Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

LEPHT HAND

LEPHT HAND artwork

Brain Rot and Capitalism: Amogh Sahu on Social Media, Desire & the Death of the Event

Oct 11, 20261 hr 31 minAudio

Is Everything Predictable?: AI, Prediction Markets, and the Philosophy of Foresight: https://www.index-space.org/programming/is-everything-predictable-ai-prediction-markets-and-the-philosop-evt-xnCQQKMg0qG8Snk Acid Horizon Research Commons: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses SEREPTIE - Live at Woskob Family Gallery: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/events/electro-acoustic-ambient-sereptie-kbd-and-evan-odell Are our critiques of social media smuggling in old humanist baggage, treating addiction as misplaced desire that needs a therapy of the soul? Emma leads a conversation with Columbia philosopher Amogh Sahu, with Sereptie in tow, that interrogates the popular diagnosis of online addiction and the pull of social media’s relational machinery. Drawing on Marx, Deleuze, and Baudrillard, we ask whether resistance is futile, and whether the Luddite and “return to nature” impulses offer a way out or just another image to be absorbed. And is brain rot’s warping of our collective sense of time a symptom of something much larger, and is what we perceive as pathology really the system working as intended? Support LEPHT HAND: Join the Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/LEPHTHAND Emma's Substack: https://elftheory.substack.com/ Sereptie's Substack: https://splitinfinities.substack.com/ Merch and Design Shop: crit-drip.com Acid Horizon Links: https://linktr.ee/acidhorizon Sereptie (ambient project): https://sereptie.bandcamp.com/ Acid Horizon Research Commons is now live: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-main The Lenox Institute for Advanced Study: https://lenoxinstitute.org/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Hey everyone, this is Serepti and welcome back to another episode of Left Hand. Before Emma kicks off our interview with Amog Sahu, a couple of quick announcements. Starting Thursday, October 29th, and running through Thursday, December 10th, Emma is leading a course at Index Greenpoint in Brooklyn called Is Everything Predictable? AI, Prediction Markets, and the Philosophy of Foresight. Guest faculty include Leif Weatherby, David Z. Morris, and Mario Krisch.

SPEAKER_03If you're not in the city and you want to keep learning with us online, Acid Horizon Research Commons Fall Course Series is in full swing, with new courses on the way in November, plus a rich archive of past courses. Head to the show notes and click the links to join. On a personal note, I'm returning to live performance under my Ambient and Lo-Fi project, Serepti, with shows in central Pennsylvania and the surrounding area. On Wednesday, October 28th, I will be at the Wascob Family Gallery and State College alongside KBD and Evan Odell.

SPEAKER_03The podcasts keep me busy, but I hope to play out more in the coming months, and I am planning a show in Japan next year. If you are a promoter, venue, or fellow artist putting together a bill in the Northeast, or maybe even beyond, I'd love to hear from you. You can reach me through the show notes. In today's episode, we talk about brain rot, not just in the conventional sense, but how we might theorize the feeling that our thoughts, images, and even our sense of time are being flattened into one undifferentiated flow.

SPEAKER_03Okay, let's hop into the discussion.

SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome to Left Hand. This is Emma Stam. I'm here today with Sarepti and our guest Amog Sahu. Amoog is a lecturer in discipline in the Department of Philosophy at Columbia University. He received his PhD from Columbia and an honors BA from the University of Toronto. His primary research interest is the ethics and politics of intellectual production, framed by a background in the history of critical theory and the foundations of ethics.

SPEAKER_00Today, we're talking about Amoog's recent essay on the critical functions of brain rot and what brain rot does, what it accomplishes for political and economic purposes. So, welcome to Left Hand, Amoogue. It's great to have you.

SPEAKER_02Happy to be here.

SPEAKER_00For our episode today, we read your recent essay that is up on Substack on Brain Rot and how Brain Rot fits into existing discourses around the commodification of attention, what gets frequently called the attention economy, the assetization of the mind. There are thinkers from a wide range of disciplines that have held forth on this topic that I haven't seen a great deal of scholarly work that uses the term brain rot specifically.

SPEAKER_00I mean, there is a lot of discourse online that uses this phrasing, but we're still just beginning, I think, to grapple at a certain level with the phenomenon of brain rot and really kind of trying to figure out its ontology, what distinguishes brain rot from other sorts of framings that we might bring in here. So I wonder if we could begin this conversation with your understanding of what brain rot is, what its manifest positive features actually are.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I would start with a sort of historical background. I'd say talk of brain rot fits very naturally into a very familiar pattern of sort of modernity criticism, right? The general idea that modern social life is too fast, too complicated, too fragmented, and this has negative effects on our ability to reflect, think, make decisions, and so on. That's been around almost as long as modernity itself.

SPEAKER_02And you can see brain oftentimes the brain rot discourse has trouble extricating itself from these very general claims about isn't modern life so terribly fast? Isn't everything so terribly complicated? So it's part of this sort of semantic web of yeah, fragmentation, disembedding, atomization, and all of these kinds of anti-modern buzzwords. But if I was to define brain rock more specifically, term that emerges 2023, 24 in common usage, right?

SPEAKER_02Sort of labeled the Oxford word of the year in 2024. And in the contemporary sense, it names both a certain type of content, right? So-called brain rock content, which is extremely hard to describe, I think, but I think everyone knows it when they see it, right? It's sort of, I would describe it as kind of digitally generated images, which evoke a certain feeling of like nonsense, uncanniness, and almost a kind of Kantian, like the limits of sense are being transgressed.

SPEAKER_02So it's sort of response dependent that way. These images evoke a certain feeling of like cognitive alienation or um, yeah. I say I'd stick with uncanniness. So there's a kind of content usage, but the more common usage and the one I spend more time on has to do with a type of pathology that comes from use of digital technology and specifically use of social media, right? Which is a felt sense of cognitive degradation that comes from consuming too much content in general, but possibly consuming too much brain rot content.

SPEAKER_02So the content use and the sort of pathological use are kind of internally related. The feeling is like the lack of sense in these brain rot images effectively becomes all you're capable of producing or processing. It represents how degraded your cognition becomes when you use social media too much. So implicit in brain rot, as you can see, is both a kind of diagnosis, right? There's a thought about like, okay, you're spending too much time on the platforms and you're consuming the wrong kinds of things, or you're consuming them in the wrong kind of way.

SPEAKER_02And then there's a kind of somewhere in the background, some theory of like healthy cognitive activity, which is like, you know, in order to make these judgments, you got to have some story about what good thinking is, good, that kind of stuff.

SPEAKER_00So we have brain rot as content and brain rot as a condition of the psyche. And I think it's helpful for us to disambiguate these two phenomena. And I'll note here that your essay does focus on the latter, the felt experience of cognitive degradation, although the connection between the two is something that we could potentially explore. But while we're still framing this, I wonder if you could say a little bit about either one, perhaps focusing on the latter, but really either one, in its particular capacity as productive for capital.

SPEAKER_00And one thing that I'm thinking about here is, as you mentioned just a moment ago, the fact that, of course, there's a history, a very long history of discourse around the fact that the weakening of the psyche, something about consciousness or subjectivity in a derelict state is productive for political economy. But it seems like there is something specific to what brain rot actually does, what its function actually is.

SPEAKER_00So if you could just lay that out a little bit for us, that would be helpful.

SPEAKER_02Sure. So the theory I propose in the essay has to do with the sort of monopolistic character of contemporary social media platforms. So to abbreviate the story considerably, it's not story unique to me. It's the idea is that tech platforms make their profits partly by, or well, rather, extract rent is probably more accurate, by signaling to signaling to investors that they have a large captive user base.

