Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Just Killing Time

Just Killing Time artwork

THE POET OF WICHITA - The Woman Who Haunted Herself

Jun 26, 202640 minAudio

🕰️ For four years, a stalker who called himself The Poet terrorized Wichita, Kansas - rhyming threats, a stabbing in a mall parking lot, a wreath set on fire on the front door - all during the height of the BTK murders. The city spent $370,000 and ran down more than 300 suspects. Then one weekend, the Chief of Police read the whole file and saw what no one else could. This is the story of Ruth Finley 💛 - a soft-spoken phone-company secretary, a devoted husband, and a secret buried so deep that even Ruth didn't know she was keeping it. It's one of the strangest, saddest, and most human true-crime cases ever to come out of Kansas - and it happened just up the road from my front door in Derby. 🔎 What you'll hear: The 1946 Fort Scott attack at the root of it all How BTK-era fear made an entire city believe The Poet's siege - the red bandana, the threats, the cruelty and the patience Chief Richard LaMunyon and the clue that cracked it The confession - and the doubt that never fully went away The buried childhood trauma that explains everything 📍 A personal Derby aside: the "Glen Hills" case I still remember 📍 A Wichita / Sedgwick County true crime story, told Kansas-honest: documented facts and personal opinion kept clearly separate, no padding, no guessing. ✉️ The Time Killer Files: Send me the false-stalker case from your own town - the phantom attacker everyone feared who turned out never to exist. You might hear it on a future episode. ⚠️ Content note: This episode discusses childhood sexual abuse and suicidal thoughts. U.S. support: call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline); RAINN 1-800-656-4673. 📚 Sources: Corey Mead, The Pursued (2025); Gene Stone, Little Girl Fly Away (1991); Wichita Eagle archives; Wichita PD case history. 🎧 New here? Follow the show and join the Time Killers - new episodes every week. #TrueCrime #PoetOfWichita #RuthFinley #WichitaKansas #BTK #KansasTrueCrime #DerbyKansas #justkillingtimepodcast #elizabethstanton #derbykansas

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00It is June of 1977, and it is late. The kind of late where the only light in the house is the one you forgot to turn on. Ruth Finley is 50 miles past tired. That afternoon, her husband Ed collapsed in the backyard, and the doctors think it's his heart. So tonight Ruth is doing something she has almost never done in her entire married life. She is alone in her own house in the dark with the radio on for company.

SPEAKER_00And the radio is no comfort. Because in Wichita, in the summer of 1977, every newscast circles back to the same three letters. BTK. For three years, a man who signs his crimes bind, torture, kill, has been walking into ordinary homes on ordinary streets and leaving bodies behind. He has not been caught. So worries she turns the dial to something softer.

SPEAKER_00And then the phone rings. A phone ringing that late only can be the hospital, so she picks it up already braced for a nurse's voice. Instead, a man she has never heard before says, Is this Ruth Smock from Fort Scott, Kansas? And the floor goes out from under her. Because Smock is her maiden name. She has not been Ruth Smock and she has not lived in Fort Scott for 31 years.

SPEAKER_00Whoever this is has reached three decades back into a part of her life she has spent her whole adult life burying. He says, I know all about that night. And Ruth does not have to ask which night he means. I am Elizabeth Stanton, and this is Just Killing Time, a true crime conspiracy, and stories that keep us up at night.

SPEAKER_00And tonight is the story of a woman who was hunted across my own backyard for four years by the most dangerous man Wichita couldn't catch. A stalker who wrote in rhyme, who stabbed her at a mall parking lot, who set a burning wreath on her door while a city, already terrified of one monster, started to wonder if it had now two. They called him the poet.

SPEAKER_00It would take four years, 300 suspects, and$370,000 before anyone understood the truth. The poet was real. He just wasn't anyone anybody thought. This is the story of Ruth Finley. Stay with me. So welcome back, Time Killers. Pull up a chair. Now that I've told you before that this show was born out of Wichita, out of a city I've driven my whole life, just 10 minutes up the road from my own front door in Derby, close enough that Wichita is basically my hometown.

SPEAKER_00And most weeks when I bring you a Wichita case, I'm bringing you a killer. Tonight I'm bringing you something stranger and honestly sadder than that. Tonight nobody dies, and by the end, you may not sh be sure who the victim is or whether the word victim even covers it. I want to be straight with you, this one kind of got under my skin in a way most don't. It would be the easiest thing in the world to make Ruth Finley a punchline. The woman who made it all up.

