Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Inside Geneva

Inside Geneva artwork

Who will defend the International Criminal Court?

Oct 27, 202641 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail This week on Inside Geneva, host Imogen Foulkes asks whether the International Criminal Court (ICC) can survive Washington’s brutal sanctions. James Goldston of Open Society tells us the sanctions mean a “financial death sentence” for the court’s judges and lawyers, who can no longer use credit cards and even US based systems like Microsoft. Philippe Bolopion of Human Rights Watch says the court is a last resort for the victims of terrible atrocities, such as war crimes and genocide. But Richard Goldberg of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies describes the ICC as a “kangaroo court”, which he believes is intent on prosecuting US and Israeli citizens. Tune in for a lively debate. Get in touch! Email us at insidegeneva@swissinfo.ch Twitter: @ImogenFoulkes and @swissinfo_en Thank you for listening! If you like what we do, please leave a review or subscribe to our newsletter. For more stories on the international Geneva please visit www.swissinfo.ch/ Host: Imogen Foulkes Production assitant: Claire-Marie Germain Distribution: Sara Pasino Marketing: Xin Zhang

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_07SwissInfo podcasts. This is Inside Geneva. I'm your host, Imogen Folkes, and this is a production from SwissInfo, the international public media company of Switzerland.

SPEAKER_00In today's program, we start in the United States where Donald Trump has denounced the International Criminal Court, accusing it of illegitimate and baseless actions against the US and Israel.

SPEAKER_13No. But it's starting to really deliver justice for victims. Often it takes too long, but it's the only way to signal that there will be no impunity for the most serious crimes.

SPEAKER_16As far as America is concerned, the ICC has no jurisdiction, no legitimacy, and no authority.

SPEAKER_19And there's now talk that they're going to go after Donald Trump. They're going to go after Secretary of War Pete Heggseth. They'll go after Marco Rubio. They'll go after maybe our command structure in the military.

SPEAKER_14Secretary of State Marco Rubio says the Trump administration is launching a diplomatic campaign to dismantle the International Criminal Court. The ICC is tasked with investigating and prosecuting genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.

SPEAKER_07Set up in 2002, the court is designed to prosecute individuals, not states, for the most serious crimes genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and the crime of aggression. 125 states recognize the court. And although the ICC is not a United Nations body, UN human rights investigators can and do share evidence with it.

SPEAKER_07Should it be indicting elected leaders? Does it have jurisdiction over states who are not even part of it? And if it doesn't, but national governments don't or won't investigate and prosecute suspected atrocity crimes committed by their citizens, how can real accountability be ensured? Opinions are divided, as you will hear from our three guests today.

SPEAKER_04My name is James Goldston. I'm the executive director of the Open Society Justice Initiative, which pursues law reform and legal action around the world to defend human rights and democracy.

SPEAKER_13Philippe Bolopion, and I'm the Executive Director for Human Rights Works.

SPEAKER_19I'm Richard Goldberg. I'm a senior advisor at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a nonpartisan national security think tank in Washington, D.C.

SPEAKER_12Attention, tribunal. Judges from Britain, America, Russia, and France assemble in Nuremberg's courthouse. The tribunal sits in judgment upon 20 leaders of the Nazi Party.

SPEAKER_07The ICC is, of course, not the first international court. In 1945, the Nuremberg trials, supported by the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain, and France, ensured that key leaders of Nazi Germany were prosecuted for war crimes and crimes against humanity.

SPEAKER_07In the 1990s, international tribunals for Rwanda and former Yugoslavia sought justice for those who had suffered the most terrible atrocities, including genocide. The International Criminal Court, says James Goldstone of Open Society, was born out of the same desire for justice.

SPEAKER_04It was the dream of the generation that gave us Nuremberg after the Second World War. And when it was finally activated at the beginning of this century, it was seen as the last place that victims of the most serious crimes could go to secure some form of redress for the violence that they had suffered. So it's a precious public good that the world as a whole thought was vitally important. And so it's really a significant departure and quite a loss, and I would say a great disappointment to see the United States now really turning its back and not only turning its back, but aggressively trying, in its own words, to dismantle this institution.

SPEAKER_07And Philippe Bolopian of Human Rights Watch points to what he sees as the success of the court today.

