Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Just Killing Time

Just Killing Time artwork

THE TRUTH ABOUT FLUORIDE - Water, Toothpaste, & the Government

Oct 27, 202644 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

🦷 Why is fluoride in America's water and toothpaste? Episode 42 tells the true history of water fluoridation: a Colorado dentist, an Alcoa chemist, Grand Rapids in 1945, Crest toothpaste, and the 2026 court fight. πŸ’§ At 4:00 p.m. on January 25, 1945, fluoride went into the water of Grand Rapids, Michigan, and a whole city became an experiment. 😳 It was planned to run fifteen years. Five years in, the government endorsed it anyway. From there the story runs through a 30-year dental mystery, an aluminum company's lab, a control city that quit, and the toothpaste on your sink. This episode follows the money, the paperwork and the people who asked questions, and keeps documented fact separate from claims that are still argued. Both sides get heard: the ADA and CDC on one hand, the NTP review and the court fight on the other. πŸ”Ž WHAT YOU'LL HEAR 🦷 Dr. Frederick McKay and "Colorado Brown Stain," 1901 βš—οΈ Alcoa chemist H. V. Churchill finds fluoride in Bauxite, Arkansas, 1931 πŸ“ Dr. H. Trendley Dean, the 1 ppm threshold and the 21 Cities study 🏭 The contested industry thread: Kettering Laboratory, the Manhattan Project and Christopher Bryson's The Fluoride Deception ☒️ Harold Hodge and the plutonium injections (brief) πŸ§ͺ The four fluoridation trials: Grand Rapids, Newburgh, Brantford, Evanston βš–οΈ A 1950 endorsement mid-experiment, and a control city that quit πŸͺ§ Stevens Point, the John Birch Society and Dr. Strangelove πŸͺ₯ Crest, Muhler and Nebergall, and why fluoride is STILL in toothpaste πŸ“œ 2024 to 2026: NTP review, Judge Chen, Ninth Circuit, Utah, Florida, RFK Jr., EPA, FDA πŸ“Œ QUICK FACTS β€’ First fluoridated city: Grand Rapids, January 25, 1945. β€’ Cause of Colorado Brown Stain identified by an Alcoa chemist in 1931. β€’ Public Health Service endorsement: June 1950, five years into a 15-year trial. β€’ Control city Muskegon began fluoridating: July 1951. β€’ First ADA-accepted fluoride toothpaste: Crest, 1960. β€’ Toothpaste poison-control warning required: April 1997. β€’ 2024 Cochrane review (157 studies): water fluoridation's benefit appears smaller since toothpaste became common. β€’ 2024 NTP review: moderate-confidence link between fluoride above 1.5 mg/L and lower IQ in children; insufficient data at 0.7 mg/L. β€’ May 21, 2026: Ninth Circuit vacated the ruling ordering EPA action, without deciding if 0.7 mg/L is safe. ❓ QUESTIONS THIS EPISODE ANSWERS β€’ Why is fluoride still in toothpaste? The ADA's 2010 recommendations say the topical effect is now believed to be the predominant one, and toothpaste is regulated as an over-the-counter drug with a warning label. β€’ Did a court rule fluoridated water unsafe? Judge Edward Chen said so in 2024. The Ninth Circuit vacated the ruling on procedural grounds in May 2026. β€’ Who found the cause of Colorado Brown Stain? Alcoa's chief chemist, H. V. Churchill, after dentist Frederick McKay chased it for thirty years. ⚠️ History and public debate only, not medical advice. Ask your dentist or doctor about fluoride. Documented fact, contested claims and Elizabeth's labeled opinions are kept separate. πŸ“š SOURCES NIDCR, The Story of Fluoridation (nidcr.nih.gov) β€’ CDC, Timeline for Community Water Fluoridation (cdc.gov) β€’ Science History Institute, Pipe Dreams (sciencehistory.org) β€’ ADA, Fluoridation Facts (ebooks.ada.org) β€’ Colorado Dental Association (cdaonline.org) β€’ Democracy Now!, Bryson interview, 2004 (democracynow.org) β€’ Longworth review, The Plutonium Files (journals.sagepub.com) β€’ National Inventors Hall of Fame (invent.org) β€’ Indiana Public Media (indianapublicmedia.org) β€’ PolitiFact (politifact.com) β€’ University of Manchester (manchester.ac.uk) β€’ ADA News (adanews.ada.org) β€’ E&E News (eenews.net) β€’ Beveridge & Diamond (bdlaw.com) β€’ HHS and FDA (hhs.gov) β€’ CareQuest (carequest.org) β€’ WHO Bulletin (scielosp.org) πŸ•―οΈ Just Killing Time with Elizabeth Stanton: truth, crime, conspiracy and a little hidden history sprinkled in. Email us your Time Killer Files at JustKillingTimePodcast@gmail.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Four o'clock in the afternoon, January twenty-fifth, nineteen forty-seven, Grand Rapids, Michigan, at the Monroe Avenue water filtration plant, the city's chief chemist, W. L. Harris, supervises as powdered sodium fluoride goes into the system of basins, hoppers, filters, and tanks, and then flows out to an entire city. The experiment was planned to run for 15 years.

