Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Partnering with over a hundred college presidents, the non-profit Citizens & Scholars launched a Faculty Institute a few years ago. It’s an 18-month professional learning experience for faculty to design or redesign a course to equip students to have respectful discussions and solve problems across differences. Today on the podcast, I talk with Rachel Piontak, senior program officer at Citizens & Scholars, and director of the Faculty Institute. Rachel has a passion for helping students develop civic skills, and she has a lot to say about the importance of this work, how her faculty colleagues go about it, and the kinds of impacts it can have on students. Episode Resources · Citizens & Scholars and its Faculty Institute · Rachel Piontak on LinkedIn · Interactivity Foundation and their Encouraging Bold Imagination activity · “Teaching in an Election Year with Bethany Morrison,” Intentional Teaching ep. 50 · “Pop Quiz on Faculty and the Law with Kent Kaufmann,” Intentional Teaching ep. 86 · “Web Literacy and the SIFT Method with Mike Caulfield,” Leading Lines ep. 54 Support the show Podcast Links: Order The Norton Guide to AI-Aware Teaching by Annette Vee, Marc Watkins, and Derek Bruff. Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPCEA, the online and professional education association. Subscribe to the Intentional Teaching newsletter: https://derekbruff.ck.page/subscribe Support Intentional Teaching on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/intentionalteaching Find me on LinkedIn and Bluesky. See my website for my "Agile Learning" blog and information about having me speak at your campus or conference.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Rachel PiontakThere's no doubt about it. It's a hard time to be an instructor right now. But students are going to be having these conversations one way or another. And what better place to practice them than in an environment that can provide that guidance and that scaffolding and those tools?
Derek BruffWelcome to Intentional Teaching, a podcast aimed at educators to help them develop foundational teaching skills and explore new ideas in teaching. I'm your host, Derek Bruff. We've heard that entry-level jobs for college graduates are getting harder to come by, thanks to companies choosing to use AI to do the kind of work that entry-level employees used to do. One of many challenges this poses is that those entry-level jobs were places where college grads learned important skills, like having productive conversations across differences, finding and using credible information, and collaborating with others to create solutions.
Derek BruffIf college grads are to get whatever the new entry-level jobs are, they might need to develop those skills not on the job, but during college. Citizens and Scholars is a nonprofit organization whose aim is to help college students develop and practice these essential civic skills. Partnering with over 100 college presidents, Citizens and Scholars launched a faculty institute a few years ago. It's an 18-month professional learning experience for faculty to design or redesign a course to equip students to have respectful discussions and solve problems across differences.
Derek BruffThat seems like a tall order here in 2026, honestly, and I was curious what the work looked like. Today on the podcast, I talk with Rachel Piontak, Senior Program Officer at Citizens and Scholars and Director of the Faculty Institute. Rachel has a passion for helping students develop civic skills, and she has a lot to say about the importance of this work, how her faculty colleagues go about it, and the kinds of impacts it can have on students. Oh, and she tells us about that one time she was on a panel at San Diego Comic-Con.
Derek BruffR achel, thank you so much for being on Intentional Teaching. I'm very glad to have you on the show and to learn a little bit more about uh your work and how you're making higher ed a better place right now. Thanks for being here.
Rachel PiontakThanks, Derek. I'm excited for this.
Derek BruffAnd you are one of the first guests to experience my new opening question. Um, Rachel, can you tell us about a time when you found joy in your work in recent weeks?
Rachel PiontakWell, first of all, I'm honored to be among the first to get to answer this question. Um, and it truly could not have come at a better time because it just so happens that in the last two weeks I had the great privilege of working with not one but two different college campuses in um helping to co-facilitate and lead um uh trainings around productive conversations and other civic skills. So while most of my life is spent remote and planning for these types of things and working alongside faculty, this time I was actually in person with them for many, many hours.
Rachel PiontakUm and in particular, I was leading a breakout room around collaborative problem solving with some folks from an HBCU in South Carolina, and it was small groups. There was um a moment where I asked them to imagine a world where all students are thriving. It was an activity from the Interactivity Foundation, if you're familiar with them, and we were walking through a real exercise in collaborative problem solving. So they were imagining a world where all students, all college students, had their basic needs met.