SPEAKER_00But I'm not going to do that. And I don't think you'll want me to once you've heard the thing. Because what happened to Ruth started long before any letter in a farmhouse to a little girl who had no word for what was being done to her. So hold that thought. We're going to get there. To understand the poet, you have to understand Ruth first. And Ruth is about as Kansas as a person gets. She was born Ruth Caroline Smock on the 1st of February 1930 in Richards, Missouri, a speck of a farm town just over the line from Kansas, the kind of place where everybody's people knew everybody's people.

SPEAKER_00She came up in the teeth of the Great Depression. A daughter of farm folks who had nothing, and they made do. And she was raised on a code I suspect a lot of you grew up with too. You do not complain, you do not cry, and God forbid you ever made the scene. Tears were a waste. Asking for help was weakness, and calling attention to yourself, that was about the worst thing a person could do. Remember that code because it's loadeberry.

SPEAKER_00She married Ed Finley, a quiet, decent, bold-headed accountant, and the two of them built exactly the life they wanted. It was small, steady, and invisible, a modest one-story frame house on East Indianapolis Street in Wichita. They had two sons, and Ruth worked as a secretary at Southwestern Bell, the phone company. She liked ceramics and liked to paint. They were by every single account kind and ordinary people who wanted nothing more than to be left in peace.

SPEAKER_00But there was a night Riss never talked about, and in 1977 a stranger on the telephone dragged it right back into the light. It was October 1946. Riss was 16 years old, a high school girl in a rooming house in Fort Scott, Kansas. She'd just come back from buying groceries when she heard the screen door open behind her. A man, tall, dirty, wearing overalls, maybe about fifty, grabbed her from behind and started tearing at her clothes.

SPEAKER_00Ruth fought. She jammed her thumbs into his eyes and he said something to girl she would carry the rest of her life. He said, I'll fix you so no one will look at you again. And then he pressed a rag soaked in chloroform over her face. When she came to, she had first degree burns on both thighs. The man had heated a plat iron on the stove and he branded her with it. The local paper, the Fort Scott Tribune, put it in the page the way papers did back then, and this is what they said.

SPEAKER_00Sex Maniac uses flat irons in branding local high school girl. She was 16 and she survived it, and then she did what her whole upbringing had trained her to do. She folded up small, put it somewhere deep inside, and never spoke of it again. For 31 years that worked. And I think about that headline. Not even her name in the big type, just the thing that happened to her, and that was 1946.

SPEAKER_00There were no counselors waiting at the hospital, no advocate, no word like trauma in common use. You went home and you got on with it. And nobody said it out loud again. And that silence is gonna matter more than anything else in this story. So now it's 1977, Ed is in the hospital, and a man on the phone is reading Ruth's own nightmare back to her out of a 31-year-old newspaper. He says he found the clipping tearing down old houses in Fort Scott.

SPEAKER_00He wants money, and if she doesn't pay, he'll tell everyone what happened to her. He says, I know where you were. And she slams the phone down and falls into a dead ten-hour sleep. Now, Ed comes home. Turns out it wasn't as hard at all, thankfully. Just an old injury flaring up. And meanwhile, Ruth, she tries to put it out of her mind, but it doesn't stop. You know that dark cloud that just gnaws at you.

SPEAKER_00Oh God, I feel sick over it. It comes to her office next. She got an envelope on her desk at the phone company, her name scrawled across it, and inside that same 1946 headline, and then the calls started coming to the house. Then downtown, and you have to picture late 70s downtown Wichita, the stores already bleeding out into the malls on the edge of town. A man falls into step beside her on the sidewalk. He's late 40s, skinny, kind of graying at the temples.

SPEAKER_00He knows where she works. He says strange needling things. And as he peels off, he leaves her with this. Some people's fantasies are other people's nightmares. That's so gross. Oh gosh. And then comes the letters. And the letters are like nothing the Wichita police have ever read. They write. They're riddled with misspellings, and then dropped right into the middle are these enormous tongue-twisting words.

