266. Jack Mintz: Canada vs. Trump — Trade War Explained by Economist
1 hr 8 minAudio
Economist Jack Mintz explains how Trump’s trade war and Mark Carney’s negotiations are reshaping Canada’s economic strategy, including tariffs, corporate taxes and inequality, with host Chief Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Aaron PeteCan Canada survive Trump's trade war?
SPEAKER_01Do actually have a fear that uh we don't know what the end game we want out of this.
Aaron PeteWhen you look at our previous election and the platform Prime Minister Mark Kearney ran on, how do you think he's performing as a negotiator with the US?
SPEAKER_01So far, we the results have not been very good. And and so whatever strategy Ken is following, it's not working at all. In fact, it's things are just getting worse with even higher and higher tariffs being put on us.
Aaron PeteWhy should workers trust another corporate tax cut?
SPEAKER_01I think one of the great values of dropping the corporate tax is that everybody benefits. And we're not picking which sectors are going to win. All the sectors benefit.
Aaron PeteWhat are your thoughts on do we tax the rich? How do we address the income inequality we're seeing in Canada?
SPEAKER_01The idea that somehow the rich are getting away without paying taxes is not true. In fact, the rich do pay a lot of taxes.
Aaron PeteDo you think it was a good idea for the Canadians to walk away from the negotiation table? Dr. Mintz, thank you so much for being willing to join us today. Would you mind briefly introducing yourself for people who might not be acquainted with your work?
SPEAKER_01Okay, well, thank you very much, uh Erin. It's a pleasure to be with you today. Uh I'm uh Jack Mintz. I'm um uh still President's Fellow uh School of Public Policy at the University of Calvary, uh, although I currently live in Toronto most of the time uh these days, this is how one does things. Uh and I've had a uh very long career, uh basically an academic all my life, but also have done other things. So it's been a uh a bit of a different type of a career than most people have had in my field.
Aaron PeteTremendous. Uh my first question is bold. Can Canada survive Trump's trade war?
SPEAKER_01Oh, I think so. I mean, Canada, you know, countries uh have had uh you know tariffs in the past and and things like that. I think we get a little bit too excited uh over these things and forgetting that, you know, one time they were tariffs uh in the past, and you know, it we still saw economic development and and everything uh like that. However, there was no question that uh, you know, once we went into the Canada U.S. Free Trade Agreement in uh 1988 and then later on NAFTA in 1994, that we got access to the U.S.
SPEAKER_01economy, allowed a lot of our companies to achieve uh economies of scale, you know, cheaper uh uh production, uh, because they could have a much bigger market to service. And of course, you know, the world changes a lot. You know, 1988, you know, we're talking about almost uh well, almost 40 years ago, 45 years ago. So it's uh, you know, the world has also changed a lot, and and we have different kinds of businesses today than we would have thought about uh back in in the 1980s.
Aaron PeteHow does this impact Canadian standard of living? This is one of my primary concerns. What what do you think that's gonna look like if this continues?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think the tariffs you know do have a negative impact. Uh it's a negative impact for for everybody. You know, I'm I'm uh I am a believer in the value of uh free trade. Unfortunately, I think the world is shifting away from that. Uh, we're getting a much more nationalistic world than we've seen uh years ago. And we have to remember the 1980s was the time of you know the Reagan Revolution and the Thatcher Revolution in the UK. And you know, at that time many countries believed in trying to open up their markets uh and try to get uh more free trade.
SPEAKER_01Um we also uh we also seen at that time uh deregulation and tax reforms taking place, including in this country. Uh, and so there was a whole uh package of what you might call liberal type economics, uh, more a shift more to the free market than we had seen uh previously. And uh and so so that was a very uh different time today, uh especially uh starting uh in my view after the financial crisis in 2008-9, uh, we started seeing a very different kind of world world develop, uh, where governments uh uh have taken on a bigger role in the economy.
SPEAKER_01Uh the idea of governments getting out of the way has now become governments should be in the way, uh, and industrial policy is in vogue now. Uh the idea of having tariffs has now, you know, become more and more common across countries. Uh and so we've had uh these kinds of changes that I think have happened that are uh that are a bit unfortunate, I think, in in terms of the way the world is evolving, but this is not the first time we've seen these kinds of cycles. Uh I've been reading a lot of things lately that's kind of interesting, but uh it's a book by uh by a very good historian uh at Yale, uh his last name is Westad.
SPEAKER_01Um, and uh he's sort of drawing a parallel between now uh what we're seeing around the world uh to uh the late 1980s, uh which we have to remember uh led to eventually the First World War. Not a very pretty picture, to be honest, uh, or and one and one that's very concerning, if this is the kind of direction that we're now going into in the in the coming number of years.
Aaron PeteI guess one of my concerns, to be honest with you, is that while it may impact all Canadians, it will impact Canadians very differently. And I don't know if you saw uh Premier Doug Ford's comments uh saying that he has a lot of real estate uh and that Donald Trump can kiss his ass. Um I think that plays well with uh like his his numbers went up after some polling in response to that. But my fear is that of course Premier Doug Ford, Mark Carney, they're not going to feel the very real impact of this trade war the same way a single mother is going to feel who lives in poverty trying to raise her family.
Aaron PeteAnd I just felt like that was a bit tone-deaf from my personal perspective because it's not reading the like if we are going down this path, the ramifications, we're already our economy's not in great shape. And so we're going, we don't know how long this is gonna go. Marcani chose to bring back our uh team back from the US, and that's gonna have implications for very vulnerable people. And I often don't see, like I understand Marcani's come out and said, we're gonna do things to support uh people through this and businesses, but rarely, uh, Mr.
Aaron PeteMince, have I seen that really impact vulnerable populations, people in real poverty, uh, whenever government comes out with supports. What are your thoughts on how we make sure we support those most vulnerable?
SPEAKER_01Um, you know, first of all, we we have really had a bad decade coming into this uh trade war. Um, you know, uh economic growth has not been particularly good. In fact, we've been one of the slowest growing OECD countries, not negative. I mean, it hasn't been a recession, although, you know, the pandemic was a very tough time for a number of people. But the trade war is gonna hurt our growth. I mean, it's not gonna be devastating. I mean, it's not gonna cause a depression, in my view, in terms of what's happening right now.
