Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Just Killing Time

Just Killing Time artwork

NINE LIVES ON 1-35 - The Verna & Roger Stafford Murders

Aug 18, 202632 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This episode is dedicated to my best friend who I call sister, Dena Tackett. We have driven up and down I-35 for each other for decades. Right now, while this episode is live, a decision is sitting on Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt's desk that could put a mass murderer back on the street. In August 2026, a divided Oklahoma parole board voted 3-2 to recommend release for Verna Stafford - a woman who, alongside her husband Roger and his brother Harold, was part of one of the most brutal killing sprees in Oklahoma history. In the summer of 1978, the Staffords staged a fake highway breakdown on Interstate 35 near Purcell, Oklahoma, luring an Air Force family - Melvin Lorenz, his wife Linda, and their 12-year-old son Richard - to their deaths for six hundred dollars. Three weeks later, they walked into a Sirloin Stockade restaurant in Oklahoma City, robbed it, and murdered six employees - a pastor filling in for a night shift and four teenagers working summer jobs - inside the restaurant's walk-in cooler. This episode covers all of it: the highway trap, the massacre in the cooler, the drunk phone call Roger himself made from a Chicago payphone that accidentally broke the case wide open, Verna's plea deal and testimony against her husband, Roger's execution in 1995, and the parole hearing that happened just this month - including the raw, emotional testimony from victims' families and Verna's own statement to the board. I'm also sharing exactly where I land on her "controlled wife" defense, and I don't think everyone's going to agree with me. This is a hard one, Time Killers. Nine names, nine families, and a case that is very much not over yet. If this episode moved you, the best way to support the show is by leaving a rating or review wherever you're listening - it genuinely helps other true crime listeners find us. And if you've got your own highway story, a case from your home state, or a piece of hidden history you think belongs on Just Killing Time, email me directly - that's what the Time Killer Files are for. Thank you for Killing Time with me tonight. Sources referenced in this episode include Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals records (Stafford v. State), OSBI investigation reporting, The Daily Oklahoman, the Muskogee Phoenix, The Oklahoman, and reporting on the August 2026 Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board hearing. Just Killing Time with Elizabeth Stanton is a true crime, conspiracy, and hidden history podcast. New episodes drop regularly - subscribe so you don't miss episode 32.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Right now, while you're listening to this, there is a decision sitting on the desk in the Oklahoma State Capitol that could put a mass murderer back on the street. Not might happen someday. It's happening. This week, this month, while this episode is live. Now, five days before I sat down to record this, a divided Oklahoma parole board voted three to two to recommend to police a woman who helped kill nine people.

SPEAKER_00Nine. A family on a highway, six teenagers, and a pastor in a walk-in cooler. She's 73 years old now, and she's been locked up for 46 years. And one board member sitting in that room said something that stopped me cold when I read it. They said, This is one of the most notorious murder cases in Oklahoma history. Right up there with the Oklahoma City bombing, probably.

SPEAKER_00Wow. So when you compare that to this, this is why you need to hear this episode. Now, Governor Kevin Stitt has 30 days from the day he receives the full file to make the call. Grant it or deny it. So somewhere in Oklahoma City right now, the clock is running, and by the time you've hit play on this, it might already be over. So let's go back to where this actually started because trust me, time killers, this one has a highway, a steakhouse, and a drunk phone call that blew the whole case wide open at a plea deal that's still making people furious after 46 years later.

SPEAKER_00This is Just Killing Time. My name is Elizabeth Stanton. This is a podcast about true crime conspiracies and stories that keep us up at night with a little hidden history just kind of sprinkled in as well. If you're new here, welcome. I'm so glad you found us. A buckle up because this episode is 31. So we've got a backlog of good ones waiting for you after this. If you've been riding with me since episode one, you already know how I do this. Facts first, my opinions clearly marked as mine, and nobody's story is treated like a footnote.

