🩸 They called it "bad blood." It was syphilis - and the U.S. government let it run untreated in 600 Black men for 40 years, on purpose. Episode 37 of Just Killing Time takes you inside the Tuskegee Syphilis Study, the U.S. Public Health Service's 1932-1972 experiment in Macon County, Alabama that has become the defining case study in American medical ethics and government betrayal. Host Elizabeth Stanton walks through the real, documented history: what syphilis and "bad blood" actually meant medically and culturally in the Jim Crow South, the brutal mercury-and-arsenic treatments doctors used before penicillin existed, and exactly how - and why - the government let a curable disease run its full course in human beings who trusted them. 🔍 What you'll learn in this episode: • Why Dr. Thomas Parran's 1929 report named Macon County the "ideal location" for a no-treatment syphilis study • The real folk-medicine meaning of "bad blood," and how the government weaponized a trusted local term • The actual medicine dangled in front of these men - arsenicals, bismuth, mercury, and the deceptive "Last Chance for Special Free Treatment" letters• Nurse Eunice Rivers, the Black public health nurse whose complicated 40-year role in the study is still debated by historians • Whistleblower Peter Buxtun, who was ignored for six years before AP reporter Jean Heller broke the story in 1972 • The $10 million settlement, the National Research Act, the Belmont Report, and how they built the informed-consent rules that govern medicine today • President Clinton's 1997 apology and survivor Herman Shaw's response, in his own words • Why public health officials still cite Tuskegee today when explaining medical mistrust in Black communities This is hidden history - fully documented, apologized for by a sitting U.S. president, and still barely covered in American classrooms. 📖 📚 Sources cited on-air include: Britannica; HISTORY.com; The Washington Post; James H. Jones's "Bad Blood: The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment"; The American Scholar; BET News (Jean Heller interview); OJIN: The Online Journal of Issues in Nursing; Harvard's Schlesinger Library Black Women Oral History Project; The Baltimore Sun; the Clinton White House Archives official transcript; Encyclopedia of Alabama; and Actas Dermo-Sifiliográficas. ❓ Quick facts for anyone searching this case: The Tuskegee Syphilis Study ran from 1932 to 1972 in Macon County, Alabama. It involved 600 Black men - 399 with syphilis, 201 without, as a control group. Researchers told participants they had "bad blood" rather than disclosing their actual diagnosis. At least 28 men died directly of syphilis, roughly 100 more died of related complications, 40 wives were infected, and 19 children were born with congenital syphilis. The study ended after AP journalist Jean Heller's 1972 exposé, and President Clinton formally apologized to survivors in 1997. 💬 Time Killers, this one is heavy - I want to know what stood out to you. Send your thoughts, and if you've got a case for a future Time Killer Files segment, you know where to find me. 🎙️ Just Killing Time is a true crime, conspiracy, and hidden history podcast hosted by Elizabeth Stanton. New episodes cover the cases and cover-ups your history class skipped - the stuff that's HIS-story, not history. Thank you for killing time with me today. 🖤 #Tuskegee #HiddenHistory #TrueCrime #MedicalHistory #GovernmentExperiments #JustKillingTime #TuskegeeSyphilisStudy #BlackHistory #MedicalEthics #ConspiracyPodcast
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00In the fall of 1932, in Macon County, Alabama, hand-painted signs started going up outside churches and country stores. They read, Free Blood Test, Free Treatment by County Health Department and Government Doctor. And underneath, in bigger's letters, you may feel well and still have bad blood. Come and bring your all of your family.
SPEAKER_00You may feel well and still have bad blood. That is not a public health flyer, that is a sales pitch. And the men who answered it were being sold something the government had already decided it would never give them. Six hundred black men in one of the poorest counties in America lined up for what they told was free medical care. 399 of them already had syphilis. 201 did not, and were kept as a comparison group.
SPEAKER_00Not one of the infected men was ever told the word syphilis. They were told they had bad blood. And here's the part that should make your skin crawl before we even get to the details. This didn't happen for six months. It didn't happen for six years. The United States government watched these men die of a curable disease on purpose for 40 years into the Nixon administration, past the Moon Landing, past Woodstock, past the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr.
