279. Dr. Cindy Blackstock: Is Canada Still Discriminating Against First Nations Children?
59 minAudio
First Nations child-welfare advocate Dr. Cindy Blackstock joins to explain Jordan’s Principle, federal discrimination, residential schools, government surveillance and accountable reform with host Chief Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Aaron PeteDr. Bloxcock, I'm wondering if you can ground us in what exactly is Jordan's principle?
SPEAKER_03Because he is First Nations, we have the feds and provinces arguing.
Aaron PeteCanada says that more than 10 million products, services, and supports were approved between 2016 and September 2025, and it has renewed Jordan's principle with another 1.55 billion through March 2027. A reasonable Canadian might ask, how can a program of that scale be discriminatory?
SPEAKER_03Discriminatory because what the federal government is doing is they are announcing the money, but they are not necessarily meeting the needs of the children.
Aaron PeteFirst Nations children represented 42.5% of foster children living in private households in 2021 census. People sometimes call contemporary child welfare the new residential school system. Is that comparison factually sound?
SPEAKER_03Well, I think that there are a lot of um a lot of similarities. The similarities is are that children are removed and placed in other homes.
Aaron PeteWhat they all dispute is whether or not there are 215 confirmed graves in the Kamloop's apple orchard outside of the building. And I'm wondering where do you draw that line? Dr. Cindy Blackstock, thank you so much for joining us today. Would you mind briefly introducing yourself for folks who might not be acquainted?
SPEAKER_03Sure. Um I'm delighted to be here, by the way. And uh yeah, I'm uh from the Git Max First Nation up in northern British Columbia. And I grew up on forest ranger stations and lookout towers for those old enough to remember those all over northern BC. Um my work originally was in British Columbia. I was doing child welfare work for the province for about uh about 10 years, and then with the Squamish Nation, and then later with a provincial organization that helped train social workers to work with First Nations maintaining new eat people in BC and did policy work.
SPEAKER_03And that happened until about 2000 when I was asked to work with uh colleagues across the country to create something called the First Nations Child and Family Caring Society. And what we do is we really focus on ensuring that First Nations kids have substantively equal access to health, education, and social supports so that they, you know, have a chance to thrive.
unknownDr.
Aaron PeteBlockstock, I'm wondering if you can ground us in the circumstances facing indigenous children. There are many who listen to this program who have heard about the politics of reconciliation, some of the issues we're running through in regards to DRIPA and the Cowichan decision. And as you might imagine, some of the reconciliation project has become somewhat controversial. But I think what should never become controversial is the well-being of children. No matter who they are, no matter where they come from, that should always be uh a focus that is apolitical and important to all of us.
Aaron PeteCan you just help us understand from your perspective the work you've been doing and what you see on the ground in many First Nation communities?
SPEAKER_03Well, uh, what a lot of people don't know is that the federal government actually funds public services on reserve and in the Yukon. Uh and they do so to a far lesser level than every other uh child gets. And that's been going on since Confederation. So if you're a First Nations child on reserve or in the Yukon, you're getting all the trauma from residential schools piled on top of you. And you're getting less opportunities to deal with it, even with basics like water, uh, lack of funding for a proper school.
SPEAKER_03And so those are the types of, that's the type of unfairness that we have been working to address. And we worked originally with the federal government to document it, come up with solutions that were economically based and evidence-based. Um, we did all that work for a decade, and the federal government never acted, and kids were really being hurt. Like the rates of overrepresentation grew 10 times while we were sitting at that table. So it came to a point where we had to go to the chiefs across Canada and get authority to file a human rights case against Canada.
SPEAKER_03And that case uh took nine years to get to a decision in 2016. Uh, but it found that the government was racially discriminating against kids. And uh since then, we've had to get 35 or north of 30 orders to get try to get the federal government to implement it and stop that behavior.
Aaron PeteWow. And so when you're seeing these children, like I think as a First Nations chief, what I often see is people whose parents are really struggling with their own addictions and with their own history. I think one of the things that doesn't get talked about as much about Indian residential schools is that they were not taught how to be good parents in those schools. And so a lot of cultural teachings, a lot of lessons about just how to be a good parent, how to set a good example, um, how to stay sober, teaching your kids life lessons along the way.
Aaron PeteA lot of that just isn't instilled because the parents are very much recovering from their own experiences. And so you have young people, little children, who don't have a lot of people to look up to and admire and go, okay, my uncle is a dentist and my dad's a doctor, and and my cousin's a lawyer. Like you don't have that same, I can just go ask any of these people. And that's often one of the concerns I've always had about the reserve system specifically, is all of your neighbors are in the same boat as you. And where in the community I live in, like my neighbor is a plumber and the other person's an electrician, and the other person's a lawyer.
Aaron PeteAnd so you like I could go down the block and ask my friends and and neighbors, hey, could you tell my kid how how you got into that? Could you take them for lunch? And we don't have that, and it's even worse if you're in the north or if you're in a remote community, and so you have a lack of potentially positive influences, but then on top of that, you have a lack of funding. And then on top of that, in order to leave your community, you kind of have culture shock because if you're coming from high the nation all the way to Vancouver, it's a very different culture, it's a different pace, there's a different sense of community.
