Economists Jack Mintz and Eric Protzer join host Aaron Pete to discuss how Canada can navigate Donald Trump's trade policies, assess Mark Carney's economic strategy, and strengthen the Canadian economy through trade diversification, tax reform, and improved productivity while reducing its dependence on the United States. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Aaron PeteWhat are your thoughts on supply management and the process to resolve that with the US?
SPEAKER_02Well well, I I think you're gonna be very hard-pressed to find a serious economist of any kind who supports supply management. Why are we actually destroying milk and and cheese and what have you when we could be uh selling it? I'm just wondering how would you rate the performance of Prime Minister Mark Tarney to date? I'm personally actually relatively pleased with his performance.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think I have uh a bit of more of a mixed view. I'm not a big fan of industrial policy.
Aaron PeteHow hard do you think Canada should fight for access to the American market and trying to continue to grow that?
SPEAKER_00I think in the end it's gonna have to be with the United States, whether we like it or not.
SPEAKER_02We can't uh continue to be in this position where we are just utterly beholden to the United States strategically. We can we can be a better friend and an ally, we can be uh a more uh sovereign version of ourselves if we uh if we diversify our international trade at the same time as maintaining a trading relationship.
Aaron PeteEric is making the case that maintaining the status quo creates its own economic and strategic risks. What do you say to that argument? Eric. Jack, thank you so much for joining us for another nuanced debate. I'm very excited to have you both on. I'll ask each of you to introduce yourself. Jack, you've joined the show before. Would you mind briefly reintroducing yourself to listeners?
SPEAKER_00Okay, well, I'm uh President's Fellow of the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary, although I live in Toronto, so it is very confusing for people. Um, but I also do a number of other things, including regular column in the financial posts, as well as various consulting things. And lately I've been working with the Inter-American Development Bank on Caribbean and Latin American uh tax systems. And so uh uh that's just one example of the various things that I did.
Aaron PeteThank you, Eric.
SPEAKER_02Uh I'm I'm Eric. I'm a senior research fellow at Harvard University's growth lab. Uh I'm I'm from Vancouver Island. Uh and uh I've worked on you know different uh economic policy issues around the world, uh, different governments, different places, both developed and developing settings. Uh obviously uh have this new book out that I'm eager to uh chat about Canada after America.
Aaron PeteEric, would you mind? So this is uh a bit of a debate, but also meant to be a discussion, a thoughtful discussion. Would you mind outlining and summarizing uh the book uh and then we'll let Jack respond?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, certainly, certainly. Um so you know, we're we're obviously in a precarious moment in Canada's economic history. We we've seen that uh there has been, you know, a series of threats, coercion from the United States in the form of disruption to our trade relationship. Uh unfortunately, we are uh, you know, the smaller partner in that. We don't have huge amounts of leverage necessarily. And so there is this question that everybody's been thinking about of how do we navigate this?
SPEAKER_02How do we uh respond um to that kind of threat? So, what we try to do in the book is we try try to think through very carefully um how do we envision a uh you know, a new kind of international trade relationship for Canada, not a world without the US, but a world in which we're not so much hostage to the US, not so singularly dependent on that relationship overwhelmingly. Um, so uh how we attack that is that we first recognize that the disruption of the trade relationship with the US amounts to a shock to Canada's economic geography in a sense.
SPEAKER_02That uh, you know, we've benefited for a long time from being adjacent to the world's largest economy, and that has made us uh you know a proximate uh economy uh to uh the the rest of the world in in a sense, but now we're dealing with a situation where there has been an effective increase in distance, uh, which makes us uh considerably more remote. Uh so we what we've uh done is we've analyzed, well, what are the different industries that are uh compatible with that kind of remoteness, that kind of uh distance?
SPEAKER_02And and there are um you know some obvious options. For one, Canada has absolutely got to take advantage of its natural resource endowments. There uh is definitely hunger for that uh around the world. Um there are other uh you know obvious industries like uh tradable services, things like like finance and software, uh where um the logistical challenges may remain, but you're not shipping so much, or there's not intensive supply chain coordination. But then uh with with regard to um uh uh goods themselves, uh we emphasize that there are some supply chains that are more distance resilient than others.
SPEAKER_02So uh, for example, things like pharmaceuticals and aerospace tend to have uh more global or less uh you know distance sensitive supply chains. Uh, we then unpack, well, what can Canada do to bolster that? Um uh Canada has unfortunately been a laggard on commercial innovation for quite some time. It's it's uh RD in the private sector as a share of GDP has been persistently low versus peer countries. Um we uh we argue that that is uh in in no small part a scaling phenomenon, that uh Canada struggles to scale up uh companies in several important uh industries and uh particularly in industries that are intensive in uh regulatory requirements or or cap requirements.
SPEAKER_02We um have a chapter furthermore on uh housing, just denoting that uh even if Canada is successful at activating new innovation industries with a global reach in order to make sure that most Canadians can actually access that wealth, it's important to address Canada's persistent uh urban housing shortages so that more people can share in that prosperity.
Aaron PeteJack, I'll pass it over to you. What are your reflections on what you just heard?
SPEAKER_00Well, let me first of all uh start that uh I don't think uh there's uh much of a disagreement on my part about the value of trade diversification. I mean, we've been talking about that in Canada for years and years and years. Uh in fact, back in the early night um 19 uh 70s, it was I think it was the 70s or 80s anyway, you know, it's early 70s. There was this uh concern about uh US uh tariff on uh on goods uh uh as part of the conversion to the uh uh moving away from the golden gold standard in the in the United States that Nixon brought in.
SPEAKER_00And that prompted uh uh Canada to start saying we need to develop other uh other markets. Um but of course, as what we saw later on, that didn't happen. In fact, the opposite happened. Uh Canada became even more linked uh to the United States. And and the problem is, of course, the uh economics drives you there. Uh uh trade is very much affected by transport costs uh and and and and also culture. You know, it's easier to deal with a country where you have the same culture, the same language, uh, compared to trying to deal with uh very different cultures elsewhere.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't mean you can't do it, but it's but it is uh there's a tendency to, you know, gang companies when they're first going abroad, they tend to look at the United States partly for that reason. And it's also a very it's a huge market, it's one quarter of uh the world GDP, so having access to that market was very important, which is of course what the 1988 free trade agreement was all about with the United States, that Mulrini uh was able to actually under uh uh undertake a major change in Canadian philosophy at that time, uh, which uh there was a lot of deep anti-Americanism at various points in Canadian history.
