281. Sylvain Charlebois: Are Canadians Being Overcharged for Groceries?
30 minAudio
Sylvain Charlebois, also known as the Food Professor, explores Canada’s grocery prices, food inflation, the Loblaw boycott, bread price-fixing, grocery competition and interprovincial trade barriers with host Chief Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Aaron PeteAre Canadians being overcharged for groceries?
Sylvain CharleboisIt depends on your perspective, I guess, but if you actually look at the data, uh, it's hard to see any evidence of that. What did the bread price fixing scandal teach you? It was a bit of a uh trust breaker for me, uh to be honest. You can actually run food cartels uh or you can conduct some price fixing schemes in Canada, but you can't do it without law blow.
Aaron PeteWhat did you think of the reaction from citizens boycotting law blow?
Sylvain CharleboisFrankly, if you do boycott one chain in Canada, you may end up making things worse because let's say that the boycott would have worked, it would have actually increased prices elsewhere.
Aaron PeteCan we realistically bring those prices down? Or are families being asked to accept this is the new norm? Thank you so much for being willing to join us. Would you mind briefly introducing yourself for people who might not be acquainted with your work?
Sylvain CharleboisSure. So my name is uh Sidven Chalabois. I'm uh I'm an academic. I'm director of the Agri-Food Analytics Lab at Dalhousie University uh in Halifax. Uh, and uh our work is very much about the food supply chain from farm gate to plate. Um and uh I've been running the lab for about a decade now, and uh, used to be at Guelph, University of Guelph, and before that I was at the University of Saskatchewan.
Aaron PeteLet's get right into it. Are Canadians being overcharged for groceries?
Sylvain CharleboisUh it depends on your perspective, I guess. But if you actually look at the data, uh it's hard to see any evidence of that. Um, I mean, basically, I've always asked my students and people who do challenge uh the quadro of groceries that we have. Like, how do you measure greed, really? And uh the answer to that question from my perspective is to look at at financial statements. And uh there are two metrics that I look at very closely to measure whether or not in retail if there's abuse, and that would be uh same-store food sales compared to uh food inflation.
Sylvain CharleboisSo obviously, if uh growth of food sales uh are is higher than food inflation, that's a sign. The bigger sign to me is gross uh margins. Gross margins is basically revenues minus the cost of goods. If that goes up, that's a sign as well. But when you look at food retail, uh there's I mean, for the three, the big three, uh, so Sobase, uh Loblaw, and Metro, uh, gross margins have actually just haven't moved at all.
Sylvain CharleboisMaybe there's there was probably one quarter uh by law law three years ago that was a little above uh their threshold, their their average, but that's basically it. So, in other words, uh grocers tend to make their money selling clothing, cosmetics, um uh procedurum drugs, uh, especially proscriptum drugs. In fact, the last for the last quarter, the CEO of uh of Loblaw uh is on record saying that the GLP1 phenomena is really bringing a lot more business to to shoppers, which is really their bank.
Sylvain CharleboisSo up the food chain, it's a little more difficult to to assess uh because you have uh many private companies, some public companies, but many private companies, and and the public companies are most of them are not based in Canada, so it's a little harder to assess. Uh margins when you look at you know, Cargill, Tyson, Proctor Gamble, Pepsi, margins have actually uh have increased on average, uh, but not that much.
Sylvain CharleboisAnd so that's why it's always a little bit more difficult as soon as you uh leave distribution, going through processing and even in production, uh, it's harder to assess with another there is greed going on.
Aaron PeteGrocery prices are rising more slowly, but they're still substantially higher than five years ago. Can we realistically bring those prices down? Or are families being asked to accept this is the new normal?
Sylvain CharleboisYeah, so actually in the last five years, uh food prices in Canada have gone up 28.9%. Uh that's basically the G7 average, uh, really. Some countries have actually seen worse, like the UK, for example, uh, even Germany has seen worse, but we're basically average. But the unique thing about Canada is this in the last five years, 17 times from one month to another, uh, food inflation, the food price index dropped 17 times in the last five years.
