267. Terry Glavin: This Journalist Questioned Kamloops 215—Then They Tried to Cancel Him
1 hr 19 minAudio
National Post columnist and author Terry Glavin joins to examine Kamloops 215, residential schools, media accountability, denialism, reconciliation and public trust with host Aaron Pete. Send us Fan Mail Art Is Not a Thing From media art to digital activism: art as critical inquiry and world-building. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show nuancedmedia.ca
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Aaron PeteTerry Glavin, were you cancelled for questioning the Kamloops 215 story?
SPEAKER_00There were certain people who made a very, very vigorous attempt to cast me out and to declare me a heretic. What did you say? There were 1,300 children whose remains were said to have been disinterred or found or discovered at residential school sites across the country. None of that was true. Something wasn't true. Never happened.
Aaron PeteOut of curiosity, you've studied residential schools. How would you describe them?
SPEAKER_00I think I may have been the first national columnist in Canada to say that it is not unreasonable at all to describe the residential schools pro the federal residential schools project as policy of cultural genocide.
Aaron PeteI have no quarrel with it. The Globe and Mail has called the original coverage a failure of journalism, while Canada Land has revisited its treatment of the story. Do you feel vindicated?
SPEAKER_00Well, I felt vindicated a long time ago, I suppose.
Aaron PeteBased on everything presently known, what do you believe is beneath the Kamloops orchard? Children's burials, unrelated disturbances, or something we cannot yet identify. Terry Glavin, thank you so much for being willing to join us today. It's a privilege to have you on the show. You're much mentioned by individuals like Tara Henley and Harrison Lauman. I'm wondering if you could first briefly introduce yourself.
Aaron PeteWell, I'm this guy, you know.
SPEAKER_00I'm a journalist and an author. I've been around for a long time. I'm currently an uh have been for some time now, a columnist for the National Post. Formerly contributing editor in McLean's Magazine, columnist with the Ottawa Citizen, briefly a columnist for the Globe and Mail. Um, came up in the business in reporting, and I've written several books. Um most of my interest over the last 10 or 20 years has been international human rights, the Middle East, the Far East. And um, but I have written uh two or three books, maybe four, that you could say are either set in what we used to call Indian country or address issues related to uh Canadian history and indigenous crown relations and so on.
SPEAKER_00Spent a lot of time up uh up coast with the Gigsan. My first book, actually, was about uh the Gixan and their cosmology and their land claims, which ended up being the leading Aboriginal title case in Canada. And then with the Chilcotin people, which is now the leading Aboriginal title case in Canada, uh co-authored a book with the Namaya people, um the Chilcotans who won that case. And uh yeah, that's basically who I am.
Aaron PeteWere you canceled for questioning the Kamloops 215 story?
SPEAKER_00Uh I was canceled for well, I wasn't canceled. I think people there were certain people who made a very, very vigorous attempt to cast me out and to declare me a heretic and somebody who should be banished from the company of civilized people. Didn't work. Didn't work. But yeah, it was pretty rough. What happened? Well, I wrote the uh let's see.
SPEAKER_00Um we're gonna go back to 2008 now. It was a long time ago. And I at the time there was this very, very unsettling, crazy person. I don't I mean to unuse uncharitable language, a defrocked United Church minister, who was really terrorizing, I would say, indigenous communities with these horrible stories about the murder of indigenous children at residential schools, about uh secret graves.
SPEAKER_00Um, and um he was quite popular in a certain section of what you might call the American left, wrote a book, Noam Chomsky, the sort of popular American left-wing guy, praised the book, and it was absolute rubbish. And it was um uh I have to tip my hat to Jorge Barrera, the Aboriginal People's Television Network at the time. He went to work for CBC afterwards. He did a lot of work on this too. Um and that's my first sort of introduction to the whole residential school graves thing.
SPEAKER_00And then in 2021, while I was working at McLean's, um suddenly there were headlines all over the world. I mean, all over the world, about a mass grave that had been unearthed in Kamloops. And um that happened on a Thursday. On the weekend, the Prime Minister lowered the flags on Parliament Hill. On the Monday, he ordered the lowering of all the flags across the country on all federal buildings and on all diplomatic missions around the world.
SPEAKER_00On Tuesday, Chief Rose Casimir of the Kamloops said, you know, we never said anything about mass graves. We didn't say we found a mass grave. But it was too late. And um I actually wrote the original story about this for McLean's. And there at the time, McLean's, and this is actually a big part of the story because it's this the story that I ended up writing for the National Post that got me into so much trouble was a story about journalism. It wasn't even about residential schools, about which I really don't hold any heterodox view at all.
SPEAKER_00Um, but that story for McLean's never ran. And uh there were about 14 of us at the time who were kind of disappeared by McLean's, and it became something else. It's sort of like the national version of Toronto Life magazine or something now. And anyway, the National Post said, you know, Glavin, it's got to be you. You know, you co-authored a book with uh with the former students of St. Mary's Indian Residential School. You know, you've been around this issue for a long time.
SPEAKER_00Um, you know, on the anniversary, you've got to be the guy who says, What the hell was that all about? So I wrote a piece, and I wrote a piece about what had happened. And Kamloops, you know, was just the sort of lit the fuse. It wasn't the whole story at all. It was, you know, it was the precursor to the story. And the story in my mind was largely about politicians, liberal politicians who very explicitly said they wanted their own George Floyd moment, you know, recalling the riots from a year earlier in the United States over the murder of George Floyd, a black man, in I guess, Minneapolis.
SPEAKER_00Um, and uh we got we got our own George Floyd moment. We got what the federal cabinet wanted. And um we saw Sorry, who sorry, who said that?
Aaron PeteWho said they wanted their own George Floyd moment?
SPEAKER_00Carolyn Bennett specifically referred to George Floyd. Yeah, we need our own George George Floyd moment, the Minister of Crown Indigenous Relations, I guess she was at the time. Um and uh yeah, I would say that this was a a a national psychotic episode, really, that was incited by the Prime Minister and his cabinet. And um it was an event that the mass media uh played a very important supporting role, I regret to say, as a journalist.
SPEAKER_00Uh nothing to be proud of in that regard. And uh yeah, I made a lot of people angry. What did you say? Well, I simply reported that there had been no, you know, you added it up from that summer. The title of the piece was Year of the Graves, and it was about six, seven thousand words long. Still holds up. And I simply noticed that um, you know, by the end of that summer, by the end of by by the time the Mohawks actually, God bless them, managed to get the flags raised again, um, there were 1,300 children whose remains were said to have been disinterred or found or discovered at residential school sites across the country.
SPEAKER_00None of that was true. Something wasn't true. Never happened. And that's what you wrote? Yeah, I just said, okay, you know, this is this was the claim, and this is what actually happened. And you go through each of the the places, the the localities where these uh horrible findings w were reported around the world to have occurred. And what what I found interesting is that in almost every case, the local First Nation that was uh you know on the ground uh involved or associated with an alleged discovery was almost invariably the most circumspect, the most cautious in their language.
