Globe and Mail columnist Andrew Coyne joins to discuss Canadian media subsidies, political bias, Mark Carney, Pierre Poilievre, BC’s election, Kamloops reporting and free speech with host Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Andrew CoyneMy name is Andrew Coyne. I'm a columnist for the Globe and Mail.
Aaron PeteYou've criticized David Evie's decision to call them early election. What makes this more than just ordinary political opportunism?
Andrew CoyneThere's limits, and I think there's a pretty broad feeling that this was uh pretty shameless.
Aaron PeteRobert Feith also acknowledged that there is probably unfair bias against conservatives in Ottawa coverage when he joined the show. Do you agree? Yeah, I think that's probably true. You signed the Ottawa Declaration opposing journalism payroll subsidies. What convinced you that those subsidies threatened the independence or credibility of the press?
Andrew CoyneI think the whole idea was misconceived to begin with. We did that to ourselves. We gave our critics uh that that stick to beat us with, and we never should have done it.
Aaron PeteWhen Rosemary Barton pressed Carney.
Speaker 2No possible conflict of interest in your assets. That's very difficult to believe.
Speaker 1Look inside yourself, Rosemary.
Aaron PeteDo you think he meaningfully addressed the concern around Brookfield and conflicts of interest?
Speaker 1Uh, not in that answer, certainly.
Aaron PeteThe Globe and Mail's editorial, There Is No Reconciliation Without Truth, described the initial Camloops coverage as a failure of journalism. Do you agree with that assessment? Andrew Coyne, it's an honor to have you on the show. Would you mind briefly introducing yourself for listeners who might not be acquainted?
Andrew CoyneMy name is Andrew Coyne. I'm a columnist for the Globe and Mail, uh, and I'm honored to be on the show.
Aaron PeteWell, we appreciate you joining us. I'd like to start with British Columbia. Uh, it's the province that I live in. You've criticized David Evie's decision to call them early election. What makes this more than just ordinary political opportunism that we've come to expect from party leaders?
Andrew CoyneWell, it's a question of degree. Uh uh you're right to say that we do expect, unfortunately, political opportunism. I wish we didn't, but uh that is often the norm. But this is really pushing it. I can't find an example in Canadian history uh of a prime premier or a prime minister calling an election with a full majority, no, no danger of falling on the uh on a confidence vote, uh when the opposition party, the main opposition party didn't have a permanent leader. Uh, in fact, it just lost their leader. Um it's hard to find examples anywhere in parliamentary democracies.
Andrew CoyneIt's a it's a very rare thing because I think people rightly view it as dirty pool. Um you know, we we all understand, as you as your question alluded, that politics can be a rough and tumble business and people are always seeking advantage, but there's limits, and I think there's a a pretty broad feeling that this was uh pretty shameless.
Aaron PeteWhat do you react to David Eby's argument that the conservatives have been struggling to find their footing for since the 2024 election, uh, with having um an interim leader removing John Rustad, having an interim leader, Trevor Halford, uh, then going through an election, having Carrie Lynn Findlay, then having Carrie Lynn Findlay uh lose uh many of her uh MLAs, and then entering this election that they have just not been able to find stable footing throughout this process.
Andrew CoyneThat's a perfectly valid point. Uh, that is a point that you would, you know, if you were the opposite of their opponents, that you would make. And it is um um telling about the some of the difficulties the party has had and some of the divisions within the party. You can make that point without timing your election to the absolute maximum advantage, at least seemingly so. Now, it's interesting that it seems to be backfiring on them in a couple of ways. Um one is that, as I said off the top, people are viewing this as dirty pool. Secondly, that behind the scenes, as it were, while uh uh the Conservative Party in some ways was at its lowest ebb uh under Ms.
Andrew CoyneBindley's uh leadership, um, the forces of what I might call normalcy were reasserting themselves. Uh and the party had it showed a surprising ability to pull itself together uh and to put um, I think, more reasonable people in positions of leadership uh for the election campaign. I mean, uh as they all always, the old saying has it, the prospect of being hung in the morning tends to concentrate the mind. So clearly the party membership and the leadership could see that they were heading for disaster if they didn't do this.
Andrew CoyneBut it has uh added to the sense of this whole thing kind of backfiring uh on on EB. So as I say, he the the the all the the the travails of the Conservative Party are absolutely legitimate fodder for the NDP to point out and to raise questions about, but you don't need to do this kind of shenanigans to make that point. And of course, that comes back to a point, which is it's not supposed to be within the purview of the premier to do this. All of the provinces in the last 20 years, at one point or another, passed legislation saying we're gonna go move to fixed election dates.
Andrew CoyneAnd for the very reason that people had seen uh premiers and prime ministers timing elections to their advantage, and quite rightly people said, wait a minute, why should they get to do that? Uh, this is supposed to be a fair fight. We don't let the the one side in the Stanley Cup final decide where the game's gonna be played and how long it's gonna last. Why do we let the leaders of governments do that? So they all passed this legislation and asked to be congratulated for their fair-mindedness in doing so, but they inserted this little uh uh you know loophole in it saying, oh, nothing in this actually constrains the the power of the lieutenant governor to call the election at any time he or she sees fit, i.e., on the advice of their first minister.
Andrew CoyneAt the time, this was we were all told this is just pro forma. We have to put this in because otherwise we'd be vulnerable to a constitutional challenge. But since then, we've seen in you know virtually every province um snap elections being called after we were told that they were a thing of the past. So if you want something that breeds public cynicism, it's when governments refuse to be bound by the laws that they themselves passed.
Aaron PeteMay I ask on a broader scope? My other fear with this election being called is it feels like leaders are no longer viewing it as their duty to really provide a clear vision for what the province or the country looks like in a really deep manner. Uh, in the previous uh election with uh Mark Carney and Pierre Poliev, I criticized the fact that platforms came out, I think it was like 11 days before the election, and not giving citizens time to review that. I I know we can be cynical and say people don't read that. I have a lot of people who listen to the show who are very engaged and do a lot of research on these things.
Aaron PeteAnd I just think just out of respect for human beings and the democratic process, a clear vision should be put to the electorate and decide what direction we're moving in. And I'm having trouble figuring out from all parties. They have policy prescriptions, but they do not have a vision for where our province is going to go. And that sort of concerns me because uh, as as you might imagine, people need to make investment decisions. They need to decide what province they're going to live in over the next 20 years, they need to decide where they're gonna live, how much groceries are gonna cost. And when we don't feel like we have a clear path forward, I just worry about the health of our democracy when it we're not giving clear mandates to people.
Aaron PeteWhat are your thoughts on that?
