I spoke recently with Philip Ball, the prolific and extremely gifted writer on the sciences, principally about his recent Book How Life Works, but with occasional oblique references to other of his books, such as The Book of Minds and Beyond Weird. We discussed many things: a possible shift of paradigms in the life-sciences, Neo-Darwinian orthodoxy, cognitive systems in organisms, xenobots, batrachian epithelial cells, medicine - and even a little metaphysics. In case the Substack player proves recalcitrant or unpredictable, the recording can be watched on YouTube here. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit davidbentleyhart.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00you are Philip Ball a writer of on the sciences I shouldn't say on any particular science because you've written books on quantum physics on science of mind on the the new the new let's say just trends will be good at that in the life sciences and on many other things in the history of science i think actually the first book of yours i read was paracelsus is that right um ah yes okay that goes right it's right here on my shelf goes back uh many years uh so yes it's biography of paracelsus funnily enough i'm writing about alchemy again at the moment so are you
SPEAKER_00Do tell, actually, before I go on.
SPEAKER_02Well, as light relief from some of these sort of weightier tomes, I've occasionally over the past several years been writing books for a company, a publisher called Quarto, who published beautiful highly rated books. And I've written one on history of experimental science, one on the history of the discovery of the elements. And they asked me if I'd like to do another. And I said, well, yes, in principle, I have nothing in particular in mind. And then they said, well, how about an illustrated history of alchemy?
SPEAKER_02And of course, I couldn't resist that. It's been a subject that I've been interested in, certainly since before the Paracelsus book. So that's what I'm engaged in, trying to encapsulate the whole thing in rather frighteningly few words for this massive subject. But that's an interesting challenge in itself.
SPEAKER_00Well, I once, years ago, I have to admit, when I was younger and poorer, wrote a kind of coffee table book on the history of Christianity. And I found the hardest thing of all was what I had to decide not to say. um it uh it that's the discipline that's that's the hardest for someone if you're if you're both if you have a great deal of facts at your fingertips but you're also naturally garrulous so um
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, that's and it's a good discipline for me because I have that that failing as well. I tend to write too much. So if I know that I only have a very limited space available, it focuses the mind. It also relieves you from the pressure of feeling you have to be comprehensive because clearly that's not possible.
SPEAKER_00analogously to the way in which the knowledge that wants to be hanged in the morning focuses the mind. I mean, it's a matter of deadlines, you know, and time available. All right, so you are Philip Ball. Let me explain to those. I have to be, I'm an admirer of your work, to be honest. Well, that doesn't sound like a terrible, I'm an admirer of your books. You've written, as I say, what i think is probably the best uh guide to quantum physics for the uninitiated the intelligent general reader who may not be a specialist or have any specialized knowledge but is curious and intelligent i i think uh there's no other book i would recommend if someone who wants to learn
SPEAKER_00uh what the questions are what the advances are what the and um I feel the same way uh about many of your books I think they're just exemplary uh guides for those who might and it's a very difficult skill to master it seems to me to explain very complicated very abstruse material ideas with that kind of clarity, without seems to me sacrificing substance.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you don't make the sort of statements that simplify to the point of distorting the material. So I am actually, I was an admirer of yours before you ever dropped me a line.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's really nice to hear, David. Thank you. I'm very flattered by that. I guess I'd like to think that part of that process of trying to communicate something that's complex in a clear way, certainly with the book on quantum mechanics, comes about through feeling that actually we need to find a different story to tell. I mean, we're going to... no doubt talk about this for my latest book as well. But that was really the impetus behind that book on quantum mechanics, that it wasn't just to convey to a wide readership, you know, what this notoriously difficult subject was about, but was actually, it came about because of a realization I had, having written about it quite a lot,
SPEAKER_02around that time, that we were telling the wrong stories and that the simplifications that we habitually make about quantum mechanics were actually ones that were conveying the wrong picture. They were really a grasping for a kind of classical analog that we could, you know, intuit. And the whole point of quantum mechanics was that it doesn't give us that. And so really, that book was an attempt to try to convey that, to try to make us really confront the what seems to us to be the strangeness and what certainly is the radicalism of that idea.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think you pulled it off marvelously well, let me say that. I thought, among other things, for instance, that if I wanted had some student or curious person curious uh about say what decoherence means your book is the best i've come across at giving an explanation that i assume he or she would be able to follow again as i say without without losing the thread or without it becoming overly simplistic the same is true of the book that prompted this conversation uh how life works i i was i was planning to i do this quite often have a pile of of uh
SPEAKER_00oh that's hilarious yes I see the color of the book matches the background amazing no actually this is this is the the printer's art now they can make transparent books um that um uh the deals with really rather remarkable movement in the life sciences I'd say over the past what seven decades or more eight decades well I I mean I tend to to date it back to the time of Barbara McClintock for some reason but but you might you know you know uh the actual dating isn't important but again it's it's a wonderful text in covering a great deal of very
SPEAKER_00difficult material with grace and clarity. And again, as you say, the great question that seems to run through it is, are we telling the right stories?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it had a similar genesis in that regard that I had felt. In fact, with this one, I had felt since my time as an editor at Nature, the science journal in the 1990s, it was then that I started to learn about molecular biology in the first place. But the more I heard about it, the more it changed. It seemed to me that there was something not quite matching between the popular story that we're told of how this comes about and what some of the papers that were coming through Nature and what some of my biological colleagues seem to be saying.
SPEAKER_02lived with this for years with these sort of misgivings and trying to grapple with exactly how to articulate those. But it wasn't until, I guess it's now five years ago, 2019, I had the opportunity to, I was invited to be a visitor at Harvard Medical School in the Department of Systems Biology for kind of as long as I wanted. And I ended up going for the summer for three months because I could take my family at that time. And I turned up there with a sort of ragbag of questions and misgivings and so on, and was hoping for some clarification from the experts I was going to be speaking to.
SPEAKER_02It seemed to me that pretty much everyone I spoke to in that department, and it's a particularly, I think, progressive and interesting and diverse department, it seemed that everyone was kind of saying to me, Yes, it's true that we're not telling the right story. And it's even worse than that. But they also gave me some way of thinking about what the stories should be. So I came back from there with what turned out to be a very sort of baggy document of all kinds of notes. And I had no idea what I was going to do with this.
SPEAKER_02Until, of course, I realized I had to write it up as a book. And I did so not in order to tell people what these new stories were, but in the desperate hope, really, that I might discover for myself in having to delve into the details, to discover for myself what those stories were. So this book, How Life Works, is an attempt to try to at least sketch out what some of these new stories might be.
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, actually, I mean, I thought, I mean, for me, of course, the two books you've written on mind and life connect to one another in ways that might not always be apparent to everyone, but because of my special philosophical interests, which I may or may not address as we go along. This book, in part because, of course, part of the question of what's going on in the life sciences simply has to do with cognitive systems and how they operate in organisms and seemingly in organisms at the cellular level and in the process of evolution and how to understand this.
SPEAKER_00which for me of course places it all within a somewhat broader metaphysical Horizon where questions of mind occur as well but uh to step back for a moment again I suppose I should explain to those uh listening to this that um we first uh gotten you dropped me a line when you were writing your book on mind and um we corresponded about that which I I thought was a wonderful book as well by the way if I haven't already said so
SPEAKER_00Again, because of how many difficult issues in theory and in the scientific findings, such as they are, such as they can be, that you describe with considerable clarity and clarity. i went back over our correspondence actually i was shocked at how much of it there was my my short-term memory has been you know slowly abandoning me as of age so i just remembered that we'd exchanged a few emails i went back for pretty long um exchanges um and i think uh you know
SPEAKER_00The question that both books raise for me, but this one especially, is whether you're willing, and I think you are, to talk about not just well of course yes are we telling the right story is it too much to say that that we're watching I mean obviously slowly gradually epically a kind of serious Paradigm shift in the life Sciences the very the the the foundational principles of of how we ask the questions rather than just how we interpret the results
SPEAKER_02I think, I mean, I'm something of a conservative here, I think. Maybe surprisingly, because there are some people who will see my book as being somewhat radical.
SPEAKER_00I think it's very judicious in that regard, is that you're not guilty of overstatement, but you do, I think... raise this question for any reader.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I think it's a very fair question. I mean, I guess I feel I've never been quite sure what really qualifies as a paradigm shift, if anything, in science. Obviously, there's always been a big discussion about whether that Kuhnian model is the right one to describe the way science advances. I do think that there are some profound changes that have happened in really, in this case, I think in the past couple of decades, actually, in the way we think about how the, what we might call the fundamental level, or let's call it the microscopic level or the molecular level, how life proceeds.
