288. Tim Caulfield: Why Have Canadians Lost Trust in Experts?
1 hr 7 minAudio
University of Alberta professor Timothy Caulfield discusses institutional trust, COVID-19 vaccine mandates, Joe Rogan, misinformation, Big Pharma and media accountability with host Chief Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Timothy CaulfieldI'm Timothy Caulfield. I'm a professor in the Faculty of Law and the School of Public Health at the University of Alberta. Who can we trust anymore? The body of evidence tells us, you know, if you think about it globally, that much of the distrust that we're seeing right now has been manufactured. It's been manufactured by certain actors and by influencers. I just want to put like some quotes to you who Before you do the quote. I know what you're gonna do. You're gonna quote politicians and scientists who say, get vacuum from Biden to yeah.
Timothy CaulfieldSo you have to be careful with quote farming, right?
Aaron PeteMy concern is like less with people with social media platforms and more like the state's power over people.
Timothy CaulfieldSo the the you know, the little online uh podcaster is not a little thing, right? In my own sphere, um, studies have consistently shown that you know online influencers have a huge impact on health decisions, right? A massive impact on Joe Rogan has a fan, huge impact.
Aaron PeteHuge, a huge impact. He regularly says he's a meathead. He regularly says, like, I'm an idiot, I don't know everything about everything. I'm just speaking with people.
Timothy CaulfieldThis I'm just, you know, I'm a meathead, I'm just asking questions, is an invitation to this false balance, both sides, middle ground fallacy that's fueling so much public discourse right now. So, who would you blame for the polarization?
Aaron PeteTimothy Caulfield, thank you very much for joining us today. Would you mind briefly introducing yourself?
Timothy CaulfieldSure, I'm I'm Timothy Caulfield. I'm a professor in the Faculty of Law and the School of Public Health at the University of Alberta. I'm an author, I you know, and I explore health and science policy, especially around the misinformation space.
Aaron PeteI have a very important question to start with. Who can we trust anymore?
Timothy CaulfieldHoly cow, that's a little question to start with. Exactly. You know what? And I'm I'm gonna turn the question on its head a little bit if I if I might. I I I think that what we've really seen over the last, especially last few years, but I think this has been a phenomenon that has happened over the last six, seven, eight, maybe the last decade. This lowering in trust in institutions, right? This this increasing distrust of institutions. And look, uh there are communities that have historical reasons for being you know, justifiably, you know, not trusting institutions.
Timothy CaulfieldThere are individuals that are in that same place too. But I think all the body of evidence tells us, you know, if you think about it globally, that much of the distrust that we're seeing right now has been manufactured. It's been manufactured by certain actors, by you know, influencers. Um, and we know this because the distrust is not spread equally, right? There's not an equal distribution of distrust. The the distrust has grown within particular sectors of society.
Timothy CaulfieldSo when you ask the question, who can we trust? The answer will be different depending on what community you live in, you know? And so um I think I think there are still trusted voices out there, but it is becoming increasingly difficult to find those voices because our information environment is so chaotic. And we are constantly told, we are constantly told not to trust entities. And that distrust, I once I very recently I gave a talk and I argued that we're living in a distrust economy.
Timothy CaulfieldUm there are these actors benefit from creating distrust so their own narrative, their own agenda, their own products can have space.
Aaron PeteFascinating. I I just kind of want to start maybe by grounding it in my perspective, and then I I want to go through questions, but I want you to pick apart where I'm at because I imagine I'm part of that grouping that's lost a lot of trust. And you might see it, and from the phrasing of like your response, you you framed it as like people are telling me not to trust. But I'll I'll kind of lay out kind of chapters of where I've lost trust in our institutions, and then we'll we'll dive into other questions. But I think the big one, as I'm sure you're you're aware more than most, is COVID, is where we had institutions more than I feel like we had experts, telling us how to think about things.
Aaron PeteAnd the the vilification of people who I found to be good faith actors, asking honest questions, being accused of being anti-vaxxers, um, be like I had a reaction to the first vaccine, and I really struggled. I was fainting a lot, I couldn't think straight. So I didn't get the second vaccine. And I was invited to events, and I said, hey, I actually don't have my passport, not able to attend because of that. And I still have organizations that won't work with me because they think I was driven by an ideological malice against that rather than anything else.
Aaron PeteAnd so just seeing, we know that Justin Trudeau had said before, hey, we're not gonna do vaccine passports because they're gonna be divisive. And then what did he do about a year and a half later? He did the passports and they were divisive, uh, which his original claim lived up to it. But then we've seen different issues arise. How my university uh UBC responded to the discussion I was incredibly disheartened by. I've always remained honest that I think my university education at the Fraser Valley in a Bachelor of Criminology was much more valuable to me because we did debate ideas.
Aaron PeteI debated the idea of whether or not there's systemic racism as an Indigenous person, saying that there isn't systemic racism, to put myself in the shoes of people who might question whether or not that's real. And that was it was incredibly beneficial to my understanding of how to take a position and steel man it and try and understand it deeply. We did not do that at the University of British Columbia in the law program during when governments were making huge decisions about our liberties. During that period, the the classmates I had were saying, if you make me go to school, you're gonna kill my grandma, you hate us.
Aaron PeteAnd so we just had this breakdown. Right now, you may be aware, I've interviewed um people about the unmarked grave story, which is hugely divisive in our country right now. And you have the Liberal Party of Canada, CBC saying, if you talk about this, you're a denialist. You're actually a bad person. And you might actually have to go to jail if we enact this law because of how you think about things. And I've interviewed Francis Widowson, Tim Thielman, Candace Milcom, people who are staunch questioners of the unmarked graves. And they've always said, we don't question the harms of Indian residential school.
Aaron PeteWe don't question that those schools existed and that bad actors existed in them. We question the specific claim around the 215. And I've tried to do that thoughtfully. Um, I push back against their arguments, but there's this kind of institutional bias against those folks and will not speak with them candidly or fairly. And so I do, in kind of response to that. And the last piece I'll share with you, uh, Tim, that I have serious concerns with and why in part I host the show the way I do, is because on CTV News, on CBC, on all of these channels, they bring in lobbyists or people who are campaign managers or people like that to debate the issues, not individuals always like yourself or people who are actually experts in the topic.
Aaron PeteThey'll bring on strategists to say, this is what Pierre Poliev or this is what Mark Carney should be doing. And so you're getting people who are literally funded by campaigns in order to give their political opinion. And so I don't view the news as honest. I view universities, the professors within them. I know a lot of them, they'll message me, hey, you're having more honest conversations than I can have in the classroom. There has been this breakdown. And so I would just land there that, like, when I look at Joe Rogan, who got vilified throughout this, he ended up saying that, hey, COVID shots probably aren't good for kids.