Rachel PiontakAnd I did this three different times with small groups of faculty from across disciplines. And without fail, I teared up a little bit each time, just hearing the passion, the just the deep care that they have for their students' holistic well-being. And of course, the exercise is intended to highlight and help untangle the different ways that we go about seeking solutions together. And yes, that happened too, but really the joy came from just hearing their kind of off-the-cuff reflections on their hopes for for their students.
Rachel PiontakSo it was really beautiful.
Derek BruffI love that. I love that. I love I sometimes you have to work a little to uncover the sense of mission that some faculty bring to their work and and how deeply they care. I mean, sometimes it's right there on the surface, but
Rachel Piontaksure.
Derek BruffIt's always delightful when I hear it.
Rachel PiontakExactly. It's it's always there. I want to believe it's always there somewhere, but sometimes you have to root around a little bit to really find it.
Derek BruffYeah. Oh, that's lovely. I love that example. Um I uh I I am new to the world of citizens and scholars as an organization. Um, and I'm curious if you could tell us a little bit about the organization as a whole, and then maybe an example of something that's that's happened recently, uh, other than that really joyful moment that kind of gives a sense of what the organization does.
Rachel PiontakAbsolutely. Um, so we're a relatively small but but mighty organization. So when I give you an example, it's going to be just one sliver. Um you may you may have been more familiar with us by our previous name of the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship Foundation, and that's who we were, you know, pre-2019 when Rajiv Vinnakota, our president, came on board. Um, we switched the name and and really shifted the focus to be more intentionally around young people and developing Gen Z and all generations coming soon thereafter, right on their heels now, um, about developing civic leaders, um, creating those civic solutions that we so desperately need in these times.
Rachel PiontakUm, so that has really been the focus of all of our work organizationally since 2019. Um and we do it primarily through higher education, community-based work, and then workplace development. So it's it's a trifold focus. Um, of course, I work in the higher ed part, and that's why you'll hear me talk about faculty and our university partners quite a bit. Um, but we have great programs going on with our 14 to 24-year-olds through our Carnegie Young Leaders program, um, as well as with uh workforce development, uh doing some modules and trainings around what it means to have these civic skills in the workplace, too.
Rachel PiontakUm but a real, let's see, diving in, getting less abstract. You'll you'll have to keep me keep me honest here because I tend to get like real lofty and excited about these things, but to get put some feet to the ground. Um one example, again, pretty recently over the last year or so, that I've really seen this work take root of its own accord, um, has happened in our partnership with it's a small minority-serving institution in New York, um, in the state, not the city.
Rachel PiontakAnd and we had had a few of their faculty attend our faculty institute, which we'll get into later. And they had done some really great work redesigning courses back on their home campus. And one of them actually redesigned the entire curriculum for the first-year seminar. So for all first year seminar courses, they were now focusing um on embedding those dialogue across different principles. I know. Very incredible. Um, and it and that was really just the beginning, unbeknownst to us at the time.
Rachel PiontakSo through our further conversations, they really wanted to expand this work campus-wide. So we co-created with them um a curriculum to uh facilitate a spring symposium this past year, which was attended by over a hundred faculty and staff. So, really branching into that staff side. And then most excitingly for me was seeing the way that they have since implemented these principles on their campus.
Rachel PiontakSo it was perhaps I'm just like easily excitable, but I was already stoked about the course redesigns and particularly the first year seminar redesign. But now we have folks working in HR to redesign onboarding policies. We have folks in student affairs who are really working to adjust how they approach orientation and training student leaders about orientation. What does it mean to have productive conversations with your roommate? Everything that you can imagine that takes place on a college campus, they're making really intentional and really impressive efforts to um to infuse it with these civic skills.
Rachel PiontakSo um that's not just me and my program. We're we're a small team, but we've been working a lot with our campus-wide immersion team to really uh make sure that support continues. So just being alongside these schools in what they're doing feels like a success as is, but but really seeing what this school has has done with the work is impressive.
Derek BruffSo um I love that, and I love the idea of embedding some of these skills in so many ways that students encounter a college or university. Um and I am so let's let's go kind of high level here for a minute. Um
Rachel Piontakgood.
Derek BruffSo you mentioned dialogue across difference. You mentioned civic skills. Okay. Those are not one and the same, are they?
Rachel PiontakNo.
Derek BruffCan you give us a Venn diagram there? Like what else what else is happening?
