The midterms are over in the US. Will our newly elected leaders be able to help those struggling with poverty? Over the last few decades, we've spent trillions on government welfare programs. So why are homelessness and dependency still such enormous problems? Could it be that we're fighting poverty with the wrong ideas? You can't solve homelessness simply by giving someone a house. You can't eliminate poverty simply by giving someone money. Socialist "solutions" are not the answer. So why do we keep treating the symptoms while ignoring the root causes? Today, we ask: How does our modern approach to poverty alleviation compare with God's design for human flourishing? In Part 2 of this thought-provoking conversation, host Scott and co-host Luke take the seven biblical principles of compassion introduced in Part 1 and compare them with today's dominant approaches to poverty alleviation, homelessness, and social welfare. Together, they explore how modern welfare systems can unintentionally encourage dependency, why addressing the root causes of poverty matters more than treating its symptoms, and how biblical principles of family, work, personal responsibility, freedom, and spiritual restoration offer a radically different approach to helping those in need. Christians aren't just called to care for the poor. We're called to care for them in ways that actually work! This is Part 2 of our two-part series on poverty and biblical compassion. We highly recommend listening to Part 1 (November 3, 2026) before jumping into this conversation! Who is the Disciple Nations Alliance (DNA)? Since 1997, DNA’s mission has been to equip followers of Jesus around the globe with a biblical worldview, empowering them to build flourishing families, communities, and nations. 👉 https://disciplenations.org/ 🎙️More About Scott Allen: In addition to hosting the Ideas Have Consequences podcast, Scott D. Allen is an author and teacher on Christianity and culture, worldview, family, Biblical justice, and poverty. He serves as the president of the Disciple Nations Alliance (DNA) Global Secretariat office. After serving with Food for the Hungry for 19 years in both the United States and Japan, working in the areas of human resources, staff training, and program management, he teamed up with Darrow Miller and Bob Moffitt to launch the DNA in 2008. 📌 Recommended Resources: 👉 Book: The Tragedy of American Compassion by Marvin Olasky | Goodreads 👉 Book: When Helping Hurts Book Summary by Steve Corbett and Brian Fikkert 👉 Book: Discipling Nations - Darrow Miller 👉 Course: Kingdomizer 102: Love In Action 💻 Follow Us: 📸Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/disciplenations 📽️YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/c/DiscipleNationsAlliance/ 📲Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/disciplenations 📩 Ask us anything: info@disciplenations.org Episode Webpage
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Scott AllenChristians say, yes, we have to care for the poor, and it never gets beyond that. Well, that's true. That's true. We have an obligation to care for the poor that's biblical. But we also have an obligation to care for the poor in a way that's biblical. There's a how to that as well that needs to align with the truth of the Bible and biblical principles and what it means to be a human being. And that, I think, gets almost no attention. And because it doesn't get attention, we just kind of go along with whatever the prevailing practices are out there under the rubric or the banner of caring for the poor. We not only have to care for the poor, but we have to do so in a way that's biblical.
Scott AllenAnd here's the deal: the biblical one actually cares for the poor. It actually leads to positive outcomes for the poor in a way that if you're not, if your principles aren't biblical, you're actually harming the poor. If principles aren't biblical, you're actually harming the poor.
Luke AllenLadies and gentlemen, welcome back to another episode of Ideas Have Consequences. This is the podcast of the Disciple Nations Alliance. Thank you guys all for joining us today. We really appreciate each one of you guys tuning in. Uh for each episode. It is always so fun to just uh hop on the podcast here and uh enjoy a discussion with my team and our guests. And I uh hope that you are just sensing how much we enjoy this. Uh we love it, and we uh appreciate that you guys uh listen in as well. Um if you're listening to this and you're a Christian, you most likely are, then you'll know that our mission as Christians is to spread the gospel around the world to all the nations.
Luke AllenHowever, our mission, the Great Co-Mission, also involves working to transform our cultures so that they increasingly reflect the truth, the goodness, and the beauty of God's kingdom. Tragically, the church has largely neglected this second part of her mission, and today most Christians are having little influence on their surrounding cultures. Join us on this podcast as we rediscover what it means for each of us to disciple the nations and to create Christ-honoring cultures that reflect the character of the living God. Hi guys, my name is Luke Allen. I am the producer and the co-host here on the show, and I'm joined today by our host and my dad, and kind of our our guest today, you could say.
Luke AllenDad, how are you doing today? Hey, great. I'm doing great, Luke. Thanks. And uh, Dad, as as you know, we have a big announcement that we need to share with everyone listening in today. Uh tomorrow is your birthday, so that's the big news today. Happy birthday. Yes, indeed. You're right. I um what's happening? Yeah, 32. That'd be weird if I'm almost 32. Uh this last year you had three grandkids. That was kind of the big the big thing that happened, right? Um you now have seven grandkids in ages of three and under.
Scott AllenSo but nobody's pregnant right now, so that's the big question mark next.
Luke AllenYeah. Not that you know of. Not that I know of either. What do you know of? I'm not saying anything, not that I know of either. But you never know when there's uh, you know, they just keep coming. It's kind of contagious. That's right. It's uh we celebrated your birthday early last weekend and it was just chaos. And we had four generations there in the living room and eating cinnamon rolls for breakfast, and uh it's just like baby mode right now. You know, it's so fun to see all the kiddos. I love it.
Scott AllenIt was very, very fun. Yeah.
Luke AllenKind of chaotic, but it's it's great. Um, for you guys uh listening, uh, like I mentioned at the end of or the beginning of last episode, uh, we are coming up on the end of this year, and as such, we're gonna be taking a break in the month of January of 2027, uh, just to kind of reset for the year, get our guests lined up and make a few uh changes to the podcast. If you guys have any uh comments, suggestions of ways that we can make this show better and just increasingly serve you guys. We love to hear those.
Luke AllenAll of your guys' suggestions are always super appreciated and helpful. Uh, if you want to reach out to us, you can reach us by email. Uh the best email for us is info at disciplenations.org. You can also find us on social media. We have the Disciple Nations Alliance on Facebook and Disciple Nations on Instagram. Feel free to uh DM us there if you have any questions about the podcast. For the next few months, uh we have some great guests coming up, excited to share some episodes with you. We're gonna be talking with uh Joe Rigney here in just over a week uh about the scary topic of Christian nationalism, so that should be interesting.
