Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Nuanced.

Nuanced. artwork

294. Trevor Tombe: Will Canadians Be Financially Better Off in 2027?

Nov 16, 202657 minAudio

University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Trevor TombeI'm Trevor Tuma, Professor of Economics at the University of Calgary.

Aaron PeteWhat grade does Kearney deserve on the 2026-27 budget?

Trevor TombeSo some positives in the budget, uh, but on fiscal sustainability and debt challenges, it's a fairly low grade.

Aaron PetePierre Polyev released a video suggesting that Carney is essentially putting government spending on three different credit cards and calling some of it investment. Is this fair criticism or is Polyev misunderstanding how government actually works?

Trevor TombeNo, I think that is entirely fair criticism. The deficit is in this budget 62.5 billion. But the amount that the government is projecting that it will need to borrow in 2027 is 169 billion.

Aaron PeteAre we really moving away from thinking about future generations because they're ultimately the ones that are going to carry these bills?

Trevor TombePart of the fiscal challenge is that our government finances are set up to redistribute a considerable amount to elderly individuals from younger individuals. And that will grow in time. And we need to shrink old age secured. I guess I'll just be blunt about that. That's my personal view.

Aaron PeteDo you expect to see Canadians start doing better in 2027? Trevor, thank you very much for joining us again. It's privileged to have you back on the show. Would you mind really quickly just reintroducing yourself for listeners?

Trevor TombeSure. First of all, thanks for having me back. It's really great to be here. I'm Trevor Tuma, Professor of Economics at the University of Calgary and its Department of Economics and the School of Public Policy.

Aaron PeteFantastic. Let's ask the tough question first. What grade does Carney deserve on the 2026-27 budget?

Trevor TombeI mean, budgets are incredibly large documents that touch on so many different areas. And there's always, you know, no matter who's in government, something in there that one can agree with or disagree with. So I'll start on the positive. I think Canada's uh commitment to increase military spending to 3.5% of GDP by 2035. I think that's a really important, both international objective and something that, given that Canada has committed to it, that we need to follow through on it.

Trevor TombeAnd what we saw in this budget is that we're going to be rising from uh the 2% of GDP that we were previously at to 2.6% next year. And so we're moving towards that goal in a really, really meaningful way in the short term. And that's a larger increase than I would have anticipated. Of course, we'll have to ensure that uh money is well spent, that procurement issues are sorted out and so on. So that's quite a positive. Second positive is the tax change that not new in the budget, but announced in September that they kind of awkwardly called the productivity mega deduction.

Trevor TombeBut putting the title of the tax change aside, I think that's a really important way to lower taxes on investment. And it is critically important for Canada to boost the amount of investment. And so this is a kind of policy measure that I think itself enjoys broader, you know, bipartisan support, both conservatives and now the current liberals in government. And so I think that's a pretty meaningful change. Where I think it falls short, though, is on addressing some of the debt challenges that we have that will only be growing larger in time.

Trevor TombeThe federal government did benefit from a considerable amount of windfall, uh, for lack of a better word, due to high oil prices raising um corporate profits of oil and gas companies. That leads to considerable revenues for uh the federal government through the corporate income tax system. And so it's not just Alberta or Saskatchewan or Newfoundland, Labrador, and BC that benefit from oil prices. It is the federal government as well. I estimate the deficit next year would have been 14.5 billion, were it not for policy changes and choices that the government took to basically move entirely into the space that a stronger than anticipated economy allowed for.

Trevor TombeThat does mean that public debt's higher than would have otherwise have been the case. And the trajectory for the government's overall debt as a share of the economy, which is, I think, a really important metric, is for it to rise in every single year of the budget horizon. And combined with our aging population, the military spending pressures that we talked about, I think we really need to put a lot more attention, not just federally, but provincially as well, into where we're headed in terms of overall levels of public debt.

Trevor TombeAnd so some positives in the budget, uh, but on fiscal sustainability and debt challenges, it's a fairly low grade.

Aaron PeteCould I get a grade from you, a B plus, B minus?

Trevor TombeYeah, uh that's a little awkward for me to uh to do. Typically, there's not just one person in a class. Uh, so uh I'll uh withhold any kind of letter grade, uh room for improvement.

Aaron PeteHow would you compare it to the 2025 budget then?

Trevor TombeYeah, the the 2025 budget really didn't do much on um efforts to boost the economy and boost investment. This is what the mega deduction really is. This is, though announced in September, so not new in the budget, this is the largest reduction in the effective tax rate on new investment in Canada in 20 years. And so it was under Prime Minister Harper that we saw um anything comparable to what we have in that mega deduction. And again, I hate the name, it's really awkward, uh, very transformer-esque, but it anyway, it as a policy measure, that's quite positive.

Trevor TombeBut nothing like that in budget 2025. And that was, you know, sometimes the government's first budget is not really what reflects their overall fiscal policy. Sometimes there's not a lot of time between the end of an election and when the budget needs to roll out. But this budget, there clearly was a lot of time. Um, and the mega deduction quite important, but the longer-term trajectory is, I think, something that um we need more attention paid to. And quite frankly, deeper reforms in Canada, not just on the regulatory front, but in terms of uh the overall tax system itself.

