Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Inside Geneva

Inside Geneva artwork

WHO candidate Budi Sadikin: no country can fight a pandemic alone

Nov 1, 202628 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Here is episode two of our series in partnership with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute, bringing you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization (WHO). Budi Sadikin is currently Indonesia’s health minister, but has spent most of his career in finance, as a top executive at Indonesia’s biggest bank. “Before, my job was to make my clients wealthy; now my job is to make my people healthy,” he says with a smile. Sadikin believes his experience in finance will help him tackle WHO reform, even as the organisation suffers big cuts in donor funding. But he is also a firm believer in health equity, telling us that during a global pandemic, emergency treatments “should become global public goods.” He says his good relations with the United States will help him encourage Washington to rejoin the WHO, but also warns that “if any country believes it can safeguard its population on its own during the next pandemic, that is scientifically and practically impossible.” Listen to the full interview and subscribe to our Inside Geneva podcast. Get in touch! Email us at insidegeneva@swissinfo.ch Twitter: @ImogenFoulkes and @swissinfo_en Thank you for listening! If you like what we do, please leave a review or subscribe to our newsletter. For more stories on the international Geneva please visit www.swissinfo.ch/ Host: Imogen Foulkes Production assitant: Claire-Marie Germain Distribution: Sara Pasino Marketing: Xin Zhang

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Hello and welcome to this special series from Inside Geneva. In partnership with Geneva Graduate Institute's Global Health Center and SwissInfo, I'm Imogen Folkes.

SPEAKER_01Since 1948, thanks to the diversity and the commitment of its 194 member states, the World Health Organization has had a profound impact on improving the health of human beings around the world.

SPEAKER_02A vaccination campaign to combat the polio virus, which has re-emerged in Gaza for the first time in a quarter of a century, continued on Monday. The United Nations-led mission is working with Palestinian health authorities.

SPEAKER_04Supporting health services and tackling disease outbreaks in conflict zones. And advising on essential medicines. But it's also an organization facing huge challenges. The United States, a key donor and global superpower, has left.

SPEAKER_03Oh, that's a bad one.

SPEAKER_04Other member states are cutting their funding, and public health advice everywhere is being undermined by myths and disinformation. So who really wants to be the WHO's Director General? In this series, each episode brings you an in-depth, exclusive interview with a candidate for the job.

SPEAKER_04Today we hear from a man who made the perhaps surprising switch from high finance to public health.

SPEAKER_05Before, my job is to make my clients wealthy, now my job is to make my people healthy. We cannot determine which country which people should live and which country which people should die. Emergency vaccine, therapeutics, and also diagnostic tool should become global publicus. If any country believes if the next pandemic happens, they can secure the safety of their country alone, it is scientifically and practically possible.

SPEAKER_05My approach is not telling these 194 members of WHO this is my priority. I will again turn the table around and ask them, what are your priorities? At the end of the day, these 8 billion people have some similarities. They want to live long and healthy.

SPEAKER_04But just before we start, some information about our editorial process. Geneva's prestigious Graduate Institute has invited all the candidates for an interview. We have key questions about global health challenges and about leading the WHO, which all candidates are asked. And some individual questions, because of course we want to get to know them not just as health leaders, but as people too. And the order in which our episodes appear has no significance.

SPEAKER_04It's simply related to which candidate found time for us when during their very busy schedules. So, let's meet today's candidate.

SPEAKER_05My name is Budi Sadikin. I am the Minister of Health of the Republic of Indonesia. My job is to make the Indonesian people healthy. 290 million of them live in 7,000 inhabited islands.

SPEAKER_04Quite a challenge, I imagine. Is that what you imagined you would do when you were growing up? A lot of people say, no, I wanted to be an astronaut or something.

SPEAKER_05Did you have other dreams? You exactly have my mind in your mind. So when I was young, I want to be an astronaut.

SPEAKER_04But you ended up health minister. Let's look a bit at your background then. What brought you into public health? What motivates you to get into that field? Because your background is in finance and business, I understand.

SPEAKER_05I used to run the largest bank in the country. And you know, being the CEO of the largest bank of the country, you make so much money. And suddenly the president asked me to run as Indonesian Minister of Health at the beginning of the pandemic and become the first Indonesian health minister without medical background. To be honest, I'm shocked. I never thought that I will be in this position. But you know what the president asked me? Hoodie, we need somebody that can save 280 million Indonesian lives, get the vaccine.

SPEAKER_05We don't have the vaccine at the time, get the money, and please vaccinate 210 million Indonesian people. Because the target at the time is 210 million Indonesian people, ASAP, and to save their lives. So after thinking for one day, I realized that I have enough money until I die. But this is an opportunity to save people's lives, and I think I am gonna enjoy it. And during the process, I feel that it's so fulfilling this job.

