Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of Indigenous Services Canada with host Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Mandy Gull-MastyMy name is Mandy Golmasty. I'm the Minister of Indigenous Services Canada.
Aaron PeteIs there an issue within the ministry that you would like to see change?
Mandy Gull-MastyIndigenous Services Canada should actually not be a ministry.
Aaron PeteIs your government actually planning to abolish the Indian Act?
Mandy Gull-MastySo it was an interesting comment. Is that going to happen in 2027? I wouldn't hold my breath.
Aaron PeteWhen I interviewed Conservative MP Billy Morin, he had shared that you had personally messaged him to discuss crossing the floor to the Liberals. And I'm wondering if I can get your perspective on what happened there.
Mandy Gull-MastyYes, I constantly texted him. I think more in a joke. I didn't really think that he was somebody that would be a four-crosser. But yeah. On a number of occasions I texted him, hey Billy, a lot of friendly faces that are familiar on this side, hoping you would consider joining.
Aaron PeteShould Indian residential school denialism be criminalized?
Mandy Gull-MastyI don't know if meeting somebody who's denying residential school with criminalization and putting them in jail is going to be the best pathway forward for that person.
Aaron PeteIs there an endpoint to reconciliation? Minister Golmasty, thank you very much for joining us today. I'm wondering if you could briefly introduce yourself for listeners who might not be acquainted with your work.
Mandy Gull-MastySure. Hi, Wajam. My name is Mandy Golmasty. I'm the Minister of Indigenous Services Canada. I'm Eu Cree from the nation of James Bay. I am from the community of the Cree First Nation of Waswampia.
Aaron PetePrime Minister Mark currently recently announced his intention to move beyond the Indian Act. Is your government actually planning to abolish the Indian Act? And what would replace it from your perspective?
Mandy Gull-MastyThat was a very interesting moment at the First Minister's meeting. You know, we did see the Premier of Manitoba stand up and talk about abolishing the Indian Act. I think that this was something that the Prime Minister seemed open to understanding, uh, open to I'd just try to have a greater input of information to him in terms of what would that look like? Uh right now at this time, you know, we've had a preliminary conversation of trying to understand what that means.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd what next step would it take for us to, you know, first and foremost, ask communities, uh, what would it mean to move beyond the Indian Act?
Aaron PeteDo you think that that is something if you get good input on, that's something we could see follow-through on within this administration, like within the next four years before the next election?
Mandy Gull-MastyThat would be extremely ambitious. That would be extremely ambitious. We want people to understand that if you're moving beyond the Indian Act, you're talking about, you know, first and foremost, looking at what it means when you're registered under the Indian Act, what does status mean? You're looking at governance, how do you create that pathway for communities to be able to determine what their governance system is going to look like if they're not under the Indian Act or what their electoral code would look like. Uh, there's a huge conversation around land. What does that land management look like?
Mandy Gull-MastyUh, what does the federal oversight process look like as we would step out of this space and provide authority to community? So to me, uh, I can't say that I would be able to realistically put a time frame on that. I do think that it would be over-ambitious for it to be achieved within one single mandate because there are so many complexities around where nations are at. You would have to build their capacity for them to leave the Union Act. Uh, and also there are so many levels of different governance and relationship with provincial and territorial governments that that would have to be part of the conversation too, and redefining that relationship space.
Mandy Gull-MastySo it was an interesting comment. Uh, is that going to happen in 2027? I wouldn't hold my breath. Uh, is it something that, you know, you could see discussed by this government, you know, in the year coming forward? Maybe. So will it be done within the mandate? I don't think it would be sensible to assume that you can meet the needs of over 600 First Nations in that space uh within uh within that time frame.
Aaron PeteSo this leads into the question. NDP MP Leah Gazin has described the Indian Act announcement as a distraction from your government's Bill C39 and its implications for Indigenous rights. Um and Senator Audette has also raised concerns that this conversation could overshadow the urgent need to pass Bill C2. And I'm just wondering, what are your thoughts on their concerns and their criticisms of this announcement?
Mandy Gull-MastyI'm I'm, you know, I'm always going to be uh respectful of MP Gazan uh Gazan's views. I don't know if they necessarily reflect, you know, the approach that we're taking as a government. There's been a lot of conversation around Bill C39. This is one of the bills where it is aligning the internal mechanisms of the federal government to be more efficient and how it undertakes assessment. Right now, when you're doing uh a project in development, you are required to participate in two environmental assessment processes, the federal and the provincial.
Mandy Gull-MastyIt's quite duplicative. So that is one of the primary objectives. And there's also, uh, and I've heard this from MP Kazan herself, the assumption that you would not be allocated sufficient time to be able to do the work that you need to do, which is not the case. The bill actually says in plain writing that if First Nations wish to have additional time for further consultation or engagement, it shall be allocated to them. Um taking, you know, taking the position of the Senate, uh, they are the second sober thought to bills in the House.
Mandy Gull-MastyI'm going to be respectful of my senatorial colleague uh and, you know, maybe not comments on what she has shared, because I am trying to maintain that objectiveness and that neutrality of how the House of Commons and the Senate are supposed to work with one another.