Trevor TombeI think it's due for really a comprehensive review and overhaul that we haven't seen since the 1990s. Uh, given the big changes in the economy, the uncertainties, the need to boost growth uh to help not just for its own sake and improve living standards and affordability, but the long-term fiscal trajectory is helped by improved productivity and investment and in economic growth too. And so I think the longer we delay deeper, harder looks at the whole kind of structure of the tax system in Canada, the the more difficult these longer-term challenges will be.

Aaron PeteOut of curiosity, what would you say to Canadians about this budget? What do they need to take away from this? Obviously, they may not be directly impacted by the mega deduction or these things. What do they what should they expect from this budget?

Trevor TombeYeah, uh I mean, I I think individuals are affected meaningfully by the mega deduction over time. If it boosts investment, and there's every reason to think it will, incentives matter, taxes matter, and this is a real reduction in the effect of tax on investment. Business investment and capital accumulation, that is the most important source of real income growth. And so growing incomes faster than prices is key to easing sustainability and cost of living pressures and improving living standards.

Trevor TombeAnd you can't do that without productivity growth and labor productivity growth, the biggest contributor is business investment. And so it's measures like this that in time can move the needle on investment growth, productivity, and therefore our incomes. And so it does matter, though not something you would directly see day to day. That probably the biggest measure that you would see for most Canadians is also something that was previously announced, not found uh brand new in the budget, is the suspension of the federal excise tax on gasoline.

Trevor TombeThat's something where you'll kind of get a benefit from it, see the benefit at the pump, um, you know, almost every day, depending on how frequently you may drive past one or fill up. And so that's a measure there that's of pretty significant importance. The rest, you know, there were some interesting changes on simplifying the tax code. And I think this is also something where uh there's broad support for it. I think my colleague Jack Mintz wrote a piece on some big bang reform options for Canada. And this falls far short of what was proposed there.

Trevor TombeBut one of the proposals that was interesting was that you could give people the option to claim a tax credit of a certain amount and not need to provide any kind of receipts uh or documentation, that sort of thing. You tick the box and away you go. So different types of um what was previously things that you need documentation for. Now you can kind of roll it up in this single credit. And you you can claim that single credit and be on your way, or you can go the old route and with all the receipts and documentation.

Trevor TombeSo I think around tax time, folks might uh benefit from the lower burden depending on their circumstance that creates. And hopefully there's more of that to come. But otherwise, I'm not sure the budget itself is going to be something that individual Canadians remember. Uh now, in fairness, most budgets are like that. I think budget 1995, you know, a big one. Perhaps um, you know, Harper's budget in the financial crisis uh is quite a memorable one. But for the most part, it's the policies that people will remember rather than the budget itself.

Aaron PetePierre Polyev released a video suggesting that Carney is essentially putting government spending on three different credit cards and calling some of it investment. He argues that the debt doesn't disappear because the government describes it differently. Is this fair criticism, or is Polyev misunderstanding how government actually works?

Trevor TombeNo, I think that is entirely fair criticism. And it's always incumbent on opposition parties to critique a government, of course. And I actually thought that video on the credit card analogy was fairly effective at communicating in a very simple way what is, but I think quite true. The deficit is one thing. And often we think that a government deficit is its borrowing. But there are other uh contributors to public debt that goes beyond the deficit itself.

Trevor TombeOften, and not just governments, but any entities or businesses. When you purchase an asset that has a long life, you don't immediately expense it, you depreciate it gradually over time, but the cash still goes out the door when you buy that equipment up front. And for governments buying capital, it's usually pretty big. And so that means the borrowing requirements of the government are considerably larger than the deficit itself. So for perspective, next year, so 2027, the deficit is in this budget 62.5 billion.

Trevor TombeLarge enough, and I mentioned it would have been 14.5 were it not for uh for policy choices there, but the amount that the government is projecting that it will need to borrow in 2027 is 169 billion. So there's quite a big gap between the 62 and a bit deficit and the 169 borrowing needs next year. And that gap is quite large over the whole projection horizon. So we have hundreds, literally hundreds of billions of dollars uh in additional borrowing over and above the deficit itself.

Trevor TombeAnd so what we call things certainly matters. And I'm not going to take anything away from accountants uh who definitely need to label things accurately and report on things and accrual approaching for approaches to revenue and and expenses makes a lot of sense. But we need to keep in mind as Canadians that that single bottom line is not the end of the story, that there are a lot of factors that contribute. And it's really that that accounts for the rising uh overall federal debt to GDP over the coming years.

Trevor TombeThat additional amount that we need to borrow to cover uh a lot of things, but um capital being a big source of that.

Aaron PeteI have your graph here that you had uh put on X. And I'm wondering if you wouldn't mind walking us through from your perspective. So for people just listening, you've kind of set out uh a really well put together graph that kind of summarizes the 26-27 budget.