Sylvain CharleboisStill, still, we're fourth at 28.9%, which tells you that food inflation is a problem, of course, but the worst problem that we have in Canada versus other countries is is price volatility. Uh, we're we're very vulnerable to currency fluctuations, geopolitics, uh uh increase in input costs, like what happened with Ukraine, for example. So you can see that our chain uh is very is way more vulnerable than other chains around the world.
Sylvain CharleboisThat's the biggest problem. And to answer your question about whether or not food prices will drop, uh food inflation doesn't necessarily work that way. Now, one year we in the last 20 years, there there was one year where prices did drop in 12 months, uh, but it was barely 1%, basically. It does happen from time to time, but it's very rare. I mean, the economics of food uh supply chains basically will make costs go up.
Sylvain CharleboisAnd when costs go up, it's very hard to bring prices down.
Aaron PeteWhat information would you need before you could confidently say consumers are or aren't being overcharged?
Sylvain CharleboisWell, you look at two things. You look at the cost of food, food prices versus affordability uh on the other side, meaning salaries and things like that. So salaries in Canada have actually gone up, uh, although this year in 2026, it has slowed down. The difference between Canada and the US is that you have more unionized positions, uh, which means that collective agreements are negotiated every three years. So every three years you have this cycle of renegotiation that do that does have an impact on on wage increases compared to the US.
Sylvain CharleboisIn the US, you tend to see wage increases happen way faster because they're not at the mercy of uh collective bargaining, essentially. And so so we have caught up in 2025. Really, it was a uh it was a I think wages went up 4.3 percent in total, which is really good. Uh, but now things have slowed down. At the end of the day, you have to look at disposable income, and this is why Canadians are feeling the pain. Um, about 10 years ago, uh, the average household was spending about 18% of its disposal disposable income on food.
Sylvain CharleboisOkay, 18%. Now we're up to 22%. So we went from 10th place uh in the world uh to sixth, uh, sorry, we went from sixth place in the world as having the lowest percentage dedicated to food uh to 10th uh in the world when you look at the disposable income dedicated to food. So that's why I mean that shift is pretty dramatic in just a few years, and that's why a lot more people uh are are feeling the pain.
Sylvain CharleboisThe other issue that we have in Canada, which is unique to Canada, is the fact that over the last 18 months, uh food inflation was above headline inflation. Uh this month, like the month of August, it was the first time we saw the reverse for the first time. So, but when food inflation is higher than general inflation, that's when people notice higher prices at the grocery store.
Aaron PeteIn a 2018 column, you called the bread price fixing scandal inexcusable. What did the bread price fixing scandal teach you?
Sylvain CharleboisUh it it uh I had an episode of of uh of self-doubt, to be honest, because I actually had confidence in the in the industry. Uh it was a bit of a uh trust breaker for me, uh to be honest. And uh of course on my show I've had the CEO of Lobla on and uh the CEO of other grocers on on my show. But since then, uh what what I do now when I look at prices and when I look at patterns, I I do look for uh potential uh situations where uh collusion will occur.
Sylvain CharleboisI mean, the the reality is that there's been a lot of consolidation up the food chain. And uh as soon as you start having vertical integrated organization, which was the case between lobla and western uh western bakeries, then you increase your chances of seeing some some collusion. And that's exactly what happened with the bread scandal. But the other thing that I've learned from the bread scandal is that um because we did we were asked by the Commission Bureau to investigate into this, and they asked us whether or not it was possible that there was a bread cartel in Canada.
Sylvain CharleboisAnd so uh we were doubtful, but but then we actually did look at the data, and our conclusion was was fairly simple. Uh, we saw the pricing pattern from 2020 to 2015, and it was clear that there was there was collusion going on. Uh but from 2015 to 2017, when Loblaw disclosed to the Bureau without others knowing, that's when you saw again a different pattern when it comes to prices, which means basically only one thing is that you can actually run food cartels uh or you can conduct some price fixing schemes in Canada, but you can't do it without law blah.
Sylvain CharleboisThat's really the key here. And that's why, in my view, that's why law law threw everyone under the bus, because I mean, we did the calculations, it was just impossible to uh do what they did without law and Western Baker.
