LEPHT HAND PATRONS Q&A: Part 1 - Spinoza, Sound as Image, and the Consolation of Philosophy
1 hr 15 minAudio
AHRC Courses: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses Several weeks ago, we asked patrons to contribute questions to our very first Q&A episode featuring Serpetie, Emma, and Bob. In the discussion, we tackle questions on the topic of Spinoza’s subversive political legacy, how the thinkers we read shape the way we relate to others, and whether sound or image is closer to memory, the body, and the symbolic. Along the way: Deleuze’s consolations, the gaze of eternity, and the surprising case of Spinoza and the premonition. Support LEPHT HAND: Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/LEPHTHAND Emma's Substack: https://elftheory.substack.com/ Sereptie's Substack: https://splitinfinities.substack.com/ Merch and Design Shop: crit-drip.com Acid Horizon Links: https://linktr.ee/acidhorizon Sereptie (ambient project): https://sereptie.bandcamp.com/ Acid Horizon Research Commons is now live: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-main The Lenox Institute for Advanced Study: https://lenoxinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hello everyone, we're glad you tuned in for another episode of Left Hand. Before we begin this QA episode, a quick note. This ended up being quite a long discussion. And because our public feed has a limited number of hours and minutes, we've put the first hour or so here and reserved our final discussion of Renee Girard and Peter Thiel for our contributing subscribers. Also, among the big changes noted at the start of this episode, the classes that will be made freely available to the public will come first to left-hand subscribers.
SPEAKER_02While we set up our website and Patreon to deliver those classes in the accessible and handsome format we've envisioned, I've included links to both Emma's and Bob's classes in the patron exclusive portion of the episode. So if you are already a patron, thank you. And if you're not, becoming one will help us find the extra funds we need to publish longer episodes on our main feed. Now, without further ado, the QA.
SPEAKER_02Okay, everyone, welcome to the special episode of Left Hand, where we tackle the QA questions that were submitted to us over the period of what, four to six weeks, something like that. There are a few of them sitting in the clip. And we here at the podcast have been quite busy with a few things in the studio today. We have Emma and we also have Bob Langan. And I think it's important to say maybe at the top of this episode, some of the shuffling that we are doing in the world of Asset Horizon Research Commons Left Hand, the Asset Horizon podcast, and so forth.
SPEAKER_02Over the past year, we have been graced by the presence of Emma, and she has brought to us many interesting discussions and guests, and she will continue to do so with Left Hand. Although, because of your support and because of those who have supported the classes at AHRC, it has allowed us to onboard Bob Langan, who just delivered an excellent class on Jung and Spinoza for the Acid Horizon Research Commons. And he will be doing more with the Left Hand podcast, mostly in 2027, but I have a feeling we'll be getting started a little bit early by doing a couple episodes either in November or December of this year, including this one, the QA episode.
SPEAKER_02So we'll hear from him in a bit. I'll also say this in conjunction with this mini overhaul that we are doing of both the Asset Horizon and the Left Hand podcasts, you will be seeing some new freebies in your world. And so those of you who support the Asset Horizon podcast currently at the, let's say, the$5 level or this podcast at the$5 level, we are now creating a way where you can take advantage of our growing archive of classes just by stepping up your Patreon contribution.
SPEAKER_02And then you don't have to pay for the archive separately. And actually, that will bring the price down and all will be right with the world for everybody. However, in addition to that, we are going to release a few of these classes for free for the general public, just so that listeners and viewers of our podcast can see what we are up to, and also to offer just a nice gift to folks. And among those classes will be both Bob's class on Young and Spinoza and Emma's class on acid communism will be made available so that if you haven't taken advantage of those, you will be able to do so with relative ease.
SPEAKER_02But with that said, let me just welcome Bob and Emma back to the podcast. Bob, do you want to say anything about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I just wanted to say thank you for that announcement. Real excited to be part of left hand and further contribute to what you and Emma have already done here so brilliantly. Real excited to get on board and some of the things that probably the topics I'll be covering are kind of touched upon in some of the QA stuff we're getting to today, but really excited to be here.
SPEAKER_02And Emma will be appearing on more episodes of Asset Horizon going forward as we shuffle the roster a bit. I don't know if you want to say a couple things about that, Emma.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm really excited about all of these shifts. It's been a wonderful year. It's been really interesting. I think it's a logical evolution in terms of the range of my interests, in terms of what Bob is bringing. So I'm really excited for 2027.
SPEAKER_02All right. Thank you both. Yeah, and we have a grab bag full of QA questions here today. And for the first time, I glanced at the questions, but I purposefully failed to prepare for this so that these questions would hit me raw. So you're going to get my raw and shallowly considered response with each question, with the hope that amid responding, it will stir the deep, dark, and murky waters of my knowledge base.
SPEAKER_02Maybe, Bob, what why don't we do this? You reach into the grab bag. What is a question that interests you? I'll let you read the question and then you take a stab at answering it, and then we'll just kind of go around Robin. We'll have Emma and then I'll do the question. In some cases, maybe one of us will just pass on it. I don't know. Sound good?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, sounds good to me. I'm going to just take a glance in here and I'm going to start with oh God, I apologize if I mispronounce this, but Andre uh Cerna, who, and again, if I mispronounce that, my deepest apologies. But Andre writes, lately, I've been thinking about the ways in which rationalism continues to shape our everyday lives and how we have moved from the Kantian idea of autonomy toward a condition of complete cybernetic heteronomy. Maybe you also discuss this in some detail in Antiochulus.
SPEAKER_01I also think Tikan touches on this when discussing the power dynamics of the early modern state, and in the process, has a bit of a beef with Kant and his monopoly on morality. And another thing, it would be great if you could talk about Spinoza's philosophy and its subversive political readings today, such as in Negri, Hart, Stolze, etc. Obviously, I chose this question mostly because of the last part. I might leave the bulk of it to you two, but I will take a stab at that last part first. Yeah, this is of great interest to me, Spinoza's readings for a political philosophy.
SPEAKER_01And the fingers that you bring up are very crucial to figuring this out, just to set the scene. Post-war Marxists, mostly French, also Italian, European Marxists post-war, very interested in trying to conceive of instead of a Marx plus Hegel, a Marx plus Spinoza, basically try to reread or jettison dialectics working towards an external unity, towards something based on affect and imminence and things within, say, an imminent reality or an imminent plane of existence.
SPEAKER_01Altoussey, Louis Altousse is probably the most one of the early major proponents of this in some of his works on Marx and trying to think of instead of again working towards an external causality, some sort of causal imminence. There's different ways of approaching this problem. There's the Marxist who are approaching it more from the Marx side. You also could put political thinkers like Antonio Negri into this. Then you have the people who are really under the hood with this problem, a book Craig and I have talked about a little bit that we might talk about at some point, Hegel or Spinoza by Pierre Macaré.
