Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ideas Have Consequences

Ideas Have Consequences artwork

Is Our Compassion Making Poverty Worse? | Part 1

Nov 4, 20261 hr 11 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Our modern approach to fighting poverty is fundamentally flawed. We've spent trillions fighting poverty. So why does it persist? Have Christians adopted the world's faulty definition of poverty? And in doing so, have we lost sight of what biblical compassion really looks like? Can we truly eliminate poverty without understanding human nature and God's design for human flourishing? This week we're doing something a little different! No guest this time, just our host, Scott, and producer, Luke, unpacking one of the most important questions Christians face: How can we help people escape poverty in ways that actually work? Drawing from Scripture and nearly four decades of experience in poverty alleviation, Scott shares seven biblical principles for compassionate ministry that challenge many of today's conventional approaches to helping the poor. This is Part 1 of a thought-provoking two-part conversation you won't want to miss! Who is the Disciple Nations Alliance (DNA)? Since 1997, DNA’s mission has been to equip followers of Jesus around the globe with a biblical worldview, empowering them to build flourishing families, communities, and nations. 👉 https://disciplenations.org/ 🎙️More About Scott: In addition to hosting the Ideas Have Consequences podcast, Scott D. Allen is an author and teacher on Christianity and culture, worldview, family, Biblical justice, and poverty. He serves as the president of the Disciple Nations Alliance (DNA) Global Secretariat office. After serving with Food for the Hungry for 19 years in both the United States and Japan, working in the areas of human resources, staff training, and program management, he teamed up with Darrow Miller and Bob Moffitt to launch the DNA in 2008. 📌 Recommended Resources: 👉 Previous Episode: The Church has the Answerers: Poverty, UBI, Homelessness, and AI jobs | Ena Richards 👉 Book: The Tragedy of American Compassion by Marvin Olasky | Goodreads 👉 Book: When Helping Hurts Book Summary by Steve Corbett and Brian Fikkert 👉 Book: Discipling Nations - Darrow Miller 👉 Course: Kingdomizer 102: Love In Action 💻 Follow Us: 📸Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/disciplenations 📽️YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/c/DiscipleNationsAlliance/ 📲Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/disciplenations 📩 Ask us anything: info@disciplenations.org Episode Webpage

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Scott AllenBiblical compassion is personal. It's personal. It doesn't treat the poor as this kind of amorphous category, right? The poor. What is actually the root of the poverty and the brokenness here? It's going to categorize people based on the need. So not only the context, but the need. Are they temporarily unemployed? Are they addicted? Are they severely mentally ill? Are they abandoned? Are they disabled? The basic idea is that different contexts and different needs are going to require different responses.

Scott AllenThat's the key. And the idea is that our work can become an act of service. And when that's offered faithfully to God, it becomes an expression of worship.

Luke AllenHi friends, welcome back to another episode of Ideas Have Consequences. This is the podcast of the Disciple Nations Alliance. As Christians, we all know that our mission is to spread the gospel around the world to all the nations. Amen to that. However, our mission, the Great Commission, also involves working to transform our cultures so that they increasingly reflect the truth, the goodness, and the beauty of God's kingdom. Tragically, the church has largely neglected this second part of her mission, and today most Christians are having little influence on their surrounding cultures. Join us on this podcast as we rediscover what it means for each of us to disciple the nations and to create Christ-honoring cultures that reflect the character of the living God.

Luke AllenHi guys, my name is Luke Allen. I am the producer and one of the co-hosts here on the show, and I am joined today by my dad and our host, Scott Allen. Hi, Dad. Hey, hi, Luke. Hey, it's uh fun being on with you today, Dad. I think this is the second time we've ever done just a one-on-one podcast. Just the Alens uh here on the show, so this is always fun. Um, Dad, uh, before we get rolling today, I just wanted to give people a little bit of um just kind of uh uh an outline of what's coming up. For those of you guys who are new to the show, um we have been doing this podcast since actually, Dad, I'm gonna let you guess.

Luke AllenHow long do you think we've been doing this podcast? Oh man, that's uh boy, you're putting me on the spot. Luke, so six years? Uh okay, well, you over guess, so five years almost exactly. I looked it up this morning. There's a picture of us. I mean, I was close, right? Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But back in the DNA office in Phoenix, what the first episode we ever recorded was November of 2021 around that little circle table with all those mics and just Yeah. It was fun. Five years now. Absolutely. It's a good time.

Scott AllenIt has been, it's been great, Luke. So I've I've so enjoyed this podcast.

Luke AllenSo yeah, me too. This is one of the highlights of what we do here. Um, as we have been doing the last few years, guys, we are going to be taking the month of January off. I just want to let you guys know that. Uh, just uh it for us, it's a time to recuperate um to get our guests lined up for the year and hopefully make a few uh changes to the show and a few updates for you guys who have been listening to this show for a while. We would love to hear any feedback you have as we're coming up on this time of reset. Uh if you have any recommendations of how we can improve this show, any questions, comments, concerns, guests recommendations, anything like that, uh please send us those, uh send us those sometime soon.

Luke AllenWe would love to see those. The best ways to reach out to us are on our email, uh, which is info at disciple nations.org. Sorry, that's a little bit long of an email, but again, it's info at disciple nations.org. Or you can always find us on social media. We are the Disciple Nations Alliance on Instagram and Facebook. Uh, but yeah, again, we'd love to hear from you guys. Um before we get rolling today, Dad, if you were sitting here and this was a live podcast and our audience was right there, and you could tell them something here after five years of the show, what would you tell them?

Luke AllenUh thank you. Okay, that's a great speech. Fantastic.

Scott AllenThank you for for listening. We're so grateful. And um, you know, I I would say that I really hope that this is edifying and encouraging and beneficial to you and to uh to to hold fast to God's word and to love it, love it and apply it to your life. Yeah.

Luke AllenThere we go. Uh speaking of applying the word to your life, uh, today's topic is something we've talked about on the show since I think day one. This is one of the core topics of what we talk about here on Ideas Have Consequences, because it is really at the heart of our ministry, the Disciple Nations Alliance, the question of how Christians can more effectively and practically help those who are experiencing poverty around us. Uh, the Disciple Nations Alliance background comes out of Relief and Development Ministries that, Dad, you were a part of, Darrow, Bob, the founders of the Disciple Nations Alliance.

Luke AllenAll of you guys have years and years and years of experience uh traveling around the world to some of the most impoverished places there are, and asking the question of simply how can Christians help more effectively. The Bible was written as the blueprint and the guidelines for our life, for how us as Christians and us as people can live the most flourishing and abundant lives uh that God has in store for us. And as such, it's going to give us guidelines for how to address every topic. Uh, but obviously, poverty is a huge issue, so it's going to address that.

Luke AllenUm, over the last few months here on the show, we've talked a lot about socialism, a topic that is uh way too popular right now in the West and really all over the world. Uh, and it's it's uh you always hear from socialists and Christians who kind of lean socialist that they are being the most helpful and the most compassionate to people experiencing poverty. Like if you want to care about people in poverty, then you need to become a kind of socialist in the way you view economics and the people around you, which is just so false.

