Send us Fan Mail This week on Inside Geneva, host Imogen Foulkes looks at the race to become the next UN Secretary-General. Antonio Guterres will step down in just six weeks, but the UN Security Council cannot agree on his successor. "The whole process is so strange, completely untransparent," says Louis Charbonneau of Human Rights Watch. He is concerned that some candidates for the UN's top job come from countries with poor human rights records. Richard Gowan of the International Crisis Group warns: "It's a bleak time. It feels as though this selection process has existential implications for the UN." The UN is facing huge financial and political challenges. Can it survive if member states cannot even agree on a leader? Listen now to the full episode. Get in touch! Email us at insidegeneva@swissinfo.ch Twitter: @ImogenFoulkes and @swissinfo_en Thank you for listening! If you like what we do, please leave a review or subscribe to our newsletter. For more stories on the international Geneva please visit www.swissinfo.ch/ Host: Imogen Foulkes Production assitant: Claire-Marie Germain Distribution: Sara Pasino Marketing: Xin Zhang
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02SwissInfo podcasts. This is Inside Geneva. I'm your host, Imogen Folkes, and this is a production from SwissInfo, the international public media company of Switzerland. In today's program.
SPEAKER_04The United Nations is facing a major internal deadlock. Who will be the next leader and why are world powers clashing over the selection process?
SPEAKER_11We can say, I think, quite objectively, that it's a mess here, race. Either of the last two. By recent standards, this is very, very complicated and very, very uncertain.
SPEAKER_13But who gets the job will be decided not by the public, but largely behind closed doors by exclusively 15 countries on the UN Security Council.
SPEAKER_01The whole process is so weird. I think the best analogy to it is the selection of the Pope. Completely untransparent. It's hard to get more opaque than the process of selecting the Secretary General. Who will replace Antonio Guterres as the next Secretary General of the United Nations?
SPEAKER_07The Secretary General's role is very key in highlighting some of the worst humanitarian and human rights crises around the world.
SPEAKER_09The United Nations is searching for a new leader at a particularly difficult time for the organization, which faces a funding crisis, wars, and geopolitical turbulence across the globe.
SPEAKER_11It's a bleak time. It does feel, as I've said, that this selection process has existential implications for the UN. But it it's not game over.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome again to Inside Geneva. I'm Imogen Folks, and today we're going to take a look at the race to lead the United Nations. Current Secretary General Antonio Guterres steps down at the end of this year, and for many months now, several candidates have been campaigning hard to take over at the world's top multilateral organization. One many view is vital to maintaining some form of peace and diplomacy in our world.
SPEAKER_02But an organization that faces huge challenges, financial and political. Now, hazard warning, as we recorded this episode, the UN Security Council was going through yet another series of secret ballots to try to identify possible favourite candidates. One or two may or may not have emerged by the time you listen, but still we thought we'd give you a flavour of how this somewhat odd election is developing and why human rights organisations have concerns about some of the candidates.
SPEAKER_02Let's hear first from Richard Gowan, who is the International Crisis Group's expert on global issues and institutions.
SPEAKER_11So I think there's a sort of strange mix of emotions amongst UN insiders in New York. On the one hand, there is a sense that this is a really important race. The UN is going through very difficult financial circumstances. Clearly, the Security Council is really divided, and Antonio Guterres, the incumbent Secretary-General, is seen as a bit of a lame duck, actually a very lame duck. And so UN officials and diplomats say we need new leadership.
SPEAKER_11We need someone who can get on top of the managerial problems and the budget problems facing the UN, and also someone who can restore the UN's standing in international peacemaking. On the other hand, while everyone feels this is very important, there is real confusion and I think real concern about how the race is going to play out. I mean the race has been going on throughout 2026. For much of 2026, it was a pretty slow, pretty incremental process.
SPEAKER_11It's suddenly become quite dramatic with uh new candidates jumping in, uh, most notably Lana Nusape from the UAE. And the Security Council is meeting. The Security Council is holding pretty regular polls on who should become Secretary General. But the the results are unclear, and there is a fear that we'll get to the end of the year and we won't actually have agreement on who should be leading the UN.
SPEAKER_02Let me just come to that, the process of it. I've watched a few of these. This particular election seems to be more opaque, more complex, more confusing.