SPEAKER_00And I want you to know, time killers, I want you to tell me what you think about all of this because I have strong feelings that I'm going to share tonight, and I don't think everybody's going to agree with me, which is exactly how I like it. You can always email me directly at just killing time podcast at gmail.com. Send me your own time killer files about stories that you know from your hometown, and let's talk about. Now, tonight we're talking about Verna and Roger Stafford. And here's the thing that got me with this case the second I just started digging into it.

SPEAKER_00This happened on Interstate I-35, the same Interstate 35 that runs right past Wichita. And I use this highway all the time. I go from Wichita down to Fort Worth to go see my very best friend in the entire world, Dina. Shout out, Dina. And um, I mean, this highway, I have rode it ragged, right? And we are going down through southern Oklahoma and all the way through the state to get to Texas.

SPEAKER_00And I gotta tell you, some of the stories that I had personally experienced on that highway are harrowing. Usually, though, it has to do with weather. Southern Oklahoma doesn't do well with snow and ice, just FYI. So here's the deal: this is the same highway a lot of you have driven a hundred times without thinking twice about it. And that's the road these killers used as bait.

SPEAKER_00Now, Roger Dale Stafford was born November 4th, 1951, in Sheffield, Alabama. And by the time he hit his 20s, he'd already killed someone. Sounds like a swell guy, doesn't it? Now, January 12, 1974, Roger shot and killed a 20-year-old assistant manager named Jimmy Earl Barry at a McDonald's in Muscle Shoals, Alabama, and walked out with about$1,390. And Barry was shot four times.

SPEAKER_00That murder sat unsolved for four years. And I wish you'd have filed that away because it's the blueprint. It's a fast food wooker who's alone, closing up the night, killed for cash. Four years later, Roger runs that exact same play, and he just brings his family along and raises the body cap. By the summer of 1978, Roger was married to a woman named Verna, and his brother Harold ran with these three people broke, moving from Oklahoma City and Tulsa looking for a quick score.

SPEAKER_00Just another little FYI. I lived in Tulsa after I graduated from high school for a couple of years. I love, love, love Tulsa. That's where my grandmother lived as well. So I'm very familiar with all of these areas. These are my backyards, we shall say, right? So the highway. June 22nd, 1978. Intersect 35, like I said, just north of a little town called Purcell, Oklahoma.

SPEAKER_00Air Force Technical Sergeant Melvin Lawrence, 38. His wife, Staff Sergeant Linda Lorenz. Did I just pronounce it right? Melvin Lawrence. Lawrence. Oh dear. Botching up victims' names. Literally, I could not make a bigger faux pas than that because honestly, those are the people that I want to tell this story for. I screw the killers and their notoriety. Really, it's the victims that deserve to be remembered because they're the ones worth fighting for.

SPEAKER_00So Staff Sergeant Linda Lorenz, 31, and their 12-year-old son, Richard. That gets me real choked up and mad. They were on the road. Melvin's mother had just died of cancer, and the family was driving up to North Dakota for her funeral. They were towing a camper, and the family dog was riding along. On the side as Interstate 35, they saw a car pulled over, and its hood was up, and a woman was waving for help.

SPEAKER_00God, these bastards. You know, the Daily Oklahoma reported this. They said he never stopped for hitchhikers, but a woman was waving for help. And that woman, unfortunately, was Vernus Dafford. She'd staged the whole thing. Court records from the appeals spelling out Berta flagged the family down while Roger and Harold stayed hidden. She told Melvin her car had overheated, got him out of his truck, and that's when Roger and Harold came out of the tree line demanding money.

SPEAKER_00According to the retrospective reporting The Muscogee Phoenix, Roger and Harold came out of the woods demanding money, and when Melvin refused, he was shot. Then Linda offered assistance, Roger shot her too. Young Richard was shot through the camper window. Now Melvin Lawrence was a firearms instructor for the United States Air Force. Both he and Linda were career service members. And none of that training mattered on the side of the highway because the threat wasn't a stranger with a gun drawn.

SPEAKER_00It was a woman asking for help. Tell me, how bad does that just punch you in the gut to know that this despicable woman used that to allure good people to the side of the highway? She deserves to rot. And I think we'll talk more about it. We'll talk more about it. I'm getting digressed and getting mad. So you know, every one of you listening has pulled over for somebody at some time or thought about it.