Aaron PeteWell, thank you for that. With respect, on February 27, 2026, you told Parliament that Bill S2 was necessary and urgent. Since then, the government has resisted the Senate amendment, ending the second generation cutoff. Consultations have since concluded, and the government has missed a court deadline. If we agree that rules are discriminatory, why hasn't your government worked to resolve this within the calendar year?
Mandy Gull-MastyI'm sorry, could you repeat the first part of your question? Because I didn't hear exactly what you said.
Aaron PeteSure. On February 27, 2026, you told Parliament that Bill S2 was necessary and urgent. And since then, your government has resisted the Senate amendment, ending the second generation cutoff. Consultations have concluded, and the government has missed a court deadline. If we agree it's discriminatory, why hasn't it been resolved yet?
Mandy Gull-MastyActually, what I had said on February, in February was that it was necessary and urgent for us to respond to the enfranchisement that the bill was originally set up to respond to. So I want to be very clear that when I made that statement, I was speaking specifically about the enfranchisement that the bill is looking to address. It is necessary. There was a court hearing. The Nicholas case uh, you know, urged government to be able to pass that. Since we were, you know, still studying the bill and is still under parliamentary process in the House.
Mandy Gull-MastyUh, we are still respecting what is outlined in the NYClays decision, and we are moving files forward in terms of the people that have been enfranchised. Now, what I would like, you know, to be very clear upon is the second generation cutoff consultations, the collaborative consultations, had already been launched two years ago and they were underway during the whole discussion of Bill S2. And one of my first public um interviews was stating that the enfranchisement bill S2 was what I was putting forward because it was very specific in terms of registration, and that, you know, we were looking at doing more work in the second generation cutoff space because that was a different type of registration.
Mandy Gull-MastyI felt that it needed its own standalone legislation. So while the Senate has decided that this was the time to add these second generation cutoff uh amendments to S2, uh, that is their prerogative as the second sober thought. Uh, but it is my intention, uh, since I've been mandated to be in this role and still today, to really take an approach that is conducive to putting more than a one-parent rule uh lens on the space of registration.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd I want people to understand that yes, there are some nations out there that wish to have a one-parent rule. They would like to adopt that, they feel that it would be the best frame for their nation. There are also nations out there that do not want to have a one-parent rule and want to be self-determining in that space. And it's my duty as a minister to be able to find a pathway between those two uh points of the spectrum. I think there is a pathway to do that work, but I also want people to understand something really important.
Mandy Gull-MastyOkay, I'm gonna go through the hypothetical scenario of if government passed Bill S2 and there were nations who did not wish to have that applied to them, what would that next result be? It would be a challenge to the law. It would be something that would really infringe on the timeline of implementation because we have to respect the rights of those nations who wish not to have that law applied to them. So it's really important that, you know, you take the time to analyze, okay, what would it mean for us to have one parent rule in place?
Mandy Gull-MastyWhat would it mean for us to create the space for communities to be self-determining in terms of looking at who their members are, what does it mean to be part of your nation? And there's been, you know, a lot of feedback, a lot of discussion in this space. There's also actually been a lot of commentary about, you know, attempts at saying that I'm misleading people. I want to be very clear. I'm not only speaking about membership and membership registration. I'm actually speaking about status and what it means to be self-determining in status.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd that's something that I've heard from many nations across the country. Uh I want to be respectful of everybody that has an opinion in this space. But ultimately, I do subscribe to the belief that First Nations need to determine who their members are, what it means to be a part of their nation. How does that look like? That's for them to do the work, and it's for me to be uh in my ministerial role and providing the pathway for them to action that.
Aaron PeteThank you for that. I'd like to ask a personal question. As you may recall, in 2019, Jody Wilson Raybald refused to take on the file that you now carry because she opposed the admin being the person administering the Indian Act. And I wonder, just on this note of who's indigenous, who's not, how have you personally come to fill this role? What is it? It do you feel at times your own indigenity is impacted by trying to manage this very complicated government-led file?
Aaron PeteHow do you process sitting in the seat you're in today?
Mandy Gull-MastyUm It's not easy to take on this role. It's not easy to be the minister that implements the responsibility of the Indian Act. I do not enjoy being that minister. But what I do enjoy is knowing that the changes that you can action, the discussions, the conversations that you can have in trying to remove the harms of the Indian Act are part of the role that I have in being progressive for First Nations.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd I accepted this role. I have a lot of respect for Mrs. Ray Bowles, but her decision was hers at that time with that prime minister. This is a new government, this is a new prime minister. I'm a new minister. I took on this initiative because as a former leader, I know that if you are not at the table, decisions are being made about you, irregardless of whether you are there or not. And for me to come into this space with my my other colleagues who are part of cabinet and to be able to have that voice and to be able to have these conversations is pushing the government into a new space with the parameters of the Indian Act.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd I'm very happy and pleased to remove barrier, to remove the constrictions of the Indian Act and to do everything that I can in my power to be sure that as we move forward, there's a new relationship, there's a new role, there's more empowerment, there's more space for communities to decide for themselves because we have that capacity. We have the capability to do that. So my decision to accept was to be sure that the change that I expect from government and from how First Nations people are governed in this country is met.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd if I have to be the one who goes in there and does it, then I hope that I am the first of many who will continue to take down the barriers and the walls of the Indian Act.