SPEAKER_00Five years in, the government endorsed it anyway. The city had spent nearly a year getting ready. Public health service examiners in White Smokes, well, they checked almost 29,000 children in Grand Rapids. And 40 miles away in Muskegon, they examined another almost 8,000 children. Now, Muskegon's water was going to stay exactly as it was. Those children were the control group. Same exam, no fluoride, so scientists could compare.

SPEAKER_00And nothing like it had ever been tried on purpose in American City. I don't know if I believe that statement, but that's what it says. And I'm not sure that's right. Now, fast forward 81 years, two states have outlawed it in their community water systems. A federal judge ruled that that amount in your tap poses an unreasonable risk to children's IQ. And five months ago, an appeals court vacated that ruling on procedural grounds.

SPEAKER_00Isn't that terrible? Procedural grounds. The man reading the National Health Department stood in Utah and said, quote, fluoride should not be in the water. And right now, though, in a bathroom near you, there is probably a tube of toothpaste with that same ingredient. And yet nobody is complaining or marching about that. So how do we get from one January afternoon in Michigan to a federal courtroom?

SPEAKER_00Well, the trail starts with a dentist in Colorado, and then it takes a hard turn through an aluminum company, and it runs straight through a tube of crest toothpaste. This is Jess Cling Time. I'm Elizabeth Stanton, your nightlight for the stories that keep us up at night. This is a podcast about truth crime conspiracies with a little hidden history sprinkled in.

SPEAKER_00So it's Colorado Springs. It's now 1901, and a young dentist named Frederick McKay, fresh out of dental school, and he had just arrived from the East Coast. He opens a practice and he starts looking in people's mouths, and what he finds stops him cold. Local people, many of them born and raised in town, have brown stains on their teeth. In bad cases, entire teeth look splotched the color of chocolate candy.

SPEAKER_00McKay goes looking for an explanation and there just isn't one. Nothing in the dental liturge. Now locals blamed it on eating too much pork or bad milk or water too rich in calcium. And most of the other dentists around him just shrugged it off. When the Colorado Springs Dental Society finally ran a count, the numbers kind of vary depending upon the source, but somewhere between 80 and literally 90% of locally born children had it.

SPEAKER_00So it was most of.

SPEAKER_00Black had scoffed that a condition of this comic could never have just gone unreported. And he spent days on the streets watching children play and wrote that it was, quote, a deformity for life, having these brown stains on your teeth. And the two worked together until Black's death in 1915, and they pinned down just two things. The staining happened while the child's teeth were still forming, so only kids were at risk. And the second thing, the one that would change everything.

SPEAKER_00The stained teeth were strangely resistant to cavities. Now McKay's hunch was that it was the water, that Black wasn't buying any of it. Then in 1923, McKay traveled to Oakley, Idaho, where patients and parents said the stains began after the town laid a pipeline to a warm spring just five miles away. McKay tested the water and he found nothing. He told the town his advice was let's just go ahead and abandon that pipeline anyways.

SPEAKER_00And within a few years, younger children there were growing in their adult teeth without a mark. He had proven it was the water without being able to say what it was in the water. The answer though arrives in Bauxite, Arkansas, a company town owned by the Aluminum Company of America. So Alcoa, the Aluminum Company of America, McKay and a public health service colleague, Dr. Grover, came to examine the children's teeth.