SPEAKER_00Uh, and yet he won an election on free trade, which was really quite a significant change. And uh generally that has done Canada quite well uh in many ways, but of course it does make you vulnerable in trade to the most, you know, to one particular market. But when you look at uh, you know, the major goods that we sell to the United States, uh, the auto industry is completely tied into the North American market. Uh, it is very unlikely that it could expand other countries. I'm not uh sure whether Eric has that view or not, but I don't see Yeah, I would I would agree with that.
SPEAKER_02Uh sorry, I'll let you keep going, but we can I'll jump in with more thoughts when you're done. Keep going.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but the auto industry I think is going to still be very tied up, and that's our second largest export uh in terms of auto and parts to uh to the rest of the world. In the case of um of the res of energy, uh, which is our most important export, uh, we could have actually done some more diversification. I mean, certainly both in terms of oil and natural gas, we could have sold more to the rest of the world, but we hampered ourselves in terms of allowing that to be built over the past 10 years, 15 years.
SPEAKER_00In fact, uh they were people forget back in the uh in the in the first uh first part of the second decade of the century, uh there were a tremendous number of LG proposals uh for the West Coast. I forget the number now, but uh I was on the board of a company that was uh that was uh had one of those proposals, but they all fell away except for uh one basically. And so, which we finally uh got into protection in 2027. But we had a government at that time that completely discouraged any type of international exports.
SPEAKER_00And so we suffered as a result while Australia and the United States was building LNG for the rest of the world uh and uh quite profitably. So uh we did hurt ourselves there, and I think there are diversification opportunities, no question in my mind, uh, with that. And as you go down all through the different types of goods and and services that we sell, there are there are some opportunities, but I don't think it's going to be that easy to ever replace the US market uh for Canada. And so it's a question of management. And I think a lot of the hostility and issues right now that people are raising about concerns or vulnerability is due to kind of the recent American posture, you know, under Trump.
SPEAKER_00But things will change in two, three, four years, five years, as we saw back in the 1970s when when the uh Americans were uh put on this 10% ta uh tariff, and then all of a sudden everybody uh started reacting to it in Canada. There was a great deal of uh anger about US investment in Canada, as we might remember back in the 1970s. We wanted to block it. Uh and so uh that changed a lot uh later on because the economics simply drive you there.
SPEAKER_00So so we'll have to see what at the time. I don't have a problem with diversification if the economics allow that.
Aaron PeteGo ahead, Eric, if you'd like to respond.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, certain certainly. I I I mean, I I I think we have a lot of agreement, uh, quite honestly. I I know this is supposed to be a debate, but I I think we can have a thoughtful discussion. I I think the point on the auto industry is uh very salient. Um, I mean, there's a lot of uh evidence. People even talk about in the literature with a reference to the auto industry about factory Europe, factory North America, factory Asia. And uh the reality is that that industry is very much regional. It's it's not really a hugely globalized industry.
SPEAKER_02And it's because the logistics involved are so intense. You know, you have new uh car models coming out all the time. You have uh hundreds of thousands of models being produced, lots and lots of different parts. If something goes wrong, you need to have a factory right next to you to coordinate. And uh that is one area where I would doubt that Canada would be able to uh you know create a more globalized auto industry in in particular. And that that's why uh we emphasize in the book the importance uh of uh you know developing other areas uh of trade, other kinds of industries.
SPEAKER_02Uh it does include natural resources, like you mentioned, Jack. Uh, that certainly is one area where Canada has not done enough and could do more to get our natural resources to global markets, um, but also to develop uh other advanced manufacturers to uh solve our issues that are so persistent with our uh laggard status as an innovator uh in order to build up new, really globalized industries, uh, build additional sources of income, uh, not only because those things are worthwhile doing for their own ends, but because uh it reduces how lopsided the relationship with the United States is and thus the amount of leverage that any future administration um could possibly have over Canada.
SPEAKER_02I I think it's a really interesting question, and especially, you know, today uh when we're talking, it's the US midterms, right? Um, it's a really interesting question of what will happen politically in the United States uh and how will that affect Canada's future? Can we just, you know, sort of uh forget anything happened with uh Trump and go back to a world of continued integration with the United States and hoping that uh thing things all play out nicely? I I think what um what Trump has revealed is that uh, you know, even if we do have good friends as things were when uh NAFTA was signed originally, it's difficult to envision what's going to happen 20 years later, 30 years later, and uh Canada can't really control what happens in US politics.
SPEAKER_02Um I so I I do think it is worthwhile to nevertheless diversify international trade just to remove that possibility of well, you know, there could be a future US president in the vein of MAGA who uses that relationship as a cudgel again. Uh things are cyclical in politics, they can swing back and forth. Uh diversification off Canada's trade relationships, I think, would be nevertheless helpful.
Aaron PeteJack, in September you published an article arguing that trade diversification comes with a heavy economic cost, warning about lost GDP and jobs. Eric is making the case that maintaining the status quo creates its own economic and strategic risks. What do you say to that argument?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think uh, first of all, uh what I was trying to argue was that trying to force uh trade diversification by subsidizing industries to export to certain industries, uh countries and things like that is is not going to be a way of trying to solve our problems. Uh actually what we uh we'll probably get into this, but we need to uh I think focus on building up um the uh uh the competitiveness of the canine economy, investment and things like that, which is a a goal right now of the government. There may be different ways that one can argue about how to do that, but I think there's uh certainly uh, you know, I I think certainly there's uh uh you know things to think about.
SPEAKER_00Um what I was trying to say is that trying to stop our trade with the United States and simply uh thinking that we're going to export more to other countries uh by kind of forcing it uh through government policy, I'm not sure is as as successful as one would think. We have done the right we have actually created a number of trade agreements uh since NAFTA in 1994, of which the two most important ones was the original one, the Trans Pacific Partnership, uh and uh which was later renamed to add the word progressive because liberal tradable government liked the word progressive in it.
SPEAKER_00Um but uh uh but we um we also had the uh CETA, the one with the comprehensive economic trade agreement with uh with the European Union. And but when you actually look at what they actually accomplished in more trade uh with other countries, you know, it's been positive but not particularly large. And in fact, I uh one of the pieces I did write was showing actually which share of uh imports um of another country uh does Canada account for.