Trevor TombeYeah. So if there's any engineers in the audience, this graph will be quite familiar, uh, illustrating flows in and out of a system. This is uh what's called a Sankey diagram. And I think for budgets, it's really nice because you just kind of look at it and you get a sense of scale immediately, where things come from, where they go. So you can see on the left are federal revenues, mostly from taxes, personal income, corporate income, GST, and a little bit from a wide variety of other things, excise taxes and import duties and so on.

Trevor TombeUm, add to that EI premiums and some revenues from crown corporations, things like that adds up to the $540 billion in revenue that we're expecting for the fiscal year. And then the borrowing is added on to that. And you can immediately see that that deficit's a meaningful share of revenue. It's not just a tiny little rounding item here. It is a meaningful contributor to what we're spending, which is on the right. And here's where I think things are pretty interesting for the federal government. I mean, on the left, revenue comes from income and consumption taxes.

Trevor TombeThat's probably not new, uh news to most people. But on the right, what the federal government does with the revenue, that's uh, I think something that many people don't appreciate, that the federal government largely doesn't do a lot directly. Provinces do a lot in terms of delivering public services to individuals. But on the right, we see that the federal government largely just transfers to people in the form of old-age security, EI benefits, uh child benefits, to provincial governments through the health transfer, through equalization, the social transfer, and other uh smaller transfers.

Trevor TombeAnd it also transfers to other entities. And this is kind of in that bucket near the bottom there, the other transfer payments. So I work at the University of Calgary, and we receive federal funds to do research initiatives on different things. So that would be a transfer payment in that bucket. So at the very bottom, you see the federal direct expenses, like what the federal government actually does itself directly, is only 150 of the $600 billion uh in total spending by the federal government.

Trevor TombeSo that's roughly a quarter of its overall spending. Three quarters are just transfers. And that means while efficiency within the federal government is very important, uh, ensuring that it is appropriately sized, that departments are not too large, that the federal programs are either fulfilling a clear need or not. These kind of reviews are very important. Paul Martin's being a particularly effective one several years ago.

Trevor TombeThat's in the direct expense bucket, and that matters. But there's a limit to how much that can matter. If we really want to change the overall size of the federal government, uh, especially when we're thinking longer term, we have to think about transfers. And notice at the top, old age security. $89 uh billion dollars in transfers to elderly individuals in the form of this old age security and what's called the guaranteed income supplement. This is a program that you can see right there, it's quite large.

Trevor TombeAnd it is one of the fastest growing areas of spending, too. By 2030, the government expects that to reach 110 billion. So pretty large growth. And that means that effectively the entire more, 10% more, than the entire corporate income tax system will be funding old age security. And so having conversations, I think difficult conversations about whether or not these transfers are too large. Do we need to think harder about who receives them?

Trevor TombeHow much? Um, what's the income cutoff for them? How are they scaled back? You know, it's one thing to have programs that address seniors' poverty, and that's fine. That's mainly the guaranteed income supplement. The broad, universal, nearly universal uh support to all seniors that provides uh with no exaggeration, billions of dollars to seniors' families with incomes that are above the Canadian family average income level. That's a big contributor to the fiscal challenges federally.

Trevor TombeUh, transfers to provinces too. Should they be so large? Are they some reforms that we can do uh there to improve not just federal fiscal sustainability, but maybe even more flexibility for provinces to experiment and innovate and improve the delivery of public services? So I think that's where the hard conversations are, and you get that from the graph that the feds just transfer a lot to people, provinces, and other entities. And that's where we should look for the really big uh changes in spending.

Aaron PeteYou mentioned it, and I think we discussed it in our previous conversation, but would you say this is one of the first times a poorer group in like a government system like ours is contributing and giving money to a wealthier group overall?

Trevor TombeThat's a good question. I mean, I I guess no. There's lots of policies that uh have disproportionate benefit to higher income individuals. Uh so one example of that, actually, I'll I'll pick on my own sector. Uh subsidies to post-secondary education. Uh, this is something where public funds are going towards uh, on average, individuals that have much higher lifetime income levels. And so you're gonna have tax payments being made by the broad Canadian public in support of individuals who typically have higher levels of income.

Trevor TombeSo one might characterize that as regressive. Uh or things like um excise taxes, consumption taxes. Uh, these, at least as a share of a family's income, are much higher among lower income individuals than higher. So, yeah, old age security in in some sense is less regressive if you were to sit down and measure this than some of those other policies. And so it's it's not so much about um transferring from low income to high, although there's certainly some of that.

Trevor TombeUh it's much more about transferring from uh young to old, where the average income level among recipients, uh, some recipients of old age security are higher than average, but it's not quite as stark as any other program I could uh imagine, which is not to say we shouldn't have a hard look at OAS, but I don't want to exaggerate how regressive it is.

Aaron PeteWe were talking a little bit earlier about the debt, and you also have a really good visual here as well on what that debt looks like. Would you mind walking us through this piece as well?

Trevor TombeYeah, so this is actually something that uh uh is part of a piece I published over at financesofthenation.ca if anyone wants to kind of explore that. And and this highlights that there are two different measures of debt that the budget reports and that in in in fairness are you know fine accounting measures, but the government highlights and emphasizes uh what is called federal debt. This interestingly is a measure of kinda I think of it like the accumulated deficits of the government uh over time.