SPEAKER_02And one way of doing that is by monetizing attention, i.e., tracking clicks, time spent on ads, time spent on web pages, and that's supposed to indicate potential future profitability. Now, I think there's a good question here, and it's a question I don't completely address, about whether it is brain rot itself that is functional or whether brain rot is a byproduct. And I don't think that's adequately addressed in the discourse because it's like it's different, it's sometimes a degree of intentionality is kind of imposed on this, where it's like, oh, tech companies want to rot your brain and so on.

SPEAKER_02And the sociology to back that up is not yet there. It's definitely what the sorts of stories people tell in the story that I tell has to do with the idea that brain rot is an important byproduct of certain techniques of attention monetization, right? That like because you want as many, because you want to have a high number of clicks, a high amount of clicks, or you want to have you want the user to spend as much time on the platform as possible, you thus get sort of negative brain rot effects as a result.

SPEAKER_02But I think implicating brain rot specifically in the kind of causal story requires us to say more about what it is, other than this kind of gestural, like, oh, it's bad stuff that happens when you spend too much time on the platform. I s but I use the gestural definition because I think the kind of conceptual core of the thing is gestural, right? That is sort of like the more precise you get, the more you're kind of leaving the popular discourse. So that's fine, we may want to do that. But I think this level of precision indicates how deep the how yeah, how what where people are at with this.

SPEAKER_02So I don't think there's in, I don't think we there's we can yet say that it's productive for capital. What is true is that there are certain, yeah, as I said, there are certain techniques of attention capture which seem to generate brain rot or seem closely connected to brain rot that are kind of useful existing strategies.

SPEAKER_03I'm very happy that you brought up Dulozin Guattari in this short essay, because I mean that they're figures that we're working with on this podcast and Asset Horizon quite a bit. Emma and I, we have a series of events upcoming with our friend Stuart Kendall. And one of the questions that I've been trying to think through recently, in conjunction with Duluz and Gotari, and we could say apparatuses of capture, the attention economy, and so forth, has been basically staging a face-off between Deleuze and Baudrillard, and basically broadening this question.

SPEAKER_03Because when we look at the work of Baudrillard, what we might call the procession of similar, which is central to his theory, which we could say brain rot is a species of that. Um, one of the criticisms that Baudrillard has of folks like Deleuze and other previous post-structuralist theorists, is that a theory of desire is not going to be sufficient to explain the deeper implications behind digital technologies and their effect upon us. And the reason that I wanted to bring up the project, I'm just writing a short paper for this event, but I think this is couched in a bigger problem that both Deleuze and Baudrillard address, which is in this world of profuse digital media, is anything like a new event possible anymore?

SPEAKER_03And it makes me wonder the extent to which our training on certain kinds of content, timeline media, and so forth have attenuated, we might say, our intellectual or attentional capacities in such a way that it elides the possibility of other kinds of experiences. And so for Baudrillard, the big thing is that with the procession of simulacra, the profusion of images and discourse, especially in our society, one of the things that I think he accurately predicted was that everything that is spoken or every image that is taken is now part of this massive flow of information, this uptake, you know, into platform capitalism, whether it's Facebook or Instagram or Twitter or whatever else.

SPEAKER_03But not only that, one of the things that Baudrillard points out that I'm trying to work through right now is he's saying that he doesn't say it in these very specific terms, but our attentional capacity and our ability to experience a new event, if you will, is pre-empted by this profusion of images. And he calls it an empty present and it has this sort of negative quality. However, looking at some research, and I put this in quotes, that I've seen on Instagram reels, like some of the things that appear in my algorithm lately involve basically, I would say, sort of like philosophical or intellectual interventions into what happens to you when you consume social media.

SPEAKER_03And there is a particular creator out there who highlighted an editorial paper on various research into the way that social media and digital media affects our attention and the malleability of our sense of time or temporality. But one of the interesting things that this study points out is that our training on timeline media, our acclamation to it, being inured to this profusion of images, has the effect of elighting the interval between intense or event-dense experiences.

SPEAKER_03Like everything gets contracted or compressed in a way such that all of these things that we experience, doom scrolling, create this continuous flow of intense experience that in the moment alters our sense of time, but as many authors speculate, have deeper effects for how we experience any kinds of events at all. Will we be able to experience something interesting, important, or remarkable outside of social media in the same way if we stay steeped in this environment?

SPEAKER_03And one of the things that your paper points to is the kinds of analysis between the economic dimension, the ways in which online content generates a form of surplus engagement, and that surplus drives the algorithm versus the affective dimension of it. Being steeped in brain rot has instigated all sorts of new questions. Should we be Luddites? Should we take this sort of moral position which you highlight in the essay? And raises questions about the quality of interaction that we have with the world and with each other and so forth.

SPEAKER_03One of the questions that you leave us with at the end of the paper is to what extent should we think of resistance to brain run, if we should resist at all, strictly in economic terms, or should we think more in terms of attention being bound up with affect? And how do we sort of bridge the divide between what might be the attentional or affective aspect of the economy versus the brutally economic aspect of it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's a lot there. I uh to start, I think, with like an as I think your sort of intervention there depends on an aspect of the essay that we haven't sort of brought out. So I'll maybe spend a bit of time bringing it out, which is that the brain rot, the notion of desire comes to play a central role in the notion of brain rot because the psychology a lot of people bring to bear when they're asked to clarify brain rot is basically Christian, that there's an understanding of addiction based on misplaced desire.

SPEAKER_02If you're if people are pressed, they'll say something about instant gratification. And the general theory is like brain rot is a pathology of desire in a recognizably like addictive sense, in the context of like it's a pleasure of the flesh, if we want to use the biblical language, if we like, right? It's like these pathological desires are being brought to bear, and what we need is a therapy of desire, right? Like that's the sort of way people understand it. So that's kind of one kind of classically humanistic model of the psyche that gets brought to mind, brought to bear.

SPEAKER_02Another way, in another kind of traditional, like a bit of enlightenment background that is that people bring to this is the idea of like a traditional life of the mind, intellectual life of almost you imagine a kind of country gentleman with a large library and leisure to pursue the good life and so on, right? And like the ability to withdraw from their desires and to spend time reading the classics and all this kind of stuff, right? I'm not people don't necessarily have all of this in mind, but but these are two bits, two bits of kind of let's say traditional humanism, the baggage of traditional humanism that people bring to bear.

SPEAKER_02One, the diagnostic baggage of like brain rot as bad desire, and then a sort of ideal, a classical humanistic ideal of a sort of intellectual living the life of the mind. Now, I for various reasons, right? These night neither of these are particularly tenable. I brought Deleuze in mind to question the kind of the psychological, the diagnostic account, right? It's like, well, you can only theorize brain rot as uh diseased desire if you believe in traditional desire in the first place, right?

SPEAKER_02It's if you think of desire as a complicated set of assemblages, whatever, however, one understands Deleuze's theory of desire, then obviously you'd want to think about, you'd want to think about what's going wrong in brain rot differently. And secondly, this traditional idea of the intellectual, right, is it's very helpful, I guess, in a way, for people to pump intuitions about what's wrong with brain rot. It's like, well, clearly if you're spending a lot of time consuming this content, you're not able to, I don't know, live this sort of traditionalized life of the mind.

SPEAKER_02But obviously, there are all kinds of reasons why that ideal is questionable. It's elitist, it's narrow, it depends on a certain conception of knowledge and a priori knowledge that we possibly don't buy. So we're left, I think, given all this, with the need for a story, a story about what makes brain rot pathological, which doesn't depend on psychology that we don't necessarily buy, and also a story about what the ideal is that brain rot is pushing us away from, right?

SPEAKER_02And what's interesting about the the Baudrillard you talked about is that, well, we get a version of the ideal in talking about this sort of eventality, the idea of interesting experiences, the idea of yeah, breaking from the mundane, and well, I don't know if that's so much, but yeah, that's kind of part of it. And then it sounds like the diagnosis, if we get one from Baudrillard, it has to do with the kind of, let's say, de-localization, decontextualization of images, right? It's like you might think of images as having a kind of rootedness, embeddedness in some original context, or I mean, this feels bad to put in Baudrillard's mouth, but I'll go with me for a second.

