Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Intentional Teaching, a show about teaching in higher education

Intentional Teaching, a show about teaching in higher education artwork

Light Bulb Moments from 100 Episodes

Oct 14, 202658 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Welcome to the 100th episode of Intentional Teaching! I am very excited to reach this milestone, and I am deeply grateful to all my guests and all my listeners for making this possible. I learn so much from my guests, and I'm thrilled to know that folks out there appreciate the interviews and the show. In this 100th episode, I take a look back at some of the light bulb moments I've had interviewing guests over the last four years. What quotes and ideas and examples have really stuck with me and informed my work? My hope is that you'll find these moments interesting and perhaps useful to your work in higher education, and that this clip show might interest you in digging into the podcast archives and listening to some older episodes. Episode Resources Episode 2: AI Writing with Robert Cummings Episode 5: Transparent Teaching with Mary-Ann Winkelmes Episode 7: The Hidden Curriculum with Anthony Jack and Missy Foy Episode 11: Generative AI in Computer Science with Brett Becker University College Dublin's statement on the passing of Brett Becker "Promptly: Using Prompt Problems to Teach Learners How to Effectively Utilize AI Code Generators" Episode 41: Take It or Leave It with Stacey Johnson, Emily Donahoe, and Lance Eaton Episode 51: Teaching Habits of Mind with Becky Marchiel Episode 58: Writing, Editing, and AI with Heidi Nobles Episode 68: Teaching with AI Agents with Matthew Clemson, Isabelle Hesse, and Danny Liu Episode 69: Take It or Leave It with Stacey Johnson, Liz Norell, and Viji Sathy Episode 71: Defending Higher Education with Kevin McClure Episode 77: Peer and AI Review of Student Writing with Marit MacArthur and Anna Mills Support the show Podcast Links: Order The Norton Guide to AI-Aware Teaching by Annette Vee, Marc Watkins, and Derek Bruff. Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPCEA, the online and professional education association. Subscribe to the Intentional Teaching newsletter: https://derekbruff.ck.page/subscribe Support Intentional Teaching on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/intentionalteaching Find me on LinkedIn and Bluesky. See my website for my "Agile Learning" blog and information about having me speak at your campus or conference.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Derek BruffWelcome to Intentional Teaching, a podcast aimed at educators to help them develop foundational teaching skills and explore new ideas in teaching. I'm your host, Derek Bruff. I hope this podcast helps you be more intentional in how you teach and in how you develop as a teacher over time. During my time at the Vanderbilt University Center for Teaching, I hosted an educational technology podcast called Leading Lines. We had a great team across the CFT, the Institute for Digital Learning, and the libraries.

Derek BruffAnd the podcast served as ongoing professional development for all of us, giving us an excuse to reach out to faculty and staff across Higher Ed, doing interesting things in their teaching to learn about their work. In October 2022, after I had left Vanderbilt and the Leading Lines podcast had been canceled, I appeared on Bonnie Stehoviax, a fantastic podcast teaching in Higher Ed, with something of a retrospective of Leading Lines and its six years of episodes. I told Bonnie during that interview that I was not done podcasting.

Derek BruffAnd she even put that quote in her graphics for the episode. I was indeed not done podcasting because I launched Intentional Teaching this podcast in November of 2022, just a few weeks after that episode with Bonnie aired. I had picked up enough audio engineering know-how from the team at Vanderbilt, especially our technical producer, Rhett McDaniel, that I felt confident I could produce intentional teaching all by myself, as long as I had some decent commercial software to help me out. I jumped right back into podcasting, reaching out to my ever-growing professional network to invite colleagues on the show.

Derek BruffWhere leading lines focused on educational technology, intentional teaching has a broader scope. Any element of teaching in higher ed was on topic for the new show. And boy, have there been some spicy elements of teaching in higher ed over the past four years. Back in late 2022, I was somewhat ambitiously assigning three digits to the episode numbers in my file system as I made the episodes 001, 002, and so on. In the hopes that one day, one day, I would need that hundreds digit.

Derek BruffWell, listeners, today is the day. Welcome to the 100th episode of Intentional Teaching. I'm very excited to reach this milestone and in just under four years since launch. I am deeply grateful to all my guests and all my listeners for making this possible. I learned so much from my guests, and I'm thrilled to know that folks out there appreciate the interviews and the show. Several times this year I've traveled for work and met someone who introduced themselves as a listener, and I can't tell you how rewarding that is. I wanted to do something a little special for this 100th episode.

Derek BruffAll of my guests have been fantastic, but there are some interviews where a guest says something that has really stuck with me, some insight or example that has continued to inform the educational and development work I do with faculty and other instructors. I wanted to highlight those moments here in the 100th episode. I've got something of a clip show. I feel like putting together one of those episodes of 80s sitcoms. Clip shows are actually a lot of work, as I've been finding out putting this episode together. I want to share some of those interview moments that have really stuck with me and offer some commentary about why those moments have continued to inform my work.

Derek BruffMy hope is that you'll find these moments interesting and perhaps useful to your work in higher ed, and also that this clip show might interest you in digging into the podcast archives and listening to some older episodes. I've tried to create these episodes to be somewhat evergreen. You know, when you're talking about AI and teaching, things change rapidly, but um certainly some of these episodes uh still hold up really, really well a few years after they first aired. Before we get into the clips, though, I wanted to share uh just a few stats about the podcast.

Derek BruffThe big number is for my podcast host, Buzz Sprout, which tells me that intentional teaching episodes have been downloaded 54,350 times since I started the podcast. That includes all 99 regular episodes and three extra episodes. I had two episodes that were kind of rebroadcasts of my interviews on other shows, and then I had that oral history of the Vanderbilt University Center for Teaching. So I've actually, there's actually 102 episodes in the feed right now. That yields an average of just over 530 downloads per episode, which feels pretty good.

Derek BruffThat's just an average, of course, which episodes have been most popular. Let's take a look at our top five. Number five, digital accessibility with Amy Lomolini, which has had 746 downloads. Number four, teaching with AI agents with Matthew Clemson, Isabella Hess, and Danny Liu, with 779 downloads. Apparently I'm big in Australia. Number three, AI Aware Teaching with Annette v. Mark Watkins, and me, with special guest interviewer Stacey Johnson.

