Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ideas Have Consequences

Ideas Have Consequences artwork

Christian Nationalism: What Does the Bible Actually Say? | Joe Rigney

Nov 18, 20261 hr 4 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Should America be a Christian nation? Should our laws reflect biblical principles? And what does it actually mean to say that Jesus Christ is Lord over all, including government? Few topics have sparked more controversy in the US in recent years than Christian nationalism. But beneath the heated debates and political labels lie some critically important questions: What does the Bible actually teach about government? What does Scripture tell us about nations? And how do we balance religious liberty with biblical law? In this episode, we welcome back pastor, author, and theologian Dr. Joe Rigney to discuss his new book, Five Views on Christian Nationalism. Bringing together five prominent Christian thinkers - Joe Rigney, Albert Mohler, Doug Wilson, Paul D. Miller, and R. R. Reno - the book explores competing perspectives on Christianity, nationalism, and civil government. In our discussion with Joe, we explore the biblical foundations of government, the separation of church and state, religious freedom, natural law, theonomy, and whether Christians should seek to build explicitly Christian nations. If Jesus is Lord of all, what does that mean for politics, government, and the future of our nation? Join us as we move beyond political rhetoric to examine the biblical ideas shaping one of Christianity's most controversial debates. Who is the Disciple Nations Alliance (DNA)? Since 1997, DNA’s mission has been to equip followers of Jesus around the globe with a biblical worldview, empowering them to build flourishing families, communities, and nations. 👉 https://disciplenations.org/ 🎙️Featured Guest: Dr. Rigney serves as a Fellow in Theology at New Saint Andrews College. He is the author of seven books: Live Like a Narnian: Christian Discipleship in Lewis’s Chronicles (Eyes & Pen, 2013); The Things of Earth: Treasuring God by Enjoying His Gifts (Crossway, 2015); Lewis on the Christian Life: Becoming Truly Human in the Presence of God (Crossway, 2018); Strangely Bright: Can You Love God and Enjoy This World? (Crossway, 2020); More Than a Battle: Experiencing Victory, Freedom, and Healing from Lust (B\&H, 2021), Courage: How the Gospel Creates Christian Fortitude (Crossway, 2023), and Leadership and Emotional Sabotage (Canon Press, 2024). Previously, Dr. Rigney served as a professor and president of Bethlehem College & Seminary in Minneapolis, a pastor at Cities Church in St. Paul, and a teacher at Desiring God. Joe is a teacher who can’t help but tell others about the things that fascinate him, and he is a generalist who is fascinated by a great many things. He loves to teach classes on biblical theology, C.S. Lewis, Shakespeare, English literature, and political philosophy. Beyond teaching, writing, and preaching, Joe loves to coach high school football, play baseball with his three sons, and spend time with his lovely wife Jenny. 📌 Recommended Resources: 👉 Book: 5 Views on Christian Nationalism - Canon Press 👉 Previous Episode with Dr. Rigney: The Sin of Empathy: Compassion and Its Counterfeits | Dr. Joe Rigney 💻 Follow Us: 📸Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/disciplenations 📽️YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/c/DiscipleNationsAlliance/ 📲Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/disciplenations 📩 Ask us anything: info@disciplenations.org Episode Webpage

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Joe RigneyWell, what has God's image on it? And it's like human beings do. And so human beings can't render to Caesar that which belongs to God, meaning they can't render their souls or their or their selves, their total selves, uh, to any human authority, uh, because God alone is Lord, and He's and He's the Lord over all the other Lords. So all ultimate allegiance must go to Him.

Scott AllenThe concept of nations is a deeply biblical theme, actually. It runs right through the scriptures from Genesis to Revelation.

Joe RigneyAbsolutely.

Scott AllenSo it has to be understood. And

Joe RigneyKeller was a good example of a true blue Kyper. Like he really did bring the Kyperian mindset and therefore I think accommodated in many ways on the secularism, progressivism of New York City, because it's it's principled pluralism. That's another kind of Kyperian ideal where we don't try to have a Christian public square, a Christian state, a Christian nation in those ways, because uh we we're gonna be principled pluralists, we're gonna maintain pluralism in the public square.

Luke AllenLadies and gentlemen, welcome back to another episode of Ideas Have Consequences. This is the podcast of the Disciple Nations Alliance. As Christians, we all know that our mission is to spread the gospel around the world to all the nations. However, our mission, the Great Commission, also involves working to transform our cultures so that they increasingly reflect the truth, goodness, and the beauty of God's kingdom. Tragically, the church has largely neglected this second part of her mission, and today most Christians are having little influence on their surrounding cultures. Join us on this podcast as we rediscover what it means for each of us to disciple the nations and to create Christ-honoring cultures that reflect the character of the living God.

Luke AllenHi guys, my name is Luke Allen. I'm the producer and co-host here on the show today. Uh, at least for today's purposes, the backseat driver, uh, let Dad run the interview today, which was fun. It was a fast-paced.

Scott AllenApologize, Luke. I uh yeah.

Luke AllenIt's all good. We didn't have too much time with today's guest, so I let you take it away. And you actually read the whole book that we were interviewing our guest on today. I didn't, so it was more fitting for you to run the interview. Dad, um, would you mind just introducing today's guest, the book we talked about, and then also the book was built up, it's a unique book in its layout. Would you mind explaining that as well?

Scott AllenAbsolutely. Well, let me start with uh our guest, Joe Rigney, um, is back on the podcast from Moscow, Idaho. Joe is a theologian, pastor, author, and a fellow of theology at New St. Andrews College in Moscow, Idaho, uh, where he also serves as an associate pastor at Christ Church, Moscow, Idaho. Uh Joe previously served as president and professor at Bethlehem College and Seminary in Minneapolis, working together with John Piper and his ministry. Uh, he's the author of many books, great books, um, including leadership and emotional sabotage.

Scott AllenAnd then the book that we're going to talk about today is a book that he conceived of, the concept of it. It was a really creative concept. Uh, the title of the book is Five Views on Christian Nationalism. Uh, that's a book that came out here just a couple of months ago, and I had a chance to read it in its entirety on the flight down to Brazil. Luke and I, Luke, that you and I were uh that trip we took earlier in September. It's such a great book. Um basically what um Joe and his team did is that um they they they kind of collected contributors, in this case, um there's five in total, including Joe himself uh and Douglas Wilson.

Scott AllenUm and then the other three contributors are uh Rusty R R or Rusty Reno, um who's uh a Roman Catholic and uh is the editor of First Things magazine, so really prominent in um Catholic circles. Uh Albert Moeller, the great Albert Moeller, uh who is one of the most uh respected um and principled leaders in the Baptist world, and then Paul Miller as well. Paul was one that I was uh least familiar with, but he had uh really interesting positions uh uh right in the cabinet, I believe, in the Bush administration.

Scott AllenHe's also a Baptist. Um so he's the one that kind of came into this discussion with a lot of experience in government. Uh so it's really fascinating. Um and the basically the way they said Joe set up this book is that he um he wanted to set it up around a hypothetical scenario and uh have each of these five respond to questions uh coming out of that scenario. And it really the way I would describe it, Luke, is it's an exercise in how to think, and I love it for this, it's how to think biblically, carefully and biblically from the standpoint of biblical principles, first principles, about the whole area or sphere of civil government.

Scott AllenUh what does that look like when we're operating biblically, when we assume the lordship of Christ and the authority of God's word, and we apply that to the sphere of civil government? What does that actually look like when it's carefully and correctly applied? So it's a it it's something that you and I, and we at the DNA, we love to see Christians do in every area, whether it's marriage, family, church, business, economics, you know, we need to think biblically, right? Because God's word isn't just spiritual, it's not just uh personal spiritual salvation and these kinds of things.

Scott AllenIt's it's his handbook for all of life and all of society, because he's the Lord of all. Um and so it's really great in that respect. It's a it's a to me was a great model. So here's the scenario that they set up. Um uh the year is 2099. The United States has sadly fractured into a number of smaller regional states or now nations. Um and one of them has attracted large numbers of church-going evangelical Protestants.

