Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Just Killing Time

Just Killing Time artwork

HELEN LANE LIVES - The Henrietta Lacks Story

Oct 6, 20261 hr 25 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

🧬 Who was Henrietta Lacks? In 1951, a 31-year-old Black mother of five went to Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore for cervical cancer treatment. While she was under anesthesia, a surgeon took two small tissue samples that no one had asked her about. One of them grew in a lab when no human cells ever had. Those cells, called HeLa, are still alive today, and they have been used in research on polio, cancer, viruses, HPV and genetics. Her family was not told for decades. This is the full story. 🎙️ In this deep-dive episode of Just Killing Time with Elizabeth Stanton, we follow Henrietta Lacks from a tobacco farm in Clover, Virginia, to a segregated ward in Baltimore, and then follow her cells around the world. 🔎 WHAT YOU'LL HEAR • How a rookie reporter in 1974 found the scrawl "HELEN LANE LIVES" on a bathroom wall and unraveled a hidden name • Henrietta's life as Loretta Pleasant, a mother of five in Turner Station, Maryland • Dr. Howard Jones's notes on a tumor that looked like "grape Jello" • What a radium treatment actually involved in 1951 • How George Gey and Mary Kubicek discovered the first immortal human cells • Her death on October 4, 1951, and the red toenail polish that changed how a lab technician saw the cells • The Tuskegee HeLa cell factory that helped test the Salk polio vaccine • The "HeLa bomb," contaminated cell lines, and a scientific cover name • The Lacks family's story: blood draws that felt like a cancer test, and Elsie's death at Crownsville • The BTK connection: a daughter's stored Pap smear and the police warrant that used it 🕯️ • Moore v. Regents, the 2013 HeLa genome, the NIH-Lacks Family Agreement, the WHO award, and lawsuits against Thermo Fisher, Ultragenyx, Novartis and Viatris ⚖️ ❓ QUICK ANSWERS Was it legal? Sources agree taking the tissue was legal in the 1950s. Johns Hopkins says it never sold or patented HeLa cells. Why "Helen Lane"? A scientist told Rolling Stone no one was sure how that name caught on. Was she ever paid? No. Her estate has since settled confidentially with Thermo Fisher (2023), Novartis (2026) and Viatris (2026). The Ultragenyx case was active as of April 2026. 📌 KEY FACTS • Born August 1, 1920, in Roanoke, Virginia; died October 4, 1951, at age 31 • HeLa cells double about every 20 to 24 hours (Johns Hopkins) • About 20,000 tubes of HeLa cells a week were produced at Tuskegee at the peak of polio vaccine testing • WHO posthumous award: October 13, 2021 🩺 WHY IT MATTERS Johns Hopkins calls the 1951 collection of her cells an acceptable and legal practice for the time, says it never sold or patented HeLa, and says it could and should have done more to inform her family. In this episode, documented facts are kept separate from my opinions, and my opinions are labeled as opinion. Where sources disagree on a date or a number, I say so out loud. 💬 TIME KILLER FILES: Ever wonder what happened to a sample taken at your doctor's office? Email me your story and tell me what you think. 📚 SOURCES • Rebecca Skloot, The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks (2010) • Johns Hopkins Medicine, "The Legacy of Henrietta Lacks" • Britannica, "Henrietta Lacks" • Embryo Project Encyclopedia (Arizona State University) • Johns Hopkins Magazine, "Immortal Cells, Enduring Issues" • Rolling Stone, "The Double-Edged Helix" (1976) • NIH, "The NIH-Lacks Family Agreement" • WHO news release, October 13, 2021 • Moore v. Regents, 51 Cal.3d 120 (1990) • Lacks v. Ultragenyx, D. Md., Civ. No. DLB-23-2171 • Gartler, Nature 217:750 (1968) • Brown & Lowenberg, Stanford J. of Law, Science & Policy (2009) • 42 CFR 493.1105 • Seeger Weiss LLP case page (April 2026) • NPR, PBS, CNN, AP, STAT News 🔔 Follow the show so you never miss an episode. 🎧 New episodes on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music and iHeartRadio. Follow @just.killing.time.pod on TikTok and Instagram. #HenriettaLacks #HeLaCells #HiddenHistory #TrueCrime #BTK #JustKillingTime #KeepTheLightOn

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00One day in 1974, a rookie reporter named Michael Rogers walked into a bathroom in a medical school library in San Francisco. Somebody had scrolled words upon the wall in a felt-tipped pin, and it said, Helen Lane limbs. He had no idea who was Helen Lane. He shrugged it off and he moved on. And then two months later, he just happened to be flipping through Science magazine, and there she was again.

SPEAKER_00Helen Lane, the magazine explained, was the source of a line of cells called Gela cells, of such in common strength that they had revolutionized how scientists grow human tissue in a laboratory. The paper was short, technical, and did not say one word about who Helen Lane actually was. So Roger, he followed his reporter's nose to Baltimore, and he tracked down the scientist who wrote the paper.

SPEAKER_00And there he heard a name he had never come across in all of his reading about Gila cells. And when he asked about it, the scientist replied, Well, that was her real name. I don't think anyone is quite sure how everybody got to calling her Helen Lane. Now Helen Lane was a mistake that stuck. Her real name was Henrietta Lanks, and she was a black tobacco farmer's granddaughter from Virginia, another five, and she had been dead for more than twenty years.

SPEAKER_00Nobody had told her family. Nobody had asked for permission. And her cells? Well, those were not dead at all. They were alive in freezers and incubators in laboratories around the planet. They had helped make the polio vaccine possible. They had been carried into space. They had been infected, irradiated, poisoned, frozen, thawed, shipped, and sold.

SPEAKER_00Today, 75 years after a surgeon at John Hopkins snipped two small pieces of tissue from her cervix, some of those cells are still dividing. Now hold on to that because it is the thought to carry with you through this whole episode. Here is a woman who was told nothing, ask nothing, and pay nothing, and a chunk of modern medicine is standing on proof body. So pull the blanket up.

SPEAKER_00This one has a segregated hospital, a scientific establishment that treated a patient like raw material, a family kept in the dark for a quarter of a century in lawsuits that are still in federal court as I record this. And before we are done, it walks right into my own carved canvas. This is just killing time. I'm Elizabeth Stanton, your nightlight for the stories that keep us up at night. We are true crime, conspiracy, and a little hidden history sprinkled in.

SPEAKER_00Now before we start, Time Killers, I want to hear from you. Has anyone in your family ever had tissue, blood, or a biopsy taken and then wondered where it went? Did anybody ever explain to you what a hospital does with a sample once the test is finished? Tell me what you think about this story. And remember, you can always email me your own time killer files at just killing timepodcast at gmail.com. And the best ones will end up on the show.

SPEAKER_00Now, I'm gonna just tell you personally, when I have had a biopsy done or a cervical pap smear, for example, because of this story. I had no idea that they didn't just test for the cancer cells and then discard my material. Oh no. Oh no, no, no, no. That's all what they do with it. They don't dispose of it, they keep it and they catalog it. And that horrifies me.

SPEAKER_00And it should horrify you. Now let's get back to the story. A quick word about how I'm gonna handle the facts on the show. Everything I read to you is documented history. It comes from sources I list in the show notes. And when I'm giving you my opinion, like I just did, then I will tell you it's my opinion. And when the sources disagree with each other about a date or a number, I just I just tell you, and I say it out loud because you deserve to know when the record itself is blurry. And this story has a few of those spots.