SPEAKER_02I talk about it as how life works, but maybe that's too grand. And I think that we're still assimilating those. And I think that one of the things that it really has overturned is the notion that was really predominant since the 1950s, since Crick and Watson really, and the discovery of DNA and how it seems to encode information. I think what is being challenged is that narrative, is the idea
SPEAKER_02And the more I think about it, particularly in the light of what we now know, the more banal an idea it seems to me to be that the answer to how life works is that it's just encoded in this string of DNA. And, you know, that it's just a program that has to be read out. And the cell is, if you like, the machine that reads out the program and builds us. And this idea stemmed, I mean, you can certainly trace it to Owen Schrodinger's very influential book, What is Life, published in 1944, where this was before we even knew that DNA was necessarily the carrier of the genes, let alone how it did that.
SPEAKER_02But Schrodinger suggested that there has to be something that he called a code script, really what became known as a program in the computer age, that was basically describing laying out not just how to build the organism, but how the organism then works on a day-to-day basis. And So this was the idea that, quite explicitly, Crick and Watson inherited, and it seemed to them that by discovering that DNA has this ability to encode information, as it seemed in the same sort of way that we were then encoding information in binary form on magnetic tape,
SPEAKER_02It seemed like, oh, here's the last part of the puzzle. That's how the information is encoded and it just has to be read out. And I think until the Human Genome Project got underway, that began in the 1990s, well, in 1990 itself, to understand this, to decode this information. Until that happened, that was really the paradigm change. that life was certainly at the developmental process, how we grow from fertilized egg was a reading out of that information encoded in the genome.
SPEAKER_02And all we had to do was to figure out the details of how that happened. And I think that what has become clear since then, ironically, because of the capabilities that the Human Genome Project gave us, the capabilities to look and compare DNA and to more generally probe the cells at that very detailed level, it's become clear that it's an inadequate way of describing that process.
SPEAKER_02that actually the story I tried to tell in How Life Works is one where there is much less, there isn't centralised control of that process. There isn't, and in particular, there isn't this bottom-up control sort of feeding of information from a prescribed form in the genome that is simply read out, that actually the informational flow, if we can think about it in those terms, that's going on in life and particularly in our sort of life, multicellular, multi-tissue, that it goes in all directions.
SPEAKER_02which genes are being activated, and even what the genes are making, which proteins they're encoding, is dependent on higher level information, information coming from the environment, information coming from other tissues and other cells. So there's this constant flow.
SPEAKER_00From the organic system itself.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt.
SPEAKER_02No, well, that's that's really the you know, in a nutshell, I think that was the story that I'm trying to tell. And it's I mean, in some sense, I feel like when you tell it that way, it sounds quite simple and perhaps unsurprising as well, because, you know, this this notion that somehow you could build. something, again, we're always talking in metaphors, if you could build some entity like us, doing it from a blueprint is a terrible way to make anything that complex, because it's like trying to put something together, an incredibly intricate clockwork mechanism together.
SPEAKER_02And if you just get one of those parts out of place, the whole thing fails. Now, the standard story in biology has been, oh, well, there's redundancy in that system so that, you know, if this element fails, there's another pathway that can do the same thing. Which, when you think about it, is simply saying the answer to the fragility that will come from a very complex mechanism is to give it more complexity. I don't see how that's ever going to work. The actual answer, and we see this again and again in different systems at the molecular scale and upwards, the actual answer is to relinquish that sort of control at the bottom level, at the genetic level, to actually distribute the control, if you like, or the causation is really how I think about it, to all these levels so that something going wrong on one of them can be compensated for at higher levels.
SPEAKER_00but of course though there are multiple levels then there also has to be you know what the mind tells us there must be also some sort of coordination that allows the system as a whole to say that you know something has gone wrong at this level it can be corrected at this level and I mean and that would it seems to me make it all the more problematic to try to understand it simply in terms of a blueprint uh that contains all the information in itself because well let me actually come to think of it let me let me make one distinction here when you're talking about code and encoding we should probably uh
SPEAKER_00clarify one thing. The word tends to be used equivocally in my experience when talking to molecular biologists. Sometimes it is used in that total sense of a code, a blueprint, something that determines from the bottom up the entire structure, function, life history of an organism. But of course, Crick and Lawson were probably, I mean, right, at least using the language analogously to be excited to discover means whereby information coded is passed on.
SPEAKER_00the germline, if you like, and to quite often, these two things become conflated, the notion that there's some kind of coding is taken to mean that there is a program, a sort of an invariable program that determines all things, rather than simply saying that the DI DNA is a vehicle for what I think Dennis Noble likes to call templates.
SPEAKER_00uh shared across Generations that nonetheless require a real agency at the cellular and and organic levels uh to be used to be employed in various ways in various contexts in reaction in relation to shifting environmental conditions and any number of other things that as yet we we probably only have the haziest notion of Is that fair? Let me say that.
SPEAKER_02I think it absolutely is. I think you're totally right that there has been all along this elision between coding at the genetic level, meaning that there is, if you like, there's some kind of information in there that is used. I mean, really what we're referring to at that level is the genes encode possible protein structures. And I'll say a bit more about that careful wording. in a moment, but that is a quite different thing, as you say, from the notion that the genome as a whole encodes the structure of the organism and those two are completely allied so often and they're totally different things.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, I think what we can reasonably say to use the, I mean, it may just be a metaphor. Some people say, actually, it's much more precise than that. But to use this notion of coding, we can reasonably say that a sequence of DNA that we identify as a gene, there is information in that, in some sense, that is encoding DNA. the structure of the sequence and therefore the structure of a protein molecule.
SPEAKER_02And that's using this notion of coding in the same sense as Morse code or anything else. One thing is representing something else. So a particular sequence of the chemical building blocks of DNA is representing a particular amino acid that goes into making the protein. So that in itself is fair enough. There are complications even there, because I think it's fairest to say that our genes tend to encode possible proteins.
SPEAKER_02They don't uniquely, on the whole, our genes don't uniquely encode a particular protein. on average, each of our genes encodes around six different proteins and some of them encode dozens or maybe even hundreds. And there's arguments about how many of those actually have biological functions, but certainly different proteins get made. And the way that happens is that the sequence in the gene is transcribed to use a sort of technical term into this molecule called RNA, messenger RNA, which is similar to DNA.
SPEAKER_02And that then sort of goes off in the cell and is read and translated into a protein. But before that happens, the RNA gets chopped up on the whole. There are bits of it that get taken out, bits called introns that just get chopped out and thrown away, basically. Or not always, but that's the usual picture. And the other bits... called exons are stitched back together and they can be stitched back together in various ways to create templates for different proteins and how that sticking that as as it's called that splicing of exons is done might be different in different tissues so there are signals this is again this sort of top down i i well not top down this sort of you know it
SPEAKER_02There are information going in all ways. There is information coming from the outside to the cell that informs that process of splicing. So it informs which particular protein is made from a given gene.
SPEAKER_00You know, I have no problem with the talk of top down and bottom up because you're stuck with metaphors one way or the other. But yeah, the interesting thing for me, of course, there also, again, is the degree of sophistication and at times, innovation at the level of the cognitive system.
SPEAKER_00This issue of a paradigm shift, I think one can defend that language even in Kuhnian terms or in the terms from Polanyi or others. in that it's historically demonstrable that it's not something that happens suddenly. It doesn't have to happen catastrophically, and it doesn't require simply abandoning entirely every advance made in previous imaginative paradigms.
SPEAKER_00But nonetheless, I mean, I think we could say that 17th century science made, for instance, early modernity, there was, a genuine attempt, a successful one in terms of creating an intellectual culture for a new method, the mechanistic philosophy. That is a real shift in the way we thought about nature and it yielded its fruits. It still does.
SPEAKER_00it's a precious attainment to be able to look at discrete processes and understand them empirically in terms of how they work. How does, you know, how does this valve function? Where does this screw go in and all that? But at the same time, you know, as clearly the case the paradigms we work within also do determine how we ask questions and and how we interpret results I tend to resist the notion that the sciences need to ask philosophers to help them out with many things though I know that sometimes it does help because I've seen examples of philosophers making very bold statement I mean scientists making very bold statements
SPEAKER_00that a better training in simple logic might've spared them the embarrassment of making, you know. But it does seem to me though that you do have to examine, when you get to the point where you have to base, examine the basic premises within which your discoveries are being framed so that they can intelligibly make sense of the discover, and where Kuhn is right, the discoveries that are being accumulated,
SPEAKER_00that something something very profound and foundational is shifting you know and and I I for myself I think this is happening in the life sciences I don't think it means that um that there's going to be some sort of uh epochal break with with everything we've discovered hitherto or you know But it is a profound, I think, to assimilate and understand and better appreciate the things that we've been discovering or the scientists have been discovering.