Scott AllenUh maybe, maybe Joe is thinking of Idaho, I wonder there, but possibly. Uh they make up 75% of the population with a minority of Catholics, Mormons, Jews, and atheists. Uh the framers of the new government for this new nation have invited a number of theologians to consult on some critical questions. And here's the questions, and every contributor had to respond to these questions. Um Question number one, should we acknowledge the living God, the Lordship of Christ, and the authority of scriptures in the Constitution?

Scott AllenUh, number two, should we establish a particular church as the official church of the nation? Number three, should elected officials be required to have a Christian testimony of faith and or just a profession of uh acknowledgement of biblical authority in the Constitution. Uh how should non-Christians be treated? How should Muslims, Hindus, atheists, and others be treated? Should they enjoy the same civil liberties and opportunities as Christians? Should we privilege Christians?

Scott AllenAnd I won't go on, but there was probably two or three other questions like those that were very that really are gonna flesh out, right, very carefully what what it looks like to apply the Bible in this area of civil civil government. So in that respect, it was really a terrific exercise. And uh basically the way that the book was set up is each each of the participants had a chance to respond to those questions and um and then after they responded, the others could critique their responses. So Joe responded first, gave his answers to the questions, and then the others gave relatively short, you know, five to ten paragraph responses, pushbacks, questions to Joe, and then Joe got a final word, and then that pattern was repeated throughout the book until they all had a chance to respond.

Scott AllenSo what what a great way of fleshing out uh, you know, kind of a an issue that needs careful thought. I just thought it was such a fascinating structure.

Luke AllenYeah, that's what attracted me to the book uh when I first saw it. I mean, I think it was when it was first being theorized, and I saw Doug Wilson sitting down with Al Muller, and I was like, well, this should be interesting, you know, two people that don't tend to cross paths very often. And yet, as I mean, like this book does, I love it when Christians come together from different backgrounds, different theological uh viewpoints, and do something together and just show our unity. I mean, it's that's what we should be doing all the time, and yet we like to stay in our little echo chambers sometimes and just kind of talk past each other, which is not helpful.

Luke AllenUm, so just choosing a topic like this, fleshing it out. And like you said, Dad, there was kind of, I think, more unanimity than they were expecting uh along the topic of Christian nationalism, spooky Christian nationalism, you know, the scariest topic in America today, um, which it is fitting we're talking about this on Halloween week because it's, you know, there's nothing scarier today than saying the word Christian nationalism in America.

Scott AllenWell, and I think in some ways what Joe was was trying to do with this book was to push beyond that label and say, hey, you know, what we're really talking about here is just what does it look like when we take the Bible seriously and apply it in this area of civil society and civil government, right? And rather than just kind of uh labeling people as Christian nationalist and then, you know, just writing them off and not listening to them, he's like trying to get beyond that, below that, and say, what what let's really flesh this out? And it was really terrific. I mean, it there, like you said, Luke, there was quite a bit of unanimity across the spectrum, Baptist, Presbyterian, Catholic.

Scott AllenThat that struck me. There was one uh participant, Joe Miller, or Paul Miller, we're gonna talk about. He was a Baptist. He was the one that really stood out as um the he had the most disagreements uh with the others. And so it wasn't a disagreement between Catholics and Protestants here. It was uh there was some unanimity between the Catholics, Protestants, Presbyterians. It was two Baptists that were kind of disagreeing with each other. So it was pretty fascinating. Yeah.

Luke AllenYeah. Yeah. Well, it was a great discussion. It was practical. It was helpful to kind of get into the weeds of what are we talking about here, how to just take the Bible, apply it to something super practical, like politics, like the state, like policy. Um and uh yet I I do think we we got into a little bit of deep waters when uh on some theological topics, um, which I we don't tend to do very often here on the show. Uh we're we're we're big on talking about the practical application of the Great Commission here on the show, and as such, we don't tend to get very deep into theology very often.

Luke AllenUh today you will hear some big theological terms come up, um, things that I think if we were gonna have if we had more time with Joe, we would have liked to delve into more because I think there was some disagreement in quite a few of those categories, and yet we kind of just let that breeze by in this for the sake of talking about the book today, talking about Christian nationalism, staying kind of on track, uh, even though some topics were brought up where I would have loved to go deeper with him, but you know, due to the time, we weren't able to, maybe we'll have him on again. But uh, for me as a takeaway, just uh just uh to give you guys a little idea of what you're about to get into, my favorite uh part of this discussion was when he was talking about freedom of religion.

Luke AllenThis is a very practical concept to think about when we're looking at the riots going on in Italy, uh France, I guess the most over the last week, and this idea of um neutrality amongst religious groups inside of a nation, which I think a lot of people miss here, the uh the ideal that was set uh by our founders, the ideal of freedom of religion and freedom of speech as all things being equal when it comes to religions uh or when it comes to speech.

Luke AllenAnd uh the way Joe unpacked that is he said, No, you can't actually uphold freedoms without uh the basis of a Judeo-Christian culture. That is first and foremost a priority if you want to even have freedoms within a nation. And then from there, from the roots of a Judeo-Christian tree, you can grow things like freedom of speech and freedom of religion. And therefore, the phrase freedom of religion probably isn't as helpful as using the phrase tolerance of religion, which is more of the way that the U.S.

Luke Allenis set up. Dad, I thought that was a super helpful segment when he was talking about that, because that is the way that you the US operates essentially, is we need Christianity to kind of stay at our base operating principles as far as as biblical principles in the basis of our nation if we are hoping to see these freedoms endure. Uh, and as such, it's not really this like freedom of religions as in they're all equal. Uh, and that can be kind of confusing for people. What do you think about that section, Dad?

Scott AllenYeah, I think you said it really well. I thought that was also a very helpful section. And I think this really gets to, in some ways, some of the most um difficult to understand and important parts of the discussion of the application of the Bible to uh civic life, uh civic civil government, um, policies, laws. Um what do you do with um you know with people that have different beliefs? How do you live in a pluralistic society? And like you said, Luke, I think um uh uh right now the way that that we tend to kind of think about that in our secular society is this um this kind of position of of neutrality, the the government needs to be completely neutral on anything religious.

Scott AllenBut the problem with that is that that itself becomes a view. There really is no neutrality, right? You you you you

Luke Allensomething will always rise to the top.

Scott AllenSomething will always rise to the top. And when you have this kind of quote unquote neutrality, uh these religions are very different, um, especially as that as it comes to this question of freedom and religious freedom. Uh most, I would say all except for Christianity, don't have a root or a basis for it. They're gonna end up coercing belief. Um uh but Christianity does. Christianity has a kernel within it, uh, based on how God has created human beings, who God Himself is.

Scott AllenUm, you know, and Joe's gonna get into that. There's a basis, a kernel, a foundation in Christianity for a religious belief and tolerate uh religious toleration. But it's not the kind of neutrality that that you hear about today, this kind of strict separation idea. And so Joe, I thought, did a great job of explaining that. It really helped me a lot, actually.

Luke AllenYeah. The way Darrow sometimes puts it is at the root of every culture is a cult.

Scott AllenYes. Uh,

Luke Allenand what he means by cult isn't like a wacky cult, he's talking about just a form of worship or a belief system.

Scott AllenYep.

Luke AllenThere's always going to be a belief system behind a culture and therefore behind a nation. Uh so the question isn't, you know, what belief or is there a belief system behind it, it's which belief system is it, and is that belief system the most helpful for us as humans and bringing about human flourishing? So just unpacking which one works the best is the question we're talking about today. We think it's Christianity. Uh but you know, obviously people will disagree with that, and that's why you want to just get into these discussions and prove why it actually works the best.

