Send us Fan Mail This week on our Inside Geneva podcast, we ask whether the world has forgotten women in Afghanistan. Under Taliban rule, they cannot work, go to secondary school, leave the house alone or even visit a public park. Human rights defenders say the world is looking away. Some argue that what’s happening in Afghanistan amounts to gender apartheid and want it recognised as a crime under international law. They also warn that if the repression of women in Afghanistan is not challenged, it could happen in other countries too. Listen now to the full episode. Get in touch! Email us at insidegeneva@swissinfo.ch Twitter: @ImogenFoulkes and @swissinfo_en Thank you for listening! If you like what we do, please leave a review or subscribe to our newsletter. For more stories on the international Geneva please visit www.swissinfo.ch/ Host: Imogen Foulkes Production assitant: Claire-Marie Germain Distribution: Sara Pasino Marketing: Xin Zhang
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03SwissInfo podcasts. This is Inside Geneva. I'm your host, Imogen Folkes, and this is a production from SwissInfo, the international public media company of Switzerland. In today's program.
SPEAKER_00A ceremony to mark five years since the Taliban returned to power. Five years since female lawmakers, judges, and lawyers in Afghanistan were forced to escape or go into hiding.
SPEAKER_03It's 25 years since the Taliban were ousted from power in Afghanistan, and five years since they came back.
SPEAKER_04As a longtime human rights lawyer, I am truly shocked by the deteriorating human rights situation on the ground in Afghanistan, especially for women and girls.
SPEAKER_02In Afghanistan, the exclusion of women is visible everywhere.
SPEAKER_01Afghanistan is the worst country right now in the world for the Borman. Boman, they don't have the right to work, they don't have the right to education, they don't have the right to political participation. For sure, we are calling it gender apartheid.
SPEAKER_02When you go out in the streets, you hardly see any women.
SPEAKER_03But is that enough? When girls can't go to secondary school, when women are barred from working, leaving the home alone, even going to public parks. Some Afghan women and some international lawyers are calling for official recognition that what's happening in Afghanistan is gender apartheid. Today we're going to talk to two of them.
SPEAKER_04Hi there, my name is Karima Benun. I am a professor of international law at the University of Michigan Law School.
SPEAKER_01Hello, hello Imogen. I'm Zalkayev Tali, Director of Women and Children and Legal Research Foundation, organization which is working since 2003 in Afghanistan.
SPEAKER_03And then later in the program, we'll hear from a regular on Inside Geneva, Farishta Abbasi, from Afghanistan herself, and now with Human Rights Watch.
SPEAKER_02It's very unfortunate to see how the world has forgotten about Afghanistan, and no one seems to really want to take action when it comes to the rights of women and girls in the country.
SPEAKER_03But first, let's hear my conversation with Professor of International Law Karima Banoon and Afghan human rights defender Zarka Yafdali. Some listeners may remember I first talked to Karima about the situation for women and girls in Afghanistan in 2023, two years after the Taliban had returned to power. She warned then about growing oppression, but three years on, the scale of it seems to have surprised even her.
SPEAKER_04As a former UN Special Rapporteur, as a longtime human rights lawyer, I am truly shocked by the deteriorating human rights situation on the ground in Afghanistan, especially for women and girls. We see the many, many decrees rolling back their rights, virtually every right in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. And I think as distressing what we see is an international community that is willing to look away while half the population of a country is stripped of its basic rights and dignity.
SPEAKER_04And the one positive piece of this story has been the determination of Afghan women human rights defenders from Afghanistan in Afghanistan, in exile, people like Zarka who have refused to give up, who have continued to inform the international community, who have continued to try to support women and girls on the ground. The challenge is now to sustain interest so that we don't have to wait many more anniversaries until there is improvement in the situation for women and girls in Afghanistan.
SPEAKER_03Sarka, let me bring you in there because as Karima said, you have worked tirelessly to support women and girls in Afghanistan. You're, of course, Afghan yourself. We saw the Taliban coming back to power. A few people, I have to say, mostly men, said, ah, but it's not the same Taliban as a few years ago. It's a different one, they're more flexible.
SPEAKER_01It hasn't really turned out that way, as far as I could see. Afghanistan is the worst country right now in the world for the woman and also humans' rights as well. During the past five years, when Taliban came back to power in Afghanistan, they denied all women from their basic rights. During the past five years, Taliban leadership announced more than 260 decrees. More than 80% of these decrees are targeting the rights of women and girls in Afghanistan. And when there is a systematic discrimination, for sure we are calling it gender apartheid.