SPEAKER_00I shouldn't use the we form there. I have no right for inclusion in that pronoun. But I mean, the things that have been discovered, the basic models of thought, basic models of interpretation do have to be altered. I was... i think i was in high school i had just finished high school when barbara mcclintock won the nobel prize for instance uh for those who don't know i mean she did experiments on um uh on maize you know um and and uh the ways in which uh cells cellular processes uh
SPEAKER_00repaired damage done by actively restructuring the genome and using it in a way not pre-programmed, not predetermined. and for many decades this you know this this uh fell on deaf ears for the most part not everywhere but but her work she won the Nobel Prize in what 1983 so I would have just finished I left high school early went to college but I just finished and I had a biology teacher in high school Mr Whipple
SPEAKER_00Well-trained, it was a good school. So you actually had real scientists training, teaching science classes. But he was very sort of dogmatically neo-Darwinian and very dogmatically materialist too. Scornful of religion or philosophy that wasn't just grounded in a certain sort of empirical investigation. and i remember asking him i didn't really understand but when when he explained to me what she had won the the prize for this set off a chain of questions in my mind regarding well you know what about the narrative that he had actually given us that was sort of in the biology textbook we had of
SPEAKER_00Well, something like the Richard Dawkins picture, or whether I don't blame him for it. I just mean that sort of picture we get from the reading of something like the selfish gene in which there is the active thing, the active element is the gene, whatever that is. walled off from somatic cells that passes from generation to generation and preserves itself as a sort of immortal gene line through constructing these vehicles that come and go, that are transient.
SPEAKER_00transient means of transport so to speak for the survival of the gene and I asked him you know doesn't uh you know when he was explaining what what she was being given the award for did this fundamentally and at that time also I had heard a bit about Lynn mark at least in her um where I uh and he he he just said well i think what we're talking about is a recursive process and that the genes encode the cells to which seem to be kind of very strange the notion that that you're who's still trying to rescue the notion of a purely genetic centric account in which the genes sort of have a blueprint for correcting their own blueprint that again you know
SPEAKER_00I think that as long as one, and I think this is true today, I mean, you look at a biology textbook, a pretty doctrine to even ones printed last year. So being taught by people in the life sciences who have a more sophisticated grasp of the ambiguities here, nonetheless, do tend to start with a fairly doctrinaire and fairly linear sort of genetic centric. um doctrine which is then you know once that's been fortified then those who go on to graduate studies may move beyond it in detail but not necessary but take some time to realize that the details have begun to alter the principle so uh that's a long and wandering way of saying i think i think you can justify talk of a paradigm shift without it
SPEAKER_00becoming someone assuming a prophet's mantle and claiming that the whole structure of the sciences to this point has to be abandoned.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's perfectly fair enough. I mean, I think it's clearly going to continue to be the case, probably indefinitely, as far as I can see, that we know that we have this stuff called DNA. We know that proteins are made from it. We know that many proteins do particular roles in the cell. There are enzymes that catalyze particular reactions. and so forth. We know the structure of the cell is, you know, there may still be aspects of it that we don't understand, but we know that pretty well.
SPEAKER_02So all of this is secure knowledge. It's not, no paradigm is going to undermine that. I think where the paradigm has, where you could reasonably say there's been a shift in paradigm is in the issue of gene regulation, which is about how those genes are, in some sense, controlled, whether they're actively producing their protein or not, which protein they're producing, and what role they have in actually maintaining that larger scale structure.
SPEAKER_02And that, I mean, I think you're absolutely right, David, that Barbara McClintock's work was pretty central in that. And that was clearly one of the major messages that she wanted to put across, that actually seeing the genome not as this passive repository of information that is read out, but seeing it as something dynamic, something active. something that is operating on itself in some manner, was really the perspective she brought to it.
SPEAKER_02In fact, she said we ought to be seeing the genome as a sensitive organ of the cell, which was such an interesting phrase, and I think a very sort of prescient phrase. You're absolutely right. At the time, people didn't really know what she meant by that or how to think about that. But now that we're starting to understand this process of gene regulation, how genes are turned on and off to enable the or during, I should say, the the developmental process.
SPEAKER_02So that, for example, a skin cell is different from a heart muscle cell because different genes are active. It's that process where I think there's been a really profound change, not just in our understanding of how it works, but of how central it is both to development and to evolution. And there, you know, the standard way of thinking about this. And this was this was true right up until actually right up until I think about 10 or 20 years ago.
SPEAKER_02was that it was a bit like a system of switches. So we knew that genes were regulated, were turned on and off. We knew that since the 1960s, at least, the work of Francois Jacob and Jack Mono, who won a Nobel Prize for it. And they studied how this regulation happened in bacteria. And there it seemed quite clear. kind of digital and quite sort of neat that you would have, to put it very simply, one gene produced a particular protein that was able to stick to a bit of DNA next to another gene and block the transcription process from happening.
SPEAKER_02So block that gene from being active, if you like. And so it was a bit like you could imagine this as a kind of digital circuit, like in a micro electronic device. And so this was a very neat way of thinking about how gene regulation happens in order to enable development, in order to give cells different characteristics. And that was everyone was sort of happy with that. And they assumed that, you know, it must happen in the same way as it does for us, because in fact, it was Mono who came up with this famous phrase that what is true for E. coli, the bacterium, is true for the elephant.
SPEAKER_02We now know and we've only known for the past sort of 10, 20 years that the way gene regulation happens in us is really profoundly different and much more complex and much more interesting, much more rich, but also bizarre. poorly understood at the moment. It seems to involve many different molecules, whole committees, as I talk about in the book, committees of molecules, particular proteins, pieces of RNA that don't encode proteins, but are themselves regulatory.
SPEAKER_02And this is one of the real paradigm shifts that's happened that actually we found that that a huge amount of our genome encodes these RNA molecules that they just function in their own... Non-coding RNA, yeah. Non-coding RNA, and they are almost all regulatory in some sense. They're involved in gene regulation. And some of those are very long molecules that seem to sort of stick to whole sections of chromatin, the stuff that the chromosomes are made of, this mixture of DNA and proteins.
SPEAKER_02Some of them are absolutely tiny, so short, in fact, or at least the bits that seem to do the work are so short. that they're too short to encode any meaningful information, it seems. So how on earth does something that small perform any particular role in the cell at all? How does it do anything specific? And in fact, I remember very well when we first found out that the genome seemed to be transcribed to this degree, that all this non-coding RNA existed,
SPEAKER_02I remember being contacted when I wrote about this in Nature by someone who had worked for years, for decades, on gene regulation in bacteria. And he was totally mocking of this work. He said, it just doesn't make sense that something that can't bind specifically to a bit of DNA or to some other molecule, that it could have a specific effect. And it was a very good point.
SPEAKER_02At that point, I didn't have an answer myself. It seemed that this was what we were starting to find was the case, but it wasn't clear how. Now we are starting to understand that what happens with gene regulation in us and in complex creatures like us is that it is this complex coming together of many molecular components, many of which are surprisingly unspecific in what they stick to. This idea that all biomolecules, proteins and so on just find a particular target and stick to it doesn't apply anymore.
SPEAKER_02Many proteins, including some of the most important ones and including pretty much all of those involved in gene regulation, are fairly promiscuous in what they stick to. And so this whole set of conversations between molecules that are just kind of, you know, talking to each other in relatively non-specific ways, out of which somehow comes a well-defined kind of yes-no decision about should we turn this gene on or off. And so that's why I talk about it as a committee.
SPEAKER_02It discusses, if you like, around a sort of table all these different molecular components and somehow comes to a decision. And the way that seems to happen is what we call combinatorial, that it's not this digital logic of this turning this on or this turning this off. It's this particular collection of molecules in this particular context will give rise to this outcome. Those same molecules will be involved in other decisions and in other contexts, and they will give rise to other types of decision.
SPEAKER_02And so there's a kind of fuzzier logic to this process. A logic that is much more versatile and I think crucially is much more able to improvise. I mean, you know, that's a very sort of anthropomorphic way of putting it, but I really think that's what we see.
SPEAKER_00Well, maybe an anthropomorphism, but you've just raised a very interesting question, but I'll let you continue.
SPEAKER_02Well, I can imagine what you might be asking, David, but we'll see. Yeah, I mean, I think that's you know, and that's I mean, I think this is a reflection of why I suggest in the book. And, you know, you've said it just now that the better way now to think about the way life works at this level is. uh cognitive whether that's a metaphor or whether it's something more than that it's a it seems to be a cognitive process in the sense that you know this is what happens in our brains our brains aren't digital computers that take in all this information and compute the right outcome they improvise daniel dennett would disagree with you but uh
SPEAKER_02Well, I wonder if I wonder, I mean, you may be right. I'd be interested to know what Dan would say about that. But I think it's, you know, certainly the idea that it's, you know, our brains are having to weigh up and evaluate, give value to or ignore different inputs. You know, sometimes our brains will have an input and will ignore what it has been told. I think in the same way that cells sometimes have to,
SPEAKER_02you know, ignore a particular signal if you like the balance of information, the balance of sort of feeling amongst the other molecules, you know, lies elsewhere. So there is this much more fluid and much more innovative and improvisational nature to the way cells work at the molecular level, certainly in complex creatures like us. It's less the case in bacteria. And I think the reason for that is that, you know, the more complex the organism is, the more unpredictable the environment is, the challenges that it faces are going to be.