Scott AllenYeah, and I think you see this kind of uh modern day way of thinking most clearly when it comes to public schools. Public schools are not supposed to uh put their finger on the scale in terms of any religion, right? Not Christianity, not Islam, not Buddhism. They're supposed to be neutral. But what that says, in effect, is that uh God doesn't have anything to say about any of the subjects that a kid might be studying at school, you know?

Luke AllenYeah, there's a religion for that. Secularism.

Scott AllenThat's not religiously neutral to say, to make that statement that God doesn't have anything to say about uh math, science, or anything else, right? So again, it's just you you you have to kind of first, step one, there is no neutrality. There's always going to be a religious belief at the core, uh, as you said, Luke, a cult of worship. Uh, step two, is there one that can affirm religious freedom and respect uh the conscience and the right of people to make these decisions at the heart level? So yeah, there were so many good things that I thought that came out of our discussion today.

Scott AllenAnd as you said, uh Luke, I wanted to get a lot of the issues out on the table, but we didn't have a chance or time to kind of flesh them out or push back. There were some that, especially towards the end, as we were talking about Abraham Kuyper, and I thought that was a really fascinating discussion. But I had, uh, Luke, I uh yeah, it would have there would have been things I probably would have disagreed with had we had a chance to kind of probe into it a little bit more. But at least uh today you're gonna be able to hear what Joe has to say about these things at kind of a kind of a very concise level.

Scott AllenAnd I think he has a lot of really good things to say. So

Luke Allenyeah, with that, let's hop into the discussion with Joe Rigney.

Scott AllenWell, it's so great to have back on the show Joe Rigney. Joe, thanks so much for taking time to to be with us and uh and to discuss your um really wonderful and important uh recent book, Five Views of Christian on Christian Nationalism. Uh I devoured that book. I thought it was incredible. And I think for me, Joe, the thing I loved about it was, you know, at the DNA, we we talk a lot about applied, you know, kind of practical applied theology. Um, you know, no sacred secular divide, so the Bible, you know, Christ is Lord over all the areas of life and and society.

Scott AllenSo how does the word of God apply in every area? Um uh what principles can we bring into how we think about everything from you know uh family life, marriage, economics, uh business, you name it. And what I loved about this book was that that's essentially what you were doing in the area of of civil society, civil government is it was a really great kind of exercise to get uh some terrific thinkers together and say, you know, let's work out what it looks like. What does this look like practically?

Scott AllenAnd the the way you set that up with the scenario and the questions, I thought was was wonderful. So congratulations on all of that.

SpeakerYeah, well, I'm really grateful um that it came together the way that it did. Um, you know, the goal when when when the Christian nationalism conversation has can has continued as it has over the last you know four or five years, um we were thinking, how do we actually bring people together who often just talk past each other and uh different perspectives, um lots of confusion about that term. And so um the goal and and then also there's ways in which um even just the the framing really does matter. And so the idea that we had was let's see if we can put this hypothetical scenario, um, not as a scenario that anybody hopes happens, you know, the idea that the United States has broken up into smaller nations, but really as a kind of thought experiment to force um principles to reality.

Scott AllenYeah

Speakerand uh and what would you actually do if if you could? Like what would be uh some of those principles, how would they get worked out, and see if that didn't illuminate um differences or actually you know highlight some some surprising agreements across different different lines um in the discussion. And so, you know, getting two Presbyterians, two Baptists, Roman Catholic, um all walk into a bar and uh debate Christian nationalism. Um and uh and so yeah, we're really happy with the way uh with the way that it turned out and uh with all the the participants who are willing to to um do it with us.

Scott AllenAbsolutely. Was this your concept to set it up this way? Um

Speakeryeah,

Scott Allenoh yeah, well good, yeah. No, I thought that was really creative and very, you know, really wonderful. I thought it elicited just great responses. I guess one question to start with is uh why these, you know, these five, okay, the five include yourself, uh uh Doug Wilson, but um Paul Miller as well, uh Albert Moeller, and congratulations on getting Albert Moeller. That was wonderful. And RR Reno, too. I'm a big fan of R R Reno and First Things. I just thought, what a great group that you you pulled together. Uh I love the diversity uh of this group.

Scott AllenBut um, I guess how so the question is, you know, how did you come to those folks? And the follow-up would be, you know, today, nowadays in the Christian nationalism discussion, it seems like you're hearing this kind of consolidation around um people that are sometimes referred to as the new Christian right, Joel Webin, Dale Partridge. Uh there's these others that are very outspoken in terms of affirming that they are Christian nationalists. And I guess the the follow-up question is why why not one of them?

Scott AllenI was just kind of curious why they were not included in this project. Well,

Speakerso yeah, the genesis of the book is now, you know, gosh, it's got to have been 18 months or so. Um so in terms of who we were thinking about, uh we wanted uh nationally recognized names, if possible, folks who people would recognize as serious Christian thinkers. Uh we wanted to try to get some diversity on there. And so I know that the the most difficult one was um, you know, both Pastor Wilson and I, we passed from the same church, so how much diversity can there be? Um but there is some difference in terms of the theological influences, which was one of the things we wanted to explore.

SpeakerUm so Pastor Wilson has um benefited heavily from the Reconstructionists, um, would self-describe as a Kuiperian. Um I wouldn't. I I didn't have a Reconstructionist phase, and I um I'm much more critical of Kuiper. And then uh so I kind of operate more in a classical uh Protestant mode, uh similar to where Steven Wolf, um, you

unknownknow,

Speakerif Steven could have been a part of it, we would have had him, but he was doing other things, and so um I kind of filled that slot, he and I, but our categories are pretty similar. And then we knew we wanted to get um you know the the uh Baptists involved because America is a Baptist nation. Um even even our um the non-denominational, all of those are all effectively Baptists, and there's some diversity within Baptists uh among Baptists on these kinds of questions, um, and kind of the what people think of as the mainstream modern Baptist view, I think, which is represented by Paul Miller in terms of its academic form.

SpeakerUm, you know, strong separation of church and state, um, you know, very minimal uh Christian element in civil society, very, very restricted in a lot of ways. Um but there's this other Baptist view that I think Dr. Muller has articulated, um, which is much more Protestant, uh classically Protestant in its in its orientation. So we wanted to see them kind of uh represent different shades of baptism. Thought, just like we were representing different shades of uh Protestant and Presbyterian thought. And then Rusty Reno has written extensively on the question of nationalism, uh and he's written as a Roman Catholic.

SpeakerUh he's so he's a little bit outside of the kind of evangelical Protestant tribe that we largely uh represent. And uh and yet he's done a lot of really important thinking on the question of nationalism, which was the other thing we wanted to tackle. Um, what exactly is a nation? Does America qualify as one? Um, what does it mean to preserve one or for one to become Christian? Um those questions are always wrapped up in that. And and uh Rusty's done a lot of thinking about that in some of his work, and so um so he was willing to join as well. As to why, you know, guys like Joel Webin

unknownor

SpeakerDale Partridge weren't uh, you know, again, 20 20 um or so months ago, um, I don't know that Dale Partridge would have made sense, the lineup would not have even been a thing. And I think um, you know, there there is an element of um we want to represent kind of where a large portion of evangelicals are, and I'm not sure. I mean, I think those guys do have a large following maybe in online or have have some resonance. They've got lots of uh Twitter followers and things like that. Um but uh but wasn't really kind of the mainstream element that we were wanting to kind of represent in terms of who's a well-respected, um, prominent thinker in a lot of these areas and has written extensively on it.

SpeakerAnd certainly at the time that wasn't that wasn't the case.

Scott AllenI see. Well, that's helpful to hear. Yeah. I thought it was fascinating that um it, you know, as I was reading through the book um and list you know, the answers to the questions that each of you came forward with and critiqued uh on from one another, there was pretty widespread agreement on a lot of things amongst uh almost all of you, with the exception of Paul Miller.