Aaron PeteYou also became the first woman elected grand chief of the Cree Nation government. And I'm wondering, you sat in that seat, likely trying to hold government to account, pushing them to deliver on things. What is it? What is the change in perspective that you now have sitting in the seat you're in, where at one point in time you would have been pushing the minister to deliver. Now you are the minister. Is there like lessons learned or behind the scenes? Is it harder to accomplish things than you might have expected? I'm just wondering what the difference between those two worlds are.
Mandy Gull-MastyHuge, huge difference because being a client of ISC and then becoming the minister, just seeing and understanding all of the steps that have to be taken for a decision was really surprising to me because it is quite complex in terms of how the political ministerial office works, the department side, the public servants, how they have to action a decision, how we are accountable to our own internal measures, how we find alignment and balance between those two things.
Mandy Gull-MastyIt did make me realize why I did not get, you know, the answer that I wanted and the time that I wanted. And it also caused me to pick up the phone and call some former ministers and say, hey, you know what? So sorry. I was so rough on you. I didn't understand how complex this system was. And in addition, I think uh part of the learnings that I have as a minister is really seeing that parliamentary process in the legislative space and how it translates into action and being implemented by the public service domain.
Mandy Gull-MastySo all of the policy development in that space, the mechanisms that you have to use for engagement, for consultation, for collaboration, finding a pathway when, you know, policy works in one community but doesn't work in another. This has probably been one of, I think, the greatest highlights for me so far is being able to work with a prime minister that hears, understands, and accepts that regionalization of how we work with indigenous people in this country is the next approach.
Mandy Gull-MastyYou can't have a national pan decision-making process and apply that to everybody. First Nations are not all in the same space. So I'm really pleased. This is not one of the headlines that you'll see, but I found that that was something very, very progressive in terms of the decisions that we've taken so far.
Aaron PeteI'm very grateful to hear that because one of my chief frustrations is we work with Indigenous Services Canada BC, and I often find that they need to go back to Ottawa to get approval or to get support, or that a lot of the policies controlling decisions are not led by the BC Indigenous Services Canada, but by centralized control systems. And that's my regular critique to them is I'd like to see this where we can just have a conversation and resolve this. Because you can come to my community next week and see. But for yourself as minister or for people out in Ontario, they're not going to come to my community and understand the real circumstances on the ground.
Mandy Gull-MastyGood. Happy that you're pleased. We are continuing to improve in this space. So more than willing to receive feedback on your thoughts of how that's looking like in real time. Really glad to hear that, you know, you you feel that this is the right path.
Aaron PeteWhen I interviewed conservative MP Billy Morin, he had shared that you had personally messaged him to discuss crossing the floor to the liberals. He also suggested the discussion was around getting enough MPs. And I'm wondering if I can get your perspective on what happened there.
Mandy Gull-MastyI uh, you know, I really have a lot of respect for MP Morin. Yes, I constantly texted him. Um, I think more in a joke. I didn't really think that he was somebody that would be a four-crosser. But yeah, on a number of occasions, I texted him, hey Billy, a lot of friendly faces that are familiar on this side, hoping you would consider joining. Um, I think that, you know, all bets were off. There were a lot of people coming over on the liberal side. Uh, if he had wanted to do that, I know that this party would have, you know, been one that would have received him.
Mandy Gull-MastyI think that Billy was, you know, maybe making more of a story than the actual conversations, you know, that were taking place.
Aaron PeteGot it. The Auditor General had found that Indigenous Services Canada had failed to effectively implement and measure its new fiscal relationship with First Nations. We've seen billions invested. I don't think that that can be denied, but insufficient evidence about whether those investments are closing the gap. And I'm wondering how do you digest that? What are the steps needed in order to really address the living conditions in community?
Mandy Gull-MastyThis is such a good question. I really appreciate that you brought this up. I have a lot of respect for the Auditor General. I think that, you know, she has an incredibly important role. Uh, it is one where she looks at standard accounting practices and applies that lens on the work that government does. I think there's a component of that that it that can be measured uh within Indigenous Services Canada. But I have to say that the nuances of, you know, accounting practices do not always reflect what it is that First Nations are prioritizing in terms of advancing their nations.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd I don't know if a binary pass-fail system is the appropriate lens to measure how communities are moving forward. And I'm saying that because in this country, we have some extremely high capacity, innovative, very advanced communities that don't really come to Indigenous Services Canada, you know, for very much service. Uh, they're able to operate internally, they're able to advance the needs of their members. And then we have some communities that are really in a space where they're more challenged, they're challenged with just daily operations, they need a lot of support, uh, they need, you know, a lot of programming services to build up.
Mandy Gull-MastyThere's not a lot of innovation opportunity. Often they're very remote, they're isolated. So that's quite a huge spectrum to group everybody into one, you know, criteria for measurement. I don't think is adequate or reflective of how they're advancing. And the criteria for, you know, measuring change, I think has to really be what the community wants it to be. You know, I can come in with my calculator and say, you know, X number of square footage has been added to a building.
Mandy Gull-MastyBut if that building is a school that has extremely low attendance rates and they've gone from, you know, 12% to 78%, that's a huge increase. And that is the case in some of the servicing that we do. We've seen in some places, you know, an increase of 10% overall in graduation rates. That might not seem like a huge number. It is not 100%. I'll I'll give that to the auditor general. But that 10% actually, you know, responds to a number that was quite low.