Rachel PiontakOh man, I don't we're gonna need like a poster board size Venn diagram. And and truly, we we begin a lot of our our sessions with this conversation, not not to be um, you know, rigid in our definitions, but to say there are a lot of different ways to describe this. Some of them are buzzwords in a good way, some of them have been tagged as buzzwords in a less great way. And it truly depends on where you are, sometimes geographically, sometimes ideologically, but um for the most part, we aim to follow the language of the institutions with whom we work.
Rachel PiontakSo for this school, they're using the term dialogue across difference to encompass kind of those civil discourse dispositions, you could say, whether that's curiosity, um, generous or deep listening, perspective taking, intellectual humility, those components they would put under that dialogue across difference piece. And I would say that's what we mean when we're talking about having productive conversations as well. So that's one of the civic skills with C&S that we really focus on.
Rachel PiontakUm, is that getting us into a little bit more of this middle Venn diagram?
Derek BruffYeah, well, I had um Bethany Morrison on my podcast a year ago. She's
Rachel Piontakwonderful.
Derek BruffOh, yeah. She is. Um, and you know, she talked about civic engagement, I think was the term that she used, and talked about um, you know, like voting and knowing about voting and voting registration, and you know, like there's a a kind of uh engagement in the political structures.
Rachel PiontakSure.
Derek BruffUm and I I feel like that's part of a bigger umbrella, but it's it's not the same as dialogue across difference.
Rachel PiontakTrue, true. They're can we say they're familially related, but not fraternal twins, perhaps?
Derek BruffYeah.
Rachel PiontakI don't know. Don't take that metaphor too far. I haven't I haven't followed it to the end of its trail. But it is true. I think the voting and and volunteering, those sorts of things are very much related, but I would perhaps categorize them more as an output, whereas the dialogue across difference principles, having productive conversations, knowing how to navigate, assess, and use credible information. Um, and really, I think more to your point of the civic engagement, that third civic skill that we we really talk about of collaborating to create solutions is when kind of that rubber meets the road.
Rachel PiontakSo we've got these skills, we've we're understanding where we're getting our information and sense of factual knowledge from. Um, what are we doing with that? And the the doing piece, I think, is where civic engagement really comes in and has its time to shine. So they're all very important, and I think you can't do any without the others.
Derek BruffYeah. So collaborating to create solutions could involve some type of engagement with the electoral political system. Absolutely. But it it's not necessarily that either, right? There's other ways that groups of people get together.
Rachel PiontakTruly. And and sometimes they don't they don't find a solution, but that doesn't mean that productive conversations didn't happen.
Derek BruffYeah, yeah, yeah. Well, and then another thing I read about citizens and scholars is is this argument. Um, it's an argument I hear all the time in the world of uh kind of faculty responding to AI, which is because of generative AI, entry-level jobs are changing or disappearing. And um, I think C&S has made the argument that some of the skills, the durable skills that students might learn their first two or three years on a job, um, like uh having productive conversations and collaborating for solutions, there if if they don't have those entry-level jobs anymore, they may need to develop those skills earlier in the process, right?
Derek BruffAnd so is that part of the kind of argument for embedding these in higher ed?
Rachel PiontakAbsolutely. I think that's spot on. I mean, we we talk a lot about civic skills to what end? You know, what why are we doing this other than this wonderful sounding thing of creating civically engaged students and and future leaders, which in and of itself I think is sufficient, but perhaps not the complete story because these civic skills are also workplace skills. I mean, you're absolutely right that having productive conversations, talking through, and we use, oh man, Derek, we use AI as a topic in um in examples for how to have productive conversations about AI policies or how to create collaborate together to create solutions about AI policies.
Rachel PiontakAnd so we're already seeing this come to play with it as just a topic, if not the the in all and end all and be all. But
Derek Bruffum
Rachel Piontakyeah, I do think absolutely that these skills are preparing students for the workplace in a way that generative AI just cannot and will not.
Derek BruffRight, right. Yes. How do we engage productively with other humans? Um AI might play an assistive role in that, but it can't do it for us.
Rachel PiontakSure. It can help edit your emails so that you sound less cranky, perhaps, but you still need to know, you know, how to have that conversation face to face and and what you're putting into that prompt in the first place.
Derek BruffYeah. Okay, so I want to talk about the faculty institute now. Um, I'm a faculty developer, and so this type of work is near and dear to my heart. Um, what is the origin story of the faculty institute and and what is it trying to accomplish?