Luke AllenUh, because if you want to help people who are experiencing poverty, there's one manual you should go to. It wasn't written by Karl Marx, it was written by God, the Bible. So, how can Christians apply what the Bible says about poverty uh into our lives practically to help those around us? Uh, it it talks about it a lot, and it's something that is at the heart of what we do here at the Disciple Nations Lines. So we want to talk about that with you guys today. Uh uh we have it's kind of like a teaching today, not really, it's it's still podcast style, but Dad, you did, I know that teaching last week on this exact topic um of kind of what is a biblical theology of uh compassion and ministry uh towards those who are struggling in poverty.

Luke AllenSo we just wanted to share that with you guys in somewhat of a concise manner today as well as next week here on the show. This is gonna be a two-part episode. So I hope you guys can stick around for both episodes. This today we're gonna be talking more about kind of the biblical basis and the grounding, the theology of engaging in poverty. Uh, and then next week we're gonna talk a little bit more about different approaches and practices and how to apply that practically for each of us into our lives. So this doesn't just stay head knowledge, but actually becomes hand application. So, Dan, I'm gonna hand it over to you uh just to get us rolling today.

Luke AllenAnything else you'd add there at the beginning for uh introduction's sake? Yeah, you know, thanks, Luke.

Scott AllenI thought you set that up really well. I I think um this is this we're doing it because we were um invited by the Center for our friends at the Center for Biblical Unity to be part of their um leadership cohort training. And um and so I had an opportunity to put kind of some of the kind of the main lessons we've learned over many years of kind of applying the Bible to this question of what does it look like to truly effectively work with the poor to help them kind of rise out of their poverty and be all that God intends them to be.

Scott AllenAnd there's so much to say on this subject. This is going to be just some highlights, but as you said, Luke, um when we I mean the DNA, we are all about biblical worldview discipleship, breaking down that sacred secular divide and helping people apply the Bible uh holistically in every area of their lives, especially in their area of vocation. Um and because we came out of a background in poverty alleviation and development, um, this was our first opportunity, meaning meaning myself, Darrow, and Bob, to apply what we were teaching in this in our vocation, which was work amongst the poor.

Scott AllenIn other words, we said, if we just went to the Bible and we pulled out scripture uh principles from the Bible uh about the kind of work that we do, how would it look different from the prevailing industry? You know, because there is a relief and development industry, or there's a common practice of work amongst the poor in places like Oregon or Portland or um, you know, internationally. And so it was really, you know, what I'm gonna teach here are some of the things that we learned, some of the most important lessons we learned by just going strictly to the Bible, you know, and and just saying, what are we gonna pull out of the Bible?

Scott AllenAnd this is something that all Christians need to do, regardless of the kind of work that you do, because this same exercise that we're gonna model here as it relates to poverty and development can be applied to business and economics and uh work in the home. Uh, you know, just go to the Bible, study it, and pull out principles and truths that that shape the way that you approach that differently than the culture around you is modeling work in that area, if I could. So I would just say that, Luke, in terms of just some setup here.

Scott AllenSo Totally. Yeah, that's great. Practical theology. Exactly. Practical theology, exactly. So we're going to get into a practical theology of work amongst the poor. Um, and that really is the title of the teaching, and I'll get into it right now, Luke, is a biblical theology or a practical biblical theology for compassionate ministry amongst the poor or those who are struggling with poverty. And I just to begin, I think the place you have to start biblically on this is by defining terms. And the first term that you need to define uh is poverty.

Scott AllenUm what is poverty uh biblically? And this is really uh I just want to pause on this one for a little bit because when culturally in the West, uh we define poverty uh in kind of a one-dimensional way. We define it materially and individually, um, uh almost entirely materially. Uh I remember when I studied the origins of the welfare state um under Lyndon Baines-Johnson back in the 1960s, there was a a bureaucrat that was working on the quote-unquote war on poverty, and he kind of quipped that, you know, the the way you overcome poverty is you just give the poor enough money so that they're not poor anymore.

Scott AllenAnd I thought that's it. That's that's that's this that's a one-sentence encapsulation of this materialistic view of the poverty. Poverty, it's all material, it's just people don't have enough stuff, money, whatever. And if you give them enough, they won't be poor anymore. And I, you know, I think that's very prevalent. That, you know, in the West. That's the way we tend to think about poverty in the church and out of the church, by the way. But biblically, uh, that's not the way that the Bible is going to define poverty. The Bible is gonna define poverty relationally.

Scott AllenAnd this gets back to the very way that God created the universe. He got, as we teach often in the DNA, at the core, at the foundation of everything, of all that exists, is a relational God, a God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, who existed before time and eternity in relationship, in loving relationship. And so consequently, when God created this world and he created human beings in his image, he created us fundamentally for relationship. And we talk often of the four relationships that God created at the beginning.

Scott AllenUm, the first and most important is our own our relationship to God. The second is our relationship to ourselves, the third is our relationship with others, other people, and the fourth is our relationship to the rest of creation. Those four relationships are the fundamental relationships that God created in the beginning. And again, the first and the most important is our relationship to God. Um when the fall happens in Genesis chapter three, those relationships are broken. And when our relationship with God is broken, we're alienated, separated from God, all the other relationships break as well.

Scott AllenWe're alienated from ourselves, from others, and from creation. And that's the that's the cause of brokenness and poverty. That that really is a biblical that you know, when we answer the question, what is poverty biblically? We we would say it's broken relationships. And we can think of it in terms of those four. Our broken relationship with God, we could call spiritual poverty. That's the deepest and the most fundamental poverty that anyone can experience, a spiritual poverty. The next is the broken relationship to ourselves, um, alienation, we could call that personal poverty.

Scott AllenUm the third, broken relationships with others. This would be relational poverty. This is something that is prevalent right now in the United States and throughout the West. Loneliness, isolation. Um really those two, that broken relationship to self and to others, rooted in a broken relationship with God, are really acute right now in the West. And if I could just pause here on this one, too, and say, you know, we don't think of ourselves as poor because we have a materialistic definition of poverty. You know, we think of ourselves as a wealthy nation, whatever it is.

Scott AllenThe West, the West is wealthy, the third world is poor because they don't have as much stuff as we do, right? You know, they're they're they're not as materially developed. Uh but uh when you look at poverty in this way, um we struggle with poverty maybe more acutely than the quote unquote third world.

Luke AllenUh because we wasn't that the famous Mother Teresa say did she say that to you, or am I mixing up stories here?

Scott AllenShe when she first came to New York, you know, and she sh Mother Teresa's passed away now, but when she was at kind of the peak of her ministry, she visited New York and she um is quoted as saying, when she arrived, this is the poorest city that I've ever been in. Yeah. And then of course, that for Western people, she you know, we go, what in the world are you talking about? New York is not poor. You come from Calcutta, India, that's poor. How can you say New York is the poorest city you've ever been in? Um she was looking at poverty biblically, right, or in in a different way than this you know, secular materialistic paradigm, right?

Scott AllenYeah, but she was seeing something different. And she had what she had in mind specifically was the issue of abortion, that that was a kind of poverty that you would actually take this precious, priceless gift of children that God had given, and essentially throw them away. You know, what what kind of poverty would lead somebody to throw away this priceless gift, you know? And um, so that that's what she was looking at specifically there. And she her comment was this is the poorest city I've ever been in.