SPEAKER_01But pockets of the economy are gonna be hurt. And I think Ontario is the one uh and Quebec that I think are gonna take the biggest brunt. Uh, and that's because uh the United States, uh, and there's various objectives that they have. I know you know it's pretty easy to, you know, to uh you know criticize Trump and everything else, but if you go back, what are the three major objectives they had? I think it's very important to understand what your opponent is trying to do. And and uh one part of it has been uh to uh reindustrialize the heartland of the United States.
SPEAKER_01And and of course, you know, Canada has not been the problem. And that's the part that I think we probably resent most is we're getting uh you know pushed hard now by uh by the US, especially for the auto sector uh and other parts of manufacturing, such as the steel industry, aluminum, etc. Um, but um, but that has been the objective, and and a big part of that has been China uh in terms of what it has done internationally, where it's used its uh subsidies and its developing status when it came in to the World Trade Organization that's been able to, in a sense, use their status at that time to grow very quickly.
SPEAKER_01And they've overinvested in capacity uh in order to uh you know really grab large parts of the world market share. And that has been a you know, uh that has been something which at first everybody thought was great. We're seeing this wonder, you know, uh reduction in world inequality as a result because of the huge growth that happened in Nation and particularly China. Uh, but of course now we're we're finding that pockets are are really hurt. And so this trade war, which uh Trump is now using, uh, and we're now getting particularly hit, I think, in the manufacturing sector, is gonna is going to be very bad for Ontario.
SPEAKER_01And of course, there are going to be people that are going to be hurt. You know, you you look at the auto sector, for example, you could have, you know, people who have been, you know, have had good jobs, relatively good paying jobs, and then all of a sudden they're not going to have a job anymore. Um, in fact, we've already seen a loss of jobs uh in Ontario and in Quebec uh as a result of uh of the trade war. And this this is very, you know, uh very difficult for people that all of a sudden, you know, they have families and uh and everything else. And and and I can understand in a way, uh, you know, the Premier of Ontario being very upset, uh, you know, if he if he's really thinking about, uh I'm sure he is a bit like this, uh, if if he if he sees that, you know, there's going to be people really hurt uh as a result.
SPEAKER_01But I but I do actually have a fear uh that uh we don't know what the end game we want out of this. I think there's a real contradiction in terms of what we're trying to do as a country in terms of our trade relations. Either we want to have um some sort of uh continuing access to the United States, uh, which is gonna have to we're gonna have to look at some uh aspects of that. We can go into more detail after this uh if you want. But either we want to have Fortress North America, which uh the Prime Minister said uh, you know, he's he's in favor of, as long as we can get to kind of like more like zero tariffs between United States and Canada, which I can understand that argument, um, or we're gonna be diversifying our trade and moving away from the United States.
SPEAKER_01Those are two different things. And and a good example of that has been the issue over China and Chinese EVs coming into Canada, and also the transshipment of uh manufactured goods from China going through Canada into the U.S. Uh that that is something which the Americans have been particularly uh egged about. And in fact, that's been one of the issues involved with this uh latest breakdown with the trade negotiations, where United States said basically to their partners, including Mexico, we want more like a common tariff where uh we're which is going to stop this transshipment of Chinese goods coming into into uh U North American supply chains.
SPEAKER_01Um, because for example, Chinese steel gets mixed with Canadian steel. The auto companies are having trouble knowing where the source is from ultimately. And so uh, you know, unless they they get identified. Uh and so therefore you you end up getting some very uh the Americans are getting, you know, we're are quite are getting quite upset about that. Uh and in fact, they put out a whole long document, which I got the other day, but I haven't had a chance to read it in its entirety. Um, but it is an issue, and and that's what happens when you have a fortress North America.
SPEAKER_01In fact, you know, one of the one of the ways that you might think of having fortress North America is to have a customs union where we have a common tariff around North America. Uh and uh but part of that would be no tariffs within North America, uh, which I think would be a good place to move to. And I don't think that's where Trump is. I think Trump is wanting to try to get auto trade production that's in uh Canada, as well as steel and aluminum, and shifting that into the United States.
SPEAKER_01And that's that puts us in a very difficult position. And not surprising, it's gonna force us to probably look for more partners abroad if if after Trump comes, the United States or leaves, then I should say, in a couple years' time, he'll be gone. Uh then the question is what's going to happen after that? And and uh and what kind of uh you know regimes we're gonna see. And and and I doubt very much that we're going to see uh a big shift away from terrorists necessarily, but although maybe future regimes will be much more willing to work with Canada uh than what we're seeing Trump doing right now.
Aaron PeteYou had named kind of one of the primary objectives. Are you able to share those other two objectives from the U.S.?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm glad you reminded me of that. So one has been the uh deindustrialization of the of the heartland and and uh and so it's really protecting manufacturing. But, you know, as Trump has said himself, but some of the other people in the United States, you know, you can't, you know, if you don't have uh auto manufacturing, how are you gonna make jeeps and uh, you know, other things for military spending? And then of course they also have they raise issues around semiconductors and uh et cetera, et cetera. So that's that's part of it. Um a second objective, which is an important one, by the way, is is revenue.
SPEAKER_01And in fact, I think that's actually one of the reasons why we won't see tariffs disappear in the future, because the U.S. government is now becoming very dependent on revenue. It's roughly uh$200 billion a year and uh$2 trillion over 10 years' time, which goes, which is very important for the deficit of a country that already has a huge deficit. And so I can see that you know uh those revenues uh are going to be very important to any future government, not just the current government in the United States, and will be very difficult to undo for that reason.
SPEAKER_01Uh in fact, I I went to a Washington conference uh a year and a half ago. Um, in fact, I was the only Canadian invited. It was a very interesting group, uh, very high-level uh individuals, uh, including some people from the Trump uh administration, uh, and some very top academics there and things like that, and and and and others from various think tanks and and and parts of the administration and things like that. Um but the question they wanted that I was asked to discuss is is it better uh to raise corporate taxes?
SPEAKER_01This is what the Democrats had wanted to do when Biden was in power, or is it better to raise tariffs? And that's a public finance question. That's not a trade issue. And in fact, we forget that that there are many countries around the world that have tariffs, at least to some degree, and some are very dependent on tariffs. In fact, I have a nice little diagram that shows the percentage of revenue the government raises is are is what are called international trade taxes. It could be export taxes or or uh tariffs.
