Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Leaves in the Wind

Leaves in the Wind artwork

The Light of Tabor: Notes Toward a Monistic Christology

May 23, 202447 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is the first of the Stanton Lectures that I delivered at the University of Cambridge at the end of April and through the first week and a half of May this year. It is not, however, a recording of the lecture as delivered on the first night of the series. Due to some errors of planning, which led to technical issues of an irresoluble nature, that recording was never made. The rest of the lectures were properly recorded, however, and will be posted in due time. I apologize for my somewhat torpid performance here. In part, it is the result of having no one to react to whenever I turned my eyes up from the page, but in larger part it is because I am still in a very melancholy frame of mind over losing Roland. His was a long and happy life, I realize, but knowing that does not yet offer much solace. So forgive me, please, for delivering the lecture here without much in the way of brio or enthusiasm. An audio recording was, it turns out, captured on Catherine Pickstock’s phone, which included her introduction to the lecture series. It arrived after I had made the alternative video recording. I attach it here: If the Substack player fails to function properly, the recording is also available here at the YouTube annex: This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit davidbentleyhart.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00i'm ready for my close-up mr demille so this is a recording of the first lecture in the recent stanton lectures that i delivered at the university of cambridge this one i believe was 30th of April and it's the first in the series and so has to be recorded in order for the lectures to be intelligible.

SPEAKER_00Those lectures were captured at the time and will appear in the due order once this recording has been properly posted, but on the day a series of technical issues or issues of planning conspired to thwart the recording that was supposed to be made live. What I can't reproduce here, of course, are the questions I was asked at the end of the lecture,

SPEAKER_00which were fairly extensive, took the better part of an hour, or certainly the answers I provided at the time. But I did try to take account of the more significant questions raised that evening in the lectures that followed. So ideally, nothing has been lost. So all that having been said, I shall begin. The lecture series as a whole is called The Light of Tabor, Notes Toward a Monistic Christology.

SPEAKER_00And the first lecture goes like this. For in him we live and move and are, as indeed some of the poets among you have said, for we too are his race. So being God's race...

SPEAKER_00Acts 17 verse 28-29. In this first lecture I wish to pose a series of questions of a slightly provocative but I hope not wholly irreverent nature. I know, however, that the topics I want to address have as a rule consistently proved to be perhaps the most volatile in Christian theology. In the history of the faith, no debates have been more contentious or more catastrophically consequential than those concerning Christology.

SPEAKER_00Among all the issues that have down the centuries divided believers and afforded them opportunities for despising one another, at least those especially adamant on how we should formulate the unutterable or express the ineffable or define the incomprehensible, none has resulted in greater institutional fragmentation, political disarray, and religious dissension than that of the unity of all things in Christ has proved to do. And the mischief continues down to this very day.

SPEAKER_00I expect to fare no better than anyone else on that score, and I hope actually to fare considerably worse than many. The reason for the issue's perennial volatility is not, it seems to me, difficult to find. Christology is putatively the attempt to say how, in the single person of Jesus of Nazareth, divine nature and human nature have been united to and reconciled with one another. But, and this let me note at the very start as the somewhat scandalous claim I want to

SPEAKER_00defend and all that follows, such a project can never arrive at a satisfactory conclusion, not simply because the mysteries toward which it points exceed our understanding, but also because the very terms in which it has been conceived and phrased are probably inherently deficient. It's rather late in the long Christian day, admittedly, very near evening, perhaps, to advance such a claim as a reproach or a protest. I'm not advocating some great revision of the tradition's established language here.

SPEAKER_00Two natures in one person must remain the basic grammar of Christian confession. And all things being told, no one is likely to propose anything better. What, however, remains open for discussion and inevitably for quarreling over is how both that duality and that unity are to be understood whether, for example, person here corresponds only to the word prosopon or only to hypostasis or to both,

SPEAKER_00understood as synonyms of one another. How hypostasis relates to physis and then physis to ousia, whether physis means an ensemble of properties or instead means a more radical or more concrete kind of identity and so forth. Alas, I suspect that such questions are inherently unanswerable in part. because of a fundamental inadequacy of the various resolutions towards which the Christological controversies of the Hypatristic period increasingly forced all factions,