SPEAKER_02And therefore, you need something that has this flexibility, this versatility. And I think really, in a way, the ultimate expression of that for creatures like us is our brain. You know, it seems to me our brains are there to take the pressure off the lower levels, to take the responsibility off genes that cannot possibly encode answers to every challenge that we will face. You know, brains are, I think of them as evolution's way of thinking.
SPEAKER_02relinquishing control from the genes and allowing it to be more improvisational for complex creatures where the challenges they face simply can't be predicted.
SPEAKER_00Right. Although, again, I hesitate to say what brains are for so much as what brains do, or what minds do, or however. But of course, that in itself assumes already, if the brain has to take that pressure off the lower levels, that's something that occurs already at a highly developed level. And that... is itself meant, it's a language is so hard here, has the effect of preserving the complexity of the system for all of its fragility and complexity and perhaps advancing that complexity.
SPEAKER_00So that's what I mean. It raises questions simply because whenever you start talking about cognitive systems and the way in which an organic system achieves a higher functionality or higher level of complexity or a more a more open and uh for a potential sort of structure you also invoke questions of intentionality towards ends that somehow
SPEAKER_00would seem to lie beyond anything like the the momentum from the past of sheer physical causation and that's what when I talk about the paradigm shift what I mean is um this again I'm not getting I'm not trying to get better physical here I I do that anyway but I mean that's all I'm trying to do is that in the in what invariably of course tends to happen where there is a real change in the models we're working with is we tend to reconstruct the past according to the narrative we're trying to create right and this often means uh giving things an opprobrious reading or a very prejudicial reading that's not especially accurate i mean the 17th century quite rightly abandoned lots of elements of the old inherited
SPEAKER_00unexamined notions about just like folding bodies and things and that had begun well before the 17th century actually 14th and 15th century scholastic uh examination of mechanics had begun people like Thomas Bradward Dean and others but at some point there was you know the sort of baconian Revolution and thought says we're going to uh we're going to set aside um sort of the aristotelian etiology the formal and final and all that now again makes perfect sense in creating a space of examination and the ideal at least of an inductive method but at the same time it meant grossly oversimplifying what the issue is so that you create the false notion of a continuum between what cause or idea meant in antiquity or the middle ages and what was now being talked about
SPEAKER_00And I think there's there's always that sort of conservative stress in that is that we're always when if a paradigm shifts, we're still bound to a picture of the old models and we and sometimes the only way to break away from them is to create a fiction about what the old model was, which is what I think, for instance, not intentionally, I think Bacon thought he understood what the schoolmen were talking about. We seem to get a point now where there is this reluctance perhaps to give up on certain models just because of how much we have learned using those models, how fruitful they've been.
SPEAKER_00but at the same time the life science if I were to try to I would say that you do see what looks like and again I wonder if I'm not a doctrinaire Aristotelian I know these are Thomists who just want to turn everything back into a very simple notion but but I mean I'm sorry there is a there's a sort of vindication in some sense in that using the structure of mind or mental agency to understand the structure of life or the structure of reality is not an implausible thing to do that in fact it helps clarify again it may just be another model but of course we work within models we understand that they're methodological fictions in some sense using metaphors maybe analogies are better because analogy has you know somewhere between univocal and equivocal uses of word they are cognitive systems maybe but not in the way that
SPEAKER_00I'm a cognitive system when I'm trying to work out a route to the store or something or find my way to the end of an argument or write a poem. But there's an analogy there. And readmitting that sort of structure of rational relations in which you're not afraid to talk about finality or the difference between a sort of top-down, bottom-up or formal and material, relationship in the structure of something has also you know it can be terrifically liberating but it's funny how it happens by steps you see the life sciences people talking about information which is not quite talking about form or at least not as it came to be understood in the 17th century reading or talking about teleonomy as a way of not quite saying teleology and that's fine i i
SPEAKER_00But the essential intuition from which the older model worked for all of its, both its flaws and its strengths was that just this, that the mind-like structure, whether it's emergent from that physical reality or is something else, the mind-like structure of relations between a future end and an impulse between a formal and a material constituent of any structure organic especially is is something that shouldn't be resisted out of hand for fear that it makes it hard to see what you're seeing
SPEAKER_00Um, and that I have to say, I mean, that's something that interests me now is seeing that, that, that, uh, if anything, if I, that I find it interesting in the, in, in the culture of the life sciences in the past 10 or 20 years, it is people like James Shapiro or Dennis noble, uh, or at the philosophical side, people like Evan Thompson, not feeling constrained to fight against, uh, using that model that imagery those metaphors those analogies however you want to frame it uh and and insisting on something that looks more like machine processes you know and um you know and of course that's why i say it raises these issues of the relationship between mind and life or or you know how one should understand the either the emergence of the former from the latter or the latter from
SPEAKER_00uh structure of reality that that resembles more the former um in you know physics for instance people like paul davies trying to say should we write laws of information into the laws of physics into the basic laws of physics or robert rosen in biology it was a brilliant man i don't know if you know if you've read a lot of robert rose and i assume you're quite familiar with him in fact i'm thinking yes i know you are um you know trying to see uh make the laws of life a fundamental paradigm uh not emergent but somehow fundamental in understanding now again these are all ways of navigating a terrain they're not uh
SPEAKER_00the moment they become metaphysical dogma, as is the habit, say, with some of my Thomas friends, or Thomas acquaintances, actually get along very well with Thomas, as well, then, you know, it becomes, it becomes just another set of blinders to where, you know, you've decided what you will or will not see. But I think that, and I don't mean to keep recurring to this issue of a paradigm shift. I do see this as a very curious moment in that regard in that is it the narrative that we're working with also seems to be a way of recovering much of the past with a new narrative of the past as well of the sciences and trying to find fruitful ways of synthesizing the wisdom
SPEAKER_00of a variety of perspectives and that was foreclosed in the great revolution i think of of early modern science i mean a new method was uh you know and again a very fruitful method was decided upon it was never practiced with perfect fidelity because pure induction is impossible i mean it just is the inductive method is a pure induction that doesn't start with some context of
SPEAKER_00what is this for, cui bono, is almost impossible, except that the most basic levels of mechanical function. But nonetheless, if I were to take a large lesson from your books in that regard, it is that that real narrative, you're right, the narrative has to change. But I think it's a narrative that has to change, first and foremost, by surrendering the useful prejudices of the modern scientific project and discriminating the prejudices from the principles that have been discovered.
SPEAKER_00Again, I'm taking a long time to say something very simple, but I'll give a simple example. I'm talking about whether the sciences need philosophy. I don't know. do need logic though um for me a good example of of the problems you know like benjamin libit's experiments in the 70s that about whether we have free will or not um well intentioned though they were had such overwhelming
SPEAKER_00well basically mechanistic premises written into the method itself that the interpretation of the results that many got that limited himself at first and then others got from those experiments was preposterously were preposterously illogical they simply they did not follow from what had been seen but the reason that they seem to is because the actual method had so entirely isolated what was going on in a room at a certain moment with a person interacting with technology as though it were another person, another piece of technology without an intentional history, past or future.
SPEAKER_00They drew conclusions that were almost the exact opposite of what they should have drawn from what they were seeing. And a good example of that to my mind, again, brilliant uh neurologist a neuroscientist uh Sapolsky um I can't remember his first name Robert Robert Sapolsky yeah all right he wrote this very uh large and and and uh a book on whether we possess free will you know and the scientific content of the book is is
SPEAKER_00very up-to-date, and it will be of great interest to many readers. People should read it. But the actual argument he's making, there are just very fundamental logical errors on every page of that book.
SPEAKER_02I completely agree. In fact, I would have to also say that even the scientific argument he's making that some of the cases that he presents are ones that have been strongly challenged in terms of whether they show what they purport to show. And sometimes he says that, but nevertheless, it doesn't seem to stop him in his own way.
