Educational Technology Advice for Academic Leaders with Derek Bruff
46 minAudio
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. About a year ago, I appeared on the Ed Up Provost podcast hosted by Gregor Thuswaldner to share some educational technology advice for academic leaders. Topics included strategic planning around edtech adoption to managing innovation and organizational change to investing in faculty and staff, and I think my advice holds up well. Today, I'm sharing that interview here on the Intentional Teaching podcast feed. Whether your job title includes the word provost or not, I hope you find the conversation useful. Episode Resources The Ed Up Provost podcast Gregor Thuswaldner on LinkedIn Support the show Podcast Links: Order The Norton Guide to AI-Aware Teaching by Annette Vee, Marc Watkins, and Derek Bruff. Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPCEA, the online and professional education association. Subscribe to the Intentional Teaching newsletter: https://derekbruff.ck.page/subscribe Support Intentional Teaching on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/intentionalteaching Find me on LinkedIn and Bluesky. See my website for my "Agile Learning" blog and information about having me speak at your campus or conference.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Derek BruffHey, it's Derek. I didn't want to air a new interview with one of our fantastic intentional teaching guests here on the next to last day of the year. But I didn't want the podcast feed to be empty either. So I'm sharing an interview I did for the EdUp Provost Podcast. The show is hosted by Gregor Toothwaldner, Experienced Provost and editor of the Chief Academic Officer's Handbook from Johns Hopkins University Press. Gregor's podcast is aimed at provosts and other academic leaders.
Derek BruffAnd he had me on in early 2025 to share some advice on educational technology with that audience. We covered a lot of ground in our conversation, from strategic planning around ed tech adoption, managing innovation and organizational change, to investing in your faculty and staff. And I think my advice folds up well almost a year later. Whether your job title includes the word provost or not, I hope you find my thoughts useful. Thanks to Gregor for asking great questions and for giving me permission to share our conversation here on the Intentional Teaching Podcast.
SPEAKER_00Today I'm joined by Dr. Derek Bruff. Dr. Bruff is an educator, author, and high education consultant. He directed the Vanderbilt University Center for Teaching for more than a decade, where he helped faculty and other instructors develop foundational teaching skills and explore new ideas in teaching. Dr. Bruff consults regularly with faculty and administrators across higher education on issues of teaching, learning, and faculty development, and he is an associate director at the Center for Teaching Excellence at the University of Virginia for the 2024-25 academic year.
SPEAKER_00Dr. Bruff has written two books, Intentional Tech, Principles to Guide the Use of Educational Technology in College Teaching, which was published by West Virginia University Press in 2019, and Teaching with Classroom Response Systems, Creating Active Learning Environments, which came out in 2009. He writes a weekly newsletter called Intentional Teaching and produces the Intentional Teaching Podcast. Dr. Bruff has a PhD in mathematics and has taught math courses at Vanderbilt and Harvard University.
SPEAKER_00So welcome to the Ad Up Provost Podcast, Derek.
Derek BruffI'm very glad to be here. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's great to have you. Because I really liked your book with the title Intentional Tech: Principles to Guide the Use of Educational Technology in College Teaching. Because in your book, you stressed the fact that teaching and learning goals should drive instructors' technology use and not the other way around. And that's a really important lesson, obviously. So your book came out five years ago, and I guess we're all waiting for a second edition because a lot has happened since happened, yes.
SPEAKER_00And so, you know, my question to you is what advice would you give to provosts on supporting faculty who may be resistant to integrating new technologies. And, you know, I'm thinking of AI, VR, augmented reality, et cetera, into their teaching.
Derek BruffGreat question. Within the last five years, we had uh the COVID-19 pandemic and all the changes to teaching that had to come very quickly. There were certainly faculty resistant to some of those technological changes, but they didn't really have a choice in many ways. But when it comes to some of these more recent tools like virtual reality and AI and others, um, we do often have choices, which is good. It's good to have choices. Um, I prefer to have choices than not. But that the the key principle that you referenced, I think, is still kind of front and center.
Derek BruffSo in the book, I talk about my favorite educational technology being wheels on chairs. Right. Because when I, you know, I've if I'm teaching a math course and I walk into the classroom, I have a plan for the day. I have a lesson plan, I have activities I want my students to engage in. I've kind of designed the learning experience. And if the furniture in the room can be responsive to my intentions, then it just makes everything so much easier. Right. And so, and I, you know, I share that because that is the principle, right?
Derek BruffOur teaching goals or pedagogical aims should drive our technology use. I also like to share that because sometimes faculty get intimidated by new digital technologies and don't always reflect on the fact that we teach with technology all the time. Right. Many of those technologies are analog and they're very familiar, right? When I walk into a classroom, I know what to do with the chairs, I know what to do with the whiteboards and the chalkboards, right? These are technologies and we use them for specific purposes. We're just not having to collectively figure out what those purposes are, right?