Aaron PeteAnd he ended up being right on that issue. But it was on right on that issue. He was on CNN. Um, it was being pushed by CNN. Well, see, like the the recommendations have since changed in response to that. But I'll let you kind of respond to that and then we can get into more of the specifics.
Timothy CaulfieldLook, I I think that the there's a lot going on in what you just said. Let's start with the debate aspect. I think that there has been, and I've been, you know, targeted with respect to this. Those of us who are concerned about the spread of misinformation, those of us who are concerned about the role that the online media is having in shaping public discourse, um are often held up as some uh as individuals that are trying to suppress um particular viewpoints, or that we are against freedom of expression, or we're about cancel culture.
Timothy CaulfieldWell, this is something that we've actually studied, and we've studied it in the context of COVID. And a lot of the narratives that you just described were, you know, there people have suggested that they were marginalized or silenced. That's not the case at all. They, you know, ended up being a dominant uh narrative. Um, whether you're talking about the Great Barrington Declaration or whether you're talking about perspectives on the harms caused by the COVID vaccine, which are often wildly misrepresented. Um so that's a little bit of a false narrative.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd it's raised specifically to sort of legitimize these views. There was a fascinating study that was done in in um Europe uh a few years ago. I think it was published in Nature Behavioral Medicine, and they asked the public, uh, you know, what do you think? It's a really clever study. What do you think the experts think about the COVID vaccine? So what do you think the public health experts, the you know, the the PhDs, the the individuals who are actually doing the research on COVID, what the COVID vaccine, what do you think they think about the COVID?
Timothy CaulfieldAnd the and the public said, four out of five people, Aaron said, we think the experts are divided, right? Like 50% think this and 50% think that, which couldn't be further from the truth. You know, you know the data, you know, the there is you know almost universal agreement among the biomedical experts um that the COVID vaccine has a very impressive safety profile and has saved millions of lives. Um but the public thought the experts were split.
Timothy CaulfieldSo why am I raising that? Because that is the power of false balance, the power of the middle ground fallacy, the power of both sidism. Um, I'm a huge advocate for freedom of expression. Um, I think the way that we counter, um, and so I bet we're on on I agree with this, the way that we counter uh misinformation is through um more content, accurate content, right? That counters it in the marketplace of ideas. And I think most people advocate for exactly that, right?
Timothy CaulfieldThey advocate for exactly that. Um, the reality, the other the other good news story is that went from that same study, is when you talk about what the scientific consensus says on a topic, first of all, you explain the nature of the scientific consensus. It is not a meta-narrative that we get from the star chamber. You know, here's the memo we're supposed to tell people. It is hundreds, sometimes thousands of studies that point in a particular direction, always contested. That's the nature of science. You explain, you explain what the scientific consensus actually is, and then you explain the degree to which there is one, if there is uh uh scientific consensus.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd even among skeptics, you can change people's minds. So I do think it's important to talk about what the science on a topic actually says. Uh, I do think it's important to counter misinformation when it resides, but I also think we need to be careful about how we represent the debate and the way we talk about the debate to the general public. We just just studied, uh just just published a study just like uh a couple of weeks ago, where we looked at how this is directly on point to your how how you started this conversation, where we looked at how uh discussion about the COVID vaccine was represented in the the mainstream media, right?
Timothy CaulfieldSo not even online, like which we've also studied in the mainstream media, so the primary uh what people think of as the legacy media. And uh we found that it was right out of the gate politicized, right? So, yes, they are they did represent what this the science says, but it very much became a political story, right? Um, almost out of the gate. And I think that's really important because the more these topics become tethered to political identity, the more they become tethered to the community and the team that you belong to, the the the more likely it is going to be a polarized discord discussion, the more likely the discourse is going to degrade.
Timothy CaulfieldUm, and the more difficult it is going to be to be allow people to for their positions to evolve. You can't evolve your position if it's it becomes an ideological flag. And that's exactly what we've seen with so many topics, especially in the health space, but others, obviously, um, they become ideological flags. And we have to avoid that, I think, also in our our public debates. It has to be about the facts, the science, and and how those things are interpreted. I'll stop there, but I could go on.
Timothy CaulfieldI could go on.
Aaron PeteWell, let's keep following up on it. So, who would you blame for the polarization? Because I know that legacy media and politicians will say the people became divided, but the state had done things that had never been done to a to the the world before. Like these things had just never arisen the way that they did, because we have a globalized economy where like countries were all agreeing they were gonna do something to their population in a way that you just couldn't have done in the 1900s.
Aaron PeteYou couldn't have had the control over the population, the way that that control and authority was exercised on churches and in on individuals. And so, of course, once you have your civil liberties questioned or challenged or your ability to go to church, then people go, Well, I'm gonna be I'm gonna raise my flag on this side of the aisle the second you do that to individuals. And so who do you put the onus on for a brunt of that?
Timothy CaulfieldSo I I think this is a really interesting uh question for a whole bunch of reasons, obviously, a lot of layers there, right? First of all, um this is sort of a an associated response to something I said earlier. Often, often those who have advocated for um you know passports and for mandatory vaccines, it was it was presented as if it was a government conspiracy almost, right, to control the population. Um, yeah, I'll be honest, I was involved in some of these conversations.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd there was disagreement, strong disagreement. Like everyone knows, everyone that when I was in those conversations, everyone knows this was an extraordinary measure. No one thought this was something that should be done lightly. And I'll be honest with you, even within the public health community, there's disagreement about when mandatory um vaccine policy should be implemented. Uh, the literature is really interesting on mandatory vaccines. I'm actually amongst the cohort of my colleagues, and I'm not gonna name names, I'm on the more let's be careful side of the equation, um, than those, you know, let's let's implement them.
Timothy CaulfieldUm, but I still think there is a place for mandatory vaccination policy. Um, they it does work, and I want to be careful when I'm gonna define what I mean by work. Uh, having a mandatory vaccine does, in general, whether you're talking about school policy or others, get more people vaccinated. So if there is a crisis and you're trying to get more people vaccinated, mandatory vaccines do work. Of course, as you've highlighted in your question, there are you know fallouts from that that also need to be weighed when you're making a decision to do that, right?
Timothy CaulfieldBut I think it's really important to highlight that when these decisions were made around the world, it was made, you know, and I obviously it wasn't in every room. Or I my sense is uh despite you know the idea that there was some world economic forum or uh conspiracy or some you know national conspiracy, uh though people considered all the above, right? Um studies from the United States have found, for example, with uh mandatory school vaccines, it does increase the vaccination rates, um, which we you know for look what's happening with measles, etc., can have a benefit uh on the population.
