The fall season of AHRC courses begins next week. Enroll in two classes and get a third free with code 3FOR2FALL2026. Bob Langan's Jung and Spinoza: God, Affect, Destiny, beginning October 4th: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses/p/jung-and-spinoza-god-affect-destiny Is psychology, as we've inherited it, equal to the challenges we now face? A polished, audio-only version of the opening remarks and initial responses from our recent AHRC public panel, hosted by Bob Langan and joined by Gabriela Sova Spulirova, JF Martel, and Christian McMillan. The panel asks whether Jung can be "radical," or whether his notion of interiority forecloses that from the start, and whether our conception of the psyche remains too divorced from the material. Full panel: https://youtu.be/N1dbLVTA-l8 Support LEPHT HAND: Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/LEPHTHAND Emma's Substack: https://elftheory.substack.com/ Sereptie's Substack: https://splitinfinities.substack.com/ Merch and Design Shop: crit-drip.com Acid Horizon Links: https://linktr.ee/acidhorizon Sereptie (ambient project): https://sereptie.bandcamp.com/ Acid Horizon Research Commons is now live: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-main The Lenox Institute for Advanced Study: https://lenoxinstitute.org/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hello everyone and welcome back to Left Hand. Today we interrupt our regular programming to bring you a polished audio-only version of the opening remarks and initial responses from our recent AHRC public panel, Does Psyche Matter, Jung and the Unconscious, in 2026. Hosted by Bob Langan and joined by Gabriela Sova, Sperlarova, JF Martell, and Christian McMillan, the panel takes up a pointed question.
SPEAKER_02Decades into the era of psychotherapy and within a world of deepening crises, is psychology as we've inherited it equal to the challenges we now face? It asks whether Jung can be radical or whether his notion of interiority forecloses that from the very start, and whether our conception of the psyche remains too divorced from the material. The full version of the panel is available on the Acid Horizon YouTube channel, and I've included a link to it below. As you listen, take note that the fall season of AHRC courses begins next week.
SPEAKER_02If the contents of this discussion are something you'd like to pursue further, we recommend you enroll in Bob Langan's class, Jung and Spinoza, God, Affect, Destiny, a four-week seminar beginning October 4th on the implicit monism running through both thinkers, the union of knowledge and affect, and the point at which Jung must, in a sense, become himself Spinozist for his psychology to succeed. I should also remind you that if you enroll in two classes at AHRC this fall, you'll get a third for free.
SPEAKER_02Just navigate to the show notes and find the code for use at the time of enrollment. Anyway, let's get this conversation underway and delve into the question of whether or not psyche matters.
SPEAKER_04Thank you, Craig, and thanks everyone. Thank you for coming to this latest public panel of the Acid Horizon Research Commons. I am Bob Langan. I have a PhD from University of Essex. My book, Young and Spinoza, is available through Rutledge. I am the co-runner of the blog concerning depthology, philosophy, art and more, the Substack University Drift. And as Craig just kindly reminded you, I'll be teaching a class on Young and Spinoza with the AHRC in the fall. Please check it out if you are curious.
SPEAKER_04And speaking of Young, our topic today concerns Carl Jung. It's called Does Psyche Matter? Young and the Unconscious in 2026. And the question of whether or not Young and Jungian psychology is equipped to deal with the social, political, and ontological problems of our time. Before I introduce each of our panelists, I'm going to give some brief remarks and I'm actually going to open with a quote. And this quote is from the correspondence between Jung and his colleague Han Schmid-Gezan from December 1915.
SPEAKER_04Schmid-Gezan was talking to Jung about his theory of psychological types, and Han Schmid-Gezan was concerned that Jung was prioritizing the introverted functions of the psyche as opposed to the extroverted attitude and functions. He was valorizing the introverted nature of our mind. And this disagreement ended somewhat acrimoniously, so Han Schmid Gazan ends his correspondence with this following passage. There you are, he's saying to Jung, sitting in a tower on the Obersea, part of Lake Zurich, where Bollingin Jung's famous tower he eventually built.
SPEAKER_04Having become Nietzsche's heir, father to none, friend to none, and sufficient unto yourself, vis-a-vis here and there, a few other male and female introverts are living, each in their own tower, loving humankind and those farthest away, thus protecting themselves against the devilish love or their closest neighbors. And from time to time they meet in the middle of the lake, each in their own motorboat, and prove to each other the dignity of man with best regards, Han Schmid Gazan.
SPEAKER_04Now to me, that sort of it gets to the crux of the issue, which is Jungian psychology, with its emphasis on finding the symbolic in our lives and withdrawing projections to discover archetypal access within. A, is this diminishing the outside world too much? And B, does this prevent a Jungian perspective from dealing with social and political problems? And this is obviously a very old chestnut in the field that many people have worked on. I'm not saying anything new in that regard.