SPEAKER_01That's as under the hood with this stuff as you can get. That's basically why did Hegel read Spinoza the way he did. Hegel's treatment of Spinoza was extremely influential. He both respected Spinoza, famously saying, you're either a Spinozist or not a scholar at all. But that also said Spinoza can't account for the finite, the individual, the subject, everything collapses back into a faceless substance. And that's what I, Hegel, can get us past. Macaré, he's not the first person to point this out, but he says this is not a fair reading of Spinoza, that Spinoza accounts for the individual.
SPEAKER_01And Hegel might be reading Spinoza this way because he's afraid of certain things in Spinoza's system, the openness, the a broken one, if you will, that's completely open and not going towards a absolute end, so to speak. So that's another book on this. And then just the last thing I would say on this point, which I think is the most pertinent, probably the most interesting for all of us here, is any sort of post-Marxist, post-leftist political philosophy, I'm convinced has to account for affect somehow and almost the evaluation of affect.
SPEAKER_01And a lot of the more current thinkers on this problem, whether whether it's Ted Stolze, who has a great book on ethics and Marxism and how Spinoza is a good resource for this, how do we choose the effects? How do we not get drowned out in negativity? Or his anthemon, Spinoza and his evaluation of affect and distinguishing affects that we create versus things happening to us. He's really crucial to that. And Spinoza's philosophy is crucial to that. So yeah, I think in terms of like affect or just a, I think this will probably come up with a few other questions in this chat.
SPEAKER_01A positive political philosophy, Spinoza is center of. So yes, I will leave it at that and then I'll punt the ball.
SPEAKER_00I can speak to the first part of this question. I will refrain from commenting on anything related to Spinoza, but when it comes to the ways in which rationalism continues to shape our everyday lives and moving from a Kantian notion of autonomy towards a condition of complete cybernetic heteronomy. And I want to point out for listeners that cybernetic is in parentheses here, which I think is interesting, but I'm gonna make much of that parenthetical in this question.
SPEAKER_00Starting with the bastard notion of rationality and reason that we get from Silicon Valley, I think that we're at an inflection point where a lot of people are feeling something like what Deleuze theorized in the postscript on the Societies of Control, where there is this sense of a displacement of whatever force it is that we consider to move our thoughts, a displacement from that force being located within us to located without us.
SPEAKER_00So we get a Kantian notion of rationalism as being about self-legislation and the application of our intelligence, to put it in crude terms, towards the decision-making, the movement through life towards some sort of an ideal way of living, to put this in sort of simple terms. If we have this sense that thanks to living in a disenchanted or hyper-institutionalized or hyper-technological society, that we are now caught within a system where we are no longer, or perhaps some veil of illusion has been cast to the side, and we see that we were never in control, and we're kind of merely objects being acted on by forces that we can only sort of delude ourselves into believing we have any sort of agency around.
SPEAKER_00The idea that we can recuperate some autonomy by rationally, in the Silicon Valley sense, coming into some understanding of these forces and then figuring out how to optimize various aspects of our lives or of our thinking in accordance with them. While I think that there are still a number of people who subscribe to this, and I'm thinking of specific contingents of thinkers either literally in the Bay Area or sort of being inspired by the West Coast rationalist movements.
SPEAKER_00I think that the limits of that way of thinking are now becoming a little bit more prominent. So there's this whole idea of the post-rationalist, more occult right wing, the idea of like the restoration of the mystical and the romantic into instrumentalist, functionalist thinking. And as far as what we can do with this impasse, I mean, I'm still favorable towards the Kantian idea of autonomy.
SPEAKER_00And I think that the incorrect move here is to put reason on the side of the repressive. You know, this is another sort of way of only responding to the bastard notion of rationality. I think going back to understanding what it is exactly that allows thought to become free and self-directed is useful. But as far as our social condition is concerned, what really concerns me is that I don't think we're living under ideal circumstances for individuals to not simply stop at seeing the technological, cybernetic, like totalitarian matrix of being caught in this web of forces that are all serving as inputs for further outputs without any sort of possibility of stepping beyond this flattened world and into something that would be sort of more like an individual sense making or any sense making that can sort of get beyond its own subordination.
SPEAKER_00And that they're only sort of going to react to this by recourse to the mystical and the romantic in a way that's very much aligned with conservative thought. So that's not very positive. I'm not extremely optimistic, but that's my off-the-cuff way of making sense of this question. I don't know if you have any thoughts, Greg.
SPEAKER_02Well, because we recently had the event with Stuart Kendall, and we were graced with his presence and had the luxury of being able to hear him live give a lecture on waste and deep time. It got me thinking about the question of rationalism versus irrationalism, what is a sort of counterweight to the hegemony of rationalism, let's say.
SPEAKER_02Stewart's reading of Bataille is influential to me because I think what he does is he makes a kind of Nietzschean move, at least in terms of how we frame the question of rationalism versus the kinds of irrationalism that it represses. Rather than saying, well, which one is it going to be? Are we going to live in a world defined by rationality? Are we going to give ourselves over to a kind of abject irrationality, despite what the risks may be?
SPEAKER_02So the reason that I like Stewart's treatment of the question in his reading of Bataille is that it's really more about the question of when. The question of when is the time for reason, and when is the time for the irrational, so to speak, really might be the question of what is the time for productive expenditure, what is the time for non-productive expenditure. And I think even those questions can be unpacked further to say there are various kinds of non-productive expenditure.
SPEAKER_02There, there are various forms of, let's say, an indulgence or an appreciation of the irrational dimension of our experience that have a particular time. And there is a time, as Stuart would say, for kinds of ordering, kinds of planning. And I don't think this is simply about being a moderate and like finding a way to recuperate non-productive expenditure in the service of productivity. I think the question of when just displaces that binary altogether.
SPEAKER_02And so that's just one of the ways that I'm kind of thinking about rationalism. I will also say there is one more thing that I did want to say. I recently picked up by accident a series of essays on Derrida and negative theology. And one of the things that I have uh done in my own personal reflections on the work of Bataille, Blanchot, Jean-Luc Nancy, and Agamben in particular, is that I see their work uh tending towards something like a negative theology.
SPEAKER_02And this was an accusation that was aimed at Derrida in his formulation of the trace and the you know the whole presence-absence distinction. And Derrida makes a very uh careful and uh meticulous argument uh against these accusations that what he's doing is a kind of negative theology. But one of the things that he does do, that I'll sort of recast in my own terms here, is that once we consider something like uh rationalism, it seems like an alternative, a sort of political antidote might be to secularize a kind of negative theology to the extent that we want to undermine rationalism by shifting completely to an irrationalist position that almost functions like a negative theology.