Derek BruffThey're well known. But when it comes to newer technologies, we do have to kind of work together and figure out what those purposes are. Why use this technology? What kind of learning experiences can it help us create? What kind of teaching goals can it help us meet? And and so my advice for provost is to lead with the why. Why are these tools helpful for faculty? Why are they helpful for students? What are the pedagogical aims of any technologies that you'd want to explore? And I think a key strategy is really just use cases.
Derek BruffSo a lot of the work that I do with faculty, I'm collecting stories of faculty and other instructors who are doing intentional, creative, effective things with technology in their teaching. And then I share those stories again and again and again with other faculty. Because, you know, we like when we're learning new things, we like concrete ideas, right? What does it look like in your classroom? What might it look like in my classroom? Why are you using this technology? Now, you know, our classroom contexts differ, and those contexts are really important, right?
Derek BruffThe access to resources, the students we're teaching, the disciplines that we're in. There's always a bit of kind of translation that has to happen when you hear a story about some other instructor using a technology. But I feel like that's still a critical way to help faculty conceive of why I might use these tools in my teaching. I need to see examples from colleagues, ideally colleagues who teach, you know, something similar to me, but it's those practical examples. And my approach is often to kind of try to pull out the key principles behind those examples.
Derek BruffI think that helps faculty translate things to their own teaching context. If they know the why, if I can identify that for them in a story that I tell, then they can say, oh, in my context, I can still go about using technology to make student learning more visible to me, for instance. Yeah. My tools, my goals might be a little different, but that principle helps me translate these ideas that I hear to other countries.
SPEAKER_00So it's really kind of figuring out the why, why I'm doing this. And then I guess the next question would be, how am I doing this?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And um so yeah, talking about the how, and you talked about the fact, you know, faculty helping faculty, you know, oftentimes universities are their own little ecosystems, and sometimes we we think we're the only university on this planet. Um, are there ways for universities to connect with other universities? Are there ways for say provosts to connect with other provosts or leaders to you know think about how we can maximize what we do in the in the tech space without the tech driving everything, but uh still the faculty being in charge of what's happening in the classroom?
Derek BruffYeah. Also a very good question. I think one important ingredient is before we kind of look at kind of what other people are doing, is who do we have on campus who know our campus well? Right. Who are the faculty and the staff who have the experience, who have the expertise, who are thinking about these things all the time, who are doing the work. Many of them are connecting with colleagues at other institutions, right? And they're learning kind of what works at this place, what works at this place, what are the what are the new technologies to explore, what are the old reliables that have fresh, fresh life.
Derek BruffAnd so I, you know, one key message is to, is to don't undervalue the expertise of your own faculty and staff. I think sometimes provosts struggle to admit that they don't know as much as other people. And so if you can say, yes, we've got, you know, we've got these instructional technologists, we've got these, you know, uh department chairs who kind of are savvy about how to help an entire department adopt some technology, that's the kind of skill set that you want to lean into. You don't want to dismiss that. My key advice is to kind of empower the folks that are gonna be doing the work on your campus to make those connections, whether it's professional conferences or social networks, or sometimes it's it's even better to you know to send a group of people not to a conference, but to another campus that's doing something that you're kind of interested in, right?
Derek BruffAnd so don't try to think outside the box a little bit. But I think the more that you can empower your academic technologist, your teaching center staff, the more they'll be able to help your faculty really adopt these tools thoughtfully.
SPEAKER_00I think that's great advice because obviously, as an academic administrator, you know, top-down approaches never work. You have to really work with the culture. And um the ideal case scenario obviously would be for everything to work and grow organically, right? For faculty to have an interest in certain technologies, to learn about them, to integrate them, to tell other faculty about them. And um I really like your suggestion of you know maybe visiting a another campus, different university, one university, and learn from them, and then come back and you know, obviously you think about your own context, which is different, and you implement the things that you find interesting and and the things that you think will work on your campus.
SPEAKER_00You know, I recently talked to a professor at a very innovative university, they're they're really known for innovation. I'm not gonna name that university. Uh but many universities, there are about 4,000 out there, as you know, but uh many universities are not that innovative, right? And they're more traditional. And and so it's really about the balance oftentimes, to to balance the push for innovative technology with you know maintaining uh the educational values, the goals, the traditions of a given campus.
SPEAKER_00So, what advice would you give to provosts? How do you go about balancing the two?
Derek BruffSo I think I think there's a kind of an institutional version of the wheels on chairs principle. So I hadn't really articulated this before, but if you think about what your institutional values are, and then try to find ways that technology can support and enhance those values. So some schools really value the faculty-student interaction. Maybe it's small classes, maybe it's research experiences, whatever it is, but that faculty-student interaction is kind of the key. It's the thing that they message all the time, right?