SpeakerRight. Um,

Scott Allenyou know, he was the kind of the outlier. Uh and that was fascinating to me. You got a Catholic, two Presbyterians, a Baptist, you know, a very prominent Baptist, Al Moeller, pretty much all kind of aligning, you know, there was different, right? You know, you had some around the edges, right, things you critiqued with each other, but but on the whole, I felt like, well, this is fascinating. There's a lot of unanimity. But uh there wasn't with the other Baptist, he was the one I was least familiar with, and as I looked into his background, I noticed that he was the one that had the most um experience in civil government himself, right? He was a member of the Bush administration, I believe.

Scott AllenAnd um yeah, so he he's a kind of a fascinating uh gentleman, but he was really an outlier. Well, I guess the question is, what do you uh uh uh you know what I wouldn't have expected that, right? He's a Baptist. But what what do you how do you describe the crux of kind of the separation between him and say the rest of you, even though I there were minor dis uh disagreements among the rest of you as

Speakerwell. Yeah, well, and and the and how it shook out that way wasn't uh wasn't intentional. We kind of, you know, we had the prompt and we had the guys that we wanted to be involved, and uh and then it was kind of where do we where do we end up landing? And so um, you know, for one, I was I was surprised in some ways at how um how Christian nationalist Dr. Moeller was willing to be. So there were some places where I didn't I didn't expect him as a Baptist to go, but was was gratified that he did because I think it does there's a minority Baptist position that he represents um in in doing that um in terms of like the wide square.

Scott AllenQuickly, you would call that a minority in that community.

SpeakerHistorically, I think um you know it is but it but it is well represented. So guys like John Gill, um there were certain other um, you know, Federalist Baptists at the American founding who I think would be very much in the uh even I think Spurgeon in some ways um would have some overlap with uh the way that Dr. Muller was talking. And so um, in terms of contemporary Baptists, um, you know, Paul Miller was much more representative of kind of that classical liberal um um he calls his view natural law republicanism. And uh and I think some of the key questions are around um what's the role of the law, um, which law is it?

SpeakerAnd so he he wanted to lean on natural law, but really not even the full orb natural law, because that would be a place where he and I would actually have some agreement. Um, but he wants to really restrict it to um horizontal natural law, how we treat other people, pure and simple, um, with no vertical axis. So the state has really no role in promoting true religion or um discouraging false religion. That's not really the something the state should ever be involved in, and he's got sort of covenantal reasons, I guess, going back to Noah to justify that. Um but I think that his his viewpoint is widely shared in a certain segment of evangelicalism.

SpeakerUm I think David French uh would be another thinker, Russell Moore. Um, those those thinkers um I think would find a lot of resonance with the way, with the kind of structures that Paul Miller articulated. Um I think there would be other other guys even in kind of the gospel coalition uh circles that he he would be pretty reflective of the categories that they they would operate in. And so it really was an important view to have uh represented. And the fact that um you know Rusty Reno and Moeller ended up agreeing with um Doug and I in a whole host of ways was a little bit of a surprise, but I think was actually an encouraging thing.

SpeakerIt gave some hope to a kind of evangelical um or at least a a broadly Christian um uh perspective that that has different roots, different traditions, but that has a lot of the same uh principles and outworkings uh in terms of what we're aiming at.

Scott AllenI was just gonna read a little bit here from um uh from Paul Miller in the book here. Um King Jesus does not yet desire the nations to call themselves by his name in this present fallen sinful age. And I can't find uh exactly where he said it, but he basically said, you know, he's not kind of king yet. He's going to be king when he comes back, but not yet. I thought that kind of was the crux of the difference. Um is just this kind of you know he he he he had a shr I would call it the way I would phrase it is a strong sacred secular divide, you know.

SpeakerYeah, no, I definitely think he um there's a you know, some people sometimes people will criticize an over-realized eschatology, a view that

Scott Allenum,

Speakeryou know, the end times realities have have so invaded that they're that we think we can get a utopia on earth. Um, which even for those of us who are post-millennial isn't isn't actually the way we think. Um I think his is a very underrealized eschatology, um in the sense that Christ's um reign is a pure and simple spiritual reign, I think, at this point, um, that doesn't have a whole lot of um historical effects. Um at best, it's a kind of um it acts as a kind of break on the worst impulses of man. Um and even then it's not much of a break because you can't make those appeals to um to Christ, actually, in the in the you know, you can't ground any action in the public square um

Scott Allenin the Christmas. Yeah,

Speakeryou could personally believe that Christ is Lord and therefore we shouldn't say kill babies in utero, but you couldn't have a law that said um we will not we we will protect human life at every stage of development and we'll do so in the name of Jesus. The in the name of Jesus part, um Paul Miller, I think, would oppose um stridently, because it would be a mixing of um the jurisdictions of the church and the state. So he has a really strong the sec what you call the secular sacred, I think really is a um a church uh state, um almost a radical separation, similar in many ways to kind of what Thomas Jefferson would have advocated for, and um, but wasn't necessarily the dominant position even among the founders.

SpeakerUm it was certainly Jefferson's view, but but was a uh you know, there was a lot of suspicion among many Americans about the kind of radical um uh separation that Jefferson was advocating for.

Scott AllenAnd on the other side, you know, on that issue of the lordship of Christ presently, there seemed to be kind of unanimity, and and the unanimity around it was that, you know, we're if we're gonna have a nation, we're gonna have laws, and uh there has to be, I think the phrase you used a lot was this ontological grounding. There has to be some kind of an ontological grounding for those laws. Uh, and that needs to be explicit, right? Is is Jesus King and Lord and is his law universal for all people and all times? Then we got to be explicit about that. Um and if that's not the case, what's the only other option?

Scott AllenIs it some human being, right, or group is going to kind of establish that?

SpeakerYeah.

Scott AllenAnd it seemed like there was unanimity, even amongst uh Rusty Reno and I don't know, on that question.

SpeakerYeah. I think that yeah, that language that's um Dr. Moeller was is I think I think there was un you know unanimity. The language of ontological grounding is I think that's something that Dr. Moeller thought was very important. Um I would talk in terms of you know the second table of the law, the law is having to do with human society like murder and um theft and adultery and so forth, protecting marriage, protecting life, protecting property. Um those second table laws are built on the first: honor God, worship God in the way that he wants, honor his name, um, keep the Sabbath. So the law kind of hangs together in that way, and our love for neighbor um must be grounded in love for God, and the state should promote obedience to both.

SpeakerAnd I think that was a similar sentiment to Dr. Moller's insistence that if if Christ is Lord over the state, and he is, then the state should acknowledge that. That was his kind of the key word for him in his his uh chapter was um acknowledgement. Um we must the the state, all human institutions must acknowledge the lordship of Christ. And then he was very um he's trying to thread a fine needle as a Baptist. He didn't want anybody to be forced to confess things, but he also thought it was fine to restrict certain civic privileges like office holding um to um those who can make that acknowledgement, who can acknowledge that Christ is necessary, that that there must be a transcendent standard and anchor for all of our human laws.

SpeakerUm so he didn't want to force a confession, but he did want an acknowledgement that that's necessary, kind of as a system of thought or a systematic foundation for the

Scott Allenthing.

SpeakerThere

Scott Allenwas a fine distinction, but I thought it was important there that he wanted the law to be grounded in the reality, I would put it, you know, as the the reality of God's existence and the lordship of Christ and and the authority of his word, right? He wanted that to be acknowledged as the ontological grounding. I fully agree with that. But for the for the civic ruler, the the president or whoever didn't necessarily need to have a personal confession of Christian faith, but they needed to acknowledge the the uh the the reality of of the grounding of our law in Christ and his word, the lordship of Christ and his word.

Scott AllenYou were pushing a little bit more than that, I think, on your response to that question, right? You you were more comfortable uh ex talk a little bit about that. I was I was gonna probe your answers to the question a little bit here, yeah.

SpeakerYeah, so I think there is a difference between acknowledging something as a um sort of um principial ground or a foundational commitment, um, that the system needs a transcendent grounding in the living God, which I think that's so Mohler's word was acknowledgement, and a Christian confession. So it was it was sort of like I think Dr. Moeller would say we need to acknowledge that Christianity is essential for the foundation of our laws.