Timothy CaulfieldSo I think that's really important, important to recognize out of the gate, because part of that polarized discourse is placing blame blame. Look, polarization has always existed. I know you know that this, it's it's not new, but what has changed is the way we feel about the other, right? So you go back a few decades, there might have even been relatively similar kind of political polarization, but not that affect. Like the other side's the enemy now, right? And it didn't, I think that the degree to which that's true is one of the big differences now.
Timothy CaulfieldSo when we had things like you know, vaccine policies that people disagreed with, it became the other side's the enemy, not that maybe I don't agree, it's a judgment and how you weighed the risks and benefit. It's they're the enemy. So I think it's really important to recognize what really went on and those conspiracy theories about what drove the decision for vaccine mandates need to be, you know, weighed, I think, with some nuance. I'll put it that way. Some nuance. So who's to blame? Okay, so this goes back to what I said at the very, very top.
Timothy CaulfieldThere is a growing body of evidence, and we've even done some research uh on this, that the distrust that we're seeing right now has been largely manufactured, right? And and I'm not just saying that through speculation. We we know uh again, I we shouldn't just stick with vaccines, but uh, there's just so much research on vaccines, so it's a good topic to point to. We know that the rise in vaccination hesitancy around the world, especially in the developed country, but increasingly on planet Earth, has been driven by misinformation, by the spread of misinformation, right?
Timothy CaulfieldA lot of that has come from the United States, but it's starting to come from, you know, all over the world. Um, and we also know that it resides almost entirely on one side of the political spectrum. Not entirely, but almost, right? So that tells us that vaccination, it's a wedge issue now. It's a wedge issue like abortion, gun control, you know, pick your topic. Um, it's a wedge issue. And the distrust that the increase in distrust that has happened, again, has happened almost entirely, not completely, but almost entirely on one side of the ideological spectrum.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd I want to be real, I know it sounds like I'm being partisan, and I don't mean to be, because historically it shifts. I, you know, I often highlight um there there was a study in the United States uh that highlighted that, you know, in the 19 early 60s and 1970s, it was the left, it was the Democrats that were kind of more anti-science and skeptical of science. You know, it's Vietnam War, Agent Orange, you know, uh Watergate. It was that side. And the Republicans were extremely strong institutional science.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd now we have a complete flip that has happened, right? So it's important to recognize that history and context matters. And in my own area, my own area, um, we have also seen that shift. I've lived it, you know, for most of my life, most of my career, I got my hate mail from the left. You know, it was like, oh, you're not, you know, there's different ways of knowing, there's spiritual uh ways to approach health, you know, there are these different kinds of cultural approaches to health. And now it's all I'm getting my hate mail from the right.
Timothy CaulfieldUm, so that's fascinating in itself. But we know that the distrust has been manufactured when you ask the question who to blame. I think we can blame our information environment, the degree to which the algorithms are driven by rage, by fear, by grievance. Um, the algorithms win when we're angry and feel polarized. So the algorithms plus influencers that benefit from distrust, political actors that benefit from distrust, state actors, Aaron, that benefit from distrust.
Timothy CaulfieldYou put those people as a combination, and you see this rise in distrust. Now, I know I'm going on too long, but it's an important question. No, not at all. Um we we say that there's this decrease in trust, but to be fair, some actors or some sectors in Canada and in the United States remain highly trusted. So scientists, healthcare providers, you know, teachers, you know, farmers, nurses, there are communities that remain very, very trusted.
Timothy CaulfieldUm, the trust has gone down uh on a popular, when you measure on a population level, but that decrease in trust has almost happened entirely on one side of the ideological spectrum. Look at data from the United States. Uh, when you look at something like measles vaccination, we've heard about how there's this decrease in uh uptake and decrease in trust in the MMR vaccines. Um, that decrease almost entirely on one side to be the ideological spectrum. And the data here in Canada is very, very similar.
Timothy CaulfieldUm, the one of the strongest predictors of whether you're hesitant or whether you haven't got vaccinated is your political identity. That's true. In both Canada and the United States. So not pointing fingers, because I think I'm not blaming the individuals or saying people are wrong. I'm just saying how where did that distrust come from? The degree, how was it manufactured?
Aaron PeteI just want to follow up on that because I agree with, I certainly put a lot of onus on social media, and there was a lot of stuff coming out in the early days of the pandemic that were completely conspiratorial. World Economic Forum type stuff, I would see on my feed. But I just want to put like some quotes to you, and just like I can see how people who do the quote.
Timothy CaulfieldI know what you're gonna do. You're gonna quote politicians and scientists who say get vaccine, you know, from Biden to yeah. So that you have to be careful with quote farming, right? Because uh there are, you know, let I'm gonna make up a number. I'll do I'll use myself as an example. Okay. Um I've probably said on in in the public 10,000 things about vaccines. You could probably go back and find three or four quotes that are less than ideal and use those, right? Quote find, you know, cherry picking a quote that makes me seem extreme or wrong, and and use that to say this is why people don't dis why people distrust the government, right?
Timothy CaulfieldUh then what happens is influencers pick up on those quotes and they talk about them on their podcasts, they use them, they create memes about them, and they share them. And that then you get the powerful confirmation bias comes into play, and everyone starts pointing, happened to Fauci, it happened to um our our pub all of our public health authority individuals. Um so, yes, uh how we talk about vaccines and how we talk about the state of the science matters. And I think we need to be really careful not to overstate the science, uh, the state of the science.
Timothy CaulfieldI think we could have, like my best book is called The Certainty Illusion, we could have done a better job job talking about the scientific uncertainty. Um, but but um, you know, is we're in the middle of a pandemic and people are are talking.
Aaron PeteAbsolutely. So I'm not raising health officers or anybody like that. I just think what what I recall, and you may have it, we have different lived experiences. What I heard from people privately in regards to the pandemic, were I just I'm a little hesitant. It's new, I don't feel comfortable. Not people who were like, I think that we should go after the vaccinated people. They're so dumb, we shouldn't even have like if that was coming from one area, and so I'll just give you a few.
Aaron PeteJustin Trudeau, they are extremists who don't believe in science, they're often misogynists, also often racists. Do we tolerate these people? Um, because of the risk posed to all of us by unvaccinated people, people are getting angry at them. It's time to start shaming them from Don Lemon. Um, some of these comments, I just think like I'm sure you saw people put those labels on their like their cars and stuff and started saying, like, I am like part of the problem or something like that on their license plate after Justin Trudeau made those comments, because I there was a vilification that I'm sure you know happened to people who did not get vaccinated in a way that I really I think also helped politicize this.
Aaron PeteSo while I I do put a lot of responsibility on social media, I think like I have the timeline here. We have a quote from Justin Trudeau, January 14th, 2021, saying having to take um more extreme measures that could have real divisive impacts on the community are not worth taking. And then later we saw it come in. Um, in May 2021, he said, We're not a country that makes vaccination mandatory, for example, but we want to encourage everyone to get it.