SPEAKER_02And I would argue that the destituent power position can be like this. I'm not making the accusation full on here, but one of the things that I think a certain secular negative theology tends to do is it tends towards a kind of hyper-essentialism that Derrida points out in his essay. That's something that actually I want to get into in an episode of either Acid Horizon or Left Hand, because I think criticisms of negative theology are just absolutely fascinating.
SPEAKER_02But I think in challenging the metaphysics that that that comes from the place of those who criticize productivism, who criticize rationalism, I think it's a very short step away from the kind of hyper-essentialism that Derrida illuminates in his explication of the problems with negative theology. This is something that I hope to work on in the context of one of our future episodes of either podcast. So, with that said, I'll turn to Emma to dip into the grab bag and find something for us.
SPEAKER_00Here's the thon one that I assume we all could have something to say to you because it's not, it's not something that wouldn't just come up in like the flow of conversation in all sorts of different contexts. All right. Alexander asks, how has the way you relate to others changed over the course of your life? Did any specific thinkers find you at the right time? And if so, what were the effects of that encounter? So I can jump in with a few thoughts here and then we can take it from there if any, if either of you have things to say to this.
SPEAKER_00I'll try to keep my answer concise because this first part of this question about how you relate to others and how it's changed is one that could accommodate hours and hours of conversation, I'm sure, between the three of us. One thing that I want to put out there, considering an audience that is made up of people who might be more introspective, people who are inclined to listening to philosophy podcasts.
SPEAKER_00So I might be making too many assumptions here, but what the heck? It has only recently occurred to me that people like to be put on the spot and have attention fixed on them and be asked to rise to the occasion of your attention. A lot of people in the world of theory and philosophy are introverted, are not inclined to become a major presence in other people's lives unless they are absolutely certain that they are wanted.
SPEAKER_00Now, I might be indulging in armchair psychologizing here, but this question seems to want that. So we're just gonna we're just gonna roll with it. I've noticed this time and time again with interlocutors and friends who love to have and listen to these kinds of conversations that I'm I wouldn't go so far as to say that there's a certain meekness or inclination towards being timid. Those words are not quite right, but I have always been of the mindset that when people want to hear from you, they will make it absolutely known.
SPEAKER_00And that being an overly large presence in somebody's life just runs the risk of violating something sensitive or special to those relational dynamics. And I mention this because again, I think that this is just a tendency among a certain type of person. Maybe that's true, maybe not. But what I've discovered in part through the vocation of teaching, because when you're teaching, you are putting Yourself in other people's faces and you are holding them in your attention and you are making yourself unignorable.
SPEAKER_00But also as I've started to become a bit more bold in my relationships with people, in terms of reaching out, in terms of making observations or making statements that are a bit of a risk, saying things that I'm not necessarily sure that people want to hear, that kind of thing, is as often actually taken as a sign of respect or affection or love. And that it puts other people at ease. So for folks who have this rich inner life introspective orientation, where I think so many of us have such complicated inner lives and complicated thoughts that we don't quite know how to show up for other people unless we are explicitly invited and there's no ambiguity.
SPEAKER_00I would say to think of it not as an imposition, but that you're doing other people a favor by showing up and just kind of putting yourself right in front of them. The second question is about specific thinkers finding you at the right time. I have thoughts about that, but maybe we'll come back to that. I'm curious about whether Serepti and Bob have things to say to this first question.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. The first thing that I mean, there's really so many things you can say. I think one of the things that I'm curious about in just looking at this question are the ways that I have changed unconsciously as a result of my exposure to certain thinkers. That's a curious question. What are the ways that reading these ideas over the years has influenced me and shaped my interactions with other folks unbeknownst to me? But I would say that the primary way that, let's say, reading theory and maybe even psychology in particular, psychological theory, Nietzsche just comes to mind on so many levels.
SPEAKER_02But and I don't want to reduce Nietzsche to a sort of self-help view, but I think his deep consideration of where values come from has ingrained in me a sense of or has developed an eye for when I have a friend, an interlocutor, a comrade, a co-collaborator or whoever. One of the things that I think my work and theory has done, it has shaped the acuity that I have for determining not only what someone's values are, but where someone is most firm-footed in their values to the point of being inflexible.
SPEAKER_02And where in a person's set of values they might accept a more ambiguous, if not contradictory, set of beliefs about things. Where is the little bit of Jekyll and Hyde in that person? Where do they kind of waver between two sets of values? And I mean, anybody could use this information to manipulate somebody. But I think what philosophy and theory has done for me is it has created an occasion or a re a reflex in me where I step back in my relationships and take time to consider what are this person's values?
SPEAKER_02What are the kinds of interactions that they value? What are the outcomes that they value? What are the kinds of things that end up leaving them satisfied? And what are the ways in which those what I find satisfying or what I find valuable, how does it dovetail with their values? And where do we conflict and contrast? I mean, in psychological theory and theories about relationships, I mean, the one thing they say is the reason that relationships come to an end typically is because of specific value conflicts.
SPEAKER_02There's some fundamental or core value that people have. And when they don't interface well, that is the demise of the relationship. So I mean, I guess I'll stop there for now. I would, I wouldn't mind hanging out on this question for a bit if we all want to kind of go back and forth on each other's responses, but I'll give it to Bob for now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. Yeah, Emma, a lot of what you said about almost finding the confidence to speak in this space is actually maybe invigorating or a source of comfort to other people in this space because philosophers often can be more on the introverted side, perhaps. Or quite frankly, and I'm just speaking for myself sometimes, afraid to speak up because you don't want to butcher it and then get outcasted, right? I mean, there is that fear. I would say that the two parts of this question, how I've related to people, how has that changed, and thinkers who've had a great influence on me.
SPEAKER_01I think I'll be able to segue into the second part of this question because for me at least, it is I can see the clear lineaments between those two sides. Frankly, I mean, in our youth, we all can be stupid, but certainly in my undergrad years, I I fell afoul of some of my close friendships, honestly. And I was called one of my closest friends called me out on a few things that I wasn't even aware I was doing that might have been pissing people off. And rightfully so. It was one of the most important conversations anyone could have had for me because I just was acting so unconsciously and projecting things I wasn't even aware of.