Rachel PiontakYou just know a way to your interviewee's heart when you ask them about the program they support. Um but yes, I'm a big fan of origin stories too, so I will try to keep it snappy, but you know, not overly romanticize something that I have so near and dear to my heart. Um, so the Faculty Institute was actually one of or was the first initiative really in signature launching from our higher ed component of Citizens and Scholars back in uh 2023, was our first cohort.
Rachel PiontakIt emerged from conversations with college presidents, um, which is really, if I hadn't said before, is really what I think sets apart C&S's approach from a lot of other civic education type of organizations that we work first and foremost through the college presidents or the university leadership. That we believe without that explicit support and backing, faculty, staff, students don't have um don't have that same solid foundation to know that, okay, they've got our backs, we're on the same, we're on the same page with our goals here, with um really building that civic muscle.
Rachel PiontakSo with that as the backdrop, there there was a conversation, again, before my time, that took place about the importance of providing professional development opportunities for the folks that we were asking to do the work, truly. We were asking folks to embed these civic skills. Um, we should probably provide a toolkit along with that. And so uh 2023, my predecessor, uh Janet, was was quite the leader and making sure that all the ducks were in a row.
Rachel PiontakUm, we had uh a couple dozen faculty from a couple dozen different institutions convene at Duke for two and a half days. Go Blue Devils, right?
Derek BruffYeah. I think
Rachel Piontakthey're blue devils. Okay. Yes.
Derek BruffI grew up in South Carolina. Um somewhere in my brain, yes, they are the Blue Devils.
Rachel PiontakI currently live in North Carolina, so I should really know this, but on the other side of the state. I've got I've got a few hours from there. Um so since then we've done now we just completed our sixth cohort just two months ago. Um it was hosted by the wonderful folks at McAllister. Okay. Yeah, yeah. So we we've done more than one a year, though. We're trying to um really focus, focus well and do the one per year because it's it's not just a once-off, it's actually the launch point of an 18-month fellowship program.
Rachel PiontakSo faculty get selected through a variety of means, whether they're um elected or nominated or they apply to attend the faculty institute. We have two and a half days really focused on the why and the how. And then the the rich, the richest part for me is the practice of it. Um, you know, so often we give folks one pagers and great, you know, conversation guides. And all of these things are so important. And in fact, if we had three hours to kill, we could go into our favorite resources.
Rachel PiontakRight. Um, but the real, I think the real magic and the real struggle, honestly, is when we try to do it. And we we take off our faculty hats and we put on our learner hats and we just try to have those conversations. We put ourselves in that position. Um, so we we spend a big chunk of time focused on that work, and then we give them uh as much time as we can, but at least at least an hour to really sit with that information, that that practice, and reflect on what it is that they want to do when they go back to campus.
Rachel PiontakSo we primarily focus on course redesigns or or new course development related to civic skills, but it's not just poli sci or public policy. I'm now naming my areas. Um, it's also, you know, biology and math professors, um, public health folks who come and say, you know, nobody walks into my classroom expecting to talk about partisan politics, but people walk into my classroom and we're talking about reproductive health or we're talking about climate change, and then before I know it, here we are.
Rachel PiontakSo um we we really spend that 18 months then afterwards supporting our faculty folks through a community of practice. We meet more or less twice a week. Um we have, they don't have to come to all of them. For anyone listening to this who's overwhelmed by this thought, we just offer a lot of sessions. Um, but we have sessions led by past faculty institute fellows as well as different experts in the field. Um, shout out to Bethany, who's going to be leading one for us this upcoming year.
Rachel PiontakWe're so excited. Um, so through that and one-on-one coaching with myself and my my colleague, we really want to make sure that whoever comes to the faculty institute has that ongoing support, not just from us, but from that network of peers across the country. So we've now worked with 181 faculty through our national institute. Yeah, from 73. You know, I just double-check these numbers, 73 different institutions. Um and then the last thing I'll say is within this last year, too, we've we've started to focus also on campus-specific institutes.
Rachel PiontakSo for those who are already in our College Presidents for Civic Preparedness Coalition, they can opt to bring us to their campus instead of sending their folks to wherever our institute happens to be. And we come and do a day, a half day, a two-day, whatever, whatever we have time for version of that faculty institute with, you know, 20, 30, 100 in the case of that school in New York, um, and and really get the work done that way, which is really, really nice, really different, but really nice.