Derek BruffWell, find technologies that are going to enhance that aspect of the learning experience, right? Technology is really good at connecting people across time and space, finding new ways to understand each other, right? I mean, it's also bad at a lot of things, but I like to think about kind of what are the things that technology can excel at when used thoughtfully. And so for that institution, maybe that's the kind of technologies that they they invest in, is things that are kind of helping people to connect with each other on campus. Another institution may be really focused on preparing students for the workforce, right?
Derek BruffAnd so they're gonna be thinking a lot about what are the technologies that our graduates are gonna need to know and to master. I'm hearing a lot of this in the AI space right now. There are some fields where generative AI is being very rapidly adopted in a lot of professional settings. And so I think it's incumbent on institutions to see that happening and then to kind of update their curriculum as necessary. Um, that may be less important for other types of institutions, right? Um, but but it is that I think that institutional wheels on chairs principle. The other thing I would say with innovation that I think is something to be kind of a little bit cautious of, and I'm gonna, I've never tried this analogy, but maybe this will make sense.
Derek BruffI recently re-watched the movie Back to the Future 3. All right. So Marty McFly and Doc Brown, and this is the third one, right? So they they they had they they were getting creative with their plots, but they were stuck in 1885. Right. Our heroes were stuck in the past in the Old West. They had a time machine. The time travel part of the machine was powered by a fusion reactor. It was called Mr. Fusion, but it only worked if the car went 88 miles per hour.
SPEAKER_00Right.
Derek BruffAnd so a lot of the plot of that movie was the fact that they didn't have any gasoline for the car in 1885. And so the challenge was getting the car up to speed. It wasn't the shiny fancy technology that was bolted into the car engine that did the time travel, right? And I think sometimes in teaching we have the same kind of scenario where it might be nice to have some amazing new virtual reality doppelganger of the instructor who is AI powered and trained on all the course notes and can interact with the students like the instructor might interact.
Derek BruffThat's great. But if it's in a course that has poorly articulated learning objectives and assessments that aren't aligned with those learning objectives and no scaffolded learning experiences for students, like you don't have the gasoline. So it doesn't matter if you have Mr. Fusion, right? And so I think when thinking about innovation, we also can't forget that sometimes it's the fundamentals that we need help with. This happens a lot in the online space where there's actually a lot of really strong design on online learning spaces. But if we get distracted by the shiny new thing, we might forget that we need to establish cognitive presence and social presence and instructor presence, right?
Derek BruffThere's some kind of core ingredients that need to be there. And particularly if you have faculty who are attracted to the shiny object, sometimes they overlook those fundamentals a little bit. And so I think that's part of the balance, too, right? Is yes, we want to be innovative, we want to try new things. That's not necessarily the latest, greatest, shiny thing. But even when it is, we also have to keep in mind the fundamentals of good teaching and learning design.
SPEAKER_00Those are great images, you know, and we should really run with them. And you should write about that in your newsletter too. That's awesome. And also love the metaphor of the institutional wheels on chairs. That's awesome. That's great.
Derek BruffYeah, and that I think about I had moments, institutional change is hard, right? I've been on committees, I've been on task force, right? But one that I was on probably back in 2012, we did a kind of scan of the landscape at our university. We had representatives from each of the colleges and schools, and they went out into their colleges and schools and tried to understand how faculty were using technology. And it was really interesting to see the patterns across that, right? What are the challenges that a lot of our colleges and schools are facing?
Derek BruffWhat are the values that we have, right? That kind of work can be a little arduous, um, but it can really help align whatever the initiative is that comes next. My doomsday scenario, this is not doomsday, but sometimes it's nice to think about the worst case scenario, right? And this is maybe not the worst case, but I have known institutions where a senior academic leader would go home for the holidays and see a grandchild using some new technology, some new app, some new device, and then come back to campus in January and create a whole new campus-wide initiative around that one experience.
Derek BruffOh my gosh. And that's maybe not the best way to think about innovation and technology, right? Use it as a data point, sure. But again, find the folks on your campus who are who are actively involved in this space and already know the landscape well, rely on them for good advice and for for information.
SPEAKER_00Yes. I I couldn't agree more. Now, um, you're at uh UVA for this academic year. What are some of the things that you see faculty at UVA do in the ed tech space? And um, how are they integrating AI, for example? What is it that you see?
Derek BruffSo most of my experience there does come around AI. Um uh so I've only been uh part of UVA for about two months now, so I'm still getting to know the landscape and the people. But one of my big projects is to is to support uh a program aimed at helping faculty make thoughtful use of AI. So it's called the Faculty AI Guides. And our provost has invested a significant number of resources in about 50 faculty who are tasked with helping their colleagues and their departments make informed choices about artificial intelligence in their teaching.
Derek BruffAnd I liked how the provost put it, we had a kind of two-day institute in August to help get these faculty ready for this work. And the provost said, it's fine if people decide to ban AI, right? They're gonna take a red light approach, but that needs to be an informed decision, not a just kind of stick my head in the sand or a gut reaction. Um, and so she's open to a lot of different types of AI use and AI policies, but she wants the faculty to kind of know and make intentional choices. And so it's been really enjoyable to get to know these.
