Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Fork The System

Fork The System artwork

Margrethe Aanesen on the future of the Norwegian aquaculture sector

Jun 9, 202628 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Our fifteenth guest is Margrethe Aanesen, a Senior Researcher at SNF - Centre for Applied Research at the Norwegian School of Economics in Bergen. Her work focuses on the management of marine ecosystem services and the valuation of non-market environmental goods and services. Her research has been centred on the societal trade-offs involved in aquaculture expansion in Norway. Welcome to Fork The System - a podcast spotlighting the innovators, researchers, and advocacy leaders reimagining how we feed the world. Feedback Form: bit.ly/forkthesystemfeedback

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Welcome back to Fork the System, a podcast spotlighting the innovators, researchers, and advocacy leaders reimagining how we feed the world. I'm your host, Sherry Shu, exploring how we can build food systems that are sustainable, ethical, and free from animal suffering. Today, I'm here with Margretta Onissen. Margreta is a senior researcher at SNF Center for Applied Research at the Norwegian School of Economics in Bergen, where her work focuses on the management of marine ecosystem services and the valuation of non-market environmental goods and services.

SPEAKER_02Her research has been especially centered on the societal trade-offs involved in aquaculture expansion in Norway. So, Margareta, I'm really excited for our discussion today about sustainable aquaculture. First question: What is the role that aquaculture currently plays in the Norwegian economy today and how has that evolved over time?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it plays a substantial role. First, it's a huge sector, it's an important sector. Of course, the oil is the most important, but uh then it comes next to metal and machinery, then comes aquaculture. And it is quite a large share of the export earnings. We have a small economy and it's very open, so that means we import a lot of stuff and then we also need to export. And an aquaculture is definitely a very important source of export earnings, and it's a quite new uh sector.

SPEAKER_01Norway has always lived from fish. This long coast, I don't know how many thousand kilometers that is, but it's a very long coast. So we can date it back to the Viking times, more than a thousand years back, that we lived from fish.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01So that was wild fish. You you probably heard about the overexploitation of fish stocks, and you have very little control of the fish when it comes, when it goes, where it is. So then in the late 60s, 1970s, they started to think, what if we could breed the fish? What if we can control it so that we know where it is and when we can harvest it? So yeah, I think it started in the 70s and took really off in the 90s around um the millennium.

SPEAKER_02What's the current balance then of what percentage of fish coming out of Norway or fish exports are wild caught versus aquaculture? Is aquaculture the overwhelming majority now, or is there still that wildfish?

SPEAKER_01It's not overwhelming, but I think it's about two-thirds or three-fourths, three-quarter is uh farmed. And we do have different kinds of aquaculture with trout and salmon and haliboot and uh goldfish, I think that try with cod, can't make it really. The cod doesn't like it in captivity. So it's the salmon. It's the salmon that uh is the lion's share of it.

SPEAKER_0190% maybe of aquaculture is is farmed salmon.

SPEAKER_02Wow, that's a lot. That it makes sense because I guess Norway is so known for its salmon. It makes sense that it's such a big portion of the total aquaculture industry. Um, yeah, so what are the current struggles that the aquaculture sector is going on? I know we've kind of heard in the news occasionally about a lot of environmental or welfare concerns. So, what are some specific problems that Norway is facing?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there have been different problems through the times when it grew. From the very start, of course, they had to use a lot of vaccines and medicines, bringing toxic substances into the water, uh, which was not good. But they were very clever at the beginning. So very quickly they breeded it and got very good breeds. So, compared to other countries, Norway uses very little vaccines and medicines in the breeding or in the raising of the salmon at least.

SPEAKER_01So, we don't have that kind of problem anymore. Then there were some with the seabed, you know that when the feces and excess feed falls down and it makes sediments on the seabed. That has also been more or less dealt with, meaning that they have to move it, they have to move the cages all the time, they can't have them stuck in one place, so you get thick sediments. So now, and this is the recent 10-15 years, it's the sea lice.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01So currently it's the sea lice. That is the really huge problem that we haven't solved at all.