SPEAKER_00This wasn't the 1800s. Some of these men were still alive when I was a toddler. This is Jess Time. I am your host, Elizabeth Stanton. This is a podcast about truth, crime, conspiracy, stories that keep us up at night, and a little hidden history sprinkled in. Today we are finishing something I started back with The Germ of Laziness. That episode was about hookworm and about a government-backed campaign that treated poor Southern people as specimens to be studied rather than patients to be healed.
SPEAKER_00Now, Tuskegee is the same story, except this time it isn't neglect. This time it's a 40-year decision renewed year after year by educated men in white coats who knew exactly what they were doing.
SPEAKER_00Sypilus is a bacterial infection caused by a corkscrew drip-shaped organism called a spirochete. It's specifically troponia palladia. Okay, maybe that's how you pronounce it, maybe. Left untreated, though, it moves through three stages over years or even decades as a primary sore, a secondary rash and flu like illness, and then a latent period where the person feels fine while the bacteria quietly settles into the heart, the blood vessels, the spinal cord, and the brain.
SPEAKER_00That's the stage called tertiary syphilis, and it can cause blindness, paralysis, dementia, and death. This is the fact my listeners kept flagging me on after the germ of laziness, and they were right too. I glossed over kind of the actual medicine in that episode. I'm not going to do that again today. If you want to ever see how cruel Tuskegee was, you have to understand what these men were denied. In 1932, there was no penicillin yet, and it wouldn't be identified as a syphilis cure until 1943, and wouldn't become the standard treatment until 1947, the year my parents were born.
SPEAKER_00Before that, doctors had exactly two real weapons, and both of them were nearly as brutal as the disease. The first was Mercury, rubbed into the skin as an ointment, injected or even vaporized and inhaled in a fumigation cabinet the patients sat in with their only their heads sticking out. It had been the go-to treatment since the 1500s. And it worked just well enough and poisoned patients just badly enough that doctors coined a grim little rhyme about it.
SPEAKER_00A night with Venus, a lifetime with mercury. Mercury caused kidney damage, tremors, mouth ulcers, and tooth loss on top of whatever the syphilis was already doing. It's crazy. The little rhyme A night with Venus, a lifetime with mercury. Interesting. Now the second newer option was arsenic based. Well that sounds good, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_00In 1910, a German physician named Paul Ehrlich, he developed a drug called arseninamine. So arsenamine, marketed as salvarcidian, and doctors nicknamed it simply 606 because it was the 606th compound Ehrlich's lab had tested. A follow-up version, Neosalvarcidian. How much fun are you guys listening to me try to butcher the pronunciation of these medicines and drugs?
SPEAKER_00I mean, you're gonna have to bear and grin with me because I'm just doing a terrible job. So Neosalvaricin came back a few years later and they were injected weekly, sometimes for a year or more, often paired with bismuth injections as a third drug in the rotation. The full course was called 606 therapy, and it was miserable. Arsenic toxicity, abscesses at the injection site, liver damage, but it was, at the time, the closest thing to a real cure medicine hat.
SPEAKER_00So let's be honest about what treatment meant in 1932. It meant choosing between mercury poisoning and arsenic poisoning, delivered in weekly shots for the better part of a year at a clinic most rural black sharecroppers in Alabama couldn't get to and couldn't afford. That is the medical reality the Public Health Service was working with when they designed this study. And it matters because it's exactly the gap they exploited.
SPEAKER_00The road to Tuskegee starts a few years earlier with a public health official named Dr. Thomas Perrin Jr. And in the late 1920s, the Rosenwald Fund, a philanthropy started by Sears Roebuck executive Julius Rosenwald, paid for syphilis testing in a treatment demonstration project across several counties in the Deep South using the arsenic and bismodes region we had just described.
SPEAKER_00Regimen that we had just described. So I'm going to butcher all the words today. Looks like.