SPEAKER_02And the thinking is, well, it's disrupted. The effect of platform technology is to profoundly disrupt our understanding of the meaning and content of images. They lose their moorings in like whatever context, whatever context gave them meaning. Now, I guess it's, yeah, I mean, part of the reason I find someone like Baudrillard kind of difficult to think with is that it's not obvious, at least in this case, is that it's not obvious for someone like Baudrillard that like brain rot itself is necessarily bad, right?

SPEAKER_02In the sense that like it's, I mean, I would say post-structuralist generally, like they don't have a certain kind of classical humanist baggage that a lot of people they're not fans of the subject in the first place. So the fact that the subject gets messed around by brain rot is not is no problem. I think, but I think you rightly know that doesn't mean that they're kind of uncritical of digital technologies, they just don't do it from the point of view of the kind of classical enlightenment subject, right? It's like a different kind of angle. Okay, so that's I think, and so I would put Baudrillard with someone like it's I know the sort of distinction you want to draw, but from the sort of from the point of view of kind of the of the contemporary discourse, both Deleuze and Baudrillard are kind of advances over the kind of Christian enlightenment folk psychology that we kind of bring to the bring to this.

SPEAKER_02Discussion. Okay, that's my kind of preface, kind of trying to tie together what you what you're what you were talking about with the terms of the essay to deal with your question directly. I think what Emma's last question highlighted is that I actually think the economic and the affective dimensions of brain rot are not, have not been convincingly tied together. They have been shown to be related. But I don't think that the like, and this is part of what leads to a deep, on my part, degree of confusion and ambivalence about what to do about it. Because unlike something like classical Marxist exploitation, where supposedly, if you believe the Marxists, the injustice and the pathology of exploitation is not is kind of central to the economic explanation of how it happens, right?

SPEAKER_02It's like the the fact that the worker is deprived of their agency is deeply connected to the fact that X amounted labor time is stolen from them and that leads into profitability and so on. We have nothing so neat yet with something like Brain Rot, right? What we have is, as I as I was saying earlier, a kind of broad, sketchy economic story about engagement and retention, right? And then an understanding of the negative psychological effects of engagement and retention without a kind of a dialectical analysis kind of doing more than correlating them.

SPEAKER_02And the reason this is important is because it has implications for resistance, right? It's it leaves open whether resistance requires us simply to modify the platforms or to modify the engagement techniques, or whether it requires this much more thoroughgoing rejection of the technology. Because I feel like the Luddite view has a kind of, for want of a better word, essentialist diagnosis of brain rot, right? It's like, look, brain rot comes from the technology itself, the infrastructure itself, writ large, gestures widely.

SPEAKER_02And I sort of don't, I don't feel like enough has been said to explain that. Because I even and I'll connect this back to Baudrillard, what features of the technology exactly yield, I don't know, uh sort of event eventality, like you sorry, yield to this kind of loss of the capacity for new experiences, interesting experiences. Like I can see a skeptic saying, one, Baudrillard is talking about things much wider than specifically digital platforms, that it's like a general critique of post-industrial capitalism, at least, a general critique of the spectacle.

SPEAKER_02It justifies Luddism only in so far as it justifies, and here I sort of gesture an Emma, a general anti-civilization, anti-modernity, anti-modernity politics. So I think I think like Craig, your intervention I think usefully highlights some of the gaps in this kind of discourse. Like I think people don't have a good theory of what brain rod is or where it comes from in that sense.

SPEAKER_03Amid your response, my mind went to that quote by Mark Fisher where he discusses how if something does not manifest as a post, let's say, it did not happen. And if we were just to approach the issue from that vignette, I think one of the challenges that, at least from the experiential or affective side of things, we now live in a context where even our whole notion or concept of the event is bound up with its presentation in an online format, its situation in a flow of other images of its kind, even if it means sort of stripping it down or calibrating it in such a way so that it becomes legible to anyone who's using social media.

SPEAKER_03One of the implicit or background concerns that we have with respect to our experience of social media is whether or not an experience is interesting, significant, remarkable, important, all of those things, and whether or not that the remarkability of an experience is an excess to anything that's presentable online. And to me, I think therein potentially lies the travesty of our times, is that we could not live a life and have a metric or a kind of knowledge about what constitutes a good experience in the absence of social media or in the absence of a post.

SPEAKER_03It makes me go to a figure like Klesowski, for example, or like Blanchot. Are we losing touch with that sort of incommunicable dimension of our life when we cleave ourselves to these platforms or just allow ourselves to become inured to their presence in our lives?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's a helpful question. It's trick. I mean, I struggle a little bit with the uh incommunicable dimension because, in some sense, I guess the thinking is it's not so much that the incommunicable dimension disappears because that would grant the technologies a degree of power they don't have, right? It's more that we have some kind of relationship of repression or denial or ignorance, or it's like the incommunicable vanishes from view in a certain way, right? It's like it's not thematized, it's not like we don't have the right kind of relationship to it, is I guess what I'm hearing.

SPEAKER_02It's so yeah, I think I think that's true. I would also highlight, I mean, I keep harping on this, but it would highlight that like this is surely a more general concern. And that doesn't mean it's it's it's it doesn't mean it's not valid. It to some extent one could have similar kind of qualms about like generalized like generalized language, globalized culture. Like this is I think this is the problem of incommunicability, I think is a sort of general problem of like mediation.

SPEAKER_02And I mean, to to wit, you might think the problem is like getting rid of language entirely. Again, I gesture back at getting rid of language entirely, getting rid of culture entirely, and so on. Now, obviously, that's like a slightly uncharitable and crude way of reading these distinctions between the communicable and the incommunicable, and also this very important idea about the need for novelty, the need for a kind of direct, uh sort of use hesitate, use but immediate relationship to your life, such that new events appear as new, interesting events appear as interesting, and not just through the lens of digital of digital media and mediation.

SPEAKER_02The difficulty is just that I feel like we have less of a grip on the non-digital side of the equation than that critique suggests we do. Because to illustrate, you might think like the people who make this one one very influential group of people who make this criticism in the US are the political right, the sort of trad political right, where the thinking is the remarkable and the novel is associated with some notion of the natural, with what it's like, well, when we retreat to the trad life, we will get that will resensitize us to real natural events.

SPEAKER_02Now, as flawed as that kind of criticism might be, and as kind of ill-thought out as you might think it, that at least gives us a handle on these distinctions. Like we have some kind of way of being like, what social formation corresponds to like this better relationship to immediate events? It's like, okay, a two-person family, nuclear family, clearly defined gender roles, and you know, you're off the grid, you're separated from cities, the hellish cities that perpetuate all of this mediation.

SPEAKER_02But I mean, in spelling it out, it's kind of a reductio, I think. But I think it's very important the fact that this is very sort of symptomatic of the brain rock discourse, which is that there is often a yearning for a standard of criticism, something like ordinary human life or vital, really lived human life that acts as a kind of, you know, idylle to which we might return. But we just we have, I think we're sort of collectively still struggling to give that content.

SPEAKER_02Now, Baudrillard obviously has his own very specific views about where to go from there. I have mine, which are not as well developed. But I think it's important to rest on the general idea that like we both feel we, on the one hand, we feel we have an immediate grasp on what's wrong with brain rot. We can say what's wrong with brain rot by considering sort of like these very elementary things about our condition, that events are remarkable, that events are new, and so on. It's almost sort of existential reflection, right?

SPEAKER_02But on the other hand, we really struggle to give those immediate notions any kind of concrete social content, or at least we're skeptical about what concrete social content we can have.

SPEAKER_00I want to be clear that I'm not in favor of vanquishing language or returning to case me. Yeah, no, I mean it was fun to have conversations much like the one we're having right now in the context of a course where we set the stakes as high as they could possibly go to the very notion that perhaps the developments we associate with civilization were flawed from the start, were misconceived.