Aaron PeteAnd then by August 13th, 2021, he began to take steps, and the federal government began to take steps to do that. And so it was a 180 from our prime minister acknowledging um in May that this would be divisive, um, and then a decision to proceed with it. And so, like, I know you were aware of that, and I'm sure those were some of the conversations that happened behind the scenes, but that's what I think some people go to um when they respond to that. And I'd just be interested in in how do we like I agree with you. I think it's happened, it's in the past now, but how do we rebalance that and make sure that there are there are systems in place in the future to make sure that there is healthy debate?
Aaron PeteBecause I don't think you and I disagree that just the rollout, the communication style, I just think had a lot to be desired. I would have liked to see Dr. Bonnie Henry sit down with a concerned citizen and really like answer some of those questions. Vet it, make sure they're reasonable questions, make sure they're not worried about the um World Economic Forum. Or like chip in the vaccine or something like that. Exactly. Like make sure they're grounded in reality, but like have those people seen so that when somebody is watching who's afraid feels represented by the person asking the question.
Aaron PeteAnd I always go back to this because it was a really important moment to me. I know people hate Justin Trudeau right now, but when he used to do those sit-downs where there was a room full of people and he was in the center, and some person would put up their hand, and I'm sure they selected the people beforehand and vetted the questions, but there was just something cathartic about seeing your leader surrounded by their citizens and answering questions. And I just didn't, I watched the news every day trying to figure out what I was allowed to do, mask, no mask, what's going on. Um, but I just didn't feel that the public debate was strong enough to quell a lot of these fears.
Timothy CaulfieldYeah, I mean, that was not an ideal quote. You know, I can remember that. It's like, you know, it was not an ideal quote. Because look, I I it's hard. Some you're in the middle of the pandemic, and and it can be very hard not to get frustrated with people making decisions that aren't that you feel, that you feel aren't evidence-based and you fe personally feel might hurt you and the community more broadly. But I do think what we we we need to always sort of check that. And you know, I have to remind myself of it.
Timothy CaulfieldI'm not ideal. I've I've you know sometimes, you know, rage posted too. Um, I think that we need to check that because shaming um it's that's not a strategy that's going that's going to work ever, right? We want to engage in conversation. And I think the better strategy is don't blame the people that that have these feelings. You know, talk about what the evidence actually says and talk about the individuals that maybe are spreading the misinformation. Um, you know, that's where the energy, uh, the anger energy maybe should be focused, should be focused more, especially if they're doing it to to create polarization, you know, to exploit a situation.
Timothy CaulfieldAs you probably know, you know, studies have shown a lot of the content about the vaccines was spread by state actors, right? That wanted to create division and polarization in Canada and the United States also. You know, they wanted to throw sand in the gears to create the situation that you and I are talking about. Um, they won. You know, that that strategy worked. You know, here we are, years later, still talking about it, still a polarized, polarizing discussion, despite the fact that you know the COVID vaccines are probably the most studied biomedical intervention in human history.
Timothy CaulfieldWe have so much evidence, we have safety monitoring going on, and still we're having we're still we're having these these conversations. So I do think that's can I just quickly jump in?
Aaron PeteLike I would just like again counter that with like the trucker protest, it's come, I'm sure you saw it came to light that like they were not in like in the wrong the way that that was pitched at the beginning. And so, like again, my concern is like less with people with social media platforms and more like the state's power over people. And then they give a narrative that these people were doing horrible things and starting to act and they needed the emergency powers act, and then like a whole review comes out that says, like, almost none of what the government claimed on stage that happened happened.
Aaron PeteAnd so, like, I'm just I like I'll always side with the little podcaster over the state when actions like that are taken, because obviously it's the people with the guns and the authority to arrest people, debank people that need to be worried about more than it's the person with a microphone online getting a couple thousand views.
Timothy CaulfieldWell, look, we know that podcasters and influencers have a huge impact in Canada. I don't know if you've saw the study that came from McGill in Toronto and Blanky on the name of the uh the institute, where they found that online influencers, talking to one now, talking to one now, um, have a greater have did you see the study? Have a greater impact on public discourse in the political sphere than the media or even politicians. Like they have so the the, you know, the little online uh podcaster is not a little thing, right?
Timothy CaulfieldIn my own sphere, um, studies have consistently shown that you know online influencers have a huge impact on health decisions, right? A massive impact on and there's a little bit of a paradox there, and it's kind of funny because you you asked if we went out, we interviewed a thousand Canadians and said, you know, do you trust uh Tom Brady? We'll say that, someone who I love, Tom Brady on health. People say, no, I don't. But we know that that in that he might have an impact. We can measure the impact that they have on beliefs.
Timothy CaulfieldJoe Rogan has a fantastic, huge impact, huge, huge impact on so there's a fascinating study that came out in JAMA, Journal of American Medical Association, just I'm gonna say three or four months ago, where um he had Mel Gibson on his show talking about ivermectin and cancer. There is zero evidence, zero evidence that ivermectin can cure autism or cancer or COVID, right? Um it's become an ideological flag. But that discussion with Joe Rogan and Mel Gibson um resulted in a spike in the prescriptions, not just the sale, the prescription of ivermectin for cancer, despite the fact that you know there's studies and experts and research institutions that tell us that you know this is not not a good idea.
Timothy CaulfieldUh, there was a the Edelman Trust Barometer. I don't know if you know familiar with this international survey that happens every year. They recently came out with, and this is right on point, Aaron. You're you're gonna love this data. There uh they came out with uh their their latest one that I think did it come out in February? I want to say February, March of this year, um, where they went specifically to this question. So they said, um, you get advice from the medical, your doctor, the medical community, or you get advice from online. And they wanted to get a sense of what do the public, what does the public do when there's this conflicting information out there?
Timothy CaulfieldAnd 51%, I think they it's 16,000 people they they survey. So it's not an insignificant uh number. Uh, they found that 51% of the population said they will listen to their MD. Only 51%. And in Canada, I think it was only 42%. And in the United States, I think it was only 37%. Now, look, I don't think you should blindly listen to your doctor. That's not that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying that that demonstrates the power of these online influencers to shape public discourse, and it's increasingly so, right?
Timothy CaulfieldSo, yeah, uh the government may have a narrative, but the online the narrative pushed by the online influencers, and many of them don't follow journal. I'm not saying this is you. Many don't follow journalistic standards, they don't follow scientific standards, etc., etc., etc. So what those, you know, on online influencers say, not insignificant. On c on the contrary, it's becoming a dominant voice.
Aaron PeteI agree with you. I guess you and I both know like Ivermectin isn't considered dangerous or a huge risk to take in comparison to other things. So if you were to juxtapose the example of Joe Rogan and I think you said Mel Gibson uh talking about Ivermectin, to what Purdue Pharma did to people and how it reshaped our our North America in a lot of ways. And the use of drugs.