Derek BruffThat's at 791 downloads. Number two on the list is Surviving Peak Higher Ed with Brian Alexander with 850 downloads and the distinction of having the best first week of any of my episodes. Seriously, I don't I don't know what happened with that episode, but it took off like lightning. And the number one most downloaded episode of the show is Rethinking Teaching in an Age of AI with James Lang and Michelle Miller. That one's gotten 1,147 downloads as of today.

Derek BruffThanks to Jim and Michelle for coming on the show. Pretty early in the AI era to help us figure things out. Looking over my own records of the show, Intentional Teaching has featured 165 guests in its first 99 episodes. Part of that's because every now and then I bring four guests on the show, and that is ambitious when I get to the editing. Early on, I started tracking some numbers. I saw some patterns. I seem to perhaps not surprisingly interview a lot of mathematicians since I am one.

Derek BruffBut also I've had a lot of biologists and English faculty on the show. And so I did a count. I'm pretty sure those three disciplines are the most common ones among my guests. And English has the most representation. 14% of all my guests come from the world of English. Biology is in second with 12% of all guests, and mathematics is in third with 11%. If you don't know this about me already, I do like counting things and tracking things. Alright, now it's time for a trip down memory lane with some of my favorite bits of tape, over 99 episodes of intentional teaching.

Derek BruffLet us start with episode two, way back in November of 2022. I interviewed Robert Cummings, who is a professor of writing and rhetoric at the University of Mississippi, also Executive Director of Academic Innovation there. I had met Bob through my uh then new job at the University of Mississippi's Center for Excellence in Teaching and Learning. Thanks again to Josh Eiler for hiring me uh that fall. Um I uh I talked to Bob about generative AI and its impact on writing and the teaching of writing, which sounds like, I don't know, every other episode these days, but um, this was in fact an interview that I recorded before, several weeks before ChatGPT launched.

Derek BruffUm and so Bob and several of his colleagues in writing and rhetoric and computer science were exploring earlier versions of generative AI and their impact on writing. He and I had a great conversation about all this before we knew what ChatGPT was, and everyone had to talk about AI all the time. And so I want to share a bit from his interview where he shares a story that has really shaped a lot. Looking back, that shaped a lot about how I think about what one can do with generative AI.

SPEAKER_01I attended uh a workshop on the use of uh AI writing generators back in the summer. And there was um, oh my gosh, I've got to go back and look for her name. Um, there was a speaker there who was um also a punk rocker. She was the author of a book called Broadband, it's about women uh in the early internet era. So it was a great, great title. Um that's a great title. It is, it is a really good title. Yeah. Um and I I I need to go look her uh look up her name.

SPEAKER_01I'm sorry it's escaping right now.

Derek BruffBut this is Future Derek jumping in again. The author that Bob is trying to remember is named Claire L. Evans. She's the author of Broadband, the untold story of the woman who made the internet.

SPEAKER_01As a artist, as a as a as a musician, she and her collaborator as her partner, they went and they knew something about coding. So they had they decided to use AI and the creation of one of their albums. And so they took all of the music and put it into a database. And then they took all of their lyrics and they put it into a database. And then they started their composing process.

SPEAKER_01So they got random, seemingly random outputs in their lyrics. And it wasn't like they just took those random outputs and started putting them into a song. They just looked at it, and every once in a while something would come up, and it would they would say, huh, that's really interesting. And that would be a kernel of something they would explore. Same thing musically. They would get a lot of different notes that would come out, but then every once in a while they would find something that they would want to explore, and that was their launching off part. So I would go back and say, hey, there's what works about that for me as a writing teacher is that they had a very deliberative and defined process, and they defined how they wanted to use AI in that process.

SPEAKER_01So to me, that was like it was a light bulb moment. I was like, that's how we can use it in the writing classroom.

Derek BruffSo I think that was a light bulb moment for Bob. It was a light bulb moment for me too. Um, the way he talks about that band using AI to um as kind of inspiration for new music. Um, that's uh that's the the mental model I've been calling lately a possibility machine. AI, not just not as an answer machine, which is problematic in a lot of reasons, but as a possibility machine, um, a tool we can use to generate stuff, and then we get to decide what we want to do with that stuff. Um, that's a it's a very different mental model.

Derek BruffUm, and I think that framing colored my impressions of Chat GPT and all the other generative AI tools when they came out. Um, I never really looked at them as answer machines, um, knowing that artists could use AI like what Bob described in that story. I I also really couldn't take seriously some of the broad claims about AI that that didn't account for that kind of use case. And so I've always seen the use of AI as a little bit more complex, and I've always had that possibility machine mental model certainly has an option for how we and our students work with AI.

Derek BruffUm, one more quick quote from Bob. Um, he said something else about um AI and writing that has also stuck with me. Um, here it is.

SPEAKER_01The real problem that we're going to experience as teachers, and the real problem we're going to experience as students, and the real problem we're going to experience as a public is we've never been in a situation, as at least that I can think of, where writing has been divorced from thought. So previously, all every time you encountered writing somewhere, behind that writing was thinking. It might not have been great thinking, it might have been a stranger, it might have been a group of people, and it might have been plagiarism, but at the core somewhere there was thinking.

SPEAKER_01And there no longer is. So we're not, I don't feel like I don't feel that as a public and as educators, certainly, and as students, we're really prepared to look at to to separate that out. And that's something that we're gonna have to be able to do now going forward. We're gonna have to be able to look at a piece of writing and say, okay, this is a piece of writing. I don't know if there was thought behind it. Uh so it gets into uh really into Stanley Fish territory.

SPEAKER_01I don't know if you've read Stanley Fish, is there a text in this class? But it was sort of like um reader response theory and some of the other literary theory, which I'll need to go back and brush up on now, I suppose. But um, it it gets into the idea of where does meaning get assigned? Is it upon the reader reading the text? Is it upon the author writing the text? Um, and so different people said different things, but it really hasn't felt like it had as much importance as it does now.