SPEAKER_11So it always takes quite a few rounds of voting. But, you know, we can compare it to 2006 and we can compare it to 2016. And in both those years, a leader had emerged had emerged by the late summer, uh Ban Ki-moon in 2006 and Guterres in 2016. And in each of those cases, they wrapped up the race in October. So they had the best part of three months to prepare for office.
SPEAKER_11Now clearly this race is going to continue at least until mid-November. Some diplomats think longer. And so we can say, I think quite objectively, that it's a messier race than either of the last two. Now, you can go back to the Cold War, you can go back to earlier eras of the UN's history, and you can find times when Secretary General races were as messy or even messier than this, but by recent standards, this is very, very complicated and very, very uncertain.
SPEAKER_05The first round of Straw poll has taken place. The candidates will be informed of the results through the respective permanent representatives of nominating member states.
SPEAKER_02So this race is messy, long, and uncertain. For Louis Charbonneau, UN director at Human Rights Watch, the process also lacks transparency. And because bigger powers have bigger influence, not especially democratic.
SPEAKER_01The whole process is so weird. I think the best analogy to it is the selection of the Pope. Completely untransparent. It's hard to get more opaque than the process of selecting the Secretary General because the five permanent members of the Security Council of the United States, Russia, China, Britain, and France, they have an outsized role. It goes, it starts in the Security Council, they nominate someone, and then it goes to the General Assembly.
SPEAKER_01And traditionally, the General Assembly kind of rubber stamps it. That's how it works. But the P5 can veto the Secretary General candidate that gets proposed. Even if the other 10 elected members of the Security Council say, we really like this person, if the P5 don't want that person, they're not going to get through. And that's happened before. Secretary General, former Secretary General Boutros Boutros Ghali was rejected by the United States.
SPEAKER_01They said, no way. And he didn't get a second term. So no matter what the others say, if the P5 don't approve, they're not getting through. So that means they've really got a lot of power here.
SPEAKER_12The race to become the next United Nations Secretary General has hit a roadblock. In the latest informal straw poll, the contesting candidates received at least one discourage vote from one of the five permanent members the United States, Britain, China, France, and Russia.
SPEAKER_02So who is in the running? UN Protocol, though this is not a hard and fast rule, suggests it's the turn of someone from Latin America to lead the United Nations. And there is also growing pressure for the Secretary-General to be finally a woman. Some of the first candidates to throw their hats into the ring fit both those criteria. Rebecca Greenspan of Costa Rica, former head of the UN Conference on Trade and Development, or Carolyn Rodriguez Bierkett, Guiana's former foreign minister.
SPEAKER_02She's also worked at the UN's Food and Agricultural Organization. Then, Argentina's Raphael Grossi, best known as the head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, decided he would enter the race too. In the first rounds of secret voting by the UN Security Council, all three of them seem to have significant support. But no one is quite emerging as a leader, and each of them, during those secret straw polls, have had at least one discourage vote from a member of the Security Council.
SPEAKER_02So I had a question for our expert on UN insider dealings, Richard Gowan. I have heard rumors that none of the original candidates who've been working hard and campaigning for getting on for a year got support from at least one of the permanent members of the Security Council. So that, for example, that the United States put a discourage on each and every single one of them.
SPEAKER_02Is that likely?
SPEAKER_11I think it is pretty likely. I mean, you know, we've had I think roughly ten candidates in total over the course of the last ten months. Um, some have dropped out, and some have not been very serious. You know, some of the other candidates are clearly not going to get anywhere near the top of the UN. That said, we have some serious candidates. We've uh we have Rafael Grossi from Argentina, the head of the IAEA, we have Rebecca Grinspan, former vice president of Costa Rica, and a senior UN official.
SPEAKER_11And you know, these are people who I think most UN watchers would agree do meet the criteria to lead the organization. Uh they've been plugging away for a year. The lead, or at least the perceived lead in the race, has shifted over time. But yes, uh it does seem that none of these candidates has managed to win over the US. Um, and Russia and China uh also seem pretty skeptical towards most of the candidates.
SPEAKER_11Although we hear that China actually would accept Rebecca Grimspan, so it probably does mainly come down to the US and the Russians.
SPEAKER_06After 10 years, Antonio Guterrec will leave his post as Secretary General of the UN at the end of the year. Now, a controversial new contender has thrown her hat in the ring. Lana Nusebe is a senior Emirati diplomat.