SPEAKER_00They found the same stains. A town just five miles away, though, had no stains. And McKay, he tests Moxine's water and finds nothing again. And they publish what they have. Their report lands on the desk of Alcoa's chief chemist H. V. Churchill. And Churchill isn't curious, he's worried. He had spent years knocking down claims that aluminum cookware was poisonous.

SPEAKER_00And a report about stained teeth in an Alcoa towel looked like fresh ammunition for the company's critics. So he runs his own test using a newer method, and it was photospectrographic analysis, which can pick up those trace elements that older instruments miss. A few days later, his assistant reports high levels of fluoride in the water. Churchill, he doesn't believe it.

SPEAKER_00According to the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Researchers account, he bellowed at the assistant. Whoever heard of fluorides in water? You have contaminated the sample. Rush another specimen. And the second sample came back to say. In January of 1931, Churchill typed a five-page letter to McKay, and he told him to collect water from other towns where the quote, the peculiar dental trouble had been experienced.

SPEAKER_00And he proposed they cooperate to learn what part of fluorine might play. Within months, McKay had his answer. After 30 years, the brown stain had a comma. It was fluoride, naturally high in certain water supplies. Bauxite's water measured around 13 to 14 parts per million, with the exact figure varying by account. So roughly 26 times the average by one of them. So it's interesting, and I'm I can't get past the irony here.

SPEAKER_00The mystery that stuck the dentist for 30 years was solved by the company with the most to lose from the answer. Churchill, he just wasn't trying to save anyone's teeth. He was protecting a brand. And from that moment, the aluminum industry and fluoride are tied together in a way that never really comes apart. So then Dr. H. Trinley Dean spent his early career on the problem that McKay had left behind. His first name was Henry, though everyone just used the initial H.

SPEAKER_00And in 1931, he's at the National Institute of Health, B N I H, those folks. And his assignment is to figure out how much fluoride in water it takes to stain teeth. By 1935, he's calling fluorosis, the medical name for that staining, an acute and urgent public health problem. Now Dean's team needed to measure fluoride in water precisely. So a chemist at the Institute built a method accurate to a tenth of a part per million.

SPEAKER_00Then Dean crossed the country compared with water supplies to teeth. By the late 1930s, he had a threshold up to one part per million caused no staining in most people and only mild staining in a very small percentage. And now Dean remembers what McKay and Black wrote that stained teeth resist decay. And if there is a level of fluoride just, you know, low enough to avoid staining, might it still protect against cavities?

SPEAKER_00In 1942, his team published the 21 Cities Study and about 7,200 children between the ages of 12 and 14 in 21 cities across Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio. And what they found is the more fluoride in the water, the less decay up to a point. Now, of course, the public got that cheerful version, right? Collier's magazine ran a feel-good story about Hefford, Texas, titled The Town Without a Toothache.

SPEAKER_00And what the story left out was the other half of Hefford. It's brown, mottled teeth. But so did all the newspaper reprints and readers' digest version. They all left that part out of the story. Meanwhile, a different idea was moving through Pittsburgh. In 1939, a scientist named Gerald Cox at the Mellon Institute of the University of Pittsburgh published a paper proposing the controlled addition of fluoride to drinking water to prevent tooth decay.

SPEAKER_00The Mellon family was heavily tied to Alcoa. Now, think about this. It's the Carnegie Mellon Institute, right? So, you know, all of these big names, all of these tycoons of industry, they all are tied together, aren't they? Well, the Mellon family was heavily tied to Alcoa, and some accounts say Cox work was funded by the aluminum company. The CDC's own timeline just lists the melon team and doesn't say who paid.

SPEAKER_00And that's one of the places the sources don't loan it up. Dean, according to the Science History Institute, was horrified. He had spent a decade drawing the line at one part per million to avoid staining, and now somebody wanted to put fluoride into whole cities. He wanted a long-term studies first. He persuaded his colleagues to run a controlled comparison instead. And the test site would be Grand Rapids, Michigan.

SPEAKER_00In my opinion, Dean is the most important person in this whole story and one of the most overlooked. He's the careful one. Watch what happens to his caution becomes that becomes the real plot of this episode. Now, the other thread. It doesn't start in a dentist's office, it starts at a factory. Fluoride compounds were a standard industrial chemical long before anyone thought of toothpaste. They turn up in aluminum production and steelmaking.