SPEAKER_00but in part also because it is precisely the indeterminacy in these words that allows them to function as doctrinal rules of usage. Certainly the official formulae of Chalcedonian Christology succeed no better at affirming both the full divinity and the full humanity of Christ than do the rival formulae of Coptic and East Syrian traditions, when, of course, those latter are viewed in the context of Alexandria's or Antioch's native

SPEAKER_00philosophical terminologies. Chalcedon merely established a theological and doctrinal syntax sufficiently vacuous at once to allow, yet also to frustrate, any more ambitiously replete conceptual semantics. And even then the compromise failed. The more vigorously the vying parties strove to assign exact meanings to the words they all variously employed, the more the debates tended to generate verbal distinctions that made no conceptual

SPEAKER_00differences save of the vaguest kinds. the whole process culminating in differences of a far more pernicious variety, real and permanent divisions within the faith. While those controversies were probably inevitable, the doctrinal vocabulary in which they were prosecuted probably was not. It was Christianity's unique destiny, as it turned out, to venture the whole story it had to tell about the entirety of reality, divine no less than created,

SPEAKER_00on a radical refusal to honor what Lessing so famously called between accidental truths of history and necessary truths of reason. In fact, though, far more than mere rational universality was at stake. Christology came to bear an explanatory and imaginative burden that gradually but inexorably accumulated over the course of the first few centuries of the faith and then grew ever more ponderous in following centuries.

SPEAKER_00Jesus of Nazareth became the locus of the entirety of metaphysics, ontology, cosmology, religion, and history. It was in him the tradition would situate the relation of creation and God, the human and the divine, the one and the many, mortal and immortal, passable and impassable, time and eternity, finite and infinite, beings and being, natural and supernatural, nature and grace, even perhaps the symbol and the symbolized, or history and myth.

SPEAKER_00and hence in him also it would discover with ever-repeated astonishment the place where all these distinctions uniquely and mysteriously achieve an ultimate indistinction from one another in a single event and a single identity. From the period of the Nicene Council, moreover, first through the official defeat of Arianism and then through the defeat of its ever-waning echoes in Eunomianism and other conservative theological factions, this total venture became all the more radical in its implications.

SPEAKER_00In the intellectual world of the three centuries before Nicaea, especially in the eastern half of the empire and most especially in the ambit of Alexandria, almost the entire educated class, pagan, Jewish or Christian, had presumed the existence of a derivative or secondary divine principle and had embraced what one might call a subordinationist ontology of the relation between of the sublunary celestial and super-celestial realms. Almost every system attempted,

SPEAKER_00with greater or lesser complexity and with greater or lesser mythical adornments, to connect the world here below to its highest principle by populating the interval between them with various intermediate degrees of spiritual reality. The earliest Christians could not think of God's heaven as some reality utterly discontinuous with the material cosmos. The distance between God and creation was not merely spiritual, but spatial. Or rather, the spiritual and the spatial were not as yet clearly demarcated from one another.

SPEAKER_00Within that continuum, moreover, no absolute distinction was drawn between creaturely and divine natures except in terms of eminence of power. much less was any drawn between nature and supernature, the latter not being a biblical or ancient category in any meaningful sense. The word theos was as yet a predicate, not a proper name. and even the distinction between the divine and the creaturely could be marked only in exactly as a broad and graduated interval comprising several emanated or deputed

SPEAKER_00degrees of divinity, progressively diminishing in scope and capability as they descended the spheres. The celestial distance separating the earth below from the hyper-Uranian realm of the Father or God Most High was thronged with countless powers, principalities and divinities, gods, demons, angels, stars, what have you, who in the thinking of the time occupied a rather equivocal station between the divine and the creaturely, within the one order of nature.

SPEAKER_00The ambiguity was evident even in the special reserve of the Arthrus and uniquely proper title Otheos to designate God Most High as distinct from the Anarthrus secondary and somewhat honorific title, theos, a semantic cordon that was something less clear than, say, an analogia entus, or than the difference of being from beings, but rather more like the rule of primum in aliquo generae, the principle that in every genus there is one supreme instance that possesses per se,

SPEAKER_00the true essence of that genus, and that therefore is the prime source and cause of that essence in all its derivative instances. In the late antique vision of things, God Most High enjoyed a hazily liminal supremacy at once transcendently containing the totality within himself, and yet himself falling within its compass. With the triumph of the Nicene Synthesis, however, an entire exquisitely elaborate but conceptually inchoate picture of reality was destined to dissolve.