SPEAKER_04I see Mark Saban is here, which is great. Mark Sabon was on my supervisory board for my PhD, and I was going to bring him up regardless, because his book Two Souls Alas, which is from 2019, I believe, one of the best books in the post-Joungian literature, that, in my opinion, where Mark Saban points out that Jung clearly, even how he describes the two sides of his personality, or his number one and number two personality in his memoir, Memories, Dreams, Reflections, valorizes the number two personality or the inner timeless depths.
SPEAKER_04Whereas the other side of himself is more just concerned with career, scientific exploration, more just the mundane world. But it's really the retreat within where one discovers the archetypes, the symbolic and the imaginal, all the good stuff that we associate with Jungian thought. And in my opinion, for these brief remarks, it's worth pointing out three ways in which is problematic. First, quite simply just in terms of theoretical, which is if the whole point of this is to withdraw projections, to withdraw and look within, to find the archetype within that I didn't understand that I was projecting onto someone, what can we even say of the outer world at this point?
SPEAKER_04I mean, it's pretty well documented that a lot of the women, clients, and colleagues within Young's life, in some cases, whether he had relationships with them or not, that's really not important here as much as it is to say the ideas he exchanged with them later on, he might talk about in his own texts as if he was talking to just the anima and the outside was reduced. And the main takeaway there is that because for Young, most knowledge, true knowledge is routed through within, routed to explore the numinous, you can only access through the self.
SPEAKER_04Well, again, how does that let us talk about anything in the outside world? Another concern here is just a bias that might be related to economic and material reasons. You know, I'd recently just got back from, well, literally just yesterday, a conference on young innovation at UCL that was hosted by the IAJP and the IAP, AAP, excuse me. And there was certainly some good material there, and certainly some material of people trying to really critically think about why knowledge gleamed through, say, an LLM is not sufficient as the struggle that one gains through the unconscious.
SPEAKER_04But there was also quite a bit of concern about okay, how can we prove that a digital assistant can't hold the same inner space that a true analyst can, and therefore the diet and therapy is safe. And while this is an interesting discussion and very interesting research and statistical experiments going on to try to prove that, there was a current concern for me there, which is this is still a very inward-looking way of how do we protect the profession of therapy, which therapy is good and it should be protected, but there's simply a material concern of preserving the field versus can we look outside to do it.
SPEAKER_04That was much fewer in regard from what I saw than focusing on maintaining the actual field. It's some of this evokes sort of Hillman's point of view of leaving the therapy room to try to treat the world itself, being too restricted to the therapy room and keeping the imaginal within that diet might have some limitations. And the last thing I want to bring up with my opening remarks is the more purely psychological reasons that might be holding Jungians back in some respects. Back in 1996, the therapist Andrew Samuels wrote an article titled Will the Post-Youngian Survive?
SPEAKER_04And he claimed that in more recent times, Jungians have broken into two separate camps, a psychoanalytic camp and a fundamentalist camp. The psychoanalytic camp is more concerned with trying to find a way to preserve Young within other psychodynamic and psychoanalytic theories, to almost turn the dial down on the things that we might say make young a bit weird to some extent. And then the fundamentalist camp doubles down on the inner, the valorization of the inner world. It kind of is a reactionary in that sense.
SPEAKER_04The problem with the psychoanalytic camp is that if you turn down the dial to try to even the scales between inner and outer, is are you somehow killing young? Are you losing what makes young young? So my thinking in all this has been is there a way to abolish the closed inner space of the symbolic and the imaginal can be joined by inner and outer alike. And that's where more work needs to be done. And with those opening remarks, I'm now going to turn it over to our panelists to see what they think about the questions that led to the creation of this panel.
SPEAKER_04And we're going to start with Gabriela. Gabriella Sobaspolirova is a postgraduate research student in the Department of Psychosocial and Psychoanalytic Studies at the University of Essex. Her work lies at the intersection of social psychology and post-Jungian studies with particular focus on individuation and creativity. She co-runs a blog and an emerging platform for deaf psychology called University Drift. Gabriella, I'm very sorry that we cannot see you, but please take it away.
SPEAKER_00I think, Bob, you can see me now. I hope so.
SPEAKER_04Yes, definitely can. That is fantastic.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so thank you so much for such a good intro. And I think that I should probably lay out my cards straight away and probably break some of the things that you laid out there so beautifully, because my perspective is from social psychology and social work. And I have major issues seeing the psyche as separate from the material and political and social world. It is a very difficult thought experiment for me to go in that way. It's really interesting, and I would just leave it there as a some sort of anecdotal observation that I have never been challenged on this type of blind spot that I have until I rejoined the Jungian world, which is really fascinating in itself.
SPEAKER_00I'm not saying that it's only Jungians who do it, but it is the first time I have encountered that this is being done. So let's just leave it there. So when I was reading the brief for today's panel, there came a couple of things to my mind. And the first thing is what actually happens if we conclude at the end of this evening that psyche actually doesn't matter. We go home with uh sort of an idea that okay, it doesn't matter. Let's deal with that.
SPEAKER_00So, where my thoughts went after that was what is the function of psychology, actually? And there are, of course, many functions you can think of, but I thought that there were two that were quite important in this particular context. And one of them is a meaning-making tool, psychology as a meaning-making tool, making sense of the world, and the other is therapy. And if we decide that psyche doesn't matter, what does it mean in those two contexts?