SPEAKER_00But outside of that course, I actually can't imagine anything more terrifying or awful than somehow divesting ourselves of our ability to communicate with each other rationally in language. But not that's what you were saying, Amog, but it's a basically appropriate, right?

SPEAKER_02I take it the Baudriarian criticism, right, is that it's no longer a communicative apparatus if it ever was. It's just an apparatus for the circulation of meaningless images or whatever. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, well, I can always hear the chorus of responses online in the back of my head now that I've been doing this podcast for a few months. What do you mean? You think language is bad? Okay, so so we brought up the topic of resistance. And while I'm not gonna say anything as unsubtle as language is bad and civilization is bad, I do want to say that I think resistance, at least resistance in any conventional recognizable sense to brain rot and the conditions that cultivate it, is futile.

SPEAKER_00Like thinking through a lot of the things that both of you have just said, when we talk about the inability to experience, to undergo the evental, for events to be this sort of regulating, rhythm-giving, ordering phenomenon in our lives and what it means to live without events, or in a world where the preconditions for events have been completely destroyed.

SPEAKER_00What that means to me, sort of more substantively, is that there is very little, if anything, right now that can't be surfaced and entered into the circuits of production via the internet. And this is why we don't really have an exterior to this continuous flow, this unbroken flow that is sort of the opposite of the evental, so to speak.

SPEAKER_00So to make that a little bit more concrete, I I don't think that we have anything like either a pole of absolute incommunicability or a pole of absolute positivity in the sense of like the positivist, the manifest. I think we've actually lost something that is necessary for life to kind of follow the rhythms of either being in the midst of the event, so to speak, or not in the midst of the event, in a a state that would be considered more the norm or the standard, the the condition that the event then breaks.

SPEAKER_00In order for us to experience the evental and the non-evental, we need something like a fully positive poll and a fully negative poll. But what the onlining of virtually everything does, what it means to live in a world where if it doesn't exist on the internet, it doesn't exist, or if it doesn't exist as a post or a germ for a post, is to live in a world where positive and negative have been fully relativized.

SPEAKER_00And to take this in my own particular selfish direction as somebody who spends a lot of time just reading computer science white papers. And I'm teaching a course right now at NYU where half of what we're doing is conventional critical theory, philosophy, and the other half is reading papers from archive from like the computer science repository that's just like looking at the structures of LLMs and other contemporary AI models. Looking at this in the context of the way information processing is actually structured, there is this relative relativization of, I guess you could call it like the valences of information, or it's the turn towards understanding knowledge in terms of anything that is absolute, even if it's like a conditional absolute, but an absolute within provisional contexts to the fully statistical approach to knowledge, like the fully probabilistic approach to knowledge.

SPEAKER_00So even though we're speaking about this in a way that seems very cultural, very philosophical, there is a quote-unquote hard dimension to it that has to do with how exactly the very stuff of brain rot, like brain rot the content, which leads to brain rot the condition, like the actual steps that it takes to create brain rot images and for people to stay hooked into these flows, like the machine learning algorithms that are necessary for the brain to get hooked into these things and then start rotting, as it were, are also like in a very material, very direct sense, anti-evental, because both the positive and the negative have been vanquished in favor of this continuously flowing statistical probability distribution approach to knowledge that has like again, very materially nothing to do with any sense of an absolute or an integral principle.

SPEAKER_00And I think that this is something that kind of needs to be teased out through interdisciplinary research. It's the kind of thing I'm quite interested in. But it also makes it very difficult to talk about, even to audiences that have a real serious intellectual investment in this because it's synthesizing knowledge from so many different areas. So I think this is an interesting conversation, though, that's just beginning to happen and it needs people from different backgrounds to all converge on the same territory, whether it's someone who understands transformer architectures and what it means for language to be broken down and weighted in certain ways and distributed along a vector representation, or somebody who knows their Baudrillard really well.

SPEAKER_00Like these people need to be talking to each other in order to not resist. Because I do think that there's no real resistance anymore, but at least to be able to describe the conditions of our immiseration.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. No, there's a lot there. I think, I mean, I'll just I'll start with just a couple of like resonances or exam examples that the idea of absolute valences being my temptation is to say debauched or set aside, like that is a very familiar that's very familiar to me from I guess my sort of like professional bailiwick of sort of ethics and moral philosophy. It's again one kind of standard trope of like a Catholic and neotomistic criticism of liberalism that, like, well, liberal moral philosophy has no room for absolute prohibitions, right?

SPEAKER_02It's like we were once told that various things were absolutely wrong or wrong under all conditions. Our moral world had these poles, you must not kill, and so on. And then horrific liberal culture came in and made everything exchangeable and weighable and whatever, right? So that's one kind of resonance, and obviously has a resonance also with the idea of the commodity of like what's wrong with the commodification of labor in Marx, someone like Marx, where it's like, well, human beings you might think have this sort of dignity beyond price, and the problem with the labor market is it puts a price on something that doesn't have a price, which is you know human creative activity.

SPEAKER_02So that's like a kind of preface. Now, obviously, you're talking in sort of sort of epistemological terms, but I think that's a kind of the idea that not I can't speak, I think, to the specific sort of technical stuff you're talking about, but the idea that in a sense, like the a more predictive statistical kind of collective epistemology, like divests us of meaningful knowledge, feels like a kind of intellectual analogue of this moral, of this kind of moral worry, where it's like, well, look, if we what, you know, one thing we want, if we're to have anything like a grounded sense of knowledge at all, is some kind of absolute principle or absolute starting point or something of that kind.

SPEAKER_02All we have instead are hedged and commodified predictive claims which are true in a context, and so on and so forth. Now, I think this is like extremely, extremely important, particularly to someone like me, as is as it is have had, which who has a sort of particular intellectual history with like German idealism. It's like it's a particular, I think the obsession, I think something like the obsession with sort of Hegel and Kant nostalgia that has that that's sort of like very been very in vogue in the philosophical world after the financial crisis is partly out of some recognition that like there's this desire for system and a desire for the absolute and a feeling of like, I don't know, divestment from the absolute that is out there in the culture.

SPEAKER_02And I suspect the kind of increasing quantification, predictionification of everything is one of these forces that kind of leads people to, I don't know, let's say so nostalgic epistemological journeys, shall we say? The last thing I want to say is about this important focus shift that's happened somewhat unconsciously in both of your interventions about the brain rot problem, which is the decentering of the psyche in talking about brain rot. Like both of you have importantly asked questions, not about the individual mind as a living thing, but about the very content that it consumes, right?

SPEAKER_02So brain rot here is understood less in terms of like eye strain or or nervous system stress, although I'm sure I can be connected back to those, but somehow in the destructive destruction of the very thoughts, the very knowledge, the very values that even an intact mind could respond to, right? So it's less that our brain is rotted, but the butt you know, the things that our brain might possibly contain, if I can speak that way, they themselves are rotted, right?

SPEAKER_02It's uh in a sense, even if we were perfectly functionally healthy, the images would still be meaningless or and our knowledge claims would still lack certain kinds of valences we might want them to have, right? Because those are, I don't know, structural social phenomena that can't be reduced to anything to do with individual psyches or collectives. The reason to bring this up is also it sort of pivots into the resistance is futile. Resistance to the psychological phenomena doesn't obviously seem futile.

SPEAKER_02It seems like if your concern is eye strain, then there are ways of dealing with that, certainly. And there are people who have less or more success in dealing with their own individual psychological problems. I'm told people, some people can't write, and some people put out regular substacks. So clearly, if the problem is individual, then you can resist it. But it is the it is hard to know exactly how like it's hard to even sort of can properly conceive what it might what it might look like to resist like a prevailing regime of knowledge production or a or deeper.