SPEAKER_00Arius had clung quite understandably to what he regarded not only as immemorial Christian orthodoxy, but as the sole theological model adequate to preserve a proper sense of the Father's transcendence, which he and many others could imagine only in terms of the ontic supremacy of the unrivaled One who dwells in light inaccessible there above the unreachable beyond. He and they took it to be the testimony of reason, tradition, and scripture alike that the Logos was the highest of heavenly powers. Perhaps the angel of mighty counsel,

SPEAKER_00perhaps Michael the commander of the heavenly hosts, perhaps the heavenly high priest or Korypheus, but not God in the most proper and highest sense. After all, had not the apostle clearly distinguished between the one God, the Father from whom all things come, and the one Lord, the Defteros Theos, through whom all things come? And yet the other side of the dispute had what would prove to be the more compelling, if admittedly also the more compelled,

SPEAKER_00view of the matter. To wit, if it is the case that, to use the familiar formula, God became human, that the human being might become God, how could the sun be a lesser expression of God or even merely a creature? It would seem to be a necessity of logic that only God is capable of joining creatures to God. Any inferior intermediary will always be infinitely remote from God as such. If it is the Son who joins us to the Father, and only God can join us to God,

SPEAKER_00then the Son must be capable of the Father, so to speak, and so must be God not only in an inferior and secondary, but in a wholly consubstantial sense. And of course, in time, the same logic would be extended to debates about the divinity of the Holy Spirit. Here, moreover, the now established doctrinal narrative irresistibly demanded a new speculative grammar. What had been obscurely but irreversibly inaugurated at the Council was a novel and more rigorous metaphysics of transcendence.

SPEAKER_00In affirming the consubstantiality and co-equality of the persons of the Trinity, Christian thought had also affirmed that it is the transcendent God alone— who gives creation being not through a necessary diminishment of the full divine presence, and not by way of an economic reduction of the highest divine power in lesser divine principles, but as the infinite God who is nevertheless present in the finite by an absolute immediacy of act. God Most High is, for all things, at once superior sumo and interior intimo,

SPEAKER_00not merely the supreme being resting atop the summit of the hierarchy of beings requiring lower intermediary beings in order to act within creation, but rather the one who is transcendently and so immediately present in all beings, the ever more inward act within each finite act. And this was or would give rise to an extraordinary intellectual and spiritual achievement. But, of course, we gain by losing. at least here below the moon in the land of unlikeness.

SPEAKER_00Much had been gained, clearly, above all a more radical sense of the intimacy of God's presence to creation, but something of singular imaginative beauty was as a result progressively abandoned. That initially inconspicuous but ultimately vast metaphysical revolution had resulted in from a long and intense contemplation of a specific concrete historical event. And this meant that the theology of this newly grasped divine intimacy in the story of creation and salvation would be articulated primarily in the medium of history,

SPEAKER_00not of nature. And then too, whether accidentally or necessarily, the shape of nature in its fullest analogous sense, the whole cosmic order of life, I mean, would come to be altered in Christian imagination, at first subtly, but in time drastically and irrevocably. With the overthrow of the older subordinationist theology, the late antique cosmic vision, with all its generous imprecisions and its minutely graded tiers of natural divinity and divine naturality,

SPEAKER_00and its radiant participatory hierarchies, increasingly became ever more odious and even something of a distraction. Mind you, it wasn't inevitable that all those luminous and genial presences would have to depart, nor did they do so all at once. For many centuries, angels and saints would continue to man the heavenly battlements and ward the sacred places here below. There's a particularly illuminating article by Peter Brown on this that suggests

SPEAKER_00that it wasn't really until the 11th and 12th centuries that late antiquity's numinous community of mediating powers began their long recessional progress out of the larger cultural imagination. But even then, the angels had by that time already been largely stripped both of their powers of cosmic superintendence and of the somewhat ambiguous autonomy they had enjoyed in the Second Temple Jewish and early Christian periods. I'm not saying,

SPEAKER_00incidentally, that the seeds of a disenchanted world have been planted or nurtured at Nicaea, though neither am I entirely denying it. What I do wish to say is that the post-Nicene synthesis required ever clearer and stricter delineations between the divine and the created. neither the difference between creatio ex nihilo and mere demiurgy, nor the difference between divine begetting and divine making could any longer