SPEAKER_00In the case of the United States, uh we're about 11% of um of US imports, uh, which by the way is only 1% of uh of uh US GDP. So it means that we don't have a big impact on on the United States, which is part of our vulnerability, of course. Um and the um and the and the other aspect is what it's even worse for other countries like EU. It's only like 1.7% of their imports and et cetera, et cetera. So yes, we could probably take advantage of more trade with other countries.
SPEAKER_00I think there are some uh things that could be done. And part of it is, you know, making sure we have a port system that works properly, we have a regulatory system that works properly. Uh and I oh and I've been an advocate of uh big bang tax reform, which I think could also uh you know create a lot more uh potential investment in Canada, uh potentially uh potentially scaling up businesses, which by the way, we have talked about for decades about how to scale up businesses, and of course we haven't done it uh because it's hard with a small population spread over a very large area close to the United States.
SPEAKER_00So it's been which is one of the reasons we we tend to be such a regional uh based economy. Uh but I but I think as a result of all these various factors, uh, you know, we we we probably can try to do more than we can in terms of some of the things that we we we do. Uh, but I think a lot of it comes down to domestic policy in trying to actually just generate more investment and uh and uh and uh economic growth, which uh we lost over the past decade from 2015 to 2025 was a very poor decade.
SPEAKER_00And I think we've now seen a government has gone back to really a previous philosophy of of uh you know uh trying to uh improve the conditions for for economic growth uh in the country, as well as you know, maintain the kind of social policies that we like as a country.
Aaron PeteEric, I will uh welcome your response on that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I think you raised a couple of uh really interesting points, Jack. Uh one one point that I liked and that we discussed in um you know briefly in the book is that diversification is about, well, trade diversification is about much more than just signing free trade policies, uh free trade agreements with other countries. That, you know, certainly is a lubricant to any kind of a trade relationship. But if you if you don't have the domestic capacity to actually uh operate the industry, then um you know you're not gonna see things uh uh scale up.
SPEAKER_02And and that that persistent scaling issue that you mentioned, it it is really, really important to tackle. One of the uh analytical forays we do in the book is uh looking at that that scaling and how that relates to innovation outcomes. And uh there was a really interesting pattern that we landed on, which is that uh in most tech industries, uh Canada has you know a pretty low uh presence in terms of uh the amount of RD that it does per capita versus other high-income countries around the world.
SPEAKER_02But there's one really interesting exception, and that's in software and ICT. In software and ICT, we are actually one of the top countries uh that does the most uh business RD per capita. And um we we tied this to the uh the the scaling phenomenon by uh looking at a couple of other things. One was the fact that in uh all of these other tech industries, Canada really has a a paucity of uh large firms that are present there. Whereas uh we actually do have some in software and Ict.
SPEAKER_02It it tends to be companies that aren't necessarily household names. Um so they they don't necessarily get on people's radar. It's not you know the Microsoft and the Googles of the world, but it it's it is things like Shopify and OpenText, more B2B companies. Um and uh I you know there is a a relationship there between uh size and and the ability to uh to actually innovate. Um uh you know, in other OECD uh countries that are some of the top uh innovators around the world, places like Germany and Taiwan and Japan and what have you, uh, the share of business RD that is done by very large companies, it's the lion's share in those other those other companies.
SPEAKER_02And it's because you those uh you know, those huge companies, they have the wherewithal, the financial means, uh, the resources at that scale to actually invest in in RD. Whereas um uh you know, in in uh Canada, we just uh don't have those those large companies operating. Um so we thought that was a interesting pattern to observe because uh so much of the discussion around scaling um essentially says, well, okay, Canada is small.
SPEAKER_02It's a small country. It's sort of our fate that we're not going to be able to compete with the likes of the US and China. Um, but at the same time, you know, there are other countries around the world that are smaller, not just than Canada, but smaller even than, say, Ontario, that are um considerably more successful at commercial innovation, places like Israel, places like Sweden, places like Denmark. Uh some of those in the case of the Nordics are also adjacent to much larger economies, uh, you know, Germany in their case. Um so we think that you know, there's not necessarily a complete and utter restriction on Canada's possibilities just because we're not the biggest country in the world.
SPEAKER_02Uh we we we think that rather the fact that we are successful in uh software at scaling things up and doing innovation um maybe points toward the uh importance of uh of regulatory issues and and of scaling and capital access uh in order to get those. Companies to the size and maturity that we need to in order to compete internationally.
Aaron PeteJack, can I just uh transition a little bit to the reality that we're seeing? And we're hearing from Prime Minister Mark Carney and uh President Donald Trump that there may be a deal on the table. How do you think Canada should be approaching that? Are we on the right track with a potential deal on the table? How optimistic are you? And how would you kind of navigate this from your perspective?
SPEAKER_00Well, I hope we do get a deal. I think it's gonna be very important. Uh partly because of that relationship is still there and it's not gonna disappear, and it's very important to our economy. Um and uh and so uh, but I do find it's very interesting. I mean, the one we'll we'll see, we don't know yet what's in the deal, what's even being discussed. Even all this discussion about the European Union alignment, whatever that means, we still don't understand it. Uh and in fact, I was looking up to see what does it mean to be part of the Erasmus program in you know in you know in uh in the European Union and and uh can we really actually work work in that context?
SPEAKER_00In fact, I've been talking to some people with some questions about that. But it but you know, you have to get into the details. But I found the one thing that I I find very interesting is uh the because it's one thing that Trump did mention, uh, was to uh basically build Keystone XL. Well, there goes our diversification in the energy industry, because Keystone XL will add another million uh well, it could be potentially a million more right now, probably around 800,000 barrels per day going down to the United States.
SPEAKER_00But that would all of a sudden offset some of the changes that would occur. I would not oppose that. I think actually uh Keystone XL would make create a lot of income for uh uh Canada and for and and jobs and everything else. So uh but as far as as economic diversification is actually going in the other direction. And that's gonna happen, I think, in terms of any kind of deal with the United States. There's still gonna be um uh, I think, a desire to make sure that we can maintain some of the uh relationship that we do have and not seeing uh uh our uh industries being hurt.