SPEAKER_13I've been in this field as a journalist or human rights advocate for over two decades now, and I've seen several cases that for me are incredible moments to see the former president of the Philippine, Rodrigo Duterte, in a cell in The Hague, having to answer for his uh out-of-control war on drugs against uh drug users in the Philippines. Incredible moment. Janjaweed leaders from Darfur, who wreaked havoc in the country two decades ago, held to account.

SPEAKER_13Even more recently, uh militia leader, a Seleca leader from the Central African Republic who was sentenced. I was in the Central African Republic almost uh 13 years ago. I went several times, we documented some of the crimes, horrendous crimes, that without the ICC would go completely unpunished. So is the ICC a perfect court? No, but it's starting to really deliver justice for victims. Often it takes too long, but it's the only way to signal that there will be no impunity for the most serious crimes.

SPEAKER_13Even to see the ICC have an arrest warrant against Vladimir Putin for crimes committed in Ukraine. That's huge, unthinkable a couple of decades ago. To see the ICC have an arrest warrant against uh Prime Minister uh Benjamin Netanyahu for the crimes committed in Gaza, unthinkable. Are they gonna be held to account tomorrow? Maybe not. But you know, their world is shrinking. They have now, when they travel around the world, they have to worry about 125 countries who have a duty to arrest them if they are present on their territory.

SPEAKER_07But Richard Goldberg of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies thinks differently. He believes a country like the United States, which has a functioning judicial system and anyway hasn't ratified the ICC, shouldn't be the target of its investigations.

SPEAKER_19To an American uh who watches investigations opened on American forces who operated uh in Afghanistan, obviously watching the ongoing uh investigations, indictments against Israeli leaders uh for their own responses to terrorist attacks. Uh, this obviously hits home for us. We understand the history of the ICC. We know why it was created. The U.S. uh was very supportive in past eras of setting up uh various uh dedicated tribunals to hold war criminals accountable.

SPEAKER_19Uh we remembered the uh war crime tribunals for Yugoslavia, for instance, uh and others. Uh, we understood that in a large part of the third world, there is no rule of law, there are no functioning courts, um, there are dictators that do very bad things uh to people, and uh a wide swath of the international community with good intentions wanted to find some sort of a forum to bring uh those types of war criminals uh to justice. Um, but notably Bill Clinton, the Clinton administration, was not comfortable uh with the ideas that were put there.

SPEAKER_19The idea that potentially this court could one day be abused to uh come after those that have functioning rules of law, that uh have functioning court systems, that have strict uniform codes of military justice, and hold themselves to high account as democracies and free nations uh that abide by the laws of war.

SPEAKER_08The United States has imposed sweeping new sanctions on the International Criminal Court, accusing it of trying to prosecute Americans.

SPEAKER_07The United States, under President Trump, has been sanctioning individual ICC judges and lawyers for some time. In October this year, it went further, sanctioning the entire court and imposing financial blocks and threats of punishment on anyone who does business with it. Secretary of State Marco Rubio says he wants to dismantle the court.

SPEAKER_07But Human Rights Watch is challenging the US moves in a US court. Philippe Bolopian again.

SPEAKER_13So we would have a court that will not allow impunity for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, some of the worst crimes known to humanity. So, in my view, the creation of the ICC was probably one of the greatest achievements of the human rights movement in the last few decades. So there is a lot at stake here. And to have the world power like the US announce publicly that they will use the flight of their power and their foreign policy to sanction the court, to go after each member of the court to try to get them to withdraw, it's an existential threat.

SPEAKER_13So we feel that as a human rights organization, we have to step up, and we did. We we sued the Trump administration in a US court. But I would say it's mostly for the members of the court to step up, for governments who are members of this court and you know are paying for it, are supporting it. Where are they in this moment when the US is threatening to destroy it? We we are really hoping that there will be a collective reaction. It's still 125 countries who are members of the court.

SPEAKER_13Together they are powerful and they can certainly stand up to the US. It's a really dangerous moment for international justice.

SPEAKER_07But the US has always had doubts about the ICC. It's not a member. Do you see a point that that an evolved democracy could actually prosecute its own criminals?