SPEAKER_00And during World War II, they became central to the biggest industrial project in American history. Enriching uranium for the atomic bomb at Oak Ridge, Tennessee required a gas called uranium hexafluoride. A British journalist named Christopher Bryson spent 10 years in the archives of that project, and he wrote a 2004 book called The Fluoride Deception. His argument, and I want to be clear, it's his argument, is that fluoride pollution was the greatest legal threat facing the wartime Manhattan Project and a major legal worry for steel and aluminum companies for decades afterwards.

SPEAKER_00Workers breathing that fluoride in, farmers living near the plants, lawsuits piling up. According to the book's publisher, companies including Alcoa, Kazer Aluminum, and Reynolds Metals commissioned research at the Kettering Laboratory at the University of Cincinnati to provide ammunition in those fights. I mean, the same companies, the ones that are doing the poisoning, well, they want to make sure that they have research that backs up their claims that it's no big deal.

SPEAKER_00Now, Bryson says a central figure was Harold Hodge. He was a toxicologist at the University of Rochester, who became the Manhattan Project senior toxologist and later the first president out of the Society of Toxology. Bryson makes the case that Hodge promoted fluoridation and dentistry while knowing the industrial hazards, and that he knowingly misled Congress about its safety. The medical establishment, including the AMA, the American Medical Association, and the National Academy of Sciences, and the WHO, the WHO, the World Health Organization, has long said that the case for fluoridation rests on the trials and decades of studies, not on any one person's word.

SPEAKER_00That's the contested park. And I'm keeping it marked as contested. There's another reason Hodge's name matters, and I'll keep this brief because it's a different story. Between April of 1945 and July of 1947, 18 people were secretly injected with plutonium by Manhattan Project and Atomic Energy Commission doctors. Eleven of them were at Strong Memorial Hospital in Rochester, New York.

SPEAKER_00The first at Oak Ridge in April of 1945 was under Hodges' supervision. The first patient, Ebcade, had fractures. The doctors left untreated for 20 days until after the plutonium injections began. Another patient, Etta Charlton, wasn't terminally ill. She wasn't even chronically ill. Her doctor, recruited by one of the experiment's overseers, cared for her for 29 years without ever telling her she'd been injected with plutonium.

SPEAKER_00She died in 1983. And according to the Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter Eileen Wellsom, even the Rochester scientists called their program a production line. The average dose given to patients who didn't know was five micrograms and was five times over the safe limit the Manhattan Project's own scientists had set. And the government kept it hidden until 1993. Now that's the end of the plutonium thread, but it and it doesn't prove that maybe Hodges' fluoride work was a lie.

SPEAKER_00Nobody should claim that, right? What it shows is that some kinds of secrets were being kept in the same rooms where the safety questions were being answered. And here's the problem. If you're doing this is my opinion, if you're doing something wrong in one hand, how can I trust that you're doing right in the other? If you have no problem injecting people with plutonium, how can I trust you when you say fluoride is C? So here's where their line falls.

SPEAKER_00It's documented. Industry had serious legal exposure to fluoride. It paid for the laboratories, and the government's top toxologists worked on both the bomb and the fluoride question. And this is why fluoridation was promoted to the public. And when someone's resume, come on, includes secretly injecting patients, you don't have to believe every claim they made about them to decide their work shouldn't be just taken on faith.

SPEAKER_00And I think the word conspiracy gets used to shut down exactly this kind of conversation. Asking who paid for the lab and who benefited from the research results, who wrote the safety data, and who stood to profit. Well, that's not a theory. That's homework. Now back to the trials. The public health service planned something unusually rigorous for its day. There was four paired experiments, each fluoridized city matched with a similar city that would stay as it was.

SPEAKER_00So Grand Rapids with Muskegon, Newburgh, New York with Kingston, Evanston with Oak Park in Illinois, and across the border, Brantford with Sarnia, Ontario. Two naturally fluoridized cities, Aurora, Illinois, and Stratford, Ontario, served as a second yardstick to see whether added fluoride behaved like the natural kind. Not everyone was on board even before the first vowed public.

SPEAKER_00In October of 1944, the journal of the American Dental Association ran an editorial warning against rushing fluoridization. Florididation, there's the word. And by December, the journal had softened its tongue, but still called for more research before fluoridation could be considered an acceptable public health measure. Grand Rapids City Commission had already voted yes that summer.