SPEAKER_01Women, they don't have the right to work, they don't have the right to education, they don't have the right to political participation, they don't have the right to social participation as well.
SPEAKER_03Karima, coming to you, because Sarka mentioned this term gender apartheid, which we did talk about when I interviewed you two or three years ago. We hear it more applied to Afghanistan. And you have just launched this declaration on gender apartheid. What is this exactly? And why do you want to apply it to Afghanistan?
SPEAKER_04So gender apartheid, I think, is a critically important term that really references the sort of the systematized, institutionalized, extreme form of discrimination that is applied across all the infrastructures of the state in social, political, cultural life, and so on. And we're really honored that we have some South African signatories to the declaration, which I will speak about in a moment, who were really recognizing many similarities between the experience of Afghan women and girls today and the experience of non-white South Africans during the apartheid regime.
SPEAKER_04An Afghan woman once described gender apartheid to me as really a system in which women are seen as not as human as men. And that really mirrors the experience of non-white South Africans in many ways. So the new International Declaration on Gender Apartheid and its destructive consequences has just been launched. And this declaration has a number of purposes. One is to promote the codification of the prohibition of gender apartheid in the Crimes Against Humanity Convention that is currently being negotiated in the UN.
SPEAKER_04The second purpose is to give Afghan women human rights defenders like Zarka and her colleagues and their allies a tool to use pending that codification because, as we know, it won't happen before 2029. And what we hear again and again is that women on the front lines cannot wait. And also to promote sort of forward-looking gender-inclusive interpretations of international law that can be used now. So what we're saying to governments, uh, to international organizations is don't wait for codification.
SPEAKER_04Use this term and this framework now. And I think just the last thing I would mention is something that's critically important about gender apartheid as a concept is that it uh promotes accountability for the perpetrators, but it also really references uh apartheid law generally, which looked at the comp the role of the international community as a whole. And the entire international community, uh, states, international organizations have obligations to take effective action to end the practice of gender apartheid and not to be complicit in it.
SPEAKER_04And I think that is really critical.
SPEAKER_03Sarka, I saw you nodding through what Karima had to say there. Tell me how you see this declaration could be helpful to women and girls in Afghanistan now.
SPEAKER_01Very good question. So this is why it's very important that we have this declaration. We can use this declaration as advocacy tools, gender apartheid as a crime against humanity. As Karima mentioned, some of the member states, some of the countries, if they want to hold accountable the Taliban according to the international law, they can use this declaration as an accountability tool for the Taliban. And it gave some kind of hope for Afghanistan women. Those 16 million women that they are inside of Afghanistan. And right now they are hopeless because they are thinking that the international community forgetting Afghanistan women.
SPEAKER_01The international community is um are not talking about Afghanistan women, and they took the position of silence about all of the inhumanity in Afghanistan.
SPEAKER_03What would you say, both of you, to the diplomats, the ambassadors, some of them here in Geneva, who say they do really want to support women in Afghanistan, but they don't like this term gender apartheid. They see it as a kind of a distraction.
SPEAKER_04Well, what I would say first is what they're doing obviously is not working. And they need to up their game. They need a more robust set of tools. We hope the declaration can be one of those tools. It has been signed on to by 61 people, including some of the world's leading experts in international law, human rights, and the situation in Afghanistan. And so now what we'd like is to see governments, international organizations, experts, and civil society advocates around the world using this declaration in a range of creative ways to come up with more effective responses than we've seen so far.
SPEAKER_03Zarka, you said this declaration can bring hope to Afghan women. You, of course, still work supporting women in Afghanistan and girls. You work specifically on education. Tell me how do you do that right now?
SPEAKER_01Tell me what the challenges are. As we all know, right now, when you want to work uh in Afghanistan for girls' education, for women's rights, it is very difficult. It isn't uh without uh risk and it isn't without sacrifice. It is about uh 30 days that my colleagues, six of my colleagues, including two members of my family, they are arrested by the Taliban and they are in detention of the Taliban. The only thing that they do, their crime is uh providing education for girls and working for women in Afghanistan, empowering women in Afghanistan.
SPEAKER_01But unfortunately, this is the reality in Afghanistan. If you want to raise your voice, if you want to do something for women in Afghanistan, if you want to do something for girls in Afghanistan, the Taliban are coming, they are going to arrest you, and you will be in that detention for a long time. There isn't any legal protection system to protect the civilians, to protect the women's rights activists, and also to protect the civil society in the country. What kind of action do you have in mind? Sanctions, prosecutions, pressure.