SPEAKER_13If they did, the court would not intervene, right? The International Criminal Court is a court of last resort. They only come in when others do not uh play that role because they can't or because they are not willing. The US argument that the court, because it could have theoretically jurisdiction over US citizens, is somehow violating uh US sovereignty is a fallacy. If an American citizen comes to uh, let's say Switzerland, where I am today, and commits a crime, that person who committed the crimes in Switzerland will have to answer in front of a Swiss court.

SPEAKER_13That's not a violation of uh US sovereignty, it's an affirmation of Swiss sovereignty. Now, if any of these governments, Switzerland or any other, want to entrust the International Criminal Court with dealing with certain cases, that's totally their prerogative. So I think these are hypocritical arguments.

SPEAKER_07And James Goldstone of Open Society suggests the US claim that the ICC will go after US citizens is not entirely persuasive.

SPEAKER_04The argument that the court poses a threat to American citizens seems a little out of place if we look at the history. There was one uh investigation years ago at the court that looked at the role of uh U.S. soldiers uh in Afghanistan back at the early part of the 21st century. But the prosecutor um uh affirmatively shelved that investigation uh quite some time ago. And there really is no threat to U.S. citizens at present.

SPEAKER_04Moreover, the ICC itself is a court of last resort. Uh it is premised on the notion that if a national government decides it is going to, in good faith, investigate, and if if the facts warrant, prosecute its own nationals, the ICC will back off and give precedence to the national investigation and prosecution. So the United States, like any other government, would always have within its power to launch its own investigation of anyone that the ICC decided to investigate.

SPEAKER_04But again, that's not a threat at present.

SPEAKER_07Aaron Powell Are there other reasons? Do you think are there other reasons than fear that U.S. service members might be prosecuted?

SPEAKER_04Aaron Powell Well, one of the arguments that has been made is that the Trump administration objects to the ICC investigating uh citizens of countries that have not ratified the Rome Statute, which would include uh both Israel and the United States. But there are a couple of problems there. One is that the United States uh Congress and almost unanimously uh recently supported, endorsed the ICC's actions against Vladimir Putin, who of course is the head of state of another country, Russia, that has not ratified the Rome Statute.

SPEAKER_04So um there seems a great inconsistency uh there.

SPEAKER_07So why really is the US position on the ICC so tough? Richard Goldberg's right-leaning Foundation for Defense of Democracies supports the US strategy. He told me more. And be prepared, listeners in Europe, for some views that might surprise you. For a start, Goldberg does not see the court as especially successful.

SPEAKER_19So what so what so what's the success here? With there are successes in Africa, I can point to. I concede that. That was, in fact, the impetus for the court. The British government, targeted by the ICC as well for uh now a member of the court, right? But obviously functioning democracy, functioning self-accountability in its military, high ethical standards, also investigated by the court, potentially could still be pursued, just like the Americans.

SPEAKER_07Well, the the difference is the British are okay with that.

SPEAKER_19Now it's up to the British government what they want to do. Obviously, they still participate in the court. We do not. So certainly as a non-member, non-signatory, non-ratified member of the Rome Statute, we should not be in any way investigated. And yet we are. And there's now talk that they're gonna go after Donald Trump, they're gonna go after Secretary of War Pete Heggseth, they'll go after Marco Rubio, they'll go after maybe our command structure in the military. Why? Because we took out drug boats in the Caribbean, we took the euro.

SPEAKER_07The the international lawyers, I just have to interject there, would point out, would suggest to you that the action in the Caribbean was not necessarily in the rules of engagement. Forget about the ICC, other international law that the US is a signatory to. My question to you though is if you're so unhappy with the ICC, why does the US not try to engage and accept what other countries' democracies have accepted is that not every single time is a country perfect.

SPEAKER_07Most countries' democracies don't expect ever to be in indicted by it, but they agree that there is a need for an international court just in case.

SPEAKER_19A court of last resort for war criminals in places where there is no democracy, there is no rule of law, there is no ethical military, there is no military court system that is real, and you're talking historically largely in parts of Africa, perhaps a couple other areas of the world. That's the central thesis here. That's not what it's being used for right now. And in fact, they claim now that their mandate can go after the United States, our officials, our military can go after Israel, its officials, its military, other democracies who apparently decide to go along with such a kangaroo court and allow themselves to be subject to that while being members.