SPEAKER_00It has good information in it. I didn't say it has good argumentation.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And the Libet work, of course, you know, I mean, I did enjoy that, you know, your demolition of that, David, that I saw recently that, you know, in a way, it's sort of fundamentally flawed from the outset that he's saying to people, you know, I want you to exercise your free will in choosing to push this button whenever you decide to. And somehow those experiments are going to undermine free will. Libet himself, I think, was quite cautious about
SPEAKER_00have interpreted oh yeah he to his credit i mean he his his initial response was i think our initial response is always when something surprises us to go a little too far but then immediately said well ready you know he started using terms like readiness potential and all that which is just another way of saying i felt an impulse you know before i acted on it which i think we already knew is what you do
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And, you know, and Dan Dennett has also sort of slightly skewered those questions, those experiments, too, by saying, you know, in a sense, the participants had surrendered their free will or some degree of their free will by agreeing to participate in the experiment. agreeing to abide by the rules. But absolutely, as you say, the whole notion that we are somehow interrogating the way we function in the world cognitively by sitting in a laboratory pressing buttons in response to a particular stimulus just seems a very odd idea at the outset.
SPEAKER_02But I think the way I think about some of the questions you were talking about, you were mentioning Jim Shapiro and Dennis Noble and Evan Thompson and others, all of whom, you know, it has to be said, are regarded as, I wouldn't say on the fringes of biology, but there's a great deal of scepticism towards... from biologists as a whole to what they're saying. I think part of that comes from the fact that they're trying to ask questions that biologists are not accustomed to asking.
SPEAKER_02They're looking at the bigger picture and so much of biology is so complicated that very few have the readiness to even address those sorts of questions.
SPEAKER_00If I can just add one before you go on, though, I mean, just for those who don't know, but at the same time, those figures, Dennis Noble, James Shapiro, Robert Rosen, I mentioned also, it's not the science. I mean, it's not their attainments as scientists are any question. These are issues of interpretation.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. The way I would favor approaching some of these issues that you've addressed, you've raised is through the notion of agency. And, you know, I think that that's to me thinking about agency is a is a more fruitful way of thinking about what life is. is or what it does, perhaps, than certainly than trying to boil life down to a kind of checklist of what living things have to be able to do or otherwise.
SPEAKER_02And it still seems rather extraordinary to me that not only do we not have a theoretical framework for thinking about agency in the life sciences, but it hasn't even been admitted as a question that needs to be asked until quite recently. And, you know, I've got a chapter in my book that tries to raise that issue. And I'm absolutely not the first to have done so. But I think this question of what, you know, what amongst all of this molecular complexity and cellular complexity, what is keeping the show on the road?
SPEAKER_02I think agency is at the core of that. What is it? that makes a living organism down to the level of single cells? What is it that makes it an agent? By which I mean an entity that has a purpose, a goal, and is able to manipulate its environment and itself in order to try to attain that goal. And it's a goal that has been self-determined. And it's a goal that's individual, you know, individual cells that nominally look should be identical, don't always respond in an identical way to the same stimulus, because each of them has its own agency, has its own goals that are in some sense related to, you know, I think once we think about where agency comes from, it gets us into aspects of a sort of cognitive framework.
SPEAKER_02Agents have to have memory. Agents have to be capable of integrating information that they get, but also crucially evaluating it, making, you know, again, to put it anthropomorphically, making value judgments, giving it meaning in some sense. So it gets into all these taboo questions in biology. But I think we need to recognize them as real things and embrace them to understand what it is that living things are and what they do.
SPEAKER_00Well, again, you say putting it anthropomorphic, but you notice that it's hard not to. Yeah, because because when you start talking about agency again, you begin raising all those metaphysical or philosophical questions that are. commendably often avoided in the sciences, but sometimes avoided by scientists, to the point that it inhibits what they're willing, willing to venture theoretically, or what they're willing to credit as an explanation, for obvious reasons.
SPEAKER_00But again, I mean, this takes us back to the birth of the modern sciences and said there was a, I mean, when when in the old what had been the reigning Aristotelian uh understanding of again I don't even like to use the word causality I use a separate word etiology just using you know uh atia the the word used by Aristotle simply to set them apart because um the aristotelian questions all had to do with the rational coherence of a phenomenon can you identify a substance does it have an intrinsic uh final state of all of its potentials being
SPEAKER_00being fulfilled is it therefore you know what makes it a unity as opposed to just a plurality in relation to other there's a completely different set of questions than the ones that are actually being asked in with the discovery with the Richard and Richard Discovery Galilean or late scholastic whatever mechanics Um, when you get the, but, but, but what the Aristotelian etiology did rely on was the notion that somehow mind the relations that characterize mental agency or agency in general, which is inherently, uh, uh, you know, uh, mental, uh, in, in some sense, uh,
SPEAKER_00as the model for understanding nature as a whole, the decision was taken that that was no longer to be the case. And it was presumed that you, I mean, there are people like Thomas Nagel who will come along and point out that this does not, in allowing for this model, this does not entail that you then have to embrace a theology or something as well. It's simply a recognition that the profound laws with which we're dealing might not be that somehow mental agency is a late phenomenon rather than an explanatory model in itself that can help us understand even how it emerges as a phenomenon.
SPEAKER_00Um, the, the, the, the, the, that willingness to say that there's a finality. So you talk about, um, the organisms having purposes, but of course, purposes, you know, uh, purposes, uh, when you think about them in mental terms, and I think, again, this is why people have a certain who resist that sort of language do. So when you think about purposes, intentional purposes, you're never just talking about the end that will be reached.
SPEAKER_00You're also talking about why the end is to be reached, what it is, I mean, a kind of almost structure of desire. Why does the organism choose to persist? Why, you know, choose, again, why do these systems, these cognitive systems, why they're not just data processing, but creative systems for negotiating unforeseen circumstances in order to achieve an end. And the moment you do that, you're positing a purposefulness that in some sense has this as you and you use the word value values a very great philosopher of the scientists of the 20th century late 20 the raymond sort of being rediscovered now not only in france but in the english-speaking world who uh again never flung himself into the embrace of any religious tradition or anything nonetheless um
SPEAKER_00uh what he really did was he was he was in the line of bergson and others kind of you know trying to free them from uh misinterpretations of their work and in the and and in the process started talking of a space of values that somehow is as fundamental as the space of physical causation so i mean in a sense you can't avoid the anthropomorphic language and in a sense those who resist it feel that once one does that one can't resist the sort of the metaphysical pull of of of how fundamentally this might alter our view of what the foundational principles not like the sciences but of reality might be and there's always the you know the fear that that this is going to have to be interpreted
SPEAKER_00now as you know I I'm no great fan of fundamentalists of any sort materialist or religious so I think but but I mean I understand the resistance even to the hint of the shadow of the Echo of the possibility that when you talk about cognitive systems you're talking about an intentionality that has a propulsive structure that incorporates values because for myself uh I don't think
SPEAKER_00real intentionality can ever just emerge from the non-intentional i think that as soon as there's an intention it's already premised and embraced within a prior intention just as i don't think subjectivity consciousness can emerge without it when you think of it in purely trying to make it a mechanistic explanation you end up with an infinite regress of um of the reflective nature of consciousness. But that's, that's all beside. But I do understand the resistance, I do think that you are doing something perilous.
SPEAKER_00When you when you when you allow yourself those those metaphors has to be done with great care.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a very interesting way of putting it. Maybe it is. It probably is perilous. I'm probably going to find that out sooner or later in admitting words like meaning into my book. I guess for me, you know, this is where the conservatism comes in, that at the moment, I guess I feel... I'm content to start from the old paradigm, really. Start from the position that it's conceivable to me that
SPEAKER_02I mean, I talk in the book about evolution being a goal-generating or a meaning-generating mechanism, if we want to put it that way. I'm content with that as a starting point. And I think thinking about agency as a property that has particular ingredients, and we can find out what those are, might enable us to then at least frame better questions about how how could agency arise from non-living matter if it could and then you know what are the right questions to ask to to to examine whether it could what are the components that need to be um in place it may not be possible but i but i think that's that's my starting position and i think you know this is the this is the the thing about evolution that you know it's always been a um
SPEAKER_02You know, ever since Darwin and before, really, it's always been something that's very hard to talk about in a in a strictly materialistic, objective and non anthropomorphic way. And perhaps it's because, you know, I think it's I'm prepared to imagine that it's because we as evolved beings, frame our picture of the world in that way, you know, just as we attribute mind to all sorts of places where it's not obvious that it exists, just as we, you know, have had sort of gods of the wind and so forth.
SPEAKER_02You know, this is, and just as we attribute it to AI where we shouldn't, you know, this is our failing, if you like, that we tend to do that. So maybe this is just the framing that we as evolved creatures have and find it very, very difficult to break out from. But I do think that at the moment, it's not obvious to me that we couldn't find some way in which the characteristics of agency arise arose from the non-living you know already i mean and i know that you've talked about this too already we can see in systems that we do consider to be non-living we see we can see behavior collective behaviors that have the appearance of agency we can see behaviors that even have the appearance of adaptation to the environment purely for thermodynamic reasons whether that's
SPEAKER_02The right way to look at it, whether that's the right sort of analogy to be using, you know, perhaps we don't yet know, but it certainly looks that way at the moment. So at the moment, I guess I feel I'm happy to start from the premise that actually we may be able to get agency without having without it having to be there in the first place.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, let me clarify. Well, first of all, I'm not sure which nonliving systems you mean that seem to behave the way we would agree are nonliving, because that already assumes that we have a definition of what life and living are.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I'm thinking of, I mean, for example, there's a new field of condensed matter physics called active matter, where you have particles that are made from crystals or something, but they have means of propulsion of some sort. And the way they move around looks spookily like maybe swarms of birds, or it looks like there's something sort of intelligent that's guiding their behavior, that it's certainly collective behavior.