SPEAKER_01Put pressure on the Taliban. They should not send money to the Taliban, they should not support the regime which is denying all women from their basic rights. Afghanistan is the only country in the world where girls are not going to school beyond grade six. Right now we have about four million girls that they cannot go to the school. This is not something uh normal in Afghanistan. This is the Taliban policy that denying all these uh 4 million girls that they cannot go to the school. Right now, 100,000 women they denied from the right to work.
SPEAKER_01Those women they are householders. So right now they have nothing. They don't have any income. So how they should support their family, how they should uh support their children.
SPEAKER_04So I think accountability is absolutely critical, and the declaration highlights the need for accountability in every sense for the perpetrators of gender apartheid. This certainly should be applied to the Taliban. And I look at the heroic efforts of uh women human rights defenders from Afghanistan over the last uh five years working for some kind of accountability. Uh, and we need to see the case uh that some governments threatened to bring in the International Court of Justice against Afghanistan under the CEDAW Convention for gross violations of the CEDAW Convention, the UN Convention on Women's Rights.
SPEAKER_04We need to see that case go forward. We need to see movement in terms of the efforts to prosecute uh Taliban leaders for gender persecution, another important international legal concept in the International Criminal Court. We need to see states being creative and using universal jurisdiction when they can to go after uh Taliban uh perpetrators. I mean, there's a general need to look at accountability for many decades of human rights violations by many parties in Afghanistan.
SPEAKER_04But here we're talking about the current perpetrators uh of gender apartheid. All of these efforts need to be supported. And I would also say there there needs to be a clear message that whenever governments or international organizations are going to be dealing with the Taliban on whatever issue, human rights and women's human rights are on the agenda for discussion, and Afghan women are at the table.
SPEAKER_03On that note, I've got a slightly wider question. Do you think this issue would get more attention if the discrimination was not so specifically aimed at women? Let's not forget that we have a campaign against what is called diversity equality, particularly gender equality.
SPEAKER_03We have seen in Afghanistan, but in other countries, the programs which are specifically there to support women and girls, particularly about around reproductive health, have lost their funding. Is that making your whole campaign more difficult?
SPEAKER_04Absolutely. I think it is critical to understand this issue in the context of the broader global backlash against women's rights, including in the United States, uh, where I teach. Uh, and that makes this work so much more difficult and at the same time so much more important because Afghan women's rights are inherently important in and of themselves. Women from Afghanistan have universal human rights just like everyone else.
SPEAKER_01The pushback regarding women's rights, not just in Afghanistan, but uh around the world. It is a concern about for all of us. And uh my message for women who are in the Europe is that they should push their country, they should put pressure on their governments to support Afghanistan women and support Afghanistan women in actions, not in statements and not in words.
SPEAKER_04There's also a broader regional and indeed international uh implication here. One of the things that the declaration says is that the failure to effectively support uh the work against gender apartheid uh will undermine women on the front lines. It will perpetuate gross human rights abuses, but it will also threaten the whole international framework that guarantees women's rights everywhere. And so I think it's really significant to understand that global context.
SPEAKER_04So what happens in Afghanistan matters inherently, but it also will not stay there. And if the international community hasn't learned that lesson yet, then we have a much bigger problem.
SPEAKER_03Karima Banoon and Zarka Yaftali there with some stark warnings about the implications for women everywhere if we neglect their oppression in Afghanistan. But the call for an official declaration of gender apartheid does not have universal support. Diplomats here in Geneva, while publicly expressing outrage about the treatment of Afghan women and girls, often become vague and non-committal when asked about gender apartheid. One reason could be the challenge of finding a clear definition of gender apartheid under international law.
SPEAKER_03Another, more cynical, could be that recognizing gender apartheid might lead to having to grant more asylum requests. For more analysis, I turn to Fareshta Abbasi, Afghanistan researcher with Human Rights Watch, who has just written an article urging the international community to exploit clear disagreements inside the Taliban as part of a broad range of measures to support women and girls.
SPEAKER_02So let me begin by saying that the Taliban are not a unified structure. They take different positions in different provinces of Afghanistan. And you can easily see that in implementation of the PVPV law, the propagation of virtue and prevention of wise law, um the implementation of the edicts that the Taliban have issued, for example, on women's employment with NGOs. Um, and that in the whole article, uh, what I argue is that there are provinces in which some of the Taliban local authorities choose and decide either not to implement a decree or just close their eyes on the implementation of that decree.