SPEAKER_19There's two choices here. As an American who is going to be looking out for American citizens and the rule of law and American sovereignty, understanding that we have the highest ethical standards in the world for ourselves and how we hold ourselves accountable. And we work with democracies like Israel, who we know from the battlefield in a command center, with their lawyers around, putting lawyers into the field with their units, calling off strikes, having to approve certain collateral damage estimates, having to say that we can't do that.

SPEAKER_07So in a system like that, well, Israel could bring all that to Oh, really?

SPEAKER_19Really? Yes, you could absolutely walk into court and plead your case with a court that's already decided politically, because they hate you, what the verdict is going to be. And it's not just the Jews in Israel, it's also America, because there is a larger anti-Western Marxist Islamist alliance that has been created. We're seeing it on the streets of Europe right now. Anybody who just turns on the TV and watches France, you know.

SPEAKER_07This I'm sorry, but I am not taking a side here, but I live in Europe and I'm a journalist and I'm looking for objectivity, and I'm gonna have to call you out on that.

SPEAKER_19What are what are you what are you concerned about? That there's not an as there's not an Islamist Marxist uprising going on in Paris right now and other parts of France and Italy? That's a fact. It's actually happening.

SPEAKER_07This is nonsense. Utter nonsense. All right. Look, Rich, I'm gonna move you back to the ICC. I think I think you've got the message through that you have no faith in the ICC or its judges or its lawyers. How about Western European leaders? Sure. They don't agree with the United States position on this. Why do you think that is?

SPEAKER_19Well, the European leaders who currently are overseeing a Marxist-Islamist uprising.

SPEAKER_07And that's where this particular section of our interview came to a halt, because I had advised Goldberg that Inside Geneva likes to stick to facts, and that if he continued to repeat his false narrative about the riots in France and the situation in Europe, I would at least temporarily stop the interview. His claims are ones we hear often from the MAGA wing of the Republican Party, but it's important for us at SwissInfo to point out, fact check, there is no evidence for those claims.

SPEAKER_07We'll hear more from Goldberg later in the programme, once he'd been persuaded to return to our designated topic of the international court. But first, here's some news about an Inside Geneva special series coming your way.

SPEAKER_11Since 1948, thanks to the diversity and the commitment of its 194 member states, the World Health Organization has had a profound impact on improving the health of human beings around the world.

SPEAKER_17A vaccination campaign to combat the polio virus, which has reemerged in Gaza for the first time in a quarter of a century, continued on Monday. The United Nations led mission is working with Palestinian health authorities.

SPEAKER_07Supporting health services. And tackling disease outbreaks in conflict zones.

SPEAKER_18Ebola keeps spreading in the east of Democratic Republic of Congo. It's moving so quickly. The World Health Organization adds, it's outpacing response efforts.

SPEAKER_07And advising on essential medicines. But it's also an organization facing huge challenges. The United States, a key donor and global superpower, has left.

SPEAKER_04Oh, that's a bad one.

SPEAKER_07Other member states are cutting their funding, and public health advice everywhere is being undermined by myths and disinformation. So who really wants to be the WHO's Director General? In this series, each episode brings you an in-depth, exclusive interview with a candidate for the job.

SPEAKER_07That special series begins October 31st, wherever you get your podcasts. Don't miss it. Now let's return to today's topic: the International Criminal Court. Although the court supporters, Human Rights Watch, and Open Society among them, had been preparing for more U.S. sanctions targeting individual judges and lawyers, the new blanket sanctions caused shock. Open Society's James Goldston explains their effect.

SPEAKER_04As you know, the judges and the prosecutors who uh have already been sanctioned have suffered very, very severely. It's like a financial death sentence. You lose access to virtually any kind of service that has a connection to the American financial system, whether that's computers, banks, health access, etc. So in some ways it's understandable that individuals and private institutions will do what they can to comply. But I think the requirement now that these court-wide sanctions have been issued is that all stakeholders across the board stand up for this court and make clear what is at stake and how essential it is that it survived.

SPEAKER_07Is there a way? I mean, there are still more than 120 countries have ratified the ICC are part of it. How would you be urging them to push back?