SPEAKER_02And can you tell us a bit more about sea lice? Why does it happen and what are the actual implications of it for the industry as well as I guess for the fish themselves?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a triple challenge, you can say. First, of course, it's for the fish itself, a small parasite that clings to the fish skin and eats the skin of the fish. So it's irritating and it can hurt the fish. And if it doesn't get rid of it, it can die from it because it eats through the skin down to the flesh.

SPEAKER_00Oh, wow.

SPEAKER_01And it doesn't look nice when you see a fish with much sea lice on it. And this is due to when they are very, very close, where there are very many fish in the cage. The more there are, the larger is the probability with a large sea lice infestation of the fish. Right. So this is fish welfare first. Then comes for the fish farmer, there is an economic loss because first the fish can die from it.

SPEAKER_01When the fish have wounds, they can't sell it at the highest qualities. And finally, it's the treatments. And this is where we are today. How shall we treat it? Because there are techniques to get rid of the lice. You can wash it very roughly that will wash the lice off. It's efficient, but some of the fish also die. They are not quite happy with it. Then you can have small fishes that eat the lice.

SPEAKER_01There are some um lumpsucker fish, I think it's called in English. Uh-huh. This is a fish that live wild along the coast. So lately there has been a large fishery on lumpsucker, and they release it into the cages, into the pens. So it eats. But of course, this little fish are not so happy in the pens, and it also turns out to die when it is in the pens and can't get out. Well, it should be able to come out.

SPEAKER_02Like, does it affect the surrounding fish when you introduce this new species, or are they native to the waters?

SPEAKER_01That's native, it's not an invasive, okay. But um, as far as I remember, I've read something that there is also a problem with them to the extent to which they can use it. So they're appropriate. Yeah, it's not a perfect no. So currently, these lice treatments have roared the expenses of the fish. Fish farming is very, very profitable because there is good markets, the international competition is not very large.

SPEAKER_01I think Norway now has about 50% of the market.

SPEAKER_00Wow.

SPEAKER_01And because we have solved some of the problems, as I said, we have sold the vaccines and medicines, we have a good breed on the fish, we have sold the sediments, much of it. Before the lies came, the aquaculture industry had huge profits. I mean, I think I read somewhere that it was more profitable than the oil industry. And as you know, oil is oil is quite profitable. And now margins are going down because the costs to combat the lies are very large.

SPEAKER_02That makes sense.

SPEAKER_01So yeah.

SPEAKER_02I was actually gonna say I recently saw a documentary called Eating Our Way to Extinction, which was this documentary exposing problems with the food system. And actually, they did a profile on Bergen and fish production in Bergen specifically, where one of the critiques they had was about, so they mentioned the sediment problem, but they also mentioned that fish were being bathed with chemicals before entering the pens in order to kill the lice. So is that another solution that's being explored? And like how is that weighed against you mentioned pressure washing and using those small fish to eat those parasites?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but then you again has this chemicals that gets out into the into the water. Yeah. And and there are other organisms also in this water. So that would be a typical externality that is not optimal.

SPEAKER_02Makes sense. We're jumping ahead a few questions, but is there stuff that the Norwegian government has specifically set out to do in order to prevent the worst cases of practices? So you mentioned, for instance, we fixed the problems before with sediments. I don't know if there are also stocking density requirements or ways to prevent overcrowding, but like what are the regulations in place right now for the industry? And do you think they're sufficiently pushing fish farmers to avoid the most significant harms and take the best practices, or do you think it's not sufficient right now?

SPEAKER_01Well, it isn't sufficient. I can tell you why it isn't. Seven years ago in 2018, they introduced a system that was called the traffic light system. Right. And uh this was in order to control the expansion because there are large expectations to this sector, how big it can be. It's supposed to take over from the oil. When the oil declines, some decades ahead, maybe, but up to 2050, there are plans for um five-doubling of the uh production as compared to 2010.

SPEAKER_01Okay, yeah. And the way they will do it while still controlling the lice problem. Norway is divided into 13 production areas, starting in the southeast around the Oslofjord, going in the south and then further up to north. In each production area, every farm has to count lice. Um how much lice are there, and only farms in areas with a very low number, I think it's less than 0.5 grown-up female lice, because it's only the female eyes that are very dangerous to the fish.

SPEAKER_01So only those where the average female eyes per fish is below 0.5. That means the average overall farms that's there are allowed to expand. Okay. So have divided every production area, the 13 areas, into red, yellow, green. And if you are below this limit, you are defined as green and you can grow. You can grow by six percent every second year.