SPEAKER_01And of course, as you might expect, um a lot of less developed countries have very high numbers. Um, you know, in the 20% of the revenues could come from from trade taxes. Um and in the case of uh Bahamas, which is a relatively high, you know, uh middle income country that believes in not having any income tax, uh 20% of their revenues come from trade taxes. And so, and so you know it just shows you that some people make decisions on a public finance basis, and it's really quite different than you know, other countries.
SPEAKER_01But you can you can make an argument that the corporate tax, for example, raises the cost of exporting, and goods coming into a country are tax exempt from the corporate tax. So from a trade perspective, corporate taxes are actually actually hurting the economy. They're they're like having an export tax with no uh import uh duties. Uh that's you know, in the in that sense, which is kind of surprising. But if you move to a tariff, you're putting a tax on imports and you're exempting exports, which by the way, is what we do under the value added tax that we have that actually over 150 countries have around the world today.
Aaron PeteAnd the third one.
SPEAKER_01And the third one. And the third one, which uh uh the Trump this all comes from very early on over a year and a half ago. The third argument that uh the Trump uh people had um at the time before they just after they just got elected uh in November of uh 2024 uh was uh the United States uh provides a uh uh defense umbrella uh to the Western world uh plus uh a reserve currency. And so these are like two public goods, and so government feels that they should have a uh you know some sort of tariffs in order to pay for those things.
SPEAKER_01Uh but they also link it to the trade deficit, uh, the argument that, you know, the trade deficit uh has been unfair. You know, of course, for an economist like myself, to me, this is a bogus argument on the trade deficit. Uh, and of course, we haven't seen much change in the trade deficit for the United States despite all the tariffs that have come in. But uh but that has been an argument uh made as well. Uh, but also that there are countries who have tried to take advantage of the United States through their own various tariffs and subsidies and things like that.
SPEAKER_01And therefore the U.S. would like to see that getting corrected uh where they feel they've been disadvantaged by those countries.
Aaron PeteI noticed that in your explanation of those three reasons, you didn't add a moral judgment or a value judgment on them. What are your thoughts on those three objectives?
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm not really in favor of trade production, um, although I do understand that if you have a country like China that is heavily subsidizing, and I've gone into this uh in some detail, uh, subsidizing uh its companies in order to acquire market share and export into countries that, you know, uh to really take advantage of that, uh, that sometimes you have to do things to counter that. That I can understand. Uh, but generally I'm I'm in favor of free trade.
SPEAKER_01I'd like to see countries not have tariffs, I'd like to have countries not have subsidies uh and to uh because I think there's a lot of value to free trade, uh, because if you don't have free trade, then the cost of your home goods are gonna go up, your standard of living declines, which is what you mentioned earlier on. Um uh you know, and uh it has some uh very negative repercussions for a country. And if a country is not growing, it also means it's not gonna have the money and the taxes in order to provide the kind of social services you want to help uh low-income people with.
SPEAKER_01So I've I've been a very I've always had a big concern about making sure that we have some economic growth happening in order to that we can feed a population and and and have a a stable society. So I'm not very much in favor of the first reason for having trade um that uh the U.S. government is having. I I don't blame them for trying to correct some of the negative things that other countries are doing, but this is where I think, you know, Canada, we do a few uh a few dumb things, I could say, in terms of protecting our own industries.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but uh but it I don't think we were uh a serious uh uh player uh uh or or hurt the US as you've seen in the case of China, which I think is a totally different story. Um but in the uh case of the revenue issue, I I think that's uh that's a difficult one. Uh you know, terror value-added taxes is which does put a tax on imports and exempts your imports, but it also taxes your domestic uh production at the same time.
SPEAKER_01It's meant to be a consumption tax. And in fact, my view, the United States, rather than having tariffs, would be better to have value-added taxes and really try to uh drop some of the taxes that do hurt exporting and and and hurts competitiveness uh for the economy. Um but if they if they don't have a value-added tax, I'm I'm not sure that tariffs at a low level, not a high level, that blocks trade entirely, um, but used for revenue purposes is such a bad thing, uh you know, at least from a moral point of view.
SPEAKER_01And this is this is because I'm looking at it from a very different perspective. I'm not looking at it from an international trade uh perspective that a lot of international trade economists will talk about, but they I'm looking at it from a point of view uh public finance uh questions. What's your best your best type of tax structure uh to have? And then as far as the third one goes, I think the um United States has benefited in terms of exerting its power internationally by having a reserve currency and providing that defense um uh support.
SPEAKER_01And I think the idea that they need to have other people pay for it is wrong. And I think that uh, you know, I think because uh It's working in alliance, so you're trying to get cooperation by everybody. Um, but I think that uh the uh the argument that trade deficits are terrible is is also wrong because you know your also payments also depend on capital flows coming into the country. And just because you may have a trade deficit when it comes to your merchandise trade doesn't mean that you have a bad situation if you're if you're able to um import capital, uh, which the United States has done quite successfully.
SPEAKER_01So so to me, that you know, every country is either going to be in a trade surplus position or a trade deficit position, uh, one or the other, but it doesn't mean that you're better off or worse off at all. It's uh it's it's uh a number of factors that may cause that. But it's not it, it's it's uh I don't think it's a it's something that should be an objective for governments. That's the mercantilist point of view of the world, going back to hundreds of years ago, uh where you know governments wanted to protect their manufacturing sector.
SPEAKER_01In fact, we did in Canada, we keep forgetting that, uh, going back to even at the time of you know when when we became a confederation, uh the national policy of John A. McDonnell included having tariffs in order to protect the manufacturing sector in Ontario and Quebec. And uh so we've had that objective too in the past. In fact, in some ways we still do. And and I can go into that uh at length in terms of corporate taxation, but that's uh but that's actually that uh I don't think that's an objective that I think uh is is helpful when governments are trying to protect uh various industries.
SPEAKER_01I think it's more important that if an industry is not doing well, let's see the shift of resources to things that are doing well. Uh and just to give you an example, I just ran a very good uh uh or an interesting article on Germany, uh, where you know they've had a very their manufacturing auto sector is having a very tough time too. They're laying off people and they can't compete against the Chinese. And of course they do allow the Chinese vehicles into into Germany. Um, but what's happening now is that the the auto companies are starting to move into other sectors, whether it's robotics, defense, uh, you know, a number of things, uh, and shifting out of autos.
SPEAKER_01And so you might see eventually uh not the full demise of the auto sector in Germany, but certainly a much smaller auto sector than they they've had, uh which has been a big driver of their economic growth since the Second World War.