Scott AllenSo yeah. Um anyways, and then yeah, back to the four relationships, the broken relationship with creation, that's there we're talking about uh the material world or material poverty. So certainly biblical uh a biblical answer to the question of what is poverty isn't going to ignore material, material need, um, you know, food, shelter, these things are very important, but it's gonna define it a much more broadly. And here's the here's the bottom line on this, because poverty is more than just material lack, poverty alleviation biblically has to be more than just material provision.

Scott AllenIn other words, it has to get at a healing in all of these broken relationships. And Luke, you know Francis Schaefer has been so important to the ministry. He has a quote where he says that we should be working on the basis of Christ's finished work for substantial healing now in every area. In other words, in all four of those relationships, in every area where there are divisions because of the fall. And that lays out the foundation for a biblical approach to poverty uh alleviation or working amongst the poor.

Scott AllenIt's this idea that we need to be working for restoration, redemption, healing in every one of those broken relationships. Uh you know, that that that is what Christ and the cross came to redeem and to restore.

Luke AllenYeah. So um Yeah, that's um I love that. I I think of you know the Garden of Eden pre-fall, as you know, you you would say those are probably the richest people that have ever lived on the face of the earth, Adam and Eve. You know, what was their bank accounts? Zero. And you know, and yet they had these four relationships in harmony and perfect harmony, and they were able to live the way God's designed us as humans to live in that that perfect state. Um it's because those four relationships were intact. And I I think it's interesting whenever you guys teach on this concept of the four relationships.

Luke AllenThis idea, yes, it definitely applies to poverty, but it applies to everything. It applies to, I mean, you can just just go through a list of classes at your local college, anthropology, psychology, biology, you know, physics, whatever it is, those four relationships apply to those things. And it's really interesting to that that's just a really practical when we're talking about practical theology. This teaching on the four relationships and healing those can apply to anything. So I just like to highlight that.

Scott AllenYeah, and I think you know, our our colleague Bob Bob Moffat, co-founder of the ministry, you know, he often points to Jesus himself as a model, uh, an example of uh kind of what a most perfectly developed person could look like. If our goal in poverty alleviation is to help people develop, um, you know, to develop into the fullness of what God has intended for them, you know, then you have to ask the question, what well, who's the model? Or what what what's the picture of what that looks like?

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

Scott AllenAnd Bob would say, well, the picture of what that looks like is Jesus himself.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

Scott AllenHe's the most perfectly developed person who ever lived. Now, when you look at Christ, you and you overlay that with the four relationships, he obviously had a very close, intimate relationship to his heavenly father. Um, so that was the foundation of everything. Um He uh, you know, understood who he was, right? There was no alienation, you know, in terms of his own person. He understood who he was and what his mission was, what his purpose was. He had relationships, uh, you know, really thriving relationships with other people, with his own family, with his disciples.

Scott AllenUm, not that there wasn't conflict, of course, uh with the Pharisees and others, but he had he had healthy relationships. And then materially, you know, this is this is where you know you might look at Jesus and go, gosh, did he have a big bank account? Or you know, no. Uh he didn't even have a college education. But um he was highly educated, and he um he had uh he had adequacy, if you will. He had adequate food and shelter, you know. Um so but he was, you know, so he was the most highly developed, right, if you will, person.

Scott AllenSo that's helpful, I think. You know, kind of what's our target? What's our model, right? Well, you can't you can't beat that model or target, if you will.

Luke AllenYeah, that's helpful.

Scott AllenLet's go on, Luke. Um I I want to look, um, I'm gonna base um most of the rest of the talk around principles that come from God's word specifically when dealing with people that are struggling with poverty um and brokenness of various kinds. And I'm gonna start by looking at principles from the New Testament. I, you know, again, this is this is not all inclusive. We don't have nearly enough time. There's a lot in the Bible on this subject, but I want to just start with principles from the New Testament, specifically from the Apostle Paul.

Scott AllenAnd he gives some really powerful biblical principles on how we should think about and work amongst the poor or those who are struggling with poverty. So, what I'd like to do, Luke, is look at three passages, and I'm gonna ask you to read them. And as you read them, uh uh answer the question what what principles can I glean or pull out from that passage as it relates to work amongst the poor? So if I could get your help, Luke.

Scott AllenYeah, the first one is Second Thessalonians uh chapter three, verses six through twelve.

Luke AllenOkay. You are getting put on the spot. I didn't get to read these before the episode. Come away with my smart sounding takeaways. All right. Uh yeah, Second Thessalonians three, six through twelve. Now we command you, brothers, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that you keep away from any brothers who are walking in idleness and not in accord with the traditions that you received from us. For you yourself know how you ought to imitate us, because we were not idle when we were with you, nor did we eat anyone's bread without paying for it, but with the toil and labor we worked day and night, that we might not be a burden to any of you.

Luke AllenIt was not because we do not have the right, but to give you in ourselves an example to imitate. For even when we were with you, we would give you this command If anyone is not willing to work, let him not eat. For we hear that some among you walk in idleness, not busy out. Work but busy bodies. Now, such persons we command and encourage in the Lord Jesus Christ to do their work quietly and earn their own living.

Luke AllenOkay, so takeaways from that?

Scott AllenYeah, yeah. But what what principles can we pull out of that passage in terms of how we should view and work amongst the poor Luke? Yeah.

Luke AllenUh well, don't walk in idleness. I'm seeing that right away. Um I'm also seeing that you should model it. You need to be hard workers yourself and uh to work diligently at everything ahead of you. I just finished reading Acts with my wife, and it is crazy how much those guys did in the span of a few years throughout Paul's three different trips. He was just go, go, go non-stop while working as a tent maker. Right. And, you know, staying up all night sometimes teaching these guys and then bopping around the Mediterranean.

Luke AllenHe was just on the move. It's uh it's inspiring to see. Um and yeah, I was in uh what where am I? Proverbs 13 this morning, and this I'm I'm in a very busy season of life right now, so all the verses about laziness are really popping out to me because I'm trying to eliminate laziness for my life. And uh uh there's a lot in Proverbs about the sluggard and the lazy man uh versus the diligent hands and that those those proverbs uh passages, I mean, really are the same thing that Paul's dealing with here.

Scott AllenThis is a warning. He's speaking to the church in Thessalonica, and it's a warning against uh idleness. Uh don't be idle, uh, don't be lazy, don't be busybodies is the word he uses here. But work, you know, work hard. Um, and that hard work, uh, in in his case, he says, follow my example, uh, it's so that uh Paul wouldn't be a burden to others. So, you know, we see a principle here of work uh in order to take responsibility for myself, my family, and not to be a burden on others.

Scott AllenSo this is a really important biblical principle when you're working with the poor, this whole thing about work. I'm gonna talk much more about that later. In fact, Paul says if a person's not willing to work, then they shouldn't eat. So it's this is we're this is a strong passage on personal responsibility and the importance of work in order to provide, to take care for yourselves and and not to be a burden to others. So yeah, good. We'll we'll uh unpack these in just a little bit, but I want to lay the biblical foundation for them first here.

Scott AllenYeah, go ahead, Luke. Okay.

Luke AllenWell, I have I've got some more thoughts, but if we're gonna pack further, well, I just think that verse sounds so cruel. If anyone is not working, don't let them eat. It's like, well, that's uh again the socialists, they're not gonna like that one at all. Isn't it right? What is it, the little principle there about universal basic income, yeah. Right, right, yes. No one will work and be happy.