SPEAKER_00And it got really kind of crazy. The the one I think that was absolute probably probably the most bizarre was, I mean, you're a chief of Chihuahua. You gotta have some sympathy, right? For um, I guess it's Joe Pierre, who's the chief and Amach, the old St. Mary's Indian Band, and it's adjacent or nearby is the I think it's on their reserve, actually, is a Saint the old St. Eugene's residential school. And there was a pioneer ceremony, uh cemetery associated with the residential school, but it predated the resid residential school.
SPEAKER_00They're Catholics up there. There's a church and and um and there was a hospital there for a time. And he wakes up one morning and he you know picks up the paper, so to speak, and he reads that he had discovered 182 children buried in a graveyard, some cemetery discovered adjacent to the residential school. Never happened. Simply never happened. Um, there was uh, you know, the Saint St. Eugene's is now a resort and I guess a golf course that the the tribe has successfully uh developed, and they were doing some work around the cemetery, and they inadvertently disinterred some human remains.
SPEAKER_00And of course, you know, this is upsetting for people. So they said, well, you know, stop work. We've got to make sure we know where all of the all of the burials in that cemetery are, and uh we have to be very careful to delineate the precise boundaries of the cemetery. And of course, over the years, you know, most of the crosses were wooden, so there'd been grass fires and the crosses were gone. So they did a very, very good and meticulous job of identifying each of the burials in a very respectful and and and and solemn fashion.
SPEAKER_00And um they knew the graveyard was there. There's no, they don't even know if there's any residential schools kids buried there. Um, but yeah, waking up one morning and being told that you've discovered uh the remains of 182 children from a residential school. I remember Sophie Pierre, I don't know if you know Sophie, respected elder going back years in BC, Tunaka, Tribal Council, from that community, said, Look, it was a it was a graveyard. What do you expect to find in a graveyard? So that was the kind of thing that kept happening.
SPEAKER_00It happened at Shubanakady, it happened at Penelicte, it happened at the Campsell Hospital in um, I guess that's Alberta. Um, it happened at uh Mary Avell in Saskatchewan, where you had, you know, the broadcast around the world, Prime Minister Trudeau kneeling at was what was purported to have been the recently discovered site of a child's burial with a teddy bear in his hand, and it was all very moving.
SPEAKER_00It was a cemetery. It was a cemetery. And it was not a residential school cemetery. I mean, there was a residential school there. It's an old Indian mission. Over the generations, Metis people, Cree people, uh, European settlers had been buried in this cemetery. And um, I remember Lloyd Larat, who's one of the elders there, is you know, was asked about this. He says, Yeah, we always we knew the cemetery was there. This isn't news to us. But, you know, the media shows up with the prime minister, and the story gets takes on a life of its own.
SPEAKER_00You know, the elders there understood what was going on. And that was something I found fascinating is that you basically had a lot of white people talking over the heads of indigenous people. And you did have some very, I would say, irresponsible indigenous leaders at the national and provincial level. But that's what happened in, and that's what I wrote. I mean, it was the story of the year, according to Canadian press. It was one of the biggest sort of Canadian stories in the international press in years.
SPEAKER_00Um, the Russian disinformation press, the Pravda press, and the Chinese propaganda press had made enormous amounts of hay over this story. It disrupted a Canadian initiative, or Canadians were involved in an initiative at the United Nations Human Rights Council to investigate um uh the atrocities visited upon the Uyghur people in China, which has been a really serious concern of mine for a while.
SPEAKER_00Um and the the Chinese Communist Party position was well, who are you to talk? You know, and so that that whole initiative was disrupted, and the the UN was saying you've got to investigate all these mass murders of indigenous people in Canada. It was, I mean, it there was an absolute breakdown in journalism. That was my point. It was an absolute and utter collapse um of journalism that in no small measure contributed, contributed to the and has contributed to the decline in the public trust in legacy media in this country.
SPEAKER_00And I'd just like to conclude on one thing. I'm a normal guy in terms of my opinions and my values and stuff, and I'm always sort of heartened by when I I'm a bit of a geek when it comes to public opinion polling. I just really fascinated to know what people around the world and around Canada think about stuff. And I'm almost always heartened by by because sometimes I worry, you know, the beats I cover, they're too they tend to be pretty intense. And I'm always I I tend to be kind of encouraged when when I read public opinion polls because I realize that I'm I'm I'm normal.
SPEAKER_00Like my opinions are no. And um at the end of the day, I think when we discuss this, we should recall that the majority of people in Canada are not hostile to indigenous people. They're not hostile to indigenous interests, they're perfectly open-minded about questions about Aboriginal rights and title, although that's being undermined by some pretty hysterical stuff lately. Um, and the overwhelming majority of Canadians, Indigenous and non-Indigenous, say, uh stop this, don't don't talk to us about these graves.
SPEAKER_00No more graves, thank you. If you've got proof, if you've got evidence that there's actually a burial, by all means, we should pay very, very close attention to this. Otherwise, shut up. Don't talk to us about this anymore. And you know, that is kind of my opinion as well. So I'm normal. But I think that's where we're at now.
Aaron PeteI'd just like to wrap the piece on your cancellation. What was going on behind the scenes? What were some of these people trying to do to you?
SPEAKER_00Oh, well, uh, depict me as a defender of child murderers and child rapists who should be who should not be interviewed by anybody. Because, of course, after I wrote that story, it was quite a shock to people. Wait a minute, we've you know what these mass graves don't exist. Um there was uh you know Jesse Brown's Canada Land. And uh I'm not a fan of Jesse, I have to say, he was early on one of the people who was dismissing the the the the notion of a cultural genocide occurring in Xinjiang.
SPEAKER_00And one of his co-producers was always happy to say that it was just an affirmative action program and that there are no really no huge work camps that the Uyghurs have been put into. Um I ended up doing an interview with Jesse, was very hostile, and I sort of wonder whether or not I should have done it at all. But the chairman of the Canada Council, Jesse Wente, uh told Jesse he shouldn't be interviewing me at all. There were three or four different academic associations uh that said that you know that this was horrible, that this was akin to genocide denial.
SPEAKER_00The co-inventor of the of the, or the inventor of the concept of residential schools denialism described my piece, Year of the Graves, as a textbook case of residential schools denialism. Uh last year, I guess it was last year, the RCMP uh published a survey of threats to national security and so on. They identified residential schools denialism as a threat to social cohesion in Canada and footnoted Year of the Graves as evidence of residential schools denialism.
SPEAKER_00There's no such thing as residential schools denialism, by the way. It's a phantasm that doesn't exist. It's uh there's there are people associated or people who are accused of being residential schools denialists. They're not all very nice people, by the way. They don't like me very much, or some of them don't like me a lot. Um but the whole concept is a conspiracy theory. The the pri in fact Sean Carlton, the co-inventor or inventor of this notion, has specifically described uh residential schools denialism as a conspiracy.