Aaron PeteWhat did you think of the reaction from citizens boycotting law blah?
Sylvain CharleboisUm, I mean, people have every right to boycott law blah, but I I knew uh I knew that the impact was going to be limited. Uh and so I I I was always doubtful of the impact. And frankly, if you do boycott one chain in Canada, you may end up making things worse. Because let's say that the boycott would have worked, it would have actually increased prices elsewhere, and it would it would it would have disrupted the the supply chain. Uh what was really um interesting is that people actually believed that the boycott was working while you could you you saw sales, law blah sales go up and uh the stock price go up at the same time.
Sylvain CharleboisSo it it it it kind of actually attracted more attention to law law. It actually bettered their situation. So if you want a boycott, that is your decision. But at the end of the day, uh my my view is that you may want to encourage people to buy somewhere else or to like the bike and aim movement, for example. The bike aim movement to me is a good example of how things should be done. You encourage people to buy certain things and not not buy certain things.
Aaron PeteWhere would you have directed people during that period as an alternative?
Sylvain CharleboisIn terms of uh like if they basically if they wanted to boycott loblaws and go somewhere else. What what was the reason? I mean, what was the reason why people were boycotting lobla in the first place? Because they thought that loblaw was greedy because la blah was profiteering. But when you actually look at the data, the most profitable grocery chain was Metro. So why didn't they boycott Metro?
Aaron PeteWas there so basically they were gonna get it all to the uh the bread fixing scandal?
Sylvain CharleboisMetro is accused. Metro's part of the investigation, so is Sobase. They're being investigated as well. It's not over, but of course Lobla declared its its uh its position and uh and uh and admitted that they were guilty. But I don't think that the boycott had not anything to do with the cartel or with the price fixing. People believe the reason why people decided to boycott Loblaw is that they thought that they were greedy and overpowering.
Sylvain CharleboisNow they are overpowering, but when you look at profiteering specifically, I mean the evidence was pretty clear. Metro is by far the most profitable chain out there.
Aaron PeteThere's a lot of discussion about what should be done in response. I'm sure you'll recall uh Jag Meet Singh, the former leader of the NDP, uh talking about trying to address this in some ways. I think Avi Lewis has come out with some proposals around uh government-funded um grocery stores. I imagine that the conservatives' position is more competition is better. What kind of pathway forward do you see to give Canadians more confidence uh when they're shopping, that they're getting a fair deal?
Sylvain CharleboisYeah, two thoughts on that. So, one, uh I don't think we should dismiss the concept of publicly um run grocery chains. Uh, I think there's actually some merit to that concept, but you have to do it for the right reasons. Uh, the reason I'm hearing from the NDP right now, from Mr. Lewis, is that we need to show the oligarch how it's done. We need to basically compete against the private sector, which is really the wrong reason because it's impossible.
Sylvain CharleboisUh, the suggestion is to open 50 stores. There's 18,000 grocery stores in Canada. It's it's not going to make much of a difference at all. And so that's one thing. But we do have some issues. Uh, I do believe that there is merit to the concept uh because grocers are not interested in doing business in some parts of the country, like urban centers right now. There's lots of theft, there's lots of uh homelessness, drugs, things like that.
Sylvain CharleboisUrban deserts are real. And I think that perhaps there's something to be done there with uh public chains in downtown cores. Uh the other part of the country where uh where there's there's utterly underserved Canadians is the North. Uh, for many years, Ottawa has failed to service the North. You still find cucumbers at $20 a piece, cabbage at $25. It's just unbelievable. So I would say, yeah, absolutely.
Sylvain CharleboisYou we should consider establishing um government-run chains for those particular markets. But the other thing that I think the NDP is missing is the co-op movement. Um, in Canada, there's over 500 uh co-op-run grocery stores already. And so if you want to socialize food distribution, why not actually push and promote the co-op movement? I never understood why they didn't do that.
Sylvain CharleboisThey just go right after owning and operating something they don't understand, but why not actually run cooperatives where you can actually get more people involved? You can actually make a, you can run a very inclusive model for citizens wanting to get involved in food distribution. I think the co-op movement is a powerful tool for not only the NDP, but for people who actually do care about food systems.
