Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Nuanced.

Nuanced. artwork

260. Ellis Ross: Indigenous MP Warns About the Cowichan Decision

Aug 14, 20261 hr 6 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ellis Ross, Conservative MP and former Haisla chief councillor, joins to explain Aboriginal title, private property, reconciliation, UNDRIP, Indigenous economic development, major projects, Pierre Poilievre and Mark Carney’s record with host Chief Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Aaron PeteWhat has Ottawa taught you about why governments remain so ineffective at improving people's lives?

SPEAKER_03It's not about the objectives of resolving something like poverty, which is tough to do for governments, by the way, but it but it's about a roundabout way of just getting elected, which is not why I got into this game at all.

Aaron PeteIs the cowitching decision leading towards reconciliation?

SPEAKER_03If the decision is upheld, and you're talking about properties, you're talking about property taxes. You're talking about water, sewer, electricity, you're talking about all kinds of different zoning.

Aaron PeteSo you're against the criminalization of what is often called uh Indian residential school denialism?

SPEAKER_03I'm against anything that actually restricts the freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of expression. I'm against any of that.

Aaron PeteWhat are your reflections on the performance of Prime Minister Mark Carney?

SPEAKER_03I I really measure success on the finished product. And I haven't seen a finished product yet come out of Mark Kearney.

Aaron PeteWill Pierre Polyev's leadership survive? Ellis Ross, when we last spoke, you were serving provincially, and much of our conversation focused on poverty in indigenous communities. You have now gone from Heisla Council to the BC legislature to parliament. What has Ottawa taught you about why governments remain so ineffective at improving people's lives?

SPEAKER_03But mainly the politics. But it's about a roundabout way of just getting elected, which is not why I got into this game at all. Uh, it's not what provided the results for my band.

SPEAKER_03Uh if you've got to really make some really tough decisions to resolve an issue like poverty or get the economy going, for example, you got to make some really tough decisions. And politicians are not geared up to make those kind of decisions. But that that that really sums it up for me, given where I come from, uh, from uh a small chief and counsel.

Aaron PeteIn 2020, Evan Solomon moderated your memorable debate with Pam Palmeter over coastal gas link, indigenous leadership, and the blockades. He is now a liberal cabinet minister. Does his move from journalism into partisan politics cause you to reassess how he moderated the debate, or would it be unfair to judge his past journalism through the lens of what he chose to do later?

SPEAKER_03No, I well, the the moderator didn't really have much to do in that. And in any interviews I really gave, the moderator I thought was really just there to kind of referee the process. So I didn't really put any of the the blame on how that interview went or the the content of that conversation went. I I just thought the subject matter itself was uh really really off base. And it really didn't cover uh the substance of what really happened in Kidamat.

SPEAKER_03Because yes, I was trying to resolve poverty, I was trying to resolve unemployment and everything that comes with that, uh, the violence of poverty, including suicides. But the way we did it went about it was participating in processes that allowed these projects to get going, that kick-started our economy, that got us out of poverty, that got us employed. But uh that conversation never got there because it it turned out that it wasn't really a debate about natives or economy or poverty.

SPEAKER_03It turned out more to be about an environmental conversation debate, which ironically is where we got those projects going was from the environmental standpoint through the BC Environmental Assessment and the Federal Environmental Assessment. So yeah, I don't think the moderator had much to do that. I thought the content of the conversation was really the issue.

Aaron PeteCan I ask? Like, I have tried to invite Pam Palmeter to appear on this show to get her take on all of these issues and to see where the if any of her views have changed on the crimes of poverty and how that impacts communities and how it will just reshape a kid's life if they are sexually abused and they'll never be able to reach their full potential. And it doesn't, it still doesn't feel like we've grappled with the importance of that conversation. And she, because I've interviewed people like Francis Widowson, uh like Tim Thielman, who have extreme views about the unmarked grave story and all of these things, but I'm willing to speak with anybody to try and understand their perspectives.

Aaron PeteIt doesn't mean I endorse them, it doesn't mean I agree with them, but it means that there's an importance to the conversation. And she will not speak to me uh or Sean Carleton because they believe I platform deniers. What is your take on how I should approach these things?

SPEAKER_03You're taking the right approach. I mean, the the the this is the problem I have when we talk about, say, subject matter like truth or reconciliation. For the truth, you've got to talk the truth, you've got to speak the truth, you've got to know the truth. And for that, you need facts. And so I don't see how we we have this conversation unless it's a hard conversation. And and really, the the conversations I've had were with Native leaders all across BC and Canada that were dealing with the same issues that we were dealing with.

SPEAKER_03And yes, it's they're they're not fun subjects to talk about. But it but it if you want to resolve it, you gotta you gotta face it head-on. And you gotta be really stark about the reality of not only like what you see as a leader, but probably what you grew up with. Now I'm talking about growing up as a native on reserve. But in my adult years, I actually was a native living off reserve. And yes, the the the issues are are kind of different, but they're rooted in in the same foundation of what makes Aboriginal poverty so unmanageable.

SPEAKER_03Uh we we managed it, we resolved the the majority of our issues in Kiddamat. Uh, but but it was uh through a wide range of different processes connected to independence, the economy. Uh basically the individual's right to succeed or fail on their own terms. And that that's a really tough conversation to have. Really tough. So if you haven't lit it, it if you haven't lived it, it's really hard to describe it.