Derek BruffI I haven't got I've got to know all the guides a little bit, but there's like two groups of eight that I'm kind of shepherding through this process, and it's been really fun to get to see what they're doing in their classes when it comes to experimenting with AI and then also how they're interacting and talking with their colleagues. The big trend that I'm seeing right now is that uh because again, I you know, I work at a teaching center and I'm thinking about faculty development at institutions a lot. And so, you know, 14 months ago, it was all about what am I going to put in my syllabus about AI, right?
Derek BruffAnd so you could do a workshop on AI syllabus statements and you'd have hundreds of faculty show up to that, right? Um this fall, it hasn't been quite so much that. I think faculty have largely moved into a kind of yellow light or green light phase with AI. A lot of faculty are kind of dabbling, they're kind of seeing what roles it could play in their courses. They're looking for those stories, actually. They would like to know how are their peers and colleagues using AI in assignments, in assessments, in in-class activities, what does it look like?
Derek BruffHow do you use these tools in my discipline, right? Because those answers are going to look very different.
SPEAKER_04Oh, totally, yes.
Derek BruffYeah. If you're in art and design or you're in English or you're in chemistry, like the the use of generative AI is very different in those disciplines. And so that's why I think this AI guides program is is kind of the right move this year for UVA, because at the center, we're trying to equip the guides so that they have what they need to kind of explore AI effectively, and then they can communicate that with faculty in their disciplines, where those contextual differences are much smaller, right?
SPEAKER_00Yes, yeah. Yeah, it makes so much sense to be disciplinary, discipline specific, right, in the approach. Otherwise, you know, you know, it's it wouldn't it wouldn't work. Now, going back to your book and some of the key principles that you talk about in intentional tech, what are some key principles that that provosts should keep in mind when when they shape their institution's educational technology strategies?
Derek BruffThat's a good question. So the book has seven teaching principles, because if you're gonna write a book with principles, you have to have seven of them. I think that's a rule somewhere. That's a holy number, I guess. Yes. I think. So and I was thinking kind of what are the you know one or two that are kind of most important to think about at an institutional level? And one I think is this notion of learning communities. So in the book, I argue that we can find ways to use technology to turn our classes into learning communities where students are learning from and with each other.
Derek BruffAnd I think a lot about so in my podcast, Intentional Teaching, um, last year I had a guest on, Eric Detweiler from Middle Tennessee State University, just down the road from me in Nashville. And he was talking about this commercial that he saw back in 2012 or 2013, where it was a it was a woman who had like a factory job of some sort, and she was taking online classes at night and getting a master, you know, some type of degree or certification, and then she got this great new job because of all of this. And it was kind of heartwarming, and they were trying to, you know, recruit students to whatever online program it was.
Derek BruffWhat he noticed about this, he's a professor of English and rhetoric. And so what he noticed in the commercial was she's like the only human in the entire commercial. Her learning experience is her and her computer. There's no depiction of a professor or other students, right?
SPEAKER_00Right.
Derek BruffAnd that's not how learning works for most of us. We are generally now, some folks do well in that kind of environment, right? And some folks are kind of can take advantage of resources and kind of teach themselves what they need to, but by and large, our students need learning to be a social experience. They need to have a relationship with their instructor who can help guide them and motivate them. They need to have peers and colleagues that they can learn from and with and engage with as they try to make sense of all the course material. And so this principle of learning communities, I think, can be useful when you think about technology adoption at an institutional scale.
Derek BruffWhat are the technologies that are going to help our students connect with each other around learning and with their professors, right?
SPEAKER_04Right.
Derek BruffAnd so, for instance, I'm a big fan of some type of social annotation tool. There's a few out there that are popular, but the idea is that you can have a document that we all have access to, and I can highlight a sentence and put a comment in the margin, and you can read my comment and reply to it, and you can highlight something, right? And the ability for that type of tool to facilitate engagement with the reading and engagement with other students is really incredible. And so that's the kind of thing I think of is like if we're gonna adopt and I think a lot about campus adoption, maybe we can talk a little bit about that, but but if we're gonna adopt an a technology at the institution level, I wanna think about why are we gonna use it, right?
Derek BruffWhat's it gonna accomplish? And if it has that social collaborative learning piece, that's that's a reason maybe to say yes to that.
SPEAKER_00I I absolutely agree that you know learning it cannot be uh separated from the social aspect of it, right? Because we're social beings and we learn best um with others. Um now let's switch gears and and talk about uh faculty development and faculty development programs. Are there examples of faculty, uh successful faculty development programs at universities that you see that you're familiar with that have helped professors integrate technology more effectively?