SPEAKER_00Like, does the world lose its meaning? Or are we lost? Did we just get it wrong at some point? Or does it mean that we can't make the world a better place if we can't heal it through therapy? So I'll elaborate on it a little bit, but I'll just get you out of the trouble straight away. I think that Jungian studies have something to contribute here, but I think that we really need to be cautious about where our limitations are and where the competency is of the discipline.
SPEAKER_00And I think that that's something that Jungian studies are not always very good at understanding. So I'll go back to the meaning-making situation. Like if I use psychology to make sense of the world, we see it all the time. There's plenty of evidence to know that people are using psychological talk and psychological way of thinking into understanding what is happening with the world. And I would argue is not always the most constructive way to approach the world.
SPEAKER_00But I've been recently reminded about where actually Jung started when I got a part-time job in mental health. And I think that it is a really interesting thing to bring up at this point because I don't think that Jungian psychology would have happened if Jung wasn't dealing with psychosis. And that is the reason why Freudians think differently, because that wasn't the material that was brought to them to on a large part.
SPEAKER_00And I think that it is doing something incredibly useful in this context. Like if you encounter a person who believes that he is a Jesus, for example, you treat it as an archetype, as a collective cultural, unconscious content that is coming through, which preserves some sort of the part of the being that the part of the human that is actually healthy. For example, their need to relations, which are very strongly diminished if they live in this sort of a world, rather than dealing with as delusion that has to be exercised from that person, basically.
SPEAKER_00So from this perspective, it makes perfect sense. It is a brilliant tool, go for it. However, where there are limits to that is, for example, I just had this note, very common in the Jungian circles, dealing with some political issues by assigning, for example, some world leaders saying, Oh, that's a trickster figure. So, what is it doing, right? Are we legitimizing it because we assign the mythological whatever lore that is behind it?
SPEAKER_00Aren't we supposed to just say, okay, that's an evil person who really doesn't mean well? Wouldn't that be just more productive? And in this sense, what all psychology does, not just unions, is the issue of psychologizing, applying psychology at the issues that are not necessarily psychological. And I think that there's something really problematic about that. But I'll just leave it for here. For now, we get we can come to it.
SPEAKER_00The other issue is with therapy, and I think we've talked about it many times, came to my mind when I was reading the brief, when Hillman said that we have had 100 years of therapy and the world is getting worse. So, what does it actually mean? And I know that he's not applying implying that the therapy made the world worse or that it didn't have an impact, but it has two corollates that are just running together. And I think that the therapy is really interesting tool to think about the world, because in one way we have the belief that if, for example, everyone goes to therapy, we'll all have incredibly healthy relationships and we will be so self-aware and the world will become a better place.
SPEAKER_00And if psyche doesn't matter, this is just out of the table as a question, and that's not going to happen, right? The other point is if the therapy is applied to the world somehow, it will become a better place. Again, if psyche doesn't matter, if Jungians can't address those social issues and whatever, then this is just gone. And I think that what is really helpful with Hillman is he has shifted the perspective from the therapeutic diet into the world, which is brilliant.
SPEAKER_00But I think that what I personally think he got wrong is the method he applied on it. I don't think that we should apply therapy to the world, and there are many reasons for that. First of all, I don't think that the world necessarily suffers of mental health issues, primarily. Second of all, there's always the question: who is the therapist? Who decides what needs to be treated? There's always an even relationship in that sort of a that sort of a thing.
SPEAKER_00There is um a lot of what we don't acknowledge quite often is that therapy has adverse effects as well as positive effects. So where do we go with that if we just get it wrong? Or are we just wasting our efforts? I would be very speculative here. It's my perspective that I apply on that. I disagree with Hellman, and that's sort that he believes that the psyche is basically very homogeneous and very much the same.
SPEAKER_00I think that we have different kinds of psyche, as much as we have different kinds of materials, and the material always informs the process of working with the material. Like you can throw a steel rod on a potter wheel, but you will never get a pot out of it. It just doesn't matter. And you can't bring, I don't know, a psyche of a strawberry in a supermarket or a psyche of a political ideology and apply the same method as if we use in therapeutic room.
SPEAKER_00I just think that there's a major disconnect from what it can be done in that sort of a way. Whatever. I think that Hellman did in his time what was very much on the mind of critical psychology, and that was de-individualizing the psychological issues. And he deserves all the credit for that. However, that has been 34 years or how long now, I think that it's about time to move on and updated with whatever we know about the psyche today.
SPEAKER_00So if I bring it back to the Jungians, I think that wherever Jungian studies sit within the whole psychology situation or psychology, politics, social sciences, whatever you want to put it, I suspect that there is a great tendency towards staying in self-isolation. I was thinking about the COVID image in this Dissor, that Jungian studies are still sitting at home in a quarantine and hoping that it can address all the issues of the world, all the issues of the psyche everywhere, but not engaging with other disciplines.
