Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Nuanced.

Nuanced. artwork

276. Jim Balsillie: Canada–U.S. Trade War Explained by Former CEO

Sep 23, 20261 hr 6 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Former BlackBerry CEO Jim Balsillie discusses Canada’s productivity, intellectual property, Donald Trump, Mark Carney, trade agreements and economic sovereignty with host Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I'm uh Jim Balsally. I'm the retired chair and co-CEO of Research Emotion, which I agreed to 20 billion before I retired in 2012.

Aaron PeteWhy do you think it's so difficult to build and keep a business of that scale in Canada today?

SPEAKER_00We've had a lot of erosion in our prosperity, so those that succeed, I say they succeed overwhelmingly, the wind in their face. Imagine what they could do if we put the wind in their back.

Aaron PeteAnd do you see any changes from this current liberal government in response to that?

SPEAKER_00I've yet to see anything on intangibles or statecraft. I've not seen anything on intellectual property, anything on data. I'm giving them a bit of a pass for the first year because they need to learn, but the time for giving them a pass is running out.

Aaron PeteWhat are your thoughts on CEO's pay in taxing the rich?

SPEAKER_00It would be very counterproductive to tax CEOs more. They just leave. And they can. And the companies will leave and the money will leave. And we've seen that. You're better on trying to grow the pie than to grab the pie.

Aaron PeteWhy do you think there's such a narrow-minded approach in Ottawa in comparison to the US right now? What's going on? Jim, thank you so much for being willing to join us today. It's an honor to have you on the show. Would you mind briefly introducing yourself for folks who might not be acquainted with your work?

SPEAKER_00Sure. I'm uh Jim Balsally. I'm the retired chair and co-CEO of Research Emotion, which I grew to 20 billion before I retired in 2012. Very active in uh my commercial endeavors, mainly tech, but otherwise, and um uh North America principally. And but I also do a lot in public policy and philanthropy in realms of capacity building and social services and culture and the Arctic.

SPEAKER_00So it's um it's a very rich and fulfilling life.

Aaron PeteAnd lots to discuss on all of those fronts. Uh first, I'd just like to know you helped build a Canadian company that changed how the world communicated. Why do you think it's so difficult uh to build and keep a business of that scale in Canada today?

SPEAKER_00Uh when when I was growing RIM, uh I was very fortunate because my commercialization mentors were in the United States. And so we were kind of seen as an American company, which helped me navigate uh the terrain that uh of getting money in 150 countries around the world. Uh and back then there was a real focus on Team Canada, growing Canadian companies. Uh, and that was something really Sean Cretchan and and Paul Martin really embraced.

SPEAKER_00But then for some strange reason, as the world became more hands-on with their companies and promoting them and engaging them, we went hands-off, or even worse, we focused on foreign companies growing in Canada. So that uh they figured if you helped Google put whatever or Facebook or Microsoft grow, that somehow that would benefit Canada. But in fact, it benefited their home country. So uh the thinking changed. Uh, it went from engagement for our time to uh non-engagement to uh really structurally putting wind in the face of Canadian companies.

SPEAKER_00And um and with that, we've we've had a lot of erosion in our prosperity. So those that succeed, I say they succeed overwhelmingly uh with the wind in their face. Imagine what they could do if we put the wind at their back.

Aaron PeteInteresting. I'd love to get into what putting the wind in their back looks like. Um, but before we get there, before Blackberry was a household name, how did you convince powerful customers to take a chance on a small company from Waterloo?

SPEAKER_00Uh they weren't really uh taking a chance per se. We were we used a lot of um guerrilla marketing campaigns as the expression for it. It's probably more common now where we were seeding units into influential people. And so we were playing with traditional sort of power structures where we put this in the hands of like the CEOs and their assistants, and then it transformed their relationship or or working teams in deals, and therefore these spread virally.

SPEAKER_00So uh the people who adopted it after their bosses or bosses' bosses used it, they they were told what to do. And because there was a viral structure to how we created the product and how we inserted it in the market.

Aaron PeteInteresting. Losing the signal describes you leaving Harvard for a job at Sutherland Schultz, paying roughly half of what you would have earned on Wall Street, from my understanding. What pulled you toward running a business?

SPEAKER_00Uh, it was a lot less than one half, that's for sure. Um but uh yeah, there are parts of the book that get it right. There are parts that the book gets wrong. Um but my interest, my application to HBS was I'm an electrician's son, was to um uh become an entrepreneur. And I was interested in tech, which was very um out there in the late 80s. So um yeah, that was the I was looking for that opportunity to be an operator in a tech type company.

SPEAKER_00And so I was given, I was as chief financial officer, but I was also responsible for these fledgling tech products and and I had full PL for them, and they grew very quickly, and that gave me the confidence that I I knew uh how to do this.

Aaron PeteYou've said you wanted Blackberry Messenger on rival phones before you left. Why couldn't you get the company to make the shift while you still had that level of influence?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was a very difficult time for for me because they um it fundamentally I'd spent a year and a half and bought some companies, one called uh Live Pro Profile, which you can still, I think they're still on the net, and and Nubay, and that allowed us to work cross-platform, but also it had a whole storage capability for media into the cloud. So we were uh a social media for SMS. And um and I I navigated the commercialization of RIM for 20 years to five point.

SPEAKER_00We just finished a quarter of like 5.2 billion dollars. And yeah, Mike and the new CEO just canceled it without telling me. And I was very surprised at the time. And uh they said that this would undermine hardware sales and said, Yeah, but hardware is already dead, and we weren't making money on hardware, we're making money on the services. So but when they sacrificed the services business for a new hardware OS, it uh took away the profitability of the company.

SPEAKER_00And so yeah, that was um that was a boardroom surprise to me. I was on the board call of the board meeting and they just said, Oh, we've decided this. And I called afterwards and they said it's a done decision. And uh yeah, very uh, very disappointed in that and and was surprised how I was disappointed how surprised I was because I'm thinking, how could this be? How could I let that um get to that point um where they just did something without so foundational without talking to me when I'd navigated this all this long, but it shows that you have to manage power dynamics of a board.

