is there even a road to to to go to where I want to build a mine or somewhere so that I can actually get my products to market? Is the port is the does the port have capacity? Does the train system have capacity? There's just all these questions and I believe I'm a firm believer in private investment.
SPEAKER_01At the same time I know that the government can be very helpful in enabling it by taking away those barriers that don't achieve uh public policy objectives. Okay. I I'm I'm a regulator okay I've been a regulator and I've worked in government and I could tell you that the intentions there are always good but the results are not always um everything's not entirely needed to be in the public interest. You know if you if there's a lot of time spent doing things that really don't add to your objectives and in fact could take away from it.
SPEAKER_01And I think that's the the project office is test driving a faster process and learning what works and what doesn't uh and and I totally agree with those other economists that that can't be the permanent solution. The permanent solution means to to be a whole scale uh we rewiring of tax approvals, how we interact with the provinces and municipal governments uh maybe even our risk tolerance uh needs to go up uh because if it doesn't we're not gonna get the investment we need even international investment I'm really excited about the investment summit in Toronto that's coming up uh you gotta know I work internationally you gotta know that every one of those investors are gonna evaluate the expected return of any investment here with the expected return of investments around the world.
Aaron PeteSo we're competing not with ourselves we're competing uh with the rest of the world that also has something to offer you mentioned litigation and uh with with great respect I think this is an opportunity for you to give me the cold hard facts uh about indigenous communities and where we are there are a lot of valid reasons why and they have a right to take things to court when they see an issue. I'm a First Nations chief I understand that we have the ability to do that but I wonder how you think about the impact of that decision on investments because you mentioned litigation and I see First Nations being a primary driver when the major project comes up of being a litigant either against they weren't consulted enough and all of these things.
Aaron PeteAnd like my my greatest fear out of that is that sometimes I don't think First Nation communities realize the broader system that they exist within. And that's not to be disrespectful to them but as I learn about the economy and how all of this works I go like wow this has ripple effects this has a cause and effect to systems outside of our own purview. The decision to litigate over one oil pipeline can have downstream effects to other potential proponents who want to do things even if it's not even within their territory it can have downstream effects.
Aaron PeteAnd so I think this needs to be a conversation with First Nation communities and I just want to get your thoughts on whether or not I'm correct on my analysis or not because the great risk from my perspective looking at the First Nation situation is that you have vulnerable children and families living in abject poverty while communities are deciding and they're allowed to make these decisions about whether or not they support or want to fight a pipeline or not but you you can affect families ability to rise out of poverty and you can affect our Canadian economy and the global economy in all of these ways that I just I don't always know is factored into their decision making.
Aaron PeteBut the more I learn about it, the more I'm like oh my gosh, this has so many important effects and it you can make an informed decision about these things and go, okay, I am willing to litigate even though it will have these downstream effects but I think it's really important that we understand the downstream effects and I just I wonder what your reflections are on that.
SPEAKER_01Those are really uh important issues and they they're tied up with emotion even just hearing you I you know I I can feel uh the emotion and and clearly clearly at the end of the day it's up to every community in their agency and their rights to do what they think uh feels best there's no this there's no way to change that and and I don't think we should try where I see the opportunity is is uh trying to avoid it getting to that stage and and maybe there's no way in some cases but in other cases I think there are and we've seen examples where it has worked better and it's it it means involving indigenous communities early in the process and not just because we need to you know ticking boxes but actually trying to create a partnership that yes equity is important but it's not just that it's it's the real partnership um that creates a relationship a trust that creates the space for compromise uh that creates a space for for uh moving forward in a way that people at the end of the day feel I know how we got here and I was part of it.
Aaron PeteAnd that's hard work for people that are that are so diverse number one and then it's hard work because historically maybe we haven't developed those relationships as well as we we should have and so but I think it's work that could be done and uh and and should be done and it's not going to reduce the chance that it's gonna eliminate that uh litigation risk but it's gonna reduce it in a way that I think will make it uh yeah will make it uh tractable fascinating Canada is confronting a more protectionist United States while we have this domestic economic weakness and I'm just wondering how worried are you about where we are in terms of a potential recession?
Aaron PeteYou may have heard the leader of the official opposition kind of trying to argue the fact that we're in a technical recession uh in the House of Commons and I see a lot of fear about AI bubbles and what's taking place.