Aaron PeteAnd so there are a lot of things that are intangible that prevent people and children from being able to ever reach their full potential. And that really concerns me. And I wonder how you've seen that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think that that's really true. And also I don't want to leave out our non-Indigenous colleagues who often, um, despite First Nations children getting less and having all the challenges you talk about, um, they're often judged by uh caring Canadians that don't know any better as if they get more. And uh because they don't understand these inequalities. Many people haven't even opened the Indian Act. Like I always say to the general public, just Google the Indian Act, look at the table of contents and see if uh how your family would thrive if that was applied to you.
SPEAKER_03Like try to run a business uh under the Indian Act. What if your will was overridden by the Minister of Indigenous Affairs? What if it was the Minister of Indigenous Affairs that decided if your job was registered Indian or a non-registered Indian, and that's one of the first things you get uh as a baby present? That's the reality of that Indian Act system. So uh, and one of the things I'd always say to folks is yeah, you turn on the TV or you walk into a community and you're gonna see some amazing great things that First Nations Metis and Inuit people are doing, but you're also gonna see the struggles.
SPEAKER_03But don't get hopeless because we've done the work. We have the solutions. All we need is your support to be able to push those across the finish line and make sure that governments actually properly implement them, including getting rid of the Indian Act.
Aaron PeteI'm wondering what some of our listeners have said in the comment section previously, is there's a felt sense that this like while it is true that perhaps per capita children experience less support, broadly, the amount of investments we've seen, both provincially in British Columbia, but in many provinces and federally has been historic spending by the federal government and provincial governments on Indigenous people and on the goal of reconciliation. Um, and I'm just wondering since 2021, since the Unmarked Graves story came out, there's a feeling that a lot has been done and a lot has been spent.
Aaron PeteAnd I'm wondering how you take that criticism, uh, particularly when it comes to this file.
SPEAKER_03Well, I would say that um that's a sign of how unequally these children have been treated uh over the years, is that we, as a country, uh there was a use of uh racial discrimination as fiscal policy. And so why you're seeing such vast amounts of money being invested is because it's to bring those kids up to at least the standard of everybody else and give them a little bit more help so that they can get on the right footing. You know what?
SPEAKER_03All the best investment any government can make is in kids. If you give them good quality, culturally appropriate programs and they're younger, then they're not gonna have to recover from their childhoods as adults. And not only that, you're not gonna have to pay class action lawyers, a big, huge settlement, to for all the harms uh for these children who have been victimized to when that could have been prevented. So all day long, all the research shows you the very best investment is in kids.
SPEAKER_03So when we're looking at how that the big numbers that Canada often talks about or provinces talk about, the next question is how are they structuring that money to make sure it hits on the ground? And that's often where governments fall short, right? There's way too much money going to places uh that government thinks are priorities instead of to actually address the real needs of kids and families on the ground. And we've shown how that can make a difference through Jordan's principle, for example.
Aaron PeteI'm interested in how you reflect on the years of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and what was the gap between your understanding and the federal governments? Because I think I think it's fair to say that Justin Trudeau's legacy, if whatever it ends up being, a part of that story will be his his commitment to reconciliation and to trying to take action to support indigenous people. And so what was the gap between that resulted in this case going to the human rights?
SPEAKER_03I think the like I was actually kind of surprised because in many ways this was a gift to the prime minister, this case. Uh, why I say that is that it'll in December of 2015, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission released its final report. And if you look at the very top call to action, it's child welfare. If you look at number three, it's Jordan's principle, the two things that are central to this case. And the tribunal's decision just follows a month later and it says to the government, you're discriminating against these kids.
SPEAKER_03But that was also a gift of an opportunity to implement fully those reconciliation visions. And we wanted to be financially responsible on the First Nations side. We're the ones that reached out to Kevin Page, the former parliamentary budget officer, and his incredible team, like Dr. Helena Gaspard, to actually cost out what it would be to actually end the discrimination. And how do we structure that money and then measure outcomes for kids to make sure that it's actually improving their lives?
SPEAKER_03We did all of that work, but the government just didn't take it on board. They went back, did some kind of back of the napkin kind of thing, and it's all a piecemeal solution that wasn't evidence-based, that wasn't economically cost to know from what we can see. And um, that's why they've had 35 legal orders against them.
Aaron PeteWhy do you think they did that?
SPEAKER_03I don't know. I when I look back, I've been doing this now for about 30 years, watching the federal government and really trying to get them to stop the discrimination. What I see is a recurring pattern where they know that they're harming the children, and we know this from their own documents, it's not speculation. They have a solution to fix it, and they choose not to do it. And I think that that's what Canadians really need to hone in on forcing the government to actually do the right thing, to do better when they know better.
SPEAKER_03And we're not alone in saying this. Like the auditor general of Canada, repeated auditor generals have said this. Um, parliamentary budget officers have said this, even former ministers have said this. The problem has been to get the government as a machine to actually act on the solutions that are evidence-based that First Nations are putting forward for kids.
Aaron PeteCan I ask? Like, do you think they read your report and go, we don't wanna, we don't actually want to fix that? Like, what is what is the where they're going and going, no, no, no, no, no, I want to go do like I'm just trying to figure out who's who's looking at your report and then going, we'll do the opposite, or we'll do something that isn't evidence. Like, I can't imagine somebody wants to say that out loud and say, we don't want to be evidence-based and we want to spend a lot of money.