SPEAKER_00It's a conspiracy to um to drive Indians back onto the reservation or to upset reconciliation in Canada and all that kind of stuff. And I gotta say, there are some people on the other side, people who are described as residential schools denialists, I won't name them, who think that the Kamloops announcement and the upset and the furor and the hysterics was all part of a plot.
SPEAKER_00It was a conspiracy to uh push through the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples through the provincial legislature in British Columbia and the House of Commons in Ottawa. And those people actually do. There's a couple of them who do think, well, we should just uh rewrite the Constitution, get rid of Section 35, abolish the very idea of indigenous status, get rid of treaties, we're all the same now. So, you know, I mean there's there's extremism.
SPEAKER_00I think this is the key thing that people should take away from this. This entire conversation, conversation era has become poisoned, it's become toxic, it's become wounding. Um and and and I I've said this more than once, you know, like I I cut my teeth as a boy reporter writing about, you know, going to going to the reserve, you know, talking to old guys and figuring out what was going on. And and and there was a lot of interest in, you know, uh in in the local indigenous communities where, you know, in the in the readership area of of my newspaper.
SPEAKER_00And I would not encourage this beat, so to speak, uh to any young journalist today. It's a sad and terrible thing to say, but it is so poisonous the way we talk about the Cowachan decision. Um it's it's really it's really it's really quite awful, it's quite fearful. I mean, it doesn't hurt me that much because uh, I don't know, I'm I mean, I can take care of myself.
SPEAKER_00I'm come from an Irish Catholic immigrant family. We don't get messed around with, you know. But I mean, you know, you can imagine, eh? Some young reporter just trying to write about some stuff that that might be of interest in Indian country, uh, might be even a happy story. But boy, getting at those stories, you've got to wade through all of this under undergrowth and you know crash your way through the brambles just to get at it. It's not easy. It's it's not it's not pleasant.
Aaron PeteOn the contrary, though, I would say it's fertile ground for somebody to start to lead the conversation. Oh, because yes, yes. And if you're willing to take the arrows and the tomatoes as as you've experienced, there's comes a credibility. With who you are as a person that you're willing to kind of wade into difficult waters and try and do so thoughtfully. But I guess I would just be interested to follow up because I'd be curious as to where you think Sean Carlton specifically and Pam Palmeter alongside him, where are they coming from?
Aaron PeteBecause they hate me. They won't platform, they think I'm platforming people. You and me goes, buddy. Yeah, I'm I'm a malicious person. I'm just trying to get my community out of poverty, and I'm doing my best to look at reality as it as it shows itself to me. And I never want to be intellectually dishonest and claim ground that doesn't exist or build something like reconciliation, which is a government policy that taxpayers pay into on grounds that aren't truth, on inaccurate information, because I think that hurts us in the long run and creates this space for conspiracy if we don't act honestly and in good faith.
Aaron PeteWe First Nations people asked for truth and reconciliation. We cannot now say we don't want to seek truth. And I see I just interviewed uh the attorney general of BC, uh Nikki Sharma, who's talked about criminalizing Indian residential school denialism. And I was like, am I am I on your list? Because I'm speaking with Francis Woodlosen. I've spoken to um Tim Thielman, I've spoken to Nigel Bagar, like I've spoken to these people, and they they put forward their arguments, and I'm open to hearing those. Like, what is the goal here?
Aaron PeteSo, what do you think the driving force behind individuals like Sean Carleton and Pam Palmetter are?
SPEAKER_00There is a okay, I I think, and I wrote this in my uh, this is an opinion I have uh in my piece on Year of the Graves. It's kind of an opinion, I suppose, or it's an analysis, is that we the the the Anglosphere, for sure, to a broader extent, sort of the Western world, if you like, is undergoing what you might be, what has been described as a crisis of epistemology. Epistemology is the study of how societies go about the business of determining what the truth is.
SPEAKER_00And we have 300 years of enlightenment experience and institutions in figuring out what the truth is. And if you're a journalist, you don't usually have to carry around, you know,$5 words like epistemology in your pocket. You know, the arriving at the truth is a fairly straightforward or very rigorous bit of business that based on the proposition the truth is comprised of facts. And facts are discernible and verifiable according to a certain methodology that's been tested and tried for decades and decades.
SPEAKER_00I came up in the old guild system, you know, six years an uh an apprentice, and then you're a journeyman reporter. Um and and the conventions of journalism uh very, very, very it was a trade and it had strict rules, and it was very, very rigorous. Um and, you know, whether it's in uh the field of medicine or law or um historiography or you know, in any of the social sciences and humanities, that whole notion of how you go about the disciplines and the rigor and the methods required to determine what the truth is have been completely deconstructed in many, many, many fields.
SPEAKER_00Um it is uh convenient to politicians, I think. Um you look to the United States and you have this strange post-truth environment in which the president of the United States can say whatever he likes, and it doesn't have to be true. His follows followers will believe it or support it. Um in the case of people like Carlton and Palmetter, they really are, I think, uh functions of a thing called was the there was the Frankfurt School.
SPEAKER_00Like long story short, when Marxists realized that working people were not about to overthrow capitalism and you know, seize the means of production, and uh, you know, these sort of theories and ideas were developed about hegemony and ideology. And the mutation of that school over time sort of replaced ordinary working people with you know a kind of a rainbow coalition of oppressed subalterns, and and third worldism has a hell of a lot to do with it.
SPEAKER_00And so you find it's very, very interesting in Canada the loudest voices on the proposition that you know residential schools were were an exercise in genocide and that Canada is an irredeemably racist colonial genocide state, uh, are the exactly the same people after October 7th, three years ago, who emerged, you know, screaming and shouting in the streets about Israel being a racist colonial genocidal state.
SPEAKER_00They're the same people. So it's the same kind of mindset. And and indeed Sean Carlton has been part of that as well. So um, I mean, he can explain himself. I don't, you know, it's like personally, I think the guy's a nut. Um, but that's my personal opinion. It's just that his his allegations never hold up. And he's he's a he's an obsessive. And he's dishon-I think he's dishonest. I won't call him an academic fraud because I think that would be libelous.
SPEAKER_00Um, and besides, when you look at the standards of so many of the social sciences and humanities faculties today, fraud is relative.
Aaron PeteI guess I would just follow up because like I believe in putting yourself in somebody else's shoes so you can see their perspective. And I have a real challenge with that with Sean Carleton and Pam Palmeter, because one, they won't speak to me. Um, and even so, like, so like if I put myself in their shoes, I would go, okay, we've got this First Nations chief. He's wrong and he needs to be corrected. Why wouldn't they want to talk to me off the record? Why wouldn't they want to connect with me? Why wouldn't they want to do an interview and pitch their argument to me?
Aaron PeteWell, you frighten them. Understand.
SPEAKER_00I would say it's probably because you frighten them.