Aaron PeteIt leads me into a reflection I've been having a lot lately. I interviewed different people, the premier of Alberta, Pierre Polyev, and one of the things I think I need to develop within myself and be able to maintain is an ability to somewhat predict where things are going, where the wind is blowing, what the future looks like. And the thing I love about speaking with like an individual like yourself is that that is half of the job, right? Is trying to predict where things are gonna go and reputations and the futures of companies are built on trying to project out as best as you can where things are gonna go.

Aaron PeteAnd on this, you ultimately were correct. And I just wonder how you think about that for businesses. How important is the ability to predict where things are going? And do you think that businesses do a good job of recognizing when somebody got it right, even if it was a few years ago, 10 years ago, 20 years ago, that those predictions, that ability to look out and make a prediction and get it right is a rare skill because obviously most people in entrepreneurship and business get it wrong over the long term.

Aaron PeteAnd so being able to get it right consistently is uh is a really important asset to have in people.

SPEAKER_00Well, one of the things I do is uh I call things very clearly and and sharply. Because if you if you get this muddled ambiguity, that's death. You ever been in a meeting where people don't know what to do? And so it just goes round and round to the table, and eventually everybody just muddles into something and shrugs their shoulders and says, that's a good idea, but nobody knows what they're doing. And there's really no conviction, but you have to quote unquote make a decision, but nobody's really in charge.

SPEAKER_00So um I I lay out very sharp characterizations, very sharp, uh, like hardware is dead. Uh and even though it's the most of our sales, it's none of the profit. Now, I don't put my identity or ego on the line when I do that, but I I force people to challenge me on that. And if they come up with a good argument, I I want the facts and I want the argument. And again, I don't I don't have to be right. I don't put my ego on the position, but I do say, prove me that I'm wrong, because somebody has to say, I think this.

SPEAKER_00And I think you have to characterize things crisply and even starkly, almost black and white, to just give clarity to you know, are we are we strong here or are we weak? Uh are we resourced or are we impoverished? Um is i and so I think that's that's one thing I I do well. The other thing is you you just have to follow the money and follow the leverage. Tech is a leverage game. Where's the profit pool?

SPEAKER_00And then how do you have a reasonable chance of attacking that? And obviously with RIM, we had the services business, which was all our profit. We made well over a billion a quarter on the services business, and the carriers uh were going to put that in with SMS, but it had to be a lower rate, but still every phone had SMS. And would you have used your social media on your text versus an emerging social media company? And so um, yeah, it's forcing very crisp decisions, characterizing it clearly, uh, forcing debate on these things and really looking for the leverage, looking for the profit pool.

SPEAKER_00You'll find generally um it surfaces the pretty clear strategic call. And then then there's a lot of execution that goes into that. And then you create uh rehudling structures, regular meetings to revisit your assumptions, get your feedback loops, get the facts. So there's a very intense. Um, so we had these meetings of executives and salespeople, which were very regular. A lot of people participate, get a lot of facts, distill it, uh, make a call, and then and then and then get back.

SPEAKER_00So because you the it's like whitewater rafting. Okay, this is what we're gonna do. And then we go around the bend and you encounter something new. You may encounter something surprising, you may encounter something placid where you can all exhale for 10 minutes. You don't know. So you've got to have that highly integrated, adaptive uh feedback loop and execution loop together. And and I find that really helps. But of course, as a CEO or chair, you've got to really drive that strategic thinking.

SPEAKER_00And in RIM's place, they just didn't do the decision. They didn't think it, they didn't debate it, they just made a unilateral call. And and I I think that was uh low functioning in terms of how you make strategic decisions. And that's when I resigned from the board and and sold my shares back at that time.

Aaron PeteWhere did you develop that? Was that in school or was that in your personal life? Because uh just to give you some background, I look at so many people who need to make some tough decisions in their life. They need to start to look at where they're gonna be in 10 years, where they're gonna be in 20 years, like even just at a personal level. And people stay where they are or make kind of that muddled kind of like gray zone area decision rather than really critically looking at their life or where they want to be and making tough decisions and making at times some sacrifices about like, hey, if I actually want to go make something of my life, I can stay at this nine to five job where there's no growth opportunity.

Aaron PeteSo many people stay there because it feels safer or like the more obvious choice. And you made an incredibly big decision where you could have kind of stuck with the group. Things were somewhat working during that period, and you kind of said, like, hey, if you're going in this direction, I cannot stay with you because I know where this leads. And that's a prediction, but it's also got to be tough to make that decision when you've been a part of this and and kind of walking away. So, where did you develop that mentality of really looking at the cold, hard facts and making tough decisions?

SPEAKER_00I am not sentimental. Uh and and I think being sentimental in these things is is a is a shock hole. So I I I think I I I do see things as they are and and I characterize them honestly. Now people will say, some will say that's sharp, but if you're um if you're preparing for a major boxing match and and I say, you know, your right arm's too slow and is left undercut is gonna knock you out in 10 seconds, and and we're you're going to the hospital.

SPEAKER_00Am I being sharp or am I saying, yikes, we've got to change our coaching in preparation so that you're you're attuned for this, and and you get or they say we can't be um adaptive in time in that way, therefore we have to come up with some other strategy, or you know, fake the flu and cancel the flight, whatever it is, but let's not delude ourselves. So I think there's a lot of diluting, there's a lot of sentimentality. Uh, and I don't think those are your friends.

SPEAKER_00I um I did a lot of these kind of logic games and logic tests and those kinds of things as a kid, and I just developed a belief I could figure things out. So I just walk into a room and say, I know I can figure this out. And I have that narrative loop in my head. And so um I think you people should think of the loop that they're putting in their head.

SPEAKER_00And obviously, parenting and mentoring and circumstances has a lot to do with that. But I walk into any situation and I I just know I can figure it out. I just don't doubt it. And and so I think that and that creates a determination, a focus, a grit to to see it through. So I I think those are those are good things as a is a positive self-talk, not uh not a I'm gonna go in there and knock out Mike Tyson in 30 seconds kind of thing, but uh uh a constructive self-talk, uh and then having a a super clear characterization of what is.