SPEAKER_00So let's start with Henrietta Lacks. She was not born Henrietta, she was born Loretta Pleasant on August 1st, 1920, in Roanoke, Virginia. Roanoke? Well, that's another little rabbit hole. Anyways, not to go down that rabbit hole. Let's talk about looks like Loretta Pleasant at the time. Her parents were Eliza and John Randall Pleasant. Nobody in the family is certain how Loretta turned into Henrietta, and her relatives simply called her Henny.

SPEAKER_00That's very cute for Henrietta. Her childhood was over early. In 1924, when Loretta was four years old, her mother died, giving birth to a tenth child. Her father, overwhelmed, packed up his children, and moved them to Clover, Virginia, a small tobacco town in Halifax County, where his relatives live. And then he split the kids up among family members to be raised. And Loretta was raised by her grandfather, Tommy Lax, who was at the same time raising another grandchild, her first cousin, David Lax, whom everyone called Day.

SPEAKER_00But I want to slow down on the land because the land is the first piece of hidden history in this story. The patch of clover where the Lax family lived is known as Lax Town. And it got that name because it was originally owned by white landowning slave owner members of the Lax family before the Civil War. Afterward, later generations of this family gave parcels of land to the black members of the family who descended from the people that they had enslaved.

SPEAKER_00And that means Henrietta descended from enslaved Africans and from the white owners who held them. And she grew up working land that her forebears had worked before her. Now, Sklut, the funny name, is the science journalist who spent years chasing this story and wrote the 2010 book, The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lax. You will hear her name a lot tonight because without her research, most of what we know about Henrietta the person, as opposed to Henrietta the cell line, would be lost.

SPEAKER_00Now, Loretta, she worked the tobacco fields as a child and she left school around the sixth grade to help support her family. Sloof describes her as a sturdy woman with a square jaw, short and muscular legs, and hands rough from the tobacco fields and kitchens. But she was also a woman who cared how she looked. And Sklouv writes that Henrietta kept her needles short, so bread dough would not stick under them when she needed it, and she always painted them a deep red to match her toenails.

SPEAKER_00In Sklut's words, Henrietta spent hours taking care of those nails, touching up chips, and brushing on new coats of polish. So just hold that image, and it comes back at the worst moment of this story. The couple's first two children, Lawrence and Elsie, were born before the way. According to biographical sources, Lawrence arrived in 1935 when Henrietta was 14 years old.

SPEAKER_00And Dang was 19. Yikes. Did you catch that? She married her cousin. Elsie came at 1939, and the family described Elsie as quote unquote different. She had epilepsy and cerebral palsy. And I'm gonna come back to Elsie because her story is among the hardest to hear in this entire saga. In 1941, Day and Henrietta married and they left Virginia for uh Maryland.

SPEAKER_00They settled in Turner Station, a historic black community outside Baltimore, and over the next decade they had three more children David Jr., Deborah, and Joseph. Now, Joseph, a baby, he was born at John Hopkins Hospital on September 19, 1950. So just sit with all those numbers for just a second. In the fall of 1950, Henrietta Lax is 30 years old. She has five kids, a husband, a house, and a life.

SPEAKER_00She is four and a half months away from a doctor's appointment that will change medical history. She has no idea. Her daughter, uh Deborah, the second to the youngest, is about a year old at this point. And Deborah's spend the rest of her life trying to figure out who her mother was. Sometime in 1950, before Joseph was born, Henrietta told two of her cousins that she felt a knot in her abdomen.

SPEAKER_00The cousins assumed correctly that she was pregnant, and that was the end of it. One relative later believed Henrietta was afraid to see a doctor because she was worried a doctor might take out her womb and end up like ending her chances of having any more children. And that is a relative's belief, not a documented fact. But it tells you what women and her position, what they were up against. After Joseph was born on September 19th, 1950, Henrietta suffered a severe hemorrhage.

SPEAKER_00Her regular doctor tested her for syphilis, and according to biographical accounts, the test came back negative. He referred her to John Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. And here is a detail worth filing away. Britannica notes that the tumor was never spotted by doctors at Joseph's birth or at her six-week checkup afterward. One account of her case notes that the lump appears to have grown to the size in a matter of months, and nobody just noticed it.

SPEAKER_00And on January 29th, 1951, Henrietta checks herself into Johns Hopkins and told the staff she had a knot in her woman. She went to Hopkins for a reason that they had nothing to do with Hopkins' reputation. Hopkins was one of the few hospitals in the Baltimore area that would treat poor black patients. And she would receive that care in what sources describe as the colored ward, a segregated section of the hospital.

SPEAKER_00Her doctor was Dr. Howard W. Jones, a Hopkins gynaecologist who would later be remembered as one of the giants of reproductive medicine. In Sklut's telling, Henrietta lay back on the exam table, feet in the stirrups, and stared at the ceiling. In Jones, he found the lump right where she said it would be. If her cervix was the face of a clock, Sklut writes, the lump sat at four o'clock. Jones had, by Sklut's account, seen easily a thousand cervical cancer lesions, and he had never seen anything like this one.

SPEAKER_00It was shiny, deep purple, and so delicate that it bled if you so much as touched it. He later described it in his notes as looking like grape jello. And I want to explain what the cervix is and what cervical cancer does, because this is where the medicine matters. The cervix is the no the narrow lower end of the uterus. Okay? It's the doorway between the uterus and the vagina.

SPEAKER_00And cancer there begins in the cells, lining that open, and then they, when left alone, it grows outward into surrounding tissue and eventually travels through the bloodstream and lymph system to other organs. In 1951, cervical cancer was killing about 15,000 American women every year. And according to a Johns Hopkins magazine account of the era, it was a leading terror in women's medicine.

SPEAKER_00So, Dr. Jones, he cut a small piece of that lesion and he sent it down the hall to pathology lab. And then he sent Henrietta Holly. Now the lab report came back diagnosing what was then called epidemoid carcinoma and a viscervix in a squamous cell cancer. John's, uh sorry, Jones dictated notes on her case. Among them, this is what they said.

SPEAKER_00Her history is interesting in that she had a term delivery here at this hospital, September 19, 1950. And here's a book. I love because it shows how murky old Madison can be. In 1970, nearly two decades after her death, physicians reviewed her tumor and concluded that it was not an epidermoid cancer at all. It was an adenocarcinoma. Look. Adenocarcinoma. There you go, that is the word.

SPEAKER_00A cancer of the glandular tissue. That was a common misdiagnosis at the time. And according to one account, even with the right diagnosis, her treatment would have been the same, thankfully, right? On February 5th, 1951, Jones called Henrietta with the biopsy result, and the tumor was malignant. Sklut writes that Henrietta, she told no one what the doctor said. And no one asked her.

SPEAKER_00She just went on with her day, and the next morning she climbed out of the Buick outside Hopkins, telling Day and the kids not to worry, and Skluth quotes her, Ain't nothing serious wrong. Doctor's gonna fix me right up. Well she went straight to the admissions desk. She signed a form headed with the words operation permit. That piece of paper is the only consent form anyone has ever been able to point to.

SPEAKER_00Now time for some medicine. Because I promised myself I wouldn't gloss over the mechanics. And because Elsie's story and the Tuskegee study and every other case in this series depends on your understanding what treatment actually looked like back then. The standard treatment for cervical cancer in 1951 was radium. Radium is a radioactive metal and radiation kills cells, especially cells that divide quickly, which is exactly what cancer cells do.

SPEAKER_00The catch is that radium can also cause the mutations that lead to cancer. It is a tool that cuts both ways. And here's how they used it on Henrietta. Surgeons took small glass tubes of radiate radium and stitched them into fabric pouches called brack plaques. And then with the patient under anesthesia, they sewed the patches directly against the cervix right on top of the tuber.