SPEAKER_08But Turkey is officially nominated to former Foreign Minister Federin Sinaliogu as for next UN Secretary General. Well, the 70-year-old diplomat previously served as Turkey's ambassador to the United Nations for seven years.
SPEAKER_02And then, just to confuse us and cause dismay among the long-term candidates, there were new ones. Turkey's seasoned diplomat, Feridan Siniloglu, and also a seasoned diplomat, Lana Nusibey of the United Arab Emirates. While Senior Loglu's nomination hasn't yet attracted too much attention, Nussi Bey's candidacy has been met with a chorus of disapproval from human rights groups. Joey Shea, UAE specialist at Human Rights Watch, told me her reaction when she heard the news.
SPEAKER_07My first reaction was uh I wasn't surprised. You know, we had been hearing her name floated over the past few months, but I was uh surprised with how quickly her name went from being um a candidate where we didn't put that much um emphasis into her success to her being sort of the center and the forerender for the candidacy. So it was more the speed with which she went from being an outlier, outlying candidate to being um what seemed to be the central candidate for UN Secretary General.
SPEAKER_07What makes her unsuitable in your view then? So since the start of Sudan's War in 2023, there has been a growing body of evidence documenting how the UAE has been militarily supporting the rapid support forces, a um armed group that Human Rights Watch has documented as committing grave atrocities, including widespread killings and rapes. And a growing body of evidence has shown that the UAE has been providing weapons, military support, and personnel to the rapid support forces.
SPEAKER_07And earlier this year, we released a report documenting how a UAE-based company has been deploying private military contractors from Colombia to fight alongside the RSF incident on the front lines of the conflict. And we documented these Colombian contractors being on the front lines of uh of Al-Fasher during its downfall a year ago in October 2025. Just remind us what actually happened in Al Fasher. So the city of Al-Fasher in Sudan fell to the rapid support forces and unleashed a litany of grave atrocities, including massacres, um, widespread killings, and sexual violence on an absolutely massive scale.
SPEAKER_07And it was the RSF who was clearly perpetrating these abuses. But what we also found were these Colombian private military contractors who are linked with the UAE were there at the sites of these grave abuses, looking on and not intervening. And we also know that these Colombians sort of paved the way militarily for the RSF to take over Al-Fasher. Now, when it comes to Al Nusebe, we have a litany of comments from her personally denying these claims from both human rights organizations, media reports, but also most notably the UN's own reporting on the UAE's support to the RSF.
SPEAKER_03I'm standing to be United Nations Secretary General. She looks good. She sounds good, but the sudden candidacy for UN Secretary General of Lana Nusebi from the United Arab Emirates has horrified human rights campaigners. A year ago in Sudan, militia from the rapid support forces, which UN experts say is backed by the UAE, committed appalling atrocities in Al Fasha.
SPEAKER_02So will member states share the concerns of human rights groups. Obviously, Nussi Be has the backing of her native UAE, but what about key members of the Security Council? Most notably the United States, who, rumor has it, wasn't keen on any of the initial candidates. Over in New York, Human Rights Watchers' UN Director Louis Charbonneau is also curious.
SPEAKER_01We have heard all of the same rumors and more here in New York. It's impossible to say what's going on. The US has made certain comments in public that they don't want it to be a DEI candidate, diversity, equity, and inclusion candidate, which That's what the United Nations is all about.
SPEAKER_02Well, equity and inclusion.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. We the peoples is uh at the beginning of the UN charter, right? Which is as inclusive as you get. Not we the governments, but we the peoples. The P5 obviously care about having a Secretary General who's pliable, who listens to them, who lets them run the show. And there are people who argue that that's actually the best kind of Secretary General, one who gets along well with the P5.
SPEAKER_01Obviously, for those of us who are in the human rights field, that is not how we want it, because uh, well, all of the P5 have issues on human rights, but three of them, Russia, China, and the United States, are openly hostile to the human rights agenda that we and others are pushing and think that um it should not be something that is a priority, but it is one of the three official priorities of the UN.
SPEAKER_01So we're telling member states it's got to be somebody who's credible.
SPEAKER_00Ladies and gentlemen, I'm pleased to make the following announcement in my capacity as president of the Security Council with respect to the process of selection of the next Secretary General. The third round of struples has taken place. Each candidate will be informed of their results.
SPEAKER_02The difficulty, as ever, with the UN Security Council is that its five permanent and veto-wielding members may have different opinions about what a credible candidate looks like. Richard Gowan again.