SPEAKER_05Before my job is to make my clients wealthy. Now my job is to make my people healthy. I think the best wealth is health. So it is the most fulfilling jobs, from my view, of all of the jobs that I've been done before.

SPEAKER_04I'm really, really interested by what you said there, because the pandemic exposed one of the things that the World Health Organization talks about a huge amount, which is health equity. You know, some countries got no vaccines, others had far more and eventually had to scrap them. Is that a priority of yours if you if you become director general of the WHO to make things more equal?

SPEAKER_05My personal experience. When I joined, we don't have enough money, we don't have a vaccine. So we need to fix that. During Indonesian presidency in 2022, about one and a half years after I became health ministers, those two things stick in my mind. So with the Indonesian Ministry of Finance, the idea is to establish a pandemic fund. This is a global health fund that is prepared for the next pandemic.

SPEAKER_05So when the next pandemic happens or the next global health crisis happens, we already have in global finance architecture, I came from finance. In global finance, when you had a global finance crisis, there are an institution, two institutions basically, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank that was designed back in 1944 in the aftermath of World War II to handle the world financial crisis. So the world finance architecture has these institutions.

SPEAKER_05In health, we don't have. Global health crisis happens, we don't have access to money. So we established Indonesia, initiated the establishment of the pandemic fund. For the future pandemic, this fund can provide money, like the International Monetary Fund, to every country that has a global health crisis. This is the purpose. The second initiative that is not yet finished, second problem, you have money, but you don't have access to vaccine. And access during profit, you know, it is the most non-equitable distribution of access, especially for poorer countries, but not poorer countries.

SPEAKER_05Small countries also, whether they are rich, they still have a problem in access. So at that time, I still remember that is an I need to have a pandemic treaty. Whereas during pandemic, this emergency medical countermeasures like diagnostic tools, therapeutics, and vaccine become public goods. It should not be private goods. Why? We cannot determine which country which people should live and which country which people should die.

SPEAKER_05So this emergency medical countermeasure, which is vaccine, therapeutics, and also diagnosic tools, should become global public goods.

SPEAKER_04Well, you say we need a pandemic treaty, and I hear you, but that treaty is stalled. There are still differences over pathogen access and benefit sharing, and member states in the private sector just don't seem to be able to agree.

SPEAKER_05With the conditions that the private sector that invented this should be compensated accordingly, should be compensated fairly. That is the reason why the pandemic fund is there. The pandemic treaty is being circulated, discussed in WHO meeting, World House Assembly, but unfortunately, until now, it's not yet approved. So as the only health ministers G20 left during COVID, I feel a little bit sad.

SPEAKER_05But the discussion about pandemic treaty becomes the discussions of who will benefit, access to data, etc. They forget the essence. The essence is during pandemic, this emergency medical countermeasure should become global public goods. Where everybody, young or old, poor or rich, they should have the same right to access this treatment.

SPEAKER_04Let me come on to a couple of other possible challenges. What do you identify as big health challenges around the world? Is it climate change, resistance to antibiotics?

SPEAKER_05There are many, what I call a risk factor of health. And this is every health ministers in the country are very worried about this. But as a health minister, I realize that this is something that is being pushed, the IDs. But a groups of people and donors that have convictions that this is the overall health issues. My experience as a health minister, many countries, many health ministers that I meet, they always mentioned, hey, why the country is always being pushed, being directed by thought process or thinking or strategy or program from Geneva.

SPEAKER_05We need to be able also to determine what are the priorities. So this the discussion about health sovereignty is become very frequent, being discussed by the health ministers. Where every country, especially in the global south, need to be able to have the sovereignty in prioritizing their health problems. You know, mobilizing funding in sustainable manners and have the sovereignty in local manufacturing and also research.

SPEAKER_05And finally, so they can make their people healthier. So every time I talk, I facing with the question, Budi, what will be your priority? My approach is not telling these 194 members, WHO, this is my priority. I will again turn the table around and ask them, what are your priorities? And to my surprise, I've met maybe close to 100 health ministers during my career. 60%, maybe 70% are the same, but they have a different thing.

SPEAKER_05So, like example, in Japan, they are aging populations, they are rich country, you know, they are worried about dementia, Alzheimer's, the women worry about menopause. But you know, when you're talking about Indonesia and Africa, Africa, they're worried about Ebola, Indonesia, we are worried about tuberculosis. So then they're totally different.

SPEAKER_04I'm quite surprised at this angle you're taking, to be honest, because I mean the World Health Organization doesn't dictate national health policy. It leads on global challenges. You know, childhood vaccination in poorer countries or a pandemic, which is which is global. So maybe because if you do become director general, those global challenges will be on your desk. Do you see something like climate change and health as something the WHO should should be focused on?