SPEAKER_03No, and but the crazy thing is, is uh, and I'm really open to debate on issues, right? Let's let's let's have a debate about and then let's have the best idea rise to the top for kids. I've always said this the federal government if you have a better evidence-based solution, I want to see it because we should adopt it if it's better. But we don't have that type of dialogue with the federal government. It feels like they really want to retain that control.
SPEAKER_03They want to be the ones that come up with a solution. And even when we point to why it's not gonna work, why it's gonna cost Canadians more, and really importantly, why it's unnecessarily gonna continue to cost First Nations children their lives and their childhoods, the Canadian government just doesn't like to be told what to do. But that's exactly what needs to happen. And that's been the only way we made progress, is when the courts have told the federal government, ordered the federal government to take action.
SPEAKER_03Even there, they sometimes turn their mind their their heads away from the courts and do whatever they want to do anyway. That's kind of where we are right now. But at least we can go back to the courts and we may have to consider things like contempt charges.
Aaron PeteWow. What has changed in substance under Prime Minister Mark Carney?
SPEAKER_03Um well, there is at least an economic focus by the federal government, which I would welcome. Uh, what I don't see is a lot of attention to the expense side of the federal government's balance sheet. What I'm saying there is we have a First Nations driven and design solution informed by over a hundred submissions by First Nations to permanently end Canada's discrimination and child welfare. It's called loving justice.
SPEAKER_03It benefits from all that economic public policy stuff, all the experts on children, families, everybody. That is sitting right there as a solution for the prime minister to activate. And instead, the federal government is choosing its own plan that was informed only by itself. They have no experts in child and family services. The public finance costing is very selective, if it exists at all. And it's gonna reproduce the discrimination that's already cost the federal government 23.4 billion in class action money alone.
SPEAKER_03Like you think cutting a check for 23.4 billion would be, oh, I'm not gonna do that again. I'm not gonna just, you know, let my officials go and write up some kind of back-of-the-napping solution for First Nations kids. But no, that's exactly what they're doing. And I'd like to see the prime minister really ensure that there is good economically costed out and effective measures being taken by for by the Department of Indigenous Services, because I'm just not seeing that.
Aaron PeteFor Canadians who recognize the name but not the policy, what exactly is Jordan's principle? What happened to Jordan River Anderson? And what does a failure of the principle look like?
SPEAKER_03Well, first of all, it's a sacred law. And uh, you know, whenever we name something in uh by a child, then we have to we have to ask more of ourselves. And it's also a legal right. So what happened to Little Jordan is while we were beavering away writing some of these reports with Canada, showing how um the federal government not only giving less to First Nations children who are in need, uh, but also buck passing with uh with other parts of the federal government and also with provinces, how that was actually uh creating a real hardship for little Jordan.
SPEAKER_03He was in the hospital for two years. Uh his pediatrician um said, Great, you know, he's making progress, he can go home at roughly the age of two. But he needed some in-home supports. And if he was non-indigenous, he would have gotten those supports and gone home at a far cheaper rate for the average taxpayer, by the way. Keeping a child in hospital is not inexpensive. But instead of just doing the right thing, the federal government argued about every little thing that that little child needed.
SPEAKER_03He ended up spending Aaron over two and a half years in that hospital, just because he was a First Nations child. And because he was First Nations, we had the feds and provinces arguing over who should pay. Until his sister Jurlene Sullivan said he eventually died of a broken heart. He um went uh into a coma and died at the age of five, never having left that uh hospital. And I went to his memorial in his community of Norway House Crenation.
SPEAKER_03And uh, if anyone's ever had the privilege of flying from Winnipeg over to Norway House, you see all these beautiful lakes out the windows, right? And I was looking at the lakes on my way to the memorial, and I just tears came to my eyes. I thought, that little boy never saw this, right? Just because of who he was. So in his memory, the family, his father, Ernest Anderson, and the entire family created Jordan's principle, which is very simple. It says we're uh First Nations children should have substantively equal access to the health, education, and social supports that they need when they need them.
SPEAKER_03And the safeguard is it's professionals who are going to save who they need them. It's not a free-for-all with anybody saying, I want this, I want this. It's actually, you know, you have a social worker working with the family, a teacher, a doctor, a nurse, a practitioner, whatever, um, or a culture, or an elder knowledge keeper who says this child means this cultural intervention. And the federal government, by law now, thanks to the tribunal rulings, has to honor that.
SPEAKER_03But it has not been honoring it recently. It has been rolling back Jordan's principle. And in doing so, brings a great indignity to Jordan and a great sadness to many of us who loved him.
Aaron PeteMay I ask, I served as a native courtworker for about five years and worked with many First Nations people and Metis and Inuit through the criminal justice system. But one of my common reflections was that I believe that we should just have systems built for the most vulnerable 10%. It does, it shouldn't be just the native courtworker program for indigenous people. We could create a court worker program to serve anybody who's ineligible for services and programs and who's behind the APL.
Aaron PeteRight now, it's indigenous people in many of these files: criminal justice, education, addictions, mental health, um, housing, homelessness, poverty. But my my dream, my aspiration, my hope is that that one day isn't the case. And across all of these files, we're not in the bottom 10%. We're not struggling with all of these issues the same way. But whoever group, category, individual is in that most vulnerable 10% should receive those supports. Is there a way from your perspective to expand Jordan's principle so that it makes sure that all children across Canada deserve those supports rather than just Indigenous people over the long term?
