Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Intentional Teaching, a show about teaching in higher education

Intentional Teaching, a show about teaching in higher education artwork

Benchmarking Online Education with Bruce Etter and Julie Uranis

Sep 2, 202539 minAudio

Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. The online education wings of most colleges and universities have changed a lot since 2020, with online units moving in from the periphery to the center of operations at most institutions. On the podcast today, we’re going to take a look at the state of online education in the United States, and to do that, we’ll make use of data from the 2025 Benchmarking Online Enterprise Survey (BOnES) conducted by UPCEA, the online and professional education association. On the show today, I talk with Bruce Etter, senior director of research and consulting at UPCEA, and Julie Uranis, senior vice president of online and strategic initiatives at UPCEA. Although BOnES surveyed chief online learning officers, there’s a lot in the report of interest to faculty and instructional designers and educational developers, and Bruce and Julie do a great job walking us through some key takeaways. Episode Resources Benchmarking Online Enterprise Survey (BOnES), https://upcea.edu/bones25 Support the show Podcast Links: Order The Norton Guide to AI-Aware Teaching by Annette Vee, Marc Watkins, and Derek Bruff. Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPCEA, the online and professional education association. Subscribe to the Intentional Teaching newsletter: https://derekbruff.ck.page/subscribe Support Intentional Teaching on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/intentionalteaching Find me on LinkedIn and Bluesky. See my website for my "Agile Learning" blog and information about having me speak at your campus or conference.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Derek BruffWelcome to Intentional Teaching, a podcast aimed at educators to help them develop foundational teaching skills and explore new ideas in teaching. I'm your host, Derek Bruff. I hope this podcast helps you be more intentional in how you teach and in how you develop as a teacher over time. The online education wings of most colleges and universities have changed a lot since 2020, with online units moving in from the periphery to the center of operations at many institutions. On the podcast today, we're going to take a look at the state of online education in the US, and to do that, we'll make use of data from the 2025 Benchmarking Online Enterprise Survey conducted by UPCEA, the Online and Professional Education Association.

Derek BruffUPCEA sponsors the Intentional Teaching Podcast, and thanks to that relationship, I was able to hear a few of the results of this year's survey shortly before it was released, and those data points were interesting enough that I wanted to learn more. On the show today, I talked with Bruce Edder, Senior Director of Research and Consulting at UPCEA, and Julie Uranus, Senior Vice President of Online and Strategic Initiatives at UPCEA. Bruce led the data analysis for the benchmarking online enterprise survey, or BONES as they call it, and he has some fun facts to share.

Derek BruffThis is Julie's second appearance on the podcast, and she's back to help us situate the new survey results in the history and changing landscape of online education. Although Bones surveyed chief online learning officers, there's a lot in the report of interest to faculty and instructional designers and educational developers, and Bruce and Julie do a great job walking us through some key takeaways. Julie and Bruce, thank you so much for being on Intentional Teaching. I'm excited to have you here and to talk about this fun new report that you all helped with.

Derek BruffYeah, thanks for being here.

SPEAKER_01Hey, thanks for having us. Yeah.

Derek BruffBefore we get into the report, I would uh I'm gonna ask my usual opening question, although Julie has answered this before. Julie is one of the rare repeat guests on intentional teaching. Um my question is can you tell us about a time when you realized you wanted to be an educator? And I remember Julie sharing that she was working, I think, at a learning center at an automotive plant in Detroit.

SPEAKER_01Oh my gosh, yes. And you know what? And in my prep for this, I referenced it. So I guess, yes, that is my answer.

Derek BruffSo would you like to answer this question again, Julie? A time when you realized you wanted to be an educator?

SPEAKER_01I will. Um, and I'll change it a little bit. So um, you know, I started off in the newspaper industry, and I was the person in the early days of the in a way ups uh where I was the person who took whatever random file type existed. And, you know, these were times where people were making, you know, you were creating ads like in Microsoft Word and writing it for print. So I was this technology agnostic. There wasn't a file type I didn't know the extension or what what software it you know it it pertained to.