SPEAKER_01And I stopped and I said, Well, what is this? And quite frankly, that is what put me down the depth psychology route at that point, where I said I want to understand this unconscious thing more. I'd read a little young at that point, but I hadn't gone deep off the deep end with it. And that really set me down that path and really therefore always questioning, well, what if I act this way, what is the cause of that? What is the motive behind that? What is the unconscious desire behind that? Realizing that I was not aware necessarily of how I was maintaining my friendships and the effects I was having on them did lead me down the path of, okay, I want to understand this unconscious, you know, and that led me down, that obviously led me down a certain road.
SPEAKER_01During my graduate years at the University of Essex, uh going into school, I was absolutely, and I still am to some degree, but I was absolutely the guy who wanted his sandcastle theory of everything works. I have my world building here and I figured it out how it all works, right? And reading Deleuze kind of killed that for me. That's kind of when I let that go at that point. And I realize he has his own ontology and it might do that in a different way, I think a more honest way, quite frankly. But that let me go of any motive, oh, I need to fulfill some view of the world and myself in a model of how everything works.
SPEAKER_01I kind of let that go at some point. I was just reading the things because I enjoyed it and I was more open to just chasing certain lines of thought at that point. Yeah. And then even when I when I dropped out of school for a little while, that's when I went through like a Nietzsche phase. And I think that was sort of like maybe just sort of flipping the bird to institutions and stuff and something in there about Rosanta Montt was coming out towards the way I saw the people just kind of going through the grind but hating it to get their doctorate at the end. And I really questioned that. But yeah, I mean, there were different thinkers have always come along at different stages for me for different reasons.
SPEAKER_01And that has changed how I both deal with the world and view other people. I would say my last point on this is again, after those college years, I really did start questioning every motive. But there has come to a point where it's, okay, if you're going to being in the research world or in my case, having a day job where it's just a day job of a certain persona that's well and good. But you'll, I'm sure we all notice from if you write anything and put it out there, at some point you just have to say, okay, I'm just going to put myself out there.
SPEAKER_01I might be wrong. I'm not going to be able to read every book on the earth, but I've given this problem a lot of thought and I'm going to put it out there. And I think that kind of ties into what you were saying, Emma, which is sometimes you just have the confidence to be bold and say, this is what I think. Here you go. And I suppose this past year, going from a somewhat solitary thinker to being very much in the online space with you guys, acid horizon, et cetera, has going back to maybe thinking less about just saying certain things, trusting myself a bit more.
SPEAKER_01So maybe that's kind of come full circle, but it's almost one of those things where I had to take everything apart after 15 years to put it back together, so to speak.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it's just interesting to hear, and this is just coming to mind right now. I mean, Deleuze says that thought, the activity of thought is instigated by a violence from the outside. Analogously, our apprenticeship in philosophy is often kicked off by a humiliating event. You know, being humiliated or being heartbroken. I mean, certainly in my case, I think it was a breakup with a high school girlfriend that set me on the path to looking at things like the doubtaging.
SPEAKER_02And I think I talked about that elsewhere. But also just having those setbacks in life where somebody calls you out, they call you on your bullshit, or you get a picture of yourself that doesn't correspond with the one that you carry in your wallet. And that that sets you on a path to thinking in new ways. Also, just really quickly, and maybe Emma, you want to fill in a little bit more on this too. We're reading The Logic of Sense, and we are now on series 25 on university.
SPEAKER_02And while I was rereading that again last night for the second time in my life, it made me think how even Deleuze's concept of university, which we'll get into in the reading group this weekend, uh, has a sort of therapeutic value to it, in the sense that it gives you a metaphysical picture where one might imagine yourself as an other to yourself, seeing you along your own lifeline in a sort of chronological sequence as being multiple splices of this individuating force.
SPEAKER_02And they all exist in this continuum in a way in which, for example, the me at age 25 is different than the me of age 35 and 45. And in some grand metaphysical sense, the paradox of their coexistence is made possible by this theory. And that's not explicit within the theory of university, but against other things that Deleuze says, like his own little version of Amor Fati, counteractualizing the event and so forth, seeing that metaphysical picture broadened and the space that it makes for paradox and the notion of there being an event that contains all the events has this capaciousness to it that I think allows for a kind of I it creates the conditions for a sort of self-acceptance.
SPEAKER_02I'll just say that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's a lot that we can do with this dyad, these two questions. Originally I hadn't read them as being related, but now hearing what you both have said and reading this again, how is the way you relate to others changed over the course of your life? And did any specific thinkers find you at the right time? If so, what were the effects of that encounter? Seeing how they might go together is really interesting and it's catalyzing a lot of thoughts.
SPEAKER_00But I'm gonna select one strand from all the different things that are going on in my head right now and try to tell a story. Back in, I want to say 2015, maybe 2016, I read Byang Chul Han's Society of Transparency, and it was one of these works of philosophy. As many people have pointed out, Han is a very accessible philosopher in terms of getting to what might hit you at a soul level or function as a sort of therapeutics.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't take a lot to get that out of Han. And that was a time in my life where I was very burnt out. I had just finished my master's degree. I was in the process of applying to one PhD program. I wasn't even sure that I wanted to continue in academia and was trying to wrap my head around various issues with technological society, what I was thinking about on a somewhat theoretical level, but also feeling implicated by as somebody who doesn't have very strong memories of life before the internet.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I have some, but I was really online at age seven or eight. So I feel very much like the story of the internet is the story of my life. And this was feeling both very pregnant with philosophical meaning, but also personal meaning, and I didn't quite know what to do with it. So The Transparency Society was an important book for me because it gathered together so many impressions and ideas that I was vaguely familiar with, but hadn't at that point read the original literature that he was drawing from.
SPEAKER_00And then later on, as a PhD student, I read Baudrillard's Ecstasy of Communication, which is those two books make different arguments, but ecstasy of communication deals with a lot of the same stuff that Hahn is dealing with in transparency society. The idea that an informational world is a pornographic, obscene world, pornographic in the sense of being obscene, not it's not about literal pornography, although Hahn deals with that a bit in his book.
SPEAKER_00But this idea that rendering everything in a fully representational format is profane. And that the society of technological media is a society of total illumination that vanquishes any sense of differentiation, any sense of mystery, any sense of interiority. It doesn't allow for anything that could be considered a dialectical unfolding.
SPEAKER_00All of these ideas coming together in a more sophisticated theoretical version that we get in Baudrillard, not to sideline Han, but it's just how it is. I love Han, but Baudrillard deals with a lot of the same things earlier and at a more sophisticated level, at least in this domain of topics. It was hugely influential for me. But it also affected the way I thought about myself and my relationships with other people.
SPEAKER_00I will go on record saying this in a way that I don't think in hindsight was particularly productive or healthy, because it left me with the impression that in a world of constant quote-unquote sharing, sharing is the verb that we have been given for incessant data production and the platforming and mediatization of our lives, in a world where we have internalized the compulsion to actualize by turning our lives into a spectacle where there seems to be no difference between self-actualization and the rendering of one's life a spectacle.