SPEAKER_00And that's what she used against them. According to the OSBI investigation, the entire robbery and triple murder took about 20 minutes. What they walked away with was about$600. And the reason being she needed money to find a place to live in Tulsa, and Harold needed cash for his girlfriend's abortion. $600, three lives. I just don't have a clean way to make any sense of that.

SPEAKER_00Well, they ducked the bodies, took the family's own pickup truck, and left a camper sitting on the side of the highway. It would be a while before anyone found that scene. And here's the detail buried in the reporting of this case that I've not been able to shake since I ran it. As if the murders were not horrific enough as is. The Lorenz family puppies managed to travel, tear through the screen in the camper to search for food. And then the puppies returned every night to sleep under the camper, waiting for a family that would never return.

SPEAKER_00So there's the first murder. Here comes the second. We are now three weeks later. It's July 16th, 1978, a Surloin Stockade restaurant. Raise your hand if you've ever eaten there. I have. This one was near Southwest 74th in Pennsylvania Avenue in Oklahoma City. Roger, Verna, and Harold drove from Tulsa specifically to rob this restaurant.

SPEAKER_00Court records from Roger's appeal say the three of them sat in the parking lot until every last customer had cleared out. And around 10 o'clock at night, Roger just knocked on the side door of the restaurant, and the manager opened it and found him staring down at two guns, Roger and Harold. According to the Oaklandwood Count uh Court of Criminal Appeals, the manager began taunting, saying that he could not understand why people would rob others instead of working for themselves.

SPEAKER_00Roger Stafford hit the manager and demanded that he call his employees to the cash register. And I gotta tell you guys, I have watched enough true crime and listened to enough cases to know that this was not going to end well just at this point. Like, um, I don't know if I would have called the other employees up. I don't know if I would have screamed for them to run. I don't know what you say in that moment to get them out of the store.

SPEAKER_00But here we are. Um, the manager did what he was told, and he called his six remaining employees up front. Harold and Verna helped them at gunpoint while Roger and the manager cleaned up a safe. And it was about twelve hundred and ninety dollars. Then all six employees were forced into the restaurant's walk-in meet cooler. They were then shot. Every single one of them.

SPEAKER_00He could have locked them up in the cooler, but that's not what they did. I need to say their names, time killers, because like I said at the beginning, it's the victims that matter, it's not these evil, evil killers. So Isaac Freeman, he was fifty-six. He was a pastor filling in for a night shift janitor that evening. Lewis Zakaris, he was forty-three.

SPEAKER_00David Lindsay, 17. David Salzman, 16, Anthony II, 17, and Terry Forst, just 15 years old, the youngest one in that cooler, and the only one still alive would help finally got there. She died at the hospital. According to the Forum News Service retrospective, a father of four teenage girls, a pastor filling in for a night shift janitor, and four young teens just working summer jobs.

SPEAKER_00Oh that's the sirloin stockade massacre, not a true crime headline. It's a summer job. Four kids never should have had to die for. Now, six days after the sirloin stockade mortars, Harold Stafford died in a motorcycle accident in Tulsa, and he was never tried for either crime. Thank you, Jesus, for taking him quickly. The two scenes, the highway and the steakhouse, weren't connected right away.

SPEAKER_00It took months of legwork. OSBI agent Arthur Lindville helped run the task force and decades later he still remembers it like it happened last week. He said this, you don't forget those things. A witness came forward who'd seen the stolen Lorenz putt pickup first at a convenience store and then later at a restaurant in Stillwater, Oklahoma, with two men and a woman inside.

SPEAKER_00He sat down with an OSBI sketch artist and built composite drawings, the two men first, and months later a second composite of the woman. And January 4th, 1979, those sketches ran on front pages across the state. Newspapers ran them, TV stations broadcast them, and this is where the case takes one of the strangest turns I've come across doing this show. Investigators got an anonymous tent. A man claiming to be a trucker, saying he'd driven two of the people in those sketches from Oklahoma City up to Tulsa.