SPEAKER_11So I think with Lana, yes, she formally entered the race late. But she is someone who has been talked about as a potential UN leader for a long time. I mean, she was Emirati ambassador in New York for nearly a decade. She represented her country on the Security Council, and I think even Lana's harshest critics would admit that she is an impressive diplomat as a person.
SPEAKER_11I mean, she's uh, you know, she's a political force. And so I think the Emirates hoped that when she stepped into the race, I mean, fairly clearly with US support, that she would sweep everything before her. And her campaign was clearly very well prepared. I mean, she she has a really, really effective comms operation backing her up.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they've been phoning me.
SPEAKER_11Yeah, I mean they're phoning they're phoning everyone, um, and they're spamming everyone. It's a much more professional, much more organized campaign structure than any of the other candidates that we've seen so far. And of course the Emirates can afford it. However, she faces two problems. One is I think the Chinese are not convinced that they want her. Now, this is partially because the the Chinese probably think, and here I'm speculating, that the US and Russia sort of negotiated around Lana without consulting Beijing sufficiently.
SPEAKER_11But also China has had some rocky relations with the Emirates in recent years. And so we have a sense that the the Chinese are the one veto power that have been discouraging Lana so far in the various straw polls.
SPEAKER_02Can I just jump in there? I thought maybe the United Kingdom would discourage her. I mean, here in Geneva, the UK's been the pen holder on UN Commission of Inquiry for Sudan, which clearly does lay out the UAE involvement. I I would have thought the UK might make a move there.
SPEAKER_11I think there is an internal debate in London. I think some UK officials, especially those covering Africa, do have concerns about Lana. Um, but I think that there are other UK officials who would say relations with the Emirates matter, you know, economically, in security terms, and so forth. And also if the US really wants Lana, then you know why pick a fight with Trump over this?
SPEAKER_11So we don't know if the UK is discouraging Lana right now or if it if it is um sitting on its hands. But you know, all that we're hearing suggests that it's really China um that is her main issue amongst the P5. Now, ironically, lining up with China, we see the human rights movement um, as you say, raising very detailed, very well-prepared concerns over the UAE role in Sudan.
SPEAKER_11And Lana's campaign was very well prepared, but actually there was clearly a well-developed anti-Lana campaign in waiting, sort of developed by various different human rights organizations, and ever since she jumped into the race, they have been very vocal, highlighting the situation in Sudan, highlighting the Emirati role in Sudan. And this has been a huge headache, I think, for the Emiratis and Falana's campaign.
SPEAKER_02Joey Shea of Human Rights Watch has no regrets about causing a headache. She fears the damage to the whole of the UN if its member states choose a Secretary General. Within her organization's view, questionable attitudes to human rights.
SPEAKER_07Multilateral institutions like the UN are so important for the protection of human rights, for the protection of civilians in Sudan and in other conflicts that don't get the detent the attention and national attention that they deserve. And particularly the Secretary General's role is very key in highlighting some of the worst humanitarian and human rights crises around the world. So what it says is that a country like the UAE that is so authoritarian, that has such a well-documented history of abuses, both domestically and abroad in terms of its foreign policy.
SPEAKER_07And now, you know, we're not just only referring to Sudan, but also Yemen, Libya as well. You know, we've documented UAE grave abuses in those conflicts there. Um, it says that very easily a state such as the UAE can, in a short period of time, project their influence into these very critical roles that are meant to protect human rights around the world. And, you know, we are very concerned that these institutions may be undermined by the influence of authoritarian states such as the UAE.
SPEAKER_02And Louis Charbonneau shares those concerns. Can a citizen of a country which the UN's own reports testify is taking sides and even supplying weapons in an ongoing conflict really lead the United Nations?
SPEAKER_01People run as Secretary General as an individual, not as the state. But we have to ask the question, how independent would they be? Article 100 of the UN Charter says that a Secretary General is supposed to be independent of any government and not take instructions from any government. And governments are not supposed to put undue influence on Secretary General. But is that what would happen? We don't know, but member states should think about that very carefully.
SPEAKER_02What about the latest candidate from Turkey?
SPEAKER_01It's yeah, it's difficult to say. Obviously, Turkey does not have a good record on human rights, to put it diplomatically. Very concerning. They've long been one of the top jailers of journalists in the world, right? So what does that say about their respect for free speech? Um, and this is something that is a big topic at the United Nations, protecting journalists, protecting free speech.