Andrew CoyneI agree with that. Uh to some extent, we're kind of regressing to a period, maybe a politics of 40, 50 years ago. So it was actually fairly recently that manifestos became part of Canadian politics. You probably could date it to the Liberal Red Book in 1993, which impressed everybody because it was detailed and it had costs attached to everything, and it was quite new. But that was sort of in the air at that time internationally. Uh, but prior to that, you know, people said, I'm running on my record, or uh my my policy is prosperity.
Andrew CoyneYou know, it was it was wasn't very detailed. We grew used to it after the Red Book, and every party felt felt like they had to be, had to have something like that. Um, but now we're seeing people trying to wriggle out of that, and and uh, and and you know, the smart political operators were always telling them, well, don't get tied down to to this or that uh promise or this or that uh vision statement kind of thing. It's up to them, of course. I mean, you can't compel it, uh, but but it's up to us as voters, I guess, to reward the parties uh that do present a clear and coherent vision and and and uh and punish those that just try to get by on a wink and a smile.
Andrew CoyneOf course, part of the problem, even with the Red Book, is you know, half the stuff in the Red Book was complete fiction and they never had any intention of doing it. Uh so there's also this problem that we have we've had uh parties of various stripes over the last 30 years, federally and provincially, have run, and going back even further than that, have run on one thing and then done diametrically the opposite when they got into power. Famous example in BC Gordon Campbell and the sales tax harmonization.
Andrew CoyneUh uh these are not slips of the lip. This isn't, you know, the sort of calculated ambiguity that I think is part of the warp and woof of politics. This is very clear, you know, black letter promises that are intended to be believed, uh, that they then get in power and don't just do something five degrees off of it or don't fully complete it, which again could be forgiven, but do the opposite. Uh and that has also, I think, uh bred enormous public cynicism.
Andrew CoyneIf you cannot attach any significance to what people promise to you, then what are you basing anything on? How can you make an informed vote?
Aaron PeteMay I ask on a uh note kind of tangential to that, is around lobbyists and as you described, political operatives. As I've kind of gotten into this sphere and started to understand how people operate, I've realized that many of the people on CTV, global news are actually lobbyists or work with some sort of organization that is compensating them for their opinion and views. The most, like kind of, I think, known on Twitter is Corey Tanik and his involvement, and he's been criticized harshly uh by many folks.
Aaron PeteAnd I just wonder is that healthy for our democracy to have people who work with an organization coming on the news and giving their opinion when they're connected to an organization that's either funding their position or supporting them in some way, or they're leading that organization. I just don't know if British Columbians, Canadians understand their role, how they're operating, and that they aren't just thoughtful individuals, journalists kind of giving their opinion. They're actually have other interests kind of tied alongside that. In British Columbia, we had Caroline Elliott, who had gone on global news several times, kind of offering her views on DRIPA, on NDRP, and then she's looking to lead a political party.
Aaron PeteAnd what a what a great opportunity to be able to build your brand uh through that way and then go out and try and lead a political party. What are your thoughts on the role of lobbyists?
Andrew CoyneWell, without getting into the particulars of any individual uh case, uh um uh it is a problem if people don't declare. Now, if somebody is just building their profile be en route to what they hope is a political career, I I don't know how exactly you would police that. That to me is sort of part of it, you know, ultimately whether you have it depends on whether you have thoughtful and interesting things to say. But if you are literally, as you say, um taking somebody's shilling to basically make plead their case publicly, um, you should, at the bare minimum, should certainly be declaring that.
Andrew CoyneThat should, or or it should be declared by the news organization that employs you. You probably shouldn't be commenting on things. They shouldn't be dragging you in if it's if it's completely a conflict of interest where it's just, you know, there's just no possibility to for it to be viewed as being independent or impartial. Um, I'm not sure it's hugely better that we um we we um have so many party strategists on. Um I'm not saying we shouldn't have them on. That should be part of the coverage. Um, but we we devote way too much of our coverage of politics to the game, to the horse race, rather than to the underlying issues.
Andrew CoyneIt's worse, particularly at election time, when um we mostly cover the campaign and very little about the election. Uh um we're very entranced by the positionings and the tra strategies and the tactics. And we're entranced with our own role as the people who will who will pierce the veil for you and will explain to you the game that these guys are playing. Again, there's a role for that. There's a that is part of what should be covered. Uh we do learn things about the parties from the stat strategy and tactics that they employ.
Andrew CoyneAnd it's interesting and even fun for some people. I'm not saying there shouldn't be coverage of it. It's just the the proportions. Uh, the the amount that we actually cover to who are these people and what are they going to do if they get into power? Uh, versus, oh, they made a clever attack ad, and let's get on three strategies to talk about how effective the ad is. Uh- I just think we just need to dial it proportions a little differently.
Aaron PeteAaron Powell Aaron Powell How do we take Trump's threats seriously without allowing Canadian politicians to use them as a shield against scrutiny of their own records?
Andrew CoyneWell, it that that's a fair point, is uh it and we've seen uh premiers and prime ministers attempting to use Donald Trump uh as a as a as a as a punching bag with varying degrees of success. And the fact that it doesn't always succeed is important. It shows the public is not so easily bamboozled as all that. You have to actually have a credible uh case to make. Now, you know, in in April or May of 2025, it was pretty logical that that election would be a lot of it would turn around.
Andrew CoyneHow do we deal with this guy? What's our strategy? Who's the best person suited to it? That's fine. Um by you know uh September of 2026, uh the Premier of British Columbia, um, without a whole lot else to talk about, uh, tries to say, you have to elect me to to keep Donald Trump out of your, you know, your front porch. Uh um I think people had a hard time stretching their minds around that. We should certainly be taking seriously what Trump says because um he's not always joking.
Andrew CoyneYou know, we we I think the people of Greenland and Denmark certainly learned uh that that wasn't all just a joke. In fact, at one point there were European armies mobilizing uh to deal with that. Uh um so uh he is a very strange individual with very strange views on things, and uh uh he's already done all kinds of crazy things just to do with this country. Uh so nobody should be um uh should fall into the trap of of trying to put him into a box, you know, the the of any politician we've ever seen before.
Andrew CoyneUh he is a bizarre individual and and he wishes us ill. And there's a lot of people around him who wish us ill. A lot of people in the MAGA universe have convinced themselves that Canada is a security threat. That we're this, first of all, that we're this woke liberal dystopia where no conservative can say boo. Uh, and B, uh that we're we're sort of the handmaidens to China. Uh and and uh and they've taken that argument to such an extent that some of them, some of the quote-unquote think tanks, are publishing pieces about how we can break up Canada, the uh the better to absorb the pieces of it that we want to absorb.
Andrew CoyneUh so we should certainly take that uh deadly seriously. We should certainly take at the bare minimum the the trade war seriously, uh and and and judge uh both both uh incumbent leaders and opposition leaders by their proposals for dealing with this. Um uh and it's certainly a very important issue. It's not the only issue. Nothing is.