SPEAKER_01Um, and that led me to that role at um Eastern Michigan when we were um we had that uh contract with the different UAW centers. So I had the exciting opportunities to, you know, teach photo editing to retirees, you know, advise folks on MP3 players in those early days because I'm just that old. Um but when the recession hit, I I transferred onto main campus. Um and you know that those those types of roles kind of dried up in the automotive industry.

SPEAKER_01And I found my way into distance learning. And it was, I'll tell you, it it wasn't necessarily a point in time, but it was a student population that made me realize that I wanted to do this and that, you know, I'd found my home. And it was when we started an RN to BSN cohort. That's where I found my calling. Yeah, I found my dissertation topic. Um, you know, and I learned that I really had a desire to create new access points for non-residential learners.

SPEAKER_03That's great. How about you, Bruce? Do you do you call yourself an educator? I you know, I wouldn't, and I'm also I I would love to hear more someday, Julie, about you teaching Photoshop to uh retirees. But I I wouldn't call myself an educator as much as I would call myself a researcher. Uh, and education happens to be the area or one of the areas that I have the greatest interest in. Uh for me, I I did my bachelor's degree in sociology at Penn State, and I've always had a general eagerness to understand groups, right? Uh and this group of education and kind of the ecosystem within it is one that has been confounding me for over a decade.

SPEAKER_03And so, you know, it's it's it's research like this that that kind of helps me. It answers two questions and makes three more, right? Uh I'm sure fellow researchers of which faculty often are uh understand that.

Derek BruffYeah.

SPEAKER_03Did you say you got an undergrad in sociology? Yeah, I'm uh I'm a liberal arts guy.

Derek BruffOkay. I looking back, uh, so I did an undergrad in math and computer science. I was gonna be a college math professor, that was the plan. I now spend much more time thinking about teaching and learning than I do about mathematics. And looking back, I kind of wish I had majored in sociology. I feel like it's a much better grounding for this kind of messy, complex world of education. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Liberal arts.

Derek BruffBut I took a sociology class because I went to a good liberal arts school. And so I've always had a little bit of that lens to use in my work.

SPEAKER_03So we can let you in the club for now.

Derek BruffOkay, all right.

SPEAKER_01Yes, this history, uh, history major and polypsy minor welcomes you.

Derek BruffThanks. Uh okay, so let's talk about uh the benchmarking online enterprise survey. Um, and let's do a little bit of context. What is this survey and why is it something that UPCEA does every year?

SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, um, I'm gonna give you a clue. The the name pretty much says it all. We're pretty transparent in it in what it is. So it's that's this survey is completed by chief online learning officers, and it really details the aspects of online learning and the online learning enterprise or enterprises at institutions. We're really proud of that very first word, which is benchmarking. We slice and dice the data based on the location of the online enterprises, institutional characteristics, and then this year we added a per capita factor.

SPEAKER_01So it allows anyone that's consuming this report to kind of find themselves and to do that benchmarking uh with other enterprises. Now we do it each year because you know, we have the spirit of continuous improvement and this, you know, we've got research questions, you know, a list as long as your arm at this point. So we're always changing up the survey. We don't necessarily change the questions. Some of those are evergreen for longitudinal purposes, but we do change up our special subject matter.

SPEAKER_01So this year was AI. I'm shocked. Yeah. Yeah, imagine that, right? And the autonomy that online enterprises have in choosing AI tools. Um, next year, we're all in on budget models. Um, and we've already begun some of that work. So, you know, given the instability in our sector, this information is really vital for many institutions. So it feels like an annual report is exactly what's needed.

Derek BruffYeah.

SPEAKER_03And if I could add one thing, we we've yet to say the acronym, uh, which uh Julie will say, as any good HG TV show shows, you need good BONES. So BONES is indeed the acronym for this uh this project.

Derek BruffBenchmarking online enterprise survey, B-O-N-E-S Bones. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, the N is lowercase N because you know, but whatever. Yeah.