SPEAKER_00And then you apply your toolkit of tactics and strategies to say, how can I navigate through this? And then and then you uh but you have to keep revisiting those things because things are developing all the time. Like there has to be a very regular heartbeat to that. So it's a process, it's some skills, it's a it's a personality orientation. Um that's how I approach it. But I literally just came out of a meeting now, going through three or four tech companies of mine on these very specific kinds of issues.

SPEAKER_00And um yeah. And you just um, but then part of it is is when you do it a lot, then you you see the pattern, you get you, you you really start to see patterns and you really start to that's like you, you just the more you interview, the better you get at your interviews because you've been doing it and you've seen what works and you see what doesn't work. And um yeah, in a sense, that those good habits. I journal every day about um what I did yesterday. And um it's I'm accountable to myself.

SPEAKER_00Did I was I prepared? Was I um, you know, did I do it the best I think I should and could? Did I did I eat properly? Did I did I have one glass of wine or too many glasses of wine? Um so I think you know, you have to look yourself in the face too. And um and just for good habits and good accountability. And and I think those are some of the things that I employ that I think people can generalize on.

SPEAKER_00But I think people uh the other thing when I mentor is everybody has their own style. So it's like sports, it's and basketball. I don't want you to shoot like I do, but I got to give you the ball and put you in a position to shoot uh and make a move. And we're in a team and we've got some flow, but ultimately you have to develop your own style and your own confidence in your own way. Um, and so this is not some kind of cookie cutter thing. I think that's very dangerous. So you gotta let people develop their own style.

SPEAKER_00And also, I'm very interested in business. I'm very interested in commercialization. I uh it's what I wanted to do. So it's it was my passion. Uh other people may have different passions, so it's very hard to think passion.

Aaron PeteWhen did you start journaling?

SPEAKER_00Oh, a long time ago. Long time ago. Yeah. Yeah, I would say a couple things that people may not know. Um one is that um yeah, I do write down it's just one page every day. Like, did I go to bed on time? Did I, you know, did I exercise? Did I, you know, prepare everything I should have prepared? Did I arrive on time? Did I approach that thing the way I should best?

SPEAKER_00And that is something that I think is important because it it compels you to be accountable. And and you fib to yourself. It's kind of like ate good food, had one piece of pie, and then you kind of come back two days later. I know I lied. I had two pieces of pie. Like it's funny how you lie to yourself. And uh and um apparently doctors, when you say how much you drink, they always take the number and they double it because people lie to themselves. So I think I think being honest to yourself, and I'm super honest now, like I am plainly honest.

SPEAKER_00Um and I think another thing, uh, which is again not exactly locked into this, but when I travel, um I I always try to carve out an hour to visit an art gallery, a museum, or a house of worship. And invariably um they would get, because Ren was successful, they would get somebody very senior to tour you. It could be a minister, could be a priest, could be a um curator of a show.

SPEAKER_00And it's remarkable. 45-50 minutes, you just your brain is full. Yeah, and I think you you just learn the world and don't miss a chance to learn the world. And what's interesting is that when you have these business dinners, people love talking about their cultures. They'll talk about it all day. Because and I'm a curious person, and I'm I'm extremely curious. Um, so I'll just keep asking them questions and they'll talk about their culture all day. And I'm curious and I'm interested. And I'll tell them about the the the show, I think, or the thing I saw at the museum.

SPEAKER_00And and then and then I then they uh I think it wasn't a a tactic, but I found that they they tend to trust you because you're interested in them. And and then it's 10 minutes to go on the dinner. Oh, yeah, we haven't talked business. Okay. Okay, our team's gonna work it out, right? Yeah. And if I'm not happy, I'll call you. And you'll fix it, yes. And you're not gonna screw me, I promise. Okay, good. Yeah, but um that there's a lot of trust and and subtle connective tissue in these relationships.

SPEAKER_00And uh but people have a good radar for a phony, so I wouldn't suggest you do it as a shtick.

Aaron PeteThat's actually such a good point because one of the things I learned early on when I was just interviewing past professors and stuff was how much people have learned throughout their life and how much wisdom they have to share, and nobody ever asks them. And nobody sees them as a source of knowledge. So when you do, it's like a real gift to somebody at times to ask them the correct question.

SPEAKER_00That's great. Well, that's beautiful.

Aaron PeteYou argue that Canada needs to get better at owning what it creates. Can you help me understand what you mean by that?

SPEAKER_00Yes, of course. Um, and it's an interesting time because the US, the Trump administration has just laid bare what's been going on for my whole business career because I've been in this tech world. And so when you're in the world of intangible assets, they they it's legal frameworks that determine who owns what. Whereas the jacket you're wearing, you own that physically.

SPEAKER_00That's not in dispute, but the design is in dispute. And there's fights going on in that stuff uh all day, every day. And everything you look around you, the lights, the switches, the technology, the microphone, the screen. There's thousands, hundreds of thousands of elements at play over who owns what and who gets the money and who gets the power. And we simply don't teach it, we simply don't play it. And and every other country is extremely hands-on that I've encountered that's successful.

SPEAKER_00The Southeast Asians, credible Western Europeans, Americans, Israelis, Scandinavians, Swiss, on and on. And we don't do that. So we don't, we, we, we do seven and a half billion dollars of research funding a year in Ottawa with no framework to own the ideas. It just goes in, and people think, well, that's fine. It's just global philanthropy. We have nothing, no strategies to govern the data for our economic benefit.

SPEAKER_00And even though it's creating trillions of dollars of market cap. And and and and in this interoperability, there are hundreds of thousands of standards out there that determine who wins and who loses. And and tens of thousands or new ones are created every year. We have no strategic engagement, no strategies with our firms. And I know these files very, very well. And and uh it's like we're blind to the game of owning and because you can't commercialize what you don't own.