Aaron PeteYou recently wrote a column titled, It's not disloyal to criticize the government's handling of Trump, but it can be. Where exactly is that line from your perspective?
Andrew CoyneWell, that's a good question. It's one of those things perhaps you know when you see it. Uh I'll preface this by saying I was mostly quoting um conservative uh people who are in people in the conservative party who are very concerned at where some of their alleged compatriots uh want to take the party, want to take the country. And uh um the degree to which um some small C, large C conservative influencers online seem prepared to uh parrot the Trump line and not just online influencers, but the odd MP.
Andrew CoyneUh it it it goes beyond just legitimate criticism of the of the Prime Minister, which is absolutely not just legitimate, but to be welcomed and to be sought after. Uh as patriotic Canadians, we should want the most searching and constructive criticism to be made of the people who are governing us at all times, but especially in a crisis. So there's no requirement that everybody hold their tongue uh just because uh you know we're in this sort of quasi-wartime atmosphere.
Andrew CoyneUh um but and and there's and and you can, you know, you have free speech. You can make any argument you like, and I'll defend to the death your right to make it. But if you make really stupid um uh basically apologies for Donald Trump's view of the world, if you blame Canada for every uh uh problem within between Canada and the United States, then people are gonna judge you. And they have a right to judge you as well. So you can't, you know, you can't claim free speech for yourself, but then say, oh, it's so unfair that people are are accusing me of this, that, and the other thing and criticizing me.
Andrew CoyneUm you've got to take your lumps the same way as you give them out. So that that's where I draw the line is is are are you are you basically not uh offering constructive way alternatives to how to deal with Donald Trump, but making apologies for him and basically taking his side of these debates? Again, you have a right to do so, but I'm gonna judge you if you do.
Aaron PeteWhen Rosemary Barton pressed Carney about potential conflicts arising from his private sector interests with Brookfield, he told her to look inside yourself and suggested she was approaching him with ill will. Do you think he meaningfully addressed the concern around Brookfield and conflicts of interest?
Andrew CoyneUh, not in that answer, certainly. Uh um they have set up all kinds of screens uh that he is supposed to observe, and I I don't have any evidence that he's not uh to do with his different holdings. Um this is an imperfect way of going about these things. Um we've dealt with these kinds of issues before, and we've dealt with them very imperfectly. So when uh when Paul Martin uh had, you know, was prime minister and still owned Canada steamship lines, uh supposedly he put them in a blind trust.
Andrew CoyneBut, you know, he knew what was in the blind trust. One of Joe Clark's greatest lines was he said, it's a Venetian blind trust. You know, you can peek into it anytime uh you want to, or you know what's in it. Uh, you know, in the United States, at least before Trump, there were the much more stringent rules, or at least expectations, that you divest yourself if you've got significant holdings. Uh, I know that's a lot to ask of people, but you were asking for the privilege and the right and the power to run everybody else's uh affairs and to pass laws that will compel obedience to people.
Andrew CoyneSo uh I don't think it's unreasonable to ask people in those kinds of uh positions to to divest themselves. Uh I have no reason to to doubt uh uh Mark Carney's integrity on any of these things. I don't have any reason to doubt Paul Martin's integrity. Uh but the point of conflict of interest laws and and of uh these kinds of measures is so that the public never has to wonder, never has to depend upon, oh yeah, it looks weird, but I'll I'll trust him to always do the right thing.
Andrew CoyneUh uh trust is one thing, but uh to earn that trust, you should be going out of your way to allay suspicions, allay reasonable suspicions. Uh you can't allay every you know conspiracy theory. But uh so it it's it's not a very good situation, and and uh uh I think we need to have uh a stronger set of rules about uh the the holdings of people in in executive office.
Aaron PeteAaron Powell would you have preferred he divest?
Andrew CoyneI think so, yeah. You know, I'd have to look at the particular details of this thing, but as a broad principle, I think it's a better situation. I don't think these these um um blind trusts and screens, it seem to me to be very elaborate uh um ways of trying to avoid divesting. And divesting seems to me to be a better, a better approach.
Aaron PeteCan you see why some Canadians may be skeptical or distrustful of Mr. Mark Carney as a consequence of his decision to hold this? I'm sure you've seen Pierre Polyev make those um visuals on X and on different social media platforms showing Canada's growth versus Brookefield's growth since uh Prime Minister Mark Carney's taken office. How do you how do you take that in?
Andrew CoyneI'm not sure I find that terribly persuasive. As I say, I I uh uh people are can draw their own conclusions. Um I think the public has drawn their conclusions about whether they think Mark Carney is just in it for himself. Uh so I don't think it's a particularly effective thing. So on the one hand, there's an obligation of public office holders to go out of their way. To allay reasonable suspicions. On the other hand, the people who are their critics have to be careful that they're actually raising reasonable suspicions. And if they're just kind of flinging stuff to see what will stick, again, they have a right to do it, but they may find the public doesn't find that terribly persuasive.
Aaron PeteRobert Fife joined the show and he told me Mark Kearney has had a remarkable year. As a chief, I'm still dealing with people struggling to afford food every day, and I'm seeing that get worse for everyday Canadians. What is the strongest evidence that Kearney deserves that assessment and what might be missing?
Andrew CoyneThat's a broad question. Now, this one file has a lot of proportions, you know, sex sections to it. There's the defense buildup, there's the trade diversification, there's you know, forming new types of alliances with other countries. Um there's trying to build up uh our productivity.
Andrew CoyneUm and all those things fit together in in a um a broad strategy of trying to make the country more resilient to Trump's threats, making us um harder to coerce, partly by building up our own strength, partly by um diversifying our trade and making ourselves less reliant in the United States. So I would I would I would expect, frankly, any prime minister in the situation he was in, that that would be a big part of his focus. Um and I think I think on that file, uh I think he's made a fair bit of progress.
Andrew CoyneYou know, would somebody else have done a better job and made more progress, perhaps, but uh uh you know, trying to trying to to assess it against that counterfactual, I would say he's done a reasonable job on that file. Uh I'm not as persuaded that he's he's made much headway on um um, if if he even intends to, on dealing with the deficit in debt uh on the broader productivity agenda. We've we've started to see that the the measure that was announced uh to kind to coincide with the investment summit of of cutting or or uh allowing 100 percent expense of investments for most investments uh is by common consensus among the policy community a major step forward.
Andrew CoyneFar too, you know, we should have done this years ago, uh, but you've got to give them credit for doing that. But there's so much more we need to do on the productivity front. There's so much more we need to do to encourage more competition in this country rather than having these sort of cozy cartels running everything. So much more we can do on the tax reform uh file things, uh uh and and so much more we can do to cut business subsidies and to, as I say, bring deficits and debts in the care. So the ic the the on the economic side of things more broadly, I would say they're only just getting going.