Luke AllenUh, we're also gonna be uh joined by Greg Kokel from Stand to Reason in November. So a couple awesome episodes coming up there as well as others, so make sure to stay tuned. Uh as for today's purposes, I probably should have opened up with this, but this is a part two in a in a in a series that we're doing right now on poverty, a biblical worldview of poverty. If you did not listen to the last episode, which was the episode that came out last week, part one, uh, I would highly recommend going back and listening to that. Uh, in fact, today's won't really make sense if you don't go back and start with that one.
Luke AllenSo we just would recommend to go back, find that last episode, listen to that one, and then hop into this one because this is we're gonna be be picking up right where we left off our last episode. And just as a little refresher for all of you guys who listened in last week, uh, last week's episode was all about a practical theology of compassionate ministry amongst those struggling with poverty. So basically, we just talked about a biblical worldview of poverty. We uh unpacked a couple passages in the New Testament uh where Paul is addressing those experiencing poverty, pulled some just super simple, practical, straightforward principles from those passages and applied those into this area.
Luke AllenIf you remember those ABCs we went through, A being affiliation, B being bonding, Categ categorization, D, discernment, E, employment, F freedom, and G being God. If that rings a bell, then you will be right on track with where we're starting today. Uh, because today's goal is to talk more about uh essentially we're trying to make an apologetic. Um, that the biblical worldview of any topic is always gonna be the worldview that works best or comports the best with reality, so it works the best in this world.
Luke AllenSo what the Bible says about poverty and how to help those experiencing poverty is going to be the best option. Uh so we're gonna line it up against some of the other approaches uh that our world has when confronting this topic. And we're just gonna point to the fact that uh God knows what he's talking about uh in this area as well as in every area. And then hopefully at the end, we're gonna get to some really practical action items that each one of us can take. But I will warn you that might be a part three in this series. Uh we haven't exactly figured that out yet. Depends on how long this episode goes, I guess, right, Dad?
Scott AllenThat's right.
Luke AllenYeah, so we'll see. Uh, how was that set up, Dad? Are we on the right track?
Scott AllenYeah, exactly, Luke. Yeah, today, I mean, the way I would say it, Luke, you you did a great job, but I would say we're gonna go back to those biblical principles of compassion, compassionate care for the poor. Um, and we're going to look at those in a kind of a compare and contrast way to um how they look when you hold them up side by side with some of the practices and underlying um principles and even paradigms that drive kind of the work that's being done uh to care for the poor in the United States today.
Scott AllenAnd we're gonna be looking specifically at the case of homelessness in, let's say, a hypothetical large West Coast city. You could think of Portland or Seattle or Los Angeles. What what what practices are in place today? What does it look like? What's going on behind that in terms of principles and paradigms? And how does that compare to the Bible? Well, we'll do that kind of by going through each of these biblical principal categories that come to us courtesy of Marvin Olaski, um, affiliation, bonding, etc.
Scott AllenSo and we'll review those a little bit as we go.
Luke AllenOkay. Yeah. Yeah, sounds good. Let's get into it.
Scott AllenWell, good. Yeah. So um, yeah, I I think it's great to lay out kind of a biblical theology for any subject. And here we're talking specifically about what does the Bible teach or what principles come out of the Bible when we're um dealing with this issue of poverty, poverty alleviation, compassionate care for the poor. Um, but you want to compare that with what's actually kind of the current practice in the place where you're living, you know, and then how are they different? Uh and then what are the fruits, right? What are the fruits of the biblical versus the cultural, the current, you know?
Scott AllenUm, and so that's what we're gonna do today. We're gonna do that kind of comparing and contrasting a little bit. Um, that's gonna lead naturally to the question, you know, so how do we change it, right? You know, how do we get back to the biblical? It's a huge question. Uh we'll probably talk a little bit about that today, but uh uh today's purpose uh won't be to prescribe solutions like that so much as it is just to do kind of a compare and contrast that you have to do in order to be able to move beyond that to get back to the truth, you know, the the truth of the Bible, the the true principles of the Bible that actually bear good fruit um in in terms of of helping people come out of poverty and uh begin to lead lives, uh flourishing lives, uh kind of you know, to to um you know, to walk in the fullness of what it means to be an image bearer of God, if you will.
Scott AllenSo with that, let's yeah, let's go back. I want to start with uh um we're gonna just talk through these one at a time. And I want to start with the broad biblical category. Uh these are these are categories of biblical principles. The first one is affiliation. And uh this basically says that when you're dealing with people struggling with poverty, um, the first thing that you should do is ask the question, who is responsible to help? And the Bible answers that question this way. It says, well, the first person responsible to help is the person themselves.
Scott AllenWhat you know, are they idle? You know, or are they working? Are they doing what they can do to um eliminate, you know, the the the uh the the poverty that they're experiencing so there's themselves. Then the next level, if they can't, if they're not able to for any reason, uh the responsibility then goes to the family. And the Bible um very clearly lays out marriage and family, right? In the first two chapters of Genesis is the most basic social institution. And amongst other things that the family is responsible for is the care of its family members.
Scott AllenUm and so the family needs to, yeah, the Bible says the family needs to care for one another. And you see that particularly in the passage we looked at in our previous podcast in 1 Timothy, uh, where Paul is talking about widows, and widows before they become the responsibility, the care for the widows, before that becomes a responsibility of the local church, Paul makes it very clear that the family has a responsibility. The family has to care for their own before they become the responsibility of a local church.
Scott AllenAnd the local church is the third, you know. So if for any reason the person can't help themselves, the family is not able to for whatever reason, there isn't a family, people are alone or isolated, um, then there is a role for the local church, especially towards its own members, to care for the needy and the poor. And I would say it goes beyond just its own members. There's a responsibility of the local church in the community. Um, but in the community, it needs to, it's going to need to come alongside and work collaboratively with other local churches to help meet the needs of people who are unable to work themselves for whatever reason and are separated from families.