SPEAKER_00You can't ask for money with something that's not yours. And um, yeah, it's it's a it's a structural policy failure. Um I I there's a lot of dismissal in the parochial um hubris of these things in our policy community. But what's happened is Trump has laid it so bare. And Bassant wrote a very good or gave a very clear speech on US economic state craft a couple months ago that says we're gonna architect the future because if you don't set the rules, you're gonna be living under someone else's rules.

SPEAKER_00I'm like, yeah, no kidding. And um and all these people that have been saying this is how the world works, it's a free market and it's about efficiency and it's hands-off, and it's neoliberal. There's nothing neoliberal about any of this stuff that that these are markets created by governments and modified hundreds of times a day for strategic benefit of nation states. And you've got to build the capacity and build the engagement strategies. And we we categorically didn't do it.

SPEAKER_00And we always kept wondering why are we last in the OECD and productivity growth last over the last 40 years and forecast to stay last and expertise? And they scratched their heads and made false myths: resource curves, too close to the American market, complacent culture. And I say, I dealt with hundreds upon hundreds of CEOs in my life and money managers. I've never met one that would say, you know, I'm just gonna not grow my profits this year because the fishing's good at the lake.

SPEAKER_00Like I've just never met that person making that decision. And yet these people dismiss their failures, never having been commercial actors most of the time, uh, with some constructed, because they say we obviously got the policy perfect. And I go, you got the policy exactly wrong. And and so you're not going to participate in this intangibles economy without tremendous technical expertise and front-footed statecraft.

Aaron PeteHow would you bring that in? And do you see any changes from this current liberal government in response to that?

SPEAKER_00Uh well, I uh there's a lot of very good people that are advocating for this, young scholars, older scholars, and the the kind of keepers of that old orthodoxy are aging out and being pushed aside. I haven't seen anything yet from this government. Um they're much more pro-business, which is great, and much more responsible than the than the previous government, which is good. They're smarter, they're conscientious, they're more professional. However, when you look at all they're doing, I've yet to see anything on intangibles or statecraft.

SPEAKER_00I've not seen anything on intellectual property, anything on data, anything on um happening on tokenization and unified ledger. We're we're seeing that these quote unquote trade agreements. I wrote seven years ago that USMCA was about um a hijacking of our sovereignty. And everyone said, no, this is free trade, Jim. We can't be North Korea. And now I think they actually have adults in the room reading the drafts and saying, oh my God, this is hijacking uh our sovereignty.

SPEAKER_00And I go, yeah, they grabbed half of it seven years ago and they're coming back for the next half. So um I think they're learning on the job that there's a statecraft here. Yeah, you know, we've got we but we haven't done anything on the sovereign uh data governance uh as a factor of productivity. Um the research funding and the uh IP, how to support domestic companies versus foreign companies when you do all this FDI. Uh I mentioned how these are in FTA standard setting.

SPEAKER_00I mentioned uh um tokenization and unified ledger, which the US has been very aggressive on. I haven't seen any strategies yet in the country. Tori, can you explain what that is? Sure. Um if you see the U.S. Genius and Clarity Act, they've fundamentally been very strategic saying the US dollar has to be the base currency for all digitization of money, and then we're gonna tokenize land, minerals, crops, everything.

SPEAKER_00And that has to be US dollar backed on US infrastructure. So, in a sense, if we don't respond to that, do we need our own Bank of Canada? Do we need our own Canadian dollar? Uh, do we need our own Toronto Stock Exchange? Do we need our own land registry? Uh, and so on and so forth. So, this is going for where you keep the ownership of these things is called a ledger. And if you have a distributed ledger, that's that's what you hear, blockchain, and and you start involving currencies, uh, New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq are doing full tokenized 724 share trading now, we've got to get in on that, or people will just say, I don't need New York or Toronto Stock Exchange anymore.

SPEAKER_00And so on. So, again, those are very aggressive frameworks when it comes to tokenization and a digital ledger. And if you make these ledgers talk to one another, like you can do your stocks and your money, or your land and your money, or your crops and your money, that would be uh, or your rare minerals and money. That would be called a unified ledger. And there's lots going on in these discussions, but where's our statecraft in this?

SPEAKER_00Um, and so US is just every day there's something, every week there's something very aggressive they're doing in national security, in science and technology, and AI, fintech stuff. They had very aggressive fintech stuff in the last couple of months. Um free trade stuff, FDI reviews, um standard setting. In January, the US stepped down from 66 global organizations very publicly, but they doubled down on three standard setting bodies.

SPEAKER_00What it's called the ITU, IEC, and ISL. And they're basically, and then they put all these supportive structures for American companies to draw set the rules so that they get the rents and these value chains. There's nothing in that in Canada's statecraft. Um, we can do it, we should do it, but again, that's that orthodoxy shift. Uh, and so I've I've exhorted publicly and privately the government to um get active here.

SPEAKER_00But it's a bit like learning a new language. It's it's not so if you look at the investment summit next week and you look at the document, it's almost all 19 like traditional industries. It's all, and I'm not against them, I'm all for our truth, but it's pipelines, ports, mines, energy infrastructure. It's very much, and if you you know do AI, it's a shell in energy where somebody else brings in the gear. And I would call that a traditional approach. You're not capturing the value add.

SPEAKER_00So um, yeah, this is we have all the ability to be much more sovereign, much more prosperous, but we have to develop this understanding of how intangibles works and the statecraft and the frameworks that goes with it. And um and that's why I said when I was commercializing RIM, I was pulled right into the middle of these kinds of things all the time. But very fortunately in Washington and other mentors in the US, so they helped guide that. Um, but the receptivity to revisiting thoughts in Ottawa was was was just not there.

SPEAKER_00They're very closed in their thinking. Both parties.

Aaron PeteWhere do you think that's coming from? Where do you think, like, for one, the US seems very willing to tinker and modify and take big risks? Like I would say the the war in Iran was a big risk for the president in in the upcoming midterms.

SPEAKER_00Dumb. You can call it a big risk. I I just I I I consider that irresponsible.