Trevor TombeUh I think maybe even a better way to think about it is it's like the government's net worth, uh if you will. It's a negative, so not a positive here. So it's the net uh debt, but they include in that capital. So all the physical things that the government uh invests in and builds, these non-financial assets, buildings, you know, equipment, infrastructure, uh, things like that is in that.

Trevor TombeAnd so as we shift things towards more non-financial assets and capital grows, that brings down that line, which makes it look like the federal debt trajectory is on this downward trajectory over the long haul in the coming decades. But this, I think, is perhaps not the best measure of the government's overall debt situation. Because unlike a financial asset, you can't easily liquidate a bridge in order to cover some debt payments, right?

Trevor TombeThese are assets that don't really have market value. It was one thing that if the government has some cash in on the books somewhere, sure, deduct that cash from the amount owed because it's an asset that you can easily it's financial, you can easily liquidate to cover debt obligations. And so an alternative measure is what's called the federal net debt. And this doesn't exclude, sorry, uh, it doesn't include the non-financial assets in the government's worth.

Trevor TombeIt just looks at the financial assets and the liabilities of the government. And that notice you get a very different picture. Historically, the two are differ only by, you know, a little wedge that's kind of constant over time, but over the coming decades, it looks as though the two are going to deviate pretty significantly. And it's the net debt, it's the blue line that is relevant for sustainability. And over the coming years, as I indicate there with these orange dots, the budget itself has rising net debt.

Trevor TombeAnd the blue line is my own projection that conveniently is quite well aligned with the budget dots, even though it wasn't forced to do that. This projection was produced prior to the budget. It shows that that net debt will just keep rising well into the 2040s. Now, later on, it starts to fall from there. I'd say that very long-term projections, there's a lot of uncertainty around that. So I'd put a lot of weight on this nearer-term upward trajectory of the debt federally, which will exceed the peak of COVID in just a few years' time.

Trevor TombeAnd that raises questions about sustainability, about the debt burden, about the amount we're paying out of the federal budget in interest in servicing that debt. And the government emphasizing the measure that subtracts non-financial assets, I think that's problematic and not the standard approach when we're talking about net debt and debt sustainability.

Aaron PeteSo, what should Canadians take away from this? Like I always think about how our generation and younger generations, we're not talking about setting our children up for success the way I remember it being talked about when I was a kid, and the way my grandmother thought about like, well, it's not just you, it's your next generation and next generation. We don't have from everybody I speak to, people don't think in those terms as much as they used to. We used to just like people used to travel from a country that was very in debt and had a civil war going on, sail across a boat just so that their kids could have the opportunity at a better life, like would sacrifice their whole life in order for their children to have a better life.

Aaron PeteNow we seem to be in a in a very different time where having to sacrifice for future generations, there's less weight on it. It's more about how is my living? Am I living a good life? Am I comfortable? And I just I wonder when I look at a graph like that, I think like, are we really moving away from thinking about future generations? Because they're ultimately the ones that are going to carry these bills. How do you think about that?

Trevor TombeYeah, I think about that in uh a few ways. I think actually our last conversation focused a lot on some of the productivity and economic growth challenges that Canada has had. And so I'll bring back one, I think, just stark statistic from that conversation, very much in line with what you just said, that things are different now than they were in the past for Canada's economy compared to others around the world. In 2024, the strength of Canada's economy in terms of the amount of income that it's generating per person fell below the average of the advanced industrial economies around the world and fell further behind that average in 2025.

Trevor TombeNever before in the history of us collecting these comparable statistics had Canada been a below average country. Prior to 2014, we were about 10% above average. And you know, further into the past in the 70s and 80s, we were about 25% above average. And now we're below average. So I think first we need to come to grips with that as Canadians, that our economy is a below average economy in terms of its strength. But it doesn't need to be. It is because of slow productivity, because of uh falling investment per worker in terms of businesses.

Trevor TombeAnd so we really need to focus on moving the needle on that, improving investment incentives, improving growth. And it'll take a long time to get back to where we were. But that's critically important, especially for young people. The strength of an economy matters for one's income as a worker or as uh, say, a small business owner, an entrepreneur starting up a business. The strength of the economy matters for them. It doesn't matter as much for older people because obviously they've retired.

Trevor TombeThey're no longer engaged in the same number of market transactions in terms of selling their labor or services that younger people are. And so a weak economy has disproportionate burdens on younger working uh Canadians. Now, the government at least uh recognizes that as a problem. The opposition uh party does as well. And I think many are proposing ways of helping move the needle. I think there's a lot more to do, don't get me wrong. That's important uh for younger people.

Trevor TombePart of the fiscal challenge is that our government finances are set up to redistribute a considerable amount to elderly individuals from younger individuals. And that will grow in time. Actually, we'll have a paper released through the McDonald Laurier Institute soon. I don't actually know exactly what the timing is, where we quantify some of this redistribution. And right now, about 8.5% of Canada's economy is redistributed from young to old, and that'll grow to about 10% at the end of our projection horizon.