SPEAKER_00remain comfortably uncertain. The interval between the there above and the here below, which had for so long been a spacious realm of inexact and relative degrees of the divine and the natural, now had to contract into an inviolable line of demarcation. Even the older, more continuous ontology of the temporal and the eternal began inexorably to change into a bare relation between God's timeless now and the incessant flow of creation's becoming. The two set hard up against one another on either side of an impermeable partition,

SPEAKER_00and that a metaphysical partition, unmediated by the gentle gradations of an intervening Ionian or Ival partition. The fully monotheist reserve of all language of Godhead for the transcendent God alone, which had not been a Jewish or a pagan or a Christian fait accompli in earlier centuries, was now a fixed destiny for Christian thought, one that reached its first full expression in the language adopted by all parties in the controversies that continued to unfold for more than three centuries after

SPEAKER_00the Nicene Council, and that even then reached not so much a resolution as an armistice. As Rowan Williams and others have so astutely observed, the more the full divinity of the Logos was proclaimed, the more also the full humanity of the incarnate Son had to be asserted. Lest the presence of God in Christ be mistaken for a divine substitution in Jesus for some element of his humanity, such as his soul or mind. By the end, everyone had to grant that Jesus of Nazareth possessed not only a human body,

SPEAKER_00but also a human soul in all its natural aspects. And yet his identity as the Eternal Son could not be merely the juxtaposition of two distinct someones with one another, which, despite the traditional caricature, was not the Christology of the great Antiochian theologians of the period any more than it was of any other factions. The notion of a God or angelic being veiled in flesh or of a man animated by some alien divine faculty was no longer able to bear the full weight and splendor of the

SPEAKER_00newly established Christian confession. So the determination was quickly reached, spontaneously rather than deliberately, of course, that the distinction of deity and humanity in Jesus should be described in terms chiefly of two natures, which is to say two naturally immiscible realities miraculously reconciled in one life. And this determination would inevitably militate against any strong sense of a sphere of natural commonality between the divine and the human. and would threaten ever and again to reduce the unity of the two in Christ to an

SPEAKER_00extrinsic relation merely factitiously overcome in a single, inherently paradoxical event. But of course, an inherent paradox is simply a logical nonsense. Moreover, this language condemned theology to an often neuralgic, even neurotic, anxiety to shore up the ramparts dividing the two natures with ever more impregnable devices. One sees this especially acutely in a great many later theological strategies for

SPEAKER_00widening that disjunction to as great a degree as possible. For instance, in the ontological gulf that Baroque Thomism fixes between nature and supernature, which renders the entire Christian story of creation and salvation unintelligible. Or in the barricade of really distinct and eternal energies that Polymism erects within the Godhead between God's action in creation and the Trinitarian taxes, which thoroughly subverts the logic of Nicaea.

SPEAKER_00or in the wanton dialectical hyperboles of Barthianism at its most mystically incoherent, which reduce the gospel to a collection of obstreperous oxymorons. One sees it too, however, in the contrary efforts made down the centuries to preserve some sense of a stabler equilibrium between the two natures so as to avert a precipitation into dualism, such as, for instance, the adoption of Neoplatonic metaphysics or theories of analogical ontology or,

SPEAKER_00for instance, sociological speculation and so forth. Yet from all this welter of divergent theological impulses, no clear consensus has ever emerged. Nor, I think, will one ever emerge. The long struggle over Christological doctrine in those earlier centuries had left any number of troubling questions not only unanswered, but largely unanswerable. Among many others, perhaps the most significant...

SPEAKER_00whether it really made sense to speak of the creature's transformation in Christ both as utterly gratuitous and yet also as the consummation of the creature's inmost nature. Now, none of this was logically inevitable. Setting to one side for a moment the issue of divine inspiration in dogmatic development, easy to invoke but then very difficult to understand or defend, The problem of how to understand the union of two natures in one hypostasis or

SPEAKER_00person was an emergent one in Christian thought. The vocabulary was certainly not ordained by Scripture. Even the language of nature can be extracted from the texts of the New Testament only very laboriously and assimilated to the latter use of the word only by way of a certain exegetical violence. In those very infrequent instances in which the word physis appears in the New Testament, it tends to be used with what was originally its most ordinary meaning. origin, derivation, line of descent, family, pedigree, race.