SPEAKER_03So you you latch on to any other reason why you shouldn't promote economic development within First Nation communities or cultures for that matter. So a tough conversation to have.

Aaron PeteAs you may know, Tekemloop's Teslaquetmec, Tchemloops First Nation did research, GPR ground penetrating radar, and believed that they had found 215 unmarked graves. And that's how it was reported in the CBC, Globe and Mail, uh, the New York Times. And since then, the Globe and Mail has come out and said uh there's not evidence to support that there is, in fact, unmarked graves there. Um, but there may be, and more excavations needed. The nation received around$12 million to do that excavation work.

Aaron PeteAnd to date, none of that has been done. And so it's led many people, Francis Widowson, Candice Milcom, many to come out and go, if you can provide evidence, then you need to either excavate or stop making the claim. And from my understanding, Chief Roseanne Casimir has basically said, we will one day maybe excavate, but that will be up to our community. We're not sure. It may take a hundred years to get there. What is your take on where we stand on this specific fact?

SPEAKER_03Well, it was a flash point. You can't deny it. And at the time, uh I've I've always been about the true definition of reconciliation, not the political definition that we see today. Uh because back when that all came out as a story, I I noticed a lot of non-natives Canadians wanted to be part of the story. They wanted to be part of the future going forward together. But there was resistance from the native community.

SPEAKER_03And this was a good example. My whole perspective at the time, I went down there and I I thought so this is a great chance for Canada to face its past on facts and evidence if you just dig up the remains and identify them. And it wouldn't just stop there at identification in my mind. I thought this would be a great chance of a repatriation. So you you you dig up the remains, you you cross-reference it with records, and then bring those remains back to the native communities for a proper burial.

SPEAKER_03That would have been a huge moment in Canadian history. If all this was done correctly, the federal government would have been involved, the provincial government would have been involved, the community in question would have had a big ceremony with all the chiefs and all the regalia. It would have been a whole process that to bring the remains home. But it all was all predicated in that one point. Can we clarify whether or not these are human remains or not? And I think that's the fundamental question that that's getting that that's m getting muddied now.

SPEAKER_03Because as as soon as you question it, you're turned into a residential school denier when really that's not what they're talking about. And I I think it's it's caused so much division when really this was a chance for Canadians to understand their past and start building something forward together. Because up until 2017, things were going fairly well. The courts have already said how we're supposed to reconcile, how we're supposed to move together forward, because let's face it, none of us are going anywhere.

SPEAKER_03Then this kind of stalled that process. And I I I just think that uh the the best way out of this is yet is to dig up the mains, verify them, and bring them home.

Aaron PeteWhy is that so controversial? I've interviewed many people uh on what I would call the political left. And I've spoken to Karen Restoul, who you may know. I've spoken to Tara Henley, I've spoken to many people on this issue. And there's a deep fear about saying that we just need to excavate and determine what is true and what's not true. And that doesn't take away from the rest of the history. This doesn't, this has this is a flashpoint, but it doesn't remove the other truths that we know to be verified and confirmed. And you're right that many people have stood on this issue and said, there's not the evidence to support this claim at this stage.

Aaron PeteSo let's just confirm what is true and what's not true and then continue on the path forward as as laid out.

SPEAKER_03Because uh I think it was so politicized. And I I think it it it got out of the control of the Camus band themselves. And even they admitted that uh they weren't they they couldn't verify exactly what the remains were. And if you match it up with the documentation of the records, uh the death records of some of these students, you know, that there's a lot of evidence out there that points to what is the reality of that, and nobody really wants to face that.

SPEAKER_03But but I think uh the there's one thing that uh everybody agrees on that residential schools uh for the most part was a dark chapter in Canadian history. And everybody's dwelling on that fact. And I I think this brought it to the next level where where Canadians were horrified to learn that this might be a reality in terms of the remains that might be in the ground. But the word might is a big word when it comes to this.

SPEAKER_03So I think everybody's kind of scared of what the outcome might be. And then I I for myself, I just thought, okay, if you do identify some remains and you do repatriate them and have a proper burial, that's perfect. That that that'll feed the healing between our two societies. But let's say you don't find anything and it's not confirmed, that doesn't make the issue of residential schools go away. That doesn't make the treatment of of Aboriginal people in Canada over the last hundred and fifty years go away.

SPEAKER_03I think the conversation's still gotta continue. But with a different context and take the politics out of it. And just I mean, Canadians want to reconcile. You can't fix a past. Let's face it, you can't fix a past. And to look through the lens of today and look at the history in any context is is not fair. But at least Canadians want to acknowledge and want to understand what happened back then and they want to build something forward going forward.

SPEAKER_03I agree with that. It's a great opportunity. And everybody makes mistakes. I make them all the time. That that doesn't actually take away from my intent to build a better Canada or a better society. I mean, that I don't know. I never come across anybody as perfect. It's human to be wrong. So I just think take the politics out of it and let's go after truth with facts, and then we can start talking really about uh reconciliation.

Aaron PeteI've asked many people this question, and with no disrespect to anybody's previous answer, I haven't found an answer that's satisfying to me. How do we approach people who came out early on this issue and took a lot of tomatoes and a lot of sticks in regards to this? I'm talking, and maybe not in a good way, like Dallas Brody, who comes out with a sign that says nobody's found, um, Francis Widowson, who goes around to university campuses with a sandwich board uh saying no, nobody's found, and these things like how they came out early, and they may end up being correct in the final analysis.