SPEAKER_03Right. Um, well, we'd have to talk to the family about that, but I I I can tell you that I've had some discussions with them and and they really they love all children. They want to see all children benefit by that. I it would I think it would be a great thing to see all children who are caught in these types of situations to have the benefit of Jordan's principle. It's been recognized as a good practice internationally, Jordan's principle. Um, you know, and it And again, I come back to it. It did make sense economically, because for every dollar you spend on a child, you're going to save 15 download stream on the government.
SPEAKER_03If you spend a dollar on someone my age, that's not going to be the same thing, right? You're not going to get that payoff. So it makes sense economically. It definitely makes sense morally, right?
Aaron PeteUh so I would I would I would challenge the last piece because I think elders like yourself, people who are knowledge keepers like yourself, uh, we underestimate their importance in passing on their wisdom and expertise to the next generation. And we and one of my biggest critiques of the West generally is during COVID, they did not take care of their elders. No, they didn't. They did not create a space where that knowledge transfer was taking place. And it's one of the biggest errors, I think, that the West makes is you just ship people off to seniors' homes and you visit them once a year and you miss out on so much lived experience, so much knowledge about how to face Great Depressions, global anxiety, stress, like all of those things are so important.
Aaron PeteAnd I think we miss out sometimes and we forget how important it is to speak to people who have a lived experience over a vast number of years because that helps us look at the challenges we're facing as less terrifying than they are and help give us knowledge on how to approach those.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, like I mean, um I've seen so many wonderful things around the world and across Canada that First Nations have done. And uh in Australia, for example, there is a uh something called the Victoria Aboriginal Child Care Agency, BACA, by headed by the amazing Muriel Bamblatt. And what she did is she started to notice that the children that were coming to the attention of her agency for child welfare, they weren't uh the eld they weren't able to connect with elders because the elders are being moved out of their communities because there's no aged care.
SPEAKER_03So she got into the aged care business and does uh support for elders in their house so that they can be there for the grandchildren and other people's children, and as well as created an aged care facility that allows for children to stay, right? These are practical solutions. And I just want to put a shout out to many First Nations who actually are out there helping their neighbors who are in those vulnerable situations. I can tell you, I go across the country and there are so many uh First Nations programs that are very holistic.
SPEAKER_03And many people from different cultures who also share that worldview find much more kinship and comfort in receiving services there. And um, you know, First Nations, if there's any way they can pull it off, they will uh they will be there for their neighbors.
Aaron PeteUh so Canada says that more than 10 million products, services, and supports were approved between 2016 and September 2025. And it has renewed Jordan's principle with another 1.55 billion through March 2027. A reasonable Canadian might ask, how can a program of that scale be discriminatory?
SPEAKER_03Well, it's being discriminatory because what the federal government is doing is they are announcing the money, but they are not necessarily meeting the needs of the children. So what we've seen is, for example, they announced a bulletin last February where they said for all children off reserves, and I just want to say for folks watching, most First Nations children live off reserve. So they said all those children off reserve are actually not eligible for a whole hu list of laundry list of help under Jordan's principle, unless substantive equality applies.
SPEAKER_03And then behind the scenes, they actually ripped up the definition of substantive equality and had no definition. That's the kind of game playing we're seeing. And it's a real injustice to kids, right? Because Jordan's principle has saved kids going into child offer care. It has been life-changing for kids. Uh, let me just give you two examples. Real life examples. When Canada was implementing Jordan's principle properly, our office got a phone call from a young guy.
SPEAKER_03And he was so excited because he's on his way to university. But he told us that he was going to drop out of high school because he just didn't think he could cut it until through Jordan's principle, he had a learning assessment and just realized he learned in a different way. And that was a total turning point. And the kid just did really well in high school and is now off to university. That's what happens when they do it well. When they breach the legal orders, the second story happens.
SPEAKER_03We got um a let a family received a letter uh from the government saying that they have finally, after a year and a half, it should have happened within uh 12 hours, but it within a year and a half later, they approved the mental health services that that young man's circle of care said he needed urgently. But sadly, it came six months too late. That young person passed away, uh, died from suicide. That's when they breached the orders.
SPEAKER_03So, like it really is life or death. We need to look by uh through the speaking points and PR points of the government and look at what they're really doing for kids.
Aaron PeteThe human rights tribunal said requests such as modeling headshots and gaming consoles were not what Jordan's principal originally envisioned and and found that some supposedly urgent files appeared misclassified. What should Jordan's principle not pay for?
SPEAKER_03Okay. So on that, um, we were puzzled by that because that was came from the federal government. And we said, well, then don't approve those things. Uh it it's not a carte blanche that the federal government has to approve every request that comes forward. There are clear criteria, like you need to have a professional letter behind that. That's a safeguard, right? Uh that there needs to be, um it needs to be reasonably linked to a child's needs, not just a child's wants, right?
SPEAKER_03Like all these things are there. And then what we saw was that the federal government wasn't requiring the professional letters, and they were approving these things. They actually approved that. And then they complained that they approved it. Well, I'm saying, well, don't, you know, fix your administration of Jordan's principal, right?
Aaron PeteThat's wild. Internal records indicate that the value of denied Jordan's principal requests rose from roughly 217 million to 491 million uh in 2024-25. Canada says it reduced the urgent backlog, while your 2026 July submission argues that the public cannot tell whether files were approved, denied, downgraded, or simply closed. What exactly is happening on the ground?