Derek BruffIt works. Yes. Yes. Uh and the actual title is a bit of a mouthful. So it is long, descriptive, and practical. So um Yeah. Okay. Well, um, so you know, this is a survey of chief online learning officers, and certainly that's that's one of your primary audiences for the report, are other chief online learning officers. On intentional teaching, we have a lot of faculty in the audience. And so um, I'm curious if there are some findings from this year's survey that might be of particular interest to faculty, whether or not they teach online.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's a great question. I I think, you know, like you said, the report is designed for the online leader, but there's there is a section uh labeled instruction and faculty of online programs, right? And one thing that the data showed to me that I'm sure a lot of your faculty listeners are living, is that teaching online courses were seen as now just part of the regular course load, right? 92% of our online leaders said that. And this was really further reinforced by the decreasing percentage that are being paid per course, per credit hour, or per enrollment.

SPEAKER_03Um, and this, I mean, from my perspective, it aligns with kind of this academically decentralized model, which we know most online enterprises are operating in, um, where decisions are being made by those individual academic departments. So it doesn't really come as too much of a surprise to me, but it is an overwhelming majority, right? 92%. I I think it's safe to say that is very much a norm at this point.

Derek BruffYeah. So just for clarity, so it might have been, you know, in previous decades, online teaching was a separate enterprise. And from a faculty perspective, it was it was something they did as almost like a second job. Like it was a side job, or they'd get paid extra to teach an online course. Whereas now you're seeing it more integrated into, I don't like this term, but the teaching load, right? The kind of standard duties and responsibilities of a faculty member. Some courses are on site and some are online.

SPEAKER_01Right. Or early days, Derek, I had an overload budget, and that's how we paid out online courses. And we, the continuing ad that housed online learning at my institution, we paid the faculty, the faculty salaries for those specific courses. So that model, because of that load conversation, is less and less dominant as we're seeing. So, you know, Bruce, you know, I you shared it already.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, that's what what we're seeing in the responses is exactly what we know to be true based on you know communications with with folks, you know, chief online learning officers.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and Derek, I was gonna ask why you didn't like the term. I'm curious. I I you know, as a non-faculty member, did I did I step in something there?

Derek BruffNo, no. Uh this is I have a I have uh several pet peeves in higher ed, and the term teaching load is one of them. Like I once I once did a little doodle that I posted on Twitter back in the day of someone carrying a wheelbarrow full of heavy rocks, and I labeled it teaching load. Like it it feels like a burden, right? These are our teaching opportunities.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

Derek BruffSo everyone says load. There's not a good synonym for it. So I'm stuck with that.

SPEAKER_01It's like non-traditional. We don't have another word for it. So I would challenge you, Derek, that maybe this podcast is a way to socialize a new concept. I'm kidding, I'm kidding. But, you know, I I just did um I did want to interject here and share that, you know, this report for some of us is maybe a little bit of penance for our past lives. And I'll share with you this. You know, in the early days of online learning, many of us, myself included, said, oh, we should, you know, we sold this idea, we sold the idea of online learning from this perspective of it'll be less expensive.

SPEAKER_01We know that not to be true, right? Um, and you know, when you really think about it, online learning is much more expensive than campus instruction simply because there's a pace of change with online learning and it's paired with a need to invest in technology. So when we think about it, online learning as a reality is less, it's no more than like 25 years old at most institutions. And yet most institutions are much older than 25 years old, right? They're, you know, both institutions I worked at were over 100 years old, right?

SPEAKER_01And so the investment in our buildings that are sunk costs, well, those institutions by and large aren't leasing space. So they're not supporting buildings as a service like we do with software as a service, right? You know, think about it. So for folks that dislike that entrepreneurial aspect of online learning, you know, it's good to understand that it's either that or we really have to curtail the activity and some of which is really essential for modern learners. So it this report kind of brings it all maybe into focus for folks and sheds light on some aspects of online learning that previously may have looked, you know, um, like overly aggressive or very business-like, but really it's the fact of the environment that had to be created wholly from scratch, basically.