SPEAKER_00He gave the OSBI two names, Verna and Harold Stafford. This anonymous caller who provided investigators with case breaking information was actually a drunk Roger Dale Stafford calling from a payphone in Chicago. That's reporting on the OSBI breaking the case. What? Read that back. Roger Dale Stafford, the man behind nine murders, got drunk, found a payphone in Chicago, and called the police on his own wife and his own dad brother, apparently trying to throw the whole thing off of himself.

SPEAKER_00And in doing it, he handed investigators the exact break they needed. His ego and a bottle of liquor is what cracked this case wide open. By that point, Verna had already left Roger. Investigators tracked her to Chicago and arrested her there in March of 1979. She started cooperating almost immediately, implicating her own husband. And three days later, Chicago police found Roger sitting in the lobby of a YMCA.

SPEAKER_00And according to the Daily Oklahoma, Roger actually waived extradition. He wanted to go back to Oklahoma, said he wanted the chance to clear his knee. Now, Verta Stafford never faced the death penalty. She made a deal. She pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder tied to the deaths of Linda Lorenz and Terry Horst in exchange for testifying against Roger.

SPEAKER_00The deal was written for no less than 10 years, but no more than life. And she ended up with two consecutive life sentences. Now this was said by former Ogloma County District Attorney Andy Coates. Twenty years ago, I believed Stafford would be released after a decade behind bars. Wow. So the prosecutor who cut the deal thought 10 years and now she's at 46.

SPEAKER_00At trial, Verna testified against Roger. The jury in the Sirloin stockade case took 27 minutes to convict him and 48 more to recommend death for each of the six victims. Five months later, a separate jury up in Purcell convicted him for the Lorenz family and added three more death sentences. So nine murders, nine separate death sentences.

SPEAKER_00Roger spent the next 17 years appealing. Of course he did. Good. I double I don't like I don't like the justice system and the way it works. I don't have a good answer as to what it should work like, but I know it shouldn't work like this. And according to newspaper reporting from the time, he actually married twice more while sitting on death row and reportedly settled into a kind of comfort that infuriated people across the state.

SPEAKER_00His incarceration infuriated Oklahomans, who watched him grow fat and married twice in prison. And according to Oklahoma attorney General Drew Edmondson in 1995 said that Stafford was absolutely became a statewide symbol of what has been wrong with our appeals process in death penalty cases. I agree. I agree, Prosecutor Attorney General. Can we also talk about what in the mental illness is going on with A Verna, who helped him with these murders, and then B, two other women who said, you know what would make a great husband a death row inmate?

SPEAKER_00So gross. I don't know. I don't know what draws people to these kind of evil individuals. And like that, that's a story that would keep me up at night, just thinking about that, that alone right there. So July 1st, 1995, Oklahoma State Penitentiary in McCallister, Oklahoma, Rogerdale Stafford was executed by lethal injection just after midnight. Technically, he was put to death for the Lorenz family murders specifically.

SPEAKER_00That case had run out its appeals first, even though he'd been sentenced to die for all nine killings. He never confessed. Not once, not to the Barry Inn. He said, right before his execution, I am innocent. You people are going to participate in my murder because I didn't do anything except be a victim. His third wife, the one he married in prison, spoke to the board on his behalf.

SPEAKER_00Witnesses say he that she said this. You will have to live with your code chases. And witnesses say that he saw for about three minutes before the drug started. Two minutes in, he said his last words. He said, Oh God. And then he was pronounced dead at 12 30 a.m., eight minutes after the injection began.

SPEAKER_00And here's my opinion. And I'm labeling it exactly as that. Roger Dale Stafford had a swastika tattooed on his left forearm. And his literal last breaths, he framed himself as the victim. A man who murdered a family that stopped to help him and murdered six teenagers and a pastor working a summer shift. Spent his final moments insisting he was the one ground. That's not remorse.