Scott AllenYeah, right. Something like that. Yeah. No, the Bible has a strong work ethic, and I want to talk more about that later. Um, and that's gonna come in kind of very principally here when we talk about a biblical approach to poverty and uh and caring for the poor, biblical compassion. Let's go on to the next one though, Luke, Ephesians 4 28. Just a simple verse here.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

Luke AllenThis one says, Let the thief no longer steal, but rather let him labor, doing honest work with his own hands, so that he may have something to share with anyone in need.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

Luke AllenSo that you will not have any need, but then also so that you can give to those around you who are in need, so work so much so to cover your own needs, and then also have extra uh to give away at the end.

Scott AllenYeah, it's really powerful, Luke. Exactly. You nailed it. You know, biblical transformation, uh, biblical redemption moves people from taking, you know, the thief to working. And it doesn't just stop with working, it's ends with giving, you know, and this idea of being generous and helping others because of because you have something to share. So the thief becomes a contributor. And uh, this is again a really powerful principle that's going to come into play when we look at biblical compassion.

Scott AllenUm, let's look at the last one. This one is a really rich passage of scripture that um gets overlooked, I think, all too often when we're dealing with uh this subject of biblical approach to compassion and and poverty. Yeah. First Timothy five, verses three through sixteen. Yep.

Luke AllenHonor widows who are truly widows, but if a widow has children or grandchildren, let them first learn how to show godliness to their own household, and make some return to their parents. For this is pleasing in the sight of God. She who is truly a widow, left all alone, has set her hopes on God and continues in supplication and prayer night and day. But she who is self indulgent is dead even while she still lives.

Luke AllenCommand these things as well, so that they may not be without reproach. But if anyone does not provide for his relatives, and especially for the members of his household, he has denied the faith, and is worth worse than an unbeliever. Let a widow be enrolled if she is not less than sixty years of age, having been the wife of one husband, and having the reputation of good works, if she has brought up children, has shown hospitality, has washed the feet of the saints, has cared for the afflicted, and has devoted herself to every good work, but refuse to enroll a younger widow, for when their passions draw them away from Christ, they desire to marry, and so incur condemnation for having abandoned their former faith.

Luke AllenBesides that, they learn to be idlers, going about from house to house, and not only idlers, but also gossips and busybodies, saying what they should not. So I would have a younger widow marry, bear children, manage their households, and give the adversary no occasion for slander. For some have already strayed after Satan. If any believing woman has relatives who are widows, let her care for them. Let the church not be burdened, so it may care for those who are truly widows.

Scott AllenYeah. Okay, that that's a lot. That's a mouthful there, Luke. That's a ton, yeah. There's there's so much good stuff here. And let again, the context is Paul's teaching to the church and specifically to the deacons of the church who are responsible to care for the needs of those in the church. Um, and he's gonna talk specifically about widows in the church. And the first principle I want to bring out of this, Luke, is uh he's gonna he's gonna discern between two different kinds of widows. He's not gonna just treat widows the same here. Um there's widows who, by their good conduct, you know, deserve, right, to be cared for.

Scott AllenAnd there's widows who um, you know, who essentially are idle, busybodies, and you know, they need to, as he said, you know, they need to take responsibility for themselves. So it's it's a similar uh kind of echo to what we saw in 2 Thessalonians 3, 6 through 12. You know, they need, before they get any kind of help from others, they need to care for themselves, you know, and get get working, you know. So there's there's that principle of discernment. I'm gonna talk more about that, but there, you know, we don't just treat the poor all the same.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

Scott AllenUm, so that that's coming out here, this this principle of discernment, which we'll talk more about. The other principle that's really powerful here is uh uh a principle called um affiliation, or it's the Catholics would call it subsidiarity. In other words, there's a kind of an order uh to how the poor should be helped. And um, you know, it should in in this passage you can see that order in terms of first, they should care for themselves, right? The the the widow has a responsibility to provide for her own needs.

Scott AllenBut secondly, um the family members uh that you know are part of that widow's family, let's say the children that she's had, if she has children, um they need to care for her next, right? Her own family. Yeah that that they come next, okay? So God has established these communities, the family, and the family has a primary responsibility to care for the people that are poor in their own family before someone else. But then Paul says there's certain widows that for whatever reason they don't, they're completely alone.

Scott AllenThey don't have family members. Maybe they're not only their husband has died, but they don't have any children, they don't have any extended family to care for them, they're alone. Then Paul says the church steps in, right? That's where the church has a responsibility, but not before the family, right? So this is kind of this really important principle. Again, it's called subsidiarity. It it also overlaps with uh what Kuiper would call sphere sovereignty. God has established certain spheres, the family, the church, the civil government.

Scott AllenAnd they all have important responsibilities, but uh they're but but be but they are to be functioning in a kind of order, right? Um so uh lots here in this passage from 1 Timothy 5, 3 through 16. This is all three of these are powerful, but that one in particular is really, really uh lays out just a lot of principles of biblical compassion. If I could continue, Luke, I wanted to now take what we've just discussed and uh introduce a book that a friend of ours, a friend of our ministry, Marvin Olasky, wrote many years ago that probably had more of an impact on my thinking and Darro's and others than almost any book on biblical poverty fighting.

Scott AllenUm, that book is titled The Tragedy of American Compassion. Um, and what Olasky did with this book is he did such a great service because he went back and he looked at how the poor in the colonial times in America were being cared for by families, churches. Um, you know, what was happening? There were people that were impoverished in the colonies. How were they being cared for? What was happening? What did it look like? That was his question.

Scott AllenAnd he wanted to look at that particular time period because that was a time when the Bible was much more influential on shaping, right, the worldview of the culture than it is today. Um, and consequently, you saw biblical principles being applied in the colonial times in a way that we don't see today as much. Then he went forward and he looked at, as the United States secularized, how that kind of changed the way poverty and work amongst the poor changed, the rise of the modern welfare state, and you get all the way up to a city like Portland, Oregon today, and the way that it cares for the homeless, let's say.

Scott AllenVery different. And that is what he called the tragedy of American compassion, just the loss of these biblical principles. But what he does, it's so helpful in this book, is he ends the book, the last chapter or two, I can't remember exactly now, but he lays out uh what he gleans biblical principles for poverty, fighting, and compassion from the Bible that he learned, not only from the Bible, but the example of the early of the church in colonial America. And he he he he describes these using the acrostic ABC.

Scott AllenUm, very, very helpful. And I want to just kind of go through these uh with the rest of the time we have here. Um so let me first of all just kind of what are the ABCs of biblical compassion according to Alaski? The first one is affiliation. I'll talk about these in a second and explain them. The second one is bonding, the third is categorization, the fourth is discernment, uh, the fifth is employment, uh, and the sixth goes along with the fifth, freedom from dependency. And this the last is God.

Scott AllenSo A, affiliation, B bonding, C categorization, D, discernment, E employment, F freedom from dependency and G God. So um let's look at those kind of one at a time because it's a really helpful way of kind of just laying out in front of us, yeah, what I think are just foundational biblical principles. Let's start with that affiliation A. So affiliation is going to ask the question when we're dealing, when we're working in contexts of poverty, uh, who has the primary responsibility or relationship towards this person that should be helping them?