Trevor TombeAnd so that a lot of things are behind that, but a big contributor is old age security and healthcare. And we need to shrink old age security. I guess I'll just be blunt about that. That's my personal view. Obviously, my professor hat would say, oh, there's trade-offs involved and reasonable people can debate and disagree. And that's of course true. But I think old age security is too large. It transfers a considerable amount to high-income seniors, and it doesn't need to. Our retirement age of 65 to be eligible for old age security should rise.

Trevor TombeMost other countries are increasing their retirement age. Had Canada simply indexed our retirement age to our ever expanding life expectancy, then the old age security today eligibility age would be 71, not 65. That gives you roughly 15 years of expected uh lifespan after that point of retirement, which is what was the case back when we originally set 65 as the eligibility age. Um and so those types of changes would save a considerable amount of fiscal resources that are needed to address other challenges.

Trevor TombeIf we don't uh trim on the spending side, and federally on the spending side means transfers, then to meet the challenges, we'd have to increase taxes. And taxes are not well structured to have equity across generations. Income taxes are disproportionately paid for obvious reasons by working individuals. Property taxes and consumption taxes are what older people pay. And so maybe we need to have a conversation too about lowering income taxes and raising property and consumption taxes to not just have economic benefits.

Trevor TombeAnd I think income taxes are a drag on investment and uh attracting skilled workers and so on, but also intergenerational equity. So we need to have a conversation there. And then healthcare, this is even bigger of an issue than old age security. It's it's tax-funded healthcare services uh disproportionately accounted for by older individuals. And at least in Canada, and I don't quite know why, it's always hard to have conversations around health.

Trevor TombePeople just instinctually think that any suggested change to healthcare in Canada automatically means American-style healthcare when I think there's a lot more options out there to explore, and provinces should be free to innovate and experiment and try new things so that we don't need to spend as much on health care and perhaps even get better health outcomes from it. Maybe that does mean an increased role for private delivery.

Trevor TombeMaybe it does mean uh scope for certain fees even charged by the public system on certain procedures. You know, I'm not a health policy expert, so I'll leave that to others, but something uh is needed because an aging population will not just eat up more fiscal room through old age security, but will also place increasing strain on healthcare systems that we're frankly not quite ready for. So these are tough conversations, but I think they are a necessary part of improving living standards and outcomes for young people, which have been just objectively deteriorating in in recent years.

Trevor TombeAnd so hard conversations that are long overdue.

Aaron PeteI couldn't agree more. I would be hard pressed to find somebody who would walk into a hospital. Like when I was a kid, our hospital is the exact same that it was 20 years ago. How they process you, the paperwork, the whole process is like nearly identical to when I was like five years old. And so, like the idea that we couldn't innovate, and then you see people signing up for, and I know they've gone under, but 23andMe, like how excited people were for some advancements in some new technologies that allowed them access to some interesting information that allowed them to make more informed decisions.

Aaron PeteUh, I hope we do move in that direction because my big point has been we couldn't be spending more on healthcare. Like it's it's hard to comprehend in British Columbia how much we're spending towards healthcare. And nothing's improving. And so, like, the innovation is the missing link in in how we approach some of these pieces. But I do want to move a bit into interest rates because on October 28th, the Bank of Canada raised interest rates for the first time since 2023. We spent years hearing that interest rates needed to come down to make life more affordable.

Aaron PeteWhy are they going back up? What does this mean for families? And how does this interact with the budget?

Trevor TombeYeah. So great, great question. So certainly interest rates do place a strain on individuals uh by increasing borrowing costs. And here we are in 2026. There's going to be a considerable number of individuals who are renewing their mortgage that was taken out in 2021 when interest rates were, you know, right near closer to zero than uh than they than they could get. So this will be a potential drag on on households, no questions, or businesses. It affects the cost of capital and so on. But the Bank of Canada is and ought to be singularly focused on inflation.

Trevor TombeThat is their mandated objective to keep inflation at 2%. And obviously, easier said than done. And we can look back and critique monetary policy choices in the past, but that's their mandate. That's their goal. Some people suggest that the bank should have other goals, employment goals. Uh, some suggest things like climate goals or inequality goals. And I'm firmly against all of that. They should have one goal. They have one instrument, interest rates. And that one goal that they're trying to achieve of inflation, they should stick to it.

Trevor TombeAnd so interest rates will rise if they think inflation is on the rise, as they should. And that we should keep in mind: that we shouldn't be blaming the bank itself for worsening the affordability challenge. They're trying to keep inflation from rising. Interest rates rising because inflation is on the rise. We have to think a little deeper. What's leading inflation to rise? And in this case, it's energy prices uh being quite a bit higher than it was earlier this year.

Trevor TombeThat's that's the only reason why inflation is higher this year, like now, than it was uh earlier in the year prior to the developments in in Iran.

Aaron PeteSo just sorry, just to clarify, you're saying the butt, like Pierre often makes this argument that the budget and how much the federal government is spending contributes to inflation as well, particularly during COVID. Are you saying that that's not not a factor?