Derek BruffYeah, I think we're still grappling with that four years after ChatGPT launched. Um, speaking of responding to AI, um I don't think I can count the number of times I've either heard transparent teaching recommended as a critical response to AI in higher ed, or recommended it myself, right? Like I I think I feel like I talk about transparent teaching all the time now in my consultations and workshops around AI. Um, and that idea of transparent teaching um sounds kind of intuitive, but but it actually there there's a there's a framework that comes from the Transparency in Learning and Teaching project, the Tilt Project, headed up by Mary Ann Winklemus, who I had on episode five of the podcast.

Derek BruffI knew Mary Ann through the Center for Teaching and Learning World, um, and I was excited to have her on the show and to talk about TILT, their framework. And it's it's it's three kinds of transparency. It's transparency and purpose, helping students understand why you're giving them an assignment. What are they supposed to get out of it? What what what knowledge or skills are they going to gain? Um also transparency and task, um, making it clear what they're supposed to do, so they're not kind of left wondering what that should be. Um, and then transparency and grading criteria as well.

Derek BruffSo there's kind of a kind of fairness there. Um and there's a lot to say about tilt research. Uh they they've shown some really strong effects of these transparency moves in student learning and student success and student persistence. And so there's a real there. Um and um what stuck with me from my conversation with Marianne back in episode five was something she said about the transition that students make from high school to college. I had I had shared with her that I was teaching this math class, and I had actually polled my students after the first exam, which didn't go very well, and I asked them, How did you, how did you study for this exam?

Derek BruffAnd they came up with a whole bunch of strategies, and none of them, none of them mentioned the strategy I thought would be most helpful, which is work some practice problems and check your answers, problems you'd never seen before. And it helped me see that, oh, okay, they these were Vanderbilt students at the time. They're they're good students, um, but they didn't really know how to study in my class. And Mary Ann speaks to that really eloquently in this quote from my interview in episode five.

SPEAKER_02Um But the experience that you had with your students, where they chose study strategies different from what you sort of expected, is very common, especially at the introductory level in college education, because students come out of high school um with a kind of set of strategies for learning and for succeeding in school. Um, and even the most successful students uh will hit a kind of a roadbloce they become more specialized in different disciplines.

SPEAKER_02Because the kind of strategies that you learn for high school success work equally across all disciplines. When you get to college, each discipline has its own set of methods and terms and techniques. And the same strategies don't work anymore. So the strategies your students were using about review your notes and read the textbook, those worked. Those were those kind of standard across all discipline strategies that don't work anymore inside of a particular discipline as a fact. Um, students have never done a particular kind of work before, how are they gonna know what that work looks like or how to do it effectively, right?

SPEAKER_02Like let's say we're asking students, I often ask students in an art history paper to analyze the physical composition of uh, let's say a Madonna and child painting from the 15th century, right? Um that word analyze, and what I expect students to do there, like there's a whole process of visual formal analysis in studying art. But when they see the word analyze on the art history assignment, and then they see the word analyze on their chemistry lab assignment, that means something completely different to analyze the physical composition of something in chemistry than it does to do that in art history.

SPEAKER_02So, how are students going to know how to do either of those things if they've never seen it done before? At any level, I think it is of expertise, it is very helpful for students to think about how and why they are learning what they are learning. I think sometimes teachers worry that when students become aware of the how and the why, the work gets too easy for them, right? Are we spoon feeding students? Well, no, we're not delivering a pile of transparency to their door.

SPEAKER_02It is an engagement, it is a process, it is a tool for their own analysis of how they're learning. But are we making it too easy? Is a question I hear sometimes. And I think we've got to look back at what do we mean by easy? What is it that we want them to struggle with, right? Do we want them to and what are we measuring, right? How do we measure their success? So if what we aim to measure is how well can a person figure out the secret unwritten rules to the discipline they've chosen before they need any help, right?

SPEAKER_02If that's what we're trying to measure, then don't talk with them about the process of learning, right? But instead, if what we're trying to measure is what does the student's best quality work look like? What does the top of their achievement look like when they spend a hundred percent of their time doing their best quality work as opposed to 50% of their time doing their best quality work after they've spent half of the time figuring out how on earth am I gonna do this work?

Derek BruffRight.

SPEAKER_02So it really boils down to what is it that we want to measure.

Derek BruffI connect what Marianne said to this notion of desirable and undesirable difficulties. Learning is hard work. It should be. Uh those are desirable difficulties because it's hard, but they we get a result that we want. Undesirable difficulties, uh, that's just stuff that gets in the way of what we're really after. And I I really like how she speaks to that in that quote. Um and that bit about helping students develop domain or discipline-specific study skills, I think that that helps to explain a lot of the challenges that instructors, particularly those in introductory courses, uh encounter.

Derek BruffLike you hear students who aren't doing the reading or they're not participating in group discussions in class, right? Sometimes that's because uh they don't know how to do that in your field, in your discipline. And it also, I think this this distinction Marianne points to speaks to the value of alternative grading, um, which often is uh those strategies are structured to give students multiple opportunities and chances to learn those domain or discipline-specific study skills. Um, I think one of the core tenets of most alt grading approaches is that if a student's struggling in week three or four of a semester, they are not done.

Derek BruffThat the that whatever they do then is not gonna hold them back from being completely successful at the end if they if they can figure out what they need to and hit those learning outcomes. So I I I I've I like to keep in mind what Marianne said about the challenges that students face as they go into particular disciplines and what that might mean for them. Okay, I wanna, speaking of uh needing some time to adjust to college, I'm gonna take us to episode seven. I spoke with Anthony Jack. Um I wasn't really familiar with his work, but he came highly recommended, and I have a much better appreciation now of his research on the college experiences of minoritized students.