SPEAKER_00And I think that there is a major problem with that. I think that it would be helpful. I think that the Jungian studies have a lot to contribute, but it is really important to know where, with whom, and at what time. And that's basically my initial thoughts about whatever we were talking about.
SPEAKER_04Thank you, Gabriella. Yeah, you've always kept me honest about understanding that some of the introverted bias in psychology didn't start with young, and youngians don't need to take on all the blame for that. It is inherently, by its nature, somewhat of an introverted field. It's just a question of is there a capacity to change that? And if so, why? Okay. Next to speak is J.F. Martell. J.F. Martell is a Canadian writer, lecturer, and podcaster.
SPEAKER_04He is the author of the acclaimed book, Reclaiming Art in the Age of Artifice on the Metaphysical Implications of Creative Expression. His work has been published in publications such as the Times Literary Supplement, Data Lists, Orbital Studies, Canadian Notes and Queries, and AI. With the musicologist Phil Ford, JF hosts Weird Studies, a popular podcast dedicated to exploring the intersection of art, philosophy, psyche, and the unexplained. JF, you have the floor.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Bob. Thank you, Gabriella. That was enlightening. So I am I'm not a Junion analyst. I'm not sure in what capacity I'm speaking today. But Jung has certainly been a friend of mine, a frenemy of sorts for a very, very long time. So I'm speaking from a very personal place, but I'll try to make these comments relevant. So I'm gonna approach two of the questions, maybe three, very, very quickly that Bob shared with us as we prepared for this. The first one, does our conception of the psyche remain too introverted, too divorced from the material?
SPEAKER_01Or are these actually separate problems? So this is of course a problem that both Bob and Gabriella just discussed. Is psychology in isolation too introverted, too focused on the inner world? Well, yes, but I would argue in the same sense that zoology is too focused on animals. It's exclusively focused on that because that's the business of psychology. And that's an I think that's an important point. It's not just a snarky. A snarky remark because when it comes to Jung, I think it's important to read Jung, at least from my perspective, as being part of a much bigger tradition and to see him as an emissary of a larger, deeper, older tradition, instead of seeing him in isolation as offering one paradigmatic or programmatic model of the psyche to be compared with others.
SPEAKER_01Jung, as Peter Kingsley and others have pointed out, is essentially participating in the tradition that goes, if we just follow it back in time through Nietzsche, the German idealists, Spinoza, as Bob explores in his book, through Christianity, all the way back to Neoplatonism. There's a whole spiritual tradition in what I'll call, for the sake of simplicity, the West, which I think Jung belongs to, and in light of which we can assess his work.
SPEAKER_01And so there's a critique of Jung that can come from, let's say, a radical political materialist position today. But there's also a critique of Jung that can come out of that deeper tradition. And of course, it's not going to be a pointed critique because that critique itself, that tradition implies a variety of points of view. But my point is this it's that I think that part of the political crises that we are experiencing today, and this is something I think Jung would have said and does say in books like The Undiscovered Self and elsewhere, is that we have neglected the interior world in all kinds of ways.
SPEAKER_01The capitalism neglects it in its own way, but also socialism neglects it in another way. And so there's there could be, in certain respects, something we might want to learn from Jung without taking him personally as an example. Was he too introverted? Was he literally building his ivory tower to hide from the world? All those critiques are fair, and that's perhaps is true. But when you read what he writes and you try to filter that through a kind of wider perspective on that includes and gives proper attention to material relations and political realities and so forth, I think he can be very, very useful.
SPEAKER_01For instance, just to name a very simple example, his concept of the shadow can be very, very useful for making sense not only, and I would say not even primarily, of other people's political beliefs, but of one's own political beliefs and convictions. The idea of an antiodromia, that things tend to reverse into their opposites. The idea that often what we're fighting against, verbally, physically, mentally, is not so much an actual other out there, but something inside ourselves or something out there on which we project some aspect of ourselves.
SPEAKER_01These are important ideas. I don't think that a viable and healthy political movement should be without some consideration of that psychological reality, which has ramifications on a huge scale. I also think that um there's something about Jung's emphasis on the self. Now I know this is controversial. People like James Hillman have challenged it, but I think it's too easy to misunderstand or misread Jung, probably through his own fault, on this point. In Aeon, for instance, he says, and I'm gonna read a quick passage here.
SPEAKER_01This is on page 23 of the book Aeon. He writes, the more numerous, and so he's talking about individuation, right? On which I'll say something in a second. He writes, quote, the more numerous and the more significant the unconscious contents which are assimilated into the ego, the closer the approximation of the ego to the self, even though this approximation must be a never-ending process. And so the idea that Jung posits the self as a transcendent, fixed transcendent object, a kind of template to which the individual should conform is simply misreading Jung.
SPEAKER_01For Jung, in my, at least the way I read it, individuation is an ongoing process. And so, politically speaking, you could read Jung as a kind of psychoanalytic technology for producing a subject that's adequate to social democracy, that's adequate to a world in which people are expected to express themselves, express their views, share their views, and not simply be subjected to various psychic and or techno-political forces out there. There's a kind of utopianism in Jung that I think is a useful way of reading his ideas pertaining to the self.