SPEAKER_00Such as like constantatious, uh, proglycomus, rhodomontad. I don't think I'm pronouncing any of those right. That's how big they are. They're words most college graduates couldn't define. They're sitting next to words like you're spelled Y U R, or dumb bitch, spelled D-U-M. The letters obsess over Ruth Spurns, her brand, you will, and the writer wants to see it.

SPEAKER_00It was Ed who gave him his name. Reading those rhyming, ranting pages, Ed called the writer the poet. It stuck first in the house, then the cops, and finally in the newspapers, the poet of Wichita. By November of 1978, the letters were piling up fast enough that the Finleys took them to the police. And here's where I need you to understand why this case became what it became. Why a stack of mismatched, uh, like misspelled poems landed on the desk of a senior homicide detective, it was because of BTK.

SPEAKER_00In 1978, Wichita is years into living with a serial killer who's never been caught. The killer who, like the poet, taunts the city with letters. So when Ruth Finley walks into the criminal investigation division with a fistful of threatening rhymes, the police cannot afford to assume it's nothing. The man who catches the case is Lieutenant Bernie Drotsky, a 30 years plus on-the-job detective.

SPEAKER_00And privately he thinks it's small potatoes next to the bodies on his desk, but nobody in Wichitog 1978 is willing to bet that a stalker who writes letters is harmless. The fear that this could be tied to the worst thing happening in your city is the reason everyone believed Ruth. So keep that little nugget in your back pocket. It's going to do a lot of work. And look, why wouldn't you believe her?

SPEAKER_00A soft, spoken church mouse of a woman with a steady job at the phone company, a devoted husband, not an enemy in the world, walks in with letters in her hand, terrified during the single most frightening stretch in which taught history. There's no version of 1978 where the police look at Ruth Finley and think, oh, she's doing it to herself. I wouldn't have thought it either, and neither would you.

SPEAKER_00And then it escalated. Hard. November 21st, 1978. By the way, I I think that's an interesting date that I just want to share with you because my birthday is November 22nd, 1977. So I would have been almost a year old when this happened. So Ruth is running errands downtown on her lunch hour, and she says a blue-grain Chevy screeches to the curb, and a man from the sidewalk shoves her into the back.

SPEAKER_00There's a driver he calls Buddy, and they take her purse and find uh Dropsky's business card. So the detective's business card it, and one of them cracks her in the head with a chunk of concrete. Whoay cow. They drive her around for four hours, and finally, Ruth talks her way out of the car at a little park, palms a can of maize, and sprays the man when he isn't looking and runs barefoot into the dark. She makes it to a liquor store and the owner calls the police.

SPEAKER_00Nine months later, it gets worse. August 13th, 1979, Town East. And if you're from here, you know exactly where I meet. This was the mall to go to. Town East. So the mall is still standing. I still do shop there. Um, this happened in the parking lot. Ruth had just bought a pair of jeans that she was planning for a trip to Colorado. It's dusk. The lot is nearly empty, and the same man is waiting by her car.

SPEAKER_00There's a struggle. He stabs her, and then she gets into her car and drives away with the blade still in her. His glove is caught in her window. Um, so I am not really sure what kind of blade it was. When I did research on this, um, there were two different accounts. They said it was an eight-inch boning knife, and then some say it was an ice pick. I don't think it really matters, but there was a blade stuck in her. She drives towards home with the wound, and it's two inches deep.

SPEAKER_00That's a lot. And the doctors will say later that one more inch it would have killed her. A guard is posted at her hospital room, and the Wichita Eagle beacon, which is used to be on the local newspaper, runs it on the front page. The woman stabbed, resisting an abduction, a police sketch, a warning that the man is extremely dangerous. And now the whole city is searching and watching. Because now there are two letter writing predators loose in Witch Tot, and nobody can rule out that they're the same man or they don't know.

SPEAKER_00They just nobody knew. So what followed was almost two years of a siege, and I'm gonna give you the shape of it because the sheer volume is the point. The poet left these. A 12-inch butcher knife wrapped in a red bandana. It was tucked in the phone booth in a lobby where Ruth worked, a bottle of urine on the porch, a bag of feces, broken glass, Mulotob cocktails on the front steps.

SPEAKER_00On Christmas Eve, the phone lines to the house were cut. One Christmas, the wreath on the front window was set on fire, and the heat cracked the glass with a boom while Ruth and Ed sat down in the basement. The red bandana became his signature and it turned up again and again. So I guess, like, you know, when I was researching this, I guess like the Molotop cocktail was just set on the porch. I don't know if it was lit.