Derek BruffUmly a professor of higher ed leadership at Boston University. I feel kind of lucky to have gotten him on the podcast so early in the show. Um he's got a new book out called Class Dismissed: When Colleges Ignore Inequality and Students Pay the Price. And it is very near the top of my two read stack at the moment. Uh when I had Anthony Jack on the show in early 2023, he talked about the hidden curriculum. This is the idea that there are things you need to know to be a successful college student that maybe no one ever tells you, or certainly isn't part of the uh explicit curriculum of instruction.

Derek BruffAnd uh Tony shared a story that puts such a fine point on the challenges of the hidden curriculum that I find that I fit it into workshops and consultations with faculty all the time. Here's that story.

SPEAKER_00When you think about the loaded language that we have in class, when faculty members say on the first day of class, oh, my office hours are from two to four, I had one faculty member tell me she always wondered why her students never came in that two to four spot. And she told me, she said, she finally asked, she asked me for advice and she and I said, ask, I said, define office hours. And she came back, she said, you know what, Tony? My students told me that the reason why they did not come to office hours is because when I said that my office hours from two to four, they thought that was my time to do my work uninterrupted.

SPEAKER_00Right? Something was lost in translation that had nothing to do with English proficiency, right? We have a very coded language. We cannot take for granted that everyone has. Had a chance to master this new language and the and the required skills to navigate campus before they arrive at the college gates.

Derek BruffThat student thought office hours meant the exact opposite of what they really mean. That's just it's just startling. But I don't blame the student, right? That's the point here. Like, how were they supposed to know what office hours were for? That's a perfectly reasonable conclusion that office hours is time for you to be in your office and get work done. Um, I mean, uh Anthony Jack writes a lot about first generation students, especially uh black students. And but you know, I'm a white second generation student, college student. Um, I didn't understand the value of office hours until my junior year.

Derek BruffUm and so, like, like it's it's a mystery, right? And so that kind of the the help-seeking behavior, um, I think is something that we have to pay a lot of attention to. Um, and I think that story points to that. And, you know, there's a lot involved in meeting the academic needs of our store of our students, but um I think that office hour story that that Tony relayed is it feels like a, I don't know if it's a light bulb or a threshold moment, but it feels like once you've heard that, you can't really go back to assuming that students understand all of the coded language, as as Tony says um in that in that clip.

Derek BruffUm and so I think that that that sticks with me and informs how I talk to faculty about how they talk with students. I'm gonna take a little bit of a sidebar here. Um a few months ago, I was looking up a few past guests to see what they had been up to and maybe invite them back on the show. And that's when I found out the sad news that my guest on episode 11, University College Dublin computer science professor Brett Becker, passed away in 2024. Um I I didn't know Brett outside of our podcast interview, but it was clear that he had a passion and a drive for computer science education.

Derek BruffI'll put a link in the show notes to the the post that uh Dublin School of Computer Science shared about Brett's work. It's it's really impressive. Um he was born in 1976, just like me. Um and so uh it's it's sad, it's sad that he's gone. Um I do know that after our podcast interview, Brett worked on a new kind of assessment problem for computer science students. He called them prompt problems. Um I'll put a link to his his paper in the show notes, but the the gist of it is that you know AI can code stuff pretty well.

Derek BruffUm if you're teaching, you know, first or second semester computer science, it can it can easily code all those assignments. And so um one strategy he he he was developing was to kind of work with AI. And so the idea is that uh he would give students a kind of uh uh a function that they had to write, and he would give them some output, some input-output combos that they could use to test the function. And the student's job was essentially what we now call vibe coding. The students would talk to an AI chatbot, tell it what code to write, and then Brett's platform would then take that output, the code that the AI wrote, and then test it against these inputs and outputs, um, which is a pretty standard kind of computer science assessment way to kind of see if a program's working.

Derek BruffUm and so the the challenge here is can students use their natural language to describe sufficiently well the function or the program they need to write to do the things that are specified. Um and so um I thought that was a really clever way. I haven't really thought about what that would look like in other fields, but it seems like a really sensible way to respond to the role of AI coding assistants in computer science education. And so I was really hoping to have Brett back on to talk about that. Um I I'll share a little bit of my conversation from episode 11 with Brett.

Derek BruffUm, this is from the end of the interview where he spoke eloquently about the need for computer science education to address ethics.

SPEAKER_07But you know, the the bottom line here is that um this is uh just another example of where computing is is uh having big societal effects and and big potential changes in our society because of new technologies. Uh and increasingly these have big ethical uh uh implications. And uh it's been hard to integrate ethics into computing academically. Where does it fit? How do you do it? You know, the normal academic stuff.

SPEAKER_07We don't have room in the curriculum for this. Uh put it over there, you know. And but we're at a point now where it's uh you know, I would argue that embedding ethics into the computing curriculum uh should uh should be unavoidable. Uh it I I you know uh I want to believe it is unavoidable, but one should not be able to teach computing while avoiding ethics. And technologies like this give us a a super awesome, exciting, engaging ethical playground.

SPEAKER_07And students are into this. It's in the news, it's a cool new tool, it works well, you know. So we we we suddenly have a situation where we don't have to beg students to be interested in computational ethics. They are, they might not know it, but they already are.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_07So use these tools for that.

Derek BruffThey're they're a a fertile field of ethical conundrums. I have had a few episodes of the show that featured undergraduate students who were in teaching roles. Um back on episode 32, um, I talked with Amy Fleming and student Marin Rice at Embry Riddle Aeronautical University about their students' partners program there. Marin was a student partner at that program. Um in episode 37, we talked about learning assistants with Katie Johnson and Kataria Johnson Williams at Florida Gulf Coast University.

Derek BruffKataria was um a learning assistant. I think she was a learning assistant assistant in that she was helping Katie run the pedagogy course for the learning assistants. Um then a little bit later in episode uh 62, I ran across a really interesting model of using undergraduate students to help faculty respond to AI. Um they called it the AI Teaching Fellows Program. I talked with Christopher McVeigh and Niza Singh at Boston University, where Niza was helping Christopher uh update his course to respond to AI.