Scott AllenSo the church. And then only later do you get to these other God-ordained kind of what we would call spheres of society, like civil society, government. There may be a role for state or um federal government here, but only after you know, all these previous um uh spheres are kind of exhausted, the individual, the family, the church. So that that's affiliation, basically. It's um it's a very rich biblical idea. It's based on the idea that God has created these different spheres of society.
Scott AllenThey each have a responsibility and a role to play, and those roles have to be understood and respected by the other spheres, right? So the government doesn't trample on the role of the family, or the church doesn't trample on the role of the family, or vice versa. So um so that's a those are rich biblical ideas, very powerful ideas. Um and then uh what I want to do now is just kind of say, well, what is it, what does that look like today? And again, I'm I'm looking primarily through the lens of um the issue of homelessness, which is just one form of of poverty.
Scott AllenAnd even homelessness, as we're gonna talk about later, is really uh it's a broad catch-all to all sorts of issues. But uh uh let's just call it for now homelessness in like a large West Coast city. We're from Oregon, so you could think of Portland where we have a huge problem uh with homelessness. And I want to look at current policies and practices you know that are being done towards the homeless. And before we get into that, I mean, again, I I I this is gonna be so hard to not over-generalize, but um, even here you've got to differentiate.
Scott AllenYou have um, let's just say, Christian nonprofits that are functioning, and many of them heroically and and and doing really great work. Um, I think a lot of the the Christian gospel missions, for example, um, in a lot of our cities are doing great work. You could even think of the work of the Salvation Army very often doing great work in our inner cities, and there's other organizations as well that are Christian-based, and that are applying, I would say, in really difficult circumstances, seeking to apply biblical principles in the way they're going about their work with the poor.
Scott AllenSo you have that in almost every city, including here in Benn, the city that we live in. But but what I want to say there is that that that's not the majority, let's say, or the dominant kind of way that the homeless are interacting with services. Uh right now, the dominant group is the government or government-funded nonprofits. And so they would take the lion's share in terms of engagement on this issue. So what what about you know, affiliation then, restoring uh people back into their God-given networks of uh care and support, family, church, uh local civic organizations, Christian-based organizations.
Scott AllenAnd what I would say about that, I think, is that um right now, if you especially in cities like Portland or you could say San Francisco, Seattle, uh, any city that's that's left-leaning, progressive, um, uh kind of pro-socialist, if you will, what you find there is you find that um there is kind of a um there their worldview doesn't support, let's just say, a strong kind of theology, if you will, or for family or even civic society.
Scott AllenUm what uh I think, for example, of when Black Lives Matter had their website up, um, you know, they had uh kind of one of their core beliefs was to tear down, I think that I'm not exactly sure the language they were using, but it was something like to tear down the Western prescribed nuclear family. So you see, you see in that, you know, and that there are in a city like Portland, that was a very widely supported movement, you know, and it was just indicative of kind of the dominant way of people thinking. And so yeah, we we you know, we we don't want to uh, you know, we we don't want to we we uh the the the way families are viewed often is in a very negative light.
Scott AllenThe it this would be the patriarchy, these are oppressive systems, uh they need to they they come out of Christianity, which is largely true. I mean, family is not by any means a strictly Christian uh institution, but boy, it sure does come straight out of the Bible, you know, at the very beginning of it. So uh yeah, it's it it's viewed very negatively, it's viewed as an oppressive structure. So the way that they want to work, they being um the the you know, the these cities that you know are doing the dominant kind of work towards the poor and the homeless, is they want to set up a kind of a direct response between, in this case, the state, meaning city government or state government, and in some cases federal, with the individual, without kind of working through a family, church, uh, civil society, civic society.
Scott AllenUm and that's very true. When you see socialism applied, like uh in a place like Russia, yeah, you you're going to see a breakdown of family and civic society, and everything is going to kind of devolve to the state. The state kind of becomes a god. So you see a lot of that same practice in a lot of our big cities, and so consequently, there's not an effort to affiliate because um if you know, we if anything, we don't want to push people back into these networks of care and support, but we want to undermine them.
Scott AllenSo uh so yeah, that's kind of the the way you would see it, I think, in a lot of these cities. It's just it's kind of a neglect um uh and uh antipathy um towards certainly church, family, and you know, even to a certain degree, church-based organizations. They they tend to run on separate tracks in a lot of these cities without a lot of connection to the dominant group that's involved, which is government and um government-funded nonprofits.
Scott AllenSo that's that's what I want to say on that, Luke. Maybe as I go through these, yeah, you could you could uh throw out your thoughts and comments and we'll go on to the next one. Yeah.
Luke AllenWell, I I I sometimes I'm just like, why would they want to tear down the family? Like almost everyone knows the family is a great institution. That's usually very helpful for people. And is it because like that there's like a built-in like a hegemony into the family? And that's you know, in a Marxist size, the worst thing that's a really good question.
Scott AllenI mean, I've thought a lot about this, Luke, and I think if you're if your inclination is you know towards progressivism, socialism, um what you want is you want an all-powerful state, right, that's able to kind of again own the means of production, redistribute um resources equitably, right, have this kind of equality of outcome. And um any of these other groups that stand between the individual and that all-powerful state become kind of you know, competition for power, if you will.
Luke AllenYeah, they get in the way.
Scott AllenAnd and so I think that's part of it, Luke. They we want to break down these kind of uh uh alternative sources of authority because we want to devolve all authority to the state. So the authority of the family, you know, i there's an authority structure in the family biblically, right? With the with the father, with parents, uh, you know, and that stands between the individual and the state. So if you want an all-powerful state, you know, well, we've got to break that down. Same with church, exactly. You know, or something.
Luke AllenSo if they come after the family, they usually say that the reason the family is bad, you know, is because there's a hierarchy there and there's oppressors and oppressed, you know, and they'll kind of like throw that structure on the family or the church. And yet that's exactly what they're trying to do with the state, is just take up that dominance position over everyone else. Right, right. Yeah. That's that's pretty that's a good idea.