Scott AllenUm and the goal with affiliation is to reconnect people. If there's brokenness or alienation, reconnect them with those communities that are closest to them, family, friends, neighbors, churches that should be or having a that should have a responsibility to help. Um and again, the principle here is that effective poverty uh alleviation or compassion, it works best at the most local level, right, in the family, in the church, in the local community.

Scott AllenUh it doesn't work well when there's a big gap between the person that's providing um the help, let's say the federal government through a welfare program and the person who is struggling with poverty, right? That's a big gap. You know, you're dealing with uh a far distant, removed bureaucracy in Washington, D.C. uh that doesn't even know the person by name. You know, they they they are just a statistic. So biblically, affiliation is gonna say, again, it's this principle of subsidiarity.

Scott AllenWho has the responsibility to help? Um and again, the on that, the the Bible is gonna answer that question this way responsibility goes from the inside out. The individual has the first and primary responsibility to help themselves, right? That's that was Paul's teaching there.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

Scott AllenUm, you know, don't be idle, work. That's you, that's on you. You need to work. Uh, but let's say you can't for whatever reason. You're you're you're deeply disabled, or you know, there's some kind of disaster or crisis, you can't work, you know. Then what who's next? Who's got the next level of responsibility? That would be the family, children, parents, you know, the immediate family, the extended family. They would they would say, what can we do? It's our responsibility next to help. They can't help themselves.

Scott AllenLet's say the family can't do it uh for whatever reasons. Uh, who's next? This is where we we just saw this in the passage in Timothy, there, right? Then the church can step in or uh church-based or Christian voluntary associations, they can come along and say, okay, the individual can't help themselves in this circumstance. The family is unable to, we can help. Uh next, let's say the churches aren't able to for whatever reason, there are churches, then a local community, then the state or local government, and very last, you would get into kind of federal government, right?

Scott AllenSo that that's the principle of subsidiarity. Um, it's going to start with the individual, then family, then church. So affiliation, this first this first principle is going to be, let's say we're dealing with a person who's if struggling, like a homeless person, you come across them, the question you want to ask is what who what what are the relationships that this person has? Who who are their family? What community do they come from? And why are the why are those relationships broken and how can I reaffiliate them with those people?

Scott AllenIs that possible? Like you always want to start with that question. Does that make sense, Luke?

Luke AllenYeah, I'm just thinking about how messed up our system is nowadays, the tragedy of American compassion. I'm thinking of some of the biggest areas of poverty that we see. I think Mother Teresa nailed it when she said one of the biggest areas of poverty you see in the West is abortion and that broken relationship between the child and the parent. Um, and I think I I I wish I had the stat in front of me, but you know, economic uh well-being of the children is you is one of, I think it might be the most, the leading reasons for getting an abortion. I don't have enough money to care for my kid.

Scott AllenRight.

Luke AllenIf that's the case, and that young woman has family, the family's also to blame because they could easily step in and help that mom who's usually a single mom, usually a teenager, and she's worried she can't care for the kid. If you have family around, they're also to blame in that in that situation, you know, which sounds extremely harsh, but the family needs to step in. If she's really worried about the finances, they can step in. If they can't, the local church can step in. Luckily, local churches, I think, do a pretty good job at this in the US with pregnancy resource centers and whatnot.

Luke AllenThere is there is plenty of resources to step in and help young mothers. Um, I also think of one of the other big areas of poverty, which is also a relational poverty that we see at end of life with the elderly in the West, and how a lot of old people just end up pretty much abandoned for the last 10 years of their life, not cared for by anyone. Right. And that's so sad to see because a lot of times they do have family and the families just completely disowned them. And these are it's you're putting your finger on a very acute form of poverty here in the West.

Scott AllenYou you see this all over the West. Elderly people who are utterly alone, utterly alone. Yeah, they they don't even have contact with neighbors, much less their family. It's one of the most heartbreaking kind of poverties that you see here in the West. So you're exactly right, Luke, with that. Yeah. And the Bible is gonna say, no, family has a responsibility. That's why God created the family, amongst other reasons, right, to care for its members, right? That that is uh, you know, that's a clear kind of purpose, God-given purpose for the family.

Scott AllenThe other thing I like that you're doing here, Luke, is you're you're already comparing and contrasting, and you're saying, okay, this principle of affiliation, is it being practiced or not? When I look around, you know, the community and the work that's being done here amongst the poor in my own community. And that's exactly the question that we want to ask, and we want to do some kind of analysis of that. You know, what is that principle being practiced? Why not? You know? And we're gonna do that in the second part of this um episode. We're gonna actually come back through these ABCs and we're gonna do a little analysis of just how they are, or in most cases, are not being practiced today.

Scott AllenThat's so helpful because then as Christians, that sets you up when you see what what the true principles are, how they're not being applied. Now you can you can kind of create your biblical theology to say, hey, this is what needs to change, right? This is this is how things need to change. And that that that's what you need in order to act effectively yourself, or at a policy level to say, hey, we've got to have, we've got to change things at a at a at a uh community governing kind of level at a policy level.

Scott AllenSo let's go on. Um, so that's affiliation. Uh that's A. B is bonding. Um, and bonding basically is the principle that biblical compassion is personal. It's personal. It doesn't treat the poor as this kind of uh uh amorphous category, right? The poor. Uh it looks at people individually and it asks, who is this person? Um and it uh the the principle of bonding says that poverty ministry needs to be relational.

Scott AllenIt can't just be kind of transactional. Um another way of saying it is that people need people, not just programs, right? So um this is very important because uh again, so much of I don't want to get into critiquing so much of what happens now, but just to contrast it, so much of what we do in the West in terms of poverty fighting with our welfare programs is very impersonal and it's very program-based. And um it deals with uh the poor as kind of clients, you know, or beneficiaries.

Scott AllenAnd it doesn't really know anything about them personally. But that biblically is not going to be the case because and and why is that? Because everybody is made in God's image, right? Everyone has incredible dignity, value, worth, and a story. And we have to understand all of that in order to be effective in our care for them. And uh the the other thing that I like about bonding is that when affiliation, these two go, these two, by the way, go together, affiliation and bonding. Let's affiliation is asking who should help.

Scott AllenAnd sometimes you get to a situation where there's nobody that can help. These, these, all of these relationships, God ordained relationships with family, church, community, there's just this person is really alone. Then it's on it's on uh individual Christians to come alongside that person and almost adopt them, bring them in. And you literally see this with adoption. Adoption ministry is bonding. Like this person is alienated from their family. They have no mother, they have no father, they're alone, they're isolated.

Scott AllenI will bring them in and adopt them into my family, and they will become my children. That's a that's a perfect picture of this principle of bonding. And so any thoughts or questions on that, Luke? I think as we go through these, y'all before I go to the next one, I'll just ask you if you any have any reflections on that.

Luke AllenI definitely have a lot of thoughts. This is great. Uh yeah. Personal aspect, that's so obvious. You know, if you're gonna help anyone, you have to get to know the person's story before you can actually be helpful. I get frustrated right now. We have three kids, three and under, and some of these parenting books we're reading just treat kids like they're robots. And if you just do this exact formula, then it always works out. And I'm like, no, something that works on my three-year-old does not work on my two-year-old. And I think every parent knows that because they're individuals. They're individuals. That's right.