Aaron PeteI don't like, but I'm not that intimidating. Like I just ask things. I would let them, I would let them lay out their argument without stopping them, without like arguing with them. Like I just want to hear them lay out to find denialism. And then I just have a few questions like, how can it be denialism if people are just asking questions about the Kamloops case? How is that them denying the other 150 years of history? How does that come together? Why are you trying to make it sound like um Holocaust denial? Why are you trying to create those similarities intentionally?
Aaron PeteLike, I would just have questions like that. It wouldn't be like a hostile interview. I just genuinely want to understand how they see the world because it's so different than how I see it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think they they're frightened of you. Because I don't think anyone's actually asked them those kinds of questions before. And I think they know very well that they would not be able to defend the claims they make.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_00They would be, you know, particularly, I think, in the case of Mr. Carlton, uh, would be quite, you know, I mean, he's got he's on, you know, in the Rolodex of half the CBC reporters in this country. And he's shows up in an all in all the sort of fashionable places. Um but nobody actually questions him serious, seriously about this stuff. You know, he'll say, well, we don't really mean that they're denying the existence of residential schools, but they're downplaying the impact of residential schools on indigenous communities.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, it's kind of hard not to downplay the impact of residential schools on indigenous communities if you deny that it is proper or right or decent to compare the St. Mary's Indian Residential School or the Cantalups Indian Residential School with Auschwitz and so be bohr. Okay? Now I'm not gonna have that. I there is a line where I actually I think I'm entitled to an opinion.
SPEAKER_00And I think uh I am I I I am entitled to the justifiable opinion that that is an obscenity, an absolute obscenity to equate what we all know is uh for so many indigenous people that it was really trying and draining an emotionally destructive experience in residential schools with the death camps. I'm sorry. No, we're not gonna I'm not gonna put up with that.
SPEAKER_00I won't tolerate it. And as I say, it is a conspiracy theory. And it's not you know, it it it it has gone right to the sort of liberal establishment. I hate to, I don't mean to be partisan about this, but you know, Kimberly Murray's reports, I mean, my God, you read that stuff, and it is um apart from the evidence tampering that occurs in it, uh, and the absolutely extraordinary uh claims that she presents in it.
SPEAKER_00Um it is kind of you know, textbook. Um anti-imperialist sit settler colonialism, genocidal racist state stuff. And it's very it's it's very actually weak sauce at that. And um I I don't think these people get challenged. They they don't get people honestly uh asking them honest, curious questions like of the kind the kind that you prefer to ask people in good faith.
SPEAKER_00Um so I that would be my my answer to your question. That's why they don't like you, that's why they're scared of you.
Aaron PeteYeah. Interesting. Out of curiosity, you've studied residential schools. How would you describe them? Because obviously we have a portion of society that'll kind of going, residential schools, they weren't so bad. And I've had comments in my YouTube section going like, come on, just give us one example of how they were good. And you get people who just kind of want to like push, push it to a little bit more of a middle ground. Uh, and then you have more people who are extreme who said this was all done with the best of intent and to benefit people.
Aaron PeteWhere do you land on the spectrum of opinions?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think I may have been the first national columnist in Canada to say that it is not unreasonable at all to describe the residential schools pro the federal residential schools project as um a policy of cultural genocide. I have no quarrel with that. I do have one little quarrel with it, in that the the the and it's a paradox. And it's that you know the the the actual the evidence, the more striking evidence that there was a kind of an intent uh uh with respect to cultural genocide, that in those instances the motive was actually to prevent the physical extinction of indigenous peoples.
SPEAKER_00Talking about on the prairies, right? Primarily. So, I mean, I think cultural genocide, if you want, okay. I'm not gonna call with that at all. Um, I just don't know that it's a very helpful way to understand a very, very complicated experience that changed over time. Between the 1920s and the 1950s, I think, when the federal government actually did go about the business of removing children from their communities for the purpose of kind of turning them into little white people.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's hard. Cultural genocide, uh, fine. I'm not gonna get, you know, I'm I'm not gonna get worked up either on I it's a cure, an interesting sort of academic debate. I don't know that it's very helpful for ordinary people who are trying to understand the experience, um, because it's immediately sets up a whole bunch of taboos around that you're not allowed to trespass upon. And the other thing is that the reality is, I mean, I when I was uh asked to write that book in collaboration with the former students of St.
SPEAKER_00Mary's Indian Residential School, I was asked by Chief Bill Williams, who's uh great guy. Um, Kellitz, I guess. Anyway, and he was head of the uh Indian Friendship Center and mission at the time. And um he's, you know, they'd done some preliminary work and sort of recording people's reminiscences and so on. And he was actually angry with the way a lot of white people, shall we say, were talking about St. Mary's. You're saying it wasn't like some concentration camp, for God's sake.
SPEAKER_00It was complicated. You know, and I said to him, I remember saying to him, because I had a pretty dim view of residential schools at the time, very generally, um, my friend Cyril Pierre Catesy, an elder, who um had become known, I think, in the broader Stalo community as a very, very sober, stern sort of voice on the matter of the residential schools. Um I think I went first went Ulikan fishing with Cyril when I was like 20 or something.
SPEAKER_00So I knew him for a long time. And I said, you know, I told Big Chief Williams, Cyril's gonna be my lodestar here. You know, we uh I will meet with a whole bunch of different people and I will put something together. Uh, but you know, I'm gonna be doing this with Cyril, right? To make sure that, you know, I wasn't glossing over anything. And I always had a a kind of um a lodestar, someone to bounce ideas off.
SPEAKER_00Um, and I was also really fascinated with the the history of the oblates of Mary Immaculate, did one an astonishing history. The people who ended up running the St. Mary's Indian Residential Schools, school, amongst others, they were chased out of the United States out of the after the Oregon Treaty of 1846, when British Columbia lost the southern half of British Columbia and the border was drawn at the 49th parallel. The obelisk were burned, their missions were burned down by the U.S.
SPEAKER_00Callery for allegedly siding with the tribes in the Yakima War and the Nisqually War and so on. And they're they were a really interesting bunch of people. And the early days of St. Mary Mary is interesting. The controversy there is that they refused to strap the kids. They didn't, they wouldn't do corporal punishment. So, I mean, it was all of this weird stuff that the whole, this is the other thing I think is really the most damaging, I would say, aspect of this dysfunctional conversation about residential schools, is you can't get through it.
SPEAKER_00You can't get past it to what's on the other side. The amazing history of the indigenous people in this part of the world, I would say particularly most populous in the Stalo area, the broader Coast Salish area, most populous center of human habitation in North America, north of the Valley of Mexico and west of the Mississippi, the the indigenous oral tradition, the stories, the rich oral literature of the people, the peculiar experiences that those indigenous people had with the first white people.