SPEAKER_00That's narcissism with a by count. While Roger sat on death row for 17 years, Verna was serving her two life sentences at Mabel Bassett Correctional Center in McLeod, Oklahoma. And she's been there essentially ever since. She's applied for parole multiple times over the decades, denied every time until now. According to her attorney, in all those decades, she's had exactly four documented counts of misconduct.

SPEAKER_00And I'll leave that fact sitting right there by itself for a second because that's whatever you want to make of it depends a lot on what you think prison is supposed to do to a person. June 20 of 26. So it is now August that I am recording this in June. Verna passes stage one of her current parole review. Monday, August 10th, that was just eight days ago. Um, Verna Stafford appeared in front of the Oklahoma Parton and Parole Board over video call from Mabel Basit Correctional Facility.

SPEAKER_00She told the board she'd been controlled and abused by Roger, that she feared for her own life and for their children's if she hadn't stepped, if she had decided to step out of line. This is what she said exactly. I just want you to know that I'm very sorry for what happened. I wish I had been stronger and not have been so controlled that I literally did everything he asked me to do. I'd like you to know that I've overcome being controlled by Roger Dale Stafford.

SPEAKER_00Now the victims' families were in that room too, and by every account it got heated. Kevin Buchanan, vice chair party for role board, said this. Do you believe that we are getting ready to ask that she be asked the governor to let her go on the street? And Aaron Solzman, victim of the family of victim, David Saltzman, said this. While we serve a life sentence of our own, somehow Verna Stafford is being considered for parole.

SPEAKER_00I think that's a very powerful statement in itself. And Elizabeth Payne, family of victim Anthony II, said this. She has been given something, her victims were denied. Time. Oh God bless these families. God bless them all. They don't deserve to have this kind of uh evil that has struck through their lineage.

SPEAKER_00She has been given something. Her victims were denied a tie. Tuesday, august eleventh, twenty twenty six, the board votes. Three to two in favor of parole, but only on her first life sentence. Kevin Buchanan, Vice Chair, says this. We're not talking about releasing Miss Stafford. The state of Oklahoma did not seek the death penalty against Miss Stafford.

SPEAKER_00They made a deal with her to testify against Roger Dale Stafford and ensure that he got the death penalty. This board has to follow the law, and that's what our job is. And here's the part I really want you to understand because it's easy to miss in the headlines. Even if Governor Stid approves this recommendation, Verna Stafford does not walk free. She's got a second life sentence stacked right behind the first one. And under Oklahoma law, that second sentence isn't even eligible for parole review for another 15 years.

SPEAKER_00And if this goes through, her next possible hearing on that sentence lands in 2041. She'll be 88 years old at that point. Kevin Buchanan also went on to say there's no reason to believe she will survive prison. And if the Oclevan governor denies it instead, she'll be back on the docket for this same sentence in the year 2029. Under Oklahoma law, because of how her original second degree murder convictions were written, Governor Stitt has 30 days from receiving the full case file to either grant it or deny it.

SPEAKER_00He can't just let it sit and expire. And his office has kept it pretty neutral when asked. Now, spokesman for Governor Kevin Stitt said this. He uses after every parole recommendation. Opposition, of course, is already really loud. Oklahoma's Senate president probed him for a Lonnie Paxson has come out publicly against her release.

SPEAKER_00And State Representative Rob Robert Minger put out a statement that pulled no punches. This is what he said. She can say that she has changed and she can seek repentance. In fact, I truly hope she did. But what she cannot do is steal nine innocent lives and then escape the full punishment imposed for those crimes. He went on to say, I began my law enforcement career the same year this massacre shocked our state. I remember it like it was yesterday, seeing the suspect being brought into the jail.

SPEAKER_00I remember looking into their eyes and witnessing for myself the danger and recklessness that defined their character. Ah. Oh. And here's what's true on both sides of this, and I think you need both before we can land anywhere, honestly. On one side, Verna Stafford has was never charged with a crime that carried the death penalty. Prosecutors made a deliberate call not to seek it against her and built a deal around her with cooperation instead.