SPEAKER_00I don't there's lots of things I don't really understand about this case, but um just interesting details. A bottle of urine on the front porch, a bag of feces. It's it's just a lot. So enjoy everyone. And then the poet didn't only torment Ruth, he wrote to the whole city on her behalf. He wrote to a mortuary telling them to contact Ruth because she'd be needing their services soon.

SPEAKER_00He wrote the gas and electric company to shut the Finley's utilities off. He told the health department Ruth was spreading diseases, and he asked a florist to send her a single black flower. 50-some letters to Wichita businesses in six months. The experts, they weighed in, and the experts were certain a Wichita psychologist named Dr. Donald Schrogg, who'd consulted on the BTK case, profiled that the pro the poet was deeply dangerously disturbed.

SPEAKER_00And the police sent the letters to Dr. Murray Myron, a psycholinguist that was in Syracuse, who made his name on the Son of Sam letters. And Murian's uh verdict, the poet was, in his words, clearly and severely psychotic. And on the question of whether the post whether the poet could be Ruth or whether it could be BTK, both men said the same thing. No, different hand, different mind.

SPEAKER_00And the poet fed the BTK fear on purpose. In his letters, he bragged about a fox he had killed. Now, BTK's most recent victim, murdered in December of 1977, was a young woman named Nancy Jo Fox. The poet called Ruth the seventh and hardest to find, and BTK's known victims at that point numbered seven. He was daring the city to confuse him with the monster in those houses.

SPEAKER_00And by the spring of 1981, the police had investigated more than 300 people. They had zipped Ruth into a bulletproof vest, walked her through downtown as bait. They'd hidden a camera in a birdhouse in her backyard. The case had cost the city of Wichita$370,000, and they were no closer to a name than the day they started. I want you to sit with that for just a second because I keep coming back to it.

SPEAKER_00The bandana and the phone booths, the black flower, the letter to the funeral home. Somebody planned every one of those. Somebody bought the stamps, found the addresses, wrote it all in this strange rhyming hand. The cruelty of it was staggering, and so is the patience. Whoever the poet was, the poet was never in a hurry, so remember that too. Here's the thing about the poet's downfall, it didn't come from the lab or a tip or a lucky break.

SPEAKER_00It came from one mistake, and that one man who never let himself get close. The mistake was in September of 1981. The poet wrote a new letter, and this time he announced that after he finished with Ruth, he was coming for the wife of the Wichita chief of police. He named her. Her name was Sharon Lamagnon, and he described her car. He knew the way that she drove home. Now the chief was a man named Richard Lamagnon, and up to that point he had deliberately stayed out of the poet case.

SPEAKER_00He let his detectives run their own cases. He kept the Fenleys at arm's length. His men had grown close to Ruth and to Ed. They socialized, they treated Christmas desserts, genuinely liked the Finleys. Lemagnon never did. He didn't have a single warm feeling clouding his view. So when the poet threatened his wife, Lamagnan took the entire case file home for the weekend.

SPEAKER_00Every letter, every report, every incident, start to finish, and by Monday, he had an answer his own detectives could not bring themselves to see. He called sixteen officers into a windowless basement room at the county courthouse. He sat at the head of the table and said it with no warm-up at all. He said, The poet is Ruth Finley herself.

SPEAKER_00And then he laid out why. It wasn't a hunch. It was a list, and once you hear it, you cannot unhear it. In four years there had never been a single witness to any encounter with the poet, and every one of them happened in public. The Finleys lived on a dead end street, watched by neighbors, and eventually by police. And not one person ever saw the poet come or go. No footprints at the brook where Ruth said she maced her kidnapper and run?

SPEAKER_00The only footprints detectives found were hers. She said her adductor had smashed her in the face with concrete, but her face was unmarked. When she was stabbed, she called the criminal investigation office directly, not nine one, and somehow got out of the car to make that call. Because remember back in the day we didn't have cell phones, for goodness sakes, so she had to get out of her car to make that call. And then back into her car to drive herself home with a knife in her.

SPEAKER_00The poet wrote to Captain Mike Hill the moment Hill took over the case. When only the Finleys and the police knew that he'd been in charge. The poet stopped appearing in the backyard the moment the bird cave the Burrhouse camera went in. A camera only the Finleys and the police knew about. And the poet's messages in the newspaper class fights went silent every single time the Finleys left town on vacation and only started up again the day they got.