SPEAKER_00And the tubes stayed in place for several days. And afterward the radium was removed, and the patient was sent home with instructions to come back for follow-up x-ray treats. The surgeon on duty on February 6th was Dr. Lawrence Warkman Jr. And while Henrietta was sedated, he did something that had nothing to do with her care. He removed two small pieces of tissue from her cervix, one shaved from the tumor and one taken from the healthy cervical tissue nearby.

SPEAKER_00And according to the accounts, each sample was about the size of a dime. Those two samples were placed in a dish and a resident carried them to a laboratory down the hall. Nobody asked Henriette. And according to Sklut and others, the only form she had ever signed the operation permit authorized the hospital to perform whatever operative procedures and anesthesia that it deemed necessary for proper care.

SPEAKER_00Nothing in that description handles covery, taking that tissue to a researcher. Now the sources differ on the exact dates of this procedure. One widely used reference gives February 8th. So I'm going to go with the day she was admitted and signed the form and flag that the record is not perfectly consistent. And here's where I'm going to play at my flag. And this is my opinion. John Hopkins' own statement calls what happened to her cells as quote-unquote an acceptable and legal practice in the 1950s.

SPEAKER_00The sources agree that it was legally, but legal is a low bar, and it makes me furious how often it gets waved around as though it was the same thing as right. She trusted these people to treat her cancer. She signed a paper that said operation permit, and somebody used that truss to carve a piece of her off for a lab down the hall. An operation permit is not permission. And to take a piece of that woman. And by the accounts I read, the patients this happened to most often were the poor ones on the free warns.

SPEAKER_00So why did Hopkins take the tissue from patients routinely? Because of a pop of the Hopkins gynecologist name, Dr. Rachel Talindi. Now, Talindi, he was in the middle of a scientific fight over whether an early superficial form of the disease called carcinoma in situ was a true early cancer or something less dangerous. And he believed it was a cancer and favored aggressive treatment, including removing the cervix and the uterus.

SPEAKER_00And his colleagues, well, they consider that extreme. And to make his case, Talindy wanted tissue from as many women with cervical disease as he could get. And he began collecting samples for any woman who walked into Hopkins with cervical cancer, including Henri Adam. And he passed the samples to a colleague who had been chasing a dream for years. There was Dr. George Odo Guy, and he was the head of tissue culture research at Johns Hopkins.

SPEAKER_00And here's the John Hopkins physician. In their own words, for years, Guy had been collecting cells from all of his patients, regardless of their race or socioeconomic status, and who came to Hopkins with cervical cancer. So they're justifying it. Like we did it to everybody, you know. Now here's the part that the hospital does not put in its state. Multiple accounts know that Hopkins was the only hospital in the Baltimore area where African American patients could receive free care, and that the patients receiving free care in the segregated section often became research subjects without their knowledge.

SPEAKER_00So be honest with me, Time Killers. When you sign the stack of forms at a hospital desk, do you read every line? Did anybody ever explain the paragraph about research or educational purposes? Let me know what your thoughts are on. So George Guy, he was born in Pittsburgh and he spent his career at John Hopkins trying to solve one problem: how to keep human cells alive outside the human body. He worked along with his scientist his wife, Margaret, in a small laboratory in the same building as the Gybecology Clinic.

SPEAKER_00Human cells, once cut away from a body and dropped into a dish, almost always died within days. And if Guy could find a cell that would not die, scientists could study cancer, viruses, and drugs on living human tissue in a controlled setting without experimenting opacians. Now Hopkins' own account says that for years Guy had been collecting samples from cervical cancer patients, but then every sample died in his lap.

SPEAKER_00And by the time Henrietta's tissue had arrived, about thirty cervical cancer specimens had already been sent, and every one had failed. The person who actually handed or handled, I guess, the tissue was Guy's assistant. And her name was Mary Kubich. And she was a 21-year-old lap technician. And when a new sample came over from the clinic, Kubichek did the same routine every time. She sterilized her equipment, put on a surgical mask, and capped and sliced the tissue to little squares about a millimeter across, and dropped each square onto a clot made from the chicken blood in a test tube.

SPEAKER_00She covered it with a few drops of a mixture of broths, salts, and according to Kathy Gare's review of Sklut's book, umbilical cord blood. She plugged the tube with the rubber stopper and she labeled it. And the tube was labeled with the first two letters of the patient's first name and the first two letters of her last. So Henrietta Lax became Gila. And she loaded the tubes into a contraption Guy had built out of scraps, a rig that kept the cells warm and in constant motion, and then she waited, expecting the same thing that had happened 30 times before.

SPEAKER_00According to the accounts of the lab, either Guy nor Kubicek expected these cells to do anything different. A couple of days later, the little clocks at the bottom of the test tubes sprouted a whitish ring of cells. Kubicek was not impressed. Plenty of samples grew for a few days before dying. And then she looked again. The cells were not just surviving, they were multiplying. She divided them into fresh tubes.

SPEAKER_00They kept multiplying. The genetics unzipped account says one tube of cells in February 1951 didn't die at all. They doubled in number about every 24 hours, and Hopkins says every 20 to 24 hours. To put that in perspective, the ASU Embryo Project reports that Henrietta's tumor cells proliferated at about 20 times the speed of her phone, normal, cervical cells. And unlike every other human cell Guy had ever tried to keep alive, they just did not stop.

SPEAKER_00As long as they had warmth and room to grow, they just kept dividing. So let me translate that science. A normal human cell can only divide a limited number of times before it stops. And each time a cell copies its DNA, the copying machinery leaves the end of the chromosomes just a little shorter. And these protective ends are called uh telameres, telomeres, telomeres. Eventually, they wear down and then the cell quits.

SPEAKER_00An enzyme called tel lameris uh can rebuild those ends, and cancer cells often keep the enzyme running. That kind of cancer cell, one that refuses to run out of divisions, is what Guy had stumbled across. Researchers still debate exactly what made Henrietta's tumor so extraordinary. Some have suggested it was the sheer aggressiveness of her cancer, and others have floated the idea that an infection she may have carried played a part.

SPEAKER_00And her medical records on that point, well, they're contested. And the record is not settled. So in his lab, the achievement was enormous. Guy told his colleagues he had grown the first immortal human cell line. He was so sure of what he had that he began mailing the cells out. Guy was the founder and first president of the Tissue Culture Association. What? And according to Hopkins Medical Archives, that's who he was.

SPEAKER_00Accounts of his career say he began shipping those Gila cells to researchers in Texas, India, New York, the Netherlands, and beyond. And that he flew from lab to lab showing other scientists how to culture them. Now, of course, nobody asked Hidriana if she minded. Nobody was in a hurry to tell her either. She was still alive, she was still coming to the hospital for radium and x-rays, and the most important part of her body, well, scientifically speaking, was already growing in glass down the hole, and it was being sent around the wand.

SPEAKER_00The first radium treatment, well, it seemed to work. The genetics unzipped accounts as the two were shrewd, and after a second treatment, a couple of weeks later, it appeared to vanish. But within weeks, the cancer was gone, and it was spreading fast. More radiation followed at higher and higher doses. Sklut writes that the day that day, her husband later told his daughter Deborah that Henrietta hadn't seemed sick at all.

SPEAKER_00He said he took her to Hopkins and they started the treatments, and then her stomach turned black as coal, and then she died. The cousins told the same story, and that is the family's recollection, not a medical planning. On August 8, 1951, in severe pain. And with no improvement, Henrietta came back to Hopkins and demanded to be amended. And she never went home again. She stayed on the ward until she died.