Derek BruffAnd I thought it might be interesting to see. Um faculty sometimes are doing the same things that they were when I interviewed them several years later, but students, students change, um, they do new things. And so I wanted to see kind of where those three students were. Um and I did a little LinkedIn digging. Niza, uh Niza Singh from Boston University, is now chief product officer at a company called Barrister, which is an AI-powered platform for lawyers and legal work. Um I saw from her LinkedIn profile she has continued to do a lot with AI in her career.

Derek BruffKataria Johnson Williams from Florida Gulf Coast is now a software engineer level two at Microsoft. Um, I think she talked about her interning at Microsoft during our interview, and she has continued to work there and moved up the ranks. And uh Marin Rice from Embry Riddle, I cannot find her on LinkedIn. Um maybe I'm not good at searching, but um, I also know she was a global security and intelligence studies major. So my theory is that she has a job somewhere in the world where social media use is not appropriate. Um I have a uh relative who disappears from Facebook every now and then because he has a global security job, and sometimes he needs to not be online.

Derek BruffUm I should probably reach out to Amy Fleming at Embry Riddle and see if she knows where Marin is. But um, I thought that was that'd be fun. I need to have some more students on the show. It's been a little while. Um I'll I'll put that on the list for the next hundred episodes. Other things I need to do more of is the Take It or Leave It format, um, which has been very popular. Um I've had a lot of fun with that format, um, which I borrowed from the American Birding Association podcast. Thanks again, Nate Swick, for that format. Um, I wanted to include one highlight from Take It or Leave It here on the 100th episode, and I'm gonna go with my first Take It or Leave It panel, episode 41, featuring Stacey Johnson, Emily Donahoe, and Lance Eaton.

Derek BruffWe um we talked about three essays as we do on that format, but one of the essays was about AI, and it was making the claim that generative AI would handle the routine and tedious work of an instructor, freeing up time for, quote, the most educational and relational tasks. All three of my guests said leave it on this essay, which was fun. And I could quote any of them, but I I've picked my my former University of Mississippi colleague, Emily Donahoe, um, who had who had something to say about this idea of uh routine, tedious work and important educational relational tasks.

SPEAKER_09I'm gonna totally agree with Stacy, and I'm gonna leave this take. And I'll tell so I was reading through the article. Here are some of the things that they said could be outsourced to AI. Um, one is uh writing syllabus policies, one is finding course materials, one is uh providing grades and feedback on student work, right? And I think, you know, the this this take kind of started with this idea that um that AI can free up time for the most important educational and relational tasks.

SPEAKER_09That's the direct quote. And I think the premise of this is totally wrong because it assumes that there is any work that is not relational, right? Like I think all of these tasks are highly relational. If I'm writing syllabus policies, I want my students to hear my voice and like know who I am in my syllabus policies. If I'm responding to their work, if I'm giving them feedback on their writing, they need to know that that's me on the other end, right? It's not a thing that I could automate. Um, especially because you know the most effective and durable forms of learning happen in the context of a relationship.

SPEAKER_09And outsourcing teaching to AI is a great way to lose credibility with students and lose that relationship and lose a lot of potential for learning. So I mean, I think if faculty feel like they can't concentrate on those important tasks because they're too busy doing other things or they're overwhelmed, then we should decrease faculty workload or like decrease course sizes rather than using AI as an excuse to just continuously ramp up the expectations for productivity.

Derek BruffI'll point out um I think Emily and I both do this a lot now, which is um most problems in higher ed would be made easier with smaller class sizes. Um that's usually not uh something in control of individual instructors, but um if there are any higher ed administrators listening, smaller class sizes makes everything easier. I think that's true almost all of the time. Um and I appreciate Emily for putting that in the mix. So um speaking of University of Mississippi colleagues, uh I wanted to share a fun moment that happened when I interviewed Becky Marshall in episode 51.

Derek BruffShe's a history professor at the University of Mississippi. And she talked about teaching this um intro survey history course, and not so much focusing on the, what did she call it, times and places, the kind of facts of history, but helping develop uh the habits of mind of historians in her students, helping them start to think like historians. And the way that she described it, it sounded so familiar to a paper. Uh it was a 20, 2006 paper, I read probably not long after that.

Derek BruffIt was probably somewhere between 06 and 2010. Paper by history professor Lyndall Calder. Uh he called it uncoverage, so kind of not the coverage model for a history survey, but um moving away from that, um, and thinking about this the skills or the habits of mind of historians. Anyway, what she described her teaching uh in so many ways resonated with what I remember Lyndall Calder writing about. I just I had to ask her. We actually ended the interview, I hit stop, and then I was like, okay, do you know this paper? And Becky's face lit up, and um, yes, and in fact, the paper had been transformative to her teaching career.

Derek BruffAnd I was like, okay, hold on, hold on. I gotta hit record again. And so um we recorded a little bit more where we talked about Calder's uncoverage idea. And um, I had previously only shared this little extra conversation as a bonus episode, um, but I wanted to include it here because it was just a really charming moment um for me and I think for Becky during that interview. I'm really curious, um, given how you described the habits of mind approach to your history survey course, um, have you ever read a paper about uncoverage by Lindell Calder?

SPEAKER_03I have read it and I love it. Um yeah, so this was um so I took a um I went to Northwestern for my um PhD, and they offered an opportunity to take a um a year-long class that was kind of a graduate certificate in teaching and learning. So we go through all these sort of workshops and do all these readings um over the course of the year, design your own class and teach it. Um, but they also really encouraged us to think about discipline specific sort of pedagogy.

SPEAKER_03So while I was kind of learning these general things about teaching and learning, I was also sort of um, you know, reading into what historians had said about how this literature can help us think through things. Um and the uncoverage article was one of the first ones I can remember having kind of this light bulb or this like aha moment, right? So this piece talks about how, I mean, especially like I was saying in the this survey, right, that the idea that we're gonna talk about like time and place, right? I'm gonna tell students everything that happened in the US since 1877, like that's ridiculous, it's impossible. And if that's my goal for myself too, right?