SPEAKER_00One suspect bit every fact, and it was Briggs. That last detail kind of gets me. The class finds going quiet whenever they went on vacation because it tells you Lamanyan was right. And it tells you something else. Nobody around Ruth was lying to protect her. Ed was a covering for her. The poet just went on vacation when Ruth did. Because the poet packed the same suitcase.

SPEAKER_00And not one of those good detectives who loved her could see it. Precisely because they loved her. Sometimes the only person who can see the truth is the one in the room with no feelings in the way. And that's a cold gift, but it is a gift. Lemagnan didn't arrest her on a theory. He set a trap made of patience. For two weeks the police watched the Biddleys around the clock. A car, a helicopter, a surveillance van block that was two blocks away from their home with a very long lens trained on the neighborhood mailboxes.

SPEAKER_00And one morning they got it. Ed pulled up to the mailbox. Ruth reached her arm out of the passenger window and dropped in a handful of letters. The postal inspector pulled the mail before pickup. Two of the envelopes were from the poet. And then came the part that turned certainty into proof. The poet had mailed a letter to the chief's wife, and at the bottom of that page it was torn off in Ruth's office wastebasket.

SPEAKER_00Detectives found the missing piece, and under a microscope, the torn edges matched perfectly. The way two halves of the same ripped sheet can only match each other. The stamps matched a roll from her desk, and there was no longer any room left for doubt that the hand that held the pin was Rick's. So October 1, 1981, they brought Ed in first.

SPEAKER_00They read him his rights, walked him through it, and then showed him the surveillance photos of his wife mailing the poet's letters. Ed, who had spent four years sleeping in the backyard with a shotgun, waiting for a man hunting his wife, looked at Captain Hill and said, before he understood, well let's go get him. And then they made him understand. Ed took a polygraph that afternoon and he passed it clean. He had never known.

SPEAKER_00Not for a second. And then they brought Ruth in. Captain Hill walked her through it gently first, and then he set the stack of letters on the table and asked if she had written any of them. She said no. He told her he could prove she had. He showed her the photograph of her own arm, reaching out the car window, dropping the poet in the mail. And Ruth Finley took a look at that picture, and by every account in the room, she did not understand what she was seeing.

SPEAKER_00She wasn't performing. Something in her face went vacant. I'm the poet, she said, like she was asking the question for the first time herself. Hill kept on. Softer. Ruthie, why? He asked her. I'm not mad at you. I just want to know why. She said, I don't I don't know. Over and over. Why did you make up the abduction?

SPEAKER_00I don't know why. Why did you stab yourself? I don't know. And she admitted the things one by one. The letters, the knife and the phone booze, the filth on her own front porch. But she admitted the the way you'd recite directions to a place you've never been. She had no memory of doing any of it. She was telling Hill the only thing that fit because he was telling her it was true.

SPEAKER_00And Ruth had spent her whole life terrified of a man's anger and desperate to please. How do you feel, Ruth? Hill asked her, and she said, I wish I was dead. A few leaks later, she put it another way. I think I might have died and gone to hell, and I think I'm coming back though. I told you up front this wasn't um that I wasn't gonna plunge from this.

SPEAKER_00So here it is. Not everybody brought the bot, sorry, bought the she had no memory of it version. Chief Lamunyan, the one man who got her, who cracked this when nobody else could, stayed skeptical to the end. And he said flat out, I think she's lying. He believed she knew exactly what she was doing every step. And I'm not gonna stand here and tell you that he is wrong because I don't know that, and neither can you.

SPEAKER_00What I am gonna tell you is that the doctors found when they finally went looking, that's where the story stops being a hoax story and turns into something I genuinely did not see coming. The district attorney never charged her. After reviewing her psychological evaluation, the Cedric County DA declined to prosecute on the grounds that whatever Ruth had done, it was not malicious. She was placed under round-the-clock psychiatric watch, and then she begins the real work.

SPEAKER_00Seven years of it, with a psychiatrist named Dr. Andrew Pitkins. And in that room, slowly the truth came up from the bottom. Ruth kept seeing a red bandana, the same red bandana the poet had used as his signature. It filled her with revulsion she couldn't explain until after months when she finally could. When Ruth was a girl on the farm, a grown man, a neighbor, a friend of the family, someone trusted, tied her up with a red bandana, took her out to the barn, and sexually abused her.