SPEAKER_03Oh boy. So um remember I told you about that bulletin with that substantive equality. Well, what substantive equality is just for your listeners? I know you know that with your legal background, but it's um the best quote I've had is from a U.S. Supreme Court justice in the 1955, Justice Frankfurter, who said there's no greater inequality than the equal treatment of unequals. So when you have children who have had with carry more burdens, uh residential school, unequal services, all the rest of that stuff, then they're gonna need a little bit more help to get achieve the same outcomes, right?
SPEAKER_03That's that's substantive equality. So it's a bedrock principle of Jordan's principle. And when the federal government behind the scenes ripped up the definition of substantive equality, they then uh put out a claim, well, all the urgent backlog is gone now. Well, how did they make any des and and then on top of that, we said, Well, how can you do that when you have no definition? And then, second of all, where is your decision making process? Right? And they said, We don't have one.
SPEAKER_03They have no decision making process and guidelines. And what they said in their in reply when we said, Well, how can you possibly implement a program without definitions and without any kind of decision-making process? They said, Well, children are unique. And I thought, well, so are people who've uh come to the border every day with different stories. But that doesn't mean it's a free-for-all for decision making. And how can the public have any confidence that you're doing the job right when it's all this smoke and mirrors?
SPEAKER_03So uh that's that's what we're trying to fix at the tribunal right now. That's why we've got live action on Jordan's principle.
Aaron PeteWow. At 21, you became a provincial child protection worker. You later said that you would remove children, believing there must be something better. Yeah. Only to discover that the system often had nothing better to offer. Is there a decision or a child you still revisit in rethinking that chapter of your life?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, there are. I I not only just uh removals that I did, but also removals that others did. And um, it wasn't just the social worker making the decision. It was just that you didn't have the tools to do it. I often say that child welfare is not really the major problem. It's poverty, poor housing, the trauma from residential schools that people didn't get help for, uh, the survivors, and all those parenting skills, the lack of the parenting stuff didn't get addressed early on.
SPEAKER_03Uh, domestic violence and substance misuse that flows with those uh mental that those are the fires that breed the overrepresentation. And they're the same fires that hold children down from succeeding in the same way in school and also fuel them going into juvenile justice and having poor health outcomes. So when uh when I look back when I was 21, I think about some of the kids who came to us and they were like their parents are just fresh out of residential schools, right?
SPEAKER_03Last one didn't close until 1996. A lot of people don't uh don't uh understand that, right? So when I was doing child welfare, it was right in that period when they were still running or they were just closed. And their parents getting access to parental mental health supports wasn't available, right? So you end up with this definition of neglect in child welfare law that says uh neglect is when uh you don't meet the basic needs of the child and the parent is unable or unwilling.
SPEAKER_03Well, with some of these parents, neither was true. The service didn't exist, right? They were given a chance to choose. They were they would have taken the support had it been available, but it wasn't, and that's why their children went into care. And then when you get into care doing child welfare, that that piece I remember is we had to do all kinds of risk assessments on the parents, right? But we didn't have a to do a risk assessment on what we had to provide on our side, and I and as you got better uh more experience in doing child protection, that's what you do.
SPEAKER_03You would look at what you is what you have to provide really any better, not just for tonight, but over the long run. And I'm not an idealist. I think some of our kids probably do need to be in child walker care, but not at the root 17 times the rate of everybody else.
Aaron PeteThat that leads me into another question, and I think you're a good person to ask, because I avoid child and families like the plague, because it's just riddled and like kudos to you and people who go into that field, because it is like I worked in criminal justice and I'd see the family lawyers and how hard that work is on everybody involved. Like, nobody walks away from a jurisdiction issue or a divorce proceeding and walks away clean. Everybody gets hurt in the long run of that.
Aaron PeteAnd I just I have trouble watching it. I have trouble thinking about how that shapes the child. I mean, between you and I, like I'm I'm working within my community to try and address sexual abuse of children. Yeah. And the pushback that I get from some people shocked, broke my heart to know that there were people who didn't want me to dig, who didn't want me to go through these things, who said, you don't want anybody innocent to get called out. And it's like, well, of course, but if somebody gets called out who's innocent and we catch 10 predators, I can live with that ratio with a great night's sleep on my hands.
Aaron PeteBut one of the things that I do see, and I wonder how you think about it, because you mentioned you're practical. You mentioned you're willing to debate your ideas with the federal government. You seem very grounded in the reality of the circumstances. But I would say that I find your profession, the area of social work, invites in a lot of left-leaning people to the point where within my community, we've run into issues where social workers are trying to usurp chief and counsel to do what they think they want to do. One example is they tried to convince a family to move into an abandoned house because they could they could get cheaper housing there.
Aaron PeteAnd we said that house is not available, and they tried to work with a community to try and break the locks and move the family in. And we were like, What are you, what are you doing to us? Like, we're here to support, we're here trying to help, but you can't approach us this way. And I find that sometimes they're they're so sympathetic to victimhood that sometimes they don't realize that to your point, sometimes the best thing is for a child to be in care. And that's not my preference, that's nobody's preference, but you have to look at the realities.
Aaron PeteAnd I wonder, I'm sure you've run into people who are even more extreme on that side of like no child should be in care no matter what. How do you navigate those tough conversations where their heart is, of course, in the right place? They're trying to support children, but they're going about it in perhaps the wrong way.