Scott AllenSo if that but if that's your if that's your ideological framework, affiliation doesn't make sense. And so consequently, it's not practice. You don't have city governments, state governments working with the homeless by beginning to say, you know, who who are your family members? What are they doing to take care of you? Uh, how could we reaffiliate you with your family members? What relationships have broken down? That doesn't really factor in at all to the work that's being done. It's just offering aid and services directly to the individual, uh, really wholly apart from any kind of concern or connection to their family.
Scott AllenUm so I would say that's that's that's the way it looks currently. Um and let's go on to bonding because the affiliation and bonding go together. Bonding is is the principle that um when we're working with the poor, we are again, it would actually challenge that phrase, the poor. We're do we're dealing with individual people that have names and stories. Um and uh so we have to deal with them as individuals in a very personal way.
Scott AllenHelp occurs, uh, this is biblically I'm speaking here. Help occurs through sustained personal relationship. People need people, not programs. That's the idea of bonding. And and again, that ties into affiliation because where do you have that kind of bonding? You have it in your own family, right? And you have it in local churches and local communities. Where you don't have it is with kind of an uh amorphous, distant bureaucracy, right? It's there there you're dealing with programs, and and it has to, by its very nature, be impersonal.
Scott AllenAnd again, that's what we're seeing. Uh so because affiliation isn't a value, neither is bonding. You have professional case management and programs that you necessarily have to handle huge caseloads. And because of that, the assistance becomes uh very impersonal, uh, very programmatic, bureaucratic, transactional. Um it you it just has to by its very nature. You you can't have this kind of bonding, this person-to-person connection if you break down the the the institutions and organizations where that naturally happens, family, church, um, civic s civic society, and things like that.
Scott AllenSo um so yeah, we don't see a lot of that. We don't see we see both of these principles being violated in a lot of the practice that's being done. Towards the homeless, let's say, in a lot of our cities. Luke, any thoughts on that?
Luke AllenYeah, I mean, I just totally agree. It's uh 1984. If you've ever read that book, this makes a lot of sense. Right. It's Big Brother just taking care of all the cogs in the machine. And um, I mean, this is a big reason that I have an issue with the public school system, is it it was founded by socialists and the modern public school system, and it views students kind of as just students, one big, you know, mushpot, and you just treat them all the same instead of seeing them as individual image bearers of God.
Scott AllenYeah, I mean, Luke, maybe you could even talk about that. I think that you you have a real personal experience with that um in the area of education because we homeschooled um, you know, one of the things that is a benefit of homeschooling is that you, you know, your your parents are schooling the the children, and so they know them intimately. There's a clear bonding there, and they know their strengths and uh areas of challenge and things like that in a way that you can't when you're dealing with a much larger, more bureaucratic type of system like a very large public school or something like that.
Scott AllenYeah.
Luke AllenYeah. And I mean, any student knows this. There's different forms of learning, there's different ways people absorb knowledge. In the US right now, out of the five major learning categories, the we only use one, which is the read-write learning category. Read a book, process what it means, you know, spit it out. And that's how people learn. There's there's not much kinesthetic learning, there's not much oral learning, there's not much, you know, um, visual learning, a little bit more these days, but it's it's just kind of you're thrown in that box and good luck. Off you go, student. And that does not work well for students.
Luke AllenEveryone learns individually in different ways. Some people learn experientially, some people learn intellectually. It's uh, you know, we're just unique individuals. So if you can have a tutor, which you know most people that struggle with education end up getting, is the tutor, the purpose of the tutor is to recognize your individuality and then teach you from that space uh how to learn. Absolutely, you know. Absolutely. Obviously, it just works a lot better.
Scott AllenThis goes back to the beginnings of the welfare state. Again, Marvin Olaski's book, The Tragedy of American Compassion. He's in that really, again, I just want to underscore how important that book is if you care about this subject of compassionate ministry to the poor from a biblical perspective. Because he goes back and he looks at the United States during the colonial era where the the the worldview that was shaping a lot of the policies, principles, actions was biblical, much more biblical than it is today. And so consequently, the way that they uh worked with the poor was very different.
Scott AllenAnd then he he looks at how the emergence of the welfare state um as a result of kind of the secularization of the society and the emergence of ideologies like Marxism, progressivism. Uh you, you know, along with that you have this welfare state that kind of comes into being really at the turn of the century, the, you know, early 1900s, and then giving kind of full flower during the Johnson administration's war on poverty. But but there you saw um, for the first time, you saw aid, you know, welfare aid and programs given directly to uh individuals.
Scott AllenAnd so, for example, women could get aid directly um uh as opposed to uh well, and the effect of that was to break down marriage. Uh, you know, it I I don't think that was necessarily maybe a stated goal, but it was certainly a byproduct, is when you deal with in a kind of an amorphous bureaucratic way and you're giving aid directly to individuals, then all of a sudden where they would, you know, if they were if they before, you know, they needed to kind of bond with each other and be in a family to provide for that kind of care that they needed, uh that just got that just undermined that.
Scott AllenAnd uh and and you still see that today. Uh so a lot of this uh kind of centralized, bureaucratic approach has the effect of of itself undermining these very institutions that are needed to help, uh, that can personalize the care, if you will. So that that's bonding. Um let's go on to categorization. That's the next one. That different problems require different responses. Biblically, again, we looked at the first Timothy passage where Paul talks about widows who um are impoverished because of idleness versus widows who are truly, you know, they're virtuous and hardworking, but they're truly alone.
Scott AllenSo he's Paul is going to kind of create different categories and he's gonna discern, uh, make some that's the next one we're gonna talk about, discern what what kind of help needs to be done based on these, you know, these different categories. So when we talked about this in the last podcast, we talked about categorization in terms of context. Is the context a context of an emergency relief situation, or is it uh an ongoing long-term development context? And we also talked about um categorizing based on root cause.
Scott AllenWhat's the root cause of the brokenness? Are we talking about drug addiction? Are we talking about mental health? What's really going on down here? Are we, you know, uh or is it even a deeper worldview, you know, kind of uh level issue that needs to be addressed with biblical truth. So uh what what what's what's the cause? We it basically the idea is we can't treat everything the same. We have to kind of separate and categorize because different problems require different solutions. It's really that simple.