SPEAKER_01When we start to look at the uh FTEs devoted to the online space, right? You know, those folks, the number of people, and for the, you know, we've done a good job this year of relating it to budget and and and headcounts and things like that to say there's more bodies and people involved in the online enterprise than you may realize, right? And it's everyone from instructional designers that, I mean, when you think about it from a faculty perspective, they may have never engaged with a instructional designer or a learning designer until they began teaching online.

SPEAKER_01Think about it. You worked with, you know, the Center for Teaching and Learning, and you had professional development, but you didn't have a person assigned to you helping you, you know, and that comes at a cost, right? And so there's a lot of that that in the report when you think about it and when you start to dwell on it, you're like, wow, yes, this is different than what I've experienced on on campus instruction. So it makes a lot of sense sense, but intellectually we don't always get there, right?

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah, and I'll also add here, you know, to kind of emphasizing Julie's point, there are areas where they're becoming more often a responsibility of the online enterprise, right? We've already mentioned software, but help desk or technical support for the LMS, uh, the teaching and learning center. We've mentioned supporting software, right? So there's all these other things. So with those increased responsibilities or roles comes increased staff, right? And we we see that reinforced in the numbers. The the numbers jumped uh from, I believe it was a median of 15 last year to now 20 that are funded by the online enterprise.

Derek BruffAnd we're also seeing just to make sure, so those would be full-time equivalent staff positions that are kind of housed or funded. There's their staff lines in the online enterprise.

SPEAKER_03Funded is the key word, right? So theoretically, they could they could live somewhere outside of the online enterprise, but the online enterprise itself funds it, right? And I think that's particularly true with you know some things around maybe the LMS or you know, there's little nuances there, but funding is the key word.

Derek BruffOkay. Okay.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Uh something else, while we're talking numbers, um, yeah, I know one of the things that I really want to talk about is around kind of budgets. Uh, and I know Derek, when we were talking prior to the conversation, you know, it's there's a lot of uh of uh turbulence to navigate, shall we say. Uh and so while some of it is of institution's own doing, much of it is not. Uh and what we found is that even though the collective whole of the institution is taking hits, they're still investing in online enterprises, right?

SPEAKER_03And it's it's it's really, from my perspective, and and really backed up by some of this data, is not only because they see online as a way forward from a strategic perspective, but also they want it to help uh cover broader institutional shortfalls, right? Like funding. And like those demographic shifts where maybe there's not as many traditional undergraduate students. Uh so kind of putting a finer point on that, the median budget for online enterprises increased from 3.5 to 4.5 million from 24 to 25. And during that same time, median gross revenue jumped from 6.7 to 11 million, right?

SPEAKER_03So clearly those investments are yielding fruit already, right? Sure. Yeah.

Derek BruffSo that's money the institution has invested in the online enterprise versus tuition revenue primarily that's coming in. Um and it sounds like like achieving some efficiencies there.

SPEAKER_03Some are. Yeah, some definitely are. Uh one of the interesting things in this report was some of the differences between average and median were considerable. And it really reinforces the ideas of the the haves and the have nots. I think some institutions have scale but don't have efficiency, while others have efficiency but don't yet have scale. And so there's only there's only some that are really threading that needle between the two. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, it and I and to be fair, let's be fair and say that for those that may not appear to be efficient, their online operation may have more roles built into it naturally. They may have the teaching, you know, like they may be, you know, um supporting, you know, areas of the campus that aren't directly tied to student services, right? Like I when, you know, in in my days as a chief online learning officer, we had a whole enterprise around accessibility.

SPEAKER_01And we took on all of the accessibility work for the entire campus because there was no one else to do it. There was no one else to caption courses where there were videos that may be used in an on-campus section, right? So that was our job. And so taking on these larger areas like the Teaching and Learning Center, there are folks that don't necessarily have direct student contact or have a role within the enterprise that you would traditionally see or that you would commonly see, and yet they are part of that.

SPEAKER_01So they're included in our accounts. So what we probably in a future iteration of the survey, you'll probably see us break that down a little bit and say, okay, of your FTEs, how many of them are faculty facing, how many of them are student-facing, et cetera, to get a sense of that.