SPEAKER_03Well, I think that one of the things that we see in child welfare is so much burnout. So there are very few people who actually stay around a while. Um, it is actually, you know, and this is kudos to the folks working in First Nations child welfare agencies. The turnover is much less. You're gonna find people there who've been doing it for 20, 30, 40 years. And they know all the extended families. They've got their feet on the ground, they're centered in what's happening. And they're having those hard conversations you're talking about, about sexual abuse and physical abuse and how we need to hold ourselves accountable.
SPEAKER_03You know, Terry Cross said it really well. He said, self-government is when you embrace what hurts. You know, when we're having those conversations with each uh about ourselves and how to hold ourselves to a standard for our that our kids are safe, and and that is really self-government. So that's really important to know. Uh, in terms of my colleagues, oh, I have colleagues all over the map, right? I mean, I have a I am one of the people who would often critique social work, right, as a profession.
SPEAKER_03Because I think that we really have largely abandoned the social justice part of it, which is going after those baseline problems that are feeding so much uh so much harm for families, right? Let's get at the real causes. And then if we do that, we'll make things a lot better. And we have to be realistic. Someone has to be there for that child. One of my great mentors, Elsie Bledov, he says, you know, we have to be there for that child. We have to show them someone cares, right?
SPEAKER_03And so, and uh, and um, you know, uh, I'm gonna throw out Mary Tee Gee's teaching from her mom, Sarah T. Who said, you don't need laws from for children. They've done nothing wrong. What we need are laws for adults. And I've knocked and believed that. Both professional adults, but also people in the communities and uh neighbors.
Aaron PeteThe privacy commissioner found that the federal government's wrongfully collected information from your personal Facebook page. Separately, the tribunal found that Canada retaliated against the caring society by excluding you from a meeting. What did that teach you about how government power behaves when it is challenged?
SPEAKER_03Well, I that was at a time when they didn't want to talk about the real facts about what was happening to the children because of their conduct. And so um, we know in those documents that I have and that the privacy commissioner and the tribunal both um looked at when they came to their conclusions. There's actually an email in there by a person who said, the reason we're doing this is to try and find priviless and vexatious grounds to get the case dismissed. And that often happens to us as First Nations Metal peoples when you're challenging the government.
SPEAKER_03And in my case, I was using the the courts to do it, a legitimate, peaceful, legal process to hold the government accountable. Um they saw that they were losing that process. And so the only other way is to get rid of me, to try and discredit me and therefore discredit the movement. Um so the documents show that they were following me around. Like uh they would be, they would be following my personal movements. Um, they would note when I was not at some place and when I was at certain places.
SPEAKER_03Um, they would collect information from my Facebook page, not just things that I posted, but things that other people posted. And then they would take their URLs and they would go on to their pages. So this was like a spider's web. And uh there was over 189 bureaucrats involved in this, right? My whole reaction to this thing was you're spending this kind of money following me, a social worker? I don't even have a parking ticket, right? Like you should be spending this money fixing the problems for children, and then you wouldn't have to worry about this case, right?
SPEAKER_03But that is but that has been the instinct, and I will say to you, I can share with you with you right now, is the federal government, after all those legal findings, was asked to sign an undertaking to say they stopped the surveillance against me, and they refused. So um, just even uh about a year ago, I filed another privacy request to try and get documents about me, the department had. They did not uh deliver those documents as the law requires. And so just uh this week I had to file a judicial review to try and get those documents to find out if that surveillance, in fact, is still happening or if they actually are acting in a legitimate way.
SPEAKER_03So um I have no assurance that it's not ongoing.
Aaron PeteThat's wild. First Nations children represented 42.5% of foster children living in private households in 2021 census. People sometimes call contemporary child welfare the new residential school system. Is that comparison factually sound?
SPEAKER_03Well, I think that there are a lot of um a lot of similarities. The similarities is are that children are removed and placed in other homes. Where we have some gains is where there's a uh indigenous child welfare agency. We know from uh a series of reports that they're far more likely to be able to keep that child in their their extended family, their community, or at least with people that they know.
SPEAKER_03Off reserve, where 72% of all First Nations children in care live, off reserve that they receive services largely from the provincial governments, their the placement rates are not as encouraging. Why? Number one, they're not as good at working with community uh to support our families so that they can take in an additional child. They don't have those relationships or that culturally appropriate approach.
SPEAKER_03Number two, um, there is some real issues with the um with the standards that they will sometimes apply. Um, I'm not saying lower the standards for First Nations kids, far from it. Uh, I think we need to have good standards, but we have to support people in being able to achieve those standards, i.e., you know, and differentiate between what is a safety standard versus just the way we live, right? Like I had to share a room with my sister all the time we were growing up.
SPEAKER_03Uh, but under some child buffer regimes, uh, that's not permitted if a child's in foster care. So, you know, we all want to do our due diligence, but we have to be realistic too. And it's really for those off-reserve kids that I'm the most concerned.
Aaron PeteAfter 14 years on this case, tribunal member Edward Lustig resigned in July and said that parties on both sides seemed incapable of reasonable compromise. Is he right about your side?