SPEAKER_00As we're seeing right now in the auto sector, in the manufacturing sector in Ontario and Quebec, there's been job losses. There have been I've been talking to a number of uh Canadian companies that uh, you know, they've been holding off to see how everything kind of works off, but it's it's now two years, and uh uh they're already starting to expand their production in the United States. Uh they're not leaving Canada yet, or some have decided to do that, but uh but you are getting that. Why? Because the U.S. market is so large, and that's why the scaling up in Canada is tough for that reason.
SPEAKER_00It's because of the size of the market. Now, I agree with Eric, there's lots of exceptions to that. I was a board, I was on the board of Brookfield Asset Management, a terrific international company that that works everywhere. I know the founder, very good friend of mine of OpenTex, although they're having a lot of trouble lately at OpenTax for for uh given the changes in tech artificial intelligence and what's impacting on on the business. But uh, but this is not to say that we can't we can't do well, but where I think we hurt ourselves is in some of the some of the um regulations that we have uh that I think have made it harder to have a stronger IT sector.
SPEAKER_00So take a look at our uh telecommunications sector, uh protected by international comp uh from international competition. But do you see our telecommunication sector going international, becoming you know, big players uh at the international market, like some of the companies that you see internationally? No, you don't. And that's because they they have a well-protected, easy market in Canada to deal with, and they don't have to go international. There's nothing pressing them to do it. And and and it's the same thing with our banks and and others.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, so we actually through our various regulations and things like that, we we d we we sometimes encourage companies just to be domestic. And that's what worries me now about some of the insuring that we talk about and some of the uh regulations that we're now thinking about, you know, favoring domestic um producers and things like that. It's gonna be just another form of protection uh for the domestic market, which means that we won't scale up. We'll we'll end up being mainly working in our own country.
Aaron PeteEric, what are your reflections on that? How would you how do you think we're approaching President Trump in the correct way and moving in the right direction?
SPEAKER_02Well, I I think we've gotta see how the uh midterms can come in, quite honestly. And and uh I wouldn't be surprised if privately part of the strategy on the part of you know Carney was playing for time a little bit to see how things would shake out because if uh I I checked the betting markets this morning and on poly market it says there's a 77% uh implied probability from speculators that uh the den Democrats will take the U.S. Senate. And that that does change the calculus involved.
SPEAKER_02It does mean that Canada gets more leverage in in making a deal. Um, you know, obviously I I uh would agree with Jack in in that we we should you know get some kind of uh agreement if it is sufficiently favorable uh to Canada. Um, that is uh an important thing to do if it is the right deal and not one that just you know is overwhelmingly lopsided and would destroy Canadian industry. Um but uh you know at the same time as working on our international trade diversification strategy, yeah, we can't just uh completely abandon and ignore the American market.
SPEAKER_02It it is uh right there and overwhelmingly large, and and we should continue to uh to engage. Um I I thought uh Jack's comments on uh regulation were um uh very much on point. One of one of the uh topics that we touch on in the book is uh, for example, the set of regulatory uh practices and and conditions involved in the uh life sciences sector in Canada that can make it very difficult to scale up a company.
SPEAKER_02If you look at the time it takes to get a medicine to market in Canada versus the most competitive comp uh, the most competitive countries, it's staggeringly long. Uh, you know, we're talking about uh years sometimes to get a new medicine to market. And you can even find uh instances uh in the news of Canadian biotech companies that say, well, you know, we built this company in in Canada, but ultimately we had to go to uh a completely different country to get it to market for the first time because it was just faster.
SPEAKER_02Uh and you can imagine how that kind of uh that kind of slowness can uh make it very difficult to launch and to you know start making revenue as a Canadian biotech company. Um the the you know you know the issue is that uh there's all these approval procedures, some are federal, some are provincial, and uh other countries tend to do these things in parallel so that there's multiple things happening at the same time. Canada tends to do them in sequence. And and you can imagine if you're doing the same steps one after another very deliberately, uh it might save some bureaucratic cost involved because you avoid redundancy and maybe something fails at an early stage and you avoid certain steps of the process, but it also makes it very long and it makes it very difficult uh for a Canadian life sciences company to to uh mature and get to market as a result.
SPEAKER_00Could I just add one point because I agreed with I agree with the points, Eric, but I would add on another another point. That's the way we run our healthcare system in Canada. When I was on the uh panel on healthcare innovation, we heard from the people that actually were innovating, you know, new types of medical equipment, new types of drugs, things like that. Their comment was about uh was about the formularies in in Canada, where uh it was very hard to sell domestically in the K market. They basically had to go uh they had to export.
SPEAKER_00And the reason for that was because the formularies uh only will accept new innovations if they reduce costs. But if they have significant benefits at a higher cost, they reject them. And so the domestic market is basically shut down by the healthcare system and the way we run the healthcare system in Canada. And in terms of trying to go to export, then they complained it was really well, they I shouldn't say complain, but they raised they raised the issues of how how difficult it was actually to export to international markets because Canada's um uh government is relatively small, and that the American uh producers have a uh a lot more power in various markets because the commerce department in the United States is very will really go after a country to open up uh you know to open up their market to to American producers, or Canada doesn't have the same leverage.
SPEAKER_00So I think, you know, in my view, uh necessity is always the motherhood of invention. Um Israel is absolutely remarkable. It's it's the biggest spender of RD as a shared GDP in all OECD countries, 6% of GDP. They are have they are very innovative, but of course that's been hugely driven by security requirements. And so um uh and as a result, but they've also have a lot of innovative things and other things as well, but they've really sponsored that through a very uh very common a very well pre uh developed plan to to uh be highly innovative and it's done the uh country very well.
SPEAKER_00And so it is possible, like Eric said, have a small country to do well, but but you really have to create the conditions to do that. And as long as we continue doing some of the things that we do in Canada, we won't be able to scale up. And I think that's that's the issue.
Aaron PeteEric, when you look at Prime Minister Mark Carney right now, he's getting close to two years into his mandate. And I've interviewed multiple people, including Jack, where we talk about external politics, creating relationships with the EU, um, trying to navigate the U.S. relationship, trying to sign other agreements. But then, and I I think you alluded to it, the internal mechanisms of improving cross-provincial trade, uh, updating our tax policies, these have all, from my perspective, potentially been lagging.
Aaron PeteAnd I'm just wondering, how would you rate the performance of Prime Minister Mark Carney to date?