Andrew CoyneAnd in their initial budget, I would say it wasn't a huge departure from what uh a Justin Truder government had brought in. So not not not a huge amount of progress there. We will see what this upcoming budget, if they show a bit more sense of the gravity of that particular aspect of the crisis we're in, the productivity uh side of things. So, you know, uh uh uh uh it's a mixed bag as most of these people are. Uh it's hard. You you you you have to suspend judgment a little bit when you're only a year, year and a half into the uh into a government.
Andrew CoyneUm you you have to give us give yourself a say, you know, to try to think where do I think they're going in the future? What do I have any expectation that they will do more, or is this as good as it's gonna get? And those are all very difficult judgment calls. So you know, I tend to, I try to certainly while somebody is prime minister, I try to avoid uh too much in the way of an overarching assessment. And even afterwards, they're always a mixed bag. People ask me, what do I think of Mulroney?
Andrew CoyneWell, he did some good things, you know, free trade and tax reform. He did some not so good things, you know, on Meach Lake and Charlottetown and some of his ethical issues. And the same thing with Cretch, you know, he had some major successes and some really problematic uh issues. And I I'm just always mystified by people who want to who want to just say they're one thing or the other, you know, he's all good or he's all bad. They're all going to be mixtures. Nobody's uh, nobody's a saint, nobody's an irredeemable sinner.
Aaron PeteIt's interesting that you say that because I always think about uh Pierre Elliott Trudeau and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Constitution being one of his most controversial. And now if you ask people, do you like the Charter of Rights and Freedoms? Do you think we should have like that's off the table to most Canadians now, but at the time was extremely controversial being brought in.
Andrew CoyneUh well, and it's certainly um uh renewed controversy uh with the advent of the sort of almost routine use of the notwithstanding clause. So that controversy at the time has has continued on in certain circles. You're right to say that if you do polling of the general public, the charter is uh enormously popular, including in Quebec, by the way. Uh um, but amongst uh uh some conservatives, it's it's always been uh uh a bit of a struggle, uh um with some contradictions.
Andrew CoyneI think it was Stephen Harper who said a conservative is somebody who wants to abolish the charter but also wants to add a property rights clause to it. Uh uh so there's uh there's always a little bit of contradiction in some of these things. But but but the the what we've been seeing with various conservative premiers um invoking the notwithstanding clause, conservative with the small c invoking the notwithstanding clause uh uh almost routinely. I mean, I'm exaggerating slightly, but they're using it much more often than anybody ever anticipated.
Andrew CoyneI think it's pretty clear the agenda there is to try to make it uh to normalize it, to, to reduce the political stigma associated with it, and therefore basically to make the charter live or die at the at the at the sufferance of of the premiers. That you know it applies unless the premiers don't think it should. Uh and and we have not resolved that conflict or that controversy uh yet. And in fact, we're heading for, it sounds like, for even more controversies to come on that issue.
Aaron PeteRobert Faith also acknowledged that there is probably unfair bias against conservatives in Ottawa coverage when he joined the show. Do you agree?
Andrew CoyneYeah, I think that's probably true. It, you know, one of the uh the abiding afflictions we have in this country is what uh the the journalist and author Richard Wynne called one and a half party rule. That, you know, the liberals are in for so long periods, and then they're briefly uh um replaced by the conservatives, and then they get back in for a while, that that has, I think, fed into both parties' worst instincts. It it it it if you take talk about the abiding sin of the liberals, it's arrogance.
Andrew CoyneAnd I may say the abiding sin of conservatives is a kind of a chippy resentment that everybody's out against them. And um I wouldn't be at all surprised to find that on balance the the Ottawa gallery tends to lean a little bit to the left, or somebody's saving a lot, that the that the the academia does, that the bureaucracy does, that I don't think that's necessarily untrue. It's what do you do about that? And if you come into office with sort of feeling like everybody's out to get you and you can't make any headway, then you're gonna, you're gonna, it's gonna be a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Andrew CoyneFact of the matter is most journalists, most academics, most judges, et cetera, are trying to be fair, whatever their initial uh predispositions. Not all of them, you're gonna run into bad apples, but most of them are trying to be professionals. And if you appeal to them on that level, most of them will respond. Uh, if you really want to see uh when Ottawa was really a company town, it was in the 50s, uh, you know, when when when the Liberals under Mackenzie King and Louis Anleron had been in for 22 years, uh uh, you know, I could forgive uh John Diefenbaker uh a certain degree of paranoia because it was quite overt in those days.
Andrew CoyneIt's much more easily disrupted now. It's much harder for a really hardcore groupthink to set in in Ottawa the way it might have in the past. I remember even during during the days of Meach Lake, for example, uh everybody in Ottawa had signed on for it. Uh it was it was your badge of membership in the in polite society. Uh and and uh I think that'd be much harder for that to happen today because of social media, because of various other things. Uh uh, but it's still, yeah, I uh it's still going to be a factor.
Andrew CoyneAnd any incoming conservative uh prime minister, I think has to be smart about how they deal with it and try to win people over and try to show that you're not the they don't have horns and you're not the bogeyman that some people might imagine you are, and and and just appeal to the professionalism that exists in most people.
Aaron PeteAnd just out of curiosity, if a conservative prime minister had said the same things about their financial interests that they gave to Rosemary Barton, do you think the reaction would have been different?
Andrew CoyneI think it really depends. Uh um uh you know, Carney has uh uh a long track record in public life. So people, he's not an unknown quantity. People can judge him based on his uh record in in in office as the as a governor, etc. So you earn a certain degree of credibility if you've been around for a while, and I think I'm sure that would be the case for a conservative as well. I don't actually subscribe to the theory that that uh any conservative would be uh treated differently.
Andrew CoyneIf a conservative came out of left field, if nobody'd ever seen them before, uh and and they they had mega bucks behind them, uh and and people were just trying to figure out what is this person about, um, where does where does his money come from, et cetera, then they might they might run into something of that. But that, as I say, that's more to do with conservatives typically being uh the party of the outs, people who were not part of the Central Canadian elite, people who are not part of the liberal uh uh uh consensus on things, uh, are always gonna be to some extent a disadvantage because they're coming from outside the the circle.
Andrew CoyneUm, but it's it's just I just don't think it's uh um an impermeable, insoluble dilemma. It's just it's just an initial thing you're gonna deal with when you first come in.
Aaron PeteSo I interviewed Pierre Polyev, and my personal belief is that he is there in his role as the honorable opposition to offer criticisms of the government. And I approached the interview as such, focused on what his feedback was, what he would do differently, and tried to lay it out in that way. What is the strongest criticism Pierre Polyev makes of uh Prime Minister Mark Kearney that you think deserves more attention?