SPEAKER_01If you are yellow, you are not allowed to grow, but you don't need to take it down. And if you are in a red area, you should ideally take down your production by six percent, because that means that there is too much fish in this area, and that means that the lice is spreading too fast because they think right.

SPEAKER_02But I'm assuming companies don't want to slow down their growth, right? So of course not. Yeah, have companies been trying to avoid the system or like are they actually treating the lice properly?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, every farm has to report to the food authority, matelsina, right? Have to report it uh weekly, relatively frequently. They need report, they count themselves and they report it to this uh authority. This matelsina, this uh authority can come visiting, right? And they have the right to check, and you just have to, oh, you haven't counted wrongly or reported wrongly by then.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so there are still accountability mechanisms to prevent cheating the system, right? Um but you mentioned earlier you don't think the regulations are sufficient, and there's a reason for that. So, what does you think it's insufficient? What is the reason for that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, as you said yourself, it's difficult to have farms to reduce their production. So, first, the government has been really careful with reducing the production in these red areas. They have given warnings and said you have to remove it, you have to improve. Um also, these production areas are really large. So, if the problem is in the northern part of the area and you, your farm is in the southern, you can argue that the distance is so far that this is not the problem.

SPEAKER_01So that's the first thing why I don't think it's working properly. And the second is that the government has set up a new uh types of regulations. Okay, and maybe they will continue this system, but they are uh exploring more direct measures to cope with the lies. They are trying to give the fish farms uh monetary incentives to cope with it themselves.

SPEAKER_02I see.

SPEAKER_01Not prohibition, but that they have the incentive to try to get rid of the problem by themselves.

SPEAKER_02So kind of carrot versus the stick approach, right? And what do some of these improvements or adjustments look like? What would be something a farm can do themselves to reduce the problem?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is, of course, to develop the technology to have better ways of combating uh the lies. And something they are exploring now is to have larger fish that they make the grow-out season in the sea shorter. Okay. So they keep it on land and freshwater for a longer time so that they are larger when they get out in the sea and they are there for a shorter time. So this should reduce the opportunity for the lice to infest the yeah, it's only in the ocean, not in the freshwater.

SPEAKER_02So they're just reducing the time that they could be exposed to the lice, right? Yes. Okay. Exactly.

SPEAKER_01Yes, they call sea lice, so also.

SPEAKER_00So that is yes.

SPEAKER_02Good point. Um, is there anything else? Is it just the or are there kind of new technologies being developed? I heard a bit about offshore farming. Does that make a difference at all or not really?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. This is a larger um trend or a larger expansion of the sector. Okay. And means then a larger scale. What I talked about now is on the single farm scale. What can the single farm do? Whole sector, what they can do, that is, as you mentioned, putting it up offshore. You have not the small cages or pens that we have now along the coast, but these are will be larger installations, not as large as an oil platform, but towards that direction.

SPEAKER_01And the most important thing with this is that they are taken out of the fjords. It is in the fjords that the wild salmon is infested. One of the most important reasons for why sea lice is so dangerous when it comes more and more when there are much uh farmed salmon in the fjord, it spreads, it doesn't stay there. It looks for new hosts and it goes on the wild salmon. So this will take the pens out of the fjord and into the open sea, and then it will be much harder to infest the wild salmon.

SPEAKER_01You can take the whole farm on land, uh, but you know Norway geography. We have a very long coast, very much water, we have little land and we have very much mountain. Right. I mean land-based area Norway is not very large.

SPEAKER_02Makes sense.

SPEAKER_01Um so this probably will be costly, and one of the reasons that the aquaculture sector has been able to grow so fast is that the the area hasn't been contested. The coast is so long, so they could have used it. But going on land, the competition for area will be larger.

SPEAKER_02That makes sense. So does that mean the industry is generally tending more towards offshore farming compared to the other solution? And is this something I guess broadly the industry has supported, or has there been a lot of resistance from seafood companies, for instance, against these regulations, against pushes for offshore?