SPEAKER_05It is definitely should be focused on. But then I will ask also the country, what are your priorities? What are your priorities? Like, for example, like you talk about Africa now in Congo, their priorities, I need to fix the Ebola state. I need to get the vaccine of Ebola outside. In many countries in Asia, South Asia, they have a lot of tuberculosis problems. So it doesn't mean that that one issue is not become a priority.

SPEAKER_05But it's also fair to listen to 194 member states, what are their priorities? Definitely global climate change is there, but definitely also other issues also very high in other countries specific for their priorities. And I would like to respect the priorities driven by the country because the country should be given the right to determine what are the most pressing issues of the healthcare sector.

SPEAKER_05This is always the input that I receive from the country. Please listen to our voice. You know, there are many smart people in the world that have the ideas on what priority health sector that they have to do, but please listen to our poor country, you know, about our priorities in our own field. That is what I would like to share with you.

SPEAKER_04You've also suggested, which I find really, really interesting, that maybe the WHO does too much and should refocus on core work. What's an example of too much? And what is a core mandate?

SPEAKER_05This is a consistent message given to me by the health ministers. They are doing too many things and they're afraid they achieve almost nothing. They need to focus on its core strength, which is number one, is to set norms and standards based on science. And then number two, to use their convening power, you know, to rally around institutions, whether private or public, to help the country achieve their objective.

SPEAKER_05But the key to help the country should be there. So the perspective is not the perspective from the donors, not perspective from Geneva only, but the perspective of these 194 countries in Africa, in Asia, and South Latin America. There is a debate whether WHO should have a very strong logistic centers about delivering the emergency medical countermeasures, or they can work with UNICEF and piggybacking the existing mechanism that UNICEF has.

SPEAKER_05Whether we have to take a lead in crisis country, or we work together with another organization like the International Red Cross or other agency, and we take a backseat in supporting the. I give you another example. Whether we would like to be aggressive in the pre-qualifications and take it everything to Dominatio to approve, or we should delegate to a regional regulatory medical authority, like the African Medical Authority, maybe the South American, or like example, the European medical agency.

SPEAKER_05So they have a lot more authority to approve the medical devices, vaccine, or therapeutic tool faster, rather than have to go to Geneva for every approval of new drugs or new treatment. Those are the inputs that I receive from the countries.

SPEAKER_04Okay, so that is very interesting, one, and something we hear a lot across the UN system is the need to really avoid duplication. You talked about the core work standards and advice based on science. There's a big challenge to that, which has been growing since the pandemic, which is a lot of mis and disinformation about science and growing mistrust, for example, of tried and tested vaccines, which the science tells us have saved millions of lives.

SPEAKER_04What would you do to restore trust in the science?

SPEAKER_05This is a very challenging issues in every country, including Indonesia. What I see recently, the way the way information is being disseminated, totally changed with the social media. Totally changed. Algorithms, you know, chatbot, robots, activities that in in my feedback is only used in politics. Now it's become spread and influence the people, and they become very powerful to shape the mind of every citizen of this planet Earth about something.

SPEAKER_05So my first reaction this WHO and other organizations is not only about health, it happens also in other things, about peace, about environment. It's talking about politics. You know, all of this new information channels change the landscape drastically about what we call correct or science-based information. So my first reactions, WHO needs to establish again the credibility.

SPEAKER_05So every people believe, every people trust that if this source mentioned about something, it has a credibility and they will listen. Number two, of course, we have to follow the trap in the way people communicate with others. Unfortunately, before we do press conference, we do journal, you know, we do debate, it's becoming outdated. People would like to see 30-second TikTok video.

SPEAKER_05People would like to see something put on Instagram. You know, very short, not a very complicated, but make people understand. So there has to be change also in the way we communicate to people. And we are talking about 8 billion people on this common place or common house, what we call planet Earth. We need to speak with them. We need to reach their mind and convince their mind that, hey, this is the right thing to do.

SPEAKER_05Because at the end of the day, these 8 billion people have some similarities. They want to live long and healthy. That is something that we have to do.

SPEAKER_04And that we all have in common. That's absolutely right. Quick question on WHO membership. You've kind of addressed some of the funding challenges by pointing out how greater efficiencies could be achieved. What about the United States then? Would you like to bring them back? Could you bring them back?

SPEAKER_05I'm a strong believer. It started under COVID. If any country believes if the next pandemic happens, they can secure the safety of their country alone. It is scientifically and practically impossible, in my view. So during the pandemic, what we have to do is to work together. It is impossible. I have seen that. It is like when you have an alien attacking you from outside. Then the work will realize that we need to work together, you know, to defend our home planet.