Scott AllenYes. And

SpeakerI would say we need to confess Christ. So sort of Christianity as a system of of uh meaning, a system of belief that forms the background conditions of human society, something like that, would be Mohler's. And I think I I think that we need that, and I think the way to get it is actually to say we must confess um I believe in God the Father, Almighty, maker of heaven and earth, and in Jesus Christ, his only begotten Son, our Lord. And that we should expect our rulers to make that, and if they can't, then they'd be disqualified from holding office. That that's sort of the the necessity is to have that as a confession, um, where a nation, through its representatives, um, can say we believe.

SpeakerAnd I think that that's probably the biggest difference between um the Baptist, even that kind of stronger Baptist position represented by Dr. Moller, and uh a Presbyterian position is is the willingness to say um nations can say we believe. Um

Scott Allenlet's yeah, let's talk about that. Let's flesh that out. That that distinction, I think that's really good. And again, you were representing what I think you called the classic Protestantism kind of position in regards to the answers to these questions. I'd like you to have to flesh that out a little bit, but but um so you were uh just to pick up what you were saying, you'd you'd like to go beyond just an acknowledgement on the part of civic leaders and officials, uh let's say predominant ones, presidents or whatever, uh, you know, beyond just the ontological grounding of the law in the Lordship of Christ and the authority of Scripture to a confession, a public confession of faith.

Scott AllenUh then the question that I think I have to follow that up with is what about non-Christians? You know, do they have a role in um uh uh you know kind of civic leadership? And how are they treated? Uh yeah, to flesh that out in your view, you know, how are non-Christians to be treated, Muslims, Hindus, atheists?

SpeakerYeah.

Scott AllenUh, you know, this whole question of religious liberty and how in a in a in an app in a society that was trying to strictly apply biblical principles to civic law, w how do I mean I'm sure you agree, right? Religious liberty is that comes out of our tradition, right? But but how does that actually work and look?

SpeakerYeah. So it is a it is a question of uh kind of definitions and and how you how you define that term. So um in in my view, um public offices, such as uh, you know, so hold it being a president or a governor, and in this hypothetical that we're constructing, what are we aiming at if we could have our way? And it would be and significantly for the the hypothetical, it wasn't simply 100% of everybody is evangelical. Um it was, hey, there's um there's largely uh a heavy evangelical population.

Scott AllenIt was 75% or something like that. But then

Speakerthere's means 25% of your population is made up of Catholics and Mormons and Hindus and Jews and atheists and and so forth. And so it's a reasonable, and it was deliberate to say um you still we do have to have these, we have these people, what do we do? Um and so restricting office uh to those who can make that uh Christian confession, I think is an important thing because um I think the nation should be founded on it. I think that it would be, you know, let's put it in the Constitution um that we believe in God and that our laws are gonna be founded on his law. Uh and then you want the guardians of that, the rulers, the magistrates, whose whose role it is to interpret, apply, and guard society to be bound to that same confession.

SpeakerSo I think public office would be restricted in that way. Um in terms of those individual uh lives, um, people wouldn't be harassed because they weren't Christians. Um so religious liberty means we're not gonna try to coerce that religious confession, we're not gonna put a gun to your head and demand um you know, uh believe in Jesus or else simply because it's impossible to get. Like that just it can't happen. That's not how living faith comes. Um and it would be a violation of um kind of classic Protestant um categories of the inner man and the outer man.

SpeakerAnd so while the the magistrate can um promote and encourage things um and discourage things in terms of the public arena, in terms of our actions in public, um the inner man, the God alone is the Lord of the conscience. That's a key Protestant um insight, um, is that God alone is Lord of the Conscience, and therefore we um we don't impose, we don't have magistrates who try to impose in the realm of inner belief or or conscience through coercion.

Scott AllenAnd this sets us apart from Islam and other you know religions, atheism for that matter, I'm I'm thinking of particularly of uh you know communism, you know, such a strong socialism, which is kind of very much a coerced type of thing.

SpeakerYeah. Um

Scott Allenwhat's the root of that? Do you think I know this is a deep question and there's long answers to it, but if you could just put your finger on uh the the the tip of it, what's the what's the what's the root of that in the scriptures? Is it yeah?

SpeakerI would say it's two things. I think it's the way that God constituted us as body and soul. Um and so um while you know rulers, um whether that's you know parents or pastors or um civil civic rulers are concerned about the soul and want to encourage the soul, the the tools that God has given them to do so are all kind of external tools. So um parents can spank their kids, but they can't change their hearts. Pastors can preach the word and and bring it to bear, say, thus saith the Lord to people, but that they that's that's about the extent of it.

SpeakerThey can't do anything more. It's it's gotta be heart work. And the same thing for civic uh rulers. They can pass laws and they can promote what's good and discourage what's evil in terms of public behavior, but they can't actually get at the heart. And so I think that's a big part of it, is the s the inner man-outer man distinction. And that's also related to the doctrine of justification by faith alone. It's a it's a key Protestant insight to say um that our works, our our external works have no bearing on our right standing with God. It's all faith and it's in the inner man, and it's you stand before God on your own two feet um solo as an individual, and you'll answer to the Lord for whether you believed or didn't.

SpeakerAnd so, because of that, because God is alone as Lord of the conscience, because he's the one who makes that ultimate determination um in terms of our salvation, um, no human being of any of any sort can intrude into that, which was a counterbalance even to the at the time, the Roman Catholic um assertion that the Pope did have some jurisdiction and it was possible uh to coerce faith, and you had inquisitions and things like that. Um, and Protestants said this is wrong because we are the inner the inner sanctum belongs to the Lord alone and we're justified by faith alone. And so that's kind of the foundation of Protestant political philosophy.

Scott AllenThat's really good. And would you add to that, you know, just the concept that human God created us with with a degree of agency and free will, um, you know, that that deep heart, as you were saying, there's there's choices that are made there, and God created us in that way and it needs to be respected.

SpeakerYes. Um

Scott Allenyou know, and not just by the civil government. I I think of you know, when I was dating my wife, my wife to be, you know, I really I fell in love with her before she fell in love with me. I really wanted her to love me.

SpeakerRight. Yeah.

Scott AllenBut I couldn't figure out, you know, what lever to turn and what button to push, you know. There isn't one,

Speakerright?

Scott AllenYeah, exactly. And finally I just had to come to the conclusion, or I think God, you know, spoke to my heart on this, saying, you know, uh, hey, you know, those that heart decision is hers to make, you know, and that that's that's where I operate, that heart level, that deep level. You're just gonna have to trust me on that. You know, there's nothing you're gonna do. And I uh so I think that's just true, right? It's just it's just true to who we are and who our nature is. Christianity just recognizes that. How would you tie that into Jesus' um you know, famous uh, you know, offer and give unto Caesar what is Caesar's, and uh give unto God, what is God's?

Scott AllenBecause that's often brought up in this discussion.

SpeakerYeah. And I think well part of that is um, you know, they ask the the question that question to Christ comes up because who, you know, who's do we have to pay taxes? And they and he says, Show me a coin, whose inscription is this, whose image is this? Yes, and it's the image of Caesar, and so render to Caesar the things that are Caesar. Caesar has his image on it, it belongs to Caesar. Well, what has God's image on it? And it's like human beings.

Scott AllenHuman beings, yeah.

SpeakerAnd so human beings can't render to Caesar that which belongs to God, meaning they can't render their souls or their or their selves, their total selves, uh, to any human authority because God alone is Lord and He's and He's the Lord over all the other Lords. So all ultimate allegiance must go to Him. And where that where that comes into play is it it does allow for a distinction that I think is a is a Protestant one, um, which is you can have certain kinds of compulsion in terms of behaviors without attempting to coerce the conscience.