Derek BruffI think so. I think we did some good work when I was at Vanderbilt University. Um part of our teaching center was the support uh for faculty for use of the learning management system. And so we we had adopted Brightspace, and so we called it Brightspace support at the CFT. And we had a model, it kind of took us a few years to figure this out, but we were we were a teaching center that grew into academic technology support. And so we had this kind of core of faculty development um in what we were doing.
Derek BruffAnd one of the things as we kind of transitioned early on to doing all the LMS support at our center is I realized there was a kind of a paradigm shift between the folks over in IT and how we approached it. And neither approach is wrong, they just served kind of different purposes. So the IT folks tended to solve problems quickly and efficiently for faculty. Their goal was to get the problem resolved as quickly and efficiently as possible. Our goal was to develop faculty members' skills in teaching with the technologies.
Derek BruffNow, we often had to solve a problem quickly and efficiently for a faculty member. It's not that we didn't do that, but we were always looking for opportunities to think about what is the faculty member trying to accomplish pedagogically? Yes. Is this the tool they've asked us about may not even be the best tool to do that, right? And so instead of just solving the tech problem in front of us, we would try to contextualize it in the teaching, teaching uh context and the moves they were trying to make as a teacher, and then help them think about how we can use technologies well to support that.
Derek BruffAnd you know, faculty didn't always have time for that conversation, but when they did, we were in a position to help them kind of think through what those technologies could be. Uh my my colleague Stacey Johnson headed up that team, and she used to say, it was like you're going to McDonald's and you order a Big Mac and they say, Do you want fries with that? And we were like, Do you want to talk about teaching too with your tech support request? Right. Um But I think that blend is important, that approach of kind of thinking about how do we develop our faculty's skills over time at teaching with technology, at teaching online, whatever it may be.
Derek BruffThe other thing I think about a lot is that faculty, especially around technology, but really any kind of teaching change that they they they want to make, they need time and access to expertise. Faculty are experts in their own domains. They are not necessarily experts in technology or even instructional design, right? Um, and they also are very busy, right? Whether you're on the research track and you don't have a lot of time for teaching because you're trying to publish papers, or maybe you're in a teaching track and you have five classes and 150 students and you still don't still don't have a lot of time, right?
Derek BruffRight. So the programs I think that have been successful are the ones that somehow manage to provide the time and the access to expertise. So for instance, at Vanderbilt, we had one called the Bold Fellows Program. It stood for Blended and Online Learning Design. I like that. It's our best acronym ever. I love that acronym. It was so good we we reused it for another program later. But the idea was that a faculty member could come with something in their teaching that wasn't quite working right, kind of a problem to solve. And they would also come with a graduate student who would help them solve that problem.
Derek BruffAnd so we were able to provide some funding for the grad student and a lot of support for the graduate student. And so whatever intervention they were designing had a kind of blended or online component to it, right? So they were trying to use technology to solve a problem in their teaching, but the faculty member didn't have enough time to do it themselves. And so, in that setting, at that institution, we were able to provide time in the form of a graduate assistant. And we did our work helping the grad assistant figure out what are the skills you need here, what are the technologies you need here, right?
Derek BruffRight, right. And so I call that a win-win-win because a faculty member gets a second set of hands to solve a problem. The grad student gets a lot of great professional development that's useful for their future faculty career. Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
Derek BruffAnd the students in the course have a better course experience because it's been more thoughtfully designed with new tools. So that's not the only way to do time and expertise, right? But I think you have to think about the time and expertise. How can you provide that, right? Is it summer support? Um, is it a course release? Is it smaller section sizes, right? Is it is it an undergraduate? So at Boston University last year, I don't know as much about this program because I didn't experience it firsthand, but my understanding is that they hired undergraduate students who were a little savvier about AI and paired them up with faculty who were wanting to experiment with AI in their teaching.
Derek BruffAnd so the undergraduate's job was to help the faculty member learn a little bit about AI and then also imagine what are the activities and assignments and assessments that might might use these tools. And so I thought that was an it was another great solution. It was it did involve some resources, right? The undergraduates were paid for this work, but it it again gave the faculty member more time and access to some expertise that they needed to make some changes in their teaching.
SPEAKER_00It's always great when you get students involved, you know, be that a graduate student or undergraduate students. I think that's that's fabulous because uh we're learning institutions, or we're supposed to be learning institutions, and it means that everybody's learning, right? And that's fantastic when undergraduate students help faculty in the tech space. That's great. That's yeah, I like that.
Derek BruffAnd I, you know, I always think about the teaching skills that we have as instructors, like that's a place of learning too. I don't think we should be static in our approaches to teaching. We should be continuing to learn new ways to teach, new ways to connect with our students, new technologies to figure out, right? There's always opportunities to continue developing our teaching skills over time. And that's part of that learning institution, right?