Scott AllenThey're unique.

Luke AllenAnd it's the same here. It's it's you have to get to know the person's story. And to do that, you have to have a personal connection with them before you can help them. A lot of people, I think if you went out and surveyed, you know, one of those person on the street interviews, it'd say, if you gave everyone in the world a million bucks, you know, if Elon Musk forked out his dough and we all had a million, he'd probably be more than a million bucks, actually, um, you know, would we all be good and no more poverty? A lot of people would say, Yeah. And that is not true. That is not true. And in five years, we'd be right back where we started, and they'd have the same disparities in our classes, and you know, most people would have already squandered their money and we'd be right back in the same place because it's not a money issue.

Luke AllenUh it's a personal issue. Yeah.

Scott AllenThere is material poverty. It is real, but it's, I think in some ways it's the least acute type of poverty. Spiritual poverty is much more acute, much more serious. And um relational poverty is is so painful and deep. We were talking earlier about elderly who are utterly alone or isolated. There's there's there's a there's not really a poverty uh in terms of its seriousness, it's acuteness that can compare to that, you know.

Luke AllenWell, and even with physical poverty, like you're saying, a lack of money, yeah it's it's usually something else is causing that. Right. And and we know this because uh our friends at work for the living, at work for a living, the the the work training uh group that helps with poverty. Yes. Uh Ina Richards, the founder of it, always says, if you are discipled, you will be working. And it's very true. If you're a disciple of Jesus, you're gonna go find a job, you're gonna work, and you're probably not gonna experience physical poverty for very long unless you know some outer outer uh catastrophe affects your life, like a hurricane or your house gets destroyed or something.

Luke AllenBut still, you'll probably be able to figure out a way through that, especially if you have you know a community around you. So it's the physical poverty we see usually, and I know I'm painting with a very broad brush here, usually isn't caused purely from you know just a lack of money alone. There's some other factor there. Is that fair?

Scott AllenYeah, no, I think that's right. Um let's go on, Luke. I don't I don't want to take too much time here today. I'd like to get through these ABCs. We've talked about affiliation, we've talked about bonding. C is categorization. Um, and this principle basically says that effective uh compassion has to be discerning and dis well, discerning is the next one, but distinguishing. It has to distinguish between, first of all, different contexts.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

Scott AllenUh for example, is this person struggling because there's an emergency, uh, a temporary emergency, maybe a flood, drought, hurricane, you know, a war, uh, or maybe they just lost their job, you know, they, you know, just suddenly they're uh suddenly unemployed, you know, versus uh kind of a law a context of long-term development. So it's gonna categorize people differently. I'll talk about that more in a second.

Luke AllenIt's also that's what I should have done a second ago. Yeah. You got to categorize. Exactly.

Scott AllenIt's gonna categorize people based on the need. So not only the context, but the need. Are they temporarily unemployed? Are they addicted? Are they severely mentally ill? Are they abandoned? Are they disabled? So the basic idea is that different contexts and different needs are going to require different responses. That's the key. They're gonna require different responses. So you have to kind of do some kind of categorizing. Let's talk about that first one, the different context.

Scott AllenThis is a really helpful principle that uh uh, you know, I think I just want to make sure that our listeners really understand. The the the the biblical compassion is going to ask the question, what's the context? Is it and and I want to talk about three. I want to talk about emergency relief, rehabilitation, or development. Those are three very different contexts. So in emergency relief, it's an emergency. It's temporary by nature, it's temporary.

Scott AllenThe the the idea here is let's stop the bleeding, right? Somebody's really, you know, they're they're really in desperate need. So we've got to go and we've got to provide temporary emergency relief. So you see this in any kind of disaster war. Um, that's really important, right, for for um biblical compassion. But that's very different than the next one: rehabilitation. Rehabilitation is taking a person who's experienced an emergency, but the emergency has passed, and now it's we're on to restoring.

Scott AllenHow do we begin to restore what's been lost or broken? This is also temporary. And then the last category or context is development. This is a this is a poverty that isn't necessarily due to emergency an emergency disaster kind of situation. Um, this is ongoing. And then the question here is how do we help people to grow, to be fully restored as God's image bearers? I mean, they everyone bears God's image, but um to be the fullness of what God intends as his image bearers.

Scott AllenSo um again, for relief, the goal is to provide essential help quickly to stabilize the situation. In rehabilitation, the emphasis shifts from doing things for people to beginning to work with them to restore what's what's been broken. And then in the development context, this is an ongoing process of helping hurting people grow and provide for themselves so that they can contribute to others and you know, kind of achieve the fullness of that God-given potential that each person has.

Scott AllenUm, the emphasis in development is on participation, it's on responsibility, it's on work, and it's in its on increasing independence. Now, here's where this becomes really important. You often, because these contexts uh we we don't uh we we're not careful to categorize based on these contexts, it's easy to come in and provide emergency relief in a development context, and that's not going to help. Okay. Yeah, just giving somebody something you know can can lead to dependency, right?

Scott AllenSo we we uh there's a there is a time, a context, where just giving people temp shelter, food is really appropriate. That's in an emergency situation. But if it's not that context, it's you that kind of help can be really damaging. So this is the this is the the biblical compassion is going to ask that. What is this context? How do we categorize? Um, thoughts on that, Luke?

Luke AllenOh, I just think that's so important. I mean, I'm just thinking of like a local homeless shelter. That's probably the first thing you need to do is categorize. You know, a lot of people that are homeless on the streets, at least where we live, are addicted to drugs. That's the way it is. Right. That's a very different category than the guy who's out of his work and he's trying to get back on his feet. Right. And just very different.

Scott AllenIs it really going to help, you know, that person, you know, exactly. So yeah, so we have to categorize. And the third, or the the next one, ABCD, fourth, discernment goes along with categorizations. We have to discern the root cause. What is actually the root of the poverty and the brokenness here? Um uh it's not just enough to come upon a person who's struggling with poverty and say, what do you need? Um, you know, they may have an answer to that question, but but the biblical principle of discernment is going to say, what's really at the root of this?

Scott AllenAnd again, we saw this in the 1st Timothy passage with the widows, right? Paul is asking us to discern between different kinds of widows, right? Um, what's really going on here? Are they poor because they're just lazy and kind of mooching off of others? Idle? Or are they poor because they are really alone and isolated and they don't have anyone to help? So, so discernment. Um and I think for us, Luke, uh the the question that I think is important to ask here when we're talking about root causes of poverty um is oh, what again, we talk about this a lot in terms of worldview, you know, that uh truth at the level of worldview is going to lead to positive outcomes.

Scott AllenIt's going to lead to positive outcomes at the level of values, behaviors, and consequences, that tree that we always show. But lies at the level of root, at the level of the root, are going to lead to poverty and brokenness. And so a good example of this is the story we tell often in the DNA, the story of Arturo, Arturo's uh work in um the highlands of Guatemala, in a very impoverished community. Arturo Cuba, a good friend from uh Peru, who was a missionary in Guatemala.