SpeakerSo um, and parents recognize this. You can discipline your kids in terms of their external behaviors, knowing that hopefully that discipline extends to the heart, but you can't you don't have direct access to it. You can't really get at it directly. And I think a similar distinction applies to the state, where the state can promote certain behaviors, it can say we really want to encourage this through various means, whether it's praise and commendation or um civic privileges or even financial incentives to say these are the sorts of things we want to encourage.

Scott AllenWe want churches in our community, not synagogues or something like that. Exactly, which means they could

Speakersay, um, you know, oh yes, you can build a church there, no, you can't build a mosque there.

Scott AllenRight. Um

Speakerand so zoning laws would be a way of saying, hey, the public square, we are gonna sort of order society. Um it doesn't mean you can't be a Muslim, right? But you can't have a mosque at the on the town square. Something like that. You can't have your minarets, you can have church bells ringing, but there's no call from the minaret because the public square belongs to Jesus. And so that would distinguish, I think, the Protestant notion of religious liberty, which is really a kind of religious toleration, um, which says these people are wrong, they have false religion, um, and yet in the interests of um civil society, in the interests of evangelism, in the interests of preserving that human agency, um, we're gonna tolerate their false belief.

SpeakerUm, but we're also gonna not but we're gonna make sure not to encourage or encourage it in any way. We're actually gonna maybe it at times actively discourage it, um, but still leave them free from harassment and persecution, um, where we're not chasing them around um with swords trying to get them to get baptized. Right. And part of that

Scott Allentoo is just love your neighbor, right? I mean, they still are our neighbors, right? Yes.

SpeakerYes, they they are. So central to loving your neighbor is both respecting his ability to make a choice with his own soul and how and how he's gonna raise his kids and so forth, um, but it's also loving your neighbor to not permit gross idolatry because that displeases God, right? This is one of the lesson, main lessons actually of the Old Testament is that when God's people tolerate brazen idolatry, putting up high places, um, worshiping false gods, making offerings to Molech and Kemosh and so forth, um, this displeased God, and he brought judgment for that um the wrong kind of toleration of public, brazen, um, high-handed uh rebellion.

SpeakerAnd um, this would be a key kind of dividing line, I think, among some of the participants, um, is I would look at the Old Testament as a model, right? So we're we're not Israel in the sense of there's only one unique special nation. America is not that. But in many ways, we're the extension of it because now all nations are called to the obedience of faith, um, which means all nations are summoned to be like Israel in worshiping and obeying God in every area, in every uh area of area of lives. So that means I would look at Old Testament kings um and who are evaluated on two things mainly.

SpeakerIf they're evaluated on their personal piety, did they individually um walk in God's ways and seek to obey him as a as an individual, as a person? And what was their public policy? Did they tear down the high places? Did they um uh promote true worship? That makes like those sorts of things were also a major part of how they were evaluated of are they faithful kings or not? And if they if they weren't, um God judged not just them, but the nation as a whole for their um for their disobedience.

SpeakerAnd so I would say that's a model. Whereas I think Paul Miller would say, nope, that was the old covenant, we don't operate that way anymore at all. Um we don't look to Israel's kings as models for our rulers, that's not how it works anymore.

Scott AllenCome back to Paul Miller on nations too, because that was a kind of a really interesting divide there, just the concept of nations. But yeah, if further exploring your own beliefs and what you're calling classic Protestantism on this, um, talk more about the law, if you would, Joe. Um, yeah, the Old Testament law and and how that applies if we're creating the hypothetical uh civil government based on biblical principles that you're talking about. The way I've heard this and I think kind of affirm, you know, and I'm not the deep thinker that you are or scholar, but um, you know, that you kind of it's helpful to divide Old Testament law into uh the Ten Commandments, um, uh you know, the uh the application of the Ten Commandments uh for the nation of Israel, kind of the civil code uh for ancient Israel, and then the uh Levitical laws, the pr the law, the laws of the priests.

Scott AllenAnd of the three, only one kind of are uh is is applying for all time and all pol all culture, right? The uh the Ten Commandments. Uh it I know this is a sticky area, there's a lot of nuances, and I'm not an expert by any stretch on theonomy, and but talk about your own views on that. You know, what how does the if we're trying to understand that Jesus is Lord, his word applies, and he's given a law, how do we bring that Old Testament law that into you know how how ought that to apply today?

SpeakerYeah, so um this is this is the the classic tripartite division of the law, which you just kind of articulated. Uh-huh. Um, I think is a um it goes back to Aquinas, actually. It's it's actually something that it's older than Protestantism, but Protestants very much embraced it. It's in the Westminster Confession, uh, it's in the London Baptist Confession. This is basically the way that most Protestants and the distinction has to do with um three big categories of law. So there's natural law or moral law, so which is universal. Um it's the sort of thing that's written on human hearts. Yeah, the

Scott Allenlaw written on the heart, the conscience, this kind of thing. Exactly. Yes,

Speakerand so these are sorts of things that you you know by nature, right?

Scott AllenUm,

Speakerand that all humans are obligated to obey um at all times and all places. And and the things that are in that list are actually pretty basic. Um it's stuff like love God, love neighbor, or fleshed out, you know, and loving your neighbor means respecting his uh respecting marriage, respecting life, respecting property, respecting his station, honor your parents, things like that. Um and then also honoring God, set aside time to worship him. Um don't take his name in vain, worship him the way that he wants, only worship God. So that's that's universal and and basic. Um but then there's divine law, um, what theologians call divine law, um, or which shows up in Moses as the ceremonial law.

SpeakerThe thing about this is um it's specially revealed, it's not something that you can know by nature. It's you only know it because God wrote it down for you or spoke it um in a specific way. And so this is where the types and ceremonies of the Old Testament, things like circumcision, um the sacrificial system, the food laws, these sort of temporary, um they they communicate spiritual truths um to us now, they were binding on Israel, um, but they were meant to instruct Israel in God's ways, um, point to the gospel, point to redemption. Um, that's divine law. And the um confessions have said, and following you know the book of Hebrews and places like that, is uh that those laws um were fulfilled in Christ.

SpeakerSo that they no longer are binding. We don't have to get circumcised, Jesus declared all foods clean. Um, those ceremonial laws, which aren't universal, which aren't morally binding on all men everywhere, um, were fulfilled in Christ. And therefore, there are sort of um New Testament versions of them. I think baptism would be an example of a New Testament ceremonial law. Um, the Lord's Supper would be a New Testament ceremonial law. You need a Bible to tell you what that means. Um, you can't just know it by nature. But it's but it's that's the form it takes. And then the civil laws uh of of Israel were basically applications of both of those for Israel's context.

SpeakerIt was God saying, okay, given these universal moral principles and given these um specially revealed redemptive laws that point to redemption um uh and God's covenant, um, given those two, um, how should that work itself out in Israel um in the in in its in the Mosaic era? Yeah,

Scott Allenparticularly

Speakerparticular time and place. And so what do we do with that? Well, the confession says the those laws expired with the that nation. So when Israel ceased to be a nation, which it did um in the first century, those laws that governed Israel also ceased. In the same way that we don't um we don't obey the laws of England because we're we don't live in England, we're not under that those laws anymore. But for us, what that means is we can consult the Old Testament law, those civic laws, as wisdom because we can basically look at the

Scott Allenhow did God apply it? Yeah, how

Speakerdid God apply it in Israel's day? Okay, now we can look at ours and say, well, the universal principle is still there. Yeah. How do we apply that in our day and and we can work its way out? But it doesn't have the same uh obligatory force that it did for, say, David or Solomon. Um for us, it's wisdom, it's instruction. Um, and so we learn how to apply the law that way. It's one of the ways I think that why we meditate on the law is we're supposed to make these distinctions among universally applicable things and which things were temporary and which things were applications, and we're supposed to reflect on that with God's help, and then that would that leads us so that we can live rightly, obey it, and pass laws um in our own context.