Luke AllenYeah. Let's compare and contrast. Yeah, go ahead, Luke, on that. Yeah. Well, I that just reminds me of kind of the worldview tree, right? Or um uh the way ideas flow through culture is a lot of people when they see an issue in the world, they'll go after the fruit, the consequences. You know, people are homeless, put them in houses. Right. But you have to go deeper than that. Behind the consequences, what's causing it?
Scott AllenWhat's the deeper levels exactly?
Luke AllenThe values, the beliefs, and behind the behaviors is values, and behind the values is a cult, a religion, a belief system, a worldview. And that's gonna look unique person by person, even though the consequences at the fruit level will look the same. So you can't just look at the fruit and then think diagnosing that is just picking the fruit or something like that. That's way too surface level.
Scott AllenYeah. Yeah. And actually, Luke, I think in some ways, Darrow, uh, our mentor, you know, and co-worker, he often talks about, you know, how we tend to focus on the outcomes, the fruit, if you will, that fruit level. And we don't go deeper into the worldview level, the roots. Um, and so at the fruit level, if the fruit is bad, you know, uh, then we just replace the fruit, right? Let's but uh Darrow, you know, he kind of humorously says it doesn't do a whole lot of good if you want an orange and you've got an apple tree just to take the apples off that tree and uh tape up a bunch of oranges, right?
Scott AllenIt's just not really going to work. Next season you're gonna get a bunch of apples again, because at the root of that is an apple tree, right? Not not an orange tree. So if you want to change the tree, you've got to change the root, is Darrow's point on that. And I think there's a great application to homelessness right now on this. The homelessness itself is kind of the symptom, the, the, the, the, the, the, the surface symptom, if you will. Um, so it just putting people in housing isn't going to really work. It's kind of the equivalent of taping, you know, the uh oranges on the apple tree, right?
Scott AllenYou can put people in a house, but unless you get to the root causes uh that are driving them to be homeless, just putting them in a house isn't gonna help, right? Um so but that that's what that's actually what we see. So we don't see a lot of categorization. In fact, the the reason that people struggle with homelessness as a category is that it masks a lot of other things that need to be held up and you know categorized, if you will, things like drug addiction and mental health and even broken down families and lies at a level of worldview that need to be addressed.
Scott AllenIf you just kind of lump all those together and then tape over that the label homelessness, then you're not going to uh, well, first of all, it's gonna create problems. You're gonna treat everything as a homelessness problem by putting people into housing. And again, don't get me wrong, I mean, people need shelter. But if you take somebody who's drug addicted and has serious mental health issues and you put them in a house, uh they're still gonna have a drug addiction problem. You're not really going to help them as much as you, you know, the the shelter may provide some incremental help.
Scott AllenUm does that make sense? But that's what we see. You know, so much of what we see. It's called housing first. You know, housing first is the policy of uh at the federal level, the of HUD, housing and urban development, has as its official policy, housing first. Um but the problem I have with housing first is again, it's it's it's failing this categorization principle from the Bible. It's it's lumping everything together as a housing problem when it's not. And what you got to do is say what's really going on here, if it's drug addiction, let's treat it as drug addiction and not housing.
Scott AllenUm if if it's broken down families, let's deal with that uh and not a housing issue.
Luke AllenUh so thoughts on that, Luke. Oh no, I just I agree. And I think making it breaking it down in that, you know, the worldview tree really helps there. Is is just again, you can't just pick the apples and replace them with oranges. You can't just chop off the branches and think it's not going to grow back as an apple tree. You can't even just chop it down and think it's not gonna grow back because those roots are still there. Anyone that's picked weeds knows that you gotta go for the roots, you know, if you want to actually see change. I I just don't see many people doing that. It's so easy to go after the consequences after the fruit.
Luke AllenYou know, there's actually a meme about this. It's like a British girl, and she's like, if you're homeless, just buy a house. Right? It's funny, but it's there's millions of dollars being spent in the US on building like you know, apartment complexes and all these things, like they're picking people into houses. And it's like putting a band-aid on a bullet wound.
Scott AllenWhen what affordable housing, yeah, exactly. It's interesting too because uh your brother Isaac, you know, I I I guess I can mention him by name here on the podcast, but uh shout out, you know. Uh yeah. So him and his wife, you know, when they first got their job out of college, they were uh they qualified here in Oregon for affordable housing, this kind of subsidized housing. Um and again, the uh in Oregon, a state like Oregon, and this would be true in Washington, California, many other states, um there is these big programs to subsidize housing to get people into to low-cost housing.
Scott AllenUh because again, the the policy is housing first. But we had a chance to hang out with Isaac, you know, the in when he was living there with his wife, and and uh what I noticed was, yeah, there's a lot of dysfunction, right? There's a lot of uh drug addiction, you know, there's just a lot of brokenness, but um, but it's not treated because the goal wasn't to treat that, the goal was housing, you know, and so I guess in some ways they would say success. We got them into housing. But are these people then really, you know, are the problems that they have that that are really keeping them from being all that God wants them to be being addressed?
Scott AllenNo, they're not. Um, so yeah, that was I I think that personal experience with that was interesting to me to see that, actually to see that and be there. Um so let's go on then. Yeah, discernment uh is the next category that we looked at. Um, and again, that goes with categorization and discern discernment is that is the help that's being offered, will that help actually restore people to all that it means to bear God's image into the flourishing kind of life that God intends for his people?
Scott AllenOr will it reinforce destructive behavior? Um again, I think what we're seeing today with so much of our homeless policy in our in our hypothetical big West Coast cities is is that um no, there isn't really a focus on um kind of eliminating destructive behavior. Here in Oregon, I mean that you saw this in spades where um you had uh at the level of policy, there was a state referendum that legalized uh uh all forms of uh drugs.
Scott AllenUm and it was so destructive, it just caused so many people to to become addicted, or those that were addicted to become even worse, and many, many died. And of course, people from other states came into Oregon because it was um legal to do your meth or your heroin or whatever you wanted to do. Um so uh again, the the the basic idea behind that was um, you know, we want to provide kind of low barrier access and harm reduction reduction approaches, um, separate from any kind of uh question about changing behavior, you know, if the behavior is drug addiction, we're you know, we're actually going to reinforce that, not seek to change that.
