Hello folks, welcome to a special TSB program covering the Canvas hack. How bad is it? What is known? How does it compare to other breaches like PowerSchool and others? We'll discuss it from within this podcast. Here are articles that we've read that have covered the saga from when we've laid eyes on it. This is not everything, and some of this may be blogged on our blog. Instructure hacker claims data theft from 8,800 schools, universities What we know about the Canvas hack that has impacted thousands of schools Instructure confirms hackers used Canvas flaw to deface portals Instructure reaches 'agreement' with ShinyHunters to stop data leak US govt seeks Instructure testimony on massive Canvas cyberattack There are other outlets also covering this, including the BBC, PC Magazine, The Cyberwire Podcast, and more. We are not reading and discussing any particular article, we're painting a picture of what seems to be the overall problem and how Canvas is now joining the party of very large breaches. Their PR was great, telling users what was going on, but yet, when you hear how the actors got in, you'll start wondering. Contact information is going to be given throughout the program, and thanks so much for listening to this special program. See you next time!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The opinions expressed are those of the show hosts and may not necessarily be of any company in which the show hosts may represent. The following podcast may contain some strong language. Parental discretion is advised. The Security Box, Program
272, Intermediate A. Canvas. Hello everybody, welcome to the Security Box program number 272A.
I'm Jared Reimer. The whole Security Box and Throwback group is along to talk to you about Canvas. The biggest educational breach we have ever seen to date. Could it get worse? Probably. We talk about numbers. We talk about how these things work in the accessibility realm based
on the fact that you can, in theory, use them to communicate with your instructor. And we talk about a whole bunch of other stuff too. We even have a little bit of errata at the end. covering some of the other items that have been posted to the blog. The show notes contain some of the articles that have been read. However, there
may be other coverage that we did not link to that's out there. And, of course, other podcasts that are talking about this as well. Remember that this is a developing story. And if things change, we will definitely try and keep our eyes and ears on it. Since I know I've got sighted podcast listeners. I did not give out any contact
information for today's program, so let me quickly do that now. You may email or send an iMessage to tech, that's T -E -C -H, at m. as in Mike, E -N -V -I dot org. You may call my comment line at 888 -405 -7524 or you may go ahead and catch
me by text or WhatsApp at 804 -442 -6975. And now, without any further ado, let's go ahead and get started. You've got Jared Reimer, Preston Gaylor, Nicholas Jackson, and Terry Ring from Woodland Hills, California, Chicago, Illinois,
Santa Barbara, California, suburbs of Pennsylvania. Until next podcast, where we will have a full program talking about news, notes, the landscape, and more, I'm Jared Reimer saying thanks so much for listening, and please, make it a great day.
everybody this is jared this is a special tsb this is program 272 a canvas the biggest breach compared to what to others If you're listening
to this on replay, there may be some other background activity that's beyond our control. What? Do you think, Mr. Ring, this breach could be compared to? No. One of them was in the healthcare industry.
The other is in the educational industry. Here comes a J. Wow. No. Mr. J, what can the canvas breach be considered comparable to? What two
major breaches? Hmm. Well, I did kind of look at your notes, so I'm not sure if that was cheating or not, but let's see. Change healthcare is one of the ones I think that... Change healthcare is correct. Mm -hmm. And then I'll have... That one, for some reason, is not coming to me at the moment, but change healthcare... It's another
educational breach we talked very heavily about. Wait a second. I don't know why it just came to me. It wouldn't happen to be Power School by any chance. Power School's correct. Well, and not having read the article, so that's kind of dangerous, about some of the newest developments,
There was a bit of a rant that I was going to go on, which, given the level of passion I might have about it, might scare you. Well, this is our main topic today. This is a special program because this seems to be a big, huge, developing story. And this is bad because not only are we learning... that this was not actually the first
breach this month. This is the second. This means this agency has had three breaches in a 12 -month period, give or take. It was so bad, Jerry. It was actually on our WGN News side yesterday.
It was so bad that Herbie sent me an article on Sunday and said it was Blackboard. That was why one of my articles stated Blackboard. Yep, I do remember hearing Blackboard was a part of it, too. Blackboard was not a part of it. That's what we... Had to correct. Blackboard is not part of this. Okay, yeah. Got it. Got it. Herbie
sent me the article through Google and he mentioned Blackboard. And I happened to then read it and it was a lengthy 14 -minute CNN article on this very breach. That's why we've been publishing so much lately. For those who are listening via the podcast, you will have a list of everything
that I have. We are not covering any particular article in any detail, but we do have a structure that we're going to follow. And I call this podcast Educational... Infrastructure Under Attack, Canvas, Power School, and Change Healthcare. The Security
Box Podcast 272A Introductions Hello everybody and welcome to the Security Box Podcast 272A. On this program, we are going to discuss a rapidly evolving cybersecurity story involving Canvas by Instructure and how this incident may represent something much larger than a single breach. Over
the last several days, reports have surfaced involving claims of stolen data, portal defacements, and operational disruptions connected to the Canvas learning platform. According to reporting from Bleeping Computer, attackers claimed data theft impacting thousands of schools. and universities, while later reports indicated vulnerabilities
tied to free for teacher infrastructure and defacement activity. But this episode is not simply about one company. This story fits into a broader pattern involving Centralized cloud infrastructure dependency
on software as a service, ecosystems, operational disruption, and the growing cybersecurity risks facing education and other... critical sectors. We are also going to compare this incident with
Power School and Change Healthcare because together these incidents paint a concerning picture about how dependent institutions have become on centralized digital platforms. As always, this is a developing story. Information may change after this recording.
And before we continue, I think I'm just going to change files and kill this idea of reading this version. And I'm going to go to this file. Because I think it'll do a lot better. Even though
it's taking two presses to do one line. So with that in mind, folks, Let's talk about the initial, holy crap, what the hell's going on? Here we are. So, apparently, this started well before
we started blogging and reading. This, apparently, started initially first in late April. Do you think the actors, and we'll talk about who they are in a bit, but how do you think the actors got in? Well, I read some of these, and honestly,
It would not have been the first guess that I would have had. I'm listening. So, as I understand it, it had to do with, I think it was called XSS scripting. XSS scripting, otherwise known as cross -site scripting. Yes. So you think after
the first time they did this, Canvas, or infrastructure in this case, would have gone in and fixed the hole? Yes, sir. What? Just his reaction. That's
why they got in again through the same vulnerability. This time they ended up doing what? If it's what I'm thinking of, it's defacing the portal so that if anybody logs in during that time, they
get a message that basically says, your school has been hit. Correct. Defacement is correct. And that's not... I mean, defacement goes back to when we covered it. Oh, God. Probably 20 years ago. 15, 20 years ago. So it's not even anything new. No. But it's not typically done. So... This
is not the first go -around for these guys. In fact, if you read the blog, how many of those names in one of the stories where they recapped everything this group has done, how many of those companies sounded familiar to you? Too many.
Including one we just covered on a regular TSB, not an A, B, or C. And you could tell when I started writing this up that I so... Wanted to go on another diatribe. Because as you'll see.