Derek BruffAnd I'm hoping listeners are thinking a little bit, like, what do I know of the online enterprise at my institution? How is it comparing to what we're what we're talking about right here? One thing that you mentioned earlier that I appreciate about the report is to break it out by various different characteristics, um, because different types of institutions, different sizes of institutions are gonna are gonna look differently along these. I mean, I, you know, there are institutions I know that are that have far more uh students enrolled in online courses than in on-site courses, right?

Derek BruffUm and so there's lots of different models for doing this out there. Um so let's talk more about budgets. As you mentioned, Bruce, it's a turbulent time in higher ed. Um what what does the survey have to say this year that might help guide institutions through these rather choppy budgetary waters? What are what are you seeing in terms of trends or ideas from from the community?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I think, you know, to me it's it's what are the strategic priorities of your institution? Um if you're a traditional undergraduate-focused institution, even someone like that or an institution like that, we saw uh, I believe the number is 88% of traditional undergraduate students are expecting at least one course uh for their on for their program, even if it's a traditional residential program, right? They want at least one course online. So it's really how much of a role does online play in that strategy.

SPEAKER_03I I also mentioned previously a lot of institutions are looking to online to kind of balance the books, right? And and whether or not that's uh advisable or attainable, especially for everyone, can be debated. But I think there's some really clear roadmaps in the report for achieving some of those things. A lot of times uh leadership will come to an online leader and say, hey, I want you to double revenue. And you say, Great, what's my increase in in budget? And they say, I don't think any, right? And so there's some of those elements in there that allow you to say, okay, for us to achieve a revenue of X, we need an investment of Y, right?

SPEAKER_03Or you can do kind of the inverse. You can figure out, okay, we have this many student credit hours, we have a student credit hour goal of this, what's the investment needed? And so I think just kind of helping to fill in some of the blanks in terms of those equations that are so often well-meaning but uh incomplete, I think there's some real opportunity there in the report.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and Bruce, you you mentioned this in in your presentation at Solar about the whole notion of competition. And I think that that's another really good point. I don't know if I'm I'm jumping ahead as to what you had in your i i in in your mind's eye for our discussion today, but uh the there there's a notion that institutions are that online learning is an unlimited pool of learners. And That's what we're seeing.

SPEAKER_01And Bruce, correct me if I'm wrong, but that's not really the case.

SPEAKER_03No, it's not. I mean, obviously the percentage that are enrolling in online programs is increasing. But when you look at some of these numbers, you know, it's not an even distribution where the level of a lake is raised for all institutions, right? It's what we're seeing is outsourced or outsized market shares for select institutions. And in the report, you know, one of the things we wanted to know is what is your vision for the next three years? And three-quarters, 75% said we expect to obtain a greater market share of the online marketplace in the next three years, right?

SPEAKER_03There's no way that three-quarters are going to be able to do that, right? And I think, I think, you know, if you were to ask institutions, you know, maybe at the happy hour at one of our conferences or something like that, they might admit to it because only 23% said their approach to marketing their online programs is they're better than better than their competitors. Right. So we're not better at competing, but we're banking on more. That doesn't add up, right? So it's it's kind of a confounding data point to me, but it's it's clear that the proverbial chips are being pushed pushed into online, and there's gonna be winners and there's gonna be losers.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's we've done nothing and we've seen no increases. What are we to do? Um, folks, that's not how anything works. Do you remember that commercial from Verizon, the woman walking around going, that's not how any of this works? Um and and so unfortunately, yes, as Bruce said, there's gonna be winners, there's gonna be losers. And, you know, we hope that by including some of this benchmarking information, we're giving folks the tools. And it's not just Julie, former colo, saying that you need to do this.

SPEAKER_01It's it's really the notion that we're giving, we're providing a report so that those folks that are charged with the online enterprise can go and advocate for the faculty that they work with, for the learners. You know, it's not everybody wants a bigger fiefdom here. It's like, no, our learners actually do need math tutoring, and I need a funding line for math tutoring because if we're going to have any quad courses, I need to have something to back up and to support those learners. And it doesn't magically happen.