SPEAKER_00Sulfur and molasses tonics, sassafras, tea, iron tonics, sometimes literal bloodletting. Passed down the same way, home remedies get passed out anywhere poor people don't have reliable access to doctors. And that's exactly why bad blood was the perfect lie. The public health service didn't invent a scary new word to trick these men. They reached into a phrase these families already trusted. One that meant something's wrong, but it's manageable.
SPEAKER_00And it's ours. It's not a shameful like the other word. They weaponized a bulk term, specifically because it was gentler than the truth. And the offer wrapped around that word was genuinely appealing to men who had almost no access to medicine of any kind. Free transportation to and from the clinic, a free physical exam, free hot meals on exam days, and this detail that historians point to again again as the study's cruelest hook.
SPEAKER_00Free burial insurance. In the Jim Crow South, a proper burial was a real financial burden for a sharecropping family. The Melbourne Fund in New York philanthropy quietly paid the Tuskegee Institute to cover burial costs for men who died during the study. On the condition that the family allow an autopsy first.
SPEAKER_00That just takes my breath away, you guys. Oh, it's so gross. I mean for anybody that says the government, oh, they would never do that. Oh yes, they would. And all you need to say back to that ignorant person is Tuskegee. So the government tangled a dignified funeral in front of dying men, and the price of that dignity was permission to cut them open when they finally succumbed to the very disease the government refused to cure even though they had a cure.
SPEAKER_00Let that sink in. And this is the medicine detail I most wanted correct. Some of the men actually were given real treatment at the very start. In the studies early months before the funding fully collapsed, a subset of the men received partial courses of the arsenic and bismuth regimen. Not enough to cure anyone, but real injections of real quote unquote medicine.
SPEAKER_00It was just enough to be worse than nothing because half-treating syphilis can drive the infection into hiding without actually killing it, while still exposing the men to the drug's toxic side effects. When the money ran out, the partial treatment stopped entirely. And from that point forward, for the rest of the study's life, the only quote unquote treatment administered was aspirin and iron tonic, dispensed for symptom relief, dressed up in front of men as ongoing care.
SPEAKER_00Later, when the public health service wanted more invasive data, specifically spinal fluid samples to track how far the disease had progressed into the nervous system, they didn't ask for volunteers for a free for a diagnostic procedure. They mailed every man a letter with the header Last Chance for Special Free Treatment. Inviting them in for what the letter implied was a curative shot. And what actually happened was a lumbar puncture, a spinal tap performed without effective anesthesia, a procedure that even today causes painful and sometimes weeks-long headaches.
SPEAKER_00And it offered these men nothing therapeutic. It was a pure data collection sold to them as their best chance at a cure. No single person kept this study alive longer than the black public health nurse named Eunice Rivers. She was born in 1899 in Georgia, trained as a nurse at the Tuskegee Institute, and was pulled into the study in 1932 as its scientific assistant and in practice its glue.
SPEAKER_00The one constant presence across all four decades. Long after the original PHS doctors had rotated through and moved on to other postings. Now, Rivers, she drove out to the men's farms. She knew their wives and children by name. She scheduled their exams, chased them down when they missed appointments, and according to her own 1977 oral history interview held at Harvard's Schlesinger Library, she saw her job as looking up for these men's welfare with an assistant she didn't control.
SPEAKER_00She also, by her own account and by the study's own records, was the one who kept them coming back for 40 years. Which meant she was also the one who kept them from seeking treatment anywhere else. Historians are genuinely split on how to hold Nurse Rivers. And I'm not gonna pretend it's simple because it isn't. Some view her as complicit, a black woman who used her position and education to preserve her own employment and status while helping white doctors exploit men who look like her father, her brothers, her neighbors.
SPEAKER_00While others argue, she was doing the only thing that felt like agency inside a system stacked entirely against her and against them. Staying close enough to the men to bring them small comforts, vitamins, a sympathetic ear, rides to the doctor in a study she had no power to shut down. I don't land on that side. I don't land on that side.
SPEAKER_00She was not there to help them. She knew what was going on, and she drove them to their appointments. And she helped that machine run for 40 years, killing the very people who trusted her. That is beyond disgusting and gross, and I hope she rots for it. That's my personal opinion. I hope that she burns. So this study, it was budgeted for six months in 1932, was still running into 1972.