SPEAKER_01How worried are you that we are we are walking this line as we just walked away from the United States trade uh negotiations so so I'm out of the forecasting business these days uh but I have seen those I have seen those comments and and there there's no crystal ball here we do not know what's going to happen with with uh the situation with the United States there are different scenarios that that could occur that could create stronger growth and lower inflation than we expect and slower you know uh there are just many scenarios you see some of them in the monetary policy report that the Bank of Canada put out in July and I think that's the right way to think about it.
SPEAKER_01But what we need to do is focus on what we can control. Okay and we can't control what um what President Trump what other European countries want to do. We just that's just not something we can control. We can control though how we prepare ourselves to be resilient and to grow over the long term and how to if we do have a significant slowdown in growth how we can get through it uh and keep people and keep pull uh uh relatively well.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And so um I don't see I don't see um forecasts out there that have recessions as a base case, partly because partly because we've done some of the adjustment already. I know that the last GDP numbers were really positive. There was a lot of investment especially in machinery and equipment. So that was was a much needed piece of good news. But to be careful because one quarter isn't isn't a trend.
SPEAKER_01And so and so I guess I'm not gonna answer your question because I think that's not the most important one. And it's not I know why I know why Mr. Pladyev is talking about it because we need to be prepared and we need to do what we can to avoid it. I think the real business here for Canadians is how patient are we going to be and how determined are we going to be and ambitious to create the winning conditions for families and for businesses over the longer term.
SPEAKER_01Because there's I don't think that the trade situation with the US is ever going to go back to where it was um before I think we need to we need to make it as good as we can and continue to trade with them and work on a positive relationship with them, diversify where we can and make our economy especially our internal economy trading with ourselves as strong as possible. And once we've done that we're going to be in a much better position to continue and improve how we face other really important issues like the aging of the population healthcare um housing affordability how to build those houses all those things that many of us have our hearts set on.
SPEAKER_01You've mentioned that and I think the prime minister has mentioned that he doesn't think the relationship is ever going to go back to what it was why do you think that is well I think that the relationship um between a president and a prime minister uh can improve and can be more friendly and even some more trust than there is today yes of course when I meant the trade relationship I was really talking about the tariffs if you look at in the first administration with with uh President Trump the tariffs rose and with the President Biden administration they pretty much stayed where they were they usually don't get unwound and so they've gone up a lot maybe some of the extraordinary tariffs the 50% would come come off but in general um I wouldn't expect the average tariff rate to come down to where it was prior.
SPEAKER_01We can adjust to that it's it's it's uh it's something that Canada can adjust to what is really difficult and I hope does improve is just the uncertainty of where policy is going. That applies to Canada and that applies a lot to the US because that's where the investment environment and and uh I guess even the confidence of Canadians really rests kind of knowing what they're facing how are they going to succeed in the future uh and so and so um that part I think I'm always gonna have hope that that part improves the tariffs part in terms of the average tariffs I think they're just gonna be permanently higher than they were when we started what would you like to see Canada do immediately to start to improve the strength of our economy if we were able to go back to our MLAs and our MPs and say we've got to get moving on some things what would you like to see take place pretty quickly here?
SPEAKER_01Well I'd like to see what's taking place right now get carried out and actually implemented. And so a lot of what I'm saying is something that is being tried right now. So faster approvals more uh substitutive compliance between orders of government so they're not all doing the same thing doubling up on regulations thinking thinking about about how to enable investment uh through through changes to the tax system I know that takes time but all these hard this hard work uh to to create a structural environment that's more uh appealing to domestic and international investors that takes time too because people need to agree to it and you have to decide what you're gonna put on the table and then you need to negotiate it.
SPEAKER_01I know when I was doing Basel III in Basel on the new regulations for banks it took months and months to get agreements on different kinds of of proposed international standards. I don't think I think that task was a walk in the park relative to what candidates achieve and so what I would do is actually execute on what we've got on the table which is a lot and get to work on the kinds of things the economists you're talking you were talking to have mentioned that are structural reforms that take time.