I think. When I shoved everything. Up chat GPT. And it gave me these notes. Which I did. Rework and make them more paragraph friendly. Because it does short paragraphs for some reason. Sometimes I like them, sometimes I don't. But when I did
this and maybe added a sentence or two from the text file that Terry has. I think it did a great job. All of the links, including the ones that we added about the potential so -called payment, we don't want to say it's a payment. We'll call
it what it is, an agreement. And I really don't like... The way that this is done. Because you cannot shred the evidence. Bleak Bing Computer has it in screenshots on their articles. And that leads me. And that leads me. I've got to
warn you. That leads me to the passionate thing I was going to get into. Do you want to do it before we get into our first segment? Yes, because I think if we get into our first segment, then this is going to feel way unrelated. I thought a background would be more appropriate first. Yeah. And then we'd do a few questions, see how many people were reading. And then we'll get
to work tearing this apart. Mm -hmm. Go ahead, Mr. J. All right. So if, in fact, keyword, if, in fact, a payment was made, I'm going to start by saying that I do understand the quandary in which this company found itself however that
being said this kind of reaction and again keyword if there was a payment made makes me want to bang my fucking head against the wall because because What this is going to do is essentially, as I said, not confirmed yet, but if it turns
out to be true, it will send a message to all fucking cyber criminals that this shit works. And the payments, assuming that this was made, are going to get bigger and bigger and fucking bigger, and they're going to be in the fucking billions before you know it. And the other issue I have with this, why in the absolute fuck do
you trust these people? I get that, again, you're in a bit of a quandary. Timing is awful. But... Do you really, for one damn second, believe that they're absolutely going to keep their word? These are fucking cyber criminals you're dealing with, not honest, wonderful men of integrity or people of integrity who give a shit about being honest. I mean, I know there's a lot to
be seen, but by doing this, And I think what's infuriating is that there's a lot of shit to draw on. Other companies in other sectors have done this, and look where the hell it got them. You're not wrong. And that's the question. Where did it get them, Mr. J? It got their data leaked
anyway, and in some cases, they got hit again. Well, double extortion, as the term is defined, is not... exactly done that way. Double extortion
means you get extorted to so -called restore your data. Then they want you to pay them to, quote, delete or, as it's being mentioned here, shred. The data. That's double extortion, Terry. Double extortion, if they come back to you and
hack you again, that would be a single extortion attempt again, not double. And it's even gotten so bad that we've even seen a couple of cases. of triple or even quadruple extortion attempts in a single transactional period set. It would
not surprise me if this gets into the billions, and it would not surprise me if Nick was right. And it's probably too much to hope for because I haven't read the latest article about this, the one about DHS getting involved, I believe you said, in the title. Yes, DHS is now going
to investigate this. incident, but what about DHS and the rest of us that have already gotten pilfered? We never heard anything about any of the investigations they've done. No way. They're never up front with us, you stupid No. But what I was going to say is it's too much to hope for, but I would have hoped that there would have
been a very strongly worded press release from DHS or somebody saying, do not pay these people. Well, it's said every time. The FBI says it. Police agencies have told companies not to do it. It's said every time this happens, it's mentioned.
Then I really feel like banging my fucking head against the wall then. How do you think I feel covering this show before you even showed up, Nick? And again, as I was about to say, The scary thing is that I really have not been in this industry that long, and I'm already saying shit like that. Well, Nick, you know, at least you're doing your homework. That's pretty obvious, and
you are helping us out, and you are taking us to the masses. Hey, Nick. Why don't you go search my blog for some of these and see how long I've been covering half of this shit. Oh, no. I gave ChatGPT my educational archive, my power school archive, my change healthcare archive, my breaches
archive. Oh, yes. If you just sat And did term searching. Yeah, if I typed in power school, or as you said, change healthcare, that's, I mean, that's at least pages of reading material in themselves. I mean, in, there was a list of
terms that gave me during this whole discussion, and there was only one of them. I was not too familiar with. And it's something to do with... I think it's CRLF, which is basically a... Is it CRLF? I forget now. But there was one term out of six that we were talking about, it and
I. And I only... did not really understand one. Security now talked about it and then it sort of disappeared. That's how long I've been around this fucking ecosystem. Yes. And no one is still apparently learning and I guess that's why we're the only ones that haven't... I mean, that's why the network is the one that has not... I
mean, we've had an XSS attack about 20 years ago. So again, not new. We had a blog specifically talking about and posting Amber alerts and cancellations of them. Well, somebody got into one, posted
an iframe that was never in that post to begin with. And then I got an email from Google who blocked the webpage because it was malicious. I had to go in and remove the offending iframe and then tell them, rescan it, I took care of it. And then they removed the block. That's the
only other fucking issue I've had on this goddamn network. Between that, the HT access issues, about 10 years ago or so, give or take. And that's... The fuck it. The only other time we had issues
was because other customers who ran CMSs were not updating their shit. And the one guy who claimed that was running security now, who listened to security now, excuse me, not running it, listened to it, was blaming me for that shit. Oh, jeez.
And then when I started getting angry at him, he's like, well, you need to watch your language. I said... You don't understand something. I've been doing this ever since I started my domains in 2005. And here you are calling me up, telling me to keep my stuff as updated when you can't even do anything. You listen to security now. We're having issues and you don't even know half of what to do here. My customers have very lengthy
passwords. I have a guy in New Zealand that keeps my blog up to date. How much better can I get? I've had Sean Everest on my staff for at least 20 years. Yep, and he's definitely committed.
Because I read his postings. People may not like him, but he's done a damn good job for me. Yes. And then when we didn't have auto -updates, when there was an update and it was the middle of the night, he sent me an email and said, hey, just want to let you know I updated WordPress. It prompted for an update. Hey, I updated these
plugins. They pinged and said, you know, we need updates. Well, it wasn't that exact wording, but you get the idea. Yes. Right. So even though people may not like him, he's been working for me for 20 fucking years. Years. I wouldn't have it any other way. No way. I mean, he's very,
he's very, like I said, he's knowledgeable. He knows his shit. And when he doesn't know his shit, he emails me and he tells me, this is what it's saying. I don't know what this is. You know, email your people and find out. So I took what he gave me and I emailed my people. Yes, we're
all going on fucking tirades right now. Wow, look what I started. Thank you very much, Mr. J. Who? Go ahead. This podcast, I think, really needs the NSFW. Well, we already do that by default. We already put in the... Disclaimers. The two
disclaimers. We should change it to may contain extreme but don't lie. Oh, this one does. This one does. And if anything, make sure you have your imaginary diapers. That's the next ingredient you need. And I've got a meeting tomorrow. I've got a meeting tomorrow and we're going to try and get this up. At least merged. At least merged
tonight and out tomorrow. Yes, because I know one thing. I don't want you to be late and I don't want your ass to get kicked on the way down. Every time I leave my house, I'm wondering if I'm going to make it down there alive. Yeah. Yeah, then all of a sudden, I mean, this is never
going to happen, I don't think. Just ask Preston how many times I've been on the phone with him between going from here to the nail salon and back. about how many times I almost got my ass. At least twice. I know at least one of them. At least twice. Wow. But yeah, so I can just imagine somebody tunes in and it's, this is the
security box now being hosted by Mr. J. And then it would be, what happened to the other guy? Well... Well, unfortunately... Long story. He got run over by a semi walking home from headquarters. I mean, walking up in the bus stop from headquarters. Jared got run over by a semi. By a beer truck.