SPEAKER_01Um, we speak about uh him as a as a person, as an individual, but obviously we have serious concerns about Turkey. And what all we can say at this point is is that we don't know who's going to be Secretary General, but certainly whoever it is, it can't be somebody who is going to be influenced by governments that have poor records on human rights, and they need to themselves have a strong record of upholding human rights and being independent.
SPEAKER_01Uh otherwise, in the world we live in today, where human rights are no longer something that a lot of governments are saying we, you know, this isn't something we don't care about, or they're openly hostile to it. We've seen this in the United States. We need somebody who isn't of that ilk. Otherwise, it's going to make our lives a lot more difficult. I mean, we'll work with whoever is there.
SPEAKER_01We have no choice, just like journalists have no choice. They have to interview whatever leader is there. But certainly, we would like to see the UN headed by somebody who is committed to human rights and is willing to stand up for the we the peoples around the world.
SPEAKER_04Deep disagreement is emerging. None of the candidates has secured support from all five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council.
SPEAKER_10Gaza, Ukraine, Sudan, Iran, climate change, artificial intelligence, war and peace.
SPEAKER_02The disagreements over the choice of UN Secretary General are, as we know, not the only challenges facing the UN. The world is witnessing a record number of conflicts, and the UN is clearly failing in its peacemaking role. Its humanitarian agencies have suffered devastating financial cuts, even as the number of people in need soars, and the United States is abandoning some UN agencies, like the World Health Organization. So, I asked Richard Gowan, is the UN becoming irrelevant?
SPEAKER_02Can it, should it, survive?
SPEAKER_11So I have heard that senior US officials and at least one European Foreign Minister have repeatedly asked the candidates to be Secretary General. You know, why? Why would you want this job now? And I think that's a very, very fair question. And I'm not sure that even the best candidates have a totally convincing answer to that. Um however, I do think that the mere fact that we see you know, we see some serious people in this race and the fact that the race is starting to get some some real global attention is a sign that you know the UN still has resonance.
SPEAKER_11And I think if you talk to a lot of diplomats in New York and Geneva and Vienna, they would say no one has come up with a convincing alternative. You know, the the famous Board of Peace uh has you know, all for the world, you know, that has sort of deflated in less than a year. Um you have groups like the G7 and the BRICS, but they're not really capable of replacing a lot of what the UN does.
SPEAKER_11And actually, in this moment of global turmoil, there is a a recognition across different groups, across different blocs, that we still need the UN. And that you need a UN leader who can bridge some divides, manage some pretty nasty situations, and make a convincing pitch that the organization can survive.
SPEAKER_11So it's a bleak time. I mean it it does feel, as I've said, that this selection process you know has existential implications for the UN. But it it's not game over. Um we do still see a lot of people who really want this race race to deliver new leadership, stronger leadership, and maybe someone who can dig the UN out of the hole that it has fallen into.
SPEAKER_02Well, whoever becomes UN Secretary General is going to need, it seems, a very big shovel, and hopefully a team of 193 diggers. That brings us to the end of this edition of Inside Geneva. My thanks to Louis Charbonneau, Joey Shea, and Richard Gowan. If you've got views about the future of the United Nations and who should lead it, write to us at insidegeneva at SwissInfo.ch and subscribe to us and review us wherever you get your podcasts.
SPEAKER_02Next time, we'll be asking whether the UN can agree on any controls for lethal autonomous weapons. Join us on November 24th for that. For now, I'm Imogen Folks. Thanks for listening. A reminder you've been listening to Inside Geneva, a SwissInfo production. You can email us on insidegeniva at SwissInfo.ch, and subscribe to us and review us wherever you get your podcasts.
SPEAKER_02Check out our previous episodes how the International Red Cross unites prisoners of war with their families, or why survivors of human rights violations turn to the UN in Geneva for justice. I'm Imogen folks. Thanks again for listening to the
Send us Fan Mail In episode four of our series interviewing candidates for director general of the World Health Organization (WHO), we talk to Gevorg Tamamyan. This series is in partnership with the Global Health Centre...
Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...
Send us Fan Mail Here is episode two of our series in partnership with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute, bringing you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World...
Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...
Send us Fan Mail This week on Inside Geneva, host Imogen Foulkes asks whether the International Criminal Court (ICC) can survive Washington’s brutal sanctions. James Goldston of Open Society tells us the sanctions mean...