SPEAKER_00Near the inn, Henrietta's sister Gladys came to Baltimore to see her, and Sklut writes that Henrietta was thinking about her children, especially the youngest, Deborah, whom she would never get to dress in beautiful clothes, braid, or teach her to paint her nails. And according to Sklut, Henrietta looked at Gladys and whispered, Don't you let anything bad happen to them children when I'm gone? Henrietta lacks, she died at twelve fifteen in the morning on October 4th, 1951.

SPEAKER_00She was thirty one years old. The cause of her death was recorded as terminal uh urea, a blood poisoning that happens when the kidneys just cannot clear waste. In her case, the tumors had completely blocked her urethra, so that her body could not pass urine and doctors could not get a catheter in. A partial autopsy would show that the cancer had spread throughout her entire body. There was no obituary.

SPEAKER_00And here's a detail from the Sklut's account that shows the mindset of the place. Word of Henrietta's death reached the guy lad quickly, and as her body cooled in what the book calls the colored freezer. That gets me right and going, I don't like that. The colored freezer. Guy asks her doctors whether they would perform an autopsy so he could see whether other cells from her body would grow the way the tumor cells.

SPEAKER_00She was barely gone, and the lad already wanted more. And here's where the law makes a distinction that matters, because according to accounts of the era, taking tissue from a living patient did not require permission. But an opsy, that did require the consent of a family member. And someone from Hopkins phoned Day Lax to ask, and he said no. The next day when he came to the hospital to see his wife's body, the doctors well they asked him again.

SPEAKER_00They explained that they wanted to run tests that might someday help his children. Day's cousin told him it would not hurt anything, so Day agreed. So Gravy husband said no and then they came back the next day and while he stood there to see his wife's body, they asked him again, and this told them this time they told him it's gonna help his children. I cannot tell you what anyone in that room intended, but I can tell you how it looks to me.

SPEAKER_00It looks like a man being worked while he was too broken to say no a second time. And I'm angry about it and I think you should be too. I'm keeping the light on for this next part of the story because it's about an autopsy. And I think it's the moment that this whole story turns. So stay with me. The pathologist removed tissue from almost every organ in her body. Mary Kabugchek was there to collect samples for Guy, and was the first time she had ever seen a dead body.

SPEAKER_00She stared at Henrietta's arms and legs, anything to avoid looking at her face. And then her gaze fell on Henrietta's feet. Skoot quotes Kabubchek years later when she said, When I saw those toenails, I nearly fainted. I thought, oh geez, she's a real person. And I started imagining her sitting in her bathroom painting those toenails. And it hit me for the first time that those cells we'd been working with all this time and sending all over the world, they came from a live woman, and I'd never thought of it that way.

SPEAKER_00Henrietta's body was sent by train from Baltimore to Clover in a plain pine box. It had rained for days, and her son David remembered the rain pouring down on the day of her burial. She was buried in an unmarked grave in a family cemetery in Laxtown within a few feet of family beliefs of her mother. No stone, no marker, and no one told them what was still alive in Baltimore. The horror in that room is not the lap technician merely feigned.

SPEAKER_00It was that it took a pair of rant-painted toenails for anyone in the building to remember they were cutting into a person. And for months Henrietta had been just a label on a test tube, two syllables on a rack. And the woman herself was down the home. That makes me so sad. Now we get to the part of the story that Hopkins and the textbooks love to tell because the cells did not just live, they changed the world.

SPEAKER_00The early 1950s was the worst polio epidemic in American history. Jonas Salk had developed a polio vaccine by the early 1950s, but nobody could prove it worked at scale. Testing it meant a field trial on a scale that the medical world had never attempted, run by the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, the organization we now know as the March of Dimes. The plan was to inoculate roughly two million children and test their blood for immunity.

SPEAKER_00That's insane. That's my personal opinion. That's insane. Absolutely insane. That required mixing each child's blood with cells infected by poliovirus, and the standard cells for the job came for monkeys. They were expensive, and getting them meant killing monkeys. Guy and his colleague at the foundation discovered that Gila cells were susceptible to poliovirus, which made them ideal. Now they needed them by the billions. And the foundation decided to build a Gila production factory.

SPEAKER_00And the man who pushed for the site was Charles Bynum, a science teacher and one of the first black executives in the foundation's history. He argued for the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama. What? That oh god, it's so gross. Well, the factory was up and running in a matter of months, and it began with six black scientists and technicians and eventually grew to a staff of 35, many of them women.

SPEAKER_00And at its peak, it shipped roughly 20,000 tube cultures a week, about six trillion cells. Two scientists led the work, Dr. Russell W. Brown and Dr. James H. M. Henderson. And their names deserve to be said out loud. Now listen to how Rebecca Sklink describes what happened in Alabama. She said this. Black scientists and technicians, most of them women, used cells from a black woman to help save the lives of millions of Americans, most of them white.

SPEAKER_00And they did so on the same campus and at the same time that state officials were conducting the infamous Tuskegee syphilis study. And if you listened to my Tuskegee episode, you know what that means. In one place, in one moment, the federal government's public health service was withholding penicillin from black men to watch syphilis kill them. While in the same town, black scientists were growing a black women's cells to help defeat a disease.

SPEAKER_00The counts note that the Tuskegee University Lab and the U.S. Public Health Service syphilis study were separate operations. And a book on the university's history specifically works to correct the false belief that the university itself ran the syphilis study. But they existed in the same town at the same time under the same pattern of who was treated as a partner and who was treated as a subject. So the cells, they just kept working.

SPEAKER_00And in 1955, Gila became the first human cells to be successfully cloned. Researchers used them to study how viruses infect human cells, and they were sent up on early space missions to see how zero gravity affects human cells. They were used to study the effects of radiation, and federal legislation passed in 2021 lists the contributions, work on chromosomal conditions, cancer, HIV, homophilia, leukemia, and Parkinson's disease.

SPEAKER_00Researchers used Gila to describe how thalidomide caused birth defects, and that knowledge was later applied to treating multiple myeloma. And there is more. German virologist, his name was Harold Zerhalsen, used Gila cells infected with human papillomas virus to show that certain viruses cause cancer. Work that led to the HVV vaccine and won the 2008 Nobel Prize in Physiology in Medicine.

SPEAKER_00The 2009 Nobel Prize for the Discovery of Telomarase concerned the cell diffusion machinery that I had described earlier. And the NIH lists Gila among the tools in that research. The 2021 Nobel Prize for the Discovery of Receptors for Temperature and Touch also drew on Gila work, according to the Gila 100 initiative. Those are milestones. And the WHO, the World Health Organization, says more than 50 million metric tones of Gila cells had been distributed worldwide.

SPEAKER_00Though that figure sounds astonishing enough that you should know it comes from a WHO statement reported by the Associated Press. The WHO also says they have been used in more than 75,000 studies. Other tallies vary. One institute cites roughly 110,000 papers and 11,000 patients, patents, sorry, not patients, patents. Biography.com says over 10,000 patents, and the numbers depend on who's counting and what they count, but every version of the count is enormous.

SPEAKER_00And here's the fact that gets me every time. In a 2010 review, the London Review of Books noted that Gila cells are advertised in life science journals and sold in small vials for anything from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars. Hopkins says it never patented Gila, never sold the soul's cells, and never made any money from them directly. And I will take Hopkins at its word on it. But a market grew up around the cells, and the woman they came from was never invited to it.

SPEAKER_00There is a problem with an immortal cell, and it took years of science to admit it. Gila was too good at surviving. Researchers discovered that the cells could float through the air on dust particles, land in a neighboring dish, and then take over. Labs everywhere were growing Gila alongside other human cells, and Gila was quietly winning. In 1966, a geneticist named Stanley Gardler from the University of Washington stood up at a cell culture conference in Bedford, Pennsylvania, and dropped what people in the field later called the Gila bomb.