Andrew CoyneUm I think the the I think he's on solid ground in saying that the that they are um uh um not um um really fully versed in or fully approaching the economy the the way they should be, that it is uh it's piecemeal measures, that they're not um uh really grasping the kinds of measures, the kinds of spending controls, for example, the kinds of tax reforms that are required. Um I think he he he is it's it's a fair game to say uh that um uh uh however much he may have changed certain policies of the government, that a lot of the same people are still in place.
Andrew CoyneAnd people deserve to know that. That um I mean it's certainly been a 180-degree change in a lot of policies. Um I think it's fair for Poe to say that they've basically stolen a lot of our policies, uh we the conservatives, um, but that only gets you so far. It's always gonna be a difficulty for anybody in politics if your opponents are willing to swallow themselves whole uh and and abandon all the policies they were that you were criticizing them on and take your policies, um you're it you're gonna have a tough time.
Andrew CoyneUh um because it it it's it's the game isn't supposed to work that way, uh, but the liberals are an endlessly flexible bunch. And this particular moment in our history, uh with Trudeau having become so unpopular uh that anybody associated with him really couldn't put up much of a fight within the party. And you have this guy who's been the central bank governor for two countries, uh um sort of ready and available at a particular moment when the country is in a crisis. You put all those things together and and Kearney's been given kind of free reign to just completely remake the party in his image.
Andrew CoyneAnd in the course of doing so, it makes it very difficult to be uh the opposition leader. You can absolutely point out that this is what's going on. You can raise questions about how permanent is this? Is this actually what the liberals are going to do in the future? Or is this just a brief period during Mark Carney's uh crisis mentality and over time? You know, you can certainly point out the degree to which uh the liberals continue to cultivate client groups across the country. Uh and I I I've often thought there's a fruitful line of argument for conservatives to get a hearing on themselves as an alternative in terms of economic policy, is to look at all the, is to frame a lot of these policies as not just bad policies for the country, but also the means by which the liberals cement themselves in power.
Andrew CoyneUh so these tens of billions of dollars in business subsidies that the government hands out every year are really dumb economics. They they distort investment decisions, they don't get people focusing on the real economic returns and benefits and costs and benefits of different investments, but just on the on the tax goodies or subsidies that are attached to them. They're really bad policy. But oh, by the way, they also create dependencies and and and advocacy groups across the country that have a vested interest in liberals staying in power. Um and there's a whole range of these kinds of policies that I think it's very fruitful uh for the conservatives to to campaign on.
Andrew CoyneUm but to come back to something you said at the beginning, yeah, he it to if you're the opposition leader, your job is to criticize, your job is to poke holes and to show the flaws in government policies. You can just do that if you want to. There's nothing wrong with that. But I do think uh if you want to get a hearing, you also have to say, uh, what would you do differently? Um, what would be what would your front bench look like? What would you, what would a polyevre or a conservative government look like?
Andrew CoyneI do think there's a an enlightened self-interest in presenting yourself as a government in waiting. And I think one of the things that has really uh hurt Pierre Poe and hurt the party is uh people look at him and they say, well, I'd hire him to be opposed to be the opposition leader. I think he makes a fine opposition leader. I'm just not as persuaded that I could see him as the prime minister. Uh and until and unless he and the party overcome that, uh, I think they're gonna have trouble.
Aaron PeteJust to quickly follow up on that, we we st you spoke at the beginning about how um the liberals are now taking a lot of Pierre Polyev's policy prescriptions. And then at the end, you had just commented that he needs to put forward an alternative. And I'm just wondering if you can clarify that.
Andrew CoyneIt's a really difficult dilemma. The more that they take your policies, the more you've got to think about okay, how do we differentiate ourselves? You have to think about, frankly, why am I do I want to be a conservative rather than liberal? If if if Mark Kearney is bringing in all the policies that I want to see done, uh, what's my continuing reason to oppose them? Well, okay, it's it's uh I don't trust them. I think the the overarching culture of the party will reassert itself over time. I think there's a bunch of issues that they haven't addressed. So I think you have to you're when you're faced with that very difficult political domain of what do you do when you're up against these shapeshifters who could adopt all of half your policies without blinking, is where can we go that they can't go?
Andrew CoyneWhat policies can we take, uh can we put in the shop window that they can't steal because they would just run into too much trouble with particular interests within the party, for example? Um, you've got to be mindful of that that you don't lose touch with the center ground of Canadian politics in so doing. So the uh um, you know, you don't want to just be extreme for the sake of being extreme, but you want to find points of differentiation that that even Mark Kearney can't uh uh can't uh elide.
Andrew CoyneUm, and that's a the difficult challenge. And the only thing I would say is is uh be patient. Um this the election's not coming tomorrow. Um you know, unpopularity comes for all people in politics. Mark Kearney's riding high right now, but there will come a time when he's not riding so high. Uh when when one thing or another, either you know, bad economics or a policy that backfired or what have you, um, they'll start to accumulate. And, you know, every politician um at some point or another that comes for them.
Andrew CoyneAnd so be be ready and waiting and and and available and and and spend the time until then building up your own credibility uh as an alternative government so that when the time comes, people will turn to you. You know, there's no reason in theory, in principle, there's no reason why the public shouldn't have turned to the conservative leader when the Trump threat emerged. It wasn't a given. It wasn't, there wasn't some law of physics that said that they would they would turn to the governing party. Uh and and conservatives have to think about that as why didn't they turn to us?
Andrew CoyneWhy weren't we the party that people uh wanted in the in the crisis? Why wasn't Pierre Poyev the leader uh that that they that they trusted in that moment uh to defend their interests? And and and once you've done that kind of searching scrutiny, then then then try to act on it.
Aaron PeteIn your 2021 conversation with Nigel Beale about your father, James Coyne, you explored Canadian independence and economic nationalism. Growing up with a father who had publicly clashed with a prime minister, what did you learn about standing up to power?
Andrew CoyneWell, certainly that that uh that it matters. It matters uh that that one person can make a difference, that your your conscience uh uh is uh you know has to amount for something. You can't just swallow yourself whole. Um you can't just say my way or the highway either. There's got to be some reasonable degree of compromise. And people forget, you know, it it tends to, the whole thing tends to be created a bit more than it actually is. But there wasn't actually a huge clash of policy vision.
Andrew CoyneThis was part of the game the Diefenbaker conservatives were playing was when it suited them, uh they would say, oh, you know, uh don't blame us for high interest rates. That's the independent Bank of Canada. Remember, the Bank of Canada was still quite new then, it was only about 22 years old, uh, uh, or 25 years old, but but when it when it suited them, they would say, Oh, but the the Bank of Canada is it's run amok. The governor's uh doing all kinds of things that we don't agree with. Uh the fact of the matter is the the there was virtually no um fundamental disagreement on monetary policy.