SPEAKER_04I think it's incumbent uh on everyone just to recognize what is at stake here, what has been gained, and what the just extraordinary loss would be if this institution were unable to operate in the future. And we know that the court has been taking steps in recent months to shore up its capacity to operate even under the withering force of sanctions. Um, but I think it's absolutely incumbent at this point for um all parties, states, civil society, citizens of the world to uh speak out in defense of this institution, to provide the support that they can, financial, political, and otherwise, to ensure that it is able to operate going forward.

SPEAKER_04You know, different parts of the world have different tools that they can use. Now is the time for them to use those tools to defend this institution, to support the victims of crimes that this court serves.

SPEAKER_07And Philippe Molopion of Human Rights Watch warns the sanctions imposed by Washington were never designed for such cases.

SPEAKER_13These sanctions were designed for terrorists. They were not designed for international judges and prosecutors. I was at the security conference in Munich a few months ago. I met there with the president of the ICC, Tomoko Akane. She's a Japanese judge, venerable Japanese judge, elected to this position in her 70s, incredibly courageous and unflappable. But she's now under this type of sanctions. For what? What crime did she commit? Because she did her job as an international judge.

SPEAKER_13That's the first part. The other part of the sanctions is that it becomes impossible for me or my organization to collaborate with the court. In the past, we did that all the time. We are trying to support the work of the ICC. I met with Tomoko Akane a few months ago. Now she's under sanction. I could not meet with her anymore without taking huge risks. I could be liable for up to 20 years in jail in the US and massive fines for violating these sanctions.

SPEAKER_13So it means that not only are these individuals severely impacted, but it impacts the entire ecosystem of organizations like mine that are trying to support the idea of international justice. And that's very much why we sued the Trump administration in US court. We are making the case that these sanctions are actually a violation of our freedom of expression, our freedom of assembly, that they contravene international law, that it's an abuse of power by President Trump to impose these sanctions.

SPEAKER_13And we're actually quite hopeful that the US justice system will recognize these sanctions for what they are.

SPEAKER_07What about the IT companies and banking software systems that are going along with this? Surely they should be saying no. Or could you sue them as well?

SPEAKER_13Look, they are governed by the US government and they have to abide by US law, sadly. So, you know, the problem is not really these companies, it's it's uh the abuse of power by the Trump administration trying to use a uh a sort of legal device designed for terrorists and trying to apply it to international judges. Even us as a US-based organization, we have to be very careful and we have to comply with these uh with these uh sanctions, or we take uh risks that are really unbearable for the organization.

SPEAKER_13So that's why we we are suing to try to assert our right to continue to do our work. But to answer your question, we are not blaming the the companies that are affected by this, we are blaming the Trump administration, which is imposing this on everyone, whether they like it or not. The problem here is the US government and the Trump administration, which is trying to use the full weight of US power to silence the court. Why? Because the court was bold enough to do its job and issue an arrest warrant against the Israeli Prime Minister.

SPEAKER_13At the end of the day, that's the reason why we are in this situation and the Trump administration is not even trying to hide it. They are proud of it.

SPEAKER_02The International Criminal Court is asking its member states to stand up against sanctions imposed on it by President Trump. The White House issued the sanctions yesterday in response to what it called illegitimate and baseless actions targeting America and Israel.

SPEAKER_07So what could persuade Washington to call off its sanctions? Richard Goldberg has an idea.

SPEAKER_19That the United States, Israel, other democracies can simply never be investigated by the ICC. Airtight. I don't know if you can make that airtight. I don't know if you get it ratified. That's obviously a decision point that's on the table right now, by the way. I mean, we should be clear. I mean, the sanctions announced on the ICC come with a six-month window provision. They could have been immediate. What is the off-ramp that is envisioned here? It's not a nice letter to the president saying, I promise we won't investigate you.

SPEAKER_19That's not going to cut it here. They talk of fundamental change or fundamental reform to the ICC would therefore depend on amendments to the Rome statute that ensure the United States, its officials, its military will never be investigated and prosecuted. Israel, other democracies like that will never be investigated or prosecuted. If the British government wants to sign on to that as well to protect its own citizens, it should. That would be a really smart thing for the British government to do, even if they support the ICC.