Rachel PiontakSo
Derek BruffYeah, yeah. Well, um, could you share maybe a couple of examples of of, and you don't have to name names, but kind of the work that faculty have done coming out of the institute, are the you know, courses they built or changes they've made, or I don't know, something to give this a little more color.
Rachel PiontakAbsolutely. Let's see. You know, it's a few that jump jump out at me just uh off the cuff. Was a course redesign from a faculty member in Oklahoma. So already thinking about the context in which they're working, they they redesigned a course that on the on the face, I think didn't sound you know so splashy and dramatic, but but they redesigned a section, I believe it was constitutional law, was their course, um around re around examining the status quo.
Rachel PiontakSo examining court decisions, how are we defining the status quo and how did how did that happen, basically? You know, how do we feel about that? Sure. Um and so rather than having students do it as they had in the past, which was choose a side, write their research paper around it, you know, like the cla the classic. And there's we don't want to fix what isn't broken, but in this case, she left the faculty institute and said, you know, I think we can do this better. I think we can be more intentional and strategic about how we're asking students to think about these issues.
Rachel PiontakSo she completely redesigned that component of her course, which where the students had to, they were assigned to a different side of the issue and they knew in advance which sides they would be assigned to, but it wasn't necessarily in alignment with their personal values or views. And then they had to write for their case, and then they had to read the other side, and they had to then discuss, so there was a real life component, um, discuss what stood out to them about the other side, like what was a good argument that the other side made and why, and how did that impact their own argument?
Rachel PiontakSo she really the core of the activity curricularly was not that different, but the way that it was teased out, I think was really powerful. And I'm also saying this, having read some of those student reflections from that course, where you know, students said this was really uncomfortable. And I didn't exactly like it, but it also made me really good at pausing before I ask my question or pausing before I get defensive. So that's, I think, just a beautiful example of what you can do without, you know, without burning it down.
Rachel PiontakIt's it's just a shift. And then um, and in Illinois, we had a wonderful faculty member who was able to teach a course in the communication department that was specifically around civil discourse. And so it was a small class, very discussion heavy. Um, but some of her students volunteered to share with us at an event that we did um earlier this year as well. And one of the students shared his reflection that was most important to him from this class was practicing through mistakes.
Rachel PiontakAnd he said, you know, I took this class because, you know, I thought it might not be too, too hard, but also I figured this will make me a better speaker, like a better public speaker. And what I actually learned was that I needed a space to bumble along, to make my mistakes and kind of fix it as I go and to realize that I'm not gonna get it perfect the first time. Because we see that a lot with our students being hesitant to speak up for fear of being misunderstood or whatever the 2026 version of cancelled is, you know, being being really um strongly self-censoring.
Rachel PiontakAnd so for this student, this redesigned course from our faculty member uh created a space for them to trip all over the place and and to do so in a learning environment that that supported that growth. So um, I mean, just two super quick examples, but they're they're really doing incredible things. I'm so proud of them.
Derek BruffYeah, yeah. Well, and so that second example, right? Uh um practicing new skills that are challenging, right? Like you need a space to not do that well for a while before you get better at it, right? Like
Rachel PiontakRight, right. Which I think just speaks to the importance of bringing this into the classroom. Um, I know that there's hesitancy around inviting hard conversations or perhaps conversations around controversial topics.
Derek BruffYeah.
Rachel PiontakUm, and I get it. I I taught public speaking for several years and many times had like a okay, let me rewind the tapes. Like, what did I say? Should I reword this? Um it's it's a challenging time. It's a there's no doubt about it. It's a hard time to be an instructor right now. Um but students are going to be having these conversations one way or another. And what better place to practice them than in an environment that can provide that guidance and that scaffolding and those tools?
Rachel PiontakUm, I'm making assumptions now that all the faculty are going to provide those things before having the conversation.
Derek BruffPrecisely,
Rachel Piontakyeah.
Derek BruffAnd I did want to ask about the faculty who are maybe a little hesitant to engage in some controversial topics given the current political climate and their campus or their state or the freaking world. Um and so I'm wondering, do you have more advice for them or strategies or tips that you would suggest or or just even words of encouragement?