Timothy CaulfieldBecause one of the great challenges is look, Big Pharma's been a bad actor, right? Um, you know, you could I've written about it. I've written about it, right? Um, they've been a bad actor. And so you can always point to those those bad actors, right? But but a lot of these medical interventions that are that um they they're studied with you know, using a variety of methods, a variety of individuals, uh, you know, public money, private money, public private money, studying, uh, studying these interventions.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd of course, there's this massive paradox, right? Because often the exact same people that won't are are hesitant with vaccines, or I'll even go so far as to say, are anti-vax. Those individuals, and let's let's be honest, like vaccines are the most studied biomedical intervention. They're there's you know independent safety monitoring, um, on and on and on, right? Unlike almost every other biomedical intervention. But these individuals are anti-vax. So they won't, they won't take the highly regulated, highly studied safety monitored intervention, but they will take unproven ivermectin, unproven, they'll inject themselves with an unproven um uh peptide.
Timothy CaulfieldUh, they'll, you know, they'll take unproven supplements that are known to cause harm. So you have so, yes, what you say is really important, right? That that their big firm has been been a bad actor, but it's not like that is being deployed um in a kind of conceptually consistent manner. You know, these are these individuals also not, you know, using Viagra? Are these individuals also not using testone replacement therapy? Are these individuals also not using Botox? Are they not using uh peptides? On and on and on.
Timothy CaulfieldSo why am I raising that? Because we know that it's more than just the idea of this pharma conspiracy, there's something else going on. Otherwise, um that concern would be deployed in a more conceptually consistent manner, and it never is.
Aaron PeteWell, I guess I would the only other piece I would add is the financial benefit, right? We know that Purdue made made billions of dollars from their approach specifically with uh um not heroin. What was the drug that they were delivering to people? It wasn't uh I'll have to look it up. But they they had gotten people to use drugs um as a way of coping with pain, um, and then they became addicted to that and made a lot of money from that. Joe Rogan, when he speaks to Mel Gibson about using ivermectin, he makes nothing personally, financially, from that.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd regularly says, designed a Spotify contract for was it 150 million dollars making that number up? You know, and and also a lot of the people that are pushing this misinformation, they sell supplements. Like, um, and I I'm not again not just speculating about this, is something you know, people have looked at this systematically. So many of the voices that are pushing the anti-vax rhetoric sell supplements, completely unproven supplements, right? So there is a conflict there. People, people choose, and uh by the way, I'm not saying either one of those is good.
Timothy CaulfieldI'm not defending, I'm not defending Purdue. Far from it. You know, this is something I've been very critical of in my career. Um but people deploy that concern about about conflict of interest very selectively, right? They deploy it in a way that you know fits their narrative. And we all do it. Like we all do it, right? We all do it.
Aaron PeteInteresting. Yeah, because I guess like the challenge with trying to catch somebody like Joe Rogan is he regularly says he's a meathead. He regularly says, like, I'm an idiot, I don't know everything about everything. I'm just speaking with people. Uh he does like what like an episode on who built the great pyramids to like other things. So, like, he's not a person who takes himself super seriously. And so I and I imagine your pushback and frustration would not be like that, but like that approach gives people a lot of trust in you, and therefore um they're more likely to trust you because it doesn't feel like you're forcing yourself uh on them.
Aaron PeteAnd just to clarify, it was oxy uh cotton that was uh the thing that Purdue was pushing people on.
Timothy CaulfieldBut look, the other pushback is we know that he has has an impact, right? Um, yeah, wellness influencers, and again, just using my space as an example from Gwyneth Paltrow forward, have always used that, saying, look, you know, I'm just giving, you know, my perspective, um, I'm you know, filling a need. Um, but we know that it's having an impact. Um Joe Rogan must know like that this is going, you know, the Ivermectin thing is going to be controversial and it's gonna help, you know, get clicks and views, right?
Timothy CaulfieldUm and this, I'm just, you know, I'm a meathead, I'm just asking question, is an invitation to this false balance, both sidism, middle ground fallacy that's fueling so much public discourse right now. Um and it's not like the discussion with Mel, you know, Mel Gripson was completely unhinged, right? It wasn't like it was a thoughtful analysis of the existing data. I would be less critical, right? If someone said, Oh, here's the animal studies that we've done, you know, here's the speculation as to why it might work, it probably won't work, you're gonna have to pay for it.
Timothy CaulfieldYou know, that's very different. Like misinformation is disempowering, right? It takes away people's autonomy because they're, you know, they it's lies. It's it's making it more difficult for people to be well informed to make autonomous choices about their health.
Aaron PeteTim, I did not expect this conversation to go here, but I'm really enjoying the back and forth. And I think I'm actually the perfect person for you to push back against. One term, one, one term I'm actually personally like just don't believe is a useful term is the term misinformation. And I want to get your take on that.
Timothy CaulfieldOkay, another great question, Aaron. Um, and you know what? Um this is maybe this doesn't surprise you. That's also true in even even in the in, let's call it the misinformation community, right? They're misinformation researchers, um, misinformation um uh policy people. There is a discussion about that term, you know, there really is. And so on the one hand, on the one hand, um, people don't like the term for two reasons. And one I think is more legitimate than the other. Uh so let's go with the the the the the reason why the more legitimate concern.
Timothy CaulfieldThe first one is it's too broad. It's too broad. And some scholars and some policymakers, you know, are just think that we should focus on disinformation. So this is um lies and twisted science, et cetera, that is the the purveyor knows is a lie, right? And they're deploying it with the knowledge that it's a lie for personal gain or political gain or whatever, right? So focus on disinformation. Whereas misinformation, the broader term, could also apply to individuals that, you know, they they are they don't know it's a lie, they believe it, and they're just doing what they think is best for themselves and their community, right?
Timothy CaulfieldUm, that's that's sort of a broader definition. And I use the term misinformation in the broad sense. Um, and I and I think a critique of me doing that is is welcome, right? Because I do think we need to think about this because it's become such a big issue. Um I I think it's we use and I use the broader term is we need an umbrella term. And and for the pre people that receive that information, uh, that's what matters, you know, whether it's true or not, that's what really matters. The other reason I use the broader term, and I and I'm not just saying this through speculation, this is through you know, studying this area on and on.
Timothy CaulfieldMost of the of the misinformation that does harm is demonstrably false. Like it's flat earth kind of stuff, right? And so I don't buy the crit, you know, the critique that, well, who who why do you get to decide it's it's misinformation? And you know, those that that critique I think is valid around around the edges, but most of the of the misinformation that's doing real harm in this current moment is stuff that's demonstrably false, right? And so calling it misinformation, I think, is you know, for brevity's sake, is is fine.