SPEAKER_19That is a possible off-ramp, uh, but it's probably the only one. Otherwise, the Trump administration will have two years to try to grind the operations to a halt as much as possible to see if you cannot stave off this disaster that's coming of this uh you know pseudo-kangaroo court coming after the United States and its allies.

SPEAKER_07So that would be the deal. Amend the Rome statute so that United States and Israel have impunity for eternity.

SPEAKER_19United States, Israel, I would say Great Britain. I would conclude democracies.

SPEAKER_07But such a solution, an international court for some, but not all, and certainly not the powerful, is in Philippe Bolopian's view impossible.

SPEAKER_13There is no uh renegotiating the Rome uh statute. You know, that took years to achieve in the first place. Governments are not going to want to uh exclude any citizenship from the reach of the court, you know. And I think these are just arguments that are put forward to try to weaken the court, to uh make it irrelevant, and you know, to dismantle it brick by brick, to use the words of uh Marco Rubio himself. That's the goal. It's not to make it stronger, uh refine its uh its mandate, it's to dismantle it brick by brick.

SPEAKER_13You have to take this administration at its uh words, they mean it.

SPEAKER_07Talking to Richard Goldberg, it's clear Washington or the current administration is indeed deadly serious. The disdain for the ICC is palpable.

SPEAKER_19If I believe that I'm going to put some unelected outside of my jurisdiction, outside of my control, hodgepodge of random countries, and they're going to be the ones who get to sit in judgment of the United States of America.

SPEAKER_07Everything has to be patronizing.

SPEAKER_19That's no, that's actually that that's actually what is happening. And that's not allowable from a United States perspective. It should not be allowable to anybody in the United States. Republicans, Democrats should not be for this. I mean, it's just crazy.

SPEAKER_07Can I just ask you then? Okay, stay out of the ICC. You don't the America doesn't want to play a role. But why go to the length of sanctioning lawyers and judges? That looks very punitive, a bit like bullying. It looks as if, as Marco Ruby said, you're trying to dismantle the ICC when other countries, 120 countries, still want to keep it.

SPEAKER_19Yeah. So uh I will say this I have never supported truly the onesie twosie, you know, whack-a-mole approach of like hit this judge, hit this prosecutor, all that. I never thought it would work. I don't think it's unduly punitive. I mean, these people are truly trying to wage lawfare against the United States and our closest allies without basis and without jurisdiction. But the question then, of course, is well, then how do you actually respond to this threat that's coming at you?

SPEAKER_19A form of warfare. It's what it is. Lawfare is an extension of war. This is what this is. This is lawfare. And so if if a if an entity is coming at the United States, I I don't think it's effective to just hit one judge, you know, one court person, some secretary taking notes. I think you have to go after the court in its entirety. I have for several years now called for direct sanctions imposed directly on the ICC as a whole. And the message to all the top funders of the ICC, remember, the closest allies of the United States make up most of the money that goes into the ICC.

SPEAKER_19When you think about Japan and Britain and Canada and France.

SPEAKER_07But none of them agree with the US on this one.

SPEAKER_19Well, that's a shame because I am happy to make sure that any transaction that is attempted to go to the ICC for funding uh results in sanctions on the bank that attempted the transaction. And that's within our jurisdiction, and that's how you actually uh force change here.

SPEAKER_07Trevor Burrus, Jr. That sounds like a serious threat. So where does the ICC go from here? Philippe Bolopian tries to stay hopeful, but he wants solidarity from the ICC's member states too.

SPEAKER_13I think the ICC can survive this. I think the ICC will survive this if all of these countries come together and decide to protect the court and stand up for what they believe in, their values, the idea of international justice, and they're very powerful. Is the US gonna be able to pick off a few of the members of the court? Yes, I have no doubt that they will already. They put pressure on Venezuela, on Chad, on Aru to uh to announce that they would leave the court. But you know, look at the list of the members of the courts.

SPEAKER_13It's a powerful group of countries, and and hopefully they will they will stand by what they uh they believe in, even in the face of uh uh US bullying.

SPEAKER_07You said you were fairly hopeful that the International Criminal Court could survive in the face of US bullying. On a broader level, from human rights watchers' perspective, how do you rate the health and life expectancy now of these fundamental principles, the ones that we grasped with both hands in 1945? Because it does seem that every day you see another strike against those principles.