SPEAKER_00Newburgh started in 1945 under Dr. David Ost of the New York State Health Department. And in 1949, the first children who had drunk fluoridated water since infancy were they started school. And examiners in Grand Rapids, Newburgh, and Brantford reported sharply fewer cavities. Newburgh's early numbers showed about 32% fewer decayed missing or filled teeth. Towns across Michigan, Texas, and Wisconsin began fluoridating on their own, and the number of Americans drinking fluoridated water nearly doubled in a single year to just under a million.

SPEAKER_00Then came June of 1950, five years into the trial meant to last 15. The American Dental Association, the state dental directors, and the U.S. Public Health Service all endorsed fluoridating public water. Dean had wanted to wait for the trials to finish. But top administrators at the Public Health Service, well, they overruled him. And a Wisconsin committee had been pressing them to act on that early data.

SPEAKER_00The control group, well, they vanished next. In July of 1951, Muskegon, the unfluoridated city, decided to fluoridate its own water in response to what it was seeing in Grand Rapids. The 15-year comparison lost its control city just six years in. Children in both cities, you know, they kept getting examined, and by 1960, decay rates were roughly equal, which makes sense since both cities were by then drinking fluoridated water.

SPEAKER_00What did the trials show, though? After 10 years in Grand Rapids, cavities and baby teeth were down about 54%, and in permanent teeth, about 60%. And according to the ADA, the American Dental Association. In Newburgh, children had roughly 60% fewer decayed permanent teeth than children in Kingston. Numbers shift slightly by source and by age group, but the direction was kind of consistent across all the trials.

SPEAKER_00So, meanwhile, the push for fluoridation in Wisconsin ran into a Poet. In Stevens Plate, the city council went back and forth in 1949 and 1950. And in May of 1950, well, they ordered Floridation to begin in secret. Assuming the experts would carry the debate. Local poet in Gadfly, Alexander Wallace found out and he went public. God, I love a whistleblower.

SPEAKER_00He printed handbills with a school and crossbows telling people to get the poison out of their drinking water and organized rallies where supporters sang goodbye, Florine, to the tune of Goodnight, Irene. And on September 19th, 1950, voters rejected Floridization 3,705 to 2,166 votes. That vote handed opponents a playbook.

SPEAKER_00Call it an experiment. Voters weren't thrilled about volunteering their families as guinea pigs. And when experts insisted the science was settled while the trials were still running, it helped the doubters. Like, I mean, off script here, I think that we have to doubt anything about this entire podcast, Just Killing Time, is the undercurrent of the entire thing is you cannot trust the government.

SPEAKER_00They are not there to help you, they are there to do thy own will. And um they will experiment on us, the late, you know, the useful, um, sorry, the useless eaters is what they call us. And they have no conscience, there's no like morality in a lot of this. So um, yeah, these voters, they were the guinea pigs, and they should be uncomfortable having their families experimented on.

SPEAKER_00You should be uncomfortable having your family experimented on on the government. And we could think about all kinds of things just today on why some medicine is free and why some medicine costs hundreds of thousands of dollars. So let's think about that for a second. Back to the story, I digress. In 1952, Congressman James Delaney of New York held hearings on chemicals in food and cosmetics.

SPEAKER_00And fluoridation came up. The committee's chief counsel, Vincent Kleinfeld, he pressed Dean on whether modeled teeth were an abnormality. Dean said children wouldn't have objectionable modeling at one part per million. And Kleinfeld, well, he shot back with a question that still hang in the ear. Who decides what is objectionable, Lopter? And then the Cold War got a hold of it. By the late 1950s, the John Birch Society and other right-wing groups were calling fluoridation a communist plot.

SPEAKER_00In 1964, Stanley Kubrick put the idea in the mouth of a deranged Air Force general in Doctor Strangelove, who calls fluoridation the most monstrously conceived and dangerously commute communist plot we have ever had to face. Now the movie was a joke, and the whole country got it. And I think it's funny that Stanley Kubrick, who is part of the programming of our country, um, he made a movie about this.

SPEAKER_00And what else has he made for our country as far as movies and programming? Something interesting to just think about. Now, birchers, that birch society did real damage and not to the government. By tying fluoride to communist mind control, they handed everyone a reason to laugh at anyone who asked about it. Every question, even the sharp ones like Kleinfeld's, got filed in the same drawer as that general.