Trevor TombeNo, no, no. That's that's a great question. I mean, that there's a difference between talking about the acceleration we've seen this year, like the inflation of just over two that we had in January to now over three right now. What accounts for the change? That's energy, full stop. Uh fiscal policy absolutely affects uh prices uh and inflation. How much is a quantitative question? And if we look back uh to COVID, there was a mix where you had supply side factors like energy and fertilizer, especially following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, but you also had demand side factors, um, such as perhaps monetary policy itself being a little too easy for too long following the pandemic, and fiscal policy expanding dramatically uh following COVID, being outsized relative to um relative to the economy's capacity to absorb it without price increases.

Trevor TombeSo absolutely, I would not say that fiscal policy is not a contributor. Lots of things are contributors to inflation generally. Uh, I think that's especially the case um for the for the experience following COVID. But you know, right now, the rapid change we've seen over the span of months, the stance of fiscal policy is not all that different now compared to where it was in January. Now, that's not to say that if the government didn't cut back on um fiscal expenditures, that that wouldn't help offset some of the rising pressure from energy.

Trevor TombeI think that's a fair enough statement. And then the question is, how does the federal government meaningfully shrink spending? Well, as we talked about, we'd then have to talk about transfers. And uh, I guess as a friendly, uh hopefully constructive critique of the conservatives, they're not proposing we explore a reduction in old age security, quite the reverse. And so it's a it's an all-party problem uh that we have these sources of federal spending pressures that no one's quite willing to touch. Uh but to the generic point that fiscal policy can matter for inflation, yeah, that's true.

Aaron PeteI'm wondering, Trevor, we talked about this last time and it was the the title of our episode, but it feels like Canadians just cannot seem to get a break. That it doesn't seem like there's a light at the end of the tunnel. Do you expect to see Canadians start doing better in 2027?

Trevor TombeYeah, that's a tough question. Projecting forward at uh this moment in particular, Ryan, uncertainty is so high, is really difficult. I do think there appears to be signs that things will no longer be escalating in Iran, and that may lead oil prices to begin falling. Uh, futures market prices, for example, are consistently showing oil prices declining through 2027. And that's going to matter for individuals in terms of affordability because the direct effect of energy spending is quite large.

Trevor Tombe$90 per barrel global oil prices compared to $60 where we were prior to all of this uh beginning. That's about $500 a year for the average family in just incremental spending from that rising oil price. Futures markets now have prices falling back down to about $75 by the end of next year. So easing energy price pressure, if that occurs, as markets right now currently suspect, that will help directly.

Trevor TombeUh second is if if growth can continue and stabilize and investment increases, that'll help too. And I think a lot of that'll come from maybe stabilizing some of the uncertainty around the trading relationship with the U.S. It's it's hard to read the tea leaves on this, and I certainly don't want to hang my hat, but it it sounds like there may be uh the potential for an agreement reached with the United States. That'll help uh quite a bit, uh, improving the business environment and a lot of hiring and investment decisions are prudently stalled uh until some of this uncertainty is resolved.

Trevor TombeAnd so I think 2027 may very well be a year that we see improvement. But the scale of our relative decline over the past 10 years is such that one year of positive steps forward will not be enough to bring us back to where we were. If we can boost growth by, you know, a half a point or one percentage point over and above normal, which would be a large shift in our overall economic growth rate, we'd have to sustain that for the better part of a quarter of a century in order to get back to where we were.

Trevor TombeSo we have a long haul ahead, and a lot of effort needs to be taken by governments to try and move the needle on investment. And piecemeal policy approaches are gonna fall short. Um, so we need to think bigger. Um, but yes, I I am of the view that next year will be uh better, but I don't want to overstate that then all of the all of the challenges are solved. Far from it.

Aaron PeteOkay. I'm going to lay out my fears to you and you can eviscerate them.

Trevor TombeI am I am a hopeless optimist, and so maybe you'll you'll inject some realism here too.

Aaron PeteTremendous. I look at this situation. I don't know if you follow Professor uh Robert Pape, um, but he's uh a professor, he's uh studied uh tensions with Ira Iran for many years, for I think over 20 years. And one of his concerns and what he talks a lot about is the escalation trap. And now we don't just have the U, like a lot of people are looking at the US, what happened in the midterms, how Donald Trump was impacted by that, and go, oh, he doesn't have an incentive to escalate. But that doesn't account for whether or not Iran has a reason to escalate.

Aaron PeteUm, now that Donald Trump is in a weakened position, a lot of people predicted that Iran may end up responding and escalating themselves. The Houthis, there's other groups that may have an interest in escalating the tension. My understanding, and you probably understand this better than me, is that Saudi Arabia and the UAE do a lot of investments within particularly tech in the United States, and they have been significantly negatively impacted by the Middle Eastern conflict. And so there's fears that they may not be able to continue to invest the same way they were in the US economy, which may also have tremendous impacts uh to the world order and how our economies continue to operate.

Aaron PeteAnd so, with those two pieces of uncertainty, I remain really concerned that we don't really have a control. In the first 90 days of the war with Iran with Donald Trump, it was kind of like did Donald Trump and and uh the Republicans want to continue? Now there are other players who are starting to see gains, starting to see that their uh perspectives are able to take shape. And that raises concerns that it's not only what Donald Trump wants to do or the Republicans on how what happens in the Middle East continues to take place.