SPEAKER_00Its appearance in 2 Peter 1.4 may constitute an exception, assuming that the phrase theos kinonif visios does not simply mean something like members of the divine family. But as a rule, the word does not bear the weight of anything so imposing as a large metaphysical category anywhere in the New Testament. When Paul speaks in Romans of what is paraficin, outside nature, He's doing so in much the way in which Aristotle so unfortunately used the phrase in the politics as referring to something outside its proper place in the cosmic or

SPEAKER_00social order. In Paul's case, meaning either outside natural processes of procreation in Romans chapter 1 or outside a natural line of descent or pedigree in chapter 11. In that acceptation, physis differs little in meaning from hienos. And this brings me to those verses from Acts with which I began this lecture, which recount the story of Paul favorably quoting someone, probably either Cleanthes or Eratus, to the effect that we are all, simply insofar as we are human,

SPEAKER_00God's race, or offspring, or family, or genus, or what have you. And then, radicalizing the claim by speaking of us as quite literally congeners of God Most High, jenos un ipachontes tu Theou, nota bene, the definite article in that phrase. For, as Ephesians says, it is from the Father that every kindred within the heavens and upon the earth receives its name, ton patera, ex hupasa patria en uranis,

SPEAKER_00ke epi is onamazete, All spiritual beings, whether below or above the moon, whether on the earth or among the planetary spheres and fixed stars, share in a single divine and natural genealogy, a single genus or kind. This is not to deny that the New Testament distinguishes between the attributes proper to divinity broadly construed and those proper to the realm of generation

SPEAKER_00and decay. The principal difference, however, is, for want of a better word, physiological. The difference between immortal and mortal frames, which is also, in a very real sense, a spatial separation. We have come to think of a thing's nature as something like its intrinsic essence. And that's all for the best, perhaps. For Paul, however, and really for the whole of the New Testament, our essence does not necessarily differ in any significant way from that of astral intelligences, or angels, or heavenly spirits of whatever kind. Rather,

SPEAKER_00our bodies, bodies of flesh and blood, of sin, of death, are what separate us from that which is above. And it is our bodies that must be redeemed, according to Romans 3.23. It may be something of a reigning piety among systematic theologians today to proclaim that there is no such thing as a logos assokos, a fleshless logos, and that nothing of the sort is implied by the prologue of the fourth gospel.

SPEAKER_00Whether one takes that to be a plausible reading of John, and I most definitely do not, at least as regards authorial intention, It is certainly the case that for Paul there is and must be, at least according to the language he uses again and again, a Christos Asarchos, whom we know no longer according to the flesh, as otherwise he could not save us.

SPEAKER_00Paul is quite clear on this matter. Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God, neither does perishability inherit imperishability. He says, And it is precisely by his having set aside the composite, inherently perishable, animated, carnal body, the soma psychikon, and assumed instead a spiritual body, a soma pneumaticon,

SPEAKER_00like that of angels, that Christ has been transformed into life-giving spirit. has conquered the celestial powers and has taken his seat beside the Father above. And thus, too, as spirit, he can also join us to himself, return again to raise us up out of the realm of death and make a way for us through the heavens to the Father. It seems clear that for Paul, Psyche was chiefly the life principle proper to the realm of generation and decay, which can't depart the aerial and terrestrial sphere,

SPEAKER_00while pnevma is a kind of life not bound to death, and so is able to move at liberty among all the cosmic realms below and above. And in Christ, we too shall be set free from our somata epia, earth-bound bodies, and receive somata epirania, heaven-stationing bodies, heaven-traversing bodies. in their stead. For whereas the former are limited by thora, atemia, and asthenia, decay, dishonor, and weakness,

SPEAKER_00the latter enjoy atharsia, doxa, and dynamis, incorruptibility, glory, and power. So, the first man out of the earth, earthly, the second man out of heaven, As the earthly man, so also those who are earthly, and as the heavenly, also those who are heavenly. And just as we have borne the image of the earthly man, we shall also bear the image of the heavenly man. This for Paul...