SPEAKER_01So when we say that we want to grow programs, we want to increase our offerings, there is inherently a cost. We are building those buildings through technology, and that's that's not an easy task.

Derek BruffYeah. And I guess big picture, I mean, there are, as I understand it, the fewer 18-year-olds now in the United States than there used to be. And that number is not expected to go up anytime soon. And so so I think a lot of institutions are looking at adult learners as uh a way to bring in more revenue and to continue to fulfill their mission, right? Um and what I'm hearing from you is there are only so many online adult learners out there. Um, and with if if everyone's trying to grow, then some folks are not going to be able to hit those marks.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I I think one thing that higher education struggles to do in general is talk about the value that it actually offers, right? What is the value equation for completing some of these credentials? Julie, you've talked about outcomes. Institutions internally, you know, yes, they know all of the outcomes, but student-facing, like even look at like program pages, for example. Very rarely does it have a concrete example of student outcomes beyond just you now have this knowledge. That's great, but talk about some applications. Talk about how your alumni are leveraging that in their day-to-day.

SPEAKER_03Like I we're there is an erosion of trust within higher ed, and there are a lot of reasons for it. But I think one of the reasons it has been relatively rapid is our inability to talk about the value equation that we offer. And I think we have a new opportunity really to do that, particularly with online and adult learners, right? And faculty are doing great, great things, and we just need to make sure it's it's understood and communicated effectively, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, unfortunately, if we don't tell our story, someone else will, and they'll fill that space with their own narrative. And we're seeing that time and time again. Um, you know, we struggle with, you know, over in the continuing and professional ed side of things, there are plenty of programs that are non-credit that are workforce aligned, that do the things that everyone says we're not doing. But let's be honest, there's no federal data set. We can't report them anywhere.

SPEAKER_01It doesn't count for five, you know, for federal finance. You know, like all the measures that we use to evaluate degrees and those outcomes and and what occurs with a learner, they don't exist everywhere and they're not, you know, they're not consistent within higher ed. So it's very easy for us to slip into the, oh, they know us, they know what we do. No. Um, I I can't tell you how many times, how many times have you explained to your family what you do for a living?

SPEAKER_01And they don't understand it in any way. And when you come to Association Land, they really they're like, Don't you work at a college? No. Okay, no. So I work at it, just doesn't work. And so I actually this winter I was at a dinner and it was, you know, at a a family vacation home. Like, and and I had to explain to someone that do you know that institutions don't do not receive the money that students pay for federal financial aid?

SPEAKER_01This person thought that when you make payments to your student loans, they went to the institution. I said, no, it's like a mortgage, it's like a it's financing. And they're like, I never knew that. There's so higher ed is a closed system, and we don't do a good job of bringing folks in and helping them understand us.

Derek BruffWow. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Um the financial aid, the financial aid thing blew your mind, didn't it?

Derek BruffIt did, it did, it did. But I but it's another example of what I do here a lot, which is when I kind of talk to folks outside of higher ed in my daily life. There's, you know, they may have their their experience, right? They went to college, they have a kid in college, right? They have a kind of slice of that of that piece, but they don't understand how the system works. Um, even sometimes some pretty basic parts of the system. Um I'm wondering also, I'm gonna try to try the segue. Are there parts of the system that faculty sometimes don't quite understand?

SPEAKER_03I think there's parts that even the administration doesn't always understand, right? You know? Yeah. Like from my perspective, you know, each institution is so unique when it comes to their online enterprise. Some were very strategic in terms of how it was created, how it's been resourced, and how it's fit into the larger vision of the institution. Others very much grew up between the cracks in the sidewalk, right? And so with that, you get these PhD level financial models and all of these different resource-sharing things that I think you know can hamstring faculty, right?

SPEAKER_03When they're trying to develop or uh you know bring a program to market that they understand there's a need for, the dollars and cents have to work for the institution, right? And sometimes those equations are so incomplete that even if the program would undoubtedly be successful, it can't because of various reasons behind that. Julie, is there anything you'd add to that?