Aaron PeteWe don't know until we excavate, but they have taken a lot of negativity. They've been called deniers, they have been ostracized. I've been invited to speak about the unmarked grave story and my perspective on it, but they don't want Dallas Brody, Francis Widow Sim, Tim Tio and these people who are willing to come out. Now, again, I don't have to agree with their tactics, but it's a conversation that many people don't want to have. And so their approach, while aggressive, uh could be what the moment was calling for in order to get Canadians to grapple with a very tough conversation about the the validity of the story.

Aaron PeteHow do you think we should approach people who came out early on the story?

SPEAKER_03Well, I get it. I understand it. And from what I read and what I I heard, uh what they were saying, they they were just trying to get to the heart of the matter in terms of getting the facts. And they couldn't get it. And given the sensitivity of what they were talking about, I I could see how people were getting upset. But to politicize it like that is where it really went off the rails. But to get even deeper into this, uh I I I'm a firm believer in the freedoms that Canada provides to everybody in Canada.

SPEAKER_03It's one of the things that makes Canada unique in the world. And we're talking about freedom of speech. And that's where we're talking about in terms of those people I came out early. We're talking about freedom of religion, we're freedom of freedom of expression. But to really prove that you believe in those those freedoms, you have to accept those opinions. I mean, it's it's when we start talking about censorship and you start talking about how you want to talk about a real sensitive topic topic but you can't because maybe the government's talking about finding you or sending you to jail.

SPEAKER_03That is not what Canada's about. That's not how Canada was built. It's not what they envisioned. So no matter what the topic, I mean, we're talking about uh sensitive topics like the Holocaust, for example. Talking about uh other uh genocides happening in Africa, where we're talking about uh racial wars in Serbia and Bosnia, all these sensitive topics that nobody really wants to talk to about what is at the heart of the matter. In other countries, you could go to jail for talking about that.

SPEAKER_03But in Canada, no matter how pleasant, and I've been in part of a lot of unpleasant conversations, but I've never said that person without opinion should go to jail. I mean it to believe in the Charter of Rights in Canada is to say you can have your opinion, but no matter how insensitive it comes across, you've got to respect the freedom of speech that actually allows that to happen in Canada. And that that goes for anything, not just residential schools.

SPEAKER_03And I I do appreciate listening to the different opinions from all spectrums, whether you're talking about the left, the right, the middle. But ultimately you've got to, at some point, if you want to resolve it, you've got to come down to truth and facts.

Aaron PeteSo you're against the criminalization of what is often called uh Indian residential school denialism?

SPEAKER_03Um I'm against anything that actually restricts the freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of expression. Uh I'm against any of that. The the the bar has got to be so high for a government to restrict your freedom of speech. It's got to be really high. And I always question whether or not Canadians understand when they're talking about amending their freedoms, they're actually putting it into the hands of uh politicians. And to ask a politician to create legislation that speaks to your morals or your values, yeah.

SPEAKER_03I'm not sure about that. So one of the reasons why I uh I believe so much in freedoms is because First Nations never had it. My ancestors didn't have the right to vote until recently. We didn't have the right to hire lawyers, we didn't have the right to have potlatches, we didn't have the right to own land unless we uh enfranchised. We didn't have rights. And so I I come out as a politician in 2003 and I start to read the Constitution, I read start to read the Charter, I start to read the Indian Act.

SPEAKER_03And I think, you know, with the tools that we have in place today, that there's a way to fix our future as Aboriginals, and at the same time we can strengthen Canada. But I don't see how you strengthen Canada when you weaken the freedoms. I mean, the you really gotta fight hard to protect your freedoms. You you can't be apathetic about it. And I I think it's really worth fighting for when you're talking about Don.

Aaron PeteEllis, you're probably one of the best people to ask about this. I often feel like because I'm commenting on these issues, that I'm not reflective of many Indigenous people. And I'm sure you've struggled with that feeling as well of like, there is kind of your prototypical First Nation person who would likely think that we should rest deniers that uh anything that goes against the environment is a terrible thing, and that doesn't often get like that kind of stereotype of First Nations people. And nor you nor I reflect that kind of typical First Nation person that people will think of in their heads when they think of someone.

Aaron PeteAnd so I don't always know how to approach issues because I don't want to pretend I'm reflective of every First Nations person, nor do you. But we're often put in these circumstances where we're speaking about really important issues on the stage. How do you grapple with that balance of it's your perspective, but you also led a community for a very long time? And now you're you're still being put in that position of reflecting First Nations perspectives. But often when we go out and speak, they're like, well, we don't hear that from other First Nations people. How do you digest that and work through it?

SPEAKER_03Well, it's it's it comes down to the the uh freedom of expression and everybody's right to their own opinion. And it goes both ways, by the way. Uh I've heard some horrible conversations about people talking about colonialists or settlers. And that's to to put a negative spin on that, to talk about how evil the colonialists are, the settlers, or how First Nations like us, me and you, are assimilated.