Scott AllenAnd he was working amongst the Pokemchi, very impoverished group of indigenous farmers. They were Christians, um, but they had high degrees in their community of malnutrition, undernutrition. Often the children would die before the age of five. It was very tragic. So Arturo asked the question, what's the root? You know, what why are these, what, what, why are these people so poor? And as he got down to it and really lived with them, bonded with them, and asked, you know, the hard questions, he discerned that the the root of this was a lie.

Scott AllenAnd that lie was that um that you know, that rats essentially uh are more powerful than we are. And these farmers were allowing rats to eat half of the corn crop every year. And that that was why the children were hungry and there was so much malnourishment in that community. Well, that's a lie, and he got to the root of that by challenging the lie with the truth, you know, and the skit, you know, that we talk often about, you know, who's who has dominion here? You are the rats. And and then when the dawn, when the uh when the uh when the truth dawned on them, you know, they were the ones that came up with their own solutions to that by protecting their corn crop.

Scott AllenSo biblical uh compassion's always gonna be asking, what, you know, it's gonna ask a question like this, what lie is at the root? Is there a lie at the root of the poverty and the brokenness? It's not enough just to treat the symptoms, right? We have to go down deeper, you know, to the root causes. And if it's if it's a lie that's at the root, then we can't just deal with the symptoms. We've got to replace the the lie with the truth. And that's gonna result in the the change that we're looking for. So so that's this principle of discernment, Luke.

Scott AllenYeah. Any thoughts on that? Ideas have consequences. Ideas have consequences, exactly.

Luke AllenExactly. And this is why we have a tree on our logo of this podcast, is because we're trying to treat the the root causes down here, the ideas, the worldview, which will turn into behaviors and values and actions. But you can't just treat things at the level of actions because it's not actually gonna uh you know change the root right now.

Scott AllenBehavior has long-term immediate needs, exactly.

Luke AllenYeah, have a long-term change. So you gotta attack it at the level of ideas, worldviews.

Scott AllenPerfect. Yeah. All right, let's go on to the um the next two, which I'm gonna lump together under employment, E, employment, and f freedom. And this principle basically says that able-bodied people should be encouraged to productive work and not to dependency. Um and dependency is here the opposite of freedom. Uh, freedom is being independent, caring for yourselves, and not being dependent on others.

Scott AllenIt's it's a form dependency really is in some ways a form of slavery. So the biblical principle is to say uh how can we help people who are able-bodied be encouraged towards productive work? So the question that it's going to ask is: will the help that I'm providing, will it foster dependency or will it lead to greater freedom and personal responsibility? Um, I have quite a bit to say on this one. I just want to go through some of this fairly quickly because this is where we get into work.

Scott AllenAnd boy, the Bible has a lot to say about work and the goodness of work. And it begins uh, you know, way back in Genesis with God Himself. Uh, God is a working God. It says in Genesis 2, 2 through 3, by the seventh day God finished the work that he had been doing. And on the seventh day he rested from all of his work. So God works, he creates, he created everything that exists. He's a working God. Work is good, work is part of what God does. And consequently, when God creates human beings in his image, uh, guess what?

Scott AllenHe creates us to work, because that's part of what it means to bear God's image. Uh, Genesis 1, 27 and 28. God created mankind in his own image, male and female, and he blessed them and he said, Be fruitful, increase in number, fill the earth, subdue it, rule over the fish of the sea, and the birds of the sky, and every living creature that moves on the ground. You can see the work here. God's giving us work to do in his creation. Be fruitful, increase in number. Do the work that you're doing right now, Luke. Raise families, right?

Scott AllenThat's a lot of work. Fill the earth, subdue it, rule over the fish of the sea, govern this creation, create new innovations. So this is kind of the biblical picture of work and why it's so important. Um, it's part of our created purpose. This is it's an expression of being an image bearer of God. Um, it's work is stewardship, it's taking the things that God owns and it's uh as stewards of that, cultivating it for its full potential.

Scott AllenUm work is loving service, it's actually meeting real human needs uh and expressing love for our neighbors through our hard work so that we have something to give to meet needs of others. Um and then biblically, work is even worship. This biblical word, uh this Hebrew word avoda, it's a word that can mean work, service, and worship. And the idea is that our work can become an act of service, and when that's offered faithfully to God, it becomes an expression of worship.

Scott AllenThis is this is really powerful. You know, Darrow talks often about the um woman, you know, who has a sign in her kitchen, and the sign says worship service is held here three times a day. This is a uniquely biblical idea that the work that she's doing to provide, excuse me, for her children and her husband in the home, preparing nutritious meals is actually worship of the living God. So all that to say this there's such a deep, rich biblical theology of work that uh you just have to kind of uh appreciate that a little bit as we as we look at this principle.

Scott AllenUm applying it to work amongst the poor, uh, biblical compassion is always going to ask this question: what can this person contribute? What can they do? It starts with that, not what can I do for them, but what can they do? Um never do for someone what they have the God-given capacity and responsibility to do for themselves. This is a biblical idea. And the opposite of that is that we harm the poor when our compassion unintentionally strips them of the opportunity and the responsibility to work.

Scott AllenUm, our good friends at the Chalmers Center, uh, Brian Fickert, Steve uh Corbett, um, when they wrote their really excellent book, When Helping Hurts, this is really what they kind of settled on, this really important principle. And amongst other key takeaways from that great book, which I encourage all of our listeners to read, When Helping Hurts, um, is that in the name of compassion, we can actually hurt, we can harm the poor if we communicate number one, you're deficient, I'm a provider.

Scott AllenNumber two, you are a recipient or a beneficiary, and I am the one who contributes. And number three, you have needs and I have resources. If we treat the poor in that way, um, we can actually harm them in the name of compassion. So, and and not only do we harm them, but we create a dependency. So they are not free, they're dependent on us or the government. So biblical compassion is always going to help people to work, to contribute, to provide for themselves.

Scott AllenUm and this is so deeply biblical. Um, everyone has a need to contribute. Again, it's our it's our imago day, it's our image, it's it's what it means to be a human being, a an image bearer of God. It's it says to the person that I can meet legitimate needs, I can provide for people. Uh that that you you gain a sense of your humanity when you see that. It's not just that I I you know animals are fed, right? We feed animals, we feed the livestock or whatever it is.

Scott AllenHuman beings can work and provide for others. That's part of what it means to be a human being and not an animal. Um uh my work, I have something to contribute that provides dignity, right? I'm capable of contributing. Uh that also uh underscores responsibility. Others depend on me. Uh service, my work benefits my neighbor, um, etc. and et cetera. So um basically the bottom line is never foster dependency or entitlement with the kind of help that we're providing, but always work towards helping a person become free, independent, and give them the dignity of work.

Scott AllenAgain, not everyone can work. I understand that there's people that have disabilities that prevent them from being able to do that. But if if most people don't are able, and uh even people with different kinds of disabilities are able to work and contribute. So biblically, that's always going to be something we've got to work for. A lot there, Luke, on that one. Um, we're almost done. Um, but just any quick reactions or thoughts on on all of that?

Luke AllenUh I just think of AI, you know, right now, and I think of a lot of the creators behind AI. I think their incentive for creating it is essentially their worldview says humans are animals. So if we can take the work away from humans and just feed the animals, then they'll be happy. Uh I'm all I I I like AI. I think it's going to be an interesting, you know, part of the future landscape. It's not going away. Uh and using it to create shortcuts is fine, but how you fill those shortcuts is my question. So a lot of people want to create shortcuts so that they can have more sloth, more slothful time, less work.