SPEAKER_01Um yes, you're right. Administrators don't understand things, faculty don't understand things, we're just bumbling along, bouncing off of one another all the time, right? No, but um, I think one of the one of the great misconceptions within higher ed, and particularly with faculty, is that the online operation or the professional continuing ed folks, they're doing their own thing over there. They're the skunkworks. And and what you really need to think of us as maybe is more the RD for the institution.

SPEAKER_01Think about it. We don't have the ability to just pilot things, right? Our accreditation doesn't allow us to start and stop things on a whim, right? We don't do that. We can't. We'd have to have a teach out, right, for everything. And that would be a terrible existence. So when we're thinking about programs and we're thinking of these, you know, innovative programs, different credentials, things like that, we're looking at different cues maybe that help us discern whether or not that program is viable.

SPEAKER_01Do we have a student population? Do we have that, you know, I I use this example all the time. Um, we were having a conversation about a social justice um program. And I said, great, where am I going to contact potential learners? And I said, who is the person who might take this program? And I was told, well, people who love to learn. Okay, um, there's not a mailing list I can buy for that. I don't know what to do with that information, right?

SPEAKER_01And so, like the inputs that I need to be able to say, yes, we can support this. There is a learner population, and we know what the technology is going to require, and things like that. I I can't do that in a typical environment, or I'm doing that off to the side. And it looks like this very opaque process because to expose it to daylight would potentially have faculty shrieking because they're like, why are you looking at it in these terms? And we're a public good.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I know we are, but I can't draw resources from other very important strategically aligned programs for the institution to run this one because I just I can't justify it. And that's a really hard conversation to have, and it's a new conversation in higher ed. And as we become more and more resource constraints, you're going to see more conversations like this. And unfortunately, it's just the nature of it. You know, that's how the world around us is speaking.

SPEAKER_01We are maybe the last frontier of organizations or a domain that doesn't think in those terms, but it's creeping in. And it's a it's a terrible decision to make when we know what might be very strategic or versus something that is mission-aligned. And, you know, reconciling those areas is is sometimes tough.

Derek BruffAnd I think what I'm hearing is that it's not so much that online is chasing the dollar and we're turning into some type of big business. It's that we're trying to do new things. And so the pathways to get there are not well-worn and familiar. No, right? Like, like we every institution with a long history of undergraduate enrollment, they already know what they're doing with undergraduate enrollment, right? Like, like, like, and the undergrads and their families know kind of what to expect there. But when you're trying new things and you're trying to build new programs and reach new students, you've got you've got to find those pathways.

SPEAKER_01Right.

Derek BruffUm, and that can look like uh corporate takeover, right? Yep. But it's only because it's the businesses that are also trying to do new things, right? And yes, they may have a different profit motive behind it, but some of this is just inherent in trying to build out new structures. Yeah. You've got to look at things like how do we afford this great thing that we want to do.

SPEAKER_01Well, I'll I'll use an example. Um, years and years ago, we were the first entity on campus to have a CRM. Now that's a customer relationship management system. Now we know that most institutions have those tacked on to their SISs. They are very efficient at recruiting undergrads, but 15 years ago, it was the continuing ed folks that were like, how do we keep track of all these people that we can't bring into the student information system because they live in a non-credit space?

SPEAKER_01We have to figure this out. And now that's morphed. That dollar amount, that dollar spend was probably off of online education because we were trying to sort out how do we create this funnel for this non-credit or this non-act, you know, this non-credit activity. How do we do that? And how do we keep track of everything? Well, a CRM is fundamental, like we're talking like Salesforce, we're talking slate. Many of you know what this is, right?

SPEAKER_01And we're familiar with it on our campuses. A lot of that came in through your continuing and your online folks because they saw the need because they were getting all of these folks into a funnel and they didn't come to open houses and we didn't go to their high schools, right? It was a very different, you know, that's the undergrad model in a lot of ways. And we didn't do that. So we needed another way and we needed to append it with technology. And so in that way, it's like, well, yeah, we'd done something long ago that looks very business-like, and now it's pretty much throughout higher ed.