SPEAKER_02Well, I I I think he's been uh you know very energetic and he's made a number of uh you know significant moves to uh try to get things in in the right direction. I'm I'm personally actually relatively pleased with his performance. I I think the reality is is that uh a lot of the things that Canada needs to do are objectively very difficult and very politically contentious. That's that's a big uh uh part of the challenge. I you know, I think that uh where Mark Kearney has done uh maybe especially well has been on uh trying to expedite getting Canada's natural resources to world markets in particular, things like the major projects office, things like trying to negotiate a West Coast pipeline, um, uh thing things like the um uh the the new taxation regime uh to reduce the uh marginal effective tax rate on on uh capital.
SPEAKER_02Uh that that's very helpful for all these capital-intensive resource projects. Uh, I think that if there was to be uh an Act II, uh, I think more could be done with regard to fixing the innovation problem specifically. And the there has been um some movement on on that. Uh, you know, the the RD tax credit spread, uh, they were updated uh to an extent, for example, but there's still bias towards being favorable for uh small firms and then you know not necessarily providing the same generosity as from scale.
SPEAKER_02And if we have a scaling problem, it might be worth thinking about uh rebalancing uh that relationship as an example.
Aaron PeteJack, what are your take on Prime Minister Mark Carney and his performance?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think I have a a bit of more of a mixed um view. Uh on one hand, uh, and here I agree with uh with uh Eric, is that uh I think that there's a um I'm really pleased to see that there's this orientation towards uh economic growth and in in public policy. We didn't have that for 10 years under the Trudeau government. And so there's been a shift back to really what the Harbor government is trying to do, uh, as well as the Creaton and the Martin government, uh and the Mulroney government, uh which by the way, I worked under all of them.
SPEAKER_00So I really have uh I have had I've had gone through these different governments, and the Trudeau government was really quite a uh a big shift in public policy, away from uh looking at uh you know, uh thinking about economic growth. Um so I think I uh I'm really pleased to see that, and I agree with uh some of the things that are trying to be achieved, like to reduce regulatory costs and things like that. But my biggest concern is that there's still uh uh a problem, I think, in terms of uh of uh how to approach these issues.
SPEAKER_00Um my view, uh I'm not a big fan of industrial policy. I affect the United States really, you know, you're now seeing Trump get into industrial policy, but frankly, the U.S. has been, I think has always had a very strong private sector despite what the government does uh in the United States, which is amazing. Uh but in Canada, we've always been so reliant on governments to direct things. But I think that we do need to have some general regulatory changes and some general tax changes and things like that.
SPEAKER_00So even the even the um uh productivity uh mega uh deduction, uh which Eric referred to, uh, I'm not a big fan of that. In fact, it to me reminds me of the 1970s when government started with all these investment tax credits and accelerated depreciation favoring some industries over other industries, which is what this one's doing. And and it it leads to um unfortunately, it leads to uh you know some serious um uh distortions in the economy.
SPEAKER_00And then what happened since I was brought into finance in 1984, we it was there was a view that I had to clean up the system. There were a lot of companies ended up not paying taxes, so a lot of these incentives didn't matter anymore, uh, or at least, you know, and or they were trying to figure out how to get their tax losses from one to another. Uh, the system was just completely uh out of whack. And so the view became we had to we we had to clean up the system, get rid of all these uh investment tax credits, accelerated depreciation, special preferences in the system, and just simply lower corporate rates, which were quite high actually at that time.
SPEAKER_00And and so I'm I'm a great fan of neutrality when it comes to business taxation, in that in not trying to pick which which industry is going to be the winner and the loser, but really to support all of them. And and that's that's what I see right now with the current system, which I think is a problem, in in terms of there's still a lot of being direction coming from the federal government about which industries to invest in. And I think I think that that's that could be a recipe for failure down the road.
Aaron PeteEric, what are your thoughts on Jack's perspective on taxation?
SPEAKER_02I I well, taxation among other other things that uh Jack mentioned. I I mean, um I I I think there's there's other elements actually where there could be uh uh increased neutrality to Jack's point, where it might actually help scaling specifically. Uh one one of the issues we touch on in on in the book is uh you know, it's politically contentious, but Canada actually has very preferable uh corporate tax rate for rates for small businesses compared to other uh high-income countries around the world.
SPEAKER_02Um there was a um uh you know a paper from um some academics in Alberta, it might have been University of Calgary, if I'm remembering correctly, that was looking at the size of the the tax wall that's um in companies face as as they scale. It's absolutely huge in in Canada. That was like a patron.
SPEAKER_01Oh, that was your was that? Oh, there you go. It's so funny.
SPEAKER_00Uh yeah, well, I won't disagree with you. I'm listening.
SPEAKER_01We talked about that in the book. That's hilarious.
SPEAKER_02Um the the uh the other um the other um you know article that I liked on this topic was from a uh Bank of Canada economist who uh looked at changes in the um the tax threshold uh that applies to small versus you know larger businesses in Canada over time. And um what the really interesting finding was was that uh small businesses actually adjust the amount of uh of business that they do, the amount of uh revenue that they do, so that they can come in just under the threshold where the tax level changes.
SPEAKER_02And and you know, it goes back and forth over time, but they keep you know running and trying to hit this moving moving target. And uh it's it's really easy to imagine how that discourages scaling. If you have an incentive to stay small, stay below this uh threshold, then um uh you know, of course, companies aren't just going to grow to uh to become bigger. And um it does come with a significant cost. The I remember the OECD uh estimated that the the uh cost uh in terms of you know foregone tax revenue uh that is associated with the very favorable low tax rates for small businesses in Canada is uh bigger than the entire cost of the SRNED uh tax credit.
SPEAKER_02So that would be one element you know where maybe a more neutral tax system uh could come into play.
Aaron PeteEric, very quickly, I just I don't think I got your answer on the comment. Do you think Canada should try and enter into a new trade agreement as soon as possible? There's talks that there may be one on the table. Would you in in principle support trying to resolve this as well?
SPEAKER_02Sorry, with the United States, you mean specifically?
Aaron PeteYes, correct.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. I mean, provided it's it's the right kind of uh agreement. I, you know, the the prior iteration that we saw in in the summer, uh, I I just don't know how Canada's auto industry would have survived on under that one, quite honestly. And you know, not that I have you know years of experience in the auto industry, I very much don't, but uh it it seemed like, by all appearances, that it would have been close to fatal, if not de facto fatal to Canada's auto industry. So, you know, that that's a version of a deal that would not have been acceptable.