SPEAKER_00And and their comprehension of Christianity and Catholicism and how any syncretic form of Catholicism had emerged here before the missionaries are even arrived. You know, the if you look, if you do a proper history of Catholicism in lower, you know, the southern half of British Columbia, there were prophets, there were Christian prophets, and they were all indigenous. There was a really interesting thing going on there, really interesting complex. Um and then, you know, I mean, just the history of the participation of indigenous people in the early uh emerging sort of European-influenced economies, the Hudson's Bay Company, um, like a third of the Hudson's Bay Company workforce west of the Rocky Mountains were Hawaiians.
SPEAKER_00And in Peter C. Newman's sweeping history of the Hudson's Bay Company, they don't even get a footnote. And then you had, you know, the seal, the fur seal industry. It was almost entirely a coastalish affair. Really huge sealing schooners, and they they hunted seals as far as the Sea of Akotsk and they overwintered in Yokohama. I mean, there's all of this fascinating history uh and the the the contributions that indigenous people made in building the society that ended up being British Columbia, all of that stuff you can't get anywhere near it.
SPEAKER_00You can't get anywhere near it for two reasons. You've got to walk through all the residential school stuff in order to get anywhere near it. You have to construct this notion of indigenous peoples, these sort of meek children of the forest that were brutally acted upon, rather than robust, tough guy participants in a lot of this stuff. Um, and it punches a hole in this sort of narrative paradigm that unites Pam Palmetter, Sean Carlton, Justin Trudeau, Mark Miller, and a lot of other people, and much of the bureaucracy, which is that indigenous people were acted upon and that they are victims, and that they've all they need healing.
SPEAKER_00Now, maybe it's because of the company I keep, Aaron. And coming up, you know, as a journalist and just as a guy, you know, the indigenous friends and neighbors and even distant relatives. Um what I always like to say about that period before the sort of uh postmodern post-truth environment took over the conversation, was uh it took a lot more than some white guy wearing a Walmart war bonnet at Coachella to hurt their feelings.
SPEAKER_00They were tough guys, they shut down half of this province, for God's sake. Railroad blockades, you know, logging road blockades. They they they you know, they came from these little reserve communities and they said, no, this isn't right. We need to stop the wealth leaving our territories. We need to talk to the local fishermen, local sawmill workers, we need to stop this from happening. They were tough guys. And, you know, at the height of that activism, which was pretty spooky for a lot of people, the public opinion polls showed that most British Columbians actually supported the indigenous position on the question of Aboriginal title.
SPEAKER_00You know, rather than cast white people as these, you know, racists and you know, the enemies of these poor indigenous people whose feelings can't be hurt, we have to protect, um, to the point of sending anybody to who disagrees with us to jail for two years. Um you know, there it was a very robust movement. And you're familiar, you would be familiar with it yourself in Stallow Country, the fishing rights struggles that your people went through.
SPEAKER_00My God, this was not for the faint of heart. And um, and and so, you know, there's just this rich pageantry of story and history, I think, that we're we're almost it's almost impossible for us to get our heads around the fact that this actually occurred. One last thing, I was talking to a publisher last two weeks ago in Toronto. He'd phoned me up. He'd I'd written this piece about British Columbia's history and James Douglas, the Octoroon, as they used to call him, governor of the colony and his wife, who was an Irish Cree woman, uh Lady Amelia, and this polyglot society that it was emerging in British Columbia.
SPEAKER_00And he said, Well, why don't we know? And it was the struggle against slavery, too, which was hugely important to this, you know, during the American Civil War, and you know, they were pushing up into across the West. Uh and I said, Well, you know, the residential schools thing is a lot, it's like the only thing you're allowed to talk about. And it's really hard to push through all that stuff in order to get at these stories. And he said, Well, you can't exactly push through it. I mean, you know, there were 215 children who were discovered buried at Kamloops Indian Residential School.
SPEAKER_00And then I went, Oh my God, where do I, where does one begin? Right? Where where do you start? So I don't think I'm gonna write any book for that guy, but uh it's uh yeah, no. It is the the this it it's it has been, I think, extremely damaging to reconciliation. I think it's been extremely damaging to relationships between ordinary people who are both indigenous and non-indigenous, whose opinions on these subjects actually are not that much different. The only place where they get an airing, I'd say, is is places like uh Nuanced.
SPEAKER_00So well done.
Aaron PeteThank you. Uh, just following on that same line, you wrote a book based on testimony from survivors of St. Mary's Indian Residential School, which my grandmother attended. What did those survivors teach you about respecting testimony while still verifying factual claims?
SPEAKER_00I think the main thing, and after Camloops, by the way, it was updated. There was more the the elders got together and said we need to republish this book, and there were some other testimonies that they wanted to get in there. And so I thought that was pretty cool. Um I think the main thing is curiosity, you know, and and and generosity and sympathy and understanding. You know, when you can get people who had completely different kinds of experiences at St.
SPEAKER_00Mary's. I mean radically different experiences.
Aaron PeteCan you make some of those just to help us understand the differences?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, to just talk about them and to appreciate that there can be such things as significant differences in individual experiences, and to respect that. Um you know, and and a lot of it, uh, I it's a difficult thing to talk about. A very difficult thing to talk about because it involves what the you know the term we use now is spirituality.
SPEAKER_00And there is a very profound spiritual, very deep spiritual component to this. I don't think it's unique to what we might call Catholic Indians, but um there is there are reasons why Catholicism so easily took root. Uh the there are reasons why a syncretic Catholicism emerged that was kind of like the old Smitla Secret Society, the Spirit Dance, you know, and it was kind of like Catholic devotions that white people would know.
SPEAKER_00But it was lively and it was beautiful and it was deep and it was indigenous or indigenized. And uh so that aspect of it, I think is very, very, very, very powerful, very warm, very welcoming. But uh I think you know, you can get it wrong. I think that's the thing. You know, if you try to impose a narrative paradigm on top of it, uh you can get it wrong.
SPEAKER_00I I think what it's curious, I think. Uh have you been in the you've been in the big house, obviously. Yes. Yeah. Do you find it curious that one of the most important institutions of coastal society, you know, the big house or the smoke house, people will call it. You basically, you know, it's not like you're not allowed to talk about it exactly, but it's like you just leave it alone. Don't like I'd be into a big house, and it's like, okay, you can take notes for yourself if you want, but you know, don't write about it. You know, you sit over there with those guys and don't eat too much salmon and careful drive when you drive on the way home.
SPEAKER_00Um the those institutions that are not subjected to scrutiny and are not pulled into acts of performance and are not problematized in the context of you know overburdened theories about indigenous, non-indigenous relationships or colonialism. Those are the institutions that seem to hang on and survive in a really healthy kind of way.
SPEAKER_00So I find that curious. That's something I learned a lot. I took a big lesson from that.
Aaron PeteWhat were some of the challenges people faced at residential school that stand up to you?
SPEAKER_00I think the main one is, as you might imagine, being pulled out of your community and put in this big institution, and you don't get to see your folks for weeks or months on end. That is really scary. Really, really, really scary. Um, and it is damaging. I mean, it all depends. There are I know that there was one study that seemed to suggest that language retention um among indigenous people between the 50s and the 70s was was greater among residential schools graduates than otherwise, right?