Who would like to... Start on the next Braille page to read segment number one. What happened with Canvas? I can start. Go ahead, please. All right. So title was just read, but might as well because sometimes things bear repeating. Segment
one. What happened with Canvas? Canvas is one of the largest learning management systems in the world. Schools and universities rely on it for coursework, assignment submissions, communications, grading, document distribution, scheduling, and accessibility accommodations. According to reporting from Bleeping Computer and CNN, Attackers claim
to have stolen data tied to thousands of educational institutions. Reports later emerged involving portal defacements and exploitation tied to flaws associated with Canvas free -for -teacher infrastructure. Now, to be honest... I will say, to be fair... That system is still down today. Oh. The rest
of Canvas is up. Free for Teacher is still down. I didn't know that existed. That's what I was... I didn't either. Yeah, that was the only thing I was going to say. I read all of this coverage. But it... We need to come in when we need to come in, folks. But that... Platform is still down today. Right. And in fact, I was a gateway
tutor at Santa Barbara City College, and I believe that we used Canvas many, many, many years ago. I don't know what they do now. How accessible was it? From what I remember, it was fairly accessible. Because back when I started, I had a customer who was using Blackboard and asked me how it worked. And I went in there and we were messing
around with it. And I think they eventually got their accessibility ducks in a row. This was 2006. So both of these are good. Oh, and by the way. Blackboard is not immune from the incident issues. According to ChatGPT, they had issues in 2011. Oh, boy. So, but we do know that this
is three in roughly a year for Canvas. Wow. Are they trying to be the next T -Mobile? You know, that was kind of what I was wondering when I saw that. And two in a month? Not even a month. Two in, let's see, they started on April 28th?
9th? Yeah, I think it was 9th. Something like that. Let's just call it 28th just, you know, for, you know, purposes. So if they started on 28 and they were detected on 29, okay, that's the first one. The second one was March 3rd.
And then we started getting coverage over the weekend, which is why I've been blogging so much lately. Well, part of that was to try and catch up on older content that I wanted to blog anyway. Right. You mean May 3rd, though, right? Oh, excuse me. Yeah, it's good to see. Is he trying to rush the month already? Shut up. I've been running with my head cut off, press boy. I know. I'm sorry for the comment. You're good. You're good.
No, you're good. I'm leaving it because that's what live podcasting is for. And I'm not angry at you. So... You're good. Yep, I know. I'm good. You're good. The timing, Mr. Ye. Sure. The timing of this incident could not have been much worse. Many schools were either in finals week or approaching
the end of their academic terms. Students suddenly faced concerns about assignment access, coursework availability, communications with instructors, and submission deadlines. into something much larger. It became an operational disruption. And by the way, when Herbie sent that to me,
and he mentioned Blackboard, and then I happened to read this CNN article, my first thought was, why the fuck is CNN covering this? And they didn't cover it from a tech perspective. They covered this from a school perspective. And they had tons of students of both genders speaking out
on experience. And our student newspaper at Stanford. They had an article about it because they were hit too. Apparently, I didn't know this, but Stanford has courses apparently that use Canvas. And I believe I've conservatized the number at 8800, but we know the number is 8809, while CyberWire
says 9K. That's a big difference. That's huge. I don't like the fact that they can get away. I can get away with 8 ,800. What's nine institutions, right? Right. I mean, I'm not saying that those nine should not be counted for. But I'm rounding
to the nearest hundred because we really don't know if there's anybody else out there that hasn't at least, or at least in structure hasn't said that it's a larger number. Right. Next paragraph, please. Sure. When learning management systems
fail during finals week, education does not merely slow down. In some cases, it stops entirely. That is a major point listeners should understand. And I think... And I think that should be read again. I will read more than... I'd be more than happy to. Because based on the CNN article, that's
what I got out of it. Same here. That is a major point. Okay, so the one before that. When learning management systems fail during finals week, education does not merely slow down. In some cases, it
stops entirely. That is a major point listeners should understand. Which it did. There are some places. That actually halted the finals until next week. Yep. Yep. Or, in some cases, it's been reported they just sent everybody home. Yep. Never mind the accessibility, you know,
and other aspects of this. I'm talking generalized. Just go home. We don't know what's happening. We're not going to stay open another week to deal. You all are free for the summer. Yeah, just go. Yeah, goodbye. Thank you. We'll give you your certificates. Nothing. But that's part
of the problem. That's part of the problem. Go ahead with the next paragraph. Okay. These platforms are no longer optional convenience tools. They are now core infrastructure. And that's the end of segment one. Great. Do I need to, in future
files, mention, since we're paginating everything, do I need to put an end of segment marker in there? Will that help? I don't think that's necessarily... something that's needed because it's pretty clear like in the file that was just maybe that was more of a courtesy than anything else because it does say you know right below that segment two right and you see a page number of some sort
yeah kind of in an odd spot because it's segment two and then at least in my file it's the and then it's the next page yes bigger problem Well, that's... It's also that way in the 40, which I'm now reading from, even though it's taken me two thumb presses to read that way, but I think it's much stabler than the 20. Yeah, yeah. But, no, I think you make it pretty clear that
we're entering into a new segment. I thought I'd ask. All right. Does anybody... Have any comments? Mr. Ring, you've been kind of quiet over there in Chicago. Well, just outside of Chicago. Please pop off and let us know what you're thinking. I agree with Nick's I think
you're right too, but I don't think they have a choice because you can't really back up something like canvas. You can't. What was it? Over 200 million records? 280 million confirmed. I thought I read 275 million, but... They didn't say how much the ransom was. We're not talking about
the ransom. We're not talking about... Hold on a second. We're not talking about the ransom. Never mind the ransom. We're talking about records exposed. Yeah. And the number is somewhere between 275 and 280 million, depending on what you read. All of Bleeping's numbers are 280. Okay. But
yeah, there's no, as far as I know, backup solution that would support... anything of that magnitude. No, because each one can be ran on their own network. It's like WordPress, right? So if WordPress gets hacked, it's our own problem. We have to
upgrade our own version. Of the software and anything we have in it. Right. I'm using WordPress as the example because that's the CMS system everybody uses. Although there are others. The biggest one is WordPress. Now, what would be
bigger, Blackboard or Canvas? I didn't ask what's biggest today. But I bet they're both equally used in their own way. Okay. So, that is where
we are. I think what we'll do is we'll read one more segment and then I'll do a file break. Okay. Just so that, you know, if something happens... We have something safe. Yeah. I think that'll be good. Sorry to get off topic a little bit,
guys, but our commercial for one of our favorite companies is on my TV right now. Which major company? LifeLock. Correct. LifeLock. Oh, not them again. Why in the middle of... Jeez. No
wonder we're in the wrong business. We're in the wrong business. Oh, yeah, we gotta start... Yeah, we gotta work for LifeLock. We gotta see if, you know... We can extort people for money, you know? That's right. We're, um... They're claiming they can help you before shit happens. That's the key word. But they screw you over
in the process. That's why we hate them with a burning passion. Well, no company can help you before anything happens. Because there's nothing to alert them to. Unless they have some kind of clairvoyant who works there that we don't know about, but I don't think so. Because they say, if you hear it, it says, we'll help you.
So if something happens, we're right there. You call us up and we'll take care of it. Right. Yeah, I've read. some pretty damning reviews from just random sites. I don't remember now where some of them were, but I mean, some of the people were talking about how unbelievably lax they are. I mean, one person I remember said
that... Oh, they are. They are. Lackadaisical, yes. But one person who wrote a review said that apparently LifeLock called for this particular employee, somebody else who worked in that office, and actually gave their name and some of their personal info. Like, hi, I'm looking for a blank
with their credit card number. Whatever I think it was, that's probably what I would imagine it would have sounded like. And a social security number of... Right, exactly. It's like, okay, thanks for that information. Now I'm going to go get a credit card. Yeah, get a credit card.
in their name. Try to buy a car in their name and maybe a house in their name. Yeah, you know, do stuff like that. That I'll never pay for. That I'll never pay on. Actually, some of them, they'll start to pay on it to make it look good. Right. Out of that person's account, no doubt.