SPEAKER_01And this is, I would argue, this is precisely what Deleuze does with Jung in his writings, where individuation, individuation reinterpreted in a fully kind of imminentist paradigm, becomes the means by which we collectively and individually create ourselves and our world. And this don't, I don't think that Deleuze could have, and Guattari could have developed some of their theory of individuation without Jung. In fact, as we know, whenever Jung comes up in their work, it tends to be somewhat favorably.
SPEAKER_01I will leave it at that and we can explore details as we go.
SPEAKER_04That was great, JF. Thank you. And I do think it's really important to keep in mind that Jung is part of a larger tradition that precedes psychology itself. And there is, you know, that's almost more of where he should be compared to some respects as well. Thank you for that. And next on our panel is my friend Christian McMillan. Christian is a lecturer and member of staff at the Department of Psychosocial and Psychoanalytic Studies at the University of Essex, where he teaches on Young and post-Youngian studies.
SPEAKER_04In his doctoral thesis, The Image of Thought in Young's Whole Self, a Critical Study, Christian focused on similarities and differences in the thought of deaf psychologist C. Young and French post-structuralist philosopher Gilles Deleuze. Publications include Young Literature and Aesthetics and Young in Philosophy, Young and Deleuze Enchanted Openings to the Other in the Internal Journal of Youngin' Studies, and Archetypal Intuition Beyond the Human and Psychoanalysis, Culture, and Society. Christian, the floor is yours.
SPEAKER_03Thank you. Yes, thank you for reminding me of those publications. It looks like it's been quite a long time. And just to say a quick hello, or it's lovely to see a few people that I know here, like obviously Gabriella and Cassie and Mark, and indeed Nick Langan, I think, is with us as well. So it's always lovely to see members of your family joining us. So, yes, I've enjoyed very much what the other panelists have said. I mean, my own interest in this really comes from trying to mine those areas of Jung's thought where I feel as though there are these kind of pockets, maybe pockets of imminence, as I don't know, I might call them, in which he's reversing the priority of the interior over the exterior.
SPEAKER_03So, one example of that, if I was just to go straight to it, would be in his little essay, a short essay, Archaic Man from 1931, in which he problematizes the relationship between the projection and the source of projection. If any of you have had the chance to read that essay, it's a really interesting one. He kind of goes back on the hypothesis that perhaps we are the source of the material world rather than the material world being the source of our projections. We're somehow made up of, we're made up of something, spirits, we're made up of some kind of material forces.
SPEAKER_03He refers to mana. We're actually composed of this rather than this being a projection. And he calls it a thought experiment, I think, or perhaps Paul Bishop does in his book on the archaic past and the present. And or he calls it some kind of a hypothesis. And I just think this is one of those interesting examples of where he's problematizing that, as I said, that interior-exterior kind of relationship. One might also be able to discern this in the in the creation of the concept of the psychoid itself. And I use those terms deliberately because I think Jung was an experimenter in the Deleuzean sense, or he, I think he Deleuze would have been complimentary about Jung's ability to create concepts.
SPEAKER_03That would destabilizing to habits of thought. And the psychoid, although the psychoid has a long history going back to Aristotle, Jung, you know, he doesn't just use the psychoid in the sense that Aristotle used it in the context of Entelershi. He doesn't just use it in the sense that Hans Driesch redeveloped it in the period of neo-vitalism at the end of the 19th century. He develops his own kind of understanding of what the psychoid is. So he he creates this idea, he creates this concept to destabilize what I would call transcendent forms of synthesis or illegitimate forms of synthesis, if we were to borrow the language of Deleuze and Guattari from Antiedipus.
SPEAKER_03And I think one way one could read it, if one was perhaps being charitable to this idea of the psychoid as a kind of synthetic power, is that there's it's a distributed form of synthesis. There's a passive form of the synthesis. It doesn't have a subject, it doesn't have a transcendent source, and from it the actual emerges. And within this synthetic power, or within all actual structures, this synthetic power continues, as in Simondonian terms, a kind of metastable source that allows things to transform, that allows categories to transform images of what we take things to be to be transformative rather than become rarefied and static.
SPEAKER_03And I think that may be one of the so the psychoid and the essay on archaic man, there are only two examples. Perhaps one could also read this into the work on synchronicity, but there are all maybe three examples of where Jung is really problematizing this idea of where are the syntheses from which actual structures emerge and which allow actual structures to transform. I I think a lot of post-unions, or some post-unions at least, tend to get either fixated on maybe one side or the other. Perhaps a lot of post-unions are sidetracked into what I would call the phenomenological camp, which for me a priori prioritizes some form of a subject or particularly some form of a transcendental subject that then has to do the work of accounting for the possible experience of reality, whether it's possible psychic experience or whether it's possible experience in general.