Luke AllenYes. But if you use it as a tool to give you more time to do other work, great, that's fine. You know, but this idea of letting AI eventually do everything for us, not a biblical concept, not good. You want to avoid that?

Scott AllenOh, it's gonna it's gonna create immense harm, you know. And uh, you're totally right, Luke. I think uh a lot of these, like I think of Elon Musk, he talks this way often. He just says, hey, I'm looking into the future and I see a future where AI, robots, they're going to do almost all the work that needs to be done. So what do we do with human beings then? Well, they need to be given as what did you call it, Luke, uh this basic income? What do you call it? Universal basic income. Universal basic income. Just give them on and keep them happy so that they can eat and and and then yeah, put them in front of a TV or some kind of form of entertainment.

Scott AllenIt's very much this brave new world idea, right? Just keep them distracted, keep them entertained, um, and and then this'll be good. This will be good. I whenever I hear that, I'm like, yeah, this is it's such a clash of worldviews, right? Because the bib the Bible says, no, people will be miserable because God created us to work and to contribute, right? And if you strip that from people, uh it's not gonna go well, you know, at all. And um, so I think that's a that's something that Christians need to speak up for quite forcefully based on just what does it mean to be a human being in a biblical theology of work.

Scott AllenEverybody longs to contribute, you know, have that dignity, that agency that comes from meeting legitimate needs, serving other people because of their work, right? Creating new things, you know. So, yeah, that really has to factor into this whole AI discussion 100%. Last thing, and I'll be done. Um, A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and this one's the last, but it is the most important, and that is God, that poverty is ultimately rooted in that alienation from God.

Scott AllenSo Christian approaches to poverty fighting have to work to help restore and re-establish that. Um, people need to know the Lord. They need, we we need to share the gospel. That that needs to be a part of the work we do with the poor. That's not separate. Um, that that that's integrally a part of the work that we do when we're helping the poor. And you see this, I think, i in a really acute way when you're dealing with a problem like drug addiction. Um, you know, you can get people Off of drugs through rehabilitation, different kinds of programs.

Scott AllenBut to overcome an addiction is almost humanly impossible. And this is where you need supernatural strength. You need power, right, from God. And in order to get that kind of power, you have to be your relationship with God has to be re-established. You literally need to be filled with God's spirit. And then you have the motivation, the power that only comes from having that first and most basic relationship restored. So again, much more to be said about that, but but no approach, biblical approach to poverty fighting or compassion would be uh complete in any way unless that most basic relationship was addressed and there was work done to restore people in that relationship.

Scott AllenSo that that's a lot, Luke. But I those are some of the most important lessons, principles that we have learned over the years. There is a very uniquely biblical approach to working with the poor. And because it's biblical, because it's from the the God's holy word, it's revealed, it is effective. In other words, it it works, right? You know, and it you know, this is this is what you were talking about proverbs earlier, applying God's word, the application of God's word it has a practical effect.

Scott AllenIt doesn't work like magic, you know, that but it tends to have positive outcomes when you apply these principles, these biblical principles. And it's gonna look very different if you are starting from a non-biblical worldview and you're you're working from a different foundation in terms of poverty alleviation. That's what we're gonna get into on our next, our next episode on this loop.

Luke AllenYep. Yep, we are gonna get into that next episode, so stay tuned. That episode will be out next Tuesday. Um, but yeah, what what you were just saying about uh kind of pulling principles from the Bible and applying them into a specific topic like poverty. This is what we do with the disciple nations all the time, kind of discipleship, but at the level of culture, so taking a cultural topic, issue, whatever it is, and then seeing what the Bible says about it. It's not very hard like we did today. We we we started this with three verses. Uh we we used more than those, but most of those principles were pulled from that one in Second Thessalonians.

Luke AllenWhat was that?

Scott Allen2 Thessalonians 3, 6 through 12. Exactly. Ephesians 4, 28, 1 Timothy 5, 3 through 16. Again, there's many more, and so you can't just, you know, kind of pick three verses and say our passages, but but but but but yeah, go to the scriptures, glean it, mind the scriptures, especially paying attention to the first, I think the first couple of chapters of Genesis, because this is always the way that you know we're going back to the way God originally created things and intends them to be.

Scott AllenSo all of our work has to, in a sense, be trying to get back to that, you know, what what was that original intention of God?

Luke AllenSo that's great. Yeah, I enjoyed that, Dad. I like the way you broke that down. That was super helpful. I was taking notes, and I hope you guys listening were as well. Um, this is something that all of us uh have a part to play in uh because we live in a world that has fallen and broken for most of us around 60 to 80 years of our life. So, what are we gonna do with that time and uh hopefully you know bring a little bit of God's truth, goodness, and beauty into this world and seek to bless those around us? That's what we're here for. So figuring out how to do that practically is what we're trying to do here.

Luke AllenUh, I definitely know I've have some application points I need to apply into my life. And there and me too, Luke. Me too. It's all talking about that I guess next time.

Scott AllenYou're like, okay, am I doing now that I know, am I doing what I should be doing on in this area? Yeah.

Luke AllenYeah, take a look in the mirror. It's good. All right, anything else you want to add before concluding, Dad?

Scott AllenNo, that's it. That's it. Um and I hope it was helpful for for folks that are listening again. Much more that could be said, but I think these are really foundational kind of ideas. And I again I hope that this has been helpful.

Luke AllenAwesome. And if you guys listening have any questions, comments uh about today's uh episode, we would love to hear those. Again, if you guys want to reach out to us, you can uh reach us at our email, which is info at disciple nations.org, or you can find us on social media. We are the Disciple Nations Alliance. That's the ministry behind this podcast. And this podcast is again Ideas Have Consequences. Thanks again for listening, everyone. Have a great week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Christian Nationalism: What Does the Bible Actually Say? | Joe Rigney

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Should America be a Christian nation? Should our laws reflect biblical principles? And what does it actually mean to say that Jesus Christ is Lord over all, including government? Few topics have sparked more controversy...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Our Modern Approach to Fighting Poverty Isn't Working | Part 2

    Nov 11, 202659 minAudio

    The midterms are over in the US. Will our newly elected leaders be able to help those struggling with poverty? Over the last few decades, we've spent trillions on government welfare programs. So why are homelessness and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The World Is Drowning in Ugliness. Beauty Is the Antidote | Jenny Jee-El Park

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    What if one of the greatest things missing from modern Christianity isn't truth, but beauty? Dostoevsky famously wrote, “Beauty will save the world.” But what did he mean, and why does beauty matter so much to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Return of Socialism: From Marxism to Wokeness | Kevin Briggins

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    Why is socialism making a comeback in America? In this episode, Kevin Briggins from the Center for Biblical Unity and co-host of the Off Code Podcast joins us to unpack the growing influence of democratic socialism and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Not Yet Now Kingdom of God | Zach Dasher

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Is the Kingdom of God something we’re still waiting for, or is Jesus actually reigning as King right now? Not as the consummated King, before whom every knee will bow, but as the King who has authority over this world....

    Credit the people on this episode