Aaron PeteMay I ask, just bringing it back, you mentioned the conference you were invited to, and you were one of the only Canadians invited. Why do you think that was?
SPEAKER_01I was the only non-American there, actually.
Aaron PeteYeah. Yeah. Why why do you think that was?
SPEAKER_01Oh, I think it was just uh it was uh the title of the conference was uh on tariffs and other destination-based taxes. So it was meant to be very much on tax policy. Uh and um it was organized by uh Georgetown University and uh PwC. Um uh and I was quite surprised to be the only one outside the United States to be invited, but uh it was it was really uh an excellent day. I thought uh a lot of very interesting arguments were given about about where the U.S.
SPEAKER_01was going on trade policy, the whole issue around tariffs, etc. And of course, uh, you know, it was uh I think I think it was well worth uh attending the day. And but particularly I was struck by some of the comments that uh I heard from uh some very serious representatives of the the Trump administration.
Aaron PeteThe reason I ask is because I spoke to a member of parliament, Ellis Ross, and one of his comments in taking negotiation courses for his, he was a former uh chief counselor for Heisla Nation, one of his points was that he thinks that Canadians have a real hard time putting themselves in the shoes of Americans and understanding where they're coming from. And they view everything that's happening right now as an attack on Canada. And and perhaps rightfully so. Maybe you agree that it's an attack.
Aaron PeteWhat I've heard, and I try and follow some conservative commentators just to try and put myself in their shoes. Like, what are they thinking? And one of the comments I heard from an individual named Sega and Jetty was that during NAFTA, the US made certain concessions because they just didn't realize that deindustrialization was going to be such a big issue 20 years later. And so when they crafted NAFTA, the Canadians asked for a bunch of things to support our auto sector. And the Americans were like, sure, it's not, it's nothing to us and it's everything to you, why not? And so now that they have de-industrialized and and they are trying to uh reinstitute that base, they're like, no, we actually have to take all of that back now.
Aaron PeteAnd the way I see our politicians behaving, the way I see some of our uh political commentary class, it's very anti-American. It's not anti-American government, it's not just anti-Trump. It kind of is going deeper than that to an anger towards Americans. And I think in any healthy negotiation, as Ellis Ross pointed out, you need to put yourself in their shoes if we're gonna have productive conversations, if we're gonna get anywhere. And I find that you were the only one invited to this conference just kind of echoes this feeling that, like, you don't want a bunch of Canadians there because maybe they're not going to be as mindful of the the Americans are trying to focus on their interests, and you're able to kind of walk that ground with without conceding that they're correct, but not get emotionally invested the way I see so many of our political commentators get emotionally invested in this conversation.
Aaron PeteIt doesn't mean don't care. It just means stay grounded in the facts and the objectives that they're laying out as their arguments as to why.
SPEAKER_01Well, well, I agree very much. If you want to succeed, you have to understand what your the, you know, what your other side uh is looking for. And that's why I I uh when Trump got elected, uh, there was this paper that came up that uh that Stephen Moran uh was the main author of, but sure I'm sure it had a number of people that were involved in in writing it. But it made very clear why Trump was moving into a world of trade of uh trade tariffs and and uh and a much different approach.
SPEAKER_01And you can argue some of it is good and some of it is bad, et cetera, et cetera. But uh but at least you would understand what their objectives are. So when I went through the three things, the revenue argument, the you know, the deindustrialization argument, and the trade deficit, you know, public good argument, uh, that uh that these, you know, uh at least you could you can understand where they're coming from. Um in the case is it a is it an attack on Canada? Not not particularly. I don't think it has to be an attack on Canada.
SPEAKER_01Um, because I look at what Mexico is doing. I mean, we're not seeing uh the same confrontation happening with with Mexico and the United States. In fact, what people don't realize is that since uh January of 2025, uh Mexican exports to the United States have gone up by 24% during all these uh issues around trade and tariffs and things like that, because they've been hit too with some tariffs. Uh but what's happening is that Mexico, uh, first of all, uh being a low-cost country because of lower wages, there's a lot of third parties that are going to Mexico in order to get access to the U.S.
SPEAKER_01market that way. Um and the trans shipment argument uh of the of the Americans is also against Mexico. It's not just against Canada. But we're not getting Mexico coming out and, you know, uh telling, you know, a president of the United States to kiss my ass. And and uh, you know, and and that uh you know we're you know we're gonna ban with middle powers and uh now there's a rupture and this won't be going, you know, we're not gonna be going back, et cetera, et cetera. Uh all that is all that does is just uh further uh aggravate, I think, what what potential could be what could be done.
SPEAKER_01And so I it comes back to me, and this goes back to the point that I said earlier on, what it what is our end strategic goal in all this? Is it to basically drop any free trade agreement with the United States? And we're we'll just go on our own, have a let's say try to have a more competitive economy, try to trade with other countries, um, stop our or really cut back our relationship with the US and and dependency on it, uh, which is more than just economic, of course, it's also defense and and other things we have to remember.
SPEAKER_01Um, is that the goal? Uh is the goal for what I would let's say call Fortress North America, where you have a defense, uh security and uh and an economic pack uh that was really part of the the the goals later on. Or or is it uh maybe to have uh a you know a new Kuzma relationship? Uh there may be tariffs involved, but maybe other things that we can get that uh that can be cooperative. My view, I I'd like to see the third happen.
SPEAKER_01I don't want to see it, I think the U.S. is the most dynamic economy in the world today. Um, it is uh, you know, and having being right next door, having the same culture, and we're already many of us still are very tied into what happens uh in the United States. We watch the same television programs, we see the same movies, we we we go down to football games in the United States, you know, et cetera, et cetera. You know, culturally we have a lot of attachment to the US. Plus, a lot of people have their kids that live in the United States or families that are living in the United States.
SPEAKER_01So it's uh, you know, it's a very uh you know, it's to tear that apart, I think, uh is is something very difficult. So I don't think the first option is a very good option. I think there's a huge amount of costs associated with it. It's kind of like Alberta trying to separate, you know, or Quebec trying to separate. There's very big costs associated with that. And trying to give up access to the American market and our relationship with the U.S., I think would be a huge error. So that leaves Fort Dear's uh America or North America or having some sort of uh trade relationship that is that's comfortable enough for us for to give some benefits.
SPEAKER_01I think those are the those to me are the best options uh that are available to us. And and uh I think for now, given the way the U.S. administration is working, I think the second option of Fortress North America is very difficult. So we have to tread through what we can at this point.