Aaron PeteA big dumb risk, maybe. Um and so so you have a lot of big risks being taken. And from what I can see, very naively, it seems like the balance of power is recalibrating. We're hearing about how we're becoming a multipolar world where there are different uh states that have more power, China being one of them. And so it seems like the US is trying to reorient and seems like they have, as you mentioned, uh best in being willing to take um some real actions and take some risks.

Aaron PeteAnd then on our side, we're we're hearing we're gonna step back from the US. But to your point, I've interviewed a few economists and they said, hey, when we heard about the major projects office, that was supposed to be a temporary tool. Um, and they were gonna update the infrastructure for how we look at major projects over the long term. They have not done that. They said they were gonna look at our tax, a tax uh review and and updating that. They have not done that. What do you think is going on? Why do you think there's such a narrow-minded approach in Ottawa in comparison to the US right now?

Aaron PeteWhat's going on?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I would say my first thing would be to those economists where's your scholarship been on state craft for Canada in the past 25 years? Because I can't find any uh new thinking, new institutions, new policies for this world of intangibles, which is 92% of the value the SP 500. So um there's a place for the process bureaucracy, of course, and there's there's a place for tax competitiveness, of course, but those are necessary but not sufficient.

SPEAKER_00And so it's a two-legged race, and I'm simply trying to invoke the second leg, not to the exclusion of the first leg, but as a necessary complement to the second leg. Um, I do think, I do think when it comes to this office and what they're trying to do and moving major projects and changing the culture that they inherited from the previous administration, uh, has been quite constructive. Uh and and I do think they're hardworking people trying their very best and conscientious and experienced in this.

SPEAKER_00Uh, what I've not seen is any expertise on these realms of the statecraft that constitutes the 92% of the SP 500. And if we don't invoke that more, are we taking economic strategies akin to Russia, where it's just oil and gas and minerals out of the ground? And I think we're capable of a of a much more prosperous, much more advanced Scandinavian-like economy than that. But again, I need to see uh um the understanding and the activities and the statecraft and the expertise and the capacity building for that kind of world in harmony with yes, approving our major projects, whatever the machinations are going to be, and uh um and having a competitive tax code, which we absolutely need to be.

SPEAKER_00Uh, I think it's fairly clear our tax code is not competitive with the US. And what if people and companies and money can move with the stroke of the pen or the click of the mouse, then they will. So it's not a hard tax assessment. Are you competitive with the jurisdiction that can hoover our opportunity sets? So uh I think that's fair game. And I've I I've talked to the policy people in finance about that because they're they're now worried that startups that it used to be 30% left Canada, now it's 70%.

SPEAKER_00And I said, if I was losing 70% of my customers every year, my future every year, I'd have an emergency meeting and sit down and say, what is going on? And I can tell them, because I'm active in that community, what their thinking is, but I've not seen anything to respond to it. And when you're the CEO or the prime minister, you have to parallel multiple files. You need to get resources moving to ports and out of the ground, but you need to parallel the 21st century aspects of our economy also.

SPEAKER_00And I haven't seen it yet. Um I'm I'm public and getting more public about what needs to be done. Um I'm giving them a bit of a pass for the first year because they need to learn, but the time for giving them a pass is running out, and it's it's gonna have to be sharper, the characterization of the blindness of inattention to these 21st century realities.

Aaron PeteThere are a lot of critics of this current government. Uh, one of them is this guy, David. I don't know if you've ever heard of him. He hosts a show called Moose on the Loose, and he regularly questions Mark Carney and a lot of Kearney's team because a lot of them were former ministers under Justin Trudeau. So there isn't this new government coming out of nowhere operating. It's a lot of the same traditional players from the previous government. And one of his big fears and concerns that he raises a lot, and he has a chart outlining Mark Kearney's potential conflicts of interest, is around Brookfield.

Aaron PeteAnd one of his predictions and his beliefs is that Mark Kearney is actually more interested in seeing Brookfield succeed than Canada succeed. And his argument for that would align with Pierre Polyeves, who's put out this chart of how much growth Brookfield saw versus how much growth Canada has seen in the past year. I'm wondering, as a CEO, like as a former leader yourself, how do you think about that criticism? Um, is he completely wrong, or is there hints of concern that you would have as well in regards to his relationship with Brookfield?

SPEAKER_00Uh I think Prime Minister Carney is his scores very high on conscientiousness. Um pride, uh, which is dangerous when you have blinders. However, I do think his conscientiousness he sees himself as a historic figure, which he has the opportunity to be. Um I do not think that he he he would not say, gosh, I could put X million dollars in my jeans into heck with Canada.

SPEAKER_00I don't think that's how he thinks. I think um I think that's a lot how Trump thinks, but I don't think that's a fair characterization. But again, a lot of people go after people with money in public office in Canada. There's an envy structure. And and if you've been successful, then you just go after that money and naturally you have to have to have trusts. So I think it's you, and then you get people who haven't accomplished things in politics because those are the only people that have, you know, that you can't, you're not envious of.

SPEAKER_00So I don't think that's there, the way going after them in the Brookfield. I think that's undermining the countries. People doing that are compromising the country. Um, they're driving away good people, they're creating a false narrative. Um, so I don't think uh I don't think that's a fair criticism at all. Uh I think in terms of the same people, I think there's some fairness to that. I think we've had an but I think it's a broader issue, which is the thinking structure of Ottawa and our policy community, it's the same people.

SPEAKER_00They're all the same Ottawa Mandarin Bay Street people with this neoliberal thing. Um but the issue with the conservatives is they're just simply saying, well, let's just be more neoliberal, even more neoliberal. So they're not putting any thinking into the window. And you hear all this stuff, let's get a deal done with the United States. It's kind of like me saying, Well, just buy the house. And they go, Yeah, but it's five times too expensive, it's decrepit, and we have to sign a clause that the prior owner gets to live in it forever.