SPEAKER_02prevailing regime of like what I want to call like the the de the denovatification the flattening of time itself if that is ultimately the source of brain rot then I think it's hard to disagree with with Emma's claims that absent something very something much more radical resistance is kind of futile.

SPEAKER_03I'm wondering if the moral reaction to brain rot and even like some of the structural critique that we're doing here isn't exacerbated by the technologies in which it's embedded and emergent alongside of course AI, its surveillance dimension, predictive markets and the militarization of all of these technologies not only that just the the medium of conveyance is one in which where we are able to see more transparently the very forces that have imposed these technologies upon us.

SPEAKER_03So at the same time that we are receiving the pressure of having AI in Microsoft Word or as part of Google Gemini every time we do a search on Chrome or or what have you that comes alongside the videos that I'm getting of Siamese cats in cottage core eating buffalo wings right with no deny ma or like real ending to the video. It's almost like a mockery of that so on the one hand we're consuming these these these images which in the context of making sense of them there's a sort of ambivalence or there's at least a novelty in the way that we're experiencing these kinds of images.

SPEAKER_03But also there is a sort of question of agency and Promethean shame lurking in the background. One of the things that I think is useful and we haven't touched on on either of our podcasts recently or even in the context of this discussion is something like Marx's notion of the general intellect or fixed capital in the ways that I mean really centuries now of labor have fed into the technologies that have been created. They have been in the hands of the ruling class and now they're being delivered back to us in a way in which we are as individual flesh and blood beings the subject of surveillance and also the subject of a kind of mockery at the same time that instigates all of the moral questions that we've raised here and these these reactions towards Luddism or whatever else, which makes me think that initial moral impulse is not necessarily to be discarded because I think it even the reactionary impulse of going trad wife or whatever comes with the the impulse to find a way out, a line of flight, an escape from it.

SPEAKER_03This isn't to say that all of these tendencies or all of these impulses are necessarily of the same value but one of the things that I think is coursing beneath all of them is the Promethean conceit that has long been embedded within our culture and that has infused the productivism that has brought about these technologies. And the question of agency is being put before us again alongside surveillance, alongside what I'm calling the mockery and so forth.

SPEAKER_03And really the challenge to create something new or an alternative or mitigating these forces somehow, I think forces us to contend with that implied agency or the value of agency.

SPEAKER_02I mean just on the general point about impulses I think that's an excellent word for describing these kind of like folk critical formations that we're kind of talking about that it's my worry about them isn't so much that there's nothing in them or whatever, but there's a kind of premature hardening of impulses into views into theories, which I think happens a lot of the time in online discourse, which is perhaps itself a symptom of brain rot. Sure. Right to where the take right on something yeah I might even define a take as an impulse that is prematurely hardened into a claim which is on the route to calling itself a theory or something going by well that's a bit a bit too cute.

SPEAKER_02But yeah so they're impulses and precisely because of their nature as impulses they can go in a bunch of directions but oftentimes they're sort of not conscious of themselves often as impulses. So they kind of make anyway so on the agency point I think that's one of the things that illustrates how much how murky these kind of brain rotty waters are is that there are plenty of genuine values that are significant that people are grabbing onto here. But often it's kind of not immediately clear which bits of the technology suppress what we care about and which bits of the technology realize it.

SPEAKER_02So I'll take something like agency my own interest is in a kind of classical socialist conception of agency that goes back to someone figure like Lukac but also is present in the early Marx, which is the idea that what's politically desirable the guiding value of social struggle is a kind of self-conscious making remaking productive relationship with the the so the the social world you live in also with nature that the more social struggle advances by overcoming alienation and overcomes alienation by people learning much more about how they relate to the world and how they using that information to bring themselves in alignment with the material world around them.

SPEAKER_02So the process of communist planning obviously in in as Lucat would traditionally see it is a kind of realization of that. And it's a sort of glorious if I may say so myself glorious enlightenment ideal brought to its highest and possibly crazy extent right Adorno famously is incredibly skeptical of this and believes that the the level of transparency and coordination that are kind of fully knowledgeable Lucatian society is a sort of license for dictatorship and maybe a little bit of alienation isn't so bad and so on.

SPEAKER_02Nevertheless, I think this kind of this kind of planning coordinating knowledgeable unalienated agency has a big purchase nowadays. I mean I think if you think about the experience of the pandemic you think about the experience of these sort of constant global shocks we're living through the feeling of disrupted temporality right it's very weird. It's interesting that we keep talking about eventality I feel like there's a kind of negative traumatic eventality that the people are living through where global developments from COVID to Trump one to Trump two to Gaza just sort of strike them and they do experience novelty in a very base and crude sense right but what they feel unable to do I get the sense of is to integrate these events in any meaningful way into any kind of narrative anti-narrative whatever whatever one wants to say they're just sort of brute repetitive forms of sameness where the same is a world that constantly seeks to throw you off balance and I think that's the Baudrillard position.

SPEAKER_02Yeah practically yeah yeah exactly right and so I yeah I think I I bring that up partly to illustrate the kind of agency that would be that I think is kind of desired on the sort of socialist view which is like well all this is happening because of the anarchic chaos of capitalist production and what's needed is a kind of big daddy so to speak right to come in and order history by by taking the disordered fragmented realm of knowledge culture the economy and I mentioned those in that order because of I suspect that's how Lukac orders them himself into a plan in of into some kind of coherent conscious plan.

SPEAKER_02Okay bring it bringing this back to brain rot, it's actually really interesting like exactly how brain rot is supposed to stand in the way of this kind of agency, right? Is the idea I the sort of tempting thing to say is that well are brain rotted right and so they're not in the position to be the kind of Promethean communist beings that Lukas might have liked them to be right but individual agency the agency of individual I was about to say economic units is a little bit dystopian individual agency is not necessarily the focus of the traditional socialist vision right so it may be the case that bits of digital technology can be purposed and repurposed to create forms of collective agency right it's like this this traditional socialist view is very sympathetic to concentrations of power to concentrations of concentrations of technological might or at least not reflexively skeptical of them let's at least put it that way right so to that extent a social media platform I mean you see this in the constant this sort of new discourse around like can AI make socialist planning possible right it's the people's brain rot is what you're agitating for.

SPEAKER_02The people's brain rot that's right and again like you might be skeptical you might not and it's the point is just that like this agency stuff cuts a bunch of ways right whose agency and who because I feel like the vivid image people have of brain rot is this kind of like that it destroys the individual right but a lot of the left critics of brain rot weren't big fans of the individual in the first place right the the the the individual destroyed by brain rot is also the individual ideological construct of liberal individualism, the atomized self and so on, which we wanted to transcend anyway right so so there's going to be a question of like which bits of brain rot do you want to keep which bits you don't right and so that in that respect the anti-humanist post structuralists you can find their way to liking brain rot.

SPEAKER_02And here the person I'm thinking of is obviously Nick Land who's maybe doesn't deserve the label post structuralist as honorific post structuralist. But like yeah I mean there's a land thought here right which is like yeah who cares about brain rot that's just the exhaust fumes thrown up by the necessary instrument of progress and you know it's just a classical humanist moans and cries uh that we have to grow beyond.

SPEAKER_00Well I wonder though if brain rot doesn't create the individual I mean yes of course we can only go so far in rendering our criticisms of brain rot and the conditions for it before we start sounding like the humanist thinkers that we generally don't caucus with on this podcast. But I've been thinking a lot about resistance and maybe want to qualify further my belief that resistance is futile because any resistance that I can think of that would look like what we broadly consider to be a an alternative path is validating as as much as it is leaving.

SPEAKER_00It's validating by leaving it's sort of in the same sense that responding to criticism is dignifying it. There's something similar going on there. So in my notes here something that I have written is the tragedy of our extremely online condition isn't so much that it forces us into a nonsensical flow of thoughts and impressions but that what it requires to get out of that flow, the self that we assert against the backdrop of all this madness is a tool no less than the the madness is a tool.