SPEAKER_001972. In that time, the world changed almost beyond recognition around these 600 men. World War II came and went. The Nuremberg trials produced the Nuremberg Code in 1947, the first international standard demanding informed consent for medical research written specifically in response to Nazi doctors experimenting on concentration camp prisoners.
SPEAKER_00And the Tuskegee experiment kept running by the public health service. They kept going. In spite of all that. And I think that they're personally no better than the Nazi doctors who experimented on their captives. So that timing's, I'm gonna say not a coincidence. That last year the civilized world formally declared that using human beings as research subjects without their consent, that's important to know, and that it was a crime against humanity.
SPEAKER_00The United States government was in year 15. I'm doing precisely that to its own citizens. Let that sink in. Then in 1943, researchers confirmed penicillin cured syphilis. By 1947, it was recommended standard of care nationwide. It was cheap, fast, and dramatically safer than the old arsenic mercury regimens.
SPEAKER_00The Tuskegee study had already collected 15 years of data at that point. This was the moment to end it. Instead, PHS officials made active, documented efforts to keep their subjects away from penicillin, writing to local draft boards to have them in excused from military service specifically so they wouldn't be treated for syphilis as part of a service physical and coordinating with area doctors and health departments to keep the men out of any clinic that might cure them.
SPEAKER_00How unbelievable and evil is that? It's just beyond reprehensible. So by the time the study finally ended, the human cost was cataloged in the study's own. Follow-up record. Of the original 399 infected men, at least 28 had died directly of syphilis, and roughly a higher more had died of related complications.
SPEAKER_00And at least 40 wives had contracted the disease from their husbands. 19 children had been born with congenital syphilis, passed from mother to infant in the womb, causing bone deformities, blindness, deafness, and organ damage in children who were never part of the study and never gave consent to anything. And they never had a chance. Those 19 children were the detail that kind of undoes me.
SPEAKER_00Every time I think about this case, this wasn't contained to 600 men who, wow, that's unfair, at least walked into the clinic themselves, but the government's decision reached into Krims. I I still don't think, and this is Elizabeth talkie. I don't think the numbers are correct. There's no way the 600 men walked into clinics and only that many died of synthesis.
SPEAKER_00I just don't think so. I think that history is written by the winners and the victors, and that is his story to tell. And I think that they watered this down. I just think that it doesn't. The math does not math in my mind. So, back to the story. The person who's most responsible for ending this study is a man most Americans have never heard. His name was Pierre Buxton.
SPEAKER_00Buxton was a young public health service venereal disease investigator working in San Francisco in the mid-1960s when he came across the study's records almost by accident. He was doing casework in his own job. He was appalled. And he did exactly what you're supposed to do inside a bureaucracy. He raised it through the chain of command. And in November of 1966, he filed a formal retin protest with the PHS Division of Banereal Diseases on ethical grounds.
SPEAKER_00It was rejected. The study, they told him, wasn't finished yet. Seven months after Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in 1968, Buxton filed a second protest, this time explicitly warning that the study was a political liability given the country's racial climate. Again, he was told his concerns were irrelevant, and according to later accounts, he was summoned to Atlanta and personally admonished by senior CDC officials and told in essence to drop it and get back to work.
SPEAKER_00By his own later description, Buxton had also years earlier compared what he was seeing to the Nazi medical experiments he'd heard about growing up, and he was an Australian Austrian, sorry, Austrian born Jewish refugee whose family had fled the Nazis in 1938. The comparison was not made lightly, and it was not received well.
SPEAKER_00Every institution has a Peter Buxton somewhere in its history, the person who says the quiet thing out loud, twice in writing, through the proper channels, and gets told to sit down. What makes the story remarkable isn't that he raises the alarm, it's that the system ignored him completely. And he didn't let it go. Buxton eventually left the public health service for law school, but the study never stopped gnawing at him.