SPEAKER_00From all of this, thinking in a way that at the time I thought was lucid, but in hindsight doesn't seem quite so coherent. All I could make of it in terms of my personal life and just kind of mediating inner and outer life is that you can't really be open with people fully. You always have to keep something to yourself because if you believe that you can spill your guts fully divulge all of your secrets to another person, you are doing a pornography of the self, so to speak.
SPEAKER_00And you relinquish some autonomy, you relinquish quite a lot of dignity, spirit, grace. And I just didn't think that there was anything constructive towards the kind of person that I wanted to be or life that I wanted to live, if you weren't kind of keeping some cards to your chest all the time. But there's another text that I want to bring in here and a whole other way of looking at things that represents to me just an evolution, honestly, mostly in the way that I relate to other people, although there's a theoretical dimension to it as well.
SPEAKER_00Heinrich von Kleist on the gradual production of thoughts while speaking, uh, German playwright, but this is a very influential essay. I read it in a literary theory course. The idea that you cannot predetermine the flow of thought before its realization in the moment in language. And the way that this maps onto what I was saying earlier is that you might think that there are aspects of yourself that you keep to yourself, you keep your hearts to your chest, thoughts that you have, aspects that can be rendered as concepts, words, but you don't share them with another person.
SPEAKER_00But I'm more partial now to the idea that unless you have some notion of an other or a witness, I'm not sure that it's even logical to speak of those parts as having a lot of reality to them. I think the belief that you're keeping some things to yourself is more of kind of a feeling or orientation than something that is quite what it seems to be. Like you've got these attitudes or beliefs or secrets or what have you. And in in some sense, they represent this interiority that the informational society, the Silicon Valley Rationalist Society, that's a callback, seems to want to completely defing, to completely obliterate.
SPEAKER_00I don't think that those things are actually substantiated unless we can imagine some other. Maybe it's an other that's within ourselves. Maybe it's it doesn't need to be an actual other person. But I'm actually even more partial these days to the idea that what it means to be, what it means to be invested with thought, what it means to be a thinker, is to be in communication. And I've developed this, or I did develop this very bastardized notion of it because I was just reacting basically to technological society.
SPEAKER_00And to wrap this up, it it has been better for me, both as a theoretical thinker, somebody who reads theory and philosophy and takes it quite seriously, but also just as a person to trial this in my friendships and my relationships, to not think that there are always going to be parts of myself that can't enter into conversational play, but instead to just not think that way and to not think of myself as anything like a black box. And uh, I actually think that is a wiser move.
SPEAKER_00And I kind of hate using this term in this context. I just can't think of any other, a more intellectual move, even if uh maybe it doesn't appeal to those of us who wish to preserve some sense of mystery or enigma around them.
SPEAKER_02Have you spent a lot of time with Klasowski's work?
SPEAKER_00No, I haven't.
SPEAKER_02He's somebody that I think you would benefit from if you wanted to develop that line of thought. He's awesome for that. Bob, I don't know if you wanted to pop in with a response there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, just quickly there. I think some of the stuff you were just saying there, Emma, made me think too, you know, in addition to thinking of another where these things we try to interiorize always play off upon. It's just also just everything's inherently relational, even the things that maybe we think we're not enunciating outright. And I'm thinking in terms of whether it's the idea of, oh, this is something I thought or wish I don't like it myself. I'm going to repress, but then it still comes out within whether it's a classical Freudian slip or just unconscious desire, like in the anti-edipist sense, where you might have a pre-conscious setup of or an intellectual idea of what politically I should stand for, but then your unconscious desire may not cohere to that in the slightest.
SPEAKER_01I mean, that contradiction will get revealed one way or the other through your actions. I mean, I've to go back to something Craig said earlier, sometimes relationships ending because your values are different. I mean, I've been in situations before where you don't want, you consciously don't want that friendship to fall apart or something. But even if I don't speak up, hey, I don't agree on this anymore. It's going to come out one way or the other because everything is relational at the end of the day, too, right? And that's the affect of rationality, too.
SPEAKER_01Like if you're not cultivating and an outright saying on and acting upon it, it's probably going to come out more violently and forcefully, like that violence of thought, like like Craig was saying. The other thing, just to put a ribbon on this for myself, this topic, because it's really good, is this might relate to one of the other questions indirectly, but why do we read all, or why do I read all this stuff? Why do I read philosophy? Why do I read depth psychology? And I think that can be. Different for everyone. I think I would not presume that that could be a universal answer. I think there's certain things we probably have in common. We wanted to have a we find it intellectually exciting.
SPEAKER_01We might just enjoy it. We probably want a political or civic utility to it, some sort of radical change that could come out of it for society. But also, is it just an ethic or a way of being? Can it, can this stuff, does the quality of what we're forging hold up when shit hits the fan and things get bad? And there's a lot of passages from even that 25th series of University and Logic of Suns that Craig mentioned. I mean, I was kind of a pig in shit with that this week because I I I love when Deleuze writes on that stuff.
SPEAKER_01I just love when he brings up eternal return and university and seeing things from that gaze of eternity. And I sent it to a friend of mine who's a practicing depth psychologist. And she said, kind of following it. She's just, she's just starting to get into Deleuze. So some of these terms are just whizzing by her head, but she could follow it. And she said, okay, well, I hate to put my clinical cap on for a second here, but what are you getting out of this? And I think she was anticipating me giving like an intellectual response.
SPEAKER_01Well, you see, and it's had you know it can connect to Spinoza's idea of God and you know, other philosophers, something like that, right? But I just said, no, I get sort of a deep joy or even sort of like a beatitude out of some of those passages. And I'm not like I'm very open about that. Like it does give me that kind of soulless. And it has those kind of passages during moments of loss or grieving. I will crack open some of those patches, passages and read them. And they do work for me. They do hold up in those instances. So, a friend was pleased I didn't fall back on a dorky rationalist explanation for why I like that passage.
SPEAKER_01But then B, I think it's different for everyone. But in my case, I do think this should cash out in those extreme moments for us. We should be open to it failing and then letting it go or moving on to something else, never stick to one thing, and that's it. But if it's not providing something in those moments where we really need it, for me at least, I need that. And I that absolutely affects, again, A, why those thinkers have affected me, but then B, my outlook on people and life and events in my own life as well.
SPEAKER_02Despite Deleuze being influenced by the Stoics and the logic of sense in particular, I can't recall if the word ataraxia ever comes up in the text, right? The feeling of inner peace and calm as the Stoics and I'm not sure if it does.