Scott AllenUh so we'll help you as a drug addict. Um, you know, we'll give you clean needles or whatever it is. So, boy, it's just so broken in this area of discernment. You know, we're we're we're not helping people that are stuck in these um, you know, these really destructive behaviors. So uh I I I always think of Marvin Olasky's, you know, book because uh he gave an example that really stuck in my mind. He talked about help that was being offered in the in the colonial era.
Scott AllenAnd um a lot of but there was a huge problem with alcoholism in the colonies, you know, just like we had today, and you've always had there were problems of alcoholism. And uh you had churches uh that were seeking to help the poor, but um they would be kind of quick to discern whether the person was an alcoholic and whether they really intended to get off, you know, off booze or not. And the way that they uh offered their help wasn't in an indiscerning kind of a way, hey, we'll give you help regardless of uh or not uh of whether you you seek to give up the bottle.
Scott AllenBut, you know, they said they had huge wood piles out in the back of the church, right? You know, because they heated with wood. And uh basically their qualification to get any kind of help or assistance from the church was to split wood, you know, and you had to be there at a certain time of the day. And uh, you know, if so that was just their way of practicing kind of discernment, you know, we'll help you if you want to get off of alcohol, but you have to, you know, we we have to discern whether you want to or not. And if you're not, we're not gonna reinforce that really, you know, destructive behavior, you know.
Scott AllenSo it was so we do so little of that today. Yeah.
Luke AllenYeah, yeah. That's good.
Scott AllenAnd then, you know, next is employment and freedom. Um, and this is the principle that the Bible we we spent quite a bit of time on this just because work, there the Bible lays out such a huge and strong kind of theology for work, for creativity. God's a working God. He created us in his image to work. Uh, work is a part of what it means to be an image-bearer. It's part of our dignity. You know, through our work, we're able to make meaningful contributions to serve our neighbors, and it goes on and on.
Scott AllenAnd there's even the biblical word avodah, which um work when done with excellence and offered to God is actually a form of worship. Um, the Hebrew word work and worship, avoda, is very similar, uh, which is really powerful. So the Bible places a huge emphasis on work, and you see it in the New Testament where Paul, you know, is very quick to say, follow my example. When I was when I was with you, you being the church, the local church that he was serving, um, you know, I worked hard as a tent maker so that I wouldn't be a burden on you.
Scott AllenAnd um, and he goes on and states explicitly principles like if a person is unwilling to work, then they shouldn't eat, that everyone has a personal responsibility to work and to provide for their own needs and the needs of their families. So those are all these biblical ideas. And freedom goes along with that because when you work, um you are free, you're providing for yourself, so you're free of dependency on others. And uh, yeah, the the Bible doesn't want us to be in a situation where we're dependent in a long-term way.
Scott AllenObviously, when you're children, you're dependent on your parents. But as adults, uh to set up adults, able-bodied adults in a condition of dependency is dehumanizing. It's treating human beings like animals, right? That are uh animals have to be dependent, you know, like livestock have to be dependent on others to care for their needs, but uh not human beings. That's not the biblical vision for human beings. So then we look at the situation today in a lot of our cities on this issue of employment and freedom.
Scott AllenAnd what you see there is employment services may be offered, but they're certainly not prioritized. They tend to be offered as kind of one service amongst many. And I think the reason that you you see kind of a just like you see a downplaying of family, you see a downplaying of work, and not even that downplaying, I go to say active, uh and actively trying to create or foster uh conditions of dependency. And let me just give you an example of that. Like so um if if you're below a certain line, a poverty line, in a state like Oregon, you qualify for all sorts of benefits, um affordable housing, food, you know, government welfare in all sorts of different ways.
Scott AllenIt's significant. And the the um condition for those benefits is being below that line of income, such that if you went out and found a job and let's say didn't pay that much, um you would be disincentivized from taking that job because you're gonna, uh even though you're earning money, you're gonna get a whole lot less in terms of benefits than you would if you didn't work. So you see that over and over in our cities where work is is, I would say, actively disincentivized.
Scott AllenYou know, because again, you you lose, there's this cliff, this big drop-off of benefits. Um so that's the situation. Why is that the case? I mean, why is work disincentivized? I think part of the reason is again this progressive socialist framework. It if you go back to Karl Marx, let's say, you know, he saw workers, workers of the world unite because workers were being oppressed by um greedy capitalists. Um there's this negative view towards free market, towards you know uh industry, work.
Scott AllenUh you know, it it workers are seen as victims, right? You know, there's the the victimizers and uh and the victims. Um, you know, to to work is to put yourself under the thumb of some greedy company corporation that's going to just exploit you, right? Is kind of the idea. I think there's just this kind of natural antipathy towards those things in the same way there is that we talked about earlier with churches and civil institutions, uh or civic society institutions.
Scott AllenSo employment, it's just not prioritized. It's not really um a uh a kind of a clear goal. Let's get people uh off of aid and support and back kind of in a situation where they're working. Um so you you don't see that again actively kind of uh uh promoted.
Luke AllenLuke, anything on that? Uh yeah, I think that's a that's a great point. I mean, both of these biblical words um that we're talking about here, at least in the biblical definitions, employment and freedom mean very different things than what the world defines them as today. For example, employment is seen as a good thing in the Bible, it's a pre-fall concept, it's it's a blessing. Uh the world doesn't really like employment, though. They think work is toil and is something you want to avoid, you know. And then freedom also is heavily misdefined, um, which we could go on and on about that.
Luke AllenUh but just what is freedom and the idea that your work brings you freedom. I don't think people would usually say that. They would say, no, not working is freedom.
Scott AllenSpecifically, your freedom from dependency on others or the state, I think is really what we're talking about. Yeah.
Luke AllenIt is, yeah. But a lot of people would say, but if you really want to be free, you should not work at all, and you should just go travel the country and roam like a vagabond, you know. That's freedom. You which obviously would lead to dependency because you would have nothing eventually. Uh what was the other thing I was gonna say? Uh that idea of like employment, yeah, leading to freedom, though, is not incentivized right now. Uh and it doesn't make sense to me. If you want an economy that's flourishing, you want as many free people working, being creative, creating more and more resources, more assets, building the economy, adding more to the economy.