Yep. Wonder if I should do that file break now.
Holy crap. Let's do that. Let's take a file break. When we come back, we'll continue. This is TSB 272A dealing with Canvas. I'm Jared Reimer. This is the Jared Reimer Radio Network. to the security
box. This is program 272A. Usually I do these alone, but I thought it would be good to have the entire TSB slash throwback group on. They're on with me on the talk of teams. Continue where
we left off. I will read segment number two of the file. The bigger problem. One of the reasons this incident matters so much is because of centralization. Over the last several years, schools increasingly
consolidated their operations into centralized cloud platforms. This accelerated dramatically during the pandemic. What once may have been handled across... multiple systems now often runs through one platform. This includes assignments,
messaging, testing, grades, accessibility accommodations, document delivery, instructor communications, notifications, everything becomes centralized. That creates convenience, but it also creates
dependency. And dependency creates what? I have it right here, so I don't know if I can... Yeah. The answer I'm looking for from the other two are risk. When one platform becomes deeply integrated
into educational operations, a security incident can ripple across thousands of institutions simultaneously. Exactly what happened. Correct. 8 ,000 of them.
But yeah. Yes, 8 ,809 of them to be exact. Yes. if not more. Wouldn't surprise me if that number goes higher. This is not just a technical problem anymore. It becomes a continuity problem. It becomes infrastructure, an infrastructure problem,
and And increasingly, it becomes a societal problem. That'll end that segment. I'm curious on, I didn't ask it, but maybe this could be a question for the group. What would we possibly mean by societal?
A societal problem. I don't know if I have the right idea here, but what I'm thinking is potentially something like critical infrastructure, for example, that might on one centralized platform and you
have a lot of, say, rail services that use them. And say somebody decides to infiltrate and hack them. Now, in certain places, you basically bring commerce, you bring... Transportation, you bring everything to a standstill. Okay. That might
make sense. I didn't think to question it, but... You could be onto something. And yeah, and it all comes about because a lot of people at various agencies say, oh, it's convenient. Yes, it'll all be in one place. And we can collaborate with
different networks. So it's so great. And then. Like I said, that gets compromised and potentially somebody goes in there and is able to shut multiple networks down. Yeah, then it does become a serious risk because everybody's depending on that centralized network. Mm -hmm. It's not quite a perfect connection,
but technically we already saw this with what happened in Taiwan. Yeah. That was one hell of a story. And yeah, if that happened there, what's to stop somebody from doing that to, say, the
New York subway system or BART again? Or hitting something like Amtrak, you know? Uh -huh. Yeah. And then they all be stuck here in L .A. Well, folks, we can't go anywhere. We got a train stuck
ahead of us about a half a mile away. And there's one stuck behind us, so we're not moving. Nope. And we don't know what the problem is. Uh -huh. And then out on the freeway, traffic jams are beyond terrible. Well, we already have that problem. Oh, but it'll be about five times or ten times
worse once this shit happens, if it does. Yeah. Yeah, and then, of course, I'm... Up here. It's like, well, I was going to go down south, but no trains are operating in either direction from Santa Barbara. So I guess I won't be taking the
train anywhere. And then if they wanted me to come down to headquarters, well... I'm seeing nothing but all kinds of alerts across the network, so... Yeah, I would love to come, but... I think we got seven broken down buses on the orange line, and the red line is stopped, so... Yeah, so, I mean, as much as I'd love to come down
there for the meeting, I don't think I can get there. Sorry. Yeah, an Uber would be a little bit expensive. It'll be about $50 to $60 each way. Dang, I didn't realize it was that far. Holy crap. It's about $40 to get me to Braille.
Somewhere in the 40s to get me to Braille. And don't forget, though, in that situation, you're going to have major surge pricing because a lot of people are going to be basically seeing the same thing. It's like, oh, I can't take the train to work. I've got to do this. I've got to get a ride share. And so there's just going to be a demand like you've never seen. Yeah. So it should be $60 each way, but it's probably going
to be more like $80 or $90. And because I'm not traveling over 100 miles, they won't reimburse me for that. Nope. Well, that doesn't make sense, though, because... 100 miles? You're well outside of L .A. and the areas they would cover. I know, but remember the trip that I took to take on
one of the early morning ordeal? I never took part in any of the other ones this year, but that early morning trip that I took? Oh, the weekend one? Yes. Where I asked them if they could reimburse me for my hotel and then I found out that I could crash somewhere. Uh -huh. They
wouldn't have reimbursed me for the hotel because I would have to travel 100 miles. Right. So yeah, if you lived in San Diego, which would be pretty ridiculous, living in San Diego and working for and doing any kind of contract work for LA Metro
from San Diego, that's questionable. Yeah. Actually, and here's the sad thing, even from here it wouldn't work. Yeah. Because I think Santa Barbara is under 100 miles. Just barely, but under. You're closer to that mark than I am. Right, but still
not enough. Now, if you were coming there from, and this would be a headache to try and even remotely organize, but if you're trying to get there from Seney and Nez, that, I think, could easily get you that 100 miles. Who would like to do segment number three? The Power School
Connection. Actually, Jared, while I wait for my chicken cordon bleu and broccoli to cool, I will gladly do it. All right. Ooh, chicken corn on blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blue. Haven't had that in years. But this time it has, I think it has like ham and broccoli. Mmm, that sounds good. There's like two and a
half at Walmart. Chicken cordon bleu. I think it's my fault. Well, it's not too bad of a price. It's cheap. I don't know what page you're on because I'm on a 40 now. I'm not on a 20. Seven.
So you're on seven. Yeah, I was going to say, I actually downloaded my usual 30. Okay. I'm on 7, too. It's showing 7 on the 40, so... Okay, that's great. Yeah. Well, get yourself stabilized. I am. I'm here. And start when you're ready. Yep. I'm just waiting for this to cool, babe.
I'll get an A &W. Listeners of this podcast may remember our discussions involving PowerSchool. PowerSchool residents highlighted concerns involving centralized student information systems and the concentration of educational records. One, attendance data. student demographics, three grades, four
administrative records, school operations. Our school demonstrated what happens when educational administrative systems become highly centralized targets. Canvas demonstrates something slightly different. Canvas is operational. It is the day -to -day workflow of education itself. That distinction
matters. Go ahead, please. Our school represented the exposure of educational records and administrative systems. Canvas demonstrates What can happen when the operational side of education becomes dependent on centralized platforms? This may
represent the next phase of cybersecurity risk in education. And unfortunately, that mirrors patterns we have seen in other industries. That ends that segment. Good job. It's not long, but gentlemen, huge. We talked about Power School. Yep, yep. And they never really came out and
weren't really clear what the hell happened. No. And it wasn't like CNN did a huge story like they did for this. No. CNN said... Nobody said anything except the tech press. Wow. That's why I had to do a double take when Herbie sent me
the CNN article. Is that? Is that? Is this? I will take segment number four. The change healthcare
comparison. To really understand why this matters, we should compare this incident to change healthcare. Change healthcare became one. Of the clearest examples. Of centralized. Operational dependency. In modern healthcare. Oh yeah. And we cover them
too. On this program. All over the place. Up and down this program. For months. Healthcare professionals. providers relied on change healthcare systems for, this is actually a starred list this time, claims processing, prescription workflow,
insurance verification, payment processing, operational coordination, When those systems were disrupted, the impact spread nationally. Nationally is the word. Jared, you've got to learn how to read here. Number one, providers struggled. Two, pharmacies
experienced Delays. Three. Payments stopped flowing normally. Four. Organizations scrambled to find alternate workflows. The incident. Demonstrated
that centralized cloud systems can become critical infrastructure. Canvas may now be demonstrating the same thing in education. I guess while we have a page change, I will ask what you guys think. Think of that. There's your answer. I
swear I think I'm about to break the rest of my nail off because my nail is about broken off. Well, I think that will be the target. Sadly, I don't think that this is wrong. I don't think that the GPT of chat is wrong here. I don't either.