Rachel PiontakYeah, I appreciate that you tacked that on there. Um, because I think we all need some of that right now. I mean, starting with the the encouragement piece, or perhaps more of a reflective prompt, is is just to hold grace for yourself, hold hold that space for kindness, knowing that you are not just one thing. You are an instructor, you're a faculty member, yes, and you are all the other identities that you hold. And sometimes those those crash into each other.
Rachel PiontakSometimes those are in conflict in the classroom. And so knowing where your edge is and where where you can engage and frankly where where you can't, um, I think is a really crucial first step. And we talk about that at the institute too, is is first needing to know and reflect on who you are and what you're bringing into that space before you can expect the same of your students. Um, but very practical, advice-wise, I mean, just knowing your institutional policies and your state policies as applicable for the public schools out there, um, and and understanding what in what ways is academic freedom operationalized in your context.
Rachel PiontakBecause if I have learned anything from working with these 73 institutions over the course of our faculty institute history, it's that there are 73 slightly different ways that this is interpreted on the college campus. So really trying to recognize what that means for you in your context is number one. And then number two is really just having something in your back pocket, being whether it's a de-escalation sentence stem or you know, a one-minute reflective paper activity, just something that whether or not you intend to bring up the hot topic of the day, it might enter your classroom unannounced.
Rachel PiontakIt might just come from the outside. And that happens, I think, more often than than folks want to admit. And so just recognizing that if and when that happens, you have something. And it does not have to be something bright and shiny, but just saying, hey, I'm noticing there's some tension in the room. And let's take a moment to take a deep breath, and then I'm going to consider, you know, what these comments have have what you all have said, and we're gonna return to it in the next class. Or, you know, we're gonna take a moment to take a deep breath again.
Rachel PiontakI love deep breaths, and then we're gonna write down, you know, how you're feeling about the comment that was just shared. Just take a moment to do that, and then we'll continue. Having something like that that's applicable regardless of the circumstance, can really um can really go a long way in making you feel a little more prepared and a little less anxious about what happens in the classroom.
Derek BruffYeah, yeah. I'll add one element that I heard from my colleague, my Vanderburg colleague, Stacey Johnson, is that if you've got that, whatever that move is that you think you might need to make when the conversation gets hot or hard, is to practice that move with students before that day.
Rachel PiontakOh so
Derek Bruffit's not the first time you've done it, and that it's not the first time they've done it, right? But if if if your move is, let's take a minute and write down how we feel about this thing that just happened, like try that in week two, right? Right, find a reason to kind of build it in there so that the students know this is part of our toolkit for dealing with stuff in this class.
Rachel PiontakAbsolutely. Honestly, I love that. I think that's I'm gonna borrow that too.
Derek BruffYeah, yeah. It's so good,
Rachel Piontaknot just for the faculty, but for the students, yeah.
Derek BruffYeah. So uh one of the things I I wanted to ask you about um is I think a component of at least our current way of dialoguing across difference. It's not always a productive way, but I feel like there are a lot of people who are basing their opinions on, shall we say, unreality? Um
Rachel Piontakwe shall say.
Derek BruffAnd whether that's you know, something I read online and I didn't really investigate it, or some announcement I encountered that was actually an intentional lie by someone in a position of power, or I I wanted to prove my point to my you know crazy uncle on Facebook. So I turned to Chat GPT and it gave me this information, right? I feel like we have kind of an issue with I don't know, facts.
Rachel PiontakOh, is that all?
Derek BruffRight. And so I guess I'm wondering like to what degree does that that challenge get woven into um your work with faculty and the work that faculty do um around this kind of dialogue across difference and
Rachel Piontakso I'll call it navigating credible information. I think that is inextricably linked to having productive conversations in order to ultimately ideally collaborate to create those solutions in whatever realm that may be. Um and it's man, I mean, I'll tell you this one of the best lessons I saw about credible information skill building, truly, learning how to assess and um and find trustworthy sources came from one of my first year students um two years ago, one year ago, some number of years ago, uh they they chose misinformation and disinformation as their you know final long informative speech topic.
Rachel PiontakAnd I thought, okay, great. We always need to talk about this. But the fact that it came from an 18-ish year old speaking to other peers, and that he was able to say, you know, how many of you have seen this post holding up his phone? They have to use you know visual aids too. So
Derek Bruffcheck, check.