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah, no, couldn't agree more. And I think when you do that, then you over time create a culture, right? Um, where that seems to be the norm, where everybody's you know continuing to learn and improve in their teaching. And and talking about you know, creating such a culture, what can provosts do? How can provosts help create such a culture where um technology is seen as a tool for enhancing student engagement and learning rather than a distraction or a burden?
Derek BruffYeah. So again, I think this idea of kind of leaning on the expertise you have on your campus, right? And so, not the kind of top-down approach, but to say who are the folks who are doing this work, who are experimenting well. I think that's important. As one example, in 2020, our provost at Vanderbilt knew we had gotten through the spring semester and we were looking ahead to the fall, and we knew we'd be teaching a lot of online and hybrid. And she wanted to give faculty the tools they needed to do that well. We had kind of the summer to regroup and plan.
Derek BruffAnd so she came to my center and basically said, What are four or five technologies that you think we should adopt for the whole campus? This is the year I'm just gonna write the check and make it happen. And so I'm so thankful she came to us though, right? Because my staff and I were the ones who had been talking to faculty about technology for years and had a good sense of which tools were gonna be broadly useful, flexible for a lot of situations. And so, and we got some real wins out of that, right? There were a few tools that got adopted that year that really took off at Vanderbilt and have, you know, been consistently adopted since then.
Derek BruffAnd so I was impressed that she was one, that she was able to pony up the money kind of on short short notice. That doesn't always happen, right? But the I think the bigger thing is that she came to the folks who were kind of on the ground figuring stuff out. And so I think that that's really important. I think it's important to have a process for adopting new technologies so that it's not kind of static. And you know, if you don't have a ton of resources, you may, you may not be able to give faculty everything that they want, and that's okay.
SPEAKER_03Right. Right.
Derek BruffBut, you know, um, one of the things I was really proud of at Vanderbilt, um, we switched LMSs from one to another and were able to save enough money that we were also able to adopt a classroom response system. So this is this was the subject of my first book back in 2009, right? These are kind of in-class polling tools. And we were in a situation where a lot of faculty were using these tools, but they were all kind of making their own course level adoptions. And so students were having to pay$30 here and$30 there and buy something here, and there was no kind of centralized support for any of that.
Derek BruffBut these tools are super flexible and useful for active learning, for student engagement, for formative assessment. It's why I wrote a whole book in them, right? Because they're they're kind of useful in all teaching contexts. And that was back when they were just multiple choice questions. They're even more robust now. And so we were able to save enough money from the LMS switch that we were able to kind of add on a classroom response system for the campus. And so I like that, thinking here's an LMS. This is supporting a lot of different teaching functions on our campus, kind of on-site classes, online classes. But we're also adopting a tool that's super useful in the classroom for active learning, right?
Derek BruffAnd now everyone has access to it. They don't have to pay extra for it, right? They can talk to their colleague down the hall who's using the same tool and learn some things from them, right? Those are the kind of wins that I I try to look for at an institutional level.
SPEAKER_00That's great. It's great to hear that you were able to save money. Oftentimes, when you switch to another LMS, it's quite the opposite. Right. We have to pay more for a shinier product, be that as it may. Now, how should Provost evaluate the success or effectiveness or also ineffectiveness of technology integration at the institutional level?
Derek BruffSo there's a very there's a kind of pragmatic answer to this and then a more kind of conceptual answer. The pragmatic is a lot of these tools will have some kind of dashboard where you can see how many faculty are using them, how many students are using them. And so when we pulled on those five tools in one summer at Vanderbilt, we tracked that kind of thing over the next year. And a couple of the tools really didn't have a lot of uptake. And so it didn't make sense to support them at an institutional level, maybe at a college level, right? They were only used in a couple of departments, and so you kind of think about that differently.
Derek BruffSo that's a practical answer. I think conceptually, I like to think about the typical faculty member, not the superheroes, right? There's always going to be some faculty who are so far ahead of everyone else and so willing to roll up their sleeves and figure stuff out that we love to write news articles about these faculty who are doing amazing things. And that's great. I love to support those faculty any way I can, but I also know they don't need a lot of support. They will do it themselves, right? Right. That's not my benchmark. My benchmark are the typical faculty.
Derek BruffYou know, I'm also not looking at the ones who will never adopt an LMS or any technology, right? That's a different case. But kind of the middle of the bunch, most of those faculty want to do right by their students, want to teach well, want to have some semblance of work-life balance, right? And so uh how are they adopting technology? And specifically, I would say, are they feeling comfortable to be a little creative with their technology use? I think about you know, faculty in 2019 and how they use their LMS.
Derek BruffAnd for a lot of faculty, it was pretty basic stuff, right? You're just posting some documents and maybe using the gradebook. And then 2020, a lot of us had to learn all the different tools in our LMS, and we realize there's a lot there that you can be creative with. Most LMSs will have a whole suite of tools that are designed for engagement with students. And so after 2020, I see so many more faculty who are they're not just doing the basics, they're kind of picking and choosing a few extra tools that make sense for their teaching context. And so that willingness to experiment a little, to be a little bit creative, to not just do the basics, they don't have to be super crazy innovative, but if they're comfortable with that, I think that's a good sign that your technology ecosystem, the technologies and the people are working pretty well for your faculty.