SPEAKER_02That's what I'm arguing that could be exploited by holding some of them accountable, um, by making sure that the world is watching them. And this week is the 25th anniversary of war in Afghanistan, decades of impunity in Afghanistan. It's time to hold the perpetrators accountable. It's time to send a reminder and a notice to perpetrators of um serious violations in Afghanistan that they're being watched.
SPEAKER_03I'll move on to that, the accountability in a moment, but just staying with the idea that there is division, that some of these more repressive laws are not really implemented in some provinces. Looking at it from the Geneva perspective and the UN humanitarian agencies, you think therefore it's worth it for those UN agencies to stay, work where they can, try to engage, try to keep women working for them?
SPEAKER_02Yes, of course. In the past five years, um we have never disagreed with engagement. We have never called for the states and organizations to stop engagement with the Taliban, but we want to make sure that this engagement is principled. So, for example, when it comes to the humanitarian aid organizations, we have called on them to make sure that they are not reinforcing Taliban's abusive policies. You can easily see that if you speak with the aid organizations that are operating on the ground, they will tell you that they are not dealing with the same restrictions in every province of Afghanistan.
SPEAKER_02So, for example, in one province, women may need to be accompanied by a Mahram or a male guardian. In some other provinces, women need only Mahram when they travel outside their homes. In some other provinces, they need a Mahram when they travel outside that province. So these restrictions are really being implemented differently. It's also because the Taliban laws are quite vague. So it gives a lot of room for interpretation to the local authorities on how to interpret the law and then how to implement that. So there is a little bit of space for um choice that these um local authorities have when it comes to the implementation of these laws.
SPEAKER_03It's interesting you say some of these laws are quite vague because from the outside, what we see is one really brutal repression after another. I mean, the phrase has been used Afghan women are being erased from public life. Is it more complicated than that? And in the provinces where it isn't, where that's basically what's happening, how can it be challenged?
SPEAKER_02So on the bigger framing, I mean, human rights watch reporting, we have identified the situation as the crimes against humanity of gender persecution. The International Criminal Court has issued arrest warrants for the Taliban leaders. So the repression is brutal. But Afghan women in Afghanistan are resisting to these rules. There are still women who are working with the aid organization to support the aid delivery, especially for women and girls. That's the space we need to keep and protect and expand.
SPEAKER_02And in the article, one of the methods or one of the ways that I'm trying to explore and recommend to the states is to expand that space by holding the Taliban authorities accountable, especially in the local level. Because in the past five years, most of the accountability has only focused on the Taliban leaders, which don't really seem to have much left to care about. But the local authorities definitely have a lot to lose. So it's Afghan women who still, despite all these restrictions, despite all these bans, go to the streets every day.
SPEAKER_02And some of them are being detained, arbitrarily detained, because they're still going out to the streets, they're still resisting to the Taliban repression. They're being detained, they're being tortured, their family members are being tortured with them. So it's important for us to recognize their resistance and also to protect their space.
SPEAKER_03How though? You talk about accountability. We've mentioned the International Criminal Court. It's a good signal, yes, but the wheels of the ICC move very, very slowly. The ICC itself is challenged at the moment. How practically to get accountability on the local level? What would you suggest?
SPEAKER_02So the UN Human Rights Council established an accountability mechanism for Afghanistan last year in October. That provides a big window of hope, but also opportunity for victims in Afghanistan to ever get justice. Disney mechanism, if it's fully funded, if it has the resources and can deliver its comprehensive mandate, have the capacity to investigate serious human rights violations at a local level. So the important message that needs to be sent to the Taliban right now is that it's not only people who are decreeing these edicts or people who are coming up with these restrictions are responsible and will be held accountable, but whoever who is implementing it in provinces of Afghanistan, in districts of Afghanistan, can be investigated and can be held accountable too.
SPEAKER_02So it's important that this message is being sent consistently to the Taliban local authorities in Afghanistan, because we already see that some of them are just not implementing these laws, or there are gray areas, let me say that. In some provinces, there are a little bit more opportunities compared to other provinces of Afghanistan. So that gap can be exploited. If a commander or if local authority in Ruhr in the central province of Afghanistan hears that there is a mechanism that is currently identifying perpetrators, he's going to be careful.
SPEAKER_02He will think about his future, he will think about the future of his children, and he will make sure that he's not on that list. That's how we can support and protect this space for Afghan women.