SPEAKER_01No, I don't think the sector, the industry themselves are against it. Okay. But it is, of course, uh a matter of costs, and also operating it, because now it can be operated from distance now because it's so close to the coast, so that they can have equipment out there and they can sit on land and the operations are you don't need people there all the time. Okay. So how they will do this with the offshore, I'm not sure if they uh yeah, I'm an expert there, but it's huge investments we're talking about.

SPEAKER_02That brings me to kind of a question about what companies occupy in the whole space. Like, has there been a lot of lobbying towards the government for less uh regulations? To bring some context into this, in the same documentary I mentioned earlier, I remember there was an interview of one of the government ministers for Norwegian's aquaculture ministry or fisheries ministry. She was kind of being interrogated because she had stocks in one of the major fish companies, and there was that warning that there's that conflict of interest, or the industry was kind of lobbying the government to avoid regulations to increase their own profits.

SPEAKER_02Is this an issue you see continuing? And how is that situation in Norway?

SPEAKER_01They are, of course, lobbying for their own interest, as many, many sectors do, I suggest. They do pay taxes to the state. They pay a production fee, a small part for every kilo produced, it goes into a fund. And also they need a license to farm salmon in the sea. Very early, they got it for free. Then it was a fixed price per license, I think it was 100,000 kronor.

SPEAKER_01Now they are auctioned. And because it's a limited number, they are quite restrictive with how many new licenses are issued, and it's on only every second year. Because it has been a so profitable industry, I think the last auction, the most valuable licenses are auctioned for more than 100 million Norwegian kronor. And this goes into a fund. And this fund money is then given out to municipalities that host uh aquaculture uh locations.

SPEAKER_02With industries or companies that occupy such a large percentage of the economy of a country, there's always, I think, the question I have, which is how does any regulation get passed? Because there's obviously incentives for industries to lobby them away or to not want to comply with them. But I think the unique thing about the Norwegian salmon industry is it seems like they have been mostly willing to comply because you know, they the government raises these fees or requires that these licenses be limited. And the producers know that because there's so much money to be made from this industry, they ultimately have to comply, right?

SPEAKER_02They they don't have many other choices to easily pick up and move somewhere else with the same access to the long coast or access to the waters or access to salmon that Norway uniquely has. So there is that opportunity for the government to say, yes, you can make all this money and be very successful, but you have to play by our rules. So yeah, that's that's very interesting.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but there is one thing that I should tell you that where it has been problems and much disagreement, that the current government also introduced a rent taxation that was introduced two years ago only on the sea-based production, because it was a tax on the use of common resources, the sea, the sea and the current and sea areas. So they should pay for using that. But they have managed to readjust their accounting because the company owns both the smalt, which is in the freshwater, and the grow out phase, which is in the sea, and it's only the sea-based part that is taxed with a resource tax.

SPEAKER_02I see.

SPEAKER_01So many companies have managed to move production between the different parts of the company.

SPEAKER_02So there is a tax, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay. So the government had expected some billions in this tax, and it turned out that it was less than a billion. I think there was some. Some hundred million. So, of course, they try to avoid. But I think that due to the very, very high profitability of the sector, they have somehow agreed to play on team. Very many, most of Norwegian politicians think the sector is good and should grow.

SPEAKER_01They have support among politicians. Because they are a rural sector. They create jobs in rural areas. Makes sense.

SPEAKER_02So yeah, I guess that brings us pretty nicely into the whole conversation about Norwegian society broadly and their perspective on the industry. Would you say then because it brings so many rural jobs, is it broadly supported by the average Norwegian, especially rural Norwegian communities, or are there still groups that are against it because of the environmental or welfare implications?

SPEAKER_01I did a survey on this among the Norwegian population and their opinion about the planned expansion, that it should increase fivefold up to 2050. It was interesting because people in rural and coastal societies where aquaculture were present were far more positive than people elsewhere. For instance, in larger cities like Oslo. And I think that the main opposition is maybe among environmentalists and GOs.

SPEAKER_01And at large, there were a support for the sector, but there were also concerns about the environment. And they are, because they are so profitable, they are investing in some of these farms, and they are quite generous in the societies that where they operate. They try to act positively, and I think there is a mutual uh gain there for the farm and the population.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, that makes total sense. And even among the supporters of salmon farming, are there demands in Norway broadly for better practices, like more regulation or stricter rules for how to deal with sea life, for instance, among Norwegian consumers and the general public? Is this kind of an industry that people are aware has these problems? And is there pressure from Norwegians to improve things?