SPEAKER_03And then we lose those elements of Jung's thought in which he's trying to very much problematize where syntheses are actually potentially located. So the question about, you know, is psyche relevant anymore, for me is a question about where is this power, this constitutive power, actually to be located, or what is it that this power can actually do? And I think what I find useful in Jung's work is that he is problematizing that. Perhaps it would be nice if he did it more often than he did in the collected works, but there's a tendency for that to be ignored if it doesn't necessarily fit within a particular kind of post-Jungian paradigm that then tries to codify or define the field as a whole.
SPEAKER_03And I think those areas, those moments of immanence in Jung's work have often been neglected. So to just kind of go back a little bit to the essay on archaic man, a short essay, a small essay, in which Jung is writing about, of course, in language that would not be particularly palatable to us today, is talking about primitive peoples, and he is referring to history, although he says this kind of mentality exists in the present as well. As I said, he's postulating the idea that perhaps uh we don't project spirits or animistic sort of contents into the world, but we are the synthetic products of them, which is a really, really kind of interesting reversal.
SPEAKER_03He goes back in the essay and sort of refutes that a little bit later, and he misuses Levey Hul's understanding, the anthropologist Leve-Hul's understanding of participation mystique, in order to try and account for the notion of projection having a source. But if one reads participation mystique in the way that Deleuze and Guattari kind of understand polyvosity in their work on the primitive socius in Antiedipus, then I think something richer can come out, something uh you know, more materialist can potentially come out from a fruitful dialogue between those three writers, then is necessarily offered in archaic man, but it may have been another inspiration for Deleuze and Guattari's kind of materialism that emerges in Antiodipus.
SPEAKER_03And the way, of course, Jung writes about mana in that essay as a kind of power, forces that actual things are composed of, but that retain in those actual things and allow them to transform. Then we have a link to the sort of more Sundonian notion of change that I mentioned earlier. And so that there are these material sort of elements in Jung's thinking, but they do tend to get a clouded by that phenomenological and sometimes the right word, empirical apology that Jung makes occasionally, which is that I'm only dealing with the facts of experience.
SPEAKER_03And I think when he makes that apology, then that kind of turns one is able to look at turn his work into, perhaps implicitly perhaps, but turn his work into right, we need to account for the conditions of all possible psychic experience. And that's where Deleuze's critique of the image of thought can be useful, because the same critique of Kant and the determination or the imminent criteria that Kant used to try and determine what possible experience and what can be leveled, uh the way Jung sometimes refers to archetypes as the possible condition of fantasy production.
SPEAKER_03But again, what's glorious about Jung's work is that he will place archetypes in many, many different contexts to experiment with them. And this is something we I think we need to remember, or at least I like to remind myself of the collected works are a showcase of an individual with his colleagues to a certain extent, experimenting with a number of different concepts that he is creating and moulding in very, very different environments over a long period of time. So there is no consistency, but there is in in the work in the words of someone like Connor Heaney, who's a Deleuzian writer who wrote a great paper called Pursuing Joy with Deleuze in 2018, you know, there is an on there is a pi an epistemological openness.
SPEAKER_03But I think the danger today in Jungian studies is that tends to get closed down, and that's where the the perhaps the political, the social and material aspects of what his work can do are being occluded or being somewhat excluded and indeed cancelled. There's a lot more, like I think the other two speakers have said, from slightly different perspectives from me, that can be done with Jung's work. But I believe the power of all psychotherapy has to start with a critique of the Oedipalized subject or the image of what the human subject is taken to be in the modern period, as if that's some kind of a universal subject.
SPEAKER_03Jung is less guilty of reifying an image of the subject than Freud is. I personally am confident in making that rather bold statement. But it's now up to the job of post-human studies to kind of continue to carry out this challenge, this revolutionary challenge, as I think Deleuze and Quattari would have called it, of continuing to critique the boundaries of the form of the subject. And this is why, yeah, again, with a nod to Mark, it's lovely to have Mark here.
SPEAKER_03If any of you haven't had the opportunity to read Mark's paper, recent paper in the JAP, Dissolving the Psychological Subject Inside and Outside the Therapeutic Bond, that's a wonderful starting place. And by starting place, Mark, I don't mean an easy place, but it's a wonderful starting place to engage with this very notion of dissolving the psychological subject, which so much of Mark's work has been, I think, on a true trajectory towards. And Simon and Jung are nicely conjoined in that work for those of you who have never maybe seen a Simon-Joung connection before.
SPEAKER_03So I think I'll be quiet now, Bob, but just uh thank you again for having me on. Thank you very much, Craig. And I hope I can look forward to the questions that are coming.
SPEAKER_04That was great. Thank you. And the thanks again to all our panelists for their thoughts. In a little bit, we're going to open up to questions. Feel free to put anything in the chat, and either I'll read it for you, or when we get to them, I'll ask if you want to read your thoughts aloud. But first, I wanted to turn it to our panelists and see if they had any questions for one another's remarks. And I'll ask that before I selfishly ask any questions that I myself might have. Then I'll go ahead myself and ask a question.