Luke AllenThat just that makes so much sense to me, you know, instead of making as many people dependent as possible and then taxing the rich. You can only do that for so long until the rich have nothing left, you know. So I'm like, where's the long-term scheme here? What happens when the rich have nothing left? You know, they're not really building anything new. There's not more wealth creation happening.
Scott AllenYeah, there's a you're you're putting your finger on the active kind of disincentivizing of this that happens in so many of our cities that because you have uh the poor, the homeless, etc., um, you can make an appeal for the the state, the state specifically can make an appeal that uh we need to raise your taxes in order. to care for these people. And so there's so much money that comes into these programs that what that does is it creates again this perverse incentive to keep people dependent.
Scott AllenYou know, because the the dependency is tied to the money, you know, the the tax money that comes in. So it's it's very perverse but it's a fact. I mean there's there's there's an act of incentivizing to keep people homeless and dependent or impoverished and dependent on a state. So yeah I think that's part of it.
Luke AllenAnd then the other part is they I would say this worldview we're talking about has a scarcity mindset. So they don't actually think you can keep creating new wealth. They think there's limited resources out there and we're slowly sucking them up. So how can we slow down that process of sucking them up? Whereas we as Christians have an abundance mindset, be fruitful and multiply. And there is endless resources out there that we can continue to create, find, uh use and move forward and create create new things.
Scott AllenSo it's that that really changes things from the get-go, your finger on just yeah no it's such a it's such a huge worldview difference between a biblical worldview and a secular progressive or socialistic worldview. You just put your finger on it really well, Luke. I mean a biblical worldview um you know sees a kind of an expanding pie, right? You mentioned be fruitful and multiply but um you know we see a world of expanding resources. Why? Because human beings are creative. We're made in the image of creative God so we create new things.
Scott AllenAnd that new those new things computers or whatever they happen to be you know that creates new industries that creates new wealth. If you come from the other side this kind of socialist side you'd I think it's rooted in the fact that you see human beings not as image bearers of God and kind of creative generators of wealth and new resources but you see them as animals. Again it's that Darwinian paradigm right um kind of the survival of the fittest. All that to say when you look at the world you see you see a world of scarcity of limited resources um and uh and so consequently everything's focused on how to get a hold grab hold of those limited resources and reallocate them equitably uh so to speak exactly that's a really important worldview difference here so yeah I mean that's that's there's a lot there but we should we should keep going.
Scott AllenYeah no exactly so employment and freedom from dependency uh again not not valued you know in so many of the systems that are functioning today. And then the last one is uh you know as I said earlier it's last it's not least it's actually the most important one uh A, B, C, D, E, F, G, G is God. Um, and the principle is that spiritual restoration is foundational to whole person restoration. We talked about uh a biblical view of poverty when we when we're working in this area of biblical compassion and poverty fighting, you have to define poverty biblically and we talked about how ultimately it's rooted in relationships.
Scott AllenAnd the most important relationship is our relationship to God. So to really become all that God intends us to be as human beings, to flourish and thrive, you've got to have that most basic relationship restored. You have to know who God is, be in right relationship to God, be filled with his Holy Spirit, empowered to do what's right. So any kind of work amongst the poor has to prioritize that. It has to prioritize gospel proclamation, evangelism, discipleship, these have to be really central because that again that the of the priority that first and most basic relationship.
Scott AllenAnd you know the practically when a person is drug addicted, let's say, people that know the Lord and are filled with the Spirit, they have so many more resources, God given resources, to overcome an addiction than a person who doesn't know the Lord. And that's just I think proven uh in the real world. So God Yeah isn't that um in the AA what what is it um alcohol isn't that the first step in this it is yeah yeah find a higher power yeah it it's that I I in my own power the basic idea is in my own power and strength this is this is too much for me this is too great for me and it's true that if if you've ever been deeply addicted to something you recognize the power that it has over you which ties back to freedom Luke we talked about freedom so addiction is kind of the ultimate bondage it's not the ultimate bondage but it's a severe bondage um and the biblical you know the biblical principle the biblical vision is freedom freedom from those kind of powerful bondages of addiction uh and and to get out of that that hole that pit um you need help you need help of community and you need help of God and even Alcoholics Anonymous AA starts with that we need a you know they they've kind of secularized it a little bit higher power or whatever but but they've got the right idea you need help uh you need help beyond yourself uh you need help from God and that's exactly right and so any Christian approach is going to recognize that uh and affirm that and work towards that that's going to be a central part of what they do so again looking at uh the way that it's that we have what how is it practiced today?
Scott AllenWell our public agencies that are primarily responsible for doing work with the poor state agencies you know are by their very nature you know secular they operate in a secular framework and so what does that mean? That means this is completely absent that there's none of this that happens. Now the the way that it would happen in a city like Portland or Bend is you would have Christian nonprofits working side by side with the government that can bring this in Salvation Army, uh the gospel missions, etc. They can bring this element in and they do.
Scott AllenBut again they're not the primary or dominant players out there right now. They kind of are operating in a parallel universe if you will so I I I again speak very highly of a lot of these ministries um but but the the main ones that are doing the work right now these big well-funded state welfare agencies and bureaucracy and the nonprofits that are working with them yeah they they are operating in a completely secular framework um so God doesn't factor into that at all so um I I just I hope that this has been kind of helpful to do a little comparing and contrasting I think one of the reasons that you have bad fruit let's say you know in a city like Portland homelessness continues to grow um even though you know lots and lots of money have been thrown at that problem you know it continues to grow.
Scott AllenAnd I think the reason that you're seeing that kind of result is because as a state, as a people we've drifted away right from these clear biblical principles in almost every one of these areas as we've seen they're being violated, they're not being followed, there's different beliefs, values, practices, and they're not working, right? If anything they're they're leading to worse outcomes. So I think you know Luke as we wrap this podcast, you know, the the natural question people are going to be asking is okay so what do we do?
Scott AllenRight? How do we you know how do we how do we fix that problem, right? And I think that's that's absolutely the right question to ask. I think again before you do it though you have to do just what we've done which is if if you were functioning completely let's say or more or less from kind of a a the a the framework of biblical principles what would that look like then compare and contrast that to what it looks like right now in terms of the dominant practice that's out there. Yet you just have to kind of hold those two up side by side because that that has to come first and then you can begin to say okay now what do we do?