SPEAKER_03Well, uh, what I can say is I can stack the number of letters we've written to the minister asking to sit down and actually talk about what Canada's plan is, what we've to have in loving justice and find common ground. The government's response so far is they refuse to do it. They won't even sit down with us. And more importantly, than you know, I mean the Caring Society, along with the Assembly of First Nations, are the two that brought the case, but there is a group called the National Children's Chiefs Commission.
SPEAKER_03Um, this is a group appointed by leadership outside of Ontario to oversee First Nations reform. It was appointed by the all the chiefs across Canada. They do incredible work, uh, chaired by uh Chief Pauline Frost. They have written to Canada. They were a key part of creating Loving Justice. They wrote to Canada to say, let's sit down and get some common ground. And they won't even respond to their letters. So I don't know. Like uh, you know, you there's only we can bring the horse to water, but whether they'll drink, they're not drinking.
SPEAKER_03They're um they're just wanting to proceed uh with their own plan. So I'm not sure how to break through on that.
Aaron PeteOutside Ontario, Canada proposes approximately$27 billion over seven years, followed by$4.4 billion annually. Your loving justice plan calls for First Nations-led governance, needs-based funding, independent enforcement, and continuing tribunal oversight. In plain language, what is the single defect that makes Canada's plan unacceptable?
SPEAKER_03Because Canada's plan won't solve the discrimination. Therefore, it's going to create higher costs for kids. They're going to continue to lose their childhoods, and Canada's going to be cutting another check for um uh class action lawyers. We're not saying that the amount of money is uh the major issue. Um under the Loving Justice Plan, it's in the same ballpark. What we've done is actually build in accountability measures and use evidence to ensure it actually hits the needs of children on the ground.
SPEAKER_03Canada is the formula, like just some bureaucrats got together very well meaning, I'm sure, just as others have been in the past, but it's it's not not hooked to need at all. Or the capacity of the nation to deliver the services.
Aaron PeteThat's one of my biggest concerns whenever First Nations want to take over and self-govern. It's not a bad thing to want to do that, but I think you need to do so very judiciously and very mindfully of the risks. And when we look at certain files where First Nations were eager to take on authority, and then there were there's a lack of recourse for families to get proper appeal processes and resources and recourse. I wonder how do you find that balance between the right to self-government while also making sure that people have the opportunity to be treated fairly?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, that's a big difference between that Canada's plan and the loving justice plan is uh we actually uh and keep in mind the loving justice plan was created by First Nations, including leadership. And what they said is there needs to be a dedicated capacity building stream so that you actually have funds to be able to go out there and do consultation with community, with experts, develop programs, recruit and train staff, be ready to on day one to be able to um service those kids.
SPEAKER_03But that takes time, takes some resources. Canada's plan, there is no capacity building stream. They will cut you the check and expect you to deliver the services. And their answer is to say, well, every child gets about$2,600 per capita for prevention services to keep them out of child welfare care. And if you're one of these communities that doesn't have capacity, well, you just take some of those kids' money. Well, what is that gonna create? Communities with high capacity are gonna be able to give their kids the full amount, but communities with lower capacity are gonna have to take money away from their kids to be able to build up the capacity to deliver the services.
SPEAKER_03And then what happens to the kids in the meantime? That's the kind of lack of thinking and clarity that we see from the federal government's plan.
Aaron PeteYou have connected continuing noncompliance with residential school denialism. One difficulty from my perspective is that denialism can encompass both rejection of the documented residential school system and really, to me, good faith questions about particular claims that are being made about Camloops and the unmarked graves uh claimed to be there. Um Camloops has come forward about a month and a half after and said, these are anomalies. We have not confirmed the burials of 215 children in this location, although the reports by the CBC, um, the New York Times, and others purported that there were confirmed bodies.
Aaron PeteAnd I've had Francis Widowson, um Tim Thielman, Candace Melcom who helped compile the book Grave Error, and none of them dispute the real harms that took place in residential schools, that people died for a lot of causes, including abuse. What they all dispute is whether or not there are 215 confirmed graves in the Kamloops apple orchard outside of the building. And I'm wondering, where do you draw that line?
SPEAKER_03Well, I think questions are fine. Um uh, but also uh accusations uh without a lot of information are a real problem. And uh I find people are very quick to rush to judgment without actually having uh the facts behind you and having done the good work. Like I uh one of my things uh uh is I work with uh the family of Dr. Keir Henderson Bryce.
SPEAKER_03And I don't know if you've had a chance to kind of look at some of his early work, but he used to be the chief medical health officer of the Indian Department, right?
Aaron PeteYeah, he wrote a book and he had to come out because of the um the government did not want to take his claim seriously. So he had to leave in order to have that report published.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, he was basically pushed out, right? And he was finding children were dying at a rate of roughly uh, you know, 25% a year. And if you mapped them over three years, 50% a year, right? Unnecessarily. He called it uh a national crime, is the title of his pamphlet in 1922. Headlines across the country, right? Um, where I find this kind of critique from uh folks like uh Mrs. Willison and others, uh, really deficient is that they're making the central question about are there bones in the ground instead of the more substantive question, which is we know even from archival evidence, such as from Dr.
SPEAKER_03Prager Henderson Bryce, that the thousands of children died unnecessarily. Those are just the ones that died from preventable causes of disease. But you add on to that the ones that die from maltreatment, etc.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_03What have we learned from that as a country and how has that changed our behavior?