SPEAKER_00so that's that's the kind of right right so that's why i want to make the distinction i mean um uh i'm trying to avoid taking this down the wrong rabbit the rabbit hole so i want to get back to the the the matter of the book um but when i talk about uh whether or not the intentional can can emerge from the non-intentional i'm talking there in terms of strong emergence uh not suggesting that the purposes and meanings don't evolve with organisms with life, they do.
SPEAKER_00I just don't believe that meaningfulness as such, purposefulness as such, can arise from the non-purposeful. And the reasons for that, though, are so outside this line of conversation that I would just be... boringly gesturing in in the direction of things that i argued elsewhere but don't have the time to argue here but but i i what what i i don't mean uh though is that that that you have a one-to-one correspondence between cognitive behavior and a uh you know some sort of conscious intentional structure at the lowest levels i i do believe that um
SPEAKER_00if I were to characterize it again, I mean, that's why I'm not averse to using their Aristotelian language is something more like it, that those processes are formed, in a sense, by a formal principle that that involves purposefulness before they themselves exist. So that yeah, as, as our species evolved, with it came new spheres of meaning new millions in which
SPEAKER_00that one can negotiate. And I mean, here it's not unlike, you know, Evan Thompson trying to explain how consciousness interiority emerges from a certain comportment within a, you know, he'll use the term teleology and all that, but he's still trying to get back to where you can explain this precisely in, in a sense, the terms of this movement from negotiations of entropic conditions to fully formed intentional life. My inclination is to think that that a step is missing there that will always be missing the the intentionality, the purposefulness will not appear will not evolve within the organism, unless it's already in another sense of governing.
SPEAKER_00a sphere of etiological determination in the way that Royer talks about a sphere of values. But again, I'm perfectly open to the view that it could possibly, I just say for myself philosophically, I find that it leads to too many logical regresses that for me fall away more easily than they would for you because i'm an instinctive idealist anyway so i have no problem with putting mind in some grand sense first and in that sense someone like bergson would be an example people talk about vitalism as as though that there really were these semi-cartesian people who thought that there was a life principle a sort of
SPEAKER_00essentialists infused into mechanical nature but that's not actually what the interesting philosophers of that they rather their view was that there was in some sense innovate not unlike robert rosen's notion that those laws of life are so fundamental that they will exhibit themselves and i would say laws of mind as well exhibit themselves even at levels of what we would say are not living or not conscious. So I mean, I, again, as I say, it all depends on on how you want to using the term life, how one's using the term consciousness.
SPEAKER_00And is getting stray into into where you're trying to point to something rather and and say something meaningful about it, though you lack the explanatory vocabulary. But it is true, I mean, you're right, that this has always been an issue in evolution is that, were working within a paradigm that starts and this is true science of mind to you start with a paradigm that has excluded mind like structure, mind like relations from the picture within your working.
SPEAKER_00And then you try to reintegrate the phenomena of life or mind into that picture. I mean, at first, that wasn't the case, obviously, in the 17th century, if you're a real Cartesian, you would just say, Well, yeah, nature is mechanical, physical nature is mechanical. And then there's a completely different sphere of reality where the life principle and the mind principle and the God principle and that there's an interaction in some mysterious sense between these two. But of course, that's lazy.
SPEAKER_00intellectually it's philosophically lazy it would be also lazy for scientists to rest content with that they they they're looking for explanations that are more fundamental that are comprehensive that in fact can can take in the full phenomenon of life or of mind or whatever without at some point saying but this is an area of mystery that's out from outside the machine and so commendably that that sort of dualism was rejected but that again that's all within the modern picture that's all within the post-cartesian picture no one in the ancient or medieval world asked the question that way so it's not even relevant to talk about that as
SPEAKER_00a different paradigm. It's not like an early defective attempt at the modern sciences. It's asking a completely different set of questions. And so I still find many of those questions solvent. I still find, and not just in the Western tradition, you know, I am also a student of Asian language and religions. you know, those profound arguments that you find in Adi Shankara and others about about the structure of consciousness and about the difference of life from non living that I find powerful and I do.
SPEAKER_00So the only thing I urge on people in both camps, though, is to remain open to both. possible stories or not just both but all the possible ways in which we have to think this through because so what happened to poor Thomas Nagel when he got mind and Cosmos you know impeccable atheist credentials I don't think anyone's going to accuse him of being a mystic or or uh or a dogmatician but he was Savage uh because he said you know with the and what he was saying was that there's there's this there's a degree of information in the structure of life and in the structure of mind that isn't accounted for it seems to me he's you know he's again he's seems to him is not accounted for now maybe made a mistake in saying something nice about the intelligent design people which i wouldn't do i'm actually more censorious of them than he is but you know even so
SPEAKER_00all they really said was that they're asking genuine questions and shouldn't be so maybe they are i i'm just so afraid of dogmatic uh uh and also i don't like the the cartesian model they work and they're still talking again they've just gone back to the notion of a great designer out there in the beyond But it does seem to me that where it's good of you to be conservative and not wanting to venture extravagant hypotheses, it seems to me also that one has to leave open the possibility that those extravagant hypotheses may also be common sense in just as more idealist persons of my sort should be willing to, you know, I try to...
SPEAKER_00try to acknowledge that I don't really know what the laws are that are fundamental. You know, Paul Davies is right, maybe there is a way of writing the laws of information directly into the laws of physics. And you might be very right that as an evolved, or in my case, semi evolved, a cognitive system with intentionality and something approaching a rational mind, I cannot help but interpret reality according to the model of my own phenomenal experience.
SPEAKER_02And that, you know, that seems to me plausible. But at the same time, yeah, I absolutely would say, and I think I did say in the Book of Minds, that the sheer existence of minds is baffling.
SPEAKER_00I love that book. I love that book.
SPEAKER_02Nothing in the laws of nature. You know, much more baffling than the existence of colliding black holes. There's nothing baffling about that. The laws of physics can tell us exactly that that's what we might expect. There is nothing in the laws of physics that would predict the existence of minds, the way we conceive of them. So I think we absolutely have to start from that recognition, you know, at the very least, whether or not we believe we can get there eventually. I have no idea, but I think that it's really important to make that clear, that it's minds are profoundly puzzling.
SPEAKER_00Well, again, as I said, I'm an admirer of that book in part because of that sort of very, well, the intellectual honesty there and also that you're not trying to trivialize the question. There are those who do. I've known both philosophers and scientists to say, well, there's nothing really mysterious about conscious mind. And then they tell you why. And what you get is a causal narrative from which mind has already been subtracted.
SPEAKER_00uh and and you're right i mean to me that's the great the great mystery that that that that makes all confidence about all metaphysical pictures of the structure of reality um premature let's put it that way um So what do you make of these xenobots that Michael Levin has created? Since we were talking about Daniel Dennett, let's take a complete journey over there to Tufts University because, of course, a friend of Dennett's is Michael Levin.
SPEAKER_00Well, actually, maybe you could describe the sort of these kind of filial cell experiments.
SPEAKER_02Mike is one of those people who every time I speak to him, he seems to have 10 new ideas. And I think to some people, that's intensely frustrating. I think for me, it's very stimulating, even regardless of whether any of them will go anywhere. But he's an incredibly creative scientist. So this notion of xenobots, this was, I guess it must be about three or four years ago, possibly more now, that it began, that basically he wanted to, he's interested in, he would call himself a developmental biologist.
SPEAKER_02He's a very unusual sort of developmental biologist because he's interested in the possibilities of development, perhaps, well, certainly including ones that maybe we haven't seen realized yet. And in order to explore that, he did what seems like a very simple experiment of taking cells from frogs, from developing frogs, just taking a bit of tissue, disassociating it into cells and just seeing what they would do. and it's an experiment that could have been done in fact in some ways has been done previously.
SPEAKER_02What we observed was that these cells would aggregate into clusters of maybe I think it was sort of dozens to a hundred or a few hundred so they were clearly, if you like, it looked as though they had some developmental plan. They went about aggregating into these clusters and then stopped aggregating and the clusters themselves started behaving like little organisms, at least to all appearances. These frog cells, frog skin has, they're skin cells, and frog skin has little appendages called cilia on them that beat about, just we have them on the inside of our gut too.