SPEAKER_03We're selling out somehow because we promote uh anti poverty measures that include economic development. That's offensive. But it's still your right to say it, it's still your right to have that opinion. I mean, that that that's what that that's a good thing about Canada, no matter how offensive your opinion is. How uninformed or informed you are, it doesn't matter. I think what we're really talking about, what the what the basis of that is, is tolerance. Now I'm not talking about extreme hate, extreme violence to justify your opinion, whether you're talking about the far left or you're talking about the far right.

SPEAKER_03Not talking about that. I'm talking about the adults in the room that can have a civil conversation. And we can walk away and say, hey, we did agree or we didn't agree, but still, we understand each other. I was told this a long time ago as a basketball player. Uh the elders used to come into our practices and race hell on us for not working hard enough. But this one elder came in one night and he was talking about our work ethic. And he said, remember, the younger generation is always watching you.

SPEAKER_03And they're going to build on what you've done or haven't done. So keep that in mind when you guys are out here. So I took that to the level of being a political figure when we're talking about these issues. If I'm just hammering it on residential schools or colonialism or settlers, I know my kids are watching. I know my grandkids are watching. And at the very least, I should tell them you should be tolerant of other people's perspectives and opinions. That's what's going to make us a stronger country.

SPEAKER_03That's what's going to foster reconciliation. But if you're adamant that someone should go to jail or get fined, is that really the country you want to live in? You want a police state where somebody's going to be watching what you say or what you post? And you're going to be criminalized for that? Given where natives come from under the Internet Act, I don't think we should be going too far back. I think we should be strengthening our freedoms.

Aaron PeteMany First Nations voters and organizations have traditionally aligned with the liberals or NDP, but values such as family responsibility, local autonomy, entrepreneurship, stewardship, and suspicion of centralized government can also be described as conservative. Why has the Conservative Party not converted those shared values into stronger Indigenous support?

SPEAKER_03That's a good question. I don't get the First Nations support as an MLA or as an MP. And most of it is attached to their parents voting NTP or their grandparents voting NDP. Back at a time when First Nations issues didn't matter. There was only a few political parties talking about at the time. And so I think there's that emotional allegiance to them. But uh I I get questioned a lot as an Aboriginal from other Aboriginals saying, how come you're a conservative?

SPEAKER_03And my point is, why aren't you a conservative? I believe in justice. I believe in equality. I believe in independence, not only as chief and counselors, but for the individuals themselves. I believe in all of that, and that's why I joined the Conservative Party. And so, and that's what I learned as a young man in my village and also as a chief and counsel representative. It was my people that wanted more police presence in our community.

SPEAKER_03It was our people that wanted justice for crimes made against them. Even today, we still want that. And we still want the services. With no tax base in our community, we actually we relied heavily on the Indian Act funding that came from Ottawa before, but we wanted more because we were deficient in, say, fire protection. We're deficient in our clinic, we're deficient in our public works. So if nobody understands Indian Act funding, if you need uh, say,$100,000 to run your public works under the Indian Act, they'll give you 70%.

SPEAKER_03And they'll say, good luck with that remaining 30%. And if you're a band that has no money, you're trying to find ways to get that extra 30%. And with no tax base, you know, you can't go to your band members and tell them, hey, can you give me 30% to buy a new garbage truck? You can't do that. So you're looking at different ways and different tools that municipalities might have or a provincial government might have. And you you got to be creative.

SPEAKER_03So it's it's a lot of different things that that that that affect me. But it all comes down to what is best for the First Nations that can actually help make the region, the country, and the province stronger. Because we did it in Kidamat. We resolved all those issues, and we didn't override anybody's rights. We didn't affect anybody's properties, and we we made the country stronger.

Aaron PeteAaron Ross Powell Is the Cowichan decision leading towards reconciliation?

SPEAKER_03It it depends on what happens next. Number one, we've got to wait for the outcome, uh, the appeal. That's gonna take years. The uncertainty around uh the land itself is is gonna sit there for quite a while until that decision is reached. And if if the decision is upheld, uh in my mind, there's two consequences. Number one, you get you're gonna have to deal with some type of jurisdictional framework to talk about how this is co-managed from the first age perspective as well as from a mispality and a provincial perspective.

SPEAKER_03That is that that raises a whole pile of different questions. Because if it does come down to that, and you're talking about properties, you're talking about property taxes, you're talking about water, sewer, electricity, you're talking about all kinds of different zoning. Let's face it, a lot of chieftain councils uh have no experience in. They have none of that because we don't have those types of policies on reserve.

SPEAKER_03But on the other hand, the other option as well is maybe it comes down to some type of compensation. Land, money, or both. Uh who's to say? But there's too many factors in play now. You you've you've got the decision you've got to wait for, but you also got uh TRIPA, which is formal legislation in BC. And sooner or later that's gonna get inserted. I know it's not inserted right now, but it is being thrown on the table right now for other issues.

SPEAKER_03So it's gonna get even more complicated if things keep going the way it's going, because nobody seems to have an answer apart from saying uh maybe we'll amend the constitution uh to protect private property. But even that, do you do this a country or do you do it province by province? It's gonna be a long time before that story has a conclusion.

Aaron PeteCan the Aboriginal title and fee simple title coexist on the same parcel meaningfully?

SPEAKER_03Well, yeah, because it does in Kidamat. But it it all depends on what your objective is. So in Kitamat, uh our village, we acquired three pieces of private property, and we kept it in fee simple status because business likes certainty, and we didn't want to rewrite the whole book on land regulations or taxation or leases, so we used existing processes, but we never gave up our rights and titles to that land.