Mandy Gull-MastyIt could have been in the 1 to 2% range. So while I want to respect the work that she does, I also think, you know, one of my objectives as a minister is to have a conversation around if we are going to do auditing of First Nations and we're going to do evaluation, the component of culture that is not reflected in standard accounting practices has to be taken into consideration because we are doing the work of providing service, we are doing the work of supporting operations, but we're also doing the work of protecting, reinforcing, uplifting, in some cases, even ensuring that, you know, things like identity, language, and culture are returned to community and protected in community.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd this is something that I don't think is always represented in the Auditor General's reports. You know, I read them, I respond to them. I think for me it's it's a guide and a tool. Is it the same outcome and the same report that we get from community in terms of how things are advancing? Not necessarily in all cases, but it it is one of the one of the measuring sticks that's in the kit to see and assess what we're doing and moving things forward.
Aaron PeteOne of the pieces that's somewhat inside baseball, but I'd just be interested in your. Thoughts on because as a First Nations chief, I'm trying to figure out what path is uh has the brightest light at the end of the tunnel, I suppose. And one, I just uh MC'd leading the way, the conference with First Nations Financial Management Board, the Lions Advisory Board, the Tax Commission. And I'm just wondering, they're doing such innovative stuff to support First Nations and really developing their sovereignty. But I don't always hear them in the same conversation as Treaty or when we're talking about leaving the Indian Act.
Aaron PeteThey are taking steps to remove authorities from the Indian Act. How optimistic or how excited are you about the work that they're doing to uh down that path? Is that the path you think is likely the way out for many First Nation communities of the Indian Act?
Mandy Gull-MastyThe work that they're doing is extremely progressive. I'm really encouraged by it. That, you know, that space is going to serve a lot of communities. It's going to be an outlet for them to maximize everything that they want to do in terms of development, uh, OSR and the own source revenue space. It's going to create for them tools to be accountable to their membership, to have a better way to communicate that information. It is the decision and the responsibility of communities to do that work.
Mandy Gull-MastySometimes some of the tools that are in place work really well for some nations. Sometimes I think there's a lot more capacity building that has to be undertaken to help support communities. I really believe that accountability and transparency are two things that are absolutely necessary if you want to be elected into a leadership role. If people are selecting you to make decisions for their community, for their nation, for their future outcomes, you have the responsibility to communicate that back to them.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd there are some very clear instances in this country and some communities where that is not demonstrated. And it is my role as a minister to be able to ensure that leadership has all of the necessary tools in place to help them showcase that accountability and transparency to their members in the best way possible, with documentation, with clarity, with measures for how they want their communication to be carried out either in their language, in English, or in French, and to be respectful of that space.
Mandy Gull-MastyBecause that's that's the lens that I carry as a former leader that we held our government um meetings in our language. It was live streamed, it was on the radio, uh, we had multiple general assemblies, we showed our financial position, people could ask us questions. There was a lot of follow follow-up. So I do understand how that worked within my nation. But it is my expectation that as we push things forward and we get into a working relationship and more resources made available to you to make leadership decisions, that you are also making those decisions based on the direction that you get from your members, the input that you have from your elders, that you've taken the time to listen to the youth in your community, that there's space for women, that you are reaching out to those people who need representation, you know, in two-spirited spaces, that you're taking into consideration those that are struggling in the social space.
Mandy Gull-MastyUh, you, as a chief, know yourself the importance of all of the different tools and all of the different people that you represent. And you need those two things to mesh and align. So for me, accountability and transparency, it's about making sure that your members know and understand that you are making the best decision for them based on what they've told you, but you're also being clear on how you're trying to get there.
Aaron PeteWhat do you hope your legacy is within this file?
Mandy Gull-MastyUh, well, I think, you know, one part of my legacy is probably going to be uh sealed on day one that I decided to become the Minister of Indigenous Services Canada. What I what I don't think will always be known and understood because it's not the popular part of the work, uh, you know, that we made a lot of internal decisions that really reshape the space to take consideration of the uniqueness of First Nations, their relationship with their territory, their who they are as First Nations people, the pride of being able to speak your language, to grow up in community, uh to honor your cultural practices, to also really understand that although we are one First Nations people in this country, we are not able to all have the same approach, same solution.
Mandy Gull-MastyThat regionalization approach is really important to me. Uh, and also, you know, I think being in this space to say, I am an agent of change. I am somebody who's going to introduce new ways of thinking, that I'm going to challenge my colleagues to pay, you know, attention and be aware of how their ministries also serve Indigenous people. It's not just the work of Indigenous Services Canada or CERNA or Northern Affairs. We at Cabinet, the entirety of the Cabinet table, have a component of the Indigenous thread that runs through our ministries.
Mandy Gull-MastyUm, those are things that are really important to me. Uh at the end, I guess I'll see what was the most popular thing or least popular thing, uh, and you know, have a reflection at that time. The work that you do right now, you're not working to build a legacy. You're just working to do change, change management, systems change, changing the way people are thinking of First Nations. Uh there's often a lot of opinion. I really challenge people, you know, to ask questions when they read stuff or, you know, they listen to the Facebook news.
Mandy Gull-MastyUh, I'm somebody that's very open. I like to give information. I like to respond to questions. I'm available on all social media platforms. I don't always answer back in, you know, five minutes, but I am somebody that likes to be open because the accountability and transparency also applies to me. I like to give people the uh, you know, the inside look on what my thinking is.