And it analyzed all the articles I fed it, including all of the power school stuff and the change stuff. Which, by the way, I'm not going to include in our show notes the links to those searches. You will go search them out yourself. I will include all of the articles that we've read to date. That's the best I'm going to do for this program. That is already a lot of material, though,
so... Yes. I think that's fair. I think that's fair. Schools have increasingly become dependent on centralized learning management systems in... What is this? Much the same way healthcare providers became dependent on centralized healthcare processing systems. Yes, I think this 40 is much better,
even though I still don't like it much, but... At least it's not breaking my words in half. Or, we hope, telling you about the fattery charge. That was my 40, which I haven't heard anything from them. Maybe I'll have to call them and find out what's going on with my fattery. Yeah, I guess you might have to. Well, my 30's no better
off because I can't even get a USB drive into the thing without having to reset it because it's 20 years old and it's not even being maintained anymore. Same with my BrailleNote Apex. I mean... I can read on this. Mine's still standing, and I got it in 2018 from the States. So, yeah, mine's doing, bro, it's working. But remember, your
Sense is a newer model than this 2007 model. Oh, yeah. This is the 6 that I have over there. Yes, and the thing I have... I got this in 2012. You're not too far behind me. Right. And just to give you an idea of how it's kind of fading,
I don't think it can deal with modern WPA3 networks for Wi -Fi because I could not, when I was at my parents for a while, connect at all using this device to their Wi -Fi. And everything was correct. The credentials were all good. But my BrailleNote Touch, which is slightly newer, not
by much, had no problem whatsoever. But yes, I think... It may not be by much, but I think Wi -Fi security has advanced to a point where the Apex can't deal with it. That comparison should concern everyone. Because it shows how
cybersecurity incidents... increasingly evolve beyond simple breaches. They become operational crises. Schools have increasingly become dependent
on centralized, learning management systems. In much the same way, healthcare providers became dependent on centralized healthcare processing systems. That comparison should concern everyone because it shows how cybersecurity incidents
increasingly evolve beyond simple breaches. They become operational crises. Or crisis. Crises. You said it right the first time. Okay. Crises is correct. I was almost going to go to crises. No. But that doesn't sound right. No, that's...
No, that actually... That reminds me of what Leo Laporte said one time on his show. He was talking about crashes and viruses, and he invented the word crasheses. Crasheses. Yes. Okay, wow. Well, you do have to turn things into a little bit of comedy around here. Yeah. Have a few crashuses. Some crashuses every now and then. Yep. Bring
on the beef. Yum. Yeah, well, I guess that's better than having a vashus. Or a virie. Yes. Although... Chat says that virie isn't really common. Viruses is more common in the ecosystem
than virie. But some people have called it virie, and it's not technically wrong, but it's viruses. Oh, it's too bad there's not an independent version of this, because if we were talking more about this... I have the perfect fit. Virus, virus, viruses all day long. I can actually play that deck talk thing. Yes, because that's deck talk.
Not a full -on group. Oh, wow. Tell your computer so long. You're screwed. Although, the problem is that we don't have that problem anymore. No. Thank goodness. Although, you can thank the evolution
of all of what we've been through for the last 30 years for what we have now. Mm -hmm. So if it wasn't all of that work for 30 years, we probably would still be doing slow... Let's see if we can leave a flash drive somewhere and infect
people that way. Oh, that still is sometimes happening. It's not common. No. Is what I'm saying. It used to be more prevalent in the 80s and 90s. In fact, that's how the first virus was found. Somebody picked up a flash drive. It's like, gee, I wonder what's on this thing. Mm -hmm.
It was an experiment by the author to see how fast it would spread. And once they got it... Oh, crap! This is spreading faster than I thought. All right. Technical debt and dependency. Oh, boy. This goes back... This goes back to our
very last program last week. But before we do that, Mr. Ring, pop yourself off of mute. And let us know if you have any comments from our last segment. Okay. Who wants to read segment number 5 on page number 11? I'll do it. Alright,
Mr. J. On Podcast 272, we discussed technical debt. Many people think technical debt only refers to outdated software or poorly maintained code. But technical debt can also appear as accumulated dependency. Organizations gradually centralize operations into platforms because doing so is
efficient, cost effective, and convenient. Exactly some of the things I just said. Over time, however, those platforms become deeply embedded into daily operations. Eventually, the organization cannot function without them. That creates systemic fragility. Technical debt is not always broken code. Sometimes technical debt is over -centralization.
That may be one of the most important lessons from the Canvas incident. Cloud platforms are often marketed as resilient, scalable, and simplified solutions. But concentration can also increase systemic... That's right. That's right. But concentration...
I mean, look at how things have happened. I mean, not just in... And sorry to interrupt you, but not just in this breach alone. The Cloudflare incidents where all of our Amazons went ape and everybody couldn't figure out what was going on because Amazon pushed an update. AWS, yep.
They pushed an update. And how many AWS issues have we had where sites like PayPal and other major... Company websites went down because somebody did something and broke shit. Right. That was what I was just going to point to. Yeah, the
big Amazon basically meltdown last year when pretty much everybody's device had issues. It wouldn't work and you couldn't really access it. And this community of all people went ape. Oh, yes. Yes. And me? I was like, I tried it
once, and I'm like, well, I'm off to a meeting anyway. Wasn't I off to a meeting that day? I think so. I thought you were, actually. So I tried it once just because I got messages about it, and I basically said, I don't know. I don't really have time to deal. I don't frankly care. Pay me when you find something. And maybe when
I get back, I'll go find articles and we'll blog something. Yeah, I was... Yeah, you called me and told me and I'm like, go up on like bleeping or ours or something and... Go make yourself useful and pretty. Well, I have a local anecdote
about that that really underscores what we were just talking about and what I was just reading. Just to prove that this didn't just affect Amazon devices, what I learned that day was that our utility billing service apparently uses them because oh shoot yes I remember I was I don't
know if I wanted to just get my payment for my water bill scheduled or whatever it was but I remember seeing a message about that that they here in Santa Barbara were affected by that major breach. So it rippled well beyond just Amazon. Exactly. And I believe we covered that then.
That this wasn't just an Amazon device. And when I posted the article on the tech board on 295 on LiveWire, where this podcast will go, by the way, The fact of the matter is that we posted articles about it, and Michael, who you guys heard as part of last week's program, when he commented, oh, well, we'll cover this briefly
in Arana unless we should cover it next week. But I do have a story on Podcast 269's Stupid Idiot. Oh, yeah. Yep. But anyway, he was commenting how bad it was and what was Amazon thinking and what happened to the guy who pushed the button. And I basically said, we know nothing, Michael.