Aaron PeteOne of my final big questions is just when you look at our global economy I'm wondering how how you take information in on that front because there's just so much going on that I don't feel like I grew up with to the same extent with things taking place like the war uh in Iran and how that's reshaping BRICS and how they're starting to work together and they just met um I think it was India China Russia and Iran just met and had a conversation there may have been more countries involved in that but like they're trying to start to look at their own monetary system how how much time goes into those kind of global issues from your perspective well given my work uh a lot of time does because uh at the Bank of England I'm interested in in financial stability issues as they pertain to the UK which is a financial center those stability issues will you know require knowledge of what's happening in many markets including the ones that you mentioned I think that the and that was the same it wasn't much different when I was at the Bank of Canada I I think as a as a citizen uh that it's impossible to to read it all uh I would say I would say three things one is don't even try to read it all because it's impossible and confusing and so um but at the same time don't rely on just one source to be your source of truth because truth is in silos these days and so I try to look at the news that I would normally look at and then look at another another um another stream another silo that may have different views or have a different take on what happened than than the traditional news that way I get a fuller picture.
SPEAKER_01I guess the second thing is do it with a purpose. Why do you want to know all this? Is it just for interest or do you want to know how it's going to affect your community your personal finances and that helps you uh found triage to prioritize okay and then and then the third thing is um don't despair I have so much faith in Canada uh and I realize that what's in the news tends to be more the negative things and the positive things and so to ground me I look around uh at the community that I'm in and the communities that I'm in and I look for news that shows shows uh the lighter side of what what is going on as well and how kind we can be to each other and how communities can come together.
SPEAKER_01And I find it really in COVID and other times I think that Canadians are up to that task.
Aaron PeteFinal question for you you studied economics at Wilford Laurier and Western before spending two decades putting those ideas into practice at the Bank of Canada and you have now returned to an academic environment in Princeton.
SPEAKER_01What did making real decisions during an economic crisis teach you that textbooks and economic models could not well two things one is that you don't have all the time in the world to look in your textbook to figure out what to do because it won't be there. Taking decisions is about taking decision under uncertainty and sometimes very quickly uh number two universities don't prepare you for the simple fact that if you're gonna achieve crisis management you're gonna achieve really good decisions is not about you it's about you and your team and that productive discussion pulling together to make sure that everybody's got their thing to do supporting each other and in the crisis say in the global financial crisis in 2008 COVID crisis I couldn't have achieved half of what I did without without the team and the relationships that I had built uh prior to the crisis hitting do you have any regrets or things you would have done differently uh based on those two major experiences Oh my gosh I'm always looking at what I could have done better so it's hard to just pick one um I'm proud of I'm overall proud of what of what we did.
SPEAKER_01I think that I think that um on the communication side I think that that uh central banks and including me are too um restrained about we're restrained about what we say we try to be so careful that sometimes our message doesn't come across as as well as it could and so and so um maybe maybe I would have um I'm not saying I would have said everything that came into my head but I wish I had have uh worked more on how to how to be clear to Canadians and speak in a way that that is understood and accessible and meets the people where they are I tried to do it but I still feel that I have some work on that front.
Aaron PeteHow can people follow your work?
SPEAKER_01Well I have a I have a LinkedIn page uh I think there's an there's a a link to my my C V that has a list of my publications uh and the speeches and work that that I'm doing right now. But as I said I'm on I'm on LinkedIn.
Aaron PeteTremendous well thank you for being willing to do this today uh and answer these questions. I find this area doesn't get a lot of coverage um of course within your realm I'm sure you're talking to economists all the time but outside of that I find it's a really important area for people to learn about and start to understand all the factors because I have this deep belief that if you're not informed on a lot of these things, the world happens to you rather than you being an active participant in the process.
Aaron PeteAnd the more you understand and it can seem boring to people but the more you understand the bond market and how the global economy is shifting and you're not going to get everything right but the more you're kind of thinking how do I make decisions and project outwards? How do I look outwards and go, okay, I think this is where the world's going and you do that even implicitly when you buy a house, when you have children you're predicting that the future is going to be relatively stable. And so the more you learn about stability or lack thereof, the more you're able to adapt when COVID happens, when the 2008 financial crisis happens, the more you're kind of able to shift with the ebbs and flows of our society more broadly and I I really want to encourage people to move in that direction.
Aaron PeteThe more information and the more grounded you are in in where you are in the world, the more you're able to respond to different scenarios and circumstances that come up and that empowers you to lead other people and help them make more informed decisions and and that's how we kind of ripple outward. So I'd appreciate you being willing to share this information today because I hope people take a lot away from it and just learn how complex these decisions are and how many factors have to go into them and how much research I'm sure goes in behind the scenes to try and make some of these informed decisions.
SPEAKER_01Well thank you so much for not only invit not only the invitation but your initiative to do this.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...