SPEAKER_03Like I am not going to achieve that goal, right? That's just like literally impossible. Um, and so right, the article really talks about right the idea of uncoverage, right, rather than thinking I need to cover everything. Um, instead, sort of prioritizing what do I want students to be able to do, to understand um by the end of the course. Um, and so for me, like that is really one of the places where you know it's like, okay, if I don't, if I can't teach them everything, what do I want them to understand? And especially what do I want them to do, right? That's different from just like what do I want them to have encountered or something.

SPEAKER_03And so um that's that's kind of where I landed on um, yeah, love, love the uncoverage. It really it really resonates. I think it's really important when um the idea is time and place. We're gonna talk about all the all the all the time.

Derek BruffThat's great. Yeah, and it was helpful for me too, because I having had a time and place history experience, you know, in high school, it was it helped help clarify, oh, there's a there's a total totally different way to do this that um that that just has different kinds of results for students.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think too, if you like it also kind of took some of the pressure off, right? I think about my course as right, it's an introduction to time and place and historical habits of mine. It's not the only time students are ever going to encounter American history. And so I also think, you know, if I can convince them that history is like even kind of interesting, there might be a moment further down the road, a moment uh that I am not a part of where they run into something that we didn't cover in class and they actually might pause for a moment to try to figure out, you know, what it's about. Like maybe that's wishful thinking, but right, it's like, but it's not my job to introduce them to to everything, right?

SPEAKER_03So yeah, um, that's helped me yeah, come to terms with that reality that I can't I can't share it all.

SPEAKER_11Yeah.

Derek BruffAll right. Now, I don't want this hundredth episode to be like two hours long. So I'm gonna be a little selective here. Let's do three quick hits, relatively quick hits on AI aware teaching. Um, first up, um, from episode 58, my University of Virginia colleague Heidi Nobles, who is, among other things, director of UVAA's writing across the curriculum program. Heidi's professional background as an editor has shaped the ways that she works with AI around writing. And not unlike that moment with Bob Cummings in episode two, Heidi's comments about working with AI, treating it like a human editor in some really thoughtful ways, not just a copy editor, but other forms of editing, developmental editing that human editors can provide.

Derek BruffUm, her her strategies have continued to inform how I think about the potential of kind of collaborating with AI in ways that preserve our agency but leverage the strengths of the technology. Um, Heidi had several great ideas. Um I'm gonna share one where she talks about using AI as a virtual beta tester.

SPEAKER_11Again, practically a few ideas that I use would be like setting up a beta test group. So you can open your chat agent and describe the people that you would want in your beta test group and then ask and then give it text and say, Hey, can you discuss this? And then you can insert yourself in there and say, Hey, I'm I'm your focus group leader, and I was just wondering if you could talk more about this idea or that idea. And those could be just ideas that you're still playing with. It could be um so you could just describe it, hey, I'm thinking about working out this idea, and here's kind of you know, it can be really, really raw, um, which is really nice.

SPEAKER_11And then you can see where they go with it and um you know, bounce things back and forth and try to try to prompt them to get the material that you like, get the responses that you want, which is a simulation of what we would do in a workshop, um, of trying to you know submit our work. And um, in a creative writing workshop, traditionally, right? Like I submit my work um a few days before the class period, and then everybody reads it, and then we go in and I do not get to talk, I just sit there and take notes, and then they discuss my work and I get to see what they how they responded.

SPEAKER_11And so, yes, a passage that I was trying to make them cry and they think it's hilarious, that's a problem. And I don't I don't argue with them. I'm just like, oh, I need to revise that. Um, so similarly, you can try to get that feedback, um, and then you can go back and revise it and see if you get a different response from the virtual beta tester.

Derek BruffHeidi mentioned other strategies like um having your AI pretend to be um a journal reviewer, um, giving it the the review guidelines um for that journal. Um, or I like this, I hadn't thought about this in a while, but taking your essay or whatever you're writing, dropping it in what is now called Gemini Notebook, having it create one of those cheesy podcast style audio summaries of your work, and then comparing that, like like what did the AI think was important uh about your work, and does that align with what you thought was important?

Derek BruffAnd if it doesn't, does that cause you to rethink kind of how you prioritize or talk about what you're trying to do? Um I thought that was really clever. And so um, here's one more word from Heidi that kind of wraps this up uh in a way that I think is helpful.

SPEAKER_11Um so all of these strategies mirror work that you would actually do with a human editor if you had access to that person. Um and I also think I don't know, the luxury of working with an actual trained editor is is lovely. If you get it, please do it. Um given that most of us are doing it with people who don't have training, um working with the bot can help us learn strategies that are portable from when we're working with our peers.

Derek BruffAnd speaking of not having humans nearby, um that was a pretty good segue segue. Uh episode 68, um, that's the one with the Australians. Matthew Clemson was the biochemistry faculty member I had on the show. And he talked about the AI tutor bot that he had built using the cogniti platform. He called it Dr. Matabolism. Um, and this is one of those bots that's been trained on the course material and also uh prompted to engage in Socratic dialogue. So it's meant to kind of know the stuff well and also act like a human tutor in some ways, where it would not just give away the answers, but help students think more deeply by asking questions.

Derek BruffAnd um, in part, uh Matthew talked about kind of one value of the of the bot was that, um, and I've heard this from other folks doing tutor bots, is that students often are hesitant to ask their instructor a question that they feel is like a dumb question and they don't want to be embarrassed. And so they'll work that out with an AI of some sort, and then maybe come to office hours later with a more well-developed question. Um uh the bot kind of gives the students a kind of a rehearsal space um for that. That's a term that you'll actually hear again in an upcoming episode of Intentional Teaching.

Derek BruffUm, but the part that really grabbed me um uh when when Matthew was talking about his tutor bot was um it was how he compared it to other things that were already happening in the course. Um and so uh not thinking of it not as a replacement for students coming to office hours, but actually as a replacement for a different strategy, which is the 2 a.m. Google search when you're stuck on something. Here's Matthew.

SPEAKER_06And it was really insightful for us not to just not just to see what topics they were asking about, but the way that you ask a question about a topic tells me a lot about how much you understand that topic and what misconceptions you have. And that's really insightful for me as an educator that I could see those misconceptions coming out in the questions. Um, so I'm sure that most of those 16,000 prompts, they were Google searches before.