Andrew CoyneMy father had made some speeches about what he viewed as being a kind of a crisis of dependency on foreign uh capital, foreign investment, foreign, foreign lending, that we were quote unquote living beyond our means. And and, you know, uh in in current times, it it has a certain resonance uh uh that that uh I'm not sure I would agree with it at the time he was speaking, and and uh not sure he necessarily held held the same views later in life, but at that moment that it that was certainly something that was concerned him and concerned a lot of people.
Andrew CoyneBut he stopped making the speeches. So he wasn't trying to make himself a martyr, he wasn't trying to to make him set himself up some kind of alternative government. What really happened was that the the the the the Dayton Bayer government decided they wanted to have a head on a pike. They wanted to make a show of having a fight with him. And so in early 1961, there was this extraordinary meeting they had in my father and the finance minister, Donald Fleming, where the gist of which was Fleming said, uh, oh, we've got a we've got a budget coming up, uh, and there'll be some things in it we don't think you'll agree with.
Andrew CoyneWe can't tell you what they are, but we don't think you'll agree with them. So would you please resign? Which is preposterous. Uh and and no uh Bank of Canada uh governor could ever uh have agreed to that. You cannot, you know, the the the position of the Bank of Canada governor has to be sort of like a Supreme Court judge. It has to have a uh a weight and a and a and a tenure to it that you don't just hire and fire them uh like any uh any political appointee. And if if it ever um amounted to that, then neither of those institutions would amount to much.
Andrew CoyneSo uh uh uh uh I think he really felt he had to stand on that principle of the the independence of the position, uh and and the the the and and against the Deepmaker government's uh attempts to to demagogue that. So, you know, it it it uh growing up in a household in the aftermath of that, uh I was very, very lucky in that I had a uh remarkable moral example to look up to in my own father. Uh and I'm I feel enormously blessed uh to have had that uh um experience.
Andrew CoyneAnd you know, it's not coincidental, one of my favorite movies is uh A man for all seasons. I only figured this out much later. Because I used to love this film when I was like a teenager. And it was only later I figured out I I guess there's a certain weird similarity in those those two situations. Uh and and uh so I as I say I feel very fortunate.
Aaron PeteWhat do you admire most about your father?
Andrew CoyneHe was a man of great conviction and principle. Uh uh, he was utterly honest, uh um without pretense, almost to the point of ridiculousness. Uh um he didn't didn't think people should smile for the camera, for example, you know. So he was very old school. Uh but but his integrity uh was uh um just beyond uh anything I've ever seen.
Aaron PeteYou signed the Ottawa Declaration opposing journalism payroll subsidies. What convinced you that those subsidies threaten the independence or credibility of the press?
Andrew CoyneWell, I just from the get-go, uh um uh I think the whole idea was misconceived to begin with. Um, the the problems of the Canadian media uh are to some extent self-created. Uh we, you know, yeah, the internet came along. The internet's affected everybody's business model, not just ours. Uh, but we didn't particularly handle it very well. We made every mistake it was possible to make. Uh but it it at the same time, it didn't mean the death of the industry. It means that we're going through a big transition.
Andrew CoyneSo we're moving from a business model that was mostly based on advertising finance, where like 80% of the of the revenues were coming from advertising and only 20% from subscription sales and newsstand sales. Uh uh, we're moving from that model to one in which the the reader's going to pay a lot more. The advertisers have deserted us. You know, Google and Facebook made a better mousetra, uh, and there's just no two ways about that. But it took us a long time to figure that out. And instead of getting busy on making that transition, difficult and painful though it may be, we spent a lot of useless time whining and and and pleading to government uh in various ways.
Andrew CoyneUh either to force Google and Facebook to transfer money to us, because they had it and we didn't, uh basically the sum total of the argument, uh, or or direct subsidies from the government. And I think it was uh I think it's a real shame uh the industry went down that route. You know, when when when the Kent Commission reported in 1980 on newspaper concentration and the state of the newspaper industry, uh one of their recommendations was that the government should fund newspapers, I think it was for mostly for foreign bureaus, but should fund journalism.
Andrew CoyneAnd to their immense credit, uh the entire industry rose as one and said, get out of here. We don't want your money. I think maybe the only industry in Canadian history that rejected a government handout. Uh well, they're singing a very different tune, unfortunately, today. And it's it absolutely harms our credibility. Uh, I don't think for one second that anybody is thinking of ways they can uh, you know, let's support the liberal government because they will give us money. But it again, it's like any conflict of interest thing that we're usually the first to point out.
Andrew CoyneIf you're leaving position in the people in the position of credibly wondering whether that is uh affecting your coverage, then you shouldn't be doing that. And it certainly means that every two-bit critic online uh that has a criticism to make of anything that any of us writes, the first thing they say is, well, I guess it's just because you're getting money from the government. So we did that to ourselves. We gave our critics uh that that stick to beat us with, and we never should have done it. And my broader worry is not that it will align us with the Liberal Party per se, but that it it will over time align us with the idea that that government should bail people out, bail industries out.
Andrew CoyneHow do we credibly argue uh don't bail out the auto industry if we've just been bailed out? And over time, I don't think it'll even occur to us. Uh we'll just internalize, as every industry does, this idea that, oh, the forces of nature have dictated that we can't possibly survive without government handouts. People rationalize their own self-interest and they turn it into immutable principles. Um and and for us to join that, I think is terribly tragic.
Andrew CoyneI think it's going to be very difficult to get us off the public hook now that we're into it. I mean, it was supposed to be a a temporary brief emergency thing. Uh, and here we are years later, and we're still taking the money. Uh, I just think it would be better if we if we if we got out of it.
Aaron PeteAnd I would just say that you take our earlier discussion about um that there may be a bias against conservatives in Ottawa coupled with the subsidies, and that equals the sense that the liber the the media is bias against conservatives and is pro-uh liberal.
Andrew CoyneIt's it's a disastrous combination uh in terms of the how people perceive us as an industry. Absolutely right.
Aaron PeteI would just follow up and just share like one of my big concerns, and I'm sure you've noticed it, is here I am as an independent uh content creator, journalist. I don't know what to call myself, somebody who likes to think issues through. And I don't have the same newsroom team you have. I don't have the same access to resources and experts in different fields, uh, guest booker who's able to organize the most qualified individual. And I do think I have a lot of trust, because I'll admit when I get something wrong, but I of course see this difference between legacy media that's existed for a long time that has checks and balances.