SPEAKER_03We never gave it up, it's still there. It's not official, it's not in writing, you don't see it anywhere. But it's there. But we use uh existing processes uh to actually make sure that it's it's run in a way that's consistent with BC and federal laws, and it works. There's no real need for us to insert our arbitration title into it. But we know it's there.

SPEAKER_03So it can work. But one one of the issues I uh I brought up when we're dealing with this kind of issue, I said, why do you want this responsibility? Why? Like what when you start to manage land like this and you want to take it on, you know, lock, stock, and barrel. You want to exclude the municipality, you want to exclude the province and the feds, you got to rewrite the book now. And we're talking about responsibility of the land, and more importantly, you're talking about liability.

SPEAKER_03Something happens in a chunk of land there, you can't go running back to Canada or BC. It's your signature on that decision. You're the one that's gonna have to pay for it. Are you ready for that? Because we're talking insurance, we're talking court cases, we're talking old pile of stuff. It's much better to actually go with an existing process. Maybe down the line there, you become an organization that has a continuity and the corporate memory to actually deal with this.

SPEAKER_03But right now we're not there. And right now, the mechanisms that BC employs and Canada employs, they work. They work for the benefit of all of us, not just First Nations. So for us, yeah, it definitely works. But there's so many different designations of land in BC and Canada that uh if you understand it, you you can put together a framework of how to deal with the different designations and just private lines as one of those components.

SPEAKER_00When does reconciliation end?

SPEAKER_03Oh well, I don't go with the political definition of reconciliation. I go with uh the definition that was laid out by the courts, and the courts definition is mainly about uh reconciling uh rights and title interests with uh crown interests in terms of title. And to that end, it was really about when uh when the crown is aware of a decision that they're gonna make that might affect Aboriginal rights and title, then they've got to consult and accommodate to the best of their ability to reconcile the two worlds.

SPEAKER_03That's all that's all chaos now with uh with the cow chin and the private land and stuff. But that that that that decision was made in the interest of society overall. No, you were we're not talking about a veto, we're not talking about you know one side winning or losing, we're talking about what is best for society. So, under that definition, it probably doesn't end until maybe a First Nation signs a treaty with BC in Canada, and you give up your asserted rights and title for defined rights and title, and then it becomes a different type of cooperative agreement.

SPEAKER_03But if you're uh a non-treaty band, then every time a decision comes up that affects your rights and title, then that reconciliation process has to kick in.

SPEAKER_02Do you support the new proposed pipeline to Vancouver? Yes. The one proposed by Premier Daniel Smith.

SPEAKER_03Um I've never I've never really I've never really supported anything outright. I've always actually wanted to learn the process in terms of how these projects get approved. Uh I got my start in the council uh on environmental issues for Kitamat for past damage. We had 60 years of industrial damage. And so to understand how we got there was an eye-opener, but to understand going forward how these projects get approved is more important in terms of how do you address environmental issues, say around a marsh or around an old growth area or a berry-picking area, for example, and then how do you address Aboriginal perils that?

SPEAKER_03So it's it's not that I don't support or support the pipeline, it's just that I don't understand the process that they're they're considering. I I don't already I don't get it. I I get environmental assessments. I I read the Federal Environmental Assessment Act years ago. I read it again. I know the BC Environmental Assessment, I know the permitting, I know what it takes to get a project completed and started. What the federal government and the major projects office are talking about is not really lining up with how I've learned to get projects built.

SPEAKER_03I mean, you you do want the highest environmental standards, but they haven't really talked about how they're gonna uphold those environmental standards with this fast tracking process that they stop. And I haven't gotten any real clear answers on how it's gonna work. If you're gonna fast track it, you're gonna have to omit some parts of the Environmental Assessment Act that people aren't aware of. I mean, to do a project in a time span.

SPEAKER_03I'm I know it's possible. But you I don't understand how they they can be open and transparent with the Kenyan public on saying they're gonna uphold the house environmental standards, but we're gonna do it in a time frame that's never been seen before. And I think that's probably one of the reasons why they haven't really initiated any new projects. All the projects they've announced that were already projects that had been in works for years, already three-quarters complete. So it's so it I'm kind of questioning when do they come out to announce their process and what's that going to entail?

Aaron PeteIn April, you submitted a detailed parliamentary question asking how the major projects office would protect Aboriginal and treaty rights, provide nations with a sufficient capacity, and preserve environmental safeguards. What should happen from your perspective when a project is in the national interest but affects First Nations, um, affected First Nations remain opposed?

SPEAKER_03Well, the thing about it is you can oppose, you can support, but but the courts have already laid down that you must consult. And if the crown, and to a lesser extent, the proponent has done their job, they've done everything they could to consult and accommodate, and the First Nation still opposes. Well, the courts have said, Crown, if you've done your job and you did it to the best of your ability, then you still have the right to make a decision, saying that you've exhausted every avenue to consult on the comedy.

SPEAKER_03And you're doing it to protect society's interests. So I still stick with that. Uh the Haida court case of 2004 lays it out quite clearly. And Chil Colton later on, 10 years later, brought it to a higher level. Now, what's confusing things is uh DRIPA, United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People in Ottawa, and the DRIPA legislation in BC. That's what's confused things. That's got nothing to do with the courts of Canada. That came from the United Nations.