Aaron PeteIs there an issue within the ministry that you would like to see changed by the time you're done, that you would be able to rest easier at the end of your term or at the end of this work that you can say that was something that was important to me?
Mandy Gull-MastyI'm going to say the most important thing to me is the launch of the pathway forward in how Indigenous Services Canada should actually not be a ministry that exists. It is a space that First Nations communities have a lot of capacity to be able to do their own service delivery, their own decision making. I don't know if this is something that can be done in one mandate. I don't think it is because it kind of falls within the space of, you know, moving beyond the Indian Act, but I do think that the more we are able to empower a community to do the work of Indigenous Services Canada, just the better it's going to be for them in serving their nation, serving their members, creating a stronger pathway, developing a community that people are proud to live in, that they want to contribute to, that they feel strong about who they are.
Mandy Gull-MastyHow that's going to look, I don't know. But, you know, this was what I shared with the prime minister when I took on this role that I really felt Indigenous Services Canada is a space that, you know, is not going to be necessary forever and we should move away from it. So I have my own, I guess, similar thinking to uh, you know, Premier Canu and how we need to empower community to do this work. Um, but we'll see, we'll see how much I can push that forward.
Aaron PeteShould Indian residential school denialism be criminalized?
Mandy Gull-MastyThis is such a tough space to be in. This is such a you know a hard conversation to have. I come from a nation where I was asked to be part of um the delegation that went to Rome to give the Pope, former Pope uh Francis, advice on his journey to Canada. And I had gone into that space with one very specific view. But I went there knowing that I was responsible for opening a conversation about a really challenging space for First Nations survivors.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd I remained neutral, of my own opinion, to try to be able to create that space and listen to all of the different reflections that I heard. This was probably one of the most challenging things that I've ever participated on to sit with the Pope, to hear survivors tell their story, to hear the harm, but to also hear that some survivors were not able to forgive, were not able to talk about what had happened to them. And then to also hear some survivors to talk about forgiveness and the healing and how it helped them move into a new space of how they live with the truth and reality of what had happened to them.
Mandy Gull-MastyThat's a really big spectrum. That's a really big spectrum. And when I think about denialists and I think about the messages that they share, I often feel that we as governments, provincial, federal, territorial, and school system, could do a better job of communicating to people the realities of what happened in residential school. I think this is lacking. It's probably my biggest critique. Uh, when I was in high school, we learned about Christopher Columbus sailing the ocean boom, 1942.
Mandy Gull-MastyVery little to zero on residential school. And I think this is a conversation that we need to have to bring down uh, you know, people's ignorance of just not understanding or not being aware. Uh, I also come from a place of being somebody who is trained in conflict management. Uh, it was probably one of the tools that helped me shape my vision on being a peace practitioner. And the restorative justice approach and the restorative relationship building is something that, you know, I value.
Mandy Gull-MastyI don't know if meeting somebody who's denying residential school with criminalization and putting them in jail is going to be the best pathway forward for that person who's ignorant in their belief, who doesn't know any better. And is that going to help the residential school survivors deal with that? Because one of the things you know that I shared with my colleagues on the Hill is if we were to go down that path, every time somebody would be put in jail, it is residential school survivors that would bear the brunt of people sharing their views.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd I think that is another layer of harm that is unnecessary. I don't want to put them into that space. For some people, that may be something that they're willing to accept. Uh, but you know, I really listened to my elders in my region, the residential school survivors that I worked with, who shaped my thinking in this space, and just felt that for me, that's not the right pathway forward. We need to do more work in being sure that people are educated, that they understand that you give information. For some people it will work, for some people they will never accept because they're just ignorant or they're blatantly racist and they're always going to do that.
Mandy Gull-MastyUnfortunately, uh, you know, that is their decision, that is their path. But I think that 90% of people would be open to learning, would be, would probably have a different lens if they personally understood and went through, you know, an experience of working with residential school survivors. And if anything, I would love to see a denialist go to Indigenous community and do work and support and go, you know, spend time and trying to understand the impact that that system had on their family.
Mandy Gull-MastyI think that would be an extremely valuable experience for them.
Aaron PeteMinister, that was the best answer I have heard to date in regards to this. I've spoken to former Minister Gary Nanandassangere, and with great respect to him, I just felt like yours was much more clear. My big fear is exactly what you're describing, that this adds fuel to the fire and creates a complex topic. Like I'm sure you're aware of the Camluke's 215 question, that remains have not been excavated. And so people that from my from everything I can understand, I've interviewed Francis Widowson, I've interviewed uh Nigel Bagar, Candace Milcom, some of these people who are described as denialists, and they're not denying harms at Indian residential schools happened.
Aaron PeteThey're not denying that Indian residential schools exist. They are questioning and challenging whether or not 215 unmarked graves are at Kamloop's residential site. And I understand that that can be offensive to many of the people there who may feel that they know that there are unmarked graves there, but graves have not been excavated. And it's reasonable to say that it is a question at that site. And to turn this into everybody's denying the harms of Indian residential school, I think is really dangerous and misses the mark on what the issue between the two communities are.
Aaron PeteAnd I fear that we're getting into a more polarized issue with First Nations and Canadians. And I'm wondering, do you feel that same way that the temperature has risen somewhat since that 215 unmarked grave story between the two communities, Canadian and the United States?