SPEAKER_04You know, this idea of creating concepts was pretty prominent in what you said, Christian. And I know JF as well on a relatively recent Substack post, you brought up the same thing as sort of the core motif of Deleuze, the creation of concepts and this sort of productivity. And one thing that Christian and I have talked before is how to really look at alchemy in this sense. Because alchemy, I think, Christian, is potentially another example of what you were talking about, which is on the one hand, alchemy can just be seen as a mode of representation, just a pure mode of making it something analogous to, oh, this is just like the psychic processes going on within me.
SPEAKER_04And the alchemists were just playing out those psychic processes, but projecting it onto the materials that they were working with. But there's another way of looking at this too, which Jung, in certain works, such as Mysterium Conuncionis, he starts to maybe appreciate it in this way a bit more, which is what he's really seeing is that there's a sort of productive power common to both human and non-human, sort of beyond both human and non-human that might precede any sense of subjectivity. And I was wondering if any of you have any thoughts of being able to look at things, even such as the archetypes this way as well, beyond just a mode of representation and set another concept, if you will, something that is created that precedes and sort of transcends the human itself.
SPEAKER_01If I may then I think that I think this emphasis on, I love that what Christian was saying about the experiment of Jung and the way in which his uh collected works are foremost a kind of a series of experiments, explorations. And I used to find it extremely frustrating reading Jung to see all these kind of contradictions in the way that he would present the archetype. Sometimes it's just like, oh, this is just uh a kind of reflex pattern that evolved over time.
SPEAKER_01And sometimes, no, this is a like a literal god that enters into the psyche. Or and what I found useful was to read Jung backwards, right? To kind of like really start at the end with the psychoid stuff and then kind of assume that that's where he settled metaphysically and then kind of read it all in that light, but also without trying to paper over that creative experimental aspect, which I like the way that you you liken that to alchemy. I read medieval alchemy as a kind of a similar sort of experimentation, an ongoing experimentation.
SPEAKER_01Alchemy was one of the few cultural practices that really crossed cultural boundaries in the Middle Ages, where you had like Jewish, Christian, and Muslim alchemists sending each other letters. This was uh a game, you could say, without trying to diminish it, that people were playing together. And there's all been all kinds of theories as to what they were really trying to do. Were they trying to tear and land it to goal? Were they trying to like transcend the material world? I'm not even sure if if they all agreed on what the point was, but there was something about the activity that was productive in itself.
SPEAKER_01And and I think the same is true of what Jung is doing, and the same is certainly true of what Dedeuze did in his career. And in that Substack post, it was called the One Idea of Gilles Dedeuze. My my my argument there, contentiously perhaps, was that Dedeuze's real idea was this con this concept of concept creation. But there are implications to that concept if you take it seriously. It means that concepts, as important as they are, as useful as they can be, never do the work that certain philosophers have wanted them to do, namely to define reality, to tell us what reality is.
SPEAKER_01In a certain sense, Dadoz's philosophy requires you to embrace a kind of, and this is cont I admit this is a bit of a controversial comment I'm making. It requires you to embrace a kind of naive realism, a kind of just so self-evident world in which philosophy can be then take place as a creative activity. And so there's a political reality that precedes philosophy. And that political reality is the kind of the world in which we engage in this or that or the other activity.
SPEAKER_01And then the question becomes well, how many of us and to what degree can they engage in creative activity? And that's what justifies, I think, a political program of emancipation, liberation, justice, and all that. It's to allow as many people as possible to do what people like Jung and Deleuze were able to do. Oscar Wilde says this beautifully in The Soul of a Man Under Socialism. Essentially, what you want is a society that allows people to play, and but play is the thing.
SPEAKER_01And that's that's kind of what I love about if I have to really kind of question myself and ask myself, what is it that I love about Deleuze and Jung? I remember a uh a professor at the University of Toronto once literally cornered me at a party and asked me to reconcile my admiration for Deleuze and Jung. He said, You have to pick one, you can't take both. He was a really, he was quite quite the number this guy. And and I just I wished Christian Kerslake had released his book, Young and the Unconscious. I could have just handed him a copy, and that would have been the end of it. But at the time, he saw this as trying to like he was trying to like smoke out my inner fascist.
SPEAKER_01But I think that's where I I find the real value in these thinkers' work. It's in how they're performing for us, they're giving us an example of. A kind of utopic engagement with being that I think all of us deserve to have a chance at or trying out.
SPEAKER_04Any thoughts of that?
SPEAKER_03No, I I I enjoyed your comments, Jay. I agree. That may be the more aspirational end goal of what Jungian psychotherapy could orientate itself towards trying to achieve, which is the creation of sort of a community of experimenters, perhaps. But I mean whether it's Jungian Jungian psychotherapy psychology, whatever analytical psychology, or whether it's any other therapy really, I mean it does it doesn't really matter. I think that ultimately is the end goal. But perhaps if one is to read Jung's works with this not in the direction of recognizing him as someone who was perpetually playing, is a nice way to put it, then it might position Jungian psychology as somewhat the flag shape of that enterprise.