Aaron PeteMy understanding from Mr. Greer's comments to Rosemary Barton in a CBC interview is he basically said, we were at the negotiation table, we were having these conversations. Prime Minister Mark Carney pulled his team from the negotiation table and walked away. There are theories that um Prime Minister Mark Carney didn't want a deal, and that's why it took so long to start having serious conversations. I don't know where you land on that, but broadly speaking, do you think it was a good idea for the Canadians to walk away from the negotiation table?
SPEAKER_01Uh well, I think uh it may have not been wrong at this point. Um there was a very good article in the New York Times yesterday, which I read, uh, which uh I think the value of it had talked to both sides, both American and Canadian negotiators, to get a fuller picture of what happened. And it seems to me that um, you know, I actually think there could have been a deal. Um I it it the the problem, the part I think the biggest issue was the fact that there was an agreement to reduce the auto-terrorists and the uh and aluminum and steel terrace as well.
SPEAKER_01Um and then uh the pressures came uh from the uh protected industries. And this is a problem when you start doing these sorts of things. You know, you bring in policies to protect an industry, and then all of a sudden they start fighting very hard to keep it. Uh and we know this ourselves. We we have that with supply management, this dominant policy ever adopted in Canada 40, 50 years ago, and we're still stuck with it, and nobody wants to get rid of it. And yet we know it raises milk prices and eggs and and poultry prices for Canadians and hurts low-income people and has herd export industries, et cetera, et cetera.
SPEAKER_01So this is what happens. And so in that trade, yeah, so um I think the uh the shift to basically take large automobiles out, if this is true. I mean, I wasn't there, so I don't know exactly what the terms were. Nobody really knows. But if this is uh if this happened, I can understand why why the Kids would walk away on that. I think I think they I think it's somewhat bogus uh over the French issue. I don't think that was the appropriate argument. In fact, um the Americans for a long time, in fact, I even had had calls from streaming companies uh in the United States uh to look at these issues, but um there was a proposal, or there's this 5% tax that uh was going to apply to streaming revenues, and with the revenues being going uh given to the CRTC for you know for our Canadian films and uh et cetera, et cetera, uh we can debate whether that's a good or bad thing, because I I'm not exactly uh I don't like that policy at all, to be honest, uh for me reasons.
SPEAKER_01Um but um uh but I do think that uh and and they also uh Canada wanted to have uh the streamers give prominence to Canadian and uh uh you know Canadian uh films, et cetera, including the French Canadian ones. And and the United States was resistant to that because from what I read, uh because they don't feel it's right for governments to tell um businesses or how to run themselves. And so uh I think there was you know that kind of uh objection to it.
SPEAKER_01I I think that issue could have easily gone away and I don't, you know, had to be uh didn't have to be dealt with the way it did. Uh we already gave up the digital services tax, so I think the streaming thing could have been handled because that that issue has been around now for a couple of years. Um and then um, you know, the other the other issue I think is over the trade agreement issue, uh, where the United States uh actually people forget that under CUSMA, under the current agreement, uh there's a provision that a uh uh if one of the countries, one of the three countries, had a um a trade agreement with a non-market economy.
SPEAKER_01Ooh, guess who is the non-market economy? Anyway, uh it starts with a C. That name. Anyway, uh they they basically would get uh the agreement when the Kuzma would no longer apply to them, and there'll be just a bilateral agreement between uh between the other two partners. That's actually that's what it states. Uh in that case, that that limitation was specifically related to uh uh to more comprehensive trade agreements.
SPEAKER_01Uh but the U.S. is wants to apply this to a larger set of agreements, uh, you know, partner trade partnerships and things like that. And and there's no question that uh uh Canada's deal with China, I think, was uh had had irritated the Americans, but I think the bigger issue is over trans transshipments. And that's why the Americans said we want to have the right to, you know, uh to have a, you know, we would like to we want to have similar tariffs. So this goes back to the Fortress American argument.
SPEAKER_01And and I I think we're again this is where a deal could have been made. I think that could have been dealt with by by by pushing hard to get reductions in tariffs internally, uh, with the idea of moving towards a some sort of customs agreement. And I do I do remember at the time of um Canada US agreement, there were there were issues around U.S. wanting to dictate policy to, you know, and especially NAFTA, I should say. Um, you know, but and Canada and Mexico being much smaller than the United States, of course, U.S.
SPEAKER_01carries the big weight. But there, I think there were certain panels that were going to be allowed to, you know, certainly to have a certain amount of consultations that the U.S. just simply can't unilaterally force everybody else to adopt exactly the same, you know, a certain custom tariff rate. Uh, it would have to be done by, you know, by negotiation and discussion. So I think we could have tried to push for these things, if this is correct. But I have to admit, I wasn't at the table. So I'm I'm I'm you know, outside of reading some of the things that are being said, I I have no better uh information than what we know publicly.
Aaron PeteWhen you look at our previous election uh and the platform Prime Minister Mark Carney ran on, how do you think he's performing as a negotiator with the U.S. from the promises he made? Obviously, we're we're getting to kind of extreme views. There's people who think he is uh so invested in Brookfield that he is doing everything in the interest of Brookfield and not Canadians. And Peter Polyev has put this argument forward that if you look at Brookfield's growth versus Canada's growth, Brookfield is outperforming Canada uh in terms of their growth.
Aaron PeteAnd then you have people who are like, well, Mark Kearney's standing up to the Americans. He's standing our ground, he's uh elbows up. How are you kind of reading the actions and decisions and strategy of Prime Minister Mark Kearney?
SPEAKER_01Well, well, first of all, I think the the Brookfield stuff is uh, you know, uh I think it's a bit of a red herring. Uh Brookfield is uh, but I have to admit I'm in I was on the board of Brookfield at one time uh for 10 years. So uh it's a very fine company run by very excellent people, and it has done extremely well over the past 20, 25 years. And so uh hats off to them. And uh and you know, the only the only question that I think comes up is whether um the prime minister has sufficiently guarded himself from you know from potential conflicts of interests.
SPEAKER_01Uh he has taken his wealth and he says he's put it into you know um you know uh you know some you know uh arrangements where uh he he's not controlling investment decisions, but he knows what's in there. So, you know, that's where the the accusation comes. But I think it's a bit unfair. I I don't I don't uh criticize him for that. In fact, if we're gonna look at every politician that way, then we won't ever, you know, we may lose out some very high quality leadership uh for that reason.