SPEAKER_00Around 1972, he gave his documents to a friend, an associated press reporter Edith Letterler. According to Letter's own later recollection, when Buxton first described the study to Bert over dinner, she asked, What? Black people? All of the b and then asked to see his paperwork. Spranted across his couch and told him, I was horrified. Letterer's bureau decided the story needed a more experienced investigative reporter, so she passed the documents to a colleague in the AP Washington's office, Gene Heller.
SPEAKER_00On July 25th, 1972, Gene Heller's story ran under the headline Simplest Victims in U.S. Study went untreated for 40 years. It first appeared in the Washington Star and was on the prep page of the New York Times that very next day. Heller, then 29 years old, and the only woman on the AP's special assignment team, later called it, in her own words, one of the grossest violations of human rights I can imagine.
SPEAKER_00Notice what it took to end 40 years of government sanctioned horror. Not an internal review, not a whistleblower hotline, not a congressional oversight committee doing its job. It took one reporter, one leaked file, and one newspaper willing to print it. Now the public's reaction was immediate and furious. Senator Edward Kennedy called congressional hearings at which Buxton himself testified alongside officials from the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.
SPEAKER_00Under that pressure, an ad hoc advisory panel was convened in August of 1972, and by the fall, the Tuskegee study of untreated civilists in the Negro Mail, 40 years, six months, and a promise it never intended to keep was finally, formally shut down. A civil rights attorney named Fred Gray filed a class action lawsuit on behalf of the study's survivors and the families of the deceased.
SPEAKER_00In 1974, the government settled out of court for$10 million. Good board, that's not enough money. That's just not enough money. And it was to be divided among survivors, spouses, and children, along with the government commitment to provide free medical care for the rest of the surviving men's lives, later extended to their wives and children who'd been infected. Raise your hand if you want medical care from the government.
SPEAKER_00I don't think those people did. That same year, 1974, Congress passed the National Research Act, which created the Institutional Review Boards, the ethic committees that today must approve and monitor any study involving human subjects at essentially every hospital, university, and research institution in America. In 1979, the commission created by that act published what's known as the Belmont Report, which laid out a core ethical principle, respect for persons, benefits, and justice that still govern human research to this day.
SPEAKER_00Every consent form you've ever signed at a doctor's offer or office or clinical trial exists in some direct lineage because of what happened in Macon County, Alabama. It took another 23 years for a president to say the word sorry out loud. On May 16, 1997, in the East Room of the White House, President Bill Clinton formally apologized to the study's eight surviving participants.
SPEAKER_00Five of them, Herman Shaw, Charlie Pollard, Carver Howard, Fred Simons, and Frederick Moss were present in person, along with the Congressional Black Caucus and Fred Gray, the attorney who had fought their case decades earlier. Clinton's words, read from the official White House transcript, said this. The United States government did something that was wrong, deeply, profoundly morally wrong.
SPEAKER_00It was an outrage to our commitment to integrity and equality for all of our citizens. We can look you in the eye and finally say on behalf of the American people, what the United States government did was shameful. And I am sorry. Herman Shaw was then about to turn 95, had spent 65 years leaving, he'd walked into a church one day in 1932 for free health care and gotten it.
SPEAKER_00He told the room this. And in another point that day, quote Shaw was quoted as saying this. In my opinion, it is never too late to work to restore faith and trust. So listening to that, I keep coming back to the word voice.
SPEAKER_00Not we were tricked, we were victims. He said we were men. Sixty-five years after the fact, that was still the dignity he needed to have for the name on record. And I believe Herman Shaw is a better man than I am. If that had happened to me or my loved ones, I don't know if it would be, in my opinion, never too late to work to restore faith and trust.
SPEAKER_00Time killers, what do you think? Now the damage from Tuskegee did not stay contained to Macon County or the 20th century. Public health researchers and physicians, including officials at the CDC, have repeatedly pointed to Tuskegee by name when explaining persistent, measurable distrust of the medical system alone from black Americans. Distrust that surfaced again during the COVID-19 vaccine rollout in 2020 and 2021, when public health officials specifically cited Tuskegee as one reason they had to work harder to burn trust in black communities.