Derek BruffYeah.
SPEAKER_00That makes sense. Now let's talk about the future and the trends that you see. What trends in educational technology do you believe will have the most impact on higher education in the next decade? And and how can provost prepare for those changes ahead? Very good question.
Derek BruffSo my crystal ball, what's in my crystal ball today? Right. It's funny, someone asked me this a similar question in December of 2022, just a month after Chat GPT was released. Uh-huh. And and you know, the situation has changed a little bit since then. Um I would say right now, if I had to make some predictions, I think, well, AI for sure, uh, and really kind of thinking about AI beyond the chatbot as a way to interface AI, right? What does it start to look like if you have kind of special purpose tools that are trained on particular knowledge bases?
Derek BruffWhat does it look like when AI is integrated into all the digital products that we use, right? Figuring out the ethics of AI and how to use it well and thoughtfully in the workplace. So that's going to continue to be important the next couple of years. I think technologies for student engagement are going to be really key in the next five to 10 years. I think part of that is a response to the COVID pandemic, where students kind of en masse got disengaged in the learning process and we're having to find new ways to re-engage them with that.
Derek BruffOr they kind of missed out on a couple of key years in their development as learners, and now they're we're having to kind of help them figure out what it means to study and to learn and to engage deeply. But I think more generally, there's a kind of questioning of the value of higher education. And so, at least in the US context, I think there is right now. And so, you know, why should I spend X number of years and a lot of money doing this? And I think part of it is, you know, there needs to be an experience there where students are able to engage with colleagues, are able to learn, are able to collaborate, right?
Derek BruffThat they're not just kind of showing up for another boring lecture, that they could probably have Chat GPT summarize for them and save a bunch of time, right? And so, how do we actually engage students in things that matter? And so there's a, I don't know anything about this product, so I won't name the product, but the idea is that it connects faculty with micro internships at different companies. So the faculty member can say, these are my learning objectives, the companies can say these are the projects we need, and and the kind of the network connects them so a student can do a remote internship for four weeks, right?
Derek BruffRight. And so that's a kind of clever use of technology, right? Um and it's it's it's a way to provide experiential learning, maybe for some students who wouldn't ordinarily be able to spend a whole summer doing an internship somewhere, right? And so whether it's classroom engagement or online engagement or experiential learning, I think technologies for engagement are important. And I think there's also kind of related to that a continued blurring of the online and on-site. One of the things that seems clear to me is that more and more faculty are teaching both online and face-to-face courses.
Derek BruffMore and more students are taking online and face-to-face courses.
unknownRight.
Derek BruffAnd so if you look at a lot of institutions five to ten years ago, the online part of the university and the on-ground part of the university were separate in a lot of different structural ways, right?
SPEAKER_04Yes.
Derek BruffAnd now I don't think that makes as much sense anymore. And so I think provosts need to be thinking about how do we support good teaching and learning regardless of modality? What are the ways to pull that off and to not kind of silo things in in ways that that maybe made sense five or ten years ago.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, I think you're right. I think we we will see more of that. Um this breaking up of these silos that were there. And uh that is certainly changing now. Now, go ahead.
Derek BruffWell, I was gonna say, and like like there's consequences for that, right? So it used to be at a lot of campuses, if you were gonna teach online, you had to go through some kind of formal training to get you ready for that and maybe work with an instructional designer. And for the on-site classes, there were no such requirements, right? Right. And so if you blend those, then which model do you use? Do you do do you make some type of training required for all faculty, regardless of how they teach? Do you always partner them with an instructional designer? Probably not. You probably don't have the resources for that. So now you have to make different decisions about when do you require training, what types of support do you offer.
Derek BruffIt's not as simple as if it's online, you do this, if it's on site, you do this, right? You may have to have different heuristics for deciding how to how to support in different ways.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah, I agree. That's it's gonna be interesting to see how we're going to figure this one out. Now, you've talked about student engagement, and let's talk about equity and access uh to educational technology. How can institutions ensure equity and in access to educational technology for all students? And and what role can provost play in in leading those efforts? So that's a very big question.
Derek BruffAnd I'm just gonna touch on a couple of pieces that I think are important, knowing that there are a lot of other pieces to this question. I think when we think about equity and access, we often first think about the access piece of that. So, do our students have the physical devices, the laptops, the smartphones, the internet connectivity, right? Can they access the tools? And so, you know, I'll talk to faculty who are like, I would love to do this really amazing multimedia project with my students, but they don't have the hardware, they don't own the hardware to do that.