SPEAKER_02Uh but we we should nevertheless strive to get a more balanced deal and uh let's see how the midterms go today. It may be that Canada gets more leverage as a result and that uh we we can get a free trade deal um that that is more reasonable.
Aaron PeteJack, what was your take on that on that deal that was previously offered? There were concerns, I think, as well about Canadian sovereignty and and the rules around being able to reach out to other countries in foreign trade deals. Did you support that initial one?
SPEAKER_00Well, the problem is we don't really know what was being discussed. Uh, you know, you do hear a different, somewhat different points of view of obviously between the United States and Canada, and both of them are going to be presenting their their own argument in in whatever form they want to. Um I do agree with Eric. Probably uh I think the biggest concern was over the large vehicle, uh, you know, the larger vehicle uh issues, and and that may have been a problem. But some of the other things that came up, uh the Amer I know the Americans really don't care that much about uh issues about, you know, French and you know and you know being required and things like that.
SPEAKER_00I think that was that was uh I don't think there was any any basis to that. In fact, I do know that the Americans what they were upset about was tariffs on streamers. They weren't tariffs, they were ta new taxes on streamers, uh, partly because the stream I've talked to the streamers themselves about that. Um and and that was a big issue for for them, as well as previously the digital service uh uh sales tax, which of course is not just Canada, other countries they've been quite uh going after.
SPEAKER_00And there is a bigger issue out there over data saver sovereignty uh in the in the in the you know in in uh in these in these issues uh you know with Meta and and all these other American uh dominant firms in the world now. And of course the Europeans are talking about it, and we're talking about it, and things like that. And I think that's an issue that's gonna be one that's not resolved uh very easily, but I think that will be uh that will be potentially part of any uh trade negotiation, I think, uh down the road. Um so I think uh, and of course, supply management is something that the Americans have complained about a long time.
SPEAKER_00I would love to see us get rid of supply management. I think it's just a dreadful program. And it's it's a good example. When you put a policy in like that one, it's very hard to undo it uh once you create a uh a special interest group that wants to keep it in. And that's what we're gonna see with the tariffs in the United States, that even when Biden came in after the first Trump, uh, he didn't get rid of the tr Trump's tariffs very easily. And you're gonna see this after the um after Trump is gone in 2028, and who knows it could be even a Democrat uh uh government by that point in in 2028.
SPEAKER_00I will bet you that we will not see a big change in terror policy in the United States because they are becoming very reliant on the revenues. You know,$200 billion a year is two trillion dollars over ten years, and that's how they look at their budgets. And so So uh that's that's not given the size of their deficits, they're not going to be wanting to give up revenues that easily. So um and and they will also have a lot of special interest groups that will want to keep their protection, just like we've seen in Canada, with the same sort of thing. So so I think, you know, I think uh you know, uh I'm not sure what a good agreement means.
SPEAKER_00Everyone says, oh, you know, if it's a if if it's a good agreement, then that's fine. But let's see what uh what we're talking about in terms of a good agreement.
Aaron PeteEric, we needed to get here supply management. I've been accused of being a shill for big supply management because I don't ask economists enough about their perspectives on it. What are your thoughts on supply management uh and the process to resolve that with the US?
SPEAKER_02Well, well, I I think you're gonna be very hard-pressed to find a serious economist of any kind who supports supply management. There's very obvious inefficiencies in the system. I mean, it's it's a quota system, it's not truly a free market in the uh purest sense of it. And it does hobble Canadian production and productivity. It drives a cost unnecessarily. It is really an awful system. Um, there's uh two points around that that we highlight in the book about just how um absurd the uh results of the supply management system are.
SPEAKER_02One is the fact that Canada uh actually has a history of destroying dairy rather than allowing it to uh be sold. And and I'm you know, people are very concerned about the cost of living these days. Why are we actually destroying milk and and and cheese and what have you when we could be uh selling it? The the other um the other point is that uh, you know, uh we we should be trying to diversify on all fronts, and uh agriculture could be one of those. And uh, you know, there are some elements of the agricultural system that are not quite so protected, but uh dairy and poultry very much are.
SPEAKER_02Um and it's it's uh striking that New Zealand, tiny New Zealand, that has only a fraction of Canada's population, a fraction of Canada's land area, exports more dairy in Canada. It's it's preposterous. And uh they they you know do not have uh supply management uh anymore. Uh they have a very uh competitive industry there that has been forced into the international export uh sector, as it were, uh forced to become productive, to become hyper-efficient.
SPEAKER_02And uh now it's it's it's a global brand, you know, New Zealand dairy, New Zealand milk. Uh why can't Canada do the same thing? We absolutely should dismantle supply management. And it it is really just uh a set of special interests that wants to defend an unproductive, uncompetitive system that benefits them and makes everybody else worse off.
Aaron PeteJack, you've argued for major tax reform, including reducing the general federal corporate income tax rate to 10% and shifting some of the tax burden toward consumption or payroll taxes. Why do you believe that would generate more investment in prosperity?
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, uh, first of all, uh uh with regard to um uh the proposals I made on uh big bang tax reform, uh uh I want to mention that actually uh, and Eric will like this, the 10% rate would be applied to all firms and you'd get rid of the small business deduction and two dividend tax credits and things like that. It would be significant simplification. Uh but more generally, uh Canada uh collects more income taxes as a share of GDP than all other G7 countries.
SPEAKER_00Um and in fact, uh when you start looking at our uh top marginal rate of uh which is roughly uh average across the country, around 52 percent, 53.5 percent in Ontario uh and and uh and in Quebec, but uh you know uh Alberta and and uh Saskatchewan's a bit less and stuff and BC, uh no, not BC anymore. Anyway, um but the main point is that uh that top rate applies at a relatively low income level.
SPEAKER_00Uh it's only uh roughly about uh three times the average wage in Canada. Well, if you look at France and Japan, which have slightly higher marginal tax rates at the top end, uh it's uh it's in the case of Japan, it's nine times the wage rate. And in in France it's 14 times the average wage rate. So um wages. So, you know, it's uh you know, it's it's a uh we we we really do have uh you know relatively high rates. And in fact, one of the things we showed is that actually the the rates are even for low-income people, uh the marginal tax rates are or the average tax rates, income tax rates are higher uh than other G7 countries.