Mandy Gull-MastyI do. I mean, you know, people can ask questions around what is the status of the work that's being done in Campos. I think that is uh a reasonable question. I also think that there's tact and there's respect. And the way that denialists are doing it lacks both of those things. And for you to understand the progress of where community is and doing the work with, you know, all of the the um the lidar, all of the complexities of, you know, understanding who was in school, where's the documentation, who are these community members, working with the community and trying to understand what that next step is, how to be respectful, how to follow ceremony.
Mandy Gull-MastyIt is so nuanced and specific to each nation uh that you have to be in a good space to have patience to do that work. The temperature going up in terms of people questioning, I think to me, is really disgusting to know that in Canada there are people that are asking that question with the promotion of merchandise that says, do you have bonds? Or even asking if there were people buried.
Mandy Gull-MastyWe are the only group in Canada that has to defend and has to demonstrate atrocities that were carried out against them. This is not the appropriate way. So, like I said, there's a way to ask a question. You can be respectful, you can have tact. If you want to learn what the outcome is, then you can take better steps to do it than demonstrating and representing extremely racist organizations and getting into public spaces and making statements that are very harmful to residential school survivors and communities that are doing the work to answer to the projects that are being carried out.
Mandy Gull-MastyIn my own community, they're still undertaking the work of trying to have information and answers for families that do not know where their children are. And I think that's the thing we have to remember at the end of the day. There is a child out there that has never been returned to their parents, that they don't have information on where that child is, that it could not be bothered to document what occurred with that child's life. And for somebody to come and further perpetuate uncertainty or questioning or even ask for validation of whether or not that should be carried out is very harmful to the parents in the extended family that are missing that child.
Mandy Gull-MastySo I want people that are listening today, you know, respect tact, but also understanding that you're asking a question about a human being that was never returned and taken away wrongfully from a family.
Aaron PeteMinister, I recently interviewed Dr. Cindy Blackstock, who had spent her life fighting for decades for First Nations children. She described how the federal government previously monitored her movements, and she still says she still hasn't received assurances that the surveillance has ended. She also argues that your government continues to resist reforms she believes would end First Nations discrimination. How do you respond to those concerns?
Mandy Gull-MastyI mean, I can't speak to the part about uh, you know, what she's claiming around surveillance. I really don't have a lot of information around that. I could speak to the part about the bill and speak to the part about the work that is being done uh with CFS. I think that there has been a very long-standing, decades-long attempt to try to have agreement in this space. And, you know, Dr. Boxak has done a lot of work, a lot of research. Uh, I'm not diminishing that in any way.
Mandy Gull-MastyI want to be very respectful to her position and the things that she's been able to achieve. Um, but I'm also somebody that's taking on this role uh with a pragmatic lens and proposing to have a pathway forward with no determined outcome, no determined budget, no determined process that is really oriented to like a very large uh open space is very challenging for government to respond to. I am looking at trying to ensure that communities know how and have the right tools available to them to make decisions, to action a plan that is going to meet the needs of their children, that is going to give them, you know, a structure on the decision making, on understanding with clarity the funds that are available to them to action that plan, uh, that the criteria is in place for them to be more defining in this space.
Mandy Gull-MastyI just want to be clear that people understand while one national framework is the proposed process for myself really looking at that regional lens and understanding what kids need in Ontario is very different from what kids need in BC. And I'm trying to create a mechanism where I empower community to make those decisions. How they want to do that, if they want to do that within their leadership level, within uh advisory bodies from their elders, from their women, from working with their agencies, from standing up agencies, it's really up to them because I respect the space that communities do this work in.
Mandy Gull-MastyAnd for me, I'm always trying to, you know, inform communities that the regional agreements process is something that was accepted by the tribunal. Um, it is a challenging space to be in, even with that decision. But I have a mandate. I'm pushing for communities to come and ask questions and be informed on what it means to have a regional agreement, what are the parameters of what that looks like? How can I help you be sure that you are going to build on the information that's needed as you action this agreement?
Mandy Gull-MastyWhat does it mean beyond the agreement? Because that's what relationship with government is. You know, you have a time frame, you are able to make decisions within that time frame, and that's going to inform your next steps. Um, children in care, the ultimate objective is going to be zero children in care. Do I think that's going to happen within the next seven years? In some communities, yes. You know, I was able to visit in the interior of BC, Chocotine, they had zero children in care once they took over and developed their own system.
Mandy Gull-MastyIn some communities, you know, it would it would take longer for them to be able to achieve that target. But working with communities where they are, giving them the tools that they need, being able to create a frame for them so that they can define that space. Uh, why children are going into care is unique to each nation. There are some general national things that occur, but I'm also cognizant that, you know, your environment shapes a lot of impact on community and community's families. So I'm trying to create that space to be respectful of the work that was undertaken, but also be sure that communities can make a decision and have access to the resources that they need now to start building for long term and how they want to stand things up for themselves.
Aaron PeteTwo more questions, and thank you so much for your time. Prime Minister Mark Carney recently announced discussions about a First Nations sovereign wealth fund and new revenue sharing mechanisms. How do we move First Nations away from dependence on annual federal funding and towards economic independence without making participation in resource projects a condition of that prosperity? Or does it need to be?