SPEAKER_01I'm not sure if it does. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I mean, because clearly, I mean, Spinoza's influence is lurking there, but even in the University chapter, you get a sense of view from the space station, you know, like this is what reality looks like in its most encompassing perspective. And to me, as frightening as that can be, in some moments, there is the occasion where that does bring a sense of relief, calm, or just an island of reprieve from certain uncertainties, I guess one would say.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say, I mean, we'll get into this in the reading group, and hopefully it doesn't get butchered tomorrow. Um, but just that idea of through seeing things from as pure events or from the gaze of eternity and the Spinoza strum, you're just affirming the distance between everything at the same time. So even something that has been harmful to me, you're I'm celebrating the fact that it is different and unique from me at the same time. The poison has its own event, and that's different from me in a positive way. So it's this obliteration of passions or a negative view on things, which of course is what he ties into the eternal return.
SPEAKER_01When I think he thinks Nietzsche goes further than Spinoza on what you can do with that view of university, at least that's how he puts it in difference and repetition. But yeah, I get enormous joy from those kind of passages.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And and not to belabor this point, but and apologies to those who haven't read the logic of sense. I mean, you should.
SPEAKER_01But one of the things it's a banger.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. One of the big takeaways for me is to see Deleuze, the philosopher, build the system and also kind of re-schematize over and over again. I mean, he's actualizing the concept of event in the individual series. And you're seeing it not only as an exercise in philosophy, if you will, but as the actualization of a certain kind of ethic. And it's instructive, at least at the level of you as a thinker, have at your disposal amidst everyone that you've ever read, these tools to build this system.
SPEAKER_02I mean, once again, the word ataraxia comes to mind. Like if you want to find, if you want the constellation of philosophy, the power is in your hands. And that's not explicit in the text. I mean, in a way it is, but not in such pointed terms. But maybe that's something that we'll get into as we wrap up the reading group. But I'll move on. We'll go, I'll take the next question. I'll kick us off. I don't have very much to say, but I think I have something interesting to say about this question from Espen. It says, Hi, just a quick question that might spark some discussion.
SPEAKER_02You often talk of images connected to Hillman, James Hillman, or the weird or similar topics, but you also seem invested in sound through various ontological topics. Maybe this is aimed at me in particular, but uh we don't want to leave either one of you out. What is your all of your take on the classic divide between image and sound? Is sound more connected to memory and image, more to the symbolic? I don't want to privilege the one over the other, but I tend to think of sound as closer to embodied experience and therefore working on memories as embodied and not reflected like images might.
SPEAKER_02Greetings from a listening sound artist, straight out of the birth of tragedy here. Um I guess what I would say is, I mean, the easy answer is of course. Yeah, there are sound images. I think we might even argue for a univocity of the imaginal, where sound, tactility, visual images, and so forth each occupy a sort of equal status of sorts, might even be a reason that Nietzsche would endeavor to revise the birth of tragedy in the end, because he does give a privileged place to music over and above visual figuration, let's say, or an Apollonian notion of the image.
SPEAKER_02I mean, just to talk in a sort of brute shorthand about that text. But just bringing in the Hillman component here, yes, I'll say this about James Hillman. My reading of James Hillman is that he wants to return us to a more sensate, a more embodied sense of images. And maybe even tying into my comment about the rational and irrational, there is a time for that meditation on the sensate. There is a time for meditation on the tactility where the imperiousness of meaning and rationality is suspended and is not taken as a way necessarily to finalize or put its to overcode to use a word, put its stamp on those moments where we spend time and enjoy the duration of the sensate experience of a dream.
SPEAKER_02For inasmuch as I love dreams and dream work, one of the things that is just absolutely irreproducible is the dream event itself. And one that's so difficult to savor in its enjoyment. It's so immediate. And often when I wake up from a dream, one of the things that you're doing in the ensuing seconds after a dream concludes and you sit up in the bed is savoring those last speckles of dream flavor. And it's hard to bring that back often in doing something like dream work.
SPEAKER_02And the only thing that I wanted to say about this was that that might interest the person asking this question is well, recently we had Stuart Candle at Penn State. And I spent some time with him. And I had mentioned to him that whenever I'm about to do something like start a big project, or even do a long writing project, or maybe after I've read a book, or even before I'm about to reread something that I'm familiar with, like if I were to start reading Anti Oedipus again, I have this sort of strange habit that was once unconscious, but now I have made it into a sort of conscious ritual of sorts, is I would make music a two-minute track, a four-minute track about the experience that I anticipate having or about the project as I envision it.
SPEAKER_02Where the making of the music, so for example, like case in point, when I made the Vintage deck, the very first thing I did was I'm going to make a soundtrack for it. The soundtrack is going to have very little to do with the actual functioning of the deck. But what making a song about this project that has yet to be completed will do is it will allow me to steep myself in the inchoate image of the project and allow me to flesh things out.
SPEAKER_02And often the sound image is what propels the very beginning of that project or move it along to its completion. And I am obsessive about listening to certain kinds of music. If I find a song I like, I'll listen hundreds of times and learn every detail of it. And I know it seems to be a sort of strange habit, but it does something for me and it kind of creates a footprint, if you will, or a bed.
SPEAKER_02Choose your metaphor where that project can grow from this garden bed of the sound image that I've created. Emma, what about you on that question?
SPEAKER_00Well, picking up on the point about not naturalizing a primary division between the senses, of course, there are sound images, there are tactile images, there are combinations of the five senses that come to us phenomenologically that don't reduce to their components. That's absolutely true. But I want to say a few things about the difference between image and sound that I think about quite a lot.
SPEAKER_00Sound is really important to me as somebody who inhales music and flailingly tries to make it, but really spends a huge amount of time just listening, just listening, often doing nothing other than listening, just lying down in my apartment or going for a walk. I've had a number of people comment on the fact that when I go for long drives, I can drive for seven, eight, nine hours and listen to nothing but music, sometimes even instrumental music.
SPEAKER_00And it seems that's unusual that a lot of people prefer to break it up with podcasts or talk radio or something like that. So I'm just painting a picture here. Sound is important to me. That's the overarching point. Differences between image and sound that seem to bear on this question, at least they do for me. We can close our eyes, but we can't close our ears. And I think about this, it's a bit of folk theorizing, but something about the visual sense seems to me to correspond with individuation.
SPEAKER_00I don't mean that in any particular philosophical sense. I'm not referring to Simondone. I'm not referring to any psychological notion of individuation. I just mean loosely to a sense of being separate from other people and separate from the world around us and keeping it as simple as that. I'm not sure that I subscribe to the notion that some people are more inclined towards being a certain kind of sensory thinker over others. Like there's this folk notion of some people being visual thinkers, some people being more naturally inclined to think in terms of sound.