SPEAKER_00is nothing less than the transformation of the psychical composite into the spiritual simple. The metamorphosis of the mortal fleshly body that belongs to soul into the immortal fleshless body that belongs to spirit. We shall be changed for this perishable thing must clothe itself in imperishability and this mortal thing must clothe itself in immortality. So then, Much of the hope of the earliest Christians appears to fall in line with many of

SPEAKER_00the highest spiritual longings of Greco-Roman late antiquity, Jewish and pagan alike. divinization through the assumption of a glorious and immortal form, ascent through the ethereal heavens, assimilation to the state of angels or demons or gods or stars, entry into the highest sanctuary in or above the heavens. Again, we today may think in terms of differing essences or natures, distinguishing gods, angels and human beings from one another, but in the New Testament the primary distinction is

SPEAKER_00is merely one of corporeal condition. Even in John's Gospel, Jesus differs from other men in part because he descends from above. And thus his flesh, unlike the mortal flesh of those from below, is an eternal heavenly manna. And the logic of creaturely glorification or divinization so understood as a matter not so much of the union of two entirely different natures in a single hypostasis or prosopon, as of the perfection of the nature common to spiritual beings in a spiritual body.

SPEAKER_00The flesh, Paul tells us, is but a terrestrial tent, in which we groan with fervent longing to be clothed instead in our celestial dwelling, so that we should not be found exposed and naked, and so that what is mortal within us might be swallowed up in life. To be raised is to have the body of objection conform to the body of Christ's glory. Philippians 3.21 And as of yet,

SPEAKER_00the language of two natures is at most only a premonitory shadow or a ghostly implication within the deeper logic of the texts taken together as a whole. Well, very well then. That would seem to be the issue, that deeper logic. The New Testament's predominantly somaticentric theology of resurrection and glorification is most certainly in keeping with many of the most broadly shared religious aspirations of the Hellenistic world,

SPEAKER_00perfectly continuous with both pagan cults and Jewish Second Temple mysticisms of heavenly ascent and divine or angelic metamorphosis. But at the same time, the New Testament language of glorification in Christ, which so pervades the New Testament, includes many promises that seem to go much further. Seeing face to face and knowing even as we are known, being filled with the whole pleroma of God the Father, Otheos, it says in Ephesians 3, indwelling and being indwelled by him who is himself in the Father,

SPEAKER_00becoming like him and being enabled to see him as he is, being made one in the oneness of the Father and Son, and receiving the glory they share eternally. We can say this even of Matthew 5.8, saying that the pure-hearted will be enabled to see God. Ton theon absante, again, note the definite article there. Here it seems reasonable to think we are talking about something more than the mere elevation of spiritual beings out of our mortal world into the immortal company of

SPEAKER_00their spiritual kith on high. These promises seem to point toward a real union with the transcendent God, and surely this, one could argue, authorizes language of a union and a miraculous commerce in Christ and so in us between two utterly distinct natures. Perhaps. Even so, such language is still the imposition upon the texts of a category neither native to them nor necessarily compatible with the language they do in fact employ.

SPEAKER_00It's certainly very different from the bold familiarity or more precisely perhaps one would say familiality of the language of single divine and human genos. And so, to determine whether that imposition truly makes sense of the tradition's larger narrative of divine incarnation and creaturely divinization, it would probably be wise to confront a certain hermeneutical tension that subtly but irrevocably entered theological tradition after Nicaea.

SPEAKER_00Between that is what one might broadly and imprecisely call the mythic and the metaphysical dimensions of the tale. Now, As I suggested above, for Christian tradition, the identity of Jesus of Nazareth constitutes a unique point of indistinction between myth and history. This seems obvious, really. In the story of Christ, the most mundane particularities of time, place, culture and material conditions promiscuously consort with many of the most

SPEAKER_00universal human mythic motifs. In him, the invader of the underworld, the deity incognito, the descending god, the hero assumed into the heavens at the end of the quest, the dying and rising god, and so forth, all emerge. from the perpetual twilight of Ilud Tempus into the full noonday clarity of historical particularity, while the man of sorrows, the wandering sage and prophet of Greco-Roman Galilee and Judea, the son of Adam who has nowhere to lay his head,

SPEAKER_00the murdered victim of political and religious institutional power, and so forth, is unveiled as the fullest possible theophany. Now, by myth, I hope it goes without saying I don't mean a fiction or a tall tale, but only a special narrative and imaginative idiom that touches upon that dimension of the truth where reflection and fact cannot be discriminated into two merely complementary poles and that thus discloses truths not available through purely empirical propositional or historiographical methods.

SPEAKER_00Thus the most mythic of the canonical Gospels, John's is also in many respects the most objectively concrete, and in fact contains quite often some of the most precise historical claims. Even so, the sheer singularity, intensity, and indiscerptibility of this coincidence of narrative idioms in Jesus have created, over the course of theological history, a vital but often anxious tension between contending impulses to preserve the narrative's integrity against either its own more fissile or its own more fusile tendencies.