Mandy Gull-MastyThe discussion around federal, uh around the sovereign wealth fund was yes, in relation to a federal position on natural resource development. I think that's one kind. Um, it's not a space that I would limit community to. I don't, I don't think you should have one uh revenue generating stream for your nation. You really need to explore what kind of opportunity is there for you. There are some communities that will want to opt into, you know, a sovereign wealth fund. What will that fund respond to?
Mandy Gull-MastyHow will it create resources? Is it going to be kind Of, like, a greater investment stream where communities can access uh you know a percentage of what's being generated so that they can carry out cultural implementation programs. I really don't know. It's an undefined space. I think it's an interesting conversation to have. Um, are communities looking to develop their own internal wealth? Probably. There's a lot of tools available to them. There's a lot of innovators in this space.
Mandy Gull-MastyUm, I encourage leadership right now, whether you are in the path of a major project or in a national development uh space, to start doing the work with your council and the members in your community and ask conversations around how we can be in a space where we want to take on this responsibility as part of our mandate. Uh, having an investment strategy, having a policy on how you wish to be consulted, having all of the tools, uh, having people come in to speak to you from other nations that have gone through an experience of development, uh, both successes and challenges.
Mandy Gull-MastyThese are all important questions to ask. There's a there's going to be a lot of work to be done in this space. What does a sovereign wealth fund look like? I don't know. I think there's going to be more work to be done within the AFN, within groups that are not represented by the AFN. There's a lot of conversation in the spaces that deliver service for investment. Uh, I think this will be uh something that's going to be interesting, but probably also challenging to action.
Aaron PeteMay I ask, do you feel like you're going to be developing this system, or will this be led more by the Prime Minister's office?
Mandy Gull-MastyWell, we do do a lot of stuff at Indigenous Services Canada already. Um I really believe that one of the, for me, one of the priorities as minister is to enhance that capacity developing space. Uh, we do do a lot of service delivery, but building capacity and having conversations about how to empower communities to look at that development space, to look at the lens that they have is work that uh, you know, Indigenous Services Canada can fulfill.
Mandy Gull-MastyProbably going to be in collaboration with my colleagues, uh, Minister Alti, Minister Chartran. I think there's more than one space that this conversation lives in. But I also really strongly feel that if you are in First Nations leadership, um, you know, you have to have that critical lens of asking yourself, if my community members have expectation for me to create employment or to create revenue for investment into the community, what is that path?
Mandy Gull-MastyWhat is that path? I come from a nation that's been, you know, highly developed, uh highly impacted by hydroelectric forestry mining. Uh, we took on a lens of sustainable development, of trying to ensure that it's harmonized with our cultural activities, with our relationship with territory. Uh, that has been both a space that has been, you know, given us benefits, but has also been a space that has been really hard and challenging to live in. Uh all parts of that uh pathway forward are things that, you know, with each year we are learning more and more and going through more and more.
Mandy Gull-MastyBut that's a conversation that you need to have with your members. Where are we in that space? What does sustainable development look like for us? Or if we are not open to development, then what is the alternative? How can we generate revenue for our community so that we can go out and pursue the things that our members want us to do that are not deliverable, you know, from government program or from, you know, whatever other funding sources that come into the community. This is really important for leadership. You want to be a leader, you want to be somebody who protects people, but you want to be a builder, you want to be a developer, and you want to be respectful of what it is uh your members are asking you to do with that space.
Aaron PeteMinister, I understand you have two dogs, Minnie and Monica. And you actually wrote a book, a children's book, inspired by them. Could you share a little bit about the book? It goes through being different, experiencing bullying, and finding acceptance. Could you tell us about the book you wrote?
Mandy Gull-MastySure. I have two dogs, Chinese crested dogs. They are hairless. Uh, I do have a copy of my book right here. Uh, Minnie and Monica. This book is trilingual. It's in French, English, and in Cree language. Uh, we launched this book as an initiative to talk about bullying. Uh, the story is about my dogs and how they look different and how they get bullied at the dog park by other dogs that have fur. Uh, it was a project that we launched, and and I still continue to do work in this space to talk about show, to talk with children about bullying, about being kind to one another, about how you know we can accept people that look different and how we have to be uh inviting, and that there's a lot of opportunity to make new friends and to learn new things.
Mandy Gull-MastyUh I usually at the end of those classroom visits bring Minnie in. Children are quite shocked when they see uh the dog from the book showing up in class. It's really been an interesting space. Kids of any age have the most interesting things to tell you. They have all kinds of questions. I think it really helps them understand who their leaders are, that they can see themselves in these spaces, that is a, you know, there's that human connection.
Mandy Gull-MastyI've absolutely adored these things. Uh, I've done it within my own nation. I'm looking forward to doing it in other nations as well. Minnie doesn't travel as much. She's getting quite uh up there in terms of age, but this is a space that I encourage leadership to think about too. You are there to serve people who vote for you, but you are there to make decisions for the people who can't even vote yet. And getting into classrooms and working with kids for me has been such a profoundly eye-opening conversation, what their worries are, what their concerns are, what they're going through, just taking the time to chat with kids.