SPEAKER_05So therefore, I'm a very strong believer that US and Argentina should be bad and part of WHO. We cannot solve this global health problem alone. We have to do it together. We cannot do this exclusively, you know, the South and the North, the West and the East, you know, the non-US with the US. It is uncomprehensible for me. You know, we need to work together. If we have problems in communicating, you know, argue, debate, it's like in family.

SPEAKER_05If you have some debate with family, and family, your member family is very pissed off with you and he left your house, they have still your family. You know, we have to bring them back and live as a family. It's good. For everyone, for US, from non-US, from Indonesia, from European, for African, if these 8 billion people, 194 countries work together, especially on health. And maybe, in my view, with the very tense geopolitical situation now, with every country have their own view, health can be an example of how we can work together.

SPEAKER_05Why? Because our problem in health is the same. You live in Geneva, you live in the US, we all want to live long and healthy. That is very common. Nobody wants to live short and unhealthy. So we should be able, you know, to talk and discuss how we can together achieve that objective.

SPEAKER_04We have seen real increased lack of respect for health workers and hospitals in conflict zones, whether that's in Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine. How would you address that with member states and with their armed forces, the fundamental need to protect medical workers and allow them to work?

SPEAKER_05I'm very sad that as a human being, I think the value of human beings, every human being, is to value other human beings alive and professions, whatever their professions are. Whether it is health workers, whether they are a journalist like you, whether even whether they are politicians, I think it is our job as a good human being, you know, to treat them well. So it is very difficult for me to accept if we do bad things to other people in whatever professions are, especially the healthcare workers, because their job is to save lives.

SPEAKER_05If their job is to save lives, even if you deal with an army, your enemy, there is a strict rules and regulation that you have to respect, especially the healthcare workers. So what will I do? Of course, that has to be the instruction should be given by the leaders. So it is our responsibility, not only me, I think everyone, every human in this planet, especially who believe in multilateralism, we need to convince leaders of countries that are in conflict to respect this principle.

SPEAKER_05So I feel very sad to see that. This is not the world that I would like to see in the future. I don't want to see my children to live in a world where people don't respect the dignity of other human beings.

SPEAKER_04I've got two short questions for the end, and they're the ones that I'm asking every candidate. This is a very different one. What do you like to do when you're not working? Obviously, you're a very busy guy, but what do you like to do when you're not working?

SPEAKER_05I'm a marathon runner. I'm 62, but I've still run marathon. So I would like to finish, train my six majors. I only do two, I would like to get four. So I will do training, marathon for my next marathon.

SPEAKER_04Good for the health then. And very finally, why does the world need the WHO? And why does the world need you to lead it?

SPEAKER_05Number one, people want to live long and healthy. And WHO's job is to make sure that every man and woman in this planet Earth can live long and healthy. Why do they need somebody unconventional like me? Because WHO now is in the unconventional time. They need unconventional measures, therefore, they need unconventional people that have the track record to reform large organizations, the track record to mobilize large funding, the track record to convene country people with different opinions to agree on something, and the track record to deliver etsk.

SPEAKER_05To execute etsk. And I think that is something that I can bring to WHO.

SPEAKER_04The series is a co-production from the Global Health Centre of Geneva's Graduate Institute and SwissInfo. Tune in wherever you get your podcasts for our future episodes, where we'll be talking to more candidates to be Director General. And for more information about the WHO and its possible leaders, take a look at the Global Health Centre's dedicated platform by going to gh platform.org forward slash WHO dash DG election.

SPEAKER_04I'm Imogen Folks, thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. UN Secretary-General: who wants the world's toughest job?

    Nov 10, 202632 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail This week on Inside Geneva, host Imogen Foulkes looks at the race to become the next UN Secretary-General. Antonio Guterres will step down in just six weeks, but the UN Security Council cannot agree on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. WHO candidate Gevorg Tamamyan: ‘Geography must not decide who lives’

    Nov 8, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In episode four of our series interviewing candidates for director general of the World Health Organization (WHO), we talk to Gevorg Tamamyan. This series is in partnership with the Global Health Centre...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. WHO candidate Maria Neira: ‘We need to rebuild credibility and trust.’

    Nov 7, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. WHO candidate Hanan Balkhy: ‘The bottom line is that the funding is slimmer’

    Oct 31, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Who will defend the International Criminal Court?

    Oct 27, 202641 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail This week on Inside Geneva, host Imogen Foulkes asks whether the International Criminal Court (ICC) can survive Washington’s brutal sanctions. James Goldston of Open Society tells us the sanctions mean...

    Credit the people on this episode