SPEAKER_00He had tested the first 18 established human cell lines. Every one of them carried a particular version of an enzyme called uh G6PD, a variant found almost exclusively in African Americans. Yet most of those cell lines were labeled as tumors for white patients. Yet most of those that's that's weird. And the only explanation was that all of them had been overrun by Gila.

SPEAKER_00Think about that. Because they're airborne. Six of these samples came straight from the American Type Culture Collection, a major repository of the cell lines. And according to accounts of the meeting, the mood in the room, well, it shifted dramatically. His findings were published in Nature in 1968 in a short paper reporting that a survey of 20 human cell lines showed identical enzyme patterns. Results he read as widespread contamination of cultures by the first established human cell line Gila.

SPEAKER_00Now, many scientists, they refused to believe it. It was easier to assume that their own cell lines were unique. And a cytogeneticist named Walter Nelson Rees eventually used the unusual marker chromosome in Gila to unmask scores of contaminated lines and published lists of them in science.

SPEAKER_00It is not ancient history. A 2015 estimate from a database of misidentified cell lines said Gila was the most common contaminant responsible for about 24% of the false lines. Discover magazine has quoted Gardler saying about the modern DNA fingerprinting technique. And what I find fascinating is how Gila went from being a miracle to being a nuisance.

SPEAKER_00And how the person behind it is still nowhere to be found. In all of these years of papers, the woman had been reduced just to two syllabus syllables and a rumor. For decades, the name that circulated in the scientific literature was Helen Lane. And where that name came from, nobody can explain. Remember the scientist in Baltimore who told a young repolter that nobody was quite sure how everybody got to calling her Helen Lane? Well, that conversation happened in the mid-1960s.

SPEAKER_00Michael Rogers wrote it up, and his story ran in the Rolling Stone magazine in March of 1976 under the title The Double Edged Helix, with a subtitle that promised confusion and possibly disaster from those vigorous cervical cells from Baltimore. And in the article, he wrote that Gila, according to science, is cell culture shorthand for Helen Lane. And Helen Lane is a big name in that arcade pursuit.

SPEAKER_00The article revealed her real name, and according to one city, um, it was the first time the mainstream news source revealed that the woman behind it, behind Gila, was black. Nobody even knew that. Well, the timing was terrible. It landed shortly after the Tuskegee study became public, and readers immediately connected the two. A note on the sources: Reverence books differ on exactly when the Lax family learned that Henrietta's cells were alive.

SPEAKER_00Wikipedia says 1975. Other accounts describe scientists contacting family in 1973 or 1974. The Rolling Stone article ran in 1976. The dates blur because the family was never sat down until they found out in scraps over several years from people who did not explain very well. In the early 1970s, Gila contamination was up-ending cell science.

SPEAKER_00And a Hopkins geneticist named Dr. Victor McCusick had an idea. If he could get blood from Henrietta's living relatives, he could isolate genetic markers that would let researchers tell which cell cultures were truly Gila and which were imposters, because the Laxisans were Hopkins patients. He already had their medical record and contact information, and he sent a postdoctoral fellow, Susan, and I'm not sure how to say her last name, it's HSU.

SPEAKER_00So Susan HSU is what I'm gonna call her to collect the blend. And here's where the accounts diverge. HSU believed she had explained things. According to a Johns Hopkins magazine article, she recalled giving Henrietta's husband, Day, a technical explanation using terms like genetic marker profile and genotype. And day, well, he had a fourth grade education. Neither he nor his daughter understood that the blood was going to be compared with the cells growing in labs around the world.

SPEAKER_00Both believed, as Sklut documents, that they were being tested for cancer. That they were being tested for cancer. Deborah, who was in her twenties, kept calling Hopkins afterward to ask for her cancer results. And no one there knew what she was talking about because there was such a test. When Deborah went to Hopkins to give another sample, she met McCusick. She demanded to know how her mother had gotten cancer and what it meant that part of her was still alive.

SPEAKER_00That's so sad, you guys. Oh, I can't imagine having to ask those questions. Well, McCusick explained what Hila had contributed to science and gave her a copy of a genetics textbook he had written. You know, it was called Medig Medical Genetics, which included a section on Henrietta. Well, as you can only imagine, Deborah could not follow the language. But she stared at a photograph of her mother in that book, one that she had never seen.

SPEAKER_00And she wondered how the doctors had gotten it. Makusick later told Sklut he did not remember meeting Deborah at all. Deborah barely understood what a sound was. When Mikusick described Gila research, she pictured researchers around the world injecting her mother with terrible diseases. And every time she heard about a new experiment, Deborah panicked. Meanwhile, Mikusick and HSU were writing up their results.

SPEAKER_00In the January 30th, 1976 issue of Science, they published a paper titled Genetic Characteristics of the GELA Cell. And it listed 43 genetic markers from the Lax family DNA. And it identified Henrietta by name, and it labeled for family members, husband, child 1, and child 2. Now the opinion, and I want to say it plainly as I always do, this is where the story stops being about a hospital that followed the rules of its day and becomes about people who knew better.

SPEAKER_00By the 1970s, the Tuskegee study was in the headlines, telling a black family what was being done with their blood was not exotic. And still a doctor was left. I'm sorry, and daughter was left believing that she had a cancer test pending. That's heartbreaking, while her family's genetic information went into a scientific journal under her mother's name with the rest of them labeled husband and child. And nobody had to twirl a mustache for that to be a failure.

SPEAKER_00It only takes an institution that decided the laxuses did not need to understand. And that makes me angry, and I think it should make everybody else angry too. So, have you ever donated blood or DNA to a study or used a huge like a home DNA test? And wondered? Who ended up with the results? So tell me your thoughts on that, by the way. Back to the story though. Later in 2001, according to Sklut's timeline, Deborah and her brother, Zachariah, um, finally saw their mother's cells.

SPEAKER_00A researcher at Hopkins named Christopher Lingauer, he invited them into his lab. And according to Sklut's account, he showed them the freezers where the cells were stored, and then they looked at the living cells under a microscope. Lingower handed Deborah a vial. And she warmed it in her hands and said her mother was probably. Afterwards, she told Sklut that she had just witnessed a miracle, but she also made a point to Sklut that she was not chiefly concerned about money.

SPEAKER_00She just wanted to know who her mother had been. Deborah told Sklut something that was stuck with people who read the book. And here's the quote. Only thing we got of our mother is just in records in her Bible. And I promised I'd come back to Henry and his daughter Elsie. She was the second child born in 1939, and she was described by the family as different.

SPEAKER_00She had epilepsy, she had cerebral palsy, and according to a summary of Sklut's research, Sklut suggests her conditions were likely caused by congenital syphilis, passed from her mother through, and I want to be careful and note that this one reading is of a contested record. Around the time Henrietta was diagnosed, Elsie was placed in the hospital for the Negro in S. in Crownsville, Maryland. It was later renamed Crownsville Hospital Center, and she died there in 1955 at the age of 15.

SPEAKER_00According to Sklut, after Henrietta died, nobody visited her. Deborah did not learn if Elsie existed until years after her mother's death. In 2001, Deborah asked Sklut to help her find out what happened, and they drove to Crownsville. Most of the hospital records from between 1910 and the late 1950s had been destroyed because, well, they were contaminated with asbestos. But a historian, Paul Lurz, had saved some clockbound books of autopsy records, and astonishingly, one contained the reports from 1955.