SPEAKER_01I think the more general question, which uh is the one that you're getting at, which is the you know, how how would you rate the performance uh uh so far of of the government since it's got elected uh a year ago last April? Um and on the trade side, uh there was a promise we're gonna have a trade agreement by July 2025. Well, we're not even close to that uh so far. And uh and I know it's hard because you have uh a very micario president on the other side.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and so I'm not fully blaming government for not getting a trade agreement, but I do feel I I do feel though that uh I think it's been unfortunate this current uh stoppage to the to the negotiation has been been unfortunate. Canada was very slow and dragging its feet uh to negotiate. And in fact, the American criticism was that uh Canada would meet, but then they had no, they were making no offers. It was just, you know, just a discussion about which areas to cover, which is a lot different than coming in with a true offer.
SPEAKER_01And that only happened recently, where the Americans started getting offers. This has been quite different than the Mexicans that have been negotiating over uh for some time now uh with the U.S. And Scheinbaum, uh the president Mexico, uh Mexican president, even said a couple of days ago, you know, we're looking forward to having an agreement with the United States, which would be really quite something if she ends up getting one and we we're still not even talking to the Americans. So I think I I think this is a a real concern on my part, actually, in terms of where we're going.
SPEAKER_01So I think on on all this, I just so far we the results have not been very good. And and so whatever strategy Canada's following, it it's it's not working at all. In fact, it's things are just getting worse with even higher and higher tariffs being put on us. So I I think I think it's been very unfortunate. Um uh the the other set of issues is the idea that we're gonna get the K economy to grow more. And and so there has been some real significant improvement, and it's certainly a big change in attitude uh with the current liberal government compared to the Trudeau government, where it's instead of always just doing thinking about redistribution of in uh of incomes in society, there is uh uh and identity politics and everything else that we've seen uh during the past decade, uh we're we're seeing right now um a government that at least has a focus on economic issues and and not just strictly social and uh and distributive issues.
SPEAKER_01And so uh although they still haven't undone some of the other things that were earlier on, um, but at least there has been that. But but the problem I find, and this is my my view, and it goes back to what we were talking about earlier on, I like governments if you're going to try to get more economic growth, try to remove those policies. Policies that are hurting economic growth. And that's why I'm a big fan of regulatory reforms and tax reforms. Currently, the approach of the government is to be a partner with the private sector and to create funds that are going to be subsidizing the private sector.
SPEAKER_01And to have a regulatory system that doesn't undo the problems with the regulations, but instead has a uh a process which overrides regulations, but for only those projects that are picked by the government. And to me, uh to me, this is I know some people may like this as a way of proceeding, but for me, this is not the way I would like to see uh you know uh see see the how how the how the uh economy should be run.
SPEAKER_01And so uh I'm I I think so far we're not getting many results there either, um as as there's been hardly any projects that have actually started up, except for the ones that you know would have happened anyway uh in Canada. So and and we're still taking a very long time to get a uh get things going. So I I don't feel we we're getting that success yet.
Aaron PeteAnd that's what I've heard from economist Trevor Toom and economist uh Joseph Steinberg, is that when Mark Kearney was coming in, he said we need to do two things at once. We need to negotiate with the US and we need to do things to reduce policy barriers and see more trade amongst the provinces and reduce any barriers there. We haven't really seen big action on that. There was a lot of talk at the beginning of the trade war that we were gonna remove all of it, and that hasn't really uh taken place. There was talk about taking other steps to start to strengthen our own economy.
Aaron PeteAnd the whole idea of the major projects office when it came about was we're gonna put this in as an interim solution, and then we're gonna address the deeper issues around what's going on, why are projects taking so long and actually improve that process. We see the inter-term solution being utilized and things going to the major projects office, but for one, we actually haven't seen anything proceed based on that. And two, we haven't seen any reforms to the internal regulatory process. So there is some more certainty on those potential projects.
Aaron PeteAnd then I think the third one that um economist Trevor Toom mentioned, and I'm sure you and I can talk about now, is taxes and reforming our tax code to make ourselves more competitive. Could you talk to us about that? Um, why should workers trust another corporate tax cut?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think that's uh, you know, often an argument made against corporate taxation. But I always, you know, I've worked in around the world uh with the World Bank, the IMF, uh OECD, and in a lot of countries. And so I know that the taxes could be a very powerful mechanism in terms of of uh creating more jobs and creating attracting more investment. And I know that I often use Ireland as the best example, but I I actually have a history of what happens if you kind of doubt some of the story about Ireland, because I had a conference once where I got really uh raked over the coals uh were uh by the Irish about how successful their tax policy has been.
SPEAKER_01Um but if you if you look at Ireland, it's a very good example. Uh it it was a poor cousin of Europe uh for centuries and uh uh and still pretty poor according just after the Second World War compared to Great Britain and and other uh countries around the OECD. Um but the army started in um uh after the 1960s uh to undertake kind of three or four very important policies. Uh one was to educate the population. A lot of people didn't even have high school education, never mind uh tertiary education, you know, post-secondary education.
SPEAKER_01And so uh they they really try to push hard uh students get through their um high school education and then even with free tuition try to get people into post-secondary education, which they did. So they were building up a skilled labor force. Uh that was part of their objective. Um the second one was they uh eventually opened up themselves to trade by joining uh the European Union in in the early 1990s, but that was also uh very important in terms of of uh having more access to a larger market.
SPEAKER_01Uh and and the third thing was their corporate tax policy. And the corporate tax policy, where they first had a very high rate, you know, close to 40% or whatever the number was back in the 1960s, they said, you know what, we're gonna try to attract manufacturing and financial service firms. So they dropped their rate on their income to 10%, lower than anybody else at that time. Like it was such a it was such a unique thing to do. Uh, but it aggravated the European Union uh later on after they joined uh the European Union, and um and they told Ireland, look, you got to you got to uh do something where you you can't have this big differential where initially it was like 36, 38 percent versus uh 10 percent.
SPEAKER_01And so the Irish, they did drop their top rate for a bit, and then in 1999 they said, okay, we won't do state aid anymore. We'll get all companies 12.5%, lower than any other country in the in the OECD. But by that point, they were attracting a huge number of multinationals coming to Ireland to set up shop manufacturing. In fact, it's still today, manufacturing is like 20% of their GDP, and Canada is less than 10%. That's the difference. And so um, and and instead of having people that were leaving the country emigration where they were going to Europe, UK, Europe, and United States and Canada, they started reversing.