SPEAKER_02Well, they're similar to that. Sorry, not of our gut, of our lungs. Yeah, our lungs.
SPEAKER_00I know all about them.
SPEAKER_02And so the cilia, what seemed to happen on these clusters of frog cells is that they somehow coordinated so that they were beat sort of like rowers, one direction on one side, one direction on the other, which meant that these things could start seeming to swim around. And so they could move around. They seemed to interact with each other. It looked as though, I mean, certainly they seemed to have particular behavioral tendencies. Some just swam in circles. Some would move linearly. They seemed to be able to navigate mazes.
SPEAKER_02They did all kinds of things that looked organism-like. And Mike called these xenobots from Xenopus levis, the Latin name for the African... Claude Toad, I think it was.
SPEAKER_00I would hope he also just took it from the Greek, Xenos.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. That's what I wanted to believe. And maybe it originally comes from that for the toad itself. So exactly.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it does. It does.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And they certainly are. So, yeah, Mike published this work and there's been a lot of debate about it. There are some developmental biologists who say, well, we knew all this. We've seen these kind of bits of tissue doing stuff before. There's nothing, certainly nothing intentional in what they're doing. It's just that these cilia move automatically, mechanically. They'll do that anyway. And so that's all we're seeing.
SPEAKER_02But others are saying it does look like there's something developmental here. These structures seem able to heal themselves if they're damaged. You know, it seems like they have some kind of, if you like, program for maintaining their integrity. They even seem able to...
SPEAKER_00Sorry, we're shifting here between the computer and the anthropomorphic.
SPEAKER_02We are. We're mixing metaphors like mad here. And, you know, one is, again, impossible to avoid. They seem to some of these structures seem almost to shepherd other cells, other of these frog cells into new xenobots. So they seem to be able to. not replicate in the strict biological sense. There's no reproduction going on here in terms of cells dividing and copying, but they seem, in a sense, to be able to make new versions of themselves, to be able to, if you like, to reproduce after a fashion.
SPEAKER_02So they show organism like behavior. And Mike is arguing that this seems to be a developmental program, if you like, that frog cells potentially have, but that are never realized in normal frog development. And he's very recently shown similar kinds of behavior for human cells. In fact, he saw it a long time ago, but he's only just just published it. So there are anthro bots as well now. And so there's a lot of debate about about, you know,
SPEAKER_02what the nature of these things are, how to think about them properly, whether they're just an epiphenomenon of what these cells do or whether they genuinely do seem to show some target structure for cells. And regardless of that being the case, and I'm agnostic about which way to think about that, certainly there's potential for trying to think about ways to use these structures in biomedicine, perhaps to sort of ferry things around.
SPEAKER_02in the bloodstream. And Mike is actually forming with his collaborator, Josh Bongard, computer scientist at Vermont, is also involved in this. And they've formed a company to try to commercialize this. But I think what really interests me in that work is the more general idea that, and I think this seems extremely likely to me, that our cells have you know they they if you like they sort of well they do have their own agency that gives rise to the structures that form us it seems extremely unlikely that and that that is all they can form and in fact we have reasons to believe now that they can form other things as well stem cells you know will form uh that other cells can form these sort of organoid like structures that
SPEAKER_02kind of recapitulate the organs that form during development. But because they're forming just in a glass dish, they're a little bit different, and we might be able to make them more different. And I think that there are particular developmental trajectories that cells have. In fact, this is something that Conrad Waddington, the developmental biologist in the mid-20th century, talked about.
SPEAKER_01Right, right, right, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, it seems very likely to me that there are possible things that our cells can form that they haven't formed or don't form in the normal course of development because there is no, you know, no case for it. Just like, I mean, again, this comes back to this kind of innovative ability and improvisational ability, just like, you know, there are behaviours that we could potentially do that we will never have any chance occasion to do in our lives. I think, you know, if we think of cells as cognitive entities, it's perhaps unsurprising that they should have possibilities that in the normal course of events, they don't get to realize.
SPEAKER_02But perhaps we can find ways of giving them that opportunity.
SPEAKER_00which raises the issue of medicine which is the one thing i want to make sure we discussed before going our separate ways dissolving into our separate mists of pixels or whatever um though i will say i mean about the michael what i found interesting about if again as you say it's a matter of interpretation of the results cells you know the way he describes is almost as if these these cellular aggregates sort of established a bowel plan you know in coordination so that there's a midpoint and the cilia for rowing around the nutrient-rich environment you know um
SPEAKER_00you know and and and then of course when you start asking questions of improv i guess maybe why dennis noble likes the image of the music of life think of life where they can improvise because it also has a series of resolutions it's it's stretching out towards uh but isn't isn't just a fixed uh pattern of genetic uh determinism again though that takes us back to all those metaphysical questions that i've been skirting so i'll jump over to medicine because one of the really uh i thought that actually one of the chapters and i have autobiographical reasons for this that i found most interesting was uh the one about
SPEAKER_00possibilities of future developments in in medical therapies in in our understanding of medicine so if you could say something about that yeah um
SPEAKER_02Well, I guess, you know, having looked at all of these new ways that we have to understand how life works, I guess it seemed like an inevitable question. You know, what does that mean for our ability to develop new therapies? And I think one of the things that occurred to me most of all is if we recognize that, as I argue in the book, there is this I talk about. causal spreading, a dispersion of the locus of causation throughout the organism, if you like, at various levels, so that cause isn't all happening at the genomic level.
SPEAKER_02sometimes the true cause of perhaps, you know, of a particular developmental feature, I mean, like our fingers, actually, you know, that's not something that is caused at the developmental level. The reason we have five fingers is something that we really have to understand at the level of the sort of tissue level, really. If we recognize that there is that spreading of the locus of causation, then if we're interested in intervening in the biological process, as we are in medicine, to create some particular outcome or to prevent some particular outcome,
SPEAKER_02We're going to be most effective if we can identify the right causal level at which to make those interventions. And this is, you know, something that we're already sort of starting to see. It's already plain, actually, that this this the promise from the Human Genome Project that it would lead to this deluge. And I think it really was a promise. If you look back.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, people were talking that way. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02that it was going to revolutionize medicine. The master key to life. I mean, it's revolutionized some things, but it hasn't led to lots of new treatments. A lot of people have recognized that that has been disappointing. It has led to some, but not nearly as many as one might hope. And I think the reason for that is that we have, in the course of having completed the genome, that we have started to learn that actually the genome is not the right place to go to treat, to intervene in many cases because it's not the real locus of causation.
SPEAKER_02And one way we can see that is that actually for many of the traits, many of the complex traits and diseases that we're interested in, anything like heart disease, neurodegenerative diseases, The the genes, the parts of the genome that seem to be associated with that are spread out over many different genes and even not even genes. They're spread out in the on the whole. They're in the bits of the genome that don't encode proteins. They're in these non-coding regions of the genome, which I think is really interesting.
SPEAKER_02It's all about regularity. But there's so many of them, you know, and each of them has such a little effect that you're never going to get anywhere by trying to target those bits of the genome or those gene products. And that's an expression of this sort of dispersal of causation. I think all we're seeing there are the echoes of the causes that are happening higher up. And in particular, you know, I think, for example, a lot of causation resides within the immune system as a whole.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02We saw this during COVID, the problem with COVID, it wasn't so much things that the virus was doing directly for people who had severe COVID and many people who died. It was the immune system's response to that, which, you know, for some people just went into overdrive and our organs were sort of shut down as a result. So it's often so much of disease gets funneled through the immune system.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, we're seeing now the immune system is being targeted in one way or another for treating cancer, for example. So, you know, there is an example of where in order to intervene effectively, we really need to start by identifying where is the real locus of causation and what can we do there to change the outcome? So I think it's, This is why genomic medicine has been disappointing so far and why I think for a lot of conditions, it's fundamentally going to be very limited and perhaps often useless for producing cures.
SPEAKER_00Of course, though, I mean, if you're looking elsewhere for the springs of causation, of course, you're also looking at those within the context of the entire organics of the entire system. So you know, it's, it's, you know, we're talking about a long development of fairly sophisticated understanding, not only of the discrete systems, but how they interact with the larger system. And that might be it would be so convenient if you could locate a simple, you know, central console control system where you could go in and do a little bit of rewiring prudently and know that the system as a whole.