Aaron PeteUh, what are your reflections on that?

Trevor TombeSo excellent point. And I would not offer a counterpoint to any of that perspective. I'm sort of a deer in the headlights when it comes to the geopolitical and uh military and strategic uh issues and dynamics that are happening around the world. But I will offer a uh, I guess, a positive, not spin, but perspective on even that scenario. Higher energy prices absolutely is a drag and a strain on individuals and families in the short term because of the costs uh that are uh involved at the pump, or in Atlantic, Canada, heating oil is a big, big factor there that's increased quite a bit, uh, straining them far more than the rest of the country.

Trevor TombeBut Canada as a whole benefits from high oil prices. We are a major oil producer. A $10 per barrel change in the world price of oil would boost our economy by a few tenths of a percentage point, uh, which doesn't sound like a lot, uh, but it is, and increase federal revenues by something approximating $3 billion just from that $10 per barrel change. GDP growth would accelerate in almost every province with higher oil prices.

Trevor TombeAnd it's hard to see that day to day uh because of the cost of energy that is a direct expense for households, but we produce oil. We are an oil producing and exporting country. And when the price of what you produce and export rises, You benefit. Those benefits are, you know, it's I guess then we need a conversation around how we manage those benefits, especially the fiscal benefits that come with it. But there is a positive implication of high oil prices on Canada.

Trevor TombeAnd I think this is all the more reason for us to really lean into being a resource-producing country. It's what we have a comparative advantage in, lots of natural endowments. And so increased pipeline capacity to export the very valuable commodity that we have is all the more important in the scenario that you that you outlined. So there's trade-offs, but on the whole, Canada's economy has improved when oil prices rise, even if affordability is strained.

Aaron PeteStillantis is now at the center of controversy over its Brampton plant. Public funding commitments and obligations to Canadian workers. Ottawa has served the company with notice of default over its 2022 agreement. What does the situation tell us about governments trying to protect jobs by subsidizing major corporations?

Trevor TombeYeah, I have always been among those skeptical of the wisdom of governments providing subsidies to businesses, not just, you know, autos, which is, of course, a large recipient uh historically in Canada, but really any business. There needs to be clear reasons for the subsidy in terms of a market failure. And sometimes the market does not produce as much of something as we would like, because the benefits of it may accrue beyond the specific firm.

Trevor TombeSo I think about, you know, we provide subsidies to many businesses for research and development activities. You know, we we do subsidize research. And that's because when things are discovered, the benefits go beyond just the individual firms who do the research. And so there are broader public benefits. And so providing a subsidy, that I can see the logic. It makes sense. But auto manufacturing, there's no clear market failure here. We're providing a subsidy because we feel as though we are in competition with other jurisdictions who are also providing subsidies to try and attract the location of a plant.

Trevor TombeAnd so everyone's engaged in subsidy competition. That doesn't benefit the economies involved at all. It can have implications for a local economy, the particular city that we're locating the plant in, but we must keep in mind that that meant a negative impact on other parts of the country who are funding the subsidy to locate the plant in that location. So there are more costs than benefits when you're subsidizing anything without a clear market failure.

Trevor TombeNow, the specific legal issues involved with Stilantis, I will just uh wait until that goes through the court. Uh uh I don't know. Part of me is skeptical. Um, it does appear as though the government's being particularly political on this, which is perhaps not surprising given um, I guess, the electoral calculations involved. But that makes me skeptical about the merits of the legal claims that they're making. But perhaps I'm mistaken there. So I guess we'll wait to see what a judge has to say about contractual obligations uh in exchange for the money.

Trevor TombeBut to the general principle, you know, it's not money well spent. It lowered demand for Canadian workers elsewhere in the economy. And so the costs are bigger than the benefits, even though the jobs at the particular plant are very visible and easy to point to. The job losses elsewhere were likely larger, though not visible. Anytime we distort economic activity, we are shifting resources from where they had alternative uses. And unless there's a market failure, those alternative uses were more valuable.

Trevor TombeAnd so it's these kind of policies that um are really not well advised. But and uh this is uh, I guess, not unique to Canada, but all major political parties favor subsidizing some sector or another because there are electoral implications, because these can move votes in certain ridings. We see that in terms of not just protections for uh auto manufacturers, but protections for dairy farmers.

Trevor TombeIn my own province of Alberta, we have uh a government that uh at least is outwardly quite supportive of markets in general, uh, but providing considerable public support for petrochemical refining operations in in the province. And so it's it's common. That's not to excuse it, uh, but we do need to, I guess, think uh more deeply as Canadians about whether or not the market is operating uh effectively. Is there strong reasons to think there's a failure?

Trevor TombeAnd if not, don't provide a subsidy. We can help communities in other ways.

Aaron PeteYou've been supportive of allowing businesses to immediately deduct more capital investment, which is what we're seeing with uh some of the mega deductions. Critics would argue that governments keep offering corporations favorable tax treatment while ordinary Canadians struggle with housing and groceries. We saw that in the BC election with Emily Lowen. Why should Canadians believe these business tax measures will ultimately improve their lives?