Timothy CaulfieldThe critique that uh the other critique that I don't buy is that the idea of misinform the word misinformation has been kind of weaponized by those who are trying to stop the crit critics. Just like the the term fake news was kind of monopolized by Trump and MAGA, the word misinformation, the same thing has happened, right? They've they've made it into um a a word that rep that is you know woke or are politically polarizing.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd I don't think we should, you know, by not using it, those people who are trying to chill the discourse are winning. They're winning, right? So I I don't buy I don't buy that. Um increasingly, so having said all that, Aaron, uh when I talk in the public, I increasingly use words like like lie, something that, you know, I they words that are sharper and go to the to whether this is true or not. But I I do want to come back to this.
Timothy CaulfieldI know I'm going on a little bit, but I I love this topic. Maybe you can see this. Um I I do think that we need to recognize that very often this is about stuff that is demonstrably false, right? I don't think we should move away from we're not talking about. For example, who should get the COVID vaccine? You know, what population would benefit now, you know, most from the COVID? You can have a reasonable conversation about that, right? You know, should it be out risk? You know, when I have strong views about it, but I think you could put a number of scientists or vitamin D, like who should be getting vitamin D supplement?
Timothy CaulfieldWe could have a reasonable conversation about that. And I shouldn't call someone who disagrees with me, you're spreading misinformation, right? That's not the kind of stuff we're talking about. We're talking about things that are demonstrable. The COVID vaccine is not causing turbo cancer. The COVID vaccine is not resulting in sudden death. There's zero evidence of that. Like zero. There never has been. The the MMR vaccine does not cause autism. We have no evidence to support that claim. It's a it's a lie, it's always been a lie. So I think we should focus on the big stuff before we you know worry about these things at the margins where that critique about the the the phrase, uh the word misinformation, I think has more power.
Timothy CaulfieldSorry, I went on way too long here and there. I apologize. You kind of wound me up a little bit.
Aaron PeteNo, you you you hit the nail on the head, which is uh if you're going to say that I'm like it sounds like we have different understandings of what was good for youth and uh the COVID vaccine. If you think I'm wrong, uh just say you think I'm wrong. Like saying, like, if I heard somebody say, like, oh, Aaron's a purveyor of misinformation from that, I'd be like, I have tons of different conversations and I have tons of different thoughts. Everything I say is misinformation. That's how I and you kind of described like it gets used often so broadly as to not mean as much because it's hard to know.
Aaron PeteLike, is everything Joe Rogan's ever said misinformation? Is it like certain pieces? Like, that's where, like, to me, if you think he's wrong on something, and I'm not saying you specifically, but the the general you, just go after what I said and say, I'm a liar, I'm wrong, uh, I don't have the facts about like that that the adding the teeth to it, I think, is important. But I find in news media so often people go, oh, like Joe Rogan's a purveyor of misinformation. And it's like, on certain points, you may argue, absolutely he is, but when you just say it so broadly, it just makes it sound like you don't like the guy.
Aaron PeteLike it doesn't, it doesn't give enough meat to the bones for me to be convinced that you actually have a substantive argument in it to to like actually go toe to toe. And I know you can, but so many people who use the word so often just kind of throw people into buckets that I just don't find it like informative when when people use that term.
Timothy CaulfieldIt it has it is fascinating. And you know, I've watched sort of the evolution of the term misinformation. I've been researching this area for a long time, and most people didn't care about it. You could say this is misinformation, and be, you know, it was like a niche topic, right? So it's fascinating for me to see that term become sort of central to public discourse about all the things that we're tackling, uh, we're tackling today. I don't have a problem saying Joe Rogan is a purveyor of misinformation because he has been a purveyor of misinformation, not every episode, but um, he has been a purveyor of misinformation.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd and um, I do agree with you that the term shouldn't be used as sort of a global insult to silence people. And there is a very interesting irony that's happening here because, and again, I've experienced this personally, um those exact people who critique the term often use it as a weapon, right? So, you know, Caulfield, he's the spreader of misinformation, right? So it's really sad that it's come to that, right? And I think we have to try to um own the term again, the those who are trying, you know, who are trying to do rigorous work in this area.
Timothy CaulfieldUm, not everyone's gonna agree with us, but let's, you know, back up our claims and and try to reclaim it with substance.
Aaron PeteAnother piece I'd be interested, because we're kind of talking about the media sphere and how it's working. One of my personal predictions is we're in a time of great transition. And Canada, um, from my perspective, with how they've supported traditional media, has just slowed the process. But that we're kind of going through this wave where, like, yeah, cable news is kind of dying. I think everybody knows that. And so we do need to transition to something where people can watch it on YouTube. But then we need to build in the same types of guardrails that traditional media had, and there's just been no force and effect.
Aaron PeteLike if CTV news was to go, we're going online fully now, we're we're done with cable news, we're gonna move in this direction. Cable news can error stuff, but we're going online. Then you have, but they have not, I've watched them not like adapt. They don't do good thumbnails, they don't do good marketing on their stuff. So they just haven't figured out how to pitch people the news episode in the first minute of the show. Like those types of kind of technical things you have to do for YouTube. And so you have people like myself who I I often worry about my role in this. Like, I want to make sure I'm a good faith actor. I've interviewed journalists.
Aaron PeteHow do I do this properly and ethically? I try and have people like yourself on where you're you're the main voice. I'm asking questions, but you're you're giving more of the insights. But I do see people who have just like, oh, if I say the most extreme thing, you get more views, and then people tune into the next episode, and you can, I would have grown much faster had I taken that avenue. And so and there's no incentive to, there's a disincentive to take the route I'm taking, which is slower growth. People regularly comment, like, oh, you should be bigger, but it's like, but I don't want to say a crazy thing just to get views.
Aaron PeteLike, you want to be ethical with your voice and responsible. So we're kind of in this transition where like this is where it's going, but there's not the safeguards and and rails in place and the personal ethics and accountability that people have in order to want to do that in a good way. One of the people I've really enjoyed, and I'd be interested if if you followed him at all, is Diary of a CEO, because it seems like he's got um, he's got more, he's in the UK, he's one of the most popular um shows. He he seems to do a better job of trying to ground the conversation in the evidence, and then people kind of criticize it from there.
Aaron PeteSo I'd just be interested in do you think we're in a transition and and how do we support that transition and encourage people who have independent shows like this to move in that direction, to follow best practices? Like, I don't see kind of a united front where if you're starting a YouTube channel, here are kind of the best practices on how to be ethical and responsible with it. Like I think that would be helpful for people in order to keep not only their show grounded, but also I don't want to be a person who looks back on an episode and goes, wow, I was just doing it for clicks.