Rachel PiontakUm, and you know, students raised their hand and he said, Okay, great. What if I showed you this other one? And it was, you know, same topic, very different facts, and you could just see the wheels turning, the, well, I've never seen that. That must not be true. That doesn't align with what I was already thinking. And very expertly, this student broke it down, broke down misinformation, disinformation, you know, through a couple of stats. Like if you shared two incorrect things on your TikTok or whatever, can you share on TikTok?
Rachel PiontakI don't know.
Derek BruffI think.
Rachel PiontakOkay. Um, just how fast this information spreads and how quickly it can take root. I mean, that, and I'm sorry that I can't just give that presentation to you to then embed in your own life, but there's something about students learning these skills for themselves and putting it into practice that is enormously powerful. And this is not to negate the role of librarians or faculty members, though I will say I think navigating credible information, media literacy, um, all of that does not, should not just fall on the shoulders of our incredible librarians, but should really be something that, much like productive conversations, is embedded into the courses.
Rachel PiontakUm, it's really, it's really critical thinking skills that we're trying to develop. I mean, it's the face of it looks a little different depending on where you're sitting, but ultimately we want students and ourselves to become better at really sorting out where did this come from? What is it asking of me? What is the angle? Everything has some sort of angle. It doesn't mean it's automatically nefarious.
Rachel PiontakRight. Um, and you know, who stands to benefit, you know, all of the sift method, the the crap method, if you're familiar with that, or as our wonderful colleague Amanda says, uh, the carp method. Okay. It's for when things seem fishy, which
Derek Bruffso good.
Rachel PiontakSo good. Um, whatever method you you teach or or employ in your classrooms, I mean, that's that's going to start not only giving us a framework to to think through the, you know, I saw this post on Facebook and now I'm gonna use it to this is the hill I'm gonna die on.
Derek BruffRight. Yeah. Um,
Rachel Piontakbut it but of course, an acronym alone does not a critical thinker make. Um, and so it's really again tying back to the other civic skills that we've been talking about.
Derek BruffYeah. Yeah.
Rachel PiontakBy, you know, learning to pause part of this. And I think the struggle that I have is to use the sift method requires me to slow down a little bit.
Derek BruffYeah.
Rachel PiontakRequires me to maybe do some extra research before I get on my high horse. That is never wrong, by the way.
Derek BruffRight,
Rachel Piontakright. And
Derek BruffI've interviewed Mike Caulfield about the sift method. He we had him on my old podcast. And
Rachel PiontakI mean,
Derek Bruffhe is just um uh uh uh he is he's hard to keep up with. He has so many great thoughts. But um my
Rachel Piontakgosh, I can't. But like that's
Derek Bruffstep one of Sift is he's tried to design it so that it it doesn't take a lot of time, but taking that pause is the first step.
Rachel PiontakExactly, exactly. And that is absolutely a part and parcel with civic skill development overall and and asking further questions, which again the Sift method has us do. Um, I think it's it's not a distinct set of skills in the way that I thought it was when I was an undergrad and learning how to research for my research paper and make sure I didn't use Wikipedia too much. Like it is that, but it is so much more than that.
Derek BruffBut I do think that so one, I think higher ed has done a bad job of teaching information and media literacy. I think there are individuals in higher ed, most of whom are librarians, who do an amazing job doing it in whatever sphere of influence they have. But I I feel like structurally, we haven't decided at the curricular level,
Rachel Piontakyeah,
Derek Bruffthis is something all students need better skills at, right?
Rachel PiontakYes.
Derek BruffAnd so, but where I have seen that taught, it is it is usually distinct from things like productive conversations and difficult dialogues, right?
Rachel PiontakNo, that is so, so true. And what we're really seeing now is a push for more of this type of change at the gen ed level. So absolutely in a first-year seminar course if you can, but in any of those gen eds, um, one of the sessions we did just two weeks ago was solely with gen ed faculty. So, you know, biology, history, English, they were getting those students in year one or two, typically year one. Um, and how are how are we going to start infusing this into our biology classes?
Rachel PiontakAnd that I think is really exciting and really powerful. Um,
Derek Bruffour time is running out, but I have one more question I have to ask you. I was on your LinkedIn page and I saw that you were on a panel at Comic-Con. And I would love for you to tell us about that.