We don't know anything. Right. Go ahead and finish the paragraph. Okay. I think I remember where I was. Yeah, that's where I just thought I was. Perfect. But concentration can also increase systemic risk when backup workflows disappear. And in many organizations, backup workflows no
longer exist. I'm going to read that again because that's... Truly terrifying. Please, please read that again. But concentration can also increase systemic risk when backup workflows disappear. And in many organizations, backup workflows no longer exist. And why do you think people are
like... Well, why don't you just run on WordPress or run on some CMS platform? Because if I run my own website through a CMS, if it crashes, that's... Down goes JaredReimer .net. My ass. Yep, down you go. And I don't want to be dependent.
On full PHP. Because somebody found a bug. Not in my code. Necessarily. But they get into the server. Through an XSS attack. Which basically. Gives them full access. To the entire server. Oops. Hence how they could. Deface the portal.
which is how they were able to face all these different schools portals by putting messages on their portals without touching others Mr.
Ring, make yourself pretty. No comments. I think he's speechless. Yeah. Completely speechless. I will go ahead and cover accessibility. This
is segment six on page... I'm actually surprised that this actually worked. Because I was almost wondering if I had to use the 272 moniker. But I see that the page numbers are actually working. Because I put 272A... Vertical bar 12. Like vertical bar 1 for example. And I wasn't even sure if that was even going to work. Oh boy. Mr. Ring.
Make yourself pretty. Before we get into segment 6. Not having. Backup option. I agree with that.
Is there any other things that... Why do you think every month, although I haven't done it the last two months, but that's because of my schedule, but why do you think most of the time I've tried to run backups of the entire at least on my website and some of the others along the network that I can help maintain. If you have a cloud service to have a backup of a backup.
But there's no option for that. There's no option for it. I know that. So that's why I said that. But why do you think... Why do you think I won't run on a CMS? I mean, the only reason why I have the blog on a CMS is because that's the only way that works. But when you talk about running a website on a CMS, yeah, you can get a backup of the database if you find the database in your
directory structure to back it up. to put it back in place. Could be very interesting. Yep.
Is it me, or was 6 supposed to have a period, and I just used a colon there? I agree. Was all of this colon, or did I fuck up? That is a colon.
Was five coloned or period? I'm going back to look right now. That was a colon. Okay, so we are consistent. Okay. Yep. Okay. Before I go on to page 12 and talk about accessibility stuff,
is there anything else that anybody would like to comment on, even through the first five? I don't think I have anything else left to say. In terms of that. Accessibility implications.
This is also an accessibility issue. For blind students and students with disabilities, platforms like Canvas are often essential tools. for participation in education. I think I'll read that again. This is an accessibility issue for blind students
and students with disabilities. Platforms like Canvas are often essential tools for participation in education. Now there are, I numbered these, accessible document distribution, assignment submissions, communications with instructors.
Alternative format materials. Scheduling. Notifications. And finally, testing accommodations. Stanford had a system very much like that when I was there. It was a system called coursework. And yeah, it was a lot of things like that. where I would
have to go on there and I would be told, hey, there's a new file uploaded and they had at the Disability Resource Center a course created where they could basically drop alternative format things in there and I could grab them. So, I guess chat wasn't so far off. No, it was not.
And Stanford, again, they had a... And I think they still have a system called Access, A -X -E -S -S, I believe. And it's very much like that. You don't necessarily... communicate directly with instructors that way, but it has stuff about grades, it has financial things too, I think,
and just a lot of things all in one central location. Which is helpful. Yes, but if access gets hit... Mr. Ring, do you have any comments? I've unmuted you during the set. Do you have anything in regards to these accommodations stuff? I've never used
a saw like this. I wouldn't know if... We'll mute you. We'll come back to you. I'll give you a hand since you're out and about a little bit. Okay. Okay. When centralized systems fail, disabled users may be disproportionately affected because
alternative workflows are often limited or non -existent. This is something mainstream reporting does not always discuss. Accessibility increasingly depends on digital infrastructure. When that
infrastructure experiences disruption, accessibility itself can become disrupted. That is an important consideration institutions should not overlook.
That's definitely a true statement. That is definitely true there, Jared. I believe you're right. Mr. Ye. I really don't have anything else to add
to that. I think that's true. Yep. Very accurate. I believe... We're on segment seven. I don't remember. I think seven might be the last. Yeah. Where things go from here. At the time of this
recording, many questions remain unanswered. Number one. The exact... scope of exposure remains unclear. We don't really know how many people are affected. We know about how many schools, but that could change. The precise number of
affected institutions may continue to evolve. I think that's important. Most likely will evolve. Yes. I believe when I finally do the news segment for next week's program, unless you guys want to push it back a week, we can do that. But we can discuss that later. But even if I... Push
a new segment out. A lot of it is going to be this. Number three. Questions remain regarding what data was actually accessed or removed. We see reports that it's usernames, passwords, and
simple data of that sort. Usernames, passwords, email addresses. But what actually is stored in these systems? I think I asked such questions in my own writing, did I not? I think you did. Herbie said he had Blackboard. I told him he
can submit his comments for next week. Because he told me this was concerning when I reported back that this was Canvas and not Blackboard. But he also made it clear that he doesn't use his... Well, Buzzman, our line is open. He doesn't use his educational address for anything online,
so he's going to be fine. I think this water's going down the wrong way. Number four. Uh, Additional disclosures may still occur. But regardless... Will occur. A will. That's my prediction. I agree.
It says may, but I believe you're right. I believe you're right. I don't want to speculate and say will when it may not, which is why I was almost tempted to change it to say will. But I think you're right. I think it will happen. Because that seems to be the way these things work. The, oh, what was it? There was another breach where
we got an initial number, and then later it turned out, oh, this was way worse than we thought. That's most of them. That's most breaches. So I expect this to change. 500%. But regardless of the final numbers, one thing is already clear.
Education technology platforms now represent high volume targets because they combine And we've got a start list here. Sensitive data. Operational dependency. Massive user populations. Centralized infrastructure. Cloud integration.
Institutional trust. I think that list should be read again. What do you guys think? I think so. Okay. Let's go back here. But regardless of the final numbers, one thing is already clear. Education technology platforms now represent
high value targets because they combine. sensitive data, operational dependency, massive user population, populations is the word, centralized infrastructure, cloud integration, and instructional trust. Institutional?
Or institutional trust. Excuse me. Good lord. Okay. Construction 2. Because you know they're in the process of breaking things. Yes. Well, that too. Okay. That combination makes them extremely attractive to attackers. And, unfortunately,
education may now be entering its own change healthcare moment. I was right. That was the last numbered segment. Gentlemen? No, we're beyond
that. We're not just entering the change healthcare moment. We're far beyond that. I agree. I believe it was... Which one was it? McGraw -Hill. I believe we're in it already. Long past just entering it. I think it started with the college system
here when we got called for a ransomware attack back in 2017. When I was at Valley College with that whole college system there, you could go to nine educational schools, including Pierce and Valley and several others, and be logged into the same. They all use the same platform. So I got a phone call and an email. And, of course,
I covered that then if you search Valley College on the blog. Mm -hmm. Back in 2017. Do we even have any updates on McGraw -Hill since I published
them? Probably not. I don't know. Haven't seen anything since then. Who would like to read our closing? I'll do it. Go ahead, Mr. Ye. All right. Closing. The Canvas story is not simply about
a hack. It is about dependency. It is about centralization. It is about the growing role of cloud infrastructure in modern society. And it is about what happens when the systems organizations rely on every single day suddenly become unavailable, compromised, or disrupted. Technology platforms designed to
simplify operations can eventually become critical infrastructure. Once that happens, cybersecurity incidents stop being mere IT problems and start becoming societal disruptions. We will continue monitoring this developing story and provide updates as additional information becomes available.