SPEAKER_00I don't know what that means. I don't know why that would be. Um the other thing is that um I think the wounding, and I I I I'm I it's an idea I have, and I'm not sure I don't know if I'm right about this, but you know, Catholics are weird, right? We're we're you know, I I was raised Catholic, I can say this. We, you know, see the Protestants are great, you know, they have their own ideas, and everything is symbolic and metaphorical to Protestants.
SPEAKER_00It's all kind of intellectual, but to Catholics, no, it's real. He's you know, Christ is president in the Mass and all this kind of stuff. But it it is it is real. You know, there's a certain way of uh appreciating spirituality that is is is very objective in in Catholicism and also the role of the priest. My God, I mean he's not just some guy who makes a speech on Sundays and you know leads a sing song. This guy has the power of administering the sacraments of the Mass.
SPEAKER_00This guy hears your confession, he knows your deepest thoughts, he knows your sins. And when the trust in a priest is violated, this is the psychic damage that this will cause is almost indescribable. That's the other thing I think that's important to remember about all of this. And I don't want to I don't want to say this is the common experience with indigenous people, but nonetheless.
Aaron PeteRobert Jago said you were not a residential school denier, but argued that your article omitted important context uh about some of these cases, including Tekem loops. What do you think he got right in his criticism?
SPEAKER_00Well, I can't say that he did because he he he his main complaint was that I failed to report that Chief Rose Casimir intended to and was going to exhume those graves. Okay I talked to Rose Casimir, like I think he before it was after Year of the Graves, and then before Robert said these things. There is no there there was no plan then four or five years ago, and there isn't now.
SPEAKER_00So I'm sorry, I've been kind of exonerated, right? Um, and I think Robert, bless his heart. I mean, there's family stuff involved. Okay, and I think that might have influenced some things, you know, an attitude I think Robert was actually taken advantage of by Jesse. I think he exploited Robert. I don't have any quarrel with him. We'd always got gotten along like a like fine, you know.
SPEAKER_00He's a very interesting guy. Um and uh unfortunately for Robert, I think that his criticism has not held up because events as I describe them and the intentions of the Kamloops leadership um have been borne out.
Aaron PeteWhat's going on from your perspective with the community? I think I saw a report that uh could be Roseanne Casimir said, it'll take maybe a hundred years for us to get around to excavating uh and confirming the remains. Um, as you may know, there are other reporters like Blacklocks who are trying to get the records of what's being submitted and the information being to the federal government. And they seem to not want to share publicly uh what's being communicated between the two parties.
Aaron PeteUm, are they just stuck? Like some will argue, they're just stuck in an impossible position. They feel like they're standing on a fault line. So if they come out, do the excavation and find out there's nothing there, then denialism will run rampant. And so the position is argued that they're not wanting to excavate because this is a vulnerability, a chink in the armor. And if they excavate, they're in a bad situation. But people say then they're guilty of um what people are accusing them of, of being dishonest and not being upfront. And that the longer this drags on, the bigger the issue becomes, the more clouds hang over our head, the harder to push through this issue.
Aaron PeteAnd then I believe, and I hope I'm not mischaracterizing, I believe Francis believes they knew from the outset and that their previous chief was aware that this was a bold claim that was going to have some results to it. That's what she, I think, intimated to me in our conversation. Um, but I don't want to misquote her, that they know and that people are continuing to talk and behave like that there are confirmed remains there, that the local university is still making those claims, that they're still acting like this is all the case.
Aaron PeteAnd so that if they weren't guilty then, then they're definitely guilty now of being dishonest. What are your thoughts on where the nation is and what's going on here?
SPEAKER_00Well, I tend to be a pretty forgiving guy. I think this may be one of my faults. Um try to put yourself in her shoes, right? Like, let's just say that, and I think a case, a very strong case can be made. I think the evidence is pretty clear on this, that Rose Casimir was at the center of this little dust storm, this this little hurricane, um and got kind of swept up in what she was being told by this committee of knowledge keepers, as they are called, on the in the community.
SPEAKER_00Very powerful committee, and you know what it banned politics can be like. Um and she kind of had to say what was being expected of her, right? Meanwhile, she has this, and I won't name her, but a very high-priced public relations animateur of the whole event. And then she's got Tanya Talaga from the Globe and Mail, who's there days before the announcement was made. Tanya's acting as some kind of an interlocutor between the Globe and the Prime Minister's office and Maurice Sinclair.
SPEAKER_00And it was really weird. Um and I think they said things that they shouldn't have said. And I mean, if you read the press release, it's kind of weird, sort of new age language. Like, what the hell? You know, we are we dealing with a discovery that you've made or not? You know, what's all this stuff about knowings? And what do you mean a child as young as three years old? Who is this child? Um, and and and then the next thing you know, it's an international story, right?
SPEAKER_00And it's like, holy cow, and the flags are lowered on Parliament Hill. What are you gonna do? Are you gonna come out and say, actually, I think we may have been wrong about this? You know, that's that's tough. That's tough. A lot of people, I think, have vested their entire careers and their academic reputations on the proposition that anybody who questions the likelihood that there are bodies in that old apple orchard is equivalent to a Nazi who should be put in prison for two years.
SPEAKER_00Academic and political reputations have been built on cattle and everything that happened after. And that's why it is such a sensitive topic. One of the reasons why. And and I mean, I in the community itself, you know, I know some of those people. And um I remember a couple of months, I think it was after Manny, after my piece came out, uh Year of the Graves. I've known Manny Jules half my life, more than half my life.
SPEAKER_00Former chief and a really important guy, very, very important leader. And Manny was very clear, you know, like the 13 major families in Tekemlips, they want to see an exhumation or an excavation of some kind. We can't just keep this up. We need to deal with this, right? And um also around that time there was a perfectly reputable uh geospatial site inspection guy who provided the count, who's curious about all this, you know, just as a uh an innocent citizen who happens to be professional in these areas, who said, wait a minute, I've done, you know, here's a here's all you can get these site surveys that show very clearly the history of soil disturbances in the vicinity of the orchard.
SPEAKER_00There's absolutely no reason to assume that the anomalies that you have encountered can be explained by what even a lot of the older Kamloops people said were just scare stories they were telling each other when they were kids. That there were, you know, there was all these septic drainage tiles and all this other work that had gone on there. That report was given to Chief Casimir. I think it's a terrible position that they have allowed themselves to be put into.
SPEAKER_00Um they've got to sort of carry on as though it is true that there are, you know, that these stories about children being woken up in the middle of the night and forced to dig graves for their dead classmates in these weird rituals overseen by nuns in the middle of the night under the moonlight, that these stories are somehow true. You know, so many people.