Scott AllenBut we do have to we do have to do something we have to move beyond and I I guess I would just I would simply close with a couple of simple thoughts on that. First of all we as individuals or even as local churches we can't change these big state and national policies on our own for sure we that but that doesn't mean that we're powerless to do anything about it. And I think we we we we can apply these principles ourselves we can say you know in terms of the work that I can do with the people in my life that are struggling with poverty maybe they're in my own family and I'm going to apply that principle of affiliation and bonding.
Scott AllenI'm going to be careful that before you know they go off and get a lot of help from state and federal I'm going to come alongside make sure I come alongside and do my take my responsibility to care for them. So we we ourselves can apply these principles and even beyond ourselves I think our churches can do that. Our churches can apply these principles certainly for the people in the church right the the members of the congregation but even beyond that we can we can come alongside other churches in a community and we can say we're going to work together to apply these biblical principles of compassion together in a way that makes a real difference with the poor in our community.
Scott AllenNow the challenge is you're going to be kind of running up against this larger apparatus that's there operating through the state that is operating from different different principles and it's going to be a whole lot easier just to get all this help, right? And so people will gravitate towards whatever is easiest. Where can I get the most help uh in the easiest way um so you you do have to deal with these this this um larger system this systemic problem if you will um how do you do that uh that's a longer term problem but this is where um Christians have to work together and mobilize together and say uh some of these policies that the state is operating from in this area of welfare and care for the poor are dehumanizing, are destructive they're leading to um uh they're leading to worse outcomes for people and for the problem as a whole and we can't just be passive about that and say oh well you know so be it there's nothing we can do or it's not our job or we don't get involved in politics or whatever whatever the cop-out might be we have to say no we're going to uh we're gonna work to change that at a policy level you know and maybe it's a good time to say that we're heading into an election uh the most basic way you change things at a policy level is you vote and again I'm I'm I'm just reminded that half of Christians on any given election don't vote.
Scott AllenSo when you don't vote, when you don't care enough at least to do that most basic thing at a at a policy level um then yeah you're just basically saying I don't care about these destructive policies that are in place. And so I I don't think that uh that is faithfulness the Christian faithfulness and uh bothers me Luke so any thoughts for you on on some of those kind of quick responses anyways?
Luke AllenYeah I mean I think of with quick responses sometimes uh Christians especially young Christians they see an issue and they say oh God's burdened me with this issue which he probably has and then they'll just go and do whatever the world does to solve that issue. You know you'll if there's a homeless program in your community you'll just join right in and um or if uh you know there's like a justice issue you're just gonna join the fight and become a justice social justice warrior whatever it is uh and this is where taking every thought captive is very practical where biblical worldview is practical you you can join you can help and see if if there's ways to help but you do need to ask big questions too what is this organization I'm joining uh how does it define a human?
Luke AllenWhat does it mean when it says humans? How does it define poverty? How is it defining employment? Is employment something that's a good a blessing something we should be pushing people towards or something that we think is bad for people you know what is justice? You know what is what is equality in the Bible what does that mean? Asking those simple questions is going to help a lot and uh for a lot of us you know it's you you want to go and just join right away something it's we need to practice discernment too you know taking everything absolutely making it obedient to Christ there's so much yeah because I think Christians say yes we have to care for the poor and it never gets beyond that.
Scott AllenWell that's true. That's true. We have an obligation to care for the poor that's biblical. But we also have an obligation to care for the poor in a way that's biblical. Okay there how we do that that you know there there's there's how there's a how to that as well that needs to align with the truth of the Bible and biblical principles and what it means to be a human being. And that I think gets almost no attention. That's what I'm hearing you say, Luke and I completely agree with that. Yeah so because it doesn't get attention we just kind of go along with whatever the prevailing practices are out there under the rubric or the banner of caring for the poor.
Scott AllenAnd that's exactly right we we not only have to care for the poor, but we have to do so in a way that's biblical and that actually and here's the deal the biblical one actually cares for the poor it actually it leads to positive outcomes for the poor in a way that if you're not, if your principles aren't biblical, you're actually harming you're very
Luke AllenSomeone or some set of ideas is always
Scott Allenactively influencing culture.
Luke AllenIf it's not Christians with the biblical principles then it's going to be someone else with worldly destructive principles. And that's it's really that simple. It's either God's way which is the way that works or it's the world's way a way that is going to ultimately lead to harm and destruction. And those are your options. In closing I I just wanted to point to a couple of Proverbs that I read yesterday and I found very convict and uh might be a good place to wrap up. These are both in Proverbs 14 first one's Proverbs 1421 it says he who despises his neighbor sins but blessed is he who is kind to the needy and then down in verse 31 he who oppresses the poor shows contempt for his maker but whoever is kind to the needy honors God.
Luke AllenSo with that uh thank you everyone for listening today and I hope that you are guys are able to join us next week here on Ideas have consequences this is a discussion about uh helping people who are experiencing poverty that we will continue uh definitely here on the on the show so I hope you guys are able to tune in to us next week here on the podcast Ed thanks for your time today great to be with you Luke
Should America be a Christian nation? Should our laws reflect biblical principles? And what does it actually mean to say that Jesus Christ is Lord over all, including government? Few topics have sparked more controversy...
Our modern approach to fighting poverty is fundamentally flawed. We've spent trillions fighting poverty. So why does it persist? Have Christians adopted the world's faulty definition of poverty? And in doing so, have we...
What if one of the greatest things missing from modern Christianity isn't truth, but beauty? Dostoevsky famously wrote, “Beauty will save the world.” But what did he mean, and why does beauty matter so much to the...
Why is socialism making a comeback in America? In this episode, Kevin Briggins from the Center for Biblical Unity and co-host of the Off Code Podcast joins us to unpack the growing influence of democratic socialism and...
Is the Kingdom of God something we’re still waiting for, or is Jesus actually reigning as King right now? Not as the consummated King, before whom every knee will bow, but as the King who has authority over this world....