For additional... Hang on one second. For additional coverage and comment... Yeah, I've got it. For additional coverage and commentary, visit the blog at technology .jaredreimer .net Thank you for listening to The Security Box. Podcast 272A. And I'll read the final paragraph. This is Jared Reimer, and we will talk to you next time. And
I did see that IT didn't properly get graded, but that's okay. I knew what it was, so we're fine. Okay. I tried to do much better with that. Mr. Ring, you popped off of mute. Go ahead, please. Oh, I got sick. What a story. Yeah. Kind of makes
him want to go run and hide. Why do you think I wanted to do this this week? I wasn't... Because most podcasts will wait until we have something. And I blogged all week. I mean, I think it was at least once or twice a day I was blogging something with this since Sunday. Yep. So... We don't work
that way. You stupid... Oh, excuse me. Oops. You stupid fuck. Um, gentlemen. A little bit... Let's do a little bit of errata. Um... So it looks like our good friends at the panel of C
haven't learned anything. Nope. Apparently not. They definitely haven't. I'm about to have a dying display. Where is my power cord for that
display? Is there anything else that you guys want? Oh, so on Podcast 269, we gave out a stupid fuck award. It turns out that the guy who got
the award got himself deleted from Livewire over the weekend. Apparently, He continued to tell
lies and make up stories. And the administration team had enough. And so he got thrown off. only did he do that, he probably would have been able
to come back in six months to a year, but then he logged into a different box to try and apologize for his wrongdoing. And that box just got deleted yesterday. And we believe we know that. But he's
also got friends on there too. Which could in theory bring him on to do whatever. And if they do, they'll get thrown off too. One of the rules Of the system. Is that you are not to bring on. Deleted colors. So we'll see. Who is going to.
I'm having trouble trying to keep this charger. Plugged in here. We're going to see. Who is the next one to go? Because we think that box was his second one. He said it belonged to somebody else who couldn't talk. But that box was hardly, if ever, online. So we believe he used it as a communication box. A potential communication
box for himself. Good job. Oh, I just found something that really is wonderfully encouraging. So what about the article that was posted the other day? Hackers use AI to basically exploit or actually
to develop zero days. Yeah. And we covered that. Type of thing. What was it, last year? When it was in Prototype? Yeah, I believe so. And that podcast, if you haven't heard, sans 39A. That covers AI. And, or not 39A, excuse me, 39. We
don't have A's and B's for that. So 39 covered... a webinar talking about AI and what it can do in the bug bounty exploit field. And that came from SANS directly. And considering that AI is being used more often to craft phishing emails...
Yes. I'm not surprised. Although I still need to tell people to look at where it's going. Because just because it crafts the emails, they still have links to where they want you to go. That's not AI. That are not Amazon. That are not Apple. There was one I got that was like devinsalliance
or alliance at gmail .com. It's like, no, I don't think you're Apple. You guys hear about that? Tim Cook stepping down? He will be stepping down in June from what we've heard. I didn't read the article, but I did see. And they already have his successor for him. I forget the guy's
name. So... Yeah, we got a lot of blog on... Canvas. So lots to read. That's pretty much mostly what there is. Can you blame me? I mean, yeah,
there's... Well, no, not at all. I mean, yeah, I guess Sean posted a thing about an update run. You know, a lot of major companies updated yesterday. A lot of software was updated. Yeah. And then I... I think there was another thing, and maybe we talked about it. Oh, I think we talked about this. Sean posted this. Can ChatGPT be charged
for murder, gentlemen? I think the answer is yes. Yeah, but see, this is where I have an issue, though. Yes and no. I mean, not the AI tool itself,
but the people who run it. That's right, right. Yeah. I read that piece by him. I would say maybe accessory, but... Well, it can't do any time. And it can't do any community service as an AI tool. Somebody has to take the brunt of the crime.
So that would be OpenAI. And they're already hemorrhaging financially from what I've heard and read. Let's do a quick file break. I'm not going to do any intro type thing, but let's do a file break. I want to cover two other things.
We will continue with more of the security box. I'm Jared Reimer. We are in Iran. So, gentlemen,
I'm not going to do the whole security box thing, the music at the beginning, which is okay for now, but I've got two more. Okay. Did you guys read the four years for swatting piece? Oh, gosh, yes, I did. BS? Total BS. Question mark? Total
BS. And what major company, in fact, they're in SANS 41, which is ready to go. Which also will cover this very topic of Canvas. But at the time, I guess they weren't saying a whole lot. Which major company is back in the Sands
headlines? Uh -oh. Oh, that's right. Yes. Is it a time to get rid of them? We keep finding problems and it affects a whole bunch of shit.
Just close it down at this point. I said that months ago. Because they were in the news every week. Oh yes, because they had to issue another patch and something else was compromised. So here's another patch and another. And people
weren't always downloading them or applying them. This continued to be a problem. Yes. Okay. We could talk about the student stopped multiple trains faceable possible time, but I think instead of covering that one, how about the no formal charges 15 -year -old suspected of exfiltrating
data? Except reporting indicates that it's a 23 -year -old. Right. So we don't know what's going on here. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. I thought the 23 -year -old was the railroad, the train story. The 15 -year -old I thought was somebody else. No. Well, there was a train story of a 15 -year -old, but in... That was
the... But in this... Oops. In this story, we first... Which leads to a blog post. The first thing they said was that it was a 15 -year -old. Then, it changed... To a 23 year old. With a
21 year old accomplice. But when you first read the article. It stated it was a 15 year old. Which is why I titled the blog post that way. And. The other thing. Why. Are these two. Ransom negotiators getting four years each when you
knew damn well that they were charged with money laundering. Uh -huh. Sean has something on New Zealand students' detail caught up in a university
hack. I don't know if anybody read the blog. I think I read his thing, but I didn't read the article. And how about the multiple people busted? we all know the crime rings will go unabated so those are some of the other items that are
covered do we think that the hunters of shiny Shiny, happy people. Uh -huh. Did you read the article where they stated that they, quote, shredded
the data, end quote, end quote, returned it back to Instructure, end quote? I have not read that particular article, no. Tell me when you do, and when you do, please tell me if that makes any sense. I can tell you now. That's bullshit.
I think I fed that article into chat and I said, why are they claiming that they shredded the data and they returned it back to Instructure? This isn't paper. No. What's that, Rick? time
you shred digital files is when you are getting ready to sell a computer or you want to get rid of a hard drive. That's when you shred files and that's used but that's used As a program,
there's a program that does it by overriding the drive X amount of times so that the files cannot be recovered. That's shredding files. I forget which article it was in. Shiny, happy
hunters. Let's see. The company states that 30 million... Educators and students use Canvas platforms over 8 ,000 schools and universities worldwide. Oh, wait. I think I need to go into... You know what I think it came into? I think that
was part of the... It's not this article. It's the latest one that we blogged, I think. Let's see. We have been informed that no instructor customers will be extorted during this incident publicly or otherwise. This agreement covers
all impacted instructor customers and there's no need for individual customers to attempt to engage with the unauthorized... Oh, this is that article. Okay. I'm reading the blog post, Shiny Hunters in Structure and Data Removal, Mr. J. I think I just went by it. But, yes, I do remember
passing it. So, yep. It's already been leaked. You posted that crap on your own extortion webpage. And we have images in the article. Well, not just that. And I'm sure that other people are going to want this data too. And so they're going
to use it and probably leak it elsewhere. Yeah, yeah, really. You really removed it. Sure. paragraph is not making any sense. How can you return the data? Shredding is not the same as in paper form.