SPEAKER_03A body that has no clue on how far and how advanced Canada has come in terms of dealing with Aboriginal issues. So you've taken a foreign a foreign entity and you've taken their narrative and you've plunked it down in a country that is doing its best to resolve Aboriginal issues. And they, yeah, it wasn't perfect. But at least you resolved one of the fundamental questions, is exactly a question. What do we do with a First Nation that still opposes?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, you do as much as you can. But to be fair to society, who still wants doctors, nurses, roads, uh communications, you want all the services and privileges that Canadians enjoy today, government's got a duty to look out for that. And they're probably both at the higher levels, Aboriginal Western title and society's interests. But uh, I mean, let's face it, the the Trans-Canada uh the Trans-Mountain Pipeline, there's a lot of First Nations that still oppose that.

SPEAKER_03But Canada did as much as they could to consult and they still made that decision. LG Canada, there's First Nations and entities that still opposed it. But Canada BC still made their decision. What were the results? Canada got more money. They they fed, not across the board, of course, but they fed that back into infrastructure. They fed it back into highways for terrorists, bridges. Uh, some of the services that people depend on.

SPEAKER_03It well it should go back to that. And that that actually resolves the idea of raising taxes or cutting services for that matter.

Aaron PeteJournalist Robert Fife from the Globe and Mail recently told me he does not believe Pierre Polyev will remain conservative leader through the next summer. He believes he will be done by Christmas. Will Pierre Polyev's leadership survive?

SPEAKER_03Um, I don't know. That's not for me. I I just know that uh the the principles for the conservatives is what I aligned with, and that's why I joined them. But I I found out about Pierre Polyev long before he became leader. I was watching him on committee on CPAC. And I was uh I was very impressed with his focus on in committee and his knowledge, and I'm still impressed with him. I don't think uh people have really seen the truth, Polyev.

SPEAKER_03Uh he he's he's actually uh I I don't characterize him as a politician. I really don't. I I I just think that he he's a guy who truly cares about Canada. And he's got the background. Uh it's not a great background to come from, where he comes from. But he's he's turned that into something else. I I think he's a good leader. I think he's really what Canada needs. Canada is lacking a vision right now, they're lacking discipline.

SPEAKER_03Affordability is through the roof. The relationship of the United States is not great, it's getting worse. Uh the security of the Arctic, when we're talking about China and Russia uh encroaching on Canadian sovereign waters, that that's that's going to come to a head pretty quick. Um I really think the best choice Canadians can make now is select a leader that will make the tough decisions and not just stick to the politics and and grand announcements.

SPEAKER_03So I think Canada really needs them.

SPEAKER_00How do you reflect?

Aaron PeteThere's a uh frequently circulated line that he said, which is uh, I'll quote directly my view is that we need to engender the values of hard work and independence and self-reliance. Uh, that's the solution in the long run. More money will not solve it. And he was speaking about Aboriginal people in June 2008, uh, around the time Stephen Harper made his apology about Indian residential schools. Do you agree with him?

SPEAKER_03Um well, the the way he said it, of course, of course, uh that's what the issue was. And uh to my recollection, he apologized the next day. But you know, I've seen this across all your yeah, I've seen this all across political parties. Uh I had like the NDP in BC, for example. Uh I had a debate about L and G. And the NDP debated that for future generations of Aboriginals, Aboriginals should not be looking at L and G.

SPEAKER_03I mean, I I've when I was in MLA, there there was politicians that were laughing at my friend Roe Jones Jr., talking about how his people didn't even like him and even laughed at his nickname. I mean, you you see these transgressions all across the different political parties, uh really not knowing what it's like to be an Aboriginal. And so they make these remarks from the outside looking in without knowing what it's really like to be an Aboriginal growing up.

SPEAKER_03And all it takes is a little bit of education. All it takes is to be around one of us and provide you insight into what it's really like. Like uh Billy Moran, for example, uh, same kind of background. Right? But he sees a bigger vision. And he he he's just like me. He wants to bring the native community together, the non-native community together. And like I say, it goes both ways. Like I I don't condone any of those kind of comments.

SPEAKER_03In the same manner, I don't condone anybody talking about settlers or colonialists or assimilated. Like uh like I'm not the only one that gets called assimilated. I I've seen other Aboriginal leaders get called that, and worse, they get called apples. Red on the outside and white on the inside. Uh that that that kind of conversations is not needed. Especially now. I think we're at turning point in terms of so many different issues.

SPEAKER_03This is not the time for divisiveness. Now is a time to pull together if we wanted Canada to survive going into the next five, ten years.

Aaron PeteFormer Chief Billy Morin did come on the show and he shared his experience with being invited to cross the floor over to Mark Kearney. Were you invited to cross the floor over to the the liberals?

SPEAKER_03No, I wasn't invited. I don't think they'd I don't think they wanted to invite me. I think I'm a little too hardened in my views. And I I believe do as you say, say as you do. And I believe in getting things done. I believe in justice. So, no, I I I think they learned pretty quick that uh I'm not the guy to approach.

Aaron PeteWhat are your thoughts on those floor crossings? There's many Canadians who fear that something was offered, something was provided to encourage them to cross the floor beyond just a polite invitation. What are your thoughts?