SPEAKER_00And I think that we can see time and time again, that's the playbook that is used. If you are questioning things or um just not going along with the narrative, you if you have, you know, what to use your brain, you are called a conspiracy theorist. And I don't think that there is a conspiracy. I think you're just theorizing and coming up with logical conclusions.

SPEAKER_00My two cents. Now let's talk about the thing sitting on your seat. The story of fluoride and toothpaste starts at the same moment as the water trials, and it's driven by a very different kind of money. In the early 1940s, a young Indiana University student named Joseph Mueller started studying fluoride and tooth decay at the suggestion of a biochemistry professor, Harry Day. In 1949, Procter and Gammel gave the university a$5,000 grant to research putting stanus fluoride, a compine of fluoride, and tin into toothpaste.

SPEAKER_00So he wanted to study stannus fluoride, a compound of fluoride and tin, into putting it into our toothpaste. A year later, chemist William Nebergal, he joined the team, and over the next 14 years, Proctor and Gamble committed more than three million dollars. This is in the 1950s. Three million dollars. The hard part wasn't showing that fluoride works, it was keeping it working inside of a tube, according to them.

SPEAKER_00Fluoride reacts with many of the ingredients that normally go into toothpaste, and when that happens, it stops doing its job. Mueller's team tested more than 150 fluoride compounds. Then Nevergall baked a sample of toothpaste abrasive with high period purity stanus fluoride in a laboratory oven. And that experiment led to the formula built around an abrasive called calcium phosphorphate, and he started his first clinical trial on school children in Bloomington, Indiana in 1952.

SPEAKER_00Crest with fluorostan reached test markets in 1955 and then went national in January of 1956. Procter and Gam's own figures from the clinical study said children aged 6 to 16 averaged 49% fewer cavities. Americans in PG's telling were developing about 700 million cavities a year, according to them. In 1960, the American Dental Association gave Crest its seal of acceptance, the first therapeutic toothpaste it had ever accepted.

SPEAKER_00Within two years, Crest was the best-selling toothpaste in America. Indiana University held that patent from 1958 to 1975 and collected royalties that helped finance a dental research institute people called the house that Crest built. Well, that's the same pattern we saw with Alcoa. Industry money funds the research and the research gets results and the products sell. Doesn't mean the results might be wrong.

SPEAKER_00But Crest's ADA acceptance rested on clinical trials. But if you were taught to follow the money when you read about a drug company, then you should follow it here too. Always just follow the money. So why is it still in toothpaste even as people fight to pull it from water? Well, there's several reasons and a few might surprise you. First, where fluoride seems to work. The early water trials couldn't separate two effects, fluoride that touches your teeth, and fluoride you swallow that gets built into the developing teeth.

SPEAKER_00The scientists, sorry, the science had shifted since the ADA's own 2010 clinical recommendations say the topical effect is now believed to be the predominant one. In plain terms, fluoride appears to help most when it sits on the surface of your teeth during the acid attacks that cause cavities. Toothpaste puts it right there at a very much higher concentration than water, and then you spent most of it out. The CDC and the ADA still say water and toothpaste work together and protect better than either one alone.

SPEAKER_00Second, it's now regulated like a drug, right? And the FDA treats anti-cavity toothpaste as an over-the-counter drug. Did you hear that? The FDA treats anti-cavity toothpaste as an over-the-counter drug. Since April of 1997, every tube has to carry a warning. If you swallow more than you were using for brushing, you need to get medical help or contact a poison control center right away.

SPEAKER_00The ADA has required a P-size amount label since 1991 for products seeking its seal. Then the FDA made the 1997 label mandatory, and the New York Times reported that poison control centers had logged 4,453 cases of unintended fluoride exposure the year before. 99% minor and non-life threatening.

SPEAKER_00Third, the kids. Small children, well, they swallow toothpaste. And that's why the American Academy of Pediatrics, they advise just a tiny smear, about the size of a grain of rice for children number three in a P-sized dab from three to six. Too much fluoride in childhood causes dental fluorosis. The same condition McKay spent his career studying in Colorado Springs. Fourth, nobody is going after it.