SPEAKER_00And so uh we really rely on income taxes a lot, including corporate income taxes, and and that's more than uh other countries. And they're they and economic studies have shown they are the most uh economically distortive uh taxes to have. They discourage work, they discourage risk taking, uh, et cetera, and uh discourages venture capital. Some of the things that Eric would like to see that makes it harder with the kind of tax system that we have at the personal level, uh uh, particularly. And and at the corporate level, we we have all these distortions in the system that we keep making even worse lately, you know, especially in the past uh 10, 10 since 2012, basically, where governments have been throwing in more investment tax credits and sell you know, special preferences and um and uh and have no longer been cutting the corporate rates.
SPEAKER_00What's happened to all the other country uh countries have been cutting rates and Canada no longer uh stands out. So um so on so the corporate taxes, uh, you know, we've lost the tax advantage that we created by 2012. And so uh uh so generally our income taxes are too high. The good thing about consumption taxes and payroll taxes, that's an area where we don't have as much taxation as other uh OECD countries and uh and G7 countries. And I've been kind of uh I realize GST raising the rate is tough because seniors pay it and they don't they have fixed incomes and they're very opposed to increasing it.
SPEAKER_00I think Harper figured that out when he decided to cut the GST rate. Um but the one uh the one idea that I'm kind of attracted to is bringing in a payroll tax uh on employers to fund uh healthcare, a dedicated tax. In fact, maybe creating something like a special fund. And and since five or six provinces already have that kind of payroll tax, maybe you could have a joint federal provincial employer payroll tax to fund healthcare and add more money into the system.
SPEAKER_00And that actually might be more appealing, I think, to people in terms of a of a of a shift toward away from income taxes towards uh towards a less damaging tax.
Aaron PeteEric, what is your response to that? Your book makes a slightly different argument, and I'd just be curious as to how you take Jack's comments.
SPEAKER_02Well, well, I I think uh slightly different, but sort of thinking in similar directions about how do we incentivize uh people to uh you know to innovate more and to build more, to scale more. So one example is that uh we we reflect on a um tax policy in Sweden, where when you are a founder and you've got uh equity from a successful exit that you're looking to sell, uh they have a policy where you're you're allowed to not simply you know just immediately uh pay capital gains and what have you.
SPEAKER_02What they allow uh the these founders to do is uh put their uh earnings into a special vehicle that can be reinvested uh as you know, they they can defer the capital gains on the condition that they reinvest their earnings. And uh it I think there's a strong argument that uh that that specifically creates and you know incentives and action in Sweden for people to become repeat founders, for people who are successful founders to then go on into angel investment, venture capital.
SPEAKER_02And uh what's nice about that is that it's it's not merely um you know uh changing incentives overall. It's it's really targeted at the people who uh are successful and have the know-how to actually do these things, to do it over and over. Whereas uh in in Canada, there's uh a relatively um you know uh strenuous set of policies uh on on you know the the the threshold at which you have to start paying uh capital gains on on your overall uh uh lifetime uh earnings from these things.
SPEAKER_02And it it's it's important because the the know-how that you gain from going through these things, if you're then able to transfer that to other people, you're you're spreading knowledge throughout a system, you're enabling uh more people to scale, yourself to scale more. Uh I recall one paper, for example, showing that uh successful former founders then go on to be better venture capitalists who uh you know create more successful investments, allow those companies to scale up. Uh so that would be one example of a tax reform that I would be interested at looking at in the case of Canada.
Aaron PeteWe only have a few minutes left, uh, but I do want to go over a few different, I think interesting questions for each of you. So I'll start with you, Jack. How hard do you think Canada should fight for access to the American market and trying to continue to grow that? Oh, sorry, Jack. Sorry.
SPEAKER_00Yes, can you hear me? Sorry. Yeah, yeah. Sorry, go again. My apologies. Um Well, I I think we have to fight hard for our access to the U.S. market. I don't think that's something you want to give up. And uh and so we're gonna have to have some sort of trade agreement. May not, it's not gonna be the same trade agreement as NAFTA was and even Kuzma. Uh new issues come up, but if we can end up uh having something that is positive for both countries, I think uh that will be a good thing, not a bad thing. We we are dealing with a very different world today.
SPEAKER_00Um in fact, uh I've just been finishing reading a book by Brendan Sims on the return of uh of uh you know of uh of uh superpowers or of great powers uh in the world. And it's fascinating reading when you think about it. But we are in a very different world today with with uh two major superpowers, uh with another one that's still continuing as a bit of a major power as Russia, but uh only because of the military strength that it has.
SPEAKER_00And uh and and that puts us in a very difficult position about who we're gonna be friends with. And and so I think it's uh I think it's a different world we have today than we had uh just 25 years ago when the United States dominated the world uh entirely. And so uh we are gonna have to figure out where we want to position ourselves. And I think in the end it's gonna have to be with the United States, whether we like it or not. Um, and and and and uh yeah, we we can trade more with Europe and some of the friendly countries like Japan and South Korea and things like that, but it's uh uh when you start looking at what's happening around the world, uh alliances are going to build, I think, uh particularly those countries that are gonna be uh with the Chinese side and those countries that are gonna be with the United States.
SPEAKER_00And that's why I think in the end, uh it's gonna be the Western Alliance. It's gonna have to be strengthened.
Aaron PeteEric, what are your thoughts?
SPEAKER_02Well, well, uh yeah, and I think it highlights an important um uh you know tension that is very much in the uh public's eye, which is how do we how do we manage uh you know the relationship with the United Nation with the United States at the same time as diversifying our trade relationships? And uh it's it's important not to think that these things are opposites somehow. Uh you know, the the the impact of geography, of cultural similarity, of of linguistic overlap between Canada and the United States, it is overwhelming.
SPEAKER_02And it would be unrealistic to think that the United States is not going to be a dominant trade partner for Canada in in the future. Of course, we're going to keep trading with the United States on a huge scale. It's just that at the same time as do as we do that, we can't uh continue to be in this position where we are just utterly beholden to the United States strategically. Uh, you know, we can we can be a better friend and ally, we can be uh a more uh sovereign version of ourselves if we if we diversify our international trade at the same time as maintaining a trading relationship uh with the United States.