Aaron PeteBut she acknowledges that. That's like I interviewed her, she acknowledges Bryce's report. I think she has some, she believes that the government did in response to him coming out, did more than often gets commented on. But she doesn't dispute any of that. And she commented that what the Soviet Union did by sending priests into community to go live with community rather than having children removed from community was likely a better option, um, all things considered, than what Canada ended up doing. And like if you were to put the two up against each other, what the Canada did was worse.
Aaron PeteAnd she gets labeled a denialist for talking about the Kamloops issue, but she's not denying, I think, the former.
SPEAKER_03Well, I'm happy that she's not denying Dr. Peter Henderson's work because it wasn't just Dr. Bryce, who was, by the way, the the um, he was the uh president of the American Public Health Association and the author of the Ontario Health Code uh that has been mapped on to provinces like uh across the country and U.S. states. So this was a guy who was top of his profession, but even he had the humility of bringing others along with him, right? Uh other physicians to be able to validate his his claims.
SPEAKER_03Um I have a problem when we have people who are so dogmatic and that they're not able to think about what is what is the good, the good public end that I'm contributing to through my conduct and my behavior and the way that I'm positioning myself, either uh intentionally or unintentionally. What am I doing that's in the public good? And so for us uh at the Caring Society, for me personally, one of the things I've really tried to do throughout my life is to spend more time trying to do right than being right.
SPEAKER_03I I will intentionally uh surround myself with questions. When I'm running something, I'm actually challenging myself it uh as many ways as I possibly can to see if there's actually something I'm missing, something that maybe that uh, because we all have biases, right? Uh something that I'm just picking up on more instinctually. I really want to do the right thing for uh for the kids. And that's why I really invite critique, I invite hard questions.
SPEAKER_03What I don't invite, and which I have very little tolerance for, is people who make very strong dogmatic uh things that are uh where they're not doing that, where they're not having the humility that comes with uh trying to deal with a do right versus be right.
Aaron PeteIn closing, what gives you hope about the work that you're doing? Are there trends that give you a lot of optimism about where you're heading as we reflect for National Truth and Reconciliation Day? What's what's inspiring you and any thoughts on what Canadians can start to do to support your work?
SPEAKER_03Oh my god, it's the kids who inspire me. Um, you know, one thing I'll say is like I grew up in the 1960s. And uh, you know, that's a time uh we it was only in the 1960s that First Nations were really uh recognized as being people and being able to go off to university. Uh so I now see people like yourself that has a law degree and people who are doctors and uh you know, all kinds of fields that can inspire children. But what I've why it really, really is close to my heart is I've seen when children are trusted with the truth of all diversities, I mean, about all of the injustices that have happened to First Nations children and equipped with peaceful and respectful ways that they, as children and as citizens, can help make a difference, they do.
SPEAKER_03Uh in our particular case, um, children filled the courtrooms. They there were so many children coming to the hearings that we would have to book them in in shifts. And we said to the children, we want you to be like newspaper reporters. Don't just believe stuff because someone tells you. Go and listen to all the different sides of it. Go home and do some research or in your classroom and ask the questions and and then come up with your own mind about what what you think is uh is right, what is happening here.
SPEAKER_03And if you don't think it's right, then write to the prime minister because that's a person who can make a change here, right? Children can write to the prime minister and um you know, and then if a new piece of information comes up, then you say, Hey, there's something I didn't know before. Does that change the way that I feel? What I have found is that children really can see injustices. The rest of us have been bathed into them and we normalize them too often and we don't see them anymore.
SPEAKER_03Like I always say, think of the Indian status card. I actually am a registered Indian. But I haven't renewed my card since 2003 and I refuse to do so because I absolutely reject the concept that the government of Canada has any jurisdiction over the identity of First Nations kids. So it's that kind of stuff that gets normalized and even made benevolent that we have to challenge. But children, they can see it right away. What? You get a card because you're the government that says whether or not you're an Indian?
SPEAKER_03They don't give that to me, and our family is Francophone or our family is Hindi or our family is whatever, right? Uh, so they can see that differential treatment. We just got to trust them as adults with the truth. How can show them what love and compassion and courage looks like?
Aaron PeteBeautiful. How can people connect with your work?
SPEAKER_03Well, they can go onto our website, fncaringsociety.com. We have a whole pile of stories called the Spirit Bear books and films done by the great indigenous filmmaker Amanda Strong and her production company that tell the true stories of how children of all diversities joined with First Nations children to do to make the gains on Jordan's principle, to fill those courtrooms at the tribunal, to uh learn from the past and the removal of monuments.
SPEAKER_03So, what does that mean for uh all the lessons we need to learn? They're all free. They're in French, they're in English, and they're in First Nations languages. So go and check that out.
Aaron PeteThank you so much for doing this and for sharing your time and for your long career advocating for, I think, a very healthy middle ground to make sure that all young people reach their full potential and are given the opportunity to share their gifts, their unique ideas, their spirit, their heart, their energy with the world. We need more of that. And as I said, I think this needs to stay an apolitical issue where we just recognize our country, our province, our cities, our communities are richer when our children reach their full potential and show us what they're capable of.
Aaron PeteSo thank you for your work on this.
SPEAKER_03Oh, well, thank you very much. And I couldn't agree more. I uh I just think that uh if we can really pull this off by implementing these solutions, we can raise a generation of First Nations Metin Indian children never have to recover from their childhoods, and a generation of non Indigenous children who grow up to be their friends in justice.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...