SPEAKER_00He did it for the better part of a year. He pushed that bandana into her mouth so she couldn't cry out, and he told her he'd kill her if she ever told. And her parents, raised on that same hard code of no tears, no complaints, no scenes, punished her when she cried, when she tried to run. So Ruth as a little girl found the only door out that was open to her. She left. Not the room. She couldn't leave the room. She left herself.

SPEAKER_00She described floating up in a way, watching it happen to the girl down below, telling herself, it isn't so bad if it isn't me. I'm just watching it. That has a clinical name. It's called dissociation. It's how a child survives something a child cannot survive. And Ruth was so good at it, so practiced that she buried that bandana and that barn for 43 years.

SPEAKER_00Until 1977, when her husband collapsed and might die, when she was suddenly alone in the dark in a city where man was murdering people in their own homes and taunting them with letters. Every alarm Ruth had spent and a lifetime silencing went off. And the part of her that had learned as a child to split off and survive, it came back, not as a memory she could face, but as a stranger, a man who wrote letters as the poet.

SPEAKER_00The branding for Scott, by the way, the one Ruth always insisted was real, start to finish, and the doctors believed her. That was a true thing that happened to a real 16-year-old, and the poet borrowed it. The way the man borrows whatever's lying around and built it into the haunting. I've turned this over and over in my head, and here's where I land. The poet was not a lie, Ruth told. The poet was a wound that finally learned how to write.

SPEAKER_00Everything that man put on paper, the rage, the filthy words, the obsession with the brand, the threats, that was a little girl's terror locked in a barn for 40 years, with no language and no way out, finally screaming the only way it could. She wasn't hurting herself out of sport. She was the only one who could carry what had been dubbed to her, and she could only carry it by pretending it belonged to someone else. That is not the same thing as a hoax, and I don't think it's anywhere near the same thing.

SPEAKER_00Here's the better part. The tabloids never cared about, and it's my favorite part. Ruth got better. Seven years of hard, ugly, exc like excavation work essentially on her mind. And Ed, her husband, never left her side. Not for one day. Her son stayed, her sister stayed. Now she did lose quite a few friends, I'm sure. But most people, when they finally understood, gave her something closer to grace than judgment.

SPEAKER_00And eventually Ruth was well enough that she let a Witch Talk TV station tell her the whole story because she thought it might help somebody else carrying something in the dark. The response came back overwhelmingly kind. And in 1994, she even sat down with Oprah and told it again. She never wrote another poem in her life. Ruth Finley died on the 30th of May, 2019, in Wichita. She was 89 years old.

SPEAKER_00And if you read her obituary, you would never in a thousand years guess that for four years the poet had walked through her life. It just says that she knits halves, hats, and scarves and sent them to American troops in Afghanistan. It says she taught herself to code braille by hand so she could turn textbooks into something a blind child could read. And it says she loved the symphony and musical theater and walks with her friends.

SPEAKER_00That's the woman. The poet was the wound. And they lived in the same body for a while. And in the end, the woman won. Now, before I let you go, I want to tell you about a second case. And I want to be honest with you about exactly what this is and what it isn't. These are the details I can remember. And I haven't been able to put my hands on any news clipping, so I'm not giving you this as an official record. I'm giving it to you as my own memory from when I lived it.

SPEAKER_00If you were there too and you remember it differently, please write to me because I want to get this right. Years back, and I believe it was probably around 2010, there was a woman who lived in a neighborhood in my own town of Derby called Glen Hills. Close enough that I can walk to that neighborhood. And she told her husband, and she told the Derby police that she'd been raped by a stranger and they never caught him. The talk around town started calling him after the neighborhood, the Glen Hills rapist.

SPEAKER_00And I'll tell you, we were scared for months. And you locked your doors, you know, just a little earlier in the evening, and you watched your kids a little closer. There was a man out there in our neighborhood, and nobody knew his face. And then it came out that there was no man. She had made the whole thing up to cover an affair she was having. Now, I put those two stories side by side on purpose because I want you to notice how different they are. Because the difference is the whole point of tonight.