SPEAKER_00But I do think that it seems to be a bit more natural for people to call images to mind than other sense impressions. I can imagine the Mona Lisa and something about the imagination of the Mona Lisa or a lake I have visited frequently in my life. I can see that in my mind's eye to a degree of verisimilitude that feels higher than an impression of a flavor or an impression of touch.
SPEAKER_00So again, this is very much in the vein of folk reasoning, folk theorizing, but something about the imagistic, the imagistic in the sense of corresponding to the visual. Of course, that's not the way that we are tending to use the concept of image on this podcast in accordance with the way that the thinkers we deal with refer to the image. But the imagistic and the visual, something about that seems to align with something that's both more private and more abstract, maybe, than the other senses.
SPEAKER_00And sound, even though it's very easy for me to call to mind all sorts of different sounds, and I have a library in my mind of songs and song lyrics and chord progressions that will probably be the very last thing to go for me after my memories all start to fade. I will be remembering chord progressions from my favorite rock songs when I was 13, more so than conversations with friends or anything like that. Sorry, but I think a lot of people relate to that.
SPEAKER_00It does seem, again, I can't really qualify or substantiate. There's something about it that does seem to be maybe closer to the body. I'm thinking of something that I read years ago about how when we're developing in the womb, we develop a sense of rhythm early on because we hear the heartbeat of our mothers. It's so primal. I mean, heartbeat, rhythm is inside of us. Rhythm literally keeps us alive, and we have an embodied sense of rhythm without which we would quickly expire.
SPEAKER_00So maybe there's something to that. Although I know a bunch of folks might look at this as a kind of reduction to the biological and the body as primary. Something about that seems quite important. And then another thing to throw in here is the experience of witnessing through the eyes, of looking at artwork, for example, or seeing intentionally looking, something about that seems to be more sort of naturally private than the experience of listening.
SPEAKER_00And I'll use an example: going to see live music naturally, I know that's a problematic adverb, but we're gonna put that to the side for now. Naturally seems to accommodate experience as a group rather than experience as an individual. At a concert, you go and you are there with a lot of other people. Art galleries don't seem to work this way. Museums, it's not that you come to collectively bear witness just through the visual sense in the same way that people experience music.
SPEAKER_00Some of this might have to do with the fact that sound is also always inscribed in time. And I think that's another, yet another thing that we could add to this too. Which is all to say that I don't have a take on the division between images and sound, nor do I have any particularly finely wrought take on whether sound might be more connected to memory and image more to the symbolic. I also don't have a well-developed, grand unified notion of the symbolic that aligns with a particular tradition.
SPEAKER_00I'm not a Jungian, I'm not as well versed in Hillman as Serepti is, and I have all sorts of different definitions of what the symbolic means. So I can't really speak to that in general terms. But the last thing I'll say here is that in my studies on artificial intelligence and the apparent reduction of all aspects of life to the digitizable and that which can be rendered operational through digital networks, we see a reduction of all sorts of different forms of knowledge, but perhaps a better term here is impression to the imagistic through the rendering of everything into a graphical format.
SPEAKER_00So there's a concept from machine learning. I mean, it doesn't just align with machine learning, but that's the context in which I've come across this of parallelization, where instead of sequential information processing, you break a process into multiple different parts that can all execute at once. So the connection I'm drawing here is between being shown an image and you can see the image all at once. You can just see the entire Mona Lisa, and there's that information transfer that attempts to be instantaneous.
SPEAKER_00It attempts to vanquish time. Sound cannot work like that. Sound cannot work without duration. And so I do think that we're moving in the direction of the visual and the image as instantaneity. And something about this to me, again, going in a very folk direction without a ton to substantiate this at this point. You know, I could do some more writing and research about it maybe one day. I do worry a little bit that there's something that we could analogize with a transition from the convocational quality of sound, the connection to that which lies beyond ourselves that we get through our ears, which we cannot close, that we get to our mother while we're developing in the wound.
SPEAKER_00Not the wound, maybe that's a fordiance of the the the womb. The womb, the womb. Um so a move from something we could analogically think of as sound towards an image-based society, and that this is not disconnected from the idea of the society of the spectacle, the society of information, the pornographic illumination of everything, et cetera, et cetera. So even though this is all very, very sketchily laid out, it's something that I've been kind of fluttering over for years.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, really good from both you guys. A lot to think about. I a few things here, and I was thinking about this while you were talking, Emma, where the image necessarily lends itself to a more inner quality. And I also associate that with the image also just having more inherently a representational quality. And this could easily come up if we, you know, in the one person who asks to say anything about Bergson, but I'll just say it here, which is this idea that the image for Bergson shouldn't be equative with an inner representation, but nor can it be reduced to base matter.
SPEAKER_01It's something in between. It's matter itself being these aggregate parts of reality, these primary parts of reality that are irreducible, the image. And when I think about the imaginal or the symbolic, there's always been this question of, okay, are we putting it more in that representational level or something intra-mezzo? And seems to make more sense for the purposes of I think any discussion about the unconscious putting it more in that middle. It's when the you get into a frozen representation where meaning gets assigned, and you do try to interpret dreams and find a fixed position about something, and you can get into trouble with that.
SPEAKER_01The question for me, and this is germane to one part of the question, is sound less about the symbolic? And is it more memory? And is image more the symbolic? And a few things on that. One, Stephen Young said that more or less in some of his letters late in life, that music can basically be more a raw, effective experience of the unconscious. So he's aware of that. Obviously, he deals more purely with image as we normally think of it, but that's there. And then the question would be does sound have a symbol, can sound or music or anything in terms of sound, can it have a the same function of what a symbol would be?
SPEAKER_01It depends on how we define a symbol. If I define a symbol as the way Young would, which is it's something that can't be expressed in any way better than it is, it's not an assigned meaning. It's just pregnant with potential meaning. It's almost just a pure expression of some networking of something, whether it's an unconscious complex, an archetype. He compares a symbol to if I just pick have the image of an ant cutting a leaf and taking it down a branch and going back to its nest with it. The images of those things express their own meaning. So it's almost a neofunctionalism to it as well, which I associate with some of what Deleuze and Guattari do with what they call indices in anti Oedipus, where basically it should just be it's not they you they criticize symbols more in the psychoanalytic way of thinking about them in that text as more of a linear meaning, but the indice is almost just a pure function of how something is working beyond how we can normally causally break it down into representation.