SPEAKER_01You know, people were actually moving back into Ireland uh after that point. Um and and so there was a very significant change uh that occurred where Ireland was growing very quickly over the past 30 years, let's say, uh 40 years. Um and except for the financial crisis where they had bad financial regulation, got hit very hard by it uh in the late uh late 2000, they they were able to uh uh have or have become um one of the richest OECD countries in the world.
SPEAKER_01And I like to use what's called gross national income, or the GDP, uh, to measure. GDP is your measure of all the goods and services you're producing in the economy. Um, but it could be production could be owned by foreigners. Gross national income, what you do is you subtract out the payments that go to foreigners, and you add back the payments that residents in your country get from abroad. That's gross national income. I think it's a little better measure of standard living than than GDP for that reason.
SPEAKER_01But even uh, and of course, uh Ireland has a lot of payments that they make to foreign countries, uh, or the United States particularly, so they they um uh so the U, you know, Ireland is uh uh gross domestic product is much bigger than their gross national income. But even on a gross national income basis, they're far richer than Canada and many countries. They're still one of the richest in the OECD, except for Luxembourg in a couple of cases. So so this is uh the corporate tax policy was an amazing, like amazing success in in Ireland.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and it just shows you how powerful that can be. And some of the other work that I've done, uh, I can give you a good another example, which was Bulgaria. This is work that I did uh with the IMF and the World Bank because it was back at the end of the early end of the 1990s. And Bulgaria was in a very tough, uh, very tough position. Uh, and um uh it went through a very large devaluation in its currency. It had extremely high deficits, um, its economic growth was shattered, uh, its population uh you know was poor, but I think it was getting poorer.
SPEAKER_01Uh and the worst part, and I'll just give you an example, the first day that I went to Sophia to work, where you know, I was with colleagues, we were sitting in a McDonald's and we were watching a a kid that may have been like eight years of age scrumming through the garbage, pulling out paper and and and and uh glass. And and this was quite common where kids weren't going to school because they had to go and do find money, some way to support their family. And that's how you know that's what it was like in Sofia.
SPEAKER_01You saw people very poor kids in the street and and poor people and things like that. And it was terrible. Anyway, Bulgaria uh uh I won't go through all the things they did, but uh they did link up more strongly with the European Union. Uh in fact, at first they uh dollarized, they adopted the European euro as their currency for a while. Well, they didn't adopt it. What they did is they they uh fixed their currency to the to the euro.
SPEAKER_01Um they uh really opened up trade, but again, they undertook a big tax reform. And I recommended trying to get out of these tax holidays, which were a very bad tax incentive, very costly and doesn't get you that much investment as you think you do. That's why I used to do a lot of work with the World Bank and the IMF, uh, was over the issue of tax holidays uh around countries. And um, and I uh I had a way a suggestion for the government to how to get out of them, which they they ended up taking up.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but I recommended dropping their corporate rate from like 39% at that time uh down to to 21, 22 percent. In fact, they liked it so much they went to 15 percent, like Ireland. Anyway, but the combination of getting their deficits down, uh their currency stabilized, uh their tax reform um started uh started driving foreign direct investment into Bulgaria, and they started having very uh a significant improvement into their economy at that after that point.
SPEAKER_01Um, so it's another example about how a combination of very smart policies put put them together uh and and you start seeing better results. And of course, for for all Bulgarians, they started benefiting, I think, from having a government that that was much more fiscally responsible, but also at the same time being able to uh you know generate the revenues that could support better social services in the country as well. Um, and so I think it's it's a second example, but I can go through several others where where taxes do.
Aaron PeteCan I ask you about Canada? Because in 2005, you and a colleague, and correct me if I'm mistaken, estimated that proposed corporate tax reductions would generate around$56 billion in new capital investment, raise annual GBDP by$5 billion, and create around 340,000 jobs. You described the tax cuts as a policy slam dunk. Corporate rates subs uh subsequently fell substantially, yet Canadian business investment remained weak. I'm just wondering how do you reflect on that journey?
SPEAKER_01No, that's not true. Actually, if you look at uh the numbers, investment was very weak for a number of reasons prior to 2000. And then the corporate tax rate started being reduced after 2000. In fact, we had the highest corporate income tax rate amongst all OECD countries in the year 1999. The highest one, 39%. And uh by bringing down our corporate rate, plus getting rid of some of the incentives, um, we actually started getting a lot more investment during that, uh, during the 2000 decade.
SPEAKER_01And of course, things changed in 2008-09. Um, and there's been a number of studies that have shown that once you take into account all the factors that influence investment, taxes did have a positive impact. There was a very good study done by um an economist now who's uh at the uh Alberta Treasury branches, uh, but was at finance, but uh he and he and a colleague put together a really good analysis of the corporate rate reductions that took place between the year 2000 to 2005. Now, the numbers that I did, of course, uh is based on modeling, and and you know, the trouble is it's only predictive.
SPEAKER_01And there's various things that influence investment, and it's not just taxation, there's other things. That was a uh an estimate of assuming all nothing else changed, that would be the impact. But of course, um, and and by the way, I tend to take conservative estimates of behavioral effects uh in my uh in my modeling. Um but you could uh but there was there was actually a a much better bigger improvement. Manufacturing didn't do as well uh during that period.
SPEAKER_01Um, but of course, manufacturing, we've been throwing incentives at manufacturing. You know, manufacturing is the least taxed um sector in the Kenyan economy. Since 1972, we keep throwing investment tax credits at it, accelerated depreciation, uh, all sorts of uh tax uh benefits to that industry, but it hasn't arrested its decline. And that's not to say that taxation doesn't matter. Maybe the decline would have been worse if we didn't do that.
SPEAKER_01But uh but we're the only OECD country that has such a bias towards manufacturing. All the others don't. Not man, not the United States, not any of the European countries, et cetera. It's you know, only Canada. It's really remarkable. And you could see this in the publications that we put out about how manufacturing is so incentivized, and yet it hasn't it hasn't improved manufacturing. The value added share, manufacturing as a share of value added in Canada has dropped um over the years.