SPEAKER_00So I have my phone let's say in my hands I have my phone always near me and I'm scrolling through Instagram let's say and feeling the bad affects set in the the feeling of no longer being moored in a particular sensibility no longer holding on to a set of criteria by which I might select certain posts as being more valuable than others or coming from a certain cultural political milieu I'm losing my capacity to select among these these different things they're all beginning to sort of feel the same which is to me that's an account of what it feels like to experience brain rot.

SPEAKER_00I don't know if everyone experiences brain rot the same way but when I put the phone down when I decide enough's enough and I'm going to clean my apartment or hang out with my cat or whatever that decision is creating a self that is no less an image right like it's every bit as surfacable as productive in the same sense that the image of the Siamese cats eating buffalo wings is productive.

SPEAKER_00And so any any kind of resistance is actually going to feed back into this vision of a self, vision of agency that we can't seem to think our way around I think to some degree because we're trained to think about the nature of thinking or the image of thought that that is conditioned into us is not one that I'm trying to think of the best way to put it but it's not one that can really ever kind of see beyond the length of its own nose, so to speak I don't think that it's easy and maybe it's not even possible necessarily for thought to be so open, so operating in a mode not of recognition but of generative cognition that we can actually begin to kind of think alongside other people in a way that really gets us out of the imaging work of both being brain rotted but also resisting our own brain rot if we want but I keep thinking that Baudu would be a really good place to go here.

SPEAKER_00And I'm curious if either of you have actually engaged with Baudou and his thoughts on the event and the role of religion there.

SPEAKER_02Yeah it's interesting I mean on the idea of the self I want to just kind of reflect that back at you and by saying that that kind of claim is a consequence of the sort of non-psych non-psychic or not exclusively psychic understanding of brain rot, right? It's like if we understand brain rot as come out as sort of a con the extension of the logic of value and the value form to knowledge items, knowledge production in general, right? The making serviceable making productive of thoughts, bits of knowledge, mental life then yeah I mean you're not you're defin you're not escaping that by stepping out of your phone for sure, right?

SPEAKER_02In some sense you're even perpetuating it, right? Because it's I mean I would want to think a little bit more about like exactly how your thoughts yourself is made serviceable and maybe connect that back to what Craig was saying about the way that events sorry the way that images thoughts get their meaning by being put online. I guess yeah it's hard for me to think about it I just I at this stage I just don't have a good sense of exactly how the circuit produces and reproduces itself.

SPEAKER_02But I guess I would want to insist in the abstract that there is some concrete process here where one takes individual items and renders them socially meaningful and intelligible in a particular way just as you make commodities you put a value on commodities. And that process can be disrupted in various ways. And uh that process has some kind of logic but I feel like we it is hard to escape the resistance's futile position the more we kind of treat the process as a totality and a unity.

SPEAKER_02Maybe it has to be treated that way. I don't know. But I I just kind of wanted to register some kind of ambivalence on that like because I can hear all sorts of critics saying like well just get up and walk to Syria and then don't tell anyone about it to quote Adam Curtis. Right right and then okay you might say that's like okay kind of a fatuous example but then I think that presses the critic to be a little bit more fine-grained about like okay what is meant by making serviceable making productive because the thinking then is well sure individual events can like people can do things in their lives which they literally do not take a physical photo of that's not what's meant.

SPEAKER_02The thought is rather that event can't be made socially meaningful without somehow being caught up in this broader apparatus right but you can see how that well that's a sort of more complicated kind of claim and I'm immediately kind of thinking about well part of the difficulty of making that kind of claim in a Marxist context is that society is defined as you know this process of valorization and totalization and so on. So anyway I that's just I guess a parenthetical note on like how to think about this more social conception of brain rot, right?

SPEAKER_02I just raises very familiar questions from thought about capitalism full stop. Does it have an outside can the circuit be disrupted this way or that and I'm sure many of these answers have been canvassed on the podcast. So on the Badu thing it's difficult because it's what's very interesting about this this idea of brain rot is that it comes at the tail end of a decade of extreme optimism about digital technology and social media platforms.

SPEAKER_02Maybe not optimism by Badu himself given his own Maoist politics but like I remember you know as a sort of weenie growing up in the 2010s or whatever like the event was frequently cited as something that could only be brought about by the distinctive structure of digital technology and platforms and so on. Right. So we think of Twitter with the Arab Spring we think of Facebook Facebook with the Arab Spring and we think of the various Twitter influenced uprisings and the feeling was occupy Wall Street.

SPEAKER_02Exactly and so this this idea that we're now kind of counterposing all these post structuralist thinkers to brain rotten digital technology well like they were the handmaidens because of the anti-humanism of like there wasn't there was an easy sympathy that one could draw between like the idea of the event and the de-centering like it was sort of the exact opposite of the logic that that that that Craig was talking about right it's not that it's not that we lose eventality through this it's that our sense of eventality is massively jacked up we're having all events all the time.

SPEAKER_03Thinking in the Marxist idiom I unfortunately don't have much to say about Baudieu in this instance but the concept of the general intellect I think remains useful here because it might allow us to diffuse certain arbitrary distinctions that arise in the moral mode of critique because when we think about like for example I mean we're doing this on a platform right now Zoom and Emma is my friend and colleague and collaborator.

SPEAKER_03And I don't want to exist in a world where I can't make a friend like Emma. But Zoom and Patreon and Twitter and all those other things have become a sort of condition by which those kinds of collaborators and so forth are made possible. Not only that, I mean I'm thinking about the way that the autonomous thought of the general intellect that among which what was produced in a world now rife with fixed capital is also the relationality alongside brain rot, we get friendships like Emma and Craig's, for example, right?

SPEAKER_03And so now we are forced to deal with this confluence of relationality and really the disentangling of it and what we might say is the dialectic of freedom as it were if we want to pursue the Marxist way of thinking about it has to do with disentangling those contradictions and selecting the good from the bad. Personally in my philosophical and political view, I think there are some problems with that but I think that's the way the field is kind of set regardless is that in this massive bundle rubber band ball complex of relationality brain rot is intertwined with some of our most valuable relationships.

SPEAKER_02Totally no I mean just to draw out the kind of logic of the criticism right it's like the classical Marxist view being well one take on the classical Marxist view being like well capitalism sows the seeds of its own destruction by creating rich forms of collectivity that it requires but can't fully accommodate right that like well it creates relationships in the factory it creates relationships of knowledge production and rich Rich interconnection and thick bonds and so on and so forth. But those bonds lay the seed, lay the basis for resistance and ultimately overcoming because they point towards whatever.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I take it. So we can resist. But of course, that's yeah, I mean that's and the well, I mean, this is a very concrete meaning, right? At the end of the 19th, early 20th century. It's like, well, for disk production, good, mass production, good, joint stock company, maybe kind of good, seat of socialism, but within capitalism, economy basically for industry, shipbuilding, iron railroads, you just kill the managers, replace them with as a lovely world.

SPEAKER_02Now, obviously, I leave implicit the the where that line of thought has gone since the early 20th century. But the version of that thought for brain rot, and it's there in like people like Bifo and all these sort of post-autonomous people. I mean, Negri himself kind of hints at it. No, you might think, well, there are forms of collective production, a kind of new mode of production, new form of life that are gestured at within these forms of digital sociality, right? It's like you and Emma kind of laying the seeds for a future society where we will no longer be mediated by the value form, but by a conscious cooperative commonwealth.

SPEAKER_03Because that makes me feel better about everything.

SPEAKER_02I know, I know. It's like when you and Emma talk, there's no mediation. There's and it's so potent. This form of collectivity is so potent that it's sort of, you know, capital itself strains. And that's what happened in Occupy. It was like the Craig Emma kind of relationship versed up to the political. Okay, I'm lightly satirizing this, but it's sort of the logic of the position. And I think there's something to it for sure. More needs to be said about exactly what's so subversive about these forms of digital communication, because it can often seem like podcast recordings are more serviceability in MS sense.