SPEAKER_01I don't, you know, most institutions would never admit that they don't have some way to attend to their student funnel, right?

Derek BruffRight, right. And that's the RD aspect that you were you were saying. Like this is something that online had to kind of figure out years ago, and the rest of the enterprise gets to benefit from that um over time. For this year's survey, we've covered a lot of ground, but I know there's a lot more in the report. Where can listeners go to access the full BONES report this year?

SPEAKER_01Sure. So you can find that at UPCEA.edu slash BONES25.

Derek BruffThere you go. The advantage of an acronym.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

Derek BruffThat's great. That's great. Well, Julie and Bruce, thank you so much for being here and giving us a bird's eye view of the online education enterprise and helping us think about how it affects our daily lives as we as we go about higher ed. So um, this was really great. Thanks for being on the show.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks for having us.

Derek BruffOur pleasure, Derek. Yeah, been a treat. Thank you. That was Bruce Edder, Senior Director of Research and Consulting at UPCEA, and Julie Uranus, Senior Vice President of Online and Strategic Initiatives at UPCEA. Thanks to Bruce and Julie for taking time to come on the show and walk us through the latest findings from the benchmarking online enterprise survey, or Bones, as UPCEA calls it. As Julie mentioned, if you want to read the full survey report, you can visit UPCEA.edu slash bones25. See the show notes for that link if you'd rather click it than type it.

Derek BruffBack in February, I attended a session at the Top Hat annual conference focusing on navigating change in higher ed. During that conversation, I compared the working of a university to that of an orchestra. Caveat to what follows: I've never actually been in an orchestra, so this metaphor is based largely on what I've seen in the movies, although my stepdaughter has started orchestra this year, so maybe I'll learn more soon. In an orchestra, you have lots of musicians very skilled in their instruments who work together to perform a complicated piece of music. They know the score, literally, and they know how their performances contribute to the overall piece.

Derek BruffIn higher ed, you have lots of talented faculty and staff who are very good at what they do, but sometimes they don't have a sense of how their work contributes to the larger mission. They don't know the score and how their roles fit into it. I hope today's conversation with Bruce and Julie about online education provided a bit of that bigger picture. Connecting our individual work with larger institutional missions is all the more important today, given the challenges that higher ed in the US is facing. Intentional Teaching is sponsored by UPCEA, the Online and Professional Education Association.

Derek BruffIn the show notes, you'll find a link to the UPCEA website where you can find out about their research, networking opportunities, and professional development offerings. This episode of Intentional Teaching was produced and edited by me, Derek Bruff. See the show notes for links to my website and socials, and to the Intentional Teaching newsletter, which goes out most weeks on Thursday or Friday. If you found this or any episode of Intentional Teaching useful, would you consider sharing it with a colleague? That would mean a lot.

Derek BruffAs always, thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Teaching Civic Skills with Rachel Piontak

    Nov 17, 202644 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Partnering with over a hundred college presidents, the non-profit Citizens & Scholars launched a Faculty Institute a few years ago. It’s an 18-month professional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. AI Learning Assistants at Scale with Kavitta Ghai and George Hanshaw

    Nov 3, 202641 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Consider the AI learning assistant, with access to all the materials from a particular course and programmed to serve as a tutor for students in that course....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. AI-Aware Computer Science Education with Briana Morrison, Greg Nelson, and Elijah Rivera

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Before there was ChatGPT, there were generative AI coding tools. This means computer science, as a discipline, has had a little more time to adapt to AI than...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Light Bulb Moments from 100 Episodes

    Oct 14, 202658 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Welcome to the 100th episode of Intentional Teaching! I am very excited to reach this milestone, and I am deeply grateful to all my guests and all my listeners...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Curricular Responses to AI with Deborah Barnett

    Sep 22, 202642 minAudio

    Share your thoughts about this episode as a text message. Deborah Barnett is assistant dean for education at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Public Health, where she has been talking with her faculty...

    Credit the people on this episode