SPEAKER_13There is no question that we are facing a dangerous moment for these ideals, for the human rights movement, for the idea of multilateralism, of international justice. You know, one of the biggest taboos that has been broken over the last few years is the prohibition of mass atrocities. Look at the world today. The world is on fire. We have more wars and conflicts than at any point since the Second World War. And many of these conflicts are marked by mass atrocities, whether it's in Ukraine, in Gaza, in the Sahel, in Darfur, in the DRC, in Myanmar, the list goes on and on.

SPEAKER_13The ICC was created precisely to deal with these kind of cases. But before we reach that level, you know, the UN diplomacy has many, many tools to try to prevent these atrocities. And yet today they are largely tolerated. You have world leaders like President Trump who brag openly about violating international humanitarian law, the laws of war. So there is no question that it's a dangerous moment for the multilateral system, for the institutions like the UN, the Human Rights Council, the ICC that are designed essentially to make the world a better place.

SPEAKER_13And if we are not careful, we we will lose ground. I look to countries like France and Germany and the UK and Canada in Australia. Where are they when the ICC is under attack? Yes, it's fine to have some uh vaguely worded statement saying that they still believe in the idea of international justice, but they have to prove it and show it and push back in a moment like that. It's not business as usual. The worst kind of threats that I have seen certainly in my adult life against the system, and if uh governments or civil society don't join forces to push back in this moment, uh then the world is gonna devolve into a much worse place than it already is.

SPEAKER_07Meanwhile, open society's James Goldstone hopes his own country, the United States, will think again.

SPEAKER_04You know, I have a um I have a personal history here. I I uh worked briefly at the ICC as a prosecutor, but before that, I spent a number of years as a federal prosecutor in the United States, uh, in New York. And I was proud to stand up in court and uh say that I represent the United States of America. That was something that meant a lot to me. I don't want to give up on that kind of pride. I want to believe that my government recognizes the value of the rule of law and courts that defend it.

SPEAKER_04So I'm hopeful that over time, with enough support from around the world, the United States will change its view and will ultimately join this historic effort in support of international justice.

SPEAKER_07And that brings us to the end of this, for me at least, really thought-provoking edition of Inside Geneva. We hope you enjoyed the discussion. Do write to us at insidegeneva at Swissinfo.ch with your thoughts on the International Criminal Court. Subscribe to us and review us wherever you get your podcasts. And don't miss our special series of in-depth interviews with the people vying to lead the World Health Organization. What are their views on equal access to medicines, on vaccines, on a pandemic treaty, on a tax on healthcare workers?

SPEAKER_07That starts on October 31st, wherever you get your podcasts. A reminder you've been listening to Inside Geneva, a SwissInfo production. You can email us on inside Geneva at SwissInfo.ch, and subscribe to us and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Check out our previous episodes how the International Red Cross unites prisoners of war with their families, or why survivors of human rights violations turn to the UN in Geneva for justice.

SPEAKER_07I'm Imogen Folks. Thanks again for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. UN Secretary-General: who wants the world's toughest job?

    Nov 10, 202632 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail This week on Inside Geneva, host Imogen Foulkes looks at the race to become the next UN Secretary-General. Antonio Guterres will step down in just six weeks, but the UN Security Council cannot agree on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. WHO candidate Gevorg Tamamyan: ‘Geography must not decide who lives’

    Nov 8, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In episode four of our series interviewing candidates for director general of the World Health Organization (WHO), we talk to Gevorg Tamamyan. This series is in partnership with the Global Health Centre...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. WHO candidate Maria Neira: ‘We need to rebuild credibility and trust.’

    Nov 7, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. WHO candidate Budi Sadikin: no country can fight a pandemic alone

    Nov 1, 202628 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Here is episode two of our series in partnership with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute, bringing you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. WHO candidate Hanan Balkhy: ‘The bottom line is that the funding is slimmer’

    Oct 31, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Inside Geneva has partnered with the Global Health Centre at the Geneva Graduate Institute to bring you exclusive interviews with the candidates for director general of the World Health Organization...

    Credit the people on this episode