Aaron PeteNow, people will say that that's not always properly followed and fair enough. Um, I think we'll get into the unmarked grave story in a few minutes, where checks and balances are incredibly important for the health of the nation and us understanding issues. And I don't have somebody holding me to some sort of account other than my audience, which I would say is a huge risk. Like I should have some sort of code of conduct and some sort of review process to make sure that I'm holding myself accountable. And I know that a lot of people doing what I do don't follow those things and have realized that there is a real business in, if you want to call it clickbait, finding the most controversial take, having the hottest take, and kind of putting that out there.
Aaron PeteAnd I just I fear that the investment in the legacy media didn't allow for adaptation. So now you have this new form of media growing, and there's nobody kind of steering it or supporting it or helping it develop in a really thoughtful way. So my only opportunity to hear from journalists like yourself who've been in the game for a very long time, Tara Henley, Holly Doan, uh, Robert Fife, and get kind of insights is through hosting the show and getting your thoughts on what I'm doing and on where media is at. But I see this complete disconnect, and there's just no guardrails on the independent media side right now, and people will welcome that.
Aaron PeteBut I just don't know how long we can kind of have these two kind of modes of being existing and not really communicating or working with each other.
Andrew CoyneYeah, I mean, I think over time there's a certain amount of um blending and and melding that goes on. Um we're in the middle of a transition, and part of that transition, I I fervently hope, and we're seeing it to a greater or lesser extent, uh we're seeing more of it in the United States than here, is that new media, new organizations come out of humble origins where they don't necessarily have a lot of money, but they build readership, they build a followership, and hopefully they do it in the right way by being credible and and and truth-oriented and professional and fact-checking, et cetera.
Andrew CoyneBut over time, they build up businesses and they build up new uh contestants. And the one again, one of the worst aspects of subsidy is it's basically telling legacy media to go back to sleep. Uh you don't need to change your business model, you don't need to adapt to the times, you don't need to uh uh uh be entrepreneurial. Uh and and not only does that hold us back, prevents us from adapting in ways that we might, but it locks a lot of resources and manpower, frankly, uh in industries or in in firms, organizations that may or may not be um around for the long run, rather than releasing them to work for new startups.
Andrew CoyneSo there's there's the American media is is um has a lot more problems in a lot of ways, and there's a lot more just overt, awful propaganda stuff, but there's also much more in the way of green shoots of new professional news organizations starting up. So I I hope we don't fall on the trap of thinking it's either a choice between sort of deadwood uh um news organizations that may be professional and and devoted to fact-checking, but are kind of slow and dumb and and not with the times, versus new startups that are fast and loose with the facts and basically just want to be propaganda outfits for one side or the other.
Andrew CoyneAnd that those are the only choices. Um, I think there's lots of opportunity for to blend the best of the old model with the vitality of the new uh and and and and and go forward. Now, the you know, the guardrail ultimately on that is is your readership and your audience is is do people find you credible? Do they do they, you know, people of goodwill, people who are trying to figure things out and haven't already decided for themselves? You know, you get people saying, uh, I just don't trust the media.
Andrew CoyneAnd anytime somebody says that in a broad brush sense, I mean obviously you should be skeptical of everybody, but skepticism is different than just blanket rejection. And when you ask people about this, oftentimes what you find is there is a media that they trust implicitly, that they follow, they swallow every line they say. It's just they're different, it's just a different media. And what they mean is I don't trust people who tell me things I don't want to hear. And while I'd be the first to criticize our response to uh the internet and our our mistakes we've made, I I don't think we should be uh um, you know, turning ourselves insort inside out and committing, you know, ritual suicide because somebody somewhere says, I don't trust the media.
Andrew CoyneUh um uh um there's always a human tendency to want to hear uh uh only things that we agree with. That goes, that's as old as human beings. And the trouble is it's way easier now uh for people to do that, to go online and find people who will just tell them exactly the stuff they want to hear. So we've we've departed from the old gatekeeper model for good or ill. And the gatekeeper model had many failings and lots of voices that should have had more uh um uh amplitude that didn't weren't weren't amplified, and that's too bad.
Andrew CoyneBut it also kept the Nazis and the crazies out and kept oxygen so that actual reasonable debate could take place between, you know, it was the old line about reasonable people can differ. Uh and, you know, both halves of that sentence are important. It's okay to differ. It's okay to have vital disagreements about important issues. Nobody should feel like they all have to line up on one side. But you also have to be kind of reasonable about it, not as a matter of law or anything, but just in terms of, you know, if you want uh a mass audience and the credibility that goes with that, then you have to kind of earn that by being somewhere in contact with reality and not just throwing out crazy conspiracy theories or or you know um blatant propaganda.
Andrew CoyneSo all of us, whether we're old media or new media, we're we we have to kind of earn the confidence and the trust uh of the readership and the audience. And the best thing the government can do is get out of the way of that process and let it uh let it continue.
Aaron PeteI couldn't agree more. One of the greatest compliments I've received is uh interviewing people and seeing the comments go, Aaron, I don't agree with the person you had on. Like our ideologies are completely different, but I know I need to hear from people I disagree with, so I'm gonna listen and push through. The Globe and Mails editorial, There Is No Reconciliation Without Truth, described the initial Camloops coverage as a failure of journalism. Do you agree with that assessment?
Andrew CoyneYes. I mean, uh to the extent that people were flat out saying uh that these were unmarked graves, and to the extent to which the facts don't support that, then there was a rush to judgment. And and um uh that sometimes happened. You know, sometimes people uh um herd mentality clicks in uh and people um fall over each other and don't uh don't take an independent line and and look and say, okay, does this actually stand up? Now the question is, what do you make of that? Um I have a little bit of trouble with the emphasis that's put on it.
Andrew CoyneUh as if we could draw all kinds of other conclusions beyond this. So if there were um if there weren't uh bodies in these unmarked graves, or they weren't unmarked graves, is that to suggest that nobody died in residential school? Is that to suggest that residential schools weren't a terrible, uh uh um awful policy that should never have been pursued? Um there there just seems to be almost a suggestion hanging around here that, oh, we can just put all these issues to side to one side now because of this particular uh journalistic failing.
Andrew CoyneAnd I'm not saying every critic who points this out is has that agenda or anything, but it it's just whenever I see people place uh undue emphasis on something, uh I always wonder. The thing may be true in itself, but the the the the the the the weight that's put on it, beyond just uh the media got a little bit over them over their skis on this question and didn't uh didn't really check their facts, that's that's the only part that I find a little troubling about the whole thing.
Aaron PeteI would just follow up and and appreciate your feedback on the fact that so I've spoken to individuals like Nigel Bigar, uh Francis Widowson, some of the loudest critics, Candace Melcom, who helped uh get the book published, Grave Error, to see what their arguments were. And many of them go, well, what was the in undue influence and the impact of the story being written as such, which resulted in millions of dollars flowing to First Nation communities? We have National Truth and Reconciliation Day uh coming up in a few days, um, the where that became an enshrined day of reflection as a consequence of that.