Trevor TombeWell, the evidence is fairly clear that taxes on investment lowers overall investment. And this matters for Canadians because investment is the most important source of sustained inflation, adjusted wage and salary growth over time. Labor productivity is the key sustainable source of improvements in living standards, and business investment is the largest contributor to that. And I know it doesn't feel like it because it's hard to see in your day-to-day life the connection between an investment decision in a business taken in a previous year for the job and the wage that you're earning now.

Trevor TombeLike that connection is not direct. Same challenge of like free trade. You know, free trade benefits the economy, increases our living standards, improves our uh affordability and cost of living circumstances. But it's hard to walk into any particular store and point to a price and say that's 10% lower because of this free trade agreement. So the connection is more indirect. But it's there. It's there, it's real. Taxes on something detract from that thing. And so when we tax investment, we're going to detract from it and slow overall economic growth.

Trevor TombeAnd the strain that households are facing, the affordability challenges, the cost of living challenges that we face, in my view, the main reason for it is slow productivity growth from weak business investment. And so measures to try and move the needle there will move the needle. Now, 10,000 other things might happen between now and next year that is a negative on investment, but that uh doesn't mean that this policy isn't something that is effective.

Trevor TombeThe evidence is fairly clear on that.

Aaron PeteMay I ask, if you had, say, five minutes with Prime Minister Mark Carney to make a pitch on a change you think is instrumental to getting Canada in a better position, addressing some of the concerns you just raised. What issue comes to mind?

Trevor TombeWell, I won't take five minutes, I'll take 10 seconds, and I say that we need a Royal Commission to do a deep dive on the economic and financial challenges of the country. Full stop. The last time we did this was the early 1980s, following a period of sustained inflation at the time, global changes, technological advancements that were uh changing the way that we do things in a lot of different areas, the prospect for free trade with the United States, the need for tax changes. We that Royal Commission, which I guess was before I was born, but it was significant.

Trevor TombeIt led to dramatic improvements under Brian Mulroney in terms of the trading environment that Canada had access to globally. The tax situation within Canada has dramatically improved. As a result, lots of really important reforms came out as a result of what was called the McDonald Commission. And these kind of deep dives are critically important because governments are consumed by the day-to-day politics and find it impossible to even have conversations about things like old-age security or supply management or tariffs.

Trevor TombeIs retaliation another way to go? Or internal trade, you know, regulating professions separately, province by province, tax reform. You know, what's some alternative ways that we can approach income taxation that improves competitiveness and the investment environment in Canada? These are tough questions that governments shy away from because of the politics. And a Royal Commission or something like that can go away, do the kind of detailed work that you need, engage with the public, maybe even build some public support for the reforms, and then report back to the government who then might have an easier time implementing big reforms, big bang reforms.

Trevor TombeUm, so so that I think is perhaps the most important thing that the government can do. Now, I I know it doesn't sound all that uh all that sexy, you know, to have a royal commission, uh, but that uh is certainly top of my list. Somehow disconnect the tough conversations that we need to have from the politics. Uh and I do want to emphasize that this is not just um this is an issue that confronts all parties. You know, I am puzzled by the Conservative Party supporting increases in old age security.

Trevor TombeBut there it is, because of the politics. And we need some way to facilitate governments taking tougher decisions and easing some of that political pressure. And this I think is one way.

Aaron PeteThat is a brilliant answer. How can people follow your work?

Trevor TombeUh well, I publish regularly for the hub. I think that's a really great source of analysis and insight from many. And so I highly recommend uh subscribing uh to the to that uh source. And then I'm also on uh acts at Trevor Tomb.

Aaron PeteTremendous. Well, thank you again, Trevor, for joining us today and walking us through the budget, interest rates. I feel like we covered a lot of important ground here, and I couldn't agree more. It does seem like particularly supply management has come up again and again as a core issue that we don't want to talk about and that does not end up uh in fulsome discussions about how our economy needs to move forward. And so I really appreciate the recommendation on uh Royal Commission and really appreciate your optimism because I think a lot of Canadians they just don't know where we're going and how they fit into this complex puzzle.

Aaron PeteSo I really appreciate your insights.

Trevor TombeThank you very much. Really enjoyed the conversation. Take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 295. MP Dean Allison: Were Some Canadians Injured by COVID-19 Vaccines?

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 293. Rob Williams: Who Is Responsible for the Canucks' Collapse?

    Nov 13, 202656 minAudio

    Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 292. Jody Mitic: Retired Soldier on the Heartbreaking Reality of Remembrance Day

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 291. Minister Mandy Gull-Masty: Should We Abolish The Indian Act?

    Nov 9, 202658 minAudio

    Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 290. Can Canada Break Its Dependence on The USA?

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    Economists Jack Mintz and Eric Protzer join host Aaron Pete to discuss how Canada can navigate Donald Trump's trade policies, assess Mark Carney's economic strategy, and strengthen the Canadian economy through trade...

    Credit the people on this episode