SPEAKER_00And they go, I don't care, buy a house. We need a house. And I go, No, there is such a thing as a bad deal. And and and so this idea of you know free markets, it's a John Lennon song. Imagine a world where it's free markets and it's only about efficiency. It's easy if you can. Uh, in a rentier economy of intangibles, it's not a free market, it's a friction market where somebody charges a rent. They're not shipping a good. And it leads to strategic state behavior to try to jackhammer because they want the trillion dollars in their economy, not ours.

SPEAKER_00And so this is, you know, the the the right free market orthodoxy folks have to get off this John Lennon song thing. Imagine a world where it's all about free marks. It's it's not about free marks, these are social constructs. And when it moves to intangibles like intellectual property and data, those create incentives for states to bully. So if you've read USMCA, which I have, and most of these people haven't, uh, there's a million words. You will not find the words free trade in it.

SPEAKER_00And they got rid of no tariffs in that, but he put the whole country on the line if we didn't sign that back seven years ago. So, what was it about? It was about grabbing our sovereignty. It was about a new constitution for Canada run out of Washington. It sets our health policy, our environment policy, part of our trade policy, our macroeconomic policy, our intellectual property, our standards, our data and AI, our enforcement. On and on the list goes, much more of the power is in that treaty than it is in our House of Parliament, even though it was signed without a proper debate and understanding for Canadians.

SPEAKER_00Now, what I think with Prime Minister Kearney is he's a responsible person and his chief of staff, Blanchard, is a lawyer. They actually look at these agreements and go and go, they're taking us over. And they think, well, I ran a fund before. Imagine if I can't make an investment without the approval of a foreign country. I'm not a sovereign company anymore. I'm not a sovereign fund. Um, so they're starting to realize that this is loss of control. And then they looked back at the prior agreement and said, Well, we gave half of this away seven years ago.

SPEAKER_00We're just giving the next. Next halfway now. So my question is, where has anybody been in the last 10 years saying, how do we create a sovereign, resilient country? Instead, we give away so much of the sovereignty and we trumpet it that we're the victors. And and and so now what's happened that's different now is there's not a veneer of diplomacy in Trump. He's just brutish about it. And so it's laid it bare. But it was going on for 20, 25 years.

SPEAKER_00Um, so it's woken us up. The question is, uh, are we gonna build the capacity and the orientation? Uh as I say, you know, in the immortal words of Yogi Berra, when you reach a fork in the road, you gotta take it. And Trump has manufactured a fork in the road. Are we gonna learn how the world works and engage with it front-footed and sovereign? Or are we just gonna capitulate and be a vassal state? And I said seven years ago, we're on a path to becoming Puerto Rico without a passport in this structure.

SPEAKER_00And I stand by that today. And so I think Kearney's government extricating themselves from the past thinking, it's a hard job. I think he's doing a pretty good job of it. Uh, I don't find a lot of fault. I just think he has to invoke this um second leg of intangibles and statecraft, which I've spent time talking about. But my but I would like to see some humility from the whole class of them, which is y'all wrote books, y'all been advisor, y'all been given speeches, y'all been mandarins.

SPEAKER_00Why in the last 20 years did none of you bring this intangible statecraft to bear when it was so plainly obvious at play globally? And that's a hard question to answer, but I think that people should say, yeah, we've got a course correct our approaches and we're learning and we're gonna build expertise and we're gonna bring in the the right voices. But they tend to bring in the same old people that put us in in this hole. So, you know, I I I I'm a proud Canadian.

SPEAKER_00I want them to do well. I don't want to be sharp with them. Um, but we we they've got to bring in updated thinking and new voices and proper experts. You know, they gotta, and I haven't seen that yet.

Aaron PeteThat's one piece. Uh, we talked about it a bit a bit earlier, which is if the whole board gets it wrong, like they should not be encouraged to continue down that track. And I find your ability to kind of prosecute past governments so plainly as like, hey, look at the results. Shouldn't you be able to justify why we are where we are right now? Is something I just don't see a lot of our media do. Like, I don't know if they don't understand the issues, but like you have laid it out more clearly than I've ever heard it discussed.

Aaron PeteAnd I've spoken to economists, I've spoken to journalists, I've spoken to a lot of people who are more in the know than I am. But I feel like in this short conversation, I understand where the hesitancy to continue with the USMCA is, why we are slowed in our growth. And I just wonder how do we go about addressing that? Is that like demonstrating that our politicians have not been successful? Do we like it feels like the US does that more? They're more okay with holding a politician to account and somebody being ostracized in politics as a consequence of a bad decision.

Aaron PeteLike the idea that politicians are held accountable for the war in Iraq and Afghanistan and the things that took place, they're still very much in the zeitgeist of Americans and how they decide who they are going to support and who they're not going to support. And I just don't see that same level of either knowledge base by the public or prosecution by journalists to hold politicians accountable. How do we kind of shake people and get them to wake up from your perspective across the country so we can vote in a more thoughtful way, so we can get better platforms from different parties on how they would propose delivering on these types of issues?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I think you brought up a lot of good things. One, I think the media has to become more savvy on these issues and hold the government to account. I think they are starting to do it this year more because the pro the Trump has laid bare our lack of resilience and the need for sovereignty. And and and sovereignty people, they play rhetorical straw man games. We can't be North Korea. But, you know, I'll just say sovereignty this way. It'd be like somebody saying, you know, honey, why do we need a guard dog? Nobody ever breaks into our house. And I'd say, think about that for a second.

SPEAKER_00And people don't exploit those that are resilient. And so, yeah, we have to build that resilience clearly. I think the conservatives have to put something better in the window. They were all the big free marketeers for the data companies when they were building monopolies, not understanding that in libertarianism, the principle is the sovereignty of the self and the respect for the individual and their family. And libertarians distrust concentrated power.

SPEAKER_00And yet they had nothing to say on these hyperscalers when they became more powerful. They violated your privacy and autonomy and the well-being of your family. The libertarians should be the first ones standing at the at the front saying we have to stop this runaway power. And yet they got, because they have simplistic conceptions of how the world works, say, no, this is a free market. And it's not a free market, it's a social construct with a state back here driving it and hauling out Canada.