SPEAKER_00When the FDA moved in October of 2025 against unapproved prescription fluoride drops, tablets, and lozenges for children, the action just, well, it didn't apply to toothpaste, mouth rinses, or dental office varnishes. And it did not affect water fluoridation. And fifth, maybe the most interesting, the argument that toothpaste changed the math for water. A Cochrane review published in October of 2024 looked at 157 studies and concluded that the benefit of water fluoridation appears smaller now than before fluoride toothpaste became widely available.

SPEAKER_00Professor Tanya Walsh of the University of Manchester, a co-author, said the benefits of fluoridating water have declined in recent decades. The ADA pushed back though, pointing at studies the review excluded, including communities like Juneau, Alaska and Calgary, Canada, that saw more decay after removing fluoride from their water. And the HHS itself notes that fluoride is not added to drinking water in most of Europe.

SPEAKER_00I hope you hear my pause. Interesting because Europe doesn't allow a bunch of ingredients that is allowed in our food. So, for example, if you're going to buy a box of cereal for your children, what is allowed in the United States and the chemical, I'm going to call it shit store that's in it, Europe bans that. They will not allow those same ingredients in Europe. So I think it's interesting that they protect their citizens a little bit better than maybe our government does here in America.

SPEAKER_00So here's the thing. If we're going to be honest about the toothpaste, it's where the fluoride debate gets questionable, right? Because you get to pick your tube of toothpaste, right? You read the label and you decide how much your child gets and you know whether you spit your toothpaste or not. Nobody votes on it, nobody mixes it into your tap. If the real fight is about consent and about who gets to decide what actually goes into your body, then toothpaste is part of this story where you're actually the wine deciding.

SPEAKER_00There's fluoride-free toothpaste, it exists. Though you will not find an ADA, the American Dental Association, seal on it, because the ADA seal requires fluoride. So I'm gonna say I'm not a doctor or dentist, and you can make your own choices. In my family, we do not uh use toothpaste with fluoride in it. That is something we marketably steer away from.

SPEAKER_00So we do not do any sort of toothpaste that has that in it. We also um use a Berkey water filter to filter our city's water, um, even though, according to the officials out of Derby, Kansas, at the at the water treatment plant, they say they do not add fluoride to the water. I still filter the water and I use special filters that filter out fluoride because I feel so passionately about it for my own family.

SPEAKER_00I think that heavy metals, so think of like the tin and the toothpaste, and I don't want any part of that. And I understand you can't control everything, right? But what you can do is what you can do, and so we try to limit the amount of metals that we consume in our food and our water and all the things. So you have to do what's right for you and what's right for your family, but the thing is you have to think.

SPEAKER_00You've got to do your own research and not just blindly follow the programming on television with the cool ad from the toothpaste company, right? Back to the story. In 2024, the National Toxology Program, part of the Federal Department of Health and Human Services, published a review of the research on fluoride and children's brains. It reached, quote, moderate confidence that higher fluoride exposure, particularly drinking water above 1.5 milligrams per liter, more than twice the U.S.

SPEAKER_00recommended level, is associated with lower IQ in children. The report's own authors acknowledge that their findings don't speak to the 0.7 level used in the United States, where there wasn't enough data to just say.7 pose an unreasonable risk of reducing IQ in children under the Toxic Substances Control Act.

SPEAKER_00He was careful to say his ruling does not conclude with certainty that fluoridated water harms public health. He ordered the EPA to respond and left the method to the agency. He did not ban anything. Dental and public health groups said the ruling reflected a fundamental misunderstanding of the science, and the ADA urged the EPA to appeal. In March of 2025, Utah became the first state to ban fluoride in public water.

SPEAKER_00Florida's ban took that effect on July. And on April 7, 2025, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. appeared in Utah to praise the ban and said he hopes many more states would follow. ADA President Rhett Kessler said officials who back misinformation are doing something injurious to public health. EPA administrator Lee Zeldon announced the agency would review the science. Oh, that word misinformation.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a dangerous term. Woof. In October of 2025, the FDA took action against unapproved ingestible fluoride for children drops and tablets, saying most kids shouldn't get them unless they're at high risk for cavities. Kennedy called it driving the steak through the heart and outdated science. And ADA spokesperson, Dr. Scott Tomar, told the Washington Post the FDA's final report was far more measured and thoughtful than its first press release.