SPEAKER_00The story cannot be allowed to separate into utterly incompatible diegetic genres, but neither can it be allowed to collapse into an utterly fantastic confusion of voices. And this particular tension, especially after Nicaea, came inevitably to express itself in a more general tension between, again, the story's mythical and metaphysical dimensions, or perhaps I should say framings. In the Gospel of John, for instance, there's obviously already a fruitful ambiguity in the description of divine status

SPEAKER_00to Jesus. At times, the language and imagery seem barely distinct from any other late antique picture of a heavenly agent descending into earthly guise and then ascending again out of the earth. At other times, however, the language and imagery point toward a real unity of Jesus with the transcendent God, the Father of all, even to the point of full equality. John 20, 28. Definite article yet again.

SPEAKER_00After Nicaea, though, when the doctrine of the equality and essence of son and father had been established, the balance of authority between these two intonations shifted irreversibly in one direction. The older imagery of the pre-existing great angel or secondary god or Logos Asarchos, who at some juncture in the history of creation had descended from the Ionian heavens into sublunary time, now had to yield over complete hermeneutical primacy to the more paramount imagery of the incarnate Logos, who is at once fully a man upon the earth in time,

SPEAKER_00and also fully the transcendent God in the eternity beyond all eons. Yet this task of demythologization, if you'll pardon the term, I'm not sure I will, but if you will, I'd be grateful, was complicated from the first by the equal or greater authority that scripture seemed to accord the former imagery. And ever since, the effort to shift the hermeneutical balance from myth to metaphysics without losing the narrative balance between myth and history has never ceased to be a

SPEAKER_00process both precarious and inconclusive. Theology has been marked since the first ecumenical council by a restless oscillation between efforts on the one hand to maintain the loftiness of the metaphysics against the degrading gravity of the myth, and on the other to preserve the radiant particularity of the myth against the corrosive universality of the metaphysics. At times, theology has seemed embarrassed more by the extravagance and naive vulgarity of the

SPEAKER_00grand epic of God in Christ, and other times more by the etiolated rigidity of its logical abstractions. Even with the nearly total abandonment of the dominant angelomorphic Christology of the early church, to use what is now the technical term, which I dislike, Theology could not free itself from this anxiety or this indecisiveness. Thus, over the centuries, an impulse toward constant and frequently necessary re-mythologization of the story

SPEAKER_00has been every bit as prominent a part of the tradition as the impulse toward demythologization. Typically, in fact, the two impulses have been combined in a shifting, complex counterpoint. Even as austere a metaphysician as Thomas Aquinas, for example, could assent to the proposition that any one of the divine hypostases might equally well have become incarnate, which in one stroke severs Trinitarian theology from the scriptural and patristic logos metaphysics of the Son as the Hidden Father's one true manifestation,

SPEAKER_00and substitutes tritheism for Trinitarianism. as we'll discuss later or consider those lutheran theologians of the last century in the anglophone world robert jensen most notably who undertook a project curiously simul procesus et recessus in this regard at once affirming a fully historicized and so to speak humanized understanding of the divine identity of christ shorn of all the godly exotic asiatic magian hellenistic

SPEAKER_00apocalyptic appurtenances of the tale of a descending celestial divinity But only so is then radically to mythologize the Father in the theogonic and somewhat German idealist register as some fantastic, omnipotent, deliberating, quasi-psychological subjectivity whose eternal but willful Ur und Scheidung to determine himself as Trinity was accomplished in a real, reciprocally passable relation to the finite historical person of Jesus of Nazareth,

SPEAKER_00sublated, so to speak, in the spirit, which, I have to be honest, for all my affection and reverence for Jensen, strikes me as more incredible than the angelomorphic picture, indeed just ultimately an impossible picture. I'm not suggesting that what became the dominant tendency in post-Nicene dogmatics and theology was haphazard or that it was a violation of Scripture's integrity, inasmuch as the mythic idiom is always already a way of conveying a truth that

SPEAKER_00can't ever be properly captured in propositions, it's also always an invitation to constant interpretations and reinterpretations even some that might appear to alter the narrative valency of the texts profoundly. And so it's perfectly correct for theological reflection to attempt to take the story to another depth or height or to read it at a new angle without feeling bound to what may or may not have been the intentions of its author. I admire, for example, John Bear's recently exceedingly rich and luminous treatment of John's gospel and