SPEAKER_02Um, the addition of Craig may just be another face on a screen in a very long life of seeing faces on screens. I I think it's really interesting that this kind like this kind of more affirmative relationship to digital technologies is just no longer part of the dominant discourse. I just don't see it as a widely held position anymore. It feels like it died in 2016 and hasn't returned since or something. I don't know.

SPEAKER_03I mean, just speaking for myself, it almost seems as if exhaustion is a nonpartisan issue. And this is where everybody's coming from at this point, but yeah, totally.

SPEAKER_02Which was the motivation behind the brain rush essay, which is like that. There's a felt collective exhaustion, but which can't be, I mean, yeah, as we're seeing, I think the consensus is kind of illusory because you poke at the exhaustion and people are exhausted by different things. Some people are exhausted by too many virtue signaling PMC types, and other people are exhausted by people exhausted by virtue signaling PMC types, shall we say.

SPEAKER_00Well, I wish I could say that the real resistance is the friends we made along the way. I I don't believe that. Um although it's a nice thought to hold on to. I so there are a couple of things I I want to say here. Maybe first to your last point, Amoog. I think that it is a valuable conversation, the one around the weight that we put on brain rot. And I'm glad that you brought the counterposition into the conversation, because really any comprehensive, serious treatment of brain rot has to consider that it to some degree at least is conditioned, modulated by all of these other problems that are, we could say, more immediate, more material, that have obviously been spoken about and theorized to a much greater degree than whatever it is precisely that falls under the category of brain rot.

SPEAKER_00The reason that I wouldn't completely fall on that side, and of course you said that you don't endorse that as the quote unquote the T P, the position to take on brain rot. The reason that I don't think it's tenable is because I mean, if you look, especially on Twitter, which on this podcast we refuse to call it X. We just say Twitter, which I'm very okay with, because I actually really haven't used it since it became X.

SPEAKER_00But that website, there seem to be so many victims of brain rot or slingers of brain rot, sort of the same people, the the ones who seem most brain rotted or most likely to convey brain rot, who are not hurting materially whatsoever. I mean, people from the tech world, people from the tech right who have a lot of money, who have have greater means than yours truly and most of my friends and loved ones.

SPEAKER_00So I don't buy that as something that would vanish if we all had a better quality of life. Although, of course, there there is a conversation I think to be had around compulsive behavior, health. We could try to tease that all out without reinforcing particular models of wellness or ability or disability that we're going to be critical of here. That that's all there. But I think that would take us down a sort of a line of conversation, at least, that I don't feel particularly well prepared right now to go down.

SPEAKER_00One thing I want to bring up here, though, is um uh a bit more applied, and this is on the topic of optimism or pessimism regarding digital technologies. I'm familiar with the the optimism of the 2010s that you speak about, Amogue. Although even back then there there were thinkers who were incredibly critical, either coming from a history of Marxist or post-Marxist tech criticism or writing a little bit more at a superficial level about the psychological effects of tech.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that was already present in the 2010s. Some of that criticism was quite light and not particularly useful these days. But even somebody like Evgeny Morzov, for example, who already in 2015 was pointing to the kind of tech criticism that was prevalent then and pushing it forward in a productive way by being extremely critical in a way that is especially generative. And he's somebody that I would point to as a vanguard of the tech critical left, even back when there was still this euphoria around tech.

SPEAKER_00But there are remnants of that mindset. There are people who are anti-capitalist, either explicitly or not explicitly, at least in their sensibilities. They're sort of more on the side of the critical thinkers, the ones who are not going to give a foothold to at least the conservative powers that be right now, even if they're not explicitly super leftist, who are still trying to use the ways and means of digital technology to create events, basically, like to create the conditions whereby we can collectively experience some sort of shift or at least have some sort of space of sanctity, of differentiation fundamentally.

SPEAKER_00In particular, I'm thinking of Dark Forest OS, the Dark Forest OS project, if you're familiar with that, of all the people, including a number of people on the left who believe it's still possible to use blockchain technologies to create what I've heard referred to as the cozy web or the more like intimate web. There are these initiatives now, like with Dark Forest OS, with people who are trying to technologically manufacture the conditions where we have a more narrated, more evental, more inward-facing, more highly contextual relationship with information with each other.

SPEAKER_00And I hear about this a lot. People will send me examples of like what's going on with the Dark Forest OS project or different things that people are doing with blockchain. And I want to be nice, but I don't think that you can technologically manufacture your way out of this for ultimately the same reasons that I was describing earlier in this conversation. Like at a very technical material level, it just doesn't accommodate that much integrity.

SPEAKER_00It's always going to be vulnerable to the kind of decontextualization, dissolution, melting from a state of solidity into air that we're seeing everywhere right now, and that is apparently impossible to think around. So it does seem for a certain kind of person who is still sort of gunning for a way forward that we can build with these tools, it's kind of a dead end. I do want to point to the fact that especially living in the city that we live in, the loops between online and offline are tiny.

SPEAKER_00I mean, the reason Amoga and I are friends is because I made friends with somebody on Facebook years ago, actually, someone we've had on the podcast, Aragorn, who, even though he's in Johannesburg, digitally introduced me to all of these people in New York City who have become friends that I hang out with in person. And there is a new kind of sociality that's made possible by these technologies. And I guess I wouldn't say that there's nothing radical in that. I don't think we can compare it to older forms of sociality.

SPEAKER_00I also don't think that it's right to think of it as a form of resistance, but I would say that I'm not, I don't think that all falls on the side of the evil, you know, the kinds of friendships that these platforms allow for. But whether it's going to just help us, you know, kind of maybe feel a little bit better as we hold hands and jump into the abyss together, or if it will keep us from the abyss, I don't know.

SPEAKER_02I think Dark Forest is an interesting example because it's I mean, with something like that project, I really wonder what their kind of diagnosis is of something like Brain Rot, or like, because it's often, I mean, I'll speak generally, when I encounter sort of blockchain enthusiasts and so on, I get very, I guess I want to say hand wavy thoughts. Like it's very much the idea that a specific group of people owning the means of digital technology is the problem.

SPEAKER_02And if we can create private, group-owned, whatever other forms, things will be okay. It does remind me a little bit of the worker-owned small businesses kind of model of escaping capitalism, where it's like, yeah, the idea of the problem as like fundamentally social and like embedded in certain ways of viewing knowledge and certain ways of talking and thinking, that's kind of not present in in these, yeah, like either sort of block people like blockchain enthusiasts and so on.

SPEAKER_02I mean, to be fair to them, it's not immediately clear what you can do about this more, this wider and more nebulous problem of like online efication as serviceability as commodification. It's it does, yeah, but that but nevertheless, it is worth asking for anyone who wants to create an independent space. What's the phrase? Private by default, public by choice, or whatever it is. What for? Like, what is it that what is it that people are trying to do?

SPEAKER_02Are they simply trying to formalize a certain friend group and provisionally kind of wall it off from like larger access and communication? I think that's viable in small and particular ways, but if you it's I think slightly quixotic to do that as a way of like turning back, of winding the clock back on these Baudriardian trends. And I think one of the things that's very difficult about these projects is that there's just this such a massive mismatch between means and ends that we are going to change the internet and take it back to the Tim Berners-Lee dream.

SPEAKER_02And how are we gonna do that? We're gonna we're gonna escape rented platforms by creating a new specific community network. And that just, yeah, yeah, your prescription does not match up to your goal. So, as with worker-owned businesses, as sort of small to medium scale interventions, I think these make a lot of sense. Now, I feel like oftentimes like the dark forest people, the blockchain people have some theory of scale up that like is part of the story that I'm not fully doing justice to.