Aaron PeteYou're now one of the of Canada's most recognizable voices on food, but I'm wondering where did that passion begin? Was there an experience to make you want to understand and challenge the way our food system works?
Sylvain CharleboisWell, I mean, the the I'm every day uh I try to make sense of things uh every single day. And so uh and I make discoveries. My team will discover things. We do research uh on a variety of different things. We have five or six projects on the go right now. It's great. Uh, I'm privileged, uh I have a lot of information. Um so my job, I feel that my job is to inform the public properly with data. And um I I find the situation we're currently in to be incredibly frustrating because most people are actually making up their minds based on pure emotions, which is really bizarre.
Sylvain CharleboisBecause I mean, my job as a scientist is to provide evidence and provide data. And so I'm looking at what's going on in the US, I'm going on, I'm looking at what's going on in Europe, I look at the data, I look at reports, and uh I trying to make sense of what's happening right now is incredibly difficult and frankly frustrating because I'm out there trying to communicate to the public, you know, this is probably a mistake. This is something that we may want to consider, but at the end, and I do have an audience. Uh don't get me wrong, I have an audience.
Sylvain CharleboisIt's just I feel that we're not necessarily listening or paying attention to what is actually going on here. We're just focusing on the noise.
Aaron PeteYou spent part of your youth working on dairy farms. What did you see there that kind of shaped your understanding of pricing and families paying for food?
Sylvain CharleboisFarming is hard work. It's hard work. In fact, on Friday, I was actually in Saskatchewan running a combine. And uh these people work very hard. Uh, but in dairy, you're dealing with livestock, it's even harder because every day something goes on. These are living beings, and so they get sick and things happen. They get pregnant and uh and they're they're worth a lot of money. Let's face it. I mean, uh, some cows can can be worth like well over a hundred thousand dollars, and so it's really uh stressful.
Sylvain CharleboisUh and it's the work ethic really that uh that affected me. And that's why today I'm up at four doing the reading. Uh I'm getting I get ready for my day. And by the time I get to eight, nine o'clock, I'm I'm I'm fully plugged into what is actually going to happen during that day. So uh it's that's right. I mean, so that's why I have a lot of respect for farmers. Farmers are misunderstood, uh, but that's why today I I do a lot of keynotes. Um, I'd say, you know, I do about one keynote a week, and probably two-thirds of them are in front of farmers, really.
Sylvain CharleboisAnd so I'm not a farmer, but I have a lot of respect for them, and they know that. And and they know that my that I try to understand them and I and I try to defend them really, because sometimes, like most businesses in the agri-food sector are are voiceless. They don't really get the proper attention. And um, and uh I'm I'm hopeful that I can actually bring more attention to them uh through my work.
Aaron PeteI'm curious. In BC right now, we're in a provincial election. And I'm wondering what should we hold. I'm in BC. What should we hold provincial governments accountable for? And what should we hold the federal government accountable for when it comes to food insecurity uh and the cost of groceries? What's within their purview?
Sylvain CharleboisYeah, so specifically to BC, uh, I think the ALR is a big problem. I actually just wrote a report uh to the government. Now you're in election, so I don't know what's gonna happen to that. But uh the ALR is a big problem. I I think BC needs to invest in processing way more. And the ALR um um, I would say, uh condition uh policy is really not helping at all. Uh so you have to process a certain amount of food that is grown uh nearby the facility that's just so restrictive, and it really pushes away investment.
Sylvain CharleboisIt's pushing people to invest in Alberta and the and Washington state so that so. So valuing processing is key in order to stabilize the entire system. And BC is certainly one province that would need to do that. In fact, in it's in BC that where farmland has actually dropped in value last year. It's the only province where farm value has dropped in the entire country. Why? Because it's not interesting to invest. And the other thing I would say for provinces is that you need to look at property controls.
Sylvain CharleboisNow, I've defended grocers on margins, but I can't defend them on property controls. These people are quite territorial. So when they they lobby municipal uh councils, making sure that there's no more than one store in a particular town. Or one store is one is is on one side of the river while another store is on the other side of the river. They actually do not like competition. They suppress competition. And that practice, the practice of property control needs to stop.