SPEAKER_00I don't think that was the case. I just think that lots of Americans chose not to trust the science because the science is written by people that may not have your best interest in mind. And I want to say this Tuskegee wasn't even the last chapter. In 2010, historian Susan Reverby uncovered a related earlier PHS program, one where American researchers, several of the same names, deliberately infected Guatemalan prisoners, soldiers, and psychiatric patients with syplis and gailrhea between 1946 and 1948, without their knowledge or consent to study prevention methods.
SPEAKER_00And President Obama apologized to Guatemala's government for that one in 2010. Still being bought and sold today while her own family lived without health insurance for decades. Tuskegee is not an isolated, ugly chapter.
SPEAKER_00It's a pattern. And once you see the pattern, you can't funsee it. So, for example, last night my family watched that mid-1990s movie storing Dustin Hoffman and Rene Russo, and it was called Outbreak. And it was about a virus that was contracted and started spreading through a very small California town. And the government's um what they decided that they wanted to do in order to contain that virus and be able to keep that biological weapon was they wanted to wipe out the entire town, all 26 foot then.
SPEAKER_00And it was, you know, of course, the heroes in the movie, Dustin Hoffman and Kiwi Getting Jr., that said, no, we're not gonna let that happen. And they, of course, didn't, and that's how the movie was. I totally highly recommend you to watch that movie because um, while it is Hollywood and it is the made-up story, I still think that it's interesting in the parallels on how you see the government respond to different things, especially when it comes to medicine and commercial law and who gets treated and who doesn't.
SPEAKER_00So, just a little homework on the side for you, time killers. If you've not seen that movie, it is a good one. And I watched it with my daughters who had not seen it, so that we could talk about some life lessons that you can learn from that movie. Now let's close this episode. We have 600 men who answered a sign promising them dignity and cure. What they got back was instead four decades of being watched, measured, and quietly denied a cure that existed the entire back half of that study.
SPEAKER_00Twenty-eight of them died of the disease outright, a hundred more died of what it did to their hearts and their minds, and forty wives caught it from their husbands who never knew to warn them. Nineteen babies were born already carrying it, and one nurse held that entire operation together with kindness, I say facetiously. And she did more harm than good. Thank God for that one whistleblower who spent six years being told to be quiet and refused.
SPEAKER_00And thank God for the reporter who turned his documents into a front page story that finally, finally made it stop. And 25 years after that, one president stood in the East Room and said the two words that those men had waited their entire lives to hear. If you take one thing from this episode, Time Close, let it be this hidden history isn't always a shadowy government file buried in a bolt somewhere. Sometimes it's in flame sight in the National Archives, apologized for on live television, and still most of us never get taught it in school.
SPEAKER_00And that is not an accident either. That's a choice about what gets called history and what gets left out of it. Thank you for again killing some time with me today. Alexa, what is a chemtrail? Chemtrail. Trails left by aircraft are actually chemical or biological agents deliberately sprayed at high altitudes for a purpose undisclosed to the general public in clandestine programs directed by government officials.
💊 The Shkreli Playbook: The Wall Around a 62-Year-Old Pill In September 2015, a decades-old medicine for a parasite infection jumped from $13.50 a pill to $750. Everyone remembers the smirk in the hearing room. Almost...
💊 A hotel room in Rockville, Maryland. A government doctor. A drug company that needed its painkiller approved. A Justice Department memo says the three days they spent together helped shape the OxyContin label, and...
💊 On July 15, 1962, The Washington Post called FDA reviewer Dr. Frances Kelsey a hero for keeping thalidomide off the U.S. market. What that front page left out: Richardson-Merrell of Cincinnati had already distributed...
💉 Episode 43: The Swine Flu Fiasco (1976), the pandemic that never came. One Army recruit died. The U.S. government vaccinated tens of millions of Americans. The predicted pandemic never arrived. Reports of a rare...
🦷 Why is fluoride in America's water and toothpaste? Episode 42 tells the true history of water fluoridation: a Colorado dentist, an Alcoa chemist, Grand Rapids in 1945, Crest toothpaste, and the 2026 court fight. 💧...