SPEAKER_03Well, there's no rule against it, there's no legislation. Uh for me, it and I'm not talking about anybody else, I'm just talking about myself. It it all comes down to your morals, your values, my integrity, my character. Um, I've I've never believed in walking away from somebody. I mean, I the the the conversation back when Z M LA was I was gonna go join John Rustad with the newly formed BC Conservatives.

SPEAKER_03And but people forget that during the leadership race for the BC Liberals, I was a candidate, and I made a commitment that that I said that if I win or lose the leadership candidate, I'm still gonna stick around and I'm still gonna be an MA and I'm still gonna help the BC Liberals. And I stuck to that. And I yeah, the offers were there for me to cross the floor to be a BC conservative. But I still remember the commitment, the promise I made. And so I I when I became an MP, I said, look, I'm gonna finish on my term, like I said, I'm gonna do.

SPEAKER_03But then I'm not gonna run again, I'm gonna run for a federal conservative. So I think it comes down to uh what your values are and what what your constituents think. I made a commitment, I ran under the conservative banner to my constituents. I said, Yeah, I'm gonna run for the federal conservatives, and I'm gonna champion the riding. That's what I'll do as a conservative. And I I can't go back on that.

SPEAKER_00You're surrounded by members of parliament from all political backgrounds.

Aaron PeteHow many people do you think percentage-wise hold those same type of values about representing uh dancing with the one that brought you that kind of mentality, that integrity that you're talking about? How many people do you think in Ottawa hold that type of integrity?

SPEAKER_03That's a tough question. There's a lot of people there. Like there's a lot of conservatives as well. I mean, some of the conservatives that I knew that crossed the floor, I thought never in a million years would they cross just based on what they said in the house, what they talked about. I I it was a total shocker when when a couple of them cross the floor. But it's it's it's really hard to see unl unless you get up and and you openly admit it to people that I will never cross the floor, I'll never back down on this.

SPEAKER_03Uh and whether or not you're willing to follow up on that with your actions. So I'm not I'm not really aware of how many people have the I'm sure there is a lot of them. I mean, I I know for uh a few that I've in our circle I talk to a lot, I know then they're gonna be a conservative with or without government. They're gonna be conservative. It's it's based on their value system in terms of freedoms, crime, justice, economy, uh, fiscal responsibility in terms of the budget and spending.

SPEAKER_03I mean, the the those those people I talked to, uh uh I think are never never in a million dollars will cross the floor. But I haven't talked to a lot of them in terms of the House of Commons itself.

Aaron PeteI've had Globen journalists, um, Globin Mail journalists Robert Fife and Tony Keller on. Robert Fife described Mark Kearney as having uh a remarkable year, was his words. Tony Keller confirmed he believes that Mark Kearney's also had a remarkable year. What are your reflections on the performance of Prime Minister Mark Kearney?

SPEAKER_03Well, I come from the world of doing stuff. Like LG Canada didn't materialize out of nothing. Uh Cedar LG was it was a component of the agreement we signed with uh LG Canada. Uh we signed forest agreements, we acquired land, we we did, we built things. So I I really measure success on the finished product. And I haven't seen a finished product yet come out of Mark Carney.

SPEAKER_03I I've seen the announcements. Um but but a couple of examples was the idea that somehow Mark Carney was going to handle Donald Trump. And now every day you hear some news story about more terrorists coming from the United States. Uh you see the comment that he made that uh the intermediate powers should unite under one banner, you know, as a way to compete with the higher superpowers, and then trying to walk that comment back.

SPEAKER_03I mean, you you're you're dealing with a superpower, you're dealing with one of the biggest economies in the world, and yet you're making these comments. And it this is what like I I took uh twice, my bank counsel brought in professional negotiating courses. And in all those courses, I don't remember uh the instructor telling us that it's a good idea to insult the person you're negotiating with.

SPEAKER_03I mean, one of the things that the liberals said is what's the difference between what's so great about Canada? And the prime minister said, oh, the greatest thing is that we're not Americans. Why say that? I mean, this this is not how you negotiate. And that granted, this is this is on a larger scale. But Canada, you you've got some you've got some resources and you got some advantages that you should be using if you can understand the mentality of the United States.

SPEAKER_03You know, it's uh I thought this was common knowledge, and I guess it's not. I went to this conference in Alberta a few years ago as an MLA, and I was invited to this uh fireplace discussion, and they had a ex-Democrat senator. And after his speech, he they asked for questions. And so I wrote, I texted my question, and they chose my question. And I I asked him, said, So, what what do Americans think about the soft root lumber agreement?

SPEAKER_03And the the senator, here's a good question. He's asking, what do we think about the soft root lumber agreement? He said, we don't. He said, Canadians, you think you're the only ones that have to deal with unemployment and your economy? We do too. But we also have to deal with global security. We have to deal with uh foreign countries, we have to deal with China, we have to deal with the Arctic, we have to deal with so much. He said, but have you ever come, have you ever guys ever come to Washington and talked about how we cooperate on how we look after how we look after North America?

SPEAKER_03Because that's what Americans have to think about. They they feel they have a responsibility and duty to the world. And I've thought a lot about that. It's because we're always thinking about the perspective me, me, me. You know, you know, I'm I'm the one getting the dirty end of the stick. And this is what they they they teach you in negotiation courses. You know, you you got an objective, great. But the the guy on the other side of the table, they got an objective too.