Aaron PeteAnd we had a whole movement through Justin Trudeau and it provincially here in BC, through uh John Horgan and David Eby of let's go all in on reconciliation. Let's put the pedal to the metal, full throttle. We get it now. There are dead children in this apple orchard. And so, Mia Culpa, here is everything, no checks and balances. As you know, the government did not was not forthright about what was going on with the $12 million that Camloops received. And so those arguments, I think, also need to be put back to us. And I guess I feel as a First Nations chief myself that I am carrying the load of that story each time I speak, each time I go out, because I had nothing to do with that story.
Aaron PeteI was it broke news just to me as it did everybody else. But First Nations across Canada are now carrying that story on their back. And I'm sure you saw the news of white supremacists being outside of uh Kamloops. And I'm I condemn that completely, but you can see how it took the Globe and Mail a very long time to come out with the honest reality that that story was not verified and confirmed. And I think media more broadly, like the CBC has just even recently, like a month ago, came up with a podcast saying that residential school denialism is afoot.
Aaron PeteAnd it's like they're kind of tying in this story with like I have not heard Francis Widowson, Candace Melcom, Nigel Bagar, any of these prominent figures ever question whether kids died, um, whether or not there was a horrible abuses, but it's kind of put in all in one. And then you you kind of amplify the feeling that it this is a fight uh to the death if we're going to like not kind of own the story as is. And I'm getting concerned at the rising tension of uh the events that just took place, and this is not kind of calming down from my perspective.
Andrew CoyneYeah, and and I so I think we should stipulate no good comes from propagating a lie uh that that uh um uh uh or or certainly not on balance. Uh um, you know, it is, I think, in my opinion, it's a good thing that people uh are taking seriously um reconciliation. We can debate about exactly what it means, but that that there I think there has been a kind of a massive national ownership of the fact that um the residential schools was a disastrous policy that we sh we sh that went on way too long, uh, and that a lot of us, including me, were far too complacent about.
Andrew CoyneWe're not as seized as we should have been uh with what a terrible wrong that had been done in our name as a country. Uh and as I say, way past any period when you could say, oh, well, this was the folly of the past. Uh so it it some people might be inclined to say, well, maybe this was a lie, but if it helped, you know, create awareness, then that's not too too bad, is it? No, for the reasons you're saying is that then anything anybody is is saying around it is going to be suspect. And people are going to be uh uh uh rolling their eyes and and not listening to things that are fact-based and are true and really need do need to be said.
Andrew CoyneSo there's no justification, should be no situational justification of, well, at least it advanced awareness. Uh um and I hope nobody would try to to to um to make that case. And in the in the for this, in in which is basically the flip side of what I was saying earlier is I hope nobody's going to say, well, because that wasn't true, then there's no issue here. And as I say, the people you're talking about, I I know have not said that, but there are people in the in the in the ether, in the community, who would be only too willing to say, oh, well, this whole thing was a fuss over nothing.
Andrew CoyneUm we can, you know, we don't have any further work to do as a society in trying to better the lot of all of our people, including First Nations. Um, and and uh so there's sort of type one and type two errors that you can make coming out of this. Um, and and the long and the short of it is uh um, you know, get your facts straight.
Aaron PeteLeah Gazin, MP Leah Gazin, has recently come out again and said we should criminalize Indian residential school denialism. And uh, I imagine she would include this type of discussion on what happened at Kamloops as part of denying residential school abuse. How do you take in that legislation?
Andrew CoyneIt's it's an appalling idea. Nobody should uh want to criminalize uh debates about things, even if, you know, even if errors are involved, even if lies are involved, it's not a a helpful uh way to address that, to have the government weighed in and penalize people for being wrong. Uh so even if even if I thought somebody was a residential school denialist, and I do think those people exist, um, and not the any of the people you're talking about, but I do think it exists, I don't think there's any benefit to society from criminalizing that.
Andrew CoyneUm, you know, we have the we have evolved very tentative, careful, cautious limits on speech over the centuries through trial and error, and they should be very limited. Um, you know, libel, even that on its own is a really tricky area of getting that right. Uh uh, you know, there's there's one or two other things, uh, incitement to violence, where you're you're you're so, you know, the connection between the word and the deed are so close that the word is almost akin to the deed.
Andrew CoyneWhat you're standing with a riled up mob and you say, let's go burn that house down. Uh, these kinds of things we've we've developed. We don't need to add new things on top of that that we haven't thought about, about issues that are still live issues. You know, I I have some sympathy if you're in Germany with the history that they've had, that maybe if I were in that particular context, uh I uh you know, denying the Holocaust, even then, I'd be really leery. Uh, I don't think there's any benefit uh to be criminalizing one side of a very live recent debate where the facts are still being nailed down, uh, doesn't lead anywhere good, in my view.
Andrew CoyneThat that if you're gonna do take the enormous step, the enormous step of criminalizing speech, you better have the most airtight uh case that there is harm, irrefutable, identifiable harm that uh that any individual person could agree, any reasonable person could agree was harm. So things like incitement to violence pass that test. But it's got to be the highest possible uh bar. And and you know, criminalizing uh a live debate like this is is an appalling idea.
Andrew CoyneAnd I I do not believe we will ever go down that road.
Aaron PeteI am grateful to hear that because it is, I think I've taken a lot of negativity from all sides for speaking with people that I I disagree with on a lot of the aspects of the arguments they put forward. But I just I think that's the best path forward is to speak with people we disagree with to try and understand their perspective. You don't have to agree with it, but it just brings the temperature down in the room. It makes people feel like it's okay to have an opinion. Like, I just don't think that should be the defining aspect of who we are as Canadians, is what you believe. And if we disagree, then we can't be friends and we can't talk and we can't have lively discussion.
Aaron PeteI just don't think that's an interesting country to embrace. I think it's far more interesting to speak with people across the spectrum, try and hash out ideas and see what is the best path forward and assume some good intent. So, Andrew, I really appreciate you for being willing to do this. I know you take a lot uh on X and people giving their viewpoints, but I really appreciate this conversation. I think the there's value in kind of hearing from different people, but also I just think it was good to ask you some questions that I don't I don't hear sometimes in your panels.
Aaron PeteUm, and that's not your fault, but sometimes you don't get asked questions. I'd be really interested in getting your take on. So it was a real privilege uh to speak with you. You're like a legend in Canadian journalism. Uh, I followed you since I was a little kid, started reading the Globe and Mail and the National Post, and just becoming really interested in these. No, no, no, no, no. Um, but just your decision to leave the National Post over the controversy. Like that was all very interesting to me because again, it just spoke to your principles of not wanting to be tied to a political party. And I just I really appreciate you being willing to share the time.
Speaker 2Well, that's very gracious of you. Thank you very much. I enjoyed this.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...