SPEAKER_00I I mean, what is what would Justin Trudeau what happens if there's you know an excavation there? And it proves absolutely nothing. And you have leading members of the community who are finally unafraid to say, we told you so. We told you so. What's Justin Trudeau gonna say? The next time he, you know, during a break in one of the, you know, his dance videos with Katy Perry, you know, a reporter says, It turns out that canal's thing was uh wasn't what you said it was.
SPEAKER_00Nobody wants this story to be fully and honestly told. Or very few people do. And I would say this goes for, I don't want to, you know, sort of both sides, if you like, of the argument. The people who are called denialists and the people who make the accusation of denialism. I don't want to overgeneralize. I think Francis is an honest broker, for sure, Francis Woodowson. Uh, I think also Barbara Kaye is a perfectly honest and decent person.
SPEAKER_00I mean, these are people whose opinions are just totally different than my own. Yeah. But um, you know, nobody wants to see that peep that community of people vindicated. So it's just this is what happens when you won't deal with the truth. It gets away on you, you know. And there are a lot of journalists in this country who are gonna want to scrub their bylines from a whole bunch of stories they've written.
SPEAKER_00You know, about children, children's corpses sunk at the bottom of lakes and priests decapitating altar boys, and child babies being thrown, you know, thrown into ovens. Um a lot of people have actually vested you know a great deal of political capital and income and reputation in these stories being true.
Aaron PeteI guess uh my follow-up just out of curiosity would be like one of my criticisms, um, and I think you'd be sympathetic to the first nation, it sounds like you are, but is that we're governments. Yes. So we can't, we can't, we're taking taxpayer dollars. Like we're not, it's not like we made a claim, like none of none of anybody else's business, which is how I feel like the nation is kind of phrasing it, like this is our our business, it's not your business. It's like, well, you made it a national headline, like it's no longer just your business now.
Aaron PeteYou made it a global phenomenon, obviously in in keeping with Justin Trudeau and the Liberal Party and the media and all of these things, but you were a participant in this process, and so now it's not just your business anymore. Now you can't like I don't think it's a defensible position to say this is for our community to decide now. Like, no, you made it a public thing. If you didn't want it to be a public thing, it shouldn't have gone out in the news, it shouldn't have had a press release, it didn't need to be like a national story, you let it be, and and now the roosters have come home and you have to deal with the consequences of that.
Aaron PeteAnd I think it's it's it's wrong of them because this is having impacts not just on their community, it's impacting my community, it's impacting people on the East Coast, it's impacting First Nations and Indigenous people across Canada. And so the the consequences of your actions aren't just being felt by you. I'm being called a grifter because of what they did. And like that's leaking on to other First Nations.
SPEAKER_00This is something that's really important to notice is that one thing that I find, you know, uh another opinion I actually have on the subject is and it's main, it's I get a little bit angry, I have to confess, when I have, you know, this vast um body of literature that has come to be called the oral tradition. And in the case of the Stalo, it would be Chaals, the Transformer, and then the stories of Raven and and and uh you know Hok Hok, the great bird of heaven further up the coast.
SPEAKER_00I mean the Norse sagas, the Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita, that level of literature, right? Serious stuff, world patrimony, conflated with stories that your uncle said he heard his grandfather tell him about one of his cla something his c one of his classmates said. You know, these are different uh types of literature, different types of knowings, different types of knowledge, different types of oral history.
SPEAKER_00The the conflation of these things I think is just unspeakable. The conflation of the residential school system in Canada with the Nazi death death camps of the 1930s and 40s. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. No. The conflation of the very, very, very real suffering that indigenous people, many indigenous people endured in residential schools, not in some kind of Oprah Winfrey way, you know.
SPEAKER_00I'm talking, you know, court evidence, convictions of people who abuse the children in their care. The conflation of the the the agonies of those indigenous people with fabulous stories about, you know, children being uh woken up in the night to bury their classmates. I'm sorry. You know, they're the the in the real world, um, we gotta deal with the real world, and in the real world, I think there is now a fairly significant body of evidence to suggest that a great deal of harm was done to reconciliation, to Canadian identity, to our understanding of our own shared history by this mass psychosis that was induced largely by the federal government.
SPEAKER_00And that a lot of journalists in this country collaborated in. I don't think anybody wants to, you know, there's not people don't want to deal with this. People do not want to deal with what happened. And so the people who will notice that, wait a minute, you know, a lot of lies were told. A lot of people who will be saying these things, they don't have a filter. Well, let's be kind put it that way. You know, I'm not saying Francis Whiddowson. Some people around that community, they basically do.
SPEAKER_00They want to get rid of, you know, get rid of the Indian Act, get rid of treaties, get rid of status, you know, screw this Aboriginal rights nonsense. You know, there's all kinds of agendas at work here, I think. And we really should be honest about that. That is certainly the case in the matter of the Cowchan decision. That's certainly the case in the matter of the way the provincial government has, I think, foolishly attempted to integrate the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People into every single statute and zoning by law and traffic ticket in PC.
SPEAKER_00Bless their hearts for trying, I guess. I don't want to be too I don't want to be mean about this. Um, but the whole damn conversation is just so wounding now, so furious and crazy. Um a lot of damage is being done by this, a lot of damage.
Aaron PeteMay I ask, based on everything presently known, what do you believe is beneath the Kamloops orchard? Children's burials, unrelated disturbances, or something we cannot yet identify? Well, that's an interesting question.
SPEAKER_00Uh, and I, you know what's interesting about it? The word believe. That's what it's come down to, right? You can't, you know, we're not allowed to it's not it's not about what we're allowed to know. It's what we're expected to believe. And I all I've always said from the beginning, phew, given, you know, what we know just on a preliminary, uh, you know, if I if I didn't know what I already knew about you know, these stories about Queen Elizabeth kidnapping children from the Kamloops Indian residential schools and taking them away, all this stuff, on the face of it, it's not entirely implausible that through the history of this Indian residential school that there would be there would be the remains of children that were unaccounted for in an orchard.
SPEAKER_00It's not totally implausible. Um just very briefly, there are children who died at residential schools and whose remains were never brought home. This happened. This happened, and you know, the federal government committed took them five years, I think. They committed only 38 million dollars to memorializing these sites at old residential schools.
SPEAKER_00Um and only five something five million dollars of that money had been spent by the time the Kamloop story broke. Um I don't know what to believe. I only know what I know, and I know what I can reasonably conclude, and I think a reasonable person would have to conclude that if you're making making an extraordinary claim, my God, a massive crime scene, 215 corpses, you know, secret moonlight burial rituals, if you're making an extraordinary claim like that, I bel what I believe is that you should at least have an ordinary degree of evidence to support it.
SPEAKER_00That's all. And we don't have anything like it. We have no evidence to support it.
Aaron PeteThe Globe and Mail has called the original coverage a failure of journalism, while Canada Land has revisited its treatment of the story. Do you feel vindicated?