Mandy Gull-MastyNow I see kids that, you know, I visited while they were in grade one, are now in grade two and three, and they know who I am. And I think it just helps them understand that when we're a part of a nation, we all have a responsibility to give back. Uh, we all have a role to play. Whether you are 75 or five years old, uh, a good leader will know and understand the things that are important to all of their members.
Aaron PeteFinal question, Minister. I always try and put myself in the shoes of people I may disagree with just to understand where there's a difference. And one thing I'm hearing more and more is the question: when does reconciliation come to an end? Everybody acknowledges that I know the atrocities of the past. Billions have been spent to try and address that and support families. Court cases have resulted in settlements. And I'm just wondering from your perspective as minister, is there an endpoint to reconciliation?
Mandy Gull-MastyThat is a really interesting question because it's one that I've asked myself too. You know, I often hear billions have been spent. We have to think about, you know, that's let's look at the past 10 years. Roughly, let's throw a number out there. $10 billion spent in 10 years to correct hundreds of years of underfunding, hundreds of years where resource was never allocated, hundreds of years of standing up a system and health services and education services and economic development in a place where very often there was none.
Mandy Gull-MastySo when you further add on the layer of what residential school has done, what kind of harms were perpetuated by the 60s scoop, and all of these policies, and you mix them up in a great big bowl, that bowl is quite large. And I don't think, you know, the question is how much has to be spent on reconciliation. I think there is a component of responsibility that we have because government policy and legislation requires us to drive these things.
Mandy Gull-MastySome of it is, you know, investing and ensuring that we're building a system that is going to create space to heal from the trauma that was perpetuated by government. But I think that there's a human component of reconciliation that is not uh something that can be costed out. And reconciliation is about relationship to me, ultimately at the end of the day. The reconciliation approaches of the former government was their own. The reconciliation approaches of this government are going to be shaped by the space that we're in.
Mandy Gull-MastyThe reconciliation response by the next government will be in that time. And I think that is the conversation that people have to ask themselves. Instead of focusing on X number of dollars of investment into this space, what about the human component? What are you doing as an individual, as a person, as a leader to ensure that you're working towards the reconciliatory nature of relationship? And I think that's something that I don't hear a lot about.
Mandy Gull-MastyFor me as a minister, that reconciliation component in looking at relationship actually resides in institutional reconciliation. What kind of changes can I make within this institute to be a better partner, a better service provider, somebody that's going to empower and help lift up the people that I serve? That means I have to do a lot of change within the institute itself, helping people understand that that's part of the process. Reconciliation, it's been it's taken hundreds of years to perpetuate the harms that have existed in this country.
Mandy Gull-MastyIs it going to take hundreds of years for reconciliation to heal from them? I hope not. But we are the drivers and determiners of what that time frame looks like. I think that we could do better.
Aaron PeteThank you so much for being willing to share your time. I know how busy you are. And I just I do appreciate you answering some, I hope, tougher questions, but I also just appreciate the sincerity you brought to a lot of your answers because I do find that the political temperature has increased where it feels like at times both sides have a slogan and they yell it at each other and we're just talking past each other. And I don't think many of us are part of either of those two groups. We're just trying to find a way for, like for me, to make sure my members rise out of poverty, that the living conditions in their homes are better, to make sure that homes are now built to their building code of the province rather than being built below those standards, to make sure that kids have the opportunity to reach whatever goal they dream of, and that we don't have a s a segment of society that are put behind the eight ball, so they can't rise up.
Aaron PeteAnd I really hope that that's the end result of reconciliation. My hope is that we do see over the next 20 years that Indigenous people are not at the belower the lower rates of education rates, employment rates, addiction rates, uh, and that we see them rise up so that we're not talking about them as being the most vulnerable anymore. We're talking about them as being the most successful. And when you talk about children graduating more, and we see 10% and hopefully 10% the next year, so we're on a trajectory out of a lot of these circumstances, and so that we can see our people rise up to the position that you're in today, where we're leaders and we're setting the example.
Aaron PeteAnd I think you're inspiring a lot of people. It's not an easy file to carry, particularly with First Nations having to hear their concerns and I'm sure know their concerns from the seat they're sitting in. Uh, so great respect to you, Minister, for being willing to take on this very difficult work, a file that's very controversial right now, uh, and trying to find the pathway forward. So I really appreciate your time uh and you answering all of my questions.
Mandy Gull-MastyThank you. I really appreciate being on the show. Happy to have this conversation, happy to come back to answer any questions on the work that we do here and happy to learn about your leadership and support you as well.
Aaron PeteBeautiful. How can people follow your work?
Mandy Gull-MastyUh, you could follow me on our Facebook page, Mandy Golmasty is the professional political one. Uh, on my social media, Mandying Around, if you want a glimpse into my personal life. I'm maxed out on my Facebook friends, uh, but I do, you know, hope that you will follow me. I'm on all platforms, Facebook, Instagram, I'm even on Snapchat. Uh, I really love to hear from youth. So if you want to ask me questions or show me what it looks like in your world and community, uh, I'm interested to learn about people.
Mandy Gull-MastyA lot of the exchanges that I have on there uh have helped me understand in my decision making the impact directly on people that are going to live with the policy decisions that I make. So really appreciate that.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Economists Jack Mintz and Eric Protzer join host Aaron Pete to discuss how Canada can navigate Donald Trump's trade policies, assess Mark Carney's economic strategy, and strengthen the Canadian economy through trade...