SPEAKER_00Ruth Finley invented a stalker and could not have told you why she'd done it. The lie came from a part of her that a grown man in a bird created when she was a little girl, a part she had no access to or memory of. The Glen Hill story, if my memory holds up correctly, was the only other thing entirely. It was a choice. It was a cover story, a decision made with both eyes open to protect a secret. Sang she, a woman whose attacker doesn't exist, a neighborhood holding its breath, but these are opposite souls.

SPEAKER_00One with a wound that learned to write, and the other one was a calculation. And the reason it matters, which is which is when we can't tell them apart, we do real damage. And to the Ruths, who were genuinely victims of something. And to every actual victim of an actual stranger who now has to walk into a police station and be doubted because somebody else lied on purpose. And that brings us to the Time Killer files. This is the part of the show where I turn it over to you, the Time Killers.

SPEAKER_00Every week, when you send me things in my email, I want to hear about the cases from your own backyards, the stories that never made it past the local papers, the ones your grandma maybe still won't talk about. And this week I'm asking for a specific kind. I want your false stalker stories. The phantom attacker your town was terrified out, that just never turned out to be real or existed. The panic that gripped a neighborhood and then quietly just evaporated.

SPEAKER_00Where were you living? How old were you? And how long before the truth comes out? Because I think those endings tell you everything. And I just want to know. So send me those to the Time Killers community, which is at just killingtimepodcast at gmail.com. So here's where I lead you tonight. For four years, an entire city went looking for a monster, put a woman in a bulletproof vest, hid cameras in a birdhouse, spent a third of a million dollars, and chased a man who rode and rhyme through the streets of Wichita, while a real killer watched from the shadows and must have been laughing.

SPEAKER_00And the monster was never out there. The monster was a little girl's terror, more than 40 years buried, finally clawing its way up into the light, the only way it knew how. I don't think Ruth Benley was a villain. I think she was the longest suffering victim in her own case. And I think the saddest, truest thing about the whole story is that if just one grown up all those years ago had believed a crying child and asked her what was wrong, there might have never been a poet at all.

SPEAKER_00So take care of the quiet ones in your life. The ones that never complain, never cry, never make a scene. Sometimes that comb is not peace. Sometimes it's a door. Somebody learned to close a long time ago. Just check on it, that's all. I'm Elizabeth Stanton. This has been just killing time. Thanks for killing time with me today.

SPEAKER_01Alexa, what is a chemtrail? Chemtrail. Trails left by aircraft are actually chemical or biological agents deliberately sprayed at high altitudes for a purpose undisclosed to the general public in clandestine programs directed by government officials.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. THE SHKRELI PLAYBOOK - Big Pharma Blocks Generic Manufacturers

    Nov 19, 202629 minAudio

    💊 The Shkreli Playbook: The Wall Around a 62-Year-Old Pill In September 2015, a decades-old medicine for a parasite infection jumped from $13.50 a pill to $750. Everyone remembers the smirk in the hearing room. Almost...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. THE EMPIRE OF PAIN - The Opioid Epidemic

    Nov 17, 202645 minAudio

    💊 A hotel room in Rockville, Maryland. A government doctor. A drug company that needed its painkiller approved. A Justice Department memo says the three days they spent together helped shape the OxyContin label, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. THE WOMAN WHO SAID NO - Thalidomide Samples the FDA Never Tracked

    Nov 5, 202629 minAudio

    💊 On July 15, 1962, The Washington Post called FDA reviewer Dr. Frances Kelsey a hero for keeping thalidomide off the U.S. market. What that front page left out: Richardson-Merrell of Cincinnati had already distributed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. THE SWINE FLU FIASCO - Who Pays When the Vaccine Hurts?

    Nov 3, 202648 minAudio

    💉 Episode 43: The Swine Flu Fiasco (1976), the pandemic that never came. One Army recruit died. The U.S. government vaccinated tens of millions of Americans. The predicted pandemic never arrived. Reports of a rare...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. THE TRUTH ABOUT FLUORIDE - Water, Toothpaste, & the Government

    Oct 27, 202644 minAudio

    🦷 Why is fluoride in America's water and toothpaste? Episode 42 tells the true history of water fluoridation: a Colorado dentist, an Alcoa chemist, Grand Rapids in 1945, Crest toothpaste, and the 2026 court fight. 💧...

    Credit the people on this episode