SPEAKER_00will respond well um I mean science medicine is still modern medicine is still a very young science and in fact in practice it isn't really a science at all it's it's there's medical science but what most physicians do of course is is something uh is is therapy I I have let me tell you I have a a particular appreciation you mentioned Celia earlier about 10 years ago I I um
SPEAKER_00uh had a very severe illness uh that came about through exposure slow but constant exposure exposure to toxic aspergillus niger and other um mold toxins and i was a sort of a physical wreck for three three or four years um you know the the the damage system wide or the the pathology was was quite severe and the lungs have never entirely required um
SPEAKER_00uh uh recuperated but curious enough i mean i had an interesting experience later about the sort of the the um kind of mechanical approach that the sciences i mean that the medicine does sort of take to the body and understand better why looking for that say that that central controls uh uh seems so plausible um quite often this happened to me the reason you're since getting over the initial illness nonetheless i was in very bad health
SPEAKER_00the strangest things like my metabolism wasn't functioning properly i'd been getting it's getting bigger and bigger but i was eating fairly a very abstemious diet i don't sugars and carbohydrates and things like that just aren't have never been part of my diet and i just thought that there was some sort and i did exactly what i should have known not to do which was to say well there just must be some sort of genetic predisposition But I've been on a stew of medications. I would be given one medication and then that would create effects that were corrected with another.
SPEAKER_00And so just recently, just like half a year ago, my new primary care physician is a nurse practitioner rather than a fully certified person who's done residency. And she uh uh proved to be you know have a much wiser approach than than some of those going she looked at my medication said you know let's just take you off all of these except for one for lung inflammation within a few weeks my metabolism sort of kicked into overdrive again my health returned i've dropped like four and a half stone
SPEAKER_00american listeners 60 pounds in six months without um and and i realized that the the medical regime the regimen which was i think impeccable in terms of the mechanical logic in it that you know here's a problem you fix it discreetly uh was making me sick i didn't realize that was keeping me sick and there no way you know we just don't possess the science that can look at the system as a whole yet and see all the little causes that occur both at the level of just the general uh structure of a human physiology but my own you know my particular how i react to certain things how my how i react at the cellular level even the molecular level but it does think seem to me that that yeah i mean that that that uh
SPEAKER_00Whereas we don't, you know, again, we don't want to doubt those really powerful therapies that have dealt even before the genome project or the few that that have actually come out of the human genome project. We still think about medicine and medical care in terms of interlocking discrete parts. And it is you do wonder and I mean, we're talking about a project of many centuries, whether we can ever uh have a paradigm shift there as well that again not getting rid of the old but but that is better at understanding systems you know as a medical concern not just as systems biology but systems medicine and uh
SPEAKER_00That's sort of what that chapter in your book, it made me, actually just made me think of my own experiences, but it did raise all sorts of interesting, if at the moment, totally unanswerable questions about what medicine could achieve starting from a greater plurality of perspectives.
SPEAKER_02I totally agree. Yeah. And, you know, I think you're absolutely right to say it's still a, you know, a young science. I mean, it's extraordinary how well, you know, I have my own sort of experiences as well. Just recently with this after between. really finishing the book and publishing it, I had prostate cancer and it was of a sufficiently expensive sort that I had to have treatment, that I had to have surgery. And, you know, I had it and it was it's done.
SPEAKER_02It seems to be fine, but it's still very striking to me that, you know, it's really a sort of high tech medieval thing. cure that you just cut it out and stitch, stitch, you know, stitch me back up. And now the stitching is done and the cutting is done by robots. So it's actually, you know, far less traumatic than it would be. But basically, that's the you know, that's the the regimen, either that or you're blasting it with radiation to kill off, you know, as much as you possibly can. And, you know, this is often how medicine is often done.
SPEAKER_02We're still at either that stage or we're at the stage of basically trial and error of screening possible drugs without any particular mechanism in mind and just seeing, what works. And again, we saw this during the pandemic, that drugs that were used for something else were being screened to see if they worked against COVID. And sometimes there was a kind of vague rationale for why they might, but nothing more than that. And we found some useful ones. um way so you know whether we can ever really get to a gen more general sort of rational uh medicine is is really unclear i think it's some you know there's there's certainly suggestions that if we that what we need for that is some systems scale uh understanding of what is going on in us individually which with you know um monitoring of
SPEAKER_02sort of in-situ real-time monitoring of all of our metabolites and so on might become more possible. People talk of each of us having a digital twin, basically a computer model of what's going on that can be used to predict the outcomes from possible drugs.
SPEAKER_00But again, that's still a... I'm not sure virtual life works any better than virtual mind, but who knows?
SPEAKER_02No. Exactly. I'm really not sure because, you know, our understanding of the whole system is at such a rudimentary level. And, you know, it's striking to me, again, that as a result of all of that, often some of the most effective cures are ones that are able to tweak our own uh defenses particularly tweak our immune system to get into action so it's really the immune system that ends up doing the cure of you know whether it's immunotherapy for cancer or for for other treatments that we can intervene perhaps in some way to you know to fine-tune that fine-tune what the different components of the system are doing but in the end we're relying on uh you know that natural system to be able to do the job um
SPEAKER_02And it may be that this will be the way a lot of medicine will go, that rather than finding magic bullets to hit particular targets, I mean, of course, this is what vaccines do as well. It's simply getting our immune system into gear. for dealing with the situation. So it may be that that is in the end what we will be doing, fine tuning the body's own defences and relying on those.
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, you know, there is, again, as we were talking earlier about the paradigms of the sciences trying to integrate the the superior technical knowledge we've acquired with with different perspectives some of them from the past I mean you do know that I don't want to sound new agey too that there are you know these old uh older uh traditions of of of care that it's nothing else uh you get people who complain that that uh the whole body the whole system the whole organism isn't what we think about in the uh in in modern medicine but tend to start again as uh from from the notion that we're working with discrete mechanical processes in alliance with one another that they can be treated separately whereas there is some serious wisdom in the notion that uh certain kinds of you know
SPEAKER_00In those cases, I mean, it was like diets and herbs and teas and things, but that in the long run, a fuller grasp of just the way in which you assist medicine would be better at assisting the whole body, the whole organism, the whole system, however you want to describe it, to do the things that it's intentionally, let's say, directed towards doing to sustain life.
SPEAKER_00you know it's it's um I wouldn't say interesting it's a pleasing thought but again you know there too we're only at the beginning of a long long process we're always only at the beginning of Discovery uh but the Discovery does rely on rethinking you know telling the right stories or telling different stories or telling Fuller stories
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I think it absolutely does. And, you know, that was, as you say, one of the motivations behind the book. And, you know, having said that, I mean, I hope that my book will come across not as a kind of critique of the way, certainly not of a critique of the way biology is being, how we're talking about it, but actually as a celebration of how profoundly, how amazing it is that we have found out these new, you know, narratives, this new understanding of how we work at this level.
SPEAKER_02It constantly amazes me that we know anything about these because they are so complex that, you know, we absolutely need this detailed, very reductive work to be able to understand anything about it. I think what I miss is an integration of that understanding.
SPEAKER_00Well, to end where we began, because I think it's been almost two hours, I've just realized, and so once again, I've gone beyond what I was trying to, I was trying to limit it to no more than 90 minutes, but I never succeed at that, is that the sort of the Kuhnian model of paradigm shift, whether it's overstated or not, it's just that the model produces very fruitful model will produce things that in a sense will ultimately subvert itself to some degree and that's part of its fruitfulness you know that the fruitfulness and the mechanical paradigm has allowed us to discover all these things that call too reductive an account into question and so it is worth celebrating uh without uh prejudice and certainly uh uh without blame um but anyway so let me ask you this uh how are you doing
SPEAKER_00before, how's your recovery been from the
SPEAKER_02Oh, thank you. Yeah, no, well, I mean, yeah, I'm doing very well. I mean, it's, you know, it's fortunately a very standard operation now and, you know, much less invasive even than it was five years ago. It went very well. So I'm feeling, apart from the inevitable effects of a prostatectomy, which are sort of longer term, but in immediate terms, I'm feeling very much back to normal. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Glad to hear that. That's good to see. The modern mechanistic approach is a good thing. Well, look, it was lovely talking to you. It's good to see you face to face than just corresponding by email. I hope you're well. Thanks so much for talking to me.
SPEAKER_02Oh, it's a great pleasure, David. Thank you so much for asking. And it was lovely to meet you, too.
SPEAKER_00We'll take care and I will stop the recording now.
Navet (Tredi), 23 Vendémiaire, CCXXXV This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit davidbentleyhart.substack.com/subscribe
And, at last, the final chapter in the sprawling epic that was this year’s Stanton Lectures. That infernal machine the “Owl” seems to me to have done an especially bad job of separating voices from the ambient sound in...
The penultimate chapter in this year's Stanton Lectures, again recorded - with questionable success - by the diabolical contraption known as the “Owl.” This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other...
This is the third of this year’s Stanton Lectures, once again captured by that unpleasant little automaton the “Owl.” How well that device dealt with the acoustics of the lecture theatre is something of an open...
Here is the second of this year's Stanton Lectures, delivered at the University of Cambridge earlier this month. In this case, the lecture was recorded at the time of its public delivery. The device that captured the...