SPEAKER_06They were searching keywords, they were trying to dig up information and and possibly not using the best keywords or the best terms in those searches to uncover the information that they really needed to answer their question. So I think it's it's great to have some access. It's all anonymized. I don't know what students are asking what questions, but I can see the questions and and the answers and make sure that the AI is behaving itself too.

Derek BruffYou know, I I think this this issue of what do we compare the new thing to, what is it replacing from our old ways? I think it's really critical. And if you think of AI as replacing human instructor interaction, there's all kinds of problems there. But if you think of it as replacing a crappy 2 a.m. Google search and it being a better alternative to that, maybe it having more accuracy or more helpful approach than Google might have. As Matthew says, the instructor gets some visibility into the types of questions that are being asked of the bot. I think that's really interesting.

Derek BruffThis is a, I think, a core way I think of educational technology and how we make sense of new technologies is let's not assume that the new thing has to be compared to this old thing. There may be other old things that we can compare it to and think a little more constructively about the new thing that way. Alright. Alright, episode 77 features my interview with Merritt MacArthur and Anna Mills about the Pear Project. This is the Peer and AI review and reflection project, where Merritt and Anna and a bunch of other writing instructors are having students get feedback on their writing from a peer, a fellow student, and then also getting feedback from an AI that has been given a very, very detailed prompt to try to direct it to give just the right kind of feedback for student writing.

Derek BruffAnd so this is this is kind of my go-to example now when I want to help people see that using AI and teaching may actually be useful. That there are ways to think very strategically about AI and the ways that it can interact with students that will support the core learning girls' goals, and then also maybe help students think a little bit differently about their relationship with AI. And so one of the things that uh came out in the interview is the importance of the sequence here.

Derek BruffThe students get structured and scaffolded feedback from a peer, and then they get structured and scaffolded feedback from the AI. And that sequence seemed to be kind of important. Um here's Merrick MacArthur talking about that importance and what they found in their early studies.

SPEAKER_08So our students are developing expertise. They don't have it already. So if they've tried to write something, they've seen other examples of that genre, you know, put that you provide in the class, and then also seen their peers try to write that thing, and then gotten feedback from their peers on their attempts to write that thing. At that point, I feel like they're in a stronger position to assess AI output, you know, and AI feedback. Um, and they can push back against it a little bit more. And in our first study from 2024, so this was published in Computers and Composition 2025.

SPEAKER_08Uh, 25% of the reflections we coded, you know, because we did a subsample of the 654 students, I think it was 131 students, uh, 25% of them uh said something, like basically pushed back against the AI feedback that just were skeptical about it or said it didn't align with their goals or whatever. And like whenever I saw that, it made my heart sing. I was like, that is developing AI literacy, you know, to not just trust it.

Derek BruffSo just as like Bob Cummings help helped me see early on to think of AI as a possibility machine, or at least that's one way we can think about it. Um, it's one thing to kind of have that notion ourselves. It's another thing to create learning activities that help students develop that mental model of AI. And that's one of the things I like about the Pair project is that it is, I think, helping students develop those new and different and probably better mental models of AI. Um, and so I've been really, I've been really attracted, especially this year, thinking about how can we reframe those mental models for students?

Derek BruffWhat are the activities, the assignments that can do that in a constructive, productive way? And I think Pair is a is a great example of that. And I look forward to uh the next round of results from their Ongoide Research Project. Um thanks to Merritt and Anna for coming on the show. Um I'll have to have them back soon. All right, there's a lot more we could say, certainly about AI. Um, I'm not gonna drop some quotes in here, but my my conversation with Jim Sites about moving writing into the classroom has been really important in helping me think about kind of the the pros and cons of doing that kind of work.

Derek BruffAnd and really I've I've used it to point a lot of faculty to thinking very deeply about what's the what's the hard part of learning we're asking students to do and how might we better support them in doing that. Um, maybe through moving that into the class time. It's kind of a flip class argument, but for an AI age where we're thinking really, really intentionally about the best use of our class time to support students. Um, I had Chloe Lewis on the show to talk about AI and math, and she's teaching these students who are um, you know, not math majors and are taking the one math course they have to take to get the to get the credit, and they often have a lot of math anxiety.

Derek BruffThey don't they don't believe in themselves and their own mathematical abilities, and so when the AI says, you know, something is something, it they they tend to take the AI more seriously. And so she's working to build the students' confidence in their own math skills while also helping them develop a healthy skepticism of AI. Um, I thought that was really, really thoughtful. Um I had Leon Furz on the podcast recently. Um uh he was the one who helped me see this kind of mental models idea and how important it is to how we interact with AI, whether it's an answer machine or a possibility engine.

Derek BruffAnd he he pointed out that the the user interface, the design of these tools often direct our mental models, and that that sometimes that's not super helpful. So um lots more we could say. Um I know this show is is been a lot of AI lately, and it will continue to be a lot of AI. I think that's a healthy interest of mine, um, but it's not exclusively AI, and I wanted to end this hundredth episode with a little advice from a couple of past guests on facing the kind of challenging times that higher ed is in the middle of right now. On episode 69, I had a take it or leave it panel, um, and they discussed an essay by Kevin McClear called Higher Ed is Adrift, where really he was kind of critiquing the institutional responses of higher ed colleges and universities to the uh current U.S.

Derek Bruffpresidential administration's ongoing attacks on higher ed. Um 2025 was a rough year, folks. Um 2026 is not much better. Um, but um on the panel, on the take it or leave it panel, we had this was another one with Stacey Johnson, um, uh a longtime friend and colleague from my days at Vanderbilt University. And Stacy shared some wise advice for those of us who are trying to figure out how to handle the current moment. Um and it's advice I've thought a lot about um since she shared it.

Derek BruffHere she is.

SPEAKER_10There are there's a certain personality type or like brain chemistry type who um arrives in these sorts of more chaotic moments and more uncertainty. Um maybe you have a colleague who is always looking into the horizon and gets really bored with routine and is terrible at returning emails, but when there's a crisis, they're at every meeting, they're getting stuff done, they're showing up.