SPEAKER_00So I think the conservatives have to not be afraid of an intellectual journey and stop thinking that they learned all they need to learn in high school and put something better on offer as an alternative. Um, so that's part of the problem is if you're not offering something compelling on alternative, if and you know, and then the media should pick pick up more in the critiquing. I've invested a lot in supporting investigative journalism and young scholars and these digital issues and capacity building and think tanks.

SPEAKER_00And so, you know, uh it's a super meaningful life. Like I just have such a fun and meaningful and interesting life. And so I I do understand my role to avail resources to the good people, perhaps do some air cover to push away the bad people, um, and let these people have a much stronger voice in architecting the future they're going to live in. Um but everyone has to do their part. But it's a beautiful country, we love it. Uh, there's so many good people.

SPEAKER_00But I do think your point of sharply going after those things that should be challenged. You know, what one thing I say to people if you look at the bone structure of a whale's fin, it's essentially the same as the bone structure of a human arm and hand. It's almost exactly the same. Evolution is conservative. It's very hard to break free from these old thinking. And we went on a wrong path about 40 years ago, 38 years ago.

SPEAKER_00And we never got, we reinforced it. So it's gonna take a lot of work to break from that thinking. But it used to be in the 30s, you'd see advertisements, exercise your lungs today, smoke a cigarette. And then the person on the Tour de France would get a cigarette, take a couple puffs, and race ahead of everyone else because they just had a cigarette. And then, of course, somebody had the temerity to say, I think smoking's bad for your health. And that person was ostracized until, you know, the facts were overwhelming. So I do think as a country and as a civil society, media, young scholars, political actors, I do think we we owe it to use this opportunity of awakening to raise our game and characterize um the world is as it is, and how do we do better within it?

SPEAKER_00And I think we have all the power to do it. I think we have all the skills. The things I talk about are not about money, they're zero to few dollars. You'll start to see some very quick returns. So mine is an optimistic story. I believe in our people, I believe in our capacity. Uh I think we could be turning it around um very quickly. But it is something else when you see how stubborn they are to do it. It's like, no, I'm gonna keep smoking that pack of cigarettes today because I want to win a day because I want to win that by grace.

SPEAKER_00It's I I must I must tell you, I, I, I do kind of it is something funny because they're they're holding on for just such dear life. But uh, I think it's gonna shift, and there's so many good people, and the the facts are so obvious, it but it is it is something I also tell you.

Aaron PeteTwo more questions for you. One is on media. I would just be really interested in your perspective as like an independent show. I I'm blown away by the amount of money that's holding up and supporting a lot of these legacy media organizations, and just how I don't know, like how lack of diverse perspectives they are, how not eager they are to challenge government from my perspective. Like, that doesn't mean I don't like Mark Carney. I just think it's my job to criticize him and to try and find faults because he's our elected representative and he's holding a position of power.

Aaron PeteAnd I'm supposed to question the decisions they're making, question the opposition, and try and think these issues through. And it just seems really surprising to me that there has been very little interest from my perspective in new media from any of our traditional media organizations in the US. You're seeing the free press purchased by CNBC, you're seeing kind of like a mixing, you're seeing Spotify investing in Joe Rogan, you're seeing a lot of kind of playing with what future media is.

Aaron PeteAnd I don't know if you know who Stephen Bartlett is, but he hosts Diary of a CEO. I think he is the greatest podcaster of our time, just in understanding how to add value to viewers, how to really entrepreneurize the process of creating a good show that's engaging. I know he does a ton of market analytics and how people are engaging with his content behind the scenes. And I just don't see that in Canada right now. Podcasts are either owned and controlled by global news, CBC, and those are kind of your top ones, or you have a few independent shows that are already connected to, as you've kind of described, a think tank or another organization.

Aaron PeteWhat do you think is going on in the media ecosphere? Because I kind of put that at the root of holding government accountable, informing citizens, like it plays such an integral role in how we understand ourselves and what's going on. And I see that as our weakest link right now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and and I I I would say, and I'm going to take this in a path you may not have anticipated, that uh um when you when you think of the creation of because the biggest investment is probably CBC, right? Is they they're getting their one six billion a year or something like that. It was 90 odd years ago, 100 years ago, whatever, give created because there were no Canadian stories out there, and they wanted to tell Canadian stories. And now, and they're a full stack producer of content, and that was the public good.

SPEAKER_00So, what is the public good now? Well, I would say um I use the Environment Canada weather app. It's fantastic, it does everything I need. I use it every day. It doesn't track me, it doesn't surveil me. One of the most surveilling apps is your weather app. So that's a public good. Um, and I I would say, what is the public good in media right now? Well, I would say there's two things. Number one, the presentation engine was taken over by a company that uses it for social media to trigger negative uh emotions to addict you.

SPEAKER_00And and and I I would say that should be a channel that if this is a 12-year-old girl, she can turn into 12-year-old girl channel that is about feeding information that's flourishing and what you may be interested is closer to me, but not exact, and you tune your channel. So the public good is has moved from the full stack content creation, which is not getting a lot of eyeballs, um, to the presentation engine. But where is that strategic discussion? Second of all, Europe is starting to do open um ad stacks where you can have your characteristics for ads.

SPEAKER_00So if Aaron has a as is characterized as having you know an addiction for red gummy bears, and one, that's not true, or two, it is true, but it's a deep, deep, dark secret, you can change that parameter. And um and therefore it becomes open the the ad uh servicing uh structure. And they could actually say, we're gonna fix the because you can't deal with these things ex post because the US comes in and does all this hacking through trade agreements and threats and all that stuff and calls it irritants and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_00So we can't be sovereign on that. However, you can create a competitive alternative. And and I think if you restructure the ad market, I think Facebook and Google take$20 to$30 billion a year outside of Canada, and you start to turn that so that the water starts flowing in another direction, you may find that you've changed their behavior, you're flowing a lot more money. And if you have the presentation engine uh for everyone else, not for yourself, because you don't want to compete with everybody who's doing this content, um, that that you're you're you're servicing public good.