SPEAKER_01It was uh close to 20% back in the 1970s, I think. And now it's less than 10%, it's around 9%. Uh employment as a share of total employment has dropped. And this is not to say that taxes don't work. This is to say other factors were happening. Because we also saw in many other countries a reduction in employment, you know, the importance of manufacturing. Why? Because we've seen this huge growth in Chinese manufacturing and Asian manufacturing that has and that you know had done had uh taken a much bigger share of the world market, which goes back to our whole discussion about trade, because that's one of the things that the US policy has been reacting to now.
SPEAKER_01Um and how did China do it? Subsidization. So it doesn't tell you that this doesn't is isn't a story that taxation doesn't matter or subsidies. They they can matter. But it's also um but I think I think one of the great values of dropping the corporate tax is that everybody benefits. And we're not picking which sectors are gonna win. All the sectors benefit. Does anybody lose from corporate rate reductions?
Aaron PeteYes.
SPEAKER_01Yes. If you're a company that gets very fast write-offs for capital, such as effectively you have negative effective tax rates at the margin on your marginal projects, um, then dropping the corporate rate actually might increase your effective tax rate, not reduce it. Um, but that's because you're creating a more neutral system, like where the the accelerated appreciation has less meaning when you drop the corporate rate.
Aaron PeteMy last question for you, and thank you so much for your time. Uh, I've just been thinking a lot about, I don't know if you know of Emily Lowen. She's the leader of the BC Green Party. I had her on, and she she's a follower and a fan of like people like Zoran Mandomni and others who are arguing that we need to tax the rich. Uh that and I think it's correct, and you can correct me if I'm mistaken, that we have seen a growth in income inequality, that the rich are getting richer at a higher rate than the median household income is going up.
Aaron PeteAnd so there's a felt sense that individuals, uh, young people in particular, are starting to fall behind. They can't buy a house, they uh groceries are continuing to go up year over year, and yet people in older generations are likely going to benefit from uh their Canada pension plan uh and other services. So you effectively have a wealth transfer from the poor population to the rich population. Relatively speaking, obviously, if you're retiring, you might not be, you know, might not feel rich, but much in a better position than young people who can't afford a house.
Aaron PeteWhat are your thoughts on do we tax the rich? How do we address the income inequality we're seeing in Canada?
SPEAKER_01Okay, so there's a lot to that. So, first of all, let's let's talk about has income inequality increased or not. So if you look at uh what economists measure is what is the genie coefficient, which is a measure of the uh degree of inequality in uh in an economy, um, it did increase a lot in the early 90s and and 80s. Uh, but actually, if you look at the numbers post 2000, there's been hardly any change. In fact, it's kind of gone down slightly. Also, the question is which genie coefficient are we talking about?
SPEAKER_01Are we talking about the genie coefficient that is uh based on market incomes? Or are we talking about the genie coefficient uh that's based on um uh that's based on uh what your market income is plus the government transfers you receive minus the taxes you pay? And the genie coefficient, when you take into account government transfers and taxes, is much lower, meaning much more equality uh than than without it. So taxes and transfers in the Cain system does reduce inequality quite substantially.
SPEAKER_01In fact, it does so much more so than let's say you find in the in the United States, uh, for example, and we're very similar to a lot of other countries. So we don't have this kind of problem that's you know that that's being said, uh, you know, uh, that you know, our tax transfer system doesn't lead to more inequal equality. It does. And and in the past 20 years, we actually haven't had uh that much reduction. In fact, there's been some numbers that uh Phil Cross has put together that I've seen where he's measured, for example, the top 1% in terms of their share of income.
SPEAKER_01The story in Canada has been not the not the same as the story in the United States. So let's that's uh there's a question there in the first place. Then secondly, the question is do the Brits not pay enough tax? Uh well, if you look at income taxes, they certainly do pay a lot more. In fact, the top 10% of taxpayers in Canada, the top 10%, pay uh are responsible uh cover uh over 50% of income taxes that are paid in Canada.
SPEAKER_01There's a lot of people at the lower end that don't even pay income taxes at all. So uh the idea that somehow the rich are getting away without paying taxes is is not is isn't is is not true. In fact, the rich do pay a lot of taxes, but the ones that do get a lot of breaks are often because governments are throwing brakes at them. And in fact, that's one of the concerns I have right now of all these incentives that go to things like film tax credits that lines the pocket of Hollywood producers. Uh uh we we now having subsidies for this green thing or that type of investment, et cetera, et cetera.
SPEAKER_01And what does that do? That just generates more um more wealth uh for owners of capital. And so uh I'm very much in favor of getting rid of business subsidies as much as possible, and and I'm very much in favor of of uh making sure that we do have a fair tax system on the personal side by getting rid of some of the uh special incentives that we we throw into it in in the guise of of uh industrial policy.
SPEAKER_01So um I I kind of question these things. And and the other thing is that we have to remember people do move. And if you tax rich people too much, then that's that could end up causing uh a fall in uh in incomes.
Aaron PeteThank you, Mr. Mintz. Uh would you mind telling people how they can follow your work?
SPEAKER_01Uh well they can uh I I write every week in the uh National Post uh for quite a while. In fact, uh my article coming out tomorrow is going to be on gambling taxation, which is uh which sort of came out of uh I went to a conference last April in Munich on on gambling and I was asked to give a paper on taxation issues, which was the first time I really got into them, um, which is kind of interesting in itself. Uh and uh and so that's um uh that's what I've been um you can find a lot of the things I've written.
SPEAKER_01Also, uh I do have um a number of papers that I write um for publication, uh, but they come out in various places. Some are published by the School of Public Policy. I'll be having an interesting one coming out in mining taxation in the near future. Um, I'll be uh I've done a lot of work with the Inter-American Development Bank. There's a major paper that came out a couple of years ago, um, plus CD How, I have a major paper that came out in income tax reform or on tax reform in general, uh, which uh people can read too.
SPEAKER_01So I show up in a lot of different places, but uh those are some of the that's that's where you can find them.
Aaron PeteThank you, Dr. Mince, for joining us today and walking us through some of this. I found your tone to be very calm uh and able to examine both perspectives, which I think is really important because the political temperature right now on this issue is incredibly high. And I think the more thoughtful information we can have as voters, uh as citizens, is gonna be more and more important as we try and navigate this because we don't know how long it's gonna go on for. And I think our government has a vested interest in us being more fearful, and I think that's when we need to start looking at the data points, looking at the information, and looking critically at what our options are and trying to help them make better decisions by giving them our perspectives.
Aaron PeteSo, thank you so much for joining us today.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...