Scott AllenGotcha. Yeah, that's so helpful. So uh would a theonomist uh would that would they kind of push that further? This is where I'm not even completely clear, you know. Yeah,

Speakerso I think that most like reconstructionists reject the tripartite division. They think that that was a mistake. Uh-huh. Um and and and essentially what they do is they say the civic laws are binding. They'll agree about the ceremonies, the ceremonies were fulfilled in Christ, but the civic laws are still binding unless

Scott Allenuh

Speakerunless God explicitly removed them. Unless He told you don't do it.

Scott AllenThank you for clarifying. I've always had a question about that.

SpeakerAnd so because of that, they kind of in some ways collapse the moral and the civil together.

Scott AllenGotcha.

SpeakerAnd therefore it's still binding, the penalties are still binding, it needs to be done exactly that way.

Scott AllenThank you so much, Joe, because people are opposing. Yeah, people are always telling me, Scott, you know, you're a theonist, you know. And I'm like, okay, I guess I well, I don't even know what that is. But uh So now I do. Thank you, Joe. And I'm not a theonymist. Okay.

SpeakerRight. Yeah, exactly. So if if and and there's obviously a range even among theonists about it, but I think that's

unknowna good thing.

SpeakerThere really was a question. Um, they challenged that tripartite division and said that's not really the right way to think about the law. Yeah. And therefore they were willing to just bring the Old Testament penalties, and that was the way that God wanted modern societies to be governed, in a kind of um it's a blueprint, um, not just in as a model or an example, but as in like it needs to be brought forward exactly as it is, um, as opposed to recognizing that um you know there are different circumstances, and so the the moral principle of don't murder, for example, is abiding. But what the specific laws are, how how you go about restricting it, um, what the penalties are, um, all of that sort of stuff has some um it's it's wisdom, it's it's what statesmanship is, the art of statesmanship is trying to determine just like parenting, actually, this would be a good example.

SpeakerNo,

Scott Allenno, exactly. You can think so clearly about this when you just think about parenting on it. I think that's a really good analogy. So, you might have

Speakeryou have two kids and you both you know, in both cases, the the rule is don't sass your mom. Um, but one of your kids, if if they start to sass mom, all you have to do is give them a stern look and they get right back in line. And with another it's gonna take a couple of SWATs.

Scott AllenRight.

SpeakerUm and and a wise parent is gonna use the right tool in order to the goal is the obedience,

Scott Allenright?

SpeakerNot just a wooden application, um, and say, well, if if um because the the rule is I gotta do a SWAT, I gotta do five SWAT, I gotta do the same amount of

Scott Allenthings.

SpeakerNo, exactly. The goal is the

Scott Allenheart, right, exactly. And you

Speakertake into account the circumstances on the ground, which I think is g it gives Protestant political thought a kind of flexibility, the right kind. So there is something firm and steadfast in the universal moral law that's unchanging, and laws should promote obedience and discourage disobedience every which way. But then what does that look like on the ground? And this is actually to the religious liberty question, um, some of those, like what kind of laws you have, would would be dictated by, well, what are the people like? Um and so even, you know, classic Protestant thinkers said, you know, it's undesirable to have large numbers of atheists in your society because you can't believe what they say, they have no transcendent grounding, there's no re there's they can't, you know, so help me God means nothing to them.

SpeakerAnd therefore, how do you get how can they even take an oath of office if they can't they don't really believe in God, so they can just lie. And so at the and at the same time, they said, but sometimes you're in a circumstance where you have that, and a wise leader is not going to try to root out every form of atheism at the risk of destroying the whole society. He's gonna say we might have to tolerate some of these evils for the sake of a greater good, namely the preservation of the people itself. And so that's that's the kind of wisdom calls and why the art of politics or the the art of statesmanship um is such an important one for Christians.

Scott AllenYou know, yeah, I I love what we're doing here, even in this discussion, is that, you know, right now when you talk about Christian nationalism, it's it's just this label that gets kind of put broadly over, oh, you know, you you you're you're a dangerous person, right? You're a you know, you're you're uh uh creating some kind of a theocracy or whatever it is. And what you're doing is you're just saying, no, it really uncovers or it it's it's really uh it it it should be an exercise in how does the Bible apply

Speakerin

Scott Allenthe area of civil government, and it's this is deep. There's a lot of there's a lot to this. It requires a lot of deep and good uh biblical thinking and practical application. Let let's bring up one more. I know I just uh want to be careful with your time, but uh under the uh the questions we're asking of of your particular answers, classic Protestantism and how it answers, uh I, you know, am a fan of uh Abraham Kuyper and the concept of sphere sovereignty. I really love that because it it puts government into a broader frame than just civil government.

Scott AllenIt says, you know, government operates at all sorts of different levels, self-government, there's government in the family, there's government in the church. So there's this broader understanding of government that has to be kind of understood and respected. Talk about that. Yeah. And as you do, um, you know, talk about your concerns about Kuiper as well, because I know that you have some concerns uh as well. I'd like to hear more about that.

SpeakerYeah. So um so sphere sovereignty is kind of one of the distinctive Kuiperian or neo-Calvinist contributions to political thought. And it really is the development of an older idea of the different um in the Lutheran church, it was called the three uh different estates, um, or we we would say something like different institutions, and with kind of the three basic ones being the church, the state, and the family.

Scott AllenYes,

Speakerum, and uh um or the church, the nation, and the family sometimes. So so and I think that um is fine. That's part of my basic paradigm, and each of those um as a as an institution has a represent has a head. So the fathers rule the home, pastors rule the church, um, rulers rule the nation. And so you have these different um bodies, corporate political bodies um or corporate bodies um that God has established and that have authorities and rule and have different tools. You know, you've got a rod for dad, you've got a sword in the hand of the state, you've got the keys of the kingdom, the preaching of the word, and the sacraments for the ministers.

SpeakerSo all of that's fine. What Kuiper did is he he essentially kind of radicalizes that notion. Um, and you can even hear it in the term sovereignty. Um, because the idea of sphere sovereignty was that there really was um um these were autonomous spheres where they shouldn't have any overlap, or that overlap should be really, really minimal. It's sometimes unclear how much and how many spheres there were. So um Kuiper in principle said there's you know hundreds of spheres because I think that you know plumbing would have its own sphere. Um

Scott Allenteachers in the classroom or teachers in the classroom. So

Speakereducation was a sphere, arts was a sphere, business and then various subcategories. So it was really um it was a very much bigger kind of kind of thing. And the the sovereignty idea was is that everybody has to stay in their lane when you're speaking about these different hats. Whereas I think the classic Protestant view said, yeah, these are different institutions, but they all work together and help each other out in the furtherance of their mission. So you have a job as a dad, but the pastors and the magistrates should be helping you do your job better. And if you utterly fail, if you totally abdicate or are abusive, then the state and the church can sort of intervene um in gross negligence um or gross abuse of power in order to check it.

SpeakerUm that, by

Scott Allenthe way, gets close to that Catholic idea of subsidiarity too, right? It does. There's some

Speakersimilarities there, without the kind of um hierarchy that the pap the papacy tends to put itself at the top, the the church is is over the others. But

Scott Allenthis idea that yeah, there's certain responsibilities at certain levels and it has to be kind of starting at that most basic level and then kind of

Speakerum and then the other thing um about Kuiper was that part of his reason for doing the the s the sharp division between the spheres was uh he lived in a time where secularism had had was running rampant, liberal theology was running rampant in the state church in Holland, and he was a member of the dissenting church. And as a result, he basically wanted to modify the Protestant confessions um to change them from classic Protestant theology, which said, or political philosophy, which said the state needs to acknowledge Christ and needs to obey him.

SpeakerAnd Kuiper said, no, that's a holdover of Catholicism. Um the state needs to be governed purely by natural law, not by revealed law, not by the Bible, and um and was a very much more restrained. And the reason for this is I think he was in some ways retreating because he the the the state church was corrupt, and so he didn't want them to have that jurisdiction. But rather than saying, hey, we live in a time like Josiah when we need a reformation in the church and a reformation in society, he basically retreated and made it so that the um the state no longer was obligated to obey Christ.