SPEAKER_00So the light's still on, everybody. And right here in this next part, it's hard to hear. In 1955, the year Elsie died, Crownsville held more than 2,700 patients, nearly 800 above its maximum capacity. Sklut found that the doctors at the hospital had experimented nonpatients without their consent. Lurs had told them it was possible Elsie had been subjected to a procedure called.

SPEAKER_00This is a big one. Hippod pneumonia, pneumocephalography, in which fluid is drained from around the brain and replaced with air or helium, so the brain shows up more clearly on X-rays. It is only a possibility. The records do not prove it. What they did contain was a photograph of Elsie taken not long before she died, showing a guru in terrible physical condition, crying, her held, her head, held in place by a pair of white pants.

SPEAKER_00Elsie's story matters here because it shows what kind of medical world Henrietta's family lived in. It is the world that took cells from the mother without asking, drew blood from the children under a misunderstanding, and it placed a disabled daughter in an overcrowded institution where, according to Sklut's research, doctors experimented on patients without their consent. In 2010, Elsie finally got her own health stone, dedicated the same day as her mother's.

SPEAKER_00Deborah Lax did not live to see her mother's story become a bestseller. She died in 2009 and her mother's book was published in February of 2010. While the Lax family was trying to understand what had been done to their mother, the American legal system was working out who owns the cells taken from a human body. The answer so far has been not you. The case is called Moore versus Regents at the University of California.

SPEAKER_00And it was decided by a California Supreme Court on July 9, 1990. John Moore was a man who began treatment for hairy cell leukemia at UCLA Medical Center in 1976. And his doctor, David Gould, removed his spleen and then asked him to come back regularly over the years for motor blood and tissue sample. Without Moore's knowledge, Gould used his cells to develop a valuable cell line.

SPEAKER_00The University of California obtained a patent on it. They issued March, that was issued March 20th, 1984, listing Gold and a researcher, Shirley Kwand, as inventors. Gould signed deals with Genetics Institute and Sandas pharmaceuticals to develop the sign the cell line commercially. According to the Embryo Project's account, Moore had signed a consent form once, but refused to sign his rights away at later visits.

SPEAKER_00In 1983, Gould asked him to come back to correct what Gould described as a mistake. Moore grew suspicious, found a lawyer, and sued. The California Supreme Court ruled 4-3 that Moore had no property rights in his cells once they were removed from his body. The majority wrote that the cells were no more unique to Moore than the number of vertebrae in his spine or the chemical formula of hemoglobin.

SPEAKER_00But the court also held that a doctor must disclose his financial interest in a patient's tissue, and that failing to do so could give rise to a claim for breach of fiduciary duty or lack of informed consent. Do not skip past what that means. The court said you do not own your own cells, but your doctor has to tell you if he's getting rich off of them. That is the law that Henry and his family and every patient in America has lived under four decades.

SPEAKER_00My opinion, it tells you who the system was built to protect. A cell line can be worth a fortune to a university and two drug companies. And the person it came from can be told politely that it was never theirs. And I think that that's infuriating. The ripples of the Lax case reached federal policy too. Regulators proposed a change to the federal research rules known as the common rule, and that would have required consent before researchers use even anonymous leftover tissue samples.

SPEAKER_00Science reported that the proposal was inspired by the case of Henrietta Lax. But when the final rule came out, HHS and 15 other agencies dropped that biospecimen provision, citing concerns about complexity. They revised the common rule, took effect in January of 2018, with a compromise. Researchers may obtain broad consent for storing and using biospecimens in future research.

SPEAKER_00Samples today are typically labeled with code numbers rather than initials. By 2013, 62 years after her death, Henrietta Lax was in the news again, and for the same reason, somebody had done something with her without asking. In the spring of 2013, a research team in Germany at the European Molecular Biology Laboratory sequenced the entire genome of a Gila cell line and posted it in a public database.

SPEAKER_00Nobody contacted the Lax family, and the scientists had not broken any law. And NPR reported as much. But the posting triggered strong reactions from bioethicists, Haitian advocates, and above all from the Lax family. Because hidden in the genome is information about the person it came from, and by extension, her descendants. NIH director Francis Collins explained the concern this way.

SPEAKER_00And he says the cells contain within them the original information that Henrietta was born with. And it is possible to go back and discern some of her hereditary information, which of course is then information she may have passed on to her children and grandchildren. That includes, as ADPR put it, potential information about the descendant's risk for conditions such as Alzheimer's disease or bipolar disorder. The German team may well quickly apologized and they took the data down.

SPEAKER_00The second HELO genome paper from the University of Washington group was under consideration at Nature and was put on hold. NIJ did something unusual. It sat down with the family. And on August 7, 2013, NIH announced the NIH-LAX family agreement. Researchers who wanted control access to Gila whole genome data must apply, and their requests were reviewed by a working group that includes two members of the Lax family.

SPEAKER_00Users must use the data only for biomedical research, disclose any commercial plans, and acknowledge the family and Henrietta's contribution in their publications. Colin said, NIH is grateful to this remarkable family for their willingness to collaborate with us on this very important issue. Now, Rebecca Sklut, she weighed in with a sentence that, to my mind, carried the whole story.

SPEAKER_00She said, the publication of the Gila genome without consent isn't an example of a few researchers making a mistake. The whole system allowed it. Everyone involved followed standard practices. So everyone involved followed standard practices. That is the thread through this whole case from a 1951 operating room to a 2013 database. And it is exactly what enrages me.

SPEAKER_00Nobody in the chain thought they were doing anything wrong because the system was built so that nobody had to think. Now I want to bring this story home to Kansas because there is a chapter of it that happened in my own part of the Verval. Between January 15, 1974, and January 19, 1991, a man in the Wichita area murdered 10 people. And he gave himself a name, BTK, for bind, torture, kill.

SPEAKER_00And he first used it in an October 1974 letter to the Wichita Eagle, claiming responsibility for the murders of the Otero family. He lived in Park City, a Wichita suburb, in a house he had bought around 1971. And for 31 years, police never caught him. His name was Dennis Rader, and the break of the case came in February of 2005. And on January 16th, Rader mailed a purple floppy disc to a Wichita television station.

SPEAKER_00Investigators found metadata hidden in a deleted Microsoft Word document on that disc. A church meeting agenda. Written and edited by Rader himself, containing the words Christ Lutheran Church and marked as the last modified by Dennis. And a quick internet search showed that a man named Dennis Rader was president of that church's council. And that was a strong lead, of course. But a lead is not conviction.

SPEAKER_00Police needed DNA, and they had DNA from under Vicky Weggerly's fingernails, and she was murdered in 1986. What they did not have was a sample from Dennis himself. So what they did is they had access to a sample from his daughter, Carrie Rawson. Authorities obtained a warrant to test a pap smear specimen collected from her at the Kansas State University Medical Clinic.

SPEAKER_00They compared its DNA to the DNA under Vicky Weggerly's fingernails, and it came back a familial match. Whoever left that DNA was closely related to Carrie Rawson. Add the floppy disk and add a black Jeep Cherokee that had been spotted at his home, and the police had enough. Rader was arrested on February 25th, 2005, near his home in Park City, and he told an officer, Oh, I have suspicions why.

SPEAKER_00On June 27, 2005, Rader pleaded guilty to 10 murders. And August 18th, he was sentenced to 10 consecutive life sentences, a minimum of 175 years. A note on the sources, though. Most accounts say police obtained a warrant for the Pap smear. A 2009 article in the Stanford Journal of Law, Science, and Policy by Taniil Brown and Kelly Lowenberg said police subpoenaed it from a local clinic, and it uses the case as the opening example of law enforcement reaching into stored medical samples.