Aaron PeteWow, I'm just an empty person who's just chasing the next view. Like you want to be able to have do this all with some integrity, but really there's nobody there to support you or kind of give you best practices from the outset. And everything's just taking off on this side. Like there's a lot of opportunities to grow with YouTube and stuff. And there's just nobody, there's no kind of, hey, let's try and do this in a good way. Leadership from Canada, from the news organizations, from anybody saying, hey, if you're gonna do this, here's how to do it right.
Timothy CaulfieldYeah, I think we are. There's no doubt. There's no doubt that we are in a in a transition. You know, you're living it, right? You're living it. Um, I have a lot of concerns, you know, and you've outlined some of them. The lack of standards for sure, right? You know, there is, you know, journalistic standards mean something. They mean something. The other thing I'm worried about that you didn't touch on is um the lack of journalism, right? So, what do I mean by that? So many you know, Substack voices, so many online influencers, they don't have a, they're not finding journalists on the ground to collect objective information that can inform um conversations, right?
Timothy CaulfieldAnd the more the money flows away from the entities that are doing that, that have someone in Gaza, that have someone in Ukraine, that are interviewing scientists on the ground, that are going to laboratories, they're going to hospitals, right? The more that money flows away from those institutions towards um, you know, entities that aren't doing that, they're just really aggregating information and you know, putting a spin on it, um, the more we're gonna, you know, we're losing our our our touch on reality, I guess is one way to one way to put it.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd we just become this opinion echo chamber, which is is not a good thing. So I'm worried about that. Number two, and I thought this is where you were gonna go with it, Aaron, is AI. You didn't even say that, you didn't even say uh AI. And I thought that's where you were going. Um, AI is just like um gonna change all of the above, right? All of the above. You have, you know, sub so many substacks are you can wake up in the morning and go, um hey, Chat GPT, do a summary of the news today with a rage bait left-leaning uh uh vibe in my voice, or a right wing rage baiting uh vibe.
Timothy CaulfieldUm put it out and charge people for it. And that that a you know, that chat bot is going to go to all the newspapers that have journalists um that you know, just gonna take those that the content from there and they're going to monetize it, right? So it's it's a real, real problem. And the other thing, of course, is AI is going to make all the misinformation stuff that we talked about even worse. So there was a study that was done by Angus Reed that came out just a couple months ago where um it asked the uh Canadians about AI, and you know this, you've probably even done a show on it.
Timothy CaulfieldA lot of anxiety about AI in not just in Canada but around the world. A lot of anxiety. But what they found was 95%. Think about that. 95% of Canadians are worried about AI misinformation, right? And they think AI is gonna make misinformation. You know, you don't get that kind of bipartisan numbers in Canada very often. You know, we were talking about how the word misinformation was polarizing, and I think you're exactly right about that. You know, if we went back in time even two years and asked that exact same question about just the word misinformation as opposed to AI misinformation, you would get a polarized response, right?
Timothy CaulfieldYou would get a polarized response. Now, um, because of AI, you get almost you get bipartisan support. And I've seen I've seen studies from the US similar, not quite as high, but similar, right? Um, so I think the Canadian public is right, and evidence tells us they're right, but uh that it might also be a policy opportunity to create the standards that you are you are are talking about right now. Um, and by the way, and you probably know this, but people cannot tell the difference. They think they can. There's this huge Dunning-Kruger effect that's happening.
Timothy CaulfieldPeople think they can tell the difference, they can't tell the difference, they can't tell the difference with written word, with audio, with pictures, with video, increasingly with video. In my space, there's now all these AI influencers. Have you seen them? Any of them? No. They look incredibly real, right? I think here's my dystopian prediction for the future. I hope I'm wrong. I hope I'm wrong. Um, a couple years from now, there is going to be an AI influencer that is specifically targeting you. You know what I mean? Like they're just gonna create an AI influencer that is, you know, plays to your, that plays to your rage, your fears, your concern, your political leaning, you know, whatever it is.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd it's gonna offer a supplement at the end of its pitch. But that's where we're going. So we're absolutely in in a transition. Um, the good news is, um, the good news is, and this kind of builds on something you said too, um, because I you always like to have a little bit of good news, right? Is that uh there are more voices out there, right? I like that. You know, they're young voices, diverse voices, voices with different perspectives. That's a good thing. And and I, you know, I I as I said, I've been at this a long time. It wasn't always like that.
Timothy CaulfieldYou know, I think that we're having so many people engage in the conversations that we're having right now, that's a good thing.
Aaron PeteOne of the pieces I really admire about your approach is that you've kept a list of things you've changed your mind about. And I imagine you get asked that a fair bit, but what's one of the most consequential things on that list that you changed your mind about?
Timothy CaulfieldUm can I say I'll I'll give you a grab bag, okay? Grab bag. Um, one that seems kind of har harmless, but it's not. I used to make fun of walkers, people walking, you know, which is I know that sounds like a little thing, but it's not. So I was, you know, I thought the data, so this is a good example of my own cognitive bias, right? Um, I love exercise. I always have. My my partner does, my wife does too. You know, so I've always loved it. So I thought, unless you're doing it real, Aaron, it doesn't count, right? That's complete BS, right?
Timothy CaulfieldAnd the growing body of evidence tells says that. So I've changed my mind on that. Let me give you another one, that a more recent one. GLP1s. Okay, so when they first started rolling out, um, maybe it's because of part of the things that we've talked about already. I I always think there's too much hype. You know, it's the effect size is overplayed, everyone says everything's a revolution, and um and so I was skeptical, right? I was wrong about that. You know, I was wrong about that. Um, so I think you need to always be humble and to remember that um that uh science changes.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd you know, you you were talking about, you know, Trudeau, and I'm not, I don't want to support this um uh, but I think changing your mind based on the evidence changing should be a badge of honor. It shouldn't be portrayed as flip-flopping, it should be a badge of honor. You should explain why you changed your mind. Um, but it's people shouldn't be damned for it. They should be celebrated. When the evidence changes and you change your mind, that's a good thing.
Aaron PeteI guess on that note, I also feel like we need to do a better job of tracking who got it right. Like when it was the most controversial, when it was the toughest, what was the person's position, and were they correct or incorrect, and do it across different issues so that you can understand. But one of my big concerns is that people move the goalpost. Um, I like I watch a lot of the UFC, and so uh Dana White had come out and made a comment when he started uh his new boxing company, Zoofa Boxing, and said, Judge me by the end of the year.
Aaron PeteJudge me by the end of the year on what we're able to put together. Well, it's now October, and he said, judge me over the next couple of years. And he moved the goalpost ever so slightly as to say, Don't judge me just on this year, because I don't think I did that well. And so I I worry that we don't do a good job of tracking people when they got it wrong. But also, did they, to your point, did they just own up to it? Did they just go, like, hey, I I was over my skis on this, I was incorrect, um, and I shouldn't have done that. Like, I came on the show, I was very frustrated by people's reaction to DRIPA at the beginning, and I just felt like it was another thing.