Rachel PiontakDerek, first of all, best work trip ever. No offense to any other conference that I've been to. Um, it was, you know, of course, it was through one of our incredible faculty.
Derek BruffYeah.
Rachel PiontakShimika Mitchell. She she's a faculty member in the English department at SUNY Rockland. And we had worked with her back in February. She's also an author, a graphic artist, and has done, you know, she has several comic books to her name. The Queen Amani Rainas series, I believe, is one of them. Um, but what an incredible opportunity. She's she's been involved in in the Comic Con scene for quite a while. And when we met earlier in the year, she had mentioned that she'd be putting in for a panel about academic freedom and comics in education.
Rachel PiontakAnd so, you know, we talked about it a little bit then. And then next thing I know, it's summer, and she says, Oh, by the bye, it got accepted. Do you want to come? And I look at the other panelists, and I kid you not, like having some star-struck feelings. I ordered as many of their comics as I could that would arrive in time, so I could obviously speed read them on the plane
Derek Bruffand
Rachel Piontakget them autographed. Um, but just an incredible group of creators and and artists, and really just an opportunity to hear how they are both being challenged by and are challenging the stereotypes, the the under-discussed components of US history. And they're doing that through through their graphic artistry. And I felt like a little bit like the odd person out as saying, yes, absolutely.
Rachel PiontakThese are examples of you know, civic skills and action. And I'm so, so grateful for the opportunity because it really showed me, again, just that this work is everywhere. It's it's definitely not an American government 101 week. It's it's infused through some of the most popular comics that exist. And and the folks are really trying to do this work and make more engaged citizens, you know, across the board. So I'm sorry to say that I did not um win any sort of cosplay contests because I had to fly back earlier, but uh maybe in the future.
Derek BruffUh but I bet the people watching was pretty awesome while you were there.
Rachel PiontakAmazing. So I was my senses were overloaded in the best way.
Derek BruffThat's great. Well, Rachel, this has been delightful. Thank you so much for coming on the show and um uh telling us a little bit about the work that you and your organization are doing uh across the country. Um it's uh, you know, there's what I'm also hearing from you is there are a lot of faculty and librarians and student services staff and college presidents who care deeply about growing these skills in our students. And um that's that's a good thing. I'm gonna I'm gonna I'm gonna call that a hopeful thing.
Rachel PiontakI I enjoy ending on a hopeful note, and it was wonderful talking to you too. Thank you so much for your thoughtful questions.
Derek BruffThat was Rachel Piontak, Senior Program Officer at Citizens and Scholars, and director of the College Presidents for Civic Preparedness Faculty Institute. Thanks to Rachel for coming on the show and sharing about the work C&S is doing to help college students have productive conversations, find credible information, and collaborate to create solutions. In the show notes, you'll find links to more information about Rachel, Citizens and Scholars, and their faculty institute. You'll also find links to a few podcast episodes I mentioned in my conversation with Rachel, a 2024 interview with Bethany Morrison about teaching in an election year, where she talks about teaching for civic engagement.
Derek BruffA 2026 interview with Kent Kaufman that I didn't actually mention, but I thought about, because it's all about academic freedom and the law. And finally, a 2019 interview with Mike Caulfield from my old podcast, Leading Lines, all about information literacy and the SIFT method. Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPCEA, the Online and Professional Education Association. In the show notes, you'll find a link to the UPCEA website where you can find out about their research, networking opportunities, and professional development offerings.
Derek BruffThis episode of Intentional Teaching was produced and edited by me, Derek Bruff. See the show notes for links to my website and socials, and to the Intentional Teaching newsletter, which goes out most weeks on Thursday or Friday. If you found this or any episode of Intentional Teaching useful, would you consider sharing it with a colleague? That would mean a lot. As always, thanks for listening.
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Consider the AI learning assistant, with access to all the materials from a particular course and programmed to serve as a tutor for students in that course....
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Before there was ChatGPT, there were generative AI coding tools. This means computer science, as a discipline, has had a little more time to adapt to AI than...
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Welcome to the 100th episode of Intentional Teaching! I am very excited to reach this milestone, and I am deeply grateful to all my guests and all my listeners...
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Deborah Barnett is assistant dean for education at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Public Health, where she has been talking with her faculty...
Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. How can humanities courses and majors help students develop the kinds of durable skills--communication, collaboration, adaptability, and more--that employers...