SPEAKER_00A warrant and a subpoena are different legal tools, and applying that because the accounts do not agree on which one was used. And I want to be clear about something else. I could not find any account of when or why that sample was taken beyond the fact that it was at a KSU clinic or of what Carrie Rawson was told about. Some coverage describes her as unwitting, but guessing at what she knew or what she felt is not my place.

SPEAKER_00That belongs to her. So here's my opinion. Okay. Catching BTK, of course, was a good thing. Yeah, two people were dead, their family's waiting 31 years. I'm glad he's in a cell over there at the El Dorado Correctionals facility, which is about 45 minutes from my personal home. That is not the part that forrifies me. What forrifies me is how when I first learned that detectives used a woman's pap smear to make a familial DNA match, I was actually astounded.

SPEAKER_00Every time I had had a pap smear, I handed the sample over to exam it, and I assumed that that was the beginning and end of it, tested and then properly discovered. Nobody at the prognosis or on paper ever told me it would be kept. Nobody told me it holds my DNA or that somebody with the right piece of paper could go and get it. And here's the fact that most people never hear the federal lab regulations know. As CLIA require laboratories to retain cytology slide preparations, which is the category PAPS smears all into for at least five years from the date of examination.

SPEAKER_00The wording in the federal writing that 42 CFR 493.1105 is that labs must retain cytology slide preparations for at least five years from the date of examination. So the clinic holding onto that sample after it had been tested for cancer was most likely routine and required. I'm gonna tell you the specifics of case SU's practice, but I'm just not accusing anyone of breaking a rule.

SPEAKER_00But when you see language like that, how do you know that that's actually like I I as a common person, a lay person, not up to, you know, maybe medical knowledge. I didn't know that they kept your specimen, your biopsies, your DNA, and then they could use it for whatever they want, right? Which is exactly my point. The scandal here is not that somebody broke the law, it is that nobody had to break it.

SPEAKER_00The rule says that the sample stays and the paperwork says nothing you would notice. And years later, a detective with a warrant can walk in and ask for it. So there are three different systems, each perfectly legal, each invisible to the woman laying on the table. And I would have wanted that in plain English before they signed anything. And I believe these institutions and the government have no right to our bodies without our consent, not our blood, not our tissue, not the DNA inside them, not for research, not for a database.

SPEAKER_00How scary is that? And not even for a cause as good as solving a lot of world problems or catching BTK. If the cause is that good, they can ask us. And I know the law says something different today in that gap between what the law allows and what I believe is my sole complaint. So notice the three layers because each one is documented. First, retention, the federal rule keeps the sample after the test.

SPEAKER_00Second, reuse, as we saw with Henrietta and John Moore. A sample can be used in research, whether that requires your permission depends on the rules and the form you signed. And third, police oxis. With a warrant or subpoena, investigators can get the stored samples as they did in this case. And notice how it echoes Henrietta. Francis Collins said her cells carry hereditary information about her descendants. A sample from one person can speak for an entire family, including people who never signed a single theme.

SPEAKER_00In 2013, the world debated that with a genome. And in 2005, in Kansas, a detective used it to identify a father through his daughter. So time killers, um, when you had a pap smear or a biopsy or blood work, did anyone explain to you in plain English what happens to the sample afterwards? Or did you sign something that you did not fully understand? I'd love to hear from you on this topic.

SPEAKER_00So, in 2010, the same year Sklut's book was published, a physician named Dr. Roland Potillo of the Morehouse School of Medicine donated a headstone for Henrietta's unmarked grave at Laxtown. After reading the book, her family raised money for a headstone for Elsie and both were dedicated the same day. Sklut also created the Henrietta Lax Foundation that year to provide financial help to people who had made contributions to research without their knowledge or consent.

SPEAKER_00Beginning with Henrietta's own descendants, and according to Sklut's site, the foundation had covered tuition and books for Henrietta's grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and great, great-grandchildren. John Hopkins responded to the book with a statement acknowledging the contribution of Henrietta Lax and the Gila cells, and saying that Hopkins never patented Gila cells, never sold them, and never benefited from them financially in a direct way.

SPEAKER_00Sflut notes that the statement did not address the use of Henrietta's children in research without consent. And Hopkins' current page on her legacy goes further in a line I find striking. It said, John Hopkins could have and should have done more to inform and work with members of Henrietta Lack's family out of respect for them, their privacy, and their personal interests. That same page calls the collection of hersells an acceptable and legal practice in the 1950s.

SPEAKER_00Then came the recognition, arrived in Waits. On January 5th, 2021, the Henrietta Lacks Enhancing Cancer Research Act became MOP, directing the government accountability office to study the barriers keeping unrepresented groups out of federally funded cancer clinical trials. The G8O delivered its report in December of 2022. And on October 4th, 2021, the 17th anniversary of her death, a statue of Henriana was unveiled in Bristol, England, and nine days later, on October 13th, the World Health Organization's Director General, Dr.

SPEAKER_00Tedros Adhanam uh Gabra Gabracias is his last name, presented a post-humous award to her 87-year-old son, Lawrence Lax, at the Who headquarters in Geneva. Tedros did not mince words. He said, What happened to Henrietta was wrong, and Henrietta of Lax was exploited. She is one of the many women of color whose bodies have been misused by science.

SPEAKER_00Tedros continued, many people had benefited from those cells. Fortunes have been made. Science has been advanced. Nobel prizes have been won, and most importantly, many lives have been saved. No doubt Henrietta would have been pleased that her suffering had saved others. But the in doesn't justify the means. He also pointed out the irony that cervical cancer, the disease that killed her, can now be prevented in part through an HPV vaccine developed with help from Gila cells.

SPEAKER_00Yet the WHO said that as part of the year before, fewer than 20% 25% of low-income countries, fewer than 30% lower medical, lower middle income countries had access to that HPV vaccine through national immunization programs compared with more than 85% of high-income countries. So just think about that gap. The black woman with a from a tobacco farm, she dies of cervical cancer.

SPEAKER_00Her cells help be build the vaccine that can prevent it. And the countries with the least money are the ones that are the least likely to have the vaccine. So back to the story on October 4th, 2024, 2021, sorry. Exactly 70 years after her death, the estate of Henrietta Lax filed a federal lawsuit against Thermo Fisher Scientific, a Massachusetts-based science and technology company.

SPEAKER_00The complaint alleged that ThermoFisher sold Gila-derived products, including things like peptide and RNA standards and contract development and manufacturing services, and knowingly profited from a sell line taken without the consent. In the complaint's words, LAX family, sorry, LAX estate and family haven't seen a dummy. Notice what the lawsuit did not claim.

SPEAKER_00It did not say the original 1951 taking was illegal. It could not say, right? Because it was not. The claim was unjust in Richmond. And that company was continuing to profit long after the origin of Gila became widely known from something that should have been the estate. The family's lawyers wrote: Black suffering has fueled innumerable medical progress and profit without just compensation or recognition.

SPEAKER_00And too often the history of medical experimentation in the United States has been the history of medical racism. Thermo Fisher tried to get the case thrown out, arguing the statute of limitations had expired. The family's attorneys argued that the company was still benefiting from the cells today. And then on August 1st, 2023, which would have been Henrietta's 103rd birthday, they announced a settlement.

SPEAKER_00The terms are confidential, attorney Ben Krupp told reporters. I can think of no better prose on what would have been Henrietta Lacks' honor and bird birthday than to give her family some measure of respect for Henrietta Lax, some measure of dignity for Henrietta Lex, and most of all, some measure of justice for Henrietta Lax. He also said, not only were the Gila cells derived from Henrietta Lex, the Gila cells are Henrietta Lux.