SPEAKER_00So they're they're using an old model of public good in delivery and thinking, where the leverage points have gone through the ad stock and the presentation engine. And but that's again understanding how platforms work in a digital economy. And that should be a public policy discourse in Ottawa, because they clearly want to stop the harms here and they want to get the money. They want to be more sovereign, they want to get hurt less, they want more revenue, but they're coming at it with an old incentives ex post taxing model, and they're getting into the strategic geoeconomic shenanigans, you know, bullying of the US.

SPEAKER_00Um, and there we are. And so, but again, it's that who in that shop thinks about these things, has expertise on these things. Um that's what I mean by if you start to do that, everybody wins. And then how that works in terms of competitive media, well, people will start to consume the media through the presentation engine that interests them to their and you and it becomes a very vibrant, true, you know, vibrant open market for best content.

SPEAKER_00And um yeah, and you can enforce standards and you can attune it to the right audiences. So again, not hard to do. I'm not the first person to think of this. A lot of work's going on in different jurisdictions around the world. I haven't seen it here. We get caught in this loop of online harms and can we do privacy and can we attach digital services and who gets the subsidy? But we're not in a generative, thriving model. It's kind of a reallocation, shrinking, coping rock-a-mole model.

SPEAKER_00And uh, but it's it's people using an old playbook for an old economy. Um and and yeah, so so I didn't answer your question directly, but I I'm trying to say, let's move upstream structurally in responding to these things. And then you'll find it's it's kind of like somebody that says, I've got really bad lungs, I need a bunch of pills and surgeries. And I say, Okay, we can do that, but you really gotta quit smoking. And and so, in a sense, yes, I I understand our current triage, but we have to get to the ex ante upstream cause.

SPEAKER_00And I would argue, what in these realms are we doing ex ante? Now, there's a lot going on in terms of the traditional stuff for mining and resource, other resources and energy and oil and gas, and I'm all for all of that. Um, but in these other realms that we've spent our time talking about today, I'm not seeing any points on the board yet. And and maybe thoughtful discussions with you and other people. And I'm being called a lot to talk these days. Like I'm the biggest keynotes and engagement.

SPEAKER_00So people are realizing, yeah, this is something we should be thinking about. And um yeah, I'm happy to do it. It's a proud, I'm proud Canadian. I love our country. I believe the moral code is you leave a campfire better than you found it. And um this is something I can do. And there's so many good people out there that want a better country. Let's just get the right young people at the table and being heard and being engaged.

Aaron PeteLast question, and thank you so much for your time. This one will be quick. What are your thoughts on the claim of taxing CEOs more and that CEOs make too much money? You mentioned envy earlier, and I think that's a piece of the pie, but we're seeing uh the Green Party in BC talking about taxing the rich. You have Mundomni talking about going after billionaires. Um, you have Bernie Sanders talking about that. It's starting to catch more and more wind. What are your thoughts on CEOs' pay and taxing the rich?

SPEAKER_00Well, um, as I've said before, we only have one marker for our tax competitiveness, and that's the United States. So I could tell you lifetime capital gains is order of magnitude plus bigger in the US than it is in Canada, how they treat these things. So um yes, Canada's just not competitive. Uh now, is US ine inequal? Yeah, it sure has got huge inequality. And I have issues with the inequality, and it's something I uh engage with.

SPEAKER_00But the idea that if you try to tax a CEO, and we're already, you know, the personal taxes are much higher than the US. Um, yeah, all the CEOs are just moved to the US. They can they can say I'm CEO, I live in the US, and other than a few companies that are here for whatever reasons, they'll just move their companies or move themselves to the US. Like I said, people, capital, and money can move, and that's the nature of the world. So um, and and you saw some deeply irresponsible moves by Christian Freeland and Justin Trudeau to drive entrepreneurs away with the capital gains.

SPEAKER_00And and and now we've got this whole pattern of saying I'm going south, and and we have to reverse that, which could take a lot of work, but um uh yeah, I they they would be very counterproductive to tax CEOs more. They just leave and they can. And uh and the companies will leave and the money will leave, and we've seen that. And so yeah, I think you uh, you know, it's a competitive world in these frameworks.

SPEAKER_00So I think you're you're better on trying to grow the pie than to grab the pie. It'll be counterproductive. And I think that's why we're seeing these issues in the country.

Aaron PeteThank you, Jim. This has been one of my favorite interviews today, I think in large part because you think about these issues deeply. And when I ask people about their thoughts on media government subsidies, not to shame any of my past guests, but a lot of them say the same thing. Remove the subsidies and you'll see a flourishing. The way you approach the question is from your understanding of the technology and of what's working in other countries. And it just felt grounded in your own understanding of these issues and what's working and what's not working. And just it felt like you went more to first principles of how did we arrive here?

Aaron PeteAnd it was just very refreshing. And one of my hopes is to interview more CEOs and get the business perspective on some of these issues because it's fine to talk to politicians and journalists, but there's a missing link. And I think that's the business community. And so it's just been a privilege to speak to you today. And I find you to be very thoughtful and meticulous on how you arrive at your conclusions, and as you said, very sharp on what your diagnosis of the issue is. And I just really greatly appreciate that.

SPEAKER_00Very kind of you to say that was a real pleasure to speak with you today. I look forward, I look forward to the next time. Sounds good.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 295. MP Dean Allison: Were Some Canadians Injured by COVID-19 Vaccines?

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 294. Trevor Tombe: Will Canadians Be Financially Better Off in 2027?

    Nov 16, 202657 minAudio

    University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 293. Rob Williams: Who Is Responsible for the Canucks' Collapse?

    Nov 13, 202656 minAudio

    Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 292. Jody Mitic: Retired Soldier on the Heartbreaking Reality of Remembrance Day

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 291. Minister Mandy Gull-Masty: Should We Abolish The Indian Act?

    Nov 9, 202658 minAudio

    Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...

    Credit the people on this episode