SPEAKER_03What about this push for declaring what's happening in Afghanistan gender apartheid? Now, some of the supporters of that think it would be a really significant move, which would also have that they're going to be careful if they hear that kind of effect.
SPEAKER_02So this is a campaign that is led by women of Afghanistan. And I do believe that women of Afghanistan need to be heard. If they think that the current international mechanism does not reflect the extent of the repression, then gender apartheid should be codified as a new crime under the new crimes against humanity 3D. The international law has expanded over years with different experiences. And I do believe that what is happening in Afghanistan is quite unique. An Afghan woman believed that nothing captures no crime, no international crime, and the international human rights law currently captures the extent of that repression.
SPEAKER_02So it should be supported and should be codified.
SPEAKER_03So you would see it as not the answer, but another element where pressure and public accountability could be achieved?
SPEAKER_02Definitely.
SPEAKER_03Do you worry, though, that on a broader level, the issue of rights for women, gender equality is being deprioritized by some big powers? I think particularly the United States, which is is increasingly its diplomats are uncomfortable with words like gender in any UN policy document or any human rights treaty. Do you think that's part of the reason that Afghanistan and women in Afghanistan are getting less attention now?
SPEAKER_02Definitely. I mean, Afghanistan does not exist in a gap. For the past five years, one of the things that I've been warning diplomats that I meet with is that what's happening in Afghanistan is not going to stay in Afghanistan. What is happening in Afghanistan is not only an attack on the rights of women and girls in Afghanistan, it is an attack on the rights of women and girls globally. It sends the message to other authoritarian regimes around the world that you can get away with whatever you do in your country. So it is important for us to make sure that we are still focusing on the rights of women, on gender equality.
SPEAKER_02But unfortunately, overall, I mean, globally, that no longer is a priority. And I began by saying that this week is the 25th anniversary of war because the US is one of the countries that were heavily involved in Afghanistan. Its forces are accused of serious violations in Afghanistan, which the victims of those violations never had a path to justice. And the US actually had actively blocked any sort of pathway for these victims to access justice. But they do have an obligation for Afghanistan. They cannot just wash away their hands in August 2021.
SPEAKER_02They cannot wash away their history like that. The US has cut all its aid on Afghanistan, which used to provide 40% of Afghanistan's aid. The humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan, as a result of that, remains acute. Around 600 um health facilities have shut down in Afghanistan. They were providing health services to women and girls in Afghanistan as well, as well, I mean to the population of Afghanistan. So it's very unfortunate to see how the world has forgotten about Afghanistan and no one seems to really want to take action when it comes to the rights of women and girls in the country.
SPEAKER_03Well, of course, you are originally from Afghanistan yourself, and we've been talking for a few years now. Inside Geneva Podcast knows you quite well. That's a hard future you're looking at if you look at the situation now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's difficult to think of a better future under the Talib. Um, but as I have said this many times, women in Afghanistan are still existing. Female doctors, healthcare workers, despite all these restrictions, are still coming out of their houses. They go to their health facility, they probably are being stopped at their checkpoint, they probably are being interrogated, they need to be accompanied by a male family member, but they still go to the clinic and they still provide healthcare services to women and girls. For me, that's resistance, and that gives me hope.
SPEAKER_02And that's why I argue that that space needs to be protected.
SPEAKER_03And those words of hope from Fareshta Abasi bring us to the end of this edition of Inside Geneva. My thanks to Fareshta, Karima, and Zarka for their time and analysis. We hope you enjoyed today's programme. Drop us a line at inside Geneva at Swissinfo.ch with your thoughts. Or review us and subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. Join us every other Tuesday on Inside Geneva. In between, catch up on some of our previous episodes.
SPEAKER_03What's it like for a nurse working in the Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo? How are people in Gaza surviving when reconstruction is stalled? And will a woman finally lead the United Nations? All that and more wherever you get your podcasts. I'm Imogen Folkes. This has been a SwissInfo production. Thanks for listening.
Send us Fan Mail This week on Inside Geneva, host Imogen Foulkes looks at the race to become the next UN Secretary-General. Antonio Guterres will step down in just six weeks, but the UN Security Council cannot agree on...
Send us Fan Mail In episode four of our series interviewing candidates for director general of the World Health Organization (WHO), we talk to Gevorg Tamamyan. This series is in partnership with the Global Health Centre...
Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...
Send us Fan Mail Here is episode two of our series in partnership with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute, bringing you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World...
Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...