SPEAKER_01There hasn't been some extremely much criticism, but lately with large wounds due to the sea lines, and because they are putting more and more fish in the pens. And now it has come up in some documentaries and in the media that up to 20% of the fish die in the yeah, it's a big number. And this, of course, raises uh questions about fish welfare. For sure. And people ask, what is this about?

SPEAKER_01And it was also uh some years ago a big debate whether they were uh toxic, that for instance pregnant women and small children shouldn't eat too much of it because they lived in these pens and there could be mercury or different things in the water that I got in. I think it ended with that they couldn't prove high toxicity. I know consumers are concerned about this question.

SPEAKER_01Why do they die from themselves in the tents couldn't be good?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So is there anything you think, both I guess Norwegians and non-Norwegian consumers of Norwegian salmon, which is probably many of us, what can we do to push the industry towards better practices? Is there anything we can do? Is there ways to even buy or support certain salmon producers with our dollar that are doing better practices?

SPEAKER_01There is a very small portion that is organic bred salmon. That means that there are much fewer fish in the pens. I think it's also something what they use for feed. Very much of the feed is of soya. Okay. So they use less of that and more fish oil from wild stocks. The fish welfare is supposed to be higher there. So if such a label could work and we could trust it, and there could be much information campaigns about this, I think that could uh help.

SPEAKER_01If we could get some type of farms that have very low uh mortality rates, if there would be some way that they could signal it, for me that would matter at least.

SPEAKER_02I mean, I think the organic fish manufacturing is interesting. I I didn't know fish were mainly fed soya. Obviously, the question I have about if they're fed fish oil instead is what if that requires a lot more fish to die in the wild to get that oil? I guess there's trade-offs with everything. So maybe there are ways to kind of mitigate that trade-off or find other forms of fish feed that are less damaging. I guess there is an incentive to align animal welfare and the environment with consumer concerns, just even in a selfish way, which is you don't want to eat fish that you feel is contaminated, diseased, or produced in like a way that hurts the end product.

SPEAKER_02And so if consumers want a good product, they also probably want better conditions for the fish and better environmental circumstances. So if consumers are aware of that, that could be a pathway towards shopping for better produced fish.

SPEAKER_00That's my wish, at least, for the future of the sector.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. No, very well said. And I also hope the sector tends more towards that direction. Hopefully, with a combination of government policy, as you said, as well as like consumer awareness, we can get there. We can kind of encourage the industry towards these more organic, more welfare-friendly, and environmentally friendly practices. That's it for this episode of Fork the System. If you have a guest or topic you'd like to hear about, share your ideas using the feedback form linked below. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Janet Enosi on the role of technology in sustainable African aquaculture

    Nov 17, 202621 minAudio

    Our twentieth guest is Janet Enosi. Janet is currently a Master's in Aquaculture student at the University of Highlands and Islands, the University of Crete, and the University of Nante. She’s passionate about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Caroline Cotto on why taste is plant-based's defining problem

    Oct 13, 202630 minAudio

    Our nineteenth guest is Caroline Cotto, a Director at Food System Innovations who oversees NECTAR, an initiative accelerating the alternative protein transition through taste. Her commitment to saying “yes” has led her...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Monica Chen on building passionate youth leaders in food

    Sep 8, 202630 minAudio

    Our eighteenth guest is Monica Chen, the Executive Director of the New Roots Institute. New Roots educates high school and college students on the devastating impacts of factory farming and supports them as they become...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matthew Dominguez on stopping the Save Our Bacon Act

    Aug 4, 202634 minAudio

    Our seventeenth guest is Matthew Dominguez, the U.S. Executive Director at Compassion in World Farming, where he leads a team dedicated to improving the welfare of farmed animals and advancing a food system that is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Renan Danielski on using sugar beets for cellular agriculture

    Jul 14, 202634 minAudio

    Our sixteenth guest is Dr. Renan Danielski, a New Harvest Postdoctoral Fellow at Lethbridge Polytechnic’s Advanced Post-Harvest Technology Centre, specializing in the upcycling of agricultural co-products into...

    Credit the people on this episode