SPEAKER_03I think so. Yeah, I mean to just go back to the point about experimenting with concepts. You know, there are there are good concepts. There are not so good concepts. Or in what is philosophy, their last joint publication, Deleuze and Guitarino, but also percepts and affects in slightly different contexts. It's about what the work of these concepts can do, putting the concepts to work, which of course is very much a different mission from trying to identify what truth is.
SPEAKER_03So there is no truth goal in this concept of creation, there's no attempt to try and determine what truth is. There is just the uh the capacity to encounter and engage and create with this world. And I think again, sometimes it's difficult to perhaps find the evidence in Jung's own thought, given his uh interest in the transcendent. But I would also say the transcendental and the two are very, very different, but they do kind of have a common source in a in a way of thinking. It's sometimes rather difficult to find the imminent within his thinking.
SPEAKER_03But it it it is there. But it just tends to get lost under these words like spirit or perhaps psyche, which then looks a little bit like transcendental subject, at least as far as I can tell. But Bob, I'm gonna ask you, because you've obviously done a lot of work on this in the book Jung and Spinoza, where you've looked at psyche, spirit, and matter and how spirit sits within a kind of spinest framework. I was just wondering if you could you could come back on that, that problematizes the way that perhaps spirit is often regarded by Jungians, post-Jungians, and other people as something belonging to a to the transcendent, or it's otherworldly, or it is an other in the sense of a negative theology.
SPEAKER_03But you're considering it in the four as far in terms of it being an imminent productive power, as far as I can tell.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, thank you. My work on Jung and Spinoza, that was one of the key turning points for me, which is in the work of, say, Harold Abenspacher, who's a physicist and Jungian scholar, and he's very much interested in dual aspect monism. So, what is dual aspect monism? Very briefly, you could have a version of dualism, such as just pure Cartesian dualism where mind and matter are treated as separate substances. You could have materialism where mind is reducible to matter, or an idealism where everything is an idea or idealist.
SPEAKER_04And then there's dual aspect monism, which suggests that mind and matter are two aspects of the same ontological one, some underlying neutral substance, and uh is interested in this because he reads this into the dialogue between Carl Jung and the physicist Wolfgang Paulie, which came to be in the later stages of Jung's career and led to their joint publications on synchronicity. Synchronicity being an example of something complementary between mind and matter, but it's suggesting something underneath that they're both expressing.
SPEAKER_04One can't be reduced to the other. And Abenspacher credits Spinoza as the originator and Western thought of this idea of a dual aspect monism. But it's a bit curious, you know, for Spinoza, it's not two separate lines that go back to a single one of thought and extension going back to an underlying one. It's really an infinity of things, all the different modes of substance being expressed in at least two different ways. So therefore, it almost has three factors instead of two. What is interesting in the dialogue with Jung and Pauli, Jung says this.
SPEAKER_04He disagrees with Pauly on the dual aspect route. He says, no, it's not only just psyche and matter, it's psyche, matter, and spirit. And spirit and matter are the two aspects, and psyche is what is in between. It's the surface between the heights and the depths, essentially. And what this does is it eliminates the need to find the hidden source that these things emanate from. Instead, you're dealing with something that's purely on the surface, expressed in two different ways, that is composed by those two different things, but you're not tracing back lines that go on forever to find something.
SPEAKER_04To me, this is also important because it kind of you can start thinking about instead of just a purely the problem of inner and outer, you're sort of removing that instead talking about things that are purely on that level of psyche and things that might be more in the material or that spiritual realm is said, expressed in two different ways, but all those things are expressed on the same flat line, if you will. So when you guys are talking about creating concepts, I look at that as the production of things on that same line. It's always open. You never find an endpoint. There's no totality to it, but it's always sort of this open ontology.
SPEAKER_04And I do think there, Young, perhaps unwittingly, not always consciously, was heading in that direction. And it's, as JF said, his later writings suggest that. I also think some of the stuff in Young's earlier work with complex theory and this disassociative lateral version of the psyche was going in that same direction as well. And maybe at times archetypes get too representational in between, and there's that hermitage into the tower in between, but it is spanned by those two aspects elsewhere. And personally, that's what I draw it from because I think that's where a lot of interesting things are.
AHRC Courses: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses Several weeks ago, we asked patrons to contribute questions to our very first Q&A episode featuring Serpetie, Emma, and Bob. In the discussion, we tackle...
Is Everything Predictable?: AI, Prediction Markets, and the Philosophy of Foresight: https://www.index-space.org/programming/is-everything-predictable-ai-prediction-markets-and-the-philosop-evt-xnCQQKMg0qG8Snk Acid...
The Lenox Institute for Advanced Study: https://lenoxinstitute.org/ Acid Horizon Research Commons Ongoing Courses: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses Can something as ordinary as a selfie crack open a...
Is astrology a harmless distraction or a pseudo-science opening a path to fascism? Or can it help us reclaim an imagination lost to the hyper-rationalism of modernity? In this episode, Sereptie and Emma trace the...
Listen to the full episode here: Enroll in Bob's class at AHRC: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses/p/jung-and-spinoza-god-affect-destiny In this Patreon exclusive episode, recurring guest and friend of the...