Aaron PetePeople in BC, we have this law on the Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People, and I thought people were just overreacting to the law. And so I kind of made some snarky comments on Twitter, and then I came on the show and immediately started with like, I was wrong. There are reasonable concerns that legitimately we can discuss here, and I'm gonna go through them now. Just like owning that helps people know, like, oh, you're like a good faith actor in a way that like I can have more confidence. What's your thoughts on that?
Timothy CaulfieldYeah, I this is a really interesting question. And and I think that I I agree that you should always talk about the evolution of your thinking. I I think it goes to that idea of, you know, I work in the biomedical space, so I'll use this language, that scientific humility idea. There's really interesting research, Aaron, that says that you know, that scientific humility, having that characteristic, um, has a whole bunch of positive uh attributes associated with it. And one, you know, not falling for misinformation, being more open to science as it evolves, et cetera, et cetera. But I do think we need to be careful to not valorize an individual um just because they got it right.
Timothy CaulfieldYou know, the the I hate cliches, I hate them, I try to avoid them, I don't use it anyway. The broken clock cliche, you know, that um even a broken clock is uh, you know, right once a day, um, or twice a day, I guess. Um that that is a mistake. So the example I often use is um, let's say there is a weather uh institute, and they use AI and all the very best um science to determine the weather, and they say, tomorrow it's not going to rain.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd then you go to this, you know, this individual that reads the tea leaves, right? And and uses fur from rabbits or something, and then decides, you know, tomorrow um it is going to rain. I want to make sure I get that right. I can't remember what I said about the institute, the weather institute. And and if this individual turns out to be right, that doesn't mean we should ignore the the weather institute and start listening to individuals that read tea leaves to predict the weather, right? That doesn't mean that at all. Um you try to make the best decision you can with the available evidence at the at the time.
Timothy CaulfieldBut you should say that. You should say, given the available evidence I have right now, this is the decision that we're making. And Aaron, if you don't buy that, we're paralyzed. We're paralyzed. No one, you know, we wouldn't be able to build bridges. You know, no one goes, I was joked that no one goes on all knowledge is relative airline, right? We don't, and uh, you know, the Bernoulli effect is just an idea. You know, no one does that. But when something becomes a wedge issue, all of a sudden people, you know, have these kinds of conversations.
Timothy CaulfieldAnd I think we need to avoid, we need to try to avoid that. So when you're going back saying, okay, who was right, who was wrong, I do think you need to put a lot of context in that. I do like the idea of talking about the evolution of ideas. You know, it's funny because I do that with sports casters. I don't know if you do that. Like the sportscasters say, oh, the the Patriots are gonna lose for sure against the Bills, and then the Patriots win and they reflect. I you're right. It gives them more credibility. And I think that is true regardless.
Aaron PeteI agree. And sorry, I just I didn't mean on like one issue, then they become the hero of the story forever. I more meant like if you're like a commentator like like myself. People do do that. I I believe you. But I think like if you're like if I'm a commentator and I say it should be like I did a breakdown on Dripa and I say this is what I think, and then I get it wrong, I should A come out. But then if somebody had like a chart and it was like Aaron got this wrong, this wrong, this wrong, this wrong, this wrong, I should be, I should give up my YouTube channel. Like I should, I've lost credibility, I should walk away because I've lost the public's trust.
Aaron PeteLike I've I've not been able to predict or or have any ability to look outwards consistently, where I think that that's how we should be able to judge, particularly news, news coverage people is like, are they getting issues right and helping you make informed? Because that's that's the the business that I think I'm in, is like, am I helping people make more informed, thoughtful decisions, or am I setting them up for worse? And if I'm having on the wrong guests and asking the wrong questions and making people make bad decisions when they go to the grocery store or something, like then I should stop doing what I'm doing because I'm actually doing a disservice.
Aaron PeteAnd we should do a better job of it in some way tracking that because, like, as you said, like one organization that I respect, but I disagree with a lot is Juno News. I don't know if you know Juno News, um, but they're um a news organization and they just keep posting things about like the Cow Chin decision means everybody's losing their land, Dripa means the government controls everything, and it's just like you guys are just wrong. Like, and I'm happy to debate you, but I just like disagree with you fundamentally. And if you get this, this, and this wrong, I like I don't think you should be as trusted as you are.
Aaron PeteAnd so, like, I I think there should be a way of like more tracking organizations and people on that kind of front. Well, I you know, I I wish you were right.
Timothy CaulfieldBecause if you look at what's happening, uh I it's so easy to pick on the United States, but we're gonna I'm gonna do it anyway. Um people do track how often RFK Jr.'s been wrong, like exactly wrong, not just kind of wrong, exactly wrong. And he must know it's a lie, you know, hundreds of times, right? There's still a large sector of the population that believes him. Look at Donald Trump. Like every single time he opens his mouth, there's a you know, something that's not true that falls out, right? Um still people believe him.
Timothy CaulfieldUm or they're draw, I think more importantly, they're drawn to his his his gestalt, his the gist of what he's saying. There's this fascinating research. Um Stephen Lewandowski from um and others have have worked on this, um, where they talk about the difference between belief speaking and fact speaking. And have you heard about this? So in the past, uh journalism and media uh and really just commentary more broadly leaned on fact speaking. So the you know, the what there was the facts were tethered to reality, you know, tethered to the facts, tethered to evidence, tethered to science.
Timothy CaulfieldUm, that's fact speaking. Um belief speaking is starting to take over where people just say it emphatically enough and with enough passion that people believe it. Tucker Carlson, very good at this, right? Just say one of my favorite examples of it is immigrants are eating cats and dogs, right? Remember that? Um, I I don't think anyone really believes, you know, maybe I I should take that back. They maybe there are some people that believe that literally, they believe the gist of what was being said, right?
Timothy CaulfieldAnd um so unfortunately, you know, I wish uh you were right. I are and I agree with what you're saying, and I'm glad that people are keeping a track of all the demonstrably false things that have been said. But that's just one piece of the puzzle. You know, people are still drawn to the gist of whatever the message is, um, regardless of whether it's true or false. And and unfortunately, I worry that kind of discourse is going to continue to dominate our information space.
Aaron PeteTimothy, uh, can you share with me uh how people can follow your work? I know you have some books available. Can you share how they can find that?
Timothy CaulfieldYeah, for sure. Um you can find me online. Uh, I'm uh on Blue Sky and I'm on Threads, I'm on Instagram, I'm on Facebook. I'd I'd love to hear your thoughts, but no hate mail. I I get enough of that.
Aaron PeteSo well, thank you so much for being willing to do this. It's really fascinating. I liked having my own ideas challenged, uh, and you've done a lot of work in this space, so super grateful to share the time. Thanks for having me on.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...