The fact that shred logs were given to you does not mean it was actually done. They already started processing, putting the data out there, even on their leaked site. Shiny Hunters has now removed the Instructure entry from its data leak site,
which usually happens after victims pay a ransom. However, as the FBI repeatedly warned, paying a ransom does not guarantee threat. Actors will not also sell the stolen data to other cyber criminals. We've seen this happen. be fucking far. There was supposed to be a webinar today.
I hope that it went well. They've done everything PR right. LA Metro, if you're listening, maybe you need to take PR lessons from these guys. At least they did everything right. When they didn't have much, they said, we're aware of it. We're trying to figure it out. When they had
something, they told us. Yes, it's not pretty. But this is the best... we can ever get. Then it talks about how that was exploited through
XSS and so forth, so I'm not going to go through anything else. Mr. Mr. G, welcome back to TSB. Thank you. Yeah, I definitely agree. I'm glad that, you know, at least like we said earlier, folks, I'm just thankful and blessed that my
That when we talk today, they are doing everything right. Except fixing their shit. Yes. Because they would have never had the second problem this month if they would have gone in after they found out how they got in there. Gone fix the XSS exploit. vulnerability and shut them out
before they got in again. That's the only thing I say they got wrong. But everything else, IMHL, they did right. You can't have it any other way. Yep. That's the way I see it. Oh, boy. All right,
gentlemen. On the next full program, tool friction, accessibility, enforced workaround, in parentheses, technical neglect debt. Do we want to have this
program because we did this one this week because I felt it was necessary and I was going to do it alone if you guys didn't want to do it. But do we want to come back next week at our normal time, 11 a .m.? Personally, I'm really torn because Part of me really, really wants to do that because
on the 27th, I have something going on, so I wouldn't be able to stay for the whole thing. Especially if it drags into, you know, four or five hours, as sometimes these do. They do. Turn it on for the rest of the day. Message announcements paused for eight hours. Sorry. But yeah, I can wait. Yeah, if we want to do it next week, I'm cool with that. I don't have anything big going
on after work. It just might be a shorter broadcast. Hey, that's okay. Shut up, glasses. I wasn't even talking to you. Then, let's see. What do
I have going on? What is next? Let's see. That's May 20th. 20th. I don't have anything scheduled, so I could push the start time to later, although Nick won't be here regardless. Yeah. No, if we do it on the 20th, I will be here. Oh, you'll be here? Okay. It's the 27th. Yeah, that's the one where it would be a little tight. Then why
don't we stick to our schedule of the 20th? This was an intermediate anyway because we needed to. Either I did it myself or you guys came with. It didn't matter. Liberty. Liberty, liberty, liberty. Liberty. I love the one with the child.
I love the one with the child. Liberty. No, it's Liberty. Liberty. I don't remember that one. I just remember the really annoying singing one. Oh, they played that. quite a bit. I just dropped this. And also, hey, there's also We Are Farmers. Oh, right. The Geico. We're more cautious. And
then, of course, you've got, like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. They're not anymore. I think they got thrown out of California after all of the wildfire trouble. I think I heard something about them getting thrown out of here. I think that's changed, actually. I think they're not...
No, I think they're still around in California. Somebody was not going to offer insurance anymore after all of those devastating fires. I forget which one of them it was. No, I think it's if
you live within certain areas now, they're not going to issue you a policy. Even though you're required to have a policy to live there. Right. Yeah. Problem much. Yeah, basically. Alright,
so... We will... I guess... This has been a very fascinating show. I appreciate everybody coming on, coming this with me, so I didn't have to do it alone. No problem. Not that I didn't mind
doing it alone, but I thought this would be fun doing an extra with everybody. Yeah. And I will... Go ahead, Mr. G. Yeah, I was going to say, I very much enjoyed digging deep into this, and I guess it's safe to say we'll be monitoring. I think I've been doing most of that. I know.
My blog has been taking names. So - That's true, but it never goes without notice. It's a huge industry to fill. It is. It is a big industry
to fill. So that is what I'll say until the day I perish from this - from this industry. Oops. Did I say that? It's okay. I didn't mean to say that. You're okay. Does anybody have anything
else? We'll play a few tracks just to give people to relax a little bit. It's a crazy world out there. I think a little bit of... Easy listening from Craigology. It's perfect. Piano in the Wilderness. A 2026 release. We'll play several from that album. That's pretty good. Preston. Very good.
Take my happy ass. Yep, I'd be glad to because as of this taping, I have another show to participate in, so I'll be leaving too. So folks, this has been Security Box Special Edition covering the Canvas. Canvas. Disaster. Like I said, we'll
be monitoring as things progress or as the updates progress. So stay tuned to jaredtech .help and emailhostsecure .com for the blogs, podcasts, music, and much, much more. And while you're on your preferred podcast client or player, we implore you to subscribe to Jared's Technology Podcast Network. Where we'll have this program and - You're breaking. Interest across the landscape.
I know, I'm in my office. I was putting my Braille sensor. Anyway, subscribe to Jared's Technology Podcast Network, where we will have this program, other odds ends across the landscape, and much, much more. And you're definitely welcome to check out our other podcast by searching Jared Reimer in your preferred podcast app of choice. And if you want more conversation in the industry,
we invite you to tune in to The Throwback Certified every Saturday at 8 p .m. Eastern with SecurityR at 9 p .m. Eastern on 98 .6 MX server number three. And all that. So we say thank you for listening. Stay tuned for more great content. Unless you're listening on the podcast, you'll get a big old box of silence, but we all need that from time to time. So thank you for listening. We will bid you adieu for now. On behalf of everyone
at Security Box, this is Preston, Jared, Nick, Terry, and you at home saying thank you for listening. Have a safe week, a productive week, and as always, Watch us vote. Watch out for those links. And stay safe. And stay aware. Because we're all in this together. So make it a good day. And just for good measure. Bye for now. Let's get
into a couple of tracks of Craigology. Working remotely.
Welcome to podcast 280 Intermediate D. I'm Jared and the podcast is now available for everyone. On this podcast, the Evolution of Cyber Security, part 3: Organized cybercrime and social engineering, part 5. The podcast...
Hello gang, welcome to the security box, program 280 Intermediate E. On this program, we're covering something called PHP2Shell two vulnerabilities that were disclosed the same day. Not only that, we have a third vuln...
Welcome to Sans, episode 43 where your blood may decide to boil. I'm Jared, and this episode will cover the Newsletter that was released on October 13, 2026. On this newsletter, there will be some good news items that...
Welcome to podcast 280 Intermediate D. I'm Jared and the podcast is now available for everyone. On this podcast, the Evolution of Cyber Security, part 3: Organized cybercrime and social engineering, part 5. The podcast...
Welcome to Sans, Episode 42. Its been awhile, and this episode explains why. I hope that we can continue Sans, I'm going to start on the next issue very soon now. If you want to read the newsletter, please use this link...