SPEAKER_00Then, on May 21, 2026, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, well, they vacated Judge Chin's ruling, it did not decide FOIC 7 is safe. It said the trial court had made quote unquote procedural errors and it sent the case back. As of this month, the EPA's own review is underway with no end date in sight. And the CDC's page still lists 0.7 milligrams per liter as recommended.

SPEAKER_00And according to the Fluoride Action Network, and come on. An antifluoridiation group, so that's their count, more than 80 communities have stopped fluoridating since the 2024 ruling. The Delta Policy Group, CareQuest, says no additional states enacted bans in 2026. So here we go. The dentists show that the trials showed fewer cavities in kids.

SPEAKER_00The skeptics were right, though, that Federal Toxology Agency found an association with lower IQ at higher exposures, and that for decades the public was told the question was closed. Now, at the level in your tap, the scientists still don't agree. And the court case that was supposed to settle it got thrown out on how the trial was run. So I I gotta tell you, I don't want to expose myself multiple times a day to something that could cause, you know, a lower IQ.

SPEAKER_00Um and I think that all of this has been designed, and I don't like it. I don't like it. Now look back at the whole chain. The dentist, he spent 30 years chasing brown teeth. The answer came out of an aluminum company's lab, and the most careful scientist on the project, well, they wanted proof first, and was overruled halfway through the experiment. And let's not forget it was a stinking experiment on people.

SPEAKER_00Then the control city, well, they quit the experiment and just started fluoridating the water. And a poet with a handmade handbill beat the experts in Stevenshoite and General in a movie made by Stanley Kubrick. He made the whole debate into a punchline. In a lab in Indiana, the different company found a way to put the same chemical into a tube of toothpaste. Grand Rapids City Commission voted yes in the summer of 1944, and the whole city drank at the result at 4 o'clock in a January afternoon, while the experiment meant to prove it was still running.

SPEAKER_00The question a congressional lawyer put to Dean in 1952 is still sitting there, unanswered, 81 years after the four o'clock on a January afternoon. So think about all of this. The next time you squeeze toothpaste onto your toothbrush, you'll know how it got there. Now what you do about it, that is yours to decide. And I think that's the entire point.

SPEAKER_00So thank you again for killing some time with me today. I'll leave the light on.

SPEAKER_01Alexa, what is a chemtrail? Chemtrails, trails left by aircraft, are actually chemical or biological agents deliberately sprayed at high altitudes for a purpose undisclosed to the general public in clandestine programs directed by government officials.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. THE SHKRELI PLAYBOOK - Big Pharma Blocks Generic Manufacturers

    Nov 19, 202629 minAudio

    πŸ’Š The Shkreli Playbook: The Wall Around a 62-Year-Old Pill In September 2015, a decades-old medicine for a parasite infection jumped from $13.50 a pill to $750. Everyone remembers the smirk in the hearing room. Almost...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. THE EMPIRE OF PAIN - The Opioid Epidemic

    Nov 17, 202645 minAudio

    πŸ’Š A hotel room in Rockville, Maryland. A government doctor. A drug company that needed its painkiller approved. A Justice Department memo says the three days they spent together helped shape the OxyContin label, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. THE WOMAN WHO SAID NO - Thalidomide Samples the FDA Never Tracked

    Nov 5, 202629 minAudio

    πŸ’Š On July 15, 1962, The Washington Post called FDA reviewer Dr. Frances Kelsey a hero for keeping thalidomide off the U.S. market. What that front page left out: Richardson-Merrell of Cincinnati had already distributed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. THE SWINE FLU FIASCO - Who Pays When the Vaccine Hurts?

    Nov 3, 202648 minAudio

    πŸ’‰ Episode 43: The Swine Flu Fiasco (1976), the pandemic that never came. One Army recruit died. The U.S. government vaccinated tens of millions of Americans. The predicted pandemic never arrived. Reports of a rare...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. SEMMELWEIS REFLEX - The Doctor Who Said Wash Your Hands

    Oct 22, 202652 minAudio

    πŸ§ΌπŸ•―οΈ Episode 41: In 1847, Dr. Ignaz Semmelweis cut deaths in a Vienna maternity ward from 18.3% to 2.2% with a basin of chlorinated lime. The medical establishment ruined him anyway. This is the true story behind the...

    Credit the people on this episode