SPEAKER_02Like the the thinking is almost kind of Gandhian that, like, okay, well, if we do our particular little thing well, it will generate momentum in a particular way. And people will see that, but that's tricky, actually. That's tricky because scale up requires communicability. How are people gonna hear about your little individual internet community network? Right? Is it not our people not gonna have to see it on social media and so on?

SPEAKER_02And so, yeah, and I think I mean, again, I can hear sort of friends of mine saying that, well, it's too deterministic a picture of like how communication works, that either you're in an isolated cavern or you're part of the machine TM. Well, fine. If it's too if well, the difficulty with these types of initiatives is they often have no theory of society. So if you think the critic's view is too deterministic, it's kind of on you to explain how you think your particular your like it's on it's your responsibility to have some story about brain rot and so on and so forth.

SPEAKER_02And the story they have is largely, yeah, sort of voluntaristic and individualistic. Well, if you have to raise money for art or creative projects, you have to go to GoFundMe, and GoFundMe is bad because it's kind of collective and blah, blah, blah. If you have to find bits of code, you have to go to GitHub and get GitHub, you don't know whatever. I don't know who's made this little tool that I'm looking up and using, and so on. But all that stuff is a little gestural. Like, as with we can only get so far here.

SPEAKER_02I mean, we can't really get far beyond the level of impulse if we're just working with like these sort of basic dichotomies of the local and the global, the immediate and the immediate. And I think a lot of these, yeah, a lot of these experimental initiatives like really don't go beyond that level. I haven't either, but you know, the problem's the problem, even if none of us have solved it.

SPEAKER_00It's about the words themselves. The words brain rot. And a cognate that is just as much in the cultural zeitgeist right now is slop, especially if we look at brain rot as content, brain rot content and slop content. Often you could use those terms interchangeably. What seems interesting to me about the phrase brain rot is that it's playful, it's got this self-aware dimension to it.

SPEAKER_00There's an irony. As an anecdote, I have a nephew who is 10 years old, completely addicted to digital games. And there's this one game he plays called Steal a Brain Rot. I think it's actually in the Roblox world. Like Roblox has all of these different games. And one of the games is called Steal a Brain Rot. And it's so strange to me to be seeing this child playing a game that's named after a condition that we obviously can and should take so seriously.

SPEAKER_00Like it becomes this sort of lightweight, you know, this thing, it's it's not really a big deal. And it rather reminds me of the way that people laugh about Trump, like all of the memes that were produced about Trump even before the 2016 elections. And it was always something that I found disturbing, you know, because whenever you surface something as a target for humor, you're validating it and normalizing it and bringing it into society in a way that condones it.

SPEAKER_00The same thing is happening with brain rot. You can imagine sort of, especially younger people sort of jokingly referring to themselves as being brain rotted, and slop doesn't have quite that connotation. So I guess the question would be: what should the tenor of the discourse be? We've talked about the substance of brain rot and whether it might actually be attributed to all of these other things or not, whether it has this degree of internal integrity that we seem to be imbuing it with just by having this conversation.

SPEAKER_00But I mean, even more crudely, is like, how serious is this problem? What is the sort of right feeling to have about it? And that's the last question I think I put out there.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I'll speak, I guess I think brain route should be treated less as a ready-made pathology. It should not be taken at face value in that sense and substantialized. It should be treated as a kind of expression of at once a kind of project and aspiration, which is it expresses a deep feeling that something is wrong with the conditions of contemporary experience, thinking, intellectual production, which has to do with extremely basic cognitive functions, which has to do with the way we see the world, the way we process the world, the way we narrativize our experience, sort of synthesis, the way we synthesize events into sequences, etc.

SPEAKER_02Right? Things are wrong at that very deep level. And furthermore, there's a there's an explanatory claim. Like the reason things are wrong in that way is because of the structure of digital technology somehow. Maybe not exclusively, maybe the explanation goes back in a Baudriadian sense to kind of larger modern forces, but in any case, right? So it's but it's aspirational in the sense that both sides of the diagnosis are left open-ended, right?

SPEAKER_02What precisely is wrong with cognition and what notion of right, that we've sort of investigated, but also what precisely about society generates this again, uh slightly open question. But it's like an important and deep project of contemporary social criticism to kind of make good on this connection somehow. I guess I see it as something that we have to make sense of rather than something we can hope to set aside.

SPEAKER_02So to that extent, like part of the reason we've had so much trouble disentangling it is just because there are these bigger problems about how to think about thinking and how to think about society, which also remain unresolved, sort of bits of 20th century baggage, right? And to that extent, we kind of balloon around from the abstract to the concrete, to the abstract to the concrete, because we don't really have kind of orientation on those types of questions.

SPEAKER_02I'll end on uh again another kind of ambivalent note. Even the amount of definition you feel like the problem might have at an individual level, right? You might think, and I speak as someone who's on the front lines of the brain rot epidemic, you might think, well, you know, when you're suffering brain rot, your headaches, your eyes hurt from blue screen exposure, there are all of these very obvious health effects. I can just, I will just attest from personal experience that it is extremely hard to draw the line of addictive and non-addictive tech use.

SPEAKER_02There is no existing medical practice that has successfully done it. Um the smartphone discourse often the policy fixes that they come up with short circuit the problem by simply by recommending that kids or people under a certain age don't use smartphones at all. Right. And that's obviously a way of not fully answering the question, right? Of like, well, what exactly is supposed to be bad about these? An interesting conclusion, though, as I've sort of thinking about sort of some personal history around this stuff, is that it's hard to fully get a sense of like the pathological addictive quality of these technologies without kind of critically investigating your own concept of the value of interesting information and the value of knowledge.

SPEAKER_02Right. Because the driving force at an individual level is the desire to know new things, the desire to be excited, entertained, titulated, etc. And you don't get anywhere with that. It's hard even to make a first step with this unless you have some kind of critical understanding of how much knowledge is enough. When is being interested or amused or titillated healthy or unhealthy? And I I frankly don't even know where to begin with that stuff.

SPEAKER_02That requires that requires, I think, a little bit more possibly conversation with Craig about the concept of inventality and rhythm and so on. But yeah, I'll leave it there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I mean there are uh all sorts of, as they say, implications for further research, right? But this has already been quite a lot. So thank you so much for giving us so many different things to think with. This has been really great. Thanks, Amoge.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, yeah, happy to do it. Yeah, thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. LEPHT HAND PATRONS Q&A: Part 1 - Spinoza, Sound as Image, and the Consolation of Philosophy

    Oct 31, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

    AHRC Courses: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses Several weeks ago, we asked patrons to contribute questions to our very first Q&A episode featuring Serpetie, Emma, and Bob. In the discussion, we tackle...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Selfie That Wasn't: On Projection, Spirituality, and Knowledge of Other Minds

    Sep 20, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    The Lenox Institute for Advanced Study: https://lenoxinstitute.org/ Acid Horizon Research Commons Ongoing Courses: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses Can something as ordinary as a selfie crack open a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Does Psyche Matter? Jung and the Unconscious in 2026 — AHRC Public Panel (Audio)

    Sep 2, 202652 minAudio

    The fall season of AHRC courses begins next week. Enroll in two classes and get a third free with code 3FOR2FALL2026. Bob Langan's Jung and Spinoza: God, Affect, Destiny, beginning October 4th:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Was Adorno Right (and Wrong) About Astrology? Irrationality, Imagination, and Epistemic Flight from Normalizing Power

    Aug 18, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Is astrology a harmless distraction or a pseudo-science opening a path to fascism? Or can it help us reclaim an imagination lost to the hyper-rationalism of modernity? In this episode, Sereptie and Emma trace the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Scandal, Shadow, and the Underworld: Where the Symbolic Meets the Political

    Aug 7, 20265 minAudio

    Listen to the full episode here: Enroll in Bob's class at AHRC: https://www.acidhorizonpodcast.com/ahrc-courses/p/jung-and-spinoza-god-affect-destiny In this Patreon exclusive episode, recurring guest and friend of the...

    Credit the people on this episode