Sylvain CharleboisAnd if there is one government that can level a government that can actually address that, that would be a province. So I certainly would encourage the BC government to work with its municipalities and restrict property controls as much as possible to increase competition so consumers have access to more choices and lower prices.
Aaron PeteAnd the federal government, what would you want to see them take action on?
Sylvain CharleboisWell, at the federal level, actually, there's some interesting things going on, to be honest. I'd say like the food strategy isn't wasn't really a strategy. It was a list of good ideas. And so food hubs, uh, certainly I would say that in BC uh you would need some food hubs to be built to basically increase exchange between farm gate and uh and retail and service. So that's a step in the right direction. There's more money.
Sylvain CharleboisUh, a couple of weeks ago, there's uh there was a billion dollars dedicated to manufacturing. Great idea. The um there's also there was an also an announcement in the aftermath of the investment uh summit in Toronto to uh provide um some uh tax credits uh when it comes to RD uh equipment purchasing, all these things. Uh certainly, so that's a productivity. I think they called it the productivity fund of some sort.
Sylvain CharleboisThose are track tax credits uh given to companies if they want to invest and increase productivity. That was another step in the right direction, as far as I'm concerned. Um, and uh so there seems to be some movement there that are that is going to help the entire agri-food sector. But the one thing that uh that is still missing uh that uh Mr. Cardi has advocated for, but nothing has been done really is interproficial trade barriers. They're still there. I mean, they were supposed to be gone more than a year ago, they're still there.
Sylvain CharleboisAnd we believe that the average household could save anywhere between $500 to $700 and $750 a year on food should we actually liberalize the entire country, especially right now in light of what's going on with the U.S.
Aaron PeteAre we too dependent on the United States for food?
Sylvain CharleboisWell, I mean, under Trump, uh, I think it's it's plainly obvious that we are dependent, but I I'm a I'm a I'm a North America fortress kind of person. So I actually do believe that we actually have a lot to offer to America. America has a lot to offer to Canada. We happen to have a regime in the White House that doesn't necessarily believe in globalization. Uh they believe that that uh globalization is is is uh is a is failed policy.
Sylvain CharleboisI don't agree with that, but that's really what's going on right now. I I I do believe that we will continue to depend on the US, uh, but the US will also continue to depend on us for certain products. I mean, it's it's hard to overlook a market of 350 million affluent consumers. So we're just right next door. That's our competitive advantage. And so we we should use that connection in order to develop new markets as well, not to block that opportunity and diversify.
Sylvain CharleboisWe need to nurture that relationship while diversifying as well. I think, and we haven't done that enough.
Aaron PeteLast question What is stopping new grocery competitors?
Sylvain CharleboisThere's I mean, the business case is weak. I mean, follow the money. Uh Lobla's investing in California and and Washington State, and nobody's coming here. Why? There's no wealth. Uh there's uh I mean our population is not growing, the GDP per capita is not growing. Uh, we're the worst uh amongst uh OCD countries. And so those are metrics that grocers would look at, right? If there's no wealth, how can you grow the market?
Sylvain CharleboisAnd so so within you have some grocers that do control the market very well. And so would little and all D come in to a country like Canada where distribution costs are very high? Ask Target. They came in in 2014, they left nine months later after opening 125 stores. It was a huge failure. So no other grocer would want to become the next target.
Aaron PeteWell, I know uh that we only have a moment left, so I just want to appreciate you for the work that you do. It's really fascinating being able to speak with individuals like yourself who have taken a topic that we all interact with on a daily basis and dive into it and offer insights that that help a more informed electorate make more informed decisions. And I find it so interesting that in your day you go into so many different spaces, uh, whether you're grocery shopping or your house shopping, and there's just such a complex world behind that.
Aaron PeteThere's so many levers and tools and decisions being made at all levels of the supply chain that that give you a humility of how complex our world is and how complicated it is to go pick up your $4 avocado. So thank you for the work you do, and thank you for uh attending today.
Sylvain CharleboisWell, thank you for the work you do as well. Thank you for having me.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...