SpeakerAnd so his claim, you know, every square inch belongs to Jesus, there's not one square inch that he doesn't claim, was actually a loud shout that was masking a retreat. Oh, interesting.

Scott AllenI'll have to go back and look at that history of his own personal application of that. Yeah, but

Speakerhe's very clear. He says, um, we don't I I think that he says, I think the Reformed confessions are wrong. Um we differ from Calvin, we differ from our Protestant forebears um on the question of the state's role in encouraging true religion and suppressing false false religion. He said that's absolutely out, it's absolutely bad. And so in some ways he s this is my criticism, is he opens the way for a secular public square.

Scott AllenGotcha. Uh because you can't. How ironic, too, because he's so famous, you know, for right? Not one square inch, right? Yes, that's the quote we always use. It

Speakerdoesn't seem like his

Luke Allenlegacy remembered that very well. Yeah. Right.

Scott AllenBut

Speakeruh well, um well the thing is is this actually explain he can explain why um if you think about the heirs of Kuiper and the neo-Calvinists in America, um, it's why it's guys, uh Calvin College, um, it's it it it really does accommodate itself to secularism and to modernism.

Scott AllenIt does. And that's a question I've often had. Why is that? Why does it seem to drift secular? Yeah.

SpeakerYes, because and the same thing why the institutions founded by Kuper did the same thing. So the Free University of Amsterdam, the political party he founded, none of them preserved themselves for more than a generation. Um and part of the reason was is there was a secularizing bent embedded in the system.

Scott AllenWow, we've got to look into that more. That's so fascinating. And

Speakerso it's actually a really great debate between him. So Kuyper was on one side, and a guy named Hudemacher was his sort of conservative adversary who said, You're giving away the farm by changing the confession, by modifying the state's obligations to promote true religion, you are fundamentally giving away the game and it won't work. And I think Hudemaker was right. Um but it's why guys like Tim Keller, for example, Kim Tim Keller was a is is a good example of a true blue Kyperian. Like he he really did bring the Kyperian mindset and therefore I think accommodated in many ways the secularism, progressivism of New York City.

SpeakerUm because it's it's principled pluralism. That's another kind of Kyperian ideal where we don't try to have a Christian public square, a Christian state, a Christian nation in those ways. Um because uh we we're gonna be principled pluralists, we're gonna maintain pluralism um in the public square. Um and it's and it's just a um so anyway, there's a secularizing and I think polytheistic tendency embedded in the Kyperian system.

Scott AllenAnd the only reason

Speakerthat it doesn't follow through everywhere is usually because it it links up with um theonomy. Um post-millennial theonomy acts as a kind of uh immunity boost for the Kuiperan system, which is why a lot of the reconstructionists, a lot of the theonymists really like Kuiper because they like the rhetoric of every square inch, but they just combine it with a very fundamentally different um system that says all of Christ for all of life.

Scott AllenYeah, no, that's really good. Well, listen, we're out of time. Joe, I'm so sad. I have lots of other questions I wanted to ask. I I thought the way you started, by the way, with just nations, before you talk about Christian nationalism, you better understand nations as a concept. And is that a good thing, a biblical thing, or not? I thought that was a super helpful um discussion that came out of the book. And uh again, one where I think you all aligned with the exception of uh of Paul Miller. He he's not a fan of nations. He's I'd I'd probably put him more as a globalist. I don't know. But uh we might have to save that for another discussion.

Scott AllenBut uh at least our listeners, I do want you to be thinking, I I I feel I've always felt like nations, the concept of nations is a deeply biblical theme, actually, that runs right through the scriptures from Genesis to Revelation.

SpeakerAbsolutely.

Scott AllenSo it has to be understood um as a concept. And I so appreciate too the contribution of Yorm Mazzoni, where he compares or contrasts nations to empires. I found that to be so helpful.

SpeakerYes.

Scott AllenJust on that, Joe, I th one last thing I could squeeze it in. We

Luke Allengotta we gotta wrap up.

SpeakerIt's okay. I can take it. Let's go.

Scott AllenOkay. Yeah, you've been using the word Christendom a lot, and I I've been listening to you. And uh I'd love for you to explain that just briefly, because when I think of Christendom, I think of empire meaning the Roman Empire Christianized, where this you know Caesar's been replaced by the Pope, um, and they called that Christendom. But I don't think that's what you mean by Christendom. What what

Speakeruh Yeah, so Christendom, uh as I would use it, I think as Pastor Wilson would use it, is what you happens if you have a bunch of Christian nationalisms. So you get a bunch of different Christian nations, all of whom um they're independent, they they think of themselves as imitating Israel in the best senses of the word, um, honoring God's, you know, covenanting with him, um seeking to honor him in their laws and customs and so forth. Um but they're different, right? So Nigeria is different than America, is different than England, is different than France. But if they were all Christian nations, what would you call the collection of them over against other nations like um China and the Middle East for right now, um, that would be Islamic or communist or so forth?

SpeakerWell, the c a collection of Christian nations would be called Christendom.

Scott AllenOkay. A collection of not an empire.

SpeakerBut not necessarily no. But I think

Scott Allenthat's a slightly slight danger in using that phrase because we at least I do, I think most people associate it with a particular time and place where it was kind of the political system of the Roman Empire Christianized.

SpeakerYes. But I but I think that even um after the Reformation, when you had sort of different emerging nation states and things like that, um kind of on the biblical model, looking at Israel as kind of the model nation, um, when you had uh Christian uh Germany and Christian um England and Christian Italy and Christian Spain and Christian Poland, um even though some of those were Catholic and not Protestant, um what what did you call that collection of nations? Christian America, for that matter. Okay, and you call that you call

Scott Allenthat Christendom. I wouldn't say

Speakerthe Christian. So oftentimes what we sip at we we we um shorthand it with Western civilization.

Scott AllenYes.

SpeakerUm but I think something like Western civilization was Christendom.

Scott AllenI see. Okay, that's helpful, Joe. No, that's fair. I just I just wanted to ask that question. A

Speakerrecovery and renewal and improvement. So Christendom 2.0 ought to learn from the mistakes of Christendom 1.0 as we try to make progress in Christian maturity.

Scott AllenThank you for all you're doing on this front, Joe. It's so helpful. And I just uh I really applaud you for this great book. I want to encourage all of our listeners to, especially those involved in the in politics and civil society, and at some level that's all of us. Um go and read this book. You've got a lot of it. Thanks, Joe. Thanks for the time.

SpeakerThanks, guys.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Our Modern Approach to Fighting Poverty Isn't Working | Part 2

    Nov 11, 202659 minAudio

    The midterms are over in the US. Will our newly elected leaders be able to help those struggling with poverty? Over the last few decades, we've spent trillions on government welfare programs. So why are homelessness and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Is Our Compassion Making Poverty Worse? | Part 1

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Our modern approach to fighting poverty is fundamentally flawed. We've spent trillions fighting poverty. So why does it persist? Have Christians adopted the world's faulty definition of poverty? And in doing so, have we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The World Is Drowning in Ugliness. Beauty Is the Antidote | Jenny Jee-El Park

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    What if one of the greatest things missing from modern Christianity isn't truth, but beauty? Dostoevsky famously wrote, “Beauty will save the world.” But what did he mean, and why does beauty matter so much to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Return of Socialism: From Marxism to Wokeness | Kevin Briggins

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    Why is socialism making a comeback in America? In this episode, Kevin Briggins from the Center for Biblical Unity and co-host of the Off Code Podcast joins us to unpack the growing influence of democratic socialism and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Not Yet Now Kingdom of God | Zach Dasher

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Is the Kingdom of God something we’re still waiting for, or is Jesus actually reigning as King right now? Not as the consummated King, before whom every knee will bow, but as the King who has authority over this world....

    Credit the people on this episode