SPEAKER_02So I do think that both of these things have to be pursued.
Aaron PeteAs a follow-up to that, Eric, you talk about the Australia model. And I'm just wondering if you can very briefly outline what the Australia model tells you, what you think we should take away from that. And then Jack, I'd like to pass it over to you to give some thoughts on that.
SPEAKER_02Well, the the Australia model makes the point that uh even if Canada is relatively cut off from American markets, if there's increased friction, that it is possible to be both remote and also prosperous, uh, as Australia proves. And um, it it's interesting to see the set of industries through which they do that. Uh, Australia's international exports are overwhelmingly dependent on mining and agriculture. And uh those things have particular qualities in that they don't have this intensive regional supply supply chain coordination like you get, for example, in the automobile sector.
SPEAKER_02So they're they're able to prosper because they've been able to specialize in industries that are resilient to remoteness. And that paves the lesson for Canada. Uh obviously, mining and agriculture are good examples of that. But then we highlight in Canada after America, well, there's there's also other ones in advanced manufacturers like aerospace and like life sciences.
Aaron PeteJack, what is your perspective?
SPEAKER_00Well, actually, I do a lot of work on Australia. In fact, I'm just finishing a paper for the Australians on mining taxation. Um, the um uh the Australian Australia's been a remarkable country, uh, especially since uh after the 1980s, where they shifted from uh a lot of uh uh regulatory control uh over the economy. You have to remember Australia was created um partly because of the interest of having uh stronger internal trade uh amongst the different parts of Australia.
SPEAKER_00Because they're all, you know, Australia's kind of you know, you have different parts of the country that's all around the middle. The middle is kind of barren, it's like they're our Northwest territories, the middle, but the you know, the population is either on the east, west, north, south. And so uh internal uh getting rid of internal trade barriers was a major motivation for the creation of the Federation. And so they've always been very concerned about trade. And and uh and so uh they're they're big, you know, they do have very significant um uh uh comparative advantage in the in the resource sector, including agriculture, obviously.
SPEAKER_00And uh and uh but what happened in the 1990s is that the the economy was not doing all that well, and so they decided to undo a lot of the bad regulations and tax policies at that time. They moved they adopted the GST uh as an example, they got uh rid of a bunch of tariffs, and because of the because of the tariff uh reductions in Australia, the auto industry could no longer compete internationally or in Australia, and so the Australians decided, well, we're not gonna keep you, we're just gonna let you go.
SPEAKER_00And they also got rid of supply management uh through a very very innovative policy, which allowed them not only, this is one thing we don't do in Canada, they export a lot of uh uh dairy products, not just milk, dairy products, because in Canada our raw milk is too expensive. And so you you we're not gonna be exporters of cheese and exporters of codities and other products that could go, you know, that are derivatives, uh, when you have such a high cost of raw milk. And so that's just a bit of an example, but Australians have done a lot of this movement towards economic efficiency and approved allocative efficiency that has allowed them to grow in in uh and and and uh and and allow their uh economy to to do a lot better.
SPEAKER_00And and I think that is the example I like using for Canada in terms of undoing some of the things that we're doing right now. Um, even unless early the healthcare systems very run similarly to all the European ones, where they have a public and a private uh parallel systems and and uh and etc. And in fact, if you look at their spending as a share of GDP, much lower than what you find in Canada in terms of government spending, and and also their debt isn't as high as in Canada.
SPEAKER_00So they've had a lot of very smart uh policies that they've adopted over the years that made them very competitive.
Aaron PeteEric, could you share where people can find your book? And if you have a copy, if you could uh show it to the uh uh certainly.
SPEAKER_02Um so uh people can find our our book, Canada After America, in uh bookstores uh across the country. You can get it uh online. The publisher is uh Sutherland House. Uh you can just Google Canada After America, a strategy for prosperity in a changed world. It's it's you know it's on Amazon, it's on indigo chapters, all of that. Um I I also want to flag that as uh concomitant with the launch of the book, we're opening a new policy shop at McGill University's Maxwell School of Public Policy, uh, a new growth lab uh office there.
SPEAKER_02Uh, and we're very eager to work with policymakers across the country on economic policy issues. So uh we are uh eager to uh talk to everybody.
Aaron PeteJack, how can people follow your work?
SPEAKER_00Well, basically, uh I don't have a website. I don't know why I've never decided maybe just never had enough time to create these things. It's not been a big, I guess, priority for me. Uh, but I do uh in terms of the my financial post articles, you can usually get them on the website of the financial post. Um and uh I usually publish a lot of my work uh through various um various things. Uh for example, uh there's a massive paper on mining taxation in Latin America and the Caribbeans with the Inter-American Development Bank.
SPEAKER_00There's papers that are published in various journals. I've also published uh uh with uh various think tanks, including the C.D. However Institute and uh McDonnell Laurier Institute, and um and uh, you know, and I forget I can't remember all the others. Fraser, I think, has also published some of my stuff. So so it's it's scattered around in different places. I do try to get the ideas out uh in in various ways, but uh uh but that's a way that people could find it. And uh uh and of course they've had some book publications in the past.
Aaron PeteTremendous. Well, I know both of you are thinking, well, we didn't really debate or disagree extremely, and I think that's the gift, right? Like I view this as very important. We set this up as a debate, but it didn't need to go there because there is overlap, and I think that gives hopefully Canadians reassurances that we're all thinking these through issues through and trying to find a path forward. And it's we're we maybe disagree on the fringes, but agree a lot on the pathway forward, which gives me a lot of hope that um we have a lot of academics and experts like yourself willing to come forward and have the debate.
Aaron PeteYou don't know how many times I've reached out to people and they go, I don't want to disagree with another person on camera. Like I just don't want to be a part of that. Um, so the fact that you were both willing, you still deserve absolute kudos and respect for being willing to hash out your ideas. Eric, you didn't exactly know what you were walking into. I don't think you did either, Jack. And yet we we founded a lot of calming ground. And I'm never going to complain about that or see that as a negative. I think it's an absolute win for our country uh and for the path forward. So thank you both again for joining us today.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, thank you both as well. It's been a real uh pleasure. And yeah, you know, I I always find uh a good uh discussion very stimulating and productive. So uh agree, agree. It was it was a it was a good chat.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...