SPEAKER_00And nine days later, on August 10, 2023, the estate filed a second suit against Ultragenics, the pharmaceutical of Nevada, it's Novato, California. The estate's complaint says that Ultragenics, a company developed treatments for rare diseases, uses GELA cells as the engine of a proprietary manufacturing platform for gene therapy. And according to court records, Ultragenics' own chief scientific officer described the platform this way: We like to think of this as letting biology do the work.

SPEAKER_00In the estate selling the company used Gila cells like a dairy farm treats cows. Ultragenics denies the allegations and is argued that the estate sued the wrong defendant using an invalid legal theory in pursuit of huge profits that do not exist and that the claim was filed too late. This is the company side, and you are entitled to hear it. The case went to the U.S. District Judge Deborah L. Boardman in Baltimore.

SPEAKER_00And on May 20th, 2024, in a 76-page opinion, she denied Ultragenics' motion to dismiss. She wrote that if what Lax alleges is true, it is plausible that Ultragenics is liable to Lacks for an unjust enrichment. She rejected the company's argument that its use of HELA cells was too remote from the original takey, writing that it is not law, and that she wrote a side sentence that I love.

SPEAKER_00She said, yet the end of Henrietta Lacks' life was not the end of her story. The company did argued that Maryland statute, which prevented unregistered out-of-state corporations doing business in the state from using a statute of limitations defense, was unconstitutional. And on March 3rd, 2025, Judge Boardman rejected that argument too and ruled that the statute is constitutional and said discovery would proceed.

SPEAKER_00On August 5th, 2024, the estate sued again, this time targeting Navartis, a Swiss pharmaceutical company and Viatris. That's how you say. Oh, wait. Navartis is the Swiss pharmaceutical company and Viatris and its subsidiary Myelin Pharmaceuticals. According to a legal summary, the Navartis complaint cited products including the herpes drug, Van Beer, and CART C cancer therapy, uh, chimrhea, and the gene therapy Zoljin Zima, and noted that Navartis had acknowledged on its own website that LAC cells were surreptitiously commercialized for research purposes without her knowledge.

SPEAKER_00In February of 2026, Novartis settled. The Associated Press reported that the two sides said in a joint statement they were pleased they were able to find a way to resolve this matter filed by Henry Lack Henrietta Lac's estate outside of court. The terms are not public. And the estate's law firm reports it resolved its case with Beatrice in March 26. Also confidentially. As of the most recent public information I could find from the estate lawyers in April of 2026, the ultragenics litigation remained active.

SPEAKER_00Lawsuits move, and by the time we hear this, that could have changed. So check the show notes for updates. So we don't know, you know, anything about the settlements or the dollarabouts outside of those settlement rooms. But what I can tell you is that a family of descendants of a black tobacco farmer from Virginia has now forced three companies to the table. And the legal theory that got them there is unjust enrichment. Claimless says a company should not keep a benefit.

SPEAKER_00It did not. It is my opinion that this is one of the most important consumer fights of our time, and your cells are worth something. That is no longer just a philosophical idea. One more image. On October 2024, John Hopkins broke ground on a 34,000-foot square foot building on its East Baltimore campus, named in honor of Henrietta Lacks.

SPEAKER_00It will sit beside Deering Hull, home of the Berman Institute of Bioethics. Hopkins University President Ron Daniels said at the ceremony, Today we make a concrete commitment to ensure that Henrietta Lacks' name will be as immortal as herself. Her granddaughter, Jerry Lax Y, had said earlier that it is important for us to humanize the Gila cells by acknowledging the contributions Henrietta Lacks unknowingly made to the world.

SPEAKER_00Some of the family's lawyers claim go further than the courts have gone. In a statement accompanying the 2023 Ultragenic suit, the family's legal team said that the retrieval of Henrietta's tissue was part of a conspiracy to harvest tissue for research from black women without their knowledge or consent in racially segregated wards throughout the 1950s. That is an allegation made by the family's attorneys, not a finding by any court, and that's exactly how it should be heard.

SPEAKER_00So let's tie this all up. In 1951, a 31-year-old woman walked into the only big hospital that would treat her and signed a paper that authorized an operation. She trusted the doctors to fix her. While she was under anesthesia, someone took two pieces of her and handed them down a hallway. The pieces did something no human cells had ever done.

SPEAKER_02They lived.

SPEAKER_00Henrietta died eight months later, and her body was sent home to Virginia on a train and buried in the ray, and her family was told nothing about what was still alive in Baltimore. Then those cells they went on to defeat polio, be carried by a team of black scientists at Tuskegee, in the same town where the federal government was letting black men die with untreated syphilis. They went into space, they taught us how viruses cause cancer, and they helped build the HPV vaccine in the science of telonberies.

SPEAKER_00And they became so ubiquitous that they took over other scientists' experiments, forcing the field to admit how careless it had been. So I don't know. I the whole thing just kind of makes me sad because I think that the line that the um what did they say in the midway through the story that the the outcome was worth what happened essentially.

SPEAKER_00I I think that's such a dangerous line to say. I really do. I I really do because you know consent is important and informed consent is important. Informed consent means that you understood what was happening to your body. So this one is just I get it, it did a lot of good. It did a lot of good, that's great, you know, and it you know, our tissue helps catch killers.

SPEAKER_00But it's the not knowing and not having informed consent about what is actually happening to a part of you in your body, that's the part that gives me unease and makes me really, really upset. And I think that, you know, poor Henrietta. The only time she was looked at as a human being is when that lab assistant looked at her red painted top bales. And that makes me sad too.

SPEAKER_00So my last opinion that I'm gonna say tonight is she deserved to be asked. Thank you for killing time with me tonight, and I'll leave the light on, so have a good one.

SPEAKER_01Alexa, what is a chemtrail? Chemtrail. Trails left by aircraft are actually chemical or biological agents deliberately sprayed at high altitudes for a purpose undisclosed to the general public in clandestine programs directed by government officials.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. THE SHKRELI PLAYBOOK - Big Pharma Blocks Generic Manufacturers

    Nov 19, 202629 minAudio

    💊 The Shkreli Playbook: The Wall Around a 62-Year-Old Pill In September 2015, a decades-old medicine for a parasite infection jumped from $13.50 a pill to $750. Everyone remembers the smirk in the hearing room. Almost...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. THE EMPIRE OF PAIN - The Opioid Epidemic

    Nov 17, 202645 minAudio

    💊 A hotel room in Rockville, Maryland. A government doctor. A drug company that needed its painkiller approved. A Justice Department memo says the three days they spent together helped shape the OxyContin label, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. THE WOMAN WHO SAID NO - Thalidomide Samples the FDA Never Tracked

    Nov 5, 202629 minAudio

    💊 On July 15, 1962, The Washington Post called FDA reviewer Dr. Frances Kelsey a hero for keeping thalidomide off the U.S. market. What that front page left out: Richardson-Merrell of Cincinnati had already distributed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. THE SWINE FLU FIASCO - Who Pays When the Vaccine Hurts?

    Nov 3, 202648 minAudio

    💉 Episode 43: The Swine Flu Fiasco (1976), the pandemic that never came. One Army recruit died. The U.S. government vaccinated tens of millions of Americans. The predicted pandemic never arrived. Reports of a rare...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. THE TRUTH ABOUT FLUORIDE - Water, Toothpaste, & the Government

    Oct 27, 202644 minAudio

    🦷 Why is fluoride in America's water and toothpaste? Episode 42 tells the true history of water fluoridation: a Colorado dentist, an Alcoa chemist, Grand Rapids in 1945, Crest toothpaste, and the 2026 court fight. 💧...

    Credit the people on this episode