SPEAKER_01And that's one reading of a Jungian symbol. That's at least Way I go with it. Okay, so can sound fulfill that purpose? We know there's the exhaustedly repeated account of one of Young's patients of she was a recalcitrant and very rationalist, and she was resistant to Jungian analysis. And then she has a dream of a scarab beetle. She goes to her meeting with Young the next day, and a beetle lands on the window as she's talking about the dream, and Young picks it, takes it and it's like, yeah, here's your beetle.
SPEAKER_01And then she's like, oh my God. And the scarab beetle is an image of rebirth, and it opens her up to that. Okay, great. Can sound do the same thing? All right. So not to always fall back on my main guys, but I did just teach this on Sunday. So I'll just go for it. In the 1660s, 1664, Spinoza gets a letter from a friend of his. He was a collegiate and a so a liberal Christian named Peter Bolling, who was within Spinoza's inner circle, within the Dutch Republic circle of like underground thinkers dealing with radical philosophy, let's say, a radical for the time.
SPEAKER_01And Peter Bolling was one of Spinoza's friends, and he writes to Spinoza because there was a plague outbreak at the time, and Peter's son died. And Peter Bolling tells Spinoza, I had an omen was going to happen. I was in the middle of the night and I heard a sickly breathing. I just heard sickly breath and I couldn't figure out where it was from. His son was fine at the time. It wasn't coming from the house. And then a few days later, his son gets the plague and quickly dies. Peter Bolling probably didn't die too long after this, also, probably from the plague. And he's asking Spinoza, was this a premonition?
SPEAKER_01And astonishingly, Spinoza, our arch rationalist philosopher, says, Yeah, it was probably a premonition. So why does Spinoza think it's a premonition? Well, he doesn't think it's a sound literally went back in time, but he thinks Peter Balling imagined the sound, and it could have been an omen about something that was going to happen to his son. How? Well, not through, again, matter going back in time, that can't happen. But because, and this is where Spinoza's drawing upon affect again, because of the father's love for his son, he had an apprehension of his son's essence or his son's effective power, to use that phrase instead for the purposes of this conversation, and therefore permutations and things that might happen.
SPEAKER_01So if we applied the Bergson lens to it, it was almost a widening of the aperture of potential things coming through that he apprehended in that moment, coming with this weird image/slash sound, the sickly breath, which came to pass. So why is this example relevant besides this kind of a cool, weird example of something? Because that's performing the role of a symbol, in my opinion, at least in my reading of a symbol. There's something that's it's an aberration. It doesn't make sense, it doesn't have a causal or material explanation, but it's gleaning something that one has to almost transmutate to grapple with to understand why this means something to me.
SPEAKER_01Well, father's love for son, and then something out there as well. It's a commonality between myself and something else that can't be expressed through representation, can't be expressed clearly through language. It's something common to the personal and something infinite out there, something other out there. And in that case, yeah, I of course sound can do that. It might be, and to some extent, you know, it avoids the problem sometimes of representation and freeing things and putting them more in the heights when they need to be in that middle.
SPEAKER_01It's just also there's risks with that as well. I think sometimes the idea of the sound can become an image to its own degree, right? How do you keep things without giving them make forcing them to give birth to a very specific meaning sometimes? I think that's always the game with this. What you were talking about, Craig, which sometimes with dreams you're more inclined to amplify it through, say, music than a strict interpretation. I mean, at least in some traditional readings, that kind of amplification or active imagination through art that makes a lot more sense than trying to pin down a specific meaning.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes there's a uh danger or something lost in overinterpreting one's dreams as well. So yeah, I mean, I think any if we take that idea of all images are sort of that in-between representation and a more base states of affairs, then I don't think it's limited to different senses. As Emma was saying, you got to be careful of, well, are some people more inclined to this kind of learning or this kind of experience? But I think potentially the game, you know, would be open to all there's all sorts of things that I can perceive here that I don't have an adequate understanding of, but they might reveal themselves, just like in that that one example of the imagined breath.
SPEAKER_02You know, in my master's project for my MA in education, part of the literature review was actually reviewing theories of multiple intelligences. Howard Gardner, I'm not sure if you're familiar with that. By some accounts, the theory has largely been debunked. And the research, at least at the time, at least what I read, seemed to indicate that despite there being this myth of, oh, I'm a visual learner, I'm a tactile learner, something on the order of like 90% of us are more inclined towards visual learning.
SPEAKER_02That's what, by whatever standard measure they used for the study, which I did this more than 15 years ago now. But you know, there is something interesting to think about with respect to music and sound from an archetypal or symbolic perspective, which is something like what they call the forbidden interval, the tritone in music, which there's this whole myth around like you you shouldn't play, like in the Middle Ages, it was said that the Catholic Church had banned the use of the uh tritone and the composition of music.
SPEAKER_02I think that's largely been debunked, but I think it was in the 18th century the the whole myth had sprouted up on the basis of some musical writing that came up at the time. And the use of that particular uh of the tritone and music was associated with the devil. Like that was, you know, Satan's music. It sounded like a donkey kind of hee-hawing. And uh when I did Prague Rock, my band was using the tritone in every song. Like that was the basis because we wanted that that discord, that dissonance that it tended to produce.
SPEAKER_02And you know, it's interesting to think about certain kinds of compositions as being more or less along the continuum of certain sort of archetypal figurations or symbolic figurations, or even bands that are particular songs like M and I are huge fans of Mr. Bungle. I mean, total trickster energy in that band. Take a band like Creed, for example, very heroic, failed heroes, we might say. But I mean, there's a lot of places we could go with this.
SPEAKER_02Maybe we'll finish up on one question. I wanted to do the question on Girard. Maybe Emmy, you can kick that off if we can move forward.
Is Everything Predictable?: AI, Prediction Markets, and the Philosophy of Foresight: https://www.index-space.org/programming/is-everything-predictable-ai-prediction-markets-and-the-philosop-evt-xnCQQKMg0qG8Snk Acid...
The Lenox Institute for Advanced Study: https://lenoxinstitute.org/ Acid Horizon Research Commons Ongoing Courses: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses Can something as ordinary as a selfie crack open a...
The fall season of AHRC courses begins next week. Enroll in two classes and get a third free with code 3FOR2FALL2026. Bob Langan's Jung and Spinoza: God, Affect, Destiny, beginning October 4th:...
Is astrology a harmless distraction or a pseudo-science opening a path to fascism? Or can it help us reclaim an imagination lost to the hyper-rationalism of modernity? In this episode, Sereptie and Emma trace the...
Listen to the full episode here: Enroll in Bob's class at AHRC: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses/p/jung-and-spinoza-god-affect-destiny In this Patreon exclusive episode, recurring guest and friend of the...