Derek BruffSo it's not fair for me to provide this kind of assignment. And some students who have access to resources knock it out of the park, and others have to kind of struggle with their, you know, five-year-old cell phone, right? That's inequitable, right? That is, I don't know if you can solve that problem, but I think provost are in a in a pretty good position to address that problem in some ways, right? To think about how can we fill that gap for students that need it? How can we provide certain levels of things across the board? So this is coming up all the time in my conversations around AI right now.
Derek BruffAll the best AI tools you have to pay for. The free versions aren't nearly as good as the paid versions, right? And so is it fair for students of means to have access to really great AI assistance in their learning and students without means to have to kind of suffer through with the free versions of these things? Well, one thing I'm seeing uh institutions do is to adopt some kind of paid AI tool. There's several out there, right, for the institution, so that now all faculty, staff, and students have some access to that.
Derek BruffNot unlike we ought, you know, we adopt an email program for the institution, right? It's just part of doing business, is you have to provide certain tools to your faculty and your students. That helps to address the equity piece, right? That's going to help to close it a little bit. Or the access piece, I should say. The other piece is a little more subtle, and that's kind of the know-how. And this comes out in the AI conversations as well. So, you know, if you're a if you're a typically aged undergraduate and you've come from a high school where half of your high school teachers were using AI thoughtfully and intentionally in their courses, you come in knowing a lot more about what AI can do, what it can't do, what it's good for, what are practical uses as a learner, what are the best tools to use.
Derek BruffThere's a lot of know-how there, right? Right that other students aren't going to have given their prior educational experiences. And so that's another place, that's where I think it's more on the faculty to try to close that gap. I think we have an imperative to think about what about the technologies do our students not know about and how can we build that into our instruction? Whether it's AI literacy or information literacy or whatever it is, we need to kind of not assume that students equally bring the skills, right?
Derek BruffSo if I'm teaching, you know, a sociology class, I may not assume they all have a great sociology background, but I may be making assumptions about how skilled they are in using technology, right? It's easy to say, oh, 20-year-olds know how to use all this stuff, but that's not necessarily true. And they don't necessarily know how to use these tools in an academic context either. And so that's where I think the more we can teach this, the more we can solve some of those know-how gaps. That makes a lot of sense.
SPEAKER_00You know, Derek, I wish we had more time. But unfortunately, out of time, and we only have time for one last question, and that's the question I get to ask everyone on this podcast, and that is which book you've read, and it doesn't have to be a tech book, but it can be, of course, which book you've read in the past year has had the greatest impact on you and why?
Derek BruffSo I realized I was going through my list of books that I finished reading, and then I realized the book I need to identify, I'm not quite done yet with. Because it is War War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy, and it is a huge book. It is, yes. I've talked about this on my podcast. I am doing a slow read of War and Peace, one chapter a day, through the calendar year 2024. Oh, that's fantastic. It's so good to read it that slowly and to kind of dwell on the writing and the plot and the characters at that pace.
Derek BruffBut what's really done it for me is there's a whole online community on Substack of other people doing this. We have a leader, he kind of sets the agenda and gives us notes and stuff on the characters and the plots and everything. But it's the community piece, right? It's me finishing the chapter for today and pulling out my Substack and seeing how other people have reacted to it, what questions they have. And so it gets back to what I said about kind of social learning, right? Like I would never have finished War and Peace without having this community of slow readers to interact with and engage with.
Derek BruffBut now I'm I'm I'm you know, I'm still like 60 chapters away from the end. But it's a big book, and I'm I'm I'm gonna make it. I'm gonna make it to the end of the year.
SPEAKER_00That's fantastic. You know, I did something similar a couple of years ago with a larger group of colleagues. We spent a hundred days on Dante, on the Divine Comedy. Of course, the Divine Comedy is not that long, but you know, when you look at the cantos and you spend a day on each canto, you know, and you really think about it, uh, you dwell on it, you think about the uh different ways how you can interpret the cantos. Yeah, it's it's fun, it's great. Not to be read all the time, to take some time with it. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome. Well, great. Well, thank you so much for a great book recommendation. And uh, you know, I'm sure that you know sales of War and Peace are gonna go up now. And uh yeah, thank you so much for being on the edit programs podcast, Derek. It was a real pleasure talking with you.
Derek BruffWell, thanks for having me. I really I really enjoyed our conversation.
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Partnering with over a hundred college presidents, the non-profit Citizens & Scholars launched a Faculty Institute a few years ago. It’s an 18-month professional...
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Consider the AI learning assistant, with access to all the materials from a particular course and programmed to serve as a tutor for students in that course....
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Before there was ChatGPT, there were generative AI coding tools. This means computer science, as a discipline, has had a little more time to adapt to AI than...
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Welcome to the 100th episode of Intentional Teaching! I am very excited to reach this milestone, and I am deeply grateful to all my guests and all my listeners...
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Deborah Barnett is assistant dean for education at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Public Health, where she has been talking with her faculty...