SPEAKER_00Um Well, I felt vindicated a long time ago, I suppose. I felt vindicated as soon as I sent the story into the National Post before it even appeared. But I get what you mean. Uh to some extent, I think. I mean, at the time, people should remember it wasn't public because it was too scary to say anything like this. But there were indigenous people who were calling me from across the country saying, You hang, you know, serious people. Hang in there. This is a complicated story. You tried to tell the story of what happened. Something very strange happened in 2001, 21.
SPEAKER_00And I had journalists for every major news organization in the country phoning me up and saying, You hang in there, Glavin. What you did was important. And I also saw what happened to journalists who said that publicly. How wickedly and viciously they were treated. Just for saying, Yeah, Glavin's written an interesting piece here, people should read it. Um so yeah, I guess you could say I feel vindicated to some extent. Since my story still holds up after all this time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I also find it very odd, don't you, that people say, Oh my god, you know, we this long overdue reckon, you know, long overdue um reckoning with residential schools. And my God, we didn't know about these horror stories about children being taken away from their families and all this tuberculosis and all these deaths. Well, you know, where the hell have you been? You didn't know this? Like, you know, people who shouting the loudest, you know, declaring their virtue, you know, confessing their absolute ignorance about this chapter or in in in Canadian history, you know.
SPEAKER_00Um so yeah, vindication, uh, it's not something I mean, it sounds like a boast, if I were to say that. So I'm I'm reluctant.
Aaron PeteI guess I would just challenge that that type of thinking of like feeling, like I get why you would feel like it's boasting, but I think we're in a time now, you talked about like post-truth era, where the only thing you have is your credibility on the last story, in my opinion. Like where you land on these issues currently really define you with with Canadians. If you don't, if you got the COVID story wrong and you have not come out to take accountability for potentially reporting that wrong, I'm not saying you did. I'm just saying if you get those types of stories wrong and you don't come forward and confess you were wrong, you're you have no credibility.
Aaron PeteAnd so credibility, I think, is growing. It used to be if you had a badge that said the CBC or global news, you had credibility. Now it's where are you on these issues? And can the audience or can Canadians trust you to be an honest broker? And why people like Francis are growing followings is because they're willing to say the uncomfortable thing. The media ignores them and they just continue to grow because people are like, well, they're being honest and you're not. And so I'm not going to bet it all on the global news that won't even touch this story.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I do find it amusing that Francis is sort of dismissed as this disreputable right-wing nutcase, when in fact she's not. I mean, she comes from a left-wing Hegelian, even Marxist tradition of thought. But also that people who complain about the right wing making hay out of this issue, well, that's what you get. If you're if people aren't, if people, if reasonable people of reasonable political opinion are not going to deal with these issues reasonably and honestly, there's going to be somebody who will who will make a big deal of it.
SPEAKER_00And you might not like them. Like this is, I think, a very interesting, it's kind of a function of the our epoch, our the moment in history, is if you look at Trumpism in the United States. I have I have to ask the Democrats is how did you lose to this guy? You know, I mean, and the other thing, you you know, you said something very interesting. You know, you said something along the lines of, you know, the truth is really all we have, right? Um that used to be a very, very important bit of knowledge.
SPEAKER_00That even in the great causes of social change and social justice, well, the you know, the wealthy might have the armies and the banks and the insurance companies, and but we have the truth and the truth will out, right? You could say that now. If you can't say that, then you got nothing. You got nothing. This is also interesting, very much an establishment issue, that this is mainly a phenomenon of wealthy white people or upper upper middle class white people.
SPEAKER_00If you talk to most indigenous people, I mean they listen to the CBC like everybody else does. So, you know, on this issue, they might not be as well informed as you might be.
Aaron PeteAre people still listening to the CBC? I'm not sure about that.
SPEAKER_00Well, curiously, you know, there is a problem. I mean, I you know, you should be, you remind me of Peter Zofsky. Are you older? You're probably not old enough to remember Peter Zofsky.
SPEAKER_02I am.
SPEAKER_00He was a CBC radio guy, beloved across Canada. Didn't matter whether you're conservative or liberal, you know, a guy who could talk to fishermen in Newfoundland and loggers on Vancouver Island. And it was a place, you know, we had what was it called? Morningside. What you do, by the way, is very much like that tradition. CBC should hire you and pay you seriously big money for what you do. That CBC used to do this. CBC used to do it.
Aaron PeteThey're busy ignoring my existence and pretending uh we don't have a platform here. Um, but Terry, how can people follow your work?
SPEAKER_00Well, you can read read the National Post. I would very much like it if people would subscribe to my newsletter. It's called The Real Story. And for God's sake, save me from myself and take out a paying subscription. I'm an idiot. I just apparently, you know, I just recently learned it was buy low, sell high. I mean, I was just such a fool. I was on Mike, uh, you know, Michael Campbell's Money Talks podcast a couple of weeks ago, and he lectured me about how I'm not running my business properly. And he's probably right.
SPEAKER_00But it doesn't matter. Just subscribe to my newsletter, and I'd very much appreciate it.
Aaron PeteWell, thank you for doing this, Terry. Uh, I have a lot of respect for people who come out on issues and and state their position and lay out their their argument clearly and take a lot of negative feedback. I like I respect Francis for being willing to do what she does because it's not evident when you get removed from your university that it's the right decision. Like a lot of people would choose the safety and security of their job over speaking what they believe to be the truth. And I believe you did the same thing and were maligned for that.
Aaron PeteAnd it takes a lot of bravery and courage and a certain type of integrity to do those types of things. So it's just always a privilege to speak to people like yourself who are seeking out the nuance and trying to find a way to honor what you heard from real-world accounts, right? Both you and I have spoken to people who were abused and harmed and have bad experiences, but that doesn't mean we run from the conversation about cam loops and go like, well, I heard their story, so I'm not going to deal like be an honest broker on this issue because they're different and we can acknowledge that and hold space for both.
Aaron PeteSo I'm just very grateful for your time today.
SPEAKER_00Well, you're very kind. Thank you very much, Aaron. And I wish you all the best strength to your sword arm. I think you're doing magnificent work. Keep it up.
Conservative MP Dean Allison discusses the Allison Inquiry, COVID-19 vaccine injuries, compensation claims, government accountability, vaccine mandates, Justin Trudeau, Pierre Poilievre and public trust with host Aaron...
University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe examines Mark Carney's 2026 federal budget, government debt, Old Age Security, interest rates, inflation, productivity and Canada's 2027 economic outlook with host Aaron...
Daily Hive national sports editor Rob Williams joins to explain the Vancouver Canucks rebuild, Quinn Hughes trade, Whitecaps relocation risk, BC Place, taxpayer spending, FIFA World Cup, BC Lions and sports journalism...
Canadian veteran and former sniper Jody Mitic joins to discuss Remembrance Day, Afghanistan, the New Veterans Charter, veterans' benefits, Mark Carney's defence plans, drone warfare, and returning to military service...
Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty joins to discuss Indian Act reform, Bill S-2, residential school denialism, reconciliation, Billy Morin's floor-crossing claim, First Nations child welfare and the future of...