SPEAKER_10So, one of the things that I would say is try to um borrow some of that energy from them. Whoever, whoever your colleague or your person is in your life that really is going to derive energy from these moments and find ways to contribute, like they are in your life because that's their role right now. You don't have to do that role, you have a different role.

Derek BruffOh, yeah.

SPEAKER_10So spend time with that person, contribute to what they're working on, be supportive of them. Like, I just feel like every person doesn't have to step up in every way all the time. And it's okay to know you, know where you thrive. Some of us are amazing at creating strong, healthy networks. Some of us are great at leadership development, some of us are great at building enthusiasm for specific projects that are against the wall. Um, so if there is a person in your work life who's good at this, now's the time for them to shine.

SPEAKER_10Let them have that.

Derek BruffTwo episodes later, I invited Kevin McClear on the show. His essay about higher ed being adrift was just really uh it was well timed, let's say. Um we talked about it on two different take it or leave it episodes, and then I had had Kevin on to kind of uh talk about uh uh his essay there and respond to some of what was raised. And um again, lots we could say, but um Kevin is a professor of higher ed and educational leadership at UNC Wilmington. And when he came on the show, I shared Stacy's advice with him, and I think he kind of added to it and built on it.

Derek BruffHere's what Kevin had to say.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think that's exactly right. You know, in a lot of ways, what they were advising was these don't have to be huge leaps for you because they're likely gonna be less uh successful or maybe less sustainable if you're to do that. And so for me personally, for example, I am not yet someone that you're likely gonna find at a protest. And that doesn't mean that it would never happen or that I haven't considered it, but but it's not something that I I generally am doing and find comfortable.

SPEAKER_05My wheelhouse, what where I find where I get a lot of strength or or where I'm able to exercise my strength more, is in being kind of a voice of calm, bridging folks that may be coming from different perspectives. And so what that looks like for me on a personal level is um I'm heavily involved in my faculty senate. Um there are these kind of initial conversations around an AAUP chapter. I will likely be a bit of a bridge between I have very close relationships with our campus administration.

SPEAKER_05I don't mind inhabiting these spaces where there might be conflicts in some cases, but I have relationships across the board, and I can say, I don't think that we're that far off here. I think that there is common ground here and ways that we can complement each other. And so that's a way that I'm gonna try to lean into my strength. Um, similar to you, uh having some voice out there where I'm writing and trying to pose good questions for us, trying to bring forward some practical solutions that could be helpful.

SPEAKER_05That's that's a strength that I'm hoping to be able to leverage. Most days it doesn't feel like enough. Um but I am trying to listen to the voices of the people that I spoke to who said, I think that those are those types of voices in your head that this isn't enough are the types of kind of self-defeating cynicism that's gonna get us into trouble and and keep us stalled.

Derek BruffI think I've followed Stacy's and Kevin's advice through a lot of my work, but this intentional teaching podcast in particular. Um, I've been trying to look to colleagues who handle crises well and trying to channel some of their energy. I think there are folks who speak very directly to the challenges facing higher ed, and I'm kind of envious of their ability to kind of speak truth plainly. Um and so, you know, I'm gonna call it an attack on higher ed if it's an attack on higher ed, trying to channel some of that truth speaking.

Derek BruffBut I'm also using my strengths, which for better or worse include podcasting, um, the technical skills, yes, but also I think I've gotten to be a pretty good interviewer over the years, and I've got a network of folks who are doing really interesting work. And um, those strengths allow me to create resources that I think instructors all over higher ed can use to inform their teaching in the midst of what um guest Brian Alexander called the polycrisis. And I'm gonna keep doing that. Uh I can't promise a hundred more episodes of the show, but you know, maybe, who knows? I can say that I have.

Derek BruffI think I counted eight interviews already recorded for upcoming episodes, so I need to start editing and getting those out. I'm very excited to share those with you. Um thanks for indulging me with a little bit of um nostalgia, I guess. I don't know. I, you know, doing this podcast for four years, it's been really helpful. As I said, you know, my old podcast, Leading Lines, was was a form of professional development for me and my team. Um, and I see that with intentional teaching as well. I learned so much from my guests, and then I can use that to help faculty at University of Virginia and elsewhere. Um, and so it's just an honor to be a part of that process and an honor to have some listeners out there who are finding this show useful.

Derek BruffSo thanks, as always, for listening. Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPSIA, the Online and Professional Education Association. In the show notes, you'll find a link to the UPSIA website where you can find out about their research, networking opportunities, and professional development offerings. This episode of Intentional Teaching was produced and edited by me, Derek Bruff. See the show notes for links to my website and socials, and to the Intentional Teaching newsletter, which goes out most weeks on Thursday or Friday.

Derek BruffIf you found this or any episode of Intentional Teaching useful, would you consider sharing it with a colleague? That would mean a lot. As always, thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Teaching Civic Skills with Rachel Piontak

    Nov 17, 202644 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Partnering with over a hundred college presidents, the non-profit Citizens & Scholars launched a Faculty Institute a few years ago. It’s an 18-month professional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. AI Learning Assistants at Scale with Kavitta Ghai and George Hanshaw

    Nov 3, 202641 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Consider the AI learning assistant, with access to all the materials from a particular course and programmed to serve as a tutor for students in that course....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. AI-Aware Computer Science Education with Briana Morrison, Greg Nelson, and Elijah Rivera

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Before there was ChatGPT, there were generative AI coding tools. This means computer science, as a discipline, has had a little more time to adapt to AI than...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Curricular Responses to AI with Deborah Barnett

    Sep 22, 202642 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Deborah Barnett is assistant dean for education at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Public Health, where she has been talking with her faculty...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Durable Skills in the Humanities with Chelsea Brislin, Shawna Felkins, and Jennifer Osterhage

    Sep 11, 202650 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. How can humanities courses and majors help students develop the kinds of durable skills--communication, collaboration, adaptability, and more--that employers...

    Credit the people on this episode