SPEAKER_00concur with many of his theological arguments. despite being unable wholly to assent to a number of his purely exegetical moves. For instance, I believe that even if the term Logos Asarchos is of much later theological concoction, still the ad litteram reading of the Johannine narrative, that of the Logos becoming flesh or of the one from above entering the darkness below, really is meant to be understood as involving a divine agent who enjoyed an Ionian

SPEAKER_00pre-existence before coming to sojourn in an earthly body. I absolutely agree, however, with Baer that Jesus of Nazareth is not for John's gospel merely an episode in the course of the existence of the divine subject who ultimately shines out from Christ. But I suspect that in another sense the earthly existence of Jesus is presented in the gospel. Mythologically it's true, but not just symbolically as an episode in the course of the life of the spiritual creature through whom that subject shines.

SPEAKER_00I'll come back to that later. Here I'll say only that even if I'm mistaken here, I think intellectual honesty obliges us to pay attention to the ways in which John's Gospel and other texts of the New Testament the Pauline corpus most especially, work within the conceptual paradigms of the first century, even as they strain against and refashion those paradigms. After all, nowhere in the New Testament is it ever directly asserted that in Jesus, God became a human being,

SPEAKER_00even though the whole of the New Testament irresistibly urges theology toward that belief, or so I would argue. In part, this may simply be because of certain semantic scruples shared by Jews, Christians, and pagans in the first century. There simply were very few ways of piously or intelligibly uttering the phrase, as it would have seemed to suggest in most contexts that the father of all had undergone movement or change.

SPEAKER_00By very definition, religious or metaphysical God, Otheos, was a name belonging to the one who necessarily and uniquely does not become, and who cannot be made into something else, who cannot be in any way associated with any of the meanings that the verb egonin in John 1.3. might be said to bear. In fact, there was as yet no verbal, much less conceptual convention for distinguishing between becoming and being made,

SPEAKER_00and there was definitely nothing like the Nicene-Constantinopolitan vocabulary of the co-equality of the Father, Son, and Spirit. This is certainly not to say that the Fourth Gospel in any way denies that the incarnate Logos was fully human, pilots idoo o anthropos should be taken with absolute literality but but as i noted above in late antique thought the difference between human beings and other kinds

SPEAKER_00of spiritual agents was chiefly physiological What John's Gospel says is that the Logos became, or was made, or came to, or was born as flesh, and even then the text describes his advent in an earthly body as the act of having tented among us, eskinos enimin, which is the imagery par excellence of a nomadic sojourner who comes for a season, only then to depart again. Nor is there any affirmation of flesh in these claims,

SPEAKER_00as the same gospel also insists, What is born of the flesh is flesh, and what is born of the spirit is spirit. For the spirit gives life, but flesh is worthless. He sucks ook opheli uven. Or I suppose one could translate that something along the lines of the flesh ain't worth nothing, honoring the original's double negative. And there I'll stop for now.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Quick Message

    Oct 14, 20262 minAudio

    Navet (Tredi), 23 Vendémiaire, CCXXXV This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit davidbentleyhart.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Light of Tabor: Notes Toward a Monistic Christology

    May 31, 20241 hr 19 minAudio

    And, at last, the final chapter in the sprawling epic that was this year’s Stanton Lectures. That infernal machine the “Owl” seems to me to have done an especially bad job of separating voices from the ambient sound in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Light of Tabor: Notes Toward a Monistic Christology

    May 29, 20241 hr 13 minAudio

    The penultimate chapter in this year's Stanton Lectures, again recorded - with questionable success - by the diabolical contraption known as the “Owl.” This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Light of Tabor: Notes Toward a Monistic Christology

    May 27, 20241 hr 19 minAudio

    This is the third of this year’s Stanton Lectures, once again captured by that unpleasant little automaton the “Owl.” How well that device dealt with the acoustics of the lecture theatre is something of an open...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Light of Tabor: Notes Toward a Monistic Christology

    May 25, 20241 hr 28 minAudio

    Here is the second of this year's Stanton Lectures, delivered at the University of Cambridge earlier this month. In this case, the lecture was recorded at the time of its public delivery. The device that captured the...

    Credit the people on this episode