SPEAKER_03Now, how do you how do you make those both objectives happen at the same time? That's the trick. That's what you're trying to resolve. So I don't get you know what the strategy is behind this and what really has been accomplished, apart from announcing projects that have already been in works for years. But I do I do care about the country. That's that's basically why I stay so involved.

Aaron PeteA few more questions. Thank you so much for being willing to share your time. There's a claim that Mark Kearney has moved politically right um in since taking office. Do you agree with that assessment?

SPEAKER_03Um no, I don't. I know he's taking some of the conservative ideas, like uh getting rid of the carbon tax, for example. Uh, but I don't think he's moved right. I don't think we'll know for sure where he's moving until he actually accomplishes something. Uh maybe the pipeline to Vancouver is the is the accomplishment. Maybe that's it. But there'll be so much to accomplish in within that context.

SPEAKER_03Uh you'll have to fulfill the Alberta MOU, for example, and all those terms and conditions inside that. Uh, you'll have to resolve uh the the the killer whale campaign that's coming up. And you'll have to resolve how you fast track not only the environmental assessment for that, but you'll have to uh fast track how do you address Aboriginal as a title in that same equation. So yeah. I I don't think he's actually done enough yet to see to to prove whether or not he's moved far to the right or not.

Aaron PeteIn the 2020 provincial election, your mother was dying, but she insisted on voting, and a ballot box was brought to her bedside. When the ballots were counted, you won Kidamat Village by a single vote. Do you know whether or not that was hers?

SPEAKER_02And what did that moment mean to you?

SPEAKER_03My mother was uh one of my biggest supporters. She didn't understand the issues that I was trying to deal with in terms of L and G or structural redevelopment, or but she was my supporter. And she she always made a point to vote. And I wasn't aware that she she had done that. And she she actually passed away on her birthday, January 1st. And it was uh when I was told about that, like I'd I'd never won the vote in the Aboriginal community, even though I'm Aboriginal.

SPEAKER_03Even though I was I'm trying to resolve Aboriginal poverty using the tools and mechanisms that are available right now. But when she she often talked to me about how surprised she was about not only how far our community had gone, but how far I had gone. Because I didn't graduate. I'm born, raised on reserve, and made all the same mistakes other personally made.

SPEAKER_03But for some unknown reason, from a higher power, I was kept out of prison. I was kept off the streets, I was kept out of drug abuse, uh, did the alcohol abuse big time. But when she was trying to explain it to me, she was using native words because there's no English words to describe it. And I and I was trying to wrap my head around it. Now that I'm older, I can see what she meant. Because now I have grandkids and I have a vision for them. But it but it's completely different from the vision my mom had for me.

SPEAKER_03Like she was just struggling to put food in the table. She was knitting socks and you know, sewing the holes in our socks and our shirts and you know, pinching her pennies, so it it meant a lot. It still means a lot. Uh, I still think about them quite often. Both my dad and my mom. But but my mom in particular, because she didn't understand exactly what I was doing, but she believed fully in it, and she believed that was the answer.

SPEAKER_03And both her and my dad went to residential school, and they believed so firmly in what I was doing. It it's that there was a few people like that through my wife. I don't want to call it just blind allegiance, but the the the faith and confidence that they had in me was it was overwhelming.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for sharing your time, Mr. Ross.

Aaron PeteI have to say, uh, watching that debate you did with Pam Palmeter, it shaped me in ways I I'm still seeing come out because I'm now chief of my community. And as we spoke the first time, it shaped my belief that that needs to be the central focus. And I believe there's two broad camps, one focused on aboriginal rights and title, and one focused on socioeconomic conditions. And I've all in this camp because of that debate unit, because I couldn't see Pam Palmeter's argument carrying water when I'd go into my community and see the living circumstances to choose.

Aaron PeteOh, we're not going to do a pipeline and I'm going to leave these people in poverty. Just doesn't make an ounce of sense to me when I see people who aren't able to reach their full potential. Like we broke through when so many others didn't. And so we have a responsibility to make sure that future generation has that opportunity. And so I'm a student of how you think about these issues. Uh, have learned a lot through it, and I'm just always grateful when our paths cross because that was a defining moment of my understanding. It contributed to me wanting to be the Evan Solomon sitting and interviewing people and having two ideas kind of clash and see which one carries weight amongst the public and just really encouraged me to move in the direction that I have.

Aaron PeteSo I'm just always privileged to speak with you.

SPEAKER_03Oh, thanks for having me back. And stick with it. It's not a glorious there won't be thanks along the way, but when you do get there and you accomplish it and every all your people are succeeding, you know, you you'll appreciate it. You you'll thank yourself. And maybe someone will thank you. So keep it up.

Aaron PeteThank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 295. MP Dean Allison: Were Some Canadians Injured by COVID-19 Vaccines?

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 294. Trevor Tombe: Will Canadians Be Financially Better Off in 2027?

    Nov 16, 202657 minAudio

    University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 293. Rob Williams: Who Is Responsible for the Canucks' Collapse?

    Nov 13, 202656 minAudio

    Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 292. Jody Mitic: Retired Soldier on the Heartbreaking Reality of Remembrance Day

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 291. Minister Mandy Gull-Masty: Should We Abolish The Indian Act?

    Nov 9, 202658 minAudio

    Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...

    Credit the people on this episode