SPEAKER_00That's not a loophole for Bert. That's the system doing exactly what the system chose to do in 1980. On the other side, court records show Verna wasn't locked in a back room somewhere while all of this was happening around her. She's the one describing flagging down the Lorenz family. She's the one who, according to trial testimony, held sirloin stockade employees at gunpoint alongside Harold while Roger and the manager clean out the safe.

SPEAKER_00She was present and she was armed and she was active at both scenes. So, while both of those can be defended, you know, we have he made me do it. I I can't get behind that at all. I cannot get behind that at all. You know, damn good and well, what you're doing is sentencing whoever you flag down on the side of the highway to death because you know the person that you're with.

SPEAKER_00You know dang good well that after that murder, and they went and celebrated with their money, and they decided, guess what? We should go rob the sirloin stockade in Oklahoma City. So they drove from Tulsa to Oklahoma City, all of this being premeditated. And she said, you know, um, I'm gonna participate in this one too, and I see there's children involved, teenagers, and I know what's going to happen to them.

SPEAKER_00I I think she should cook. I wish she had gotten the death penalty, but you know, she was essentially a snitch and she got to cut a deal. And um, so instead she is a problem of the state, she is a ward of the state now. She is our taxpayer burden to keep locked up. And I think that's where she needs to be. That's my personal opinion. So if this one's stuck with you, or if you've got a highway story of your own, a case from your whole home state, or a piece of hidden history that belongs to the show, that's what the time killer files are for.

SPEAKER_00Send them my direction. And I want to know where you land on this one, Time Killers. You already know where I land with Verna. Do you think Verna Stafford was a controlled, terrified woman who did what she had to do to survive? Or does he made me do it not hold up against a gun in her own hand? You know, email me, tell me I'm wrong. I can take it. So, and if this is your first episode with me, hit subscribe because episode 32 drops next.

SPEAKER_00And once you're all caught up on the backlog of episodes, you're gonna understand why this community calls themselves time killers in the first place. So, thank you very much for killing some time with me today.

SPEAKER_01Alexa, what is a chemtrail? Chemtrail. Trails left by aircraft are actually chemical or biological agents deliberately sprayed at high altitudes for a purpose undisclosed to the general public in clandestine programs directed by government officials.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. THE SHKRELI PLAYBOOK - Big Pharma Blocks Generic Manufacturers

    Nov 19, 202629 minAudio

    💊 The Shkreli Playbook: The Wall Around a 62-Year-Old Pill In September 2015, a decades-old medicine for a parasite infection jumped from $13.50 a pill to $750. Everyone remembers the smirk in the hearing room. Almost...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. THE EMPIRE OF PAIN - The Opioid Epidemic

    Nov 17, 202645 minAudio

    💊 A hotel room in Rockville, Maryland. A government doctor. A drug company that needed its painkiller approved. A Justice Department memo says the three days they spent together helped shape the OxyContin label, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. THE WOMAN WHO SAID NO - Thalidomide Samples the FDA Never Tracked

    Nov 5, 202629 minAudio

    💊 On July 15, 1962, The Washington Post called FDA reviewer Dr. Frances Kelsey a hero for keeping thalidomide off the U.S. market. What that front page left out: Richardson-Merrell of Cincinnati had already distributed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. THE SWINE FLU FIASCO - Who Pays When the Vaccine Hurts?

    Nov 3, 202648 minAudio

    💉 Episode 43: The Swine Flu Fiasco (1976), the pandemic that never came. One Army recruit died. The U.S. government vaccinated tens of millions of Americans. The predicted pandemic never arrived. Reports of a rare...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. THE TRUTH ABOUT FLUORIDE - Water, Toothpaste, & the Government

    Oct 27, 202644 minAudio

    🦷 Why is fluoride in America's water and toothpaste? Episode 42 tells the true history of water fluoridation: a Colorado dentist, an Alcoa chemist, Grand Rapids in 1945, Crest toothpaste, and the 2026 court fight. 💧...

    Credit the people on this episode